The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About11-12-2003 City r.nmmi8inIJ Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor A The City of ~ventura e"', ., '.. . . ~~,..."(..,,...'" City M.~_ Eric M. Soroka Zev Auerbach Jay R. Bcskin Ken Cohen Bob Diamond Manny Grossman Harry Hohberg City Clerk Teresa M. Soroka, CMC City Attornev Weiss Serota Helfman Pastoriza Guedes Boniske & Cole AGENDA NOVEMBER 12, 2003 5 PM Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 1. CALLTOORDER~OLLCALL 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. ZONING HEARING: QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARING - Please be advised that the following item on the Connnission's agenda is quasi-judicial in nature. If you wish to comment upon this item, please inform the Mayor when he requests public conunents. An opportunity for persons to speak on the item will be made available after the applicant and staff have made their presentations. All testimony, including public testimony and evidence, will be made under oath or affmnation. Additionally, each person who gives testimony may be subject to cross-examination. If you refuse either to be cross-examined or to be swom, your testimony will not be considered. The general public will not be permitted to cross-examine witnesses, but the public may request the Connnission to ask questions of staff or witnesses on their behalf. Persons representing organizations must present evidence of their authority to speak for the organization. Further details of the quasi-judicial procedures may be obtained from the Clerk. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA GRANTING CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL TO PERMIT THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A SYNAGOGUE IN THE MULTIFAMILY HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (RMF4) DISTRICT FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2600 ISLAND BOULEVARD, CITY OF A VENTURA; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. 4. ADJOURNMENT This meeting is open to the public. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. all persons who are disabled and who need special accommodations to participate in this meeting because of that disability should contact the Office of the City Clerk, 305-466-8901, not later than two days prior to such proceeding. One or more members of the City of Aventura Advisory Boards may be in attendance. Anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the Aventura City Commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Agenda items may be viewed at the Office of the City Clerk, City of A ventura Government Center, 19200 W. Country Club Drive, A ventura, Florida, 33180. Anyone wishing to obtain a copy of any agenda item should contact the City Clerk at 305466- 8901. RULES OF PROCEDURE FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR PROPOSED SYNAGOGUE CONDITIONAL USE The conditional use application public hearing is governed by the City's Quasi Judicial Procedures Ordinance including Section 34-36 of the City Code. See attached copy of Section 34-36. The following additional procedures for the conduct of the hearing shall be used in order to assure that the proceedings are conducted in a fair and orderly manner. I. Arrival Time. Persons who support or oppose the application are requested to arrive at the Commission Chambers between 4:30 p.m. and 4:45 p.m. on November 12, 2003, for the proceedings which shall promptly begin at 5:00 p.m. II. Seatiol!. Upon entering the Commission Chambers those persons who support the application shall utilize the seating on the right hand side of the Commission Chamber. Those persons who oppose the application shall utilize the seating on the left hand side of the Commission Chamber.1 If one side or other side of the Chamber is not completely filled, at 5 :00 p.m. the remaining seats may be occupied by any persons whether they are for or against the application. The last row at the back of each side of the Chamber shall be reserved for the general public attending for purposes of observation. Further, the general public may utilize any other empty seats once the supporters and opponents of the application have been seated. The first front row on the right-hand side of the Commission Chamber shall be reserved for City staff, in accordance with the usual location for City staff seating. The first front row on the left-hand side of the Commission Chamber shall be allocated for court reporters and media. The second row on each side of the front of the Commission Chamber shall be reserved for attorneys, experts and major participants ofthe applicant and intervenor. 1 I References herein to the respective side of the Chamber are from the rear of the Chamber looking forward. III. Testimonv. Presentations. All persons who desire to present evidence or testimony shall do so under oath and shall be subject to cross examination in accordance with the Quasi Judicial procedures of the City. The attorney for the applicant shall be allotted thirty (30) minutes time for an opening presentation and ten (10) minutes time for final argument. The attorney for the Condominium Association of the 2600 Building (as a qualified intervenor in opposition to the application) shall likewise be allotted thirty (30) minutes for an opening presentation and ten (10) minutes for final argument. Any member of the public who desires to offer testimony or evidence for or against the application shall be allotted no more than three (3) minutes for such purposes. Persons testifying are encouraged not to repeat evidence which has already been submitted and may simply indicate that they support or agree with the specific evidence which has already been presented. Additionally, the first two expert witnesses, if any, for the applicants and for the intervenors shall each be allotted ten (10) minutes for their testimony. IV. Order oCParticiDation bv Intervenor. At the discretion of the Chair, the intervenor may make its presentation, conduct cross examination of witnesses and make its final argument following the applicant's presentation, cross examination and final argument, respectively. V. Decorum. All comments shall be addressed to the Commission and not to participants or attendees. All participants and attendees shall refrain from clapping, shouting, cheering, booing or in any way disrupting orderly proceedings. 2 CITY OF AVENTURA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM FROM: Eric M. Soroka, I City Manager TO: City Commissio BY: Joanne Carr, AIC Planning Director DATE: November 6,2003 SUBJECT: Request of The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc., for Conditional Use Approval to permit a synagogue in the Multifamily High Density Residential (RMF4) District, to be located at 2600 Island Boulevard (04- CU-03) November 12,2003 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item 3 RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the City Commission deny the request for conditional use approval to permit the establishment of a synagogue in the Multifamily High Density Residential (RMF4) district, as it does not meet the criteria for granting of conditional use approval in Section 31-73(c) of the City Code. THE REQUEST The applicant, The Williams Island Synagogue Inc., is requesting conditional use approval for the establishment of a synagogue in a Multifamily High Density Residential (RMF4) District. (See Exhibit #1 for Letter of Intent) BACKGROUND OWNER OF PROPERTY The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. APPLICANT The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. ADDRESS OF PROPERTY 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 LEGAL DESCRIPTION Zoning - Subject Property: Properties to the North: Properties to the South: Properties to the East: Properties to the West: Existing Land Use - Subject property: Properties to the North: Properties to the South: Properties to the East: Properties to the West: (See Exhibit #2 for Location Map and Exhibit #3 for Aerial Photograph) Condominium Parcel C-1 in 2600 Island Boulevard, Williams Island, a Condominium recorded September 19, 1997 in Official Records Book 17797, Page 2609 of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida RMF4 Multifamily High Density Residential District RMF4 Multifamily High Density Residential District CNS Ojus Canal CNS Dumfoundling Bay RMF4 Multifamily High Density Residential District Residential Residential Water Water Residential Future Land Use - According to the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan, the following properties are designated as follows: Subject property: Property to the North: Property to the South: Property to the East: Property to the West: Medium High Density Residential Medium High Density Residential Water Water Medium High Density Residential The Site - The site of the proposed synagogue is a 6000 square foot unit in the 2600 Island Boulevard building. The Project - The applicant wishes to establish a synagogue with 136 seats in the main sanctuary, a daily chapel room, a Kiddush/function room, Rabbi office, kitchen, storage area and restrooms. Congregant access is proposed by way of a paved walkway on the service drive along the south side of the building's garage, connected to the Island Boulevard street sidewalk. Removable bollards are proposed along the edge of the paved walkway to protect pedestrians from traffic on the service drive. Eight new lamp posts are also proposed along the southern limit of the service drive. The applicant has advised that management will provide ten parking spaces within the building's garage for use by synagogue staff, officers and selected members. 2 ANALYSIS Consistency with Comprehensive Master Plan - The request is consistent with the Future Land Use Element of the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan. Policy 1.3 of the Future Land Use Element provides that community facilities (including schools) and places of worship shall be allowed on property with a residential or business and office land use designation through the conditional use procedures found in the City's Land Development Regulations. However, the proposal is not consistent with the Goal of the Transportation Element of the Comprehensive Plan in that adequate parking facilities have not been provided. Citizen Comments - The City has received approximately 450 written objections from citizens and approximately 15-20 letters in support. These letters are on file in the Office of the City Clerk. The Community Development Department has received three verbal objections from citizens. One of these verbal objections was that a parking problem occurs on Friday and Saturdays at the existing synagogue in the 2000 Island Boulevard building and he anticipates this will continue with the relocation of the synagogue. Community Development Department Analysis - The applicant is requesting conditional use approval to establish a synagogue in a unit in the 2600 Island Boulevard condominium building. Section 31-143(f) of the City's Land Development Regulations, being the Multifamily High Density Residential (RMF4) District, provides that all uses in the Community Facilities (CF) District may be established in this zone if first approved as a conditional use. Churches or synagogues and other places of worship are permitted uses in the Community Facilities (CF) District. Staff's concerns with this proposal are that safe pedestrian access be provided for congregants and that adequate parking facilities be provided. I. SAFE PEDESTRIAN ACCESS The proposed access to the facility is by way of a twenty foot wide service drive between the south side of the building's garage and adjacent to the Ojus Canal. The building's loading area and parking garage is also accessed by way of this service drive. There is an alternate means of access by way of the existing boardwalk along the Dumfoundling Bay to the east of the 2600 building, although this boardwalk ends at the southeasterly limit of the building and congregants would still need to walk on the service drive, past the loading dock, to access the entry to the synagogue. In response to staff's concern for safe pedestrian access, the applicant has submitted plans to construct a five foot concrete sidewalk on the south side of the private road east of NE 183 Street within Williams Island property continuing along the east side of the exit drive from Williams Island to the existing sidewalk in front of the 7000 Island Boulevard building. This new sidewalk will provide continuous pedestrian access from the sidewalks in the public rights of way through Williams Island to the synagogue site. 3 The applicant has also submitted plans to install a five foot walkway delineated by pavers along and at the same grade as the service drive. This walkway will be connected to the street sidewalk on Island Boulevard. Removable bollards are indicated on the plans to separate pedestrians from the service drive. This plan has been approved by Miami-Dade Fire Rescue Department. The applicant has advised that there should be no conflict between congregants and service vehicles in the service drive since the rules and regulations for the 2600 Island Boulevard condominium association allow service working hours from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. on Monday to Fridays only, with any extensions to be approved through building management. Although the new entry sidewalk connecting to the existing walk in front of the 7000 building and the proposed walkway along the service drive with bollards improves the existing conditions, staff remains concerned that pedestrians will need to access this facility by way of a narrow drive abutting water and that conflicts with vehicles may still occur if vehicles are using the drive to access the parking garage or to drop off congregants at the door to the facility. II. PARKING The number of parking spaces required for this use is regulated by Section 31- 171(b)(13) of the City Code, which states that places of worship require one parking space per four seats in the largest assembly area. The proposed 136 seats in the main sanctuary require 34 parking spaces. The plans submitted by the applicant show 10 parking spaces within the garage of the 2600 building that are available for use by the synagogue; however, these spaces are currently under ownership other than the synagogue and would require transfer of ownership in order to be considered towards parking requirements. Even with the potential transfer of the 10 parking spaces, the proposed use does not meet the parking requirements of the City Code. Section 31-171 (a)(1) of the City Code provides that: "". Where a building or use which existed at the effective date of this chapter is changed in use or occupancy, additional off-street parking facilities shall be provided to the extent that the off-street parking required by this section for the new use or occupancy exceeds the off-street parking which would have been required for the previous use or occupancy had the regulations of this section been applicable thereto. For the purposes of this section, a change of use or occupancy shall mean a change from one category or off-street parking to another such category..." The applicant advises that this unit has previously been used an accessory use to the building, that is, for building storage and maintenance. No parking was required for that accessory use. The change in use and occupancy from storage and maintenance to a place of worship necessitates the provision of off-street parking as required by Section 31-171 of the City Code. 4 Criteria According to Section 31-73(c) of the City's Land Development Regulations, a Conditional Use request is evaluated using the following criteria: 1. The proposed use shall be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. The request is consistent with the Future Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan. The synagogue is proposed to be located on a parcel with a residential land use designation through the conditional use procedures of the Code. The request is not consistent with the Goal of the Transportation Element of the Comprehensive Plan, which goal is to provide a "...safe and efficient multimodal transportation system...", including adequate parking facilities. The number of parking spaces required by the City Code for this use have not been provided. 2. The establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed use shall not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety or general welfare. The establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed synagogue may be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety or general welfare. Pedestrian access will be by way of a narrow twenty foot service drive abutting the Ojus Canal. There is not adequate provision for parking on site which may create conflicts between traffic and pedestrians. 3. The proposed use shall be consistent with the community character of the immediate neighborhood of the proposed use. The proposed synagogue is consistent with the community character of the immediate neighborhood. There is an existing synagogue in another residential building within Williams Island, which synagogue will be relocated to this site. 4. Utilities, roadway capacity, drainage and other necessary public facilities, including police, fire and emergency services shall exist at the City's adopted levels of service or will be available concurrent with demand as provided for in the requirement of these LOR's. Utilities, roadway capacity, drainage and other necessary public facilities exist at the City's adopted levels of service or will be available concurrent with demand as provided for in the Land Development Regulations. 5. Adequate measures exist or shall be taken to provide ingress and egress to the proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets. Adequate measures exist to provide ingress and egress to the proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets. The roads within Williams Island are private streets. 5 6. The establishment of the conditional use shall not impede the development of surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district. The establishment of this synagogue will not impede the development of surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district. The site is located within the parking garage elevation of an existing residential building. 7. The design of the proposed use shall minimize adverse affects, including visual impacts of the proposed use on adjacent property through the use of building orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria. The design of the proposed synagogue may create adverse impacts due to the location of the entry to the facility on a narrow service drive abutting a canal. This service drive may become congested as pedestrians and vehicles access the facility at the same time. Although new lamp posts are proposed to provide lighting on the service drive, these lights may cause a disturbance to residents in the 2600 building or to residents to the south of the Ojus Canal. In the event the City Commission determines to approve the application for conditional use approval, staff recommends that the approval be subject to the following conditions: 1. Plans shall substantially comply with those submitted as follows: · 2600 Island Boulevard, Specific Purpose Survey, Sheet 1 of 1, prepared by Consul-Tech Surveying & Mapping Inc., dated 06/20/03, signed and sealed. · Proposed Sidewalk Design, Williams Island Entry Way, Sheet 1 of 1, prepared by Fortin Leavy Skiles Inc., dated 06/18/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Sheet T-1, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, dated 06/11/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Site Plan, Sheet SP-1, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, last revised dated 06/11/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Floor Plan, Sheet A-1, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, last revised dated OS/23/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Elevations, Sheet A-2, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, last revised dated 06/11/03, signed and sealed. 2. That, prior to issuance of a building permit for the facility, the applicant shall provide the following to the City, at its expense: (i) a recorded copy of the deed conveying ten (10) parking spaces in the 2600 Island Boulevard building garage to The Williams Island Synagogue Inc., and (ii) an amended site plan indicating fencing along the seawall at the service drive and appropriate shields on the lamp posts to prevent light disturbance to the adjacent residents. 6 The applicant has proffered various other restrictions contained in Exhibit #4. These conditions are attached for review. As part of the review process, these restrictions could be contained in a Restrictive Covenant to be recorded in the Public Records of Miami-Dade County prior to issuance of a building permit for the facility. 7 ~H[~~[~~ ATTORNEYS AT LA\1' l~~~~ID Clifford A. Schulman (305) 579-0613 Direet FaX' (305) %1-5613 E-Mail: schulmanc@gtlaw.com December 20, 2002 VIA FACSIMILE Ms. Joann Carr Planning Director City of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 EXHIBIT #1 04-CU-03 Re: Letter of Intent for Conditional Use Approval for Williams Island Svnagogue. Inc. Dear Ms. Carr: This office represents Williams Island Synagogue, Inc., the Applicant for Conditional Use Approval (the "Applicant"), pursuant to Section 31-73 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Aventura. As shown on the enclosed application, the property which is the subject of this application is presently owned by Williams Island Synagogue, Inc., which has consented to the filing of this application. Please note that this application is being filed under protest and without prejudice to the Applicant's rights under both the federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, 42 U.S.C. ~ 2000cc, et seq. (RLUIPA) (copy attached) and the Florida Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1998, Chapter 761, Florida Statutes (2002) (copy attached) . I. Obiection to ReQuirement for Conditional Use Approval. United States Constitution and Laws To the extent that the City's Comprehensive Plan (the "Plan") and Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") require religious institutions to seek conditional use approval, we believe that both the Plan and the LDRs violate RLUIP A in three respects: (i) by imposing a "substantial burden" on religious institutions; (ii) by discriminating against religious institutions; and (iii) by placing unreasonable restrictions on land-use permits for religious assemblies and institutions. RLUlP A forbids the imposition of a "substantial burden" on religious institutions: GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. 1221 BRICKELL AVENUE MIAMI, FLORIDA 33131 305-S79~0500 FAX 305-579-0717 www.,tlaw.com MIAMI NEW YORK WASHINGTON, D.C. ATLANTA PHILADELPHIA TYSONS CORNER CHICAGO BOSTON PHOENIX WILMINGTON Los ANGELES DENVEI SA.o PAULO FORT LAUDERDALE BOCA RATON WEST PALM BEACH ORLANDO TALLAHASSEE Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 2 (1) GENERAL RULE - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution, unless the government demonstrates that imposition of the burden on that person, assembly, or institution (A) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (B) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest. (2) SCOPE OF APPLICATION - This subsection applies in any case in which-- (A) the substantial burden is imposed in a program or activity that receives Federal financial assistance, even ifthe burden results from a rule of general applicability; (B) the substantial burden affects, or removal of that substantial burden would affect, commerce with foreign nations, among the several States, or with Indian tribes, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; or (C) the substantial burden is imposed in the implementation of a land use regulation or system ofland use regulations, under which a government makes, or has in place formal or informal procedures or practices that permit the government to make, individualized assessments of the proposed uses for the property involved. RLUIP A also provides that it is to be given a "broad construction" in order to guarantee a "broad protection of religious exercise to the maximum extent" allowed under the law. 42 U.S.C. ~ 2000cc-3(g). The Synagogue, which is clearly a "religious assembly or institution" protected under RLUlPA, is only permitted under the Comprehensive Plan and the LDR's to be in this zoning district with a conditional use permit. This constitutes an unlawful "substantial burden" under RLUIP A. Second, the Plan and LDRs violate the RLUIP A prohibitions against discriminatory treatment of religious exercise and institutions: (1) EQUAL TERMS - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than equal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution. (2) NONDISCRIMINATION - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation that discriminates against any assembly or institution on the basis of religion or religious denomination. GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 3 42 U.S.C.2000cc(B). While the Applicant is required to seek a conditional use permit for religious activities, private parties, meetings and other types of assemblies to persons located both within and without the development - and conducted at the same time in the condominium building in which the Synagogue is located - are not required by the Plan or the LDR's to obtain a conditional use permit. The Comprehensive Plan and the LDRs put the Synagogue, and any other religious institutions or assemblies attempting to meet in the City of A ventura, "on less than equal terms" with the non-religious assemblies or institutions, in addition to subjecting religious institutions to a "substantial burden" that is not otherwise applicable to like assemblies. Such disparate treatment of religious assemblies is a clear violation ofRLUIPA. Murphy v. Zoning Comm 'n of Town of New Melford, 148 F. Supp.2d 173 (D.C. Conn. 2001) (injnnction issued to prevent town from prohibiting religious meetings in single family neighborhood where single family residents were allowed to have private, non-religious parties in same area without specific zoning approval).RLUIP A claims may be brought in federal court and a successful plaintiff may be awarded under the Act. The provisions of RLUIP A have been recently upheld against constitutional attack. Freedom Baptist Church of Delaware County v. Township of Middleton, 204 F.Supp.2d 857 (B.D. Pa. 2002). This disparate treatment of religious institutions under Policy 1.31 of the Plan and the newly adopted LDR's also directly violates the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. See, Freedom Baptist Church, 204 F.Supp.2d at 869 ("equal terms" provision of RLUlPA codifies Supreme Court's First Amendment jurisprudence). The Supreme Court has held that, "[a]t a minimum, the protections of the Free Exercise Clause [of the First Amendment] pertain if the law at issue discriminated against some or all religious beliefs or regulates or prohibits conduct because it is undertaken for religious reasons." Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of Hialeah, 508 U.S. 520, 532 (1992). Because Policy 1.3 and the LDRs disparately treat religious and non-religious institutions and assemblies, the Plan and the LDRs violate the First Amendment. Id. at 533 ("if the object ofa law is to infringe upon or restrict practices because of their religious motivation, the law is not neutral and it is invalid unless it is justified by a compelling interest and is narrowly tailored to advance that interest"). Finally, Policy 1.3 of the Plan and the LDRs are also unreasonable, and thus violate the Exclusions and Limits provision ofRLUIPA. Section 2(b)(3)(B) ofRLUIPA, the Exclusions and Limits provisions, states: I Policy 1.3 of the City's Comprehensive Plan states: "Conununity facilities (including schools) and places of worship shall be allowed on property with a residential or business and office land use designation through the conditional use procedures found in the City's land development regulations. . . ." GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 4 No government shall impose or implement a land us regulation that- . . . (8) unreasonably limits religious assemblies, institutions, or structures within a jurisdiction. Id. RLUPA's Exclusions and Limits provisions codifY the United States Supreme Court decisions under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. See, Freedom Baotist Church. 204 F.Supp. 2d at 871. The Supreme Court has held that the Equal Protection Clause prohibits irrational distinctions in land use laws. City ofClebume v. Clebume Living Center, 473 U.S. 432, 105 S.Ct. 3249 (1985). In Cleburne, the City required a special use permit for homes for the mentally retarded, but did not require a special use permit for other multi-family uses such as apartment houses and boarding houses, in the same zoning district. Id. at 447. The Court stated the government could differentiate between uses only if the use which needed a special use permit "would threaten legitimate interests of the city in a way that other permitted uses. . . would not." Id. at 448. Here, no more, and no different, disturbance to the condominium residents could result from a religious worship service than would result from a community citizens' meeting or a private party. The City of Aventura has no reasonable basis to require, under the Plan, that religious institutions and assemblies must obtain a conditional use permit in order to use space in a condominium, while not requiring non-religious institutions or assemblies to do the same. Policy 1.3 of the City of Aventura's Comprehensive plan therefore violates both the Exclusions and Limits provision ofRLUIPA and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Based on the foregoing, the City of Aventura's Comprehensive Plan could be challenged under RLUIP A, the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of Fourteenth Amendment. We would respectfully request that the Comprehensive Plan language which appears to require a conditional use approval for such religious uses/assemblies be modified so as to eliminate the requirement for a conditional use approval for religious uses that are held in such facilities. This is not to say, that conditional use approval might not be appropriate for a free-standing religious institution that is not conducting its activities in a manner that is identical to other uses taking place, as of right, in a particular zoning district, and the Commission may wish to distinguish such situations. GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 5 Florida Law The Florida Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1998 also protects against the imposition of substantial burdens on religious activities. Section 761.03, Florida Statutes (2002), states: (I) The government shall not substantially burden a persons exercise of religion, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability, except that government may substantially burden a persons exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person: (a) Is in furtherance ofa compelling governmental interest; and (b) Is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest. (2) A person whose religious exercise has been burdened in violation of this section may assert that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief. But Florida went even further then this generalized protection for religious institutions and, following the lead of United States Congress, further amended the statutes in 2000 to specifically address land use decisions oflocal zoning authorities. Section 760.26, Florida Statutes (2002), provides: It is unlawful to discriminate in land use decisions or in the permitting or development based on race, color, national origin, sex, disability, familial status, religion, or, except as otherwise provided by law, the source of financing of a development or proposed development. Based on these provisions, we believe that requiring Applicant to even apply for a conditional use approval will be ultimately determined to be violate of both federal and Florida law. Reasons for the Granting of the Application While maintaining our objections, noted above, we believe that the application for conditional nse should be granted and that the application meets the specific criteria of Section 31-73( c) of the Land Development Regulations. Your review of the application submitted will GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18,2002 Page 6 show: The proposed use is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; the establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed use will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, or general welfare; the proposed use is consistent with the community character of the immediate neighborhood of the proposed use; utilities, roadway capacity, drainage, and other necessary public facilities, including police, fire and emergency services, exist at the City's adopted levels of service, or will be available concurrently with demand as provided for in the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations; adequate measures exist or will be taken to provide ingress and egress to the proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets; the establishment of the proposed conditional use will not impede the development of surrounding properties for uses permitted in their respective zoning districts; and the design of the proposed use minimizes adverse effects, including visual impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent properties through the use of building orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria. As part of your review, We would suggest the following factors should be considered: ~ A synagogue has been operating in Williams Island, at another location, for over 12 years and, to our knowledge, no complaint has ever been filed with any governmental agency regarding those operations; ~ As a result, we submit that the operations of a Synagogue on Williams Island is a "grandfathered", non-conforming use or, in the alternative, a permitted accessory use; ~ The membership of the Synagogue is approximately 200 members and of that total, approximately 90% are residents of Williams Island; ~ The Synagogue is for the Orthodox Jewish faith, which has as one of its tenets, that automobiles may not be used on the Sabbath (Le., from sundown on Friday until sundown on Saturday), which is when the majority of religious services are held; ~ The plan for the location of the Synagogue in the 2600 building will show that ingress and egress to the commercial condominium unit so designated is not through the lobby of the building but, instead, is through the "back door" of the building and on its lowest, non-residential fIoor...approximately 1,050 feet from the front lobby of the building; ~ The unit where the Synagogue will be located is a "commercial" condominium unit and not a residential unit. As such, it can be used for other purposes with significantly greater impacts than the proposed use; ~ Parking for anyone that will use the Synagogue on holidays or on a daily basis, when it is not the Sabbath, will not be in the 2600 building, but will be located on the southerly side of the existing Mediterranean Village tennis courts; ~ The Synagogue conducts two services on weekdays, in the morning and evening, with approximately 10-15 persous in attendance at each service. On the Sabbath (Friday evening and Saturday morning services), approximately 80-130 persons are in attendance. GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 7 ~ The total number of seats that will be placed in the main sanctuary will be 212 seats, and it only anticipated that this capacity will be met on the High Holy Days, which consists of only two days for Rosh Hashanah and one day for Yom Kippur. The attendance on the second day of Rosh Hashanah normal attracts attendance that is 1/2 of those attending on the first day of the holiday; ~ The "Party Room" in the 2600 building is utilized for social functions virtually each day of each weekend with occupancy far in excess of those anticipated for the Synagogue; ~ Social functions in the Party Room of the 2600 building are conducted year round and have an average size per event of approximately 80-100 people, with a great majority of the attendees at these parties being off-Island residents, who utilize their vehicles to attend these events, use the main lobby and utilize the parking in the 2600 building itself. We respectfully request your prompt and favorable review and approval of this request. If you have any further questions regarding this matter, please feel free to call. CAS/cph ~ GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. . BROWARD COUNTY .................. . DADE COUNTY ~ 'I." :. .. :~ :. .. ,-'!.',':,; :. 'i~\':~';':', ;1 ,';;;!:~'/;t:;ii':' :: <"':,:;., -','.i}.' :. .,'i;~;}/C' l~ ,:;:;i'I', :1 ;J/~liI " ,'_"""':' r, ,J,:t<J/ 'II' I', ,:;,'.:.;',: _,;;'; ';:'}~i:'; II d4'/} "IUI,I(L,I:'''''';I:I;;:' . ~1&'iJii'/Yfig!.f.IJ![,._I", ,,"-i,,'i:;,!i,'~,:, "ilil' <i!",r""'A'IRYR'Ol '. ~jl '10$ .' . 'lfLI ~" ' . '. :. ;1 :. .. :. :. '. :1 '. :. :" :" :. :" :- .. :. :. :" :1 :. :. ,0' ':. :. . ,:1 ':1 :. .... - -. ;:.:. 'i'ill' ~ :I: uJ X is :t ':"..',"'i<': ::;!;j:;,:'c", 'ill:'i'rU::i:r:ij!U,,_ I:~!i,>:.' "','J ';!.. ;,,:il._'I"~',.' ',_,; ',.-....: -'Ji';;, ,:::,::iJ'/'i,;.;,;,.", ::~~ENS DR. [ 10) '" '" a: Cl . i'l '" :J -' <.) >- a: ~-" z:i :J ' o <.) 201 TER. 'ojO. AVENTURA ~'"' Fi,..'. RescUe '::Ave~a SiiziioniFLib;-".ry AventuraMall Loehmann's . Fashion ~ Island <( ',' &l ;:,.:. , 190 ST. 188 ST. 33180 -.-.-.-..... .-.-.-.-.-.-. 33 Dumfoundling Bay ""~"'--'''''''''''''-<> ...a:w.'"ii.... . .. Maule . Lake . .. . . . . . . .. .. . . . . '10. . . . . ... ~ LEGEND ...... ci ::; III Z <( w <.) o 192 ST. g '" Z ~ o o Atlantic Ocean " Roadways City Boundary ZIP Code Boundary Railroad EXHIBIT #3 04-CU-03 EXHIBIT #4 04-CU-03 (1) Entrance to the Property. The entrance to the Synagogue will solely be through the rear access driveway located immediately south of the Property. (2) Entry Throul!h Lobby of 2600 Buildinl! Prohibited. Members of the Synagogue will not enter the Synagogue through the lobby of the 2600 Island Boulevard Building. (3) Synal!ol!ue Parkinl!. The management of the Synagogue will provide ten (10) parking spaces within the 2600 Island Boulevard Parking Garage for the use of the Synagogue staff, officers, and selected members. (4) Synal!ol!ue Membership. At least 80% of the total membership of the Synagogue shall be Williams Island residents. At no time shall the membership of the Synagogue exceed 150 families from either within or without Williams Island. (5) Occupancies. Room occupancies shall be governed by the applicable provisions ofthe Florida Fire Prevention Code and the regulations ofthe Miami-Dade Fire Rescue Department. At no time shall seating in the Synagogue sanctuary, either permanent or temporary, exceed 210 seats. (6) Advertisements for Membership. The Synagogue will conduct no advertising directed towards recruiting new members except for membership drives directed towards Williams Island residents. (7) Hil!h Holidays. During the Jewish High Holidays, the Synagogue, in coordination with the Williams Island security staff, will make independent arrangements for increased security at the sole cost and expense of the Synagogue. (8) Events. The Synagogue shall not be utilized for non-religious events or parties such as parties for Bar and Bat Mitzvah, weddings, bris, or other parties and events that are not normally and traditionally considered to be a part of a religious holiday or observance or the Sabbath. Thus, for example, while the Synagogue may be used for a wedding ceremony, the Synagogue may not be used for the wedding party. Likewise, however, as an example, a Sabbath dinner or Kiddush, either before or after Sabbath services and/or a Passover dinner, either before or after a Passover service, shall be considered to be a normal and traditional event that is not a "non-religious event or party". Food deliveries for events at the Synagogue shall only utilize service delivery facilities and approved times for delivery of the 2600 building in the same manner as deliveries would be permitted for the party room of the 2600 building. (9) Securitv Camera. The Synagogue will provide an additional security camera for the Synagogue entrance which will be wired to the existing security station for the 2600 Island Boulevard building, at the sole cost and expense of the Synagogue. (10) Landscapine. The Synagogue will supplement the existing landscaped hedge at the south boundary ofthe 2600 Island Boulevard building, adjacent to the canal. (11) Non-Access to Loadine Dock Area. The Synagogue will coordinate the installation, during non-delivery hours, of a partial vehicular gate preventing vehicle access to loading dock area only during "off-hours". (12) Guest Lists for Special Events. The Synagogue will provide guest lists for special events (other than normal and traditional Sabbath or Jewish holiday services. such as events permitted under paragraph 8) to the Williams Island front gate security prior to any such special event. (13) Svnaeoeue Sienaee Prohibited. No signage identifying the Property as a synagogue will be placed on the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building or parking garage. (14) Directional Sienaee Permitted. Directional signage shall be permitted but such signage may only indicate, in a non-religious manner, the location ofthe Synagogue. (15) Facade of Svnaeoeue. The fa~ade ofthe Synagogue will not display any religious ornamentation or signage and no stained glass windows shall be visible from the exterior ofthe Property. (16) Liabilitv Insurance. The Synagogue, at its own cost and expense, will provide a personal injury insurance policy, with the 2600 Island Boulevard Condominium Association as a co-insured, comparable to the insurance coverage provided for the 2600 Island Boulevard building's common areas and party room. (17) Special Events Must Be Hosted bv Williams Island Residents. All special events. as noted above. held at the Synagogue must be hosted by a member of the Synagogue who is also a Williams Island resident. 11 /r?J7 /2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG '" 05fl35ll02610011305466327?ll NO.S61 (;1003 . APPUCANT REPRESEHTAllVE AFRDAVIT , ......tDSeclIaft l1-7tlllll2llll.. ClrOl,.,.... Ln OMllpIII$I' CodI, .. ,"*-1lIp.___ AIIilMIll ...,.........11 . 1lII......4.......1ep~. -..arlllhlll.hll___IarIllDl. . fll"..... IlllIl:hil..........-.....a ~l~ ,. ......-....PRIPIdrMjolttD... -rf?' .1lM'4IIIonnIherwbvlsllllld 1iledes....-.....-.u...hIMduIIOf_~Iar.. 0eIl.....""" .......~. 1lI~ ulollow5: ".",. Clifford A_ Schulman ~""~---.a....., MIlloca e.-.......... ft:.1 Attorney Mario J. Garcia-Serra Attorne'\1' Please see attached list (MldlMII_ 1I$111l11"lllllll)\ IlOtlCe: NItt STAlBIENT 01 ._. ,..,,1101I IIAIlE 8Y MY PBISOII ustED 011 lItE AI'l'UtMff IIEI' I 1A11VE MADAVlT SIW.I. II ~ WON 1lIE IIlMIlUAL <<II EIRIJY APPl.'MG FC1111lIE DeVIUIPIIIHf I'EIII1' AIIl1llE OWIER qF lItE lIU8.IE!tl' tIlIIiI ~.I T. APJIUCAInS AIlD AfRAIl1S ARE MI\WD 1'01lIELY S1I'lUIII!Kr 1IIS AFRDAVlT I'URSUAIl1' 1'0 SEe st-11(11lC1111W1 IF lIE CItY'8 WI! ~ 1IlGI1!..A1IOIlS II11E QTT COE, 11M EYEIIT11fATPRIOR 1'0 ~..... OF 111I AJIIIUCl1lON 8Y 1lIE em 80MII OR CC*UlSSIOft. TIE 1NFOIlIIA1lOIt PfIOVlOElllllHE AffIDAVIT UCOIlES INOOIlIII:CI <<IIINCOII'LETE. . WI'IllfSS MY IWlO 1ttS _DAY OF AU11tOAIZBII\l:l . .4L../TA1NE OF API'I.ICI.NT: .3lOI. .,.- . /SfIDlMJ fPdrII. ,.. By: 1k AdihGII: aehan Lewingar I'tWI ~ VP & r.h*i~n of Bld2. Committee ~ 4000 Island Blvd., PH 4 Aventura, Fl 33160 &rAlt! OF R.QIW),\ I ClOIMY OF IINII bAD!:) ... - ...lIIldIralpld......, .111111III; "'I_ 1Il"1IllIlDrtI8d 1Ipl_1lIIw III the f4lpbnI aIdIr lit - at.. ~.. tD .. ~.\ . bIhJ IIlIIIrt lit GIIr IWl\, lid .... afIrm ... he/IhI tletWId.., NIdlhtIIar lit pIIJIOS88 sIlIIed .....frllllhll.ls M frlllClllleCt. 1- SWORIllO ANI> SlIlSCtllBED II!fUlE ME Ills" dlyal 0 lU.-.e"1 . c:ARLOS !ASA'"e .-,---",- , ..,c.._ . ~Odlll._ c.._. . DDDUISS ~~. =-~E=~~ 11/07/2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG 7 05035#026t00~3054663277" HJ.861 0004 ADDlicant ReDreseBtative AfDdavit (conliDned) Michael Y. Cannon Stephen Seeley )tamar Goldenholtz Bernard Desjardins Real Estate Expert Surveyor Architect Interior Designer tl/E17/2003 1&:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG 7 05E1~02&tElEln3054&&3277n NO.B&l G>E1E15 C l,\f",( -a BUSINESS RELAT10NSHIP AFmAvrT" ~.~ ...- WI L. \..1,qWU -'" SL/+...,i) ...................... III SIclIan S1.11~at....~ at..... Und D.. I ...-4llol1l1. 1110 ~ ,NIIam IlRby dildalellIIIII:.... Will y IQJIi> oIIil1o...... n,J l{1. --IISI-.~ ~.... ..,_oI...CIy OlmlloI.".......,Qr~ 1IoInl1llllllicll.. r.' 'I.wtllse~ 1)2. ~ """*"....... 1-"" _. ..... RoIIIIllMIIlp", . ___ "'111I ~ CommissIon or a c-a, 1\dIIbaIy1laul1o wIli:lI..~,.... ~ II ""-' l\.iIl- 01 Q....b..1 ,ar 01 MliIay I!oIIlI UIsIIIlIIl who _ III ilIl l\.iIl Cly ClwIU.I <<' ctIy M/rr:rf bd ~ INclI IIIl!IIIbar -~ TIle _ "''''1lusi-.1loIIIionIl1Ip ..1oIoE II L MImIlII III Qr I)...oiwb, or 1IoInl... ........,.. InIef8Sl in _ III 1% 1II_ assail or CIllIIIllIlcIcol~arAepe...M.., I] i. MImIlII III Clr Q\J..niItt.II or IIIlInI il . pi/tIIr, ~ (as 1II1Nns 01 . corposalIan _ ..noI........,_......_ ....1_...... io01l-....... W<-1Ior IlIpno; "'il.,,~ VIlIUt; II iI. Tho ~... Ri,....AIiWtM II. CIonI d. _ Q/... CIIy ea........ or lloelll.... Client a1_.._b_ i...--.iloIn............ orlllr"_""'. "_dtllO ca,c....,,;..;..,or bd; 11iv. AO!ro..,.,oil.i\oOlW ar_membar ls.QieltCllIll ~orRefll-*M; Ilv. 1110 lfpIcInIor ~...._ II. a......... "'lie_a! "'" cay QIa..... at 1looId+x III hit Dr.... ~ IIld _........, $10.000.00 01......... 01... ......G1.. Oly CllnInAon llI' IIoInl (GrillOt liar"""'" In a IIMft calendar rear. 11vi. 1IIo1llllllllar"..Qrc...... ,..lIiJanIiI;.c-""AppIiCanIGr~_""1Ild lIIIlIaclI_ ... t25JlOOOO al .. IMtlIsS 01 III ~ or ... 11IM. II a ~ --!filii'. WIINESS MYIWlD'nIS_ DAY OF AI'I'IJCANT: . 2DlIJ Ilr; *'* llII: ~ (I'linI) lPIWJ WIn E MY IWCllllS_ DAY OF I'AOPEIIIY atHJl; . 2llO3 BY: NIlIe: TIt:. /Sfgl...." ~ AiIO ~........... - 4- -cIInr.- ~.-AR*R.. ....--,.."...." ~ 1'II!nron"......., JrI "'MlSd..Al1IlIUIIctlyeaa t 1/07<2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 050~026100"3054663277" NO. B61 1>1006 , rSl4N\'") 1...>IlLl~ 5 WI1NEllSMYIWIl'MS~ DAVOF ~ .. AlbA. .oIj.1lIIIoIMl .,. Ilr jSijrIIUlI IlImI: C ifford A. .... /I'ItfJ ,... Attorney IPIWJ 'hill: IPIttO IIr; /Il4lo......) Ilr /SflplIUe ,.., 8'IiII) NImf: /I'ItfJ TilE IAtlO lie; iI'IIttI Ir: -..., IlJ: fSiw I. -- IfI1InII ... /NIO TIIII; IAWJ Tile: ~ Ilr (liiJIIItn,I Br. (SIg...a.. 1111.1 (PrRI r"._.~ fAWJ Tk (PJinI) 11110' (AinIl By. lS/8o-eJ Ilr; (SIpBft -- IPiInO - IP/IrI1 l'k .. 'llIIO: ("'*'0 It(. --- lIr- ~ 111mI' /AtllI ....., (I'rtIJ - (PJinI) ,... IAiII) 110II: 1) UN.........". ."'.. l' farbp... ..-..... 11..,,1 .......... _..... II....., - .. . ll11U.......-1D _ UolI{IIIllIM..1It CIIfI....."..ll' IA L . r ....CllrCll*,....-lIlIIpdIr........ . "'..... d "'lltcar....~IL. . .1It11 '1 p"'lIIII...................~ar. ,-It. t1/07/2003 t&,0t GREENBERG TRAUR I G .. 051'l3Slll1l2&tl'll'lll3054&&327711 !J./II..LI1'~Y\S nl(}.,lS::> 1IOI'&RI!A'IIONMCf~ 5fIIl:IM1O.- . _11'_ I .allaYOIwr,... -.................,........-, -- --...-"..---...-.......- ..-. ......._.... _"_._Ilol - _lllMII.... IIM._..6;o_...... aDO Il*r--..-..... --.... "'-. IIlGClf_1 aucrrf#WttI ~ -.... ..........---"-"'" ...............,.......,.,.............,11..."".... lie -....... .."............... Ill"''' ARWrf ~ti____~_~___. _I ..,--.-....... --,,~ Mr.....~ - ~ _CF!lGIIIll I CDIII"IGf'''1I\08 -.... -.....".......- ... -. .........,....,-.. -.-.. ---....---...........- . ; I I I ! l - _Ill_to.. ___IIIt_...... .., ---.-..... --".., ur-." NO. B&t 1;>007 11/07/2003 16:0t GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ B5B~02610B~3054663277~ NO. 861 (;1008 AU~ 20. Q2 12103, \V\().~ ; p.8 - . BUSINESS RELATIONStIP AFFIDAVttt 11IIs M*d Is llItlI8 pIIISUtN ~ Sedlan 3HIlbl(2l(llllC" ClrGf AIIelIIln land OeullllllMll Code. TIle ~""..d NIlIlIl ~ flC' ....11llI:...... 'It" 1IIflIc1\11 poItIan$ 0llIrI ; ~1. ~ (If. AIIiIlnl does IIllI haw llIusNss 1Ill1alll1. ...... NIIber of lie a, QlIloI . ,""...1Ily Cly AIhlsory Iloa1dlOtNllIclIllefl,- - ~...bt...&-1tId. Al/'llfll_br dscIoses Ilall does haW allult1ess 1lIlallDnshIp'" a..... 0/ lie car CommIsIlDn \If a ClylolMsolylloeldlO........./lI'* "bep!llI.~ulalbn: . PI- 01 COmlllloolW \If ~ 1l9InI........,. _ Oft lie lIJsI cay 000.... er <:If MllIarr IIDInI \fOIl ... ...... ItlVNj. ~ The naIln ol.. 8usIaus n Irl~\ShIp Is u IrAlwI: II L MenH' ol ClIrOllm1lsaloA \If Iloant haliIs 11I-' ~" __ ol 1% Gf..... or capilli sb:IlGf AjIpbllar........taII~ III. .......... CIl CIr CDmIIltIlDn ar IloanS Is a plRtIr. ~ !at b II-. Gf a 0Ql....40. 1ttt*Il..1d.... 01\ anr IIlIIOIIIIl arlegiOllllllock .1IIlII) -1*........... #.ppIcaIter ........M..In........ vtIlUe; IIi. The ~ Dr fIot,...e.....t Is a CIelt 0I111lO11l11er 01.. QIJ o-..w:.. erllollld ar 1 CIeIC aI enot>er ...A~ -"'"0 110m.. _olIce or far tIe_ ......,., IS lie '-01 lie CllyQ.,.,""""'or8lllnl; "ell' ConItllssIollef or lloeId........, is a CIIlC Ollie....... Dr ~1IIliW; The ~or ft.,....st.i\iIillls a CunxMrof lie memIleI ollie ClIr CI._ II ilIA or Bon (or 01 Ills or M' t(~ IIld R1A* __.... S10,OQO.ClO Gf '" __ of lie IMlIlIIIr 01.. Cly CoIlI1Ilsslon\W Bon lorllll orller ~ kll...... alIadIJJIIIl: II~ The .mer of lie Oily CIlmmls$Ianar lloIrd Is I OusIomeIGf lie ~ar ~ and llInsal:ls _I IIIIl $2S,OOO.OO ollie __ of tie ~ or 1llIpNs.,.&a.... kl . ;wen ...,... WItNESS IoftlWlOlHlS_DAYOF l!llO1_ Iliv. IJ~. '; . , . N'PUCRfT: Br. MIme: ,. (S/JlnIIrnI fFd1I;I fFd1I;I WITlESS NYlW<<llHlS _O#.YOF PAOPERlYO\'HR: .... ..,. NIl1W' .... 2AlOl. (S4JnI/lRJ !/'ItIt fFd1I;I .' "llltlRlt.....~. 'UerII,' ~~.~. 'Rllp.~""'.IIId'lnlllMld l'ttIItlII' _ MNd In Selllbn.. of"'...... CIlr eoa. 11/07<"2003 16:0t GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 050~026t00"3054663277" NO. 861 (;>009 ~u". eo 02 U!: 03, . . ,.5 wm8SNYHAN01M8 LDAY 01' N" 111';.-, ~f!r .!lllIi :3 f1B 1lES9fTA1M!: \lJsttdGII ~"""'~MldMlII (lly. ~J.J~-AA"'" By: (SCnI/tR ~ fPltlO "* AHof'\eY ~ l1lle' tI'rWJ By. ~ llr: ~ ...... (PlI/II/ ~ lAtIO llIo: jNIIJ 1k (AIII.I By. --- By: ~ Ilnl' ~ .... IPlW) "* ffIIitJ tie: ~ Ilr. ~1 llr: (S9IMn ....- IN1lI Name: IMICl ,., - l1Ie:. (PrtII1 By. ~ lIy; ~ -- (PrtII1 NaIne: ffIIitJ 1lIr. (I'IWJ T.... (HnV lit- ~ By: ,..... MImI' P'ltlI1 ...... NIU .., ,...., lie: /I'rInO IlO1E: 1) Use cJupIicalt slleels. dIIclocUlllInfo..... tor 1\$f.Jt.tJs.aw__ II AppIoItM IIld AlIiatlIInllMstd " ....., IUpIIenIeIIlI1ls Allldntl flUlllIIIlt" a.c. '''71(1t)(2Xlvt " Ihe CIty'I t.IIIIII o.4e1opoR1dllkgulalloM IIllhe car CVcIe,ln.. ..,.lhaI.....1o _IILJIJR 01.. IpplllllllOll IIylhaClly IIoud or ConItlIIIIIIII, 11M w-aaan PIO'Ided In'" ~~alMllncllnctor InooIIple\e. . 11/1'17/2003 16:l'It GREENBERG TRAlJRIG .. 1'151'l35ll1'126tl'll'lll30546632'7'71l NO. 861 GlI'l10 '''.1.,2.0. 02 121 oap p.4 nl1IOFfUlllIIA I llCIlHrfOFMlIlioIIEI 1:1.' r:. . .{"f.;'A ........., ..""........................ In ....rc.Q ............lIIII._~_._.llhhl -................................................- ~~. 'L -:f~ -'" Ilm'AIIlU1IlIN PIlII. .... )( _lONDlIllIlIClllEIl...... '19iilXKI 'ON NOIS5DO'llXl YCIIIO'H ~ !l.l.YlS:lI'IilI.I ~dN.l.1OI\'Q ;ION . 1tA1I0FfUlllIIA I ......1If1IWI1INIEI __"II"II~ ~.IIIIWIIWo"""'__ ................"'......-_.............10.....- .. A-. ............,. "" _ - -..-... N'MIf _1011I)........................._... ..... .....,......lIff'IIdIlAlIqo 1'IloIIlI"'''",*, .., ".: IfMEW IUIMIA I ClllllIIITWlMI__ -:'1ii':i11T....-....---- ........... .................--........- .. -........ rnt.,. __61_.._'" N'I'WlT _10 4lNl,,__......_... _. "_~"AIIIIIlIAllIIve .....-.... _Ill': 11f ~~ - rrA1EOFfUlllIIA--l COUllITCIf III' _...... _,....--,..~__ ...,............. MlIIlllIar.._...."""'..............- ..-.-.....-.,..- --..-... NMIf _104lNllJUlllCMl!D-......_.,.. lOlIt. .' llIlIyNllo..Il...IC.... ...taI.... ""III Iml.l~.r tl/07/2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 05035U026100"3054663277" Awe 20: 02 12:03p -- . . . BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFRDAVrr l1IIs AIlIdalll15l1l1de plnl8I1llo SecCIan 31.l'ltIIM a11he ~ aI AiIInIIIa WlI Or IIIIlt)1M111 CGcII. ThelWllllsIQ.led Mn ItIrIlly disdosa I18t 'i'! wi! or:..."".,. podians onM .... ~.~'doIIlllll- allldless,~ _ iII'/ llllIlI1berol \he ClIr ea.r' . oft or...ClJ M4iIoIy , <t 1\ lIoallllo wllttl... ~Iln wi be pr.-.s. \.. I J 2. AIIiarA hel8br disclo- ".-1Ia\'e allllllnu$ ~ .........,.,... Cily Coft1mlssIon or a ~ AiMfort llaIrd 10 wllttl\he.. . - .....n wi lIe...-ud..1aIows: .- __ 01 c...... . ... or MtftIato/ llotnI """""4- _ on \he (Us! <:Iv eo. . 'I~ or CIy AIMsory IloaId upan -.h1ch membar ... seM$\. The nalUnl ol" llUSWlSS RIlIIIlanst1f Is as loIows: III Member 01 CiW 0-. . l'l'l Olllaaldholds.. ~ ~ iI_ 011% oltJ1lllSStlscr mpItaIlloct aI A;Iplic8Itor~.boIi._ Member aI CIf' 0anunissilIn or 80eAJ is . ..mer.lllHIhaNhlllIlI (as to sllam III · """"".... 'Iftillrllllllt islIId OII.."MIIanaIGrIegianll sIOCk e.d'oaage) Gr......... III ~Gr ~_AllI~ 1II11W1IuIlnllA-..: 111. II i. The AjIjIcanl or AejlI IIUIIs. ClIIlUI & IIlIIl1ber 01.. CIy CclnInIs*ln or IloIRI en Client cllIlCIIheI plllleSI10nlII wcd<il911llm tie AIM cIllce or 101... -1l\lIllDV8r . tie -.bet ClIhe CIy Oannlsslon 0I8a11d; II ii, A CIy c.....oisslolleror IloIld member is a ClientCftle AIJIlbnt OIIb"am.illIliie; I J~. The ~orR\o.__"Is. C._oIt1ememberol"'CllyOonlmilliaa or Boalll foro! his or bar emplayel) IllllIInInsal:ls _ .. $I0,llOO.00 Of... ~ 01.. -- allloe Cily ClIt11l'Iis$\oItOl' IIOIld (or his or 1Ier""'" In...... caIIlndaryear; 11~. The _ ol lie Clly COmmISsllla Ol' 1loanI1s. QlSlomar ollie ~ 01 RljlmelIIiIM and Rnsacl$ _ thin *'5JWl00 of tie buIlness or .. #flIlIcaIII or R.,..~.w.. .. · giwln calondlIr,w. WI1NESS MYHANDllitS :l\~DAYOf ~tllGJ. "- II'l'I.I:HfT: WITNESS MY HAND 111lS _DAY OF ~lo(OWNER: .ZOO1. By: Name: llIIr. fSignatIIvI IPItII,I (PJt1O .' 'JlII1IImr '8r/SIle$$ ~. UenI,' "Q/SIMIer,' .~. ~ - 'InIM,lId PMifId' .... cIeINd .. SeeIlan N9S rlfteAWIIIlIIII ccrCode. NO.B51 1;1011 / p.3 I .' , " , , ! " I I , , , t 1/137/2003 16:13t GREENBERG TRAURIG 7 0513~026100"3054663277" NO. BIOI 1}012 ,AUI 20-02 12:03p . . p.s WIlNEISSMYIW01llIS 1.!. DAY OF ~rmf 5> ~~~- ~ (SGna/ln : chae " . Cann NIme: IfIIillJ lllle' (PrWJ lk lPltfI By. (Spn,I By. (S/gIllIaIt IlInIe' (PItIII NamE IPMIJ , Tille: (PrtIO ..... iPIIntI By. (S9Ia&nI By. ~ ~ /PIiIO ....- (F'dIO ~ jFIinIJ TlIllr. ,.., By. ~/ By. /S9IIIlI8 - II'ItItJ IL jPIiIIJ llIE jFIinIJ me: IMIIJ By. IStlJnafuw1 By. /S4InIIn - lNtII ~ fI'IW1 ~ /PIInIJ TIle: II'ItIIJ By. ~ By. ~ lIIme:. IPItiJ - IPMJ .... /At1O .... N NOTE: 1) UledulIlclII"heeIJldIKto._.!afQ4 -'lIlIforAlp._""narlK II AppliGalds and AIIIanIs we IfMsed III...., lUlIPIe_lhls AIIldnIl pInWlIllllllec. 21-7t(bl(Zl(IvI 01 !he CIy'I Utld OIltllpNlt&" I r ~1S IIIlheCllJGIIde,..lbenealthllpdlrlll_IdIlL.an"....ffft-....., br lite caw Boanl 01 ColIlmlssloIl.Ibe lIlfomlaton pI\I'itlIed In tit AIlidftlIlleco_ ~ or lIIcomplele. tl/07/2003 16;01 GREENBERG TRAlIRIG .. 05035ll026100113054663Z7711 t-IJ.B61 OOt3 ,R~E.~O:02 12:03p p.4 NOTAIIIlA1ION PROVISlDN x: aAt1!CIfIUlllllto I ~(II.n.DIOEl Michael _....... I . ... '"' ......,............- -_....~"'..._............,....II......- Y. 1=~n ~.,._orl.....h1 -' ,. ~J.1-* ... W:0IIllIS81llIl,CC_15 ., "~r'~_"'- : ~;__ nw...,,..... , STAlEClfIUlMlA I .-.m'CIfloUlHNll!l _..... - I \ '1 .................... __....MIdloIIot................................,OIlIlIll ..--. ...~.....,....._ oIil_or_1IlII - lWlllIIlO/II).I&sr.- ._....._... 1IllI1. ~__"~H"'" --"'"'*" _u ......... m1!CIf~ I OOUIIlYCIf IInJIIMIl!I -..... .......................,-- __...._tor..._tIiloil_""'....II...n1- .. -........... ... '" 011.... _ oIil..... or....... - _10_"_[ IE~'__"'_"'" .11I01. NMI'__.._A1.... .....-..., lit .. _JlI __CIfILOllll\ I COUIIIYClfllUlllllllllil .......... -Jil...........,.~....- .............-."'..___...11II1..""'11III_ ...- ..........,....., ---..-.... - SWOIlIllO NIl SIllS<: ._..INt__1l 20111. .' ...,.NIc....AllIIlaAl..... ............., 1Iy_ . _JIr 11/07/2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 05035U026100~3054663277U 11/07/2883 14:51 9547423893 GOLCENHOLZ & A5SOC 1lI1?tCJilJ 111'41 IiifBiBER6 T~l\i 1 ",11l'l'784~1'354?4ZJB'3JII 11III CO, . IltR, ~. r+~...-- ND.861 (;1014 PNX. 82 Nl. ;I]) IlIII2 ./ 1U118. ~AFfI)f.'IR" ".' ...............to.....t~"..lIIr"-'"a.o..1"" ...4011dt, nun 1....4_"" ..........._'1".............. {" 1(,", _dalllIIIl_ll__-" - "\ ._.......af -" ..,-,..., ~ ........................... \. III ....,_.............n ~.......".._o....' ... -.....,..........................- ...._..~ J 1_.,..,11..-.....-_.... PI_ t . " ., _ .... .... ... .. ..... .. ..... .....".......... r "li ..-- III ........CIIiI t l' ........................._,,~........ ........,.....Jt,. .- -" . III. ....lIartl ., ......II&......P.--~..lJ....UI' T ..-.....,-r.-1 ................ .~.h..I............ R..- 1_ I........... (II. 'llII......-. .. It.CIIII".~.."__ll . 1"1 ...~CM".. 11.....................-.....- -....... - -~.... . AlIIr{' r' ...........UIlI........RIII-. .. - 1lII--a'l ....IIaCllllllllllr"...........ClIwt .~ ......tor. _.... ...___...1llI*".................. 11 I' .....IIIIIIfljI..... .II. b. _. II. '11II......._0.--.. ........~.........nJ. . 1M --.......".............,- ....- .......... . lIW..._..2-lIM'Of 1ooL:l""'~iL ..., Illv- II... ""''''1WID1ltI_IlI.'tOf ~_.LI CIItlM '; I ... r .. l :=...=~....-' ., ,----,..-..---. d tl/B7/2003 16:01 11/07/2003 14:51 l1-e?~ 19,41 GREENBERG TRAURIG .. B5I1l35ll0261001l305466327?1l 9547423093 GOlDENHOLZ & ASSOC 6REEI<<Ila TRR.RIG,~ ~1~Ul'3547qJ0';'. ... n 01 ll10lJp . . _......1lII.:L_~~...J :r;.~r.~l1rlf ......... ( , _~~.tI" ~ ~ ... ~ ... ...... .. -... .. .1>. ,-.; I. *" .. ... r ... - 17. I .. .. i I "" .,.. -. 4 lIr: .. II.. NIt - ~- - ~ -.., 'lV"- .. -- --. "1'1/ .. ...... lit ... - ...... .., .. ... ,Fl - .. .... n - -= '.............r- "11I1111II111 -Ill.-. m -,,- ............... .IIl1i1led ....1 __" .I..................::!!:?.. Wi........ " J ,- - -. ..._-~ .t:'-- ......jIlIIr1tnl.!!...:!J.... ".._.....,ll lLl......'. ,rr 11I..-....-. .' II NlJ.B51 PAGE 63 r-Q.9Ji GllIIil3 t;l0t5 ,.1 . 11/07/2003 16;0t GREENBERG TRAURIG .. 050351102610011305466327711 11/87/2883 14:51 9547423893 GDLDENHOLZ & ASSOC . ""Uf"CItIW.J IIIg;q,l, ~r:.d\Dt:t(b 1~111 .. ~Urt'1Q4~1I1'>1'/4~,~,J1 NO.861 fJ016 PAGE 8a i'U.'!I.Jb i,'~-1 .u.....O.... ...08p .... """..l fit MIIY..... 'X___ Gc>ijt..!t.I1a. .................-.,......-.:... &.....,1Ul'.__._....f11 __... 1.......--_......... ~ X JI.., ..... _...-.~-~ 'l L' ,ce_ . . ......~_..'* .-.-.:a:&.... '11 I, \.' . '. . . ........, _ ~~T' ....- ~~r-:":''="_.. ..-...--....-.-...... - __'JII1__.._'" ._ ,-.. .......---... :rt"~". ......., _...;.,t,iMI~~~.-=r....._ ..-.............,....-..-..-... IIIlIIIIA' _....III1.lLJ_.._.... .... =...--.....r ...~.._II... ~ ....,0 ".... _~:,,~~~.i,;,.!.~.._ .........."....-.-.-... - __M11II1I' .1_..._..... ... ." .,IW..__ (;f' ...... ~~ 11/07~2003 15:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ B5035U026100~3054663277U NO.8S1 ~17 / :-. 305 861-9934 p_2 ~.sm ~ ,.3 Nov.as 03 07:49p 11/05-'03 15:02 RUf ID.D! IIID3p DDG GREENIfRG TRlUlIG . :l0S ~l 9934 BUSINESS RB.A1lOH&ItP AFFIDAVIT" 1llII.............--'" CeM'I-7Ittl121f1a1.. CII\''' _1MI 0..111. II. !a. 111I11"""'. AIIlIDt..."" .................................. 0lIIiI r HI, ..... III.'''''' nL' - N1.......".Iec:trCl - - ....carMllGlr . ......oHiiIItlt lI,.rdIA......... \.. IIf. -llnIlIr.....--.- - . - .........II..ca,Clllllradl..,. tIt~......tNr:tt.. .: .If............... foIII-.;' t . . '1 trM.JlOl\'....IIlIlIDIIt...._..... IIIl CIIr 1:1 nblll,.. ctr -'''' _ -- .. .... '" ......... .....1IeII1. ~'r lI.loIIM: III _"CllrC . I .__.............._..I'lo..lIIII...... ...."........f1I, II bf Ii IIi. .......oI~~ . ~'.lIl111llu.....1I' l' .. """'''1 IU All 1IIlIdl.... ..::::;.............................. -............ n,...UIR111..... --- ~ II'" "'~arllll . ..IIa.CIelII......,...CttC I .ulllll.......ClMIlI .......... 1 . ........... _........ _....,. 1&............. ClII Cot,_ M trBllllll; I\ClrCl.. _ . . 1lII................CIeII.......II'R...I. 4'l.~ 1III~ar""" 1 '11U~...._III"'Glro.._" .-...... ...... ",1IIlIImI)_ _____ Stt.IIGIltO ,"'........ II... .......11I.. lay 1:1 1'1~".""\II"."''''''''II''''''''' "''''CIIr~' ....... II 1011III* al....... ...........1IlII _.... twmao.... _ II... __. _II l"11 to.... .. ---.DA'lOF ..1. 111. n... n~. .2llOI. ........nOWNeA: :... ,.., =.. .... .' ~"'::::':'::'.J''':''''CIiIIIl..'''''.'~''_''T. .1&""'''" 11"...........,61 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 05035"026t00"305466327?" 305 851-9934 11/07/2003 16:01 DOG Nov.05 03 07:49p . 11/05J03 t5:02 GR[EN!Il;IlG TRlUlIG . ]:IS lll;1 9934 I ~ .IG. 01 l~IO!ll1' . . ~." .,. lbill ,. ." III - ,. If, ,- - . .. Ib I ... II' I" ,... OF Nwe",bef' .Dl.J Br: -- ~ .. .... ,. fIIItI -'M" ." -- CMI 'Iar. NIO """ ..... (I'IIlO ~ I II ." -- - IIIJ'- .. .. ,. ... iIgIIaMII e,; ,....... ~ rill 1 .., "., ,. ptIIoO iSJ)AJII lIJ; ....... ......, .... ...... 4I'IWJ ,. ...... ,-..41 IF- -- .. ,..- .. "". ,. .. IDlE: tI ____......aiJIllll.... -..... 1 1 ....... ~ ..._............-.....1 .1IIt.....__"....~ ~'::=~~-:II!J.- -:.:rf"==::;:=~1 ll':"'::::~ ~,':l!I ,.5 N1),B51 p.4 aIilJ GlmB 1t/07/2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 05035n026100R305466327~ Nov.OS 03 07:45p DDG 305 861-9934 , Il/!l$IllJ 15:02 Iit:E~R6 TRIUlIG . 115 ~l 9914 ~C,~O.lIt 1210a" ---MId --- ................~~;~ . ,~ ---....- ........... ... )(' _1V"~. ......I....L... ,.~. =-~ 1::s~1 -............--........... ......-........................................ ....lO_T ~...._.._... __1UIIIIIIl , .......-r.. .....-=-'1;t'~.:1 r~.~r' ~__ _to..... --__frC _:=..I 1M _,.. .....,..........__= '..",......_....___.. 1""_ .....aD.... 11!......._.. .... ..,,-..-........ ftJ.587 ,.4 ................. ....,,_.. ---... - .... ........tiM...... .-......., ...-~. .... -.......,... tIt_____... - ..... ...,....~.,,-.... .--..... '- .. 111' ..__......,..._._.._11II -..-. ......"IIrlllUI... --...... .... - " NO.B01 p.3 DI!4 I}01,) -- r t [ I I , 11/07/2003 1&:01 Aue' 20, 02 12 t D3p - . GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 050351t02&1001130545&3277tl NO.B&l Gl= p.3 ,/ BUSINESS RELA110NSHtP AFFIDAVIT' This MdM Ii made plnUlri tl SIc:Iion '1-71\bX2KII 01... cay Gf AvI*a IMld DeveloplIlent <lode. 'The tRI8l$igrled "'11enby ~ht(lMlt wit ~ .......... padIons ~ .. dles I!ll have a lluncs ~. fIrf lI18ft'IberGf" ClIJ Coak.6.tl.c or lIlY cay MiIsuy 8clIlII1,,,,Ncll" .1' - n..... flI""" r ~1, ~ \.- 112. Mant heleby dscIoUs IlaII deJa 11M a llUsNss r " - -lOll'" ...allllJl*r Ill.. Cily 0IIIvntssl0n or a CiIy MrisarJ 1lclanI....... .................... ~ eslDlows: lU5lnamalll Com..llliloter or ~ ~ t.IImbao).no serves an tie (UIt Cir 00nIA0lssl0n fK CitY MIIl1tr IIclInI .,. IlhIlIl member ~. ., (Ii. The nature Gf thellusMl$ AliI r~ II as faIlWs: III IIi. Iliv. IIv. Ueol1berOlCilyOllll.... or 80aId Ilalds.. ......"''''......In __ all% alWlaIISSelI fK CIfIIal RIck (If AppIicIrllor ",,"_ Idlll; MemlIar (If Cir Q....o~1 fK IlO8Id is . pamer. llIHIw II . fa.' (at " ... 0/ . GOqlOIatilllI whIllh..lIllllsIId. -.NIIillllIII or..... stacie ..d..'IJIII or Jah...... III Applcart fK ~....ln8l'lJ''''''''wnIIn; The AppIeanI or Rep.....~ Is a ClieIC 0/ allt8Alber GIlle CiIy c........... or IIcl.u or. CIlIIt oIll1ll1ler .tslIlcNI__........ _ oIlice 0( far...........1IIeaIber 0I1he carc.....lnllllor8oanl; A CIy cr..........er IlIIloan1 membIr is. Clianlalllll APl*R or 1lIlnl'lIlltve; The AppIcart ar Repe$enliIlIVe Is a cumner Ill.. member ollie ClyCGow,....... or Iloo1d (or aI his ar IIIr t1~ II1d RlsaCl$ __ $10,000.co ollie ___ ollie...... ollie CIty Cl...llissll.l ar IloanI (or lis Ill" ~ ilia gMln calendar year; The __ oIIIeCltyQA,~1 It '~.or Board Is a CUsIomerGlIheAppbntOlI\epreselllaliv end hnsads _ ..... $2S.llOO 00 of lie llusln8lls cI the #tIIIlC&Ill or fIIlnIlIIIllIIwl In a tiven oaIeI*,.... II~ WfTNESS MY HANIllHlS _DAY OF N'I'l.C\HT: Dr. tIaae' 'Ale: BJ: 1111I. ,.., .2llO1. 2001. ~, IFmII /PIWJ .' "lIlI1Ilms ~ fIeIa/IaIIIIItl" Uerr." 'tlIsIDmIr." ~" ~ Md tiIIesred PttJtlIf' IIll d8Wd il SIl:IcJn Nf5 ol..AwnIIMa Cllt'00de. . ..-...:. .~, ~~-,-,---"'.."- 11/07/2003 16;0t GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 051'l~02611'l1'l"3I'l5466327?" NO.Bol "'021 p.5 AU, 2~ O~ 12:03p WlMSSlIYlWI>llIS r;fi OAYOF~-t3 IIa .&alTA1M':(\JIleOGII ~Rodll~~ '/..",. (S/gIIab'el ~ (li/jpIIflI'f ..... Jules Trump IP!W1 IPrW1 U8: ~ 1lle: (I'ltl/l ",. fSltPute} By. ~ ......., (PltIIl naml' ~ ~ (l'IWJ llIIe: /PlWI ",. ~ By: /Sf/IfIIIft .... lMd1 H... I IFrIIII 111: IAtlCl U8: /I'Ii1O Ilr; ~) By: lSflInalllt I~ /PlfnO tlBt. IPlil(} 11Il!: "'*J TOr II'rtIII By: ~l IIy; (Si1IIalIn It -. II'rinll ~ IPlil(} ..., /NlI) ,. IPIfnI) Br. CSlgnIIIIftl By. ........ ".n /PlfnO Nant. (I'lttJ 111: IPIIII) Tile: tpIt10 l101E: t) lIIe _Ild,1IIIIII1 dl$da 111ft Ida lIIl1t'lIIlarlllpnsenlllM..... II AppIicInls IIld AIr... nlMled IolimelJSlWl:m Ill''' AIlldMlplllS\llllllo See. ~"71(b)(1llv) oIlhe Cllfs lind ~Jlllltt 1IIlI1I1lhW III lie CIy COde, In" ~..... pdar tI>> ~l&lIkn\lOII at lIuppllcallon by lie car &o.d ..^---~_Iht 1nfGIIaaIIoII...~,1ded In lie AIIIcInIt .....Incornot or 1lIeoIaplele. 11/07/2003 16;0t GREENBERG TRfUR J G .. 05l'l35ll026tOO"3054663277" NO,861 ""'22 A~C,~O 02 12:03p po" _flFlUIIIIIA , CllUlft'IflFlINIllIIIEl __~_"4A_"""_ .,",.. .~_.-, ddtt--.4I'iI...1I'''tw.t ....... -*1...--............11IIoI......................- _lO_lIUlI&tllln'lt_,,",'Z.2-...~~ ~ ~~'''A ,,,}n A ,4'/Ita. llowIl Eo A<tInIIaII J ~ 1JoIA" ' W""".i:~ MYcctltllSS1Oll'CQ!l8IElII'IIIES __"_M""" . . , SepIeIIIber 2<1, 2003 .", ......._""'............."'" -......-, ,.. .., .. ........ NOTAlllD18I PROVISION X. srAJEClfI\Clllllf. , .ccum""M:rl1~ ...... .... to II .. II....,.,...,....... .......-..-"'......---...............- ..-....~......-- -... -..-.... - _10_..... : '__IlIS_..,. lllOI. -,__olAoOdlMLIIgo __ol.., ." .. ....l SfMEClflUllD I ClIIlIIIYClf_1lIIIEl ........ ""'lI"" ......" _It-' ......._.._""........__..11II.....-- ..-....... rnr.,. __ _M_.__ - IllOlIITONIl"-::III8'_.IlIS_dlyol 2IlD1. -'_~ol_N.""" __ol....., tAr .. lll11 WJl!OF lUIlD , I CClIIIlTClf.....fINlil _.,"lId ....'1-*1,..........-- _-.......MlIhil"".._..w_............._ ..-...... rnrll\'...., -.... _._1IIt ~ &V<<lRIllO_~_",*,__a1 2lIOI. o. .....,__a1f1ol11alll""" MolId....G1-, .., 1 I I '01 11/07/2003 16:01 RU; 20 02 12:03p . . - . . . . GREENBERG TRAUR I G .. 05035l10261001130546632TI1I NO. 861 1]023 , p.3 BUSINESS RELAOONSHtP AFFIDAVW l\lIS NIicIiWlI$ made~ III SedIan 3t-71MC2l(i1 oIll1Clyol Menba Und O'_...d Code. The II1CIenigned AIIianI hereby _hit: tIlIIl<....... ~1Il" podions onIrI AIliri does IIll hM .1Ml*S R.I ti .1SNp llIIIq IIlIIIOlr 01. cay Q....J 11ft or IIIJ cay hHeort lloIldlO'llhIclIlht ..,f.dln will blI ,II~olId. ~ hInlby di$doses 11aI'- '- a Bumess R,' 1Il..sI", wiIh allllllOlr 01111 Cllt 0aIMllul0n or a cay AdYlIoIy IlOIlIIIIll ".IlII!1,.fo rll wi blI..... as IalIDwS: . fJsI..... of Coi, III': IIIf or Miri4rt lIoanI""""'" who _ Oft fie (IJsI Cly Cl....llI 1m . CIIr #4JItsf1l'I a-I ~ whldJ member J WI. \... 112- -I. .. IIi. The IlIlcn alllI .... All rnNp Is as tJlbw8: ilL MemlIerolClltc...... '.j\ or lloanIldlIs an~ ~ In _al1fool. aS$Ils or ClIpII8I"a1~ar~ ' Uember 01 CIr O...."isl1u~ or IlaIId is. palM.~ (as Illliblns ala _....deli, 'llhIclI" nollstldaa .,naIiIlIllIar 1IgiolI1II" ...... or 1* wnlIIII .1lI1\llF101R Ill' ReIlI_olilI.. lnlllJ__ 'IelIIIn; the AA*M\ar......-l......1s a CliaIlala """01" cay Q".., 11' -.orllolllll.aClent 01 anGIleo "~,,.mng 110m III _ dice or tar lie _.....,... as III mamlIer ollha cayCoA.lls8lon or8Dlm: "Cly Oamn\ISSllXIerorBoard..- is a Clientllf.. AppIcaIt or !lepillsGlIlaliva; l11e ~or n...~ Is a OI_ol..lnemberollleClyCommlailll GI' 110IIIII (orol Ills Gl'1ll!(..~ and trIIlSIds lnllI8" $10.000.0001 tle __ ollll __ ollie cay COnInissIon ar IlaIId \Ill his or Ill!( ~ In a gMn caIIndar,..ar. II Yi. the member ol" cay c.- '(fluor IlaaId Is a 041*"-01111 #tlIiCIIt Ol......e4ll1linl ancI nnsaces __ IlIn $2S,IlOO.OO ol III llUsiness ol .. ~ Oll\epleslllllalM In a PIn catendIr,..r. WI1NESS lAY HNlD lHS_ DAY I'1F .2001. IIi. H'PUCNfT: Br: tIamr. till: (liv. Ill. (llisnlIb8I ,...., (/'ItIIJ wmn:ss lAY IWlO 1l\IS _DAYI'1F l'IU'a'Il '(OWNER: .2lI01. Br: NIms: 1111: ~1 (I'l8If} (PmIJ .' "lIrt IIm1s "BuIiIe$$ 1W:1~. 'CIeft,' 'CUsbI8I;" ~. ~. arrd 'InI8owIed Ptts<<f" .. dIlIinfd " SfClJGnHllS oIl11eA~ ClyCode. t VB? /2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAUR I G .. 050351102610011305466327711 I'.O.B61 (;1024 ""l 20 02 12;03,. , . p.5 WllNESSUYtWI) 'MS -12 DAY':'= _Mat . 2f1Jf.~ M:"lES8fT~(Usted~~HlidWll By: (S/gnIIIIe 'i..et:B ~Steph~nie Trump~ Name: IFdlO TIle' (PrfrtII l1de: (AtIO 8y: /SIgnIIIft/ By. ~ IlIme: (Nt) IlIme: /PlilO ... fPfinII 'RIll' (AWl er. /SIao.MI1 8y: (lilgnIlIB ..- jAilIJ ........ /AiIII ... fPrWI lilt: /I'IilO II'(. ~J By. (SIgnaM8 ..... (PinlI twne: IAiIII) ,.,., (PinlI lJI1e' (MIO 8y: ~ 8y: ~ ..... IPIilII ~ tl'liIIJ 11IIlI: tAilIJ 11IIl: lPItIIj e,: ---I e,: ($IJnIU't ......, lPlt1IJ Nonle' lPlt1IJ . TIIIA: lAfnO 1IIe: lPIinlI ! i \ !lOll!: 11 USe CUplAIe tlJeds. dJso:loslR WoIll1l1an forllepleS"".lIvn... 21 AfIpl"II:IIIIS IIId AfliIn\S n IIMsed III lInwIf "'t'i''-~ .. AIlIdINIl pursllMlIII S& 11.l1(b)(2J(lv) GlIhe CIly's laid ~ I\IgdII1GM .. tile CIIJ Code, 11I11I __lIIIt pl\clflll 00i1$ldelllloa..1Ie .....1Ian by lie lllIyllolnl Clft~.. '1IIQ.~ a.... I.... prto.1d.d III" Alfidnltbm..laeol1totorlncompllle, 11/137/2003 t6:13t GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 05035#02611313"3054663277" NO. 861 1m25 AUG 2.0. 02 12, 031" 1".1 NOTAIIZA'IIOM MOVIION V IfmOF_ I "- CllUIIlYClf_ DIoDEl . Stephanie Trumt::: ....... I 0\1....,,.....,...-. .. .......InI.,p' _lfll_......... _.........~...._-_.........~......- X;__ - _to_SlIl":1 IEIl_"'INI':='''aI~~Q'''''' ~ . JJ(; rJJ~. " ' .~ .a-' DownE.~ ,~~, W'~J~ MV~HtllIIlllEllJllllS __"_A1'- . '. . . Septemller 2'" 2OIl3 . .' 1<HlID1IIII_...._"" --......, .., lid .-41- ITAliClf_ I .CDUIIIYOFWM 0l'IDEI -........ 1l-.1IlIIlallW.,.,.....,........ __......__--.......1........- ... -..............,.. """ -... -. -.... - _to_81_[ ._...._...... .JIlOt. .....,--..--- __tl..., .., .. p mw:Clf_ I COUIfITOF_DIaI - ft." -.....IIgl......-...w.~__ ____.....____...1.......-. .. -.. _.... ""'''''''''_IId_... ........ - IWOllIlTO_suaaweo_....._""" 1lIlI'. ....,......-..--'- --....., .., r 1 _.' _OFIUlNM I OOUNI\'OF_-llMIQ ... .. .. lOll........ ....."......rv......... _......._.....___.....1........_ III AIR ..............,......, _11I_ 01..... Ill! _TOAI<<l~ '-."'_flr" - .ZOQl, .' 1ilIlDJ'NIIl8llll11FlllllllM_ --....., .., .4 tl/07/2003 GREENBERG TRAUR I G .. 05035ll026tOOIl30546632TI1l I;(J.B61 (;1026 , 16:0t .. BUSINESS RElATIONSHIP AFFIDAVfT* 1lIiI McIIvIlIsIllldt puIIlM III llocIIon31-71~ III 110 QIy 1lI__ lind DIn"" COcle. lhI \l1lIII~'" MIlle..... disl:faIft 1lIat:......"/(' 11I1- I pclIlblt_ WI. ..... t =... a Bus-. nIl .~.. -1IIf ...... 01.. Cl1 QaT ~ 0I1IIf QIy IcIllIrxy llrIMIlo .. r' - ..... . .....1IIIIPIlL AIIlanl....,.lIoSll..lII.. -.~I',IIliot_.i1lllmcmblrIllIloClly~.,' I en QIy MviIoIy IloMIIo lIIli:It.. ..,.."."... be ....11I... ulalllMs: .... - aI Ol..,.blllllBr II' MIM1Iy /blnl1oIIIIbeI) lIIho SIMS ClI\ 119 lUll CIIr 0 ',lion << DIy IdlIiIOIy IlIlIIII upan lliIlIGh member ( )2. ... lhIl1iIUI al.. a.n." . - -.o$I.....1aIkIos: (II. "'a1C11)'O.' '.'Cl1'IlaIInlIdll"."".,___lo_allll.lIflDlal_cr ClIlIIII.... .........1lIl. 1 r II: III. MImlIIf aI DIy no T . '., II' 80Ild it . ..... GCHlUIlGlho (1110 .... aI . llOlpllo4L, wI1tlI.. nolIsledGll.........ClI'....... SIoCk ..Ad..... 01 JIIIIII WIlllInr.IIe....or RIf.uenl....In....... WIlUrt; IIle Afpiad 1Ir 1IoIp.__.....a CIInl al.....1I III __ 0... illlill. 0I1laIInl 01.. CIInl IIf IIIllI1Ifjlfl' I.~..... MIIe_ ofIoI <<v.. -........--.01.. Cllro... . - .cr,.. II lv, A QIy 0.......... er llaMI....... ii, Clldlll the ~ II' lklo-1lIf>i. [Ii II Y. llIe ~ OIll11M"ilIlIi.~ Is. eu.a. aI......af.. QlyCcIlIJ II I .. 0I11oaAl (oral '* lItlw ~....... _.... $1l1,ClllOJlO"''' ___ "'Ilalllelllber "'... <:it eN 'I r ,arllllllllfDrllllClr'" ~)IIl1"'llIIl!MIrJlllll; II Ill. The __a1tleQlyCclA "'l'I or IIaInIIs .aa.-a1.. ~ 01 ~......and IAnII:Is _ 11M P5.OOO00 aI .. .... aI .. /fpII:InI 01 .....,. in . _ CIIlIIlIIIrJUL W1tI!$$MYIWIl1ll$.J!....I>>.YOF ,~-- - .. ~ Wf1NESSII'(HAHD1II$_IlAYOF PlIOPSl'Il OWNER: .. t. lIII: ~ IJI'dlq '11'''11II11I ~ R' T ..""CIla,..,.". II;""""."" Uh.IIllI...UlIlI".,............ ....2-a"'.. A..... Qly CadI. ! ; I ! I , .i . , . i r ~ tl/07,.2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAlJR I G .. 0503511026tOOIl305466327711 '; "I:I.B61 0027 .' . mr...._.-~ _IF_ I _CIF...,11WlE/ _....._........~........__IolA~ ~... -...........,..-.,_.._._.. ___......11I...........................- "CARLOS ERSKlIll! ~~--,j""" . ",~~,bd. .",*,"0Ia"_ eo..Mlu- . DDOI4155 . ImIClFIUIIIA. I .clIlIll\'CIF_lINIEI _... Ill....... ............._ ___.......IIf.......__............_ ..~ .....IRl.,....._.._._.... ARWIl' _10____ '_.11II_--' 11II&- ....___FIII6l11l11gt __t1"" .., - - ...1 _CIF_ I COUIftYOF..-1h'.t:IEI ........ .. ~., l .,..........-IW = __,,_11I"_--- ........_ .._..... Ml't ...,... ..,_... _._IIM - _1O_.~__.._... ..... ....--.......11I..... .............. "" .. ..... IWIClFRllMlA I GCUCn'....1>>OQ .................'" .................,- ' _...........IIf.....................Il""...._ .. AllIN, ..............." _.. _or.... lilt MfWIT _lO__.-_....._... -e.. . ...--.......11I'- _........., "" .. r tl/07;"2003 16:01 GREENBERG TRAURIG .. 050351102610011305466327711 "..e 20 02 12.03p NO. 851 (;1028 p.3 . BUSINESS RElATIONSHIP AFRDAVIT' 'l1IlIl MdavlIs mde P\IIIM lo 8ec\Ion 3\-71lbl~ of.,. ~ of A1lenI\Ia IMlII OIl. I ,-11II11 CodII. The~ AlIiaIIt henby CIiICiIIe$"'''''''''' -.: ...",. ~ padIons anIrl i ~t \... (12. AIIB does I!ll- a a&less ~wlIIIllIY lt1lIdlIrollle QJ~ or.. ~ Ivtilri4fy bldlo which 1Ie.lll, Icllian... be pmlOled. Man! hertlll' dscIDIIC I\aladaes I\aIIe a _ ~.... ~ of hl Cily CammIoslan or. CIy AIMsory bldlOwNdl.. "V"ion" be Pl_Md._1aIa'IIS; . tusI name 01 CocI..llasi_ or #6iriI<<y \lOIRI Member) ""'" serves IlIIIhe (list Ciy Coli rlssoo ar Ciy AdvtIary IlcBd upon which mendler serws). ., The nalu'eol"__ All.. I~ lS8IlaIIIws: IlL IotImber 01 a,CoIamiIsi- OIllaanl holds an -'ill'" iI_ 011% of '*' asse\s ar CIlllIaIt*lcIlof~arRop._.lali~a; (Ii. Member of ~ ~_MA~ ar 8aanllS a ....... ~ (18 11>..... ria GOlpCIlIliOn whIdl... ncllilllll on IlIYlllllanalor IegianIIt*lcIl 8ld1IngeI ar Jl*t wnllnr will.. AppIcant 01 RlIpl_;~~"'" ~-*ft; II Ii lhe AppIIl:anl or Relll_IlIl.,lS a QenI of all1Gll'Aler 01.. ~ QlI,r' I: ., Oflloilnl or a ClIed of enoIlllf ploW - -...wootcIng..... lie _..... or...lIe.... ...~IS"1'IlIllIIIer of lie ~n...~llI'lloaId; [)... ACiyCommissilnerIll'Boerd 1lll!I'Ilber1s. ClielIlollle AppIo;dIll'~ II', TheApplicinlOl ~ Isa CusIonlefollle __ Ollie ClyCam-~,""ar Boerd (Grot his ar hIIr ernr*lrer) .... hns8els mare .., $\0.000.00 oIllelllRless 0I1Ie1llllll1ber 01... CIy Coollllissir,n Ill' llaanl ~ his Of her ~ in a giwQn caIendiIr,.ar, II vi, The __ of lie CllJ CommisIiaII ar IloIId Is. C\lsloI.- ollie AppIicinI or ~ and llInSIClI _ .., $25,0??.oo of .. busilI!Ss 01 .. ~ or RIplllsenIalIl' in . given CllIIeIIdllryear. WItNESS IolY iWIllllS _ MY OF .200\. N'I'\.ICRfT: 8J; tle--- ,.. ~ jFIhJ (PttrO WItNESS lolYiWIllKS_DAYOF I'ftOPER1Y OWNER: 2001. Ilr. ......... ......... 11110: /SfjnIlIn) /PttrO IPtilIJ .- "111I..... '8/$ine$$~" 'CIiel1I," 'CI/sIQI/6r; "App/i:aIr." '7l~. WId..........,., PInon"1/e ddinod i1 StcIIan!..1AS 111118 A....-.& CiyCOl1e. 1t/07/2003 16:01 Rue 2p 02 12:03p GREENBERG TRAURIG .. 050351102610011305466327711 NO. 861 (;1029 p.5 WIlNESSNYllAN01lIS3'LDAYOl' 46/ 1tIJy.,] ~ '/...&(: ) 1l1an~ ."'MiIaIl By: (SgoIat1l't Alan ~atus /PIitJ IlIme: fAWI ....., lille: (Pm/J 11l1e' (PIWJ By. (S9III<ft) Br. (S4gnIIIre ~ tPIW) ....... IPdtII,/ ,. (PritJ 1k /PrWI By: ~ By. {ll4j..An URH - Name: tPrInq 11110: IPIWJ 'Ilk /PIi'IJ &(: ~ By: /S9lIIlII ....... fI'rirfI IIanle: (NIIJ lille: - .' f1'MI/ By: ~ By: (Sip/ln ..... iPIirtJ Name: fP/t1ll ,..., /PIitJ TIII8: /FIiII} Ily. ISlJlnabI} By: -- Name: IPriIO Name: i/'IfIIO 11IIIl: tAtIIJ 111: f/'lt1l) tI01E: 1) IIsU r.""'1e_IIIIIIMIDI.,I.d1 dDn...."""_.IIIII.lnrIes I) ""pi< .... AIIlInlI_lIMHIIttlllllllJ suprh..alllls AIIIdMIlI~ III Sec.11-71~ GIllie Cl(s laid DudDplnalllllg .110,11 III lie CIlr COde, III lie emaI'" pdorlll_.I'I"'llDR aI......,noatIaR by'" CIIy lloanI or~-_ tile ...._allOll pIlMlldeIIln ... AftIdavIl 'Ie D.111IlconIct or 1ncoInplele, 11/07/2003 16:0t ~UI 20 02 12:03p GREENBERG TRAURIG .. 05035ll026t00"30546Eo327?1l NO.B6l "030 p,4 STA1l!lI'llOMlA I aullYOF "'MI:l NOTAAlZA1llIft PIIOVISlOIl >( Alan Matus _...... _dl....................., woIIIll --..-......---......,..""...- llllll..-~_did_.._11oI _1'O_..SC: l.ill.....~d ~~ E..EAN IlELLOSI ~ '!'l-V; UYCor1117~" 00'14152 '.'tcrfl' ~:June9.2008 t I~ R.NDliIIIIs..-...... ~ ~,6.ed~ _..I'IorilIoAl.... --...., U, '1"- ! t ~ . srAlElI'MRIIIl I .cDUInYOFIINI OIOEI - ... .. "'...... ...............,...- --..-.....---...-.........- ..~... ....Inl., -Mlf_" _.. _.... I - SWllNIlO""$lJlll{mll!r'_...._.'" lIlD1. ..,......_.._A1'-'" --.."""", I!r .. r- srAlEClFMRIIIl I CICMIlYllfllltlllllWlfJ -..... ".."..."'......._.,--' __.._....___...h1........_ ...A-,....... .............,_..._.._lIIol - _1'O__.liEr,_......__" IIIDI. ..,......-..-"''- _lI'_' CIOUNf'( ClF 11IM11lMlEI - ....... '. . oM ......,.........,__ __IIIs_......___........__ f.icWlta.._ar.., .... .. ~1 ... -. ...................., _ta_.._1IIlIl - SWORN 10 NIl SlI8SCllIllBl_....._*'. lIlD1. .' ..,......_.._1II1qo _lMIel-, .... : 11/07/2003 !(/I!fl/l<l,j 11.-e?~1l3 16:01 12:44 111:2& GREENBERG TRAURIG .. 050351l0261001130546632TI1I WILLIQMS.ISlAND 931 11'3 ~ G - M UIlEENllERG TRRUlIG ~ WILLIR/'IS'15LANIl NO. 861 [;)031 NO. 376 1702 /' HO.~ IileZ Rue eo, De II.oap . . p.a :-a lUUII8laA'ItONIHP JJ MDA" -......-...........,N1fIIM...._........IMfIllN' .J _10Mt. 1111~ II I..........,., ..............'1'...' f'-......-. i~' \.. IIZ. ..............-]' ~IIII-\.-.._..._a... . ~ ,""""'MIRIr ............ .. ~ I ..... Ill'" ............ .............. ........64 ......" IwClr 0..._ r . II. _....,1IoIId................1II.. JilL. I J.._ ' ......."01 '11 _.~...~.....__.... .... CIr III 1 . I' II " ClIr ,..., ... .... ... ... .... " 1III.....''''.....1l.Lr .M.II.- (JL ""'''CllII~ .. ........... ......_..'''........... CIIIIIJ-.......R~ I . .....J. III. ........._Il.". J'JJIl'.............. r .."...,... RU....... ..........................1I1l1.4..............,....." 1lIp._..Illl. ""__WIIIIlII; II" 11II,....Plp. ~ .......1......._- . ._.... "....~.r t' ............... _.........._................".. OW;I . I erlllllit. lJ". n.. 1J14 'carel " ............/t.CIIII.........,. . r.!; 1hI...........,...GlIllIlIIIIr........".._- JIlin ......... .. .llII_ .' .410 ......._............ .....11I............_ an... ......."'...1 ~b.4....__,. .............Glttll . 1 ......,..~ _I. _.11I........1 U ~... ...... ..... -. at III __".. ,........_ do. "..- --W- . at, . ;i::"--~ 'lIIo: ... ~ r .' 'Iflta.t i 1 II - "Ir .. 'CIJnI.' r -"""1.. ~ nl~.l1l r T ........ rr'............,.. ....... ..."...... ""CHi. 1t/07/2003 16;0t 11/07/03 12'44 11187/83 10:26 Aut 20 De 1I!.Oap' . , ' . GREENBERG TRAlJRIG .. 050351102610011305466327711 WILlIA'lS'ISlJ'H) 931 1773 . G - M GREENIiER6 T~IG ~ WILlIAMSol5l.JNl NJ. BEol (;>032 i'IJ.376 ""3 hU. m 1703 ,.1 . . WI1IdjMY'IWlDTHI8.2.DAV. ~rt(.3 X. ~"'ldlll-:-~~ IT..... ~. ~ .....-It'""l fk.,'-<<~ .... IIll R bo. ~ ........ ,., .., IIr- n ilL ~ .d!I'" IfF ,. ~ ". ... M 'Ml IT- "*' I~ ". ,., ~1I1" lIr- lNllI I~. ... ..- "1. .Jt/ .,. -lID 1111 lAW 1110: ~ UJ If- ,.. .....-r itII ,. I7l -~ r.... ...,.. . . .... ... ~_.. ,... .a, " .... VI.o ." .... -- .. ...- - ... II\. h.. .. .... -, Jl ~ ,. IF- ..... .... ,. .. ,..............'.a1mIUII. .. iliA,.. II .1,...... !l~~~~t:!~.:;==.\~7*1"~~L~:.~ " . . -......... . 11/07/2003 11/137/03 .11/07/93 16:01 12:44 10:27 GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ 05035U026100"3054663277" WILLIAMS. ISLAND 931 1773 ~ G - M GREENBERG TRAURIG ~ UILLlt:ll'I5*l5U=lND NO.851 [;1033 NO. 3'76 004 "fJ.593 r;J{IJ4 "....01 UhOIp '0. ..').. I J L.~,.'~ j ; !.JL ~ DlYItE.M:\IIIWI 1ft 0QIIIIIl0N IlIDt:m8I ~"'M._ ....,...... ,.1JIIiIINIIIIII ---J .......... ......4.#1.............. ...................'J U .11U........................ ............"._~._..... ..... 5WUlt1OMD__.Nt_.. ... ..,..-........ "*-...... .,....._1 =~ . ....-=:..VRr":a~~lI:M...-. ..........- ...,....................11II IIfWlr ...11II1DtuIIaIII!IJ...._IlIt_." T -DI. ....., ....::.:,................... ........ ...................d...IIt..... - ........~--... I_II).C....... ."..11111_ 1 "" .......... .."lilt......... ...... -' IwaNttoAIDIIIIIIICMID........_... 17'1 ,.... .* .......... ===-- t>--. "f" U ~ RESOLUTION NO. 2003-_ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA GRANTING CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL TO PERMIT THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A SYNAGOGUE IN THE MULTIFAMILY HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (RMF4) DISTRICT FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2600 ISLAND BOULEVARD, CITY OF AVENTURA; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the property described herein is zoned RMF4, Multifamily High Density Residential District; and WHEREAS, the applicant, The Williams Island Synagogue Inc., through Application No. 04-CU-03, is requesting Conditional Use approval to permit the establishment of a synagogue in the Multifamily High Density Residential (RMF4) District; and WHEREAS, on November 12, 2003 following proper notice, the City Commission held a quasi-judicial public hearing as provided by law to review the application; and WHEREAS, the City Commission finds that the Application meets the criteria of the applicable codes and ordinances, to the extent the Application is granted. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT: Section 1. Application for Conditional Use to permit establishment of a synagogue in the Multifamily High Density Residential (RMF4) District on property located at 2600 Island Boulevard and legally described as Condominium Parcel C-1 in 2600 Island Boulevard, Williams Island, a Condominium recorded September 19, 1997 Resolution No. 2003-_ Page 2 in Official Records Book 17797, Page 2609 of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County is hereby granted subject to the following conditions: 1. Plans shall substantially comply with those submitted as follows: . 2600 Island Boulevard, Specific Purpose Survey, Sheet 1 of 1, prepared by Consul-Tech Surveying & Mapping Inc., dated 06/20/03, signed and sealed. . Proposed Sidewalk Design, Williams Island Entry Way, Sheet 1 of 1, prepared by Fortin Leavy Skiles Inc., dated 06/18/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Sheet T -1, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, dated 06/11/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Site Plan, Sheet SP-1, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, last revised dated 06/11/03, signed and sealed. . Williams Island Synagogue, Floor Plan, Sheet A-1, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, last revised dated OS/23/03, signed and sealed. · Williams Island Synagogue, Elevations, Sheet A-2, prepared by Goldenholtz & Associates, last revised dated 06/11/03, signed and sealed. 2. That, prior to issuance of a building permit for the facility, the applicant shall provide the following to the City, at its expense: (i) a recorded copy of a deed conveying ten (10) parking spaces in the 2600 Island Boulevard building garage to The Williams Island Synagogue Inc. (ii) an amended site plan indicating fencing along the seawall at the service drive and appropriate shields on the lamp posts to prevent light disturbance to adjacent residents. Section 2. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its adoption. The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner , who moved its adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner , and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows: Commissioner Zev Auerbach Commissioner Ken Cohen Commissioner Robert Diamond Commissioner Manny Grossman Commissioner Harry Holzberg Vice Mayor Jay R. Beskin Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Resolution No. 2003-_ Page 3 PASSED AND ADOPTED this 12th day of November, 2003. JEFFREY M. PERLOW, MAYOR ATTEST: TERESA M. SOROKA, CMC CITY CLERK APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY: CITY ATTORNEY This Resolution was filed in the Office of the City Clerk this 13th day of November, 2003. CITY CLERK City of Aventura ~ ~tJOJ e ~I.li ~c-~ at 5~t-(JJ" Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Office of the City Manager VIA FACSIMILE & U.S. MAIL (305) 381-9457 October 13, 2003 John K, Shubin Shubin & Bass 46 S.W. 1st Street 3rd Floor Miami, FL 33130 Re: Special Hearing Date - Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. Dear Mr, Shubin: After consultation with attorneys representing both sides, this is to advise that the subject City Commission hearing date is now scheduled for November 12, 2003 at 5:00 p.m, If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me. EMS/aca cc: Cliff Schulman, Esq. City Commission David Wolpin, City Attorney Teresa M. Soroka, CMC, City Clerk Joanne Carr, Planning Director CM01589-03 PHONE: 305-466-8910 · FAX: 305-466-8919 www.cityofaventura.com LAW OFFICES SHUBIN & BASS PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION Via Hand Delivery November 10, 2003 Ms. Teresa M. Soroka, CMC City Clerk City of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Re: Proposed Williams Island Synagogue Dear Ms. Soroka: In connection with the specially set Commission Meeting scheduled for November 12th, please find enclosed a copy of 2600 Island Boulevard Condominium Association, Inc. ("Residence du Cap")' s Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation ("traffic report") for inclusion in the record of Wednesday's hearing. Please also find enclosed an additional seven (7) copies for distribution to the Mayor and Commissioners. As always, thank you for your anticipated attention to this matter. Sincerely, ~~~~ John K. Shubin For the firm cc: Mr. Rod White Cliff Schulman, Esq. David Wolpin, Esq. 46 SW. 1st Street, 3rd Floor. Miami. FL 33130 Ph: 305.381.6060 Fx: 305.381.9457 www.shublnbass.com . 2600 Island Boulevard Aventura, Florida ~'S;"'" TraHie Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation November, 2003 Mil.. Mo.. and Associate., Ine. Consulting I.gln_n 12900 50..1"_." 84'" SIr..' Miami, Florida 33183 305-386-1212 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation bK.da-." . The design of the 2600 Island Boulevard driveway is clearly intended as a direct, two-way access route between Island Boulevard and the building's loading dock. No additional vehicular parking or maneuvering area is provided. . The access driveway is secondarily provided as a Fire Lane, as evidenced by a fire connection point along the driveway and "FIRE LANE" pavement markings placed along the entire length of the driveway. . No sidewalks or designated pedestrian pathways exist along the driveway, and no room is available for such features without encroaching upon vehicular lanes. . If the loading dock is closed or barricaded during non-business hours, vehicular maneuvering area at the end of the driveway will be critically reduced such that vehicles will execute a tedious multi- point turn to exit. Alternately, vehicles will be forced to back out of the driveway for a distance of several hundred feet, another tedious maneuver at best and a potentially hazardous maneuver for large vehicles. . The nearest designated parking area serving the driveway, loading dock, utility areas and storerooms is over 400 feet to the east, across Island Boulevard. This parking lot is already designated for use by a tennis center. . No pedestrian facilities exist to connect the storeroom location and the parking lot. Installation of pedestrian facilities will adversely affect vehicular traffic on Island Boulevard near the 2600 building, as well as traffic on the access driveway. . Although more of a legal matter than a transportation issue, the proposed use of the storeroom as an assembly area appears to violate provisions of the City of Aventura Code that regulate parking capacity, parking location, pedestrian access to parking facilities, and other related items. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation SIIHIIIe R.~.II Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. has been retained to investigate traffic related matters at 2600 Island Boulevard in A ventura, Florida. At issue is the current and future use of an access driveway on the south side of the building, with specific emphasis on pedestrian and vehicular traffic safety near a proposed assembly room (currently a vacant storeroom). This report serves to provide a summary of our fmdings and conclusions. Transportation Land Use Municipal land use regulations clearly address multi-use and co-located entities. Many such multi-use facilities benefit from combining infrastructure elements and sharing local resources. Some elements, however, must remain exclusive to each land use due to the diversity of uses and/or incompatibility of shared resources. The following Aventura Code excerpt specifies the need for exclusive parking and loading attributes: A ventura Code Sec. 31-171. Off-street oarking and loading standards (d) Off-street loading (2) Specifications e. Off-street loading facilities supplied to meet the needs of one use shall not be considered as meeting off-street loading needs of any other use. f. No area or facilities supplied to meet the required off-street parking facilities for a use shall be for, or be deemed to meet, the requirements of this section for off-street loading facilities. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 2 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Driveway Design The access driveway in front of the proposed assembly room is clearly intended as a two-way, two-lane corridor between Island Boulevard and the 2600 building loading dock. The design has no provision for any vehicular movements other than the direct travel between Island Boulevard and the loading dock, and no additional parking or maneuvering area exists along the length of this road. . The service road is 20' wide, with two 10' lanes. The perimeter areas of the road are delineated by curbing, landscaping, and the 2600 building itself. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc, Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 3 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Fire Lane Provision The driveway's design as a two-way, two-lane road, together with existing "FIRE LANE" traffic control markings, individually and collectively reinforce the architectural intent of this access corridor. Establishment of additional uses or installation of any "encumbrances" will adversely affect the functionality of the driveway during normal and emergency periods. . The driveway design is clearly indicative of a direct-access corridor for nonnal, daily use and for the reserved use of fire apparatus during emergencies. . "FIRE LANE" stencils exist along the entire length and both edges of the access driveway. . The northern row of stencils is faded but legible, while the southernmost row of stencils is partially obliterated by previous asphalt patching work. A fire hydrant exists along the south side of the road. The Florida Administrative Code (F AC) includes statewide provisions for "Life Safety" and fire safety requirements. F AC defines areas such as the driveway in the following manner: Florida Administrative Code PUBLIC SPACE. A legal open space on the premises, accessible to a public way or street, such as yards, courts or open spaces permanently devoted to public use, which abuts the premises and is permanently maintained accessible to the fire department and free of all encumbrances that might interfere with its use by the fire department. Fire connection and 'NO PARKING FIRE LANE" pavement markings Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 4 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Driveway Exit Maneuver Florida Statutes address turning maneuvers as follows. Note that definitions contained within the Statutes specifY applicability to public and Drivate roads in the State of Florida. Florida Statute 316.1515 Limitations on turning around The driver of any vehicle shaIl not turn the vehicle so as to proceed in the opposite direction upon any street unless such movement can be made in safety and without interfering with other traffic. . . A small maneuvering area exists beyond (or east of) the loading dock, intended for use by trucks that wish to access the loading dock. These trucks stop east of the loading dock within this extended maneuvering area, and then back into the dock and receiving area Upon completing their tasks at the dock, trucks can then pull straight out and execute a right turn to exit the facility. . Any blockage of this extended area will adversely impact the maneuverability of trucks wishing to access the dock. . Conversely, any closure of the dock will adversely affect the maneuverability of vehicles that pull into the extended area with an expectation of backing into the dock. If the dock is closed or barricaded, vehicles (facing eastbound upon entering this area) will be forced to execute a slow, multi-point turn consisting of short backward and forward movements until such vehicles are facing westbound toward the exit. A multi-point turn at this location is a tedious movement at best and a potentially hazardous movement at worst. For large vehicles and buses, the 20' roadway width and small additional area near the loading dock only provide a small turning area. Little or no buffer exists between the road and adjacent curbing, landscaping and building walls, thus resulting is a risk of impact and property damage from the turning maneuver. < 110 IIlI : > m Proportional illustration of large vehicle executing a multi-point tum, moving backward and forward in small increments until the vehicle is aligned toward the exit Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 5 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Maneuvering area allows trucks to stop east of the dock, then easily back into the loading dock. Most of this area will be unavailable if the dock is closed or barricaded. Upon exiting. trucks simply turn right and proceed westbound on the driveway. Instead of a simple right tum, a multi-point turn will be required if the loading dock is barricaded, Note the contractor vehicles parked along the north curb. in the westbound lane of traffic and on the marked Fire Lane, forcing all traffic (eastbound and westbound) into the eastbound lane at the time these photos were completed. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 6 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Pedestrian Traffic Accommodation The proposal to install a sidewalk or delineated walkway between the assembly room and Island Boulevard will adversely impact the driveway, as detailed below: . Any reallocation of space along the road will reduce the width of vehicular lanes, already at the minimum of 10' per lane. . Fire Lane accessibility decreases if lanes are reduced in width or encroached upon with pedestrian walkway features. . Any roadway width reduction will transform the driveway into a one-lane, two-way facility. This is an unacceptable design and one that invites vehicular and pedestrian conflicts, property damage, and unnecessary congestion. . Vehicles cannot safely pass on a one-lane road, nor can they back out of the area along the entire length of the road. . Impact potential on the driveway increases if additional pedestrian traffic is added to the roadway. . If assembly room patrons enter the area from the seawall sidewalk... behind the 2600 Building and on a different route than pedestrians approaching from Island Boulevard... they will exit the sidewalk and proceed across the asphalt driveway toward the assembly room. lbis route occupies the same space needed for vehicular traffic and the multi-point turn on the road. ..----. Seawall sidewalk and route toward loading dock and assembly room Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 7 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Parking Facilities The parking area proposed for the assembly room is located across Island Boulevard from the 2600 building. The parking lot currently serves an adjacent terinis center. . Since tennis activities will no doubt occur during the same Saturday periods in which this parking area is to be used by assembly room patrons, we envision a traffic congestion conflict. . Parking demand may exceed parking supply due to the limited quantity of parking spaces at this lot. . The A ventura Code is not relaxed in scope nor reduced in measurable quantities due to religious practices. That is, a facility having a large pedestrian (non-motor vehicle) traffic flow does not alter the requirements for parking and accessibility at the facility. Applicable Aventura Code provisions: A ventura Code Sec. 31-171. Off-street Darkinll: and loadinll: standards ( a) General. Every building, use or structure, instituted or erected after the effective date of this chapter shall be provided with off-street parking facilities in accordance with the provisions of this section for the use of occupants, employees, visitors or patrons. Such off-street parking facilities shall be maintained and continued as an accessory use as long as the main use is continued. (l) Existing buildings. Where a building existed at the effective date of this article such building may be modernized, altered or repaired, provided there is no increase in floor area or capacity and there is no change of occupancy, without providing the total number of required parking spaces. Where a building or use, which existed at the effective date of this article is enlarged in floor area, volume, capacity or space occupied, off-street parking facilities as specified herein shall be provided for the additional floor area, volume, capacity or space so created or so occupied. Where a building or use which existed at the effective date of this chapter is changed in use or occupancy, additional off-street parking facilities shall be provided to the extent that the off-street parking required by this section for the new use or occupancy exceeds the off-street parking which would have been required for the previous use or occupancy had the regulations of this section been applicable thereto. For the purposes of this section a change of use or occupancy shall mean a change from one category of off-street parking requirements to another such category. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc, Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 8 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation It shall be unlawful for an owner or operator of any building, structure or use affected by this section to discontinue, change or dispense with, or to cause the discontinuance or reduction of the required parking facilities apart from the discontinuance, sale or transfer of such structure or use, without establishing alternative vehicle parking facilities which meet the requirements of this section. It shall be unlawful for any person to utilize such building, structure or use without providing the off-street parking facilities to meet the requirements of and be in compliance with this article. (3) Parking plan required. A parking plan shall be provided with all applications for development approval which shall clearly and accurately designate the required parking spaces, required landscaped areas and planter islands, access aisles and driveways and the relationship of the parking to the uses or structures the spaces are intended to serve. (4) Required handicapped spaces. Parking spaces for disabled persons shall be provided in accordance with F.S. ch. 553, pt. V, as amended from time to time. (5) Parking spaces for persons transporting young children and strollers. Parking spaces specifically designed for persons transporting young children under the age of three and strollers, shall be encouraged for all uses other than single-family, duplex or townhouse. (b) Amount of off-street parking (13) Non-residential: Miscellaneous uses a. Places of worship: One parking space per four seats in the largest assembly area '\\\\\""'~'" y,'''' \~,,\ ,:,",\: .li;I!" Miles Moss and Associates, Inc, Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 9 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Pedestrian Access to Parking Facilities . The lot is over 400' west/southwest of nearest room entrance door. . The lot is across Island Boulevard from the 2600 building; Island Boulevard is a 4-lane, divided roadway. . No pedestrian crossing features exist between the intended use and the intended parking area. A ventura Code Sec. 31-171. Off-street parking and loading standards (a) General (2) Proximity of off-street parking. Required off-street parking spaces shall be located on the same parcel they are intended to serve. As an alternative, they may be located on a separate parcel not more than 300 feet from the use they are intended to serve provided the owner of said parking areas shall enter into a written agreement with the City of whereby the land providing the parking area shall be joined with the primary site and shall not be sold or disposed of except in conjunction with the sale of the building the parking area serves so long as these parking facilities are required. Said agreement shall be recorded at the expense of the owner and shall run with the land and shall bind the heirs, successors, and assigns of said owner. In approving off-site parking, the City Manager must find that the off-site parking facility is reasonably located in relation to the use it is intended to serve, based upon such factors as the type of facility, likely purpose of the trip to the facility, distance from the use intended to be served, and any physical barriers which must be crossed to reach the use to be served. Parking spaces backing into a main drive aisle adjacent to the front of buildings shall be discouraged. Pedestrians will be forced to walk on a two-way, two-lane (one lane in each direction) service road to access the assembly room. The walking path will minimally be from the sidewalk in front of the 2600 Building to the ramp adjacent to the assembly room, a distance of over 300'. The nearest parking area for non-residents of the 2600 Building is a parking lot designed and operated in support of a tennis court across Island Boulevard from the 2600 Building. This parking lot has no sidewalk along its frontage and no connection to the sidewalk on the 2600 Building side ofIsland Boulevard. If this parking area is pressed into service for the assembly room, we envision a traffic and safety conflict since pedestrian traffic will be progressing in an opposite direction from the tennis courts. That is, instead of parking their vehicles and walking away from the lot and toward the courts, assembly room patrons will be walking within the lot and toward the entrance driveway of the lot. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc, Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 10 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation The shortest walking distance between the lot and the assembly room is via a diagonal walking route across Island Boulevard and a diagonal walking route across the entrance driveway of the parking lot. Both routes are potentially hazardous as pedestrians will be occupying space reserved for motor vehicle movements. Inbound vehicles (entering the parking lot) will have little time and distance to see pedestrians and execute impact-avoidance maneuvers. We believe this to be a severe liability risk for the community. . Sidewalk location note: Island Boulevard runs in a north-south direction in front of the 2600 Building, then curves into an east-west alignment just south of the 2600 Building. For the portion of Island Boulevard running in a north-south alignment, the existing sidewalk is along the east side of Island Boulevard. For the portion ofIslandBoulevard running in an east-west alignment, the existing sidewalk is along the south side of Island Boulevard. ~ . . . . . . . . . .' '-'''iflf': .:... . . . . Mew from driveway toward parKing areal \View from parKing area entrance toward driveway! Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 11 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation The most direct walking path is a diagonal route across and within a curved section of Island Boulevard. This route presents multiple hazards due to: diagonal (not 90-degree) crossing path roadway curvature limited roadway sight distance incomplete sidewalk network lack of pedestrian traffic control features, Miles Moss and Associates, Inc, Consulting Engineers 305-386- 1212 12 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Looking north-northeast along Island Boulevard CUlve toward 2600 building 2600 building driveway Sidewalk only on east and south sides of Island Blvd. Proposed parking area at tennis courts No sidewalk on west and north sides of Island Blvd, Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 13 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation Pedestrian Access to Assembly Room The room proposed for occupancy is a windowless storage or warehouse environment. The main entrance area is reached via a ramp on the south side of the building, approximately midway between the front of the building and the loading dock to the rear. The ramp is elevated several feet and appears to be designed more for cargo movements than for other ramp-installation requirements, for example, ramps used for Americans with Disabilities Act (A.D.A.) access routes. . The ramp design is substandard for the two-way movement of wheelchairs due to its limited width; Other A.D.A. accessibility route requirements may also be violated. Once up the ramp, pedestrians must make a 90-degree turn to the right to enter an alcove or roofed portion of the entrance; that is, a walkway extending from the ramp into a portion of the building that lies within the exterior wall. Pedestrians must then execute another 90-degree turn to the right in order to reach the door providing access to the proposed assembly room. . The alcove may have substandard lighting and width per A.D.A. requirements. . The assembly room door is a heavy-duty, exterior-quality door. It too may fail to comply with A.D.A. standards for door-pull effort and threshold height, but these elements are beyond the scope of this evaluation. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc, Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 " 14 2600 Island Boulevard, A ventura, Florida Traffic Safety and Transportation Land Use Evaluation C....IIIIlIIf. . Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. (MMA) is an engineering fIrm specializing in traffic engineering, traffic safety and accident reconstruction. Clientele consists ofhomeowner's groups, developers, facility managers, special event coordinators and all levels of government. Representatives of the fIrm have had the honor of addressing the A ventura City Commission on several previous occasions regarding traffic safety and land use issues. . MMA investigations address traffic engineering elements including traffic volumes, traffic circulation, intersection sight triangles and Site Plan reviews. Additional safety, liability, and accident prevention elements analyzed by MMA include human factors, visibility and perception, traffic control devices, land use, roadway and drainage attributes, vehicular injury potential and vehicular performance specifications. . The firm provides Expert Witness testimony on cases and produces courtroom displays, computer graphics and photo essays to help illustrate reports or opinions. Miles Moss and Associates, Inc. Consulting Engineers 305-386-1212 15 ~ MIAMI CAlLY BUSINESS REVIEW Published Daily except Saturday, Sunday and Legal Holidays Miami, Miami-Dade County, Florida STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE: Before the undersigned authority personally appeared O.V. FERBEYRE, who on oath says that he or she is the SUPERVISOR, legal Notices of the Miami Daily Business Review f/k/a Miami Review, a daily (except Saturday, Sunday and legal Holidays) newspaper, published at Miami in Miami-Dade County, Florida; that the attached copy of advertisement, being a legal Advertisement of Notice in the matter of i. ,.,.:-;'.".-,}...--,,'-- ",:' , CITY OFAVIII'I1JIlA NOTICE OF pY8LIC HEARING I I" Date and TIme of Public Hearing: : 5:00 p.m. iAPPIicant'Niiijj1Nuiiiliir.---' I ' I \ Applicant ReqUest: .t.- -' , " Wednesday. Nove,?1~er1~, 2003 .:~\~ ....j. T'tMt WIIIIa.I...I..d Sy~t1ei-lAG.- 1~-Q3' ' '. The applicant is requesting condi-; tiQnatuse approvaIt9t the ~tish- · \ tnent of a s)trlagOgiJ8, in a. MUltifamily, High .',' Density. Ailsi~o(RMF4). District. " 2600 I81and BOulevard, Ullit GU>-1 '~ilP'lP~ C-1,i~ 2600 I$kindBOul8v!l!Jf.)"-a.lns ~pd, a CQrldominit,lm recQtded SeP\8!:Jlber 'J91.l'lJ'l0fflc:W'~ Book.' F '1~.'Page _:pfth~.Public, , Reeoros of Mlami-Dade County. CITY OF AVENTURA - PUBLIC HEARING - 11/12/03 APPLICANT: THE WilLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE, INC. - 04-CU-03 LocatIon Of ~bject Property: . Legal DescrIption: in the XXXX Court, was published in said newspaper in the issues of 10/29/2003 Affiant further says that the said Miami Daily Business Review is a newspaper published at Miami in said Miami-Dade County, Florida and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Miami-Dade County, Florida, each day (except Saturday, Sunday and legal Holidays) and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Miami in said Miami-Dade Cl)unty, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he or she has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, comm' . n or refund for the purpose of secu~~:~adve' ent fo publication in the said newspaW O.V. FERBEYRE personal (Plans are on file andmay:be exanili1ed during nlgt!J8r:bu8i~tP,rs in the City of Aventura ~t ~i~nil)i ~Itlent Department. 19200 West Country Club Drive. Aventura. ~,33,180; Plans may be modifled at or before the PubliC t1~ri,"R' The ~~tIon may change during the hearing process' ", "',' , ,'; , . ',' ~ - ~ The PubliC Hearing wiUbs held ,at Cityof~vantura ~rnmlm,f~. 19200 West Country, Club Drive. Awntura.F1~: 33180., ,)four . comments maybe rn~ in person at th&~rillQor flIed~ wrItIngprlorto the hearing date. Refer to ~nt{pri:lp8ltyon~ and mail same to City of Aventt!ra G~ment'. C8f\le;t,'9Om,,*nlty .Development Department. Aventura. Florida. 331.ao.' .,~' ftJrther 'lnformatiOn. please caD (305)~. ,In accordance with the AmericaAs with Di$abU_: AtlQt:191O.a11 persons who are disabled and who need ipeciaI',~rnodalK!Hs to :participatt in this p~beaause of~,dIeabiIity shou~ ...tact the Office of the City Clerk. 466-8901. not later than twobU$i~~ys ,prior to such proceadings. If a person decides to flppeaI any cIecision made by the c\ty~i~on with respect to any matter (:Ql'lsidered at a meeting or ~.1hat ~rson will need a recon:lofthe proeetCiing$ and,forlliCh pu~._y~ to 'ensure that a velbatirn recordofthe~ngs is.mad8. Which I'lJCOro includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appe. 1$)9 ,b, baseet. " -' Teresa M. Soroka, ~~~7:~1M 10{29 """- -- Rue 20 02 12J02p . ,,-2 APPUCANT REPAESENTAllVE AFFIDAVIT PlnlIII\I kl Secllon81-711b1l2llOoIfleCly c/ AwnIUllLWDtYtigpmentCocr..1lIs AilPIoIIlt~ AIIIdI\1I. IleIuby made II1d IIilmItted. '!he Ialdelllaned~ ltPI-ol&1lwI D1fle....,., Dr _ 'PlIlrInlIlortJellel"'lIIlIl PIllJIll, whlel111 kltQIlod tlf1e &ocompI11)tlg 1lPtI"" lllCl"O'Mlorofflt~"'li)"".W~llbI IIcl1lleriMu1 ~lIltilllcl 1clenlIr... II PGIIOIIS "l'f1Hnllng III ~llIIllC'enIIy~Ior" DtWIQp.....lll'tml1l klllCMdan _ fltl/lPbllon. It foIIowt: NIIlIO IffIIrlaMht>,.....-.,.,~~ AntIlIoIr,..........~EIo.J 'r,,., Pill__.. "7"r IJf'F l't. ('DO"''' if_ T (~MIlIanalllhHca. HIlIINItJI NOlle!: ANY &TA19ENT OR Rl!PRSllENTATlON MADE IY AHY PERSON UIlTIiD ON mE APPUCAHr lll!PRESENrAllVE AFfIDAVIT SIIALL IE IlNDltKlllPON TlfE INDIVlDUAL OIl etmTY APPLYINQ FOIlllfE llWELllPMeHT I'ERIIlT AND llfE OWNER Cl,F TlfE IU8.IECT PROPERTY. APPUCANtI AND AAWnI ARE ADVISED TO 'tlMELY SUPPI.EMEHl' TIIS AFt:lDAVIT f'IIlIIUANr TO 8eC.ll-11(1111l1M OFtll! CltY'8 LAND DEVEI.OPMEHT REGULATIONS IN mE CIIY COO!, IN mil EVENT lIIAT PlIIllIl to .CONelDIRATION OF m! APPlJCATION IV TIll! CItY SOARD OR COllIll1lSION, THe INl'ORIIA.tIOtf PIIOVIDED IN mE AFPlIlAVIT BECOMes INCORRECT OR ltfCOMPLETE. , WliNESS MY HAND 'IlIIS g DAY Ol' N<>VI'n, IYr AlJ'lHOFI Tl OF APPUCAIiT: By: Name: 'C lllIe: TrtPt,!'" L...,uif..-.+ Addraos: 1'75'<1 Po""" d~ Le.,,, Bluel c:..o.,,\ G"bic:~ fL srATEOF Fl-ORIDA ) COUNlY OF t.lIAMl.oAQE) 8olOle me III UIldel1lgntd Illho!1ly pIlIIOndy III'lIIaJed ,. A/lI>IIoanI and/or tht owner of fit lll\Ip<Irty ItbJeollD llle IPPIcatlon, who bek1g exlK:lltO<llhl8 A/f1davtl fOl1l1e PUIpOIII BlaIed 1he!qk,and lhaIllIlnAlllld OOIl8Cl. )( AFFIANT SWORN TO AND au " I:' ~r .NoIorv_._olF_ . . ~'.I.w..I__Jlbt21.2ICaP Comm__ DD2511lZ, ~1v_!<<>faV_ 200/3 OWNER By: ~ NImI. l1Ilr. ~e( o."d ~v=\o.-x-r" Add"",, 40::0 -:p:, 1A.nd. ~ \ \I d ' 1/14-'f W',l\to.M," "'LSI...ndl., I=l.- 331bo Aue 20 02 12102p ,.2 . APPUCANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT Pursuant III Sectlon 31.71 (b)(2)(Q of I1e CIy of Avenltn Land Develapment Code, lhls ~ Representative AlfldaYllls hereby made IIld 1Ubm1tted. The 1Ilden;lgned alM1oc1zed npqsentative 01 f1e IndlvtduaI or en\lty applying forl1e DeWlbpment Pennll. which Is klenlllled kllhe accompanytng applicalJon, and lie O'M1er of 1IIe property.lbJecI \0 lIe.epplIaa1Ion (if dIfIeren1) hereby IiI1s and ldentifl8$ .U persons representing 1IIe kldMdual or entlly applying for I1e DeWlbpmenl Permit In oonnectlon wfth Itelppilcatlon, as 1oIlowi: Name Re/al!onlh/p fl... Mcmt)o,.w.-. ~ AIdIIl""'fllQtlHll,~Elc.1 T,,., Plu,.,.-..e..- 0crtt,l.. Co.<;uJf",,-t (AIlach AddIUonal Sheets n Neoessary) NOTICE: ANY STATEMENT OR REPRESENTATION MADE BY ANY PERSON USTED ON THE APPUCANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIOAVIT SHAJJ. BE BINDING UPON THE lHDIV1DUAL OR EN11TY APPLYING FOR THE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AIID THE OWNER OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY. APPUCANTS AND AFFlANTI ARE ADVISED TO TIMELY SUPPLEMENT THIS AFFIDAVIT PURSUANT TO see, 31071(B)(2)(1V) OF THE arrs LAND DEYaOPMEHT REGULATIONS IN THE CITY CODE, IN THE EVENT nlAT PRIOR TO CONSIDERATION OF THE APPUCATlON BY THE CITY BOARD OR COMMISSION, THE INFORMA110N PROVIDED IN THE AFFIDAVIT BeCOMES INCORRECT OR INCOMPLETE, ' WITNESS MY HAND THIS R DAY OF Nove"1 bl'r AVlliORlZ AT! By: 200/3 OWNER By: Name: Name: (S/grIalure) (PrinV ~ (~I) Tille: I r~,,' U.", .i/-",,+ Address: n5(~ p(J"~~ rJ~ &.,'1 Blv,l (.0;....\ G"bics. FL- STATE OF FLORIDA ) COUN'TY OF MIAMI.DADE) 11IIe: Address: Belore me lI1e undel$lgned authority pemnaUy appeared I Applicanl andlor the owner of 1I1e property subject \0 lI1e appUcallon, who being fl execuled this AIf1davit lor lhe purposes slated therein IIld lhatlls true IIld oorreot. )( ~r AFFIANT SWORN TO AND SU em I!:- fl. \Nolorv PublIC. state Of Florida " .lMVc..",liIIon~Nc>l21,2lJl1 W Commmllslon # 00258528 'R:.~'" Bonded By Naftonal Notary AIIn. ,Aue 20,02 12.03p p.3 - . BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIt" Thls AllIdal'llls made put&uanl \0 Se<<ion 31-71(bl(2)(i) of fle City of AventUlllland Development Co<Ie. The uncIe1ilgnecl NfIanl hereby dlsdoses toat (malk wlUl 'x' applicable pollions only) M'llIllt does II21l1ave a Business Relatlo~ wlUl any member of \he CIty CommI8slon or any CIly Advlsoly Board to wllIoh fle appIl0aU0n wi! be pruented. J K1. \... 112. ., IUlVesl. The nature of the Business Relationship Is u follows: III. Member of City CommIssion or Board holds an ovmershlp Interest In excess of 1 % oIllllal usets or capltat s1lld< 01 Appfioant or RepresenlaUve; II Ii. Member of City Cclmmlsslon or Boal\fls a pamer, c:o-chareholder (es III shares of a corporallon wl1lch are not Iistecl on any nallonal Of regional s1lld< excI1angel Of JoInt venlUm wllh the Appllc8nt Of Represenla1lve In any buslnesa venture; II Ri. The ,l;lp/icanl or RepresenlaUve Is a Client of a member 01 \he City CommIssion or Boanl or a ClIent 01 another professional working from the came office or lor the "'"" empbyer as the member or fle City Commission or Board; II iv. A City Commissioner or Board member Is a Client 01 the Applloant or Representative; { I v. The ,l;lplloant or Representative Is a Cuslomer ot fle member of fle CIty Comml$S1on or Board (or 01 his or her employe~ and transaols more flen $tO,ooo.oo 01 fle business of \he member 01 the CIty Commission or Board (or his or her employe~ In a given oe.Iendar year, 11 vi. The member of fle CIty Commission or Boanlls a Customer of the Applicant or RepresenlaUve and transacls more than $25,000.00 of fle business of Ihe ApfiIIcanI Of Represenlative In a given oalendar year. WIlNESSMVHANOlHlSRDAVOF Nowmb", 2001.3 APPUCANT: M'18nt hereby d'lSoloses fhat ft does !\ave a Business Relationship wlUl a member 01 lIle City Commission or a City Advl$cry Board to widell the applloaUon wlI1 be presented. u follows: . (Ust name of Commlllloner or AdvIsoIy Qoard Membe~ who serves on \he (list City CommIssion or City Advl80ry Boanl upon wl1lch member By. Name: 1lt1e: (Signature) (Pdnq (?rlnQ WITNESS MY HAND nus _ DAY OF PROPERlY OWNER: .2001. By. Name: TItle: (Signature) (PdnQ (Prlnq .' '7lI6 fenns 'Business Relationship,' 'Client,' 'Gustomer,' 'AppUcanl,' 'ReprusenfaUve' and 'interested Person' are deUned In See/Ion 2-395 o/the AvsnlUra Clly Code. A~,.~0.02 12.031' 1'.4 NOTARllATION PROVISION .. SWORN TO Nltl ....","~l~ ROSARIO R. 8ERUW)ES f' ,NotcIlY~'State IF ~--.. .~... ~: Cammmlsalon # 00258528 '....~Qj1 ,- "rilt' Bonded By NatIonal Notary A5an. , STAlE OF I\llIIII#. , .COUKlY OFMWolI-o.\DeI ..... n, .. tnltnlgnod 1IUflDIIIl', ftC10CIIlIr IlIl'GIrtd """'" .1OCIMcl..1s M'.so.t lor.. _ _lid". ond IIolI ~ no ond_ SWOON TO NltlllUllSC1\lBEIl boIolI mo Ills _lIlYol .l!OOl. ... Mionl. oIlo "'~ fdlbr OW dilly ....... lIlI ..... elf oll'rml1ll AFIWfT NololyPWlllSIo1o ol_ N.LolllI Pdnlod Nonw 01 HIWY My4)O(i..AAI....... IrAlE Of ROADA I COUKlYOf'MW.\I-oHle) Belen me, .. Ill1<lenlgnocl 'u'IloIflr, pel1Ol\Ily oppelle<l ........ ...cuIed Ills MIdi" lor.. _...lIotocl.....1n and...,.1s "" .1lIl_ '" M'lOI\1, oIlo being il1Ibr mo dlAy .......lIlI..... " Iff"" 1111 SWORN TO NltlIltlBSOl\IBEIl "'Ien me.... _ Clay ol l!OO1. AFFW!T Nololy.....1IO 61111 01_ H\.Il1II Pdnlod Nonw 01 Nololy Mycomm1stlon ',,"'" IlATEOf'ROAIDA I COUKlY OF MlMIIoO.IllE) Belen me, ... \ll1delllgnocl .uIl1ortly, pel1Ol1ll1y oweartd IIoIIho 1l00oul6d Ills M'tdaYllIor'" _.IlaIacl.....1n lnII"II'~,,", oIlIl_ 111 M'~n~ oIlo be~ lilt by mo duly IWOm, 1IIcI..... 0< .1lImI1Iot AFIWfT SWORN TO AND SUB6OII19EO belo.. mo.... _ d.y 01 . l!OOl , " HoIIIyPIiIlo6taloal_N.\.IlvI Pa1nlldNonwolNollly My.....-."",," Aue 20 02 12.03p . . WITNESS MY H ...1LOAYOF No v etII be(' .~3 REP '/... By: !ly: (Slglllllure Name: Name: (Ptinl! 11Ue: (Ptfnt) lltle' (Ptfnt) By. (Slgllltunl) By: (SIgnature Name' (PrInt) Name: (Ptinl! 1lUe' (Ptfnt) lltle: (ptfn/) By. (S/gnatUIV) By. (SIgnature Name' (print) Name: (pml) , 'nit: fPtfnt) lltle' (Prfnl! , By: (Signature) By: (SIgnature Name' (Print) Name: (PtfnQ , -. (print) lltle: (Ptfnt) . By. (SlgnaIure) By: (Signature N8n\e' (ptfnll Name: (POOl! 1lUe: (Ptfnl) lltle: (ptfnl! By. (Slgllllture) By. (SIgnature Name' (Ptfnt) Name: (Prfnt) llle' (Ptfnl! lltle: (ptfnl! , NOTE: 1) Use duplicate Shetls If disclosure Informallon for RepmenlaUve varies 21 Applicants and Afflants are advised to Umely supplement this Affidavit pursuant to See, 31.71(b)(2){lv) 01 the CIty's Land Development RegUlaUons In the City Code, In Ibe evenllbat prior to conalderaUon ot the applloaUon by lI1e CIty Board or Commlulon. the Infonnallon provided In the Affidavit b~me.lnoorrect or Incomplete. . p,S FACSIMILE COVER SHEET [B DAVID PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES, INC. TRANSPORT AnON. CIVIL. STRUCTURAL . ENVIRONMENTAL t7S0 PONCE DE LEON BOULEVARD' CORAL GABLES. FLORIDA 33134 PHONE: (305) 447-0900 FAX: (305) 4444986 ~ At,MA ~ ~ - c:;?.lJv..,o..fFRO~ /..;.: d5& ,.~ TO: RE: FAX# ~b5) q 4-/- 7',!/p7 PROJ. NO, () 3 ";)..../ tl TIME: ~: p-- DATE: III t:1. o:?---. COMMENTS: NUMBER OF PAGES BEING SENT, INCLUDING THIS ONE ~ la-~aV-ZO[3 '1;31A~ .~, WIPeIIIWW ....I~ fftDA-Consu I-Tech (orj; ~~.4:81433 ~IUolIo.l"'" II.........'......' ii-""'''''~~'iilI'~''~ 1-311 , ~ p.OaZ/aa4 F-4IZ 11W.~ ""IIIIC KY. &D,OI II.Olp , , :STc. 1U8lH9IfllLA'ttONMP AFROAVlt' p.. ~. 1lIlI.,.IlCNdtOQlMlt too... at-nMCIKIlltw Qf If MNln LW Ctl.d.,-- . . 0IcII. Tht -. '. ""U''''1rir ....t'IIt_..~tlIPbtAI...~ . C')6. Mld.L_IIIlI.IIMI"''''''- ....wlIIIlIIf...,.,OI..ClJoo...t ItDlII'..ar~ . ~ ",lI-l'HilIhlfi'\' T .""..~ . \.. ilL mMhnbr__IlIlUlWd'~"_.AldIllIlfR*Gl"QIlra... ".l1n GlW~IOIIIl""'Iii~.llI"lllnlld,.'" o;III_IlI00.,d I' IIUI'AlhIIGtY"'~."'." ~ llIlr GM.'" or our MIitI't lIiMII .... .... iiWij. .. '\lit... ot........ Rl~.dt II utllwll III, ....OfQlrCll.,.. ..1llIIlI1IIlIIII.1lMIIlIlP....1l_..I.oIW...... .........tI~lII'......_...JIl . II L ....." CIr~, LIlli '" "III ~. ca IlLIII Iflr ~lIl111t..lIllllllJlllliln ,......IIIIlIIII.,............."""-lflIl...-...... ~cr ftl;1&QJn .........Wl!lIIIl U" "'Adlalllll'lIIIl_1 r 'W.....a1I....ar..Qritrl . 1]1 .._orIClllll lIl.v.r~WOlItif-.. _1lIIOe ","'N_ ........1MIIlIMl "... CilfCRtMtlAcrton; , AC\''''' ..&.....IOIIIIIIIllIbIr~ltldd...tWIIIIIll.._- . I.Il 'NHiMO*==..~"....;........IIIrO"M'J Ihl" """....01 hla .1iIt.. ...1IIIwNlI_ .. ttO,lXllOO 0111II ~ II h........ III CIw c.t.llL..~or "NlGC'HI~4"'_--rw; . , U..... 'h"'al...~o.....dI,Ill,Il"""'U' 'J#ut~."""-~" ...... _ hn .,s.ooul " ... 11\I1'*' " .. or ~ la .. _ ""JW. . ' . Uc>? . 'Ml\.Jlt. r.tY\M)H.2...W.YOl' V~ .-or. II.... II~. .~~,..-. r ~ 11I1 MTHANDlKI _oi.VOll flIC, J ;11 D'fINliIII .1QQ11 =- .,.. r '" "RNI1Inn1 'Iull_IllllIIIiIIIa' 'CIIII." "1IllIIK.~' __lra<<II"_" " 1lMM'. dIIttd oil ....".,.,lI'IIoI\I._JLc:rt_ . , , lD-~OV-ZB[3 '1;3!A~ ..'"1"""''''' .......... FI:W-':;onsll-Tech (on:; ~~44::B1433 "~1IIWW 'f"l~I~ ... illinot.'" .~.~WllJI.~ 1-31i P.I04/004 F-4IZ .....PIfi<J II'UVloI ..~. ~. a. 1_'0." .... VIm ... MY IWlD "....::z...M'I' llF jJ., \t-tMbU 1IOC'3 ~~~":'.- :.. ~ <ut\IIJ.fr" ~ ' ,. lI\ IIIlI ~ .qw,I ,., ....A~.. .", ,., ...' ,. ,.. ""~. If' .. ....... "'ltIII ,.. .-,..~ llr- ... ~ .,. llIlr. IIJ .tI.nJ ~ .. ..... 'I'lWJ ..... lIltio.... ir: -.till NIII\II ,.... ... ." - . 'II I . f"IlIt . . ,. ...... .....a.- .trdIq .... ... f"r IIr, 'IMe 'f8! jl'L. "'1'1 IJlhII 'I'ltIII NIl- ,.. .... .,. -.J tr. M film I' -'.a. . .. lMlQ ... 11 UIIfl.fIllJ\n~Kdlulnlll~.""'IIIl. ""Wl!II EiIl1f.AIIuII....I1MHilIl~I=.... fiE16....I1==r.. ""'~l"a....' ~.....0IIf lllMlMl\lllllll 1t-.1Ih. I..."" IIr acw.IIIId.~IIoIlll""III..a Ill"'" LI..___.... .' . ,I ,\ lD-~OV-ZD[3 '1;31t~ ..' U"G.toIUIJ .............. FIIDA-':onsu I-Tech (on:; ~~""""''''IIV'1Wl''\''''' l[14,81(3l "~.YTI'..-......n"r";'~"~ 1-31i P.I03/00( F-(lZ '1W, ~ ...,.. 11.1,1 ,"0. a. a.1 asp ,.4 _.1&.1 tIW&II!ImII~ . ...~......, _tl"''' ~'IO""I. -........."':2... N..w",Jw..,.; r.'a\. Kmy~_ . 'oJ . MI' c_ DOIOllUO '\'t"J ..__.~_ j . -..- ml ...,......11II ..... _,... ,I' ", .........................7 ~~..hI.... ... MloI....'" N"'. ........._.....llII ~ 1lIOIIl1ORMIClIlll._MIilI...._... ... .....____.11.... ~~iJ:t =0:=""': ........=...~::;:;;;~_1If1lM '. ...,...... WIt .." 1M'" _., -_........ 1W111lUlI_MI I n_..",_.ol iII'IWlt' .1. .,....., "~~~.IIII- ..........., -. "-~__r .. .. . ..,....__.,.. ____._hI. - _'ftIIIIIUllMcumWIII...._. 11III1. M.\."'_IlPdl#l~ r:=stJ ," O~{G.{ALItL DAVID PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES TRANSPORTATION. CIVIL. STRUCTURAL. ENVIRONMENTAL 1750 PONCE DE LEON BOULEVARD CORAL GABLES. FLORIDA 33134 305447,0900 FAX, 30S 444,4986 E-mail: dpa@dplummer.com November 11, 2003 Mr. Clifford Schulman, Esq. Greenberg Traurig 1221 Brickell Avenue, 21 st Floor Miami, FL 33131 (305) 579-0613 RE: 2600 Island BoulevardlWilliams Island Svnaaoaue - #03210 Dear Cliff: The purpose of this letter is to address the traffic circulation and pedestrian issues brought forward by the 2600 Island Boulevard Condominium Association, Inc. and to suggest additional improvements to mitigate those concerns. The Williams Island Synagogue is proposed for relocation at the 2600 Island Boulevard building in Williams Island, FL. This synagogue will be located in an existing commercial condo unit in the parking garage adjacent to the loading dock, ACCESS DRIVEWAY/LOADING DOCK Exclusive access to the synagogue is from an entryway adjacent to a 20-foot wide access driveway, This space cannot be accessed from the lobby or elevator of the building. The purpose of this access driveway is for ingress/egress to the parking garage and the loading dock on the east end. Field observation revealed that a substantial number of contractor vehicles are parking along the north side of this access driveway narrowing the roadway width to approximately 12-feet for two-way traffic. Thus, while designed as a narrow two-way access driveway, it is functioning as a two-way, one-lane driveway. During field observations, the driveway operated acceptably because of its very low vehicular volumes and speeds, Further, this CORAL GABLES . FORT MYERS . FORT LAUDERDALE @E) November 11, 2003 RE: 2600 Island BoulevardlWilliams Island Syna~o~ue. #03210 Page 2 of 4 driveway access is used as a pedestrian connection from the water to Island Boulevard. Many pedestrians were observed walking on this access driveway even though there are no sidewalks. Their comfort in doing so may be due to the small amount of vehicles that were observed using this access driveway. The loading dock on the east end of the access driveway also has an adequate maneuvering area to better accommodate truck access to the loading dock. Trucks approach the loading dock, pull head-in to the maneuvering area, and then back up into the loading dock. On exit, the trucks simply turn right and head west on the access driveway. The days and hours of operation for the loading dock are Monday through Friday from 8am and 4pm and are closed on Saturday and Sunday. Based on the information provided, the Williams Island Synagogue will not have services while the loading dock is open. As we discussed today, the vast majority of the people destined for the synagogue will arrive via foot The project has agreed to construct sidewalk on the east side of Island Boulevard from the Williams Island entrance (NE 183 Street) south to the 7000 Building driveway. This will better accommodate pedestrians in the area and make for a safer pedestrian environment Also as part ofthe project, sidewalk will be constructed on the north side of the 2600 Building access driveway from Island Boulevard to the parking garage entrance. On days of worship, a 5-foot wide, temporary walkway is proposed. This will be accomplished using moveable posts or cones on the north side of the access driveway from the east end of the park garage entrance to just east of the entryway to the synagogue. This walkway delineates an area for the pedestrians to use as they walk toward the synagogue entrance. During this period of worship, the access driveway will be approximately 15-feet wide in the area of the walkway, which will more than adequately accommodate a fire truck. Fortunately, the loading dock is closed while the synagogue is being used. Vehicles using the access driveway during this period are anticipated to be very minimal, if any at all. After ~ November II, 2003 RE: 2600 Island BoulevardlWilliams Island Synagogue. #03210 Page 3 of4 services are completed at the synagogue, the temporary walkway area will be removed and regular operations of the access driveway will resume, The access driveway is also used as a fire lane. As you informed me today, the Miami-Dade County Fire Department has reviewed and approved the modifications to the access driveway. PARKING AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS FROM PARKING AREAS The parking garage at the 2600 Island Boulevard building has 368 parking spaces, although it is only required to have 215 parking spaces. This is a surplus of 153 parking spaces. Ten of these parking spaces will be specifically designated for use by the synagogue. They will be located on the south side of the parking garage near the entryway to the synagogue, It is anticipated that the vast majority of people will corne to the synagogue via foot. However, if additional parking is needed (beyond the 153 surplus parking spaces), there is parking for non-residents across Island Boulevard at the tennis court area. The western most parking space within the parking garage which will serve the synagogue is within 300-feet of this parking area. While marked crosswalks exist on Island Boulevard both north and south of the tennis court parking area, it is recommended that a pedestrian crosswalk be installed across Island Boulevard from the north end of this parking area to the existing sidewalk on the east side of Island Boulevard to better facilitate the crossing of Island Boulevard. This crosswalk will then be interconnected into the existing sidewalk system and the pedestrian will proceed to the synagogue as described above. Williams Island has already implemented many traffic calming features on Island Boulevard like speed humps and stop signs to keep vehicles at a low level of speed for a safe pedestrian environment, and our visual observations indicate that Island Boulevard operates adequately. ~ November II, 2003 RE: 2600 Island Boulevard/Williams Island Synagogue - #03210 Page 4 of 4 In summary: . The pedestrian access improvements and walkway will adequately serve the needs of the synagogue and will not create a safety hazard to drivers or pedestrians. . Adequate parking is available to meet the needs of this synagogue. . No hazard to fire safety access will be created by this use. . It is suggested that a new pedestrian crosswalk be installed across Island Boulevard from the tennis court parking area to better serve the synagogue. Please call me at (305) 447-0900 if you have any questions regarding this information. Sincerel <C' ,.... Tim/thy;'. President lummer, PE cc: File 2600ib.let.doc EXHIBIT BOOK FOR WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE. INC. APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL TO LOCATE A RELIGIOUS FACILITY AT 2600 ISLAND BLVD. A VENTURA CITY COMMISSION NOVEMBER 12, 2003 ( WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE. INC. APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL TO LOCATE A RELIGIOUS FACILITY AT 2600 ISLAND BLVD. A VENTURA CITY COMMISSION November 12, 2003 Tab 1. Letter of Intent and Application for Conditional Use Approval for 2600 Island Blvd, Location. 2, Letter from Clifford A. Schnlman to Aventura Mayor and City Commission Objecting to Proposed "Conditional Use" Amendment. 3. Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution I Equal Protection Clause 4. List of Relevant Case Law re: Equal Protection A. Excerpt from Vinevard Christian F ellowshiTJ of Evanston, Inc. v. Citv of Evanston, 250 F. Supp2d 961 (N.D.Ill. 2003) "~ ( B. Excerpt from Love Church v. Citv of Evanston, 671 F.Supp. 515 (N.D,Ill. 1987), vacated on other grounds, 896 F.2d 562 (7th Cir. 1990) 5, Excerpt from RLUlPA Congressional Intent 6. Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000 ("RLUIPA), 42 U.S.c. ~ 2000cc - 2000cc-5) 7. List of Case Law Supporting RLUlPA A. Excerpt from Cottonwood Christian Center v. CVTJress RedeveloTJment Allencv, 218 F,Supp,2d 1203 (C.D. Cal. 2002). B. Westchester Dav School v, Villalle of Mamaroneck, 2003 WL 22110445 (S,D.N.Y.) 8, List of Case Law Finding RLUlPA to be Unconstitutional .~ 9. Florida Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1998, ~ 761.03, Fla. Stat. (2002) ---- 10. Section 760.26, Florida Statutes (2002) 11. List of Case Law Upholding Florida Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1998 A. Excerpt from Warner v. Citv of Boca Raton, 64 F.Supp2d 1272 (S.D. Fla. 1999) 12. Aerial Photo of Williams Island 13, Aerial Photo of 2600 Building aud Parkiug Structure 14. Map of Area Indicatiug Distauce and Deuomination of Other Synagogues 15. Timeline of Synagogue Locations 16. Aerial Photo of Williams Island Indicating Various Locations 17, Letter from Joe Sins on, Building Manager for 2000 Building Re: Lack of Complaints from Building Residents ~ 18, Chart re: Inadequacies of 2000 Building Facility and Violations of Halacha Which are Compelled as a Result of Such Inadequacies, 19. Synagogue Certificate of Use and Occupational License for 2600 Building 20, Aerial Photo of 2600 Building Indicating Location of Valet, Lobby, and Entrauce to Proposed Facility 21. Reduced Floor Plans for Proposed Synagogue 22, Rendering of Fal;ade of Proposed Synagogue 23. Reduced Plans for Pedestrian Improvements 24, Reduced Floor Plans for 2600 Building Party Room 25. Register of Users and Uses of 2600 Building Party Room 26. Excerpts from Aventura Comprehensive Plan Transportation Element 27. Pictures re: Daily Use of Area ~ 28. Chart Re: 2600 Building Loading Dock Rules ~ 29. Chart Comparing Hours of Operation of 2600 Building Loading Dock and Williams Island Synagogue 30. Pictures re: Use of Area as a One Way Drive 31. Chart re: 2600 Building Parking Spaces and 2600 Building Site Plan 32. Excerpt from Declaration of Condominium re: Use of Commercial Unit 33. Case Law re: Parking Requirements and Religious Uses A. Citv of Miami Beach v. 100 Lincoln Road. Inc" 214 So.2d 39 (Fla. 3d DCA 1968) B. State ex rei, Tamoa, Florida Comoanv of Jehovah's Witnesses. North Unit. Inc. v, Citv of Tamoa, 48 So.2d 78 (Fla. 1950) C. Westchester Dav School v, Villaf!e ofMamaroneck, 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y,) ~ D. Orthodox Minvan of Elkins Park v. Cheltenham Townshio Zoninf! Hearinf! Board, 552 A. 2d 772 (Comwlth. Ct. Pa. 1989) E. Debes v. Citv of Kev West, 690 So.2d 700 (Fla. 3d DCA 1997) 34. Proposed Conditions for Conditional Use Approval 35. Chart re: Criteria for Approval of Conditional Use and Applicant's Compliance and Memorandum of Law by Cliff Schulman, Esq. Re: RLUIPA and Parking Considerations 36, Resume and Credentials of Mr. Michael Y. Cannon 37, Resume of Mr. Tim Plummer 38. Excerpt from Neuman v. Grandview at Emerald Hills, Inc., (Case No. 4D02- 1125, Fla. 4th DCA) ~ r-- ~~H~~[~~ ATTUKNF.'YS ,,'r I.."" H~~~I~ Clifford A. Schulman (J05) 579-O61l Direct Fax: (305) 961-561l E.Mait schulmanc@gtlaw.com December 20, 2002 VIA FACSIMILE Ms. Joann Carr Planning Director City of Avcntura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Re: Letter of Intent for Conditional Use Approval for Williams Island Synagogue. Inc. (' Dear Ms. Carr: This office represents Williams Island Synagogue, Inc., the Applicant for Conditional Use Approval (the "Applicant"), pursuant to Section 31-73 of the Land Development Regulations of the City of Aventura As shown on the enclosed application, the property which is the subject of this application is presently owned by Williams Island Synagogue, Inc., which has consented to the filing of this application. Please note thallhis application is being filed under protest and without prejudice to the Applicant's rights under both the federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, 42 U.S.C. g 2000cc, et seq. (RLUIPA) (copy attached) and the Florida Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1998, Chapter 761, Florida Statutes (2002) (copy attached) . 1. Obiection to ReQuirement fotConditional Use Approval. United States Constitution and Laws To the eKtent that the City's Comprehensive Plan (the "Plan") and Land Development Regulations ("LDRs") require religious institutions to seek conditional use approval, we believe that both the Plan and the LDRs violate RLUIP A in three respects: (i) by imposing a "substantial burden" on religious institutions: (ii) by discriminating against religious institutions; and (iii) by placing unreasonable restrictions on land-use permits for religious assemblies and institutions. .~ RLUIP A forbids the imposition of a "substantial burden" on religious institutions: GnUNLlIHlG TUURU;, I',A. 1221 nKlr,KF.t1. Anr-.-ur.: MI.\MI, FLUIlIIH HI31 1nc::. "":'tl./lc;un ...~ \' 'HI!\."i71).u711 ww\~.!.'II;lW.CUIl1 . . ./'" /'" ,,-- Ms. J oAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 2 (1) GENERAL RULE - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution, unless the government demonstrates that imposition of the burden on that person, assembly, or institution (A) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (B) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest. (2) SCOPE OF APPLICATION - This subsection applies in any case in which-- (A) the substantial burden is imposed in a program or activity that receives Federal financial assistance, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; (B) the substantial burden affects, or removal of that substantial burden would affect, commerce with foreign nations, among the several States, or with Indian tribes, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; or (C) the substantial burden is imposed in the implementation of a land use regulation or system of land use regulations, under which a government makes, or has in place formal or informal procedures or practices that permit the government to make, individualized assessments of the proposed uses for the property involved. RLUIP A also provides that it is to be given a "broad construction" in order to guarantee a "broad protection of religious exercise to the maximum extent" allowed under the law. 42 U.S.C. S 2000cc-3(g). The Synagogue, which is clearly a "religious assembly or institution" protected under RLUIP A, is only permitted under the Comprehensive Plan and the LDR's to be in this zoning district with a conditional use permit. This constitutes an unlawful "substantial burden" under RLUIPA. Second, the Plan and LDRs violate the RLUIP A prohibitions against discriminatory treatment of religious exercise and institutions: (1) EQUAL TERMS - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than equal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution. (2) NONDISCRIMINATION - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation that discriminates against any assembly or institution on the basis of religion or religious denomination. /"" ( Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 3 42 U.S.C.2000cc(B). ~ While the Applicant is required to seek a conditional use permit for religious activities, private parties, meetings and other types of assemblies to persons located both within and without the development - and conducted at the same time in the condominium building in which the Synagogue is located - are not required by the Plan or the LDR's to obtain a conditional use pennit. The Comprehensive Plan and the LDRs put the Synagogue, and any other religious institutions or assemblies attempting to meet in the City of A ventura, "on less than equal terms" with the non-religious assemblies or institutions, in addition to subjecting religious institutions to a "substantial burden" that is not otherwise applicable to like assemblies. Such disparate treatment of religious assemblies is a clear violation ofRLUIPA. Murphy v. Zoning Comm 'n of Town of New Melford, 148 F. Supp.2d 173 (D.C. Conn. 2001) (injunction issued to prevent town from prohibiting religious meetings in single family neighborhood where single family residents were allowed to have private, non-religious parties in same area without specific zoning approval).RLUIP A claims may be brought in federal court and a successful plaintiff may be awarded under the Act. Thc provisions ofRLUIP A have been recently upheld against constitutional attack, Freedom Baptist Church of Delaware County v. Township of Middleton, 204 F.Supp.2d 857 (E.D. Pa. 2002). This disparate treatment of religious institutions under Policy 1.31 of the Plan and the newly adopted LOR's also directly violates the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. See, Freedom Baptist Church, 204 F.Supp.2d at 869 ("equal tenus" provision of RLUIPA codifies Supreme Court's First Amendment jurisprudence). The Supreme Court has held that, "[a]t a minimwn, the protections oflhe Free Exercise Clause [of the First Amendment] pertain if the law at issue discriminated against some or all religious beliefs or regulates or prohibits conduct because it is undertaken for religious reasons." Church ofLukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of Hialeah , 508 U.S. 520,532 (1992). Because Policy 1.3 and the LDRs disparately treat religious and non-religious institutions and assemblies, the Plan and the LDRs violate the First Amendment. Id. at 533 ("if the object of a law is to infringe upon or restrict practices because of their religious motivation, the law is not neutral and it is invalid unless it is justified by a compelling interest and is narrowly tailored to advance that interest"). Finally, Policy 1.3 of the Plan and the LDRs are also unreasonable, and thus violate the Exclusions and Limits provision ofRLUIPA. Section 2(b)(3)(B) ofRLUIPA, the Exclusions and Limits provisions, states: r- I Policy 1.3 of the City's Comprehensive Plan states: "Community facilities (including schools) and places of worship shall be allowed on property with a residential or blL<iness and office land use designation through the conditional use procedures found in the City's land development regulations. . . ." ~ Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 4 No government shall impose or implement a land us regulation that - . . . (B) unreasonably limits religious assemblies, institutions, or structures within a jurisdiction. [d. RLUPA's Exclusions and Limits provisions codify the United States Supreme Court decisions under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. See, Freedom BaDtist Cburch. 204 F.Supp. 2d at 871. ~ The Supreme Court has held that the Equal Protection Clause prohibits irrational distinctions in land use laws. City ofCleburne v, Cleburne Living Center, 473 U.S. 432, 105 S.C!. 3249 (1985). In Clebume, the City required a special use permit for homes for the mentally retarded, but did not require a special use pennit for other multi-family uses such as apartment houses and boarding houses, in the same zoning district. Id. at 447. The Court stated the government could differentiate between uses only if the use which needed a special use permit "would threaten legitimate interests of the city in a way that other permitted uses. , . would not." Id. at 448. Here, no more, and no different, disturbance to the condominium residents could result from a religious worship service than would result from a community citizens' meeting or a private party. The City of Aventura has no reasonable basis to require, under the Plan, that religious institutions and assemblies must obtain a conditional use permit in order to use space in a condominium, while not requiring non-religious institutions or assemblies to do the same. Policy 1.3 ofthe City of A ventura's Comprehensive plan therefore violates both the Exclusions and Limits provision ofRLUIPA and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Based on the foregoing, the City of Aventura's Comprehensive Plan could be challenged under RLUIP A, the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of Fourteenth Amendment. We would respectfully request that the Comprehensive Plan language which appears to require a conditional use approval for such religious uses/assemblies be modified so as to eliminate the requirement for a conditional use approval for religious uses that are held in such facilities. This is not to say, that conditional use approval might not be appropriate for a free-standing religious institution that is not conducting its activities in a manner that is identical to other uses taking place, as of right, in a particular zoning district, and the Commission may wish to distinguish such situations. ,-- ~' I Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18,2002 Page 5 Florida Law The Florida Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1998 also protects against the imposition of substantial burdens on religious activities. Section 761.03, Florida Statutes (2002), states: (I) The government shall not substantially burden a persons exercise of religion, even if the burden rcsults from a rule of general applicability, except that government may substantially burden a persons exercise of religion only ifit demonstrates that application ofthe burden to the person: (a) Is in furtherance ofa compelling governmental interest; and ~ (b) Is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest. (2) A person whose religious exercise has been burdened in violation of this section may assert that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief. But Florida went even further then this generalized protection for religious institutions and, following the lead of United States Congress, further amended the statutes in 2000 to specifically address land use decisions oflocal zoning authorities. Section 760.26, Florida Statutes (2002), provides: It is unlawful to discriminate in land use decisions or in the pennitting or development based on race, color, national origin, sex, disability, familial status, religion, or, except as otherwise provided by law, the source of financing of a development or proposed development. Based on these provisions, we believe that requiring Applicant to even apply for a conditional use approval will be ultimately detennined to be violate ofbolh federal and Florida law. Reasons for the Granting of the Aoolication r While maintaining our objections, noted above, we believe that the application for conditional use should be granted and that the application meets the specific criteria of Section 31-73(c) of the Land Development Regulations. Your review of the application submitted will /"" , Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18, 2002 Page 6 show: The proposed use is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; the establislunent, maintenance or operation of the proposed use will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, or general welfare; the proposed use is consistent with the community character of the immediate neighborhood of the proposed use; utilities, roadway capacity, drainage, and other necessary public facilities. including police, fire and emergency services, exist at the City's adopted levels of service, or will be available concurrently with demand as provided for in the requirements of the City's Land Development Regulations; adequate measures exist or will be taken to provide ingress and egress to the proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets; the establishment of the proposed conditional use will not impede the development of surrounding properties for uses permitted in their respective zoning districts; and the design of the proposed use minimizes adverse effects, including visual impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent properties through the use of building orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria. As part of your review, we would suggest the following factors should be considered: ~ ,~ }> A synagogue has been operating in Williams Island, at another location, for over 12 years and, to our knowledge, no complaint has ever been filed with any governmental agency regarding those operations; }> As a result, we submit that the operations of a Synagogue on Williams Island is a "grandfathered", non-conforming use or, in the altemative, a permitted accessory use; }> Tbe membership of the Synagogue is approximately 200 members and of that total, approximately 90% are residents of Williams Island; }> The Synagogue is for the Orthodox Jewish faith, which has as one of its tenets, that automobiles may not be used on the Sabbath (i.e., from sundown on Friday until sundown on Saturday), which is when the majority of religious services are held; }> The plan for the location of the Synagogue in the 2600 building will show that ingress and egress to the commercial condominium unit so designated is not through the lobby of the building but, instead, is through the "back door" of the building and on its lowest, non-residential floor... approximately 1,050 feet from the front lobby of the building; }> The unit where the Synagogue will be located is a "commercial" condominium unit and not a residential unit. As such, it can be used for other purposes with significantly greater impacts than thc proposed use; }> Parking for anyone that will use the Synagogue on holidays or on a daily basis, when it is not the Sabbath, will not be in the 2600 building, but will be located on the southerly side of the existing Mediterranean Village tennis courts; }> The Synagogue conducts two services on weekdays, in the morning and evening, with approximately 10-15 persons in attendance at each service. On the Sabbath (Friday evening and Saturday morning services), approximately 80-130 persons are in attendance. . ' ( Ms. JoAnn Carr December 18,2002 Page 7 }> The total number of seats that will be pl:u:ed in the main sanctuary will be 212 seats, and it only anticipated that this capacity will be met on the High Holy Days, which consists of only two days for Rosh Hashanah and one day for Yom Kippur. The attendance on the second day of Rosh Hashanah normal attracts attendance that is 1/2 of those attending on the first day of the holiday; }> The "Party Room" in the 2600 building is utilized for social functions virtually each day of each weekend with occupancy far in excess of those anticipated for the Synagogue; }> Social functions in the Party Room of the 2600 building are conducted year round and havc an average size per event of approximately 80-100 people, with a great majority of the attendees at these parties being off-Island residents, who utilize their vehicles to attend these events, use the main lobby and utilize the parking in the 2600 building itself. We respectfully request your prompt and favorable review and approval of this request. If you have any further questions regarding this matter, please feel free to call. ,/'" Sit'\Cerely, CAS/cph fo1Z- r- ~ :j1;t'~ . , RECEIVED CITY Of AVlNTURA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ~,;.. ~ ( - 2003 10200 Wttt'CounIry C1ubDrlva Awntura, FloIIcla 33180 (305) 48H84O rjOMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PUBUC HEARING APPLICATION FOR CONDITIONAL USE DATE: PROPOSED PROJEaT HAME: williams Island Synagogue, Inc. LOCAT~N: 2600 Island Bou~evard, CU-1 LEGALDESCRlPTION: See attached Exhibit "A" FOUO NUMBER(al: 28-2210-081-0001 CURRENT ZONING: RMF 4 CURRENT LAND USE: PROPOSED use OF PROPERTY: (Attach ackllUona'ah..ta If MC8l11ryl Temple located on the ground floor of the parking garage which is adjacent to the condo building. ~ Harne of AppUcant or Conlaot Penon: Williams Island Synaqoque, Inc. Phone No.: Add_ of ApplICant 4000 Island Boulevard. unit PH~4 Aventura, Fl 33160 NM1t 01 Property Ownar (If 011I., lllan Appllc:anll: , Williams Island Synaqoque, Inc. Add_ of Propertv Owner. , 4000 Island Boulevard Phone No.: Williams Island, Fl 33160 /' 1, The followlna documents are reaulrtd to be eubmltted with and deemed to be Incol'llol'lltd Into this aetJUon. I' aDDllcable: ALL APPLICATIONS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY A LETTER OF INTENT. Please describe In detail, whether and to what axtent the requmed development eetlon ,erve. a pubic; benefit which would warrant the granting of the teqUllt and lpeolllc ju.uncatJon lor approVlI 01 the application, nature 01 the ~este and any other pertinent Infonnallon. Insufl10lent Justfficatlon may result In the denial of your applfoation. One (1) o~glnal application, algned and notarized by tile applicant, owner andlor attomey and, II naceuary, authorIRUon to anotl1er individual to repreNnt the applicant, One (1) original, current (wtthln 3D days) Qwnershlp and Encumbrano81 Report for the subject property and cop'" of doCllllHlnts referenced In thet report. A complete zoning hI1tory of tha property I. I'IquHd. The ettached C.rtlIIcall of Resolution. farm muat be CllCl'lnloJted .nd .Ioned hv 10 lII1Om\.n.ri. """"nw... ""'"' "'" 7....1.... ""n/Mafl.... - Tnlve (12) coplM (foIcIecI) of a reg........ CI,lnnt (within 30 ~).1lQ1lId and ..lied II\IMy oIlh1lUblect proptlty. bated upon ... Owntl'lhlp and EIIeumbtuott Repon. 8\lMV1 n.let deInNIiI eldItIng natlll'll fHllll'la, .._Ills. utlllng IlNclurM and UIII, and .xlIlIng uIIIIy InII8. Twelve (12) copies (folded) AqUOf sUlVey, p"parecllnd s..led by IItglIWllClllnd sllMYor. with 1.&00 ft. I'Idtus (rtqulnd for Ipproval 0' Iaung., bar or plcklll' liquor lloft only). Twelve (12) Hte of photographe of exltllng IlNClUl'llS on ,lie and/or 8'x10. color photographe or color rendering of proposed construclion. . Dledoeul'l of Interest Form Leller from applicant ptOvldlng evldenca of compllanca with Level of SeN1ce requirements pUl1Iuant to Sectlon 31-23g of the City Code. ~ .. I". helrlnllMlng requeNd .. I .....It of I vlola1lon notlc. or lummons? Ves No X If yes,ln whose name wu the violation or sunvnone nolle. ..rvlid? NnIrt of vlola1lon Does property owner own conllguouI properly to the subl~ prope!ty1 If 10. glv. compteta Itgll c1.acrfptlon ot .n..... conllguouI property. No .~ .. llMf. an Opllon to purchase or ..... SubJalOt property or property contiguous theNtlo. pNcllcatad on \he .pprowl ot this Ippllclllon? Yes No X If WH. who I,. th. II'IKtacI partin? (Copy of pUrlOha. lOonlrad mu.t bl lubmlttad with thIa .ppllcatlon). Do thne plans represent new construcUon? Hu construcllon .cartad? N / A Hu con.trucllon been completad? An thare any aalallng I_luraa on tha property? Wllllht .ldallng atructuraa be demollahed? V.s_ No X V.. No V.. x No_ v.. y No Yea No x 2. Labels. Notification and Advertlslna (Pursuant to Ordinance No. 97-15) ALL COSTS OF ADVERTISING, MAILING AND POSTING SHALL BE BORNE BY THE APPUCANT, ~ Tilt Convnunlty Development Department ehal prepare and coordinate a published notice of the application and the manlng 01 a courtesy notlce using labels proVIded by the applicant The fOllowing II required or the applicant and must be Dllls.nled with anv and al aDDllcaUons: One (1) notarIZed copy of a Det of the n_ and eddreH8I of al property o...,"er. IoClled wltl1ln 300 fool I'Idlua of the exterior boundary of the subject property, If tha aubJect property conetlllltea only a portion of a conllguoua ownerahlp plIClIl. the 8lllerior boundary from which thl .pproprlate I'lIdlua Ia to ba projectad wUl be the exterior boundary of the enUIll contiguous ownership pal'Qlll. One (1) aet of self-edheslve labels of the ..me Ilat to be used for mamng PUrpOl8l. FaAuI'8 of appllcanllo provide the nrqulred labels will Gonllllule Iii Incomplete aubmlllel package and may CBUse the dalay of the publlo haaring untll.uch time th8lthe I'Iqulred Iabe" 81'8 received The .ubject property shan be potted no latar than len (10) days pIlor to the public hearilg, Such polling wI be dlapl8)'ed In I menner coneplouDUI to the pub/lo, by . "In or ligna no Ieee than 2.... x 38.11I aile and containing Infonnalfon com;eming the IIlpllolflon, Including but ftftt DMIhwf t^ tho IlIftNIM fnr "."1",, .r.tln" .M.... flma .Nt "laM ttllha NIhIII\ ha.tIrv1 r- L "Kina _lid .....rlna F_ A. d1eck made payable to the c~ or Aventura for llie ..mount.of 1860,00. A. check made payable to llaml-Dad. County for 5110,00 'or Concurreney review by the county. Prior to public hearing " A checl< made payable to The City of Avantura for $650.00 to be ueed for public notice malllng&, naW&piaper advsrtlsement end property posting for publlo hearing. 4. ProDertv Violations AI part of the review, your property may be 8Ublect to vanou.lnspecliona by City peraollnel. If building, zoning or COde COmpliance violations are fo..,d, your request for a publIc hearing win be defelT'8d until \ such vIoIatlona are corrected. r- II, RaaDonalbllltv of AD DUCInt It ts the responslblllly of the applicant to a&6ure that II questions In the app&callon and all requlled supplement8ry data are submilled at the time of the filing of the appUcallon and that an IMWtlrI, plana and supplementary data Ire accurate and complete. AI required plans, supplementary data. mailing ..beta and fees must be submitted at the same time as the .ppAcatlon 18 fled, or \he applcatlon wlI be Incomplete. Incomplete appicallons will not be Icheduled for public 1le8llng and wiN be returned to \he appllcanl The r~1ntl of an Incomplete appllcatlon wIH not reserve I p1ac;e on the healing agenda. An application submitted prior \0 lhe deadUne does not automatlcaU.y Insure placement of the appnoallon on that heartng agenda. All data submitted In connection with the application becomes a pennanent part of the public raCO<<le of the CIty of Aventura. ~ For OffiCI Ute n... A..ftIJA.......... D.......&.,...... .__..__....__ 1Il.1.._l__ DEVELOPMENT APPUCATION OWNER CERTIFICATION . 1'..... -..... III tIlIl epply) ~ For UN wIJen """10".,,. III. Owner a' .ublect am= . TIlla It lo otrtlfy IhlIt .am 111. owner of \he lubjed Iallda d.. In \ha IboveappUc:aUon. . UndeI1llI1d IhIt 11m ..Iponalble for complying wtth aa Ippl1oatlon requnmtnla prior to tIIlelMllUon belnQ IChIdlMd for .ny publlo "..ring. I allO undaratand 11I.111 " my "POllIlbIIIty 10 comply wItII tilt Clly'llIqunmtnll regarding qu.>>judlcIel proceedlngl. Thl. furth.r celtlfles lh.tl have /'lid thla pelJtJon Ind tIIa IlaIIlmentl contalnecl hel'lln a.. true and corract. - Print MIme of Patltlolllr STATE OF Signature of p.tItIon.r COUNlY OF The roreooma Intlrumenl "'II Swam 10 Ind Subsaibed blfOAl mllllll_ dav 01 .. 200 , bV ""'" II pelIGl18/lv _ 10 m. or who hu ~ ..-.-. . PrilIOCl H..... 01 Nollly Public My Commlsolon E>qJIIeo: Slgnolla'.oI NocIly Public ~~1~~1~lA&a~~~tl1it.l&lt&&&111111111111111tl111~111111~l11Jl11111111141"11itl111111111111111~1&~All111" For un when DetlUoner" NOT the Owner of the Sub/eet ProDertv: Thla Is to carlify thai I am the owner of IUbjec\ lands deeaibad In \he above petillon. I have authorized Nathan Lewinger to make and file \he .foreHId petition. This further certifiesll1atl have read thia petltfon and Ihe ltatem.nts contained hereIn 'AltNa Ind corract. ~ Print N.me of Own.r Slgnalura of OWner STATE OF COUNTY OF Tbe ""ooaln1lln_ent w. SWum 10 and Sltl.crIbed bel... ma... _ day 01 200 _' by ""'" .. ....-v known '" m. or ""'" hu produoed a~ Prin*l Name 01 ~ PublIc My CommIIlIOn EIipIm: SlgnetuN 01 NoUry PuI>IIo lJllllll_1111111&111&1111111111Ii"~11Jll1&11'1&111111t1111~14Alll&lll'~.Al.~t""""""""'AIA&~111A&I&I& ~ F.enant or Owner AffldllVlt f NRt.hAn T.pwinQ"er . being firatduty nom, depo.. .nd say that I am the ownerltenant 0' the property described Ind which Is the subjel;l mailer of the PlOposed hearing; thaI aD the answers to the qUelllonaln thla appdcation, and aU sketch data and other supplemenlary mailer 11Iachad III and made a part of tile application an honest and true, I und8l1tand \his Ipplk:atlon must be completed and accuralll before a hearing can be advertlaed. In Iha .....ntlhlt I or anyone appearing on my behalf Is found to have made a mater1al mtsrepraaenlltlon, either oral or den, regarding this application. I underaland lhal any deve me eellon may be vdTdable at option of the City of Aventura~ ~ .Jtg~ft L[w I CsE ft Slgn.liI,. STATE OF t~( oA COUNTYOF J);I?>~ TIltfonalllllll ~ WII llwom 0 end Subscribed berON m.... IP day of by }J1f""~ 11...... I ~ I*IOft t , ,.. - - - ~~ry~c' ~1.t~M;=- - My Commllllon ElqIInI: j...j Jl wl!~ z -. .;'11 8 : :;1.!Jjg w ~. .. g~l! : ~. .!! u.. i l~u e DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST ~ If \he property, which It the IUbjec:I or the Ipplk:atlon, It owned or leam by a CORPORATION, lilt lilt p/1nclpllltockholdell and the peroenlage of .lock owned by NCh. [Note: wheIe the pm.. 0~11I or Itoclcholclara conllld of enatlltr COrporatlon(I), trualee(I). parfnel1~S) or other IImlIar enSiles, further dIscJoaUlll IhaD be required which dlac:loHl the identity of the IncIMdual(a) (natural persons) havtng the unlmale ownership Inlerestln \he arolllmentfoned entity). Williams Island Synagogue, Inc.. Corporation Name Name. Address. and Office Percenlege of Stock No stock issued Julius Trump, 4000 Island Blvd.PH4-Director Steohanie Trumo, 4000 Island Blvd.PH4-Director William trump, 4000 Island Blvd.PH4, President Alan Matus, 3000 Island Blvd.PH2, Sec./Treas. Henry Flescher, 19195 Mystic Point Dr.#2106, D~rector Nathan Lewin~er. 2800 Island Blvd. #3004 VP & Chairman of Bldg, Committee If the property which It the IUbJect of the appRcation 18 owned or Jelled by . lRUSTEE, 1lS! the beneficiaries of the trult and the percenlege or Inwrest held by each.. [Note: Wherw lbe benellclary(lea) conalld of corporallon(s), another InItt(I), parlnel'shlp(.) or other IImnar entlIIel, furlt1er dilcloslJre shaR be requlml which discloses II1e Iclenllty of the IndMclual(s) (natural peraona) havfngthe ulllmele ownel1lhlp Intereld In \he afol8ll1enlloned entity). .~ Trust Name Name and Address P_ntege of Interest If the property which Is the subject or the appRcallon is owned or Ieaaed by a PARTNERSHIP or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP:lIslthe principals of tile partnelllhlp, including general and IImftedfartnel'8, snd the percentage of ownership held by .ach. [Note: whele tile parlner(a) COMlst 0 another parinarahlp(s), oorporalionCs), trustCs), or other similar enSUes, further dlaclosulll "'all be required which dildo... the identity or the IndMdual(s) (nalural persons) having the ultimate ownenshlp Interest In the aforementioned entity). Parinerehlp or Limited Partnership Name. Neme end Addreae Percentege of Ownelllhlp ~ ~ If there . a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, whether conllngent on IhIo epplloaUon or not, and WIlelher . CllrportllOll, TRIM, or Pll1nOl1IIlp, 1I8l1lle 111IIIOI Of h 00nlrIcl1lUfO/lUefl beIaw, Incildlng the prlnclpel omon, lIockhold.., benef\c:larlea, or PIIfnera. (Note: ." the pmclpa/ offlotl1l, Itockhokfwa. bentfldlrtee. or parln.,. consist or anotl181 COIPOI1I1Ion, tlu8l, par\nerll)lp, or other aImIIar enllll.., IUrther dllldoeure shel be raqukad which dll<lloMs the ldanllly of \he Indlvlduel(s) (nlJural paraon.) having tile ultimate ownel1lhlp Interest In the IforemenUonecl enlllyJ. Date of ConlJael: Name Name and Addreu Plrcantage of Intere" If any ~on"ngency clause or contrae\ \erma Involve lIddlUonal PIrtlll, list allndlvlduals or officers, If I c;orporallon. paMel1lhlp, or lnl5\. . / For any changes of OWIlfll'&hlp or changes In contracts lor purchase subsequent to the elate of lhe appllcatiori, but prior to Ihe date of final pUblic hearing, a supplemental disclo$ure of interest ahall be filed. f ell parties of Interest In thl. appllcallon to the best of my 6TATEOF Tho ~ s (I ~3 If'. E'Pt.llrW PnA~ Nt"; III NoW" Public My Comrnllllon I!lIpIm: ;1OC(' 0) CARLOS ERSKINE Notary Public. SIaII aI - . . IIy~E>I*oIOI:I'O,2llIl5 c~mmllllan . 00014155 ~ Note: Disclosure stlal not be I8qUlred of any entity, the equity Interelts In whIoh .re regularly tradad on .n ellsblished securities marlcet In tilt Unlled statu or other counlryj or of sny enlliy, lIIe ownel1lhlp Inllll'Nll of which are held In . Imlted parlnwahlp coneltlfng of more thin s.ooo l'Parala Intefllslll II)d wherw no one peI1IOn or entity holda more thin Ito181 of 5% oflhaown8l1lhlp InIarest In the am/led PIIr\nerahlp. . mo-..",_ 10lMT . ~ . APPUCANT REPRESENTAnVE AfFIDAVIT Plnuant to SecIlon 31-7llb)(2)(11 0( I1e CIty 0( AventIn lind Development CodIl, .. AjljlIIcanl Repraen\eliYe HI'da\it Is heqby made IIId 1IbnIaed. The IIllIelIlglIed aulhodzed IejlfISenIIliYI of I1e IndMduel or enlky Ipp\ytng lor I1e Develajlmenl PennI, YohIcI1Is ldenlIl'oed k1 fie ~ appIlcallon,lIId'" _ 01... pcoptI1y MjGct \0'" application (II clllfelllll) hereby isis IIId 1den6tles II pet1Of1S represenlklg I1e r.dMlual or entity epptyr.g for I1e Developmenl Pem1k k1 COMICIIon with !he lIppllca\lon. III fotIows; Nam, Clifford A. Schulman flfJaBonsh/p ~..__AotIoIIdl. ~ MtIolocU. ~ ~ EI:., Attorney (AIIad1 AddItlonaf S/leeta If NeoessaIy) N011CE: ANi STAlBIENT OR REPRESElITAllON IWlE BY ANi PERSON LISTED ON TlfE APPUCANT REPRESEHTAllVE AFFIDAVIT SIW.l BE BINDING UPON TlfE INIlMDUAL OR EH11lY APPLYING FOR TIfE DEYaOPtIENT PERMIT AND TlfE OWNER OF 1lIE SUBJECT PROPERTY. APPUCAHTS AND AFfWfTS ARE ADVISED TO Tll4ELY SUPPLEIIENT TIfl6 Afi:mAVIT PURSUANT TO SEe. 11.71(B)(2j{1V) OF TIfE ClTY'SlAHO OEVELOPMEHT REGULATIONS IN TIlE CITY CODE, IN lltE EVENT THAT PRIOR TO CONSIDERATION OF TIfE APPUCATlON BY lltE CITY BOARD OR COMMISSION, TlfE INFORMATlON PROVIDED IN TlfE AfFIDAVIT BECOIIESINCORRECT OR INCOMPLETE. .- wmtESS MY HAND THIS _ DAY OF AIffilORIZED REPRESENTA11ve OF APPUCANT: By: .2001. Name: 1ll1e: Adcfr8ss: (SIgnature) (/'ttIl). ~ ~ Name: athan Lewinger (PrfnII ~ VP & Chairman of Bld~. Committee ~~ 4000 Island Blvd., PH 4 Aventura, Fl 33160 ~ STATE OF F\.ORIDA ) COUNTY OF MlAMI'[)ADE) Belote me III lIIdel1!gned aullority pereonaly eppeared III Ole eu1horIzed IIpreMnlallvG 01 the ~ andIlx' the owner of the property subject to Ille appIcallon, who being first by me duly sworn, dkIswear or alflnn flal helahe executed this AIlIda\it lor the pwposes Blaled therein and flallllllrue and correcl of. AFAANT SWORN TO AND SUBSCflIBED BEFORE ME this'" day of O~~~ .200W (Q) /7 ,. . CARLOS ERSKINE ~~ NolIuy Public - - III _ NoIary SlatI of FloIIdI M Urge . . '. MyCamillionElq:noDcl'D.2llIl5 Nameo/NoIaIy ~~ ~ Com million I ODDI4155 MyClDlMllsslDnexplrse: ~ ~ (~ -. BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT. 1l1iI NfidaYllIs made pursuant 10 SectIon 31-71(b1(2){Jl) oIlI1e City 01 Avenlura Land Deveklpment Code. The lI1denfgned AIllanl hereby discloses lhal: (m8ltc wtIh "x" applicable portions cnly) 'b(1. Affiant dots ll21 have . Busi1esa Rslallon&lllp wlIh eny member of Ihe City Commission 01 lilY City AdvI$ory IloaRIIo wI1k:h Ihe 1Il'P1lcItlan will be ~. [ )2. Affiant hereby discloses I1atM dots have . Business RelaUonshlp wi1h . member 01 !he City Commission or a City AdvillOl)' Board to whlc:h I1e appbllon will be pmented, II 1oI1ows: (LIst name 01 CommIssioner or Advlso!y Board Merrber) who &elVes on lie (LIst City ConvnIs.1on or City AcM8ol)' Board upon which member serves). The naIure of !he Busi1ess ReIatlonshJp Is as lolIows: I J I. Member of Cly Con1mlsslon or lloard holds an ownersh~ i1lerest i1 excess 011" of lolallSMlS or C8IllIaI slDc:k 01 AA*an1 or Represenlat1Y8: ( J i. Member 01 CIty Cormllsafon or Board Is . parlner, co-thar1holder (II 10 thares of . COIpllIItlan which II'll not Isled on eny IIIlIonaI or regional stock exchlIlge) or joInIl'lllIltI'er wIIh lI1e AppIcant or Represer4allY8ln any business ventU'e; ( )111. The Applicanl or Repre&enlalive Is a Clent 01 a merOOer of Iha CIly Convnlsslon or Board or a CIilI1l 01 another professional worlIi1g from 1he same Office or for !he same employer as the member of the ClIy CommlsaIon or IloIId; lilY. A City CommIssloner or lloard member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative; (] v. The Applicanl or Represanlative Is . Customer of the member of lI1e City CommissIon or Board (or 01 hie or her employer) end RntaoI8 more Ihan $10,000.00 011110 business ollha member 0I1ha City ColMlInfon or Soard (or his or her ernployllr) In a ~ caIerdar year, (] vi. The member 0I1he CIty CoImllsslon or Board Is . Customer of l1e Appllolnt or Reprl$enta1lY8 and transacts mole Ihan $25,000.00 01 !he business of lie ApplIoanl or Representative i1 a given cal8ndar year, WIlNESS MY HAND THIS _ DAY OF T ,2Of11" , ' WITNESS IG( HAND THIS _ DAY OF PROPERlY OWNER; By: Name; TlIIII: . 2OOJ.. (SIgnature) (PI1nf) (Pr1nI) ~ . 'rbe terms "Busiless R61aIlonsh!p," 'CII6n~" "CusrOlll6(: "Appllcan~" "Rllpf6$6ntallve" and "Inllll8Sfed Person' II'll dsRned In SecIIon 2.395 oIlhe AI'lIIlIura OIly Code. ., ~ NOTARIZAtION PROVISION ITA1E ClF R.ClAIlA I COUHIYClF~ ... ..... totlllldonlgnod ouIlocIr, pononaIy __Il A~ "tot/l~ tot ~..... Wlt .. by.. 4vIr _ 61_._11II Nt..... ._1Ils NIilaI'l tot... puIpOOI' _""'''whtl''''''' ""-. (I CARLOS ERSKINE \ Nolaoy Public - Stm '" Florida .~ My~EJ;nIOcI'O.llIIl5 Commlllion . 00014155 ~ ~d~m,~ PdnItd Name al "'*'r ~ My_O","", s ITA1EClFf\.ORlD!\ I .COUHIYClFIolIA/.IW.IIlEI ...... 1M, ... onIorslgned """""" peroooaIt IlJClOt/Od .............wdI1ls~tot... pullIOtO....lod .......W t\tIl""'" ""-. ...,.......~ rnt",... tit_diII_.....t\tI AFlWlT _TONIJ SUIlSClIII\B)bob'I mellls_dayal 2Odf,.. NaltlyNllc_ al_HLtIgt PdnItd Name dllclaly Mt-.: .~lt:1ph&:. ITAlEOl'I\.llAD. I COUKTYOF~ ... ..., ... undo<IIgned 1Ufooooty, pelSQOlily IlJClOt/Od __.._tot"'_.__lnandllall"""""-' "'AlIim,""'beI'og Intby... dltt.......diI........-...' AFlWlT _ TO NIJ S\J8SCIUIIEO belen me.. _ day al . 'ItI!k NaltlyNllc_dRodifaHI.IIVt PoIIlodNIIN dNollay ur~_.I.Jluo""" ITAlEOFI\DRIlA I COUIlTY OI'lMNI.o.IIlEI _ "", ... """'lOIgnod outhoIttr, penoMly IlJClOt/Od _ .--.11>10 M1dhll tot... puIllOSIt_...... tndl1all...... w-. ... -. """beI'ogln\",...d~ .......diII_or dllml1lt AFlWlT SVIOI\H TO NIJ 8UIlllCllIBeD ""lore molNs _ lIaya! 1J1S1- . NoIIIyNllcSlllIolRodifaHLtIgt _ NllNGlNallry Mr_....,...r. ~ . . ~ WITNESS MY HAND THIS _ DAY OF . 2OO'L. REPRESENTATIVE: (\Jst8d on Busln.. Relallonsh~ AIfIdI'Ill) By: (SIgnature) By: (SlgnaJure Nome: (PrtrI) Name: (Pril/1 T1lle: (pitt) TlUe: (PrInt) By: (S/gnaIutv) By: (S/9narure Name: (PrtntJ Name: (PrfnQ Tille: (PrInt) TIle: (PrfnQ By: (SlgnallKe) . By. (SiQnatuI8 Nome: (PIfnl) Name: (Pm/) llde: (Print) lite: IPrtnl) By. (Signature) By: (SiQnallKe Name: (Pm/) NIme: (PItltJ lllk,. (PIfnl) TIlkl: (PrfnI) By. (Signalute) By: (SIgnature Name: (PrInt) Nome: (Pmt) lllIe: (PrfnQ l1lIe: (PrinI) By: (SIgnature) By: (SIJ.mn Name: (PrtnI) Name: (PItJ1) 1lGe: (PrInt) T1tIe: (Pdnt) NOTE: 1) Use dupRcate aheels If dlsclOlure Inlonnallon lor ReprelenlaUVe varies Z) Appllcanle Ind AIfIanu sre advlsed kIlfmely supplemenllhls Affidavit PUlSUaIlt kI See. 31"71(bK2)(Iv) oIl11e City's Lend Development Regulations In the City Code, In the event.1hat prior to oonslderallon of 111, eppl\callon by lIIe CIty Board or CommISsion, the InfonnlUon provldeclln the AmdaVlt becomeslnconec:t or lncomplele. ~ .. , o~H~~[~o ATTORNEYS AT LAW 1~~~~1~ :- Clifford A. Schulman (305) 579.0613 Direct Fax, (305) 961-5613 E~Mail; schulmanc@gtlaw.com September 24, 2002 Mayor and City Commissioners City of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Re: Conditional Use Permits for Religious Uses Dear Mayor and City Commissioners: ~ It is my understanding that an agenda item for today's City of Aventura Commission workshop is to discuss the apparent conflict between the City Aventura Comprehensive Plan and the Land Development Regulations with respect to religious uses. I would like to be able to present to you, in person, my argument that the imposition of a conditional use permit requirement on the Temple located in Williams Island is a violation of federal law. This position is explained below. The Temple in question is located on the first floor of a condominium building inside the City of A ventura and has been operating in Williams Island for over 10 years, in one form or another. The condominium building is presently within the RMF4 zoning district. This district permits "All uses permitted in the CF district." The CF district permits "[c]hurches or synagogues or other houses of worship" without a conditional use permit. See City of A ventura Land Development Regulations, Section 31-l47(a)(I). Therefore, from a zoning point of view, the Temple is permitted to be located in this condominium, as of right, under the City of Aventura's land development regulations. As such, the Temple operates under and pursuant to a certificate of use and zoning from the City of A ventura. Policy 1.3 of the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan appears to be inconsistent with the land development regulations: "Community facilities (including schools) and places of worship shall be allowed on property with a residential or business and office land use designation through the conditional use procedures found in the City's land development regulations. . . ." However, neither the comprehensive plan nor the City's land development regulations require other types of non-religious assemblies, such as private meeting halls and theaters to obtain a conditional use permit to be located in the very same zoning district. ~ To the extent that Policy 1.3 of the Comprehensive Plan would be construed to potentially override the zoning code and require the Temple to obtain a conditional use permit, this policy is a clear violation of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, 42 GREENBERG TRAURIG. P.A. 1221 BRICKELL AVENUE MIAMI, FLORIDA 33131 305~579-0500 FAX 305-579-0717 www.<<tlaw.com MIAMJ NEW YORK WASHINGTON, D.C. ATLANTA PHILADELPHIA TYSONS CORNER CHICAGO BOSTON PHOENIX WILMINGTON Los ANGELES DENVER FORT LAUDERllALE BOCA RATON WEST PALM BUCH OUANDO TALLAHASSEE " . / September 24, 2002 Page 2 V.S.C. S 2000cc et seq. (RLUIPA) (copy attached). RLUIPA's Equal Terms provision states as follows: (b) Discrimination and exclusion (I) Equal terms No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than equal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution. 42 V.S.C. S 2000cc(b)(I). Thus, RLVIPA prohibits a government from imposing land use or zoning requirements on religious assemblies or institutions that are not also imposed on similar non-religious assemblies or institutions. Policy 1.3 of the Comprehensive Plan is clearly subject to challenge under RLUIPA. See 42 V.S.C. S 2000cc-2 ("A person may assert a violation of this chapter as a claim or defense in a ...-- judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief against a government. "). Policy 1.3 is a land use regulation as defined by RLVIPA. See 42 V.S.C. ~2000cc-5(5) (defining land use regulation as "a zoning or landmarking law, or the application of such a law, that limits or restricts a claimant's use or development ofland (including a structure affixed to the land), if the claimant has an ownership, leasehold, easement, servitude, other property interest in the regulated land or a contract or option to acquire such an interest.") Additionally, the City of Aventura is a "government" subject to RLUIPA. See 42 V.S.C. ~ 2000cc-5(4)( "The term 'government' - (A) means - (i) a State, county, municipality or other governmental entity created under the authority ofa State. . . ."). The Temple, which is clearly a "religious assembly or institution" protected under RLUIP A, is only permitted under the Comprehensive Plan to be in this zoning district with a conditional use permit. However, at the same time the condominium building in which the Temple is located has rooms available for private parties, meetings and other types of assemblies to persons located both within and without the development. However, these non-religious assemblies are not required by the comprehensive plan to obtain a conditional use permit. The Comprehensive Plan, therefore, puts the Temple, and any other religious institutions or assemblies attempting to meet in the City of A ventura, "on less than equal terms" as compared with the non-religious assemblies or institutions. Such disparate treatment between religious and non-religious institutions and assemblies is a clear violation ofRLUIPA. See. Murphy v. Zoning Commission o/Town o/New Melford, 148 F. Supp.2d 173 (D.C. Conn. 2001 )(injunction issued to prevent Town from prohibiting religious meetings in single family neighborhood where single family residents were allowed to have private, non-religious parties in same area without specific /- GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. " ~ September 24, 2002 Page 3 zoning approval). This disparate treatment by the Comprehensive Plan in Policy 1.3 also violates the First Amendment of the United States Constitution. See Freedom Baptist Church of Delaware County v, Township of Middletown, 204 F.Supp. 2d 857, 869 (E.D. Penn. 2002) (stating that the "equal terms" provision of RLUlPA codifies Supreme Court decisions concerning the First Amendment). The Supreme Court has stated that "[a]t a minimum, the protections of the Free Exercise Clause [of the First Amendment] pertain if the law at issue discriminated against some or all religious beliefs or regulates or prohibits conduct because it is undertaken for religious reasons." Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye. Inc, v. City of Hialeah, 508 U.S. 520, 532, 113 S.C!. 2217,2226 (1992). Thus, because Policy 1.3 treats religious and non-religious institutions and assemblies differently, it violates the protections of the First Amendment. See id. at 533, 113 S.Ct. at 2227 ("[I]f the object of a law is to infringe upon or restrict practices because of their religious motivation, the law is not neutral and it is invalid unless it is justified by a compelling interest and is narrowly tailored to advance that interest."). .- Policy 1.3 of the Comprehensive Plan is also unreasonable, and thus violates the Exclusions and Limits provision ofRLUIPA. Section 2(b)(3)(B) ofRLUIPA states: (3) Exclusions and limits No government shall impose or implement a land us regulation that - . . . (B) unreasonably limits religious assemblies, institutions, or structures within a jurisdiction. RLUPA's Exclusions and Limits provisions codify the United States Supreme Court decisions under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. See Freedom Baptist Church, 204 F.Supp. 2d at 871. The Supreme Court has held that the Equal Protection Clause prohibits irrational distinctions in land use laws. City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center, 473 U.S. 432,105 S.Ct. 3249 (1985). In Cleburne, the City required a special use permit for homes for the mentally retarded, but did not require a special use permit for other multi- family uses such as apartment houses and boarding houses. in the same zoning district. Id. at 447. The Court stated the government could differentiate between uses only if the use which needed a special use permit "would threaten legitimate interests of the city in a way that other permitted uses. . . would not." !d. at 448. Here, no additional disturbances to the condominium residents could result from a religious worship service than would result from a community citizens' meeting or a private party, The City of Aventura has no reasonable reason to require, under the Comprehensive Plan, GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. , . r- September 24, 2002 Page 4 religious institutions and assemblies to obtain a conditional use permit in order to use space in a condominium, but not to require non-religious institutions or assemblies to do the same. Policy 1.3 of the City of Aventura's Comprehensive plan therefore violates the "Exclusions and Limits" provision ofRLUIPA and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Based on the foregoing, the City of Aventura's Comprehensive Plan could be challenged under RLUIPA, the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause of Fourteenth Amendment. We would respectfully request that the Comprehensive Plan language which appears to require a conditional use approval for such religious uses/assemblies be modified so as to eliminate the requirement for a conditional use approval for religious uses that are held in such facilities. This is not to say, that conditional use approval might not be appropriate for a free-standing religious institution that is not conducting its activities in a manner that is identical to other uses taking place, as of right, in a particular zoning district, and the Commission may wish to distinguish such situations. Because I am unable to attend this workshop due to a previously scheduled commitment, I respectfully request that you defer this workshop to a future date. ~ Sincerely, Clifford A. Schulman Attachment GREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A. ,-- u.s. CONSTITUTION AMENDMENT XIV Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein .~ they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person .r within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. r- o~ N ~ .. eIJ = ~ .s .S ::eIJ ~ =.~ =~~ QQJ~ .~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ .....- ~ ~ r'-l QJ = = ~ .~ .S = r'-l t:~~~ =~~~ ~ Q.S = U>Q~ ~=.:= = Q = = ~ .: .5 ~ ~~e QJ QJ.~ ~""'-J. .....-e~ = ~.~ =~~ > = e QJ = ~ ~Q ~~~~ ~ :;;::: 0...... a ~-..... ~ ~ ~ :;;::: ~~~ "-~M ~ 0 a~ . ~ :;;::: 0...... ~ ~ r \ . 0';:: 'V 0 ~ . 0...... > Z ~ '-' ~o 'V\..J~ ~\O ~O\ ~~"'O ~a~ ~ -..... ~ ~~~ ~~r:/J ~~~ o ~ ~ ~ a . t- ~ o~ \O~U ~~ ~~ a\..J~ -.....~'-' ~ ~-.l :;;::: ~\.~ ~~\O ~t-lr) ~~"'O a~~ .~ ~ 0...... ~ \0 U .0\ 000 > i ~~ ~ '-'~ \..J lr) :;;::: ~~ ~ ~ lr) a ~ . ~ U~C/J ~ ~~8 ~r:/J~O\ a . -..... 0\ ~~a~ o ~ r- VINEYARD CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP OF EVANSTON, INC., v. CITY OF EVANSTON, 250 F.Supp.2d 961 (N.D. Ill. 2003). Vineyard's congregants may permissibly stage (at the subject property) a production of the musical play "Fiddler on the Roof," which includes a scene depicting a traditional Jewish wedding, Vineyard may not, however, host an actual religious wedding at 1800 Ridge under the zoning ordinance, These simple examples satisfY the court that the City's ordinance, although it does not single out a particular religious group, nevertheless classifies on the basis of religion, . . . . ~ The court concludes that the major differences between the permitted and special use organizations on the one hand, and Vineyard on the other, is that Vineyard wishes to conduct worship services at its property. Evanston's claim that it has zoned purely for land use purposes and not on the basis of religion is not supported by the facts, and its classification on the basis of religion is therefore suspect. . . . . The question is whether it is rational to treat worship services differently than, for example, a meeting of the Masons, or a production of "Fiddler on the Roof." The record does not clarifY how the characteristics of religious worship rationally justifY denying Vineyard the right to use the property for religious services. The court fails to see any basis for Evanston's argument that allowing Vineyard to conduct worship services at 1800 Ridge would pose any threat to the City's legitimate interests. LOVE CHURCH, ~ v. ~ CITY OF EVANSTON 671 F.Supp. 515 (N.D. Ill. 1987), Vacated On Other Grounds, 896 F.2d 562 (7th Cir. 1990). Suppose, for example a group of people wished to assemble on a regular basis in Evanston to discuss and hear lectures on classical literature. This group might also wish to have seminars for young people after school or on weekends to expose them to "great books." These people could rent a building in any business or commercial zone and have their meetings. But if that same group of people wished to assemble for the purpose of religious worship and to hold classes for its young people to educate them about religion, they would have to get special permission from Evanston, The only distinguishable feature of the groups in our hypothetical is the purpose and content of the assembly. Because Evanston's ordinance distinguishes between religious assembly uses and non-religious assembly uses, it classifies on the basis of religion. . . . . In sum, although Evanston has articulated some interests that we can characterize as legitimate, sometimes compelling, in every instance we find the legislative response to be over inclusive. No only do we find the ordinance much broader than necessary to serve any compelling interest, it is not even rationally related to a legitimate interest. Evanston has failed to demonstrate the existence of any genuine issue of material fact. We therefore grant plaintiffs motion for summary judgment and hold that the ~ special use permit requirement of Evanston's zoning ordinance, as it relates to churches, is invalid in that it violates the Equal Protection Clause. .~ RLUIP A CONGRESSIONAL INTENT Land Use. The right to assemble for worship is at the very core of the free exercise of religion, Churches and synagogues cannot function without a physical space adequate to their needs and consistent with their theological requirements, The right to build, buy, or rent such a space is an indispensable adjunct of the core First Amendment right to assemble for religious purposes. The hearing record compiled massive evidence that this right is frequently violated. Churches in general, and new, small, or unfamiliar churches in particular, are frequently discriminated against on the face of zoning codes and also in the highly individualized and discretionary processes of land use regulation, Zoning codes frequently exclude churches in places where they permit theatres, meeting halls, and other places where large groups of people assemble for secular purposes. Or the codes permit churches only with individualized permission from the zoning board, and zoning boards use that authority in discriminatory ways. Sometimes zoning board members or neighborhood residents explicitly offer race or religion as the reason to exclude a proposed church, especially in cases of black churches and Jewish shuls and synagogues. More often, discrimination lurks behind such vague and universally applicable reasons as traffic, aesthetics, or "not consistent with the city's land use plan." Churches have been excluded from residential zones because they generate too much traffic, and from commercial zones because they don't generate enough traffic. Churches have been denied the right to meet in rented storefronts, in abandoned schools, in converted funeral homes, theaters, and skating rinks-in all sorts of building that were permitted when they generated traffic for secular purposes. ~ 164 Congo Rec. S7774-0l at S7774-5 (Comments of Senator Hatch, July 27, 2000) ~ , UNITED STATES CODE ANNOTATED TITLE 42. THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE CHAPTER 21C-RELIGIOUS LAND USE AND INSTITUTIONALIZED PERSONS S 2000cc. Protection of land use as religious exercise (a) Substantial burdens (1) General Rule No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution, unless the government demonstrates that imposition of the burden on that person, assembly, or institution- /- (A) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (B) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest. (2) Scope of application This subsection applies in any case in which- . . . . (C) the substantial burden is imposed in the implementation of a land use regulation or system of land use regulations, under which a government makes, or has in place formal or informal procedures or practices that permit the government to make, individualized assessments of the proposed uses for the property involved. (1) EQUAL TERMS - No governmental shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than equal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution. (2) NON DISCRIMINATION - No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation that discriminates against any assembly or institution on the basis of religion or religious denomination. --- ~ 01.) = ..... "C< o~ ~s ~~ =~ o 0 ..... .~ ,... ~~ ~- ~ ~ .- 0 - ..... =.- 0,8 u;: _ rIl ~ = _ 0 ~u QJ ~ ~ N o o N ~ '...... U "'" - 0\ '--' N I.D o ...... "1j ~ ~ '<:t ...... ~ ~~ ~ ..21 ~ ~ ;::.: l.: <:\) ...s \:$ <:\) ~ ~ ~ I.D N ,.l:i (,) 1a ;:;s N ~ o '--' CO U ~ E-< U A... o 0\ '<:t ...... I ;> >-< U o Z Q) <Zl ro U b ~ ~ o 0- \:$ ~ ;::. ~ ;::.: G ~ ~. <:\) ~~ <:\)~ ~g ~N ...... '<:t N ...... "0 N 0.. g- OO ~ ~ ~ N ~ -2 ~ <:\) ;::. \:$ ~ <:\) ~ cq ~ c55 '0> .0 G ;::.: -.. o o ..l::: ~ ..l::: o~ ~ ~ \:$ 0- ..... o~ lo.. 6 .oN ~o ~o O~ ...... \:$ ro ~~ .....0 ~ . ~8 ~ o N ...... "1j N 0.. g- oo ~ 00 ...... N ~ ~ ~ "'<; ..... ~ <:\) ~ ~ -.. <:\) ;::. ~ <:\) ~ '" ~ ~ u ;::.: lo.. <:\) ..... ~ ~ ~ \:$ 0- ..... '" 0- lo..~ 68 ~o ON o . ~ca ::::::U o . :::::0 08 ~ o >-. ~ o '--' I.D 00 ...... ...... 0.. g- oo ~ If) ~ N ~ ~ ~ <:\) ~ 6 '0> .0 G ;::.: ..l::: ~ ~ 6 ..... 0'" is o ...s ~ ~ <:\) ..... 0- :S <:\) \..l j2 ~ "1j N 0.. g- oo , ~ '<:t o N ~ ~ ~ <:\) ~ ~ ~ '0> o~ ..l::: '" ~ ~ ~ ;::.: .0 ~ ~ o <:\) lo.. \:$ ~ ..21 <:\) Q '0> ..l::: \..l lo.. ~ ..l:::~ \..IN .....0 ."'0 ';:::N ~~ cq~ ~o ~~ <:\)'--' <:\)l'-- ~~ ~ >- Z; o 00 '--' If) '<:t '<:t o ...... ...... N N .....:l ~ ~ o o N ~ \..l <:\) ~ ~ \:$ ~ ~ '0> <:\) ~ -.. -.. 0- ::::.: ;::.: -.. o o ..l::: ~ S Q lo.. ~ '" <:\) ..l::: (.) "- '" ~ ~ ~ o U o '--' 0\ ...... N 0\ 0\ N N N .....:l ~ ~ o o N '"\{ lo.. ::g, ~ ~ ~ '0> ~ ~ ~ <:\) ...s '0> ~ o 0- '" .~ ~ ~ o ~ '- ~ ~ ;::.: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ A... o ;:;s '--' N o ~ N l'-- N N N .....:l ~ ~ o o N lo..~ <:\) ~ 0- cq ;::.: ~ \:$ 0- -.. -.. ~ ~ <Zl 0.. .< ..... U ~ ....... U "'" F- '--' o I.D 0\ If) If) '<:t N N .....:l ~ ~ o o N ~ ..... \:$ 2i5 ~ <:\) ..... 0- :S ~ ~ \:$ ~ <:\) ~ "f ~ ;::.: ~ -.. lo.. \:$ 6 /~ United States District Court C.D. California. COTTONWOOD CHRISTIAN CENTER, Plaintiff, v. CYPRESS REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY; City of Cypress; Does 1-10., Defendants. 218 F.Supp. 2d. 1203 Aug. 6, 2002. The Cottonwood Property is located in this area, along the comer of Katella Avenue and Walker Avenue. By 1987, this entire property was zoned PS (Public/Semi-Public). Among other uses, churches are permitted provided they receive a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). . . . . ~ [16] RLUIP A also requires the application of a strict scrutiny standard because the City's refusal to grant Cottonwood its application for a CUP involves a "land use regulation or system of land use regulations, under which a government makes, or has in place formal or informal procedures or practices that permit the government to make, individualized assessments." 42 U.S.c. S 2000cc(a)(2)(C). .... Preventing a church from building a worship site fundamentally inhibits its ability to practice its religion. Churches are central to the religious exercise of most religions. If Cottonwood could not build a church, it would not exist. . . .. RLUIP A appears to recognize this concern by specifically defining "[t]he use building or conversion of real property for the purpose of religious exercise" as the type of religious exercise that cannot be substantially burdened absent a compelling interest. 42 U.S.C. & 2000cc- 5(7)(B). . . . . ~ . ,. By passing RLUIP A, Congress conclusively determined the national public policy that religious land uses are to be guarded from interference by local governments to the maximum extent permitted by the constitution. I ~ ~ United States District Court S.D. New York. 2003 W.L. 22110445 WESTCHESTER DAY SCHOOL, Plaintiff, v. VILLAGE OF MAMORONECK, Defendants. ... we are firmly convinced that defendant's complete denial of WDS's Application was not based on any compelling governmental interest or on a fair balancing of environmental concerns with the rights to WDS to the reasonable use of its property and that defendants' abrupt reversal of its prior approval and its 3-2 vote to deny plaintiffs Application was a reaction to belated public outcry, a paradigm of what has been referred to as the NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) syndrome. We find little rational basis for such community opposition in light of the nature and publicly beneficial purpose of the project as well as the great lengths to which WDS has gone to ensure that its physical plant will maintain the highest level of architectural and aesthetic quality. .... We conclude that this denial is a substantial burden on plaintiff s exercise of religion because the modifications WDS seeks will enable it, for well into the foreseeable future, to more efficiently, effectively and, most importantly, safely serve its student population and to fulfill its religious and educational mission. . .. We therefore grant plaintiff s motion for partial summary judgment on its RLUIP A claim and in doing so annul and set aside the May 13, 2003 determination of the ZBA that denied ~ the application and order the immediate and unconditional approval and granting of WDS' s application that was filed with the ZBA on October 10. 2001 as amended on June 17, 2002. ~ ~ eJ) = .,.... "C~ = = .,.... = ~ .9 rIJ"""- =s Q.,.... . ,.... ......- rIJ rIJ .,.... = ~ Q QJ ~ ~ = t:~ =< 8e= ~~ ~~ "C QJ ~ ~ ~~ .......M ~o ~o SN ~ r, N ~ 0 ~ .- ..-.. ~~M "'~o ~ao . ~ N ;:.._ r, ~~~ ~ ..c: ~~u ~ " ~ ~~~ -S~ ~ r-. 0 ~ "'...J. 00 oQ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~Q ~ 0 C-'~~ ~'-' "'- a ~ .- \0 ~tN ~~lr) N~O', ~~oo 0- a 0 ~u~ \0 \0 lr) "'0 N o ~ ~ r:/J o ~ o ~ N r, ~ ~..-.. .......M .- 0 ~o oN ;:. 0 ~ ~o~ a> o~ ~ ~~ ~~ " ~ ~ a ~ 0- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~..-.. ~8 ofi 0- U,......; ~ ~U o ~Q ~ 0 ~U ~ '-' UM ~\O ~~ 0- ~ ....... o ~ "'0 -N ~ 0 a~ ~ ~r:/J a 0 ~~ 0- 0 ~t- ~N .~ FLORIDA STATUTES TITLE XLIV. CIVIL RIGHTS CHAPTER 761. RELIGIOUS FREEDOM 761.03. Free exercise of religion protected (1) The government shall not substantially burden a person's exercise of religion, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability, except that governement may substantially burden a person's exercise of r- religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person: (a) Is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (b) Is furthering interest. the least restrictive that compelling means of governmental (2) A person whose religious exercise has been burdened in violation of this section may assert ~ . that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief. c--- FLORIDA STATUTES TITLE XLIVe CIVIL RIGHTS CHAPTER 760. DISCRIMINA TION IN THE TREATMENT OF PERSONS; MINORITY REPRESENTATION 760.26. Prohibition in land use .~ decisions and in permitting of development It is unlawful to discriminate in land use decisions or in the permitting of development based on race, color, national origin, sex, disability, familial status, religion, or, except as otherwise provided by law, the source ~ of financing of a development or proposed development. r- "'0 "'0 N = N " ~ " ~ 0 ~ 0 ~ .. ~ r:/J . ...... r./) 00 ~ ~ " t""- O ~ ~ .... ,..... 0 ~ ~ ~~ """"'- ~ ~ OJJQJOC .... ~ ~ =~O\ -8 ~ .... 8 0'1 \::$ ~~ ~ ~ ~ \::$~ ~ OO~ \::$~ ~g ~~o \J~ ~N aO\ ~ Q.QJ..... cqO\ ~c) ~~~ ~~ ~~< ~Q .od .005 ~ rIj "~ ~ ~ ~ u~ .~ ~ U d "Q ~ QJ · 6iJ ~ " ;::::~ ~r./) rIj.. ~ '-" ~ '-" ~,..... EN aM UQJ ...cJ~ t""- ...cJN ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ = r- 0 "00"0 = = = - ~ 0 ~ ~ = ~..Q r- .9- ~ ~ - .~ .~ ~~~~ = r-~ = ~ = e ,",:g.s e ~ - ~ ~ . ~...... - ~ · .~ "0 ~ "0 ~ g = r- ...... ~ '"" .~ ~ .s ol == "0 .~ ~ ~ ~ ~=~= ~"O ..= ~ ~ ..... r- = = ~ .; z ~ 0...... ~ _ 00; =..Q OQ ~~;;.~ r- ~~ J."' ~] ~ ~ .~ .~ "0 ...... ~ ~ = = ~ ~..'" <O~~ US ~~=as O~ ~ ~.C of! = 8 -...... = 0 rT, ~ ~.~- ~ .C ; ~ -; 0 ~U.~ ~ ~ r- 0 0 ~ "O~=~ ~ = ~~-; U ~ ~ - ..= r~" "O~~ ~ =~ .~"O.c ~...... = ~ ..=.c~ U.c ~~] ~ ..... . = o U ~ N t'-- ..... N ~ .'1"""1 ...... ~ ."0"0 ..... ...... -~ ~.'''' ...... 0 . ~- ~ ~~ ~ ~ . = .....~OO ~ . . ~OO~ "0 ~ ~ \0 ..... ...... = ~ ~ -+-' o 00"' ~ :2 -+-> (]) 't:l ~ ~ ""0 ..... "' 00 (]) tl >-. (]) -+-'U-O . .... 0 b1) ""0 S ""0 s::: ;..:::: ~< oo~b~ .....~ 8~ ~ .S < c\S . ""0 ~.~ 8'C ~,.... 0 ,'" -+-' - ~.D~~ ..... (]) ~ (]) b8-+-''fl - ~ooo~ 00 ;::::s 0 (]) 0 ,..q ~ '5h s::: -+-' ,..q '.... 0 -..... ;.... (])-+-' (]) (]) ;.... U ~.~ c\S g 1:1 s -+-' 00 g ~ ~ S caoS""O '.... 00 s::: &a8,~s ~"'3B ....... ..... u 00 ~ ......... ..... ;::::s ..... -+-' OO+-'u~oo "' ~ ;.... ~ o.t)~ii: o s::: (]) U c\S oo'~,..q ~ -- -+-' """""booo(]) < ,..q '.0 ~ ~ L-Jt>:.a;::::so ',..q c\S 0..... :~tlU;> ~. ~ 'f ','_ "" ''''v C C"q \11)" ~ Q) \ r~"l ~ ~ ~ 1 ,Il'~ \ g'!Il .).'~ :, ~ 2: ~!/,1j..:l ~'J''''', Q) C 0 (,) " ~ >0) ~ ~...t;"ri\~..,~.jZ~l ~., ,9.. <( ~ ..,~.; \oJ .r;!' :;., ..... ....." ~ C C"! CD E .~ ~ ' ~: Qj ~ .E 0) 'r, ..~ Z B ),...,!: ~,...,,~ Q)::::J ,.' E ~ i, ,$, 0"'''' 0:::0) <:l 01'1 "1 " X 0 ': ;~ w 0" ~H' " .g O);w. ,.'I.'t ~ 1 . elf!'!, o ro "'il:!1 i :\1\ ..c C t:n ~i ;..,U -'j.Tr+:::r' ) ';., at:: C/)~ " '~. c:;~~;;';t1-.. l.J i1:fl. (:-, !!! t:.1 .1il! i ~"'1' '", . _......'.,L'~'.,..0~ ~ .' .... ...._~~__~...:;: :.'J'- ...... ~ 6'-0 ~.2: -clllgJ roC]):: ..c c: E ro >, ..c:roM U U . (J)N ~aiQ) :J U _...c: c:oro C])o- > T"'".~ <(NO 6' ~ ~ :J - c:- C]) C]) > ~ en <(-C]) -(/):: os E C])I'-... ro 0 . ,-NM .!!2UJC]) OJZ g c: Il'l ro :JI'-- o Il'l.!!l >-MO 6 ~ c: 2 :J ..c:C]) (J) :J C]) c: >-C]) ..c: > (J) _<(C]) ro :: -c-t:E <(coo ..c: N . roUJN '- Z C]) o U I-oc: ..c:ll'lro -M- C])o.!!l III NO '" o ~ C]) ::> Ol o OJ ro C]) c: > >,,- (/)0 ~ C]) -- ro c: (J) '^ .- C]) wO- -, ll. 'E -c .~ OJ c: en . o >,N E:2 C]) -c U UJIl'lC: _I'-ro .- N +-' C]) OJ .!!l 1ll...0 0.-. zO <(~ ..JUJ en:J -C) eno ==e> <(<( ..Jz ..J> -en :: ,i!~ 10 :_'~:.':~' ", 'f? ~'" OOJ~\'1 j, ~ 01 dJ', "" II' . ' . ""1;1" f' . f-. . I " G,I i '," t/.l~- l' ,!!l .... ,~, , '+'I +" t ..l._- ,-',..-" (",' L']"~'TI-t:" :-j_drr:I, . l- a \ tV/-t"d' . . 0 ( ! I 'lj "..1..... , . , '["-I '" :lI~' - ~ 'I . T@ ~' a ,.L) ~L~f 1 1"'1 j I, ,.,.. I J L..... ~j-1 ~~ "'J:l H~ ,. I- .1>.' , .fIlT, I I In,t" ,,~J ii'.i <,':, j 'i C]) :J ~~ 55 (J) :Du >C]) ..c ~ <(:: E:D sE :::s- OC") I- C:..cM . C])oUJN ~uuzC]) :J..c:ro U +-'cn-'oC: c: .- ..c: 0 ro C]);:-"<tCi) <(> C]) C]) 0 .- -,IllNO r 0) ::J C) o 0) C)c CO ._ c- >.0) en E .- ~~ -ol- e e CO 0 - en+:; - CO en u E 0 --I co .- - - .- S ~ 11/07/03 10:04 WILLIAMS-ISLAND 931 1773 ~ 3059515837 NO. 375 1i01 ~~ \ .. ._~ ) '~~~ .. 2000 ISLAND BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIAnON.lNc. . 1000 ISLAND BOlJLIiVAlU),W1W1\MS 15LIIND, FLoalDA 3)160 ..(305) 691;1000 - FAX (305) 691-1008 .. . .. . May 21, 2003 Mrs. Stephanie Trump 7900 Island Boulevard Williams Island, FL 33160 ~ Dear Mrs. Trump: I am writing this letter in regards to the synagOgue, which has been located in a commercial space in the 2000 building forthEl past eight (B) years. We have not experienced any significant adverse effects related to its operation. The synagogue has a separate entrance and has not impacted valeUraffic. We have no reported complaints from our building residents with regards to running of the synagogue or the presence of the synagogue in our building. If I can be of further assistance, please do not heslt;lte to contact me directly, Ver{ truly yours, Joey Sinson - Property Manager ~ ~ ,.- r- QJ = eJJ Q eJJ ~ = eJJ ~= 00 ._ ~~ == ~ = ~= ~= rI.l= e= ~N == = ~ .- ~ .~ ~j; Q~ .- ~~ ~ ~ ~~ cr QJ ~ ~ = ~ ~ ..... 00 ro ~ (I) I:.) c.S .s "'0 (I) ;.., .- g. ~ (I) a 00 (I) .- a .s I:.) a 00 - - < ~ .s I:.) a 00 >-0:5 ~i ::;j ;.., 0 000 a~ (I) I:.) ~C.S ;.., .... ~ ....-4 (I) (I) (I) ~~0:5 a - A A (I) ::;j (I),J::l", . 00 ..... "" ,J::l :>....... b1). 2:; 00 '"' 0 !:: b1) ::;j -;::: !:: . - "'0 ...... ;"'0"'0 o (I) .E ..... ._ - ;.., ....., (I) .....Ii cro!:::>,",," -'--, ,J::l 0 ro ;"'0 ~ 00._ ...... ,._. !::::;j.....-....... (I) "'0 A (I) (I) 0"'080.1:.) !:: .- 00 0 ro ,J::l ~ .- (I) A .....;..,"'00..00 '~ ~ ~ !:: ~ . '"7l (I) ro b1)@~S~S !:: 0 ro ro 00 0 .- ;.., "'0 (I)..... ;;:::: ..... ...... 00 I:.) ;.., (I) A !:l 2"- (I) I:.) '1:: "" ro :> "'0 :>I:.)C(l)~~ b ~ ro n 00 ~ ~ B ~ ~ ": ;...." .... !:: .- t:: ..... (l)oro,J::lroro > Zoo ~ A~ . . . ..... o !:: (I) a ;.., ~ oo~ ::;j !:: 00 b1) o "'0 0 .- ;.., b1) ~ ro ro >- "'0 "'0 !:: ;...." 0 !:: :>.. ro8~(/) ~soo~ g. 0 .s .~ l=i I:.) A (I) I:.) A :>.. ~<~~ !::!:: b1) o (I) !:: !:/.) 8 -,-4 ~;.., ~ 00 0 (I) ,J::lt-H 00 b1) "'0 ~ 00 .- (I) !:: ,J::l:> (I) ;..,;.., d (I) (I) l=i ..... 00 !:: (I) (I) .~ ~ 0:5 (I) ~ ~ ,J::l ro I:.) ..... (I) c.S gf 0:5 !:: '1:: 0 0 ::;j..... '.J:j "'0 .s ~ b1) ;.., 00 !:: (I) ._..... b1) ~!:: !:: (I) ~ cU '.J:j 00 00 I:.) ro E S 'E ~ .~ (I) ~oo I:.)!::OO!:: . ~ (I) b1) (I) !:: ~ 8 .s S .,g 00 0 ;.., 0 I:.) .E~.g~~ .. . !:: o ,- ..... ro ;.., ..... ::;j 0 ~!:: !:: ~ o 0 U"'O "'0 8 a 0 o (I)~ N .- ~ 00 0 ;.., "'O~oo (I) 00 (I) ;9"'O::;j nab1) 00 "'0 0 (I) !:: b1) a ~ ~ o 00 :>.. .....-.00 E .~ ~ ,J::l 0 1:.)"'0 c.8 ro 0 !::-,J::l O ro ..... U ESo ro (I) ;.., ro a !:: .- ,J::l 00 ::;j "'0 "'0 .- ~ ;.., ~ (I) ;.., ro A. (I) !:: ;.., (I) A ..... S 00 ;.., sc.8 !::"'O (I) (I) 8 i:: o (I) ~ ~ . CERTIFICATE OF USE r- City of Aventura, Florida Community ~"./"q, ~c~~~e~~ Development Department FOLIO: 28-2210~80-2770 ZONING DISTRICT: RMF4 ACCOUNT NO. 02 05281 FEE: $35.00 BUSINESS ADDRESS: Organization for Jewish Studies 2600 Island Blvd CU1 Aventura FI 33160 MAlUNG ADDRESS: Organization for Jewish Studies 4000 Island Blvd #3006 Aventura FI 33160 BUSINESS USE: Synagogue USE SPECIFICS: Synagogue CONDITION: Assembly not permitted in resident units LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Unit CU1 of 2800 Island Blvd WlIIlan Island . Condominium _ing 10 the Dec:loratlon thereof Recorded .. ORB ll1884 DATE OF ISSUANCE: 04/08/02 ( THIS CERTIFICATE MUST BE POSTED ON PREMISES-. THIS CERTIFICATE OF USE GUARANTEES THAT THE BUSINESS USE AT THE ADDRESS STATED ABOVE COMPLIED WITH ZONING DISTRICT AND PARKING REQUIREMENTS ON THE DATE OF CERTIFICATE ISSUANCE. THE CERTIFICATE ONLY BECOMES PERMANENT UPON THE ISSUANCE OF A CITY OF AVENTURA OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE, PROVIDING THERE IS NO CHANGE OF USE OR BUSINESS OWNERSHIP AND NO ALTERATION OR ADDITION TO THE BUILDING OR STRUCTURE. SUCH CHANGES MUST BE APPLIED FOR IN PERSON AT THE CITY OF AVENTURA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT. PLEASE CONTACT THE CITY OF AVENTURA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT OFFICE FOR THEIR REQUIREMENTS AT (305) 466-8940. .- , ~ -tn::;c-l-or.....r r""" J> ~nn 00 III '" III ....Ill ... 0 :TO: C -oOM lOW~O 3 III ...ol n III n n " '" I"i~~-i COO", 103 ..... OJ 0: .. ol .... ZO:r-< ITI00Q CIll ., I'-'"......,,~ Z ...ill =' -iOe Zo-.OJ> Ool ... "'1Il 0' ... !II e zo -i Z M...n - '< III c.., 0 ol "' ::ot:J0004"'T e ....M 0.. ... II , ol .. l>!Tl-t '" UlN ... . ....n ;l OO-<J> 10 rlO ." " III .... OJ O'ol -i C J>-i 1Tl. ol II C.1Il OJ 'Tl c!'T1 'Tl Z.... Z '" c.., 3 r nmz r 00 J>- .. ., III OC-; Z r WCiT1C W '" -i. wzr:::o W r'Tl -< ~-;O~ .... CO 00"'" 0-. 0", O-<:r 0 0 ITl L HOW 0 tv _ 0 nz ., m UJ....-< .. 'J o-.W'" -or.... C "'-iZ , OOt:) :I:C .... r-<J> 00 OUlJ> 0 "'0 (f) J> c;') to L~ ~Z Z ITl :I: -<00 '>J .... .... ITl 0-0 .j 'Tlc;') OtO UJ-oN XlJ> rJJ e ,,,.... rWJ> ~ ....'" -i rJ>ITlOOO J>W-i WC-i C MC 000 Z I .... om:r 0 nlTl 0~0 L~ 1T1 .... I'1Z lTle >J Z Z fT1 Z-i " Z "'to -i (l)e " n r-CD~ .. 1Tl", ...r C 0 0-. J> ., J> 0 '" 0-. .., M OJUJ I zo "'(1) '- lXl n ....... ITl -0 J>n 0 'Tl C .. e ol .... M ,.J .; n." ITl (I) OJ> c.o :I: Z-i II / J> '" 0 (I).... ... (I) ( Co-.", "0 II -i ! l'TIOC;; ....Z e ZOJ> nJ> 0 -i Z er .... e .... 0 1T1 "'MN er ..\ J>(I)J> (I).... r-i n n 'TlJ>.... "'1'1 -0 ... rzo rz , .... oZ J>Ul W W om 0 =' ~aJ"" 1T1 , 0' ....ro 0 ., 0-.<:::0 N , . 00 '- 1'1 C M (f) :I: W (.ry " -i -0 c: tv 0 -< , ~ ... l"i~L(~~ -:~:~:~~~~s:~~~; -- ."Iii; ~ 'p,wpp" ~~~~~ m:.1 ~ 1 ~ ! ,~ ~~~H?iii UU~U g I'!::n;! g I'! I'! . UI~U~ ~ ww 8~~w ! ! ~ ~~~ . " ~ ~ ~ "~~ 51 ~ .~ " <C . ~ ~ .. z <C ~ <~~ z ~ "" " h" "j z ~ " 99~d ~ ill ~ zEB . '" . . ~ <C II ., d Z ., " L> l>. V> ~. " :0 Z <3 ~ ~ I ~~ ~~ .1 .. l .. '" <:) " " :ol <<l d &I vi '" ~ o z " .. o ~ "" ., " ~ ~ L I ~ ~ >- ~ ~ II ; o z ~~~ "'.., l ,. . ! I t ~. . "i ~. f . U tit n II .. . f.~ ~G .i. oz ;. ~ i dl ~iil !I;~ '" '" ~ l., ~.,... II '" L~ " ~~ II i '" '" ~ ~ e . " N ~ 0 ~ ~i I~ L~ ,~~, i;n .."'. .'.. ! II!~ ."'" .'. ! i .'<~',," HII "" .'" '., ., I~. ','_ ..;:;;;;.;:." ~ ~ ~: ': '" !r "," 4....... "~~':~.;;;;:';~, .o:.,~~~," "'- "', .",., '::-::-~ ~~, ",-. ' ~/ '~... '" ~!~;s:~-'_,,:',-~~~ .';;::;;;, '~... -~. ., .... .. "~ .. ,. -. .- ~ , '.-. - .,...., ..::, "--' " " .-----~~--- ~n ~ 1F' ~~ : 1" It! 0 =.- ~' ~ ~--.- ei= i::: ~ J lif v 1'-- /'" I- Tm '" ~ ~@I , :'1. "V +fPt '- ~ '~ -. 11" . - ~ ..--.\; ~ .,,:"" -.. i . ., . ... · i I it ~ ~l : : : : i' : - ~ -: ~ i w ~. ; : ~ I ~ n I ~ ~ ; ; I~ ~ ::" it i '. r. ~.. ... ~ .. ~ u ~ "~ ~~~~.~: Ili ..~~~".. 7{~~-: r- ,,}~~ .J V ~'.i~.J ~~ : ~ , .:_ ..' ...- JI.. . r:.T · ,~I. · ~ 11<1 IS .:2; l -I"; II ! -&." "~~. - ::;;=. I;. - '~I~i -~, ~~ ~l. -:..... ~~ 1- ft.[ · ~~~~ w ~~lm . _ ~lli ~J 1-+ il I . ! IIr Iii I ~B n ! i I il! f+ i i !! I II II! Hi" i;. I -II.. 1:B 3911d OOSS\l 8 ZlOl-tGQLl9 ff-~i-" EGBE1:PLP9G 1:P:01 EBB1:/1:1/11 0. Igl II I \-I.h"I' J ~I~ ..... It I it Ii li!lJ!!li,11 i I'" U 1:11: I II ill !m/mUlI Hili i!l!l.i ~l 8 NDIS3G GNY 3Hn.L;:)3.LIH;:)HY HOIH3.LNI dnOHD NDIS3G SNIGHYCS3G /' ~1-----" L.lD I ,. 'l'. \ ~ ,,~ , " l ~- -- 'I 'f I Ii III 1'1 f I , " Ilf ~ I i I ., III f' II I! .. , . ~ ' . , ; i ~ ~ J I "Il:/~J !!li!j~j ~ -<>--'lle<D ;:,~~'7~I~L~':~dl'--"'''''''''''''' S1IlIddYt\l"Il'IIO~YmI<IIWlV.'n~;;::"'-"O" ':)NJ 'SH1D1S1ItJ~S"lI3lINI!>N3?~-= V'il1 NlDIOi[ -. ..y / /x~j ,/::~\ ;!~ ~ ___I . "';' ~,." l;i!!~U:: i~j :;d~ iJl>~ i !I !i ' ,., '1 ". 1 ~ 'Io~g E:lI(le= ! ~ I ~~';'i 'I' ,I, ''" '. I' / ' "'" II> I a ~~ ~o ,I i I~'~ d t mx 'Y:r, /ih! ~~ ,i~ "!i i~ i!'illl ~h i.iil II P, , q 'I I' ; ~ '"'".~:,::"''' !'>-h.! 11; / _______________ !ili',!I:' -.1, I'! l= Illll'! i'll' ;'1'1 :i! i'i~ Ii!' ':!' I II! I' I~ I': ,!: ~ 'r~ i~ / 11,1 I! II, . .,,' I"~ J ~i ,II ,/, :1' ,II' II!! !',I ~ I If II 1~ i1~ ;\S, q ,r ' p:f- :I." ' ,.,11,,:, idji I I' I,'! I,I! Ii I! ,i, il'; !!I ,1'1 . illl I," I' I: 'I' ,,1,' ;!! " . .... '. .,,,. "I" ,.~' "" "..,.,. '1""'" I li'll ." i;J r' !! b~m i! .i, q it! III II' i! ill il!l! iii ;Il; I il~i il!1 !i!l Jl '!'i:; Iii " ~. ~ _ ~lll, !i i:.; lilli III l,lil'llIJ'!! 'i,i, Ii i; IIIPI" II 11; . ~. .IBft ~~ '1~~ fa I~~I~! ,. _ , " , ' ,I " . il ,! !.ll" " !;~ , . ., " WI. II! . . . ..n........._ ~ J ~ " < , i i. :!' ~ - (" ", r- YOII:101,j'A.lNflOO 30'l10-11II'O'1l'l'l'O' AVMAI:I1N30N l::IruN3^'O':l0A.1I:l NElIS30 >l1\tM3 \>'1SI "WllllM OIS 03S0dOl:ld / / / / / / / ~ I~ 'I ~C:'<~' , ~.l n."" ".,~'.II 'I .1 ""'----. . ,\ .1 -..,;A - 0 !~l ____----~..~~:/ 11I11I1I~1I111111 d/--c-'< . ." II /",..-------------_. / / / \ \ \ \ \ \ Gi:ji; / / I I,. i;i! ~li r=jl v i~ " ~~ -------- o:;;:::.:...~~ ~a~ .l.O'v'i:::UL ;. u . UOJDO 'V'j 'DMp. I I '0 \ I MO\'~ ~l. {ttI)... LIrLO--DL (tte) 11m ..... -- ............. ..... 'II ZEIC'......--.. ...... eel.poIlD :v Z II YOlllllJ 'YlIllltGIY . I" 'C" ONYlSI SrlYm~ T _ _ ., IlL I I ilIM09YIllIAS C111ll1'n8ll_WD1l11M I~" ~ IIII111 ~~I~~ ~m ~ zEB . '" . ..: II .. "- In &" " => z ~ 0 I I ~~ f I !a t- , OJ Q j '" II ~ ~ ii t <<l . ~ .. I (, 51 ~ - , OJ ~ i\ . o z i d~ '" h I Q "J .. < ... :,; ~i~~~~?i U~U~~ ~j:!gel2ge <> III to <> i"''' . z ~ z z ~ z: ~ ~d~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ r" "'. ~ " ~~i . i ~ ~ " . ~ ..: . l!l~ ~ ~ ~i t- ~ ..: @ . ~~. ~~~ !i~ ~ ~ ~ 99hh~ h OJ ..........., I! .i;; ."" Bill .'.,>.. II!. " <::>., ~;::>. Ifl ,.<:::~::' ~~ ~,.",-.,<,/ ""'~; ~ s s i II s .~ " ~~ h I I . ~ ~. . .~ . I U 9 ~n~ II ~I I II ~ i I' I I 'Iii !I;~ s s r-- ( - -< o :E m JJ " JJ o C z o ." 8 JJ "'0 r > z .. G> ~ > " m j/ JJ -< ~ r en :-< ." r o o JJ "'0 I): ;z I, ~ ~ I I I I i i I I I I I I I 1 .... J: I .~./ I .;/.' ,"""~--r" '"l--f._n.../~' : : I I I I , '\ I ,I , I I I \ I ~ I I 1 I I'l I L____., , , =====; Iii: {; II , I ~--i1 ft.]~ \ ' . '====, l!'.3' 1 .-- : r"- ~j -. r--" _____J : U: I ~.,~ __n_., ~, ; V - : I ~! l i' c::r[!'f~~f~ (:.r~~ I .1., ~ ':I':; =-= -=: ' as ~'.'. iI' i'" .......,.. I'! '\... I ~-.:;;;,l"----~ ~,,~~~~odL)-=! ~...Lm./---~" r----J ~IOlitJII~.'" :~ .,. ~_!-!'_~~_../ , ~ ......., B -~ .,. r"l - f : ' : : :0. :-rf""\'~1,....."J~J,;~-11;:~/_J " I I 1 I ~.."{.' 6 ~ Qf M I: If..:. :3 l.._'"ji__.!. ..."J_-_........l.,l_=....--=4.~j I :~! .t-:! t - J t -., i ...-_: - r~o}--..~ -" ~'Y'l 1>...'" 16.._______1.._ .. (.., "g~. ~ A'" ~..l. ;, ~ I l~ r 1 t,.....' &.!...-, ",....0 .L~_.! :,;1 ~__J : ~lg .,... _._n..~ !' ~ I I . iii "C:r l' "P" I ' r I. . .1 ~ : I f!~~;'-' '~I ~ ,;~ ~ ' , I I, . .# . I I!: E . n I I " '.~ 'T'l1 I I ~- ~.,ef 1 ~"', t~ ' I . r.._l.,t~ ~::l L....J, ~o . l. ' .~ ) ~-----~-~-------": N > ~ 0'\ Q > ,... Q JJ C1 - .n - ~ : , .-< 0 ,... ~ !~ ::s ~ - :'" = ~ ;>1 =- ::s :~ 0 ~ =- .0' !o; a Cd !:;: ~ ..-< -. ~ -m 0 '''' ::s - " = z -. ~ = - " ::s ~ = ~ .~ .... =- , I : I I I \;,,() I i " , o (7 o o ~ I-J- Xli! i .~ ~ I ,i I . H! "i Hi !:: ;.. 'I:: " ." ..' :1' pp~ 'IXI" ~ g ~ :~ii1 ~gt = 0 e . . . i! I~~ q ~ o ~ o Rece1ved: 10/ 3/ 2 4:05PM: 30SQ33130e -> GREENBERG TRAURIGi Page 5 18/83/2882 16:88 38S9~~'. 389 JB PAGE 8S ~ ~~~ From 07/00 on ~ , No, Date Unit Name Room Event 01 09/23/0 0710 Mauricio Olarte Sun Son' s Blrfhday 0 Garden 02 10/09/0 0804 Ronnie Whi tebook Party Cocktail Party 0 03 10/22/0 2606 N i li Harei Party Lunch 0 04 10/24/0 2709 Hilda Berger Party Daughter . s Party 0 06 11/24/0 2901 Vicky Silver Party Rehearsal Psrty 06 12/25/0 3006 Victoria de Zaga Party Fest. de Casas Nuevas 0 07 12/29/0 :t(J()6 Yi c!()!."ia de -1~n Party Shabat Dinner .. 0 08 12/31/0 0906 Anna Kielmanowitz Party New Year , 5 Party 0 09 01/06/0 2109 Milli Chaikin Party Birthday Party 1 10 01/12/0 3006 Victoria de Zaga Party Dinner Party 1 11 02/18/0 0306 Sen. Gwen lIargolis Party Brunch 1 12 02/21/0 2709 Hilda Berger Party Party 1 13 03/23/0 0203 Harry Seidner Party Shabat Dinner 1 14 04/07/0 1407 Dr. Rattfe Party Passover Party 1 04/08/0 1 15 04/07/0 0806 Ronnie Whitebook Card Family Dinner 1 16 04/07/0 3006 Victoria de Zags Sun Passover 1 Garden 04/08/0 ] 04/09/0 1 ~ 18/a3/2882 16:88 3a5g?~1.389 3059331309 -~ GREENBERG TAAURIG; Page 6 JB PAGE at, Received: 101 3/ 2 4:06PM; ~ ~ 17 04/20/0 1010 Linda Senado Party Shebet 1 18 04/21/0 Rafael Torruno Party Wedding 1 19 04/ 2709 Hilda Berger Party /01 20 04/29/0 2901 Vickie Silver Party Only if rains 1 21 OS/22/0 2109 lIi.i Chaikin Part,. Jewish baptism 1 22 06/22/0 1101 Carol Prizant Card After Funeral 1 23 OS/27/0 2506 Nili Harel Party Shavoul 1 24 ~o 26 27 ..28 29 30 31 32 33 34 36 36 37 38 ~ 3059331309 .:> GREENBERG TAAURIG; Page 4 Rece1ved: 10/ 3/ 2 4:05PM; JB PAGE 84 18/83/2ee2 lG:ee 3e5g~^'3eg ,~ r- .r- Usage of Recreational Rooms (Aug 2001 - Feb 2002) Date Unit I Room Event #of Owner ' Guests 08/03 4# 1006 Memun Party Shobat 28 08/10 4# 1006 Memun Party Shabat 28 08/1 0 # 402 Sandoval Card Graduation 55 PartY '" , '^' # 3004 Meins1ei, PeAy Klddlsh -... f-. .'i0 09/29 # 1603 Nottis Party Baby Shower 50 10/10 # 607 Pludwlnskl Party KIddish 50 10/21 # 3004 Melnsteln Party Memorial 50 10/27 # 1605 Hanner Party Halloween Party 50 11102 # 2605 Hanono Party Dinner 16 11/10 # 2506 Harel Porty Dinner 49 11/17 # 402 Prfzant Party 95th Birthday 26 Partv 12/04 # 2108 Yachnovitz Party Book Club 5 12/13 # 3004 Melnsteln Party Chanukah 30 12/14 #11 10 Rnvarb Party Surprise Party 40 01/11 # 1006 Memun Party Dinner 15 01/1 1 # 203 Grimberg Sun Gorden Dinner 25 01/18 # 1006 Memun Party Dinner 20 02/14 # 90 1 Kossman PartY BoolcClub 10 Received: 101 31 2 4:05PM; 3058331308 -~ GREENBERG TRAURIG; Page 3 10/03/2002 16:00 305g3~13Elg JB PAGE 03 r- ~( Recreational Room 2002 Scbedule " Date Room Unit # Resident Event 01111 Party 0203 Grimberg Shabat Dinner 01/18 Party 1006 Memun Shablt Dinner 02114 Party 0901 Kassman Book Club 02120 Party 0000 W.I. Spa 02123 Party 3004 Meinstein Luncheon 03/02 Party 1909 Kogan Luncheon 03/22 Party 1006 Memun Shebat Dinner 03/26 party 0806 Whitcbook Dinner 03/27 party PH02 Whitcbook Pass Over 03/27 Sun Garden 3006 Zaga Pass Over 03/27 Card Room 2501 Kriger Pass Over 03/28 Party 3006 Zags ulnner 03/29 Party 3006 Zaga Dinner 04102 Party 3006 Zaga Dinner O4lQ3 Party 300(! Zl!P Dinner 04127 Party 2210 . Memun Shibit Dinner ./"""" 05106 Media 0406 Rothfield Business Meeting 05/08 Party 2609 Vasquez Business Meeting 05/11 Party 1006 Memun Shebat Dinner 05/16 Party 2506 Harel Dinner 05/18 Party 1006 Memun Sheba! Dinocr OS/21 Sun Garden 3004 Meinstein Birthday 05125 Party 3004 Meinstein Luncheon 06108 Party 0306 Margolis Luncheon 06/09 Party 3004 Meinstein Luncheon 06/29 Sun Garden 0608 Betancourt Baby Shower 06/29 Party 0607 Pludwinski Luncheon 07/07 Party 2501 Kriger Birthday 07/07 Sun Garden 1707 Pinknowski Luncheon 07/13 Party 1009 Kagan Dinner 07/20 Party ()()()() Trump Group 07126 Patty 2210 Memun Shabat Dinner 08/09 Party 1006 Meroun Shabat Dinner 08/24 Party 2603 Amunategui Baptism 09/16 Party PH02 Whitebook Dinner 09/22 Party 1606 Fielding Birthday 09128 Party 2208 Sanchez Birthday 09129 Party 3004 Meinlltein Luncheon ~- ~ ~ ~ 04/2g/2003 15:05 e4/,~/,e~J 14;5~ 305g33130g J~5~J7~~ge JB PAGE 02 PAGE 81/131 RECREATIONAL ROOMS SCHEDULE (M OF SEPT 2002 UNTIL PRESENT) "118-. - llIOF QUESTS, . EV!NT L POA. -- P . OWNERB A.8lKlC. 3D :fie 6ol>>"''' 403. G TN ~d POA r P::. 05SASSOC ao AJi:HANAI1 I,I~ET' C' ~c:t "'R RM zooe BUR 'TYl'I 100 eJlKiAGI! EN I ER 12-0= PARTY RM 2006 It TYN 120 E T PARTY '-- PROP. OWNERS ASSOC. ;,u MEETING 1 MIov 403 GOLDSMITH 3D BU~~ EErING 22-Nov M eol IIlllUOWICZ eo :jJ! T I)IHNER 27__ II" TY llOll KLODA 60 I THOAY PARTY 6-Dec Q PROP. OWNERS ASSOC. ME 1Q.Oec II IlOB KlOtlA 100 L PARTY 31. AM 2508 ~~ NEW YEA~:S ~E p. 31.Dac L 708 II OWN 50 YEAF'S EVE PTY .,Jill LNG POA PROP. OWNERS ASSOC. 30 . 3-Jln Ii 201 WEINBERG 8 U ROO~I e.Jan 201 WEINBERG 8 V 00111 1l.,J1Il 2405 MILOEHBERG 8 use Rooiil ""'" 0103 LOSMITH 4 . ,....., B1LUARD 1105 LEGQIO 4 PLAY I. 1lh11n . RI= OINITE 5 U CON! 1 D.Jan . 4 UIJ ROOIIII 1N1n TEEN RM GO 11TH 4 TUTORING 111- .. BILLIA 1102 TAYLOR 2 PLAY i. 24. .. TEEN RM 2101 MELLER 5 USE Re 2V. ., RM G02 COUER 4 USeR N 30-.... RM 2101 MELLER 5 USI! 31..... PARTY ~r~l:in 8.SAVALU 15 BUSINESS MEETING 6-F. PARTY C CULT.I..NT. COMMITTEE 50 COCKTAlljOlNNER (LECTURE) -- PROP. OWNERS C. 30 MEETING 1 R I 1102 ~OR 4 use ROOM 1J.F. IA 1102 t OR 2 'PLAY POOl. 15-... PAR lI04 LAURENCE 80 BIRTHDAY '"ARTY 18-F. nEEN 403 1,11111 4 TUTORING 27.~... T EN RM 403 GOLDSMITH 4 TUTORINcf N RM 1506 BRODA. 3 USE TAYLOR 5 USE RooM 1.Mar T 1003 ~ 3 USE ROOM 1.M.- ITH 4 TUT ING \...... 0 3002 IN 4 PLAY POot Z....r N M 5 UBi ROOM _r POOl. P . OWNERS 30 II: -... ITY RM 2003 ARG lIS 01 Al~TY 18-M.r I lARD 1102 TAYLOR 4 PLAY Oi =: ILLGF RI GOLDSMITH 6 SE - TA OR 2 P POOL. -- I t;; POA PROP. OW OC. 30 MEETING I 2405 MIL N ERG 5 USE ROOM NRM OWlCZ 4 II~ 11 INoIET . 4 USER 100 Ill' ,I' RM 04 GOLDS H 30 P R =i: TY Mot 2402 D GER 30 1803 0 4Ii LDHI R "---- TRANSPORTATION GOAL TO PROVIDE A SAFE AND EFFICIENT MutTIMODALTRANSPORTATION SYSTEM APPROPRIATE TO SERVE THE NEEDS OF TIlE CITY; TO PROMOTE THE USE OF ALTERNATIVE TRANSPORTATION METIIODS ENCOURAGING SCALED PEDESTRIAN AND BICYCLE FACILITIES, PUBLIC TRANSIT, ADEQUATE PARKING FACILmES, PARATRANSIT, AND OTIlER MODES OF TRANSPORTATION; TO COORDINATE THE TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM WITH THE LAND USE PLAN, AND OTHER APPROPRIATE AGENCIES; AND TO PROTECT RIGHTS-OF-WAY. [9j- 5.019(4)(a)] Objective 1 ( Provide the framework for a safe, convenient, and energy efficient multi-modal transportation system through implementation of the programs outlined in this element, and the concurrency and access management systems contained in the City's land development regulations. [9J-5.019(4)(b)I] Measure: Implementation of a local street traffic count program. Adoption of access management ordinance. Policy 1.1 As per 9)-5.005(8)0), the City of Aventura adopts the level of service standard as described in . the Miami-Dade County Comprehensive Development Plan, Traffic Circulation Subelement 1997, Objective 1 Policy lB, as it relates to Urban Infill Areas (UIA) [9)-S.019(4)(c)1], and more particularly described as follows: The minimum acceptable peak-period LOS for all State roads and on all County roads shall be the following: Within the Urban 1nfill Area (DIA) (a) Where no public mass transit service exists, roadways shall operate at or above LOS E; ,- Page 3 018 ~ Policy 1.4 Based upon the aforementioned traffic counts, the City shall within eighteen (18) months following adoption of the Comprehensive Plan revisit the VIA designations granted on City collectors and local streets. Policy 1.5 Within one (1) year of Plan adoption, the City will adopt an access management system, and administer these requirements upon its adoption to promote safe vehicular entrance points to the roadway system. [9J-5.019(4)(c)2] Policy 1.6 The City will develop transportation management strategies, such as but not limited to, traffic calming techniques and traditional neighborhood design concepts, to improve efficiency, and enhance the safety of the pedestrian, bicycles, and transit riders within the context of an integrated multi-modal transportation system. [9J-5.019(4)(c)7] ( Policy 1.7 Annual transit trips per capita will be utilized to determine the achievement of the mobility goals of the City. [9J-5.019(4)(c)10] Objective 2 As part of the internal consistency requirement of the Comprehensive Plan elements, the transportation system outlined in this element will be coordinated with the Future Land Use Map or map series to ensure that the transportation modes are consistent with the land uses in the area by the Plan's adoption. [9J-5.019(4)(b)2] Measure: Number of capital improvements that encourage and support a multi-modal transportation system Policy 2.1 P"rking strategies will be developed that encou.rage a multi-modal transportation system including scaled pedestrian and bicycle facilities, public transit, paratransit, and other modes of transportation. [9J-5.019(4)(c)3] ~ Page 5 ofB r A review was conducted to detemrlne the existence and condition of ports, airports, freight and . passenger rail lines, public trllIlSportiltion and modal facilities are identified in Map 24. Ports and Related Facilities The City does not possess any seaports within its corporate limits. Therefore, no reference is made to any port-related facilities on the attached figures. However, the County does contain the Port of Miami, one of the world's busiest seaports. In addition, there are several commercial marinas throughout the City. Airports and Rela,ted Facilities ~ No airports are located within the City of Aventura. Therefore, a discussion of an airport's clear zones and obstructions is not applicable. Miami International Airport (MIA) and Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport (FLL) are the closest major airport facilities. Opa Locka airport is closest General Aviation facility to A ventura. Although no airports are located within the City, the 1997 Miami-Dade Comprehensive Development Master Plan indicated that there is one heliport located in the northwest comer of A ventura. Freight Rail Lines and Related Facilities The Florida East Coast (FEC) Railroad runs adjacent to US 1 (West Dixie Highway/Biscayne Boulevard/SR 5) along the length of the western border of the City from its southern to northern limits. The FEC Railroad is used for freight operations. No freight rail temrlnal is located within the City of A ventura. ~ PagelS 0129 ~ /- \1 c ill ~ ~ 11 ~ z ;E < '" ~ " , i '" ~ " '" ~- ~ 7 BROWARD COUNlY lei g rj -liiiiiiiiiiiiliiiiiiiiiiiiiiii liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiillll_U o 9 g. . .. I . g 01Y UMIT . -----.g lEGEND i ExistIng g 8rowaid County i Mass Transit Route g: 111111111119 lves D' n Existing MIami- Dade County Road Metro Bus Routes: -.-.- 3 .. .... ... ... 9 ------- E -" -" - s --'-V ..-.-.-.-,. Blscayne Max '" Major Transfer Point * Trip Generators and Attractors Other Existing Multi-Modal _ Mamas "",,"',,"",,",, Blcyde and Pedestrian Ways FEC Railroad Heliport MlAMI.DADE COUNTY . Map 2.8 ~ c::~ ..~ ~i Ii ~~ .1 O~ -: I . "'~ . ." .... co, ca~ ~ -~ ...~ ~~ i: ., " I~ ~ " Source: Miami-Dade Transit Agency, Route Maps, 1997. 1997 Miami-Dade Comprehensive Master Plan. FTHl Future Multi-Modal Transportation City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan . 1998 SCALE IN FEET ~ way, Harris a. Walls, Inc. O3lS.OrIIndoAYo. Uo3lO _......Ra218lI f'honeo .0107-829-8880 Fall' .0107-<1211-7888 JoIx 9.16.0'1 DlIbl: 7f1A191 1 ~ rJ.. .ir:.. --.~I~ '. .. " :...... ~.- ",ot' 6',' ..- . .' , ,. _.~....... -., /. ,,~.t ~...... .-~~ (,' .,....",--- -' _.: "- '. :,;, '-.---- "'H. ~...- .;:, ~'. :..~-~ ~ I~ ;-.' r'_ ",i_I I ~ * p""""" ';", r __ ~-~ J'~ j ~-1Ii/IIlif""W 'r-'.... ..;o' "_... . '~...... ....,... r-_ ,,........,, ~ ~ j "4-'" 7:! . .".- '....... ~ ... r...-.... ,- ! 1 .... ~ ,....- W: I ,.+,~ !~~ -r r-- ~ 11/05/2003 22:45 11/07/2003 10:43 3054553553 3059370098 WILLIAMS ISLAND POA PAGE 02 rHloX. CJ.I.'~'" ~ 2600 15l!'.NP BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM AS~}IATION. INC. lMPDST AN1:..Th1FORMA TIOtiFORJ.::ONTBAC'[QRS 3. 4. 5. I 6. 7. 8. 1. WORKING HOURS: 6:00 a.m.-4:00 p.m., Monday - Friday. No extensions. unlesS approved through management first. 2. ENTRAtlCE REQUlltEMENTS: All contractors end/orvendors will be required to leave a valid picture \0 )11".: driver license, alien registration card, Pllssport, ml\ltary 10, etc.) with the receiving office. One e this is done B building Identification ba.jge will be issued to that person specifying exactly where they are permitted to work. After !.hay have completed the assigned work for the day, their picture ID will be returned to them. ALL CONTRACTOFlS MUST BE I.ICENSED AND INSUREO. All necessary permits MUST be pulled prior to st2 rting the job. NOIse IFl.ELA TED V fORK CAN NOT START UNTIL AFTER 9:00 a.m. PARKING: There Is to be NO parking in the receiving area r:xCEPT to LOACI/UNLOAD. RECEMNG LIFT: When operating the receiving 11ft, cont"aC';ors MUST use the, hand reils and chains at ALL times. ELEVATORS: All materials and contrectors MUST use the f-elght elevator OI~L Y. Under NO circumstances are tile Privata Elevators to be used. DAMAGES; COnt" clors are RESPONSIBLE for protecting unit entry doors, elevators, hallways, floors (including 1'\195), and walls. IF ANY damege occurs the unit owner will be responsible for all rllpalr coslS. 9 SMOKING IS NOT i>ERMI11'ED IN THE BUILDING. 10. SMOKE DI".TECTC RS: If any wor1< that produces duet (wllldlng, sanding, flcoOrlng, atC-) will require that the sm' ke detectors be COMPLETEL V covered NOT REMOVEI), False elerms caused by contrac\lll'$ will be chargad $60.00 for inspection and reset fees. 11. FIRE SPRINKLER :iHUT DOWN: Fire sprinkler shut.do'M1!lln units will requir'~ a $150.00 up- front fae for tha shut clown of the system and start-up per CJccu~nce. 12 TRASIi: Contractols are responsible to remove all trasl, from the unit and hallwaYll. Nothing is be stored In the h ~lIwaYll, elevetolS and/or corridolS, If any trash conStruCUlln trash is to be removed by our janitorial staff there will be a fee of $50.~IO charge for Iha removal and disposal of sul;\'ltrash. 13. CLOSING HOURS: All contractors must be out of the building by 4:16p.m. NO DXceptionsl Any work of delive y exception requesta will need to be prearranged through the Building Administration OIDe"'. .~ C:\MyAIOSIPoIlcI.. & ProoedUre ,lI\e""lYing,wpcI ~ --- "i:' l-< ~Q) ~Q) ~Q) QJ <u e a a ,~ ~ <u e = .s 8 1:: 8 eJ) 80.,0., ~ ~ ~ ~ ...... ;:l 0 0., V) V) a ~ en -.::t -.::t eJ) '--' '--' o .. .. '--' '--' ~'--''--' = 8 8 M\.CIOO a 8 8 V) 8 8 .. I I = 0.,0., N a a ~ 0.,0., ;t: 0., 0., ~ \.CI 00 - 0\ \.CI 00 t-\.CIOO I I I 0.,0., I I I I I I 00- a a aoo ~ a a a a a = "0 0.,0., ~r;'!M 0., 0., ~o.,o., = V) t- 0\ V) \.CI 00 V) t- t- V) t- o ..... = ~ ...... - = l:'-l "'0 ;... ~ en ~ l:'-l l-< c.. S .E 0 E-< = ~ I ~ ..... ~ ~ - 0 - ~ "'0 ..... l-< "'0 "'0 l:'-l ~ "'0 ~ S 1::1 ;... ...... 0 = l-< ~ . ~ r./) r./) 0 ~ r- == ~ a ~ ~ 0., 0 0 -.::t Q) ~ I = ~ 1::1 0 0 eJ) Z l:'-l = 00 ..... ;... ..... = "0 c.. = 0 S ~ 0 eJ) ~ u = ..... "'0 "0 1::1 - ~ ;:l ..... r./) = "'0 "'0 = ...... ~ l-< ~ Q I ~ Q ~ \C "'0 "'0 M 1::1 ~ ,..-.. 0 ~ r./) r- ,- -- ~ QJ ~ .. eIJ > = c.. J..~ ~ . I .. rIJ = ~ ~ = ~= c.= OO\C elJN = J.. .. C ~~ J.. ~ ~ ~ 00 \0 M ~ Q) ~ · ,...-4 ;> o ~ ~ ~ ,.....-I ,.....-I cd E u < bJJ ~ · ,...-4 ~ rJJ. · ,...-4 >< ,.....-I~ ~~ ~ ~ lr) ~ C'-l Q) S · ,...-4 ~ ~ cd ~ 8 Q) -,...-4 ~ ~ .~ u &2 Q) ~ ~ ~ ,.....-I 0 ~u o~ ~ 0 M lr) ~ rJJ.~ [j~ u .~ >< ;> ~ 8 ~~ o ~ Q) "S ~ z rJJ. Q) u cd ~ ifl bJJ ~ ,.....-I · ~ ~~ o cd ~~ ;Sy...e ">>,.- ---,- ;0;- ._~~.._."~ ~n"'_'" t;,~::; J" m /\ .~ .~ ,~ '\~ _jl, \1 \.ro ~ - ~~ ~E;~ ~ ~~I ........ 5 :e~~;!: ~~ .... 1ft....... . o. =~:: . .,' tt~ t t~ I s ~ ~~ ~ :: ! III g~g ~ gg . ;; . u .."'0 ~ . .. 0 .-- ... . :: B 0_ . t 000 ~::; N . . 000 -. I ~ _0. . .. -:"'. 0 t .: . N, ~I~ . 0 0 00' . ~. ri lL ............ . ~~ ............ 0 N 0 ., ...........:; . . . . :' ~ , , ;1 u N . ~III .. .- ~ ? . ~ ~ ;; g; .. : . .......... ~. . . ............ ~ .11 .:..: ~I ~ ............ ~ :;: ~5 .u S . :~-~- ~ :: 0 . . .. ~ .. ~ ~ 0 ~ a ~ . ~ S ~ .g .. ~ ~ . . ~I ~ ~~ =a 51 .- . 0 . ~ ~ ~ ~ u.o u . . . ~ '11 :c..;" ~ ~ 0 . ~ . -. ~I i t ; ~ . u : .- . .. . N . . . . i .~ . ~ . C!l .. 31 ... " E = ~ " ~I ~ 0 j"! ... r ~ II ~ "0 . .u Z ... . ~ . . ON ~= u. !I ii ...~!; ::::::~ 3 ::::::~ . 0 ~I ::::::~ ~ ~- ~ Z .0: q ~ " . " ~I B; ". . .....:..: ... " ~ ... . 0 ~ ... . - .. 0 ~o ~x. ... ~ sl ~=~ . :~: . ~I ~ . :;t ... . ~ 0 ~ 2 t N ~! ... . u leU: 0 u f" : ::11: ~: .0. . . . . .. . . . . .. ^hl ( . ZONING DATA ( ,--- ~, ...,,-.~"-;',fsE"~~"';. :_~....;.,.,. ZONING CLASSIFICATIONS RU-4A ;(NO. F.A.R. REQUIREMENTS)' MINIMUM LOT ~ <LOT AREA GROSS 25..72 "ACRES UNDER WATER 5.51 ACRES NET LOT l\:REA 20.2~.ACRES< . :. ,t.~ ALLOWABLE ~COVERAGE 40%~~ ACTU.AL LOT COVERAGE PHASE r PHASE I I : PilMJE ur . .. FlIASE IV'{PRQPOSEOJ ,TOTAL LOT COVERAGE: MAX ALLOWABLE ilEIGilT ACTUAL illHGIlT TOMA1N ROOF ~ COONT PIlASE I PIlAS E II PHASE I II PIlASE IV (PROPOSED) TOTAL NUMBER OF UNITS ~ NO. OF UNITS ALLOWED 45/AC. ~ ACTUAL. DENSITY 710%' 25.72. '" PARKING REQUIRED 710 UNIT.S X 1 ,25 ~. ,.,. ~... PARKING REQUIRED -,-,.".,."-, FULL PROVIDED. ^ PIlASE I PHASE n PHASE I II PHASE IV (PROPOSED) 175 175 . . 148 368 866 TOTAL "'":" .' .' ~ , ~_:". ,4,-_ .,......,. :"'_" '-.,.' ,.~ %.OP.TO'rAL -REQUIRE 72.6 % 75,1 % '74.3 % 171.16 % 10,000 SQ. FT, 1,120,363 SQ.. FT. 240,015 SQ. FT. 880,348 SQ. FT. 352,139 SQ. FT. 70,500 SQ. FT. 73,1l00 SQ. FT. 48,000 SQ. FT. .81,950.SQ. FT. "27~!,:i50 SQ. FT. 290' ~O. 290'-0. ~~. 193 UNrTS . 186 UNITS 159 UNITS. 172' UNITS 710 UiUTS 1,157 . 27.60 UNITS/ACRE 887.5 CARS '. -" ,--~.,.....~", . COMPAcTs . Pl\OVIDED 88 BB 110 o 286 \ '~-OF'.' 'MTAl, ~ .'.' TO'TAL ,- ~REQUIRED PROVIDEO 36.5. % 37.1% 55.2 % . o % 263 263 258 368 1,152 -. :._~,. TOTAL REQMREI . '241 '233 .:199 :2lli ., " -',: .88;a -. _....: ~ 2600 BUILDING DECLARATION OF CONDOMINIUM 2.28 "Unit" means a part of the Condominium Property which is subject to exclusive owner- ship, and except where is specifically excluded, or the context otherwise requires, ,~ shall be deemed to include the Residential Units, the Commercial Unit and the Parking Units. . . . . 17.1 . . . The Commercial Unit may be used for any purpose permitted by applicable law. ~ ~. ~ .~ District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District. 214 So.2d 39 CITY OF MIAMI BEACH, Florida, a municipal corporation, Appellant, v. 100 LINCOLN ROAD, INC. a Florida corporation, Appellee. No. 68-17. Sept. 24, 1968. [1] ". The appellee owns and operates a large apartment building and provides parking space pursuant to a city ordinance. The appellee brought action in the trial court alleging that the city had misinterpreted the legal effect of its zoning ordinance and as a consequence of this misinterpretation had ordered the appellee to 'discontinue using parking areas within building for other than tenants' of apartments within building.' The trial court found that any interpretation of the ordinance requiring use of the appellee's parking space to be limited to the occupants of the appellee's apartment building is unreasonable and invalid. We agree and affirm the judgment. [2] The ordinance in question simply requires builders of apartments to provide a designated number of permanent parking spaces for each family unit. Since zoning laws are in derogation of the common law, as a general rule they are subject to strict construction in favor of the right of a property owner to the unrestricted use of his property. Wright v, De Fatta, 244 La, 251, 152 So.2d 10, 14 (1963). The authorities seem agreed that the purpose of off-street parking requirements is not to provide every tenant with a parking space at all times but rather to alleviate traffic congestion. See School Dist. Of Philadelphia v. Zoning Bd, Of Adjust., 417 Pa. 277,207 A.2d 864, 868 (1965); 1 Yokley, Municipal Corporations, s 245; 58 Mich.L.Rev. 1068, 1071. .--- Supreme Court of Florida, en Bane. 48 So.2d 78 STATE ex reI. TAMPA, FLORIDA, COMPANY OF JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES, NORTH UNIT, Inc. v. CITY OF TAMPA et aI. Oct. 6, 1950. Rehearing Denied Oct. 27,1950. The point for determination is (I) whether or not the relators' application made a substantial showing of compliance with Ordinance 1206-A, as to provision for off-street parking, and (2) in view of the guaranties of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Federal Constitution and the Constitution of the State of Florida, can the city enforce such a requirement as a prerequisite to constructing a place of worship? . . . . ( There is another reason, no doubt the primary one, why the church is not bound by some of the regulations imposed on other institutions. In American life the family is the foundation on which democratic institutions are reared. The church and the school are but auxiliaries to the family. ... . . . . [1] No one knew this better than the Founding Fathers. Hence we say that when the church enters the picture different considerations actuate any and all spheres of regulation. When exposed to the illuminating power of common sense the regulation drawn in question has very little to support it. . . . . "~ [2][3] We therefore conclude that as to appellants the denial of the permit as requested was arbitrary and unreasonable, (I) because the provisions of the ordinance were substantially complied with, and (2) there is no showing that the ordinance had any relation to the public health, morals, safety or welfare. ... -/ enenu~ "oeno ~" ~ ~ on~~ ~ ~r:/)~ (]) ~ ~ ~ r'\ ~ d.- on.- ~ "'O~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ a a.-.S ~ r~ " (]) ,..,.....t:: ro.....t:: ...,...., ~;;...-o-~ ~ gp~ 0 .,~ o..(]) ~.- ;;... on ~ .S 1d .r:; 5' (]) on U ] "'0 :.e "'0 (]) ~ ~ ~ J_ ~ (]) "'O~~O~vd ~ ro - u .- ~ .- ~ (]) (]);;... s ~ 0 ~ o..s "'0 ~ 8.- C-H~ ~ ,.., en 0 - "'0 den: 0 U ~., en ~ ~ ~ . u (]) (]) (]) ~ ~o ...-en;;...u ......en v o~~ ~ ~ . (])., o..U 0(])gpS2~en~ u ~._ (]) $::::l 0 on.- ~ ~ en~ (])~::s ~"'O ~ .~ ro ro "'0 ~ :.g ro ~ ro ~~(]).~ _ den ~C-H .~~(]) ~ ~ "'0 ~ (]) . 0...- ~ o ~~.r:;"'O .~ ~ ~ ~ ro ro ~"'O ono~ 0 ~ 0.. u (]) ~.S ~ en ~ (]) '11;;'" '11 = u (]) ~ .....t:: on ~ (]) (]) ~ ~ (]) ~ ~ ~ ~ (]) 0..- - ~ o 'r;).b ~ S (]) ~ en ~ 0 I ~ 0;9 ~ ., d~ ro .u~~.....t:: ~o..~ . -~~ ;:j 0 o.....t::. I.\J o~ ~._ en .....t::._ "" ~en .en~~"'" ~~~d2(])~~.....t:: O. o~oo-ooo ~ (])._ (]) (]) (])._ u ~ .....t:: - u ~ ~ on- ~ (]) ~ ~ ~ (]) (]) on ~.r:; ~ ~ 0.. 0 ~ > ;::j 0.. ;:j ;:;> ._ < u._ (]) r.n < ~ --../ .-/ . (I.) ...... = ~ "'C = ~ QJ ~ .... ~ u ~ z o .~ "0 ~ -< ~ ~ o ~ ~ -< ~ ~ > ~ c.j..,j .- ...... = .- ~ ~ ~ .... ~ o o == u 00 ~ -< ~ ~ ~ E-I 00 ~ == U E-I 00 ~ ...... - = o U l() ~ "t~~ .- - = -o~ ......~~ .~ ~ N ~~N (I.) QJ · ~z~ ~ .> ......~~ 00 · ~ "'Coo= QJ = ;:: N = ~ ~ ORTHODOX MINYAN OF ELKINS PARK v. CHELTENHAM TOWNSHIP ZONING HEARING BOARD 552 A.2d 772 (Commwlth. Ct. Pa 1989) [2] Appellant presented uncontradicted evidence that its proposed use as an Orthodox synagogue would generate less traffic than a normal religious use by reason of the beliefs of its members that prohibit traveling by automobile on the Sabbath or religious holidays. The Board's conclusion that because 19 parking spaces were required under Section 2304(2)( d), all 19 spaces would be used and would discharge traffic to the intersection in question at the same time is unsubstantiated. r- Appellant's uncontradicted evidence establishes that at most five or six automobiles per day, in addition to the rabbi, would enter or leave Appellant's property. Appellant's entire Minyan consists of only 39 adult members. Most of these members live within six to eight blocks of the property and will walk to services. (N.T. 10/20/86, p. 68, R.r. 36a). An influx of five or six cars per day into a residential neighborhood does not constitute an abnormal traffic pattern that poses a substantial threat to the health and safety of the community. See In Re 0 'Hara 's Appeal, 389 Pa. 35, 131 A.2d 587 (1957). We must conclude that "increase in traffic at an already dangerous intersection" is not a sufficient basis for denying a r special exception when the proposed use actually contributes less traffic than a normal use of the same type. Appeal of Martin; Kern. The order for the trial court is reversed. ,,~ ~"O 00 ~~ Q)~~ bJ) ~ I-. 1""""'1 c: .~ - . G'.o 0 ~ ~ ~ .a ;.... 00 ~ .- ...... ~(!);:j "'C4-.(!) eJ ~ 8.~ 0 (!) 0 ~ ... ...... ~ (!) - ~8o .gr:n"'C ...... rIj . (!) 8 s] $-;~ ~ ... ...... ~ = ;> 1~;:j~00~ ~ 00 ~ u 0 (!)'- " "C "C ......0 ..c:$-;...... .- ...... $-; 0 - " = ~~~01)"""(!)~ ... - ..= 0 o(!)oo~~ ~ ~ .n ~ 8.-.-.n 00 ~ = 0 rIj ......"...s:::= S j "'d .s .- " ~ ~ ...... .- u 00 ~ ... ~ ..c:" (!) ~ "'d (!). - ...... "C ... ...... "u ;> 0 '0 ..c: ...... ... ~ " ......u::: 0 (!)b;....~ -= ~ r- 0= ~ VJ. 0'\ ~~ 0.000 E ~ . ~r- " ~ 0'\ ~ ~ ~ ;:j (!) "'d ~"C ~ l"""'I .- ...... ~ ~ $-; (!) (!) ~M ~ .~ ;> (!) 0'- ~ ~ S ...... " o . rIj M (!) $-; ~ u $-; ~ ~ 0 = ~~ ~ 0...... $-; ~............ ~ ~VJ. - ... ~8~(!)~~oo ~ ~ ~ - (!)" ...s:::= 8.........s:::= (!) ~= ~ 00" ...... 8'- ...... "'d ~O'\ rIj < ~(!)oo 00 <'-= ~ ~ ..- ~ ;:j 0 ~ ~"b VJ. 0 ~ (!) 0 u "0'- ~ $-;'- $-; ~ $-; 0 ~ ~ € u ;> ~ ~'oo ~ ...... ~ .n..- (!) 00...... . - ~ ~ .- 00 0 ;::::l 8'-'- ~ = ;> ~ .~ 8 ~ ~ ~ '"""' .~ ;::::l a t "'d 8 ~..- 0 u u ........- ~ ~~ 0 (!) (!) ~ '-.~ ;::::l ~ 0 U .n ~ ...... ..= eJ (!) U O'"~ ~ " ... ~ 00 [) (!) 4-. (!) ~ (!) - ;::::l8OOO(!)..c:~.n ...... rIj ~ .- 00 ...... 8 ...... ... u 8 ...... ..- .- .- ~ (!) .-.~ ~ (!) $-; ...... co 0 ,,~ $-; (!) (!) uoo(!)(!)o~"- . (!)"'d..c:~~""" - . ..- ~ ...... (!) 0 ..- . ~ o~o.no~ . ~ Proposed Conditions for Conditional Use Approval (1) Entrance to the Property. The entrance to the Synagogue will solely be through the rear access driveway located immediately south of the Property. (2) Entrv Throu!!h Lobbv of 2600 Buildin!! Prohibited. Members of the Synagogue will not enter the Synagogue through the lobby of the 2600 Island Boulevard Building. (3) Svna!!o!!ue Parkin!!. The management of the Synagogue will provide ten (10) parking spaces within the 2600 Island Boulevard Parking Garage for the use of the Synagogue staff, officers, and selected members. (4) Svna!!o!!ue Membership. At least 80% of the total membership of the Synagogue shall be Williams Island residents. At no time shall the membership of the Synagogue exceed 150 families from either within or without Williams Island. (5) Occupancies. Room occupancies shall be governed by the applicable provisions of the Florida Fire Prevention Code and the regulations of the Miami-Dade Fire Rescue Department. At no time shall seating in the Synagogue sanctuary, either permanent or temporary, exceed 210 seats. r- (6) Advertisements for Membership. The Synagogue will conduct no advertising directed towards recruiting new members except for membership drives directed towards Williams Island residents. (7) Hi!!h Holidavs. During the Jewish High Holidays, the Synagogue, in coordination with the Williams Island security staff, will make independent arrangements for increased security at the sole cost and expense of the Synagogue. (8) Events. The Synagogue shall not be utilized for non-religious events or parties such as parties for Bar and Bat Mitzvah, weddings, bris, or other parties and events that are not normally and traditionally considered to be a part of a religious holiday or observance or the Sabbath. Thus, for example, while the Synagogue may be used for a wedding ceremony, the Synagogue may not be used for the wedding party. Likewise, however, as an example, a Sabbath dinner or Kiddush, either before or after Sabbath services and/or a Passover dinner, either before or after a Passover service, shall be considered to be a normal and traditional event that is not a "non- religious event or party". Food deliveries for events at the Synagogue shall only utilize service delivery facilities and approved times for delivery of the 2600 building . in the same manner as deliveries would be permitted for the party room of the 2600 building. (9) Proposed Conditions for Conditional Use Approval Security Camera. The SynagQgue will provide an additional security camera for the Synagogue entrance which will be wired to the existing security station for the 2600 Island Boulevard building, at the sole cost and expense of the Synagogue. ~ (10) Landscapinl!. The Synagogue will supplement the existing landscaped hedge at the south boundary of the 2600 Island Boulevard building, adjacent to the canal. (11) Non-Access to Loadinl! Dock Area. The Synagogue will coordinate the installation, during non-delivery hours, of a partial vehicular gate preventing vehicle access to loading dock area only during "off-hours". (12) Guest Lists for Special Events. The Synagogue will provide guest lists for special events (other than normal and traditional Sabbath or Jewish holiday services, such as events permitted under paragraph 8) to the Williams Island front gate security prior to any such special event. r (13) Svnal!ol!ue Sil!nal!e Prohibited. No signage identifying the Property as a synagogue will be placed on the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building or parking garage. (14) Directional Sil!nal!e Permitted. Directional signage shall be permitted but such signage may only indicate, in a non-religious manner, the location of the Synagogue. (15) Facade of Svnal!ol!ue. The fayade of the Synagogue will not display any religious ornamentation or signage and no stained glass windows shall be visible from the exterior of the Property. (16) Liabilitv Insurance. The Synagogue, at its own cost and expense, will provide a personal injury insurance policy, with the 2600 Island Boulevard Condominium Association as a co-insured, comparable to the insurance coverage provided for the 2600 Island Boulevard building's common areas and party room. (17) Special Events Must Be Hosted bv Williams Island Residents. All special events held at the Synagogue must be hosted by a member of the Synagogue who is also a Williams Island resident. .~ A VENTURA LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Section 31-73(c) (c) General standards of review. In addition to the standards set forth in these LDRs for the particular use, all proposed conditional uses shall meet each of the following standards: (1) The proposed use shall be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; ~ Policy 1,3 of the A ventura Comprehensive Plan specifically provides that, "Community facilities including schools and places of worship shall be allowed on property within a residential or business and office land use designation through the conditional use procedures found in the City's land development regulations," See staff report. (2) The establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed use shall not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, or general welfare; The Williams Island Synagogue has been in continuous operation on Williams Island since 1990 in various different residential buildings and there has been no recognizable detrimental effect on the public health, safety, or general welfare, The fa<;ade of the proposed facility will not distinguish it as a Synagogue. Security will be heightened during the High Holidays, An additional security camera will be installed, Williams Island already has a considerable security detail and numerous security checkpoints. r-. ~ A VENTURA LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Section 31-73( c) (3) The proposed use shall be consistent with the community character of the immediate neighborhood of the proposed use; The synagogue is proposed to be designed in a manner which is completely indistinguishable with the surroun- ding residential community. Over 90% of the members of the synagogue are Williams Island residents and proposed condition would always require membership to be at least 80% Williams Island residents. Expert opinion and analysis indicate that religious places of worship are consistent and compatible with residential communities. r-. (4) Utilities, roadway capacity, drainage, and other necessary public facilities, including police, fire and emergency services, shall exist at the City's adopted levels of service, or will be available concurrent with demand as provided for in the requirements of theses LDRs; The proposed synagogue will not affect the City's adopted levels of service for public facilities. See staff report. (5) Adequate measures exist or shall be taken to provide ingress and egress to the proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets; .~ Ingress and egress to the proposed synagogue will be through an entrance which is over 1000 feet from the entrance to the 2600 Building. Due to the fact that this is an Orthodox synagogue, the vehicular traffic generated by the proposed use will be minimal. Pedestrian traffic has been provided for through connecting sidewalk system and protected pedestrian lane throughout the Island and to the Shul. A VENTURA LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS Section 31-73( c) (6) The establishment of the conditional use shall not impede the development of surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district; and ~ , The proposed synagogue will not impede the development of surrounding properties for their permitted residential uses. The existing synagogue, in existence for over 13 years, has not done so and there is no rational reason to believe that moving the synagogue will have a contrary impact. The properties immediately adjacent to the 2600 Building are fully developed and almost all of Williams Island is fully developed. The development of the few vacant areas left cannot conceivably be impeded by the proposed synagogue. Expert opinion and analysis has concluded that the existence of a synagogue will not adversely impact property values on Williams Island or the ability to develop the remaining lots on Williams Island. (7) The design of the proposed use shall minimize adverse effects, including visual impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent property through the use of building orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria. ~ The proposed synagogue will be located within the Parking Garage structure of the 2600 Building and nothing on the outside of the structure will identify it as the location of a synagogue. The edge of the walkway along the Ojus Canal will be landscaped to a greater degree, even though this area is the only portion of Williams Island, at present, that already has landscaping protection from adjacent waters. Greenberg Traurig Memorandum To David Wolpin From Clifford A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Re Williams Island: Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act ("RLUIP A" or "the Act") and Parking Considerations File No, 050305.026100 ~ The denial by a municipality of a religious institution's conditional use approval for reasons of inadequate parking constitutes a violation ofRLUIPA. The plain text ofRLUIPA and its legislative history show that the denial of the ability to use land for religious purposes on the grounds of increased traffic or inadequate parking are precisely the kind of land use decisions RLUIPA was enacted to prevent. In other words, such a decision violates the Act's prohibition against the imposition of any "substantial burden" on a person's "religious exercise." An action by local government imposing a "substantial burden" under the Act may still be permissible if the action is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest and if the methodology employed by the local government is the least restrictive means of furthering the compelling interest. Reported court decisions construing RLUIP A, however, make perfectly clear that municipal concerns of aesthetics, increased traffic, and particularly parking considerations, have never risen to the level of legitimate "compelling governmental interests" under the Act sufficient to insulate a municipality from a claim under RLUIP A. I. Denying the Conditional Use of Property for Religious Purposes on the Grounds of Parking Violates the Plain Text ofthe RLUlPA Statute. An examination of the text of the Act reveals that a municipality's denial of conditional use approval violates the provisions of RLUIP A. The pertinent provisions of RLUIP A provide: SEe. 2. PROTECTION OF LAND USE AS RELIGIOUS EXERCISE. (a) SUBSTANTIAL BURDENS- ~ (1) GENERAL RULE- No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution, unless the government To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 2 demonstrates that imposition of the burden on that person, assembly, or institution-- (A) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (B) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest. 42 D.S.C. S 2000cc(a)(I)(A-B) (emphasis added). The above "general rule" prohibiting a substantial burden on religious exercise applies, according to the Act, in three enumerated situations, as follows: (A) the substantial burden is imposed in a program or activity that receives Federal financial assistance, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; (B) the substantial burden affects, or removal of that substantial burden would affect, commerce with foreign nations, among the several States, or with Indian tribes, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; or (C) the substantial burden is imposed in the implementation of a land use regulation or system of land use regulations, under which a government makes, or has in place formal or informal procedures or practices that permit the government to make, individualized assessments of the proposed uses for the property involved. 42 D.S.C. S 2000cc(a)(2)(A-C) (emphasis added). The denial of conditional use approval to a church or synagogue has been held to be "precisely the type of "individualized assessment" contemplated by subsection (C)." Elsinore Christian Center v. City of Lake Elsinore, 270 F. Supp. 2d 1163, 1166 (C.D. Cal. 2003). II. The Act's Legislative History Shows That Denial of Conditional Use Based Upon Parking Concerns Is One ofthe Exact Situations the Act Was Designed to Prevent. The legislative history and Congressional Record associated with the Act explain that the Act is intended to prohibit the denial of religious exercise on grounds of general concerns for parking or traffic, as is revealed in the following comments from Senator Hatch: .~ NEED FOR LEGISLATION To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 3 Land Use. The right to assemble for worship is at the very core of the free exercise of religion. Churches and synagogues cannot function without a physical space adequate to their needs and consistent with their theological requirements. The right to build, buy, or rent such a space is an indispensable adjunct ofthe core First Amendment right to assemble for religious purposes. The hearing record compiled massive evidence that this right is frequently violated. Churches in general, and new, small, or unfamiliar churches in particular, are frequently discriminated against on the face of zoning codes and also in the highly individualized and discretionary processes of land use regulation. Zoning codes frequently exclude churches in places where they permit theaters, meeting halls, and other places where large groups of people assemble for secular purposes. Or the codes permit churches only with individualized permission from the zoning board, and zoning boards use that authority in discriminatory ways. Sometimes, zoning board members or neighborhood residents explicitly offer race or religion as the reason to exclude a proposed church, especially in cases of black churches and Jewish shuls and synagogues. More often, discrimination lurks behind such vague and universally applicable reasons as traffic, aesthetics, or "not consistent with the city's land use plan." Churches have been excluded from residential zones because they generate too much traffic, and from commercial zones because they don't generate enough traffic. Churches have been denied the right to meet in rented storefronts, in abandoned schools, in converted funeral homes, theaters, and skating rinks-in all sorts of buildings that were permitted when they generated traffic for secular purposes. 164 Congo Rec. S7774-01 at S7774---5 (Comments of Senator Hatch, July 27, 2000) (emphasis added). A review of the legislative history and Congressional Record associated with the Act dispels any doubt whatsoever as to the Acts applicability to the present situation. In fact, the Honorable Henry Hyde of Illinois argued in support of the Act by pointing to a case arising in Los Angeles with facts closely analogous to the present situation: LOS ANGELES, CA-2/25/2000 /- Orthodox Jews must walk to services on the Sabbath because their religion does not permit them to use cars. Etz Chaim is a congregation of elderly and disabled Orthodox Jews in the Hancock Park area of Los Angeles who have trouble To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 4 walking distances as short as half a mile. The members of Etz Chaim sought a conditional use permit to establish a synagogue in Hancock Park, an area zoned for single-family dwellings, because their disabilities prevent them from walking to any of the synagogues located in a nearby commercial zone. The Hancock Park Homeowners Association complained that this arrangement would hurt property values, and the permit was denied. Based on the testimony of a neighbor who argued that anyone "should" be able to walk to synagogues in the commercial zone, the state court of appeal found that alternative locations for prayer are available to Etz Chaim. In February, The Washington Times reported that, "Congregation Etz Chaim-a home-based synagogue that served many elderly and disabled members-was closed under a zoning law that leading city officials refused to apply equally to close a gay sex club in a residential area." ~ Sources: Electronic Letter from Susan S. Azad, Attorney for Plaintiffs Etz Chaim, et. aI., to Julie E. Khoury, Paralegal, Christian Legal Society (Aug. 15, 2000) (on file with Christian Legal Society). Michelle Malkin, No prayer on zoning regulation, The Washington Times, February 25, 2000. Order and Memorandum Opinion, Congregation Etz Chaim v. City of Los Angeles, No. CV 97- 5042 HLH(Ex) (C.D. Cal. June I, 1998). 164 Congo Rec. E1564-01 at EI566 (Comments of Senator Hyde, September 21, 2000) (emphasis added). III. Recent Federal Court Decisions Construing RLUlPA Hold That Parking Considerations Have Never Constituted a "Compelling Governmental Interest" Sufficient to Justify Denial of the Use of Property for Religious Purposes. Since RLUIPA is a relatively new enactment, there is a limited number of reported decisions construing its provisions. It has been fully established by reported precedent, however, that parking considerations can never constitute a "compelling interest" sufficient to support a municipality's denial of the ability to use land for a religious use. In Westchester Day School V. Village of Mamaroneck, -- F. Supp. 2d --, 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 5, 2003), the Court held that parking concerns did not rise to the level of a compelling governmental interest sufficient to constitute a defense to a claim under RLUIP A, according to the following reasoning: A prima facie case that RLUIP A has been violated having been established, the burden now shifts to defendants to demonstrate that the land use regulation To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 5 furthers a compelling government interest and that the land use regulation is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling interest. 42 U.S.C. & 2000c(a)(1 )(AHB). At the outset, the Court notes the extreme difficulty in carrying this burden. See Cottonwood Christian Or.. 218 F.Suoo.2d at 1227-28 (quoting Citv of Boerne. 521 u.s. at 534. 117 S.Ct. 2157 (recognizing the difficulty for local governments in carrying their burden under RLUIP A, because requiring the government "to demonstrate a compelling interest and show that it has adopted the least restrictive means of achieving that interest is the most demanding test known to constitutional law.")). ..- We turn now to the two major concerns raised by defendants in their opposing papers as reasons for denying WDS's Application--traffic and parking. With respect to the issue of traffic intensity, the Court extensively discussed this issue in its prior Order, and concluded that it was not a sufficient reason for the ZBA's reversal of its negative declaration of environmental impact. See Westchester Dav School. 236 F.Suoo.2d at 356-58. We are unpersuaded by the opinions of additional experts relied on by defendants (since the ZBA's initial study of the potential adverse effects on traffic) which call into question the validity of WDS's traffic study. In any event, traffic concerns have never been deemed compelling government interests. See Transportation Alternatives. Inc. v. Citv of New York. 218 F.Suoo.2d 423. 438 (S.D.N.Y.2002) (citing Whitton V. Citv of Gladstone. 54 F.3d 1400. 1408 (8th Cir.1995) (holding that a municipality's asserted interests in traffic safety and aesthetics, while significant, have never been found compelling)); Love Church v. Citv of Evanston. 671 F.Suoo. 515. 519 (N.D.IlI.1987) ("While traffic concerns are legitimate, we could hardly call them compelling."). We find defendants' second concern, parking, even less compelling. Defendants' denial of the Application based on an insufficient number of parking spaces is severely undermined by the joint request of both the Westchester County Planning Board and by the ZBA to decrease the number of parking spaces provided for in the Application. Moreover, we find nothing to suggest that the lack of parking spaces provided in plaintiffs Application will result in a direct and immediate threat to public health, safety or welfare. See Wisconsin. v. Yoder. 406 U.s. 205. 215. 92 S.Ct. 1526. 32 L.Ed.2d 15 (1972); Sherbert. 374 U.S. at 406.83 S.C!. 1790. Westchester Day School v. Village of Mamaroneck, -- F. Supp. 2d --, 2003 WL 22110445 at *10 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 5,2003) (footnotes and record citations omitted; emphasis added). The municipality in Elsinore Christian Center v. City of Lake Elsinore, 270 F. Supp. 2d 1163 (C.D. Cal. 2003) tried to point to several so-called "compelling governmental interests" in To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 6 defense of a RLUIPA claim, including "the possible inadequacy of on-site parking for the Church's proposed use, and potential adverse consequences on the parking needs of adjacent users." Elsinore, 270 F. Supp. 2d at 1172. The Court found that the only concern raised by the City that could possibly constitute a compelling interest was "curbing urban blight." Elisinore, 270 F. Supp. 2d at 1173. The Elsinore Court held that the City's denial of a church's conditional use permit was not a least restrictive means of curbing urban blight, and was in fact the "most burdensome" action that could be taken, resulting in an unlawful burden on the Church's right to enjoy "religious exercise" under RLUIP A. While one court has found that municipal concerns for traffic safety could constitute a compelling governmental interest, it rejected the notion that the outright denial of the religious use was the least restrictive means of furthering the compelling interest, and held that the municipality had failed to satisfy the Act's high burden of showing that no other form of regulation could further the governmental interest, as follows: ..-- Although the Court finds that defendants have articulated a compelling state interest, the inquiry does not end there. Defendants must next demonstrate that the governmental action taken in "furtherance of [the] compelling interest" is by the "least restrictive means." 42 U.S.C. & 2000cc(a)(!). That is, defendants must show that there are "no other alternative forms ofregulation" which would fulfill the state interest. Sherbert v. Verner. 374 U.S. 398, 407, 83 S.C!. 1790, 1796, 10 L.Ed.2d 965 (! 963), Defendants have failed to make this showing. The Court finds no evidence on the record that the issuance of the cease and desist order based on the Commission's opinion was the "least restrictive means" of protecting the health and safety of their community. Defendants' primary concern with plaintiffs' activities was the increased level of traffic on the street, and the safety issues that are inherent in an increased volume of traffic. However, defendants' actions did not address the amount of traffic generated by the participants of the prayer group meetings. Rather, the Commission's opinion speaks entirely in terms of the number of people allowed to be present in plaintiffs' home on Sunday afternoons. For example, if twenty-five non-family members were in attendance at a particular prayer group meeting and each person drove a separate vehicle, in theory there could be twenty-five cars parked in the cul-de-sac and in plaintiffs' driveway, the same number identified by the Commission as a problem, and in excess of the number of cars observed by the ZEO on three inspections of the activity. On the other hand, fifty participants could conceivably arrive at the prayer meetings in ten or fewer vehicles. To the extent cul-de-sac parking was deemed a problem, the ZEO's decision to bar off- street parking in the Murphy's driveway and rear yard seems inconsistent with the To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 7 expressed concerns of the neighbors. No justification was voiced at the hearing to support any limitations on off-street parking. * * * * In passing RLUIP A, Congress required local governments to be sensitive to the values of religious freedom and expression. It directed that substantial burdens be placed on the exercise of religion only to the extent necessary to accomplish compelling governmental interests. Even absent a federal statute, one would expect that, before banning an ongoing private religious gathering, public officials in a free and tolerant society would enter into a dialogue with the participants to determine if the legitimate safety concerns of the neighbors could be voluntarily allayed. Particularly where the participants are enjoined by religious teachings to "do unto others" as they would have done unto them, it is not unreasonable to expect the parties to be able to agree on means of reducing the impact of weekly prayer meetings on this small cul-de-sac without undermining the benefit that participants seek to derive from the practice of their faith. Murphy v. Zoning Commission of the Town of New Milford, 148 F. Supp. 2d 173, 189-190 (D. Conn. 2001). In the context of a challenge to a City's regulation of signage in under First Amendment and free speech considerations, it has been held that "a municipality's asserted interests in traffic safety and aesthetics, while significant, have never been held to be compelling." Transportation Alternatives, Inc. v. City of New York, 218 F. Supp. 2d 423, 438 (S.D.N.Y. 2002) (quoting Whitton v. City of Gladstone, 54 F. 3d 1400, 1408 (8th Cir. 1995)). IV. Non-RLUIPA Cases Show that Parking Concerns Are Insufficient Grounds Upon Which to Deny Conditional Use, In church and synagogue land use cases that predate or otherwise do not implicate the RLUIPA legislation, Courts have repeatedly reversed lower courts and local governments that have denied conditional religious use requested by churches and synagogues. In doing so, the courts have relied upon the historical public policy favoring the placement of churches and synagogues in residential settings, and have imposed high legal burdens upon local governments to justify any impairment of religious use. A case that pre-dates RLUIPA and worked to fuel the RLUIPA legislation is Orthodox Minyan of Elkins Park v. Cheltenham Township Zoning Hearing Board, 552 A.2d 772 To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 8 (Comwlth. Ct. Pa. 1989). In Elkins Park, the court rejected a municipality's denial of a special exception to use certain property as synagogue on traffic grounds, as follows: Appellant presented uncontradicted evidence that its proposed use as an Orthodox synagogue would generate less traffic than a normal religious use by reason of the beliefs of its members that prohibit traveling by automobile on the Sabbath or religious holidays. The Board's conclusion that because 19 parking spaces were required under Section 2304(2)(d), all 19 spaces would be used and would discharge traffic to the intersection in question at the same time is unsubstantiated. .~ Appellant's uncontradicted evidence establishes that at most five or six automobiles per day, in addition to the rabbi, would enter or leave Appellant's property. Appellant's entire Minyan consists of only 39 adult members. Most of these members live within six to eight blocks of the property and will walk to services. An influx of five or six cars per day into a residential neighborhood does not constitute an abnormal traffic pattern that poses a substantial threat to the health and safety of the community. We must conclude that "increase in traffic at an already dangerous intersection" is not a sufficient basis for denying a special exception when the proposed use actually contributes less traffic than a normal use of the same type. The order of the trial court is reversed. Elkins Park, 552 A.2d at 774 (citations omitted; emphasis in original). As recited above, central to the Elkins Park Court's reasoning was the fact that most of the synagogue's members "are local residents who walk to services." Id. In a case where a building permit had been refused on the ground that the space shown to be available for off-street parking was inadequate, the Florida Supreme Court held that the stated reason for denial was insufficient under the law, explaining: The contention that people congregating for religious purposes cause such congestion as to create a traffic hazard has very little in substance to support it. Religious services are normally for brief periods two or three days in the week and this at hours when traffic is lightest--early in the morning, early in the evening and at 10:00 and 11 :00 on Sundays. Many churches are like this one, in residential areas, where traffic is not heavy and where there are side streets and other facilities for parking. The church involved here is a small church which is shown to have ample offstreet parking space for all ordinary purposes. It would To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 9 rarely if ever require parking space on the street in front of the church. Even if rare occasions should require parking a few cars on the streets we cannot say that a traffic hazard would be created. This is certainly a case in which the balance of convenience rule as to range in judgment might be applied. * * * * There is another reason. no doubt the primary one. why the church is not bound by some of the regulations imposed on other institutions. In American life the family is the foundation on which democratic institutions are reared. The church and the school are but auxiliaries to the family. * * * * No one knew this better than the Founding Fathers. Hence we say that when the church enters the picture different considerations actuate any and all spheres of regulation. ~ State. ex. rei. Tampa. Company of Jehovah's Witnesses v. City of Tampa, 45 So. 2d 78, 79 (Fla. 1950) (emphasis added). Similar historical public policy considerations strongly favoring church or synagogue uses were also cited in an opinion of the Supreme Court of Indiana: It is no doubt true that automobile traffic often chokes the streets and endangers both the general and the traveling public. However, it is rarely, if ever, that people entering or leaving a church cause or contribute to traffic accidents. It would seem reasonable to assume that if regulation is necessary in the interest of the safety, convenience and welfare of the general public, that should be regulated which has a direct effect upon such general welfare. This can be, and is, done generally by traffic police, signs and other reasonable regulations imposed alike upon all persons using the streets in the vicinity of churches, without undue interference with the right of worship and free assembly. When, under the facts in this case, the welfare and safety of the people in the neighborhood is placed in the scales of justice on one side. and the right to freedom of worship and assembly is placed on the other. the balance weighs heavily on the side guaranteeing the right to peaceful assembly and to worship God according to the dictates of conscience. regardless of faith or creed. Board of Zoning Appeals of Decatur v. Decatur. Indiana Co. of Jehovah's Witnesses, 117 N.E. 2d 115, 119-120 (Ind. I 954)(emphasis added). To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 10 After an application was submitted by a synagogue for "church uses" in Cleveland, Ohio, the City adopted an ordinance as an emergency measure to change the zoning ordinance with respect to auto parking which would require one space for each four seats. In rejecting the City's denial of the application, the reviewing court emphasized the importance of the synagogue near the congregation's residences: Because they adhere to this faith their places of worship must be within walking distance of their homes. The site on which relator desires to build is within walking distance of part ofthe members of the relator organization. Young Israel Organization of Cleveland v. Dworkin, Members of the South Euclid Zoning Appeals Board, 133 N.E. 2d 174, 176 (Cl. App. Ohio 1956). The Young Israel Court specifically rejected the municipality's denial of the application based upon traffic considerations as "without substance in fact," and again emphasized the importance of locating the synagogue within a residential area and within walking distance: /- Of all nonresidential uses, a small suburban church would seem to present a minimum of objections. All of the same considerations which have been urged against permitting this church in a residential neighborhood, were present in a far greater degree in the case of a parochial school or an orphans' home, and yet they were held not to bear a sufficiently substantial relation to the public health, safety, morals or general welfare to warrant the exclusion of these institutions. It must therefore be concluded that respondents' supporting reasons for the attempted exclusion ofthe church cannot be justified on the score ofthe protection of public health and safety. Fully to accomplish its great religious and social function, the church should be integrated into the home life of the community which it serves. Churches in fitting surroundings are an inspiration to their members and to the general public. If located in the residential district--space, perspective, greenswards and trees aid in setting off the beauty of the building and thereby increasing its inspiration. To require that churches be banished to the business district, crowded alongside filling stations and grocery stores, is clearly not to be justified on the score of promoting the general welfare. We do not believe it is a proper function of government to interfere in the name of the public to exclude churches from residential districts for the purpose of securing to adj acent landowners the benefits of exclusive residential restrictions. To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page II The place of the church is to be found in that part of the community where the people live. It is to be associated with the home, its influence is concerned with family life. It is an institution to which we look for leadership in furtherance of the brotherhood of man, in molding the moral progress of our children and sustaining and giving strength to purity of our family life. To hold that a church is detrimental to the welfare of the people is in direct contradiction of historical truths and evidences a failure to recognize basic fundamentals of a democratic society. Young Israel Organization of Cleveland v. Dworkin, Members of the South Euclid Zoning Appeals Board, 133 N.E. 2d 174, 182-183 (Ct. App. Ohio 1956)(citations and internal quotations omitted, emphasis added). Finally, the Young Israel Court held that "the action of the respondent city officials in refusing to issue a special permit for temple or congregational purposes under the administrative provisions of the ordinance, constitutes an abuse of discretion which is also violative of relator's constitutional rights." Id. at 183. The importance of placing synagogues near the residences of the congregation was also noted in the context of In the context a case brought under the Massachusetts version of RLUIP A called the "Dover Amendment," as follows: It is of some note, as well, that proximity to their houses of worship is for some groups a significant component of their religious practice. Orthodox Jews, for example, believe they are prohibited by the Torah, the Jewish Bible, from using automobiles on their Sabbath. They therefore must live within walking distance of a synagogue. Boyajian v. Gatzunis, 212 F.3d I, 10 (1st Cir. 2000). Relying upon the historical and compelling public policy interests of placing churches and synagogues in residential areas, several other courts have reversed local governments' decisions to deny the religious use of land for reasons of insufficient parking or traffic generation. E.g., State, ex. rei. Wenatchee Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses v. City of Wenatchee, 312 P.2d 195, 198-99 (Wash. 1957); Diocese of Rchester v. Planning Board of Town of Brighton, 136 N.E. 2d 827, 861-62 (Ct. App. N.Y. 1956); Congregation Committee, North Fort Worth Congregation, Jehovah's Witnesses v. City Council of Hea/tom City, 287 S.W. 2d 700,704 (Ct. App. Tex. 1956). In non-religious contexts, objections by local residents to conditional use based upon fears as to increased traffic has never constituted substantial competent evidence required for a local government to deny conditional use. E.g., Flowers Baking Co. v. City of Melbourne, 537 To Cliff A. Schulman Date November 4, 2003 Page 12 So. 2d 1040, 1041 (Fla. 5th DCA 1989). For example, in Debes v. City of Key West, 690 So. 2d 700, 701 (Fla. 3d DCA 1997), the city commission denied rezoning based upon general concerns about increased traffic that were not based upon any code-based specific criteria: Because it is virtually self-evident that, by its very nature, all commercial uses create "more traffic" than non-commercial ones, it is equally obvious that local government cannot justify a denial of a particular commercial use on this ground. To hold otherwise would mean, as it apparently did in proceedings before the Commission, that the protectable rights of any owner may be arbitrarily destroyed. This is not, and we will not let it be, the law. Debes, 690 So. 2d at 701-702. Finally, general comments about increased traffic or lack of parking have never constituted substantial competent evidence. E.g., Debes, supra.; Equity One Olive, Inc. v. Metropolitan Dade County, 7 Fla. Law Weekly Supp. 712a (Fla. 11th Cir. Ct. August 9, 2000) (holding that no competent substantial evidence supported denial of variance where "Commissioner Souto commented at length on the record in opposition to the variance. . . ." stating that "to complicate things even worse, the traffic that you're going to bring to 67th Avenue, which is a two lane road, I think it's going to be tremendous."), cert. denied, Miami- Dade v. Equity One Olive, Inc., 778 So. 2d 292 (Fla. 3d DCA 2001). \\MIA.SRVOl ISA V AGEP\1516153vOl IIX8JP01_,00C\11/3/03\OSOJ5,026100 , ~ r- ) ) 1- MICHAEL Y. CANNON. MAl. SRA. AS A, CRE QUALIFICATIONS EDUCATION: Majored in Business Administration, University of Miami Attended and/or passed the following courses/seminars accredited by The Appraisal Institute (AI); The American Society of Appraisers (ASA); the American Arbitration Association (AAA); the Urban Land Institute (ULI); and the Counselors of Real Estate (CRE): Principles & Techniques of Real Estate, University of Miami; 1960 SREA Symposiums; 1985/86/88/90 SREA Prof. Practices Seminar; 12/89 Legislative Update; 8/91 Real Estate Law for Appraisers; 6/91 #ACE1034/Reviewing Appraisals; 9/91 Americans with Disabilities Act; 7/92 Standards of Prof Practice, Part A -7/92 AppraisallTax, General; 10/95 Appraisal Institute Symposium; 9/96 Leases, Analysis; 6/97 Construction Industry Arbitrator Training Program; 10/97 Standards of Prof. Practice, Part C-6/99 ULI, Latin America Opportunities in Real Estate InvestmenVDevelopment; 5/00 Marketability Discounts; 7/00 AM, Arbitrator II Workshop - Advanced Case Management; 5/01 CRE, AOR Program; 6/02 AAA, Advanced Mediator Skills Training; 7/02 PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS AWARDING DESIGNATIONS: AIREAlCourse I, II, liB; 1961-1963 SRENAIREA Mortgage Equity & Market Analysis Seminars; 1980-85 Appraisal Theory Review; 1/91 Landfills & Their Effect Upon Value; 8/91 RTC Affordable Housing Disposition; 8/91 #ACE1066/Practical Approaches to Appraising Troubled Properties; 2/92 Rates, Ratios & Reasonableness; 7/92 Analysis, Troubled Properties; 4/96 Litigation Skills for the Appraiser; 9/96 Appraisal, Guidelines; 6/97 Non-Conforming Uses; 1/98 USPAP Core Law; 10/98 Fundamentals of Arbitration Process; 9/99 Business Valuation/Discounts & Premiums; The IRS and FLPs; 7/00 Real Estate Capital Markets (Part 2); 7/00 AI, State of the Profession; 5/01 AI, Summarizing the Ad Valorem Tax Assessment Process in Florida; 2/02 American Arbitration Association (AAA) Appointed to the Panel of Arbitrators R41b and R41c Seminars (FHLBB); 1985/86 SREA Course 301 - Special Application of Appraisal Analysis; 1983 Course #ACE754/Discounted Cash Flow; 2/91 Subdivision Analysis; 8/91 FairValueM'hat it is & How to Estimate; 8/91 #ACE1090/Usefullnformation in Appraising Commercial Property; 6/92 AM, Advanced Arbitrator Training; 7/94 Appraisal, General & Law, Legislation; 4/96 Appraisal, Other Property Types; 10/96 Local RE Markets & Due Diligence; 9/97 BOMA International Conference; 6/98 USPAP Standard Three Review; 10/98 Analyzing Income Producing Prop; 5/00 Machinery & Technical Specialties; Leasing Industry Practices and IOWA Curves; 7/00 Real Property & Easement Valuation; 7100 International Conf. on Assessment Admin.; 9/01 AI, Role of Real Estate Appraisers in Bankruptcy Proceedings; 4/02 American Societv of Appraisers ASA (Accredited Senior Appraiser) - Member 10 #8888 - Accredited through 6/1/07 Appraisal Institute MAl Member #8734; Effect. 1/1/91 SRA Member (Senior Residential Appraiser); Effect. 9/1/66 The "Appraisal Institute" offers a voluntary program of continuing education for its SRA and MAl members. Designated members who qualify under this program are certified for a period of five years. am currently certified under this program through 12/31/04. Counselors of Real Estate CRE Member - Cert. #1058- Effect. 11/1/86; appointed neutral on the arbitration panel Society of MortQaQe Consultants of the National Association of Mortgage Brokers SMC (Senior Mortgage Consultant) - Effect. 10/28/78 , , - 1 - MICHAEL V, CANNON. MAl, SRA. ASA, CRE QUALIFICATIONS (Continued) PROFESSIONAL OFFICES HELD: In the Appraisal Institute (AI) Greater Miami Chapter #71- OFFICES & COMMITTEES 1966-71-73 Board of Directors;1970-71 President ;1974-76 Education Committee National Offices & Committees 1968 Member. Youno Men's Council 1974-78 International Market Develooment 1974-77 Chaoter Services 1977 Education Committee 1977-78 National License Review 1978 Chairman, National License Review 1979 Chairman, Bv-Laws Committee 1979-81 SREA Foundation 1975 Education Committee, Mortgage 1975-81 Governor of District 13, representing Florida & Bankers Association of Greater Miami Puerto Rica Members 1980 Chairman, Editorial Advisorv Board 1981 Chairman, 19811nter'l. Conference Committee 1986-90 SREA Admissions Committee 1987-88 SREA State Licensinn Liaison Comm and Trustee 1990 SocietvRTC Task Farce Member 1991&95 AI National Svmnosium Committee 1991 AI Region X Committee 1991-94 Chairman/Member, AI Nat'l. Admissions Appeal Board 1994-96 Member, AI Regional Ethics & 1998-02 Member, AI National Experience Review Comm. Counselina Panel 2002-04 Member, Aooraisal Journal Editorial Board ( MEMBER OF OTHER PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS: American Real Estate & Urban Economics Association (AREUEA) National Association of Corporate Real Estate Executives (NACORE) National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) Building Association of South Florida (BASF): Board of Directors (Life Director) - 1972 Executive Committee - 1974179 Vice President - 1975/80 Urban Land Institute (ULI): Full Member since 1977 Executive Committee Member of the Southeast District Council I , Beacon Council - Member of Economic Roundtable Forum International Council of Shopping Centers Member - 1992 International Association of Assessing Officers (IAAO)-Associate Member-1993 The Counselors of Real Estate - 2003 Committee Member: Alternative Dispute Resolution Committee Business Issues Subcommittee CRE Consulting Corps Steering Committee Education Committee Real Estate Issues Editorial Board L -2- TEACHING OR LECTURING: LICENSES: EXPERIENCE: ,--- MICHAEL Y. CANNON. MAl. SRA. ASA. CRE QUALIFICATIONS (Continued) Adjunct Instructor - University of Miami, Finance Department, Real Estate Appraisal and Florida International University, Market Analysis - 1978-1981 Instructor - Florida International University - Florida Real Estate Commission Continuing Education/R.E. Broker Recertification -1990, 92, 94, 96, 98, 2000 Lecturer at Law - University of Miami School of Law - Valuation Issues Relating to Ad Valorem Assessments & Federal/County/Municipal Tax issues relating to real property interests and business valuations - 3/94 Lecturer/Graduate Program in Estate Planning - University of Miami School of Law 1995, 1996, 1997 and 1998 Ad Valorem Assessment Issues -IMO State Association Conferences -1994-1998 Speaker at the IMO's 67'h Annual International Conference on Assessment Administration - "The Role of the Appraiser/Assessor in Ad Valorem Assessment Disputes - ValueNaluation Theories" - 9101 State of Florida Real Estate Broker (1961), Lic. #0182553 (exp. 3/31/2004) State of Florida Certified General Appraiser, Lic. #RZ684 (exp.11/30/2004) Managing Director of Integra Realty Resources - South Florida [formerly known as Appraisal and Real Estate Economics Associates. Inc.lAREEA). On August 1,1999, the firm became part of Integra Realty Resources, a national real estate valuation and consulting firm with over 50 regional offices located in 30 states. [visit our website at www.irr.com] PresidentlAREEA, Inc., a real estate brokerage company established in 1973 Vice PresidentlAREEA Assessment Consultants. Inc., 1991 to Present PresidentlAREEA Investment Advisorv & Manaoement Services. Inc. IAIAMSl Formerly served as investment advisor and asset manager to a foreign entity which owned several million square feet of commercial real estate located throughout the United States. AIAMS currently provides real estate advisory and consulting services. PresidentlChairman of the Board/AREEA Manaoement Companv, a condominium association management company that managed over 15,000 units in S. Florida. The company merged with G.D.G. Services, Inc. in 1984. Former Vice President and Chief Loan Officer of a major South Florida lending institution from 1967-1973. Staff Appraiser and Construction Loan Inspector with National Appraisal & Realtv Manaoement Corporation, 1960-1967 Real Estate Tax Assessor, Dade Countv Tax Assessor's Office, 1957-1960 -3- .- r- , \ /- l MICHAEL Y. CANNON, MAl. SRA. ASA. CRE QUALIFICATIONS (Continued) EXPERIENCE: (cont'd,) Has performed various advisory and consulting services including Market/Marketability Studies, Feasibility Studies, Due Diligence, and Valuation Analyses of all types of real estate and various types of businesses in connection with Acquisition, Financing, Disposition, Liquidation and Dispute Resolution. Has been retained in Oversight and Advisory capacity on behalf of investors and lenders relating to the development, asset and property management of residential and commercial properties located primarily in South Florida and the Caribbean, and in several instances, throughout the United States. Has extensive experience 1n Arbitration/Mediation and other alternative Dispute Resolution matters. Has supervised and administered the marketing and sales of several condominium conversions; the acquisition, renovation, and development of office buildings, shopping centers, and rental apartments. Has been retained to analyze various real estate and business investments, and provide consulting and/or expert opinions relating to equities, ownership interests, Ad Valorem Assessments, and forensic valuation analysis and damages relating to litigation and Eminent Domain matters. Has Aooeared as an Exoert Witness In: Circuit Courts of Miami-Dade, Broward, Lee, Charlotte, Palm Beach, and Indian River Counties U.S. District Court for the Northern and Southern District of Florida U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Florida U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Connecticut U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division Mr. Cannon currently authors a weekly real estate column featured in the Miami Herald. Articles, quotes and analyses have been published in local, state, national, and international media. Mr. Cannon has been a speakerllecturer before local, state and national meetings and conventions covering topics on all facets of real estate. Has testified before U.S. Senate Banking Committee in Washington D.C. and the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC) Oversight Board regionally. Authored a monogram paper entitled "Rea/ Estate Market Analysis in the Valuation Process" published by the Appraisal Institute in their research publication "Technical Report', 1993. Authored paper entitled "The Role of the Real Estate Appraiser and Assessor in Valuing Real Property for Ad Valorem Assessment Purposes - ValueNaluation Theories', 2001. Publisher of the "AREEA Report for South Florida~ covering South Florida's real estate market trends. AWARDS/HONORS: Assoc. Realtor ofthe Year Award, Hialeah-Miami Springs Board of Realtors .1966 Inducted in the Hall of Fame of the Builders Association of South Florida - 2/28/89 Featured in 1999 Who's Who in International Business in Miami and South Florida, a publication of World City Business, the local newspaper of international business. Regional "TOBY" Award by (BOMA), Building Owner's and Manager's Association, for the "Best Managed and Renovated Office Building in the Midwest Region" - 1997 Awarded the "Best Maintained Building" for five (5) years by the City of Boca Raton - 1993 Practicing Real Estate Analysis, Valuation, Consulting and Finance for the past forty (40) years, Rev. 03/03 -4- J ~, ,XPERIENCE: PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES: ~ EDUCATION: QUALIFIED AS EXPERT WITNESS: ,- PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF MICHAEL y, CANNON, MAl, SRA, ASA, CRE Managing Director of Integra Realty Resources - South Florida, formerly known as Appraisal and Real Estate Economics Associates, Inc.lAREEA, which was established in 1973. Specializes in real estate and business counseling and analysis. Performs market/marketability and feasibility studies; investment analysis; partial interest appraisals relating to real estate developments and business. Consultant to various government agencies on real estate matters. President of AREEA Investment Advisory and Management Services, Inc., which provides advisory services relating to asset, portfolio, property management/leasing and administration; and is engaged in advising lease structures and negotiations of commercial leases for landlords and tenants. AREEA Assessment Consultants performs Ad Valorem Tax Anneals. Member: Appraisal Institute [AI] - (MAl No. 8734); Past Chapter President, Board of Directors, Member/Chairman of several committees Senior Residential Appraiser (SRA) Counselors of Real Estate (CRE Cert. No. 1058) Society of Mortgage Consultants of the National Association of Mortgage Brokers (SMC) American Society of Appraisers (ASA No. 008888) Founding Member of the National Association of Corporate Real Estate Executives (NACORE) National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) Builder's Association of S. Florida (BAS F); Life Directors, Hall of Fame Member, and Past Vice President Urban Land Institute (ULI); Exec. Committee Member S. Florida Council International Council of Shopping Centers International Association of Assessing Office (IAAO) Beacon Council; Member of Economic Roundtable Forum American Association of Arbitrators; Appointed to Panel of Arbitrators Licenses: State of Florida Real Estate Broker (1961), Lic, #0182553 State of Florida Certified General Appraiser, #RZ684 Instructor/ Adjunct Instructor-University of Miami, Finance Department Lecturer: Florida International Univ; Market Analysis/Florida R.E. Commission Lecturer at Law relating to Value Theory & Valuation Theory in Estate Tax Planning and legal matters - Univ. of Miami School of Law Publisher of the AREEA Report for South Florida; Miami Herald Weekly Columnist; Editorial Advisor to various real estate journals and magazines; quoted in local/state/national media; authored papers and articles. Author of Market Analysis in the Valuation Process (AI) and Role of the ADDraiser and Assessor in Ad Valorem Tax Matters IlAAo\' Majored in Business Administration, University of Miami Successfully completed numerous real estate related courses and seminars sponsored by the AI, accredited universities and others Currentlv certified by the AI, ASA, and State of Florida's continuina education Circuit Court of Miami-Dade, Broward, Lee, Charlotte, Palm Beach, Indian River Counties U.S. District Court for the Northern and Southern District of Florida U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Florida U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Connecticut U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division Testified before U.S. Senate Bankina Committee, Washinaton, DC Rev. 03/03 11/12/2003 09:54 3054444986 DAVID PLUMMERANDASSO PAGE 02 TIMOTHY J. PLUMMER, PE l'RESll>ENT EDUCA TION: Professional Engineer State of Colorado . #29878 State of Florida - '#49676 Master of Business Administration University of Colorado Professional Affiliations: Institute of Transportation Engineers Bachelor of Science, Civil Engineering North Carolina State University Continuing Education: Advanced Traffic Signal Systems Technology Workshop, Iowa State University Project Development and Enviromnental Documentation Course, FHW A Fundamentals of Geometric Design Workshop, Northwestern University Traffic Institute EXPERIENCE: Mr. Plummer is responsible for the overall transportation planning, traffic engineering, and civil design for the company. These responsibilities include: project management and strategies, technical analysis, and quality control/quality assurance. He has over 12 years of transportation/civil experience including two years with the Florida Department of Transportation's Pistrict Six office. Mr. Plummer's general experience includes tasks related to traffic operations and safety, transportation engineering, transportation planning, traffic engineering, access management, site design, traffic calming, parking analyses and geometric design. His transportation engineering experience includes traffic impact analyses, transit studies, access management, parking studies, and safety studies. Mr. Plummer's design experience includes roadway design, site design, and signal design. His experience also includes signal timing (using TRANSYT-7F) and capacity analysis (Highway Capacity Software), as well as the intercolUlection of multiple traffic signal controllers. REPRESENTATIVE PROJECTS: Mr. Plummer has worked on various projects from planning through design. Several of the significant projects are: Graa' Smoky Mountain National Park Traffic ODerations and Safety Study Mr. Plwnmer was responsible for providing a comprehensive evaluation of traffic operations and traffic safety in one of the largest and most popular national parks in the United States. The effort included an evaluation of the park roadway system and historical traffic accident patterns, identifying high hazard locations, and recommending modifications to these locations. DA VID PLUMMER & ASSOCIA TES. INC _ __11/12/2003 09: 54 3054444986 DAVID PLUMMERANDASSO PAGE 03 TIMOTHY J. PLUMMER, PE PRESIDENT HEFT/NW 12 Street Turnoike Interchanae Justification Reaort fTlJRJ Mr. plulllll1er spearheaded the management and technical efforts of this complex TUR in west. central Miami-Dade County. This TUR included detailed technical analysis of eight interchanges and over 20 intersections. Well coordinated interaction with the FOOT Turnpike District, FOOT Systems Planning office, and FDOT District Six was key to "fast-track" approval of this project. Metro Area Connection (MAC) Liaht Rail Svstem Mr. Plummer worked on the pl;mning through the design of the MAC Light Rail System in Denver, Colorado. His involvement included developing light rail traffic signals and signage, developing a signal timing plan for the light rail system and approximately 50 traffic signals in the Denver CBD, producing traffic control plans, undertaking traffic engineering and accidents evaluations of the system, and recommending traffic design changes to the system. 1.95 Downtown Distributor Ramos PD&E Study Mr. Plummer is involved with various technical aspects of a complex urban interstate reconstruction project in Miami for the Florida DeplU1ment of Transportation. His responsibilities include alternatives development and analysis. freeway system analysis, preliminary accident analysis and traffic analysis and forecasting. OTHER SIGNIFICANT PROJECTS; . FOOT District 4 General Planning Consultant . FOOT District 6 Traffic Operations and Safety Studies FOOT District 6 General Planning Consultant FOOT District 6 Expert Witness FDOT Turnpike District SW 112 Avenue PD&E Study SR 826/NW 36 Street Interchange Final Design HEFT/NW 12 Street SEm. SR 836/NW 87 Avenue Interchange Modi:fication Report (IMR) Downtown Miami Transportation Master Plan US 1 (SR 5) ADA Study Rocky Mountain National Park Traffic Operations and Safety Study Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport Terminal Loop Road Assessment Miami International Airport Trip Generation Study Miami-Dade County Integt'llted Transportation Management System (ITMS) Miami-Dade County Congestion Management System Brickell Key Traffic Calming Study City of Boca Raton Downtown Parking Study AmericanAirlines Arena Traffic Management and Parking Study Village of Merrick Park DRl Sunrise Land DlU Kendall Town Center DRI Brevard Crossings DRl . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . DA VID PLUMMER & ASSOCIA TES. INC ---- I District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District. Case No. 4D02-1125 HERMAN NEUMAN and SEYMOUR OKNER, v. GRAND VIEW AT EMERALD HILLS, INC. . . .. The Board then voted unanimously to amend the rule governing the use of the auditorium. The ~ new rule provided that "[n]o religious services or activities of any kind are allowed in the auditorium or any other common elements. . . . . The declaration of condominium, which is the condominium's "constitution" creates the , condominium and "strictly governs the relationship among the condominium units owners and the condominium association." Id. At 456. Under the declaration, the Board of the condominium association has broad authority to enact rules for the benefit of the community. Page 1 of2 Teresa Soroka Sent: To: From: Noah Lewinger [nlewinger@yahoo.com] Tuesday, November 11, 2003 2:29 PM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Subject: Williams Island Shul, Zoning Meeting Dear Council Members, I am writing you in regards to the council meeting that is to take place tomorrow, November 11,2003. It is very disturbing that this meeting has been delayed so long preventing the construction of our new community synagogue that is greatly needed due to our capacity crowds and the inadequacies of our current facilities. I have been attending The Williams Island Shul since inception. The presence of an Orthodox synagogue was the most important attribute in my family buying two condominiums for vacation homes on Williams Island in the early 90s. As you are all well aware of, the Orthodox Jewish community on Williams Island has grown tremendously. We out grew our first facility, located in the 2800 building and now have outgrown our facility in the 2000 building. The growth of the synagogue has formed a very pleasant community in which my wife and I have chosen to raise our family and in 1999 we permanently became A ventura residents. Soon after, my parents became Aventura residents and we have purchased an additional two condominiums. Since we do not drive on the Sabbath, it is imperative that the community we live in has an orthodox synagogue in close walking distance. Our community synagogue has allowed us to fulfill our spiritual requirements and in the process become a center for the community to revolve around. The benefits we have received are immeasurable, starting with the great friendships we have made and been able to maintain through community involvement, celebrating births, marriages and even support during the grieving process. Though I 0 m very grateful for the synagogue we have, it has become more than apparent that our current facility is inadequate. The following is brieflist of why our current facility is inadequate: I) Lacks space to accommodate for all worshipers that want to attend. 2) Our current facility frequently floods with medium to heavy rain and desecrates our house of worship. 3) There is no area to accommodate children while parents attend services. Currently, children play in the RabbiDs office, which in most synagogues would be considered disrespectful. 4) There is no social facility to host after-service refreshments or other synagogue functions, an integral part of community socialization. Unfortunately, the location for our new home has met much resistance from building residents, Williams Island residents and even Aventura residents in which our new synagogue home will have no effect upon their daily lives. I have heard all the objections, rumors and slanderous statements that have been circulating. I even heard one resident complaining to her personal trainer at the Williams Island Spa. After reviewing all these objections, I wonder if these people really know why they donDt want a synagogue? Is it because a friend asked for support in fighting this? Is it a hateful dislike for certain individuals supporting the synagogue? Biases? They have nothing better to do with their time other than complain? The synagogue will adversely affect their lifestyle or financial worth? 11/12/2003 Page 2 of2 Some of the objections that I have heard have no real basis others have no legal basis. So what are the real issues? Increased traffic, security, property value, additional expenses for building residents and the law. The increase of traffic will only be foot traffic diverted from the 2000 building. People are discouraged from driving to synagogue and most orthodox synagogues that have parking, lock their gates on the Sabbath. Lifestyles of the residents would not be affected as the only entrance for our facility is located behind the building, between the parking garage and the loading docks, only used for deliveries and trash removal, with no access to the 2600 Building common areas. Security risks do not increase or decrease in moving the synagogue from the 2000 to the 2600 Building and there has never been any threat or disturbance relating to security issues. Many residents of the 2600 building feel that the synagogue will hurt their property values. Nothing could be farther from the truth as properties values at Mystic Point and Turnberry have increased since the presence of the orthodox Safra Shul. Also, please note the very strong property values and huge increases that have occurred in Emerald Hills and Oakridge in Hollywood, both located adjacently to an orthodox synagogue. Additional expenses that are unforeseen that the 2600 Condominium Association would incur having the synagogue as a resident, would be reimbursed by the synagogue as well as the maintenance fees that are currently being paid. So whatDs left? The Law! Federal law stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. I urge you to review all the facts before making a decision and distinguish the biases from the law. Thank you for your time in considering our application. Sincerely, Noah Lewinger 2800 Island Boulevard #1205 Williams Island, FL 33160 Do you Yahoo!? Protect your identity wj1h Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard 11/12/2003 Teresa Soroka Subject: Rachel Reinberg [anlhrorn@yahoo.com] Wednesday, November 12, 2003 8:15 AM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cilyofavenlura.com The Synogogue @ Williams Island From: Sent: To: Dear Mr. Mayor and City Commissioners, As a resident of Williams Island, I am writing this letter to voice my support for the new synogogue location on willims Island. I personally have been a member of the shul since it began ten years ago. I remember a time when we had no permanent facility and relocated often from various apartments to the island club. We were greatful to move to our current location in the 2000 building. However, over the past decade we have grown as a congregation and have outgrown our current space. This is not a problem, but a blessing. We have not grown because the popularity of our shul has spread outside of our community to the greater community at large. We have grown because members like myself have grown, married, and started families of our own. In addition, new and residents and old have heard of our wonderful shul and now attend regularly. Because we are a small orthodox synogoue on a small residential island we are self limited in our capacity for growth. We will never attract throngs of people to our congregation. We simply need more space to accomodate our growing families and growing community. My 9 month old son has attended services at the Williams Island synogogue every Saturday since he was 2 weeks old. He is often affectionatly referred to as the shul mascot. There he gets to experience his culture first hand along side holocost survivors and Jews from many other countries often whom were persecuted for their beliefs back in their countires of origin. He will grow up learning the lesson of what it means to be a Jew and unfortunatly that it often accompanies hatred, predjudice, and persecution. However, let him learn that from the stories of those who have already lived these awful truths. Please, do not let him experience it first hand by denying him an adequate palce to observe his religion due to the baseless and illogical opposition from a few members of this community. If not for me or the other members of our community, please act on behalf of the children of the Williams Island Synogoue. Thank you very much for your time. Once again, I beg you to do the right thing. Sincerely, Jay Reinberg, MD Do you Yahoo!? Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard http://antispam.yahoo.com/whatsnewfree 1 Page 1 of 1 To: From: Rachelle Lewinger [rachellelewinger@yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, November 10, 2003 9:14 PM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura. com; holtzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Sublect: Williams Island Synagogue cc: Commissioners @ City Manager Teresa Soroka Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Sincerely, Rachelle Lewinger 2800 Island Blvd. #1205 Williams Island, FL 33160 Do you Yahoo!? PJ.9tect your identity with Yahoo! Mail Addre~~Guard 11/11/2003 Teresa Soroka Subject: michelle [mcthomegirl@yahoo.com] Wednesday. November 12. 20031:27 PM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Williams Island Synogogue From: Sent: To: Dear Mayor and Commissioners of Aventura, I am writing this letter to voice my support for the new Shul on Williams Island. I as well as my parents, daughter, son in law, and grandson are all members of the synagogue at Williams Island. I am writing this letter to inform you that the space which we currently occupy in the 2000 building is inadequate for our congregation. The space is too small and it is not well designed for a synagogue. The new space which is located in a small corner of the garage of the 2600 building would be an ideal space. I know that some people are complaining that we will be a nuisance or intrusive in this space but this is merely an excuse for the true issue. Some of the residents simply do not want a synagogue in their neighborhood. In response to the myriad of reasons why we shouldn't be there I say this: 1. parking is clearly not an issue as an orthodox shul our members walk. For anyone who may drive the Trump family has graciously donated many parking spaces for our members. 2. we will be located in the garage of the building which does not share a common entrance or even the driveway. We enter from the side of the building and are not even visible from the street front. 3. in a community that has always had a public access restaurant, spa and tennis club we frequently have many members of the outside community within our island. The shul will bring the least outsiders of all of these facilities. 4. for those who do not appreciate seeing us walking to shul on Saturday, we have had a shul in Williams Island for over a decade and have not caused anyone harm or inconvenience. We do not hurt anyone by being there we simply want a nicer and slightly larger more comfortable place to worship. This is our right as residents of a free society. Please do not infringe on this right. Allow us our space. Sincerely I Michelle Bramson Do you Yahoo!? Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard http://antispam.yahoo.com/whatsnewfree 1 From: Annsing@aol.com Sent: Sunday, November 09, 2003 1 :06 PM To: perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com Subject: Williams Island Synagogue cc: Commissioners Page 1 of 1 City Manager tf9J @ -I" Teresa Soroka 1000 W. Island Blvd. #1609 and #1610 Aventura, FL 33160 Nov. 10,2003 Dear Aventura Council: We have been residents of North Dade County since 1969 and Williams Island since 1990. Although we do not worship at The Williams Synagogue, we feel it is an important asset to our community. Many Jews do not drive a car on the Sabbath and Jewish Holidays and therefore require a synagogue within walking distance of their homes. The Williams Synagogue has been in existence for over a decade and does not cause any traffic or parking problems. In fact, most residents of Williams Island were not even aware that there is a synagogue in this community and only learned of its presence when the proposal to move it from its present location at 2000 Island Blvd. to 2600 Island Blvd. became an issue. Other nonmembers have had the advantage of its services when ritual participation was a personal need. Moving Williams Island Synagogue to 2600 Island Blvd. would not increase its membership but provide a more serene premises in which to worship. The current space is cramped and inadequate. A larger area is needed so that meaningful prayer can take place in comfort. Kindly support the transfer of the Williams Synagogue to 2600 Island Blvd. Respectfully, Dr. Joseph A. Singer Ann Singer 11110/2003 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: Maureen 0 [moJady@bellsouth.net] Sent: Saturday, October 25. 2003 3:15 PM To: cohenk@cityofaventura.com Subject: Synagogue WiUiams Island. Dear Commissioner Cohen, I am writing to ask your cooperation concerning the Shool here. Having lived here for a number of years and attending many services. It would be a tragedy not to have a shool here as it enhances our way of life here on the Island and many people appreciate it. Thanking you in advance for your kind attention. Best wishes, Yours sincerely, Maureen Ostro..~ Maureen O. molady@bellsouth.net Florida USA. :7-~--'-""'" j~k.~V <.~~~ '~'~~'!i ,~ 11/7/2003 October 26, 2003 Dear Mr. Perlow I hope that everything is going well for you and your Family, Lea and I are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura, Many of our Congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely Mrs. Lea Pacifici. Mr. Victor Acco 2000 Island Blvd. # 605 Aventura, Fl. 33160 Tel: 305-933-8810 Teresa Soroka From: Sent: To: Subject: L Raiford [lraiford_2000@yahoo.com] Sunday, October 26, 2003 9:42 AM diamondb@cityofaventura.com Willie Trump Synagogue Dear Commissioner Diamond, We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours Sincerely, Laurence Raiford, M.D. 2800 Island Boulevard, Suite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 Do you Yahoo!? Exclusive Video Premiere - Britney Spears http://launch.yahoo.com/promos/britneyspears/ 1 Dear Commissioner Manny Grossman: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion Yours sincerely, Fanny Fraynd 2800 Island Blvd. # 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: Jose Tabacinic Otabacinic@attglobal.net] Sent: Sunday, October 26, 2003 11 :58 AM To: perlowj@cityofavenlura.com; auerbachz@cityofavenlura.com; beskinj@cilyofavenlura.com; cohen k@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com SUbject: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Council Members: We live in Williams Island already 3 years and the Synagogue has become a central part of our social life. The current location is too small for the growing number of people who is attending the services, mainly on Shabbat (Saturday) and the High Holidays. We appreciate if you can support the move of the Synagogue from its current location to the new location in Williams Island. As an observant Jew any other Orthodox Synagogue in Aventura is located at a 1 hour walk from my house, as oppose to 10 minutes from my apartment. Yours sincerely, Jose and Miriam Tabacinic 7000 Island Boulevard Apt. 2702 Aventura, FL 33160 Tel (305) 6821577 11/7/2003 Page 1 of2 Teresa Soroka From: clara12922@aol.com Sunday, October 26, 2003 1 :34 PM JeffreyPerlow@cityofaventura.com auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Subject: PLEASE SUPPORT THE MOVE OF THE WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Sent: To: Cc: The Honorable City Council Govemment Center 19200 W. Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor Zev Auerbach, Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Commissioner Ken Cohen, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Commissioner Manny Grossman, Commissioner Subject: Relocation of Williams Island Synagogue As a resident of Aventura, I am requesting that the Aventura City Council grant permission to the proposal of the Williams Island Synagogue to create a structure on Williams Island for the purpose of housing its spiritual and religious activities. I am a traditionally inclined Jew who was drawn to this area because of its beauty and because there was a synagogue within walking distance of my family's condominium at Commodore Plaza. There is no other facility nearly as close as the Williams Island Shul. But this Shul has now outgrown its current location. I am convinced that this proposal will cause no hardship to the current residents of Williams Island and Aventura. On the contrary, it would only enhance the quality of life and real estate value of the area. The City of Aventura can only gain from granting this proposal. Sincerely yours, Mrs. Clara Scholnick 2750 NE 183rd Street apt. T -2009 Aventura, Florida 33160 (305) 932-6520 11/7/2003 Page 1 of2 Teresa Soroka From: Moshe Scholnick [mscholnick@yahoo.com] Sent: Sunday, October 26, 2003 2:05 PM To: perlowj@cityofaventura.com Cc: auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Subject: Fwd: PLEASE SUPPORT THE MOVE OF THE WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Date: Sun, 26 Oct 2003 13:33:54 EST Subject: PLEASE SUPPORT THE MOVE OF THE WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE To: perlowj@cityofaventura.com CC: auerbachz@cityofaventura.com, beskinj@cityofaventura.com, cohenk@cityofaventura,com, diamondb@cityofaventura.com, ho1zbergh@cityofaventura.com, grossmanm@cityofaventura.com The Honorable City Council Government Center t9200 W. Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor Zev Auerbach, Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Commissioner Ken Cohen, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Commissioner Manny Grossman, Commissioner Subject: Relocation of Williams Island Synagogue As a resident of Aventura, I am requesting that the Aventura City Council grant permission to the proposal of the Williams Island Synagogue to create a structure on its spiritual and religious activities. I am a Williams Island for the purpose of housing traditionally inclined Jew who was drawn to this area because of its beauty and because there was a synagogue within walking distance of my family's condominium at Commodore Plaza. There is no other facility nearly as close as the Williams Island Shul. But this Shul has now outgrown its current location. I am convinced that this proposal will cause no hardship to the current residents of Williams Island and Aventura. On the contrary, it would only enhance the quality of life and real estate value of the area. 11/7/2003 Page 2 of2 The City of Aventura can only gain from granting this proposal. Sincerely yours, Rabbi Moshe Scholnick and Family 2750 NE 183rd Street apt. T -2009 Aventura. Florida 33160 (305) 932-6520 e-mail: mscholnick@yahoo.com Rabbi Moshe Scholnick 2750 NE 183rd Street - T2009 Aventura, Florida 33160 (305) 932-6520 Do you Yahoo!? Exclusive Video Premiere - Britney Spears 11/7/2003 DAVID HOLD November 7, 2003 City of Aventunl Government Center 19200 West COWltIy Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Council Member: I am writing this letter in total dismay that in this day and age an issue like this is even disputed. \Vhat is more amazing than anything is the fact that the opposition to this new synagogue is not from the non Jewish members of the community but mainly from the Jewish ones. Is it possible that the saying that history repeats itself is true because it reminds me of the same attitude of the German Jewish conununity before Second World War, who also turned their back on their heritage. My \Vife and I. are both children of holocaust survivors and very sensitive to such issues. We were also raised in a communist country where freedom of religion was never heard of. The beauty of this country that it provides religious freedom to everyone irregardless of place of origin or nature of their believes. This is also true about the new city of Aventura which can be looked upon as a modern melting pot of all nationalities. The beauty of our synagogue encompasses all of these wonderful qualities that this great country of ours grants us. We have members from all parts of the world practicing their version of Judaism as they have been thought in their countries of origin and handed down from generation to generation sometimes in fear of their life but never forgetting who they are. As you are aware for a practicing member he has to have a place of worship within walking distance, the present facilities are inadequate and this is a necessity for the community at large. Please support our efforts in building OUI new synagogue. Sincerely, David Hold Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: RAQUEAZOUT@aol.com Monday, October 27,20037:49 AM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; berskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Subject: Synagogue Sent: To: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totaily inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbats as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Raquel and Richard Perlman 2000 Island Blvd. Apt. 801 Aventura, FI. 33160 11/7/2003 Jeffrey M Page I of I Teresa Soroka From: Carla Lewin [carlalew@bellsouth.net] Sent: Monday, October 27,20033:05 PM To: diamondb@cityofaventura.com Subject: Wi lie Trump Synagogue WE ARE COUNTING ON YOUR SUPPORT Israel & Carla Lewin 2800 Island Blvd # 1405 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Bob Diamond, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Diamond: This letter is to ask for your support in the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the Aventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12,2003 hearing, The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion, Yours sincerely, Israel & Carla Lewin 11/7/2003 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: Claudia Tabacinic [ctabacin@bellsouth.net] Sent: Thursday, October 3D, 2003 5:25 PM To: diamondb@cityofaventura.com Subject: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Council Member, We are extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location in Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the Southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other synagogue. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours Sincerely, Claudia Tabacinic Tel: 305-933-8052 Cel: 305-522-3290 e-mail: ctabacinlalbellsouth.net 11/7/2003 Page 1 of2 Teresa Soroka From: Lesli KRoss [Ieslik@bellsoulh.nel] Sent: Friday, October 31, 2003 5:03 PM To: diamondb@cityofaventura.com Subject: NOV 12 CITY COUNCIL MEETING Dear Commissioner Diamond; Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it - to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern, With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of A ventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years, In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island, There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Is/and residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. 11/7/2003 Page 2 of2 Federal law stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establisrnnent or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely, Lesli K and Jordon I Ross 3000 Island Blvd, #2606 Aventura 33160 Lesli K. and Jordon I. Ross 11/7/2003 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: Larrysti@aol.com Sunday, November 02,200312:31 PM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; aurebachz@cityof aventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventra.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Subject: Synagogue at Williams Island Sent: To: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. While we are among the very few members who drive from an off Island location, the great majority of the congregants must walk in accordance with our tradition. Williams Island Synagogue has outgrown its present facility and the need is great for a larger place. That place has been located within one of the buildings on the Island and can be accessed only through an area currently used by delivery trucks and at the end of an alley. Opposition to this relocation is understandable if it were in any way to affect the life style or habits of any of the residents who reside in the building of the new location. However, if you were to visit the proposed location you too could not understand what this oppositon is about. No one who is not a member of the congregation will in any way be inconvenienced by this new location. Further, those who are Shabbath observant will be able to observe our religion in the appropriate way. We would appreclte your supporting this move. Sincerely yours, Larry and Eileen Joseph 19333 Collins Ave. #2301 Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160 11/7/2003 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: Arlene Hauben [ahauben@holmail.com] Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2003 6:53 PM To: perlowj@cityofaventura.com Cc: holzbergh@cityofaventura.com Subject: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioner Ho1zberg: There is a wonderful synagogue on Williams Island that reminds me of the shu1 on the West side of Chicago off of Douglas Park Boulevard, where I grew up. It was a sanctuary where old men in talis and some young could fervently pray together. It had a special smell -- that of tradition and religious sentiment. It wasn't glitzy or crowded, It was just a little shul. The synagogue on Williams Island is as close to that special place as I've ever found, I ask that you support its safekeeping and let it remain to serve Williams Island residents who come to recite psalms together and pray. It is an out of the way place and certainly not in anyway imposing or obtrusive. Thank you in advance for your support, We hope that you will be influential in keeping the synagogue, which can only be to everyone's advantage in a world where fire and negative forces are everywhere. While the current synagogue is inadequate, and needs to be enlarged, it brings a bright light to everyone who attends and makes the world right here a better place, Even in A ventura, not everything is rosy, We need your help. I've met you both and have faith that as wise and righteous men you will support such an important issue. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Arlene Hauben Aventura Resident Enioy MSN 8 patented spam control and more with MSN 8 Dial-up Internet Service. Try it FREE for one month! 11/7/2003 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: MGutt99@ao1.com Sent: Tuesday, November 04, 200312:02 PM To: perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofavenura.com; jtabacinic@attglobal.net Subject: (no subject) Miami, November 3, 2003 City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members; We are extremely disturbed to learn there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As every one is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregates attend this synagogue on Shabbat and the distance is too great to walk and attends any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Manuel Gutt 1000 East Island Boulevard Apt. 2102 Aventura, Florida 33160 11/7/2003 Page 1 of 1 Teresa Soroka From: Savd8@aol.com Wednesday, November 05, 2003 11 :07 AM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura.com Subject: Please consider Sent: To: My family and I have been attending services in Williams Island for the past eighteen years. As the population of the Island grew,the synagogue was moved, initially to the 3000 building, then to the 2800 building where we had a part-time rabbi. We finally relocated to a basement in the 2000 building,and contracted the services of a full-time rabbi. Still the population of the Island kept growing as more buildings went up,until now with the soon-to-be-completed 6000 building and the final small one in the planning stage,we have become a full-fledged community and we do not fit anymore in the temporary quarters we occupy in the 2000 building. Most members of our congregation cannot ride a car on the Sabbath or Holy Days, and their only alternative is to pray in the crowded quarters we now occupy, or walk for an hour to the nearest synagogue. In all the years we have been here, the practice of our reiigion has never impinged on the rights of our neighbors and has always had the support of the whole community, as we hope will continue to be the case in the future. Raymond Savdie and family 11 /7/2003 RECEIVED NQV Ct 5 L003 COMMUNITY DEI1:LllPMENT November 03, 2003 City of A ventura Government Center Community Development Department Aventura, Florida, 33180 Re: Williams Island Synagogue/ 04-CU-03/ Comments Dear Sir or Madam, The establishment of a well designed synagogue, like the one that is proposed, should be considered a "PLUS" for the Williams Island residents and the community in general. As a matter of fact, this synagogue will only replace the already existing one (located at 2000 Island Boulevard) only because the actual synagogue lacks the solemnity and space required for the proper celebration of our prayers and ceremonies. Since the establishment of the synagogue at the proposed site is considered a simple move from its actual location (at 2000 Island Boulevard), to another nearby one (also located within Williams Island), I don't see, at least objectively, any negative impact whatsoever. On the contrary, it is time to have a synagogue that reflects the spirit and character of our faithful residents. ~~IY1 . ' Henri Levi 3000 Williams Island, Ap. No 1102 A ventura, Florida, 33160 cc: Commissioners SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP City Manager@ PAUL GINSBERG, M.D. JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR c. MANIAR, M.D. HARVEY D. SCHWARTZ, M.D. ISLON SELIGER, M.D, DRUCE ZARET, M,D. JEFF M. STEINBERG, M.D, MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D. VEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M,D. ERIC F. CILIBERTI, M.D, NEUROLOGY DARRY J. CUTLER, M.D. RICHARD P. SINGER, M,D., FAAN. JILL S. LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A. HERRERA, M.D, GERALD S. GOLDBERG, M,D. TANUSHREE ROY, M.D. RICHARD TIEGEN, D,M,D" A.P. RHONDA Q, FREEMAN, PSY. D. EDUARDO CUTIE, M.D. November 3, 2003 Dear My wife and I love Aventura. We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago. But we almost could not live here. My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modern orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sundays and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island. It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten years had grown to such a degree that we have outgrown all quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place of worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful of the rules on the island. The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for Aventura. His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of truth that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed. Respectively yours, Barry J. CUtler, M.D. CI/20031103-047/BJC 4925 Sheridan Street, Suite 200, Hollywood, Florida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation, Florida 33317 16800 NW 2'" Avenue, 306, Miami, Florida 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue, 206, Plantation, FL 33324 Phone: (954) 981 3850 Phone: (954) 437 4000 Phone: (954) 3211776 Phone: (305) 652 3062 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax (954) 981 3889 Fax (954) 433 5257 Fax (954) 321 1885 Fax (305) 853 7046 Fax: (954) 452 5872 SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP NEUROLOGY CC: COmmissioners City Manager i@ PAUL GINSBERG, M.D. JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR C. MANIAR, M.D. HARVEY D. SCHWARTZ, M,D, lSLON SELIGER, M,D. BRUCE ZARET, M.D. JEFF M. STEINBERG, M.D. MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D, VEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M.D. ERIC F. CILIBERTI, M,D. BARRY J. CUTLER. M.D. RICHARD P. SINGER, M.D., FAAN. JILL S, LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A, HERRERA, M.D. GERALD S, GOLDBERG, M.D. TANUSHREE ROY, M.D RICHARD TIEGEN, D.M,D., A.P, RHONDA Q. FREEMAN, PSY. D. EDUARDO CUTIE, M.D, November 5, 2003 To Whom It May Concern; My wife and I love Aventura. We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago, But we almost could not live here, My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modem orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sabbath and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island, It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten yeas has grown to such a degree that we have outgrown our quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place to worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the Island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful ofthe rules on the island, The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for A ventura, His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of proof that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed, Respectively yours, Barry J. Cutler, M.D. 4925 Sheridan Street, Suite 200, Hollywood, Florida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation, Florida 33317 16800 NW 2'" Avenue, #306, Miami, Florida, 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue, #206, Plantation, Florida 33324 Phone: (954) 981 3850 Fax: (954) 981 3889 Phone: (954) 437 4000 Fax: (954) 433 5257 Phone: (954) 321 1776 Fax: (954) 321 1885 Phone: (954) 652 3062 Fax: (305) 653 7048 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax: (954) 452 5872 SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP PAUL GINSBERG, M.D, JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR C. MANIAR, M,D. HARVEY D. SCHWARTZ, M.D. ISLON SELIGER, M.D. BRUCE ZARET, M.D, JEFF M, STEINBERG, M.D. MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D. VEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M.D. ERIC F. CILffiERTI, M.D. NEUROLOGY BARRY J, CUTLER, M,D. RICHARD P. SINGER, M.D., FAAN. JILL S. LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A. HERRERA, M.D. GERALD S. GOLDBERG, M.D. TANUSHREE ROY, M.D. RICHARD TIEGEN, D.M.D., A.P, RHONDA <<~SY. D. EDUARvO'CU'm, M.D. NOV 0 II 2003 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENr November 3, 2003 To Whom It May Concern; My wife and I love Aventura, We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago. But we almost could not live here. My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modern orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sabbath and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island. It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten years had grown to such a degree that we have outgrown our quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place of worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the Island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful of the rules on the island. The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for Aventura, His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of proof that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed. Respectively yours, Barry J. Cutler, M.D. CI/20031103-047/BJC 4925 Sheridan Street, Suite 200, Hollywood, Florida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation, Florida 33317 16800 NW 2"'Avenue, 306, Miami, Florida 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue, 206, Plantation, FL 33324 Phone: (954) 981 3850 Phone: (954) 437 4000 Phone: (954) 3211776 Phone: (305) 652 3062 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax: (954) 981 3889 Fax: (954) 433 5257 Fax: (954) 321 1885 Fax: (305) 653 7046 Fax: (954) 452 5872 p_. r&tO f~~ ~ifV Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~. or f~ 'IIfl~-c Address: 1---f,OC7~ ~ -tic ! ro I If-vu~ ~ .3D/be r 11/f..:kr~. ~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: t-f:e lJl~ r' Address: -Z g 17<7 ~~. tf /7-0) ~~, R. ~"S'(,.e> l1Mao R. ~,~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ r-- Address: 2'3C'c(}r.R~ ~ ' r("ol ~~ / ~. 1, ~/~o ~'~~/~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~~ r. Address: "? ~C2,o ':h~ 1J4-..p ,r.?-r( 1t-IIfA<..~ ~. .3 ~! (;. C' ;1.~~/~' Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: !J/~I&- ~. Address: 2--~D,o ~-;{Jey. Zz' /7-0 I ~,~:~3Ito ~~t:;,e.- Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Mt~ ~. Address: !l.~.p ~Lc:uJl ~ -;pt I ~/ ~~. ~ 3~(t;o 4.~~f~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name ~~f 1'-. Address: t.-gM ~~:#/?C'/ ~~ . 'j'~}31('O , l'l p .J. i6(f't.t. 'f h. Pi- ((u?.v I M Il'j'ce- Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: }lL-i \\M S ll?t~J /lJ "t..U-~.61 J Address: Woo I $L ffVD 't5h J irCcXJ ft'lru1Ja A-IH _ ?J~I'o ll{f., ')..-eJ {wf..-13f+-U4, eO'''Wl. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion, Yours sincerely, Name: MR.~f.(Q!t, SJ~:(nJ t~ZiJa.....';;rE(J.i Address: 1.-~oo I b h ,....JI) cp,,-,J, *c,co ~}:;\oi!-c.. ,:n.. , 3'31~O I"\~. :tPrj R. B6k,1,v , (lp,,",,_ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: t-< t -rf{J1.6. >~,w I JJ i--bU;;re ,,,) Address: "2---goe I (.t/l,'f'.)" 13 LV H ~ f+Jf,tJ r ,jl!.fI, -{ J.... 35/t.c f1. iZ !-!.C (!. t) #€rJ I CtJ>'Ifl). Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:l1~ 'of MI? '!:>;e14J rJJuJ-,(:5{kfj Address: 2..~t>C' (!,hf!.vp fJl...J. .,jc: We:? Pr/~JIvtf1. 1/...,. 3;("" , ~~. f-i.oe, P(Of"Jo,v>), td)A,M, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: M~. 'f )jl..~ 576f/J nJUl.f, -;ell Address: z.-,("O !$,t-A--J/\ '&hl.,;ik. ~"'O Iil-ve;AJItJr2I1,fL.-.. ?o-;I(c , {,... {cilIA, !'1 R... iJ 1Irp.S>-'f f'!-ev-z,...-f3 ~ I Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: kR-.J-f'l~!?' t)iCfti10 IJJ26.h;k/~ Address: J-f? c.e I (.c-.fJVO (dU' ..Ftr?'&' JleJWdlJ,f.t.., 33/{,:) M. h~NV'f Gf.l..o~I-I/~"/ eN"'. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Ht. v'N~ (;1-t:JI1I..l /,.1 U/....{7~fJ Address: j,. rJ (i;fj / >f..Il'A/ f> 13 t.v. ..It Cc!/' rrI t )J ',J4./f, ~t-. ? ~/ [0 , r'\A ,r~:(tft/<.'( f€t~lV~MMC{( Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ltl( (11M I v'f ().( {(OIU f1 , c '" F t.. ()" / Address: ~- ~(?-r? l5-l..IrtJP 'Bu/, ff !S07/ It/e~j":;}{U~-. rt-.. 3"? /(...(? ~R. , ~ pJi<.B.Pe..H, t ;,-1,,-, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura, Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: tfrl) ~ p Po'" ,I'm fie /.. OfA Address: 'l-ti &,0 fbi-II Jp el.-.v. .If ;Cc7./ ft f~,JrtJR.. ft, fJ.... . '3 '.jib 0 /'fR, 11/., Ro. f?e> KJJ, COM f"'l. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:-tlf,t/ of rko,J /V!('IIEH>;tb Add ress: ' .L - ,- E- 211 O"V I:' t.. ':;',0 P 'jSU/.-'# I J.- ()~ It-kttlfJR...;r, ,ft.. 35/ j,c 1'1 ~. ;<e,J OCl f/~ rJ I e f' /011" . Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:::Ffrft. o.r Ift7J )11(1I~/.-.CM Address: 2-tgrm;:- /~I4VP I}L ~J.:# /.0; v /1/g,v-;Ulfj)-fL. '35IC-f? f',~. [3013 01 (91-" o.JJ> I fOMt1. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name::+ M.,rf!for! !/fel/.(t,OM Address: Ut70 1!--!./fuI) eL.rf..:Ir /.('(lV l/l(flif),eIJ,:fJ,.. "5 "31t C' A 0 'I 11_ &13~~G CO",'''? Nf... ~flfV'-' / ~'l-- / Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island, As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:..{"'^' 0 f (((I J!1(f.feL.C~ . Address:1.-'lov (St..t:f-0D 8t,jiFlJrY tf~f/1JfUl. ~ . '351 (,v , !1R. I1/1N,J1 {(l(l?Jf1ttJ/c,4Ir1. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:f/". 17-f ~j !1 !(fle t.li'fY] Ad~ress: b-- "g 0 () IS, L t}1J1) $'';..fI:: (~ 1...-- It rkr/:(,; i! Ii . 'f" . 3 31 ( 0 . !lI!. :JeHeI'l N. fect<pJ, ,iM(c/3 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /YJ;f. y M/6. 1JcJ-;[fJ;I1!11 :fe;,.t!e;C Address: -2owo !tJ..IfIJt 1].f..tl :/1/'10 r IJlttJJ(};<!1, f/-.' 33?lto , f-s. ~ /J ~(IJi& OJ 4- weU!.#Rfe Ii' ah.-I...- ~ leq r!El-fJYt/i-V r;..,12 Hf lO;h1Ie It ~JIt) 1- )e~IG6Y' .4 ~/lf/HI;J1 tif;~9;k:),J, (l",;Mf'I. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /YJ/.!, ~&:'. -Z>e-<.J::re;:vJlf;(l/ Address: '20<l<? 1$ t.AJi> &;.I:Ift /'/V'f l}1/ff/0~Il, :fJ.. 38/t 1) /rJ~. iJ.,1J.J..,i/oLlf3eA~ e~/lI,a. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion, Yours sincerely, Name: 1t(l.r.rMb. '1JeJ ~t...JffR./ Address: 2-00(7 I b,/-4,Jb euJ. ::f;I !l(rIf M6t11iJM, FL. 3? / h n<. ;"(/13 .oIl} nt?~b,f!cIJf:J' Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /rJK y-!1~ '3c) f~t.tleK/ Address: 2~ ISt-M7\ 13M!..ti- Itptf 11( c;;J1/JrfiJ, 12 ' 35/to , Jrf(, IdtJ Oct/b0,c! (lPlJA. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 4{t..+I1t5, llt?JJ -(Pic,..tlifrC/ Address: 2,<"0.0 IGh4Jp ai-I. jj /lfo~ If !tl{.;fZll:[l.... 33/ &'fJ Ae. :;;y t ;gt9~.;.d~ e~",4l. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: fit nYl;. :!le=-/Y:;;;?>;.!r.;K / Address: ,),4JI7P /[,,t,4)i> 23l.~.!/J: /'/09' Ak- !Ii/) 164- 1)., ?; SIC 0 , f1( 2E1 /!{/~~f (!'P1N' Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /j~. rt-Iltt, 16b! ~uJe::'f1.. ) Address: 2-()Of? I~I..HJ.P BAt. Ii- /'tl/.q ttltflrJ /2.. ~ 11, 8318() Rece~ved: 11/12/0312:53PM; -> HB; Page 2 Nov 12 03 12:14p MICHAEL BECK 561 865 2563 p.2 6152 Via Venetia North Delray Beach Florida 33484 Tel: 561 8652560 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN From 1997 thru year 2000 I served as a director and president of the 2000 Island Boulevard Condominium Association at Williams Island. During that period the congregants of the Williams Island Synagogue met within the building. At no time were there any valid complaints. To the contrary, the synagogue was considered an amenity to be enjoyed by residents practicing their faith and respected by those of other denominations. Had the meeting room been of a sufficient size to accommodate greater numbers its support and popularity would have benefited substantially? I have no hesitation in thoroughly recommending in the interest of the residents that the Synagogue be moved to a larger location on the island. tf;tAft" / v / (L,,{ ( .1 ~ MICHAEL A. B CK November 12, 2003 . ..- -- RUI 20 02 12'02p . ".2 APPUCANT REPRESENTAnve AFFIDAVIT PU<IlIII\I kl BacUon SI.71lb)l2)lO 01111 Ciy '" AI'lHlIIft IQI Dtvtbpmem Cccle.11Is AilPbnt IlIlhMnl&h AIIIdavlIo hereby made w Ililmltted. '!he lIlde/llgnld IlllhGr1z8(I ~llYI DlI1I b:lhIIluII Dr ,"lily IfIllIyng lor'" ~ PIIlltlI, whI::h II tlerd10d 11f1t .-....l1)'lng~ .. ancll1lov.nlroltl&plOpllltyllbleel..Ilt',~llIlcllll.1'IIlIIU holov"'arnr ldenllr... IU JlOIIClIII....enllng fl. tldMdllll orlnllylllPlrt1p Iar tho OIl'lliopmanl Pannllln conneotlcn wlIh "'appIoallon. It foI!awt N.m& Iiflol.\whp/lf.........,.,~LMdoor,p. ----~EIa.J "TlfYl P j 1I_, ... Iruff'l, (o"<:.uif"",'f (AbcI1 AddllIanel Shaata. ~ NOTICE: AllY 6TATI:MENr OR REPRESENTATION MAllE BY ANY PERSON Ull'l1iD ON lHli APPUOANT llEPRESEMTAllVE AI'l'lDAVIT IlI1AU. BIi BINDlHa UPoN THE /HIIIVlDlIAL 011 emm APPLYINQ FORM DIMiLOPIlENT PEllIIIT NID THe OWNEII ql'TIIE BUI.IECT PROPERTY. API'LICANTB AND AAlIA1n'8 AlII! AllVISED TO TIMELY SUPPl.EMENI' THIS AFt'lDAYlT PllR8UANT TO 8EC.a""I(ll1WlM 011 tltl! CIl'Y'I LAND DEVEl.OPIIEIlT ReGULATIONS IN THE CITY COllE, IN THE EVENT lIIAT PRIllll tc"C6NaIDERATlClN OF mE APPUCATlON IV 11IE CITY BOARD OR COIIIII$SJON, mE lNJlORIIATlOII PIIOVlDlla IN 11IE AFPlDAVIT llECOMes INCORRECT 011 INCOMPLETE. . WlTNESSMYHANO'lHISJ,LOAYOF NOiJP...,t",r AUlHOR By. 200/3 OWNER Br. Nama- , l1ae: ~e( o..pd De'k:-\~.r. Add,,", 40::0 i5.\A,..d. ~\\Id . ?'-'<-'t W'\\\.to.M.<"~U'\...ndl. >='.... 33160 Name: 11Ue: Mlrm: 1'75<1 Pt>IIU d~ Lr...'1 Blucl (..".,"', G(lbic:~ fL STATE OF F\.ORIDA I COUNlY OF f.lIAMloDAQE) SWORN TO AND au ~~~ ~) . .. 2000 ISLAND BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. 2000 ISLAND BOULEVARD. WILLIAMS ISLAND, FLORIDA 33160 (305) 692-2000 FAX (305) 692-2008 May 21,2003 Mrs. Stephanie Trump 7900 Island Boulevard Williams Island, FL 33160 Dear Mrs. Trump: I am writing this letter in regards to the synagogue, which has been located in a commercial space in the 2000 building for the past eight (8) years. We have not experienced any significant adverse effectsrelated to its operation. The synagogue has a separate entrance and has not impacted valeUraffic. We have no reported complaints from our building residents with regards to. running of the synagogue orthe presence of the synagogue in.our.building. If I can be offurther assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me directly. Very truly yours, l~ Joey Sinson - Property Manager - 11/1'l7/1'l3 11'l:25 31'l5 579 1'l717 GREENBERG TRRURIG ~ WILLIRMS-ISLRND [;Ii'll NO. 593 ~HfNHID .....fTOIlHE'"' AT L...'IV U~~~lo Transmittal Cover Sbeet TO Mr. Henry Fleischer clo Roberta Company Fax Number Phone Number FROM File Comments Date Time No. Pages 305-466-3570 305-937-7834 Mario J. Garcia-Serra Williams Island Synagogue Conditional Use Approval Dear Roberta, Please have Mr. Fleischer sign next to the "x" on pages 2 and 3 of the attached form and have his signature on page 3 notarized. Please fax back to me at 305-961-5837 as soon as possible. Many thanks, Mario Garcia-Serra November 7, 2003 10:09 AM Including this cover sheet 4 Please notifY us immediately ifnot received properly at 305-579-0500. The information contained In this transmission i& attorney privileged and COnfidential. It i$ intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If the reClder of this message is not the intended ntdplent. you aTe hefeby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copy of this communication Is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication In error, please notify us Immediately by telephone collecrt and return the ortglnal message to us at the address helow via the U.S. Postal Service. W. will relmhurs. you (Of your postage. Thank you. 1221 Brlek.tl Avenuo. Miami, Florld3 33131 ('OS) 5T9-QC;OO FiUC (30~ ~7~~717 11/07/03 Aue eo De 12103p - - . 10:26 GREENBERG TRRURIG ~ WILLIRMS-ISLRND NO,593 (;102 FJ - p.3 BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT- 'IlI1s AIIldavllls made pul6\181'll \0 6eGIion 31.71(b1(2)(Ii) 0111, City 01 "'ventura Land Oevelopment OOde. 1I1e un<letslgned AlRarIt hereby cIIiic:Icl$ea lilt (malk wlth "X" appIlcable potIlona 0lI1t) cf )(1. \... 112, Nrlilllt does um haw . lIlIskless Relationship wtlh any member 01 the cay OOmmlGslon or any CIty Advisory 80InI to whklh tho 'IlpUoellon \\1n blI pre.ented, NIlant helaby disclos\l6 thaI ft does baye . BlISlness Relationship wtlh . m,mber or llIe City 00mm1sa1on or 8 CIy AdYltory &arc! 10 vmrJl the applklaUon will be presented, U follows: . (Us1 name of Cornmlsalvner or AdYItory ~rd MembeIj . serve. on the (Ust City COmmls$/on or City Adl/tlorv lloallI upon which memller ,. lelVea). The nature ollie BuslneS$ Relallol\5hlp Is U follow5: ilL III. lllii, lilY. (Iv. IIvt. Member 01 City (lgmmlsslon or &arc! holds an oWllelllhlp lntereslln excess 01 '" 01 tolelassels or capltal_ of ~licant or f\epmenldve: Member 01 City Commls$ion or Board Is . pamer. ~r (u to shares 01 a OOl1lOratIan \\'hIch are nolllsted on any naIlonal or r~1 stock exctIan8e) or Jmt ventlnl wlth lie /lfpDoanl or Represenla1lY8ln any buslllllSS venIure; The Appfic:ant or RepresenlaUye Is 8 Client of . member 01 \he Cily CommIssion or Board or a OlleIlt 01 another prolO$.tonal worldng trom !he same olIlee or for the &lme ,mplayllr BlIthe member of \he Olty COllUllkslon or Bolli!; A CIly Comml$sloner or Board member is a Client 01 the Applloant or Represellla\ive; The Applicant or RopreselllaUve Is a CU$lomer of tho member of 1IIe City CommlselQn or Board (or of his or her 'mploye~ IlI\d tmnsacts mOlll1han $10.000.00 of the business 01 the lIlGIllber of Ole CIty Commls$lon or Board (or his or her emptoye~ In I glven calendar yaar; The member olllle City Comml$$lon or Board 18 a CusIomer olllle Applban\ or Repre9ll1lative and transacts more than $2.5.000.00 of lie buslness 01 the ~k;anl or flepl'8W1tadve In a Given oatendar year, APPLICANT 8y. Heme' 11ll0: .. MY HAND 11iIS _ OAY OF .2001. Slgnalure) "nO (ptfttQ Wl'll'IESS MY HAND 11iIS _DAY OF PROPER'rI' OWNER: By: NllI1\8: TIlle: .2001, ~~QatUl8) (prtnQ .' 'The /811II8 'Bus/nus Relatloll$hC>.' 'Cllenl.' 'Cttslomer.' 'AppUr;anl,' 'RepresentallVe' and 'nlerlsted P'lSon' are denned In BedIM Sl.s95 0' III. AVIIIIUI1I O/IV Cod,. 11/07/03 10:26 GREENBERG TRRURIG ~ WILLIRMS*ISLRND NU.:>:!,j [;03 flue 20 02 1I!l OSp . ' ,..5 I . . WITNESS MY HAND THIS l DAY OF NOVf.tt1 ber 'II1J/.3 R~tecI an llUlIne8s Relallons"" AIllcIavlll BY: (SlgIII//1/(I/ (.. By. (S1g1ll/Uff) Name:.J:tenf\l Fle.schufPtfnl) Name' (F'dnQ , 11lJe: (p1fn/) litle' (Pttnr) Iy.. (SlgnarUtll) By. (SIgna/ute Heme' (PdnI) Name: (plfnl) . . . Tille' (PdnI) TdIe: (PIfnl1 By: (Stgnatmv) By: (Sigrra/UII/ Name: (ptttI) /Wne' (Pdn/) . 11lr. (ptfn/) TlUe: (PlfnQ By. (Sigtlature) By: (SWill/lute Name- (prill/) Name: (/>tilII} . 11Ie: (ptItIQ 11I1e: (Prin/) 8y. (SlgnatUIII) BY. ($Igna/UIII Heme' fPdnQ Name: (Pdnt) 'l1lle' (PM/) TIlle: (PrInQ . By. (8Iqnature) By: ~Iu'" Name: (Ptfn/) Name: (l'dn/) 1llIe' (PtfnI) l1tle: (plfnl) . NOTE: 11 Use dup6cate 5heels "d~losure InlollUllon fot RepmenlaUve varies 21 Applicants and Afflants are advised to Ilmely eupplemenl ~1s Affidavit p\If$uant to Seo. al.71(bI(l}{lvl ollhe CIly'e laneS Development Regulatlol\$ In the CIty COde, In the event that prior to c;onaldelltlon DIllie applloaUon by the CIty Board Dr Camml$$lon,thelnlormallon provlded In lIIe Alfldavlt btocmlu Inoorrecl Dr Incomplete. " . 11/07/03 10:27 GREENBERG TRRURIG ~ WILLIRMS*ISLRNU NU,:>'::I.:S ~04 A~C,~O.02 12103p fl.4 ITAlI OF IUINIlII I CCUHn' OfIlWolI'OHlE) It..... 1lI11l1ltt'llp41Utloltlr,..-.r waIIII j/('lryJjJ.eis cJ..r .... .~"IollilIM""'" """*' 1lIloCl1ll"IoMd .......WlW X SWOIlN TONlD SU88ClI'8I!DbI........2 .,f/,jjDV~ NOTARIZATION PROVISION ~ ""'.M~ lnlb, "".11\' _." Nlrarltllnn hi . PMIM N... 01 NolIIy l.I,.~.M n ,""'''''' DAWN E. ACKERMAN 4~b.~.\ MY COMMISSION # DD 237799 ;,,\~.i!! EXPIRES: September 24, 2007 ~~::.:~~ BoMedThruNotaryPublIcUnderwrtters ITAlIOFIUlRIlo\ I .QlUIm' Ill'MIAMI-ONIej ... ...., .. ,,4l.....cIIIIIlIIIlIr. lIIl1GM11l' ......1tG ...... e--.r"M'*C""'1lI ...........lIlll1mllw.......WI "'" 0IlIM. ... M'lIIIl. ..,., "'loiI"" III d,q __ dlI _or.... hit A/'FWff SWOANTONlD $U8SCl\Iaen...""'.... Ills _NYGl .lIllOl. N*I' '.8lIlo f/,AnIa AI. LIIve _NlmtolllD\llr IoIr llOCllIIIIIIloI'''I*R' ITA1EDFR.ClNtIA I ClltRrlYOFMIAMI.QI,DE) Ill"'" me. ... undonlgoed .U'I1ocItt. lIIl1ON1ly -"" ...... ftIQIIId Ills M1b..Iof... P\I11lO$I' IlIleCI lie"'" .nd....,. .....W-. ... 1JIiant, ..,., bl~ I'nt llr .... 4lAy ....., 4Id _r '" .lIlm ...1 AfFl.lm SWORN to NlD 8U8SCIlIBEO. 1101?0o.. NIl_ day'" tool. N*I"'- ~lale 01 F1ilIIIlI N.\.IIvI ~ NImI olNoClly loIr_iMb\'~e: ITA1EOFMlUOA . I OOUNIY 01' MtAHI<OAD6l llllott.... III undtrtlgfted a~, ...-1Ir Il'!ItIItG ......... alllClllAld a.Is NfIIaI'ft lor... _'''Ied """"'.nd.......rue lllll-. ...M'1IIl~M1o btllg IIIItOylllll4111t hiOIlI, dIlJ_ 0I11llnft III' #ffiIJfr &WOIIN TO ANO SUB801l11lEll btfo..... ttda _ dly 01 .l!OO1. .' HolluyPWIoBlalt olFbltdIAlu. PMItd NImI f/, NoIuy M,__'JIl.r. 1 () M -to ft fl./tlI (f /'6~N 7 () 00 (fCit"- IJ (j( U V u"v17 kf.1...l?f ~ 0.v~ )~rr;o :---- fi R" F f t;t\ f11" ( O'lil{({lfH()Alt~ Ov\[A,~~y ~o()fi~ ~b{E WE Ilfl. t 14 pRot.(() v..~\T). wf VI 1/ E lAJe 1'r1..t w'" Pr'\{ LV . L. (x ff) Iv '"' A (> () (; q, ( ( f 17 II ,R/Vll~(;.S k,ffJf:t'r. +l.t c, fy 0 { ('1VO WE ......,l.I ,,~ '7 'fpo ft.i '1 fk pt v e ^' 74 II ft IJJ. CO t.l1V 70' M CJt irv~ 7~IJO' /) to ~ ~rtl ]1;. u,) r ~ 1\ C/t,vfliJrnpJf $~fI...J(Jr D~ ../::f fob- }Vor.) 7(O} 1 flU () <e/ Lv..{ flf' AMIf r: toE Pr",II.ECeH€ <:f. '1 r ~ WDttUtf ~o Cft fl...... ~ rl\lft~ .J ..[ I~ {[p ~'f ~ a. '1() 7t ~ Y IR. P.JF Ur)(;c7 6 Q[['( fl.t CI fy e { ~(~ R'i<.y ~oOJO~ ~b(E 7()M. ., It {;./P/ (f !'('oil.v 7 0 ()O (fv,,,, t) (J{{)1) u......t7 kI )."rJ ( u.-v..J ../::f ~Db- 0v~ '7 ~ rC,o 7/0) t{ot A 9f~ ~ ..----- tJo r.J ( O""'"'llfHoJVt~ ('{ '[..,tlO PI'.J E..... 71{!\ ~ w. Co u...... rK'( M 1;)1. J'r,J~ ?1Ij{). WF tf{t 14 "Rou,e Ci UJ ~ ~ft f 1 fLIJO lA."'I/>' wf t4 II e ntV f~1f t.t9!: It~ Ut"" 11 j) rfj rJI LV': It'''l ~1fu..,JoY- "i 1M.{ l.V . l (x fo Iv '" Pr c;. () (i Q.. ( fJAJ fK A "~,, 17 (f 15 Il , Rlv Il~ c;.s lout: ^"n~c('HE 't ~.JfJ~(r. wE ...Hl.I H ~ r"'lff~ .,) '1 r 4t.t. w~C{{;tf 7 "'fpo(tl ...[ I ~ fk '11/0 C~ fr~ 1 {k py""a 7{} 7t. ~ y lP. p..U ficf) ~c7 6 u. lr '( j~ Cdy e{ 1()f~ .,. ftww(f /(b4~ 7000 ffVltA- l) (J ( () V lA,r' f7 ;{:I )..l'! ( lMA.J !If v~ '17((;0 :.--- gCB tJr..... fM. ~ tJ I\) ~oofi~M(E (O~A4.ffHoAl~~ ../::f fDLr jVC lJ 7/0) { ~ t,D 0 Pl'1I EIv T~f\ ~ UJ' CO u..... w( M (h Jt,)~ fJI/(). WF 1If{!:: 14 pRoL(.() l.\.JJITf. LDf PI H E L\9t: ft"-'f w'"' 't1.{ l.V . l (x fD fy fJ A G. () G <t ( If I~ ,., ,R(V/l~(>'E to~ 1<.oJ IJ F: t (. o tV tI ~rt, 1 fq; () n \.\) r~ I( CIt,vI1.ou;~J e>RU...JO'1 DAJ ct t.v..{ fit A tJ~'* r: ^,,'~8C(lHE c:f- wE "<J~(.l"b ~ r~.+t-f ..) ~ I~ fk Fy IV Q r () 'I t.. ~ '1 r ~ WDC([;ef 'I1io Cct f,;""" 7 '1 po (t i '1 fk y ~ p,.Rr fl.cf" {;cT 6 u.[(r 10t+'. >of 1t;1).Ip;(f /{o4N 7 {JOO (fCJtu. I) fJ ( U V IA.... 11 kI U ( lMM/I 61 v~ )}{(;fJ :......----- it t P" c~ J;)c/,u ~oOJO~ "'tHE fl.t c fy ~ { ( OttllA.llfH()Nt~ ..# rob- }Vor,) 7(0) Of" e..... 711J\ '" w. Co u",... Wr M lIh }'r.J~ J~/JO' WE ~f\t /4 pRoLl() IJ..IJ\Tf. wE l4 R c l.o\9t:: It/L.t w= rt'\{ l.V . l (-( f(;) f'1 ,., A G. () (; ct ( ( f 17 " ,R/Vll~b;.E wE XoJfJfEtr. b ?'Ilftv{ wi ..( I~ f[p pYIV a. 'f f) 'I t- ~ ( 'I t,CI 0 wE ......l1l.1l.11 $ ~po Itl 1 {k YlIIPJF ow .v ~fU 1 f4J () JClJ,) r~1( CIt,vIi.orhP)} ~RU..Jo'r bN <:f lAJ..{ f If A /JAil 17 p.",i,/l..ECeH€ </. '1 r ~ WDC4..Utp ~o Cft fr~ aNn;c76u.[(j 7DJ+\ -t ft~PI(f 7000 u."" 17 {Ilv~ T b1 Y I{. & f $ f( (tV f.(o()JO~ "'b(E (O'ill"'ll fsr()iVt~ t~ c. Iy tJ! /(b4.v (j(U() kfur ~ ) } rr;o ---- ( fu,tA- A.> J:i fo 2,- j./o \J rlO) f)t oJ E.v 7411.1\" VJ' CO U.IV 70- c1J 4h ^,)~ JJIJ(). ('f '(,,00 WF H{e: 14 pRotl.() lJ..IJITf. wf &Ill/I: l-\9r= Prtt..t w,: It'\{ lAJ . L (t f& fy ~ A c;. 0 G 4. ( ( f 17 " , RI V Il ~ '-E I/o; ME t {. wE ..... I>t( ~ tl ~ ?'\fftt-{ wi " I~ f[p Fy {Io/ a r {} 'I t. ~ 7 '1 po f{ I '1 fk Y III p..U () IjJ .v ~rU 1 Itv {) ;e I.\J r~ I( Clt;ll1JJfhp)} ~Ru...Jo"/" /)1;) "" Lv..{ f If A hI '* f: to!: fIlJ"n.~C(lHe <t '1 'r G4. WDt{Vef 'Ilia cc( f/~ u~jJ~c76u.{('( l{<: e7'( o'^ q p,,,,,,Cf f/ t"l. ~ Ii .... r~ ;l:t ~"J ,....; 14 v V" -f b..1 Q - M fl'fo ~ ? (') 1)00 9(\}/J tv OIJ 7 (0) fl.q /{o,",~,JW C {y 1 P1 v~ V--\ Cj ('t'VOD lJ1 _ Cot.l..tl1~ ltuJ. (Ju. "'v........s..-I,JI\~ )~fff) /)9A4 ~ K. NYAYO(. w.-R- P[({t~""". wE ~~e C(A{}I;"/Jc1(!J f w A.fJ tvov'r"f eI J.(cuM ( 'U.tel DIv W\rrl~ lJ(4Ae! ,..,'ow i~ i 6.. '\.U ( If. ",I .....fa<< ~.; .-)/ &.) y t,/lM . U)t (}J P 10 u'4 fk~ f fiw LI q"" o R </( . ~ · V ~HU.~ 011 -r~ p l.~~ u..J~ DtJ~ C /1M. to~(f{ 10 I\l <tJ, r l' ~ lo.t " a ? rR' r . { L. ,. '" ~NtTr ~ tI,~ ,N C- 11..+ _"",of.. I'''' fli. II...-{ ,/9 ..".u.. ~ "~1.)..W" 'fo Q f "...1 J .w.. cOQ R"'E i "f pot f.. P Jl).".,.,r II., 'll. [. t.f,o<, ,{ 4< ,i'''; u> ."D(~ 6-( ~fN' c. <tL~ .", f(, ~ff'H7fwt1 I flit"'" / j5--- 1 D W. '" It ~p.I Cf Hoi,~ 7 () 00 (fCittd) fJ ( v 0 U'" t 7 ;f ~I!> ( l..W.A// fA V~ ) ~ .t ~ \J ~~O~tFf ~o~~ M(E WE flf\t; 14 ,Rot(() \.\. ~\Tf. wf f/1R s ~!: !rfl..f w~ Pr^-! "V . l- (-( 1f) fv to''' G.() G C{.( ( f I 5 " ,A(VrL~b.E /loJ IJf:: t 'r. +~ (I'y () [ (iit,'O WE ..... 1)1.1 ~ b ~ 't po fl"~ '1 fk { OfY,CA.llfHoAl!'( iii' II e Iv 71U\ It UJ' CO t.l1V;<<'( M (Jt J'rv~ f~llo. OW v ~~, ../::f ~Ob- JUO IJ 7/0) 1 fw rJ J1; l.\) r~ If (It;' fI J)rh,J f ~~U.oJ()'r D~ <::f t.v...{ fK A b~1f f: w!' f'r~,~EC(lHE tt '1 r cau.. wOctvtf ~o Crt f/~ b r".t~ .J ~ I ~ flD P'fIJO 1() rt ~ Y lP. p..RF PAUL GINSBERG, M.D. JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR C, MANIAR, M,D. HARVEY D. SCHWARTZ, M.D. ISLON SELIGER, M.D. BRUCE ZARET, M.D. JEFF M. STEINBERG, M.D, MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D. VEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M.D, ERIC F. CILIBERTI, M.D. SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP NEUROLOGY November 3, 2003 To Whom It May Concern; BARRY J. CUTLER, M.D. RICHARD p, SINGER, M.D., FAAN. JILL S. LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A. HERRERA, M.D. GERALD S. GOLDBERG, M.D. T ANUSHREE ROY, M.D, RICHARD TIEGEN, D,M.D,. A.P, RHONDA Q. FREEMAN, PSY. D. EDUARDO CUTIE, M.D, My wife and I love Aventura. We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago. But we almost could not live here. My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modern orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sabbath and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island. It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten years had grown to such a degree that we have outgrown our quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place of worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the Island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful of the rules on the island. The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for Aventura. His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of proof that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed. Respectively yours, Barry J. Cutler, M.D. CI/20031103-047/BJC 4925 Sheridan Street, Suite 200, Hollywood, Florida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation, Florida 33317 16800 NW 2"' Avenue, 306, Miami, Florida 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue, 206, Plantation, FL 33324 Phone: (954) 981 3850 Phone: (954) 437 4000 Phone: (954) 321 1776 Phone: (305) 652 3062 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax: (954) 981 3889 Fax: (954) 433 5257 Fax: (954) 321 1885 Fax: (305) 653 7046 Fax: (954) 452 5872 Roberta Mendez Subject: Rachel Reinberg [anthrorn@yahoo.coml Wednesday, November 12, 2003 8:15 AM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohenk@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofaventura,com The Synogogue @ Williams Island From: Sent: To: Dear Mr. Mayor and City Commissioners, As a resident of Williams Island, I am writing this letter to voice my support for the new synagogue location on Willims Island. I personally have been a member of the shul since it began ten years ago, I remember a time when we had no permanent facility and relocated often from various apartments to the island club. We were greatful to move to our current location in the 2000 building. However, over the. past decade we have grown as a congregation and have outgrown our current space. This is not a problem, but a blessing. We have not grown because the popularity of our shul has spread outside of our community to the greater community at large. We have grown because members like myself have grown, married, and started families of our own. In addition, new and residents and old have heard of our wonderful shul and now attend regularly. Because we are a small orthodox synogoue on a small residential island we are self limited in our capacity for growth. We will never attract throngs of people to our congregation. We simply need more space to accomodate our growing families and growing community. My 9 month old son has attended services at the Williams Island synogogue every Saturday since he was 2 weeks old. He is often affectionatly referred to as the shul mascot. There he gets to experience his culture first hand along side holocost survivors and Jews from many other countries often whom were persecuted for their beliefs back in their countires of origin. He will grow up learning the lesson of what it means to be a Jew and unfortunatly that it often accompanies hatred, predjudice, and persecution. However, let him learn that from the stories of those who have already lived these awful truths. Please, do not let him experience it first hand by denying him an adequate palce to observe his religion due to the baseless and illogical opposition from a few members of this community. If not for me or the other members of our community, please act on behalf of the children of the Williams Island Synogoue. Thank you very much for your time. Once again, I beg you to do the right thing. Sincerely, Jay Reinberg, MD Do you Yahoo!? Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard http://antispam,yahoo.com/whatsnewfree 1 ~JI).;J.003 Ylh/47lfr1. ~ ;~~ ~t~ I q;wo Jf'~ ~ tMiJ~ ~/~ ;>~/g6 12.v>>v'lwv' ~ ~AAU~ ~.idtr fAU0.l~ fvrkfr~~ . O.JM/ ~~~F ~ ~~~..4v~- ~~ ~.J:c~ . 7Jr.e-- &tA..(../ ~fA.AV' .A-o ~~~~~~~~ ~1AAv~~/~ ~~~~~. ~1lw o.MMl4f ~ lAA..t-4.0fu..::t ~ ~~~~~ f'LJ. ~ ~ ~~~..W~~-,-",-~ /~a~ ~) 31) 2J')Ci3 '/7VJ/.1z/ ~Jv Ce --?'Vl '1'"".( ;1L11,t!..J...~/ % i (1u;E.^~~) ~)vr)~cJ: r!u.W./ /q ;>.00 :Pt~ ~1 CkJ-i/JpAAJV ~};MhVl~dfJ...., 53/~6 tlvuJ ~. rlw-ll~~/ JkvON/J.;Jivl;/f\! ~ Jd1 r c ~ ~~~ J, xIvJ pr~J~ . r OJ>>JM~ _~A~ ftYI~rV-/~~ Lv~~ Ai.v-~- ~~~)~/~~. ~~ Q/ kOU A11e~/)10tM--- . :>>-~ M-U __V Ii.vtV CUt{/A-() /h-UJfl1(f .~-o ('~ ~ A-d~ :aRM.) ~~~ ~ ~~4/J~~~}~./ ~AA-RA./ ~AJJAt /Yh-uJJ /r,~- O-1J.j/))O~. ~ :4Ja/l.&~r~ vw-td1v +~./ $~./.U Q/1'I4 :z;L;,..J ~ a-,/lMJ'j rv-~J f'44~Jfv1i-u /h-J/~);~/ArI E..v WJtMJ ~-~J-' /f&i~ r./v~ ~v/ Mve ~.-~J,../ *k . ~vM;t/Jc rXQA/11/ f-j~U/>1^V 1/1~ &aJ.v,) ~ I, aZ (')03 , r;v~'~~ R, ~~J LA '). -. ".....B~-uv' eM 1 a~iLAJ0J.) .~A't_~h-A CvliJ1) , / q :20(') i.J/ed ~,JJ,1 dLliffi,y~~ f1~IAAU 4~-<-Jl, 33/ go I ~J'-j?1A.f3~/ L / :lh/ r;t,N) ~ X:o ka ~J-LI A-MJJJ!1hVV-~ f v .... ;Uv fr~~~.tAV~ArA t-. OJJJ\JWn~~..(W . ~~J/h1~j 1J2MAJ aJq1 cMJ-(~~J-{/ ~ J:tv~4f~.vfJ r~r~~{~~~~~ aJtv,,~- ~/ CJJLlJ .4e~.{ ~ ~~ a-n~7 ~~ wi1k4) ./ULdu~) h.~v ~~1 :d-eJ~~~J ~~M-U /1; ./n1-UJ.Jv />1-ud.ut . oJJ>>r) ()/td~ .~~CtA~~ r/::tv ~ ~/ 9f- .d.l{4/MA/~:f ~ IL~ -oQ/ tV ffiA1 rU'l ~L,-j r.J:1u~,k j1tv CiAAJ;ffi\1 ~j7wF~ . t '}fv~.uru~~~ ~..u?1..4U0 * . r~.r"'7 'r; y ~W>tU er CQ;J:i~v,) '3 t ) ;z.(JC 3 ~. 1(J./\) U/>'1.J ~''11/..Y\.''_AM..{)/YlJ.JIj C.A-trJ 1 ~~X-V-RJ ~j~~ ~JU\) /9 ;ZOO Ph.d &-u-'~1 t1ltl-fr/}.Jvw-L ~A-vtU) 4~lOv 33 I ~ ~~ '-trl-i /; rYh_~..,j )f-J!/(M.VJJ}A~ -J:o:tj~~~ ~/~~~k~{-w- ~)?T~~j~~~~- 0>>))/ Ir~ ~ .~ A1/)~~ ~'~--rvr! /If-UuvJ/ a"";f ~ J,M/V ~dJ kh-c) /<ZrfftM./' {>dJ-UJ- f~-OJ ~~( Aj ~h C{,~L~ aibn. ~d' /f:&aAV~~)M.(... A--()/.n1~ .~ ,t~ ~,~du;df~J ~AY>'~ ~< ~J~ )j;)A/n/./..4VJ) cd~~.J ~/ ~~~-v j\JffiAj/Yl1,u./.A,.J /'YIJU-e. .Jd . . -I- L" ~ (j OAiv.)O~ ,'XAe-/u>-{) IF~~.Av ~ ~.J :;r--~./.. cv.u:f.-iLAJ ~ cc, fV-V11 rvJ ~fv;Uv~~~xj~ Uv0~~. ~ 4-uruc~ ~-4-<J ~-~J .1f/uX- . ~J;.u.e{ iafr~~..u~ ~)1/J .20(J.{ '1?vu- &t ~v~,{ ~-1'YV~.J 0ty f ~:&v ~~ CeJw /9:z.oo:Jt~ ~~ CU.t2~ ~;:w.AJ) 4~"tcv ~ 3 I gO /yLM) Wvt-. 11v~ ffUOJV/ J{/JIf:1-/t:; ~ r"r{ ~./JJfnAJV':-1"v_~J JiJJ 7t~~~~.tr~1. OJ>>.) ~ j-M/~ ~-Y0jf?Y'~r! ru-~ evv.!) ~Lv~u M/J~4~ r-~/- +-&A~- Ov ~/~~~1 -r&: .i:o C/J--&UV ~h/ML - ?f..u cv,.L/ _ Mv,.-e) t:M..e fi{) /?Yl4'/fl;i ~-o w{ 2i~ Mi,vlu ffi/V h~ Q/n-i'.'{ k~ -1:..J;/,V~~ ~y.k-fUV~ Cu,v ,/l0-Jj ,;rndv' /Yl.QvM + (j O.Ji>>)O~ ~~e.o CVLb;to-o fA_~-U ~vf-~-)pr~~ Ano{ ~ P-/tV /'J1(j ~~.-vf/;au~-i-1M CA^AVrt ~~lt..- :?1:u ~~ ~vGA/~ .~.{j/):;( ~ ./vrl/--(JJJJ\/ 4f'L/ - ~Jj~~~ c1~ r-;/k~~ efJ! ~) 3/1 :zoo3 ~~/ .Jku\J1 ~!J-Cd- ~Jm'~/f\)/'.J ~~ 1 ~J&j;JA/JJ }j~'flVyy,v/Jf\j; ~Jjh) . /92.00 ;Jf-df ~ ~IYJJUI;e/ ~,a)J 4~ 331 FrO Ifbv,J~' ~rU1J~1 :>>:VAM/~ ,;t.id1'~UV1~./ ~>>~F );tv Jtf/;~,J~ ~r~' (}MJ H .J,4.~~h AJVv..~-U/~.//l'l"~ ~~0n4 ~ ~A~J.U~JdJ.J;/lj ~ ~rv~-i.~1o 'V~ ~~,d-' h OJi.JAkJr.,rJJ ,~ WJ.&A{) /HiJv1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ";lIfu..J .t.~~../;~ -1.J;t-U .~~ ~~/ ,L:v~ ~iV.R/ ~ /J'Y1~/rI~' 011>>) r2A~j ~~M/ tYJ/:J+o ~/ J:o ~J ~J J1-Jl.uftv^AJJ~4 ~d ~ ~ IV /\~1 rd ~ fvxlv /h..&w..bh4/-jaVJ UA-A./\M1.t -~~. Jfv~~r~~~~~ *. ~~ t~r4~~ fZ.r ~~) 3/} :<003 ~.. ~(j .~/1A^.-J ~~.vv ~'i~~ Aj~~,d f.0r11w /9 ::!.oo :Jr-t<2i 6.um>>'f tk/;J ;JJ1MJ.u ~~v..4.) 14~ .3 3 I f1() &{)jj '17'L1J/. .k-i4,Amd1/'flJ Jff/MV~~1jJ -:to felt ~~J>.Jh'7'~/V~ DeJ /tAjJc~~.!r~' ()J>>J-I~ ~~kJ. ~fw4 r~ J]/nVJ!~-A~~1uU 4v~'-V flAJ-W 'f~~/~/ t~/n4~f 1, ~ .J;; Ov ~r ~~.J:L' 7n/ (JJ,lj ~fl4 ~.J CV..f/.4-1J //Yi.-a/f"-:i ffi-ko J-AJ1l1JMJ A/'J~ -rtJU~) ".~~ Cl--r-~ -Lt~~ 4;[)v ./~J cd1b.~A-L1 ~./~ CVLL-- ~~.~~.. . 011-1-1>) ~i . Mhk-o~;t ~J ._~~/ :;rJJ~-"'J~vef iVh~.i:L-~ .vv v '"7 r ~/ rl1v />M"'~dl-1J,.u ~/1M:f~J!..' 7t~ ~~r A/~~-VvV~_~iWJ\/ 4f1;j - ~J1>>jp4 ""-M(/t~ ~ Page 1 ofl From: Maureen 0 Date: Saturday, October 25, 20032:31:51 PM To: Rerlow j@citvofaventura.com Subject: Shool Wm. Island. Dear Mayor Perlow, I live on Wm. Island for about 12 years and during that time have attended .services here, which quite frankly I hope to continue. It would be a tragedy not to have the Shool here as in the past. It enhances the life here on Wm. Island. Hope you will give this your immediate and urgent attention. Many thanks, Yours truly,.. .Maureen O. molady@bellsouth.net Florida USA. 10/25/2003 d\ b \"\. ~WC\ . Page I 01 I 07~o I wish to expiain how important it is to have a Shoal here on Wm. Island where I have lived and attended services for a number of years. It would be very sad to ioose this very important addition to Wm. Island. Please give this matter your utmost attention for which we will all be grateful. It truly enhances our life here. Best wishes, Maureen astra... Maureen a. molady@bellsouth.net Florida USA. 10/25/2003 From: Maureen 0 Date: Saturday, October 25,2003 2:36:04 PM To: auerbachz@cityofaventura.com Subject: Shool Wm. Island. Page 1 of 1 Dear Commissioner Auerbach, I am very concerned concerning the buldng of a Shool here on Wm. Island. Having lived here for 12 years I would be very upsert if for some reason we could not build a Shool here. It is of great value to us and enhances our life here on the Island. Please give this matter your u1most attention and cooperation.lre~ Yours sincerely, Maureen Ostro... Maureen O. moladv@bellsouth.net Florida USA. .... ~U-rBe1\~\ .\. - 10/25/2003 Dear Bob, I want to tell you how important it is Island. I have been attending services came to live here. I think it would be be able to construct same. It enhances our lifestyle here and I involved in this matter will give it operation. Yours sincerely, Maureen ostro.~~ Maureen O. molady@bellsouth.net Florida USA. to have a synagogue here every Shabbath a great loss should page 1 or 1 on Wm. since I we not sincerely hope you and all your utmost attention and co- ~lIn~l (~ 7f;~ n. """. @., """'{@.~ {~tgb~ ~' 10/25/2003 Page 1 of 1 ';1_: 1Ita<utUK 0 ZJ...u: s~. O~ 25. 2003 3:14:50 P?1t 7.: ~@~.CtUK SJpa: 59""9.9'" '3fIiLti4.wu 1da.d. Z)eMe~e~, '7 a.m ~ to. ad ~ ~ ~ de sMot.~. ~~ twed ku ~ a. ~ 01 ~ a.H-d ~ ~ ~. '7t ~ k. a. ~ If.Ot. to. Ita.tte a. ~ ~ a.4- it ~ (U(/t etI4tf 01 ti5e. ~ u de '7~ a.d ~ fuoIde. ~it. 7~~Ut~~~~~. ~ea~, ~O<<M ~, ?1ta.wtee#t ()d1w... ?1t~ (). ~~.fU.t ?ttYri.da. 'USrt. - .. YI~r"""""" i"-"!.....,_,..._~.;-, I..':'IJ.~~~~~~.. '.".\\~.i~\ -~~.~ ',~ ~~-~ ,..-.........._..-.,-.e>\.J'..- ~ 10/25/2003 page 1 01 1 From: Maureen 0 Date: Saturday, October 25, 20033:04:43 PM To: beskini@citvofaventura.com Subject: Shool Wm. Island. Dear Commissioner Beskin, I wish to explain how important it is for us to have a Shool on Wm. Island whre I have lived and attended services for a number of years, It would be very sad to loose this very important addition to our Island. Please give this matter your urgent and kind attention fr which we will all be truly grateful. It truly enhances our way of life here. Best wishes and many thanks, Yours sincerely, Maureen Ostro... Maureen 0, molady@bellsouth.net FloridaUSA. ... ~u-re;el\:~ ._~ ~ 10/25/2003 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16, 2003 Mr. JefferyM. Perlow Mayor City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A venturalDade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue at Williams Island with intermittent attendance to. other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in fonner. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island community point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property.value of OUf homes. I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of A ventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in Williams Island. \1JRourn, Benjamin~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd Aventura, FL 33160 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16,2003 Mr. Zev Auerbach Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A ventura/Dade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue at Williams Island with intenn.ittent attendance to other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in former. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island community point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property value of our homes. I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of Aventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in Williams Island. \Sirr~urs, ~jamin~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd Aventura, FL 33160 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16, 2003 Mr. Jay R. Beskin Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A venturalDade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue.at Williams Island with intermittent attendance to other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in former. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island cornmunity point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property value of our homes. I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of A ventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in Williams Island. \rr~urs, Benjamin~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd A ventura, FL 33160 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16,2003 Mr. Ken Cohen Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A ventura/Dade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue at Williams Island with intennittent attendance to other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in former. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island community point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property value of our homes. I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of A ventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in.Williams Island. \JK:urs, Benjamin~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd A ventura, FL 33160 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16,2003 Mr. Bob Diamond Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A venturalDade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue at Williams Island with intermittent attendance to other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in former. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island community point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property value of our homes, I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of Aventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in Williams Island. ~:r~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd Aventura, FL 33160 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16, 2003 Mr. Harry Holzberg Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A venturalDade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue at Williams Island with intermittent attendance to other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in former. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island cornmunity point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property value of our homes. I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of Aventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in Williams Island. tr?K~ ~aminKUdary ~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd A ventura, FL 33160 Williams Island Synagogue 01 October 16, 2003 Mr. Manny Grossman Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 RE: WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE Dear Mr. Perlow: I understand there is an upcoming vote regarding the construction of an Orthodox Synagogue in Williams Island. I felt compelled to write this short letter as a Jewish resident of A venturalDade County since 1983. In the 20 years my family has been full time residents in this neighborhood; we have been members of the Orthodox synagogue at Williams Island with intennittent attendance to other Orthodox synagogues in the area for lack of adequate space in former. The distance to these other places of worship is rather long for daily or even weekly attendance. From the Williams Island community point of view, I think it will have a positive appeal to many to have a synagogue in the premises, and maybe even help in raising the property value of our homes. I must add that I've had the privilege to see the proposed designs for the synagogue's interior and they are truly remarkable. Thus, as a resident of Williams Island in the City of A ventura, I want you to know that I support the construction of such a synagogue as it is being proposed. It would be very convenient for my family and other Orthodox Jewish families in Williams Island. Sincere~, B~Jin\~ Apt 705 3000 Island Blvd A ventura, FL 33160 I November 10th, 2003 A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend tbis synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuI. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Address:39~ /SL..A.torV I?/ tlD.. A tr J-jDIo (3 -14 tJetJT ~4 J FA. 33/1, () I Roberta Mendez From: Sent: To: Subject: Cynthia Morison Monday, November 03, 2003 9:39 AM Jules Trump FW: FOR JULES-RE: NOV 12 AVENTURA COUNCIL MEETING ~. 1:!J ~. ~ Westlaw_DocumentSummarv_21_12_ 4 _21_12_41_2160... 1_2160.doc (2 K... FYI -----Original Message----- From: Lesli KRoss [mailto:leslik@bellsouth.net) Sent: Saturday, November 01, 2003 9:25 PM To: cmorison@williamsisland.com Subject: FOR JULES--RE: NOV 12 AVENTURA COUNCIL MEETING Jules-- Larry Metsch provided me with the attached document on RLUIPA. similar (if not the same) information' as the ODe you received 11m forwarding it in case it would also be helpful. Lesli It probably contains in shul this morning, but ----- Original Message ----- From: <westlaw@thomson.com> To: <leslik@bellsouth.net> Sent: Thursday, October 30, 2003 10:12 PM Subject: Westlaw E-mail > (C) 2003 West, a Thomson business. Copyright is not claimed as to any > part of the original work prepared by a U.S. government officer or employee as part of that person's official duties. All rights reserved. Use of the Westlaw data delivered to your e-mail address is governed by the Westlaw Subscriber .Agreement or such other agreement as may govern your use of Westlaw data. > > > 1 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) H Uuited States District Court, S.D. New York. WESTCHESTER DAY SCHOOL, Plaintiff, v. VILLAGE OF MAMARONECK, the Board of Appeals of the ViJlage of Mamaroueck, Mauro Gabriele, George Mgrditcbian, Peter Jackson, Barry Weprin and Clark Neuringer, in Their Official Capacity as Members of the Board of Appeals of the ViJlage of Mamaroneck, and Antouio V ozza, in His Official Capacity as a Former Members of the Board of Appeals of the ViJlage of Mamaroneck, Defendants. No. 02 CIV.6291 WCC. Sept. 5, 2003. As Amended Nunc Pro Tunc Oct. 1,2003. Religious day school brought action against village, its zoning board of appeals (ZBA), and zoning board members, alleging defendants imposed unlawful and unconstitutional burdens on school to obstruct school's right to construct new school buildings. On operator's motion for summary judgment, the District Court, William C. Conner, Senior District Judge, held that: (1) Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIP A) was constitutional; (2) denial of permit substantially burdened exercise of religion under RLUIP A; and (3) complete denial of application was not based on compelling governmental interests. Motion granted. ill Zoning and Planning €=601 414k601 Federal courts should not become zoning boards of appeal to review land use determinations. ill Civil Rights €=100S 78kl005 Section of Religious Land Use and Institutiona1ized Persons Act (RLUIP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting Page 1 government to make individualized assessments was valid exercise of Congressls enforcement powers under Section 5 of Fourteenth Amendment as applied to Free Exercise Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Amends. 1, 14; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of2000, 9 2, 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000cc. ill Constitutional Law 18:=84.5(18) 92k84.5(18) ill Constitutional Law 18:=274(3.1) 92k274(3.1) Section of Religious Land Use and Institutiona1ized Persons Act (RLUIP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make individualized assessments was valid exercise of Congress's enforcement powers under Section 5 of Fourteenth Amendment as applied to Free Exercise Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Amends. 1, 14; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, 9 2, 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000cc. ill Civil Rights €=lOOS 78kl005 Section of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make individualized assessments was permissible exercise of Congressts broad power to act under the Commerce Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Art. 1. & 8. cl. 3; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of2000, 9 2, 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000cc. ill Commerce €=82.20 83k82.20 Section of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make indiVidualized assessments was permissible exercise of Congress's broad power to act under the Commerce Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Art. 1. & 8. cl. 3; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, 9 2, 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000cc. ill Commerce €=S6 83k56 Operating an orthodox Jewish day school was an Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 -- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y,)) economic endeavor within the meaning of the Commerce Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Art. I. Q 8. cJ. 3. ru Civil Rights €=>1005 78kl005 Section of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUlP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make individualized assessments does not violate Establishment Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 1; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, {1 2 et seq., 42 u.S.C.A. Q 2000cc et seq. ru Constitutional Law €=>84.S(18) 92k84.5(l8) Section of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUlP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make individualized assessments does not violate Establishment Clause. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. I; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, {1 2 et seq., 42 U.S.C.A. Q 2000cc et seq. ill Civil Rights €=>100S 78kl005 Section of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUlP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make individnalized assessments, because it is valid enactment pursuant to Congressls powers under Commerce Clause and Section 5 of Fourteenth Amendment, does not violate the Tenth Amendment. U.S.C.A. Const.Art. 1. Q 8. cJ. 3; U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 14; Religious Land Use and InstitutionaIized Persons Act of 2000, {1 2 et seq., 42 U.S.C.A. Q 2000cc et seq. ill States €=> 4.16(1) 360k4.16(l) Section of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUlP A) applying when substantial burden is imposed on religious assembly or institution as result of land use regulation permitting government to make individualized assessments, because it is valid enactment pursuant to Congress1s Page 2 powers under Commerce Clause and Section 5 of Fourteenth Amendment, does not violate the Tenth Amendment. U.S.C.A. Const.Art. 1. Q 8. cJ. 3; U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 14; Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, {1 2 et seq., 42 U.S.C.A. Q 2000cc et seq. ill States €=::> 4,4(1) 360k4.4(]) If a power is delegated to Congress in the Constitution, the Tenth Amendment expressly disclaims any reservation of that power to the States. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 10. rn Civil Rightll €=::>1032 78kl032 For a burden on religion to be substantial, within meaning of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUlP A), the government regulation must compel action or inaction with respect to sincerely held belief; mere inconvenience to the religious institution or adherent is insufficient. Religious Land Use and Institutiona1ized Persons Act of2000, {1 (a)(1), 42 U.S.C.A. Q 2000cc(a)(]). ill Civil Rights €=>1073 78kl073 Zoning board's complete denial of religious day school's application for modification of special use permit to construct new building and modify existing structures substantially burdened exercise of religion within meaning of Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIP A.); although students might continue to gather to pray and be educated without special permit modification, their religious experience was limited by current size and structural condition of school buildings, and school was entitled, within reason, to accommodate growing number of students. Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, {1 2 et seq., 42 U.S.C.A. Q 2000cc et seq. llQl Civil Rights €=>1073 78kl073 Under Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUlPA), village's traffic and parking concerns were not compelling interests that justified substantial burden on religious exercise caused by its complete denial of religious day school's application to construct new school building and renovate Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) existing buildings in questionable structural condition. Religious Laud Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, ~ 2 et seq., 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000cc et seq. West Codenotes Recognized as Unconstitutional 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000bb-1 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000bb-2 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000bb-3 42 U.S.C.A. & 2000bb-4 Morrison & Foerster, L.L.P. (Jack C. Auspitz, Esq., Joel C. Haims, Esq., Of Counsel), Bernstein, Liebhard & Lifshitz, L.L.P. (Stanlev D. Bernstei!!, Esq., Of Counsel), New York City, for Plaintiff. Thacher Proffitt & Wood, (Kevin J. Plunke!!, Esq., Lino J. Sciarretla, Esq., Darius P. Chafizadeh, Esq., Of Counsel), White Plains, NY, Law Offices of Joseph C. Messina (Joseoh C. Messina, Esq., Lisa M. Faulino, Esq., Of Counsel), Mamaroneck, NY, for Defendants. OPINION AND ORDER WILLIAM C. CONNER, Senior District Judge. *1 Plaintiff Westchester Day School ("WDS" or "plaintiff'), brings this action against defendants Village of Mamaroneck, the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Village of Mamaroneck ("ZBA"), Mauro Gabriele, Peter Jackson, James Galla, George Mgrditchian, Barry Weprin and Clark Neuringer, in their official capacity as members of the ZBA...fEM)J Plaintiff has moved for partial summary judgment nnder Fed. R. Civ. P. 56 on Connts I and II of their Amended Complaint. Connt I alleges that by not allowing WDS to nndertake the construction and renovations outlined in their special permit application ("Application"), defendants have imposed a substantial burden on the free exercise of religion by WDS, without any compelling government interest to do so, in violation of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, 42 U.S.C. & 2000cc et seg. ("RLUIPA"). Connt II of the Amended Complaint alleges that the decision to deny the Application was arbitrary and capricious and was not supported by evidence in the record and seeks Page 3 relief under the All Writs Act, 28 U.S.c. & 1651. For the reasons discussed below, plaintiffs motion for partial sununary judgment is granted. BACKGROUND The facts concerning this action are set forth in the Court's Opinion and Order of December 4, 2002 (the "Order"), Westchester Dav School v. Villar" of Mamaroneck. 236 F.Snuo.2d 349 rS.D.N.Y.2002), and familiarity with that decision is presumed. The facts pertinent to the instant motion are as follows. The Court's prior Order held that the negative declaration (a determination by the ZBA that no significant adverse environmental impacts will result and that no Environmental Impact Statement process is required) was not properly rescinded and is still in full force and effect. Additional public hearings on the Application were then held in December 2002 and January, February and March 2003. On January 10, 2003, a conference was held before this Court, during which the Court directed the ZBA to give WDS a list of outstanding issues that were of concern to the ZBA and that might impede the issuance of the special permit modification to WDS. The ZBA provided WDS with its issues list on January 17, 2003 and WDS responded to each issue on January 30, 2003. (Hammerman Aff., Ex. B; Hammerman Aff.' 17.) At the public hearing on February 6, 2003, the ZBA indicated that they wanted to hold a special meeting to "wrap up" the Application and that it wanted to address only two remaining issues at that special meeting-one, the possibility of moving the new building (Gordon Hall) slightly further from the property line and, two, the overall square footage of Gordon Hall. (pI. Mem. Supp. Sunun. J. at 7.) The ZBA also asked to see a rear visual of Gordon Hall from Skibo Lane. At the hearing on March 13,2003, after a few hours of discussion and public conunent, the ZBA closed the public hearing and began its deliberations. (ld. at 8.) Just prior to the close of the public hearing, WDS asked the ZBA if there was anything else the ZBA wanted WDS to address, and the ZBA responded uo. (Hammerman Aff.' 19.) *2 The ZBA continued to deliberate over the next two months, including publicly on April 3, 2003, May 1, 2003 and May 13, 2003. On May 13, 2003, the ZBA voted 3-2 to adopt a resolution denying the Application in its entirety (the "Resolution"). (Hammerman Aff., Ex. E.) DISCUSSION Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) 1. Summary Judgment Standard Plaintiff moves for partial summary judgment pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56. Summary judgment may be granted "if the pleadings, depositions, answers to interrogatories. and admissions on fue, together with the affidavits, if any, show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law." Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c). The burden rests on the moving party to demonstrate the absence of a genuine issue of material fact. Celotex Corvo v. Catrett. 477 U.S. 317. 322. 106 S.Ct. 2548. 91 L.Ed.2d 265 (1986); Ticali v. Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklvn. 41 F.Suuu.2d 249. 254 rE.D.N.Y.1999). A genuine factual issue exists if there is sufficient evidence favoring the nonmovant for a reasonable jury to return a verdict in his favor. Anderson v. Libertv Lobbv. Inc.. 477 U.S. 242. 250. 106 S.Ct. 2505. 91 L.Ed.2d 202 (1986); Ticali. 41 F.SutJ1l.2d at 254. In deciding whether summary judgment is appropriate, the court resolves all ambiguities and draws all permissible factual inferences against the movant. See Anderson. 477 U.S. at 255. 106 S.C!. 2505. Summary judgment is warranted when the nonmovant has no evidentiary support for an essential element on which it bears the burden of proof. Celotex. 477 U.S. at 322-23. 106 S.Ct. 2548: Silver v. eitv Univ. of N.Y.. 947 F.2d 1021. 1022 (2d Cir.199n. II, Constitutionality ofRLUIPA ill Initially, we are mindful of the general proscription that federal courts should not become zoning boards of appeal to review land use det=inations. See Zahra v. Town of Southold. 48 F.3d 674 679-80 (2d Cir.1995) (quoting Sullivan v. Town of Salem. 805 F.2d 81. 82 (2d Cir.1986)). However, "federal courts may exercise jurisdiction in zoning matters when local zoning decisions, such as here, infringe national interests protected by statute or by the constitution. II Innovative Health Svs.. Inc. v. eitv of White Plains. 931 F.Suuu. 222. 234 (S.D.N.Y.1996). Defendants argue that plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgement should be denied on the grounds that RLUIP A is unconstitutional. We disagree. A. Background of RLUIP A On September 22, 2000, President Clinton sigued RLUIP A into law. There is little dispute that it was adopted in response to the Supreme Coures partial invalidation in 1997 of the Religious Freedom Page 4 Restoration Act of 1993 ("RFRA"), 107 Stat. 1488, 42 U.S.C. & & 2000bb-2000bb-4, in eitv or Boerne v. Flores 521 U.S. 507. 117 S.Ct. 2157. 138 L.Ed.2d 624 (1997). Freedom Bavtist Church of Delaware Count\! v. Townshiv of Middletown. 204 F.SUDD.2d 857. 861 rE.D.Pa.2002). In 1990, the Supreme Court decided Emvlovment Div. v. Smith 494 U.S. 872. 110 S.Ct. 1595. 108 L.Ed.2d 876 (990), which held that rights under the Free Exercise Clause do not I1relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a 'valid and neutral law of general applicability on the ground that the law proscribes (or prescribes) conduct that his religion prescribes (or proscribes).' " 1 d. at 879. 110 S.C!. 1595. The Court refused to apply the balancing test employed in Sherbert v. Verner. 374 U.S. 398. 83 S.Ct. 1790. 10 L.Ed.2d 965 (1963), which held that gove=ent actions that substantially burden a religious practice must be justified by a compelling governmental interest. Smith 494 U.S. at 883-84. 110 S.Ct. 1595. The Court concluded that Sherbert has been largely confmed to the context in which it was decided-denial of unemployment compensation-and that, in any case, its rule does not apply to neutral laws of general applicability. Id. at 879.110 S.Ct. 1595. *3 In direct response to Smith. Congress in 1993 enacted RFRA. The statute purported to codify the Sherbert test and to apply it to all government acts that 11 substantially burden'! religious exercise, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability. 42 U.S.c. & & 2000bb-l, 2000bb(b). Four years later, the Supreme Court struck down RFRA, at least as it relates to state and local governments, in ~ Boerne. Although Congress may enforce constitutional rights pursuant to Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment, the Court in eitv of Boerne concluded that RFRA exceeded that limited authority by, in effect, defining rights instead of simply enforcing them. RLUIP A was drawn in an attempt to achieve a constitutional balance. Elsinore Christian etr. v. eitv of Lake Elsinore. 270 F .Suuu.2d 1163. 1168 (C.D.CaI.2003). The "general rule" ofRLUIPA is the same as that provided by RFRA in that state action that Ilsubstantially burden[s]" religious exercise must be justified as the "least restrictive means" of furthering a I1compelling governmental interest. II See 42 U.S.C. & & 2000cc(a)(1), 2000cc-l(a). However, RLUIP A's provisions are more narrowly directed than those of RFRA. First, RLUIP A by its terms applies only to gove=ental action regarding land use or institutionalized persons. See 42 U.S.C. & & 2000cc, 2000cc-1. Second, within those categories, Copr. <1:l West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 ..- F,Supp.2d .... (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) RLUIP A applies only where the substantial burden is imposed: 1) in connection with a federally-funded activity; 2) where the burden affects interstate commerce; or, 3) with respect to land use decisions, where the burden is imposed in the context of a scheme whereby the state makes "individualized assessments" regarding the property involved. See 42 D.S.C. ~ & 2000ccla)12). 2000cc-J(b)' We turn now to the specific constitutional attacks defendants advance. B. Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment ill Defendants argue that RLUIP A exceeds Congress's power under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment.~ AF, noted above, Citv of Boerne held that the RFRA exceeded Congress's enforcement powers under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment. In order to determine whether RLUIP A is consistent with City of Boerne. it is appropriate to look to Justice Kennedis consideration of Congress's remedial powers, as they relate to the states, under the Fourteenth Amendment. Freedom BaDtist Church of Delaware Countv. 204 F.SUDD.2d at 872. Throughout his Opinion, Justice Kennedy went to great lengths to distinguish Congress's "power to. remedy" and the Court's power to define constitutiooal rights and "say what the law is." Marburv 1'. Madison. 5 D.S. 137. 1 Cranch 137. 2 L.Ed. 60 (] 803), AF, Justice Kennedy stated in !:In!..gf Boerne. Congress' power under ~ 5, however, extends only to "enforcing" the provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment .n The design of the Amendment and the text of ~ 5 are inconsistent with the suggestion that Congress has the power to decree the substance of the Fourteenth Amendment's restrictions on the States. Legislation which alters the meaning of the Free Exercise Clause cannot be said to be enforcing the Clause. Congress does not enforce a constitutional right by changing what the right is. *4 Otv ofBoeme. 521 U.S. at 519.117 S.Ct. 2157. The Freedom BaDtist Church of Delaware Countv court found this to be a crucial difference going back to Marburv. If Congress could by statute redefme the content of constitutional provisions, Marbun"s distinction between the Constitution as II superior paramount lawll and "ordinary legislative acts" would be obliterated. See Marburv. 5 U.S. at 177. 1 Cranch 137 (quoted in Cill' ofBoeme. 521 U.S. at 529.117 S.C!. 2157). AF, Justice Kennedy stated, "any suggestion that Congress has a substantive, non- remedial power under the Fourteenth Amendment is Page 5 not supported by our case law." Citv of Boerne. 521 U.S. at 527.117 S.Ct. 2157. The Court recognized that the distinction it was making based upon Marbury "hardly supplied a bright line for Courts." Freedom BaDtist Church of Delaware Countv. 204 F.SuDP.2d at 873. In Justice Kennedy's words, While the line between measures that remedy or prevent unconstitutional actions and measures that make a substantive change in the governing law is not easy to discern, and Congress must have wide latitude in detennining where it lies, the distinction exists and must be observed. There must be a congruence and proportionality between the injury to be prevented or remedied and the means adopted to that end. Lacking such a connection, legislation may become substantive in operation and effect. Citv ofBoeme. 521 U.S. at 519-20. 117 S.Ct. 2157. The fatal flaw with RFRA was, in the Majority's view, that the statute "appears, instead, to attempt a substantive change in constitutional protections." Id. at 532.117 S.Ct. 2157. Quoting from the Civil Rif?hts Cases. 109 U.S. 3. 3 S.c!. 18.27 L.Ed. 835 (1883), the Court noted that "[r]emediallegislation under ~ 5 'should be adapted to the mischief and wrong which the [Fourteenth] Amendment was intended to provide against.' " Otv of Boerne. 521 D.S. at 532. 117 S.C!. 2157. The Court further noted, by contrast, that the "RFRA is not so confined. Sweeping coverage ensures its intrusion at every level of gove=ent, displacing laws and prohibiting official actions of almost every description and regardless of subject matter." ld. According to the Freedom Baotist Church of Delaware Countv court, it is _ precisely at this point that RLUIP A critically differs from RFRA. In limiting its applicability outside of the Spending and Commerce Clauses to those cases where governments make "individual assessments rFN31," the statute draws the very line Smith itself drew when it distinguished neutral laws of general applicability from those "where the State has in place a system of individual exemptions, II but nevertheless "refuse[s] to extend that system to cases of rreligious -hardship.r II Smith. 494 U.S. at 884. 110 S.Ct. 1595: Freedom BaDtist Church of Delaware Countv. 204 F.SUDD.2d at 873. "The RLUIP A thus cannot be regarded as in any way hostile to Smith. as the RFRA undoubtedly was. II Freedom BaDtist Church of Delmvare Countv. 204 F.SUDD.2d at 873: see also Cottonwood Christian Ct,-. v. CVDress Redevelovment Aeencv. 218 F.SUDD.2d 1203 at 1221 IC.D.Ca1.2002) (holding that Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 221 10445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y,)) because RLUIP A is based on the Spending and Commerce clauses, and the codification of current precedent on individualized assessments, RLUIPA would appear to have avoided the flaws of its predecessor RFRA, and be within Congress's constitutional authority). *5 Nor is RLUIP A hostile to eft" of Boeme. Unlike the "sweeping coverage" of the RFRA that ensured that statute's "intrusion at every level of gove=ent, displacing laws and prohibiting official actions of almost every description and regardless of subject matters," City ofBoeme. 521 U.S. at 532.117 S.Ct. 2157. "the RLUIPA here is targeted solely to low visibility decisions with the obvious--and, for Congress, unacceptable--coucomitant risk of idiosyncratic application.!1 Freedom BODtist Church of Delaware County. 204 F.SUDD.2d at 873-74. The Freedom Eavtist Church of Delaware County court further reasoned that since RLUIP A's limitations and proscriptions codify firmly-established Supreme Court rights under its Free Exercise and Equal Protection jurisprudence, see id. at 870-72. it does not "attempt a substantive change in constitutional protections," that led to the demise of RFRA in City of Boeme. The new statute thus honors Marburv's distinction between the Constitution as "superior paramount law!! and lIordinary legislative acts." ld. at 874. Finally, to the extent that RLUIP A may cover a particular case that is not on all fours with an existing Supreme Court decision, "it nevertheless constitutes the kind of congruent and, above all, proportional remedy Congress is empowered to adopt under!i 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment." ld. In fact, the Supreme Court noted four years after City of Boeme that, "congress is not limited to mere legislative repetition of this Court's constitutional jurisprudence, but may also prohibit 'a somewhat broader swath of conduct.' " Bd. of Trustees of the Univ. of Alabama v. Garrett. 531 U.S. 356. 365. 121 S.C!. 955. 148 L.Ed.2d 866 (2001). And thus, unlike RFRA, RLUIP A does not "contradict [ ] vital principles necessary to maintain separation of powers and the federal balance." City ofEoeme. 521 U.S. at 536.117 S.Ct. 2157. We therefore conclude thatRLUIPA does not exceed Congress's power under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment. C. RLUIP A and the Commerce Clause ill Defendants also challenge the constitutionality of RLUIP A as violative of the Commerce Clause. In the Commerce Clause dimension, Congress's power over Page 6 economic activity remains extraordinarily broad. The Supreme Court in United States 1'. Morrison. 529 U.S. 598. 120 S.Ct. 1740. 146 L.Ed.2d 658 (2000) delineated a bright line between the exercise of Congress's Commerce Clause power in criminal cases versus its application in those acts involving regulation of economic activity. Quoting with approval its statement in United States v. Lovez 514 U.S. 549. 115 S.Ct. 1624. 131 L.Ed.2d 626 (1995) that "we have upheld a wide variety of congressional Acts regulating intrastate economic activity where we have concluded that the activity substantially affected interstate commerce," Morrison stressed that, "a fair reading of Lopez shows that the noneconomic, criminal nature of the conduct at issue was central to our decision in that case." Morrison. 529 U.S. at 610. 120 S.C!. 1740. Morrison then left no doubt that the economic regulatory regime inaugurated in Wickard 1'. Filburn. 317 U.S. 111. 63 S.C!. 82. 87 L.Ed. 122 (19421. remains very much alive: "Lopez's review of Commerce Clause case law demonstrates that in those cases where we have sustained federal regulation of intrastate activity based upon the activity's substantial effects on interstate commerce, the activity in question has been some sort of economic endeavor." Morrison. 529 U.S. at 611. 120 S.C!. 1740 (citing Lopez 514 U.S. at 559- 60. 115 S.Ct. 16241: see also Freedom Eaptist Church of Delaware County 204 F.SuDD.2d at 867. *6 ill We conclude that plaintiffs activities in operating an orthodox Jewish day school is an economic endeavor within the meaning of the Co=erce Clause. See us. v. Grassie. 237 F.3d 1199. 1209-10 (lOth Cir.200n (holding that religion and, in particular religious buildings actively used as the site for a full range of activities, easily falls within the holding of Camps Newfound/Owatonna. Inc. v. Town of Ha/7'ison. 520 U.S. 564. 584. 117 S.C!. 1590. 137 L.Ed.2d 852 (1997) that the Commerce Clause applies to charitable and nonprofit entities because they are major participants in interstate markets for goods and services, use of interstate communications and transportation, raising and distributing revenues (including voluntary revenues) interstate, and so on); United States v. Ballin"er. 312 F.3d 1264. 1282 (J lth Cir.20021 (holding that "[ c ]hurches are institutions that facilitate the interchange of ideas, goods and services across a religious community that may span multiple states, as well as between that community as such and the outside world. This is paradigmatic Icommerce.! "). Moreover, as subsection (a)(2)(B) on its face has an Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) interstate commerce jurisdictional element, defendants are reduced to questioning the Congressional fmdings here, just as the Supreme Court did in Morrison 529 U.S. at 614- 16. 120 S.Ct. 1740. See Freedom BaD!is! Church of Delaware Countv. 204 F.SUDD.2d at 867. However, as the Freedom Bantis! Church of Delaware Countv court observed, Whatever the true percentage of cases in which religious organizations have improperly suffered at the hands of local zoning authorities, we certainly are in no position to quibble with Congress's ultimate judgment that the undeniably low visibility of land regulation decisions may well have worked to undermine the Free Exercise rights of religious organizations around the country. Id. We therefore hold that RLUIP A is a permissible exercise of Congress's broad power to act under the Commerce Clause. D. Establishment Clause ill Defendants next charge that RLUIP A violates the Establishment Clause. The Establishment Clause of the United States Constitution provides that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment ofreligion ...." U.S. CONST. amend. J. In the seminal case, Lemon v. Kurtzman. 403 U.S. 602. 91 S.C!. 2105. 29 L.Ed.2d 745 (971). the Supreme Court established a three-prong test to determine if there is a violation of the Establishment Clause (the "Lemon Test"). The Lemon Test provides that: (1) the statute must have a secular legislative purpose; (2) the statute's principal or primary effect must be one that neither advances nor inhibits religion; and (3) the statute must not foster an excessive govemment entanglement with religion. Id. at 612-13. 91 S.C!. 2105. Defendants argue that RLUIPA fails under the Lemon Test. We disagree. The Lemon Test and the Establishment Clause call for neutrality. Gillette v. United States. 401 U.S. 437. 450. 91 S.C!. 828. 28 L.Ed.2d 168 (971) ("Necessarily, the constitutional value at issue is 'neutrality.' "). RLUll' A is neutral. It does not favor one religion over any other but applies equally to all religions. See Jimmv Swa~~art Ministries 1'. Bd. of Eaualization. 493 U.s. 378 110 S.C!. 688. 107 L.Ed.2d 796 (! 990) (holding that a rule that applies equally to all religions offends neither the Free Exercise Clause nor the Establishment Clause). Accordingly, the Court concludes that RLUll' A does not violate the Establishment Clause. Page 7 E. Tenth Amendment *7 lQ]Jl] Finally, defendants challenge the constitutionality of RLUIP A under the Tenth Amendment. The Tenth Amendment of the United States Constitution provides that "the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or the people." U.S. CONST. amend. X. In light of our above analysis concerning the Commerce Clause, defendants' argument fails. The Supreme Court has explained that "[i]f a power is delegated to Congress in the Constitution, the Tenth Amendment expressly disclaims any reservation of that power to the States. II New Y ark v. United States. 505 U.S. 144. 156. 112 S.Ct. 2408. 120 L.Ed.2d 120 (1992): Gref!on' v. Ashcroft, 501 U.S. 452. 460. III S.C!. 2395. 115 L.Ed.2d 410 (1991) ("As long as it is acting within the powers granted it under the Constitution, Congress may impose its will on the States. "); see also United States v. Jones. 231 F.3d 508. 515 (9th Cir.2000) ("[1]f Congress acts under one of its enumerated powers, there can be no violation of the Tenth Amendment. "). As explained above, RLUIP A is a valid enactment pursuant to Congress's powers under the Co=erce Clause and Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment and therefore does not violate the Tenth Amendment. See Mavweathers v. Terhune. 2001 WL 804140. at *7 m.D.Cal. Julv 2. 2001). ~ m.RLUlPA Having established the constitutionality of RLUIP A, we turn now to the issue of whether WDS has made a prima facie case that RLUIP A has been violated. To make such a showing, plaintiff must present evidence that defendants' conduct in denying the Application (I) imposes a substantial burden; (2) on the "religious exercise;" (3) of a person, institution or assembly. 42 U.S.C. & 2000co(a)(1). rFN51 If the plaintiff makes this prima facie showing, the hurden shifts to the local gove=ent to demonstrate that the land use regulation is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling interest.Id. at (A)-(B). ill The Supreme Court has articulated the substantial burden test differently over the years. See Lvne v. Northwest Indian Cemeterv Protective Ass'n. 485 U.S. 439. 450-51 108 S.Ct. 1319. 99 L.Ed.2d 534 (1988); Thomas v. Review Bd. of Ind. Emvlovment Sec. Div.. 450 U.S. 707. 718. 101 S.Ct. 1425.67 L.Ed.2d 624 (1981); Sherbert v. Verner. 374 U.S. 398.404.83 S.Ct. 1790. 10 L.Ed.2d 965 (1963). In lJ!n& the Supreme Court stated that for a Copr. <rJ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y,)) governmental regulation to substantially burden religious activity, it must have a tendency to coerce individuals into acting contrary to their religious beliefs. 485 U.S. at 450-51. 108 S.Ct. 1319: see also Thomas. 450 U.S. at 717-18.101 S.C!. 1425 (holding that a substantial burden exists where the gove=ent puts llsubstantial pressure on an adherent to modify his behavior and to violate his beliefs ...."). Conversely, a government regulation does not substantially burden religious activity when it has only an incidental effect that makes it more difficult to practice the religion. !!L Thirv v. Carlson. 78 F.3d 1491. 1495 (lOth Cir.1996). Thus, for a burden on religion to be substantial, the government regulation must compel action or inaction with respect to the sincerely held belief; mere inconvenience to the religious institution or adherent is insufficient. Werner l'. McCotter. 49 F.3d 1476. 1480 (lOth Cir.l995); Jolll' l'. Cou".hlin. 76 F.3d 468. 477 (2d Cir.1996). District court cases interpreting RLUIPA since its enactment delineate the difference between a 11substantial burden" on religious exercise as opposed to an "inconvenience" on religious exercise. Consistent with the Supreme Court's substantial burden test, district courts have concluded that the regulations must have a II chilling effect'! on the exercise of religion to substantially burden religious exercise. Murohv v. Zoninf! Comm.'n of Town of New Milford. 148 F.SuDD.2d 173. 188-89 ro.Conn.200n. WDS has met the substantial burden test here. *8 In Cottonwood. the court found that the city of Cypress's zoning and eminent domain actions substantially burdened the plaintiff-church's exercise of religion in violation of RLUIP A because the plaintiff was unable to practice its religious beliefs in its current location. Cottonwood Chlistian Ctr. 218 F .SuDD.2d at 1226. The court reasoned, "Simply put, its Los Alamitos facility cannot handle the congregation's large and growing membership, and its small quarters prevent Cottonwood from meeting as a single body, as its beliefs counsel." Id. This is essentially the same reasoning WDS employs in support of their argument that defendants have substantially burdened their exercise of religion. 'WDS states that their existing facilities, some more that a century old, are inadequate for activities plaintiff deems necessary for its educational and religious mission...J::E}!Ql (pI. Mem. Supp. Su=. 1. at 12.) A brief summary ofWDS's proposed changes to its facilities will suffice. WDS proposes to construct llGordon Hall" to provide the school with many of the basic facilities it currently lacks, including a shu/ [chapel] where students and staff can pray, modem classrooms with space for technological Page 8 and other equipment essential for contemporary teaching methods, a library, a music room, an art room, separate speech therapy and other small group instruction rooms, and a cafeteria that will no longer have to share space with theatrical and other educational events. The additional classrooms will also enable the school to have smaller classes that are more conducive to learning, to allocate more rationally the space among the preschool, elementary school and middle school grades and to separate administrative functions from educational activities. (Id. at 12-13; Hammerman Aff.' 8.) According to plaintiff, the construction of Gordon Hall will also enable WDS to renovate the Estate House and Wolfson Hall. WDS plans to decommission all 13 classrooms in the Estate House which were converted from living space in th~ nineteenth century home, are relatively small, irregularly shaped and not originally designed for educational instruction, and to nse them instead for other essential school functions such as library space, computer rooms and administrative offices. One of the rooms in the Estate House will also be turned into a beit midrash [library and study center] dedicated to Jewish scholarship. Such renovatious will also include making both buildings handicap accessible, creating a second science laboratory, retreading staircases, reti1ing bathroom floors, recarpeting rooms, rewiring for computer and network capability, and installing new doors, light fixtures and audio- visual equipment. (pl. Mem. Supp. Summ. J. at 13; HammennanAff." 9-10.) The structure of the Estate House will also be reinforced and strengthened, which is crucial because, since 1998, the building has been supported by four tubular steel columns extending its entire interior height that were installed on the reco=endation of a structural engineer. WDS has been trying to get the Application approved and Gordon Hall built so that it could decommission the classrooms in the Estate House due to concerns about the structural integrity of this century old building. (pI. Mem. Supp. Su=. 1. at 13; Hammerman Aff. , 10.) llli1J *9 l2J The Fourth Circuit's decision in Ehlers-Renzi l'. Connelll' Sch. of the Holl' Child Inc.. 224 F 3d 283 14th Cir.2000), is instructive in determining the urgency of WDS's proposed changes. There the plaintiff homeowners who lived across from a Roman Catholic school constructing improvements and additions to the school without obtaining a "special exception," challenged the constitutionality of a local Copr. <I::> West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) county zoning ordinance which exempted such schools from the special exception requirement. ld. at 284. The school's construction plans sought to remove two existing structures, as well as several trailers, and to construct a 300,000-square-foot, two- story building to contain classrooms, a library, facilities for music and art programs, and other educational areas. The plans also provided for the construction of additional parking areas.ld. at 285. In upholding the constitutionality of the local zoning ordinance, the Fourth Circuit stated, "The very existence of the school is premised on a religious mission. And necessary to the fulfi!hnent of this mission is the existence of facilities which [the school] deems adequate to carry on its religious instruction." ld. at 290-91. Similarly, we find WDS's proposed modifications to be both necessary and legitimate changes in furtherance of plaintiffs religious mission of educating students with a dual curriculum of secular and Judaic studies, making defendants' complete denial of plaintiffs Application a substantial burden on their exercise of religion. Defendants charge that WDS has failed to demonstrate how the Village is substantially burdening their exercise of religion where the students at WDS have been, and continue to be, able to gather to pray and be educated just as they did before WDS applied for a modification of a special use permit. (Defs. Mem. Opp. Summ. J. at 23.) Defendants' argument misses the point. In Murohv. a similar argument was dismissed. There the court rejected defendants' contention that the burden was not substantial because the purpose of plaintiffs prayer group sessions was fulfilled as long as there were "two or more people present.'! 148 F.Sunn.2d at 188. It is the burden on the quality of the religious education that concerns us here. While it is true that the students of WDS may still, without the special permit modification gather to pray and be educated, their religious experience is limited by the current size and condition of the school buildings. See Brvant v. Gomez. 46 F.3d 948. 949 (9th Cir.1995) (stating that a substantial burden on a person's religious freedom is placed on him or her when the govemment1s action I1prevent[s] him or her from engaging in conduct or having a religious experience which the faith mandates."). Moreover, WDS, should be able, within reason, to accommodate the growing number of students who wish to pursue a Jewish education at WDS. See Cottonwood Christian Ctr.. 218 F.SuDD.2d at 1226. *10 il.Q] A prima facie case that RLUIP A has been violated having been established, the burden now Page 9 shifts to defendants to demonstrate that the land use regulation furthers a compelling government interest and that the land use regulation is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling interest. 42 V.S.C. ~ 2000c(a)(l)(A)-(B). At the outset, the Court notes the extreme difficulty in carrying this burden. See Cottonwood Christian Ctr. 218 F .SuDD.2d at 1227-28 (quoting Citv of Boerne 521 U.S. at 534. 117 S.C!. 2157 (recognizing the difficulty for local governments in carrying their burden under RLUIP A, because requiring the government lito demonstrate a compelling interest and show that it has adopted the least restrictive means of achieving that interest is the most demanding test known to constitutional law . ")). We turn now to the two major concerns raised by defendants in their opposing papers as reasons for denying WDS's Application--traffic and parking. With respect to the issue of traffic intensity, the Court extensively discussed this issue in its prior Order, and concluded that it was not a sufficient reason for the ZBA's reversal of its negative declaration of environmental impact. See Westchester Dav School. 236 F.SuuD.2d at 356-58. rFN81 We are unpersuaded by the opinions of additional experts relied on by defendants (since the ZBA's initial study of the potential adverse effects on traffic) which call into question the validity of WDS's traffic study. (Defs. Mem. Opp. Summ. J., Exs. H, M at '\I 8.) In any event, traffic concerns have never been deemed compelling government interests. See TranslJortation Alternatives Inc. v. Citv of New York. 218 F.SuuD.2d 423. 438 (S.D.N.Y.2002) (citing Whitton v. Citl' of Gladstone 54 F.3d 1400 1408 (8th Cir.1995) (holding that a municipality's asserted interests in traffic safety and aesthetics, while significant, have never been found compelling)); Love Church v. Citv of Evanston. 671 F.SUDD. 515. 519 (N.D.Ill.1987) ("\Vhile traffic concerns are legitimate, we could hardly call them compelling."). We frod defendants' second concern, parking, even less compelling. Defendants' denial of the Application based on an insufficient number of parking spaces is severely undermined by the joint request of both the Westchester County Planning Board and by the ZBA to decrease the number of parking spaces provided for in the Application. (Divney Aff., Exs. 4, 5.) Moreover, we frod nothing to suggest that the lack of parking spaces provided in plaintiffs Application will result in a direct and immediate threat to public health, safety or welfare. See Wisconsin. v. Yoder. 406 U.S. 205. 215. 92 S.Ct. 1526. 32 L.Ed.2d 15 (1972); Sherbert. 374 V.S. at 406. 83 S.C!. 1790. IBm COpT. <r;J West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) CONCLUSION RLUIPA provides that "[a] person may assert a violation of this Act as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief against a government." 42 U.S.C. Q 2000cc-4(a). We again emphasize our reluctance to act as a zoning board of appeals to review land use determinations. However, we are [rrmly convinced that defendants' complete denial of WDS's Application was not based on any compelling. governmental interest or on a fair balancing of environmental concerns with the rights to WDS to the reasonable use of its property and that defendants' abrupt reversal of its prior approval and its 3-2 vote to deny plaintiff's Application was a reaction to belated public outcry, a paradigm of what has been referred to as the NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) syndrome. We find little rational basis for such community opposition in light of the nature and publicly beneficial purpose of the project as well as the great lengths to which WDS has gone to ensure that its physical plant will maintain the highest level of architectural and aesthetic quality. rFN101 See generally Bronx Household of Faith v. Bd. of Educ. of Citv of New York, 331 F.3d 342 (2d Cir.2003) (commenting on the benefits to the welfare of the community churches provide). In support of the Application, WDS prepared and submitted, among other things, a full Environmental Assessment Form, supplemented by comprehensive analyses and extensive studies of all relevant potential environmental impacts of the project, including but not limited to, impacts on traffic, drainage, stormwater management, utilities, aesthetics and lighting. WIll Despite these efforts, defendants have denied plaintiff's Application, a project in development for over three years, in its entirety. We conclude that this denial is a substantial burden on plaintiff's exercise of religion because the modifications WDS seeks will enable it, for well into the foreseeable future, to more efficiently, effectively and, most importantly, safely serve its student population and to fulfill its religious and educational mission. *11 Weare convinced that there are no issues of material fact requiring a trial, which would not only impose substantial economic burdens on both the plaintiff and the Village of Mamaroneck but would long delay the improvements of plaintiffs physical plant which are necessary to the effective pursuit of its worthy aims. We therefore grant plaintiffs motion for partial summary judgment on its RLUIP A claim and in doing so annul and set aside the May 13, 2003 determination of the ZBA that denied the Application Page 10 and order the immediate and unconditional approval and granting ofWDS's application that was filed with the ZBA on October 10, 2001 as amended on June 17,2002. SO ORDERED. FNl. This action is also being brought against Antonio V ozza in his official capacity as a former member of the ZBA. FN2. A number of courts have addressed the issue of whether RLUIP A is constitutional. most have held that it is with respect to th~ section of RLUIP A governing the claims of prison inmates. E.g., Mavweathers v. Newland. 314 F.3d 1062 (9th Cir.2002); Johnson v. Martin. 223 F.Sunn.2d 820 (W.D.Mich.2002); Gerhardt v. Lazaroff. 221 F.Sunn.2d 827 (S.D.Ohio 2002); Charles v, Verha!!en. 220 F.Sunn.2d 955 (W.D,Wis.2002). But see Madison v. Riter. 240 F.Sunn.2d 566 (W.D,Va.2003). Further, our research has uncovered two district court cases which have ruled on the constitutionality of RLUIP A as that statute deals with protection of land use as religious exercise. See Freedom BaDtist Church of Delaware Countv 204 F.Sunn.2d 857 (holding that RLUIP A is constitutional); Elsinore Christian Gtr. 270 F.Sunn.2d 1163 (declaring 42 U.S.C. Q 2000cc(a), as applied in Q 2000cc(al(2)(Cl unconstitutional). Upon review of these cases, this Court borrows much of its analysis from the Freedom BaDtist Church of Delaware Countv court. FN3. Section 2000cc deals with "protection of land use as religious exercise" and establishes in subsection (a)(l) a "general rule" that: No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution, unless the government demonstrates that imposition of the burden on that person, assembly or institution-- (A) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (B) is the least restrictive means of Copr. 10 West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) Page 11 furthering that compelling governmental interest. Notwithstanding the breadth of this "general rule", subsection (a)(2) immediately limits the applicability of the statute to: any case in which-- (A) the substantial burden is imposed in a program or activity that receives Federal financial assistance, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; (B) the substantial burden affects, or removal of that substantial burden would affect, commerce with foreign nations, among the several States, or with Indian tnoes, even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability; or (C) the substantial burden is imposed in the implementation of a land use regulation or system of land use regulations, under which a government makes, or has in place formal or informal procedures or practices that permit the government to make, individualized assessments of the proposed uses for the property involved. So limited, the statute then, in subsection (b), imposes four proscriptions: (b) DlSCRlMINATlON AND EXCLUSION-- (1) EQUAL TERMS.--No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than eqnal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution. (2) NONDISCRIMINATlON.--No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation that discriminates against any assembly or institution on the basis of religion or religious denomination. (3) EXCLUSIONS AND LlMJTS.--No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation that- (A) totally excludes religious assemblies from a jurisdiction; or (B) unreasonably limits religious assemblies, institutions, or structures within a jurisdiction. F.Suuu.2d at 867 ("[T]he mere fact that zoning is traditionally a local matter does not answer Congress's undoubtedly broad authority after Wickard to regulate economic activity even when it is primarily intrastate in nature."). Additionally, we have already addressed defendants' alternative Tenth Amendment argument. See discussion infra Part II. B. FN5. Defendants substantial burden RLUIP A claim. challenge only the element of plaintiff's FN6. According to WDS, although the school population has more than doubled since Wolfson Hall was built in the 1960s, no meaningful new construction (i.e., other than interior maintenance and renovation) bas been done by plaintiff in nearly 40 years. (Hammerman Aff. ~ 3.) FN7. WDSls religious mission seeks, in part, to instill in its students the love of God and to instruct them in the Torah, Jewish rituals, morals and practices, and the land and people ofIsrael through a dnal curriculum of secular and Judaic studies. (Complt.~ 2.) FN8. There we found that the issue of traffic impact had been fully considered, with the then chairman of the ZBA stating that "any further study on the impact from traffic would not give the ZBA anything additional upon which to base its decision." Westchester Dav School, 236 F.SUUD.2d at 356-58. We further noted the conclusion of the ZBA's own planning consultant who, at the ZBA's request, reviewed the Application and the traffic numbers, and who advised the ZBA that he had no disagreements with WDS's conclusions.ld. at 357. FN4. Defendants' argument that Ilzoning and land use has long been recognized as a power given to the states and its officials ...11 (Defs. Mem. Opp. Summ J. at 19.) is undermined by Congress's broad power under the Co=erce Clause. See Freedom Baotist Church of Deluware Countv 204 FN9. In light of our conclusion that defendants! concerns do not rise to the level of compelling governmental interests, the Court need not consider whether less restrictive means might have been available. However, we fail to see how the complete denial of plaintiff's Application was the Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. GoV!. Works 2003 WL 22110445 --- F.Supp.2d ---- (Cite as: 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.)) Page 12 proper measure in light of defendants' concerns. For example, an obvious solution to the insufficient parking issue would have been to simply require additional parking spaces. FNl O. The Court has been favorably impressed by the presentations made by WDS counsel during prior conferences. Specifically, their plans and drawings indicate that the design of the new building (Gordon Hall) will be in harmony with the buildings with which it will connect. It will have a stone and brick exterior, a shingle roof and copper detailing and will be screened by existing and proposed trees, fencing and vegetation. It will be only two stories in height, consistent with most of the residences in the surrounding area. At its closest point, Gordon Hall will be set back at least 25 feet from the nearest property line and 117 feet from the nearest house. Even after the construction, the property will remain largely undeveloped, with building coverage of only approximately 7.5% of the 27.5- acre property. (Hammerman Aff. '\l '\l 4-6, Ex. C.) FNll. On January 10, 2003, a conference was held before this Court, during which the Court directed the ZBA to give WDS a list of outstanding issues that were of concern to the ZBA and that might impede the issuance to WDS of the special permit modification. The ZBA provided WDS with its issues list on January 17, 2003 and WDS promptly responded to each issue on January 30, 2003. (Hammerman Aff., Ex. C.) 2003 WL 22110445, -- F.Supp.2d ---, 2003 WL 22110445 (S.D.N.Y.) END OF DOCUMENT Copr. @ West 2003 No Claim to Orig. U.S. Gov!. Works Westlaw E-mail Delivery Summary Report for METSCH, LAWRENCE 2485417 Thursday, October 30, 200321:12:45 Central Request Created DatefTime: Client Identifier: Database: Citation Text: Lines: Documents: Images: Recipient(s): Thursday, October 30,200321:12:00 Central LRM DCT 2003 WL 22110445 847 1 o leslik@bellsouth.net Page 1 of2 Roberta Mendez From: Larrystl@aol.com Sent: Tuesday, November 04, 2003 8:58 AM To: jules@trumpgroup.com; roberta@trumpgroup.com Subject: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Jules: It was good seeing in Synagogue last Shabbat. I have written all the Aventua City council members (see message below.) Further I was in contact with Noel Sturtz of Young Israel and received a response. (see messages below.) As you know I will be going to Israei 10 November thru 10 December. If there is anything else I can do prior to my departure, please let meknow..........Larry (Joseph) . The following was sent to All City Council Members as per the list handed out in Synagogue: '.. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there Is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. While we are among the very few members who drive from an off Island location, the great majority of the congregants must walk In accordance with our tradition. Williams Island Synagogue has outgrown its present facility and the need is great for a larger place. That place has been located within one of the buildings on the Island and can be accessed only through an area currently used by delivery trucks and at the end of an alley. Opposition to this relocation is understandable If it were in any way to affect the life style or habits of any of the residents who reside In the building of the new location. However, if you were to visit the proposed location you too could not understand what this opposlton is about. No one who Is not a member of the congregation will in any way be Inconvenienced by this new location. Further, those who are Shabbath observant will be able to observe our religion in the appropriate way. We would apprecite your supporting this move. Sincerely yours, Larry and Eileen Joseph 19333 Collins Ave. #2301 Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160 Following are messages I sent to Noel Sturtz of Young Israel and his responses: (Please note in his second response the highlighted Items.) (To Noel from Larry) Dear Noel; Hope all is well with you. Eileen and I have returned to Miami and look forward to seeing you next Shabbat at Young Israel. As you know we also belong to the Williams island Synagogue. After many months of delay it appears that the Aventura City Council is finally going to consider their application to move the location within the Island. There Is strong opposition; so what else Is new. It seems that we Jews know how to punish each other as the opposition appears to be coming from some of us. I know that you and I have discussed this situation in the past and you indicated your support. I am asking that you make another "plea" next Shabbat at Young Israel. We will need all the "physical" support we can get at the Council meeting on Wednesday, Nov 12th at 5PM at the Aventura City Hall. IN fact, I will make some copies of the announcement and have then there next Shabbat for those who can pelp us. Thanks for your continued support........Larry (from Noel to Larry) (In a message dated 11/2/032:18:58 PM Eastern Standard Time, NDS88 writes: Dear Eileen and Larry - Welcome back to Miami. Hope everyone is well. Looking forward to seeing you in shul. It will be my pleasure to publicize and encourage support for the Williams Isl. Synagogue. If there are any "talking points" you'd like me to cover during my announcements next week, feel free to bring them to my attention. Best regards, Noel (to Noel from Larry) ..../A/"'I""" Page 2 of2 Dear Noel; Thanks for your positive response. Below is the message I just sent to the members of the city council of Aventura; (see letter above) (from Noel to Larry) Dear Larry - Thank you for sharing the letter you sent to the Aventura City Council. Unfortunately, as you are already aware, opposition to such things (by other Jews, sadly) is often more a reflection of personal "issues" than of an objective assessment of the situation. Consequently, the detractors need to hang their hat on sometimes bizarre points. This is why it will be imperative that the Williams Island shul members and their supporters be able to anticipate - and succinctly respond to _ every potential point of opposition (e.g., traffic density: how many walkers? how many drivers? average shabbatlholiday attendance? will walkers interfere with car traffic, deliveries, etc.? will this compromise building security?). Good luck, and looking forward to seeing you and Eileen. Best regards, Noel , ,'I.<1!?nm Page 1 ofl Roberta Mendez From: Cynthia Morison Sent: Monday, November 03,2003 10:02 AM To: Jules Trump Subject: FW: Williams Island Synagogue FYI ----Original Message----- From: Lesli KRoss [mailto:leslik@bellsouth.net] Sent: Sunday, November 02,20038:10 PM To: CMorison@WiIIlamsIsland.com Subject: Fw: Williams Island Synagogue - Original Message - From: Arlene Hauben To: oerlowilIDcitvofaventura.com Cc: holzberahl1iJcltvofaventura.com Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2003 6:52 PM Subject: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioner Ho1zberg: There is a wonderful synagogue on Williams Island that reminds me of the shul on the West side of Chicago off of Douglas Park Boulevard, where I grew up. It was a sanctuary where old men in talis and some young could fervently pray together. It had a special smell-- that of tradition and religious sentiment. It wasn't glitzy or crowded. It was just a little shul. The synagogue on Williams Island is as close to that special place as I've ever found. I ask that you support its safekeeping and let it remain to serve Williams Island residents who come to recite psalms together and pray. It is an out of the way place and certainly not in anyway imposing or obtrusive. Thank you in advance for your support. We hope that you will be influential in keeping the synagogue, which can only be to everyone's advantage in a world where fire and negative forces are everywhere. While the current synagogue is inadequate, and needs to be enlarged, it brings a bright light to everyone who attends and makes the world right here a better place. Even in A ventura, not everything is rosy. We need your help. I've met you both and have faith that as wise and righteous men you will support such an important issue. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Arlene Hauben Aventura Resident _~, _~.,.,__" .__~"H'" ....~,__ .",_ ~__. -_.~.._~ ~ Eniov MSN 8 patented SpaID control and more with MSN 8 Dial-up Internet Service. Try it FREE for one month! 11/3/2003 JORDON & LESLI ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Jeffrey M.perlow Mayor City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of A ventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from V\lilliams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BLVD. # 2606 AVENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. C- Lesli K and Jordon I. Ross JORDON & LESLI ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Zev Auerbach Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mr. Auerbach: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their aparhnents or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from VVilliams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BLVD. # 2606 AVENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. ~~ JORDON & LESLl ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Jay R. Beskin Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Cub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mr. Beskin: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existenCe. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of A ventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BL YD. # 2606 A VENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602F AX being crowded and without having to use residential building party roOms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that noW take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. r---' ;- Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establislunent or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to WilliamS Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of WilliamS Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of AventuIa. '- Sincerely. Jjo~r- Lesli K and Jordon I. JORDON & LESLI ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Harry Holzberg Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive A ventura, FL 33180 .... Dear Mr. Holzberg: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from lNilliams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BLVD. # 2606 AVENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. cJ210~ Lesli K. and Jordon I. R JORDON & LESLI ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Bob Diamond Commissioner City of Aventura 3000 Island Blvd. Aventura, FL 33160 p. Dear Bob: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from VIlilliams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and 3000 ISLAND BLVD. # 2606 A VENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religioUS activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUlP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establislunent or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. Lesli K and Jordon I. Ros ~IO JORDON & LESLlROSS October 28,2003 The Honorable Ken Cohen Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Cub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 r- - Dear Mr. Cohen: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. I ~ There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. TIlis is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BL YD. # 2606 A VENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. i 1 r- I We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura Sincerely. J:;LO~ l..esli K. and Jordon 1. Ross JORDON & LESLI ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Manny Grossman Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mr. Grossman: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from "Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BLVD. # 2606 A VENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 305-682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. f.. r ! We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. Jd.o~~ Lesli K. and Jordon 1. Ross T obi and Nathan Lewinger 2600 Island 5lvd. Aventura, fL 7")160 October 28, 2003 The Honorable Zev Auerbach Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Qub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 ~ I :- Dear Mr. Auerbach: The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of A ventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. We are writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RlLUP A) dearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent - and legally required - decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the Oty of A ventura. Sincerely. Tobi and Nathan Lewinger T obi and Nathan Lewinger 2600 J"land f)lvd. AventLJra} FL'7 I (~o October 31, 2003 The Honorable Jay R. Beskin Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 ~ ~ Dear Mr. Beskin: We are writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it ~ to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of A ventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RILUP A) clearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent- and legally required - decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of Aventura. Sincerely. Tobi and Nathan Lewinger T obi and Nathan Lewinger 2600 Island f:,lvd. Aventura, FL ') ') I 60 The Honorable Ken Cohen Commissioner Oty of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 October 31, 2003 Dear Mr. Cohen: Weare writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of Aventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their aparhnents or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, peopJe who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RILUP A) clearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent-and legally required-decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the Oty of A ventura. Sincerely. Tobi and Nathan Lewinger Tobi and Nathan Lewinger 2600 Island f:,lvd. Aventura, FL)) 160 October 31, 2003 The Honorable Bob Diamond Commissioner Gty of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mr. Diamond: We are writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of A ventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from -williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that noW take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RILUP A) clearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent-and legally required-decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the Gty of Aventura. Sincerely. Tobi and Nathan Lewinger T obi and Nathan Lewinger 2600 Island ['::.Ivd. /",\ventura, FL)) 160 October 31, 2003 ~ The Honorable Jeffrey M. Perlow Mayor City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: We are writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of A ventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its pUrpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RILUP A) clearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent- and legally required - decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the Oty of Aventura. Sincerely. Tobi and Nathan Lewinger T obi and Nathan Lewinger 2600 Island 5lvd. Aventura, FL )) 1 60 October 31, 2003 The Honorable Harry Holzberg Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 We are writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. Dear Mr. Holzberg: There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of A ventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams IsZtmd residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RILUP A) clearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent- and legally required - decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. Tobi and Nathan Lewinger Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31't Court Apt. 1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Jeffery M. Perlow, Mayor City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the Aventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12, 2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. Very truly yours, ~~ Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31't Court Apt. 1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Zev Auerbach, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Auerbach: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the Aventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12, 2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. Very truly yours, ~/&J) Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31't Court Apt. 1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Manny Grossman, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Grossman: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the A ventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12,2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. ~Yours, Debra Kat~ Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31't Court Apt. 1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Harry Holzberg, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Holzberg: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the Aventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12, 2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. ~ Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31't Court Apt. 1002 Aveutura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Jay R. Beskin, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Beskin: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the Aventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12, 2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. ~yours, Debra Katz Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31 st Court Apt. 1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Ken Cohen, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Cohen: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the A ventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12,2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many A ventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. Very truly yours, ~M Debra Katz Debra Katz 18151 N.E. 31't Court Apt. 1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Bob Diamond, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Commissioner Diamond: This letter is to express my support of the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I request your support in any decision made by the A ventura City Council relating to this move especially at the November 12,2003 hearing. The Synagogue has been in existence on Williams Island for many years and has served the Williams Island community and immediate surroundings as a place of worship for many Aventura residents. The current location of the Synagogue is no longer adequate to accommodate the congregation and the community. There is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura in walking distance. As it is an orthodox synagogue, many of the congregants walk to the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays. We are counting on your support on November 12, 2003, thereby permitting the relocation of the Synagogue to the requested location and allowing the observance of our religion. Very truly yours, ~ I!#'t) Debra Katz October 27, 2003 Bob Diamond, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williarns Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. ~'r/!1Yoi2L e'4iY1tz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Manny Grossman, Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Si ;etrour~ ~1;l 8151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Zev Auerbach, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 27, 2003 Ken Cohen, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. S~iu- ~I NE 31st Court Apt #1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Jeffrey Perlow, Mayor City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 27, 2003 Jay R. Beskin, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. 1lf::~~+- Apt #1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Harry Holzberg, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. y. urs, /14-- 81 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Bob Diamond, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. SM~~ Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Manny Grossman, Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. s~ Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 Aventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Zev Auerbach, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. S~~ Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Ken Cohen, Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shahbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shill. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Jeffrey Perlow, Mayor City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. SM~ Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 October 27,2003 Jay R. Beskin, Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. S~ Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 October 27, 2003 Harry Holzberg, Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Member: I am extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. I as many other congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. SN~ Adam Katz 18151 NE 31st Court Apt #1002 A ventura, Florida 33160 DAVID HOLD October 27,2003 Ciry of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Council Member: I am writing this letter in total dismay that in this day and age an issue like this is even disputed. What is more amazing than anything is the fact that the opposition to this new synagogue is nor from the non J <Wish members of the communiry but mainly from the Jewish ones. Is it possible that the saying that history repeats itself is true because it reminds me of the s:une attitude of the G=an Jewish communiry before Second World War, who also turned their b3.Ck on their heritage. My wife and I, are both children of holocaust survivors and very sensitive to such issues. We were also rused in a communist country where freedom of religion was never heard of. The beaury of this country that it provides religious freedom to everyone irregardless of pl3.Ce of origin or nature of their believes. This is also true about the new ciry of A ventura which can be looked upon as a modern melting pot of all nationalities. The beaury of our synagogue encompasses all of these wonderful qualities that this great country of ours grants us. We have members from all parts of the world practicing their version of Judaism as they have been thought in their countries of origin and handed down from generation to generation sometimes in fear of their life but never forgetting who they are. As you are aware for a practicing member he has to have a place of worship within walking distance, the present facilities are inadequate and this is a necessity for the community at large. Please suppon our effons in building our new synagogue. Sincerely, David Hold HOC ISLAND BLVD l03B . AVENTURA/FLORIDA .33160 PHONE: 305.682.1588 . FAX: 305-682-1889 E.MAILDHOLD' 54' 5@AOL.COM Jane Frankel From: Sent: To: Subject: Sea4cab@aol.com Monday, April 28, 200310:14 PM JanineDavis@Williamslsland.com Williams Island Synagogue I was told to email you with a letter that my wife Rose and I were interested in submitting to the appropriate authorities on behalf of the Williams Island Synagogue. Please forward to Jules Trump and/or to Larry Metsch. Many thanks..Ed Leventhal (My email addressisSea4Cab@aol.com) The purpose of this note is to assert our strong support for the Williams Island Synagogue's desire to relocate to a more appropriately sized and designed facility at the 2600 Island Boulevard location. My wife and I recently purchased an apartment on Williams Island in the 2000 building. Our primary residence has been in New York for almost all of our lives and this is the first time that we've purchased a home outside of our hometown. Our search for the optimal place in Florida in which to purchase a home that for now we'll use for frequent visits and hopefully someday for our primary residence was heavily influenced by our need to be within walking distance from an Orthodox synagogue. As I'm sure you are aware, there are many locations in the Southern Florida region that could have satisfied that need, however, there was no other location that registered as frequently on the radar screens of those to whom we turned to for advice in the search for our Florida home. The Williams Island Synagogue was repeatedly cited as a place where the people are warm, thoughtful, caring and genuinely kind. The beauty of the overall Island, we were told, speaks for itself. Having just finished our first stay in our new home over the Passover holiday, we can attest firsthand to all of what we had heard being absolutely true! Our experience at the Synagogue was truly inspirational and elevating as we encountered tremendous graciousness and hospitality. Our children, ages 15, 13 and 8, also thoroughly enjoyed the experience and are eager to return soon. Before buying the apartment, we inquired about the synagogue's history on the Island and were told that the record is unblemished...that the synagogue serves the spiritual needs of many on the Island, that it cultivates the intellectual interests of many who have attended the book reviews and other classes, and that it has served as a bastion of good-will, acts of kindness and charity and overall, good neighborliness. We are very excited to be new members of this wonderful Synagogue and are hopeful that the plans to relocate to the new facility are expeditiously approved. Please feel free to contact us for any additional information that might be helpful. Sincerely I Ed Leventhal Rose Leventhal H..914-967-9567 W. .212-723-6259 C..914-439-1053 1 . steven V. Ourland, M.D. · City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Harry Holzberg 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Harry Holzberg, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 . 7000 Islarld Blvd. #1709 . Avmtura, Florida 33160 · ~>><r~ . F-MfliI: flaurlarld@aol.com . City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Jay Beskin 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Jay Beskin, Weare extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. even & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, FI. 33160 City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Zev Auerbach, Commissioner 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Mayor Perlow, Weare extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to tbe Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. ci1 Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 Sen+ . stevel1 v. Ourlemd, M.D. · City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Bob Diamond 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Bob Diamond, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate obsen>ance of our religious choice. . 7000 Islarld Blvd. #1709 . Avmtura, Florida 33160 · ~~k~ . E-Mail: flgurlarld@aol.com . w@} PATTON MARINE, INC. SURVEYORS, CONSULTANTS & SUPERVISION P. O. Box 451135 Miami, Florida 33245-1135 s Our Time and Experience is our Stock in Trade Office: Fax: e-mail: USA +1 (305) 854-3821 USA +1 (305) 854-3855 PattonMar@ao1.com PattonMarine@cs.com October 30, 2003 File No. 7293-03 Page 1 of 5 Willie's Wish c/o The Trump Group 4000 Island Blvd. PH. 4 Williams Island, FL. 33160 E-mail: JulesCCiltrumocrouO.com Phone: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-466-3570 E-mail: yachtcaotainCCilhotmai1.com RE: "WILLIE'S WISH ", 1994,80' Mangusta Note: In addition to this text, there are there are 3 pages of photographs and 2 pages of description text, which are an integral part of the report and should be read in conjunction with this text. Dear Mr. George Trump: At your request, via Captain Daniel Perrin, this undersigned independent marine surveyor has inspected the teak decks on the above mentioned yacht. Date of Inspections: Location of Yacht: October 29th, 2003 Bradford Marine, secured to in-water slip under covered shed Guy Clifford Attending Surveyors: This is a strictly limited survey only and is not to be used for other purposes. LIMITATION OF SCOPE OF SURVEY: A Patton Marine Survey on the Yacht "WILLIE'S WISH" File No. 7293-03 Page 2 of 5 The survey of this yacht is based solely on a careful visual and non-destructive inspection of easily accessible portions of its structure and available equipment. Complete inspection can be made oniy by removal of flats, soles, decking, head liners, ceiling or hull lining, tanks, gas freeing and joiner work removals. This would be damaging in nature and prohibitively time-consuming and as we do not want to be held responsible, itwas not done. The information contained in this report, concerning sizes, accuracy of build, hull or superstructure geometry, ratings, capacities, speeds, etc., was ascertained from maker's plates, logs, documents, plans and certificates on board together with statements of the instructing entity. Unless specifically noted otherwise, none of the information was ascertained by direct measurement or calculation and, although all the information contained is believed to be correct, the accuracy thereof is in no way guaranteed. Complete inspection of machinery, auxiliaries, piping, tanks, systems, electrical wiring, electrical and electronic equipment can be made only by continuous operation or by disassembly. This has not been done. It is recommended and understood thatthe engines and electricai systems are to be surveyed and tested under load by a qualified marine engineer and/or marine electrician to further determine the condition of the engines, gears and pumps, heat exchangers, coolers, or electrical systems etc.. Further, no determination of stability characteristics or inherent structural integrity has been made, but some opinion maybe expressed with respect thereto. It implies no guarantee against faulty design, hidden or latent defects. This report represents the condition of the yacht on the survey report date(s), and is the unbiased opinion of the undersigned, but it is not to be considered a warranty either specified or implied. No warranty is made regarding the classification or regulatory status of the yacht. While the details reported are believed correct, the regulatory status of the yacht can only be confirmed directly by the certifying authorities. This report carries no warranty regarding ownership or any warranty regarding outstanding mortgage, charges, liens or other debt there may be on the yacht. This report is submitted for the exclusive use of the instructing client and no liability will be accepted to any third party who may subsequently read or hold a copy of this report or any of its contents. Copyright remains with the instructing client who has paid for the survey and the surveyor or surveyors. The survey is not to be given out indiscriminately. The instructing client only has the right to disperse this survey at his/or her discretion. The scope of the examinations was (further) limited by: The following report is the result of a (strictly) limited survey, and is not to be considered a full condition survey. Please observe 'x' marked boxes. o A. Specific Client Instructions (Note: this includes lack of finances or allowed time) o B. Haul Out and examination upon dock was not performed A Patton Marine Survey on the Yacht "WILLIE'S WISH" File No. 7293-03 Page 3 of 5 o C. An Underway Trial Run was not performed o D. Time constrains were present during the examination period o E. There was Limited Access to the yacht and/or specific areas onboard o F. Adverse Weather Conditions limited the scope of examinations o G. This survey is a strictly limited insurance valuation survey only o H. This survey is a damage or damage/repair survey only o I. No personnel aboard to help or lack of qualified personnel aboard causing time delays o J. Partial new construction progress report. K. Other; This is a survey of the teak decks only. TEAK DECK: The purpose of these examinations was to examine and report on the condition of the teak veneer overlaid decks. The teak veneer overlaid decks appear to be glued down to the existing fiberglass main deck. Inner and Outer Margin Boards: King planks: Teak planks: Caulking Seams: 90mm-100mm wide, unknown thickness 165mm wide, nipped to teak planking 50mm wide, unknown thickness 4mm black Thiacol type The teak decks show evidence of repairs and surface re-finishing by way of disc sander. The sanding disc marks are prominent at the port and starboard side decks at the inner and outer margin boards showing many scallops and uneven surfaces. The inner bulwarks and house sides show scuff and wear marks from the disc sander edges. Margin boards have been re-fastened by way of screws and teak plugs. The entire teak deck was wetted down with fresh water and sounded with a phenolic hammer. Please see the following list of defects: Foredeck - Port Side: . Heavy sanding disc marks in the inner and outer margin boards Voids around the forepeak hatch margin board . Voids under the outer margin board . Voids port side of port anchor windlass . Large gouge inboard off the port anchor windlass Voids outboard of the forward mooring bid Side Deck - Port Side from Forward to Aft: . Heavy sanding disc marks in the inner and outer margin boards A Patton Marine Survey on the Yacht "WILLIE'S WISH" File No. 7293-03 Page 4 of 5 . Caulking seams missing due to excessive sanding Water trapped under the inner margin board, plank ends . Water trapped under the teak planks . Voids under the inner and outer margin boards Foredeck - Starboard Side: Heavy sanding disc marks in inner and outer margin boards . Voids under outer margin boards . Missing caulking seams due to excessive sanding Side Deck - Starboard Side from Forward to Aft: . Heavy sanding disc marks in inner and outer margin boards . Water trapped under inner margin board forward . Water trapped under outer margin boards Missing caulking seams due to excessive sanding Water trapped and sprung inner margin board ends aft . Voids under outer margin boards aft Aft Deck - Port Side: Voids and sprung plank ends inboard of port transom gate at outer margin board . Voids aft of port salon glass door . Voids under teak planks on center Aft Deck -Starboard Side: . Voids and sprung plank ends forward of starboard transom gate at outer margin board . Voids under planks forward and on center . Voids forward of table starboard base . Large knot in plank . Water trapped under outboard margin board at fairlead Where the teak decks have been disc sanded, the grind mark damage is irreparable, due to the remaining thin decks, which have already been sanded down lower than the caulking seams on the foredeck and port and starboard side decks. There is water trapped under previously repaired sprung plank ends, which now have screw fastening, which may be allowing the trapped water to penetrate the deck core. Summary: Overall, the teak deck is in very poor condition. To try and do isolated area repairs would be cost prohibitive at this time. It is recommended to remove the entire teak deck on the foredeck and port and starboard side decks. The aft deck appears to be in better condition; repairs could be made to the sprung plank ends and void areas. When the teak veneer decking is removed, the main fiberglass sub-deck can be examined for any water intrusion. The area's dried out and A Patton Marine Survey on the Yacht "WILLIE'S WISH" File No. 7293-03 Page 5 of 5 epoxy sealed. A new teak veneer deck can be laid, or another option would be to fair the fiberglass deck surface and repaint with non-skid. If a new teak veneer deck is to be applied, it is recommended that no screw fastenings be used due to the reported core construction of the main deck. This will eliminate the possibility of water intrusion into the deck core material in the future. Note: This survey is based upon the observed condition of the yacht and is not a warranty either expressed or implied thereof. Latent defects that cannot be determined without the opening or removal of decking, sheathing, joiner work, and/or assembly or disassembly of all machinery including plumbing, engines, wires, etc., are not covered by this survey. This survey is prepared for Mr. George Trump, and as aforesaid does not expressly or impliedly warrant or any way guarantee the condition of the yacht. It is further agreed by the aforesaid Mr. George Trump that Patton Marine Incorporated and Mr. Guy Clifford, of Patton Marine Inc., shall not be held liable or responsible for any errors, omissions, or oversights in the surveying of the above described yacht. Respectfully submitted without prejudice, PATTON MARINE, INC. Guy Clifford Marine Surveyor GC:kh Note: In addition to this text, there are 3 pages of photographs, and 2 pages of description text. Jane Frankel From: Sent: To: Subject: Sea4cab@aol.com Monday, April 28, 2003 10:14 PM JanineDavis@Williamslsland.com Williams Island Synagogue I was told to email you with a letter that my wife Rose and I were interested in submitting to the appropriate authorities on behalf of the Williams Island Synagogue. Please forward to Jules Trump and/or to Larry Metsch. Many thanks..Ed Leventhal (My email address is Sea4Cab@aol.com) ,= The purpose of this note is to assert Qur strong support for the Williams Island Synagogue's desire to relocate to a more appropriately sized and designed facility at the 2600 Island Boulevard location. My wife and I recently purchased an apartment on Williams Island in the 2000 building. Our primary residence has been in New York for almost all of our lives and this is the first time that we've purchased a home outside of our hometown. Our search for the optimal place in Florida in which to purchase a home that for now we'll use for frequent visits and hopefully someday for our primary residence was heavily influenced by our need to be within walking distance from an Orthodox synagogue. As I'm sure you are aware, there are many locations in the Southern Florida region that could have satisfied that need, however, there was no other location that registered as frequently on the radar screens of those to whom we turned to for advice in the search for our Florida home. The Williams Island Synagogue was repeatedly cited as a place where the people are warm, thoughtful, caring and genuinely kind. The beauty of the overall Island, we were told, speaks for itself. Having just finished our first stay in our new home over the Passover holiday, we can attest firsthand to all of what we had heard being absolutely true! Our experience at the Synagogue was truly inspirational and elevating as we encountered tremendous graciousness and hospitality. Our children, ages 15, 13 and S, also thoroughly enjoyed the experience and are eager to return soon. Before buying the apartment, we inquired about the synagogue's history on the Island .and were told that the record is unblemished...that the synagogue serves the spiritual needs of many on the Island, that it cultivates the intellectual interests of many who have attended the book reviews and other classes, and that it has served as a bastion of good-will, acts of kindness and charity and overall, good neighborliness. We are very excited to be new members of this wonderful Synagogue and are hopeful that the plans to relocate to the new facility are expeditiously approved. Please feel free to contact us for any additional information that might be helpful. Sincerely, Ed Leventhal Rose Leventhal H. .914-967-9567 W. .212-723-6259 C. .914-439-1053 , 1 . stevefl V. Gurlafld, M.D. · City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Harry Holzberg 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Harry Holzberg, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation ofthe Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 . 7000 Islarld Blvd. #1709 · Avmtura. Florida 33160 · ~~ r- M....:I. fl"'lIl,.l,=,nrlG<il\~^1 rAm .. City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Jay Beskin 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Jay Beskin, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation ofthe Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would he to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. .I\...-> even & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 City Of Aventura Governmeut Center Attention: Zev Auerbach, Commissioner 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Mayor Perlow, Weare extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. JJ Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 Sen+ . steven V. Ourland, M.D. · City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Bob Diamond 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventnra, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Bob Diamond, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. . 7000 Islarld Blvd. #1709 · Avmtura. Florida 33160 · ~~ . [-Mail: f1gurlarld@aol.com . City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Manny Grossman 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2,2003 Dear Commissioner Manny Grossman, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation ofthe Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. ~~~ Steven & Caroline Gurland ~ 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 . ~ ' .7.P'/",/?~ ;/ a ' ;,;4/ ,a; DA VJD HOLD October 27, 2003 City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Council Member: I am writing this letter in total dismay that in this day and age an issue like this is even disputed. Whal is more amazing than anything is the fact that the opposition to this new synagogue is not from the non Jewish members of the community but mainly from the Jewish ones. Is it possible that the saying that history repeals itself is true because it reminds me of the same attitude of the German Jewish community before Second World War, who also turned their back on their heritage. My wife and I, are both children of holocaust survivors and very sensitive to such issues. We were also raised in a communist country where freedom of religion was never heard of. The beaury of this country that it provides religious freedom to everyone irregardless of place of origin or nature of their believes. This is also true about the new city of Aventura which can be looked upon as a modem melting pot of all nationalities. The beauty of our synagogue encompasses all of these wonderful qualities that this great country of ours grants us. We have members from all parts of the world practicing their version of J uclaism as they have been thought in their countries of origin and handed down from generation to generation sometimes in fear of their life but never forgetting who they are. As you are aware for a practicing member he has to have a place of worship within walking distance, the present facilities are inadequate and this is a necessity for the community at large. Please support our efforts in building our new synagogue. Sincerely, David Hold 3900 ISLAND BLVD 103B. AVENTURA/FLORIDA. 33.160 PHONE: 305-682-1588 . FAX: 305.682.1889 E.MAIL:DHOLD.}5485@AOL.COM Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident rrlembers; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your~ote. C L4/A'iJ V ~GNA TURE , fJ /J PRINTED NAME g-. C) ?J~ (!: <.: e.e {)..I-/fp--1J:P. ADDRESS Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. .fev~ /:8~ V&-t20. Le SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME f{ (J 5- {c; r:: f.C1A dj (!..t1 ~ 1)... ADDRESS I Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building, Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident," members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior ofthe 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident, members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. l ~U1 SIGNATU E I) (j &0 ADDRESS J-fA- U h PR..1 NAME ~ . d:i::--?4'h :r ~ VO(r;::;. YES Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and 1 request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the, synagogue. Any s00ial event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident # members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ,~ U,},ft~~ ?6ffL Mr2;O-1fI I ~~.-:R~/lrl. A I PRINTED NAMp I1.c? :3 Y'(J IV- C,,()t.{ ,..I(~ e.l..AfJ I P-, ITr 77 ADDRESS S/r7 ~ J I DATE SIGNED JYI/ Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the . synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident. members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. I .$-d/ cJo, '( ADDRESS " 11 A /:,flA H.~..r:.F- 2;"8 / 03 PRINTED NAME DATE SIG ED ~. , f'''WV'YLLt Cl-1I{. ))"'J IJ*2K" ~WA ~b61f'O Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. /?4vol-1'"~ 13~ AtJDRr:;S' EfrR7-';f s!u jpj SIGNATURE (l ~R!P4TE~~E 11 . ..7 DATE SIGNED 17ot: I r:; r; -OK.nf7 ~ W" (TtVUvt.cIf4" tjJ_ ~~E " Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident' !11embers; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs, Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance or your YES vote. .~ SIG TURE C 1vt ~ J b PRI~EJl ~ME <JJt ~J fi ciJ,.L.... C--1 <.u :l.;.;;L J.77 ADDRESS Ji (j f'} . DATESI~ .~. . Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the. synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident, members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs, Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. .J~o.N G J1Ma.~ .[/rf'dJ' IGNATURE riM b PRINTED NAME 9A1ESIGN D .:l.-gs-;,j~~ ~1 " (t(ul~.rj7 A~/r~ ADDRESS ' Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away t-om the 2600 building, and there is no usable.. connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. \_"ti[{ ~/Y}>0 PRINTED NAME (Lv J", 7{ (';Lv h 17)2... ~ r if 5"3> Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is noi visible from the 2600 building, ii is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building, Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. ~~/l\IbOk ).. 3 cfO ay DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. in advance for your YES vote. /-; u)l?- E - ~::J aJE~ [)!Ai :i~ ~- Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Halzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ~ $1<, L f? -I;; rrJ C tf LI SIGNATUR PRINTED NAME ""1Al:i'/')..\ 0 FCC lyL+ /v3.(' f)d;fI;Ptl-)1-/i.. "'?~ / (7) ADDRESS ' Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Tha!)l< you in advance for your YES vote. j ;?UftuO fNt.K,Of.J/IT2- PRINTSQ}/Ajv1Efj\. <l<1 f /7 . w....v" U!A-b f)-'IAH- 'It "p Y URE "U' J V~.. [:' t:L,!t- ADDRESS Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the- synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by residAnt members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs, Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. ~ank you in advance for your YES vote. ~~ ~~ ])la-nCL K.Jz'7 SIGNATURE PRINTED NAME 09. DO fV6 ~ III Q..(Tc<.e:e... 41/.U1~ ADDRESS shf/6j DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs, Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. J o /t han 0a/,ker PRINTEO NAME 4rJent/ll'c>c. fL '3 "31?P 5P- J fr5 DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident. members; and, their guests must park at their b:.Jilding of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in adv~~ur Y.ES vote. . ~J7~ ~'jA-"~_____ t:o~~ !/lc7!l8Y?4N P.-?d-d3 SIGNATURE D PRINTED NAME . _ j DATE SIGNED 3,131"~: Co U)VT7 (1 [ (i}r<. lfr. / "2.-vrl/J-~M fCl-' ADDRESS Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ~ ifMk. AY)t'~ Gkr~y Sl NATURE PRINTED NAME Q...P;}'~~ Nt. 34ct. #4/(0 AV~+UiG. FL ADDRESS sl?-3! 07., DATE SIGNED 33 11\0 Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs, Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ,~-Puli!~ 5f!/f.lf1!<A't-)W S//2.0~ SIGNATU . I. PRINTED NAME . _ . DATESIGN~ J..-6 b fj J [LD,,-,-f7 \' I ~D/I \]-A 20(., f;1I-f"v1.,,-,,,- {2. 33' Y ADDRESS ' , Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervisad. \iCt~rHl..~G-\ A ~ MA YI C:LI; {OO~ {~PRINT~DNAME A ( DATE SIGNED I~O -Ztf cT .;r '11/ veM.. w"\. ~(( "3 ~ Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of A ventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-I at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. SIGNATURE: ~ 0) PRINTED NAME: Y<:;UI -d ADDRESS: ).,)# C--. DATE SIGNED: ilJ " tf/t f ~lJ, Ie #/io3 Co "',.,fCv / Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior ofthe 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. cfcJ;z) ~,c. c, sf ~ 5 ~ lo3,f, Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one iifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. SIGNATURE Jr().)Ct' ~1 ADDRESS Thank you in advance for your YES vote. IftzL4D~ 08vIV ~Mmf:fL 5'-Jt!-o"$ c!& PRINTED NAME DATE SIGNED (/n~ ~Lue 'tf(/1/C" Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Wiliiams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. J I E{~ mJ :l d- 3 _ 03 PRINTED NAME r< L ......... . v II UYjfU-. DATE SIGNED AD RESS r tEs I ~ 0"" W~\,~ ~~Wl'n\um ~J Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-I at 2600 Island .Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. SlGNATURE:Cfu- ~ DATE SIGNED: 5f 2-1 [ 03 PRINTED NAME: Jon i m t'flJe r ADDRESS: J-02~1 E. Counfr:J Cluh /)r. API IrtJ[" Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of A ventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-I at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synago gue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. 1 JS /1/ . SIGNATURE: i l~)..f .~ - !5 hd / ti-3 , . DATE SIGNED: PRINTED NAME: E la/he.. ~ rr e.e VVLCl;1 ADDRESS: ~50S b' &UdIlV / elJk J)..--. I Ne",ft,<< Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of A ventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-l at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. SIGNATURE: ~ R ~ DATE SIGNED: s- -;z 0 ~ 0.5 PRINTED NAME: ~ge :4. ..r-:r..F/,.J ADDRESS: :;20:;<>5"' C:. COcJAf'J"-';> CL.Ua PI!!- --tt-/6yr !l-1Jf5u.-rD/c,4. P L '3 J' / g;::, Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident, members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting' residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. ou in advance for your YES vote. S TURE :, '-1-0/ 11/ ADDRESS - V fllil\i\ S,l~ s- I - )'IfIN ED NA~ . DATE SIGNED L l,U€, 'D f1t\r-l .i\::... $S19~ Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident? members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. , ' / L ,.- .~':-<L~~,:..",-~- --'-(--X~.I'(.'/'Iv:,,-; (~.., ( Lc:?~ l~I/J;l~} ~ C lJ~L-i> SIGNA:fURE .~. , PRINTED J\lAtAE \;\ lO'J/J ~T f@G'~ C-GL-,rS 'I)~Ivt:; ADDRESS f- / 9 ~ (-J] DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event musl have a religious basis hosted only by resident; members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs, Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ~-;/' !4r,v/./el /1.0 ;jj~? >'-\ PRINTED NflME - DATE Sl 3 flr!:, 4v\, I-/vP.?</0/~, pc ~:Y8() .... ./7 .-':;../ ..--' (_,n.s"J..'"'' Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. . e for your YES vote. 3o~e. PRINT \0 ~ rt- AD RESS J'-( 0 I 0or-\1-- (OJ'^-Ir .f~( (\0 ~ )(".;J II \ A-J~-\vl^ .{ '" "':>,?\80 Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building, Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident; members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote, SIG RE , I;) t?.J PE ADDESS Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident;: members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. / That you in advance f~our YES vote. i ...;{~ ztL~!~ frl/ n67t IlIl?fo/J I'SIGNATURE N C& fr; PRIN]:fD[NAME <';\ I' "'3731 (/11 C. U !3vl--lvt:' ADDRESS s~/' -03 DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident' members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending servicewafiCf1pere will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. ! I I Thank dvance for your YES vote. -17 {go Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. ~vance roo- your YES vote. . ) ~ .7ft e-k- IM._ . leNA TURE PRINTED NAME S ?-O () IV C '2 I I TE It /L 11 L E ADDRESS Ie It 1-1 rJ ( A-v G tJTv >1.14 ~//7 /01 DATE SIGNED L.I/-K. U I / Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Halzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. !;Ctu~' /~, Bell" vt1 12 (llHil SIGNATURE ~.. PRINTED NAME /J""~ J<l7J--- rf. ~JUI--I'te-Lf C!..J-iJ(3 Dre t'rfl' PI I ADDRESS t . Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior ofthe 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ~;I~ Lor)/- tJ/fJO;./ SIGNATURE r{ PRINTED NAME tI I.-- 0 S- 0 r eAsT Lb! (/ M IrJ r!- Lv (5 .pit I V is- ADDRESS S:-Jf=-o3 DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank y:f in advance for your YES vote. ~ j/tIMm;:/;r jcJ;vf SIGNATURE ,... ~,-..( PRINTED NA~EL t-oJor cruT L-O UY\ 'ir1 c.. u @, ADDRESS ~\~ ~ - Jo\~ c'(3\,lf'cJ> {~ ~ fYb'vvA 5- /J'-o 3 tJKIvt:;' DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thonk you in 00,,,,,,,, for your YES ,ole. ~ ~~ 1J1f::t:-llUeD~ (0/03 SIGNATURE C' ~ ~NAME ~ ~ED /J ~~I ~ j V~4 tx, H-S7'J~ , Ie... 53! fCJ ~~ss ' ( Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting , residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. S2B N \ t:" 1-- s;.~ 'bm \ et.S7,\M( \J 1\ SIGNATURE ~RJNTED NAME ""'- 1--oS'oS' e ("OVVv-t'(\~ \"'\J~ 'DR.w~ ADDRESS \ ~/IC(~ J DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ~J~~ SIGNATURE 1-,,~o {' ADDRESS 6h':.'f ck'>1i'1f ~~St 1< 11-!; mevL- PRINTED NAME CLu{!, Ibnvr:: 5- /'f-()3 DATE SIGNED Dear Mayor Perlow, and Commissioners Auerbach, Beskin, Cohen, Diamond, Grossman and Holzberg: I am a resident of Aventura, and I request that you vote in favor of the conditional use application for Unit CU-1 at 2600 Island Boulevard. The proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue is to a commercial space specifically designated in the condominium documents as a space that the developers have the right to use for whatever purpose they choose. The space is not visible from the 2600 building, it is separated from the 2600 building by a 260 car garage, it is one fifth of a mile away from the 2600 building, and there is no usable connection to the interior of the 2600 building. Most of the synagogue attendees are residents of Williams Island who walk to the synagogue. Any social event must have a religious basis hosted only by resident members; and, their guests must park at their building of residence where hosting residents will pay any additional valet costs. Children are never allowed outside while attending services, and there will be a special room for children where they will be supervised. Thank you in advance for your YES vote. ::r'~>aA ~ ~u (:;'3 S.HARV/T -;:/;%/D3 SIGNA TUR~ .' /... PRINTED NAM);: DATE 51 NED 2o.su~ E, LO-u-o"\I\.\A cb.tr- ~ ~1..~ 2> ItO; ADDRESS City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Zev Auerbach 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Zev Auerbach We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue toa different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. Sinc,r!l__ /Yluv--e'Y\ Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Ken Cohen, Commissioner 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2, 2003 Dear Commissioner Ken Cohen Weare extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue wonld be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of OUT religious choice. S~ -Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura,Fl.33160 F r-I N-. 'Y~~\'-\ .~~~~,t\~\OIU Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:}!'t '\''\\4-.., ~ftti-Oo I),,~J.!:,r"'1.QJJ Address: ~ \'J\,li)J~ n\...J,:l:t 2.,1f,o~ ~~..r(,jh {\... i,)""\(~ \ \tt"{;,t.\!. III II-~~~, em"'. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the south em portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: '-'\A....~~'" It~Qtb'" ~l'r\Jl;t'I'0J~(. Address: '2.'!:.w \':JVYnJ~ -1.\-~ ,-j::l' 2/60;' 'ft~~<J~{:Ii-J... ,':l~\\"t? , tR,. ~Jt.f>~I)t:~rC-~ . Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~.s-1'-~. ~1fi2.e\"lo ~ ~\)~",,-tJ' ~ Address:~ 17\.4>\,J'9<D\...~. .f:i )4,0(' .~~-{,~JQl1l~' >'J\~,o \'IQ..'5.~ rt:>f/,~,,J It ...---. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ ~ -l-1'W ~ ~tA&'\)'\) \-\,;,J ~f\ J Address~ \~I.g~'\) 'Q \,\. !i- ~9>rv {' J vd VI;)'\' II ~-R<-~. :'1 \ l,..o . \ >+ ~, tl"'~l \-kf..-t~V;CiOw1. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: N~~'Ml?!:>. ~::(,te:io AAJs MArl J Address:1,~ 15~f.\) 'ft,\-v. dJ- Z-S'O! 'R~~J f1....~1 ~L, , '3"$fL.... i I , I , ~ ~ h~ 53~j)'flt^cJYI ~. Dear Council Members: l - I I I , We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the reloca1ion of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on WilliarTls Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distan ce is to grecH to walk to any other shul. We w()uld appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:t'I~),:\\Q~ ~\t~,f 10 \$)t0~hAJ /l Address: 2"t><+1J r&J..,{.1,,~"9 ~d. 4t 7/6~/ f:'t~Jl$ QJ) i r . ~3 r (A) , 1-4-. ~~\~\~~~Pt-!!('q"..,,,,. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:\'1.~ ..J'\1.ltL fl j.{&t:~ J.tfW~r>AJJ Addressy<.-~o,1) " '::,c-~tl'r;> 0LY, -It '2.-:ffl.( , ~~,"<)().A If-!... ~., !~JC> . h{(" ~ f);rP~/~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~i ~ Address: 2-~w J~~ ilLJ IT- got: ~,~. b~/(;,(/ > !~ (JeA~ t!ow. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 9~ Address: ~[~ R/h;:- -# !5cs:" f-h~~7~. 35('(7 , k ?J~ 12. ftp~ gr-. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name'4 &v Address: ~~ &!r~ go~ ~~~_ B~I(.O , ;J~,'~ ~,av. , . Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~ Address: 2. '3= ~ iJtr #' gt?5--- ~~,:;:e, 5~rr;1/ , .. $a, 12FiJ~~. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name Address: 2Boe:Jot;;.d ~dt-t~ , A;e~j r~. :3 ?IClD. . ~. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name~~ Address: 2f7b,e! ~a/ rBtu, dl- ~ Af/~~/ -:r~. o3/(;C I db- ,J~ ~~r f C7H' Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:llMt~ Address:?--s-r:o lY--/JNb 130.r ~~ lJ31~ . II-o.s. -:Je (1 ~L 7 /'I. f €1!l..fJ J, !1{1-Y17!t Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: MR. & MRS. E. ZELlG 2800 ISLAND BLVD. # 2902 WIIIIA~~C: 'SI AND, fL. 3318[ Address: f'r;R. /111/'/y CR~ ss;.l'1~ Cs,<7l'1Taf(l",seiG Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: MR. & MRS. E. ZEUG 3800 ISLAND BLVD. # ?!-In. ,.ILLlAM5 ISLANU, FL. 3a16 Address: 1'1~. i!tl-!d,Y f)PL 7..6EI?G-t ilf)I'?Hl5Ip,ve;,e Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: MR. & MRS. E. ZElIG 2800 ISLAND BLVD. # 290Ei V/ILLI;,MG IGLAt4D, fL" "~Iijt Address: /'if!. 'Eo$> j) 1fl-/'7b,f.iJ, {!"f9-">I"lIS/o(l ;-Jei!_ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: MR. & MRS. E. ZELlG 2BOO IRI ANn ~I \In if 29Gc WILLIAMS ISLAND. FL. 3316 Address: 1M. ;.!tfJ coflt;J, (! OI1Ml~IO,.[&t Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue toa different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: MR. & MRS. E. ZElIG 2800 ISLAND BLVD. # 2902 WILLIAMS ISLAt4D. rL.;3,j 101 Address: ('if2.. 'Zit' I! IM./S!i-e-tf, (! fJl'/l"1/Slol.Jtt0 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Itl. -11/(5. E;t;.;e~r ~l../&- Address: 2~oo /~C.t1~j) 'i?LV..pt '2-902--- fr1e-;ltJiC/J-,:h.. 38/(.0 Dear Honorable Mayor, Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend thi.s synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. 2800 Island Boulevard, Suite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 Dear Commissioner Holzberg, We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. L 2800 Island Boulevard, uite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 Dear Commissioner Grossman, Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Laurence Raiford, M.D. 2800 Island Boulevard, Suite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 Dear Commissioner Diamond, Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. 2800 Island Boulevard, Suite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 Dear Commissioner Cohen, We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Y~incerelY, i2:~ford, 2800 Island Boulevard, Suite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: r;;A-~ jC I t Adlhess: q If-~a/ It G V $r Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: A~rah:.,.., /16b"7 Sq k-r {l/fAhetN / tJ"y #!If! Address: Ik.eI1+.dlJ rL .3J/80 Prom the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Pax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 F Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura,Florida 33180 , , I '-L i , I Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: AbraiRA. /1:16'67 &.k-r Address: fk~.f...H'~ .".-...""" ". ... .--............,. lviAk ~ry . (,J~ #;Ii . .... ----, . FL 3:i180 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 F' r Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .,,,, ."",' -------.-.---...-.... Name: A1"a ~,.., Addzess: lq667 . Ik~.J..n^~ ..",_""". 'n. - """,... Sq!<.1l Iv r Ahe fry .. ,.,-,,---,_.-. . fL 33/80 .-.........-----...... """0/ ~A October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 ~ Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: JJb"Q&~ . 1&;667 &kf ---. ."., , , ,. AdllIess: Ik~.t..r. . , Iv r AM ~f't r:L 33)80 t.I ~ tIJIl1 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 ~ Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: . Abra&"", .Ar!rlress: ler667. fk~.t:H'~ ".""---.-.-....-----...-...- . ,..",.,...,-.". {""' . 0q kif -_.. ..----............". fvl~~N .<f,> w~'4#1I r:-L 3.:t180 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: __Abt"Q &,.... /"i667 ......--....---..-....... ..-......---------,. s'k. -,. Address: fk~.f.:,r~ _..'0.....'__".....________...,.,__,_, Iv, Ahe. ~N ~- W"f ..;#11 t:"L. 3:tJ80 October 31, 2003 i-= , Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. I I" , I ! As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ffb,.a~r>l &k.f ./'1667 Ivr^he~r;l W~ #1#19 Addre$S: fk~)....r~ . - ;::-L 3:iJ80 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alt=ative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wonld appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: f)bra &,..., &rk., Address: /&1667 Iv ",.hit ~ry t.J ~ #1#/1 Ik~./-.d'~; f'L 3:tleo Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of oUr religion. Yours sincerely, Name: P L 6 &~ J' }../t.r ~.J{ Address: SUullr1 fUt.......e-L- fu'v"-'i5uv--{ APr?'H ~~ t7 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Ntune: . ff t.,d &~ J'})JIft ~.Tl P' ............... ..',""""'" . Admess: Su..rrlrl f"O...., -1U,,"~lJv-f ,4R- YH ~~ If October 31, 2003 ~ c Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Govennent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue toa different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no altemative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shnl. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...............".,,----.... Name: .. Pc 6 6-~. J'" 1jFt t.o:.rr ..............."........................... .-.,,--....... AddIess: Su..rrrl rfuw.oL.- '1GI/'- r{3vv-f Ii PI" YH ~ if October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...., .. r"')'. I .~ I _.. Name: I"" /..,6 &~ .....) '-fri \.-O-'l . j r'F.. Address: SLlV"'f'V1 (0... r' ~~ # -1Gv- "f!3ulr-{ .4 R- YH October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wonld appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1:1 (, 11 &~ J' J}t?t tc~ . ..................".,_..........".....,.....",.,........-.-..,,--. .J~. Address: Sv..rfl<"l (0'....., ~~ .t! -ruV" "i3uorf .4 Pr YH . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southem portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ,:t L {! &rt--r J' ).j~ ~ Address: Suu--rri -f"o... -"'- "1Uv->{3uv-f AFT Y11 ~~ t? October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NllIlle: fA ~ ~ &(br .J)-/-,q- L-o...., n: . Address: S~hrrl>-/ (~..., '1G"" t{!3uv--f . A Pr YH ~~ ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, fA 1.,($ &(bJ ....r ).-JY1.~..ij Name: Address: SVv-(H ...yo.. . .., ~~ ~ -1G.... t'f.!3f.1v-f A Pr YH . Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wonld appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: /Iv" Me! dr-53 --IC/Yk1rJ;v;of'lLJ' "I -)1J1 F/oll- "/7CU Name: Prom the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address; Av; Acle.f t1;~a ":::C.-V Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby p=itting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address; . Av: AcieR !f;;:s -r~_V Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trmnp Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: Av\ M'ef !1;~~" -r:::z:.-U Nlll.11e: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond . A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wonld appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Av: Acle.f t~:a -r:~T:--V Address: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, AddreSs: Av: AJ~.f ::. -r:::c-V Name: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N_;~ ~ ~ Ad. dress; 7 ( ~ <0,. 4. 7~ . ):] Il/( Vfrtlltl r? A .f' ( '3? J{ f) . q~ f ~ , ~~/i. From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, - ~ Name:. . --~ ~~'-i 7-~/V, jYt.-TfJilA P..A j:' L -1 ? If fj m.t_ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby p=itting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ~ ..,......., .,.... ....- ," ......................"............ ......""..,.........",.,.... ....,_.....".,.........",. N";nl'\^. . . . ~~~,~~~ 7-0 . . . I ~l"lVr jrt-r,.r-rtt 04 j:' L -3 i If n -- <I..$-/. I ~ , ""-l /-'1 '" ,_,,,:-::,,:;->..,:::L.. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. Yours sincerely, =,,~~,21i7~3N' /JJtr...,,f 7' II p,A I .J:' L ~ '3? J ( " ~. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shnl. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, =~;j;j;/t::t 7-3 , . .' ; rlV lVt.-Tl.I-rtr pj, j:' L. ''3? If fj - q~/. , . I ;.6..1. /'" ..: ..:.-:o,::.._.tt..~ The Honorable Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow, City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Mayor: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion Commissioner Zev Auerbach, City of Aventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Commissioner: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Commissioner: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion ~-~/ 7~ Commissioner Ken Cohen, City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Commissioner: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion r nd vd. # 2702 and, Florida 33160 Commissioner Bob Diamond, City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRillv1P SYNAGOGUE Dear Commissioner: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion Commissioner Manny Grossman, City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Commissioner: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is ~o great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion Commissioner Harry Holzberg, City of Aventura Govemment Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Commissioner: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion The Honorable Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow, City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 RE: WILLIE TRUMP SYNAGOGUE Dear Mayor: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on William Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: (S. S'I( ~ Address: ,I 9 ~.f {'. --f-r..I r/-Ai ~ '17 frzJ JZh-J '7---c.-r ~ F-L .> J (f-o From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31,2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no altemative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: IS. s I( /k'd4 ~i AddIeSS: /'l~f {'. +"1M ~"?' -:tJ-d ~~ A.1 ~ J3.{f-O October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1/S<S!(~7r( . Addtess: (9 ~ f f' _ +<.t rJ-,J /J.~ 'i' -.::fhJ ~~ ~ yC, :3 > r f-c? October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A v=tura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council M=bers: Weare extr=ely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shnl. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /S. S I( /1C~;t( . Address: (9 ~ f {'. -f-'.I r41./!.Ph' 'f' -.::f1-zJ ~~ f!-4- ?r- :>.1. ( r-o October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alt=ative synagogue in the south= portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shnl. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby pemiitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: fl. s'!( /K~/r{ -- Address: (95. f {'. +tI ~ /JA.l-,Jy'17 ~ (i-rJ'r-T-( ~ ~ 3.lrro October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We wonld appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1f!.S If /kF/7r{ . Address: /9 ~.f r. -+-"I M ~ '?' .~ fh.J~ I-- 1 ~ 3J(f-o October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~. S If /K,:r/r{ ( Address: (9:s.f {' _ -f-"II-+J 8$/Ty'17 -f1-zJ (P-r/~ ~ 1 ~3>(f-o October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: (J.. S If /K ~/t( ( AddJeSs: /9 ~.f -{' _ -F-'I eL~ 8..QTy'17 ~f$tJ~ ~ 1 ~ ::>:1 rf"O Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~~~- Name: Address: _\ C1. )<' f 1VJ{j'J'VoQ^O fWi \'lP FL. (3)~ f\~f) l. o ftu~lilP- . I From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31,2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Av=tura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council M=bers: Weare extr=ely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogne in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~\L~ Name: """"" -J'" y { 1I""1'....'(f.b ' rw Iff. 0 A.J~'1i'"~, R. 1'.-,1 ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ ~... . ~- Name: Adclress: _\ '1. o/{ ~l~~n~ ~ L W l)f. ?J Prv~V)P-, R. nl ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~~~ Name: .'-- ..,.,- -.,." Address:--1I\'Y1' ~{Y~(I~ ~t!:lt ' \+VT lff ?J Ftv~lJ!P Fe 1)1 ~ T ", October 31,2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ ,n .-.....: ...::..:....:.:.: ::".::::.:::.::..',,:::::::--:::::: .,-' '" .--"---'--' .-.....---...,.,,--....,-. ~~- Name: Address: ~f ~{9~nrr; 'I\~ . ~ Iff ?J ft.;'Ef.J"lJ,IP-, R. n)~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N_, ~ ~~ -=_\~ ~~'~ ft'l't~'t,;~lPi Ro nJ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southem portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ \)...~ Name: AddrC!lS:-ll1.'Yf ~J'9~"(j 1\..trlt ' fRT l1f ?J A-..J'f"W"lijp.' R. nJ ~ . , October 31,2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ ~~- Name: Address:_\11.o/f ~1'Y.p!J.(f'~' fWT IfF (} Av-s":"1J,r;::.., R. nl~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Prom the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Pax: 305-931-1773 ~ t1-Lr(~ ,{ G V ~r Name: (J,4IZ~ I L . Address: October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ()A-/l.FIt. AdIlxess: q lf~ 6 <<f -Sr October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ()t4/l.FIt. AddIess: q 7 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: (JA-~Flt. AdIlxess: q lff1-t-/~ 6 <<f -Sr October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ()t4~FIt. Address: q lf~v" It -Sr October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ()t4/l. FIt. AddIess: q October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ()t4/l.FIt. Addtess: q lf~v" 6 <<f -Sr 1 Dear Commissioner Auerbach, Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation ofthe Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat, as the distance is great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. 2800 Island Boulevard, Suite 2702 Williams Island, Florida 33160 October 31,2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ::',~<a~4~7~3 ,v, Vr-.,.I7"lIQb. .yL-1 {Ir" -q~ .. . ..... I .~ .~t '" .-' .~(~.. WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATION PROPOSAL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF A VENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. ADDRESS A ) L jo:7D /(S4trl/J " 7000 iSt..tWD bt..v0 / ") '79 Ill, 8 U 3 5'.f. /'1'1'1tv-f. nr?oS-l. /017:) Co0'Y?.s e. / '1 9 '7 tV. c ;8?:, sf:. Sea r: e1;: / 0 !7 r- Co/ lr? 5 jji/e. Gsf;/Io /999 M.'C:. !t-35-t '.r' ",Ie. ;2.,'2. ,,--I fA--0AL:NI;: 2t \::M~~e\. '\I..-\:'~~i' '(. C, 1.. !\Auf\ -.J d "CCl'oO-C"~ L \ 6<;00 l--l ,o,CL,- (LOCl PHONE NUMBER Jo/~!.)...N7 7 5--:lS 77.\ 0 I J-b :;JoT <f'0-r;,~3 30T- 16(;- 62.3/ ~ 0,- :;b!- H1J 7 30::;-- 9'-/ .I. {,1(71 50S" ---- 6 07---- 37 '7 J 70& - :n(j- 7907 oj - -;fc; ';f- F" ., '7 S z... '3o,SF" - ,fe: - n..... ")."'J--"'" R.1-- '7 yz.. ~OS - Lfth-- 2,00 ~O-S - Lt6b ~OO lAJ J ~ tfbG -- >()'V ].to)> bG - .1Uv w.]- b _"100 W ~ -G,q,,? ~ 40 '10 >'D0--G9r:CfO ?D 30 c - 9 ,,'T - '1 z. 0 <1 koo..&. 30$"-'1'--(") '12-09 \\CU\U-- 6-,0(Q.J1,l-e'," \(,<;OO'~ f2, 05/20/2003 11:55 ~5~37B25~~ l-I!'<::l"1L I rnf-\r<:I~IH""'l:..U I ..I. ......HL.. WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATION PROPOSAL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS 'FAM1LlAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF A VE]\,'l1.JR.A OF niE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. PHONE NUMBER '1)4) ,~'Z,){ &1- tiffil) q(7.-/I,t"J QI.{ 4 U- ~ s:rs-- 'YJ 5- C(rr-1o '1, C(, WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY fo (L SYNAGOGUE . IO<fRELOCATION PROPOSAL ._~-= ._~ ow.. ~~ ~ r Petition: , THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF AVENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. PHONE NUMBER ?tb~(fP 79~ ~o~ I:~<'-\)\~\! WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATION PROPOSAL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF A VENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. E,. L f'x'1lIc..c. ..(~ . rJ I<UZ/N ~ I.!.W1N kL.~/I-i L."'lN "\ l-<Ll? I f'I tftch. PHONE NUMBER g ~ Y6 ) -) 0 \ S <;"';0 . ~d,,, - (f...rV) Y5~ 27'-/ /6)~ ;.f~ tas( 1W1?~O'c~' ';JZ5-& .7~J/.)'?> (;, 3 c((lf (. ry 3(("l. ~ q J ~S8 3&>)8 q~ 616 ~f& ;f G~ 3fl,? 0~ 1~ tr QSLf 0~ 3~ 2~ q:;(-f- 415- (P 773 ' WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATIOtJ PROPOSAL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED. ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF AVENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. h- ADDRESS Alol 1'11.;5-h'c POr'f\te..llr :,?.:ii ;1Je-- 19Z,vO $'r#i9 '!1l " C -f.....'y (,,,III? v NAME MAR.c..c '- WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATION PROPOSAL V&fL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF A VENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. NAME ADDRESS PHONE NUMBER V\1/C. rJM9LlL4((f~<<A I~ "3 of"-Q3 / (J 3 (,3 , 120u1:1.. N~'l.:L PL vvt/Jf"n1( rC~3JI) d"u DY f'ttrt.rlE(fUIJ '3 u.J_cJ3J- () 310 3 7 ;;2.JJ if7/!-- III f?7-- 1--- P '- . JIYlJItYllI rL 33!r:fl> WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATION PROPOSAL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF AVENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. NAME N ~ r~~-iUIa.. PHONE NUMBER ~O~, ~35-(1J.{ ;o{ ,~~{- 4.J{)o WILLIAMS ISLAND COMMUNITY SYNAGOGUE RELOCATION PROPOSAL Petition: THE UNDERSIGNED LIVES AT THE NOTED ADDRESS AND IS FAMILIAR WITH THE PLANS TO RELOCATE A SYNAGOGUE FROM ITS PRESENT LOCATION IN WILLIAMS ISLAND (2000 BUILDING) TO A NEW LOCATION IN THE 2600 BUILDING. THE UNDERSIGNED FULLY SUPPORTS THE CONTINUED EXISTENCE OF A SYNAGOGUE IN WILLIAMS ISLAND AND WOULD SUPPORT APPROVAL BY THE CITY OF A VENTURA OF THE REQUESTED RELOCATION TO THE 2600 BUILDING. NAME ADDRESS PHONE NUMBER "\Cv~-w T WG1UJ0"(" JaM (Jt.A,JO 'f5Lv/'ad: ., 0)- ?'J.f-It?/! ~!r.J.~lnL 'H-O ~ t5L-J)/..:yo r ..3fJS. 9"5 ~ /f,/j 1 v . Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: AL "2-( fl--I Address: '2-- 0 "'\ 0 ~ 1'--\.';:" "2-~ ,...J ~ f,..\} ~ 0. --r d \1...- p.. ~ --:2,.?-.;'\ ')j, L) Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Address: "5 \ \ '-L.-.N, f . ~ \ n - lea ~-{.....~("l-, Fl. ~~, 910 0"c< Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. . As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: _.1\>>0 ~:A--f~.M\\ Address: ; 0 [11) W 1>-1<1 -tt:At'U> Uf- ~~ 2- bki ~~t \~~>>h~ :tl- ~~r!;( Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: tv- L ,J'-.J j I -x6s t! PJ-} Address: 'J-)(; d tV! ""2A77 S-r ..J. f-J. (] A - J'3 /? () Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:;;Y) I~;JA-Ht(h L o-f) J: IV Address: ? '\ 7 if tV, L 0 t-llJ T A If' (,-LA R --P fi r l "?r J ~(j H (,{J)~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ii/V :d/&~ Address: J"\ J -:; r! 6 /q Y!.!:- f;-'--ed- J uJ~ (Vl,J....,- 13-~'-'^- -rL--. fl/90 \ ' -, Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: Q:h AU'-VC 13 (Ad,(/- v- "Sli 75; r~ (" I/,..,h (j- ~e{-' 1u~ I1,JtntJ('{)v ~(.,. ) [{ill, 01"</( Name: ')11'Xo Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shu\. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: .7 prilru//'1' #,./-8/ Address: /;;;2.- r/. r /9Lt 5ct /I/!r"//~ /0', 7:;,)/1cl {?;t!J9 1,660# 1;,L/ r Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: iJ.oc'l~r 5'ht'JM 'j J Address: ;/,/l ;/.,r HI.; Sf- #i~ H. .ft'l3/ i;~ DIA) l... '> 17"1 Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shu\. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 15~-f.Jr,-f!::> Address: :~//L( )E 2.-10 -r;f;{Ln.. fr vEri ..,-z) M pz.. ~3 / '8 cJ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, - JI/'itJ S Name: .L TSII kK Address: ;}oo l/ / /V17 ~o~ - l~/ .AI";} ftJ,' FL >~ I 79 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, AW3G" IZl 0 .".., Name: c,>-Q v t;:.v" (,' Address: ,?? lj 1'7 }Jc--- iCf ~ /V~ f'7 f,f =73 \ 77' Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the south em portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Y /I It eoV' Add~ss: ~~ ~ /rJ() 1; _fl , g, ~ 1<'--/' / ( I ~ r-:- (91 f rJ . VL Y; 1 JD. Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: tt; J;0 Address: ~ y (9 ~h6A6~ Ai. ~fJt I~ fi-~ ~ '.M~"3 t~,i? Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /I~9Y J/.,k/- ,/ Address: /,{/:! ,./ z- 1M sr _ L-/-/fU"",'/ ,ct! 2317'1 (:ps-) L/~6 06",3>'1 Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /JPoi!IJ /Jj,~ Address: Z / / tJ rJt- Z IV 11 Ai/--f 6./1 J]179 I 0JjJ n! - '1Y r( Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: \R cl)1: ~JL( ~.J1J..---- Address: 9ct?11-! \ ~'-'\.-\R- 1\\/(--/ \1 .fA\> - J:3 \ ~ 0 Dear council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 5 -l\~ A t\ ~''EL E {Y\ . Address: 2-00\. it l ~i{t\--- f\\It..-. tJlf\~- ~L 1)1~c) Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1'0 I}t2.'( Address: /000. ~ n,c, . , ).oS f E LE fA/ J':.{ I c;: . IS/-' 17 riD R,i--r./) ff #05 ...-, )A(/;:5"f//-rui(/J I r? :3 3 / b 0 November 6, 2003 Manny Grossman, Commissioner City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Mr. Grossman: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shule. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ f.L~ LY~~~ Address: 1000 W, Island Blvd. # 1012 A ventura, Florid 33160 (304) 933-0826 November 6, 2003 Harry Holtzberg, Commissioner City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Mr. Holtzberg: We are extrernely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shule. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~~ L~/ai.~ Address: 1000 W. Island Blvd. # 1012 A ventura, Florid 33160 (304) 933-0826 November 6, 2003 Ken Cohen, Commissioner City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Mr. Cohen: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shule. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely ~~ L~flL~ Address: 1000 W. Island Blvd. #1012 A ventura, Florida 33160 (305) 933-0826 November 6, 2003 JayR. Beskin" Commissioner City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Mr. Beskin: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other shule. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely ~~ ~~G~~ Address: 1000 W. Island Blvd. #1012 A ventura, Florida 33160 (305) 933-0826 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, AddreSR: IS-itA< D. Ai.rr)f~r .-.----...-.-.... ........,.................... /'13['5"" M~tJkn7 tuqy M. M-lM I j}f;l1.eN Pi ~3/R(} .. .-......,-----... ........"..--.... .-.-.... ... . Name-: . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extrernely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: IS-hI/<. D ~ /iN! n ~y Address: /93["5" . N.RlJkff}t tuQC(.. N. M-lA# I iJi;4e# Ft ~31?() Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: ~- R-~ Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~- . R- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossrnan A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Addtes..: Name: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the cnrrent location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:$~~-L ~~ij' Address: s/9Lj ~F ~I/ Si , /?1/~J../TU^/9 ;C-L- ~7/~O .._-~----~~7;~------~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Execntive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:R~E~ ~.60h/ Address: '5/9 '-I ~ E" .2// S-r . - ... . ... ..... .... " .. ..,. ". rt//r.J-/7VAA ;r=-~ ~/to ,~~~r~~ . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Mernbers: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: #~EC-. ~bo/P' , AddJ:ess: ~ fer c..r ,tV' c .t /1 S-r .4~.J-/TUA /'9. .r-.?- '5"5/~O ~~~,~~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner JayR. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: &~E~ ~--60b/. . '" Address: -"5/9 '-I r/ C 2/1 $" ,4'~.J/Tl.JA~ .r-?- "'55/~O ~~~. ". _ .,f!", ",:'., ,'_ ,,r,__,:_:.,','.'. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: #~E~ ~-60~ , Address: 5/9 '-/ /'"" E 2/1 $1 ,,4~~^/'9 r-L- ~/fO ~~'l'~ October 31,2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Averntura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 44E~ ~~~ '" Address: "'S /9 c..j ~ c .R I J Sr- . - . ...... . .... .. ... .. .... . r?K5".J-/TOAA r-L-- ""5"S/~O ~~~~r,~ .. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: &~EL- ~--6:;,h/ .--.., Address: "5/0; L( ~.r .t 1/ S' /1'~.JJ':TUA".r'9. .r=-?- ~ /8'0 //?./7 ~- . , - - - --- - ", ._--:. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: &~Ec:... ~...60/Y' ;- Address: ~/o; L( ~.e 2/1 $' ..4K5"~^A ;r;-L---. ~/8'O ;/19~~~~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~~S~~/qd~ Address: :5 130 ~ /1'0 ~ S:-I #,;J.dr-- q~,..., H ?,.) I (0 ~~~:J ? From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N~ ~~S~~,qct~ Address: 30'" ~ /?o-tr f'{. .~ 4~r.. ;z:z "3)l J (Q ~#=-) ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~~s~.el2;d{'. Address: S I;;" ~ /7'0 ~ r'{. ~ q...:fc.r.. 72"3 ~ t (0 ~~J? October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:. ~~s~?~df Address: 3' I~", ~ /JPo ~ r-l. ~ q~,.... 72 "5,) J (0 c;e~~:> ? October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . . --..' ,--_..,- ,..'d____""__""""'_""""""_'_____""""'" Name: ~~S~?fi<4~ Address: ~ l:Je ~ /'0 ~ S'i'. .~ q~r-. H. 3), J (-0 ~#~) i' October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .,.,.,-..-,-....--.........."'....,.....-....----....".".....,.--...--..--..-..--..........,....-.--....--..."'.-.... . '" ."'-......"--..--..............--.--......,,...---....""."'.--..--.---.."..,_._, N~~~s~~cl~. . . . ...............-"".....--.......-........'.. ---"'----"" Address: 3" 1;>.. · ~ ""'0 ~ ri'. .~ q~r..H. ..3>J(~... .. ~~;) ? October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ........".__..,..........................._ .,.,......."............,.___.......".._.d"_ ...........................,...............................n.............."".......-.........-.... Name:.. ~~sg~rq JJ' Address: 3IJe.~ /'0 --5 r{. ~ ...--..,......... .;(it~,... R. "3:> J (0. . ~~.~J '9/. ~ October 31, 2003 Cormnissioner Marmy Grossman Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ., ,'"",,--,--,,-_...... ---....----"".,-.-,-,-,---...,."..".---....-.-......"., ...--.---....--.......""'......""..,......."..."."."..--..,."'...""'-............-... Name:~~S~~rqct~ . -. -- - ,.. , ,--_. . ".".-.... ,............. . .--.--.--....."'.". Address: S,ry., ~ /'005 ti'. ~ A5t~~ H. 3>J(0. .. ~#:J ? Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trnmp Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /::J- A ~4 )-/ A ~ Address: '3 <5' DOl;ye /tjP eX's.. T (, October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M, Perlow Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware,the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .". ............,,--...... ".....---...,.. "...-........",.,............. ,.-.... . .................----...."'-.,...,...-..."'''........--............. NllIne: ~.B R,4 f/A/7 .. Address: '3 c; Dc:) I'I""c ./9' ~-':s.. "T t: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..............""'...____..."'...,..,................__.n_""'_"___""""____'___'" ...-.----....,...".....................--.----....'...--.....,.."'.,--....--."-......... Name:. ~. 8 R,4 ,if A~ . Address:: '30 DOl lJI"e /()'cr~r ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, " .-----...----.. .", ',-,--,-, . ,.."". Address: .",,- ,....,.....-.........."."'-..----............-----..--....... /). 8 R/l ff A .-#1 ~ G' IS> ~ h"e ..-r:~ tJI."--, r (, Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..........----....---.........."--...........--....."......'.,,---,----_..--,-.. .----.---.....--...".-....--,...----..........' ".,,-,.., -.-....-.. Name: /fe~4 f/A/1 Address: '3 rS>/S)r!) tY"c:- /p'tr-s.. T t: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . .......................,.,.-,.--..-.........--.--."'.'..----..........--..--... ,_,.,.,_ .,............,..""""........__.._...,.........'.._n....... Name: #'8.li;4}/A~ .. Address: '3 c9 e:> C) I'I""c /.f?' o' 3,. T. (, October 31,2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~'..f3 R,4.}/A~ . ., , -"., """,.'.. Address: .~ rP e> c;4"~ /9' r::rt:.... T t: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Marmy Grossman Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .."..,.....-----.... Address: . ........ ,..,..........,..........-,.-'."... 0" .............__,..........,.__,_____".,........ ;4{-=3 7(4 f./A ~ '3 676' 6' II"'c /f1' c:r!=-.. T f- ..,.-,.-..---...... Name: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N='~r: CL~ C~~Clf{ Address: ~ ~ en U lie \? <l>) -;s QJ 60 U:,) :it So.s ~\I i=.~\ \ \jO~ F L ~ ~ t-Z\) From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trurnp Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31,2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31,2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Corumissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Marmy Grossman Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williarns Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williarns Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: J,SlV\ '351$ sw" f'.-ysh if br. t /L1il A,~"..., k Tfl<{u Address: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no altemative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:: ~o.... J51~ S~ ~/<.. It hr. *11-11) .....~"'-"; k 1f1<{c. Addt-...&&: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Arldress: ~o.-.. '3s1~ ~ "191c. if br-. .j41l A.v:1''lI~ ye... 1171'<- Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, AddreS!l: ~o..-. '3SJ~ S~~ ~k If br. */4il .A..~v..c. YL 1171''' Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura, Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: ~~ Js1. S~'\ J-f}1<. J} br. "f:J41l ,,~v~ YL 1f1'1" Name: f""'- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: ~Gi'\ Js1~ S~ J..f}1< b hr. "f:Jt.11l ,,~'W""' VL 1f1'1" Name: October 31, 2003 Cormnissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~~ Js1'!' St~'\ I-f} Ie. Jf.hr. J)t1ll ~~~""'VL 1f1t(" Andress: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~11"'1 SW~ :1S1~ ~lc_ if hr.'" ''--Ill ^y...f"""i VL 1f1<(" Address: Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ])/InII-M- /h-y1>r--l Address: '? ~ tv! (3 I~ I Sr ./IZoc 4v~f(1I- ~L , /fo From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M, Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura,Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: PN-NI--M.. ~1>TJ Address: ~ ~ ~e /ifl sr ff20~ . rll' p:'t ~ I~O October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Nmnl': p~,~ l4y1>1V Addxess: '? ':)-00 ,..J e /tf / >r #Zo& . ("4' ,c'L ;- !~O October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Pld-N'lvC ~1>'rJ Address: '?:> ~ ,JrE I~/ 5/"" .#Zd~ . fA< ~L "71t"O October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1JHNI~ 14y.fJ'tJ Address: ,??-oo,J f3 /'f / ~ PZot ? It'O . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no altemative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: .PQy./I~ ~PrJ Add= ,?:>?-OO JJ e Itf / 5/'" .#Zo~ ~L. ~ I~O October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shu1. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: .j}{d->lII-rA- Jh.yp-".l .AdL:I=: ~?-&lO tJ €. I~ I V- .#Zd(; . 1'# ;CL 3 Uf'O Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: rzJ/1J11J JG}4/Z Address:20/d..5 ~l jt'~ tav/!.F ,4,4;. /~OJ I/r.JTJ~~ fL .3.J/l'o From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Goverument Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ..._....,.__.......,...,........,_._______...".___........___n.......,__....."_...__..____.__.... .N. .~ ./1\ h4 :D 01..12 .~~l::,:~.:".,,-::~~ Mrlress:20/4S .dt:, Jj'ct ~I!J. ~/;. /"01 tll...;r~~ fL .JJJJ"D October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .""".....,.,."'..,.".."'''...,...--......-----......-- ,. "............ . ,., ....."'."'....".."'."'..-..........----..--..--......".. Name; 1JoJI4&:';Jl.. . J.,rlQfess:.20/dJ "U6 J,~ Ccvu ,4!;-. /{,.ol tI&-./T"'P" fL ,J.3JJ't> October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura,Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .--..-".-"----.-----.,-...--....-------.......... Namc: 1Jo-'14 ..~.~... . .... ...... ... . .. .ArloIess:20/dJ P6J'~~J!.i. ~!r. /(,.OJ j.JJJ'f) October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .......................,'__'_.. _..._...__..",........."".u_.....""'___"""'__'" ".____.n.."'..__...'.,_______. Namc' 1Jo~'4 ..J,;;Jl .. ... ...... .. .... ... . ~ss::Ufd.5 d6:f,~~u ~Ir. /{,.Ol tI&-./T~" fL ,J.3J J't> October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .,...............--....--.............."."'.....,.....,....--.....----....--..--...--..--.....-- .."....."..--...--......,.,."'....,."..,."..,...--...,....--.--...........--...,..--....-- .. ... ... ../f\ . .....1) . · . · Name: UolI4..;OG;J/- AtltJress:.20/dJ d6 J,~ ~U . . ~,4r. !{,.Ol tlt-'T~ fL ,J.3jJ't> October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .""'-....-........--. ,.""'-.----.-..." ".-,." "".".....----.. ."....,-........."...... ----...--.........,..,........--......,...-.....----..--.--.'. ""."'---.-..--........".,.-,----.. .."..-...--.,."'....,............--...,.,.---.........'. "'."..,....--------.-........--.--... Nam~;1JoJI~ .~~...... - " ,:,,,_::,,<:,::,,,:::,:::::":'::./"-::::--:::":-'::=="'-' Aildress:.20/dJ d63'~ lcvl!r ,4~r. /(,01 tI&-./T"'P" fL j.3jJ'O October 31, 2003 , , >-- Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .-......"........"...........,.--......-.....".........".............,...............,.,.-.---.."'.............-.---..',....--...... .........,..--......"............,..--------.'."."......'...,.,......,.,......",,-----...,.-,.- .,,-,---.,.....--_........,'-. ...".--.....".,.......-............"'..--.-.-....'."....----....,---...."."......."..,---...... .......----......,-.---.'.". -.... ..---...............,... ........,.,..---....---....."..,......."..,....".".--...... ... --.---.........-----."., N1mc: .1Jo"11J ......Jc,.~ .. ... .......... ....... .... . MJress:J,OfdJ d6 J,~ t;,;U . ~"r; /(,01 ,J.3jJ't> Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of oUr religion. Yours sincerely, Name;]) A V \ \) ~ I C. h " Address: ilill CO l \ I tv ~ A J . ~?t-. 2.~ 01 ~ u-... "'..., (S, f'S , '$ 3 If. 0 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 > Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:0AV l}). . -=b.., <. n.'.... .. Adchess: l!U.lJ . c.<9 l \ t IJ S A v' ' ~?b 2,"01 .,9\)'1-1""'1 \SfY-S131,"o , - October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NameZ\) A Vl~ ......-:D, <.h', · .... ...... . Address:i!U.U Cd> n t #..1 S A.J. . ..................."....... ""?-r-. . 2. Co () 1 · .-.-.,.,.--.-.-- .........,_..--".. $IJIJIJ'I I S I~S .1 J ,,"0 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NJmle:t A V\}) . ""':D. I <.h ~... . .... Adcltess: -lll.Ll c.<Sl t\ ( ~SA vi . J\..?t-. 2.(,. 0 :1 ................. .......,.......... ~ \Y~\J" (Sfq-S ';:C',: - 131(.0 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name0)AV \})~ 1<"', .. Address:l.lllJ Ce:>t \IIJS AJ. ~?i-. 2~o.1. S;l)'~~1 ls.:I~5 '131'-0 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N~~;J)AV (~ ~.~. 1< h '\.. .. Address: i!i.!JJ Co ~ l\ t #J ~ A vi . ~?t-. 2" 0 1 ;; '."'" IJ ,'1 (s: I i"S s J I" c October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Nll1De:))AV\~~I(.h'\<. ..... . Address: illJJ. CC)\ \, ~S A J. . ,.,..?~. 2. (. () 1 $i ...,. tJ IW 'I' t So: Iy-S , J 3 It.. D October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name;.J)AV \~-:b'<.h; Address:-L1..LLI Co1$> t\ IIJ S A v . ,.,..?~ . 2" 0 1 $iV'~~ / B~ 'i"S '131(.0 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totaJly inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventlfra. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Address: ~~C-- ~~\i,a- ; From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31,2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31,2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A verntura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby pennitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: '\Sl.)> -q; II Address: /97 07 ~ V -CNl1lfl1- ,Q IJBW/60V L lvt4y From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, n. ......."'.,.....""..--..................--......"'. . ..........,...--..---... Name:'\Sb~ -cP1/ ...........,.---.--.... Address: /97 07 . III V-t#11J/l- P jJgtV1iovl.- . . .-----...,-..----_..,." .------....,--...--- ..n' ...".,___u ......--........---... . ..--....""...--..... ..,_..._.___n.'_____... . -.........-.,........---..... lM4/ --......,.--,.."..--.... -ruM~Lfi./JY . . ./?- .rkJ~ · "3?1 g U October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..". -..,..--.--."..---..,.----.."'..--...' .....--.".-....-....--."..---.'.--.--......-.-.... ... -..."-.. ...-.-_.... . ..... ..A. ...... . . ... ... · .~_... _I} Jj ... ..... JO t.V!1:,1 Ov. L ... ... ..... .. NllIIlfl: \.l U-' I...{fr/ .. 'D Address: /97 07 7fJMfJr::fl/tY /trA? / Vi t/-t:-A/11./rLP. .rkJWi'?- '?J'I g u October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . .,-, ............."........--......"'...4-...--........--.--.."" --_---'d" ,..-- . 10. -I.. Nama: '7St.::lrc{J1I .. . 'DtA:.l/bOv'- . . .-r'... k7dt~."'..~:Y\ Address: . /9707 . ..?..... ;Yf...J-~ 'IJ 1/?iV11JfL.,Q. r4Jrz"J?/?-'- '??Jt? u. ."".,-,_...--... ",-. ............----- ....."" . .,/ k4?/ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:%>-cP//. .... ..IJ~wrkJvL ....... ..-..............--....,.....---....-............'.. . .........,.,-,-......--..,.....----...... Add=: 1'7707... ~M1Jr:::/i4Y /'J . . ~/_ ...... In J""L.. .'1/ 1/?t./nJrI.. --. r vcr _.... r,- ""37/8> U ..,-..-.......... .......-..-.---....,..... n.""___..__"'_'"'''' ...".------..-...,.. .........-........."'.. .,."-....--,,.,,_.,.--...... ....--....."'....---... . ________n ........".....------.....'... ..__n.".......__........ y '''''';;-::. J.._A. . w&-':,: . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .,?gaJj!:JovL. .. ... .........., -..--.-,----...-.,. --,.,...,....."..---......--........-----.....---..... -rbM[jiCP/J:Y . ... ........--..,--..". rkJ~/?- 01'/ g U . ."-.,..-...,,.,---.--- . ......,,--,..--_...... ..- -----.,-,-.-.--". .--..---....."......". --.-------...'...."'--' .......... ........ . y J.04 . ......_--".........,-,_..... Name:~5 cPl/ ... Aildress: /97 0' VJ (/?A/1V(L,o . . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~~rc-PI/ .1l/Ja.JjbovL. . Address: / 97 0--7 .-.......".......... . I /J. ~n.JrL,o V'7f/- . .- ---- ,'-' --- ---.-.., . ...---...,.-.....--,...... .. -r1;Mlh::Y1.ay . r4/,z,.O/?- '?7J g U ... ;/ ltA4 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~} cPl/ · .Agarjio~L. Address: /97 07 14 V~11J(L,O . p-"'-'- .-..... ...........,...-..--..............,.-.......-..--.... ....................."..........'.-. . rbMg)C/U2Y. r~/?- '?'YJ g u Jvt4/ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /lfllZa/V I1siVlMG ~ Address: ;3 L! [SAC lSA-Y be.'tb ~ '/3::?c J---k/c;~ P-c 33/6L( From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..... -................. ".......... ./l . ;.::::cc::.::;:;::::::,. Nome: '/l/lalA.f .,4. . ..'.... ...........".-.---..--.........,.............'. ..........-.."".............. ,-------------- ........--..--......."-....--...---- ..... ....-,.. ... . .'[?f- . B,~'.rAG . ,'~~:(! ,- .. "., ""- -'- " ,--...--...---.., . ....-.---,.,,'''.,-'' Address: 3L! 6A-C Epy j:),e;.~~ l-k~ p-c. 9S{6'o/.. . me October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N2mt:j//l~;1BMM~ f?-f- . .... Address: 3 -LI &SAC.... 'Et4V j5,e;:~ ~ MPc. k$qc . . . . ';t;~. . . . z,:3tbtf October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Nal1]e:J/Il~ . . ...I!S,eAMe5 [?f- ..... .... . AddICss:31./. tsA-(.. 15AY j:).e:.~ ~ ~ l-k~..~ 3"3(b''{. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .. ..... /I .. . . . . ... A....... J", ........ Name: f"l/?/ltMC. H5eAMrs n- ... .... . Address: :3 Lf &SAC 'SA-V D.e-~~. 734c.!-/.t;~ Pc- . "3"3{s;-'1!.( . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . .. /J . . r1 .. ... ... Name: J-'lI2/lc1AC .. H8MMrs Pf- .. ... ..... .... ... . . Address: :3 LI B'A-C.. E~y pZ;.~ 0-> .~ ~~ Pc.. . '"3"3{6'1:{ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely .disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ;J~/tcI,u I1BeAM~ W- . Address: 8 LI ~AC. 15AVj:)e:.~ ~ ~ l-/4~ .Pc- . S3{6'tf. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: /~/r1K- D.I/;{/ffYl'( 193J) ~R,ut.err't' (,uQV I ' JJ. Mt,4H, I ;}Z/tC# Ft '13/J'a Address: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: IS"II'/fc D.Mlrf1'(Y Address: . 193~S- M,et.Jkrrv toqy . ....... . -... . .."',--:.:, :-.::;;:.:::::;;;::_"-".,,.:::/::.: . jJ. MwtMJ . if'iN-# Ft. ~3/Ro . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name; 1S"fl1tCD .M,., 11I<Y Address: 193!">. 1f;/tt.7knv IvCf'l( . / jJ. M-[M.I . if'i#lI Fl- . 531f12 October 31, 2003 Commissioner JayR. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: . 1;5M-CD. 1U1Tn'IlY ... ..............."'..............,..--.--.-----....'.......'-.-, Address: /93!'S- NRlilkny tuqy IJ.~I #f.A.tIlFl ~3/;CJ October 31,2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:. !5"IrA< D. MIfJ1'~Y .. Address: /9 3.rS-);, .Rt.Jknv /;.Jqy . f . ..IJ.M-fAI-{j iJ'i/+e.ll. Ft. ~31? tJ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: 1S",orA< D. Ilif!fi~Y. .. /93[";- NRt.Jknv !uqy . f jJ. M-fAt-,f.J U2/te# ;Ct ~3/R() ... ............. Name: . Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: G 1iJ'\ f2c,~ bO (LY C1J c ;;LJ C-v? tV:! liS//' Name: ~r,Ji" , Prom the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Pax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura,Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A verntura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N=, G? "'>-- ----- Address: -J~ ~ '\wt) C;JJ.';r- '" From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Conunissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no . alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of ourcongregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. ..... ~ We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: '- Address: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31,2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~~~ Address: 1) ~1 ~ d- u.~;:,1( ~~~ \\ \J'-\ \ \~\Q \ -; Name: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .................."....--...............--..-.'.----........'..,..-.."...-..-...--...'....... l\ \ l\I>t-Cl.l\. .. ~ ~~Q~~lK ~ ~~(\. \J~.. \\~\D \ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue onShabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Y our8sincerely, Name: ?: ~ ..... .. ..."..... ...........----..,...--........................".'..........--....,- ",-, . '.. . ...,---. .. ........"--..-.............,,......' ......_""........ ..... . ,... .. ...,......."........,..,,--.. --. .........."... ". -..... ., ~. .. u\.{ V!\\O . . f\ \\I .\'0-. \ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, -~~; .Address: ~ ~~. .. ~. ~ l.\~>(' .. ~~f'\ .\S~ \\fd,.\D \ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..,...--....,.--..."'..". ..."........--.,.,..... . ...,..'--.."".... .........,.,--..... ........,--.....--. .........--..,.----...--.. ..........--.,....... ......,......--.....'.....'. ......n...'...___.......'. ....."......,...... :Name: ~~~ ;> Address: . lS k~ ~..-a..L\~)(' . ~~f\ W-\\\fd..\Q \ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ..."..",--"-' .--.,.--...".-..,...........-..'...'...'..-....-...-.....,.-..,..--....---...--..-- - ~~ ~ Address: 'is ~~ ~ 'B. L, >< ~~\\ \J"\ \\fd..\Q \ .. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Y ours sincerely, .............,-_......,.. .---.,."...-.........,--.... . ."._...,.".__.._-"d .---..,...,--.........,.----- ....,,-.--_.,.,....--.,... ."n,____'"'''' ...d......__.__... . n_._......____..,..'" ..,-----..",,--....... ,-...,.".,----..,.".,.--.. .,-,-..-..,.,.---.....,--..' .-.-...."--...--".,, ..,.......""--..--,,. ..........,.....--...'.-. . ......_,..,.......,. ...---"..'",-, . Name: Il. ~,.: 0, ~~..- Address: ~ ~~ .6Mk ~l.\~~. . ~~\\ . .~~ \\~\O \ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: AI/;---, 'l Address: 7~ /lJ..e IfJ5'r PFcJ/y:- .4~ ~( 5'J!,J>-O Prom the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .-...."'.--..... Address: ..---..."..,........"'.---..... AIi1r. . 7~ . lI^rEif>JJS'riJf"~ . '. ......... .........,. .............."........ .,..... ,............ ....."... ..".. ~. c:(. "....- :.::"',-",.::'" .. - ,. !J;h . --..--"......". ..----.....,.--.....".. . "-.....,,..... 1:... .'"-,,,..,..--- . ._n.....".... Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. YOurs sincerely, n' ...._._,_......""... "_.n.,,,,_"'''_ . ,---....,-,--......... ..,---.."""'----....". ..".--........-.. .. '_..0__."____..__.".. Name:.. .. ..........--..,.-. ....,.......",... ..."""-----.-.,.",,...-... .--.-........."......--..."'. .........--...---...,.."---... .)/ir Address: 7~J1lJ..rE.lf'?rtf='r:l;.r .~....c:( !J/Pu.. .....--....,...---.....--. .. ..m_"'_""'__'__" ,----"""._,-----. ........,---...". .------.....-,---..... .....".-.--.......-. .'l..... October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extrernely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Y ours sincerely, ..............-..--.. ........,......,.--..... Name: .....-..-.--.........,.-.--........'... ._n.."""""__""""" ..-.....,........--..,.,.--.....--.... ..........--..'.-- .......--......--.....,...'...--."'. ........,.-....".........-.....---..... ............_._.__...__... ."n_"""__"''''''''''__ ..-. .-...,..---...,..."......... . ----..--."'---.. . ....-...,..."..""'-' A/i'"rY . . .... Address: ?~.. ",j,~ If;JS'rtr~~ ~..c( fJ/h October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ....-.......--.."......-............ . ..--."'..---......-.--....-. .--...,.--.....,...--......-......... '_..0--_............,.----..-..--.. . ........--_.......-----.... -------.,..,........-....-.. ...----.....".....--'--. Name:. A /;'i-- y, . ..............,.-----....,...--......--..............'.-........... Address: .?~ -'l1-1E 1i'J1S'rtf=~ A_ --L . ~~c:(. .fJlh October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..... . .. . Name: ... ..A//r' y... . . Alldtess:. 7~ . ~^€/F)S'rt:f='~ ~.c{ !Jlh.. Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ?1vr-~ ftr;z:- d; J)tt<!J 55= /\l-E /;J-D(- #-20) . H.. !,J;J?8 Name: Address: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~.. ... ...... ... _ G.b. .... . Name: ----,----. #~ .. . Address: 550:0 p* ./l/J>r #=-m Art'/: .t1A::- . . R ~JI.P8 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alt=ative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. y:=~ fJ~ ADdress: 5>0:0 /rt~ .. AiPr #~ ;t"AI-t~ <PI:... >JI J?-8 .. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A verntura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, '. .. ... .. . .. . ...... ..... . >.-J_.. O~...... Name.: ~J' . Ef!/_. . .........---......".....--...."....--.....-. .. ,..,....---......". Address: 550(0 ;rf.,E .. /l,t.J>F . #=- ib! Ar".."l,1't- . . H $JIFa October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, -~~ Addre&s; 55C1f;;l.~ /?,2.J)f:r#-i7:1; ~t'II:k~ ~ PI:. .......,.--... SJI.P8 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, "- dr Rr-& . AOdr-..ss: 55aop-E ./9pr #~ /f,-"" ...ft;t:... . ',cl . 5JIJ28 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. y:~~ '&.j Address: 55c::r.o. paJ;: /9% 1?2r:Js ArI'J/ .k,r;... . ~. ~J 1;'-8 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours siucerely, Name: .-.-- ~-=e.. &fi;* /f .2-)1';- IP J~/Cf q Address: ~r<u> Al-,t:: /Lvr!-rrc- '351 r-6 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 ~ October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: :b..e . . &~;-k .~~ At~ .... /'1 .2-~<F- #" )~<f ~. R: "'5;1 n ...:.;; Na:me: . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alt=ative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely,. . .. . ..-- .. ~.... I.. ~am~ dace..... {),#.A;~ .. ,-.......,---,-...-.-- Address: $f.Q..D AI J= . /f J-flr t:F IO/lf . ~ q . '131 fa October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extrernely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alt=ative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. YOurs sincerely, Name: Address: . ____..."'.,.___".".........__...' "..n'_'_""'" . .---..."......"'.-..--.....,--..-."--. ,."---..."...------.,..,.,,.--- .. n....".........,_.....,.__..__..'" ,...,.--.-.,..."--.--.--.'..... ..u_...___....__....,.,..__.."___....'.______.."'..._____.'"..,_u__.,. ..'.0..--.'..-----..,.,.-...."'..-.....-. "..------.........--------.. , r ... ::,<:.::~JJi:~.</:..:;:::.:.L..,:n:\/..:.H ,!Lu; Af.fi: /f.2-~~)Q/<f ~ q <"$'51n . .~~.. ... ........-.. .-.... ......... -,. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Address: . .........."'-...--.......'.... ,--.........,-....-.-... ........--...."....-. -r cIo~ ............,...--........,......... ~f.ru, At ~. ~ 4. ~~1h .,-.-..----.."."------.--.'-.--'--. .............,.....-..."'.....,.--.--... . .......--.--_._.,-.,--_.,....-. ."""'........"'.......----.... .&~;-k . . /f ).fIr#, IC)/'f . Name: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ...............,---.--."...--...... ..---'...,.--......-.--.......--... ....m...........__.......,.,__..... .----.."..-----..".-.-,.-.,...-.-... . .-............--......"----..-..'-.. .-----..,.--....-..,..'.-....--....... ..--..--....,.....--...........--........ .:3;: . . . . . .. ?" .. f . _.e. r.:>I'~; ~ . Address: $!ru, AI ~ .. /f:L fir t:F-Iq;f<f . ~. q <'$31 t-a October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours. sincerely, Address: . ......."..""-_..,,.,-_. ..............-.....--.. .:3; . "':,.:::..,::,,>::::: . .e. ..............--.......,............ "" . . 7~ AJ,J; .~ ;Cf. "'$31 n ........"'......."........,..--..,...---..'..........'............ .......".--........-....,...--.....,....................--....-,. .--..""....,.-..,...".---,-..,. ...,' ..,....------.,----....... ..-...........,...-.........-.....,.--- ..".----.........,................--... .........,.............,.....---.......--...............---..'.,,-_...... . l~*.. ... ,-..-."'-... -..-.--,,----- ..... ,........".................--.. ............."....., '" ". ......-----...,--_....-. . ~; . ... .... .. /fJ.9r/- IF/t!:.>/<f .Name: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Name: JlICfhtcv .T@'ff,A/ Ad"'~, ;:; 7V/"""'~ ~ Ai rt-.- Ii 53/ P;Q From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no altemative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We wouJd appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Conunissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Conunissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuJ. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:\S,M~ S~ \ \ Oi\J Address: ~S sA rf\~ ~\C ,p<l\"'~ 0 r , (lr II S G,-",,,~,,,, [, 35,180 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..n' .........,..___....,....__.__............."......... ., ............,...,..............--..".,...--.....--.--.'..'. Name: .~~JlA.-~.sIj\ ,0('.). ......................,.....--...............'...... ,_.........",........ Address: ~S3.C N\,..~\C .pal,,'\:"'" Or . JJ..p H ~ r.v<:.....~J'"C. 1 c., "S"?, \ Bo , October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..........--..................,.............-......'.......... .......".,.,.---.............,......------..'.----.... ......,.,..,.,.-.-..-."..,.........,..,.--.....-'..-----. . .......,.,-,.-...--...,....-....,..,......".'..'..-."'. Name: . . . ~ ~ JlA.-~ SIj \ \ () ('.) . .....--.."..-......"......---.........-.... ....... .-..--.,-...-,.....--"'.....-. .,........-.....,.....-..,.,..-.-----.,.,........"'...-----.'..-...". Address: ~S 3.0 {l(\" J.\C .pal" -k 0 r . ..........::.:::"...:._:_...:\,.:..::..::.-;,:-:..:.:. flp H S Clv<:.f'-~~ 1 c.\ ~s \ Bo October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .-........,..,..--.....,........,.......--........"........."..----....... .........."......."'.........,...__.....u.........___....,_.__.d'__" .......,...".____....,..,.__....,..__........____...__.__.'......_n.'___"____ Name: '~~JlA.-~.s~ \.\0('.)...... Address: ~S3.CH'lf\.;.~, .p()~".\:.....O r "".:::;;::::::.',:;::::__:.:::::::;;:'..:c::::,.::,-,;;:;::::"''':,.:::::.;;:.::cc:,.;::.::.,;;;:..::__..:.-:::..::....::.. J}p \IS fiu<:.~J'"C. 1 C\ :<:?-\ ~ . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .........,.,........"..................".___...__..__.'...n_" .""'.-.....".--......,....--....."'......."..--....'...,,_.,...-,.....,. ..-.---...............,....--...--...,......-................,-...- Name: ... .t~~~.slj\ ,0('.) . . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .---.".......,...-..,.,.-----.....----.....--....--- . .. -------.. .-.---.."'.---.......----..".--..".. ..........,....----."""....,.."....--.......'.--......."...-..."..,...... Name: '~~CA..Q... SIj '\ \0('.) ..........,........"..............--.....'..----........ . ..........................,..........,.,.--....."......."...,,-'--......................".---.--..-- Address: ~S3.c {l(\", ~'( .pal,,'\:-'" 0 r . .....\. w.p H ~ r.v<:.~J'"C.. \ C, 'S?-\ Bo October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..--..."'.....--..,.----....--..'...-...-."'.. . ...--- ....... ........-..---....,-.....'.... .. ". --------..,.,.---.,--.,.---.. .. .".----.... ---.""---.,. Name: '~s.!lA...~ SIj \ \0('.) Address: ~S3.() r{\" ~c .po,.....\:-...pr .......__......,.,.......................__...,_. _L.:,::,....."'".::::,,;:;:;::.:::.;;:;:::....:;:::.;;:,, flp H S ~~~rc. \ C\ ~?- \ Bo Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: P ffc)1 ~ C.#-J T R. I r Address: l/)v nI F .I I,A; .s T A- (? f. From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump. Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ....--..--......."'--...".". . ............,.--........-.--".-. Name: P #-t:-H rI C#-J r/(l r Address: II}.,r / c- .I /Iv.s r If /? I!.. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shut We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Co=issioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: --c:1 (+){ c-E Address: /1 tJ ;l'c /0 .f1 / ( ER /3?l9 -sr From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .....-..---.........-.....,---............'--' Name:~ {tKC-E.. 1I/IER. .. Address: /" ~ ".IE" 18:.:\1 ~ r It? October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura, Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. r- We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 42.- ( ) E rI Address: IT tf ,.,fE 17 P T //3 ZR;~ dzl ~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any othershul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . n.......,.__.....,...__.._.,.__........____.".. .. ................--.....---...,.--........---.--.'..--.....'.. .,.._........,._.........__..."._.__......__.....'.u.__. ...---.---.--.,..-.-............".-----."...----... ... ..........--.--.--..,.,..--.....--.--....----.......---...... tLp frJ-. lj~S~ .. ,~.~ . n.........___....... .--.--....".....,.....---.. Name: E:t(J EN Address: Irtf ..vIP & p r 1/3 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ....._.....__.........,.,.___.............""'....____......"n .",_. ..______d_"'.'__,._____,_____."...._,. ..,-...........-.""'...--..--......."'....,..----.......... ....."......----...........,.--,--..-,_.........,",...-.. Z-.f ::-I'y l__$_ . ,N/ Name: ~fJ E '" Address: rf 1"'/iF ;9P r 1/3 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .."...,..---.......".......-."..---..............-.-.......... ..,...,-",_......._.......,.""..--,-----_..,',.,"_...--..- o . ____u....__........___.............".... .."..................-..."".--...---..--.........-.-.......,.. t:~~ l__ S__ ... ,~~ ., ,,,-,,,,,.,,. .."",,,,-------"" . """.....---.---..--.."".....-. . .......--................. ..........---.... .",-.---_..------".,..,--,.,------, . Name: . ea./! E ~ Address: 11 tf N"G /lP r /1'3 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ,... ...."d.",...__"d""'__""""_______""'_'____"" ."......----.........----....................--....... . - --.."'.-.,.----..,...--..".----.........---.... .. .,.-.-......."....--..--...-..-......"'.--..---."". :J:~~ .___ S_ . -# .~..:> . ......--.,..--.---........... ..........".-.......--.,..,.---...... ...........,.",..,--. ... ..........."'...--.."'.... ... ...dd"'''_' . n......."........_",. ...........".,........".".,........... Name;~IIEd Addi-esS: . I r" "v'" IF t1P r 1/3 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ....-..-.---.."'.--..---...."....-,.................. ........"......----....".,....---....,..,.....----....".'-. ,_.. .........".".....---...""...,.---.....""....-.-----... ."...............".-,....---.......-.,...---.'........ ;l::r~ ~"~ .----_.......",,-.... ... ..............._""....-. ...,-.,---,,---_.... .".,_.-..-..............-... Name: ~ iJ E tI Addiess: /1 f ,.y'" & riP r 1/3 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, \ Name: fJ tlr J F r(J=- 1ft N13 / 3C1.s r Address: ~? 00 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M, Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31,2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31,2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura, Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our collgregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~;d.h' EL-. .. .. .r Address: ?:/qLj Nk" tillS ~ I/.GJ./&/?'" r-L-"53 (PO ~ . . ...4 ~ / ~7/~ - . .........--....,....... .......,,--.....,............... ";?,C,6e?#, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: l(j fill A/'1 5 f))))'-1 Address: ) ] tJ() W-r ~"}- \(~ \! ~ I )) U?CJ Lv,$,/'1 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1J.tlll A/i 5/1)i-J~ Address: ') ] C(') W-r q~ 1+ V~ N r L ptA ..tiJ4. L11} , , I. It October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williarns Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shu1. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..,., ""'.,-""-.,.-,-...."....--.---.---......."......, ,......---.,---..---...--.,.-..,...,...,-...-....-,. . ...""".,.''''.".'''....."_,__.....____........".,,.....__..._____....'n_.___.""_'d Name:. .~ ZIJl ... bJ1 Sllh;;f~ ... AddreM: )iO~wi-9~'. . ~~t N r h ~AJ;lk11 q1i- -----M-! t+ 0 I :- ') q?CJ tv, ~Jf October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemlura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . .".."."""'-....-.-..........-."..........-.,-..-"---------..........."'-.,....--....-..--.....".,--". Name: .1) fJLAI.t5jJ;..0~. .. . Addre&s: )700 .~ .q~. .. ~ v~ N r u ftA.ti111 11\ 1=1- ~1A-,",1 )')I.RcJ Uv,5,Pr October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .......--."..--..................,.--....--.------......."'...---.--."'...-----....,.,........--.-- ......---.".'.'.".....-----.-.-........---..-."....._-,.-,......_----.--"......._--.-.. Name: 1)f-/~Aft5/!j;J~. .. . Address:)7()('l ~. ~~.. ~ V~ JV r u ~A#- ~ ! ~ 1t --M~-H~ f"\ J') X'D tv5J+ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .""."'..."...."__.,.___.,."_...."...._.__...__....____d.._.'.........,_,_,,_______. Name:1J%-!~ A/i SIl)/1Vf Address:)jtJO hLF -q~ ' . ~ \it IV' r ~ ~A~ lG1, B- ~!ff"ll )) Ro lvS)+ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extrerne1y disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..........'."..................--......-...."'...,.-----..."...,.----.-.--...",...---.--.""....---...----. ...'.........---.,...,.........--..-.,.....---.---"'..........--...........--......,-........ Name:1j f!./IL ~/15/lff1'-{< Address: 3]ChtLr -q~' . A- \(~ Iv' r L p-A ~ I l11t ~'"' I )) (.1(0 Uv5J+ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Avenlura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this rnove, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ Yor~/ Address: !(;q Df CflUAv-3 ~-A7U-Y? J . ::zs. u 291!t4-& F-L._ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williarns Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .............. .......'..-.....,..'..--..-----.,..,...-.....,., .'....--...-.,.'''...---..,..... Name: . ~ r~... Address: hltDf .~UAvJ. . ~AU~ ) - 41 L; ~~J;C. Pc..- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..,..........--....."".-.".,-.....,-...,---...--.."-..--.--_...".,-,..,-,-------,_..------_.,.."...... .""...........--.--.--.........".""-----.--.--..-..-..'."...--.....-........"..".-----...--......... . ~Yd'J::r~ J .. . Name: . 'O'Y''I.-;? . Address: . hltEf ~UAv-5 .~A~;Y7 J.~U ~.. ~L~ .::" October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby p=itting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .'..---....-."'.----...".-.-...-.,. ,......._-,-....".._-,--._------. .........----..--..'.'.--...--.,........."'.......--... '.--...."......---..--,.....--,--......... .Name;~' y~.. . Address; .. 0ltDf ~UAv;5. J. -4- (-e. .?!V~ Fl-_ ,-.-,.-.,.....--"-. ....................".,...--....,...........--.". ..'.-.--.'---.'..,--..-." ~AU---yJ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..--..-----..--.......--.....--.....-.........""""""..,.".,.."-.,..,.."........----...-----.---.- ."_"'."..........._...........__....___.....__....___....._n."""""""""'__'_""""__' .",-.",."....".-. .. .............----..--..--............--...................". . 1'_0......... v..r>~.J>./' Na.me:~ iO'f r'1-;;r . Address: 'hltn( 2e~~AU-y7 .J - .::?? u.FV~ 1'7.~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .'.....--.'."'.'.---..,.--....,...._______.,.______.,..,..___n.",.... .._....'....____........_........._."....___......___.__... ...................'.......,.,..................--.."....-.-"..... --......---.......---.-...........,...------....-----...... Name:... ~ .y~........... ..... ... ...... Address: . h,tnrf CPi:.GAv5.. ~..,r,U-y:? J - ~ Le ;g,~ 0#7> October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ................"'-......---.......----.....................-.."'.... .- ...-...---....------. '''........--......."... ."'.,.".....,.-. .---..----.,..,.....--..-------... Name:. ~,y~ Address: t~teEf ~U-Av:5 ~AUy7 J--4.U ~~..~~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, 'f om the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: // -:r-...,.t~ . Address: ;?-Pi?.. Z '--;& ~ yo- //.~r<O::;; 'f- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: . Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 11 ~,II/~ Address: #Pp:... Z '--?1'51 ~ r 1/ f'>t-"> '-f- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: .7/-;:' '^'~ . Address: . .#-p,XC "l 0~c..r I/~f-~ 'f- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: II ~.#~ Addre.ss:> #,P.J::?: /'L. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to 1eam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NlIIOe: IV ~.#~ Address: #-' f>~ Z ~.:z;& -c. r // ~f-<r::;: '-f- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Nairie: If-r . #~ * Address: ,4-Pp:'" I- ~.JI.,&~r' 1/.8f-~ 'f- Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: .)1 O.sF r/ { /1 r9&1f Address: 1;z.2 ~ tI r=' / / / _ "5 r From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31,2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island, As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. . Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: h'r'SAJ-.F,N -h \ AI"" \ , (A-S ~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez . Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..".-.---..---..-..,.,........---....... Name: J- L1ir 1-. J~\'" S,AJ.Fl~ Addressf)?;OO l1L.~. 9l}- ,~'1'4tARf+ J\ '.AI'" I ') 1-, I ~ (j r IL S ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .._-----",..._--------,-.."",._---". ..-..........--.............----....". """'--"------'--'--'-""-' ,.....---...,.. .'.'.--.'..-...----..,.--.-.------..-"'. ....----..--...,. Name: J- 1 1Jr f-'"- · . /tr" 5 ,4J..f;,M. AddreSs:J?,OO pJ ~9~ . ~~RPr -M 1 AIV\, I Yl., r cfJrA..S ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ."._---,.._-"...--,...... ....--.-.'.'..-----.-.,..----.,...-....------..".. ....--..'."'..,.---.".,.-------. .--."...---..--........---.....--..--..........-..,..-------.-. Name: J-.LU /-.. . ~~ S;ALJ.:t"1 .. , ... ..'if:::.:-,,::::.::::...,.:::.::.:,..::::::..,; Address:j?;oa pJ ~ 91}- A--~~R}+ _M1AI"I\ )~ r 8('J f^-S ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, y, t 3 (:) .__n_..."."..........."..."..._"...___..___... . ,.--------""",----...--...."....,,-- . ,. ..........",-"--,------_....__.,..,,,..,--. .'.._n_.._."'..".____..__........."... ,~~ SAJ-{;,M . 1( ~RJ+ rA- S ~ ..,' .......--.--........ .".,_..,,-.-------.. . ...........---.-.....". -... ........."..,...-,.......--.---...,.. '''''-J::,f.:T;'!: ,,--.-- Name: . J- '-LA 1- Address: 0 () -M lftl"\ \ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .. ...............,,-..--.......-- . ...-.-.---.......-..,-.'. ...."'.-..----........-...--........ Name:. J- 1 Ilr 1-. J1c~ 5 AJ..F,M AddressC)~O!? IV ~ . qL}-lvj;J!fv-~-f+ ---f\ 'AIV\ ') ~ I ~ C? r A- 5 ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: J-l r A I- Address:')'Yot? p.L~ 9~ A-VP~(..RJ+ ----f\ ,.I+[VI. \ ') , I a (j r ^- S ~. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name~~Nre Address: / r; /1 if { jJ.)J-(e~ _ . COLC ,I'.....vs J:;l/~.X-~ ~2-)" } S. 751..L/ ~~cjJ. h ' /3t~ ---- From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:B~rJfe · Address: I (.; q f { ). .7~ ~ty7 .. ,.,...--.--..,...,.....--------...,.-........'.'.-----'.. . - ..........."...--....----.-..--.....-.. . ----....---..-"'.-"..--"'-....----. ..."".-..---.,.-",."....---..,....----"""""- __ ""--'0"_--_"'--"'-'-"" ..,.-.---......."..,-------....."",----" ......--................--.......,............ Jj.)J-ItCR- . . "",-,:::":,,,,;,:,::,;;,.:,:.::;,;,.:,:,:::::--:~,..,..:.:.:::...::.::::.:.;;:....:::..':::::,::::.:,-.::: Cot:-C.. /'~ 1,:1,/~ =-~ ~J:?ciJ. h .~zr J ~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...~...... .......,._---",... ....."".,..--.........-..--.... ..",....,...... ........."...--....-.... .,.....".""". .. "'-,.--......"'-..---.....'... ,---,. - ,---- -----.....--.,."'----.-.. ..",_....... ,- ..........",............,,-. ..........".--... -. ",....----"..."............. Name .~rJfe ..,...........,.... ."..............--..--... . ,--, -.-..... ..........,.-..--...... ,---....-."...,------.. Address: IGtlf { .. 5. .::f~. /3tp-? ..,-. ---.......-...-........,....--.---...,.,.---.......'.....---..""'..............,-.----....-- .__......."...__..,.".____......"..___............___....'_.____n.....'............."'.,...____....'......__.. ........."'..---......".--....."......-...--........--..............--........--.....--..........----........ .......--."......--..--..,,--.--..--........------.......----..--.......----...........--.--.........--.--........ ----...--.......--........----..............--............--......----...--...........----.........--.......--....--... ...........................--..............--.----.--......................--........--.....--........--.... ......--.--.......--...........--...........--.--.....--...----......--............ ............."..................--.......------"........--.......................--..--...........--.--.... Jj. ... .. ..'tl . . .. . .. .. .......... -- --. ------." ... .--------..------.----.--.. . ... ;',;,::.'. ...:::::::::'::,::::::::::::::::::::::,::::::=::"::::'" ';J 1C1Zc. . :"::'::'.;.: .~. ::":.:;.:.:",;.:;;:::.. :"..;; ':. ::: ,. t:, ::].. T/.:'::-;::..: ::.:: ::. .:.'::.: :i...:.::: t:. / [. CoL...C /'....vs J4.;~ ......~ . .. r?Z:>/ ff~c.j;. h. . ." . ~: October 31, 2003 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ ... ."....-............... -......-.....-.....--......-.-..... ...._....".,_,...__...... ..'.0..__.....""'_,..________..___ ...... --.."."..........................,.,,---......--....""--.. ..........,........... ..., .....-"'......,.........---... ....__......__.,_... '_'_n....____..._."...__.,_, . ... .. _ l't Nlml6. ;:y..trv,e .'n.........". ......"...................."... ...--,.....--"". .......-......,...--............... .. .,...............,.,..............,.,...,-. .",. Address: 1.(; t, tg :> . S"..75t...e/ ./3fvVC ., , ,."-.----....."'.-.-.-.-.-..,......----......"-----.........,.----.y..."'..---..----. ...."..".....------..,.".-,..-..--..........------.......-..,--................,.--..--.---..--......'...'....'...-. . ,.,,---. .._"-",...------,.....,------_._....,,,--,-.--_._,.."..-",-----_._,_.,.,..,. ......--........."--".--.---.,..""'--.--....-"--....'.--......'...'..,-..------._,.."". ."'."..---....--"'."...,.------."--,--.--.--'..''''...--...--''...."......,--,-----......_,..".,--,....--.--,--. .--.--.----"..,--...-......,.."'.,.,-..-.'.....'--'----.'-.."'.--.,--.--.--,--,..",.".,.,-,.,.--_.--,.....,.,",.". .". --.---".., "..---.-..-.,--,...---.......,."....----.-.....'--"'..'...--.--..---.---..-,... . . t.l .... .. . .....~).J1'tfYL# ... .... ... ... ....... (" Ot.....<- ./'..-v:s .t;;t,....~ .z..~ "1~~ . . .-z.Z~ I til1h?c/.I. h. . . ~. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...-..,....."---..,---..---------.....,."'--------...". ,...,........__....,..". '..'n_.____....___.......,_.__...__... ."""n......... ....,_"..__".__...-'-'.... -..-....-."""'--.... ..-...-......,...,.----........,-,. ..............,.,. .......-.....""-.---..........,.. ....,.............. ',' .....-..--......"'.....---...... ......."'-..........--.., ...-....-,.....---..... .........,........... ,d,"_._'_"".,,____.,..__.... NameJ3.>srJre Address: / G. q <g .{ . - - -- --- ).7~. /3~ . """.---.--.----....."'.---...---............."...-.....----..-,-,.--,--.--..--......,......,...,.,-.,.--..... .------..,.......-."----------......".....--.----..........-"----,...-."..,.,.-----.--.--.'...-'."-.......'.'.. .."...--.-..---.,..".."----.----.-..,."...,--.,.------.......'.--"'--....--...,..,..,-.,-------.,.---.--.-.-.-.'--. .""'..,--..-------..--.--..,.------..,------,.,.,..,..--.--.--..--...'...,..---......-.,..,.."..--.-- . ......--..-.--.".."--,.,-----.,---,....".""..,.--..---""--'.,.--..--,--".....",.,."-".,,,.... ...---..-..--.,...,."'.....----..."'."'..--...-.-.----...'.'.."..-..----.,....."'-..-.--.--..----.'.'...-...""..". ."'..,--..-...--,..."""..-..----.--.,.....,.,--.,--.----.-'.-'.."",.--,....",.,.,--,.-- ... /JAJ-ftfYL... .. ...... ....... . ..... . . <: OL-C- !~.t;;!?"'l!'.=.,~~ .. ... . ~Z~I . tffJ:??c/I. fit. ~. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .Js...... -..... .......-..... ...............,.,_............-.--- .."n.....'.... .,........."..-...--...".'-. .--......,. ......".-...........,......--.--.... ..""no...""_'___"' ,... ,.......,.....--"........--... ,---,-"..-,---_..., ._,----_.."".,---_.......... Name . ~Nfe ".-----... ........ AddreSs: I Go f1 iff if ).7~ /3tp-:? ............,..-...................----.----.'."'.--.......'....,.-......"'.,-...----....,..-..--...-........... . "..,.--...,....--....,..--....".,.-------..'."..----..--...,.,.-----..........,---.--.--."'.,.............'-. ..". .........-..--.,....----.."..,......-."'...----...........-.------......."'-----..,.-.,."..------.". ......--....,..-.--......-..--...".,.........'.'....--....'--....--..".......----......"--... ......,.-..".....""....'.'.'......'. ".,........",.,.......,.""......,. .."........,.."...--"..,...--.,..,...--..--..,..",...--.....".,.,..--.."..,.,.".----.....,..,.--.--...'..'. ...--........."......,....--...""..,----.--.".".".......'.'"--,--...."."...--...--......"..,......'.'. ."--.--.., ".--.....,."--....,.....--...--".."'--..--"".,...-- ..,...".,--..--..--.",.--.--....".",.--...... . ... JJ 'f'.Jp L? . ... . .. . · .."..:: .~:~:7~::~::::::::::::':::::::'::::::::::::":':':: ::..:::'::::::::..:.::::..:::':::'.':.::.':.::::.::.,::...~....:...::::;:,',;,:::.:\....:..::::..:.:;:::'.;::'.:'::'::::'. \ OLC /....vs J;;1?~s.~ . .. ~z..,.} ~cII./t. . ~. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~.... ..:...._.:.:.:::::::. ,::::::'c::::::::::co,::::""""-' .-".....--.,........--........ .........., ,-.-. ..---.--.....".,,-, .. , ,.......---..........,,--...---.. Name ~rJ[e . Address; / ~ C, ll" {. ..."'....--.....----......."'.,.,.-......--....--.....". ..""",---------_.......,."".".".,------...,. .. "''',..--..-.---.-................... .".."..--..--.--......"'....-...... ..."_n.'_"___________""'_'" ...".......--...----....--..... .., .,.,,-...,-....-----........ ".----........--.,...-.."....,----..-----... JJ .}..f-f'pJ!? .. ~::~._",,- . 5.7~ /3tp:-? .,_,. ... ...... ..'.d.'," ......__.__.........."......__..........." ...",.,...._,......... r- e>t:....:C. /'...-vs J#,/~ %.~ ""ZZ"1'" J ~I%?c.j;. h. . . ~; Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Avenlura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 1l!W7J-~::J. y.yc/'C-/ . Address/G4/)r- CfiLVt"J;/ nV/ .:;Jcz.:J \ S :7]- ~7 g~,JI, ~( . From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ..............".".---...."'.".,-.........--..."-.'.... "'...---...---...........---.....".---......"."'."-. ..................,..........."....,............,.,....,_......."..., ,.."...---..---......,.--.--....."'-----...... . ........--.....,.-----...----...,."-........--.--..-...'........ "'...---........-. .., ..JJ~:r. ..., (/.yt/"'(';/. J,~ame.,/VJlflp,. :..'-- .:. L"':::::-:: Address/64/)- CP~'~" ~(/,; ~~e.:J \ S ::;iJ~>- g~ /( October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shu1. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..-.-..........,.-..-.,.----....... ,.....--....-..,."--.--...-.."".-..--.--.......".---..---....."......--.--..-.".. . .......----....."......---..-..,.,..".----....""'.-,------...----.,--. ....".....-------...,."",-,_..._.".,...,-' Name:MM~j-. y.y</~ . . Address/6v.>- 0;<:..,,-,4' P9V',i.;;/t,t>::Cl t 5 .:75 ~J;.. ~~ -4'.. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .."...--...--.............,.---......,.....-....--......'".,........-----..,.......----...,..-------.""....-......'..'"..."---..-,--.----.""'.. .. ' , -..""'..--."'."'-----.,...."".....------.....-----...--.--..".."...-----."..".,-------...... Nattle:IvfIM~3. .y.y~V....... ..... Address/64;.r.. ~~~:..~/ ~V,; .;;J~Z.J \ S 7J~ p~k.. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .".----..,.,.-.,.--.-.."".--------........-....---.,.......---_........"-..----------_.......,,.--- . ."'.."...______...__.""..,.,...............,........_......,._...""_. ' ""'0""'_"-""""'"'''-''''''''''''' Name: ~~ J' ... y.v"'C/.. Address:/64/.>-. O;~r~" ~V.; ;;!>ee.3 \ S 7J~>-- p~h ,. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island, As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ....."-.--......-.....,.--..----.,.............-......".-'.,----_..---- ""...--......".--..,.....".....-----...-...... . n.........__,."__..__......._,.,...............__,..__.... ,. ..----......."-.-........"'..,-.--.....'... Name:MM~3..Y.y~V.. .. Address/64/)"'. Q;~~4 .a&v)-.;;A~e.:J \ S 7Jl~~ ~h. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ... .............. ....,...,-.--...-,.......... .'.-''''-'---- ......"'......-...............--............ ."" .,...........__...._..........,,__, ,...... ._.d...___..".__..__.._____"".. Name:A#bJ~:T.y.yif'!/" . . Address/64/>-. Co;~'~ . ~V~ .;Ize3 t S :::?J-I / >- p~ /( Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27,2003 The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: I permanently reside in A ventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williarns Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Robert 1. Werner \2003 Misc\RTW Itr re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ ~f~ . Address: ~3 J 0' ') it! f ~/ 0 -fA- \(f tJ 're, ~!J 1M ~ 1+..bJ )) (e(l lA,SI t~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .------."'..-- --",.,'-.,-----_.~...,----,.,.,..,",.----_._"."".------."'------.........,------... 1L~ ..... __.,..._,_._...._..." no.. _..__...___".... .....".,.___......."..,...,.,__...._..,._,..,___.......,_.,-...-... NBJDt: t. .. ............ .. .. Address: ~) ()() rf P 6; () -4J- vP~(} · M ~I+ J6J 35 fee 0-"-"'-"""'" ."....--.----......... . (A,51 J\- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .",. _..,..."......-".--_.........-,,-------_....-'....-'---........".------..."..".----....".......--'. .........'~..~...........~....:.......:....:..:.....~.........:..:...... Name.. . .Address:.. ~3o<-J VIp ~O.. .. -4t \Q2U1tJ ~J. · M 11+bJ )) {to. .. ........--.. (A ~ . ?r ' j . October 31, 2003 Commissioner JayR. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Avenlura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ........--.......,.....--.........,..-".------......-.""..'.".........--......---....---.,....,."'...--.........'-.. ..~~.... N~:~... .. ... ... ..... ......... .. Address: ~ 30(") r! P6; () .. -$vF\l-1{, P;# M ~ I~ 5'3 rt(l (A 5 r- t 1 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ---.--."'...........--.............""'....---......'."'.--....-----.,..".--,-..----........,........------.."......... . fI.. f.~._ _. . .. Name:~rv~'~.. Address: . ') '3 O(~ vJ',~ 6;0 · .. -IJ-vFij ~, ~~ ' Mf/t~\ )'3r~(l . (A/SIr October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island, As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ."...... .........""'...,..--.---......."..,.,.-----.----..-.'-.'..,---..--.."..",..,---...,.,..-,-.---"""""'''- .. .~. ....,.,...........-.."'.,.-, -.... -......"-.......- ....,..,.----."--....,.......---......,..,---.,...--...".".'. ...""'.,.,__....__..__ ..... .____............. .n.._.__...,.,...__..........,.,.....__.....'.__....'.__.... ."'.-...........,......-...-. -... -.".,-,-.---.............."- ....."..-,-........"'.,..----.......--... .,._.,,___.........,...,... ,.....,_"_,,,... ..__....... '.'n.....""....___.....,__...__.....'.. A~.......... '"'....,'.-'''-''''--''' , ..-----.-.....,.. ...-..'" ,-....--........"'.,....---....". ,-- ..-..............-....... .. ...-------....-.. --.....-- ......-...---....--.......-.----...-... .Na"",,: . .. ~. ' Address: ~) '3 O() . VI f e1 () . -4J- v;p \J ~J ~(j , - M ~l!:.b.1 )3(8'( . --.--.. ......-... ...--.--.......-.... lA 5 .pr . / 1 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .' ---..---....,------........,.......--..--."....-...-.------.....'.,.".--.----."...-.-----.-.'. -,M-~. Address: 0)0-~ vip 6;r) -fJ- \IF \J-1( I t,,g. . ~. . {f1 ~ f~l 3'3 (eo. (A 5 Jk .' ~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of oUr religion. ~'C..~~~ ~~"\.~0. ~(:)~ \ZaV5;..c"-\ N~ \ 0., ~ -sb ~ ~\'" 'f\ \[ ~ rJ \\..,.y-~. F L \ ! I I i I I i I t I I Yours sincerely, Name: . \~ \\ 0.... Address: '"5;:saC) From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ."..".."-,.-..--.---.....--......,....---..--....'-.'-----..,. . ....---....--....,-...,. ...--..--........."..-,---,---...---........".....,......'.-.'..,. Name: ~ r\0.... '.' \U:"l~ ~OVs.:'-\l. Address: OZoC .N-i?\~ ~ ~~. .~.~\'" ~'C..~~~ ~\[~ rJ'tUY"O\... 'FL" '?::. ~:\~c. . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. . Yours sincerely, ..............",-. ~'C..~~~ . '?::. ~:\ ~C. .........-.--.............--.--..--.......,"--.-....._..,...."--._.._--,-," ...."'."'.,.------.-----.....---.--.......-...-...---.--..-............. ...-----.-..-.........--..--......-......--.--.--.....-...--.---.-.. . ~~~OYt-C~ . .. .. .t'l.\2 . \0., ~"'~~ .~'~ ''-\ '~\f'~ ~'tVY'O\.. FL .. .."...... ----..--"--........,,. --.-.-....-------...."...--.--.-------........... Name:'~r\~ Address: :> Zoc . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..........--.---."'."'.,.". .........-...-.-.--.............-.-.....--."."...--.-.....'..,-,,-,-. ,-..---.....,.--.".,-,---,----.......--..'......'... ..,..".-........,.,-------.,.,...---.---..-.,...-".---,..----.--. Name: '~r\~ . .~~. KoVt.'-\.\.' . .... . Address: '"5ZoC' !>l-C2. \~ ~ ~~~.~,'-\ ~\f~ tl'tuY"O\..''FL . .. .........--.......... ~'C..~~~.. .............---.............,,-.-.-. '?:::.~:\.~i.:). October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ......__..__________.._............__.".,...__.... .",,_..,_ u..._.......,....._._...._..........,..............._.............. .., ,.,.."."-.-........----.....,...."".-. ..............".",.".-,--..-...............,.,...-.....---------.......,-."..-......... ., ...... ..---... ....... ."".,----,..._--_.,....."",-,,-.,--.......--_....,",......'"---.-....".,,..--,---.-- Name: ~r\0.... . \U:"l~~OYt-~~.'. ...... Address: -0 Zoc l'!~ \ o.,~ ~~ ~~ \ '-\ ~ \f ~ t"'I'tVY"O\... pL ~"C..~~~ '?::. ~:\ ~b . October 31,2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ....-...--.---...---....--. . ..".. ---------.-......... .--...---................"'-... . "'....--.---..---.--...............-.-..--........ n_,_,"""', ." "....,_... .."". ----.-..-...-.,."'--."-,-----...-.-.-.,.""... Name: ~ r\0.... .. \M)~ ~OVs.:<-~ . . Add.ress:o"DOC' l'l~ \ ~ ~?:'b~~ \ '-\ ~'"-~~~ ~\f~ X1'tvY"O\...pL '?::. ~ :\ ~O . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .-..........--..--.... ........--....."'.".--.-..--.-----------..."."..-..--.--...',. .. . ___ _________ ...'0-"-" '. . ___ ______......."........,_,_____......,.,..,... .'n_.......__________..,. ..,_",__. ._..0..__________.,.,_._,__,______._..."". Name: ~r\0....' ~-s:: ~<.'iVs;.c..~ . n.." ......._..__......".... .----..------....,...."'."."'....------'--...,...,....-----...... Address: OZoC' t>l~ ..'\~ ~.~~.. ,~'~\'-\ ~~~~~ ~\[~'t"i'tUY"O\... pL '?::. ~:\ ~C . Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: -DlD.t,o.\ 4(JJM oS KO\fLc-8- Address:,3:~O/) t&PJ )q~ Sf. =If '=i JLf tDA'r\'I- A'-J Q;'f\ ~V 0- t:k 5~ jgO From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: .A}Cltn\ .QuMo3 KO\fI.~ . Address:L~~6/) ~,)<t} st!t~ Jll tuAY\'1-. A\JQJr\h.~o. ~ . 5"j } KO October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ............"".-...------......-..-......""....-..,.,........--."."---,---..---.---..."'----.......,.".,............-..-.-.-.,...,--..,.,... . Name:.At~tn'-t>JJMD5f<()\Jl~ '. .' Address:^3-~O/) I8P I } <1c} st tF- ~ )LJ illA vcr. A\j Qfl"\~y 0. . ~ . . 5~lKO . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:.AJDtp\ ;QJJMOgKO\f.l~ . . Adclress;.~~O/) ~, )~ Sf, #:1-J J!-l .tJJA Y\-:L A\J QJr\ ~ D. ~..l.:.. 5~)K() . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, '.' N2lDe:-A1(1tnl.QJJMoSf(()\r~'. . Arldr-"ss:c3-~O/) ttiP.~ }~ st ft'~)Lf tD:A'I\1".. A\JQJr\ ~O- ~. . 331 KO October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of ourcongregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . Name: -Alr\tA' ~J.1M 03 f<o\Jl.~ . Address:L3:~C/) mtP, l<1C};St 1t1-J JY tDA \\'1- A\J QJr\~(1 f..1:. 5~ , gO being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who carne to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of Aventura. Sincerely. Lesli K. and Jordon L Ross Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Mayor Perlow: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. I personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams lsland. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. ~:rtJ/---~ Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams lslnd Synagogue\\RJW Itr to Mayor Perlow re Shull! 0203 FtobertI. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manoy Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: I permanently reside in Aventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Rober! 1. Werner \2003 Misc\R1W Itr re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat I The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04"CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Holzberg: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. I personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams Island. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours, sincerely, 1CM1J~ Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams !sInd Synagogue\\RIW Itr to Commissioner Holzberg Seat 1 re Shul 110203 Robert t. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: I permanently reside in A ventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Robert 1. Werner \2003 Misc\RIW lit re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Grossman: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. I personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams Island. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other ShuL Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams Islnd Synagogue\\RIW Itr to Commissioner Grossman Seat 2 re Shul110203 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Maony Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: I permanently reside in A ventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Robert 1. Werner \2003 Misc\RlW 1tr rc Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Diamond: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. I personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams Island. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams !sInd Synagogue\\RTW ltr 10 Commissioner Diamond Seat 3 re Shul11 0203 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: I permanently reside in A ventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginoing or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Robert 1. Werner \2003 Misc\RTW ltr re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Beskin: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. I personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams 1sland. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. ~ Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \WiIliarns Islnd Synagogue\RIW Itr to Conumssioner Beskin Seat 4 re Shull10203 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Coriunissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: I permanently reside in Aventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Rober! 1. Werner \2003 Misc\RIW ltr re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: I permanently reside in A ventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. Sincerely yours, Robert 1. WeIDer \2003 Misc\RIW Itr re Synagogue to City Commission 052103 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: _:r.2.C t-I k; Address: 2> '(J<J NQ, 1 ~ ~ .~ 1r1.A)-1\1-- A\r~yYr;~VA fL '?;:s ~~ 0 From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:~2C tJ k; . ~~rJ2,1 .~. J:3JA ~ ~ A\JfQ'r;tuYA fL .' 53 ~~o ..... Address: . 1<1 .r~: :1" October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .......t-1...k... . . '2JC .'. .J; . . ...."..--- ....-. i<'::~:::: :::,: . ::: ,- .... "',, Name. . . Address:.~~~ JJ2, . ,~~ ~~ tt'H~'. .~. r\t ).,\(et~uYA.fL 33~O '. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . .J-1 k. .----,..,--_........... -.-. ," -.-. _........,-,--... .........,-..-..."....-. . ..' .....,-....-" .,,- ' .. .--"'---" Naine:..d=-2C . .... . AddIess:~~t) JJcl' \ ~ ~~ ttY:iA .ttIA t-'\ 1- !A\fIO'rYtwA f'L . 3::S'~O . · October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .t-J&'" . . 2C' ". .. . .,.. . ..' . . . . l\'mi1e:.:-::t:: '.' . .' . '.' Address: ~<J JJci . ~. * .l1'lA tl\1- ).,~'n1WA f-'L ~:s ,~O .' . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . J-1k Name: ..J.2C '.' .. Addre!/S:.~t)<S ~ . \~~ ~~~ l3J.A .l-\ 1- !A \te'rYruY'A . fL 33~~O . .. ...--.........".--...-..... October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name::J-2C-W k' Address: ~~t\ NQ, \~.~ ~-i tt~~ l1rA ~ 1. !A \T'O'r'Ytv.'Y'A fL' 33 V~o . . .' Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of oUr religion. Yours sincerely, Name: G~?("\ i'\ (L M J-er--- Address: )VI(b( //vi yr}-' c ///'cf~- , , ~~.._=-==- From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ......."'...__.,.,...__.,.._........,......'.u.__.......d." ..................,.--..--.........".----..........."...."....---.. /", IA.(A ...('. - J__' .Name: 0:er} <.:..--. ~~ -- . Address: JPi r I:J f 1/V1 yfft C .' J#dV-- ,.:_.:.;;::..:_::::::::;:;:.::::~-;::;:::.::;;:::::;::::::::::::::::<..::.: ; . --~~. ~ -- . --------==-- - .----- '" . ;.,:::':":'::.':::"::'::::_:':-::'~;';";"~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...........-,.,.,....--.---.."".........."'...--.--....,."..............---..,..---..-."...-.--......... ..............."..,.......,..-..........'...............,...--..............,--........""..........."'. Name: C~}!'lrL~~.' Add1css; If?! (,0' l/v1 yf..f-J C ft?dV- 1,.....:........:-.:........."..:::::.::::::::::::::;cO: 7~V ~-- - .;::- "":"",,,,;:.~~~'':':; October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .,......__.__..........__..........,..,.....___....".'...__....,.,.u....""".__..__._........__..__...."...__......... .". .......-.,.,....-. ..............................,...--..........'....------..-.............-". N~:..Ce~}btrL~k--~.". ..' Address: lPl (Dt l/v1 rf-f' C l#dV- ,".C:,-::;::: ... :.:.. .__..::~ ",',;:.::::::,;:.",:::::::::::::::: ........... ............,.,."......".....---.......--....'-' .........,.."..........". ........................ .._,_......... n..........,.......,............,.......... ,,,...........,. ;;7? ~ : ~ ~-----"".._-- ."-,,,,-,--,,~~:..: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ......."....,...--...--.....--.............'...............,........ .---...,..........--.".--.......--....--.'..........--...... ."'--" ....."...,.--..,.--.., ------...----.,.---...-........"."....-.... Name: . C~t'}vdL~ Jv- '. . Address:1Pl (Of 1ft? yf..f. C1#d'~ .-.:.::....,.:......:.........,...::::'::::::::..::::::.::::":.:::::,"": .......,...__..........,...............................u.,_,..."_,,, ......".,.................--".........--". . .......-.... ..........................---..........."...........................,............ yc- V~ _ ~------..__._--- -.~. --.,;..... October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..........----.,.....--..............'.......'...--....'.'.....".............--.--........--.....----...............----_._,-,_. .,....................,.........................,........'...n_.__.."'........,.__.....,."...."'.......___... .........---....,.,......."'...........--.-.....'...--..-..-.-...""-...--."....-----.".. Name: C~JL-trL~~".' .'. Address: It?l(b'' l/l1 rif. C i#dd- ~:. ::: ::." ',,,.._ . .;....... ; 'IF. . .... ..................._...... ..d.....__........__.........................'...............,-"""" ............................, ......,..--....--.........---.............................'.'..............."..----....,-. ........,..--................--.........--................--...................--...... 7'-;-;J;: ~ ,- ;. '. >, '.. .. ",,'...:-.;:..;.,~:"'~~..:-~;.:.;;;.: > ;.....:............ ;'.;: ...::^.~~~~.~.;.;.:.:...:..: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ........___......._,___....___...".,__.............""'..__n'___.'.._____._..,..,..,..______...".. ..................--...,..--.....""."...---........."...---..--.,.-.",......--.,.".....--..-.,,--,. . "....-...........".....--...........,.....---......--".'...,.-.......,-...-.........,.-........--'..... Name:. C~JlIt[L~4--.. . Address; J~ (Dr VvI y[.}-' C J#d~ . ; ,;'--'::::::~::. :::. ;:::::: .;,::::: ::::oo: .....",: :::.::: :::::::::::::::::::::::: ;7-:::- ~ C>. ,-" ~ ..----,-- ..---.- . /,A' ::JP Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:#~lEL- /?~bo# 51 Address: ?f/qLj /1/r fl.// \ /1//.,5"/\/,/"V/C'/'t ~.L. 33 (PO /&~~~- From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ....._,.....--". . /2d/1 r-L- '.~ "" L/ Name: /(/ifr/9'/7,C , ,c:,t;;..o /7 Address: ?!/q'f Nk 9./1$1' ,~J/6J;;C:;/?./4 .FL "5:5(PO &~ ,~4"- /' / October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. . As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .............".__.......___..,....................__....",n..."'" 'A~"'" .,..-..' . ......... .;--.....-...... ..__.._...........,.___....... .. ... .._. '.__no...."_______.__ . z..- . Name: ;:;r;.;. Pr?f"t. . AdJir.ess; ?5/q 4 /Ilk 9.// $1 . Pft/.6J~;?/-f r-L-."53fPO ~~~~~~ .--......,..-.....------...'.-----... ..........---..,.........---............".....---.... .4?ad ff .. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Goverrunent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:'g~/7EL.;-' ..............--...--.--" . Address: '6/q If Nk 9./1 Sr ,~1/bVYC;/C'~ r-L "5-:5fPO ~~7/~~ ~ ...-......---..,.............'......-.--..... .........-...,......,..............--...---.... ./?E".6o#" October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NalMf~~EL- . AdilIess: '6/q Lf /iI.k 9.// Sr , /11/.bJYC;/?PI FL53fPO ~~~ . , ~ /" -" /' - -- - - .,...,,--.,--- ,.--..".--..--....---......-. .---...--........--..,.--..............'..--...---..--.. ,. k~6t7/y October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Counci.1 City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NaTM:~dAEC- /?.c6dff' Address: "'6/QLj NF fUIS'- ./<11/6W,,;c:;/i'PI F"L 531 PO ~ ~ ~ /' ~/ - ........ ......"......... ........ ......... ..,....... -. Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ IV'- ~cu-,.:::v Address: \ "1.~G"'-;> ",\v \'r"I~ ~ ~~ Ft...... '~;S\g~ /~~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 t:: Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. Dear Council Members: As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .--...--.......--..............--.....--.........--.--.........--..--....... ........................................c.............. ...........--..--.................................--..--.--. . <:... C" '.' ~~:.:::.:;:::::"~::;::::;:y~...::..';;:::::,;:;:;;:;.::.:.;,: AddR>ii,I~;"'~"'''''~ ~. p..~___ Ft.... '3;SI~ ~. ~ /.' '. .' October 31, 2003 >- Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura,Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congiegants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..-. --.......,.--."'.---..,.---.,.-...-.-........---.....- ...----.".............--... . . . . . - . , , , . . - . - . . , . - . - . . . - - - - . . , . . - - - . , . - - . , , , . - - - - , , , . . . . . , . . . , . - - . . . . , - - . . , . - . . . , , . . .~. <:;";,,,,,".';'~.".'.""..........'. ..' .........--......."'.--.......--..........----.."......--....'....,......---.."....-.---- AIIilmB~; \~..,~~~~~. ~.. ~~_ Ft....'?$! rjO.., /~., . October 31, 2003 .... Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ._n_...__...._...........".....,.."..."._._."..............--...,........ ....-.......----."........--.....--..".........--....--..........,...,..--" ..........--.....--.".......,.----....-....'....'.-....-----.... NoD.~:~~ ~~~".' ...----.,.---..,.-.,.,.,...-....---..'..---.....-.....-...'.---....---...,....,."....'.-...... Aoi_:\~... . ~-~ . ~. ~~ Ft....c ~;slgt> ~.... ... .......--...... -.... ..--...........--....-... .-.- ... ~. / . . "",:::-:::-<"':::::-'::=:::-:',::.,::':"::':: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shahbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .....---..-........".....---.--..----..............---.'........,-,-.-".--' ...."....."...--...---.............."....".--.--.--..--...--....".-.. .".....,......".......".--...............-....--.....".--..." . Sc:.. ~ .. ""..:;:::... _.::::.::u:::::'''','_''''''::::'''':::'''':'':' .~~:/_-_:_-~::_::-:..,_:....,-:..,~.., . . ..........__.,...................__.__...____.........'....__.',..,d"U___""__"""""" Adt'l~'">~!'~ ~'. . ~"'"""'- ~t.... '"3.~ I' ~ .' ...--......-.. .....--... ....-.--...........-.............. ~'. / --'--"'- ,-'- "....-................."..'... .,,-_.,.. -.-..,. .".....__.,........_.....'.'.u.... ':::'''''''--''''''''-'''''--. . .......,.............-.......,.--...--.........--.. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...-..,.......---..".--...".........--.."......---....--.--. ...--.--...,.......--. .. ...,...--.,...--...--...".-......--...---.......--...-- ....--....................--. -<:;,.".;.,~.., ..-..".--....--......-............. ......_"...... ., .,-, ...__......__.."..__................'...........__..........n..."............,.,......,...... ~~i~ ..............................................,... October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ___..,.__.....__...._...".__..,..__.".__....___..'.....'.____...__.",n'" .. ...".--...,....".--..--.......--...--...'..........--.........---... Nome: ~"^ .~~. .' . .w..u, I"'f.f~~"""~" ~. ~~-..:' F c.... 8,;'$\ it; ~... .. ~. /' . . .......,--.. ......"......"..--.,.......--... .......,........ ,..........--.".............'........... .,-...,-.-. ,.....,........--........--..--."......-.. .............--..,........--....-.....--....--... Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~ \' Name: ~~..,..""> Address: ~~ I From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 ... r Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any othershul. Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extrernely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Sc,_~>>,-- ~V' I?<,} Address: ~~~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely ,disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 ~ Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. Yours sincerely, We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 The City Commission of A ventura InDO West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Auerbach: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. 1 personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams 1sland. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams lslnd Synagogue\RIW ltr to Commissioner Auerbach Seat 5 re Shulll 0203 llobertI. VVerner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Cohen: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens. I personally arn disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams 1sland. Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations. I attach a copy for your reference. Anyone who has looked into the matter learned that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative syoagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, 1C?t Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams Islnd Synagogue\RIW Itr to Conunissioner Cohen Seat 6 re Shull10203 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ \OM.-OI'.. (:('ev.....-c '" Address: ~~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A verntura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: tit: 11)4- r1/j 7/-tflV Address: $/1.--1 6cSt-4- 0/ 1J)(-tJ/~ fflL-~,1[d..r I;z- / ___ ~ From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: IfC1PIl<f/.;z.,> .... · ..... . ~ff. AMress::tlI1-4 6t5VL '~(poJ/cr.-.5 rtlt5(1[/Lr / rl-~' . October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Gove=ent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Ii ..... ..... ....... .--.--.----...........----.........-,.......-----."..--.......'""...--.--........--.---. Name:' 'L17}!l-f?~4'~' . MdreSB~.tlJ,J ~d 6~~ (poJ;"~ (fIt5{1i/~ /P-I-~ . ,_.. -,... ~.::__-::-,---_:.::,::: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . ii . .' . ." Name:'. '. ~.1l)L tf; ~At~ ........ . ....... . Address: :111l ~4 6t5f-.L.~ '(Pcdt'~ M~,"I ;5 i5{'I(/L.Q f!-I ~.. . _ . -' - ':--:::.::.:.r'_...:::.:::::::::'::::'::-:: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, jI; '. ..' '. Name: 'C1l?d- 11.7-4t1{/ ADdres;'.11I1 ~4 &~o/ fPaJi~-5 ~("'" /5{c-'Lfr . f2- .' /( /, . r / - 4 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .. Ii ". . .... Name; . . ~11);ltf;7--.4t1f/ .. . Address: :t1I/~4 6t5f.4- 0/ '(Po.J/~-> jI!5(?(}Lr (JZ-I-" ... . October 31,2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, . 'Ii ........ Name: . L-1l)t! rItJ 74ft? ",::::;;;:::::::::::_,,Ir;;::'::,';:::.:::::..:._::,:::::::.:':,'"::,:.:;::::,:::"":',;:::::::..:;;,'_::,,..:.::::::........... ADdresS:.J];! ,,,I6t5VL '~''{Pw/~ . tfl-t5{li/Lf I P-/~4 ;....::..'.:.::::::::.::,,::::..:.::..:;,;:::_..:::::.::::::.;:::::::..:::f'::::::,.:.:'C',::::::_:::::::::::"::c';';;: October 31,2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Ii " ' Name: ",' ~/l)/l r1tJ 7--4ttf/ ' ,-""""" ... ."".- ;;;' "', ""':-::::::-;;-::::::.",;-',:-::...:',: -::":..;;:-:::- .::',>..:._::;-;",:.::: A1!dress::J1!///6tSU-v fPrd/~-> 'tflt5(ff/LQ I ?-I__ ~' ' '- Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: f"Lo-sA..e.- S h ~e>4' Address: ! ere; 9q r. C..w>.4 ~ q;;?"l" . iF/a", tlt/T~ E< qsf!O 4- . From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Naine: f'i-~' Sh~ ~ . ;;....'..'...:...::...::-..;;..:::.......::'.:.-.:.:.-:.:..:..;:;.::.:.;..:;.:.:.:::;:::.:;..-,;~:.;::..::..:",..;:;;:.,'::"':':::'::'::':"";:: Addres&: I qq C;C; r. /' ~CJit (;??: . ~/Dalu/t~Ft !J:?/!J''- October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Govermnent Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...........----.....--....--...,...,..-........'.........--...."_...........,,.,--........ ........-----.......,........--...."'...--......'..'......,.-.,-..--,-.....,."---.---......" Name: tit-~'Sh~. ~ . . . -.€ . . Address: ('?99Q r. ~ C./lt(2?: #102.jb.r~ ,eC ~/') October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members; Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ~m~' '.~~sk~.e~' '. .' . Address: I Cf9 qq ,c".' ~4 CA.,fCl~. #'IaajHIfr~ F<- Er?/I". October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name:' .f't-~Sk~.e~. .. . Address: !Cf99t.; r-: ~CAtfp~. 1Hoa1Y-~ FL !!l:?/It>, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ..............--....,.--.........--..'.'.--..'.....--..'..--..."".--..,.......,.,.--.... ,..,--- ,........"..........................,.--....".--...".--....,......,....---."..--...... -...-..'. --..'rn.d-'...--.......... ,......,',.....,.'.'..k-- "'._.....___.__.,.___...,........'.u..... ..."..,..........,.".---.............'.--.'...... po. ....... ...... ........,.,--...,.--.... ---....".-....,.--..,......--.'...--... liame: ..~. r-. '.' b.. ~I . ..e..::2. ~~.ur ...... Address: I cr99Q ;::- .~~~ C~ P~. 'Ii':I.gihlfr~ Fe 5t:s'iIO, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: (fi-~'Sk~-€>I". Address: Iq99q ;::", ~ C-lttt:)~. {lfOgJH/t~ /",C =t1D October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: p.,~ Skbt~ . -.€- .'. Address: I crt; 9C; f^. . ~--4 C./l,t p~ . 1110,," jJ;!/t~ ,n ~cJ". October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shuL We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, NlIllJll: f"t-~ sk~.e~ Address: I ~9 fie; f. ~"A. ~ ~ p~ #lo~jb!It~ FC !n'{lt" Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ~ ~ c,lt~ Address: (q Cf 19 13- c&--r~ ~ 0 l . :;Z:~$/to From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ck 'CMAL--V2 .. Arldress: . It!( 'fqq is- '.. W~ Cp {} c. ~;~$IKO October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Y' /J .... """J.' '. .'.Name:. c.f..-o.M ~M~' .. AJidress: f q ,qq 13-.. ~~C&/ () 1:.. ':-;~~/l0 , October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, ...--..........,........,....---....".......----... Qk~. . Address: {cr,qq fi- c;;.,..~ ~ 0[; ~ ':;;~<;5I!O Name: c~ October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .' .....---..... ".....-----....".---......,.--.....,....----...'.---..."'.. . . J. . . Name: .;;~.. . c::'M~ Address: {'t1QQ 13- ~~Oc, :-;~~~IIO October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, .....---...........'.'-... . . J. . Name: . ;; ~ . C /Lf./I1L.-vt . ....... .....".... ..-.,-.- ........ ...........,.....--........................... Address: { 't , qq 13- c;..,..~CM 0 C 4 _~; ~:;:;$Ito October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ;; k .CM~. Address: {tf,qq. t3- ~~ ~Oc, ~l'~ 4~;~/to . ~,;-;. " .:: ...... ...... Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N~~~~ Address: From the desk of... Roberta A. Mendez Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, N~~Sw,,~ Addxess: October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Mernbers: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg Avemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extrernely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: 9-\ (J{ACLl::> Address: \oJ'l.....l\""'J I~K < A-b:JM'L" ~DI'4L towErL rom the desk of... erta A. Executive Assistant to Jules Trump Voice: 305-937-7811 Fax: 305-931-1773 October 31, 2003 Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: (;<-, (){p.c(O A-bJil L AddreSS: "\I.ltt..:l\"~j ~D~ IOwEfL- I~K< October 31, 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Mernbers: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: ('<-, Ot/.lAb A-bJ4L Address: -r1,)1!..,J\"t:~ ~{\~ lOwfIL.- I'";t. K < October 31, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Youts sincerely, Name; G<-.(){~ ~JiIL Addxess: '\131l...'l!.t=J ~O~ lDwfIL- I~K < October 31, 2003 Commissioner Ken Cohen A vemtura City Council City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: R-l~ :A-b.:J\4L Address: \'JU!,,(.:'j ~e:.i4L IOwflL l-::L K < October 31, 2003 Commissioner Bob Diamond Avemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: G<-,(j{~ :Prb::J4:C Address: -r \)tl...'l~,:~ ~D~ IOwfIL I~K< October 31, 2003 Commissioner Harry Holzberg A verntura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name; G<-,Ot~ A-bJilL Address; ""f>3CU\"I=J ~()~ lOwEfL- I~K< October 31, 2003 Commissioner Manny Grossman A vemtura City Council City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: Weare extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name; Q-I0t~ A-b:J\4L Address; "\>.\tt...l6.t=J ~C;~ IOwftL I~K < Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed !JItNCY B tTTI<.E:fZ /1) /..21, / D =J I t Resident's Address and Unit: :<600 .LsLllwJ} BLv]) f1\1~I\JTvRf'I Fl ~'3I{.,u Street Address . ..2?O,3 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 331 b 0 Zip Code Arleen Llanes :c: Commissioners City Manager From: Sent: To: Subject: Bethuel - Patricia & Claude [BETH-ROB@Webtv.net] Tuesday, November 11, 20031:08 PM Arleen Llanes Synagogue on Williams Island: Aventura City: NO - NO - NO ! PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT A NUMBER OF THE RESIDENTS OF wrLLrAMS rSLAND ARE UNABLE TO ATTEND TOMORROW'S MEETING RE: THE SYNAGOGUE TO BE BUILT ON WILLIAMS ISLAND. UNEQUIVICALLY : IT IS STRONGLY REQUESTED THAT THIS ACTION BE DENIED. WILLIAMS ISLAND IS A RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY - and is not, nor should it be , zoned for Commercial or Religious usage. WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION AND COURTESY IN THIS CRITICAL MATTER. Claude Bethuel 1 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Resident's Address and -:r;;pflreLl 'o,J f ~~;A<;:re~' C~1u~,'!vfAdJ.tr/1!~f Aventura, Florida :33/h() Zip Code City of Aventura Government Center Community Development Department 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (j;) To: Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. &skin, Seat 4 Commissioner 'Lev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RE: Hearing, 11/12/03 - Williams Island Synagogue, Inc.l04-CU-03 REQUEST TO BE READ ALOUD INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD: Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident at 2600 Island Boulevard. I wish to join my fellow condominium owners in opposing the establishment of a synagogue in our building. Such a plan which allows unscreened public access into a private residential building on a continuing basis undermines the large investment we make to secure our privacy. It must be made clear that in a special meeting held on December 3, 2002 unit owners overwhelming rejected the proposed plan before you as follows: Those Opposed: 70 votes, In Favor: 26 votes. (see attached minutes, 2600 Island Blvd. Condo Assoc., Inc.). Williams Island is and was established as a secure and private, double-gated residential community It is disturbing that such a proposal attempts to circumvent the expressed wishes of the families living here and would surely result in further and unnecessary litigation. Respectfully yours, l~ + 3 Date: 11/ /03 Wendy A derson-Fabbri 2600 Isla d Boulevard Unit #2905 Aventura Florida 33160-5212 ENC.: Residence du Cap Minutes of Tuesday, December 3, 2002 The Special Meeting of the Members 0 AND BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. held on Tuesday, December 3, 2002 in the Pool Lounge was called to order by Rod L. White, President at 6:10pm. c o ( p r The following Board members were present: George Lipton Lawrence Blumberg Paula Berliner William Joel - Vice President - Secretaryff reasurer - Director - Director Also present was: Diane Harari - Property Manager The Unit Owner count was ~ represented units. 58 represented units were necessary to establish a quorum, therefore a legal meeting was in order. Ms. Harari produced an Affidavit of Notice affirming that notice was delivered to each Board Member and . Unit Owner not less than fourteen (14) days prior to the meeting and that said notice was posted on the bulletin board located in the Mail Room at the time of mailing. The purpose of the meeting was to obtain a vote by members on authorizing the Board of Directors to engage legal counsel specializing in land use and zoning at a cost not to exceed $25,000.00 to oppose the Developer's proposed plans to relocate the Synagogue presently located in the 2000 building of Williams Island to Commercial Unit C-I in the 2600 building. Elliot DorfinanlUnit #404 tabulated the votes with Ms. Harari and her assistant, Tiffany Torres. O'J'I:NG RESULTS: ODDosed to Developer's plans to relocate the Synagogue 70 (Authorizing Board to engage legal counsel) In favor of Developer's Plans 26 There being no further business to discuss, a motion was made by Mr. White seconded by Mrs. Berliner to adjourn the meeting at 6:25pm. All in favor. I hereby certifY that the foregoing Minutes are true and correct Minutes for the above-mentioned 2600 I~AND BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. Board of Directors meeting. \~~~ Rod L. White \ . President . cc: Board of Directors Minute Book Dec03rd02. Sr-' u_, , '" T>.' .~.~~.lf\ND BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. 2800 Island Boulevard, WIlliams Island, Avcntura, florida 33180 . (305) 937-2008 . Fax (305) 937-0098 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed /3c19/3 F F TE j{/1/:3~/( ,AtM~ /r~~_ /1- '7 - 0 Q Resident's Address and Unit: /000 T6L/-JtV D ;"3LV.i.7 11 rOb Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3-:;/6 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ED\}.'.>,r:,~ 2')p., "f,r-\Lf:\~L S;g~ - ~J}\/ Date Signed sid l)()3 I I Resident's Address and Unit: .2(j-..J':JJ:c:LIJPi)}jLv D . cJlob ~\)CI--..j)vQ.,A )~L.. 33/(,,0 J RECEIVED LE~FIFIRESTONE 2600 ISLAND BLVD. APT. 2102. AVENTURA, FL 33160 NOV 0 6 2003 COMMUNITY DE~LOPMENr (305) 932-0247 November 3, 2003 Applicant/Properly City Of Aventura Government Center Community Development Dept. 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue Inc. 104-CU-03 request for conditional use approval for the establishment of a synagogue. To The City Commission: I am a resident of Residence du Cap (2600 Island Boulevard). This letter is to register mv vehement obiection to establishing a svnagogue in mv home The 2600 Island Boulevard condominium is a multi-religion, multi-ethnic, and multi-nationality residential luxury tower. Approximately 160+ units were purchased in good faith by the current residents as their secular lJQrne; not to be appended by any religious structure - be it a Jewish Synagogue. a Christian Church, a Muslim Mosque, or any other religious edifice. It is an unconscionable breach of good faith by the developer" against each and every unit purchaser _ who by the way were his customers, and enriched him by millions of dollars - to attempt to force a major change in the profile and character of this beautiful building, and to do so lIfmrtbl!. fal:t, and against the wishes ofthe majority. It seems apparent that from the very beginning the [applicant] developer withheld Unit CU-1 to be used as a synagogue site to replace his current synagogue located in the 2000 building. Certainly all potential unit buyers were entitled to be advised of this crucial caveat ~ they purchased a unit. On the contrary, the Developer chose to keep his true intent a secret- the buyers were never so advised [warned] of this devastating possibility. Indeed had they known the truth, for many of them it would have been a deal breaker. Forcing the attachment of a religious house of worship to any person's home, without their prior approval, is a gross violation of their rights. Any appended religious structure would be totally incompatible. It would adversely affect the market value and would negatively affect the way of life, use, and enjoyment to which each and every resident of the Residence du Cap is entitled. In all due fairness and in consideration of the rights of the residents of the 2600 Building: I RESPECTFULLY IMPLORE YOU TO DENY THE APPLICANT'S REQUEST. Yours truly, c----: --- ~~~' en Firestone Resident 2600 Building *The applicant (The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc.) and the developer of the 2600 building are one and the same. synagogue2.wps Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed {! 4 ~ / {)IkY}U1f~1- ID/~J/.)3 . Resident's Address and Unit: }..Joo Street Address :Ls/~ gILd #oy Unit/Apt '3~/bo Zip Code Aventura, Florida Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed -Pakl'c.iCl.~' (1mmin~s . fIu;n tit t'1i If) - .}a-03 Resident's Address and Unit: oI0GC 1ii.tUt~L t3/tld Street Address Aventura, Florida .33J (PO Zip Code dax/- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ~~~ Date Signed L.u(,Q~L L. ~C)D(, 00 I\J tier lD Resident's Address and Unit: ?-}YbC( d.Ll 'b~ ~wvV Street Address Aventura, Florida /1~\ (00 Zip Code Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed - ".... ~((J\l~~ r- , (0 0'$ Resident's Address and Unit: ~l.,S-- l),2:. \83 ~ <> Street Address -U..it/ApL' A ventura, Florida 33/ i:., 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed -, I~ rH r \ U S flfmtB ?lfe;. yfd/ ~ /6 -"z6-03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~ 0 37 <; \^/ C-VIJ /lJrRv IC-t,vY'J 1:;1( ,),/3/ Street Address / Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ;3;) ij{D Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 1)~ 1"1 ;:;; A~'1rf.L ~~~ /~/v0 j Resident's Address and Unit: 2RC'~ ;I;/~ !i/~L~ ")/YOY Unit/Apt Street Address Aventura, Florida 5 JIG() Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature I RI1 f} BI( 1f""5 Date Signed /D Jw( 0;5 Resident's Address and Unit: z~ Is l..APl) t)LV:h. Street Address Aventura, Florida 3~II:,D Zip Code .D-b 'J-- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed /,,//114,.) d)/LJ::1;.Je~",.J ~f'II..e. 8~~~.~~A",}-O'~~3 Resident's Address and Unit: IRp71 ~~~~~./#1' Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ZJ1J1Ii. ~ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name L eOj?fJ/c! 3/((1./ t Signature ~ Resident's Address and Unit: !fOOb fr/;;/;3!vi Street Address . Aventura, Florida ];}/ t 1) Zip Code fJtr Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Dci'?k,/o S ~ . Resident's Address and Unit: Yooo/4!/nd ?J/v/ Street Address Aventura, Florida ?~/ 6 D ~ ~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed .>!IG- {LA ( f''/..RAM Mr g- ~-'~ rt/~ )wv-,/ u>v3 ) Resident's Address and Unit: If3.>S ~~ Street Address 1'111: Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/ gv Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed CPhYW;7W~b") ~L L) 'b('-'1IUnrl Resident's Address and Unit: ( 1 ss-r- T ~ ~ P141( Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ; S I ~ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. T.,~ Printed Name Signature Date Signed RUttJ- l~U ili'J /10;' lo.!S. Resident's Address and Unit: .2 ~fJt> 1~/Mo::J];VD Street Address Aventura, Florida '3 ~ I (PO Zip Code Of) I ~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Printed Name 4L-v},J $HEFi4~N Signature Date Signed ~~ tp/!/03 Resident's Address and Unit: 2~t?() I~~ ~JVJ> Aventura, Florida ? 3./ {p 0 JkL Unit/Apt Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 13er+ha. be ~~ Ii ~(',r\\J'H':' ~AT""2-.. <7Y,'1,/k' Resident's Address and Unit: L. " - / a./;~~ .~ /o-It7-aS / I 7/ '8' lV; / / a lA/ (' rJQ./JI;-€... Street Address J1-.tI I S-O ~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '3316d Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ';',,'den.(,) Name ~a..'~ \ rJr~ ~~fY)11tf . ~<'/~__ Oa.. Sk /(~O , Resident's Address and Unit: :?COF> N~ &0) dv?U~ -1~ t6'd5)1-/6d~ :5-3Uh 0 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature I pY{,J J. BOe~NSm'N Resident's Address and Unit: :s CL-JoISLA.N/J };t..V-ll:! Street Address Aventura, Florida :?3/rcQ Zip Code ! .:J..e;.s-- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed . (oc-<....r. Gr)"-,, 1'" ~~'" U I /d C< -v.?:: Resident's Address and Unit: 30/ ;(.[- J(o"/ 1Y- Street Address Aventura, Florida ~ _~ ( 'C) Zip Code c2r'1t( Unit! pt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 0UG1\.A-5 ~lZO$5 P~fl /L / /0 !r.ti~ 3 , Resident's Address and Unit: 3go/ I/J~ 2-C? sr Street Address Zf!6( Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 55/)};) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aveotura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name --J~ef f(.lolrJe Signature /.., (. .,V.~.' '-C..AJti.J/i' /~ // ' L/ Date Signed 117- ,;) 0 - Q.) Resident's Address and Unit: !~..~! ! /3 ')':;C;~/c?nd elf! vd ...ti") ~-, .?L'/ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name j};J~E ~f5vlfIlJ Date Signed / () /;;'0 /03 , I Resident's Address and Unit: ~#-v-O JiM IIJj) PL Ilj Street Address ' v-ov Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida t!}"j-60 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature /'1 Date Signed A.i1;-J G.J'~/ /lJ 10 /;z.o /03 , Resident's Address and Unit: .7t707J :LilA #lJj) ffi v ) Street Address Aventura, Florida j 3 / b 0 Zip Code -- Ijov Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~ ~e14'1- (o!f7(o; Resident's Address and Unit: ~ Is-wall> ,b'Lt/I) Street Address Aventura, Florida 53 ( {,O Zip Code 'dJOb Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner .Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ,-,- .J "01-UtJ'I'e ~~ {>..f {PI<. 10 /ll/CJ3 I I Resident's Address and Unit: 3-600 (S'LA-JD e {[VI) d .foe Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '3"? \ ~O Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name -f1 Resident's Address and Unit: J/oOJ I~M AID bttli/ Street Address Aventura, Florida 33/0() Zip Code Date Signed IIO~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~ /'ff(J))2j.t-. WE")26'cJFF l11o/fV tiL 0c~p , /0(7/03 Resident's Address and Unit: ;3 & .2.) Ar Colfh ~ ~ ZJ~ Street Address 3 t: g--rJ 3 nit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 -3/ yo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature . Date Signed ;9~ LU~J6 /0f/7/03 / .JUVE W t;fZj301='F Resident's Address and Unit: :3(" :z s- JJ e, u~ ~UI3 OR f 8V-3 Street Address U it/Apt Aventura, Florida J 3 I yo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed U(}{(IS g (VITI........ ~6cU1A JO)V!u ? Resident's Address and Unit: '3 q L'J-U Street Address IS (jr,J) bLv () :La:> Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '3~/6(j Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed ~ A-V f rMA--V1 IV ~/7-0 '3 Resident's Address and Unit: '(000 15;,/ /YVlo r2rIlP #/fOb I1vC3MWn& PC- 3.31 ~ D , Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed D.. k.......~ L~nu" (\() t~~~. L.. - I()-~-o~ Resident's Address and Unit: 1m IsI.J ~t,~~P Street Address np? Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~.f/ to Zip Code "'?,S.. a. O{lo,) '\ ~ l.Sl.,U~ C L~') '(IGv.- J..~ .., ~ ') I.A... \.. ~ . ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~oO"4...~ ~.,C'..~ tu...L.... ~U ~r_~QQ-'P~ ~ ~ ,"=\:.Uo....L~J.(\on~" ~(..J...\ d...o.~ ~...~~.. "..' ~ ~ ~ ~q ~~~~-~~j~~~_.~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature n.ue Si!!ned 'Viti 1I./(J.~VSd~ '-Ld~ /oPJ~ / / Resident's Address and Unit: 36tl 0 Street Aventura, Florida ...3..3/ rd Zip Code /~rJ~ 1- L Unit/AW/ . Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed G~tL ~~\~ ./ /o;j ,fo ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 2000 Id~r/i0ct- Street Address Aventura, Florida '3 -'3t &6 Zip Code J~cJ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name s~ Date Signed Actftf/\ oJu-e<{" -)0/1~ 10?J Resident's Address and Unit: :2 DC> 6 r-';))~L~luJ !~o'l Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ()3/0() Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed r'\ t orf'_V)(',e, CyJ~ -) 5Z 0 /~ .~-ev -- ./' , . 'c-(/fID3 Resident's Address and Unit: / /H-n :1h 1(2-,<./ {~)t/ cL Street Address 'I/~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3') J {" Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~. T..J:, o;d..~ r+.!"'.rj L.u:.tv-5J{j ~. t/ /~ 'OS-="03 Resident's Address and Unit: t'~ ~L_J7S'1-fJ Street Address o;2A"r- Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 5.3'/(0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commiuioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commiuioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commillllioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commillsioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establillhment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make tbis use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 5'1 U PPfY)AN ~~ loj (0)03 Resident's Address and Unit: L..bOO Is I~IJ() fla..(I.-WMD Street Address 110'{ Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida :3 ~ \ (,0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed \t; \ ~ Do l/l(~'- iJ~ j)~. 10 It.) }()~ . Resident's Address and Unit: ~ ~oo Ss fa-I. Street Address B Iud I~o ~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~3/6'{) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed f ClAA.\ 6. --:D 0 ~'l ~~~ 101/3/ D '3, Resident's Address and Unit: :J-(O 00 lsla r- J gll1{ Street Address / 7D J.. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/60 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Barry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner 'Lev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~ os. e ~O u...cw- ~ ~C~~ / O/;2/[)-2 . Resident's Address and Unit: :21000 ~s~ i 12, I vi Street Address I :Lo :L Unit/Apt Avenhln, Florida 33/tu Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name J-i..j ~ 1--0 lie.- I '?:oi3J01VEf Signature .---- cJ.;RJe~ ~- / Date Signed '0/'19 (cJoa:? Resident's Address and Unit: J.boO I..!J..4NJ '-C'1+tl. Street Address ~'fvf Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .Ulbo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ';w;rv'f .])0&,,) N t:r Signature I ~ rU{/( Date Signed 'of"lo?:iJOJ Resident's Address and Unit: , ~bOO J.(J.lfM?J Li'.t-vZl . Street Address 410f Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 331170 Zip Code Mall To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbacb, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken CoheD, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and CommissioDers oftbe City of Aventura: As a resideDt of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-! and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name LOiS MA-TT Signature dw:ull Date Signed ~ 101 03 Resident's Address and Unit: Lb~ LS~~D ~4Icv~~ Street Address Ilol{ Uolt/Apt Aventura, Florida 3?,160 Zip COde Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~ }) 'I A IV V E' kr 1'+ u. S &t?u~ ,~~ Resident's Address and Unit: lo()() J:s/f1IL),) BlvD Street Address J30& Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 ~ / ~ /J Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ( r;: e .vhzv /~,.!fv:> fJJr:~ /~/7 /c 3 , Resident's Address and Unit: 1.'-1" 1s ~~ 6 /~, iJ Street Address Aventura, Florida 33/ G t Zip Code L-) c ~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature l1&;R.ih0 iJvLLB~G ~I;,.~~o Date Signed 1&(10 f l(j Resident's Address and Unit: {(s[ Y1 1\I~:3 { Cr. IF- t o~ Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida J J- ( 00 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed {\ I' l , c~ (DIe; \qs Resident's Address and Unit: J~~S\ ~\ t ~l C+ Street Address A ventura, Florida J~ I ~ () !Lf10 Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Co ltciiC L \;-0l-V~~ lit) ~ . ., . ,-" ~ . w........ I.' u (') 'J --I - _) Resident's Address and Unit: )<<::00 k CQ')c\ :?~CI Street Address !-,:Jo:L Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida :;:)It.C Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ~ ' Date Signed H.t:\1JS kJ L\~~H/\~ IG-903 Resident's Address and Unit: ;)800 IsrCt.-'ld ~tud IJ0.o Unit/Apt Street Address Aventura, Florida 30\to Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed ~/(103 Resident's Address and Unit: /ooo%W ~Uj) Aventura, Florida 331 ~ tJ c2000 Street Address Unit/Apt Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Dob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. N;~~~~ Date Signed ~ A ,k3 I , Resident's Address and Unit: /080 ~ &/1- O(Of)b Street Address Aventura, Florida :53/ 0 () Zip Code Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed _Fro.J'\t Ll Z-? Q ~ JA~ JiJ lor,! b3 Resident's Address and Unit: /f(J()Q4~4txl /(0 ~ Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '33/&0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed .Bo.X-bCl 1"'0...- L (' z.. ZtL ~Cl3 d--J Aventura, Florida 3 3 { roo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed AIR/4th ehbt/Y~ ~k~ /'0 -9--6 ~ Resident's Address and Unit: tDO D ~d.J4'...I / I!L/~ _ Street Address !?nl5 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/1.. {J Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed \/YAyrle 2bhrryS~ /{J _tjLJ 3 Resident's Address and Unit: /ro.f)()~;;;/.,~ 12(t!~-,- Street Address SotS' Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida :131 bD Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Ax LE#E EIf7iJt<J ~E~ I tJ ;/{}/0-3 . , Resident's Address and Unit: ~ I'll e, &;C1;tJtIfY C!.-f/15 P1< Street Address / oil t Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/8'6 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed &~tJ Ep.;rE/;,) c~~ loft?kB , I Resident's Address and Unit: ~O/91 e; (--tJVIJ-/~V IMP/{, 1t1J? Street Address ' Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 53/ ff) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ~m . ~~//k Date Signed lIA/cIreuJ }3: /eJ /ol!o/,;ltJ6 / ' Resident's Address and Unit: 2~ /sCM)) hv:b Street Address Aventura, Florida 331 b 0 Zip Code /..2.0 / Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Dob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ~~';;I:/in' Date Signed I&PO/o3 Resident's Address and Unit: /( ~t'ZJ iC4'hv;J :3/ i/cI Street Address /ZO( Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida :5 31 b 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~rJl WtJt-fS6rJ ~~ /h I/f) /0:3 Resident's Address and Unit: 1;j/15/ AlE 31 t!vt/,(]r Street Address :J-7/o Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida ? '310 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name 'SrI3oJG,J Do (IF'''A-t-l Signature ~~ Date Signed /0-1-0:> Resident's Address and Unit: 7PVD IsIA~" ?,l,,~ Street Address (10) Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida -n/t..O Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~Cnrl Doj2.F.....A,., ~~ /0-1-0> Resident's Address and Unit: 7DOo hl.~ i ~.Jo . Street Address lIO} Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida '3 '} I L 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A venturali am stron 1- pposed 0 the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 260 sland Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed f. [\~~ MY 10-2' ~ Resident's Address and Unit: <JoB1J J~ ~I,,~ 2-\)~ Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ ~ ( CD Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ..J=j) GA Q HAl.A (, ~~ " 1,0 /" f/o.> Resident's Address and Unit: 240.0 tJ'L.fNP ~o Street Address Af7 70.5 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '? '? I fJo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ;A.PUA- A/lt HALAC ~~b 10/09/0'3, Resident's Address and Unit: . 2600 Is/.>>-->d 'Q,lvo{.. Street Address t:f 70~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 1, 2;, I b 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name /" , ]:J{if/}t AWl/en bGz 1 , Signature ?/ f fi tte- } 'J' (l,U.{.{I-i/-e/J Date Signed J{)/6~~ Resident's Address and Unit: Jt {-'-o E/~{ E~,--d. Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .33/ " v Zip Code Yo; Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Arm (;PeA-I) trAru ah~) ~~<LIJ'- (O-Or r63 Resident's Address and Unit: 3:1yco;J~ (9/ fi, , Street Address Aventura, Florida ~?I SO Zip Code 11 1?'e'J / Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed R (rl!- f1 ' Swlr~ [/C.r )g~/~ ~ /(J- ~-o3 Resident's Address and Unit: 5QOo 15l/Jw9 6L"~ 3 3 f~0 Aventura, Florida )i: )(, 0 3 Street Address Unit/Apt Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed J\ ll\t '\ G ~,~l'l\ 5l?-~L I I) /"1/ oj Resident's Address and Unit: ~O"b ~ I,~~ PJ/IJJ.. Street Address Aventura, Florida ~ Zip Code {~-I, Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed JllA14 tel /)JL ~l, ~ ~u)f~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 JS I~.l Qlv~ Street Address Aventura, Florida ~ Zip Code to!. Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly oppose ft. to t~e jstAA!i~lll}1.fnt of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Isla.vKjfbufeva~CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed -;;e' Jl, CAK.i2.oJ/ fl~~ I~(I~~ Resident's Address and Unit: 3700 I5t-ifVblJl-U~, I Street Address :2.01 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3'3 ! 00 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~U6;2t7 ~/ces y~:! ~ ./ 1& / fi!o:S r , Resident's Address and Unit: ~'q,~ Au<key Cj'ero . e............ 20515ECountryClublli.Apt214&, Street Al ' , .. M.arn.. FL 33180 J nit/Apt Aventura, Florida ,3i:.{ '1::.:1111::" rlC.\.J' ~I-...... "", _. 2800 ISLAND BLVD. APT. 2102. LE~FIRESTONE AVENTURA, FL 33160 f~.~V~' . ~ l :.;~'., i ,- . REGElVElJ ^^1.-' (305) 932-0247 1'71-2003 April 28, 2003 ('O.$'~-:;':f.. '''V r-\~"i"o', ,. ...~ . j- ri.;',~'L~;;Ji! . Ut:;;tJ ~ ~;~.!r. '-'I~lr: .......... ,~, -- "'" City Of Aventura Government Center Community Development Dept. 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue Inc. 104-CU-03 request for conditional use approval for the establishment of a synagogue. To The City Commission: I am a resident of Residence du Cap (2600 Island Boulevard). This letter is to register my vehement obiection to establishing a synagoc;lue in my home The 2600 Island Boulevard condominium is a multi-religion, multi-ethnic, and multi-nationality residential luxury tower. Approximately 160+ units were purchased by the current residents as their secular tJQrne.; not to be appended by any religious structure - be it a Jewish Synagogue, a Christian Church, a Muslim Mosque, or any other religious edifice. It is an unconscionable breach of good faith by the developer' against each and every unit purchaser - who are his customers - to attempt to force a major change in the profile and character of this beautiful building, and to do so afler: ~ N and against the wishes of the majority. It seems apparent that from the very beginning the developer withheld Unit CU-1 to be used as a synagogue site, to replace his current synagogue located in the 2000 building, (he said he needed more space). In any event, all potential unit buyers were entitled to know of this crucial possibility l2siKill:. they purchased a unit. Forcing a religious house of worship in any person's home, without their prior approval, is a gross violation of their rights. cc: Eric Soroka 'The applicant (The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc.) and the developer of the 2600 building are one and the same. APR 3 0 2003 ~r{.)l.'" ~f THE """AGER synagogue2.wps Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners oftlfe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Na~ Signature l-ee-A(\~ ~b'tX()':. ~ ~b \.-- Date Signed :J\a.l '()?, Resident's Address and Unit: ~ L:$\CY--d 0-.0 .x\ lL\-\1:;:) G...v~",- ~ 6~ll..oo +\30I()~ . S'(D~e-\ \>A01S- ofro~it>. ~Pe(Q"'.'"' l)~~. ~JJla..~u:NL~ \Jo~ .<(-( ~ . 3) Qx..v:J4<-."8, ~ ~:J -r-k ~ . ?lllo~, E:u-urt-C e,,,'S,b.)z-v-l6<G.. - ">~ C>ui?'x,~ -+:, ~"'-- n C LJ ~O\, Z-0crt)~~> ~ . -L Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed fto;:rE rUa S:ZII//I1 r.nJ .# ~_ $:t~,cj+C./ /J/~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 31o~ k/l<-'Y1d ~ Street Address ~ Lf~ / Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/&0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ~L Date Signed hW.4AP ~I!() I1JJtfll /0/'/:;3 Resident's Address and Unit: 5tfoo J,/&id ~ Street Address '3 'hI Unit/Apt 3"3// Aventura, Florida W Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature f~~ Date Signed 10-7-03 Resident's Address and Unit: 11 ~ s-r TLl R.I'/ bef<,p-" WJI. i ...: )J-/ Gtf Street Address -} Uni Apt Aventura, Florida .3 3/ ~ 0 Zip Code . ..._~.~~._~--_._--_._--_.__._-_._._.------~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed MURIEL 5. f{OESIN(; ~.A.,,;~ AI. ~,i .''7' CJcJ.. 7 I ;'tJ 03 Resident's Address and Unit: I ODD j~/.......~ ~. Street Address :J. 'I 0 2- Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida "3 '311.0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed -:fA(J(7, OC5f1r;,rJ ~. lo/~I?/()3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~Ol!>O :::l5~ hlv9J Street Address /k-./;,D( Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ ? / bf) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name , R,u'P'/I~ K1.f,tJ I rY}.j). Si~a~ur(e ~ ' ~ ~ m.N. I Date Signed /0/7/$3 Resident's Address and Unit: )N-o b. J:'%.L. BJ,IID, Street Address :# I Cfo?. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '3 ~ J/PD. 51,of/ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed FJDtj IV kLF 11'/ _AJ~fJakl Cd flY '03 Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 [' i stfJ/IIC> "bL VD :# I qO.,! Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .33.J f) 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed '/'I\~~\.... 50&\1 ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~\obO TSL~ S5~~ Street Address Aventura, Florida 3::)\ \au Zip Code ft \ 'S'D~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~~\\O~ ~J ::=f~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~\ot>b Ys,,-~~ B\..v~ Street Address Aventura, Florida ~ 3lkb Zip Code 1"503 Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed -...."..- ........10(,4 _ / Qo """'-AI h>eL Q / 9. J' . r:c~ /0 -5' - dJ Resident's Address and Unit: ....d. "--<J W~ 4l/vt{. Street Address -..2 -'Joy. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida -3 J / C; () Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed f/oA.lo III ~o"v..,i~ h(nl,- /,( 0-1.7 /O-O?-O,~ Resident's Address and Unit: -:l? ~ {lf~ d3lv/. Street Address ~JOy:... Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .sJ/ r; cJ Zip Code ___~______~___"_.____..._,..._"___...,_.___"_,._ n.____..'....._._____-..,...--_ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed fYJ/rI/jJzLU IittLi/~;U C~~#./~A Resident's Address and Unit: 3& l~ /!/ (:I{A/TMfh~13 lItl Street Address 1 A ventura, Florida '7 ? / "lo Zip Code 8-/0& Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature !i?L C/ Date Signed --- ~ lel/AR D /lffcllEJJ /~ ~h3 ( I Resident's Address and Unit: ~t 7"-- 4/ ~'lIvr161f8 f), <J/O 6 Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ::4 ;;;/)10 Zip Code ~._----""'----_.__._.__.._-_._-----_.._-_._._-~---r--- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed _~10 N IA S~K01<R ~~~1- / OCT 0 7 2003 Resident's Address and Unit: fJI050NE 3glk. ,,",Vb Street Address '3 () 0"3 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3'3/ Bo Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name gt\8-~ ~~ ~ Date Signed OCT 0 7 2003 Resident's Address and Unit: ~ \o.f'O lJff ~ ~ Street Address 30l>'~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ?'S \ ~(?) Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed h-j {)c/w ~'17 ke.\~+~'rl~~ ID/~/o3 Resident's Address and Unit: qoo 0 T~ la-I' ol8\v4 Street Address Aventura, Florida .3311.:,0 Zip Code ~JOb Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name (rdft/#'IJ ['II /11 tu5 L. ftJt/i<tJLfr6',~"J~~ Date Signed /o/! /t/J Resident's Address and Unit: t.fO()(} :Cs {fix/ jJ iJ L tJj} ZltJb Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 1'31 r; 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ~~'1V - Date Signed ~~O~~c~^V Resident's Address and Unit: s ~ t.llcJ.t aJJ(:~ Street Address Aventura, Florida 3 31 ~ Zip Code l~f Unit/Apt ~--~._~--"-----'--'-----~----'---,-- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed L J}1i-.Jfrt'1 I~ Io/il ~ 3; Resident's Address and Unit: 35"" f J' ~a.-cJ ket~ b /~ Street A:tldress Aventura, Florida 33/ &,0 Zip Code 7=-j-S7) V Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ";;-01 5 k /I)/R;' \ ~~.y" \ - \0' l.. 0-2> Resident's Address and Unit: \ 10 Street Address Aventura, Florida 2:l~ I ~ () Zip Code \:1ol- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed f~IlNK It, Lf.-Vt :J-t<~ ~ - ~ /0-7- 03 Resident's Address and Unit: :?6'7~ Ii C~'~'4ftR'l CLII~ DR..... Street Address /~o3 Unit/Apt 7<"/0/1 Aventura, Florida ",>oJ G v Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~,~~ Jf)-tt~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~\d~0C\~\~~~. Street Address '\nl~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florid~\QO Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 4JfrHVR Siltue ~.::2.' _ /~p/.&~ Resident's Address and Unit: ..:3~ /SL/JV; B,J" Street Address Aventura, Florida ..33/" 0 Zip Code /~() ~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Gk t?;€ '11 E EJ:. ,LX: - '"YG~ -zf. ~'" . d:;e r ? )..od~ . / Resident's Address and Unit: j~Cb /471,uj ,6A- Street Address ~6~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .Jb/bv Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name lx"1J N P ~ Resident's Address and Unit: (1 ~}-7{jy'~-2 rj vJ~ ~ /lvJv,/ F [ rs Jt j> J Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name --Prfo.c K~~,d Y")C\(\ ~N~ fur:;cpwcY) Date Signed 06 /3 /OES. I I " do Jo.sJn~ . I I Resident's Address and Unit: c\ZoS ~ e:--dnl c\D6 ~;Je: f.O-<1v\-\.u C'c .,-S;:L .:5 3 I 8 D Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~gz~J:P~MQr Date Signed ();/;(j /g~ Resident's Address and Unit: 21205 Yo-at clcJo 'hr1f: (era AI!eMf LWC\ f[) 531 tL/ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name (D'tZS 0L^- t t ~ Date Signed ~j1L((o 3 Resident's Address and Unit: (UOC C'L'{/ :I':./~ ~lvJ.", J.fo :z. Arw.:t~ f{..- >~ l~d Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~K."\A- \J T UDI1 l:\-v ure Date Signed (J76/\t/~DO'7:,. . Resident's Address and Unit: :5C)OO 'T~I4->JD l)~\i~. A..\)E0t-VlLi',-I~L I ~\~ 0 , ~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. c Resident(s) Name ,\")1\(0 ~~\r\~ I\;~~ ~~~\~ ~ t:. Date Signed da I 7<'_' Ids 1(, OG /'2 CR / ().3 ( l Resident's Address and Unit: '2.\2=-S ( \::>rvv, r.lwVJ n\W~lue- 1><(\../p-n-h '(;7 R ~\BD Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature aJL-J~ Date Signed A {{-tHClR.. !( ~e ( /1;4~ ~o~ Resident's Address and Unit: /1/01 ~, Street Address /11/ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 5.3 (07> Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed l1tRD I ~)~l~~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: u~lU~Pt Aventura, Florida~ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature a/ou""f1Al1iiJf&J k!'iid ~~ Date Signed !)~;t. 1//03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~hOI) ~ ~HO:;- Street Address r Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~~i.J Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~\.o ~~~ Date Signed Printed Name ~4\C~ Resident's Address and Unit: '1.lpoo t~rwl) ~\f)) t'1 O~ Street Address Aventura, Florida ~":l\Coo Unit/Apt Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed J /0 -b -()"3 . Resident's Address and Unit: /tJ(){) J S / A JJ.7'J 1511/ () Street Address Aventura, Florida 3';2; / ,~r Zip'Code //')t/ 9 - /s70 Unit/Apt "--'---'--r---"- -- -----..--------..-.----.,---- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed q{LDR..(P I(02./tI/J ~~ ~~ buf3; }d)J Resident's Address and Unit: /r707- ~tl.A(,('( c';fJ7 Street Address Aventura, Florida JJ/fu Zip Code /~f1 Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Hv\\({Il"\ I~t:n ,"'tV ~l(~ ()e-f3/)boJ Resident's Address and Unit: /9 7b 7~ 1:; f.vl1 ~ f"'I Il/J'1 Street Address l{pff Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida fJliu Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed t,J QV\q, t f5\-e-'''' ~~\~;,- \0 \ \.(i Os Resident's Address and Unit: ~S~O My,y;l. ~",;",\\Q 1)( Street Address 2-~O'+ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~'::'\~ 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ~~~ Date Signed '}xt'\\S'_ -r;r;t' lib IOJ(P 103 l ~ Resident's Address and Unit: \DOD~ ~ -:t~la~ Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 2> ~ Iv/D Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed j)e-iHllS ~~l~ -~2j Resident's Address and Unit: \O\)t} ~~ .1t~lD~ Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ lLoD Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed - , I '\ eLl pJ Dft LUI1LJ>>>1AAJ ('" n CL-,:..uVd~ i lL)dJ..Qu'--__ / ;:/-- J:x3 ( Resident's Address and Unit: =\'1 &'6 ,: }.-/J.Li...0 6,12,0 Street Address Aventura, Florida -3 -3)6 LJ Zip Code 7L~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed IfZlI,lJ~ WA Lf) f\1 M fvL1J ~ (ptJ- 0 ] Resident's Address and Unit: ~ cJ.AJ 7!.J'CJHJO trlJ Ii lob Street Address ~ Jfl bo Aventura, Florida Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ~lt ~(I;/{I ( Su ~,~ Da;:;r~) ~;r Street A dress Aventura, Florida ;;3 If;; Zip Code ~. -r~tJ~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed t/~ L7/f:::G(~ I ~AI J'kL~/ ?~P1t ~11f1 /~0)" Resident's Address and Unit: SGA J;. ~d~ /1 ~J.J Street Address J Unit/Apt 3 ?(f Aventura, Florida ) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed P~'c&~~(}~~~v\tut.\S ~,~~~ lor/co u~~ Resident's Address and Unit: ..-- ---. .- Aventura, Florida o~eoJM~, Street Address ~?;,I'O Zip Code t.-{D( Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed LeND Rtp -j;Ll');M /tJ(J1J 5 (f2ct- cj) d~()3 Resident's Address and Unit: 30()O ~ ~ ~ Street Address . Aventura, Florida ~~/,0' () Zip Code YJ5 Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed (Jo fee /;.;11 ~ 10ft ~ / tJ -3 -tJ3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3000 !SJAAJo 7)/-//0 . Street Address RtJrb Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3::; /l:,d Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed l(IJt.,2,rl HiJ! 71f"u~ )1-3 -()3 Resident's Address and Unit: yO() /5J-~j}DJjJ.II/). Street Address Aventura, Florida s: -5 / ~ tJ Zip Code fClt Unit/Apt ----~ , - Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 ~ Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~~~. ~~1tt ;;\~~,un;t' Street Address Aventura, FIOridaj.~\ W Zip Code ~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. 1(~~;' b~ ~;'I~;; [;nit' Street Address Aventura, Florida ~\ It() Zip Code Signature ~~. Jhk ~ ~"1.t Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature J~~ Date Signed I! -rift ~ fu d11l~~ Ocr ;;(, ~ a-9 Resident's Address and Unit: / VN Ic:iJ /w-d If; t/Q/ ~O~;;2 Unit/Apt Street Address Aventura, Florida 33/6 () Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name '1tD R V lJ;J r-rS'f( r S';~J:J., . Date S1ned /V/)/03 Resident's Address and Unit: /<.7170 ;rstA,.J{) {6LVl> Street Address 300 J-. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/ &, D Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed - rr NQQ~e PlrI\\t] {~'~~~YjJ~7b Cj. ~- 0 B Resident's Address and Unit: -- )I/A. 181 ~I rVDR'ThF 4 S'ls I C9o..'/:If'l Street Address {;o ry Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '1 ~ I C, n Zip Code Oct 02 03 10:57a Robinson Rentals (8471328-5211 p.2 Mail To: The City Commillion of Aventura 19200 West Couatry Club Drive AveDtura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commisllioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Cornmbsioner Manoy Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamood, Sea' 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commiuioaer Zev AlIerbacll. Seat 5 Commissioner KeD Coben, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and COlllmissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventur., I am stronllly opposed to the establbhment of a syoaKOJue in the residential buildi_g, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urae you to voteagalD" fle conditional use applil!atioD tbat will mllke this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name I) . It-d fcI !C5 b .;)5<^- Signature -?~ ~lA>-' Date Sig.ee1 /J /1-/ tV 3 I I Resident's Add",ss IInd Unit: 2.0~([J J'J/ti/1d Bf-I/ {J Slree' Addn.. Anatllra, Florida 33 /(p 0 Zip Code 2<:;00 UnitlApl- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ).J IfAll!Y 13~?'( R I rr- Signature 1/4 ,bf;tdt t ( Date Signed 10-/-03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~~O I !'UN~ gLV]) Street Address (/0 S- Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida '3'316 CJ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed j.1l?et. J> I3c7?R/7T /O-/-d,? Resident's Address and Unit: -ZIP!)!} /5: t..1{;./o 61.-111) Street Address t/-O b Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida '3::S I tP 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name \ Date Signed ~ ~4})-ft01~ ~D3 Resident's Address and Unit: ?lg~ J11~ U Street Address Aventura, Florida ?z3rJo & Zip Code 5to~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name 4~ Date Signed Hv-~uV ~~r'(v Uc+~ I ::200 '3 I / Resident's Address and Unit: ~c"ou J::; l~cQ fJl Jd jLO( Unit/Apt Street Address Aventura, Florida "3'3 1(;6 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed g;~~~ , o cr// 2rrci:? Gat l ~O~~ Resident's Address and Unit: b60 :4/~ 6lv~ IDO( Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33(6 C) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commlulon of Aventura 19100 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerba~h, Seat 5 Commissioner Kea Cobea, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners oftbe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventun, lam strongly opposed to tbe establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the ~onditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name EO ~o PAYue.s Signature ~ Date Signed ~ /0)')03 Resident's Address and Unit: 2i,oo J:.WtNO !k~o. Street Addreu ,SOl Uult/Apt Aventu..., Florid. 33133 Zip Cod. Mail To: The City Co..-mission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissio!ler Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat S Commissioner Ken Colten, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establisbment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use applieation that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature C~R-y L ~ANeJ ~Qjo,. Resident's Address and Unit: u,cJb ):1cA-uO ~'-...O, Street Addre... (.[OJ Unit/Apt Avcntura, Florida 331:13 Zip Code Date Signed 10 I, )03 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed ~11/'</6'- WE"j)/J'J/I~ /yf~~ Resident's Address and Unit: rl-()!1/ E, C~/ 0/8 .Jr.. /fr9h , Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida :3 31 R 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed /Jp///l r ~AA1J~ f!J3wI~ /~~J Resident's Address and Unit: ~11/ P tim, ata I f'tJt Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida , 'j =; I f??j Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ;JLt5~;2I ill totl~tv CUtw~ () c::r ~, d. (J) :s Resident's Address and Unit: ~ KJ./r,vl) AN) .-flw",!,.",",- Street Address /769 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida s:S 100 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed C~/E/~ /l1lLleolr ,cAf/~1w~j/ 4 /o~h / Resident's Address and Unit: 04::V..--Zi.4O/ to'/t/ d~ Street Address /7otl Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33 / ~d Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed ~*D'l C&tkt-l 10-"3, ~) - Resident's Address and Unit: k J:'lCt\-AA\ lLV-b Street Address Aventura, Florida ~7.., I (() 0 ~ l~~) Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ~~~ Date Signed ~v 11-1 Co H €~ (~-3-tJS Resident's Address and Unit: ~hJ S5LA,0!J tt..U /) Street Address 1'7' cJ 3' Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ,!J S / b 0 Zip Code Mail To: Tbe City Comminion of Aventura 19200 Weat Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow CommiNioner Harry Holzbel'l, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Groaman, Seat 1 Commis.ioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and CommillsioDen of the City of Aventura: Ala ....ide,nt of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishmeDt of a sYDagolue in the ....idential buildinl, 1600 bland Boulevard, Unit CU.l and ul'le you to vote aaainllt the conditional.le application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name SilDature Date SiaDed 10\\ \O~ ~-=:>cr\-E{L C\-\A-"5~ ~~ Resident'. Address and Unit: l..G.oo \ '::>L.Av0.~ ~LJ i) Street Add..... Av..tu..... Florida S ~ \ (.. 0 ZlpCode L~O"2- UDltIApt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed -t'\\\o\' 1>o~~-t\~ ~~~'-- ~ \o\",\os Resident's Address and Unit: 'v\'" (j' 0 \ <;'\. ~'":)) f'"LV'\) Street Address 't 0'\ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed ~O~~ D~^,k'O~r a~aL~ Resident's Address and Unit: '~'D '3;S.U~ ~\vJl Street Address L-.-IoOk:, Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33 \ 10 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signatur Date Signed ~ <'\)(''-.M-D f\t Od-2 ~S Resident's Address and Unit: 2.~0'C) "3.-<:, ~o. ~~ K \ u~, Street Address 2- ~O k, Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida C::S3 \ l:,o Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~!-LI'e ~sS'~ 10 f>, 10 3 , Resident's Address and Unit: jOoo Zdl1#q I3Lvcl Street Address 10 1- Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida "3"3/ (PO Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed (;../c...CO\.. L /p M{()I'~ Lk/)< /' - ~F/f~J /u}-/J] Resident's Address and Unit: -2 r DU :t:-J-C-/[?,~ I) 01- VI) Street Address roO" Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida :> ,16 '0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~ /?O/}6A'\-- 5' LlfY'V-I0,,- ~ " ~ ) --AID J , . Resident's Address and Unit: d, '? Dw rs t-.Owfl /J l- (d) Street Address 306 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .1 3 / C 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ,f;h;y JV'y fi/nr { ~{Ju-Lor~lu }/ IL -f-, .!L/~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ...3'7{)lJ E5!{)nJ. J4/ud . Street Address f-3o/ Unit/Apt Aventura,Florida ,~3/ (:,0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed J:.5t1JIlrP b/dc..k Resident's Address and Unit: .3'7() () JS Jo nd ~ filA Street Address (J-,~{J/ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ,1.-1/(, II Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed ~o '" cl Y"C' \Z ~'? IMM"-' _ /(J-,j- 6"3 , i Resident's Address and Unit: ~M)h.b.""A K1IJd St eet Address ~-30~ nit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature 1...\ -eV\? \<. ~~\..v\ ~ r L .#;:7 /~/ Resident's Address and Unit: 3"}!) 0 \ ~\1\,-A \S\~i Street Address J3-30~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ ~ I ~ 0 Zip Code Date Signed //)-fl-o~ . Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed s ~. ~\)L!') _~ ----- ~elv(o} Resident's Address and Unit: 3000'PSLAVcl (3 \"",J Street Address Aventura, Florida ~l ~ Zip Code Z. 2.0"l-,..- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~~ ~~ ~\ot>~ 6:d- L ZOo.s i Resident's Address and Unit: ~ ~Q~ ~\v& Street Address b Aventura, Florida 33l b Zip Code /4QS Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name L~,"\ "':t.. ~A-<U) Signature ~~~ - Date Signed Pc..-t" '11 ~oo3 Resident's Address and Unit: "?w;;.~o \<)LP.JtlO ~\,.tJ.P Street Address \ ~ oS' Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~"b\"O Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~1'A-N f6 ~S) I<ANE , ~/e~ )() ~!?, ~ / Resident's Address and Unit: Jqx-> Js/~j tic 1 Street Address - :;z.. )'"02- Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/bn Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name (r) {ij--( d_I} h // 'I Signature )~ ~uo. Date Signed /0,/6/./63 Resident's Address and Unit: 3000 ~~qJ Unit/Apt 3-2/foD Aventura, Florida J ~~-d 1+-9-/0 cl- Street Address tve- Zip Code ~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 1(o<?e.. STer n kC/U-;/~ , /O-2.-()3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3000 h~.vo BLvd Street Address l..z (),:L Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 '3/ c",o Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 1-I1!..Ie./36/f!..T '57e/''7 ~l~ /(/-",:2.-03 Resident's Address and Unit: 3 btfo W&<"'VPV &". Street Address . /..td ~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .:3 3/ " d Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed f}e/t71/ ~ :flU/( ACME ~u A~ !6/~J Resident's Address and Unit: c3t3DoIsUvnd 6lud Street Address //!~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 3 /fpo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed tfpei..:>/tE ,,6(H8,qA:: ~/t!~ . /17 - / - 0 :3 Resident's Address and Unit: /000 ;f.6L/'f/J/ D 13 ttl 0 rr ~D ~ Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/ t." 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed _~ ('1IIJ k ~fr,,, ~llj<OuL, v ! , La h--I 03 Resident's Address and Unit: L) 6Fu W '\[SLJfi\JJ:> {t;t-VfJ I Sb'i Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '33L6 ?> Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature 'RC\"~~ \J~ J'{U.I)~~."J ~ WIL ~ Date Signed rO)1-JD3 Resident's Address and Unit: l (J II t1 e-J . :;r? L- A-tJ-1) ~v d. Street Address 6:,1l, c) Aventura, Florida It ~'1 Unit/Apt Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~ oSe: Olt:.=l€e ~~~ ( / t::) - ..< _0.3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3000 'CS. ~LU D Street Address I~O.3 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 331(;, 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~4/%~ /~/z'/u5 <':~tv'FOrzO p, 7?>ARGtI ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 3 rJ07.J / drY.?1d .Bird Street Address Aventura, Florida '3 '3 t'6o Zip Code ..:::IT 2S0 S- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed fZ:>n"H /.346/\) ~~ 13~ /~~5 Resident's Address and Unit: ,--3 000 ~~ f0U Street Address Aventura, Florida~3 ,3/6 () Zip Code :<0' OJ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed L;J..o +J~7 J(l~. t,1...rr ~~; -"'<.. 9/.~ It) Ie< It) Y .. Resident's Address and Unit: '39DDZl~(> 8c.O/P. Street Address Aventura, Florida "5 II {. 0 Zip Code ~I Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed .5 ~ tV /fL.}> PAL-I.. oT ~"iT-- # Resident's Address and Unit: 3900IS~4,f)1> ~'-vJ), Street Address <0 ( Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 3/ ~ c!) Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ~~ , Date Signed ftpJ ; 1/t ~~s. tojr)3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~~~ Street Address 170~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 331hD Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed \i~~~%~. S:},n~ \\ ~'}~ ~&) .01; Resident's Address and Unit: 6 ~Dc) "J"QMA. ~~ Street Address B l/{),:L Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~~1 ~~ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed h'~1r"" ~~~ jp D3 \-\ cl ((II c.- Resident's Address and Unit: 3'\00 \ SLA"'O Street Address ((,/1.11 l-( o~-(2 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida )111..= Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed S'-k~f~ hsc--~('1J /~ ( OJ Resident's Address and Unit: )"1/70 (SLllfV-O f>/"J Street Address Aventura, Florida <., ') {~D Zip Code !f&r(l, Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ~ N/''''- Signature /-1 ~ -------- ..--- - ~"Y ;::'" .. / . r/ !f'r.1.-f"",rc/---. ~ Date Signed Jh~ /1 tI-:l I Resident's Address and Unit: ;) 'crJ /.sc..,,; 1?<-VI> Street Address Aventura, Florida ~I ~ (J Zip Code d-I () ....-- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed (! ll/ltlL6 r;~&<? lo;YG yfrzul!_ ~~ 'I htJ /tJ3 ( , Resident's Address and Unit: l~k cJb. ;SeN' Street Address ' ~(~ V"' Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3) I to Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Q4~ Date Signed A/GrHt- ~ !I) II I t/ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: Yfoo ~~y ~-v Street Address Aventura, Florida ~ ! c. (} Zip Code Jlj lc;:/ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~fJ1H i A VOCJrl- /,.'/1 ),1.1..1./) fld(y#, lit 1ifI/ty /O~J-()J Resident's Address and Unit: I J J/lro Pi F( Street Address Aventura, Florida 3) I ~ d Zip Code ~Stt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed HRILTI'" f.. 1're.lf."tIP ~~ ~ 1'0110.3 Resident's Address and Unit: 2~c>", /3l.I}<uv AL VJI Street Address "'70;) Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida 3> jJ, J '" Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name s;~ ~~- Date Signed E\~flY\()\-~ut\er I..,hHV \u\ \ \O?J . \ Resident's Address and Unit: Lroo ~~ ~lO;- Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ""3"3 \ b () Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed e S \l\ (\ R.e<::,c; L-~-m b. Q,'LS~ 10 I ( j ),6(13 Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 r ~UHJD 1Ol\! D Street Address ~;).'),oq Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida 2>;>-, I (; () Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name U:w-iS tv\. '?-e: 55 Signature ~J;t~ Date Signed J()} In' Resident's Address and Unit: / ()~fP ~ bWi> Street Address ;2.~eq Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 ? / ~() Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 'T t:t>,:z I /1/1"15;.1:.4 Y JI 7. ~?a?W~ dct? 1c;4r:/03 Resident's Address and Unit: 3!Jo 0 ~Lf.<) ,.)/ e &I}/e:> Jeo3 Street Address Unit/Apt ?::,Q I Q 0 Aventura, Florida ..:> <s Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed j1f!Jlf}@) f- & /() - j- tlJ . Resident's Address and Unit: ci!!!1.~~AjP hr; Aventura, Florida c3JJ IIJ Zip Code ~J Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ate Signed GAA. '/:J. l-l.{SrCsritt1(y Id/z//J3 Resident's Address and Unit: .nrSNEUliJlj~~ Street Address Unit! pt Aventura, Florida ? ~/Xl> ~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed VI 'A;I)b-LI,/Jb .z~IZ;J '7jk Jffi~, /0-01-173 Resident's Address and Unit: lOGO E .rst.I'tI--".P rlLv.p Street Address 23:J L. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida J3/60 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name it:7J Z-~rJ Date Signed (0-01- 0.2 Resident's Address and Unit: IJoo "E"' ~b f3lvD Street Address 2]()"L Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~J(~o Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed JUIVIi A. Dl!uTs oH G~ , a. cLrJo. -G U / ( /1?A-~.3 Resident's Address and Unit: /OOt:? ,G. l...s'-AAI,Q ,s,O'i'. Street Address ':?oeJ.j Unit/Apt A ventura, Florida .J 7 , ~ " Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed l1l>t:roN ~. PLu'f.3'c..tl 7r~4.~<. Id~/eJ Resident's Address and Unit: '''OD ~. Js~/WD Ihlrf'_ Street Address ..7... o-:J Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3~/6o Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed l\1' S.~ /~ j !tJ'3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3rxtJ ~Ial\d Blvd ~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '35/(,0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Signature AV~~ Date Signed to) )03 Resident's Address and Unit: 3<!Cll ~ /(lJ ~\J~ Street Address Aventura, Florida ~3 J bo Zip Code J).. ~() / Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~It/-I/!t) /I ;!JA~k $///$d ~;/ JejJ .3 0/6.3 . / Resident's Address and Unit: 2~t1tJg~/~~/ Street Address /~Ij Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/10 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~'ClAc.oA€J ~c.WC:O~ ,jjf 16/0; / Resident's Address and Unit: Zb??t1 Ak/ ~A/ Street Address Aventura, Florida 3]/&'0 Zip Code II/tJ4 Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 11P'p~/1' 7/;tfJ- I 11~j~ ~ r /~~b~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~/ Street Address Uilit/Apt Aventura, Florida - ~ Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ;M(fJ/U ~~ / ~~(j;;U / /#7 Resident's Address and Unit: ~.laW ,jjd Street Address / Aventura, Florida J3dLl Zip Code ~/ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~h.~~\) ~\\- '- "'S~\J- /0 It /0'3 Resident's Address and Unit: / () oc> F 1~~lA/J rgL14!J . Street Address Aventura, Florida '] 3l' 0 Zip Code l ,5(J~ ("3/0&') Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name & !'-Oft J}/.f k 1- ~~ Date Signed 1 /3v ~ 3 Resident's Address and Unit: GS'-"~ ?lv'7 t S eet Address Aventura, FlOrida:?.2 /~ 0 Zip Code ISaC G fOe) Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed # #~)p4... ~. f!.dpJ" s;j;;j",,,{I/' /W"--"' I Resident's Address and Unit: ~~d~S~ ~M ' A ventura, Florida _==3 . .:::; / /, () Zip Code / fiZJ /- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed CJA 171 7J~. Ad~{e- ;z1////tJ,-t# 2)/ !/J4-~~~ ;' " /1/)03 Resident's Address and Unit: t/~ \~fl.&J). / Street Address /Yl? Y Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3 3/ ~ () Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ~ Resident's Address and Unit: /#~c't~-ill 0/(/,< !.~f.f Aventura, Florida :<. ?;;/6 0 Zip Code ----'_._.---~-------~-- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature VtcK/ ~ I ",k(p..lJ ~ ~~t. ~~ Date Signed u;;~k;Jr /~03 Resident's Address and Unit: /([)(}O U~SLAtJd i?Lvp. JfooB Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ?3 3 I b 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name ru~ Date Signed \l~ LW~~~ Cl <-\ , 2..") ) Resident's Address and Unit: .'Ub~ 5::'5(",..1. P.,\vi Street Address Aventura, Florida ') '?> I /, 0 Zip Code 1..fOL Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed (!ft~ LJ iu'lr~ Resident's Address and Unit: .2&00 -A 13b-L Street Address If --< P tJ J-. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 33/00 - 5,;z I 2- Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed fxfZQ1;t CJcMDi ~. / ~ P.~/OJ Resident's Address and Unit: ;2.(j:o :f:6w~ Street Address Aventura, Florida 3.J /60 Zip Code I r- c6' Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed f..Il ~M-/:JJ!(f'~ _ ~ ? Cjj~DS Resident's Address and Unit: J.6w 7Mo1-d fbkI Street Address Aventura, Florida 1]160 Zip Code bJJ2 , Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature /JJw(LcNU ~ ~Ice ~&..u., Date Signed 9/30/03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~bOO JJIQ."rA 1lvd Street Address If OJ- Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 331b 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed JG'(h h.e/l'1 ~C'~ Vy~'1-e~ qh 0103 , Resident's Address and Unit: ~" () I:) Nlq 1\<.1 {1!v d Street Address If OJ- Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 53100 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature , Date Signed ~ ,/ "AY'I1>V' . ,,/1JAtJ (/ I-~: I, /\Ncc{, II <',) i /vI~<,l /&tl4lc~u~ ) /- / Jj , .J ... q..)fl/0~ , I I Resident's Address and Unit: Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature / 1 1~. CP r / ,- ( LL4ub;~BofAt-J/;W, '/C'::~~ .''---___.'' I _.L.a . Date Signed I <1/29/03 , Resident's Address and Unit: '-';'> U-co J.Se AAJ.i>D- tJi) Street Address Aventura, Florida ...">3 i b,o Zip Code "J ? ,,;;.00_ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ~.~ 4. c,fX6.-rJ'tJi~ S-~~, '2P'8 Resident's Address and Unit: /~~fJlcnR fqQs- Street Address ~ Aventura, Florida '33(66 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signatu~. ~! 0".. ~ j'}A/~E &A",;t5..v-~S6U;h$/C Resident's Address and Unit: 0('.600 ..13".Id;;tl2> <L)).@. Street Address #~/ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida .,,33 /6z:> Zip Code ~~-... -'--_.,~- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature ,ElI.TO IT If?..saf meJ7. Date Signed ~/o<1 /a.3 / / Resident's Address and Unit: o?6tJtJ ...TskW..l) /3J..v::D. Street Address #~/ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 3.3/60 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am se:ongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential buildmg, :l()UU ISlantfIJoulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. P~ed Name twPfut fem~.v 7 e Signed ......, .--- ~ if1J 0.-l]1-? I Resident's Address and Unit: dhYD rLh~~~_ Street Address Aventura, Florida ,~/ 150 Zip Code ~~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am-,tro~ly oPPose~ the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Islan Boulevard, Umt CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. '}~/ Si~ Resident's Address and Unit: ct ~d~ _1 ~ mho Zip Code b,,~ ~ Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed f4l-J.-..)1; LA D~ENCE ~~~~ '1 J~% ~ . Resident's Address and Unit: ~ t&, <0 0 ~~\a.n~ 'B\"J-. Street Address CjiJ4 Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~~/bD Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name tD lit f? L.lflt/L I"'c , tM11< t.() (3/0IJ-J ure Date Signed eff't9 - .Utl3 , Resident's Address and Unit: Z(POO rlltwa!.%Ill -z ~Ov- . Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida jj / (; 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name f/" (Jc<P t f-tfle ;''''1 C I~A Af<,c () Ij:3, i 0 fr f' ~ Date Signed Ctf VI -OJ Resident's Address and Unit: <...({, <D 0 T ~M/' a( G ev /) ''2'_ !uJ of - Unit/Apt Street Address Aventura, Florida :3 3 ff r;, (J Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ::tJ. SK INN Y1P~~ '~~~~ Vlm IO!I(o'3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~bDV L>~~~f6\vJ Street Address Aventura, Florida 33! 00 Zip Code ~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed Afl.E~f; ifuQ1 ~ Ye)JJ~ q-3:J ~O') Resident's Address and Unit: ci400 ~~ E2v'L Street Address Aventura, Florida ..331&0 Zip Code (Par Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature tOt1d~~ Date Signed &AJf1&. alL~ R;:::';~'i:d:~itG(J[ 2701 Street Address Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ ] / to Zip Code 90. d' @4lcs, 0JCm! 2600 dslanlJ Gb; >} @Suite 2704 r::->ll)'o'l:1f,,_rq .--=i:",~ :' ':t .1 ,I~/' ;,;;;;r;;.:/""'~""""v"''; i..::;:/"""" '-''--.\h, Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Date Signed D LUAl.vJ''1 D (I\f!d!-" Resident's Address and Unit: lh 0 (\ :[(!q/JJ g((/ L Street Address 170 i Unit/Apt d).. d> &litts. ciJ&-rrpcy _(71. c()Japtil' 2600 c}slanf) @/j/pfJ. @5uite 2704 e:/!:2Jenlu{(!, ,/Y;lllo 33! 60 Aventura, Florida 131bo Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name fV'/A-f('v It"; ~ Z. 4€rt-t'tf-.+ ~72-- Date Signed 5"-lt'o-03 5-/6-0,-=>, Resident's Address and Unit: I tY-OCJ ..IS ~ 0 6?--..;0 -IF IS"CJ 2.... ;f.va.J7c.14'1 fiA- "33/&0 I Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed pO-rb[L~.1> (0 vJ Y) ~ L /~ ~I . 1Ji-.i/f~ Y24~ (if'z,g) 03 Resident's Address and Unit: cJ(o()T2 Is l(~ 151 if ~ Street Address to" Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ",,:>'-3 (00 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed J~J\JJ fp B~ou ),J Resident's Address and Unit: rJfdJO (ShlJ-AA> bJ,vy. Street Address Aventura, Florida 3'7 / ~ 7J Zip Code 7o~ Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed 11ZRGS Oi(L,O-Jl ~ (f',tiA-<Y< q~ ;(9.0.3 Resident's Address and Unit: dtoco ~Q1'lC.J ~ 0 Street Address Aventura, Florida 33/ (,,0 Zip Code Pf{2- Unit/Apt Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Signature Date Signed ,,( }/. r-A(JJ aJ..,,~ ~~. rJ- ro~ Resident's Address and Unit: 260 0 ~J..JaJ Street Address 7Hz. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida '33\ (" 0 Zip Code Sep 17 03 05:12p Robert & Arlene Diamond 305 933 9920 p. I September 12,2003 Commissioner Robert Diamond Aventura Oty Hall Aventura, RA. Commissioner Diamond, We have been "snowbird" residents of Williams Island for fourteen years. We have seen many changes during this time, Some we expected and others we did not. Those that were not. affected us negatively. At present. there are many rumours about what is, or what may be happening, all of them not expected nor in our opinion in the best interests of the residents who "bought a lifestyle" when purchasing on Williams Island. We now hear that a synagogue is proposed with extra parking required from the Med. Village, First of all, we do not have any recall as to a proposal for approval of any synagogue. During the period where there was an area set aside for religious purposes we noticed that many of the people came from outside Williams Island, It is NOT the duty of W.I. to provide a synagogue for "outsiders", Lets look at the increased traffic generated by the synagogue (for which they need the parking)... if they intend to have parties of any kind, we certainly do not welcome the increased traffic. By doing that we are opening up our gated enclave to many people. let's look at the noise factor....music, loudspeakers. For those of us who live nearby it will be a constant irritation. We certainly did not know about this when we purchased. We would like to know whom the Trumps consulted before pushing for this and what the response was In relation to the total number of residents. It is our understanding that on Nov. 411I Qty Hall will be discussing this matter, We ask that you vote against it. We have had to live with the results of some major negative tactics imposed upon us, and think it is time to say "NO!" Mr. Commissioner, feel free to table this letter at City Hall. ~~(;/? A~~nd May Karp 3900 Island Blvd. B102 Aventura 33160 ..,/ j ce: Mr. A. Epstein Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Q~ L \Jl:\-'~ Signature l~~ Date Signed ~ Resident's Address and Unit: II 0 <> lA. ()\~ t Street Address i K .'l.. Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida ~ :. l b D Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Printed Name Lf:.. \--l-/ wi.r.~~ I Date Signed q / /5 ) D.3 / / Resident's Address and Unit: l~ D 0 1:r(,.~l M-~ Street Address .1 g 01- Unit/Apt Aventura, Florida 'b ~ \ h 0 Zip Code Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Bolzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Bouievard, Unit CU-l and urge you to. vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature/ .~ ee lI+f-I kA 12- fV7 A- R V I f1J /( IfIz Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: /N4:? U4",/N.~ ~/j-O;;2 IN? .j~~d/ ~ /-SLJ.L, Teresa Soroka From: Sent: To: Subject: Arleen Llanes [lIanesa@cityofaventura.com] Friday, August 29,20033:10 PM sorokat@cityofaventura.com From: Patricia Robinson Bethuel -----Original Message----- From: Bethuel - patricia & Claude [mailto:BETH-ROB@webtv.net] Sent: Friday, August 29, 2003 11:00 AM To: Arleen Llanes Subject: Re: Aventura City Commission Agenda WE ARE GOING TO BE OUT OF THE COUNTRY HOWEVER WE WANT TO REGISTER A STRONG 'NO' VOTE FOR THE WILLIAMS ISLAND SYNAGOGUE. THIS IS A RESIDENTIAL COMMUNITY AND IT WOULD BE TOTALLY INAPPROPRIATE. THANK YOU FOR GIVING THIS YOUR EVERY CONSIDERATION. patricia Robinson Bethuel,CEO Claude G. Bethuel, President Hospitality & Tourism Associates * TASTE OF AMERICA [R] * GourmetGetaways [tm] * Fantasy Feasts [tm] Celebrating 22 Years - WOW 305 933.4005 / 9094 Fax Email: TasteAmerica@webtv.net t Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name '!Ai ~e A~~;U~ \hd~o. <ou h(l\'f(2Z ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 1bOD Js k:t<<J ~ \ vd . \.0 i I\lOKY'S js \aft'\.d . ~A~ ----I Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners Cit~ Manager G",,,,, ~;[\I (E2 ., To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin. Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed ~.~ . ~/22/03 ~~~ .JC),.--" 0__. - ,- "-"--~"'=-~~"--,---~ t\TJr"N' H. ST...i;~vlETT Resident's Address and Unit: 21396 Marina Cove Circle, Unit J-12 Aventura, Fl 33180 :\>lail To: Tbt: City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager @ CCr>1""1 \~('" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Ho1zberg, Seat 1 Commissioner MaDDY Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner 'Lev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 '0," Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CD-I and urge YQU to vote against the conditional use B pplication that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name LI";"b"1 ~,EbC.L Signature Date Signed C,/d/o,;l b}P/<::. ED"","'; ~rcGEL- Resident's Address and Unit: / b () o. :::z::s LA,.,' h;3 t.. "'.l::, ;u,07 ,4vErJTUrtA- IL. Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissionm City Manager LOt>I"" t::.~';' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. "'\. ,Mident(S) Name f1@/O!1 f))EfI?/d Resident's Address and Unit: 3MfJJ:rIlND!2LiJ/), ~~tJ~ r-JJJ; /1v607dll :1eJ//;o .JtJM ,~~J) iJl-Ul) ./fJ7oif /}vwrkt/f jj/to I RECEIVED JUN 1 i 2ull:- CITY CLERK $MIIA ~~S, ,..... Lynn Levy Broker - Salesperson Cell: (305) 778-8558 Home: (305) 932-5663 lynnlevy41@eol.com Cfaire lJl.ptuf Realtor. AssocIate Cell: (305) 632-5331 Home: (305) 933-1416 nrand10390@aol.com www.luxuryrealtors.net sion of Aventura try Club Drive 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoM'" ~"')fjJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ;('jt7vJ Ii~{j( Resident's Address and Unit: I-OOU Ivt J4adJ 4/;, ~gd? iJut1llvt2Q;. ff _g3'/f;() &5 (hI 00 f:JJ$-fati ~ -... ..... RECEIVED JUN 10 2003 CITY CLERK a--~ -=+. ~ I ~~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (0","", be"'. eJ) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed " I' /0.3 (p J b ,I 03 \Q.,Q-SC SC 14 A-C'f::: N'fflt ~\C>>~~D SC.~M~I'l~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~f?oo :rslq",d BI'I<:L A'lell\-Tv<"o.... Fla... 3~/(,o I So~ RECEIVED JUN 1 0 2003 CITY CLERK "".~-~ - - --~ T~- -~ r- r T May-13-03 12:1BP Rae Swarte 305-936-9977 P.02 Mail To: The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ('oflI"" b.-v. @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name K.H. Haller s;gnnttL Date Signed 05/15/2003 Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 Island Blvd. H 3011 Aventura, FL 33160 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COtn"" tx.... 1i> To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed S /1 {,/O.3 MUR.\E:"L ~OE.'!IN~ ~~4~7 Resident's Address and Unit: laoo ISLAND BLVD. J..'10:J.. WILLlt:lHS ISLAIv'D AI/~A/-rURA..FL. 33f(.O , RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co /l? /VI be"- ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Tbank you. Resident(s) Name~re ~ 1).,~Lco~ ft1~5 L MAQ[,AR:ef Mf:lsc.e& \.,tn~ifPM ~ Date Signed - S/{/03 . ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~ \~b Bx..JD ~~104 ':J1u...\~S tSI-M0I1 ~h.. ?'0-tb RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 0/>1 '" IYJ' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .&/176> /U'IC/?'er; Signature :il~ 4~7 Date Signed ~;;S-~3 / / Resident's Address and Unit: /iJ,? c/ K~/M~ 5t)?~ crpf' RECE\VEO M(l.'1 7 7 2003 crrt CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co I'1-'n ty". ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed ','jfE/fA Wk/Jfl3GI"/~ A";/:AL ~(b--~. ~ IS, '1-1".3 Resident's Address and Unit: /9 ?sS-L ......wA>~ ,'r/ /'1<<; vh~A ~ , RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C () ",,,,- fy"l' 6J To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~L~ Date Signed t;?vra(~ ~~ .r II r / 'LrcJ5 , , Resident's Address and Unit: IfSJ)~tvl ~~ ~..~ RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co II? IV) .fy II , @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name d~~ ki4k-~ . Signature c?~.dJ Date Signed sf; Jloy sf; J ~;7 Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 E T5~ l51t20 &CJI.j RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 , , cc: ComrrusslOners City Manager CO""Af ~l"' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 6\\:~~o~t""\~~ ~,~ ~,,~~) Signature -~ Date Signed '\/\ ~* \ 0,:> ,*lI4o~ Resident's Address and Unit: v\' 00 \54rl~ ~~ \{;o '\- RECEIVED MAV 'J 7 2003 CITY CLERK ~'-l~~~ ~L. FROM : CHASE PHONE NO. : 7574221633 Ma~. 15 2a03 09:S7RM PI Mail 1'0: The City Commbsioll of Aveatura 19100 West CoaDtry Club Drive Av.atura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM'" Iy"" (ft). To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioller Harry Holzbera, Seat J Commissioner MaDny Grossman, Seat 1 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beakin, Sea. 4 CommiuioDer Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commi..ioner Kea Cobell, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of AveDtura: As a resident of Aveatura, I am strongly opposed to the establillhmeat ofa Iynacogue in tbe residential build iDE, 1600 Island Boulevard, Vllit CU-1 and urge you to vote apinst the conditional use application tbat will make this use possible. Thank you. "ttW4 ~.~ Date Si&oed S-/~O~ S \ \'~ \o?" , Resident's Address and Unit: ~G,oo \ ">~"l) E2.Jl...V 0 ~ "2 '30 '2.. ~0""'~JVA \='1- ~ ~\ Coo I RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co "'"., bt"~. rt3 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name i. t4w~r~ alkl.1. \ Resident's Address and Unit: ~ ~ :I~J..fI {\J () ~ Lv [\ P H ~D J- RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~1V1/Y1 ty,/. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Reside7t(s) Name &-d /f:;5c/J dti:.a~ ,Y; "l~ Date Signed 5' -}f/ -() }; Resident's Address and Unit: 35Gb .J' pkJ1) ply) j}- 'joy ( RECEIVED MAV 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",,,! Deol' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. \ A Resident s) Name L Signa~e _ M ~ed t-"\ ; dt~ \\0 ~ I\J $16. '1 I y ~ ~ c;'. L &-0 '3 Resident's Address and Unit: \ 000 \ ~ \ A-l\J ~ .g, \ \/() F~O:? A\Je/\+'-Jca +='L- 5? ( GO RECEIVED MAY') 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"'lM l;)-<o.J- ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date Signed 5/13 . Resident's Address and Unit: lo-cJtJ E. 15 CZW.D :tI / 9cJ 2.. RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",,,,, (yt/. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ']";--rLP./::, L/fI f? c.1-71J Signature Date Signed ~..- L_ -!:J-=-J Cj -0:3 Resident's Address and Unit: /~ J!J~J AL-.1 /..<Cl~ ~~- - ;::-k.u~. . 63/60 RECEIVED MAY') 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/>1-"'1 f:yv' i1- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank yon. Resident(s) Name SFnatuke lvJ~ Date Signed ~~(7 ~l.. bAY ~~-C::, Resident's Address and Unit: "1000 \.~~. RIN . \ c::otr ~'wJf\~Aro.. t-- \, ~~I ~o RECEIV~D MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager CI!)""'" ty.l'.~ Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /) G1j)!J8j ~ IcLi!o cL Resident's Address and Unit: ~c,i';~ C CU~I (! / Jf5 ~ ~ Date Signed ~/7)63 #C2/Yb RECE\VEO W.'{ 7 7 2001 crN CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: COmnnSSlOners City Manager Co',,,,,,, fyv- ~ To: Mayor .Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed J~o ~j Mo'--IOM. I CLu.! 05-/'1-D.1 {)r;~{q -o~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~!;"OD {f,LCLu...tl -:i.LWJ. , '::? /I () I /1vevt. ~".C{ I rL I ~31C. D RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co'"'" ~eol' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name H,4NS k, L i :-; I'I!I iJ ignature Date Signed -- -~ ", ~ ',:> - I Lj _ () Resident's Address and Unit: .'X-", I,. I ~."'." 1'."\ It'i,:.C...J,, -; :~ '--0 , k~K\ j v L II _ _ A G--e',.yL~1 Cc -t-l.. ':i.3 \ (, Q RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co IV" ty,& To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /I?!J/i!..r~nJ Y/fUTSc-H J {)It!~ [)/EUT.5c-d Signature ~~~ (./u--' ~ // / Date Signed 6/~6ft? ~6~3 Resident's Address and Unit: Jt?&O fi" /SL,4../Y'P ;$L;/IJ d&:!3 RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO.->1'>1 tyJ' If) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. j;j;;D~;;;r JkoBS ~~~ Date Signed ~-/~ ,06 Resident's Address and Unit: ~o95h Ell-I 0'1 4ve-J1/eJRKf FL 3~{? 3$/ f! () RECEIVED MAV ? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 0 <1'1 />1 f:Jtv'iJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Name t['(\ \~ "\ Date Signed ~\~~ ) Resident's Address and Unit: eJ~ :SY RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Av:entura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.o""/Vl fiP' p/ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 'F~eE"F;: JJAG~ ~~2 Date Signed ~~plo 3 Resident's Address and Unit: ..3801 tI Eo ?,01 .>T APT 50 , 4 V f f'I TV M F L ,3.3 I 80 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 Z003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Av.entura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Com,., t).t./.~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~f).A Signature Scoff.D. Bu~ Date Signed S}J5 )6 "3 . ',. Resident's Address and Unit: 3'-100 N.&,. {Cfr<' YT. ty,;ftl(D7 A lit", fvv Ci I fL "3 3/ 'i () RECElVED MA~ 27 2003 Cli't' CLE.RK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMM [y.... fL To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Signature Ajb/f.-~/cln-rb Date Signed c- /1-tJ3 Resident's Address and Unit: _11333 J. ~~ ~~ ~;t/ 0L RECEIVED MAV ? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To; The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc~ Commissioners City Manager COI>\/" ~@ To; Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident~ Name -~4 j~r~ Date Signed 5 ~\\\03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~S';O M~,' tL ~ ~A k:- h;,,\f(; RECEIVED MAY 2 7 Z003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"'tn ty~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed B -e..-rSj ~t""al,er- &.7 AA-kA"" Resident's Address and Unit: ~- ~ 2..- 0"2, ;)oqL.\o e, 0...'1 C-\-> \.Ar\~ 3-3 l\y~ ~L ~ \go l RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C,o """" De./' @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name }2'- J:;;e.Y\~en t-5~ Signature I^-\)""'C}~ Date Signed ~J "}o:< Resident's Address and Unit: 33a) ~z-19lst2>t-. #3,d-. ~Ct{ ~L 33r36 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.t!....1'1 lYo"- ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed \^kl~ (V\A'tIl-+vWS ~_n\t)~J.i)L/ ~/J~//); Resident's Address and Unit: !2.J! b ( W ~.Il/t1lft/h lYt a II (1;J)-H~ rl 3:3/ $ 0 RECElVED MAV 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C..MfVI ~ V& To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(~ !tff20~ <J:;:TG / Resident's Address and Unit: dc/i ()3/eeJ""p C! '3/ Y /J-0htJ;A;Z~) c;t j3/1V RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cC~ Commissioners City Manager Cx>m"1 ti~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I 3m strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~~ ~Ot-.~M...,.) Date Signed .{'('V/ oj s:/ h./ (;) "3 S""'~-.: ~ ~o~'" A.,v Resident's Address and Unit: (DUO I ~ l..~b BI.i). ,IO~ AJ-IVl l"." , ~( 'HI "0 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager ~",,/"1 t::,(iI. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature d~ Fer --- ~~~)~ Date Signed rRlJrI/<" '-rEv! . , }~\~) h.,,~ Lj-y- (J..J' }-l\.-a~ Resident's Address and Unit: Jt7S"1'f. Co V4 c l vTf PR. /doD:3 /6<03 RECEIVED MAY 27 2003 CllY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C","'M bel. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) ~! r -~(4) vCc? Lme/;-6ti ( Resident's Address and Unit: 3~t0d) {)J~~~L~I 1JvvJ~ FI J3/6o RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"''''' (yoi" ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~t(S) Na~ ..J.... Q.n.y o~ . ---D~e 1<fsL ,~ 5 Resident's Address and Unit: J0c90""'J:."'=>\~ ~\Jo, '* 1.-;0)- ) .~~v~~. RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager "-r(V' CO("1/Yl U ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name CA./U)~ -thi"ZAY\\ v~ Date Signed '5;11910~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~oc!Jc) ~\~ -€\u~ oI.fD':l.. ~~"'I+? ~ \/bc) RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager tplVl/YI lY ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed s~ DJAJ-D/ST ~ !]LJAADjJr ~ 5. 22. D~ 5.2:2 .0-:' Resident's Address and Unit: -. TOLERANCE ..&!2b. Sara Dumont Apt 301 2600 Island Blvd A ventura, FL 33160 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager tolY1lV) ~(J' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. adent(s) Name ( ,J,J _~/~, Signature av~/ - Date Signed 5 <Z)-()'3-- Resident's Address and Unit: _:20/9IEa~r~(}1 ~<}ctr d f/P~d/tt-I 11. 33;/.J' 0 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMIV' IY"~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name t/a ~"~ /~ u.v Yh.-Uf:-XpU::J Signature Date Signed S/kl/tJL -5}J.-lj 63 Iuv ~ Pt?ES5 ~d.1{tf L .f}E5S Resident's Address and Unit: Jr 60 .j)M/ ptJ f2v~cjuA q ~ ..LO;) RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager Col>,"> (yll. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~gnature <_JW[k~OZ Date Signed ~ fIR (D'5 SUsAI\1 WI\I G~~ Resident's Address and Unit: <2loo I~' KI vet r/fJllo q A-ve.u ~ /+e' 3?J(P RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK A:\i ~ rt'":.lIrill1pnT nT a.v,:t.nTn..4]o . n..... ~~_......._..r 1'Oo__............_..~ ....._ __...._._.-'_... Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 C ..n11'\\SSioners Cc: OUlJ1'" Cit)' Manager C O,'hIl'lIY;I. fJi/ Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~~atu~ I2J..t.1JI.)~ K ~ 4 US Resident's Address and Unit: .:l.30(p 7000 ;J:sI/lJ)!J Blu); Date Signed RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK ~ail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: commissioners City Manager (OM/I01 ~ell" ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name I? rJ T7+ Y'l r{. r< S II f..A;tJ I1tII ~ '/VjAh.-- / Date Signed ~ v(. u;u3 Resident's Address and Unit: :<. (, (!) () I 5 &-fi-rv 'tJ 13 t-;) b 7'0/ RECEIVED MllY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK C2,~~ :;e Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO""M fYJ' # To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name k V }#~~ffl<.;v1+N CJtDat~ bM Date Signed ?~<a6 Resident's Address and Unit: .?wo /fj/p/J~.<f~\{b Avt4~,,) J - -:P- ~ RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mall To: Tbe City Commluioa of Aventura 19100 West Country Club Drive Aventnra, FL 33180 '!":: Commissioners Clty Manager ~ iJY'IIV'/--1.u a9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commislioner Harry Holzbere, Seat 1 Commi..loner Manay Groslmao, Seat 2 Commislioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 COlllm,..toner Jay R. BelkIn, Seat 4 Commllsiooer Zev Auerbach. Seat 5 ComminloDer KeD Coilea, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow aad Commill8ioners oftbe City of AveDtara: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a SY88lolue iD tbe residential bulldlnl. 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote aplnlt the conditional use application tbat will make this use poulble. Tbank you. ResldeDt(l) Name ~<i,,; lJ/,yIR-J:; alDaI r (/ Date SilDed o/S- /0 :1 . Resident's Addrels aad Unit: 351Jo ;lJf'sT;c P7 })12 37t?S- !1Yf?///N;Z/}j R g 31r-o , Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~1w~~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signa# ~- /:'0/3 c,:;/? /'- L/PM..q1f / ~~ E/LCCp\.- L/rP/lJXJ^- ~<X1/-.-r_{)..a..--..... Date Signed 5;jk I / I If J?J / Resident's Address and Unit: J.,p. 0 () 7:5"t...~ /vD f'DL.vO (\.10 ;1./ I L--&-/ ;tJ /'1 j ']: S L-tO /1, 0 i r-:: l...... / , The . S Y d n eye 0 r p RECEIVED ~c: Commissioners MAY - 5 7nn~ ~a~. CITY CLERK I Millj b ~ tff2 ~ ~crV ?~~ ~<, I< Q.u:JuJ ~ W~ }VL""A"~) lLW--- ~ ~~{k ~1'l1u ~~'Ik ~~ ~~~~_a.V,v~~io V~ Q, . ~ V~!.L-~.~~lR-U%-~ (1 "'- ~ 1--1 'IIu J~&-o ~ _N__+>I-,lA J (\ ~~ bI IN---' ~ ~ -- '-l ~ .d.o--.CI w~ -d __ d- ~~.-lU> ~ -tD J" tp--W0 ~r-'-" - "Lt ~4t> k ~~ ~. ~-h ~ r" tis ~..fu:.v -- "dS ~~ ) ~ +, M~ w--cltv ~ J\4 ~- 4h ~ofvJ) ~ &- 14~ - - -- (\W~M. ~(, ~ L.. J:hliA J tJ1v, .,'v/- 3900 Island Boulevard Suite B-106 Williams Island. F133160. Tel: 305.613 3010 . . . Fax. 305.466.3020 . Email: TheSydneyCorp@aol.com RECEIVED cc: Commissioners City Manager ~)W~ (/j) MAY - Ii 'OOJ '~IlI'lr{CI HM( Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. U/1ctb N e: BUilding7fto ~ Unit#j/O~ RECEIVED MAY - 5 7003 CITY CLERK Dear ~9#1 ~: cc: Commissioners City Manager ~~$) As a resident of Aventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island, On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, I ~ ~ RECEIVED MAY - 'i ?nnl CllY ClBU( cc: Commissioners City Manager rffY ~ Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. ~~d~ ~~1!..t;~ Name: Building: Lf {J 0 0 Unit #: vi () ~ RECEIVED MAY - Il ?nn1 CI1Y CLERK ~c: Commissioners c~~ [) Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. 1--- J~ -1:;-1-Ju~~ Name: Building: <fo-VV Unit #:2..-! () r; RECEIVED MAY - 'i 7001 CRY CLERK cc: Commissionerb City Manager ~~' ~ Dear 14f~ IM/~: As a resident of A ventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox S}llagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. ~ 3~ . ~U~~ hdj Sincerely yours, RECEIVED MAY - 5 1003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager /I.""""" ~ ' L.,-UI V I ~ {ji;; Dear 7ll~ 9'tr7 ~ As a resident of Aventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establislm1ent of an Orthodox SY11agogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, ~~ Dr. Burton and Linda S. Goldstein 2600 Island Blvd. #1903 Aventura, F133160 cc: Commissioners City Mana~er W ~7.. @ Aventura City Commissioners 19200 W. Country Club Drive Aventura, FI 33180 May 6, 2003 Dear Commissioners: We are writing this letter in strong support of the relocation of the Williams Island Community Synagogue. We are residents of the 2600 Building-Residence du Cap, We have been members of the Williams Island Community Synagogue ever since we moved to Williams Island over II years ago. This Synagogue serves the needs of a large community here at Williams Island, We respectfully request that you give positive consideration to relocation of the Williams Island Community Synagogue, Sincerely, ~S~~K~f:::::LkLj,r~1 ~ Linda S. Goldstein Burton 1. Gol~st~n, ~ ' cc: Commissioners City Manager C@ Babette Kabak Apt 806 1000 Island Blvd Williams Island Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel/Fax (305) 792 5392 Apr 30 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Commissioner of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, F133180 Dear Sir. MAY 6TII HEARING ON REQUEST TO ALLOW OPERATION OF A SYNAGOGUE IN A CONDOMINIUM UNIT On May 6th I will be overseas and unable to attend the Hearing on the issue to allow the operation of a synagogue in a condominium unit in the Residence Du Cap 2600 Building. 2600 Island Blvd, Aventura, FI33160.. I am writing to say I oppose the use of a condornium unit on the following grounds: · in the interests of fairness and equality. pennitting the use of a condominium for one religious institution would open a Pandora's Box for requests from other institutions · condominiums should be completely non-denorninational and allowing one institution to be established would imply its preference for occupants adhering to the precepts of that institution, This would set a very dangerous precedent of exclusionary practices, It should be firmly established that condominiums are solely and exclusively for residential purposes, Sincerely, /.8..~-/~~..,."€.. cI Mayor Jeffrey Perlow Commissioner Jay Beskin Commissioner Ken Cohen Gloria Muroff 2000 Island Boulevard - # 1709 Aventura, Florida 33160 RECEIVED MAY - 'J ?nOl CITY CLERK April 30, 2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~yJ @ Mayer Jeffrey Perlow 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, Florida 33160 Dear Mayer Perlow: As a resident of Williams Island I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote against the Variance that will make a move possible, Thank you for your consideration qt~Jr/ ROSENZWEIG RtCEIVEO MAY - 7 2003 CITY CLERK 2600 Island Boulevard, Apt 801 Williams Island Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel: 305-792-9905 Fax: 305-792-9962 May 1,2003 ~c: Commissioners City Manager ~~- tfD Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l Dear Mayor Perlow: As a resident of Williams Island, I am strongly against the establishment of a synagogue in 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use variance that will make this possible. Sincerely, ROSENZWEIG RECEIVED MAY - ? 2003 CITY CLERK 2600 Island Boulevard. Apt 601 Williams Island Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel: 305-792-9905 Fax: 305-792-9962 May 1, 2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~,k,~ Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l Dear Mayor Perlow: As a resident of Williams Island, I am strongly against the establishment of a synagogue in 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use variance that will make this possible. Sincerely, ~n,\--~ ~ Annemarie Burton-Rosenzweig \j ~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C .'0- ffj) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name s;gna'jif Date Signed )1rC/IELf/o,tJS' EJ..z:I7NE' -&p,t p( .5/r? /03 -6/&/0.3 . , )( Resident's Address and Unit: -.30CJO --75~ ,81 t/j) . 2 G 0 ~ /J]/E?/m49, Pi, .3:3/6'0 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C _t>e.D' JS9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature V 0 -<-Iv ,vOos,<, ,ttlte/if 77/p',/hj <(L-<-L7 ;Q (/;) 00/11-"-' . /roseA./.6-e-j CZJ;')" ~/l tt~~7 Resident's Address and Unit: Date Signed S--/-G:? ., Morton & Joyce Rosenberg 2800 Island Blvd. Apl.-2304 Aventura, FL 33160 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ())W @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~ ~ATC Lcetl..~ B. "bu.'M.~;.\ Date Signed S . 'g.. ~3 s . ~ . ?-oO'S Resident's Address and Unit: Jose & Leah B. Dumont 2600 Island Blvd # 2606 WiUlams Island Aventura. FL 33160-5211 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: CommISSIOnerS City Manager L f>>-J @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. S .K.dAlItLb 'Pffll,,7/ /n./V'. /.:f /f1 ~U- ./It/.,,t ./ ' . Si~g~. ~ DateSioned 5-l G: ~V- M If-I c. / 2<? 0 ~ ,!Jt-~ !,.nLfpC /;1.,/ 1,,) ~0l.I~ Resident(s) Name Resident's Address and Unit: 3 foo 'L..':;/~AJ)) 8/vJJ ~(J/8 ;fve.AJrute~ Flt}{/DA- .3';3/~O Mail To: The City Commission of Aveatura 19100 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (fJw 8 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny GrOllman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S Y UPPrY'\q,J LOIS rnftTT ~ Date Signed ~00.3 ~U03 Resident's Address and Unit: LbOo 'XSLA-l'JD BLvD ''lOY A-u8J TUttA-- (FL. 33 I b 0 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO""'" (y v- tJ RECEIVED MAY - 8 700:1 CITY cu_" ,', Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. :JFK-f< u Dc 5 !/f;J Name: Building: 3 DOc? Unit #: h C> '1 ~ y....U.t-;t G,d-M) Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"1 ('yvo2fj) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name A-hI) /; rd m~ !t.t.~ ~ ~~A~ Date Signed ?;/-r/!J3 Resident's Address and Unit: 33b6 /tJ (3 fi;?- ~-f .:11/)])9 _A/P/zLr)~vCv '1u 33/~/) Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"""" ~ev. It) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed .~ G6t~U~\ - ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~~C:'>o H6 l~~~ ~ "ub~ M~n,,,R,~ .t:-L-- ;'3\ ~o Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CONl"1 tx v' !) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name P/?.. &fJ~ M I L~jJ %bV 1-1, L,;;ft1A/ ~ tL, I Date Signed 'Sf/ItS S/7/t?3 Resident's Address and Unit: 2000 ~ ~-#(gOS ~ :;fif:J3/~o ) Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l1M ~v. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name B. ~ ~.)-~C\)-d Wh 11~ ~~ Date Signed .7/ ,l;> 03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~b O~ A/e2.c>7 yz A~fJI6 Av R-n rcv--<t i ff / )3100 , Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager COAl"., ty, tP To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HOlzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ( I\Ky, ( .; E pste\"l Signature ~j~ Date Signed Sic) 0 S Resident's Address and Unit: :=ss-oo Myst,'c- ~OtVj-k J\,. 23VY h((&I\~Ic... t=t ") 3{~u Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"''''' ~ev.W To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Nam kOhl'''-'/) I itrl-tu;,r:. ~ Resident's Address and Unit: )t~ ~ -..fb. ~t/ I W~I { / J-I () y Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co""m ~e". f} To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /~LL, C ~es s If+- ~/k I Date Signed 4/0 !o?? Resident's Address and Unit: / <!) () ()~. ~'#- '1{J 1- {)/VfMf~ :If. 33/"0 / Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc~ Commissioners City Manager Cc"'''' ~e". 61 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name · ~~'F~l;,~'" G Resident's Address and Unit: ~6 J/150 $ oi~. ~'t'~:2Y. ?#lap/it! 2600 e}slanf) @!lJ/pfJ. euite 2704- e-fhlllma. yia. 33160 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,.,,,, t::.ev, iJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~(A Q, \\ \ f'11 ; IE" \ - Signature Date Signed r I ').. '-)'b'(),) '~~~~^" .." Resident's Address and Unit: \ C\ '\ 6\\\~~ \'.J~ rl- t)~ ~'.\~N' \\'^- 0. . Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~OM"" f:)cv. ty To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name i?<WkCb",f'~ U,,^,,-,_ y"",,- vt. \ J:Jou..f JY IJ"1-U..-... Signature 1~~. Date Signed ~/7/0'3. 5" j, /~ Resident's Address and Unit: 2000 l<;:lc.,.,.J -8 \vL Itvw,~ I t=-L , /7D2 cc; Commissioners City Manager COMM bell'. Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. Building: tOeD Unit #: 5"0 7' RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager t "Nt'" be'" Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank. you. Name: Building: I b1)O Unit#: SO,! . RECEIVED MAY 11 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Co""'" tyv. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature 1) f ~/V)c1 Sf/rl/ffl~fl~ ~~--ri6(-Q~tIVltJ Date Signed 7J?r;j 7)dY!Jy ~1~(jJJ8 Resident's Address and Unit: 6tJ()o~/~ '6060 rJkJ~ ~ lJ6 !/M RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Com""- De"'. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ;f ;fer> VJk/(J-e/ Signature lL :L~ Date Signed J /...-- 7 --0 3 Resident's Address and Unit: ] p () 4 / {C-I}v--V /J { ';0 ..? ~ 0 3 ~11vt-1 JJ it v I RECEIVED MAY 1 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Com"" Dell, Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name t. ~W\~"lTt"_'r \-\PrW Signature ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~800~ ~2.-lor ~~,rv..~ ~~\I.. 0 \. Date Signed S-9--o~ RECEIVED MAY 1 ? 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/rJ/Yl ~v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature )-(A-Yu-JELL- WDU3oF,c JJ1;\ ~(JJW-l W fN01 X ) 1 e L (}ci::.1:f 0 t):- c5JL IA.J... '-t.. 0-0"~ Date Signed s-j<l/o.3 , s-/ /<,{~~ Resident's Address and Unit: <3 Go J.s- Ai Cen.", ~ c." e,J) ~~'L. ~ 331cRJ *' {/ tYO .3 RECEIVED MAY 1 ? 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoD,'ha, !yJ. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 1J~fUtp.,.J lJ. ~~ ~~L/ Date Signed ~ oJ" of-v '7 05- t;Jll-rJ"j Resident's A~ess and Unit: ~~7) ~ l ell' 1J'{)0J ~ A-i c.v ~l2 4- ~2J<h ~L> (}...o~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager to/l""" bell. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. , Date Signed 6:JO,\\0'3 \ Resident(s) Name l"I!-N..e-R..J) WE I N .sT~ 1111 Resident's Address and Unit: ~~~~ lJ!..:l ~\) ~~\ t..t.C-, ~ ~~, rl-. 33iio RECEIVED MAY 1 2. 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,""/>I (:yv' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name CS..,~~...... ~~~~ -f=~ Date Signed .:S\L.\\e~ Resident's Address and Unit: 2>L\~\~.~~~ ~\'d.. ~ ~ ~ ~~\~<:> RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (OIY''''' t)eJ. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 17MUr AJ J;-z.LI">> Signature ~~ Date Signed o/~3 Resident's Address and Unit: o~oo Hytf-IC- ~(...,r6 ])tt. .p:: ( 70$1' AV6v{-CAl,t( 1't- ~?/frJ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/YI/T) \:)ell. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name lie /"!WJ-1J C#-' y / S~ture i _ : ",>,;/j!:- h Date Signed .~~ Resident's Address and Unit: f'f.e/., ~ YA,.,-". T e ;//' / I 3JJ 7( N t (' AIS- ," tJ//~ j (/ 12 /,,+ :ZO~3 - If) - ., i J"../ -., .' .A, RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMM tyv. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Residen~ame J:)....l CU({C{f{.J Signature Date Signed -1} [::"' - , (Y/v] Resident's Address and Unit: I) Me TUfl eli'(,) 7../ {)( RECEIVED MAY 1 ? 2003 CITY CLERK 1{11,w (Jl/J./II/ ((vI) 17/1... (J,,(o/Jvntl {-(. )31.fv Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM/>'" be.;. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name A~7~e !If///j!;?:i f Signature j/dt;:iU:J }~0( Date Signed #/)3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~)'I;- t/ ~ t 'p~ / h' ;;J RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 0/'1"1 ~N To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name A-~"tH uf<... /{ LE / hAY rJ::!:~ Date Signed S-!O!a3 Resident's Address and Unit: RECEIVED MAY 1 7 2003 CITY CLERK / q 10 ( f\ Y\TfC F!P /JIL /7(( !\(Jr?ts\u(2A (L 33 I f-O Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C,fJI'1,v, ty>~. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~'I'\NM8 ::)A&ilnv /d&-~ rc" Date Signed s:~& j Resident's Address and Unit: " () V ()() W' ('~"nik(J./ A 5/! 1 A/Vu~~ _i~ 3 ~ )cfc) I RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~o,mt'1 ~II. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name fI G{lcJ~ a.. -10Z) Signature ~h II1L ,. . Date Signed 7fltr; [I l vO; Resident's Address and Unit: '3~3o ?/ttjdZ:;;en.J; ~'- ~Q{~. '331Yo I ~ &0:::' RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"""" be II. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. J,.";:;')Rf:V,~ ~ -- -<: Resident's Address and Unit: 3oo6is~ ~Lud ~2-L01.--- ~C4J1V4~ 331b () RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager [0/>1"" ~c,j. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .f~ . t; I~, ~ Ii. 1"t~v. ,- r~ M, L ])~"""D ;loAA.J Signature JJu;~b )( 4- Date Signed <t/ '1') cu Resident's Address and Unit: ;Lo I tL<) Lv. ~ CM,(fh -#> l/tJ J/.,_ RECEIVED MAY 1 2. 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co (Y\ IV1 t>f.;. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Ll/\-RD \ ~~,y~ Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: ~ LA11~Gl~. WJ#t Vi. 6~ I?J I ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"" ~o/. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name b,f(rf etrJJoRL4- Signature ~/C(!n~~ Date Signed S;0foJ Resident's Address and Unit: )(7)" NC.(I.. D,/L jJ}UcNh~ 11 Pt- ) LOOI/ 33(jtJ" RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/T1"1 ~(.;. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name - . -rV~lvs ;l,O€..f?/Ntf/ J..;~~e).Q/le- ~i:RI^,1i( SigAature \ ~ rt/(A \ ... ~ '~;JJvtu- ~ ---; Date Signed o.r/()~/03 , rJq O,fl 03 Resident's Address and Unit: .; &"00 ;.(~ 4?t-v.l). ~lkJlf q YeN i1/ ~q. Y!- . RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COI"'''' be J. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name t$o,,; E rs rEI".) Af(LE/'Jt;; EAn:>/l) Signature ~~~ ~J) t'" rJ1t5/"-- Date Signed 5~~ 5'"N~,~ Resident's Address and Unit: '2. PI If/ E C{)VNT'1:,'/(LVI 'pll. Ifl~~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (omm De c/o To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 1M ./(PfU1 AI Signature . {,/ /? ~/ / ./ >/>' ~ ~<~~:: .:l J. /' Date Signed /~ ~Yd3 Resident's Address and Unit: / C/o 0 ~/U />O~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,.yl/>'1 De"" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 6i~R4LI} SeHWtE//jER. Resident's Address and Unit: ..37 31dl etJtl.-A/1/?y d'1A a. JIT- .; (z.! !lYWJ7IRd-1i g3/cf tJ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co'""''''' bN' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name G:NZOJ :~ )L'1fUif ignature Date Signed ./' 1fE] -tiC/-OS , Resident's Address and Unit: !)fJ<; If (. tt9Uv)f~t {;J..t)JJ-.fl!L lJPr I ~ 'f~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/'ll/YI be'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(~Name ~ f'rM-i Vo Ld~ ff ~at~ ( -~\4 Date Signed S' 0 -03 Resident's Address and Unit: Jc,,7S- J).d/J(v!C{u~ .P~ 4 -1000 EN iW Tu rue-- _ rr=C ~ ~ ( if'D , RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: ComnnSSlOners City Manager COM"'" t:,ev' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~ Signature Date Signed 41/-~YL-)~ IJoL'l-Jt::lo:- ~/o J I Resident's Address and Unit: I~~ 'PJ&' ~/ ~t- ~ :;e. iFfOG RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COfYIJ\'\. ~e';' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name R11l'J i J /1 / tC- (/1 ,I. .' Vv ".- _,.^ ~'-/ Sig~!,ure /!w '1tt~~.~ , , "'" Resident's Address and Unit: / q! gl Nt j1q- ;I J 7/iJ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK .r9'YzP/?,6~ -l/ 33/60 I Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COf>1t>1 ~e';' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ri\ AAll~kl'\ IbB d, 6-It Signature ~~~~ Date Signed cjl/lo 3 Resident's Address and Unit: , UAJ ~r t' 01 RECEIVED MAY 1 ? 2003 CITY CLERK ~oloo w. @t9CPIVT~'1 ~ L- DR Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C' O/l'1'" t:y 11' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. i;;:;Na;'h$~ ~ Date Signed 5/jL~3 Resident's Address and Unit: :;2.f)/Pf) IV. ept/AJ~ tLvBik /6cb Ill/kAJ&~"'J '7-L~ 331/',;) RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (0"''''' I:)eol. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /)<cI,e<<II/</) F. Ut..155 Signature ;;1 f!~1.V~1 Date Signed ~ 1/., 2Joc0 Resident's Address and Unit: 3C~~?~~~. ~I ~2. 33/?,o 11103 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager LO"'''' \:::.u, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~npture Jtl ~. ,fi'''l'~L,t;/ fJ J . ,,),l {.{ (A'J ' 7:ll(/~ 7'.It) (, I2uu.i.<J It t'oj~c Resident's Address and Unit: Date Signed r. 1/- 03 - .-,,- 5=J/-tJ3 /' A :i;.ui' .. ' // ' ". " /' .,',t, ~. -. "./ ", ~ ~ / fI/~' UtL.llj /~Cll 11;1) " ! ! ' .,,!-/o ~ '" / / /-'./6 Il' RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/J"l;Y/ be v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed \Y\U~9\ ~-\:-ro\l ~~ lI~~,?5C--- \ . ')\ ~ \\)) ''-"' Resident's Address and Unit: \<Cl~)(:) 00_ 3;.~\\~~ ft-3(a/ . f'-sc \<!\,\~ \--q \=~~ L . 3J I\..o ) RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: Comnu.SSlOners City Manager Coml>1 ~(v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~es~dent(s),f~am, e r jl)liW ,- i''tfIM rt! , iJJ l1;,f,ur / I , ,gnature." " ~ , ,-.-e-r!~ D1~'d" Resident's Address and Unit: ~, A .~' ~i.(J:)~)~~ '-fP, , ,.,1 ____ ~~~ ~v~ ~_ ),..j/l~ I RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO'l-lM De,;. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date igned Resident's Address and Unit: ),boo ;;;1~'Cc( -'lue) if- I!D;r- nW.f\{--ur<<, fLf1 33 (to 0 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventora 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO//1/VO ~e"". To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature E 7) I r H I?J 4-(2,;v ~~ 6 Ck-,--,---- S-"'ArFOf.P'i', i?t\8or1 ~/Y~JJ~ L' Date Signed {/~~3 , S/ffo '3 l ~ Resident's Address and Unit: --- ! :?- (3.) '30075 <; !--1A1/f ~ /vd At ~ . A(/q1f(/~ ,F! 33/Gtf , RECEIVED MAY 1 ? 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COI11"" (:)<'01' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~~ ~~n~ture~, Date Signed ~ ~~-dk ~/y~3 Resident's Address and Unit: ;Ze;?0iV~~~ -r II /? ~'J!f3.3/c?~ RECEIVED MAY 1 'J 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co.", (Yt t)N' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature 2:tJ2/ n /1 1:./.1. Z//V (/sly :li:ruat~ Date Signed ~/6/03 , I Resident's Address and Unit: 3::0& 7l7e;s;,J.re /JOI/l./ /f03 ilve/7/u-Izo..,:Ff2. 33/.9-0 I RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co(llfl'l ~v" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .q€/foffJ z:. lowf.f\I Date Signed c ~ .{- 1- 03 Resident's Address and Unit: 3.[{r /illiG UtAH C..e~ €. :(1/ }.of t4vW7'V~/t" PI... 33 { fa RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: CommtSS10ners City Manager Co t"" (:)e'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name HVI((lI\.'1 1{0).,1I/"" Signature ~~ Date Signed ~ll;'~ Resident's Address and Unit: IDb"';~-'IIIJ~'1Jl~ Wtf1 (No(1H1/J"'E~ IJf<r16 fI RECEIVED MAV 1 'l 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO""" tell. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~V~ ~b-s\~ Signature ~ 1/ t0lz:.- Date Signed '1-f- Mrt'i 03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~ 5 ')1) t1'-\S1lt POtN1C ])f!- ::It nil RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (0"'''' ty./. dY To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~ Date Signed 5114/a3 ;;//4jZJ3 , 3~ ~eR... 1-11 LbfJ :!::ooEJ2_ Resident's Address and Unit: ;JbOO ISLfll.JD 6/...UD j.EQZ- AUf/lhl4.- -P/. 33/60 . RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (OM (y.".IS) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. sident(s) Name :/~ I ( hi {0fJ Date Signed ~ 7-ZL3 Resident's Address and Unit: jg([;(/g 3/g CJ /576 f}J.u~/ ~. g;;3/6o RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"""" ~oI' ;ffj) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU~1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature tf/14tJf'L SiLUERsrr: //V ~ ~ Date Sign ell ~ 13A3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3~~~ ~ 1([66 -- 33/U J RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK .~---------rr Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (!<Yl,M ty V' ji) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~A( f,\)~J~~J Date Signed ~/; j/o 3 Resident's Address and Unit: :33M~AJ) ~ PJLgB WM~ jJ, ~ RECEiVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C eM /'>1 ty ./. dii2 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name " ),14'I <'- ~.><......; -'.,... . ~..-~"-~ , Signature Date Signed i I ,.' ' , .... J )...--' -,-4. . 1,~ 1:-,f",..",,_.....,.u..' <.... 0,~,,!&:.~. " ,y 'r '-;-.:;::r-' ~.' ""- _ 2!: ~_~-r-" .~ -> ~ I Resident's Address and Unit: l:r re'j l ~ ! , I ,,; 7 . , 1-.. 1.. ~ ;' ! RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK , v Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO N>1 [::,..0 v" ((fi? To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. _ Reside.nt~~Name r~\tv'LLh)~>~l\lC! ) ~ ,A \ ,~~ature . " -.I' h (" J ~,r.~') i ,) Date Signed S.~,6') Resident's Address and Unit: If Ii (fJ} f ~, ,'jl / , I ,,/ ,", .' r ~ ..) r) I V ... '~'----I,: - t~, (j~ r) '" <- I '"c.. ' _o?-- 'v RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK _._-~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager to/""" t::,(J~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed /ht/?I{jfh B ~ );IIY!;~ ~-?- -/ D- /3-03 v:vftfve~jbIlYS~~ fi- 11- 0 ~ Resident's Address and Unit: /0 OD, ~ 1d.Lu..d, S-/J ;? RECEIVED MA~ 16 2003 CITY CLERK 05/14/03 11:21 FAX 52511188 ~02 --~_...--' ..'."- Mail To: The Cit)' eo..1ulou of Aveatura 1920D Wed Coati')' Club Drive Ave.tara. FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Ceil'!'" (y.l' ~ TOJ Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow CommilllioDer Barry Bobbe.... Seal I ComminioDer MaDay Gross.a., Seat 2 CommissloDer Bob DiIlmODd, Seat 3 CommwloDer Jay R. Bald.. Seat 4 CommluluD'" Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 CommwioDer KeD CobeD, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow.ad ComPdssloaers 01 the City of AveDl1lra: As. resideDt of AveDtara, I' amltroagl)r opposed to die establisbmeDt of a 'YDagoilDe ID tbe raideadal a,uildiae. 2tiOO Island Boulevard. UDft CU-l alld ur!:e you to vote...iai the eo.dido.al use application that will make this 11ft pouible. Thank you. ResideatC.) Name ?? ' ~ ,/ <_:':;::;/I~O/t(D/'( ~?2f"I"-/VL A,;c/o--, ~S?r?~fte.. v-l~4( ~~,'!!.:!;.-_.z;() Date Sigaed 0> ~ c.z /y- Z<?cd ResideDt's Acldr.. aad U.itl .-26tJC).26.hn/GIe/,41.1'''~ ;/V~ C:~ r -;f ,,2'9(5 y RECEl'IED Mtl.'i \ b 1\\\\3 C\T{ CLE.R\( Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager 00,,",1'11 t':,;. J. cfi) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S r t .. , ~'Vl ~tJ Signature lJ.(~?-, D~' '. Date Sig,ned ~\1}' / -, ,?) ,..l, / /"- ) Resident's Address and Unit: ~6lJ-l) ~,5 () y- RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.()..V\",~oI~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin. Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Jft l/') .', , .1( Lit! .if l/t At it; /" " , f Date Signed ~.l / LJ 9, 83 Resident's Address and Unit: , ! ! '1-,1 .~/ "" ./ l.-( ~C1 Ii t1:'l . ~ C""___ 'If, ~/ RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK OR. EDWIN P. FARBER Rabbi DR. MAX A. LIPSCHITZ Rabbi Emeritus YEHUDA ROTrNER Hazzan JOEL BERGER executive Director FRAN MISHLER Education Director ANNE MANDELBAUM ECEDirector MARK P. SYKES Program Direclol" REV, MARK GODOFRIEND Ritual Director LAURIE FARBER MICHELLE KONIGSBURG Day School Principals DR. RICK MARS President BRUCE MASIA Executive Vice-President RICK GOLDEN Vice-President At Large SID KOSLOVSKV Vice-President At Large MARLINE LEW Education VICe-President ALAN WOLFSON Financial Vice-President CARLA SPECTOR House Vice-President ROGER PANITCH Membership Vice-President WAYNE KEIL Ritual Vice-President ED MARGOliS Ways & Means Vice-President MARCIA ORVIETO Youth Vice-President DR. STEVE SHEiNMAN Treasurer DENISE TAMIR Recording Secretary JUDITH LIEBER Corresponding Secretary MARYUN HOLZBERG BETTE JOY FIELD Sisterhood Presidium BILL KING Men's Club President SHARON CURTIS PTA President RAQUEL SCHECK Immediate Past President ft"2 IIIlIIIICllllhIl.llld BETH TORAH ADATH VESHURUN BE N NY R 0 K CAMP U S 1n'~') n"T)J "'U'l n':1 203I5ON.E. 26 Avenue. Nol1h MIamI Beach, FL331llO-l136 (306) 932.f1TA V . Fox: (306) 933-6955 . _.BrAY.ORG May 21, 2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager I!f) The Honorable Jeffrey M. Perlow City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: As a Rabbi for over 43 years in the Northeast Dade community, it gave me a great deal of satisfaction to learn that the present Williams Island Synagogue has outgrown its cramped quarters and is presently planning to build a new synagogue in a commercial space in one of Williams Island's residential towers. The new facility will be tDtally separate and distanced from the building's residents. It will serve primarily observant Jewish residents who cannot ride to the synagogue on the Sabbath. The synagogue is a very positive and significant addition in our area. One of the bulwarks of our great democratic system is the freedom for people of all faiths to worship and practice their religion. As the Rabbi Emeritus of Beth Torah Adath Yeshurun, I believe that the proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue will be of great benefit to our entire community and I hope that you give it your full blessing and approval. ;reh':""; 12,~1y Dr. Max A. Lipschitz Rabbi MAL/mf Cff9 7000 Island Blvd,. Unit 2002 Aventura, FL 33160 May 11, 2003 Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FI 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: I am a registered voter in the City of Aventura and a resident of Williams Island. I would like to voice my strong opposition to the establishment of a synagogue in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. This is a residential area, and I believe that a religious organization of any faith or denomination does not belong in this location. We would have seriously reconsidered our decision to purchase here had we known that these plans exi sted. I oppose the establishment of the synagogue for the reason that our private residential area should not be used for any non-residential purpose which is not owned and operated by the Property Owners of Williams Island, It is for this reason that the Property Owners are currently attempting to negotiate the purchase of the Williams Island Clubs from the developers, Allowing another use which is not controlled by the residents would be counter-productive to these efforts. The security and peaceful co-habitation of the residents is my primary concern, I had planned to attend the May 6, 2003 meeting to address this issue and will make every effort to attend the rescheduled meeting on June 3, 2003, I appreciate your consideration of my views when voting on the matter. Sincerely, f1~ ;7, ~~ Jo-An B. Evans Cc: Zev Auerbach, Commissioner Jay Beskin, Commissioner Ken Cohen, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Commissioner Manny Grossman, Commissionl1r Harry Holzberg, Commissioner Erick M, Soroka, City Manager Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: COroroissioners City Manager QoI'1M tyJ 19 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name iZ-l;G.-l1U~tl-:' Signature OZ I 'If} (.J L L / ')9,']/ Date Signed r)]/o< , Resident's Address and Unit: J lOp IV E ? 5? ~~"-( ~./~ itA/!.d J J:;-{ :5 7,.1 Z () ~ I RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO.'l1m bo' @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name i1~ dc4t/j, ,/' r;;~ Date Signed 57 i/03 / Resident's Address and Unit: af () 50 ffi AJ rli/k:C 3tJo :3 ~~ fi 33/f(; RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co 1'1 "" .D{' J' f1iJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner .Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R..;dent{,} Nam~ fft;;ft!) .f . -Zl~ ~ Date Signed 0-f-~3 Resident's Address and Unit: RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (jJ t>t /11 ~ ~. {ji) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat I Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name j'i1J1~ .s:Pf/~ Signature Date Signed ~M/~ftH 5~~-7~ Resident's Address and Unit: .J'!/d ~.k/lL,6Jf;~ flt/ ~, .Q,t .1/ .JB~--j/~~ ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co.'I1'" ~(.r. (jf) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name . ./,' l'\t\(o(" ~ P dTl I (1 Signature ...Jjpd7~M_;l 'f'~ Date Signed 7. :J- 0 '?:. Resident's Address and Unit: L!J ~ S-I ,,;, f 31 c..o<iJ~ ,",p h67 ();Vi-,iIT uRet f L I 2,~1 r; CJ RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"" ~J tfftJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed silo] U-(j~1f ~(I(~ Resident's Address and Unit: j{).).l1/c (<tJ &v.D ..21 It~ P.C .J] '4> 0 I RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoMNl ty. J. @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature G'6-;J~GE a: B/~oClk g {4J-i2~!)2. Date Signed ~ 'IV Resident's Address and Unit: 2-g()O T5~ 6LVP 7>ifl/- .A 1/5Ntv!l.f'rr ?L 33/6tJ RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK "tail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 0,'>11>> f:yJ tf9 lu: 'Vlayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat I Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 ('om missioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 (om missioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Cum missioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Vlavor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a ',\ lI<lgoguc in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I alld urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible, Thank you, Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed 1fJt6fl<./...\ G,if,Tt'lBnNlO ~~~S:s~ .s- -I D '~;;:()o ~ Rl',iden{'s Address and Unit: :$ S -1{,\ 01<<;f,L.L.t\ L- U- t-f{3 f'\l)~}J L () rs<--^ f L- 3 '3U?o / RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,,,,,,,,, \Y oJ' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ....ldent(.) Name , Za~nre _,_ ;j/~.s/n J. S~c/~~" . ~.~ "<-- Date Signed J-- /d.-~:J Resident's Address and Unit: lo~o 'v:~ &,..,,:.. ~ /S'/O (J.- 1~.....7~~ eX. 33/?C.' I RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager CQIVt/Vl Dev. r1f9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 6 ttI '1,5 fl.e PllJMft)1 .sAtJvwtCU1. ~ ~ !UJ~ G/uw;CVYL Date Signed 5~/o~ ~/Jft;tJ3 Resident's Address and Unit: l.~tJO t, i41cud ~ J JI. Aft JL/.t} 1/ tWP~(), (I ?;3/~t/ RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoI\1/Y1 iY../o r!fi) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name AN" R1iC/lL/ f.J Signature t2aJ~ Date Signed ~//L- / z;3 Resident's Address and Unit: 7~ ~~. 3cY{; ~!~. 13(0-6 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoM'" bu' @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S'l). R C1.C.tl:LI If . Signature ~\)...LL Date Signed S;//'Z-/o_3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3~ ~. &vJ. ISr:36 ~ ~. 3j!~<O ( RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK --..-----r-~-.-~--~.,-.--.-- Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager [01>1/>1 De'" (ff9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name (Joi7N '13\00 ks Signature O~~ Date Signed s:- 9-03 Resident's Address and Unit: 2<iSOO IsLJ'tJVp ]?Li/j) 1ft If !tVE[Il tuMtr it- 3:7/60 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ['o/>"M ~V' C1fi!;- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. f Date Signed :7 JJ D J[)3 / Resident(s) Name GA~/ LT LJ).r;r(~rtI?I! Resident's Address and Unit: 37LJSNe 206 #feltl~{t ~fwM P15Jlft) ..J RECEIVED MAV 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co',,,,/>'} [y4/" ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~~~ ~6) Signature ~.~~ct)?~~ Date Signed .~ / I 7.. lr:DO 3 I I .. , Resident's Address and Unit: ~bOD 'J-S~ltl.)~ 6\'Ij~ "L3>oS- Q.V~\0{l~ "33/Gu RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/1'JM ~ell'@ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ,f-/f;'vDClf{i RU}}'lJI1",(I(V Signature Vkk~ Date Signed :'-/~!o3 Resident's Address and Unit: ; '" 17 0 5 Si,J. ",} f:, t V D :3 DO 'Y Auf (171 v f</). r~ / JJ t/"V RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . Cc: COm.mlSSlOnerS City Manager ~ Co""''''' tycl. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name e.eitlte0 tollf)tg4 '-- Signature (~----r&~ Date Signed "S"'-/ () -0:3 Resident's Address and Unit: &ellrt0 dJ e/Jo-!5 A /006 AIr'd.-3/3- RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager CI{)IJ1/k !Y II' @ Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name -JoYCE bAle- I IiftL 2ELl1fi/ Resident's Address and Unit: :1DDO \~6hj 3000 [) ~h!lJvl ftJ& ftJ0 Date Signed .s:- /0 - tJ 3 ,{)'--:-/ t? -,:j 3 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager C,o /" ,... \:)f II. rf:f!) Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~bd l~c~I<'"'1 k'QY"c...... t\<<../~r- Resident's Address and Unit: I ceo '...:..>I<<-.-.&. l>lu,t . 0, t..LI~.r LI~J. Signature Date Signed ;-.-~.,:i:~_/ ~~~'l S-/~- 02> ~D'l k.33/(,'2> RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 :c: Commissioners City Manager (flA1"" fJe v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~C6J) ~ Da~ r~1~ 3 Resident's Address and Unit: Z04.oo l".) .( ~ q. oe. U ~ cOt \ A~c.. <;: \ '33 ~~ RECEIVED MAY 1 It 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"",""" De oj- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. 11 Signature , I ~i Date Signed 50 q" 0 ~ Resident's Address and Unit: /Ju w JU/du Fw dZ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 200J CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co.".,'" (Y '" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ih? 15 /:>. SI/ '71' I V Signature Date Signed .sk!o3 dJn, ~.//#I, Resident's Address and Unit: 3 qoo ~f)o-Ig..1 hVr( "<03 RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/>1-"1 6e..... To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~VOiO Lt"49;'O G'l OlhVIJA- L.eqCj) D Date Signed f1I1.f4t (0 . l()~a c.m c:u; /0. ~!/.3 Resident's Address and Unit: c9~oo Island /3(t/j :ft:J9tJ:J ;/ ~16Q).,. H... 3!3J6iJ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~A1 tyv' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name f11Z:TH1! IL ft]i:IrA--rz. S.lglat.u.;} -../ /" / '/ / ') ;;;t..~+ / f( . '/; ( ..- '--------- Date Signed I / <7/ ~/Pi(jj , I \ Resident's Address and Unit: ?fI LV f~o 7]/.-Vt) ;31<><1 RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/>! m t:>e v' To: Mayor Jerrrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Q-1tlll-f'II+ 1\, Vc(,t: L Signature , ,7 ,/ /21 tI / / Resident's Address and Unit: :L-} 1\ 0 rDr~1 ~lAQ! f~bJ- ~\l 01" 'Tl! (L A fL ~~( ~o RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CD/HA, f:::t lP To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Y1~ DO";' Resident's Address and Unit: 31" ,-~.If;u ~I RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CD/l'l/>1 ~t'v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. :;':CorH- Date Signed 5/7/o~ , / Resident's Address and Unit: 3 ?oo ]:Stand f3/(~ ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK .vtail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM/J1 {)e.t. I,,: 'Vtayur Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 C"mmissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 C"mmissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Cum missioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Cummissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Lka r Vlayur Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \s a resident of Aventura, 1 am strongly opposed to the establishment of a "nagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-t and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will ma ke th is use possible. Thank )'011. I{esident(s) Name ;'~,n J;'l....!, /' Si~ture A--b~j Date Signed s - '1 -QJ Resident's Address and Unit: o hi Ij/~ Jh-<J/JI u_~'- ;: L S':J) Ii () ~;;(i/ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK \lail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/l111r ~.), 10: Ylayur Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Vlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \, a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a ,\ nagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l :lnd urgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will Imt kl' th is use possible. Thank you, Resitlent(s) Name (3 Ur IV! p: UI;Jt;V Signa tu re ;J~Ufl_/ . Date Signed / 5=9 -cJ3 Rl'sident's Address and Unit: ;\Rdj If~ 1\ I Sl---~/;IS~ /) (J ~/1/ ru 12.,P- --. ..- "33/&() RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK 'Ylail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COIl1I/1 De J, I (): 'Vlayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 (om missioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Ih-ar Y1avor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: .\s a rcsident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a "lIagoguc in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit ClJ-l alld urgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will makc this use possible. I'hank vou, Rcsidcllt(s) Name Signature 1;((10,,/ Met: /t,Ir'h4 >>eh. l~/2t'7 Date Signed s: 9~o 3 H,l'sidclI1's Address and Unit: ..:< 'tSI /11 c;: (f-?,<<, j ~ :t/{)O ( ~ 1/ ('pi f- c/ L/}- 33/6 d RECEIVED MAY j II 200J CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",,,, De.> .vlail 10: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 10: Vlayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 (ommissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 DearVlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a '.\ lIagoglle in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit Cl!-l a lid II rgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank VOIl, Residenl(s) Name C Jell r~e-J0 r1fddot SfoA1h J Resident's Address and Unit: J.tOf N ~ Ig3~t- !/larJu,1) (t, i1/ bO / (9/S RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission or Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l,AJ ~eil' To: Mayor Jerfrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name rl;f~ SW;Vf., lU Signature ~~ rJw~ Date Signed S'" I r ~cf} '3 Resident's Address and Unit: 4f:- ,~OOD '~L- M IH,v 1> ), ~() ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 Z003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COI"l.A'l be v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners orthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name. Date Signed 3/;11t)~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~~ ~~~ ~ 11 r2) ()!l RECEIVED MllV 1 4 2003 CITY CLER~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~IVINJ ~e'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners orthe City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R,,;d.n~,)N'm. q~ );wfarl/Y LJ!~JW Date Signed t1S'"~f /tJ-.:5 Resident's Address and Unit: 2- 02 ?/E t&C/4!l/pJ ,IVff~/2 5"J'/5b RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . Cc: ComnuSslOnerS City Manager v 1"'1 IV' t::.e 0/' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~RLEJ-.J ~ Y~NA ~v~~ Date Signed ~ Resident's Address and Unit: o<lm l~~BwL ~~ fl- .53rCiS hOr RECEIVED MtoV 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM/01 De". To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Na~e ~tM . I' .t\\E''''' G\e\(~:~~ ~ Date Signed 5/r/o3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~o(rS-f,GLl,,~Ql<-bD- #l7o~ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Cor>1M IY.;, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name '\ Co k ~ t ~ 1='h.-n Of) Signature QLtf-UJ~ Date Signed 'S;'-l-03 Resident's Address and Unit: .l~oo hAQ[ld, ~eud If! 00 ';() RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/>1.A't \;yJ, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-! and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .J.,.<l(.>'\ G:' ross Signature ~ .i'~- (/ / Date Signed ~~ ~q7t<?3 Resident's Address and Unit: 38"01 N-t? aO,!-.##-2h/ {l~:~, .':33/,p~ RECEIVED MAV 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager (:0/1'1'" bev. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners orthe City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name '~'^ \J F'-e;\~ Date Signed -A, !a J Resident's Address and Unit: 1m J;;~1LVd). #-c2YOt ,. Av€.-iA~y~...) n. ]J/~ (]' RECEIVED MAY 1 4 Z003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co""'''' \:y J' (f;) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed 5/5/03 , MfJ DD-IVE- dR.N_ L (!fJ .Lc p.. tJ $'- s-:- 7?3 Resident's Address and Unit: /pqO C.f5(AJ.JJ/ J2L-I/)) d"Z3VZ A/cJJTiJ ~It J rc. 'G3/&-V RECEIVED M6Y 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager lO"1At ~.I' @J To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name !th~tLUjl-c,eva- HOc I{ Mc-... Sign~ (J(!. Date Signed OS~,/2.0z, Resident's Address and Unit: Wc'{l1tc;e.Vo... f1 fn-/)1o., 260() [s e~d Bevc{ t'r220( AVeM1--uTR fe 6S/0 0 ! / RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West CouDtry Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co""M De.! 'lfP To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name g er-Lo IIi c.h C eT /1NA Yf Signature ~//L Date Signed tJs". /2, O~ Resident's Address and Unit: LW&() /5 tClMcI ri({lo( in- 22 Or )VUA {r-tft2- Fe ~516 0 , . I I RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (01\01"" De,!, r1f9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Re "dent(s) Name ~ o..~ \. ~) It {' ev'"' Resident's Address and Unit: '::2&,66 TS{~ 610-cQ!f/ a (} ( 4-u~~/ 33tC,o , RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COrvl/VI t>t.' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~~~lel 1) \S bU~ I (~ RECEIVED MAY 15 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l<.I'" \)(lI. ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Re ident(s) Name ~ f/vh..< V !JOD'''''' Am?/J{ ---- Date Signed 5/ /1/)3 Resident's Address and Unit: 8LtO --:( lw..d e; v~ j/tA~ rU ~]/L-CJ J1!Y RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK M8~ 13 03 05:23p Ch....~1 I. n"v..'s (973) 99'1-1656 p.2 Mall To: Tile City COIIIlDiaioa of AveDtuI'a 19200 W.tCo..try Clab Dm. Aventvra, 'L ]3180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COf"lVl Jy.J' Ci2 To: Mayor Jeffny M. Perl_ Co._iNtoner Ilarl'1 Rolzbe.... Seat 1 Comminioner MaDay GI'OSIaI.D, Seat 2 Commi18ioner Boll Diamond. Selt ,] Commiasiuner Jay R. Betllin, Seat 4 Commi..ioner lev Auerbacb, Seat 5 ConuDiQloner Ken Cohen, Seat IS Dear Mayur Perlow aDd Commiujoaen 01 tile City or Ave.tura: A, · tClfideat 01 Aventurl,llm strOllCr)' opposed to t.. establillla.'llt or. synlCOlue in t., residtQtill building, 2600 hlllld Boalevud. Uait CU-I lad urge you to vote ...in" the condldonal UIe application that will make thil use possible. Tha'lk you. Resident(s) Name _CJk~"K, pt1v-J(.s [O....%to {J".,.c, SiC.atun ~IQ - Date Sit_eel {t/o) (), '/03 Resident's Address a.d Unit: U,oo I.5 U/...i II g LV O. 11= l.fol...:.........AVJ,.,n/,\,A. R. RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CotW" tlo. @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners orthe City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name i28r'~ov{ch y (2e< J /111 ( r- Signature Mj~L ~ Date Signed O>-:'L,O]. Resident's Address and Unit: 2600 Is~ rtevJ. AvehlunA fc ~;160 , 'Pr 2..2 0 ( I RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.o I'I! fV1 tie v. (jY To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed, to the establishment ora ~ synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed S ) rod ~Oo3 IY\nNhi, ~. 01 ~liY'fJ \'(lox n i S Or\(We Resident's Address and Unit: 2~oo "Ys;la\A.& pI vcR ' _~H~ RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK O~) tL ~?:Jj(PD . J Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager eOA1M bt,).~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Selllt 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners <:lfthe City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly OP!)fllled to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential' building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-! and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~f. UlfL6JE ;1t(j~ f)RLDVE Signature ~ Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: ~8fJ ~a-ndgjo~ ~q ;)!f 3:3/60 I f?1I~ RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2DD3 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . Cc: COmnnSSlOners City Manager V""Nl fy/' (!Y To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name -< e;!cj$u ~ /' Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: #(!!!!r- ~//~ RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager l'o"'''' ty". ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners orthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name _~Sjgnatll_~~____ Date Signed ---~----.... II I C --- oJ~ '~~ I' . 0 (fJ (' . - ............ . ! ((;) 0' ~ -' 0 fJ-~~ i ~( Resident's Address and Unit: //;,/j/ /vE 1/ ((, I{/t -Au f '1 I/Wr OJ. :s 3 ({ {/.' RECEIVED MAY 1 ~ 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . , CC: ComnusslOnerS City Manager CoIl1M ~~. (1f& To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit cU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed aa/'~/7--/L J/~k/ S- /13/03 v / I ~\.'. \ ~ f'> ~ ~ "- \c\ ..s- /13 //)3 't- I I Resident's Address and Unit: ,,~CoDV tf~ + C-lu.-k Df SfJh A-D.L~l..(..(('Gl.. ) "f \ '33 I ~ 0 RECEIVED MAY 1 ~ 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM", l)ev ~ To: Mayor Jerrrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed J#~~ ds/os . / . -0S/0;> ~e.(l\t4 ~5k4T 11 ch {fa m ~JKM Resident's Address and Unit: !/coo 5s'IAIJ~ {JIve? jI../>03 RECEIVED MAY 1 ~ 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,,"'" 1:Yv> ;j;) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~{[(Ja;rA /!((~{') frw(?J~ J!~ Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: }C701) 55~/I14/vc/ ClI/,tf/>>~ fjV'l'l"Jfafvt . PI ".?"J!6tJ Y I RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,,.,,,, 6e... I!J Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Ozwv ~~ HAvi/t ?ellE-iM Resident's Address and Unit: .30'(0 N2 ('iOsr .tr3/~ Av?JiV/l.I<'r ~ h-. &3/fO Date Signed 5;1Q/o :3 OS' jJ't /0.:3 , RECEIVED MAY 28 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",,,,, tyJ; if} To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Ala<<t?i Kd-d W~' Signature Jlf Date Signed /1(67,/ /q/ axz3 'J Resident's Address and Unit: 201PJ~ t. Ceunfry eta/; ~ve ~JPL. " RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/Vl/VI ty~. (PP- To: Mayor Jerrrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name f~A^,~ J, j)&M, Ct:-O ~~AI~~ 0, kl1lr.c.o Date Signed S/;.,7/'-00) S/z.-1 /2(0) Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 (, ISLI/;J] bLIJ1J '*-3/0l A Vfkf1l'l~ 0L- 331 bO RECEIVED MhV 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager [om"'l tyv'JjJ) To: Mayor .Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner .Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. - sl<.-3/0> Date Signed ~/:r~ / 0 '3 s-j"l'J /03 . . .s-!?.'l, /03 I!rtI?OL.t) 'BEI,f('I,/ Resident(s) Name , ( lite-xI> 'be'f?RI71 f'na-.{.l\t\,-ew b-ey-yctt Resident's Address and Unit: .-' - .~0 DO-;S {jrND /3L-VD~ <f()5 Rft.1/lv/<.A rL 33/60 , RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co .7lm be,/' 4Jj) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. __J:h;tv-\Ie.y ~re,:>ct <Po Ila" \(IJ Uti Ie Date Signed 5hLf~;' ~/J'I!o 7, Resident(s) Name Resident's Address and Unit: ;)~ fro .uJw.J g~ ().:Xl-! A-,~ 331&0 RECEIVED MAY,) R 2003 CITY CLERK Ma~ 17 03 05.44p NOl"man Nel"O 808-788-8662 1".1 M.iI To: Tile City COIDIIl"'oa of Aveatara J9Z00 W.. Co..try Clab DriYe Ayeata.... n 33180 ~c: Commissioners City Manager Co-?t-"'1 ~l''''. I)) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. P~rIow CODllhbsiODel' a.rry Holzbel'K. Se.t J COlhmiAioner 1\&..y CrclII8..an. Seat 2 COmmiqklaer Bob Dia.oad., Seat .3 Comllli_Der Jay R. Beside, Seat 4 CO....YsJoaer Zey Auerbach, Seat S COIII_i&sioDer ICe. Collea. Seat Ii Dear Mayor Perlow 8Ild Co....iaioners of rlAe City or AlI..ta...: As a resident of Aveahl..., I am StroD," oPPOSed to tile establish..eat of a SYUCogue ia the resid~.tUi' bllild'... 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and arce you to 'VOte aEaiDst tile conditio.al use appliQtioA dud wUI llIao tbla .se possible. nank you. Reside.t(l) Naill. /' V)/.' /!f If "'/ /J:-f ,} /y~/,d~- /i1,,:rC/) ----. Si2nata. 4/. .--.'---' ( -- '" ...... '. ..- / .1,,"', . ..'\........ . , )_.... ""'",-'Z_ -:.J-/~7'- U Date Siened ,~/I -' If> ::- / . .f . '---I ,IJ2 , , Resident'l Address and U.'t: . /C' 0.... f .:...''.),,:):) -:L~(_,/'tl / (;"'1_ /--y' f.'~ """".- --, .. L:' () / RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CIlY CLERK vlail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C()II1~ ty~ (0: Vlayur Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 (om missioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Cum missioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 ('ommissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Vlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \s a residcnt of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a S\ nagogllc in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank vou, Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed -*F. 9-~c.\\\'.~ CoS\A~~O ~-~t~-fr I<,eslden!'s Address and Unit: 3qoo J:S\J'.t->~ ~\....\l~~ B-.:.10~ 1v)\.\L~N -Cs~~\) RECEIVED M~Y ? 8 2003 CITY CLERK 'Ylail 1'0: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager {'o"","'" ~llf. @ I 0: Vla~or Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 (0/11 missioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Vla~or Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a s\ nagoguc in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will lllakl' this use possible. Thank you, ReSlllent(s) Name Signature Date Signed /3E~tLV Co r;71h1/2Q 1?.tuJ1~ rhIa~ 5// SlrJ3 ReSIlient's Address and Unit: 3 q 00 r I L.tHAJ I[) P,U/D, <-f<; 'J. 0 g ()J1LL1A-.M ( r ~ Ckv(jiJ RECEIVED MAY? 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COt>1"" ~eo/' c&- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~'^\-) K.,u,^^ h'c7 Signature Date Signed j/~/c--:7 b-b-O~ ./ Resident's Address and Unit: 39DO I-::.b""c\ \5\vd . B-3o~ AppL-..iv..~ RECEIVED Fl '331bD M6Y ? B 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: COmmiSSioners City Manager I!-OM"" tyv(tfJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name / 7 Signature PY'< ~/VcC ~II-U/11 ffl,J_ /yt~h'"" (j,L/lf/IY?& / / . :I I -;>-:-:4:.u~/u"-Z., :!r'-!t,o':';171 ''''?-c...-/ Date Signed ~!~/v) :-Y/:Y/~ 3 . . Resident's Address and Unit: -5;cti /5'~~{ ~ , m~ '1--( 33/&.0 I RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: COmmissioners City Manager eo"",/}-'> IYv' & To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /' C"" I k:1Ja:/fi2,{) ~eH U /ll /f11./ Sig. n. aaare (/ ") ~JL Date Signed ,1JJo?,. Resident's Address and Unit: .3l1? ~W ;8~o I /", . {~'14f.k 3-3/&0 / RECEIVED MAV 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"" !)(,'/-rj;) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~:ure ;/ .'j"LiO/l{J J!R(Y-I,1~1- ~ ~ Date Signed ,r/;3/o 3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3;fClo 7S4~d!vj) ~lIjrJY~ Av/JL--Iv.-<t9, ft -j .:3/' G> RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission or Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: COmmissioners City Manager CO/Yl/l1 Dell'.& To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~dent(s) Name Z:~~ a5Y&1} ley Her,/ /I- Resident's Address and Unit: 67JIJ ~M.t CJ.jJ! RECEIVED MAY 2 R 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C IJ "1 /YI ty.;' tfifiJ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~t! 4~~,) Date Signed ~i~~~ Resident's Address and Unit: $1dJ ki~4J~', (J C/tJ I RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/>1/>1 fY ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name --; \,~, \ ('- ~c I :;r Si:J:: ~_~ / Date Signed G /'1/03 Resident's Address and Unit: '37 trV L;'\Anct lA,/II\~ 0~ So !;lvd l slC1Qo/ 16-307 33'(,.0 RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27,2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO,V1;Vl Dt'o/- (if) The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat I Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: I permanently reside in Aventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building, I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building, I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue, I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services, A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath, Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts, In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you, 1 RECEIVED MA~ 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK Robert I. Werner 12003 Misc\RIW Itr re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 111 THIRD AVE, SO, . MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55401 I Mailing Address: P,O, Box 581398, Minneapolis, MN 55458.1398 Telephone: 612-339.2651 FAX: 612-339.2761 cc: Commissioners City Manager (c"~''''' ty l/ . rfjJ May 21, 2003 City of Aventura City COIUlcil 19200 W, COWltry Club Road Aventura, Florida 33140 Dear COWlcil Members: I am writing to you to express my views regarding the granting of a building permit to remodel a portion of the building at 2600 Island Boulevard to house the Williams Island Synagogue, I strongly believe that the request for a building permit should be granted by the City COWlcil. My feelings are based on the following considerations: 1) The need and desirability of having a synagogue has been well established by the fact that for nearly 12 years a synagogue has existed on Williams Island. It has proven to be of great value not only to those who use the synagogue regularly, but also to residents who have special needs from time to time, 2) The synagogue has contributed greatly to provide spiritual and educational opportunities to many who reside on the Island. 3) Jews who are Sabbath observers who live on the Island, or come to visit, can observe the Sabbath without traveling from the Island by car_ 4) The synagogue and its Rabbi have created a sense of commWlity within the confines of the Island that is W1ique and special and, adds immeasurably to the quality oflife experienced for residents, guests, and employees of Williams Island, ~ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK *' Mail To: The City Commissioa of Avalora 19200 Westeo.nUy Club Drive A ventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO~I"'" ~e~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow commissiouer Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissiouer Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners oCtile City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishmeot of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the couditional use appJication that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~)/fn /., ;tI:7rll Signature ~~ Date Signe s-. J/,UJ2J,3 Resident's Address and Unit: ,300!5 JJkci AM cJ5t)3' RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK *' Mail To: The City Commission of Aventara 19200 West Country Club Drive AveDtura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,"'" [)e-- - @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Hofzberg, Seat 1 Commissioaer MaDDy Grossmaa, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioaer Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to tile establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 &land Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against tile conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .....Pv/( A1; -1C /PI. / Date Signed -?-ft5-b3 , I Resident's Address and Unit: :1 '(Yo 0 .. f2 Jlnz.-. d 1'lJ4 c15tJ3 RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK k Mail To: The City Commission of AveDtnra 19200 West Country Club Drive AveDtura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ~".'" C:t'v' If) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Coben, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against tbe conditional use application that will make this use possible. Tbank you. Resident(s) Name \ nd ^ ~\()LU-r\ , Signature l- fdJJ(J1) / ~ Date Signed 5-ao.-o~ Resident's Address and Unit: /Cf1?.& n E 3& PL, IWOlwrOt. F-L '33/CC-O . RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK r7. Irl1111 I /I/lTII/1 / I .JI' 10./ III' ... .#r:: Mail To: The City COIIlllkiuiuu of Ave.tun 19200 WestCo1l.try Club Drive Aveotura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,"''''' [yl'. @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 CommissionerMamay Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 comm.....ioner ZevAuerbaclt, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residentialbuiiding, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I aDd urge yon to vote agJIin~ the cooditionaJ use applieation that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ( ~/Au [, ~<RtI( t.</l2 -v;~ tNl1# ~h\ril1t) Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: ,}(,OO /~kA/D ~luJ7 J.dr RECEIVED MAY 2 9 Z003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co.'I1 il-1 Dev' Iff?- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City or Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature l~(u; cU(J II ,~ I~ r-: Date Signed ~ &l+i If O'lT/t Y to rMZ ~~m 1'3, BoR-GB Resident's Address and Unit: =!-(Ufto jhQliM~J~d J!:- ''5' 0 Co RECEIVED MAY 2 9 Z003 CITY CLERK --_..-.._---~--_..__._----_._-----_._--_._-- -- .,*, Mail To: The City CommissioD of AveDtura 19200 West Country Club Drive AveDtura, FL 33180 C .....missioners Cc: 01111"'< City Manager Co '^"" fyv' ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and CommissioDers of tile City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name GA~ \?....\a k \~~ t\-e () 0ea:; Signature Q~~~ Date Signed sf J-Y!h:? Resident's Address and Unit: s1Y0 W t7 ).DC} ~~ AU-e()\-u-(l~, ~L 33110 J RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK *' Mail To: Tie City Commission of Aventara 19200 West Conntry Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CC ,WYO f::p"^ . (fiJY To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner MaDDY Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventara: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date Signed Resident(s) Name ~.~ Resident's Address and Unit: <::}j ~ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK *' Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ('0 ~ M 6e..;tfP To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R~sident(s) Name . Signature.~ EJ~ ~f\J~~he ~ Date Signed ~/;u/o 3 Resident's Address and Unit: 1 qqL((C, f0~ 3G-h- fJL f\v~+O~ FrOl 331 JKJ ~. RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK May-22-03 07:22P Rae Swarte 305-936-9977 P.Ol Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,,,,,,,, ~v ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Scat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed *~s . O,i-/fU 1:>/ I'lt'C AS..sou.s Resident's Address and Unit: II. .; ".o~ Ms. Claudine Assous ~'.'. 0 ----- 0.. . 1000 Island Blvd" Apt 270 .' . ~~~'~~':L33] RECEIVED Mt..V 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (c","" -Dc..' '(jj? To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name IINCfrew E K a-J /012 / I'J-s/;I: / IV Date Signed ..:>-- ;2J-{)3 5-23-03 Resident's Address and Unit: c:2he6 IS/Me! g/oc/. .iI/;lOj /lvei1-hra H .}3/6 cJ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK 04/13/2003 22:21 3059328971 PAGE 01 -...........__.. t. Mail To: The City Comm'-ioa of Aventura 19100 West CODatry Club Drive AYentara, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ""/YO ()eo! @ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow COQUuissioaer Harry Holzbera, Seat 1 COlllmissioaer Manay Grouman, Seat 2 Commiasion.r Bob Diamond, Seat 3 ComminioDer Jay R. Bakia, Seat 4 Commi..ioner'Lev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken CobeD, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners olthe City of Annmr.: As . resident or Aveatura, I am Itroagly opposed to tlae establilbmeat or a .ynagogue in the mideatia. bllildillg, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against tbe conditio..' use appUcation tbat will make this use pouible. Thank you. Resident(l) Name Signature 1/tt~?/i44.4.~,. JI..,.~ ResideDt's Addr... aad Uait: }'c900 ~ ~ .:j'~~'€J,/ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 Z003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission or Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,...."" be,,' ~ To: Mayor Jerrrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ora synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. D Resident(s) Name 1:&'C'^W4u (..j,~ [JuXlr~ Gl ~~4~ ~ :2 Signature '?~~ ~- ~/C"--" L7 /:: 4P-L_ Date Signed 51Jd-;/63 I 1/ .ihiJ-- / 03 I I Resident's Address and Unit: 3gOO !lPJ [jtfll .!1uPhl fWJ a-, if 33/ to 0 ;2 ~ tS..s RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO."M t)"", 4P To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed j;ehtUt'~ &eS[ffL L/p~~ /7~ ?/2-! )0'3- (I I ' Resident's Address and Unit: ~ k L~i) tLt/t) ~ A-J-e IJ qo t<.A- RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK OSHER & ASSOCIATE Ma~ 22 03 07:44~ 312 238 8599 OS/22/03 09,29am P. 001 p.l' Ma~ 21 03 12:09~ Vuv~l D(tu~'" :1:131346 ,,-~ Mail Tn, Tile City ComllliasioB of Aveatara 19200 Wellt COURtry CI"b Drive AveD"'''''_ FLJJ180 c: Commissioners City Manager (;J I"',,"" lY v , &f) To; Mayor leffrey M. Perlow Commissioller Harry Holzberll, Seat I Communoaer MaAR' G",,"maD. Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat :J Commwioaer Jay R. Deskin, Sut of CommlssloDet ~ Auerhadl, Seat S COllun_inner Ken Coben, Scat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commiui~f$ of tile City of A"enhr..., As a rRident of Aventura, I a.. stroagJy opJlOAd to tbe ntllbllshllleJIt of. synagogue in rite tnideolial buildin&, 2600 Islud ,"1eY.rd. Ullit CU-t and urge you to vore apin5t tbe coaditiolla' use appljtalioa that Wll. make tllis use ~ible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name Rc1b....I'" tJrJ,o Signature Date Sigaed >~yb3 _.(5) -LJ {2..t: Resident'.. Address _ad Vait: r('r,;,.~"'/~ I (/1"1,1 Pd~ '.' ,/ dclJi[ It/, ('c,,,t,. f'I~tJ.'" , A I 'I J...!.'r ," rr"r OJ ,.. , ", w <- . . RECEIVED JUN - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mall 21 03 12:09p Vuval Dou.r 9331346 p.2 Mail To: n. City Commissioa of Aveutwra 19200 West Coo.try Club Drive Aveutara, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CohlM De ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow CommissfaDer Harry HoJzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Muay Gross....ll, Seat 2 CommlssiouerBob Diamoud, Seat 3 Commissioaer Jay R. BeskiD, Seat 4 Commissioner Zcv Averbacla, SeatS Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am. stroDgly opposed to tile establishmeDt of a syDagogue iu the resideatiaJ bniJdiag, 2600 IsIaad Boulevard. Uuit CU-l and urge you to vote against tile c8Dditional use apptieatiou tlaat will make this Dse possible. Thank you. ResideDt(s) Name 2oLcu/a \d~\ \~ . I Date Signed S)~{)3 Resident's Address aad U.it: ~~qo ,W ~_ 300L ~0jJf{()1i5 - GJPAI\~\JAt.... ~~I ~O RECEIVED JUN - 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FI33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ",,,, I:Y v' 6J Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 5" B 7~S t11 ') ~(;--;3c: (' c- /l, e- / L., .~ // Resident's Address and Unit: 5Fo~ ,,-ltC )u)VJt ;+3 !tv VJ1U{.A--/ Pv 53/~ Dare ~~.~ J';3,' :eo!7 sAD~-? RECEIVED JUN - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"""" lYv'j9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners or the City or Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit cU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~/2()bA ('~{lJoJ :&()f)~ A- /-Dill r-evJ- Date Signed ~j{9/Qf , hkfijoJ / Resident's Address and Unit: 2(;00 ]r;,>jp 1.(1 f?-J rY 1 j,~7Jb ft,J (; tJ/J reA TL Sf; / to / RECEIVED J U N - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",>^" ty..l' (IfJ Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-! and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident's :L~e?O -a~ ~ ~)~33/?a Date Signed RECEIVED JUN - 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: CommtsslonerS City Manager CfJ"".... ey"l/9 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~h..tJ ^'~\ A \..LEW \j \,./\ Pr>J \::. A. \.. L.~f.J. Date Signed c:?GO--Q:>\-OO =G--Dl-03 Resident's Address and Unit: Teen Ts\..Atm ~L.~J). -APT:-1-o2 A,"et-\WA..A...)="L s 3 \ ~O 1 , RECEIVED JUN - 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission or Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO.~A Dc~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident or Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment or a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 1J~( Sh~I(~7l ;3!~ Si1l~ .- Date Signed j ~ ?-/:/03 Resident's Address and Unit: RECEIVED JUN - 3 2003 CITY CLERK 7cJ!J() /sIa/10 </XvI), #' f~3 ~1717/t'Cl. rt.-, J a- "- dw"!)ktJ ""./ J -f'uJ UJ'''"' rd,~~ . AtJu/cI h 4- .::50'~'jofl-U. C<41~1 ~d-),:- A- (Jttl7dlJ~,,}'U/1l J ~o rna--l-/e1 v.-.hal. 4J;f';")' (j -'7f,;.s. w,/J 1(7?~:~ '/'k -fril<< C/A.cP ~~ . 1 . / /;l/~ .AJJ..c/.. Js t...JAd % vu<1IdoA--1s 0:1- ~{""/'6.- d 9u,eT I- 0 U /J.ad,~' ~)~OO mj b je ~ ~ j.'v('. c:.1 -5ko116 {if1fh5€ 71, s ""{//VI/~.4K11_ o~ ..5 _ .~_____-,- --- - ~- - ~ ~ 5y,,";lr /~ ~ aL,n'u~ rI~ 0/ L/JUJ/~~ . ':h ~:'~'7h~ I __...____. /~-I.;2-cI :1 Agenda Item No. 3 Date of Visit, Investigation or Receipt of Expert Opinion / / - / / - CI :? Nature of Contact (check as applicable) ~ Site Visit o Investigation o Expert Opinion Substance of Contact f{; 1R L a '7 ~' c,}; ';;//0 u ~ ):>. #;'f I< A1 A. ( A L'ft/ r ,....z;; c A 7i t7 IV' IJ Identity of Person Participating in Contact b ~ .,€! ",e / /' { Respectfully, Filed this J:1.... day of City of Aventura City Commission Meeting Date Agenda Item No, 3 / / - /,7 -0' J' Date of Verbal Communication: //-//-- 4'J 3 Identity of Person "(5ntity Making Communication: (. .L/;( ,i A--- /.2 " ~ ~ Subject and Substa Respectfully. Commissioner or Board Member receiving communication: Filed this I;" day of ~........~ CbyOfE"'" ',Ic City of Aventura City Commission Meeting Date/{l ~- 07" . / Agenda Item No. 5 / Date of Visit"Investigation or Receipt of Expert Opinion r<:;/; ':/ Nature o~ntact (check as applicable) I.Y Site Visit o Investigation o Expert Opinion Substance of Contact: Identity of Person Participating in Contact:,;';';,' j:- ;Jj"..j) ); /i/'1 (-1<;1;' _ , Respectfully, Co~issioner 9f13oa~~ Member: A;;, IVij<-;---Y L {) 1;1'/1 ~I/ - N;",)e".- /;,./'" _A~i~~~f;;/ ('~I!~',.:-- Filed this d- day of l/; - I ,CM ,City Clerk , \ .I ~~, Ve ~~~j~ City of Aventura City Commission Meeting Date ./"P~ /~ eo') " 6',:3 Agenda Item No. '3 Date of Visit, Investigation or Receipt of Expert Opinion Nature of Contact (check as applicable) tlI( Site Visit o Investigation o Expert Opinion Subst~n~ of Contact: , pi ..,L- . V~~//U~~~~' /V~. "./ ,;)&1(73 ,/ Identity of Person Participating in Contact: ""~ ~ {/ Respectfully, Commissioner or BoarQ Member: /5',,6 /)/t?~O"4'"~ Name ~ &~;N~____~ Signature Filed this / .1. day of ./'V , , , \... }.F e ~QyOflf;' City of Aventura City Commission Meeting Date 11 /2//0 ~ Agenda Item No. Date of Visit, Investigation or Receipt of Expert Opinion ~ IJIt/Ie:; ~ Nature of Contact (check as applicable) ~ Site Visit o Investigation o Expert Opinion Substance of Contact: "7 r (t3' V 1 ~ 17 Identity of Person Participating in Contact: Respectfully, Commissioner or Board MellJt>er: }u~M ~A'~ /~ . Name ~ ~re .J Filed this I ~ day of The written communication attached hereto is hereby filed on record pertaining to: City of Aventura City Commission Meeting Date J I-I L - 0 ') Agenda Item No. ~ - Respectfully, Commissioner or Board Member receiving communication: Filed this /!-- day of II V:' "1;; ;/L : Jav R. Beskin U IJ/" re Teresa Soroka cc: Commissioners City Manager Page 1 of 1 From: Annsing@aol.com Sent: Sunday, November 09. 2003 1 :06 PM To: perlowj@cityofaventura,com; auerbachz@cityofaventura,com Subject: Williams Island Synagogue 1000 W. Island Blvd, #1609 and #1610 Aventura, FL 33160 Nov. 10,2003 Dear Aventura Council: We have been residents of North Dade County since 1969 and Williams Island since 1990. Although we do not worship at The Williams Synagogue, we feel it is an important asset to our community, Many Jews do not drive a car on the Sabbath and Jewish Holidays and therefore require a synagogue within walking distance of their homes. The Williams Synagogue has been in existence for over a decade and does not cause any traffic or parking problems. In fact, most residents of Williams Island were not even aware that there is a synagogue in this community and only learned of its presence when the proposal to move it from its present location at 2000 Island Blvd, to 2600 Island Blvd, became an issue. Other nonmembers have had the advantage of its services when ritual participation was a personal need, Moving Williams Island Synagogue to 2600 Island Blvd. would not increase its membership but provide a more serene premises in which to worship, The current space is cramped and inadequate, A larger area is needed so that meaningful prayer can take place in comfort, Kindly support the transfer of the Williams Synagogue to 2600 Island Blvd, Respectfully, Dr. Joseph A. Singer Ann Singer 11/10/2003 Page 1 of1 Teresa Soroka Larrysti@aol.com Sunday, November 02, 200312:31 PM perlowj@cityofaventura,com; aurebachz@cityof aventura,com; beskinj@cityofaventura,com; cohenk@cityofaventura,com; diamondb@cityofaventura, com; holzbergh@cityofaventra,com; grossmanm@cityofaventura,com Subject: Synagogue at Williams Island From: Sent: To: Dear Council Members: We are extremeiy disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Wiiliams Island, While we are among the very few members who drive from an off Island location. the great majority of the congregants must waik in accordance with our tradition, Wiiliams Island Synagogue has outgrown its present facility and the need is great for a larger place, That place has been located within one of the buildings on the Island and can be accessed only through an area currently used by deiivery trucks and at the end of an alley, Opposition to this relocation is understandable if it were in any way to affect the life style or habits of any of the residents who reside in the building of the new location, However, if you were to visit the proposed location you too could not understand what this oppositon is about. No one who is not a member of the congregation will in any way be inconvenienced by this new location, Further, those who are Shabbath observant will be able to observe our religion in the appropriate way, We would apprecite your supporting this move, Sincerely yours, Larry and Eileen Joseph 19333 Collins Ave, #2301 Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160 11/3/2003 cc: COffillliSSlOners SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP City Manager PAUL GINSBERG, M.D. JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR C. MANIAR. M.D. HARVEY D, SCHWARTZ, M.D. ISLON SELIGER, M.D, BRUCE ZARET, M.D. JEFF M. STEINBERG, M.D. MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D. YEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M,D, ERIC F. CILlBERTI, M.D. NEUROLOGY BARRY J. CUTLER. M.D, RICHARD p, SINGER, M,D" FAAN, JILL S. LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A. HERRERA. M.D. GERALD S. GOLDBERG, M.D. T ANUSHREE ROY. M.D. RICHARD TIEGEN, D.M.D.. A.P. RHONDA Q. FREEMAN, PSY. D. EDUARDO CUTIE, M.D. November 3, 2003 Dear My wife and I love Aventura. We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago. But we almost could not live here. My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modern orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sundays and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island. It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten years had grown to such a degree that we have outgrown all quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place of worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful of the rules on the island. The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for Aventura. His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of truth that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed. Respectively yours, Barry J. Cutler, M.D. CI/20031103-047/BJC 4925 Sheridan Street. Suite 200, Hollywood, Florida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation, Florida 33317 16800 NW 2nclAvenue, 306, Miami, Florida 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue, 206, Plantation, FL 33324 Phone: (954) 981 3850 Phone: (954) 437 4000 Phone: (954) 321 1776 Phone: (305) 652 3062 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax (954) 981 3889 Fax (954) 433 5257 Fax (954)3211885 Fax (305) 653 7046 Fax: (954) 452 5872 JORDON & LESLI ROSS October 28, 2003 The Honorable Jay R. Beskin Commissioner City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mr. Beskin: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without 3000 ISLAND BLVD, # 2606 AVENTURA, FL 33160 0 305-682-9839 0 3Q5..682-8602FAX being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RLUIP A) stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. ~00~ Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Name: Sf ~ Henry Flescher 2106 19195 Mystic Pointe Dr. TOLERANCE Aventura. FL 33180 Address: Robert I. WerDer 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 November 2, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Ref: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 Public Hearing Dear Commissioner Beskin: The matter that you have under consideration, whether or not to permit a Conditional Use Approval for the Willie Trump Synagogue in a different location is admittedly emotional to many citizens, I personally am disturbed by the opposition to this relocation to a different location on Williams Island, Earlier this year I had submitted personal comments and observations, I attach a copy for your reference, Anyone who has looked into the matter leamed that the current location is inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of A ventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is too great to walk to any other Shul. Recognizing and appreciating the many varying viewpoints I would still appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion, Yours sincerely, --- Robert Werner 3000 Island Blvd. Apt.#3001 \Williams Islnd Synagogue\RIW Itr to Commissioner Beskin Seat 4 re Shul I] 0203 Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: I permanently reside in Aventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building, I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small number of participants do drive but that number is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual number of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts, In my opinion this request would enhance the community, Thank you. Sincerely yours, Robert 1. Werner \2003 Misc\RIW Itr re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 Alex Richbnan 3900 Island Blvd. 103B Aventura, Florida, 33160 Tel: 305-682-1588 November 2, 2003 Mr. Jay R. Beskin Commissioner City of Aventura Govemment Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Commissioner Beskin: We are extremely disturbed to leam that there is opposition to the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue to a different location on the Island. As everyone is aware ,the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. As a survivor of the holocaust ,I urge you to support this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Sincerely, "- ~~ il/Ufi'Y- . steven V. Gurland, M.D. · City Of Aventura Government Center Attention: Commissioner Jay Beskin 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 November 2,2003 Dear Commissioner Jay Beskin, We are extremely upset by the opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. We moved from Hollywood, Florida to the Williams Island location because there was a Synagogue and other amenities we consider very important to our lifestyle choices. The current Synagogue location is totally inadequate. There is no alternative for a synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. We attend this synagogue on Shabbat and we walk. The distance to another Synagogue would be to far to walk. We would appreciate you supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religious choice. ~ Steven & Caroline Gurland 7000 Island Blvd. # 1709 Aventura, Fl. 33160 . 7000 Island Blvd. #1709 · Avcntura. Florida 33160 · (954) 333-6061 . Fax (305) 792-3031 . . [-Mail: f1gurland@aol.com . DAVID HOLD November 2, 2003 Mr. Jay R. Beskin, Commissioner City of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: Williams Island Synagogue Dear Commissioner Beskin: I am writing this letter in total dismay that in this day and age an issue like this is even disputed. What is more amazing than anything is the fact that the opposition to this new synagogue is not from the non Jewish members of the community but mainly from the Jewish ones. Is it possible that the saying that history repeats itself is true because it reminds me of the same attitude of the German Jewish community before Second World War, who also turned their back on their heritage. My wife and I, are both children of holocaust survivors and very sensitive to such issues. We were also raised in a communist country where freedom of religion was never heard of. The beauty of this country that it provides religious freedom to everyone irregardless of place of origin or nature of their believes. This is also true about the new city of Aventura which can be looked upon as a modern melting pot of all nationalities. The beauty of our synagogue encompasses all of these wonderful qualities that this great country of ours grants us. We have members from all parts of the world practicing their version of Judaism as they have been thought in their countries of origin and handed down from generation to generation sometimes in fear of their life but never forgetting who they are. As you are aware for a practicing member he has to have a place of worship within walking distance, the present facilities are inadequate and this is a necessity for the community at large. Please support our efforts in building our new synagogue. 3900 ISL\ND BLVD 103B . ....VENTCRA!FLORIDA . 33160 PHONE: 305-682-1588' F..\X: 305-682-1889 E -1\1.-\1 L:DHO LD9 5 4 85@.-\OL.COM Page I of2 Teresa Soroka From: Lesli KRoss [Ieslik@bellsouth.net] Sent: Friday, October 31, 2003 5:16 PM To: beskinj@cityofaventura.com Subject: NOV 12 CITY COUNCIL MEETING--CORRECTION ON SIGNATURE Dear Commissioner Beskin: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it-to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of A ventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Is/and residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the 11/3/2003 Page 2 of2 existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. Lesli K. and Jordon 1. Ross 3000 Island Blvd #2606 Aventura 33160 11/3/2003 Page I of2 Teresa Soroka From: Lesli KRoss [Ieslik@bellsouth.net] Sent: Friday, October 31, 2003 5:00 PM To: beskinj@cityofaventura.com Subject: NOV 12 CITY COUNCIL MEETING Dear Commissioner Beskin: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it-to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of A ventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Is/and residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. 11/3/2003 Page 2 of2 Federal law stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. Lesli K. and Jordon 1. Ross 11/3/2003 Page I of2 Teresa Soroka From: LesH KRoss [Ieslik@bellsouth.net] Sent: Friday, October 31, 2003 5:16 PM To: beskinj@cityofaventura.com Subject: NOV 12 CITY COUNCIL MEETING--CORRECTION ON SIGNATURE Dear Commissioner Beskin: Before you decide how to vote on the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue, we hope and expect that you will thoughtfully, respectfully and honestly consider the following points. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it-to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. We understand that those opposed to its relocation cite security reasons. This has never before been a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The small percentage of worshippers who are not residents of Williams Island live in the vicinity, are residents of Aventura, and in the main have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non-residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Is/and residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors, whatever the underlying motivations for opposition might be. This holds especially where the issue of security is not involved. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the 11/3/2003 Page 2 of2 existence of the synagogue, and require it. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the City of A ventura. Sincerely. Lesli K. and Jordon 1. Ross 3000 Island Blvd #2606 Aventura 33160 1113/2003 Teresa Soroka Page 1 of 1 cc: Commissioners City Manager Sent: To: From: MGutt99@aol.com Tuesday, November 04, 2003 12:02 PM perlowj@cityofaventura.com; auerbachz@cityofaventura.com; beskinj@cityofaventura.com; cohen k@cityofaventura.com; diamondb@cityofaventura.com; holzbergh@cityofaventura.com; grossmanm@cityofavenura.com; jtabacinic@attglobal.net Subject: (no subject) Miami, November 3, 2003 City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As every one is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregates attend this synagogue on Shabbat and the distance is too great to walk and attends any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, Manuel Gutt 1000 East Island Boulevard Apt. 2102 Aventura, Florida 33160 11/4/2003 1/ \~ 1\j'00~ y~ Zu\:l3 / Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, 0rieJ ow.cI ~S,{C{V)Cj ~U(W\Clvu:k;" Address: ':hoo LI\c.cu.c\ ~c:l rw4P 2-1'0\ 11\~ Iii 33\00 Name: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Name: a..Jl.--- 1d~/~/ -- ' . r-fil e:.l>NAAJ [;7" U,J..2> /~I J/h .#"S-;;~ - Yours sincerely, Address: ) 0.40 &. A-1/~J.,.>-:;;A/f . ;{. 3:])60 / PAUL GINSBERG, M.D. JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR C. MANIAR, M.D. HARVEY D. SCHWARTZ, M.D. ISLON SELIGER, M.D. BRUCE ZARET, M.D. JEFF M. STEINBERG, M.D. MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D. VEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M.D. ERIC F. CILIBERTI, M.D. SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP NEUROLOGY BARRY J. CUTLER, M.D. RICHARD P. SINGER, M.D., FAAN. JILL S. LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A. HERRERA, M.D. GERALD S. GOLDBERG, M.D. TANUSHREE ROY, M.D. RICHARD TIEGEN, D.M.D., A.P. RHONDA Q. FREEMAN, PSY. D. EDUARDO CUTIE, M.D. November 3, 2003 Dear Mr. Beskin, My wife and I love Aventura. We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago. But we almost could not live here. My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modern orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sabbath and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island. It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten years had grown to such a degree that we have outgrown our quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place of worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the Island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful of the rules on the island. The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for Aventura. His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of proof that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed. Respectively yours, /7 ;2ry ~r /J1)) ler, M.D. cr/20031103-047/BJC 4925 Sheridan Street, Suite 200, Hollywood, Florida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines. Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation. Florida 33317 16800 NW 2"' Avenue. 306, Miami. Florida 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue. 206, Plantation, FL 33324 Phone: (954) 981 3850 Phone: (954) 437 4000 Phone: (954) 3211776 Phone: (305) 652 3062 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax (954) 981 3889 Fax (954) 433 5257 Fax (954) 3211885 Fax (305) 653 7046 Fax: (954) 452 5872 SUNRISE MEDICAL GROUP NEUROLOGY CC: Commissioners City Manager PAUL GINSBERG, M.D. JOEL DOKSON, M.D. MA YUR C. MANIAR, M.D. HARVEY D. SCHWARTZ, M.D. ISLON SELIGER, M.D. BRUCE ZARET, M.D. JEFF M. STEINBERG, M.D. MICHAEL SCHOU, M.D. VEENA SUBRAMANIAN, M.D. ERIC F. CILIBERTI, M.D. BARRY J. CUTLER, M.D. RICHARD P. SINGER, M.D., FAAN. JILL S. LIEBMAN, D.O. MARIA A. HERRERA, M.D. GERALD S. GOLDBERG, M.D. T ANUSHREE ROY, M.D RICRARD TIEGEN, D.M.D., A.P. RHONDA Q. FREEMAN, PSY. D. EDUARDO CUTIE, M.D. November 5, 2003 To Whom It May Concern; My wife and I love Aventura. We love what people like you and the other commissioners have done to make this city a wonderful place in which to raise our children. We loved Aventura when we first got married ten years ago. But we almost could not live here. My wife and I are orthodox Jews and we needed a modem orthodox synagogue, one we could walk to on the Sabbath and holidays. Fortunately for us, we found the perfect synagogue at Williams Island. It was already established four years earlier and in the past ten yeas has grown to such a degree that we have outgrown our quarters. Our synagogue for all these years has served Williams Island; being there to help people during their periods of grief as well as joy; being there to increase Jewish awareness and levels of knowledge; being there to provide a place to worship to those would otherwise have to live elsewhere. Never have we been a security problem. Never have we disrupted traffic or parking. Never have we been a source of embarrassment to the Island. We have always been courteous, considerate, and mindful of the rules on the island. The major reason for our growth has been our Rabbi. Rabbi Horowitz has brought together people of all backgrounds and could be a source of pride not only for Williams Island, but also for Aventura. His continuing as our Rabbi depends a lot on the new facility. If he were to leave, the loss would be enormous. I am sure that many letters from us to you will stress the legal issues, but as an orthodox Jew, I would rather appeal to your sense of values; values that I am sure your parents instilled in you during your life. Surely, during this week, the week when the Nazis years ago tried to destroy synagogues during Kristalnacht, you can find it in your heart to grant us our synagogue thus providing one more piece of proof that Hitler and all anti-Semites have failed. Respectively yours, Barry J. Cutler, M.D. 4925 Sheridan Street. Suite 200, HOllywood. Fiorida 33021 12596 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, Florida 33027 7390 Northwest 5th Street, Suite #9, Plantation, Florida 33317 16800 NW 2" Avenue, #306, Miami, Fiorida, 33169 350 NW 84 Avenue, #206, Plantation, Florida 33324 Phone (954) 981 3850 Fax: (954) 981 3889 Phone (954) 437 4000 Fax: (954) 433 5257 Phone (954) 3211776 Fax: (954) 3211885 Phone (954) 652 3062 Fax: (305) 653 7048 Phone: (954) 475 4811 Fax: (954) 452 5872 --------........----_._--~-"~~-_._------------,..---- T obi and Nathan LewJIlger 2600 l"bmd f>lvd. AventLJra, r-=-! ...,) 1 (~O October 31, 2003 The Honorable Jay R. Beskin Commissioner City of A ventura Government Center 19200 West Country Oub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 Dear Mr. Beskin: We are writing to ask for your careful and honest consideration of the application for the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue based on the legitimate facts and the law pertinent to the situation. There has always been a synagogue at Williams Island, open to any resident. Its existence has not impinged on anyone who chooses not to be affiliated with it- to the extent that a good number of property owners lived here for years without ever knowing of its existence. The issue of security that opponents to the relocation cite was never before a concern. With few exceptions, those who are members and attend services and synagogue functions are residents of Williams Island. The others live in the vicinity and are residents of Aventura, and most of them have been part of the synagogue family for many years. In other words, they have been coming to the synagogue without incident for quite some time. Their numbers are certainly a tiny fraction of the number of non-residents who regularly come to the spa (and from there have full access to the entire island), and no more a danger than non- residents who come to the island for the private functions hosted by residents in their apartments or building party rooms. It should be noted that the synagogue is not advertised or promoted in any way to non-residents; its purpose is to serve those people who live on the island. There is no other synagogue within reasonable walking distance, a requirement for those of us who are observant. This is also the reason we have no need for parking. Our current space is inadequate (our growth has come from Williams Island residents, people who purchased their homes here because there is a synagogue to meet their needs). The new space would allow us to be comfortable as a congregation, to serve our post-services refreshments without being crowded and without having to use residential building party rooms, and to have a separate room for children, under supervision, during the services. The new facility still does not allow for many more people than we already have, but would provide the breathing room and dedicated space for the religious activities that now take place in a single area that doesn't serve any function satisfactorily. Federal law (RlLUP A) clearly stipulates that zoning cannot be used to prevent the establishment or continuation of a place of worship, despite objections of neighbors. We sincerely hope that as you evaluate this issue, you will do so as a matter of law, and not be distracted by extraneous and irrelevant arguments put forth by those who for whatever personal reasons oppose something that does not detract in any way from their way of life, but whose loss would create a tremendous upheaval for those of us who came to Williams Island because of the existence of the synagogue, and require it. Please don't allow personal animosities to get in the way of an intelligent-and legally required-decision. Williams Island Synagogue is not (and is not about) the developers of Williams Island (the Trumps). It is about the families who depend on it, the community that exists within and around it, and the enhanced value (economic and otherwise) it brings to the entire area and the Oty of Aventura. Sincerely. t:-~L Tobi and Nathan Lewinger (f tr;J Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. Yours sincerely, !/4.ffi'rt/,.,./l..v rel;.->< 11ft! 10:: Name: Mr. Felix V. :&t. 1406 assel"lniln ~ 181 NE 31st Ct ~ntura Fl 33160~2676 Address: Dear Council Members: We are extremely disturbed to learn that there is opposition to the relocation of the Willie Trump Synagogue to a different location on Williams Island. As everyone is aware, the current location is totally inadequate and there is no alternative synagogue in the southern portion of Aventura. Many of our congregants attend this synagogue on Shabbat as the distance is to great to walk to any other shul. We would appreciate your supporting this move, thereby permitting appropriate observance of our religion. YO",S s;ncerely, ~ Name: VVYl 'lk Y c..[ <J 1-.. I ~..D. Address: /8'18/ NC- 3/ ,? cT # /40/ IlvR'!/Tw/l/f ;cc... 33/60 7000 Island Blvd., Unit 2002 Aventura. FL 33160 October 2, 2003 Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33160 Dear Mayor Perlow: We wrote to you on May II, 2003 concerning our opposition to the establishment of a synagogue in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. The discussion of that issue by the Commission has been rescheduled for November 4. 2003. We would, therefore. like to reiterate our strong opposition to the establishment of any places of worship for any religion on Williams Island. This is a wonderful residential area, and we carefully selected our home, for which we paid a great deal of money. We continue to oppose the establishment of the synagogue for two reasons. First, our private residential area should not be used for any non-residential purpose which is not owned and operated by the Property Owners of Williams Island. At this time the POA (Property Owners Association) has negotiated the purchase of the Williams Island Clubs from the developers. Allowing another use which is not controlled by the residents would be counter-productive to these efforts. Second, we are very concerned about the safety and security of our home. The religious- related terrorism and violence in the world has continued to increase during the summer. Unfortunately. that trend does not appear to be changing. Please do not subject the 1,700 families of Williams Island to the location of a potential magnet for terrorism or violence by permitting the synagogue to be built. We will attend the November 4, 2003 meeting to address this issue. We appreciate your consideration of our views when voting on the matter. We will consider your vote on this issue at your next election. 5i ncerely, ~:~i:~af:~ Cc: Zev Auerbach, Commissioner Jay Beskin, Commissioner Ken Cohen. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Commissioner Manny Grossman, Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Commissioner Erick M. Soroka, City Manager ~lail To; The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO""l,","", ~t'I,r.. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 , . Dear J.\tIayor Perlow and Commissioners of the Ci C"j of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island l3oulevard, Unit CU.l and urge yuu to vote against the conditionsl use a pplication that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name L /,./"b"1 .s:,E~ c L Signature Date Signed 0/rf/o:S bJrjo :> CDW'"J $,<=GEL Resident's Address and Unit: / t! f!) o' ::;z::s- LA,/ b ;1 L V .c, 2{,07 r oJc rJ TVI"tA- I~. cc: Commissioners City Manager G.",., ~~\O(. Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 ~... To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of-Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. , , Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed ~/22/03 -,~ 1\,T.AN'M. ST.EI"ETT ~-/--;L-- ~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 21396 Marina Cove Circle, Unit J-12 Aventura, Fl 33180 Dr. Burton and Linda S. Goldstein 2600 Island Blvd. #1903 Aventura, FI33160 cc: Commissioners City Mana~er Mv ~T.. Aventura City Commissioners 19200 W. Country Club Drive Aventura, Fl33180 May 6, 2003 Dear Commissioners: We are writing this letter in strong support of the relocation of the Williams Island Community Synagogue. We are residents ofthe 2600 Building-Residence du Cap. We have been members of the Williams Island Community Synagogue ever since we moved to Williams Island over 11 years ago. This Synagogue serves the needs ofa large community here at Williams Island. We respectfully request that you give positive consideration to relocation of the Williams Island Community Synagogue. Sincerely, ~~~'IL~~~~t~1 ~ ~ ROSENZWEIG RECEIVED MAY - , 2003 CITY CLERK 2600 Island Boulevard, Apt 801 Williams Island Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel: 305-792-9905 Fax: 305-792-9962 May 1, 2003 x: Commissioners City Manager ~~- Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. /04-CU-03 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l Dear Mayor Perlow: As a resident of Williams Island, I am strongly against the establishment of a synagogue in 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use variance that will make this possible, Sincerely, -- . .- Gloria Muroff 2000 Island Boulevard - # 1709 Aventura, Florida 33160 RECEIVED MAY - ? 7001 CITY CLERK April 30, 2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~1w r Mayer Jeffrey Perlow 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33160 Dear Mayer Perlow: As a resident of Williams Island I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote against the Variance that will make a move possible. Thank you for your consideration c6.Y -..0 .- cc: Commissioners City Manager Babette Kabak Apt 806 1000 Island Blvd William. I.land Avennua, Florida 33160 Tel/Fax (305) 792 5392 Apr 30 2003 Commissioner Zev Auerbach Commissioner of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FI33180 Dear Sir, MAY 6TH HEARING ON REQUEST TO ALLOW OPERATION OF A SYNAGOGUE IN A CONDOMINTIJM UNIT On May 6th I will be overseas and unable to attend the Hearing on the issue to allow the operation of a synagogue in a condominium unit in the Residence Do Cap 2600 Building, 2600 Island Blvd, Aventura, Fl 33160.. I am writing to say I oppose the use of a condomium unit on the following grounds: . in the interests of fairness and equality, permitting the use ofa condominium for one religious institution would open a Pandora's Box for requests from other institutions · condominiums should be completely non-denominational and allowing one institution to be established would imply its preference for occupants adhering to the precepts of that institution. This would set a very dangerous precedent of exclusionary practices. It should be firmly established that condominiums are solely and exclusively for residential purposes. Sincerely, Al~/~~#~ cI Mayor Jeffrey Perlow Commissioner Jay Beskin Commissioner Ken Cohen ~ cc: Commissioners City Manager City of Aventura Government Center Community Development Department 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffery M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RE: Hearing, 11/12/03 - Williams Island Synagogue, Inc./04-CU-03 REQUEST TO BE READ ALOUD INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD: Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident at 2600 Island Boulevard. I wish to join my fellow condominium owners in opposing the establishment of a synagogue in our building. Such a plan which allows unscreened public access into a private residential building on a continuing basis undermines the large investment we make to secure our privacy. It must be made clear that in a special meeting held on December 3, 2002 unit owners overwhelming rejected the proposed plan before you as follows: Those Opposed: 70 votes, In Favor: 26 votes. (see attached minutes, 2600 Island Blvd. Condo Assoc., Inc.). Williams Island is and was established as a secure and private, double-gated residential community It is disturbing that such a proposal attempts to circumvent the expressed wishes of the families living here and would surely result in further and unnecessary litigation. Respectfully yours, l~ -1- 3 Date: 11/0 /03 Wendy A derson-Fabbri 2600 Isla d Boulevard Unit #2905 Aventura Florida 33160-5212 ENe.: Residence du Cap Minutes of Tuesday, December 3, 2002 The Special Meeting of the Members of AND BOULEVARD CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. held on Tuesday, December 3, 2002 in the Pool Lounge was called to order by Rod 1. White, President at 6:10pm. [ o ( p r The following Board members were present: George Lipton Lawrence Blumberg Paula Berliner William Joel - Vice President - Secretary/Treasurer - Director - Director Also present was: Diane Harari - Property Manager The Unit Owner count was 96 represented units. 58 represented units were necessary to establish a quorum, therefore a legal meeting was in order. Ms. Harari produced an Affidavit of Notice affirming that notice was delivered to each Board Member and . Unit Owner not less than fourteen (14) days prior to the meeting and that said notice was posted on the bulletin board located in the Mail Room at the time of mailing. The purpose ofthe meeting was to obtain a vote by members on authorizing the Board of Directors to engage legal counsel specializing in land use and zoning at a cost not to exceed $25,000.00 to oppose the Developer's proposed plans to relocate the Synagogue presently located in the 2000 building of Williams Island to Commercial Unit C-I in the 2600 building. Elliot DorfinanlUnit #404 tabulated the votes with Ms. Harari and her assistant, Tiffany Torres. OTING RESULTS: ODDosed to Developer's plans to relocate the Synagogue 70 (Authorizing Board to engage legal counsel) In favor of Developer's Plans 26 There being no further business to discuss, a motion was made by Mr. White seconded by Mrs. Berliner to adjourn the meeting at 6:25pm. All in favor. . I hereby certifY that the foregoing Minutes are true and correct Minutes for the above-mentioned 2600 I'(\""" BOULEVARD CONDOMlNlUM ASSOCIATION, INC. B""" ofD,,''''''_ ~~~~~ Rod 1. White \" President ROSENZWEIG 2600 Island Boulevard. Apt 801 Williams Island Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel: 305-792-9905 Fax: 305-792-9962 May 1,2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. 104-CU-03 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l Dear Commissioner Beskin: As a resident of Williams Island, I am strongly against the establishment of a synagogue in 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use variance that will make this possible. Sincerely, Y~,(. " Annemarie Burton-Rosenzweig ~ ~ ROSENZWEIG 2600 Island Boulevard. Apt 801 Williams Island Aventura. Florida 33160 Tel: 305-792-9905 Fax: 305-792-9962 May 1,2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Re: The Williams Island Synagogue, Inc. 104-CU-03 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l Dear Commissioner Beskin: As a resident of Williams Island, I am strongly against the establishment of a synagogue in 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use variance that will make this possible. Sincerely, Gloria Muroff 2000 Island Boulevard - #1709 Aventura, Florida 33160 April 30, 2003 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33160 Dear Commissioner Beskin, As a resident ofWiIliams Island I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote against the Variance that will make a move possible. Thank you for your consider tion ~ff 71 Babette Kabak Apt 806 1000 Island Blvd Williams Island Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel/Fax (305) 792 5392 Apr 30 2003 Commissioner Jay Beskin Commissioner of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Fl33180 Dear Sir, MAY 6TH HEARING ON REQUEST TO ALLOW OPERATION OF A SYNAGOGUE IN A CONDOMINIUM UNIT On May 6th 1 will be overseas and unable to attend the Hearing on the issue to allow the operation of a synagogue in a condominium unit in the Residence 011 Cap 2600 Building, 2600 Island Blvd, Aventura, Fl33160.. I am writing to say I oppose the use of a condomium unit on the following grounds: . in the interests of fairness and equality, permitting the use of a condominium for one religious institution would open a Pandora's Box for requests from other institutions · condominiums should be completely non-denominational and allowing one institution to be established would imply its preference for occupants adhering to the precepts of that institution. This would set a very dangerous precedent of exclusionary practices. It should be tinnly established that condominiums are solely and exclusively for residential purposes. Sincerely, ~/~ cJ Mayor Jeffiey Perlow Commissioner Zev Auerbach Commissioner Ken Cohen , The Sydney Corp . 30 A~ ~vt~ As AttStP-.J ~ lV~ ~ ) frvv\ S-re..oNCr{'~ ~'5sT-- '-fLu . --~~ ------ ~~ W~~~"CLr~~<Mf cj "'-: --h ~ ~ ~--u.... JaAAVU-<.- ~ \~~(e~ ~-~. (f~ ~U6'4k ~~~(JD '-.~ ~ . Lf. I CLa U<id J-. ~ ~ lP0-4 *. ~ y\~ d^lf (i~ ~ M F ~ rv.,yCr,u,J,. Ju;. . cq~~ Ix" U _ I - . 1),VY(~ . 3900 Island Boulevard Suite B-106 Williams Island, F133160' Tel: 305.613 3010' F . . ax. 305.466.3020 . Email: TheSydneyCorp@ao1.com Dear~/~5/~ &~ As a resident of A ventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, ~ 0/ J~ M~~ ~. Dear ~/h I2h.~ As a resident of Aventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would pennit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, _~ ~ Dear ~~~L.,-,y~~_ As a resident of Aventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, t~~ RECEIVED MAY - "i ?003 em CLmK cc: Commissioners C~~ Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. V J~~- Name: Building: i.ftlV1J Unit #: -2---/ !J h -- .- RECEIVED MAY - r:; '1101 CITY ,CLERK GC: Commissionerl-. City Manager ~~( DearAr~ IM/~: As a resident of A ventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. ~ 3~ , ~U~~ $7 Sincerely yours, :-:f RECEIVED MAY - 5 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager ~~ Dear mar ~ ~ As a resident of A ventura and of Willianls Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, ~~ -- .- RECEIVED MAV - 5 7003 CITY CLERK Dear /JZ~90/h ~~: cc: Commissioners City Manager ~~ As a resident of A ventura and of Williams Island, I strongly object to the establishment of an Orthodox Synagogue, or of any denomination House of Worship, in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. On May 6, I urge you to vote against any variance which would permit this Synagogue. Thank you. Sincerely yours, I K2V ~ ~ RECEIVED MAY - 5 '003 ltlrmr~ cc: Commissioners City Manager ~)W~ Dear Mr. Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible. Thank you. . .-/ Unit#:I/O!? N e: BUilding~ --' .~ . The . Sydney Corp RECEIVED ~c: Commissioners MAY -5 ?Onl ~a~. CITY CLERK \ M~ b ~ ~ ~~ ?~ ~" I< WJ.uJ ~ LlI ~ }vl~) J lLUL ~ '1~ '1-k ~1'f/<R ~~ 'f-k- ~~ ~Svr~~-~,_/~~io ~~ Q. . ~V~tL-~,~~~U~~ (IkL ~ &-1% d.lp&--o ~~.t.f:' (\<o~~ bl V>0~ ~ -'t~ clmCI wMd -d _ d- ~~~ -\-D J." t,v-W-' ~(;.-..-d ~--hk ~ ~' ~-ls ~ (r*-.\ tk ~.fLW" - -lIS ~~ ) k +, ;,;~ ~.~~~- ~~~ ~&14~ (\~~M, i1~~- 390o.1!lland Boulevard Suite B-106 Willi ams Island, F133160. Tel: 305.613 3010. . . Fax. 305.466.3020 . Email' TheSyd C . ney orp@aol.com Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~,....l::>.~\J' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~t(S) Name jOfT tjj[EJJ//v1 Resident's Address and Unit: :JM~J1jJ/NDf3J..ut), #C%()r:Q r~ /lvc~1l J;J/lttl J~j) JjjJ/}))f) iJ!-UtJ JtJ70~ ;Jv61JrILf;J- jJ./tiJ RECEIVED JUN 1 1 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager G,,,,,,,,, ~V' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name l/f7 t1 It-/: (/ ( ( Resident's Address and Unit: !-{)06 lul JoIN Ifb/;, ~g'd? fJu0(fv~. ft _~3'/~O & S, (hI (N ~ ~ ~ t2s-fatj, .::r. am; I ~~ ~ ~- RECEIVED JUN 10 2003 CITY CLERK " ~ ~'( ~~ Mail To: The City Commission of Ayentura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager c.o~ be.... To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R,gse- SC l1 A-C'I' Nt:" It fl,)(>>A\'C.D SC.~M~N"aiL Date Signed G, / , /0.3 ~ j b ,I 03 Resident(s) Name Resident's Address and Unit: ~l?Oo :CsIQ",d BJ'/<::L So'i A'l~V\-rl.lofo... Flo... 3~/~ 0 I RECEIVED JUN 1 0 2003 CITY CLERK .........',...." '" ro....................",... Ma~ 22 03 07:44~ p.2 f'1a~ 21 03 12:0!)~ Vuv~ 1 D("IUl!"r :l:~313"6 ". ~ Mail Tn: Tile City Commission of Aventura 19100 W~t Country Ch.b Drive Ave..tu..... FL 33180 c: Commissioners City Manager [yv. (;0"''''''' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberlt. Seat I Commissioner MaDDY r;m,.man, Seat 2 Commlsslo..er.Bob Diamond, Seat J CommiJSioner Jay R. Deskin, Sellt 4 Commissioner 'Lev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commiosioner Ken Cohen. Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissio..us of th.. City of Aventu...: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to tbe establishment of. synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island BOlllenrd, Unit CU-l and Brge yon to vote against Ihe conditional use application thaI will make this Use po.sible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Rc,b...,j", els-A/:" Signa lure Date Signed _.OJJ.~ O~ 5i,/.,,0:3 Resident's Addre.u and Vnit: - I :JtJu Crl,,;.,,,,/e;-..I..,,, (/''''1 T dO:n...L-lt/. ('c,~.t_., tktJ,'" / A J '/ 3..!','[- ,t;;' r/:"ru/., " u . . RECEIVED JUN - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Ma~ 21 03 12:09p Yuval Dauer 9331346 ,..2 Mail To: The City Commission of Aveotnra 19200 West COURtry Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co h1 M b.I:,/. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Rolzberg, Seat I Commissioner MaDRY Grossman, Seat2 Commissioner.Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissiober Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner ~ Auerbach, SeatS Commissioner Ken Coben, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura,l am strongly opposed to tile establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I aDd urge you to vote against the conditional use appJieation that wDl make tbis use possible. Thank you. Resideat(s) Name 201,--Q\/ Q \l) .~ I~ . I Date Sigued S)~()3 I Resident's Address aDd Unit: ~~(),O ~ ~_ 3002- vJ -iJ1 A-CL1j 5 () vP AA-Y\JAA ~ ';) I ~o RECEIVED JUN - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura,Fl33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager LO"'''' IY,,' Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~ B7~S t11 rt., 1~3c:c c..J! j~1 #<.."../ Resident's Address and Unit: 3Fo V jt/tC 'J-U) VJL ~ !tv t:vJ74--fl~ Fu 5'3/~ !/ 6/f;o/b~ RECEIVED J U N - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"''''' lY ",. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat f Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name RIZo bA (It{),0to} E,()~ A- /!Jill r-euJ-- Date Signed ~j(9/0J , ~kfifoJ Resident's Address and Unit: c2 6 00 ]~h I.d f?,j rJ 1 /coc t+/ ;; rJIJ rJi TL!1; /60 J RECEIVED J U N - 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: C0m.m1SS10nerS City Manager CoA1M !yJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date Signed Resident's ;2~(?o ?2.$P ~ ~~I #~ 33/r:. 2J RECEIVED JUN - 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: C0mm.1SS10ners City Manager enN> "" Cy,/' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken COhen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly Opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this Use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S Tu ^-k\ Ii. '-l.EtJ Vl'hPrlJ ~ AI..L.fii'~ Date Signed c?~-C!>\-G>3 C::>G;;. - D\ ~ 03 Resident's Address and Unit: Tc;r;r, Ts~ ~....\IJ). ---..I1.r>r. ""\-02 A,"E::t-\WA.A. \='L S 3 \ ~o I , RECEIVED JUN - 3 2003 CITY CLERK Robert I. Werner 3000 Island Blvd., Unit #3001 Williams Island, Aventura FL 33160 May 27, 2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"" De""'- The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive A ventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat I Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: I permanently reside in Aventura, on Williams Island at the 3000 Island Boulevard building. I am strongly in favor of the establishment of a synagogue in the commercial space at the eastern side of the 2600 Island Boulevard residential building. I request that you favorably consider this request and vote for the conditional use application that will make this possible. I attend services frequently at the present Williams Island Synagogue. I walk to services and know that practically all attendees being religiously observant walk to the services. A small nwnber of participants do drive but that nwnber is limited as observant Jewish people do not drive on the Sabbath. Walking from the 3000 building to the 2000 building I observe no unusual nwnber of people in the area either at the beginning or end of the services. Further, I have seen few cars other than the tennis players using the "Med" Village courts. In my opinion this request would enhance the community. Thank you. 1 RECElVED MAY 2 9 2001 CITY CLERK Sincerely yours, Robert I. Werner \2003 Misc\RIW Itt re Synagogue to City Commission 052703 cc: Commissioners City Manager (01"'''' lY v. Mailing Address: P.O. Box 581398, Minneapolis, MN 55458-1398 Telephone: 612-339-2651 FAX: 612-339-2761 May 21, 2003 City of Aventura City COWlcil 19200 w. COWllty Club Road Aventura, Florida 33140 Dear COWlcil Members: I am writing to you to express my views regarding the granting of a building permit to remodel a portion of the building at 2600 Island Boulevard to house the Williams Island Synagogue. I strongly believe that the request for a building permit should be granted by the City COWlcil. My feelings are based on the following considerations: I) The need and desirability of having a synagogue has been well established by the fact that for nearly 12 years a synagogue has existed on Williams Island It has proven to be of great value not only to those who use the synagogue regularly, but also to residents who have special needs from time to time. 2) The synagogue has contributed greatly to provide spiritual and educational opportunities to many who reside on the Island. 3) Jews who are Sabbath observers who live on the Island, or come to visit, can observe the Sabbath without traveling from the Island by car. 4) The synagogue and its Rabbi have created a sense of conunWlity within the confines of the Island that is Wlique and special and, adds inuneasurably to the quality oflife experienced for residents, guests, and employees of Williams Island. ~ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK k Mail To: The City CommisSion. of Aven.tura 19200 WestCoantryClub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COtYlt'1 ~e-" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoJzberg. Seat 1 Commissioner MaDDY Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner ZevAuerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly Opposed to the atablishment of a synagogue in the residential bUilding, 2609 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name =-5:71n 1-/ ;J:/i: it .~ Date Signe s-J.u;o.,3 Resident's Address and Unit: 5O?J15 J7:kci 6M c/StJ3" RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK k Mail To: Tbe City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co."", [)e./' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner MaDny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. D.eskin, Seat 4 Commissioner ZevAuerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 near Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As.a resident of Aventura, I amstroogly opposed to the establisbment of a synagogue in the residentialbuiJding, 2600 Island Boulevard;Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~U/( /H;-ti: /i>[ , Date Signed ':;-~6-~3 / / Resident's Address and Unit: ,'1'D'DO "f2,.AR.,t4 lJid ~3 RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK k Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Qub Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ",,>"1 De"" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat I Commissioner ManDY Grossman, Seat2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of A\lentura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name \ ndA ~r()[jJ-r\ . Signature 7 PMf)1) J7\ Date Signed 5-~~-03 Resident's Address and Unit: /Cf1?./t; nE 3~ PL. 1W00wrOl. F-L '331 ro , RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK !It Mail To: The City Conuniaiuu of Aventura 19200 WestCo1lDtry Oub Drive Aveutura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,'''''''' [yo'. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamoud, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. &skin, Seat 4 Commissioner ZevAuerbacb, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Coheu, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commintioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am stroogly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue iu the residential.buiiding, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against1he cooditioual useapplicatioo that will make tbis use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name I ~{AU C. ~~/}( t~112 ~M. gA~/I- ~Ari,112 Date Signed ./ .> ;Ao tJp Resident's Address and Unit: :000 J~hftA/D ~l.uP ~ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co 'M tyV' /11 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature l\tdM,u,.I, '3.I~f Date Signed ~ bIT"! 1'1."I7It Y t: Ai( 1...~.J<1::: Ht'Ht:1 l~. 8oRGe\ Resident's Address and Unit: +.~ jhQ(1AA<LJ~d Jt:- ';) 0 Co RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK ~---- ~---_._-----_.-._-------r---- * Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West CoUDtry Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 C .....n'l1SSioners CC: OllllU~ City Manager Co""'''''' tI,/. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. P~rlow Commissioner Harry Hofzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ktm Coben, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, lam strongly opposed to1heestablishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Tbank you. Resident(s) Name BA~I.?A-ak \\ t\--€() \oer&; Signature Q~~ Date Signed rt ).1{ /h :? Resident's Address and Unit: -; 1 [j () \^'l t2 }D 9 k f!!: AU-e ~ k(t~, t::L :3 31 10 J RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK *' Mail To: The City Commission ofAventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"""" lY!"". To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 CommissionerZevAuerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners oftbe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make tbis use possible. Thank you. Date Signed Resident(s) Name ~~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~}j~ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK k Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ~ "" f:::,e..t. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. "".,..t(.) N.... S;g..,.luy p:((~ ~N~~~e ~ Date Signed ~!:Uk3 Resident's Address and Unit: -13qL{0 10c 3b~ PL f\v~+O~ F{OL 3~1 s-d L RECEIVED MAV 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK May-22-03 07:22P Rae Swarte 305-936-9977 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 P.Ol cc: Commissioners City Manager Co r-"v ~1A1"" l2>L Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name . Of-/fUZ>/I\-c As.sous Resident's Address and Unit: II. Ms. Claudine Assous ~.. - '{ 1000 Island Blvd., Apt. 270 ...... . ' ~~u,I.; 8.aoh, FL 33 ' N7V~t9 Date Signed r~t?~s / / , RECEIVED MAV 2 9 2603 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (0'''''''' be"!' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach,Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /J~re0 E K'a-J 1012./ ftJS-AJ:/iV Date Signed .;;-- :2'3- D3 5,23-03 Resident's Address and Unit: ./2.6:(90 Is 1M! g loci. .#-1 CJ.oj l/ven-6ra- fi .33/6 cJ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK U~/.~/~CQ~ ~~;~l ~C~~~~~~'. I-'AlX. l:Jl ---.-_..i.....-...._ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19100 West COlUltry Club Drive Aventllra, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (:n'l1M {)e ;/ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzbere. Seat 1 COlllmissioner Manny Grossman, Seat Z Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Bakin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Coben, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners oftbe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventur., I am strongly opposed to the establisbment or a synagogue in tbe midential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, lInlt CU-} and urge you to vote against the conditioul use application that will make tbis use po.ible. Thank you. Resident(l) Name Signature 1JI1..t/244.4~,,- ,I-L~ Resident's Addren and llnit: !/6.>QO .....~ ~ ~ ~~'€Jt/ RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO,....1h tJu. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. D G Resident(s) Name I:&'l'~ W~U (../,~ [Jwar~ CQ ~~~ ~ .-2 Signature ?~~ ~- ~/CL-? .LJ 0B. a-t_ Date Signed 5/~/6J sh()- ! 03 I / Resident's Address and Unit: 3gro !lPJ fJtJ-l /JupAol. -rt.M a... I fJ. 33 I 0 0 ;J ~ 6.3, RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO^~i1'I DN To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed ~~'tD 8tce:dffL L.(p-LJ 17~ ~/'2-J 103- (/ , '. Resident's Address and Unit: ~ l<;: L~ tLt/l) dJQG ;4-J-e1J fO RA RECEIVED MAY 2 9 2003 CITY CLERK DR. EDWIN P. FARBER Rabbi DR. MAXA. LIPSCHITZ Rabbi Emeritus YEHUDA ROTTNER Hazzan JOEL BERGER Executive Director FRAN MISHLER Education Director ANNE MANDELBAUM ECEDirector MARK P. SYKES Program Director REV. MARK GOODFRIEND Ritual Director LAURIE FARBER MICHELLE KONIGSBURG Day School Principals DR. RICK MARS President BRUCE MASIA Executive Vice-President RICK GOLDEN Vice-President At Large SID KOSLOVSKY Vice-President At Large MARLINE LEVY Education VIOO-President AU\N WOLFSON Financial VIce-President CARLA SPECTOR House Vice.President ROGER PANITCH Membership Vice~President WAYNE KE1L Ritual Vice-President ED MARGOLIS Ways & Means Vice-President MARCIA ORVIETO Youth Vice-President DR. STEVE SHE1Nl\.1AN Treasurer DENISE T AMIR Recording Secretary JUDITH LIEBER Corresponding Secretary MARYLIN HOLZBERG BETIE JOY FIELD Sistertlood Presidium BILL KING Men's Club President SHARON CURTIS PT A Presldent RAQUELSCHECK Immediate Past President ~ BETH TORAH ADATH YESHURUN BEN N Y R 0 K CAMP U S ,n)'lJ) 11i)l n1m 11')) 20350 N.E. 26 Avenue. North Miami Beach, F~331ao-1136 (305) 932-8TAY . Fax: (306) 933-0955. _.STAY.ORG ft"1 _lIll1l1l.o<<1 May 21, 2003 cc: Commissioners City Manager The Honorable Jeffrey M. Perlow City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: As a Rabbi for over 43 years in the Northeast Dade community, it gave me a great deal of satisfaction to learn that the present Williams Island Synagogue has outgrown its cramped quarters and is presently planning to build a new synagogue in a commercial space in one of Williams Island's residential towers. The new facility will be totally separate and distanced from the building's residents. It will serve primarily observant Jewish residents who cannot ride to the synagogue on the Sabbath. The synagogue is a very positive and significant addition in our area. One of the buiwarks of our great democratic system is the freedom for people of all faiths to worship and practice their religion. As the Rabbi Emeritus of Beth Torah Adath Yeshurun, I believe that the proposed relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue will be of great benefit to our entire community and I hope that you give it your full biessing and approval. ;~,~y:",~ f),~~ Dr. Max A. Lipschitz Rabbi MAL/mf May-13-03 12:1BP Rae Swarte 305-936-9977 P.02 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager /' __ Dtv. CO""" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment oCa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name K.H. Haller S"Rattl Date Signed 05/15/2003 Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 Island Blvd. # 3011 Aventura. FL 33160 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Corn/Vl tx~. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed 5"//"/0.3 MVR.\E'L ~OE."SIN~ ~~ Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 ISLAND BLVD. J..L/O:J... W/L.L'I'IHS /SJ.AIv"D A I/~AlIU R A FL. 33/'0 , RECEIVED MAY ~ 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COin"" be.!- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R,,"d.nl(') Nam. ~" 1).. .JvrA.~~ f1e)S~ e. MA-RGAF<;a M f:15'(.e:&, 'un ~~ wt" fu ~ Date Signed - 6-)) c( /0 3 . ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~\~.D ~\D :If'~{04 \JJ l u...\kl'v\J~) t S /.-Al011 ~ (..., ~'?{ b RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK 1 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C O.hl"" IYJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .81176> )u'/C/7ie7 Signature L~~/ Date Signed CIIS-~3 ,/ / Resident's Address and Unit: /hf cJ Ah//./ 2?ty:#' crpf' RECElVEO MA~ 'l 7 2001 crN CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoJt1-n f::lev' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed ';f..IEIIA WR/tJf5GP/.,- ,4AL ~-S. ~ IS, '1-..#0.3 Resident's Address and Unit: /9 ?S-S-L.J..-A >~ vh~~ , ~/'ft.( RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C-o/k/k, ':yo./' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~L~ Date Signed t; Wra I ~ ?ueu; 1; r /1 r / W7.f'3 , , Resident's Address and Unit: 1'15]-;- ~tvl ~~ ~ RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l1"> &v , To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature o~~ kf#-& . c~ Date Signed S/;do5 sf; J liP Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 E Ts~ l5'hD aD,! RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co M /11 t)l" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 6\.'-:~ '3,) o~ t'\. t>-;J ~~~ ~<.)~~) Signature ~.~ \~ ="--- Date Signed ~t*\o~ ~l4o~ Resident's Address and Unit: "\.--\, 00 \S4~~ ~~ ~o '\' RECEIVED MAV ? 7 2003 CITY CLERK ~~~~4 ~'-- FROM : CI--PSE PHONE NO. 7574221633 Ma~. 15 2003 09:57PM Pi Mail To: The City Commission of Avelltura 19100 West Coantry Club Drive Av.aNr., FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager eOM"" tyv, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. ',rlow Commissioner Harry Holzberl, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat :3 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commiuioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Kea Coben, Seat 6 near Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establisbmeat of a synagogue in the residential buildiog. 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditiooal use application that will make tbis use possible. Thank you. RXName. Slg;J:. ~ ~ }\Ch(lse r:e; f;ij ~-:'c..l~C~"'€' ~.~ Date Siened S-/ c:. 0:;0 - ...... ') 'S\\"do~ . Resident's Address and Unit: 2. c. 0 [.) \ "><...A.vi) 2J\.... v 0 '* '2 "30"2.. h 0";:N~JVA '; i- ~ ':l, i Co. 0 I RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co "'..... bt'". Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name iAwRhtrli at4J..\..\ Resident's Address and Unit: :s j0-o :r~ fft f\J () 8 Lv [) P H~D J. RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoM/YI &1/- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Reside?t(s) Name hd ~?C/j ?lJ~ Date Signed 5' -)f/ -() 3 Resident's Address and Unit: 'J;50D J.>kfl) JJk) j)- tj/)!j ( RECEIVED MAY,) 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc:<:ornrnissioners City Manager Co"".." De",. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. \ A Resident s) Name 1_ Signa~e _ ~ ~ed . t'\, ~~ \\o~ f\JS~-1 I ""1~ t;'.lJ-03 Resident's Address and Unit: \ D 00 \ ~ \ t\-l\} () .g, \ v () ~ ~o ~ A\Je/1+'-..J~ ~L- 3"51 ~ a RECEIVED MAY,) 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager CONl,vl I:Y'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Res'dent(s) Name ,- KihJ e-.U! ( J ' Date Signed 5/1.3 . Resident's Address and Unit: !rr<Jt) F. 'Be bWb #-/902- RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Ca..,.,,,,, C:,ell- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ']";-rL/2.I=- L/fI ~ <; /-J1) Signature Date Signed ~~~ -.::,---:..; CJ -0,"':, Resident's Address and Unit: //tm ~ ALJ /...<O!? aw~- - ~kfi/~' . 33/60 RECEIVED MAY ? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/1,"'1 tyv' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possibie. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S~ Date Signed ~~V+Q C:I~1.. bAY ~~-O::, Resident's Address and Unit: -'!OOD lCS;~,~~v. \ c:04-' ~~~Ar~ t=-- \. S~I ~o . RECEIV~D MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",,-"" ~o/. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /--) uj)~1 C 1u!1lo ~ Date Signed 0-/7)63 Resident's Address and Unit: 205/St! ~v~ (!/1fJ ~ /FC;Z/Y6 RECE\VED MA'{ ? 7 2003 crT'( CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager to,"'1>'/ lY'v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed /~o ~j MariDI/1.. I CLu.1 05-19 -0.1 Dr;~,q -D~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~~OD {s.LCLu..tl. ~L()d , <:;:>110/ Flvevc~I"C{{ --:PL 1 3..J.ICO RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co""'''' ~e.l' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. HA'kJS ~. Li';;l'iAli Date Signed Resident(s) Name ';--19-03. Resident's Address and Unit: Ji$00 Iskc.v{ ~luc\ /fIDeL !\- ()'t\<l,~1 Q +L '3 ':3 \ b a RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Io.._,r co""'" 1..)<' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /P!ZJ.€..i&!Ji ])/fUTSc-H J{)I!I~ j)/FUT.5c.1f j:;Q ,~ ~c-L "1 Date Signed 6/lbJ,y ~6~3 Resident's Address and Unit: Jt?&O)'5:, /SL4/Y'P ;jL;/I) o?~3 RECEIVED MAV ? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"''''' ~,jl To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. M;;~~;;1 JkP8S s;[LIuv Date Signed ~-I ~ ~o'3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~o93h ~fl-y Df /1-&11/(/ R f:} FL 3/1J? ..3S/ f 0 RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 0 'l1 '" tt v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Name Ol{\ \~ '\ Date Signed ~\~'t) ) Resident's Address and Unit: fD~ :SY RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Av,entura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.o/'l/Vl ty.J' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name f-~ec~ ~;J.GU ~2 Date Signed s-~Yo 3 Resident's Address and Unit: ..3801 rJ E: ?,ol .>T APT.so I .4 Vf,/'I TV M FL 3.3180 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Com".., t,t.l' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerba(~h, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~{).A Signature Scoff.D. BueL, Date Signed S})!)6 "3 . Resident's Address and Unit: 3,/00 NE.(C;2-<yr. ()r1;{tI/D7 All"'''' ~~Cr I Ie.. .3 3/ y t) RECEiVED M~~ 27 1.UU1 ell'( CLE.RK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMM ~",. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Signature Ajb/~~/a!frb Date Signed 0- /1-173 Resident's Address and Unit: 11333 cJ ~b; ~~ ~~/ -0L RECEIVED MAY 7 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: COmmISSIOnerS City Manager COI>>/" 'Y'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date Signed 5 ~\\ \03 Resident~ Name ~~, j~ne~ Resident's Address and Unit: 0, S'AJ ~'\~ L' tL~ ~1 l:- rZ;"I{o RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/>>"'1 (yv' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed B.e.:;-sj G.-t"aber' ~~ Resident's Address and Unit: 5' - ~ 2...-03 ;J 0(,,-\ 0 g o..y C-\-. LAn.t 3 3.3 l1y~ f=L ~ \~ c) l.. RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C-oM/I'l De"" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob I>iamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature 1',e.Y1ee Y1 l)' Es"l" -,,0 -\:);5'" Date Signed ~j" J6~ Resident's Address and Unit: 33rn Wl, \9131- ~t-, #31 d- ~QI ~L- 331~O RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Av.entura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.t!"'''''' De'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~rha~)'J - \ Date Signed - "r kl ~ ('II ATf1.-.I-~WS ~//~/~; Resident's Address and Unit: ;l/! ~ ( W~/J/fUVh lYt a 1/ ,~~:;El 39/ 8' 0 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Av.entura, FL 33180 . . cc: COmmISSIOnerS City Manager C/O ",,"1 l:X v- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(~ (vj 1Zo;J <t;;~ / Resident's Address and Unit: dv9os/eeJJlfrPC! '3/;1 frVhtJ;AiZ~) c;t j3//iJ RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C;aM"1 ry",. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~'J-..:r-l s>o~Y\f\N b~~ ~Oh~M....,) Date Signed .{( IV! <73 cl 1>-10'3 Resident's Address and Unit: fOOO I ~ Ic.~o RI...). 110:' AJ~Vl l.I\ , Fl 1~It.O RECEIVED MAV 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager ~I"l/YI t:.l II. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ;2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature kQ- Date Signed fRf!rI/<.. LEVi . , }~\<W1 ~""j '-1- y- (J-0 \)-- -A--o~ Resident's Address and Unit: JC7S- /If, Co v4- Cl v(! .0(.<" /100-3 Ibco~ RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMM b,e.l. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) ~J I ~(l) yc. e LI;ad;-8/'; ( Resident's Address and Unit: 3~f0d) {)J~~J~I 1JvvJ~ F! <-)3/ b 0 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COI'>"" IY.I- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~t(S) Na~ .J... ~y c:>:.....so..-. . ---D &-Je 1<;se- I nature Resident's Address and Unit: J0c90-:):.S\~ ~~Jo, '1\1.1.-;0)- Ri:~L.::: v..., <;L. ) RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoI'1M (:)-(<I' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name C A,; fU)lz.-. ~'I 'Z AV\ \ v~ Date Signed s:fi9/cn Resident's Address and Unit: ~ocx) IS;.\~ -e\u~ 4D'::J... ~~~I-+1 ~ \J,=>u RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager LPNVn ('y'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed 'StsQA D,JAJ.OjS[ ~ tjUlvtD)J"1 ~ 5, 22. D~ 5.2.-2.0~ Resident's Address and Unit: -. TOLERANCE ~ Sara Dumont Apt 301 2600 Island Blvd A ventura, FL 33160 RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager tolYltvJ l\< J. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat,2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. adent(s) Name .).J _ '$/A_. Signature a.v _~/ Date Signed 5 ~ :Z)-(Y~ Resident's Address and Unit: - ~/9/ ?a~rl 01 ~~ag- a ?-'PM'd./lL I 11. 3 ~ 2 (j RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C OMIV\ ()I'"' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ;2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name f~G~ /~~ yf,,~t( f:-~I3~ Signature Date Signed j1-;/tJL 5JJ--l) 63 Iuv y P,?ES5 ~6!t(iF L .'%c-.SS- Resident's Address and Unit: 3?~ .j),n/ fitJ !2v~qfuA q " ..1...0 d RECEIVED MAY? 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,,,,,,, (y", To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~gnature <_Jl!L1L~CU Date Signed f; Iff (02) S CJs Ai\1 Gff\) Gfi R- Resident's Address and Unit: 1-~oo !~, 'Klllct rfFjlfo1 !tv~~ l+e' 33/(;JJ RECEIVED MAY 27 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of A ventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 C .......r\1ssioners CC: OUUUJ. City Manager l<.. -aI C OIl'ff1'1.X . To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: .:2.30? 7oocJ:CslltiJfJ BIU.b RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK *Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: commissioners City Manager , ~e 1/. (;OMM l.) To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name R rJ T7+ ~ f\{. r< S If t./{jt) tT1'I ~ ~AJA.--- ( Date Signed ~ v(. UJU3 Resident's Address and Unit: :<. (, () () I 5 '-f'rrv D t3 t--J D 90 I RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK e2z~~ :;e Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMM f'yJ, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat Z Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name k V JJ.rt3.~ff/llt1+t/ aignat~ bU( Date Signed ?~ca6 Resident's Address and Unit: <kJo /;;/IPJJ.,c?73J\flb A-v?1l~{.l~ _,!J_ qoc. RECEIVED MAY 2 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co",,,,,, lYv- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~(wa;vf /I{(71",) /~(~t1 )/~ Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: }(POTJ f5t/ll ;five{ ?'J16tJ C( ,,/1-;>>5 f!v'('7 {arCi , PI y / RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co '>11k (XV< Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Ozwv ~~ JiAvilt ?elWiM Resident's Address and Unit: 30C{O NE I~osr .:/t.3/( h.;WiVM - h,. .:5.3/ fO Date Signed S;1Q/o 3 Of; /.(0, !o!> , RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co-?o/11 ty~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Naualah W~. Signature Jllf Date Signed /i(6ltj Pi; an3 v Resident's Address and Unit: ZOIFS t. Ceunlry CI.ah !x.c,ve ~)r-L. RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COt'Vl/VI be~, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 'PRA^,~ j, V&M, &-0 ~~ft(~~ 0, k11lrco Date Signed shOo 7/ )... 00 ') sf?.? /2(0) Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 ~ ISL;;N~ bLtJiJ #-3/0l A Vf~l~ YL. 33J foO RECEIVED MlIV 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 cc: Commissioners City Manage. to"""'" t}ev. Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. #tl-tCcYt-,;') i3~I~f( III Resident(s) Name - ( !fLeXI}' b~f(R.lr{ fY\ o.\.lVl-eW 6-eY-n+t Residenfs Address and Unit: - -- ' "2--h i;'o/s [..1Nb &VD~ lf05 frlrt1/ivl?11 r-L 3'3/60 0/7.-) !()> Date Signed ~/:r~ / 0 -; S/z'J /0'3 . . ..J/'-..", /crS RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co.","" be"'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ----1:t~\r\le..'f j:ere<c> " <R, I(a~ flu !Iii k Date Signed 5bL/h;, ~/)tf!o ~ Resident(s) Name Resident's Address and Unit: ).(0 IYOnJC1~ gl.,t ;).301 ~ 33[(,,0 RECEIVED MAY ?R 2003 CITY CLERK Ma~ 17 03 05:44p Norman Nepo 908-789-8662 p.l Mail To: Tile City COlllml8sioa of Aveatura 19200 Welt CO.ltry CI.b DriYe Aveatura, Fl, 33180 ~c: Commissioners City Manager CO"""" t::,ev. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow COllllllbsioDer u.ury Holzberg. Seat J COIIIIDWioner MaDay C,...lIIab, Seat 2 CommihloDCI' Bob Dia.oad., Sut 3 CommisaioDer Jay R. Besldll. Seat .. CODuaissloaer Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Com.issloaer Ken Cob e.. Seat 6 Dear Mayor }>e.-Iow and Coauaissioaers of tile Cily or Ave.tura: As a resident or Aveahln, I am stroDely opPOSed to the establish..ftlt or a S)'U&ogue iD the residential buildl.,. UOO Islaad Boalevard. Vnit CU-J aad urge you to vote IEaiast tlte cODditioaal use appliattion ~t will ilia k. lbb ase POlIsible. Thank you. Residellt(s) Name ,~. X).r.'~.;'/j'/'I /fr-:c-f<) /Y~/,d-:'- //rr;/) Signata ~./.. /.'.___' ( ~- ./ ~ . . / .t, ."_ _ . ..,\/ '; )---...,..,-".., -;_J-/~r U Date SirDed ,,~/I .' In :.~ / , I '--I ,"'(,,:: , , Residi!llt's AddrellS and Valt: ~),'-.)? -:::~;-.:_.... II!,. 13>_ /;. f'~ ~.- .-, .- L-' () I RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CITY CLERK .vlail Tu; The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager eoMIlo [yV' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Cum missioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 l)earYlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: \s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a S\ lIaguglle in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I a lid 1I rgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, R.esidellt(s) Name Signature Date Signed ~ ~~c..\\~~. Co~\A~-c..o ~~t_ , Residenr's Address and Unit: ,3qOCL:r:'.s~..f\t->~ ~'-\l\) ~ \S\.'-:L~~ -CS~~\J ~-.208 RECEIVED MAY? 8 2003 CITY CLERK .Ylail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Clu b Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co""'''''' \:)l" lu: l\i1ayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 ('ummissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Cum missioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear .Ylayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: -\s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a S\ lIagugue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l a nu LI rgl' you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this LIse possible. Thank yuu, I{csident(s) Name Signature Date Signed /3Ei/FRLV C().r~ /<,~~ {}.:JIh~ 5// S/ (93 Resident's Address and Unit: 3 qPQ_S \' LJHA) lL) ~lVD, l) Q. 0 g ()1LWA-/vl ( r ~ L.7f-K1LJ RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager to M"" \::)e ",. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 14 ~,^V') \( \" uVv'\ b ':7 Signature Date Signed j/~/~ S-b-O~ ./ Resident's Address and Unit: SDrDO h,lf:I""J t3\v d . 8-3o~ APe,--,-iu,,~ RECEIVED =F1"$3IbD M~V 28 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: COmmissioners City Manager COM"" f.YoJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~7 14 ..., r /) .. --.1 t f;;?/J.e/()c.,o,. !fU;?J;j--l'tL. L;,...e__9-L/.IJ./tJI?& /A:U'lw:z,.J~LG.Ht (}?'t../ Date Signed S;~~') 57/j;:{? 3 , . Resident's Address and Unit: ?/jet) ~~#{ ~ . Ifz~ :1-( 33/w I RECEIVED MAY 2 B 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager 0oM/11 IY". To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name SigJl~lUre r::.J . htv4-IW SeHU/1J/1!l/. ~~ Date Signed -<;t(Jc? . Resident's Address and Unit: 3/00 ~~W t3{1o I /~) L~k 37/~ / RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM/YI De.;. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name. ~ ~i I,ture pi ,C}o'/Oll/J kk4-MA/i2- ~ ~ Date Signed \(/';3)3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3~oo 754)))d/vJJ ~1I:J()Y~ Av/t---luA/7, ft -i-;3/' (.) RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager Co /l-lA1 Dell' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~dent(s) Name Z:~~ ~J) )e'l fler,/ II- Resident's Address and Unit: 67JiJ ~Ut CJ.;)f RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CC"7/11 \':t./. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~t! 4~~J Date Signed ~i~~j Resident's Address and Unit: d1~ k1~};v', (/ CII) I RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co".."'" ~.J' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name <; ,,;, \ (-- ~~~ Sj::: ~ I Date Signed G /17/03 Resident's Address and Unit: By trV L:;\AV\ct hlvcJ t;./\ l\~ o-~ s. lsl~,)of /3-307 33'(,,0 RECEIVED MAY 2 8 2003 CITY CLERK 7000 Island Blvd" Unit 2002 Aventura, FL 33160 May 11, 2003 Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FI 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: I am a registered voter in the City of Aventura and a resident of Williams Island, I would like to voice my strong opposition to the establishment of a synagogue in the 2600 Building on Williams Island. This is a residential area. and I believe that a religious organization of any faith or denomination does not belong in this location, We would have seriously reconsidered our decision to purchase here had we known that these plans exi sted, I oppose the establishment of the synagogue for the reason that our private residential area should not be used for any non,residential purpose which is not owned and operated by the Property Owners of Williams Island, It is for this reason that the Property Owners are currently attempting to negotiate the purchase of the Williams Island Clubs from the developers, Allowing another use which is not controlled by the residents would be counter-productive to these efforts. The security and peaceful co,habitation of the residents is my primary concern, I had planned to attend the May 6. 2003 meeting to address this issue and will make every effort to attend the rescheduled meeting on June 3, 2003, I appreciate your consideration of my views when voting on the matter. Sincerely, [J ~ I~, fv U$ Jo-An B. Evans Cc: Zev Auerbach, Commissioner Jay Beskin. Commissioner Ken Cohen, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Commissioner Manny Grossman, Commissioner Harry Holzberg. Commissioner Erick M, Soroka, City Manager Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager QoI'1I"1 ty". To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~ l1U~~ Signature (j( I 'If) (/ L 2- I ';9,,"}/ Date Signed -r)jID? , Resident's Address and Unit: J IO,S1J j1/ E ? X'~~ ~.//'>< iAA--?.d)-):;.( 2 /'.1 Z () - I RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club-Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Comm \).e'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: . As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name }1~ d~ ,-/ r;:;;~ Date Signed 5J ;/03 / Resident's Address and Unit: :2(0 fo ;J$UJrliA-ct:' ~~ fi 33 ff/() 3[20 :3 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (};/l1"" D-eJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner .Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit cU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Re.td..t(.j Nam~ /};;fIf!).f ~, -Zlt.~ ~~ Date Signed C~ f-€3 Resident's Address and Unit: RECEIVED MA~ 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Cot>t/l1. Dt'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~J1~ 5~1/~ Signature Date Signed ~M//ft:;U 5,~-?4Z5 Resident's Address and Unit: .J;!~d 4.k/lL,dJf;~ fit/ ,. ~, ~i: f/ .!41h:t-f'f?g~ ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/>1/1o ~!'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name P. /,"' j,\~R\~ im10 Signature ~tO~-l f'~ Date Signed 7 - ~~ (}) ~ Resident's Address and Unit: L!I~ 1)1 1J, f 31 00<\J~ A-!> he'! tvv-E";['A-R9t f. L, ~~I G C7 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"" \)tJ, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed :,-/11/0 J U-(;~If ~f1(~ Resident's Address and Unit: JON 1/c ref) u.~ ..21 It~ h. ..J]/~O I RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Cluh Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoMIVl t::e J. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 ' Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature G'fS7/(GE CT, 13/~oCJks (h/--}i2~!)g Date Signed s:: '1-tL3 Resident's Address and Unit: l..g0() TI/v4JVj) '6>-VP 'Pit- 4 ;4 VbtJtvlUt-; ?-L 3316~ RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK .vlail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 0/11"" tyJ, To: :V1ayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 ' Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear :Vlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: -\s a resident of Aventura, 1 am strongly opposed to the establishment of a \\ nagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will ma ke th is use possible. Thank you, Kesidellt(s) Name Signature Date Signed tflf,6fl<./..l c-,~bn:fE()NIx:) ~~'~~ S -I 0 - 2CJ 0 ~ Resident's Address and Unit: 3_0- 4. '\ I-" l%fLL.t't: 1- C:L- tf{3 f<;;Of.Jrruf-C-^ fL- 3'3t80 / RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"""/>"< De v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit cU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R..'d<nt(.) Name. lathre 4//'5/11 .f sY/).~/'~~ ~~ '<.J Date Signed .5-- /:1.-M Resident's Address and Unit: 1000 i.I~ ~, q,...;. /-5'/ 0 a l......:z~ r:%..3-3 /,;;0 I RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ""4"7 bev. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name 6 Bi '1~5fl.(? p//JMIf)i ~AtJvvuCIM. V ~ 1(4)~ 8~CVI1.. Date Signed 5~/03 5"/Jft;tJ3 Resident's Address and Unit: / ~~O t,.tJ1cud WJ I tI. Aft J.LI-tJlI tWP~(), (I 33/~v RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/l1M iYlI' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ANN R-I1U1tilf' Signature ~~ Date Signed ~//2- /03 Resident's Address and Unit: J~ ~~ 3cJ0 ~, tJf2- 53(0-6 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co...."" b-t'v'. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a' synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 5'1). R~#L;j , Signature ~f4-LL Date Signed s;J/io3 Resident's Address and Unit: q~ N, w- I St36 ~ ~- 3Jlteco ( RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club-Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Cow'" De'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name LJCiffl ~ 60 ks Signature o4tm~ Date Signed .s:-'j-oJ Resident's Address and Unit: 2'iS{)() IsLi'rWP J?W.D 1i1 If ,AVErJtUkfr; it-- 53160 RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/l'lM ~V' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Date Signed ,5' JJ f) J 1)3 / .. Resident(s) Name (;A(6.J LT LJJ,)frrJ9rt1?# Resident's Address and Unit: 3'7 LI S N e 200 #je/tl'pff t ~fwP PI 5J!fV J RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l1/VJ te v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~o ~~J Signature 0).~~~?~~ Date Signed .1) / 1 2 / 7:J)T) 3 J . . Resident's Address and Unit: ~bOD '}.'S~ttQ~ ~\\j~ "'2. 3>o..,r- t;::\0~\0{L.A- '33/bU RECEIVED MAY I 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C~I11M (yv" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat;z. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 'OHG.<>DClf.[ RIJP,vI1"'(/{V Signature Q'Ak~ Date Signed :'-/~!D3 Resident's Address and Unit: ;<7170 5JI-,J.f'J) fJtVD :3 017 'V Auf rJ1lJ r<.j). , (t ! :u t/;V RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: COmmISSlOners City Manager CO"""'" tyv' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name (!.titfrc0 to/ltJog4 ...... Signature (~----re~ Date Signed ~-lcJ-(J~ Resident's Address and Unit: &er~ a.., (!o efJo!5' A IrJO (J APT d.-3/3- RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CIOIl11>< ~.... To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Si nature Date Signed .,JoVCE bAJr .s:- /0 - tJ 3 I lift L 2EL H,d./ ,6'-0- /,;1- d 3 Resident's Address and Unit: :1 D t) 0 /lt~/;5hj YrJ& RECEIVED 3000 ~~~J PtJ0 MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 o 0 . cc: COrm:mSSlOnerS City Manager Co/"..... t:Y v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventur3, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~b~ l~"'-\<"-J k'CLrc Y") R<<-J<=-,_ Resident's Address and Unit: leoe> \,I<<-......J....!Av.l. 0, '-L'~r :r::;f~, Signature Date Signed ~~~~/~-~ ..:ft:2D } k, 33/,- 2l RECEIVED MAY 1 3 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (0""'" ty./, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed s/14/CS ;;/14))3 . 3" 05@. ~eR.. J-tILbff ~~ Resident's Address and Unit: :;JbOO tSLt11JO ~LUD j..EQz..- AUetlhtcvPl. 33JbO . RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK ._'~'~-_~"'_______".'___"'__~_'_____'._____._~__.n.__"_"__"..~~_ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (0/11"" (yol' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. sident(s) Name ~ /(h!cUJ Date Signed S- 7-()3 Resident's Address and Unit: jg(N,7g 3/5r CJ /S76 t}UA ~/ ~, ,i5;;;3/t:CJ RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK , cc: Commissioners City Manager ('0"""" ~f';' Mail To: Tbe City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner .Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Scat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As II resident of Aventura,l am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogucin the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU~1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ';I,:::, ~"J Resident(s) Name Signature tf/;//!uf'L 5iL UtR5'/c IN' ~ )Y._~~ Date Signed ~ 13A> 3 Resident's Address and Unit: '"'" ',':>' 3~~~ ~ 33/U 11)06 RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK -.--_.._..._----~ Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager {Io,.,,/>? (yv' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name ~A( II\J~J~f$J Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: 39()() ~/1>> ~ P~B W1l1~!1}, ~ RECE\VEO MA~ '6 2003 C\T't' CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Cc /YJ />1 C:;e ,/, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 1. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ""v 11 b- _ '" _ " <' .? /) r;f~7,",",,"1h"-~ ~.~ ..,e:. ,- ,'~. ~.,^--- ~ Signature 11'/)". <?~.cCo C'7~')tcfc>'\, I Date Signed ,~~ I Resident's Address and Unit: / tfr't> "1 .i,\ f/ .,' ' . -'/.,,~:-,.j" j Ii I ,,/./ '~-7 ) -,r " RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"'/>1 [yol' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. .., Resident~Name fe..1-~,t" ~.. .' ~~j?ature . :{ tf~f\ (j ."'/ Date Signed S. tf>~ 6~) Resident's Address and Unit: ~. (j tJJ:/Jl ~~)J I 7 0 Ii ~ f"\ K,L,-"I' ~ ~j J-..... f). II I , ~~) V 'lie /- v......... . RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,'I1/01 ty,j" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed /hII<IArh ~ ~jylfr5:~ ~-_/ !)- 13-03 VtJ;.j/Yc?./?oj); I/YS '~L;L-_ S-- 11- 0 ~ Resident's Address and Unit: If) O[),~ ~, S-/J If RECEiVED M~Y '6 1.003 CITY CLERK 05/14/03 11:21 FAX 52511188 tal 02 -_.--- Mail To: The City Co..iIalou of Ave.tura 19200 Wat Coa:atry Club Drive A Yeatura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Ccll?i>' (yV' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commisaloaer Harry Hobber,. Seat 1 CODumssioaer MaIUlY Grossma.. Seat 2 Commissloaer Bob DillmoDd. Seat 3 . CODllllissloner Jay R. Besldll, Seat 4 CommissioDer Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner KeD CoheD, Seat Ii Dear Mayor Perlow and CommlssloDers or the City of AveDtura: A.. a resident of Ave"tura, r am strongly opposed to tile establilbment of a !Yaegoaue In the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote apillllt the eoad,doDal use application that will make this uu possible. Thank you. Resident(.) Name ?? . ~ ,d;) /1<:'0 /I'(o/'( -=:J?e1 do A- ,p..J <:::/,0", ~5:?Y?e~<-. c:5~-. :- .~~g ~~. ,~$;~I Date Signed ~ ; /y- 2"'<-'3 Resident's Addreas aDd Unit: .-Z60CJh~nd"G'Ie/. Hv,"'" ;/V~ V:~f -;/ .,296Y RECE\'lEO "'b.'1 ,\) 2UU3 Cli'l' CLERK ".;....~..,~>'"',-"........~_.. '"' "'".""-'~""'''''''"''~'''--'''"'''''--''-''''''''''"'''''''-'-._--. w ""_...__.._...~,._,'.,,. ....", '" "U"."'_.". Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager 00111111 ~.;, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name sr A..., h'V1.{.,.J Signature M-:r D U"""',,-- Date Sig,ned \~?/4J Resident's Address and Unit: 30~i) ~5() ~- RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Cor""." '\:)ell To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~~t( dr .,(LlzttF~z{; " Date Signed 5'7 f/6J3 , Resident's Address and Unit: 'i~~ ,f to' fI) z): 2/ I J:;;LrL4 u "'"'! -, '} P , ,() ""'- ! ' RECEIVED MAY 1 6 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club-Drive Aventura, FL 33180 -:c: Commissioners City Manager Co/l1/1t fJe 1/' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~CbJ) v~ Da~ r~l~ 3 Resident's Address and Unit: ZCl{oo l,.,) ,( ~ q . IX t\: ~ cC\ \ A~c.. \=-\ '33 ~G RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COn1~ Dr ,j- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed 50 qo 0 ~ \ Resident's Address and Unit: ~q\5S 'TUkvi\!tb d[;t /JU w piCA F{j) J3/ tJ RECEIVED MAY f 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO"l-/"" fY'..... To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of A ventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~15 /:>. Sv"1T/v Signature Date Signed \s/f !o 3 ~ 7fOdQ{ Resident's Address and Unit: 3 0flo ~fJo-I~1 ~ ,;(03 RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/>1""1 be"" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~vtY/O LtCj97'O G'{ ()th V\.lA- Le{q; V Date Signed ~{O.l()~a 7n~/O.~V3 Resident's Address and Unit: 8@oo Island /3((/d :#J9tJ:J ;1. ~18C!h. H...-33J60 RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~A, ~vI To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Ii t<:.THV 1Lj]~/-rfh1.. ) Date Signed sf 105 Resident's Address and Unit: ?fico ~o 7]L-Vi) ;3l-alj RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l1/>\ ~V' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name UirJll-l',r+ ~,V~t: L Signature ~,JV "d Resident's Address and Unit: ;;2..1, \" 0 R,~~ Vt-AC(' r~bJ- ~v ~T1> iLl=\. fL ~~( ~o RECEIVED MAY 1 4 200J CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Gollo"" tt v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, ~~ D.t,~g Resident's Address and Unit: 31" ,-~.I#V ~I RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CD""fi1 ~.J. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, < +:'?!OYrL Date Signed 5/7/o,~ ~ / Resident's Address and Unit: 3 ?oo I6/(}.rtd /3/[;0/. ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK vlail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM/J1. ~", [u: !V1ayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear :vlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: .-\s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, R.esident(s) Name .5!:\0L J;'", J J p /Z~~ Date Signed S' - Cj' -03 Resident's Address and Unit: uQO? Ij/& Jh:t!JI ~ FL S';;J4{) ~f?OI RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK ylail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO-11~ b.t,), To: Mayur Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Cum missioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: -\s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a "naguglle in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. kesident(s) Name e[/(IV1~ ~ Signature ;j~aQ./ . Date Signed /' t:9 -cJ '3 Resident's Address and Unit: _t.:fdl Jf:~1\1 SI---~/915---- 41/ .e /'I ru 12.,P- :3 3/0() RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK 'ylail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Clu b Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COIl1M D,eJ, lu: 'Vlayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Cum missioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Cum missioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Cum missioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear ;Vlayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: .-\s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a s\ naguguc in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, R.esident(sJ Name Signature hi (tOri gel:: /~Ir\h4 heh. (j{~'7 Date Signed 5: 9-0 3 Resident's Address and Unit: -#' d_ 2. 'ifS:/ /V ~ (?~~ j &L ---/O(J ( ~3/6 d _J J/f?;V' I- u 1.4 RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Vlail Tu: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 I I cc: ComnnSSlOners City Manager CO/fl"1 ~v lu: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Cum missioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 l)ear \1ayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: -\s a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a "nagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 "nd urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank YOU, c. let ( r'( SfoA"J l H,esidcnt's Address and Unit: 8.tPL/"I ~ lK3~t- fNWu,a. (2, ~71 b(J ) fCI/S , RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 , , CC: ComnusslOners City Manager CO/ll/l? ~eil' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name !fr& SWIYP-vlU Signature ~~~~ Date Signed ~... !(~~ "3 Resident's Address and Unit: ,s 0 0 0 .:tL ( :, L- ~ 13 L-\i 1) ..z ~o ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/"l-"" be v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed 5/;;/0'1 Resident's Address and Unit: ~'hn ~Lu4 ~ 1fr2) OJ RECEIVED MAV 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~MNl ~u.r, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. R,,'d.nt(,) Nam. ~. Jy;fd/#Y /.,#t4~/JN. .. Date Signed ~;hf It>--s Resident's Address and Unit: 202?/ Et&C/&/pAf:// 4ffft#}12c 5"3/.Sb RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoI"1fY' ~,/' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~R.LEN ~ Y'EfuNA. Sign~~re ~ym~ Date Signed 5(~~ Resident's Address and Unit: O?lm 1~hcJ-... ~ ~~ f!.- .33rCe6 hot RECEIVED MAV 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM"" De,;< To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Re~ident(s) Na~e ~t~. Z\\.e"" G\e\c,,^evkw.c ~ Date Signed s/5'/o3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~o(r)f,G~~Ql.(.bD-- #/702-.- RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club 'Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager 0>/l1,M t>eJ. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Co kcte. l; rhn an Signature ~-UJ~ Date Signed ~-I-O=. Resident's Address and Unit: .l~oo 1~Qj)d ~eud If 100-:() RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . Cc: ConumsslOners City Manager CO/1'l/1'l I;:yJ, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .J.,.~l'\ G:' ross Signature ~ ~-.{- (/ / Date Signed ~~ ~q7a;.3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3f'ol N-t, ao~J!/+fa?b/ ~~. 331r~ RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive , Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co I>' ..... ':::e,), To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~V\ \-1 P-eA~ Date Signed 70!c J Resident's Address and Unit: f~ :J;;euJ. 1 L v{[) #-c2'/ot , fN.'-<AcIv~ /f. ])/r., (I' RECEIVED MAY 1 4 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager COMM t::t>v. Dear Mr, Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible, Thank you, Building: tf:/M) Unit #: 3'0 7 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager C;QMJ"J1. be"'> Dear Mr. Mayor & Conunissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible, Thank you. ;W Name: Building: I {)W Unit #: SO,! . RECEIVED MAY 1 'l 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co ","" \:)11", To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature V, ~tl/)tI Sfr't/lflJYVJ ~&?J7/J6t~ Date Signed 7Jlo:( ~)dPtrg cJIt17 k;jJJb Resident's Address and Unit: 6 tJtJO ~ Ju, lJ6 cOOO JkJa;ut /Jkl I/~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO.'YIM De&!. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1. Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name if ,fer~ 1AJA--/(J-e/ Signature IL i.~ Date Signed J~ 7/0 3 Resident's Address and Unit: J 9 () ~ / {C-.t;v-?J /J { v U ;{ ~ 0 3 1~1lA-1 JJ t' 0 ' RECEIVED MAY 1 7 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co /11 /l1 (yv, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name t. ~W\~,:tTC".'r \-\~yv Signature ~ Date Signed .>- ...... 0 ~ --- Resident's Address and Unit: 1..800~ ~2,/()r ~+,rv..~ ~~\~ 0 RECEIVED MAY 17. 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Corr,/VI ~l/. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat '). Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature /-1.4YLvEL.L. W~oFF JJV\ Ovf(JJ~ W fN61 X )1(S. LUci:::.lJo t";.::: c5}L&,,-,-- '-[U-&~ Date Signed S-/<I/o3 , J~/ /<th2 Resident's Address and Unit: J & ::zs- AJ CC".Jh.~c.,-q,j) ~-h.uc.'L '::fz.... 33/.kJ -:tI:= (' J'03 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK cc: Commissioners City Manager C.o/></h ~J. Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name fJ ~f2.I\p.J U,~ M1r~L/ Resident's A7\ess and Unit: ~~7) r\ l "II iJ{)WJ ~ {+f DJIJl2 4- ~2JSt Date Signed f))' ot-D '7 oS - Olf-O} ~p I "1--- 0 1--- RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager L.O,."./VI be v . To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. , Date Signed O~\O'\:\03 \ Resident(s) Name lh, az.f\1.fffi-J) W E I N ST f:: IN Resident's Address and Unit: ~~~~ ~ ~\} ~I\\ "t..t.c..., ~ ~~\ rl-. 33\~o RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Com"" I::::lll" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S<O~~""" ~~~ Date Signed j\l\\e~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~L\~\~,~~~ ~\~ ~ ~ <h. ~~\~~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/VIl'> DeLI. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name (JMUr,() k-U..;-AJ Signature ~~ Date Signed o/~3 Resident's Address and Unit: '3'~oo Hytf-fC- ~(....r6 ])4- AV6v{ul).{ 1't.. ~71fd fFf 70'/ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/"ltT'l be", To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name &- Iw,//>>Y',r ~#" , / Date Signed 1~~ Resident's Address and Unit: fv~t.1 ~ VAn..", Tel//' :q;&I,3 / I 3h 7( N e. t! All-- &P'bM tv /l.,d /::.JAJ ~ "'t I j) - RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 C I I CC: OmIl1lSS100ers City Manager CoM'" t:{i/. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat f. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Residen~ame -j)....t-Cv [(C{f(,j Signature Date Signed ~ !y!v] ~~- Resident's Address and Unit: I),c/( 1uflC1K>) '21 tJ( RECEIVED MAV 1 ? 2003 CITY CLERK. 1~1r,w \JV'-'hl ((VI} IJA- fJ v (,;-;....n tI f (- 3 3 / J't> Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COM#' be",. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat? Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name NC355 e #()hffi f Signature /Iv/iAtj }PN- / Date Signed -fJ;f3 Resident's Address and Unit: ~?1;-tftt 'p~ /h7 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/YI"1 ~". . To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name !:rf..:IH-U~ /{ Lf /hAV rJZ~ Date Signed Jj 0103 Resident's Address and Unit: / q /0 ( f\YhfC. PiP f;fz. /7(( RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK l\(je~u(2A (L 53 I rO Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.o/YI-'" Deli, To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 'SJA- "I M ~ ::J A IZ k'/7v /z:;: r Date Signed ~&) Resident's Address and Unit: j () V () 0 W. ('t9N"^-ziZ.-()..0 A J~ 1 j{/V\.-f~~ :l~ 3~}~O / RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager ~f!)/'11'1 ~II. . To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat f. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ~!I1L . Date Signed 7Ikv If }oo3 Resident's Address and Unit: '3~3Q ~en.J;~~ to~ a~~, ~3/'?o I RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co,...",.,., be II. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit cU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name J.p..cq()C~ R'1 ~ leJ ~: ~'.'"_. Resident's Address and Unit: 3ooo1:s~ iB L-ud .#- 2- ""L01..--- ~Gc.J1V4- 331b 0 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager [OM"" ~iJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name j)"t,/v~JO! - f( , I=-- ft1, LJ)~.....6 J (/) AM Signature /)w~ )(~_ Date Signed s:/ '1/ tJ.3 Resident's Address and Unit: ;LcJ I tJ-() Lv, ~ CL4. .Iflt -#-1/&:9.,. RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co (Y\ /VI tx'''', To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 111rlZn \ ~ ~f1 ~ e U Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: -EiO-1 LlUl~G {llk ' -ftiJ8IJJ#t Vi, ~~ I?'J ) ~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Com'" btv. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ,,",KIF etrlJ. .R.L4- WVC?d/A- Date Signed S~/oJ Resident's Address and Unit: j(7r" NeIl.. OJL LOOI/ if l/ eN h tl 4- J P t- 3 31 rftJ r RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/11/>1 be';' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat f Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name "v~lvs ,'):,Oe./?;Nc, 1.; ~.{e J.OfI(:.. VJ(Jif? 1'N6f Sig>>ature \ ~ fUAJ " ~ tlt;J~c; -; Date Signed ~/r:J.r/03 , ()q (),f/ OJ Resident's Address and Unit: . .. &,O() I'{Wf~ 4?J-V,h. .;)JftJIf 11 YeN 17/ R17. Ft- . RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager to/l""" bu' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name /.$01) E PS TEl" A tr.LtiDvE E.Are>,J Signature df-m~~ ~e~ Date Signed 5~ S'm'QJ Resident's Address and Unit: '2 PI '1/ E. (!()GlNr~'/b-"" 'bit :lfli':;~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (J;rnm ty v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit cU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name It? ./(/1 P U1 ^' Si.gn..a ture ...~.. ,,"/J 4~//. ~ Date Signed Y'4/~ Resident's Address and Unit: / t:JrJo ~U .r~ of( RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co .'Y1/l1 De .t ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name 6/~R~h. V --\!ell1?-E//jE,f. Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: .37 31d/ eiJtl.-AJ1lC.,v d,,/3 ~ dlr: -I (z % j}tlWTZII?r?;Ii: 5'3! E tJ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/YI"'l ()-tv" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ;2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name G:~oJ ?'O('1yuJf Date Signed JEJ -~C(-tJlj Resident's Address and Unit: !)b -S- r ') {. (!&uu/+~t t fU1JJl!L jJ tt I Y f~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/"1/Y1 De v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat.2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(f1Name 1frnAl-i VoLi\~ff (~14 Date Signed ::; t-f -03 Resident's Address and Unit: '1fo7S- .DJJ}iJrv!C{<J~ p~ 4 -(000' ~ iW 7LJ rz.,c-- _ rr=C ~?7 L ".?D , RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO/l1'" t:,eol' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-1 and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~ Signature Date Signed 4~;( Y!.-Jt-l frio L)..~t:t6- rf; /0 7 I Resident's Address and Unit: I g--,0 ,)J G 3/ C__t ~ iff iFf00 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COfl"'" ~eJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name RlfiI. lVOL ;=:'sOI../ szu~ Date Si ned ,) 7~3 Resident's Address and Unit: / ~!g/ Nt ~6t- 1;2 ?/~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK ft'j/t".-?~~ -# 33/bO Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COIl1t>1 ~eol. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name f{\ AA~Wr\ l~:,8E'",I{6-1f Signature M~,~!u+- Date Signed s/lf/o 3 Resident's Address and Unit: , UAJ~r 1101 RECEIVED MAY 1 '1 2003 CITY CLERK ~ E) I 0 0 w. @.,9 ~ AJT~'1 e L-. b g Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . Cc: COmnnSSlOnerS City Manager CO/l'l111 lyll' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ;;;;;;;Na;'hs67 ~ Date Signed 5/fL/;'3 Resident's Address and Unit: :J.,f)/Pf) ItJ, (!Pt//fJ~y tLvB/k /bcb IlI/t:;A/W~~) 7-LI 3~/?~ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager eLl"''''' I)e"" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat f. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name '6"'t<!.f/'Ate~ F; 06(55 Signature ;;1 fl~1-.v~ Date Signed ~1./..12.-0<0 Resident's Address and Unit: 3 Coo ~ 1~ At~ ~, ~.P. 331fb II< C;03 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: ComnnSSlOners City Manager to,rllr'l ~('" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Ze_nt(s) Name ~e. J . ;t 9- /Le.UtJ?f4>> I ~,~,i~..#:1P t#tv,tlJ 9&d//M<. ~~,oI.-c Date Signed ~_I/- t/3 5=1/-()..3 Resident's Address and Unit: ,;(p I ftetk,1jd//4, ( I ~ /,9~6 1/ RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aveotura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co/l"'/YI be.. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed m~~9\c <::S\ro0)) 1V\ '---0--' ~~ ')\ ~ ('t)j \ ........... Resident's Address and Unit: 1.1000 v0, 3;:..~~9~ tV)1 b, fl\SC ,,~~ \'<\) ~L . 3 "JI \. 0 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aveotura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: CormmSSlOners City Manager CoI\1M ~(V' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~esident(s) Name, . ~~c~rt~ &:. 1J1 i;J)j gnatur~-e~ Date Signed 119 Resident's Address and Unit: c2tO/f) ~J ~~ #AP~ , ~rJL- _~3IU{) / RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoI>>I"I ()e J. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident's Address and Unit: ~oo J;j I ~ '-~ -'(lId it----lfO;r !tWJ,T-U(,\ fLf\ J3 (b 0 RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aveotura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C.Om/VI ~ev'. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, 1 am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature ET)/TH t!?J4-f2,;0 ~~ 0~ 5~MFQ €fJ .0: B-1 ",cr/ Ah/ f71V.4~ Date Signed ~/~~3 . S/?'/O :5 " " Resident's Address and Unit: ---- !~ (()~ '30075 <;; [at1Lt tJ Ivd ~ ~ , AVenfura. .Ff 33/Gd' I RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 CC: Commissioners City Manager CoI'>INl ()e". To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat ~ Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. ~~ ~~n~ture~. Date Signed ~ ~~d/k ~/:r?3 Resident's Address and Unit: ;<~;?5?51t/ ~,t2/&: -r 1/ /? ~ 2' 3.3/c?c7 / / RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission.of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Comt>1 ~ev' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat J. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature !LiEl/?,If t.lJ. 2/N (!sly $bua.t~ Date Signed ~/6/03 , I Resident's Address and Unit: 3S: 19& 77l3/.:;IIC: fJiPl/?,! l!o..3 I! V e /71u./2..o.. 1:f2. 3 3/.g..0 r RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co"""" (Yol. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .::::r€ /? (J tn z:. 10 W f. N Date Signed C- ~ -J~ 1- 03 Resident's Address and Unit: 3..{{r- /illiG Ul.AN C,eec, c.. -:/1/").-1 tII-v W7'1/ te.//,. Pt... 33 { fo RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: COmnnSSlOnerS City Manager CO/lo/lo t-.eol' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name HVt({l/l.'1 l)'o)..,loIto/ Signature ~)(~ Date Signed ~ /'I/t 3 Resident's Address and Unit: llib7/{:ItAlO~IV7.~ Wt1-7 (/VoKfI/-1uWf~ ~ftf"!6 fI RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 Cln CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO,,,,IVI tell. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat J. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~~~ '1~st~ Signature U 1Ji0l~ Date Signed '4- - I'l1It 'i 03 Resident's Address and Unit: ~ ~)1) M'-\s'lc- fOt/'--11C )e. :J:t: flll RECEIVED MAY 1 2 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager cP....,"" {yJ' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed S-/S-/03 , MA DE.L-IUG. dR.rJ 1. t!(} .2c p.. AJ s-,y z0 Resident's Address and Unit: /PIJO C".f5C4J.J....J.7 121-1/)) 4-2302 A/c;..rnJ ~fj J K-' 'G3/&u RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aveotura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager lOIl1"" \:)eol' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name {Cha;t1.Ut t-c, (Wa- /1.a. r-r 11c.... Sign~ /Jr! . - Date Signed O~, /2.0 <. Resident's Address and Unit: ~ hairA.-11 tc.; (VCc. f1 rn-I Y1 a. 2600 [s eCV1tld eevd tT220( AVeMkf'o.. {t 6S.!O 0 I I RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: ConnmSSlOnerS City Manager ~,"1/Y1 ~.; To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Deskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name t~,...bcO vich 0t.r/N..~ Signature ~/L Date Signed tJl>~J2, 0 S Resident's Address and Unit: IJprfleJ /S ~cI ft(vc;( in- 22 Or )ve.u(u.rc. Fe i,?-/6o ( l RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~OI\1"" De.;. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HoIzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Re .dent(s) Name ~ CA..~\. ~}~V'e.V' Resident's Address and Unit: ':2Cooo TS{~ 61CrcQZf( a r.J ( /!-U~CvI 33/C,,6 , RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . cc: ComrmSSlOnerS City Manager l-..,.. ' (:O('l11\11 \..>< To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 . Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~lse~~d D \c, --/ltR. ! ( fJ-17O RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C 1>1 l')e.I' 0'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. l;:Ni~~v Mgua,or< 'A!il)/}L ----- Date Signed 51 I, )1) 3, , Resident's Address and Unit: f}liO;;: lfMd ~! V~ J/tA~ rt1 ~J/l.~ j]!}J RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Ma~ 13 03 05:23p Che,..~1 " Dave's (973) 994-1656 p.2 Mall To: Tile City COlluniaioa ot Aveatura 19200 West Couatry Club Drfv. Avcahi.... FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COIl1M jy.J' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow COlllmisaloaer Ib"y Holzberc. Seat 1 Commissioner MlDuy Grosamaa, Seat 2 ComllliSllioner Boll Diallload. s..t 3 COlllml.sioDer Jay R. Betkin, Seat 4 Commi..ioaer bv Auerbacb. Seat 5 COllllais,'oner Ken Collen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow alld Colltmissioners ot tile City of AnaClua: As a te.oideat of Aventu"a,. am ,trOllCI)' opposed to Clf establisla.eat of I 5ynlCOIue in l.e residealial bUildiDg, 2600 bind Boulevard. Uait CU.] aad urge YOD to vote .cains. the condltioaal use applicatioa that will make tbis use possible. Thallk you. Residenl(s) Name _CJk~y\. p~O [owAItO p~c~ SiCD.ta~ :cf 0 . Date SieDeeI fh)OJ Or ;/03 Resident's Address aad Unit; L.[,oo I-J V/-..tO € LV' O. rt: 1.[0 I. - Atlh,11I"-A. t:L. RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CoW" ~N ~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name l5er-ko V I Co h _V c20J 11'111 (r- Signature ~,L Date Signed O~/Z.,O]. Resident's Address and Unit: 2600 /sU ~evJ. Tr L20( Avel1/w-c... fc ~s/60 , I RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C...o /l1 /VI t:,e v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a "-. synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed S )Jdboo3 lYmN)'lj cA. fM ~ID'{J moxni S. Or\oue Resident's Address and Unit: 2~oo 3:SlaV\.& pI vd. . _~ H .Q RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK QNf!ri.tLlAA1~ '\=L ~~ ) (Q '0 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager eO"lM De"', To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry HOlzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Se~lit 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners (]lithe City of Aventura: As it resident of Aventura, I am strongly (}Il~(}lled to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the cOllldition,al use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~l. DtfwJr fltJ~ {?)RLDV6 Signature ~ Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: )(p80 ~&?1d,6'b..o ~o;t3:J16i) / f/1I2 RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 , . CC~ COmnnSSlOnerS City Manager vr'1N) (y/' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .( ere/ku ~ /' Date Signed Resident's Address and Unit: 1111 1<Wr- ';7/~ RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . Cc: ComnusSlOnerS City Manager C'Ol"lho De'" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2. Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed II, <:-. --- ~\L:)I'}JO (}J('~~~~ ~ O~ Resident's Address and Unit: /t/j/ IIJE 1/ Au f '1 f'ufo!" . C7. I{/t :5,3({ {;J RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CC: ComnusslOners City Manager Co""M tx''' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Signature Date Signed a~u~-/" J!~e>k/ ~ <\---\~C> ~-\O.,,\C\ S' /13/()3 / 1 ...5>/13/lJ3 1 I Resident's Address and Unit: ,,:os ro D I'J (fa.4- t C!.. ll<.- k \) { SfJ :u f\, ().L~((,"'- "f \ '33 I ~o (t:t ) RECEIVED MAY 1 5 2003 CITY CLERK Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager [oM'" l)ev. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Bcskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature Date Signed \klkt4 1!1'd:4T )~~~ ,;13/0$ -Ach,l{o m.\A,1~ .... -05/05 Resident's Address and Unit: tlcoo ::P;,IAlJjJ iJlifcP #03 RECEIVED MAV 1 'i 2003 CITY CLERK 7000 Island Blvd., Unit 2002 Aventura, FL 33160 May 11, 2003 Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor City of Aventura Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FI 33180 Dear Mayor Perlow: I am a registered voter in the City of Aventura and a resident of Williams Island. I would like to voice my strong opposition to the establishment of a synagogue in the 2600 Building on Williams Island, This is a residential area, and I believe that a religious organization of any faith or denomination does not belong in this location, We would have seriously reconsidered our decision to purchase here had we known that these plans existed, I oppose the establishment of the synagogue for the reason that our private residential area should not be used for any non,residential purpose which is not owned and operated by the Property Owners of Williams Island. It is for this reason that the Property Owners are currently attempting to negotiate the purchase of the Williams Island Clubs from the developers, Allowing another use which is not controlled by the residents would be counter-productive to these efforts, The security and peaceful co,habitation of the residents is my primary concern. I had planned to attend the May 6, 2003 meeting to address this issue and will make every effort to attend the rescheduled meeting on June 3, 2003. I appreciate your consideration of my views when voting on the matter. Si ncerely, fJ~ /J, ~M0 Jo-An B, Evans Cc: Zev Auerbach, Commissioner Jay Beskin, Commissioner Ken Cohen, Commissioner Bob Diamond, Commissioner Manny Grossman, Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Commissioner Erick M. Soroka, City Manager Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~~ To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name .tf'()13 <>/? J- L/PMA,1l / ~ ILCCp-- L /(f' /lJKJ^'- , Signature t:~ aJA-. _ (J'..J2--..... Date Signed 5 !~4-3 ~ If J?J / Resident's Address and Unit: J,-fl-O () 75'LAA/D f'JL.vb rOb /1./ t L---'-''' 10 /"] "$ T 5' L-/O /1, 0 I r::- 0 " Mail To: Tbe City CommlssiOD of Anntura 19100 West Country Club Drive AveDtura, FL 33180 'f,; Commissioners City Manager C. cj'(\lML .#u To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzbel'l. Seat 1 Commissioner MIDDY Grossman, Seat 2 CommissioDer Bob Diamond. Seat 3 CommissloDer Jay R. B.IdD, Seat 4 Commissioner 'Lev Auerbach. Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen. Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of A ventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly oppoeed to the establishment of a SYDa202ue in the residential buUdlnl. 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-I and urge you to vote against the conditioDal use application that will make this use possible. Tbank you. Resident(.) Name -:;;;till 7J1S/f//.€/);; v olDAe Jr (/ Date Sillned o/S-)tJ :1 Resident's Address aDd UDit: .3$1)0 (/JrsY;c P7 })/2 07tJS ffYtWJV!Z?9) fl g:3) TO , cc: Commissioners City Manager COM'" be V' RECEIVED MAY - 8 '003 CITY cu.... ... Dear Mr, Mayor & Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Williams Island, I am against the relocation of the Williams Island Synagogue and urge you to vote AGAINST the variance that will make the move possible, Thank you, ::f A-<-r<. !J. Dc 5 /If;- J Name: Building: 3 oo~ Unit #: h 0 "? ~ ~~ ~,d-003 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COMA1 t:,e v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Prhll r; (d lh~ (tature ~ ?-df.0AdJ-- Date Signed 1/ -r;)~3 Resident's Address and Unit: ,3366 /lJ {; fl.?- ~--r .:1)/;).])9 A,jp~~ 7-u 33/f//J Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CCM"1 ~f"' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will 'make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Date Signed .~ ff6t~~~ ~ ~ Resident's Address and Unit: ~~eo ~6 l~~~ :st" 'VD~ ,k.r~H.,R~ .t::-L-- ~:? \ 7> 0 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 C I. CC: omnnSSlOners City Manager CoO"""'! txu. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~f!... &.oROC- U / L~&jJ /;;&,(/ h, L!fift1A/ I Date Signed S-/7/6 S-/7/V Resident's Address and Unit: 2(,00 ~ ~ -#(gOS ~ :;fi~3'3/~o ) Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CO""M ~V' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City ofAventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name R~~L.q,~J Wh 11-e fl;L:t~ Date Signed ~5j S/ oj Resident's Address and Unit: ~b 0:] /Ve2-o7 rz Af:4--fJ /6 Av RM. TVJ..4, t ff / ;>310C , Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Co III hi lY v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name r ~\CZVi c,1 ~" E pstel'1 Signature ~j~ ~ Date Signed S{(~J 0 S Resident's Address and Unit: ;3s-00 Mys-h'c. ~QI-1~]v 23rJi h(fe<;t~rc... t=t ") :$ { ~u Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C/O 41/Y1 b:.e v. To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident's Address and Unit: ]tOB~'~~,~~ i ! J-I d y Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager COPl/YI t,e... To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name AaLLiC [;e.ss~ ~~ I Date Signed 4/0/0:; Resident's Address and Unit: / ([) () () Jk. ;5i/v-(/'fI 'It? 1- ()/VfM~://33/0{) / Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: COmmissioners City Manager Co,,"'" I;:::,e", To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ,2Jt~7ltpw d Resident's Address and Unit: ~6 SA e o?1fJi1. ~'Vey ~ ~aptin 2600 eJ.slanf) ef7jlvl}. emu 2704 ~m, eJla. JJ160 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager (bM"" be"" To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ~c_, ~\\\"l; t" , - Signature Date Signed ~'b'(j~ ~>>~~^" "''oJ Resident's Address and Unit: \~, ()l\\~~\N~ ~b~ ' ~ ~ -.j~,,<,\ ~'" ~ ' Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager ~OM4rl f)e v' To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 RECEIVED MAY - 8 2003 CITY CLERK Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name ?,,^^kl),".f~ ~"^-v yV\.. vc- \ 11o~e JY ~ Signature ~~~. Date Signed ~/71 03- 5" j, I~ Resident's Address and Unit: 2-000 :t<:>lc.",Jl,\vcl /tvw.h I ~L I /702 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager CD- To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Sigua':Jlf Date Signed 5/,5>/03 -6/8/0.3 . , /t.rC/~i ~.s EJ..z: fiNE' -ffoP-1 )( .l>< Resident's Address and Unit: ...3,()ttJOJ$~ g-lv]) , 2 b 0 ~ drl:Alna:/T, Pi, 3::3/60 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager C .!:>e,u . To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 7- Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners ofthe City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name Signature }./(/~/-<7;LLOOS'.:Mj~ 7r(~ih, ~~ OOya." ~s~,(/,6~1 ~r.-Y' ~ q~ Resident's Address and Unit: Date Signed .:5- j>-G..i 'I Morton & Joyce Rosenberg 2800 Island Blvd. Apt.-2304 Avenlura, FL 33160 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager Cbw To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment ofa synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident's Address and Unit: Date Signed S.g'~3 S . ~ ''2...0o~ Resident(s) Name ~ ~t.rC Le.o...""- B. "bu.'M..~~ Jose & Leah B, Dumont 2600 Island Blvd # 2606 Williams Island Aventura, FL 33160-5211 Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 . . CO: COffi1Il1SSlOners City Manager tf)W To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 Commissioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential building, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you, Resident(s) Name. "". Sigm~~ Date Signed S,l(.dNItLb flt-//,,-{ ~~V-k/A-lc./240~ ~./I.,;P/f1AJ-L t!ltt.-t M~ I~~ Irl~y /,,) ~otl"3 Resident's Address and Unit: 3fOO '-'-sl;1AJt> 13lv/J ~d18 ..1ve.....) TUIe I1J f'lt/lID4- .3';J/~O Mail To: The City Commission of Aventura 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, FL 33180 cc: Commissioners City Manager c..!J.w To: Mayor Jeffrey M. Perlow Commissioner Harry Holzberg, Seat 1 Commissioner Manny Grossman, Seat 2 Commissioner Bob Diamond, Seat 3 . Commill5ioner Jay R. Beskin, Seat 4 Commissioner Zev Auerbach, Seat 5 Commissioner Ken Cohen, Seat 6 Dear Mayor Perlow and Commissioners of the City of Aventura: As a resident of Aventura, I am strongly opposed to the establishment of a synagogue in the residential bu.i1ding, 2600 Island Boulevard, Unit CU-l and urge you to vote against the conditional use application that will make this use possible. Thank you. Resident(s) Name S Y UPPfY')qtJ Lal S ty)/1TT ~ Date Signed ~003 ~U::03 Resident's Address and Unit: 2.bOo ISLA-ND BLVD 110Y A-u~ TuttA- (FL. 33 I b 0 City Cnnlrn'-inn Jeffrey M. Perlow, Mayor Zev Auerbach lay R. Be.kin Ken Cohen Bob Diamond Manny Grossman Harry Ho1zberg The City of Aventura & ~'''ar'._'~ City MSIn~p Eric M. Soroka City Clerk Teresa M. Soroka, CMC City Atto17lev Weiss Serota Helfman Pastoriza Guede. Boniske & Cole AGENDA NOVEMBER 12, 2003 5 PM CC: COmmissioners City Manager Government Center 19200 West Country Club Drive Aventura, Florida 33180 1. CALL TO ORDER\ROLL CALL 2. 3. 4. Th ant el. Bo m. ve. ba! Dr 89< ~o1J \'1-/2003 ..../- 0 {)"!j If g item On the ~ ~ .s item, please 't-p. _ 1'. . . IS to speak On ~ --d---~ ~ mtations, All ~ r affinnation, Ot.--.cJ;/ ation, If you ~ ~~ Lsidered. The --;-- '1'......~ n U 'y request the ~ f~ ,~ ~ .representinL llon. Further t.t~ - ;to ~~~ jj; CITY OF -Q 11 PPROV AL &'\,Al} ~ ~ IN THE 1) ~\ [)ISTRICT ~ l~ ~evP~ RD, CITY ~~~ RECEIVED NOli 1 ~ 2003 CITY CLERK t} -;,~"O P4~~, who are disabled :)ffice of the City ventura Advisory ith respect to any ~d to ensure that a ,e appeal is to be W. Country Club 21erk at 305-466-