HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-12-2006
City Comrn;_mn
Susan Gottlieb, Mayor
A ~he City of
~ventura
Q
~
City MAnllver
Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM
Zev Auerbach
Bob Diamond
Billy Joel
Harry Holzberg
Michael Stern
Luz Urbaez Weinberg
City Gerk
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC
City Attomcv
Weiss Serota Helfman
Pastoriza Cole & Boniske
AGENDA
SEPTEMBER 12, 2006 following6pJILLPAmeeting
Government Center
19200 West Country Club Drive
A ventura, Florida 33180
1. CALL TO ORDER\ROLL CALL
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
3. AGENDA: Request for Deletions/Emergency Additions
4. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS:
. Key to the City to Aventura Resident and former Olympian Bob Beamon
. Employee Service Awards
5. CONSENT AGENDA: Matters included under the Consent Agenda are self-explanatory and are not
expected to require discussion or review. Items will be enacted by one motion. If discussion is desired by any
member of the Commission, that item must be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered separately.
A. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
July 11,2006 Workshop Meeting
July 11,2006 Commission Meeting
July 20, 2006 Commission Meeting
July 20, 2006 Workshop Meeting
B. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER ON BEHALF OF THE CITY TO EXECUTE AND
OTHERWISE ENTER INTO THE ATTACHED MUTUAL AID
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF A VENTURA AND
THE TOWN OF SURFSIDE FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT
ACTIVITIES; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO
ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF
THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
1lqBiIlr12,m;~~
C. MOTION TO APPROVE PRESENTATION OF KEY TO CITY
TO A VENTURA RESIDENT AND FORMER OLYMPIAN BOB
BEAMON
D. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING AND LETTING A
BID/CONTRACT FOR BID NO. 06-07-24-2, MIAMI GARDENS
DRIVE EXTENSION IMPROVEMENTS, TO WILLIAMS
PAVING COMPANY, INC. AT THE BID PRICE OF
$2,222,788.00. AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
EXECUTE ASSOCIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE
CITY MANAGER TO TAKE NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT
ACTION TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION;
PROVIDING FOR THE APPROPRIATION AND ALLOCATION
OF FUNDS FOR SAID BID AWARD; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
E. MOTION TO ACCEPT FOR FILING THE SPECIAL PURPOSE
FINANCIAL REPORT FOR THE A VENTURA CITY OF
EXCELLENCE SCHOOL FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED
JUNE 30, 2006 AND TO ACCEPT LETTER DATED AUGUST 18,
2006 ATTACHED HERETO
F. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA DECLARING CERTAIN
PROPERTY LISTED UNDER THE ASSETS OF THE CITY AS
SURPLUS TO THE NEEDS OF THE CITY; DESCRIBING THE
MANNER OF DISPOSAL; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY
OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
G. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND OTHERWISE ENTER INTO
THAT CERTAIN SECOND INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT BY
AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF A VENTURA AND MIAMI-
DADE COUNTY RELATING TO FPL FRANCHISE FEES;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS
RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
H. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND OTHERWISE ENTER INTO
THAT CERTAIN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT BY AND
2
"-'-12,- c .........
~ ~~ .'-11
BETWEEN THE CITY OF A VENTURA AND MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY RELATING TO EMERGENCY 911 SYSTEM
SERVICE FEES; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO
ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF
THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
I. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE
CITY OF A VENTURA AND MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
REGARDING RIGHT OF WAY RECONSTRUCTION; AND
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
J. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING A CONTRACT FOR
THE CITY'S PROPERTY AND LIABILITY INSURANCE TO
THE FLORIDA MUNICIPAL INSURANCE TRUST;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER, ON BEHALF OF SAID
CITY, TO EXECUTE ASSICIATED CONTRACTS;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS
RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
K. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING AND LETTING A
BID/CONTRACT FOR BID NO. 06-09-08-2, WATERWAYS
PARK EXPANSION CLEARING AND GRUBBING, TO MCO
ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. AT THE BID PRICE OF $278,658.00.
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE
ASSOCIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO TAKE NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT ACTION
TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION;
PROVIDING FOR THE APPROPRIATION AND ALLOCATION
OF FUNDS FOR SAID BID AWARD; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
6. ZONING HEARINGS:
QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS - Please be advised that the following items on the Commission's agenda are
quasi~judicial in nature. If you wish to object or comment upon any of these items, please infonn the Mayor when he requests
public comments. An opportunity for persons to speak on each item will be made available after the applicant and staff have
made their presentations on each item. All testimony, including public testiroony and evidence, will be made under oath or
affirmation. Additionally, each person who gives testimony may be subject to cross-examination. If you refuse either to be
cross-examined or to be sworn, your testimony will be given its due weight. The general public will not be permitted to
cross-examine witnesses, but the public may request the Commission to ask questions of staff or witnesses on their behalf.
Persons representing organizations must present evidence of their authority to speak for the organization. Further details of
the quasi-judicial procedures may be obtained from the Clerk.
3
1lqBiIlr12,m;~~
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
A VENTURA, FLORIDA GRANTING CONDITIONAL USE
APPROVAL TO PERMIT THE CONSTRUCTION OF A MARINA AND
DRY DOCK BOAT STORAGE BUILDING WITH A HEIGHT OF 90
FEET IN THE TC2, TOWN CENTER MARINE DISTRICT, WHERE A
MAXIMUM HEIGHT OF 4 STORIES OR 50 FEET IS PERMITTED BY
CODE; GRANTING VARIANCE FROM SECTION 31-145(c)(10) OF
THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS TO PERMIT A
VIEW CORRIDOR OF 15 FEET WHERE A 66.76 FOOT VIEW
CORRIDOR IS REQUIRED BY CODE; AND GRANTING VARIANCE
FROM SECTION 31-221(i)(2) OF THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS TO PERMIT A MINIMUM BUFFER STRIP OF 4'8",
WHERE A MINIMUM 7' WIDE BUFFER STRIP IS REQUIRED BY
CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2890 NE 187 STREET, CITY
OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
7. ORDINANCES: FIRST READING/PUBLIC INPUT:
A. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE COMPREHENSIVE MASTER PLAN BY
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP DESIGNATION
FOR PROPERTY LOCATED ON NE 207 STREET AT NE 30
AVENUE, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT
"A", FROM BUSINESS AND OFFICE TO MEDIUM HIGH
DENSITY RESIDENTIAL; PROVIDING FOR TRANS MITT AL
TO THE AGENCIES AS REQUIRED UNDER CHAPTER 163,
PART II, FLORIDA STATUTES; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
B. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY OF
A VENTURA BY AMENDING THE ZONING DESIGNATION
FOR A PARCEL OF LAND LOCATED ON NE 207 STREET AT
NE 30 AVENUE AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN
EXHIBIT A, FROM B2, COMMUNITY BUSINESS DISTRICT TO
RMF3A, MULTIFAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL
DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING
FOR INCLUSION IN THE CODE; PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
8. ORDINANCE: SECOND READING: PUBLIC HEARING:
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF A VENTURA, FLORIDA
AMENDING THE CITY CODE BY AMENDING CHAPTER 36
"RETIREMENT" AT ARTICLE II "POLICE PENSION PLAN AND
TRUST FUND" BY AMENDING SECTION 36-24 "CONTRIBUTIONS"
4
1lqBiIlr12,m;~~
AND DELETING SECTION 36-36 "RATE OF CONTRIBUTION";
PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN
CODE; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
9. RESOLUTIONS - PUBLIC HEARING: None.
10. REPORTS
11. PUBLIC COMMENTS
12. OTHER BUSINESS: None.
13. ADJOURNMENT
SCHEDULE OF FUTURE MEETINGSIEVENTS
COMMISSION WORKSHOP
2ND BUDGET HEARING
SEPTEMBER 20, 2006
SEPTEMBER 21, 2006
9 A.M.
6 P.M.
This meeting is open to the public. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, all persons who are disabled
and who need special accommodations to participate in this meeting because of that disability should contact the Office of the City
Clerk, 305-466-8901, not later than two days prior to such proceeding. One or more members of the City of Aventura Advisory
Boards may be in attendance. Anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the Aventura City Commission with respect to any
matter considered at such meeting or hearing will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a
verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be
based. Agenda items may be viewed at the Office of the City Clerk, City of Aventura Government Center. 19200 W. Country Club
Drive, Aventura, Florida. 33180. Anyone wishing to obtain a copy of any agenda item should contact the City Clerk at 305-466-
8901.
5
The City of
Aventura
&
,,~,.f
MINUTES
COMMISSION WORKSHOP MEETING
JULY 11, 2006 4:45 p.m.
Aventura Government Center
19200 W. Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by Mayor Susan
Gottlieb at 4:45 p.m. Present were Commissioners Zev Auerbach, Bob Diamond, Billy
Joel, Harry Holzberg, Michael Stern, Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg, Mayor Gottlieb,
City Manager Eric M. Soroka. City Clerk Teresa M. Soroka and City Attorney David M.
Wolpin. As a quorum was determined to be present, the meeting commenced.
Mr. Soroka discussed and recommended the temporary re-Iocation of the Northeast
Branch of the County Library to the Government Center second floor atrium during
renovation period. Consensus to proceed.
He then discussed the concept of combining a Performing Arts Center with the Library
as part of the renovation project. Consensus to authorize City Manager to execute
Memorandum of Understanding with Miami-Dade County concerning such a combined
development.
ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business to come before the Commission at
this time, after motion made, seconded and unanimously passed, the meeting
adjourned at 5:40 p.m.
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC, City Clerk
Approved by the Commission on
Anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at a meeting or hearing
will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,
which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
The City of
AVentura
~
MINUTES
CITY COMMISSION MEETING
JULY 11, 2006
Following 6 p.m. LPA meeting
Aventura Government Center
19200 W. Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
1. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by Mayor Susan
Gottlieb at 6:07 p.m. following the Local Planning Agency meeting. Present were
Commissioners Zev Auerbach, Bob Diamond, Harry Holzberg, Billy Joel, Michael Stern,
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg, Mayor Gottlieb, City Manager Eric M. Soroka, City
Clerk Teresa M. Soroka and City Attorney David M. Wolpin. As a quorum was
determined to be present, the meeting commenced.
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Led during LPA.
3. AGENDA: REQUESTS FOR DELETIONS/EMERGENCY ADDITIONS: A motion
was offered by Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Diamond and
unanimously passed to add to the Consent Agenda Motion authorizing City Manager to
execute Memorandum of Understanding concerning Miami-Dade County Public Library
in City of Aventura.
4. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS: Certificates of Service were presented to ten-year
employees Mayra Norona and Gail Fishman.
5. CONSENT AGENDA: A motion to approve the Consent Agenda was offered by
Commissioner Joel, seconded by Vice Mayor Weinberg, unanimously passed and the
following action was taken:
A. The minutes of the June 6, 2006 Commission Meeting, and June 9, 2006
Workshop Meeting were approved.
B. Resolution No. 2006-38 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE APPOINTMENT OF
MEMBERS TO THE CITY OF AVENTURA COMMUNITY SERVICES
ADVISORY BOARD; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
C. Resolution No. 2006-39 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND OTHERWISE ENTER INTO THE
ATTACHED CHANGE ORDER FOR DESIGN AND BUILD MIDDLE
SCHOOL WING ADDITION TO CHARTER SCHOOL PROJECT BY AND
BETWEEN THE CITY AND CHARTER SCHOOLHOUSE DEVELOPERS,
INC.; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION;
AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
D. Resolution No. 2006-40 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING AND LETTING A BID/CONTRACT
FOR BID NO. 06-06-02-2, AVENTURA BOULEVARD RESURFACING
IMPROVEMENTS, TO WEEKLY ASPHALT PAVING, INC. AT THE BID
PRICE OF $506,286.75; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
EXECUTE ASSOCIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO TAKE NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT ACTION TO
CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; PROVIDING FOR THE
APPROPRIATION AND ALLOCATION OF FUNDS FOR SAID BID
AWARD; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
E. Resolution No. 2006-41 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA, EXPRESSING SUPPORT FOR LIGHT RAIL
REGIONAL TRANSIT SOLUTIONS; PROVIDING FOR
IMPLEMENTATION; PROVIDING FOR EFFECTIVE DATE.
F. Resolution No. 2006-42 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING AND LETTING A BID/CONTRACT
FOR BID NO. 06-06-13-2, NE 213TH STREET DRAINAGE
CONNECTIONS, TO WILLIAMS PAVING COMPANY, INC. AT THE BID
PRICE OF $1,005,757.00. AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
EXECUTE ASSOCIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO TAKE NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT ACTION TO
CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; PROVIDING FOR THE
APPROPRIATION AND ALLOCATION OF FUNDS FOR SAID BID
AWARD; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
G. Resolution No. 2006-43 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA, SELECTING THE FIRM OF AMS PLANNING &
RESEARCH CORP. TO PREPARE PERFORMING ARTS CENTER
BUSINESS PLAN FEASIBILITY STUDY RELATIVE TO ISQ NO. 06-5-
12-2; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO NEGOTIATE THE
2
SCOPE OF SERVICES AND FEES FOR SAID SERVICES;
AUTHORIZING NEGOTIATIONS WITH AN ALTERNATE FIRM TO
PERFORM THE REQUIRED SERVICES SHOULD NEGOTIATIONS
WITH SELECTED FIRM BE UNSUCCESSFUL; AUTHORIZING THE
CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT
THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
H. Motion was approved as follows:
MOTION AUTHORIZING THE APPROPRIATION OF UP TO $85,000
FOR A SWAT VAN AND JUVENILE DRUG PROGRAM FROM THE
POLICE FORFEITURE FUND IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CITY
MANAGER'S MEMORANDUM.
I. Resolution No. 2006-44 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA DECLARING CERTAIN PROPERTY LISTED
UNDER THE ASSETS OF THE CITY AS SURPLUS TO THE NEEDS OF
THE CITY; DESCRIBING THE MANNER OF DISPOSAL; AUTHORIZING
THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY
OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
J. Resolution No. 2006-45 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA ESTABLISHING A MONEY PURCHASE
RETIREMENT PLAN FOR CHARTER SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
EMPLOYEES HIRED AFTER JULY 1, 2006; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE THE ATTACHED ADOPTION AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE CITY OF AVENTURA AND THE ICMA RETIREMENT
CORPORATION; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL
THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS
RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
K. Resolution No. 2006-46 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA RATIFYING THE RECORDATION OF "MARINA
DEL REY SECOND REVISED" RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 165, PAGE
11 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, BEING A
REPLAT OF A PORTION OF TRACT N OF MARINA DEL REY
3
REVISED (PB 144, PG 89) LYING IN THE SOUTH % OF SECTION 3,
TOWNSHIP 52 SOUTH, RANGE 42 EAST, CITY OF AVENTURA,
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
L. Resolution No. 2006-47 was adopted as follows:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
EXECUTE AND OTHERWISE ENTER INTO THAT CERTAIN
AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF AVENTURA AND
AMS PLANNING & RESEARCH CORP. FOR PREPARATION OF
PERFORMING ARTS CENTER BUSINESS PLAN FEASIBILITY STUDY;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION;
AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
M. The following motion was approved:
MOTION TO AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING CONCERNING MIAMI.DADE
COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY IN CITY OF AVENTURA
6. ZONING HEARINGS: None.
7. ORDINANCES: FIRST READING/PUBLIC INPUT:
A. Mr. Wolpin read the following ordinance by title:
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2005-13 WHICH
ORDINANCE ADOPTED A BUDGET FOR THE 2005/2006 FISCAL
YEAR BY REVISING THE 2005/2006 FISCAL YEAR OPERATING AND
CAPITAL BUDGET AS OUTLINED IN EXHIBIT "An ATTACHED
HERETO; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS ORDINANCE;
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
A motion for approval was offered by Commissioner Joel, and seconded by
Commissioner Holzberg. Mayor Gottlieb opened the public hearing. There being
no speakers, the public hearing was closed. The motion for approval passed
unanimously by roll call vote.
B. Mr. Wolpin read the following ordinance by title:
4
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA AMENDING
THE CITY CODE BY AMENDING CHAPTER 36 "RETIREMENT" AT
ARTICLE II "POLICE PENSION PLAN AND TRUST FUND" BY
AMENDING SECTION 36-24 "CONTRIBUTIONS" AND DELETING
SECTION 36-36 "RATE OF CONTRIBUTION"; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN CODE; PROVIDING
FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
A motion for approval was offered by Commissioner Auerbach and seconded by
Commissioner Stern. Mayor Gottlieb opened the public hearing. There being no
speakers, the public hearing was closed. The motion for approval passed
unanimously by roll call vote.
C. Mr. Wolpin read the following ordinance by title:
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, ADOPTING
THE 2005 EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT-BASED
AMENDMENTS TO THE CITY OF AVENTURA COMPREHENSIVE
PLAN; AUTHORIZING TRANSMITTAL TO REVIEW AGENCIES;
PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
A motion for approval, including the incorporation by reference into this hearing
of all amendments and testimony, written and verbal, relative to this item given at
the preceding Local Planning Agency meeting, was offered by Commissioner
Joel, and seconded by Commissioner Auerbach. Mayor Gottlieb opened the
public hearing. There being no speakers, the public hearing was closed. The
motion for approval passed unanimously by roll call vote.
8. ORDINANCE: SECOND READING: CITY COMMISSION ACTING IN ITS
CAPACITY AS THE AVENTURA CITY OF EXCELLENCE SCHOOL BOARD OF
DIRECTORS: Mr. Wolpin read the following ordinance by title:
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA,
FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2005-06, WHICH ORDINANCE
ADOPTED A CHARTER SCHOOL OPERATING AND CAPITAL BUDGET FOR
THE AVENTURA CITY OF EXCELLENCE SCHOOL FOR FISCAL YEAR
2005/06 (JULY 1 - JUNE 30) BY REVISING THE 2005/2006 FISCAL YEAR
BUDGET DOCUMENT AS OUTLINED IN EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHED HERETO;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO
CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS ORDINANCE; PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
5
A motion for approval was offered by Vice Mayor Weinberg and seconded by
Commissioner Auerbach. Mayor Gottlieb opened the public hearing. There
being no speakers, the public hearing was closed. The motion for approval
passed unanimously by roll call vote and Ordinance No. 2006-09 was enacted.
9. RESOLUTIONS - PUBLIC HEARING: None.
10. REPORTS: As presented.
11. PUBLIC COMMENTS: None.
12. OTHER BUSINESS: None.
13. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business to come before the Commission
at this time, after motion made, seconded and unanimously passed, the meeting
adjourned at 6:32 p.m.
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC, City Clerk
Approved by the Commission on
Anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at a meeting or hearing
will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,
which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
6
A~ City of
.l"l.ventura
,i)
..,~.,/
MINUTES
COMMISSION MEETING
JULY 20, 20069 AM
Aventura Government Center
19200 w. Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
1. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL. The meeting was called to order at 9:00 a.m.
by Mayor Susan Gottlieb. Present were Commissioners Zev Auerbach, Bob Diamond,
Harry Holzberg, Billy Joel, Michael Stern, Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg, Mayor
Gottlieb, City Manager Eric M. Soroka, City Clerk Teresa M. Soroka and City Attorney
David M. Wolpin. As a quorum was determined to be present, the meeting
commenced.
2. OVERVIEW AND REVIEW OF PROPOSED BUDGET: Mr. Soroka gave a
powerpoint presentation showing an overview of the financial performance of the City
over the last nine years. He then reviewed the proposed 2006/07 budget document, as
follows:
A. GENERAL FUND, including Revenues, General Government
Departments (City Commission, City Manager, Finance Support Services,
Information Technology, Legal, City Clerk), Public Safety Department,
Community Development Department, Community Services Department, Non-
Departmental and Capital Outlay.
A motion for approval of the General Fund Budget Revenues was offered by
Commissioner Holzberg, seconded by Commissioner Joel, and unanimously
passed.
A motion for approval of the City Commission budget was offered by
Commissioner Joel, seconded by Vice Mayor Weinberg and unanimously
passed.
A motion to approve the City Manager budget was offered by Commissioner
Joel, seconded by Commissioner Auerbach, and unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the Finance Support Services budget was offered by
Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Diamond, and unanimously
passed.
A motion to approve the Information Technology budget was offered by
Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Holzberg, and unanimously
passed.
A motion to approve the Legal Department budget was offered by Commissioner
Joel, seconded by Commissioner Holzberg, and unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the City Clerk budget was offered by Commissioner
Auerbach, seconded by Commissioner Holzberg, and unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the Public Safety budget was offered by Vice Mayor
Weinberg, seconded by Commissioner Auerbach and unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the Community Development Department budget was
offered by Vice Mayor Weinberg, seconded by Commissioner Holzberg, and
unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the Community Services Department budget was offered by
Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Stern and unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the Non-Departmental budget was offered by Commissioner
Joel, seconded by Vice Mayor Weinberg and unanimously passed.
A motion to approve the Capital Outlay budget was offered by Commissioner
Diamond, seconded by Commissioner Auerbach and unanimously passed.
B. Mr. Wolpin read the following resolution by title:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA, ESTABLISHING A PROPOSED MILLAGE
RATE FOR THE 2006/2007 FISCAL YEAR; PROVIDING FOR THE
DATE, TIME AND PLACE OF THE PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER
THE PROPOSED MILLAGE RATE AND TENTATIVE BUDGET; AND
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
A motion for approval of the resolution, which establishes a millage rate for the
2006/07 fiscal year of 2.227 per $1,000 of taxable assessed value, was offered
by Commissioner Holzberg, seconded by Commissioner Auerbach, unanimously
passed and Resolution No. 2006-48 was adopted.
C. POLICE EDUCATION FUND: A motion for approval was offered by
Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Diamond, and unanimously
passed.
D. TRANSPORTATION AND STREET MAINTENANCE FUND: A motion for
approval was offered by Commissioner Auerbach, seconded by Commissioner
Holzberg, and unanimously passed.
E. POLICE CAPITAL OUTLAY IMPACT FEE FUND: A motion for approval
was offered by Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Diamond, and
unanimously passed.
2
F. PARK DEVELOPMENT FUND: A motion for approval was offered by Vice
Mayor Weinberg, seconded by Commissioner Stern, and unanimously passed.
G. 911 FUND: A motion for approval was offered by Commissioner Joel,
seconded by Commissioner Holzberg. and unanimously passed.
H. DEBT SERVICE FUND: A motion for approval was offered by
Commissioner Diamond, seconded by Commissioner Joel, and unanimously
passed.
I. CAPITAL CONSTRUCTION FUND: A motion for approval was offered by
Commissioner Auerbach, seconded by Vice Mayor Weinberg, and unanimously
passed.
J. STORMWATER UTILITY FUND: A motion for approval was offered by
Commissioner HOlzberg, seconded by Commissioner Joel, and unanimously
passed.
K. POLICE OFF-DUTY SERVICES FUND: A motion for approval was offered
by Commissioner Joel, seconded by Commissioner Holzberg, and unanimously
passed.
3. PUBLIC HEARING: ORDINANCE: SECOND READING: Mr. Wolpin read
the following ordinance by title:
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2005-13 WHICH
ORDINANCE ADOPTED A BUDGET FOR THE 2005/2006 FISCAL
YEAR BY REVISING THE 2005/2006 FISCAL YEAR OPERATING AND
CAPITAL BUDGET AS OUTLINED IN EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHED
HERETO; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS ORDINANCE;
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
A motion for approval of the ordinance was offered by Commissioner Holzberg,
and seconded by Commissioner Joel. Mayor Gottlieb opened the public hearing.
There being no speakers, the public hearing was closed. The motion for
approval passed unanimously by roll call vote and Ordinance No. 2006-10 was
enacted.
Mr. Soroka announced that the first Budget Public Hearing is scheduled for September
6, 2006 at 6 p.m. and the second Budget Public Hearing is scheduled for September 21,
2006 at 6 p.m.
3
4. ADJOURNMENT: After motion made, seconded and unanimously passed, the
meeting adjourned.
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC, City Clerk
Approved by the Commission on
Anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at a
meeting or hearing will need a record of the proceedings and. for such purpose. may need to ensure that a verbatim
record of the proceedings is made. which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be
based.
4
A'!he City of
.t\.ventura
8
...~.,-'"
MINUTES
COMMISSION WORKSHOP MEETING
JULY 20, 2006
following 9 a.m. Commission meeting
Aventura Government Center
19200 W. Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by Mayor Susan
Gottlieb at 10:35 a.m. Present were Commissioners Zev Auerbach, Bob Diamond, Billy
Joel, Harry Holzberg, Michael Stern, Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg, Mayor Gottlieb,
City Manager Eric M. Soroka, City Clerk Teresa M. Soroka and City Attorney David M.
Wolpin. As a quorum was determined to be present, the meeting commenced.
1. EXPANSION OF DOG PARK FACILITIES: The following individuals addressed the
Commission: Robin Tobias, Mystic Pointe; Cookie Wynn, Terraces; Susie Smith,
Waterways; Scott Puch, Mystic Pointe; and Sara Fishman, Villa Dorado. Mr. Soroka
updated the Commission on the current provisions for dog owners in City parks.
CITY MANAGER SUMMARY: City Manager to study alternatives at Veterans Park
and report back to Commission at a future Workshop Meeting.
2. AVENTURA'S WORLD SHOWCASE (Citv Manaaer): Elaine Adler and Gladys
Mizrahi addressed the Commission regarding a proposed event, the Aventura World
Showcase, scheduled for Saturday, January 20, 2007 and requested the
Commission's support and the use of the south side of Founders Park.
CITY MANAGER SUMMARY: Consensus to approve.
3. RECOMMENDATION FOR KEY TO CITY (Commissioner Diamond):
Commissioner Diamond requested a key to the City be given to Aventura resident
and former Olympian Bob Beamon, not only for this athletic achievements, but for
his dedication and contributions to the community subsequent to his athletic career.
CITY MANAGER SUMMARY: Consensus to proceed.
4. CITY CLERK REVIEW: Commissioner Joel recommended the City Clerk be given a
$10,000 net bonus and the same COLA to be given to employees in October.
CITY MANAGER SUMMARY: Consensus to approve.
Consensus to authorize City Manager to expend up to $5,000 for joint advertising
campaign for shuttle bus services with cities of Sunny Isles Beach, North Miami
Beach and Aventura.
5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business to come before the Commission
at this time, after motion made, seconded and unanimously passed, the meeting
adjourned at 12 noon.
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC, City Clerk
Approved by the Commission on
Anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at a meeting or hearing
will need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,
which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
CITY OF AVENTURA
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT: Law Enforcement Mutual Aid Agreement Between the City and the
Town of Surfside
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item 2' 6
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached Resolution authorizing
execution of the Law Enforcement Mutual Aid Agreement with the Town of Surfside.
BACKGROUND
In order to improve cooperative relationships between law enforcement agencies and
provide a mechanism to share police resources in the event of emergencies or certain
demanding situations, Chapter 23, Florida Statutes, Florida Mutual Aid Act allows
agencies to enter into Police Services Mutual Aid Agreements. The various
departments use a basic Mutual Aid Agreement.
The following list comprises the circumstalJces and conditions under which mutual aid
may be requested: .
1. The joint multijurisdictional criminal investigations.
2. Civil affray or disobedience, disturbances, riots, large protest
demonstrations, controversial trials, political conventions. labor disputes
and strikes.
3. Any natural disaster.
4. Incidents which require rescue operations and crowd and traffic control
measures including, but not limited to, large-scale evacuations, aircraft
and shipping disasters, fires explosions, gas line leaks, radiological
incidents, train wrecks and derailments, chemical or hazardous waste
spills, and electrical power failures.
5. Terrorist activities including, but not limited to, acts of sabotage.
6. Escapes from disturbances within detention facilities.
7. Hostage and barricade subject situations, and aircraft piracy.
8. Control of major crime scenes, area searches, perimeter control, back-ups
to emergency and in-process calls, pursuits, and missing person calls.
9. Enemy attack.
10. Transportation of evidence requiring security.
11. Major events, e.g., sporting events, concerts. parades fairs, festivals and
conventions.
12. Security and escort duties for dignitaries.
13. Emergency situations in which one agency cannot perform its functional
objective.
14. Incidents requiring utilization for specialized units, e.g., underwater
recovery, aircraft, canine motorcycle, bomb, crime scene, marine patrol,
and police information.
15. Joint training in areas of mutual need.
The Agreement is beneficial in our mission to protect the safety and quality of life of our
residents.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
EMS/act
Attachment
CC01513-06
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER ON BEHALF OF THE CITY TO EXECUTE AND
OTHERWISE ENTER INTO THE ATTACHED MUTUAL AID
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF AVENTURA AND
THE TOWN OF SURFSIDE FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT
ACTIVITIES; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO
ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF
THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. The City Manager is hereby authorized on behalf of the City of
Aventura to execute and otherwise enter into that certain Mutual Aid Agreement between
the City of Aventura and the Town of Surfside for law enforcement activities in substantially
the form as attached hereto.
Section 2. The City Manager is hereby authorized to do all things necessary and
expedient in order to effectuate the execution of the attached Agreement described in
Section 1 above. and to carry out the aims of this Resolution.
Section 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its adoption.
The foregoing resolution was offered by Commissioner
its adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
, who moved
, and upon being
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-
Page 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1ih day of September, 2006.
Susan Gottlieb, Mayor
Attest:
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC
City Clerk
Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency:
C'Y AUnml::' ~ ~
MUTUAL AID AGREEMENT
Between the Town of Surfside Police Department
and the City of Aventura Police Department
WHEREAS, it is the responsibility of the governments of the Town of Surfside,
Florida, and the City of Aventura, Florida, to ensure the public safety of their
citizens by providing adequate levels of police services to address any
foreseeable routine or emergency situation; and
WHEREAS, because of the existing and continuing possibility of the occurrence
of law enforcement problems and other natural and man made conditions which
are. or are likely to be, beyond the control of the services, personnel. equipment
or facilities of the participating municipal police departments; and
WHEREAS, in order to ensure the preparation of these law enforcement
agencies will be adequate to address any and all of these conditions, to protect
the public peace and safety. and to preserve the lives and property of the people
of the participating Dade County municipalities; and
WHEREAS, the participating Dade County municipalities have the authority
under Chapter 23, Florida Statutes, Florida Mutual Aid Act, to enter into a Mutual
Aid Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT KNOWN, that the Town of Surfside, subdivision of
the State of Florida, and the undersigned representatives, in consideration of
mutual promises to render valuable aid in times of necessity, do hereby agree to
fully and faithfully abide by and be bound by the following terms and conditions:
1. Short title: Mutual Aid Agreement
2. Description: Since the Mutual Aid Agreement provides for the requesting
and rendering of assistance for both routine and intensive law
enforcement situations. this Mutual Aid Agreement combines the elements
of both a voluntary cooperation agreement and a requested operational
assistance agreement as described in Chapter 23 Florida Statutes.
3. Definitions:
A. Joint declaration: A document which enumerates the various
conditions or situations where aid may be requested or rendered
pursuant to this Agreement, as determined by concerned agency
heads. Subsequent to execution by the concerned agency heads,
the Joint Declaration shall be filed with the clerks of the respective
political subdivisions and shall thereafter become part of this
Agreement. Said declaration may be amended or supplemented
at any time by the agency heads by filing subsequent declarations
with the clerks of the respective political subdivisions.
B. Agency or participating law enforcement agency: Either the
Town of Surfside Police Department or the participating municipal
police department.
C. Agency Head: Either the Chief of the Town of Surfside Police
Department, or the Chief's designees, and the Chief of Police of the
participating municipal police department, or the Chief's designees.
D. Participating municipal police department: The police
department of any municipality in Dade County, Florida. that has
approved and executed this Agreement upon the approval of the
governing body of the municipality.
E. Certified law enforcement employees: Any law enforcement
employee certified as provided in Chapter 943, Florida Statutes.
4. Operations:
A. In the event that a party to this Agreement is in need of assistance,
as specified in the applicable Joint Declaration, an authorized
representative of the police department requiring assistance shaH
notify the agency from which such assistance is requested. The
authorized agency representative whose assistance is sought shaH
evaluate the situation and his available resources, and wiH respond
in a manner deemed appropriate.
8. Each party to this Agreement agrees to furnish necessary man
power, equipment, facilities, and other resources and to render
services to the other party as required to assist the requesting
party in addressing the situation which caused the request;
provided, however, that no party shall be required to deplete,
unreasonably, its own manpower, equipment, facilities, and other
resources and services in rendering such assistance.
C. The agency heads of the participating law enforcement agencies,
or their designees, shaH establish procedures for giving control of
the mission definition to the requesting agency, and for giving
tactical control over accomplishing any such assigned mission and
supervisory control over aH personnel or equipment provided
pursuant to this Agreement to the providing agency.
5. Powers, Privileges. Immunities, and Costs:
A All employees of the participating municipal police department,
certified law enforcement employees as defined in Chapter 943.
Florida Statutes. during such time that said employees are
actually providing aid outside of the jurisdictional limits of the
employing municipality pursuant to a request for aid made in
accordance with this Agreement, shall pursuant to the provisions
of Chapter 23, Florida Statutes, have the same powers, duties,
rights, privileges, and immunities as if they were performing their
duties in the political subdivision in which they are regularly
employed.
B. The political subdivision having financial responsibility for the law
enforcement agency providing the services, personnel, equip-
ment, or facilities pursuant to the provisions of this Agreement
shall bear any loss or damage to same and shall pay any and
all expenses incurred in the maintenance and operation of same.
C. The political subdivision having financial responsibility for the law
enforcement agency providing aid pursuant to this Agreement shall
compensate all of its employees rendering aid pursuant to this
Agreement, during the time of rendering of such aid, and shall
defray the actual travel and maintenance expenses of such
employees while they are rendering such aid. Such compensation
shall include any amounts paid or due for compensation due to
personal injury or death while such employees are engaged in
rendering such aid. Such compensation shall also include all
benefits normally due such employees.
D. All exemptions from ordinances and rules, and all pension,
insurance, relief, disability, workers compensation, salary,
death, and other benefits which apply to the activity of such
officers, agents, or employees of any such agency, when
performing their respective functions within the territorial limits
of their respective agencies. shall apply to them to the same
degree, manner, and extent while engaged in the performance
of their functions and duties extraterritorial under the provisions
of this Mutual Aid Agreement. The provision of this Agreement
shall apply with equal effect to paid and auxiliary employees.
6. Indemnification: The political subdivision having financial responsibility
for the law enforcement agency providing aid pursuant to this Agreement
agrees to hold harmless, defend, and indemnify the requesting law
enforcement agency and its political subdivision in any suit, action or claim
for damages resulting from any and all acts or conduct of employees of
said providing agency while providing aid pursuant to this Agreement,
subject to Chapter 768. Florida Statutes, where applicable.
7. Forfeitures: It is recognized that during the course of the operation of the
Agreement. property subject to forfeiture under the Florida Contraband
Forfeiture Act. Florida Statutes. may be seized. The property shall be
seized. forfeited. and equitably distributed among the participating
agencies in proportion to the amount of investigation and participation
performed by each agency. This shall occur pursuant to the provisions of
the Florida Contraband Forfeiture Act.
8. Conflicts: Any conflict between this Agreement and the Florida Mutual
Aid Act will be controlled by the provisions of the latter. whenever
conditions exist that are within the definitions stated in Chapter 23. Florida
Statutes.
9. Effective Date and Duration: This Agreement shall be in effect from
date of signing. through and including January 1, 2011, and under no
circumstances may this Agreement be renewed. amended or extended
except in writing.
10. Cancellation: This Agreement may be canceled by either party upon
sixty (60) days written notice to the other party. Cancellation will be at the
discretion of the chief executive officers of the parties hereto.
.2006.
City Manager. City of Avenlura, Florida
L
ATTEST:
City Clerk. City of Aventura, Florida
TERESA M SOROKA. MMC
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
t^-------
City Attorney, City of Aventura, Florida
FL
JOINT DECLARATION
OF THE CHIEF OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA POLICE DEPARTMENT
AND THE CHIEF OF THE TOWN OF SURFSIDE POLICE DEPARTMENT
PURSUANT TO MUTUAL AID AGREEMENT
A deputy sheriff or police officer of either of the participating law enforcement
agencies shall be considered to be operating under the provisions of the Mutual
Aid Agreement when:
participating in law enforcement activities that are preplanned
and approved by each respective agency head, or
appropriately dispatched in response to a request for assistance
from the other law enforcement agency.
In compliance with, and under the authority of, the Mutual Aid Agreement, hereto
entered into by the City of Aventura, Florida, and the Town of Surfside, Florida,
it is hereby declared that the following list comprises the circumstances and
conditions under which mutual aid may be requested and rendered regarding
police operations pursuant to the Agreement. Said list may be amended or
supplemented from time to time, as needs dictate by subsequent declarations.
1. Joint multi-jurisdictional criminal investigations
2. Civil affray or disobedience, disturbances, riots, large protest
demonstrations, controversial trials, political conventions, labor disputes,
and strikes
3. Any natural disaster
4. Incidents which require rescue operations and crowd and traffic control
measures, including, but not limited to, large-scale evacuations, aircraft
and shipping disasters, fires, explosions, gas line leaks, radiological
incidents, train wrecks and derailments, chemical or hazardous waste
spills, and electrical power failures
5. Terrorist activities including, but not limited to, acts of sabotage
6. Escapes from or disturbances within detention facilities
7. Hostage and barricaded subject situations, and aircraft piracy
8. Control of major crime scenes, area searches, perimeter control, backups
to emergency and in-progress calls, pursuits, and missing persons calls
9. Enemy attack
10. Transportation of evidence requiring security
11. Major events; e.g., sporting events, concerts, parades. fairs, festivals, and
conventions
12. Security and escort duties for dignitaries
13. Emergency situations in which one agency cannot perform its functional
objective
14. Incidents requiring utilization of specialized units; e.g., underwater
recovery, canine, motorcycle, crime scene, marine patrol enforcement or
investigation. and police information
15. Joint training in areas of mutual need
16. Participating in exigent situations without a formal request which are
spontaneous occurrences such as area searches for wanted subjects,
perimeters, crimes in progress, escaped prisoners; traffic stops near
municipal boundaries, request for assistance and no local unit is available
or nearby, calls or transmissions indicating an officer is injured, calls
indicating a crime or incident has occurred in which a citizen may likely be
injured and the assisting municipality is closer to the area than the officer
receiving the call
17. Mutual enforcement of all existing applicable laws and ordinances and
exercise of arrest powers within the area comprising the jurisdictional
waters within respective municipal boundaries
DATE:
51",Id-.oDr...
DATE:
/----~-
~:::?~. ~~'~--:.~------=- J
Chie(TownofSuriside Police Dept.
Su;rside. Florida
S O'REILLY
..~
--------------
Chief of City of Aventura Police Dept.,
Aventura. Florida
THOMAS E RIBEL
ATTEST:
ATTEST:
City Clerk, City of Aventura
TERESA M SOROKA. MMC
Town of Suriside. FL. CITY CLERK
JOINT DECLARATION AMENDMENT UNDER
TOWN OF SURFSIDE POLICE!
AVENTURA POLICE
MUTUAL AID AGREEMENT
This Agreement amends the Joint Declaration under the Mutual Aid Agreement
of ' 2006, to include and permit concurrent marine patrol
related jurisdiction between agencies on the waters, waterways, canals,
channels, rivers, lakes. streams. and any and all other bodies of waters. including
the Intracoastal Waterway (ICW) that fall within either jurisdiction at this or any
future time during the term of this Mutual Aid Agreement.
It will be agreed between both Chiefs of Police of the TOWN OF SURFSIDE and
the City of Aventura to the following conditions of concurrent marine patrol
related jurisdiction:
1. Both agencies will be permitted to patrol jurisdictional waters of either
jurisdiction, and to take enforcement actions as deemed appropriate
under city. state, and federal laws, rules. and regulations, and to write
boating law violation citations, make arrests, and to attend court on be-
half of the other agency.
2 Both agencies agree that any and all incidents. which require an initial
(preliminary) police offense incident report (OIR), will be completed by
the agency making the initial contact. Any follow-up investigations that
are required are to be completed by the jurisdiction the incident occurred
regardless of which agency completed the original offense incident report.
3. If an arrest is made by one agency that is operating in the jurisdictional
waters of the other agency, and that arrest results in asset forfeiture
proceedings, both agencies agree to a 50-50 share of the final asset
distribution following the payment of all expenses relating to the prose-
cution of the civil case. The jurisdiction of civil forfeiture action shall be
filed by seizing agency.
4. Both agencies have the right to set their own days and hours for marine
patrol and agree to provide assistance and aid to the other agency under
the spirit of Mutual Aid Agreement.
This Amendment shall become effective upon the signing of both Chiefs of Police
and shall remain in effect until either the current Mutual Aid Agreement and Joint
Declaration expires or either agency gives written notice to the other agency to
rescind this Amendment.
I accept the terms and conditions of the aforementioned Amendment to the
current Mutual Aid Agreement and Joint Declaration between the City of
Aventura police Department and the SURFSIDE Police Department.
~ - J.^--< (3, )e)()y
~
Date
Eric M. Soroka, City Manager
Aventura, Florida
C ~-~<J~b$~~
.., . , -ref of Police.
Town of Surfside
Thomas E. Ribel, Chief of Police
City of Aventura police Dept.
(914:Joint Declaration)
CITY OF AVENTURA
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM, Cit
DATE: September 5, 2006
SUBJECT: Recommendation to Award Bid No: 06-07-24-2 - Miami Gardens
Drive Extension
September 12,2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item 5',1\
Recommendation
It is recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached Resolution awarding
Bid No. 06-07-24-2, Miami Gardens Drive Extension Improvements to the lowest
responsible and responsive bidder, Williams Paving Company, Inc. for the price of
$2,222,788.00.
Backaround
In accordance with the City's Purchasing Ordinance, bids for this project were solicited,
advertised, and opened on July 24, 2006. The City received three (3) bids for this
project.
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
MEF Construction, Inc.
Community Asphalt Corporation
$2,222,788.00
$2,389,422.65
$2,464,881.66
This bid price allows for roadway construction and drainage system installation on
Miami Gardens Drive from Biscayne Boulevard east to the west property line of the
Terzetto Development together with street lighting and landscaping improvements from
Biscayne Boulevard to NE 28th Court. The bid also includes improvements to the
intersection of Miami Gardens Drive and Biscayne Boulevard as required by FDOT and
Dade County.
The contract price includes enhanced project elements to be funded by the City. They
include decorative street lighting and an enhanced landscaping package. The contract
cost for the enhanced project elements were $486,987.50. Therefore, the cost to be
funded by the County would be $1,735,800.50. The Joint Participation Agreement
(JPA) included a figure of $566,007 to fund the project by the County.
As outlined in the attached letter dated August 3, 2006, we have requested the County
to approve funding the revised cost of $1 ,735,800.50.
The County's Public Works Director, Esther Calas has confirmed in the attached letter
dated August 31, 2006 that staff supports the funding of the additional $1,735,800.50
from the County's share of the People's Transportation Plan (PTP) funds. The original
JPA will need to be amended and approved by the Board of County Commissioners
and the Citizen's Independent Trust will need to approve the use of the PTP funds.
Despite the additional steps that are required to finalize the County's share of the
funding, it is recommended that we award the bid to expedite this important project.
We are in the process of finalizing all required permits to commence the project with the
low bidder. The developer (Merco Group) of the adjoining property who is required to
fund and construct the portion of the roadway adjacent to their property has advised
work will commence in the next 30 to 60 days.
If you have any questions or need any additional information, please feel free to contact
me.
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING AND LETTING A BID/CONTRACT
FOR BID NO. 06-07-24-2, MIAMI GARDENS DRIVE EXTENSION
IMPROVEMENTS, TO WILLIAMS PAVING COMPANY, INC. AT THE
BID PRICE OF $2,222,788.00. AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
EXECUTE ASSOCIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO TAKE NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT ACTION TO
CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; PROVIDING FOR THE
APPROPRIATION AND ALLOCATION OF FUNDS FOR SAID BID
AWARD; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Manager has, pursuant to the various laws of the State of
Florida and the Code of the City of Aventura, properly solicited and accordingly
accepted bids for BID NO. 06-07-24-2, Miami Gardens Drive Extension Improvements;
and
WHEREAS, sealed bids have been submitted to and received by the City
pursuant to the City's Invitation to Bid/Notice to Bidders, specifications, proposals, and
requirements for the projecUwork as cited above; and
WHEREAS, staff has determined that Williams Paving Company, Inc. has
submitted the lowest responsible and responsive bid for said projecUwork; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission, upon the recommendation of the City
Manager, is therefore desirous of awarding said bid/contract to said lowest responsible
and responsive bidder.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA:
Section 1: That bid/contract for BID NO. 06-07-24-2, Miami Gardens Drive
Extension Improvements, is hereby awarded to Williams Paving Company, Inc. in the
amount of $2,222,788.00.
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 2
Section 2: That the City Manager is hereby authorized to execute, on behalf of
the City, a contract by and between the parties embodying the terms, conditions, and
specifications as set forth in the subject Invitation to Bid/Notice to Bidders, bid
specifications, bid proposal and bid requirements, or if a City prepared contract was
part of said bid proposal, said parties shall execute said prepared contract on behalf of
the City.
Section 3: That the City Manager is hereby authorized and requested to take
all necessary and expedient action to carry out the aims of this Resolution in awarding
this bid/contract.
Section 4: That the funds to be allocated and appropriated pursuant hereto
and for the purpose of carrying out the tenets of this Resolution shall be from the
Capital Improvements Program Budget Line Item Numbers FY 2005/06 - 120-5001-
541-6307 ($140,000), FY 2005/06 - 001-5001-541-6341 ($1,735,800.50) and FY
2006/07001-5001-541-6301 ($347,000).
Section 5: This Resolution shall be effective immediately upon its adoption.
, who
, and
The foregoing resolution was offered by Commissioner
moved its adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-
Page 3
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 12'h day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVEMO~L~CY:
CITY ATTORNEY
MIAMI'~
rmmm iiiI
ADA Coordination
AgendaCoordinalion
Art in Public Places
Audit and Management Services
Aviation
Building Code Compli,lnce
Building
Business Development
Capi13llmprovements
Citizen.s Independent Transportation Trusl
Communications
Community Action Agency
Community & Economic Development
Community Relations
Consumer Services
Corrections & Rehabilitation
Countywide Healthcare Planning
Cultural Affairs
Elections
Emergency Managemenl
Employee Relations
EnlerpriseTechnologyServices
Environmental Resources Mandgement
Fair Employment Practices
Fir1ance
Fire Rescue
GerwralServicesAnministration
Historic Preservation
HomelessT,u,!
Housing Agency
Housing finance Allthorily
Human Services
Independent Review Panel
IntemJtionJI TrJde Consortium
Juvenile Assessmenl Center
Medical Examiner
MelropolitJn PIJnnjng OrgJniZJtion
ParkJndRecreJtion
PIJnningJnd Zoning
Police
PrOCl.lrementMJnJgemenl
Property Appraiser
Public library System
Public Works
Safe Neighborhood Parks
Seaport
SolidWa.teManJgement
Strategic Bu.inessMJnJgement
Team Metro
Transit
Urban RevitJlizalionTaskForce
Vizcaya Museum Jnd Garden,
Water and Sewer
August 31,2006
Public Works Department
111 NW 1st Street. Suite 1510
Miami, Florida 33128-1970
T 305-375-2094 F 305-679-7738
miamidade.gov
Mr. Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM
City of Aventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura, FL 33180
Re:
Miami Gardens Drive Connector Improvements Joint Participation
Agreement (JPA)
Dear Mr. Soroka:
Miami-Dade County Public Works Department (PWD) reviewed the bid packages
submitted for the Miami Gardens Drive Connector from Biscayne Boulevard to
the western terminus of the of the Aventura Landings Development and approves
of the City's recommendation to award the contract to the low bidder, Williams
Paving Company, Inc., provided that the City and County secure an amendment
to the original Joint Participation Agreement (JPA) to revise the funds available
for this project.
The low bid, at $2,222,788.00, minus the City's commitment of $486,987.50 for
decorative street lighting and landscaping, incurs a construction cost of
$1,735,800.50 to the County. This cost is in excess of the $566,007.00 originally
programmed for this project. Additional funds to cover the increased costs will
not be available for the next three years from District 3 Road Impact Fees (RIF).
The County, however. has identified funds through the People's Transportation
Plan (PTP) for these improvements. By amending the JPA, and subject to the
approval of the Citizen's Independent Transportation Trust (CITT) and the Board
of County Commissioners (BCG), these PTP funds may be used for this project.
Pursuant to CITT and BCC approval of the revised JPA, the City may issue a
notice to proceed to begin these important transportation and traffic flow
improvements.
The County will commence the amendment process to the JPA. Should you
have any reservations or require further clarification. please contact Mr. Gaspar
Miranda P.E., Chief, Highway Division, at (305) 375-2094.
Sincerely,
'--...;
(-
Esther L. Calas, P.E.
Director
,
SEP 0'" ,'GOfi
OHICt.ut ,""
CITY MANAGE;,
Cc: Gaspar Miranda, P.E.
Leandro Gna. P.E.
David Tinder. P.E.
Sally Heyman, County Commissioner, District 4
II'~' ,\II::lj.
. r.
..... ...
..... >'
.""::- .....
~
.,.,;. -;< *
*'c:-_:,~_~_ ",_:~_:-_
~~~;;,? ~.
!'.. -
City of
Aventura
~ ~
~ lJ.,vtI'
eq~ 06 &#
Government Center
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
Office of the City Manager
August 3, 2006
Ms. Esther Calas, P.E.
Director of Public Works
Miami-Dade County Public Works
Highway Division
111 NW. 1st Street, #1610
Miami, Florida 33128
Re: Miami Gardens Drive Connector Improvements Joint Participation Agreement
Dear Ms. Calas:
As you are aware, the City and County entered into the subject Agreement in September of
2003 to construct the Miami Gardens Drive Connector from Biscayne Boulevard to the
westem terminus of the property line of the Aventura Landings Development.
The bid was opened on June 12, 2006. The City only received one bid at a cost of
$2,515,000. The City rejected the bid. After a concentrated effort to obtain additional
bidders, the project was rebid on July 24, 2006. The City received three bids as follows:
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
MEF Construction, Inc.
Community Asphalt Corporation
$2,222,788.00
$2,389,422.65
$2,464,881.66
After a careful review and evaluation of the bid packages, we are recommending that the
bid be awarded to the lowest bidder. I have attached the low bidder's package.
The contract price includes enhanced project elements to be funded by the City. They
include decorative street lighting and an enhanced landscaping package. The contract cost
for the enhanced project elements were $486,987.50.
Therefore, the cost to be funded by the County would be $1,735,800.50. The Joint
Participation Agreement included a figure of $566,007 to fund the project by the County.
The following outlines the reasons why the contract estimate is so different than the amount
included in the Joint Participation Agreement (JPA):
PHONE: 305-466-8910 · FAX: 305-466-8919
www.cityofaventura.com
August 3, 2006
Ms. Esther Calas
Page Two
1. The estimate contained in the jPA is over a year-and-a-half old.
2. The cost of asphalt has skyrocketed since the adoption of the jpA.
3. Soil tests and corresponding increase in costs due to unacceptable soil
conditions occurred after the estimate was formulated.
4. Signalization improvements required by FOOT and the County cost
$282,186.70. The total cost of intersection improvements at Biscayne
Boulevard inclusive of signalization is $489,277.
5. Permitting requirements by both FOOT and the County required revisions to
the plan that resulted in cost increases not included in the original estimate.
In order to expedite and move forward on this important transportation and traffic flow
improvement project, I respectfully request your assistance as follows:
1. Obtain County approval to fund the revised County funded cost of
$1,735,800.50 based on the low bid.
2. As required by the jPA, approve the City's recommendation to award the
contract to the low bidder, Williams Paving Company, Inc.
As always, thank you for our assistance in this matter.
EMS/act
Attachment
cc: City Commission
Tony Tomei, Capital Projects Manager
Sally Heyman, County Commissioner
CM01855-06
MEMORANDUM
CRAVEN THOMPSON AND ASSOCIATES, INC.
Date:
August 1, 2006
To:
Tony Tomei, City of A ventura
From:
Kevin Hart, Consulting Engineer
Reference:
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
At your request, I have reviewed the bid tabulation for this project and the Schedule of Values presented
by the apparent low bidder, Williams Paving Company.
The City received a total of three (3) bids for the project ranging in price from $2.22 million to $2.46
million. The total spread between all three bids was $242,093.66 or 10.89%. The Williams Paving
Company submitted the low bid in the amount of$2,222,788.00.
Based on my review of the bid tabulation and Schedule of Values, I am recommending that the City
award the contract for the Miami Gardens Drive Extension to Williams Paving Company, subject to a
satisfactory response to your reference check.
If you have any questions or require any additional infonnation, please call.
SECTION 00410
BID FORM
THIS BID IS SUBMITTED TO:
City of A ventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura. Florida 33180
BID FOR: Miami Gardens Drive Extension
BID No: 06-01-24-2
1be undersigned BIDDER proposes and agrees, if this Bid is accepted, to enter into an agreement with The
City of Aventura in the form included in the Contract Documents to perform and furnish all Work as
specified or indicated in the Contract Documents for the Contract Price and within the Contract Time
indicated in this Bid and in accordance with the other terms and conditions of the Contract Documents.
1. BIDDER accepts all of the terms and conditions of the Advertisement or Invitation to Bid and
Instructions to BIDDER'S, including without limitation those dealing with the disposition of Bid
Security. TI1.is Bid will remain subject to acceptance for 180 days after the !by of Bid opening.
BIDDER agrees to sign and submit the Agreement with the Bonds and other documents required by
the Bidding Requirements within ten !bys after the date of City's Notice of Award.
In submitting this Bid, BIDDER represents, as more fully set forth in the Agreement, that
(a) BIDDER has examined copies of all the Bidding Documents and of the following Addenda
(receipt of all which is hereby acknowledged.)
Addendum No. 1
Addendum No. 2
Addendum No. 3
Addendum No.
Dated: 7/10/2006
Dated: 7/12/2006
Dated: 7/17/2006
Dated:
(b) BIDDER has familiarized themselves with the nature and extent of the Contract Documents,
Work, site, locality, and all local conditions and Law and Regulations that in any manner
may affect cost, progress, performance or furnishing of the Work.
(c) BIDDER has studied carefully all reports and drawings of subsurface conditions and
drawings of physical conditions.
(d) BIDDER has obtained and carefully studied (or assumes responsibility for obtaining and
carefully studying) all such examinations, investigations, explorations, tests and studies (in
addition to or to supplement those referred to in (c) above) which pertain to the subsurface
or physical conditions at the site or otherwise may affect the cost, progress, performance, or
furnishing of the Work at the Contract Price, within the Contract Time and in accordance
with the other terms and conditions of the Contract Documents, and no additional
examinations, invesligations, explorations, tests. reports or similar information or data are
or will be required by BIDDER for such purposes.
(e) BIDDER has reviewed and checked all information and data shown or indicated on the
Contract Documents with respect to existing Underground Facilities at or contiguous to the
site and assumes responsibility for the accurate location of said Underground Facilities. No
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
erA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 1
additional examinations, investigations. explorations, tests, reports or similar infonnation or
data in respect of said Underground Facilities are or will be required by BIDDER in ordcr
to perform and furnish the Work at the Contract Price. within the Contracl Time and in
accordance with the other terms and conditions of the Contract Documents.
(f) BIDDER has correlated the results of all such observations, examinations, investigations,
explorations, tests. reports and studies with the terms and conditions of the Contract
Documents.
(g) BIDDER has given Consultant written notice of all conflicts, errors, discrepancies that it
has discovered in the Contract Documents and the written resolution thereof by Consultant
is acceptable to BIDDER.
(It) This Bid is genuine and not made in the interest of or on behalf of any undisclosed person,
firm or corporation and is not submitted in conformity with any agreement or rules of any
group, association, organization, or corporation; BIDDER has not directly or indirectly
induced or solicited any other BIDDER to submit a false or sham Bid; BIDDER has not
solicited or induced any person, firm or corporation to refrain from bidding; and BIDDER
has not sought by collusion to obtain for itself any advantage over any other BIDDER or
over the City.
3. BIDDER understands and agrees that the Contract Price is Iwnp sum to furnish and install all of the
Work complete in place. 1be Schedule of Values is provided for the purpose of Bid Evaluation and
when initiated by the City, the pricing of change orders. Contractor's price will not be adjusted to
reflect any deviation from the Schedule Of Values, except to the extent that the City changes the
scope of Project after the Contract Date.
As such the Contractor shall furnish all labor, materials, equipment, tools superintendeIlCe and
services necessary to provide a complete in place Project for the Bid Price of:
- .
\t.OO m\L~\OY\. 1U20 \\uY\D(WTweflT'1-Tl-OO TI-\t1I<.,AYlV
Sf\!pYl \-\-uY\O('eJ ei~~ -e-'-S-""'"t dollars and
7Gl2.D cents LUMP SUM
(Written Total Bid Price - From Schedule Of Values)
BIDDER agrees that the work will be complete in full wilhin 210 calendar days from Ihe dale
stipulaled in Ihe Notice to PI"oceed.
4. Conununications cOIlCerning this Bid shall be addressed to:
BIDDER:
Address:
Williams Pavinq COl11PmV, Inc.
11300 NW South River Drive
Medley, Florida 33178
305-882-1950
305-882-1966
Ron Smith - Vice President
Telephone
Facsimile Number
Attention:
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 2
5. The terms used in this Bid which are dermed in the General Conditions of the Construction Contract
included as part of the Contract documents have the meanings assigned to them in the General
Conditions.
SUBMITTED THIS DAY
July
~,20 06
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06.07-24-2
erA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 3
SECTION 00410
SCHEDULE OF VALUES
FOR LUMP SUM
CONTRACT
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Item Quantity Description Unit Unit Price Extended
Cost
GENERAL
I GENERAL CONDITIONS LS $ ,,-\q<Q'OD $ qq<(;1..OQ
2 MOBIUZATION LS $ n 39'6'5.'0:5 $ 11?,()"{S-.~
3 I MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC LS $ 01 'SW. at> $ '01,SOO'oO
.
SUB-TOTAL $ aCA. ;:5(of).~~
MIAMI GARDENS DRIVE EXTENSION
ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS
4 4.373 12" SUBGRADE STABILIZATION SY $ \'=!:,.')O $ 5"'\,0'5.-:P
5 4,373 12" LIMEROCK BASE SY $ ~5D $ 1"75,,\.l<>\'-\'"':,o
$ q C).CD "?').-ep.fX)
6 397 L75" ASPHALT (1ST LIFf) (S-I) TN $ :'3.5, 7;,D;(P ..,.2-L
7 397 0.75" ASPHALT (2ND LIIT)(S-I) TN $'10.00 $ ::75, 'I 't>t>.00
8 7,381 GEOGRID (fENSAR BX 1100, SY $ 5.DO $ ~,qoS.C5D
OAE.)
9 1,235 TYPE "F" CURB & GlfITER LF $ 02. .Ob $ 01,52.0.o~
10 530 TYPE"D"CURB LF $ :o'b'CO $ olD, /</O.()D
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7/17/06
3
II 111 CONCRETE SIDEWALK (5' WIDE) LF S ...f 1.)0 S '5,;).70l'~O
(6" THICK)
12 1,345 CONCRETE SIDEWALK (5' WIDE) SY S oo.DO S l")\l 'l'b<:'(::O
13 4 PEDESTRIAN RAMPS EA S A'-tl.-OO S'l"1Io,\,oo
I
14 30 TYPE IV CONCRETE TRAFFIC LF S \\P\.QO S ~'1;":,D'OD
SEPARATOR (4' WIDE)
15 2,594 REMOVE EXISTING PAVEMENT SY S 5-cD S I 'Z-S10-DD
,
16 921 REMOVE EXISTING CURB & LF S ,'S.~D S ILl l'l~.50
,
GUTTER
17 145 REMOVE EXISTING "D" CURB LF S \S-"50 S "2:2. '-\l.jC)
18 431 REMOVE EXSITING CONCRTE LF S ':5.50 S to<o '6D.5O
SIDEWALK (5' WIDE)
19 6,710 REMOVE UNSUITABLE SOIL CY S 01-\' CD S 1'-10,<:\\0'<=
19A 111 V ALLEY GUTTER LF S '-Ie.,:>\:) S L\4q')."'$b
19B I RELOCATE EXIST FIRE HYDRANf LF SlA &.00 S td'1,?l.'=
RELOCATE EXIST. UllLITY
19C 1 IN UTILITY EASEMENTS TO LF S 34\c\c-oo $ ~L\'e<.o-oD
INSTALL DRAINAGE WELLS
SIGNS
20 ROADSIDE SIGN [(TURN RIGHT AS $ I,\;':,.()Q S I'{") -<X:l
DIRECTIONAL ARROW
SYMBOL)(R3-5R) (24" X 30")( WITH
POS1)].
21 3 ROADSIDE SIGN(ONE WAY RIGHf AS S 'o':>-co S 5SS'DU
-R6-IR)
22 3 ROADSIDE SIGN [( RIGHT LANE AS S \ ,&').00 S sSS -00
MUST TURN RIGHT SYMBOL )(R3-
7) (24" X 30")(WITH POST)].
23 3 ROADSIDE SIGN [(KEEP RIGHT AS S '",,<;-0:> S 5S-S-. <.D
SYMBOL)(R4-7) (24" X 30")( WIlli
POST)].
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7117/06
4
24 S RELOCATE EXISTING EXISTING EA $ \00-00 $ ",,00.=
SIGNS
25 4 REMOVE END OF ROAD EA $-:;>0-00 $ 2Da. ca
MARKERS
26 4 RELOCATE TRAFFIC SIGNAL EA $ ~CXDOD $ '1QOD-OC>
BOXES
27 60 GUARDRAIL (ROADWAY) LF $ \OD-CO $ \oc:c>O. c::=
(INCLUDES THE COST OF SHOP
PANELS)
27A 2 SPEED LIMIT SIGN(R2-I) AS $ \,\':;-.00 $ '370'u:::,
27B SO SOLID TRAFFFIC STRIPE LF $ \.'(;0 $1'4\..\.=
(is''YELLOW)(T)
fA VEMENT MARKINGS
2& 73 SOLID TRAFFIC STRIPE (24" LF $ 2-'YO $ 2.0-\.'-\0
WHITE) (TIIERMOPLASTIC)
29 316 SOLID TRAFFIC STRIPE (12" LF $ 0."'';- $ les.,\O
wmTE) (TIIERMOPLASTIC)
30 1,710 SOLID TRAFFIC STRIPE (6" LF $ Q.<..\Cl $ (P'i~.\::j::>
YELLOW)
31 1.755 SOLID TRAFFIC STRIPE (6" LF $ o.~o $ T){)l. cD
wmTE)
32 1,115 SKIP TRAFFIC STRIPE (10'-30', 6" LF $ O'\.{D $ 4,'--l1c.00
. WHITE)
33 II DIRECIlONAL ARROWS EA $ 4S.0:> $Lf?'S-oc:>
(TIIERMOPLASTIC)
34 ~
93 REFLECfIVE PAVEMENT EA $ 3.'15 $~'1.-3~
MARKERS PERMANENT (B1-
DIRECIlONAL) AMBER/AMBER
35 4 REFLECTIVE PAVEMENT EA $ a.qs- $ (s.~
MARKER PERMANENT (CLASS B)
(BI-DIRECTIONAL)(CLEARlRED)
36 I REMOVE THERMOPLASTIC LS $ 11..l.>'L.ro $ \21..>,/;,.00
~
SUB-TOTAL $ (p'1,'\ ,"5$=\.'\j ~
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7/17/06
5
STORM DRAINAGE
37 589 PIPE CULVERT- 24" DIAMETER LF $ '31.00 $ '1'1, ,S'1'00
38 233 PIPE CUL VERT- 18" DIAMETER LF $ ca. OD $ '22, 'l?'1 ,QC)
39 3 INLET, CURB (TYPE P-6 )< 10' LF $ 5S \j I). CD $ \\p,ID'-1 \.00
40 INLET CURB (TYPE P-5 )< 10' LF $ :5ILb'oO $ 512.1;.00
41 3 INLETS (CURB) TYPE P-4< 10' LF $ 5:,"\':).(X) $ \~,,'SS.=
42 3 MANHOLES, ]-7, >10' EA $ ~<(\o.oo $ 1~,q'5'(;'OO
43 4 POLLUTION REf ARDENT EA $~ CH't.oa $ 2.'2.."1.,'C{'L.=
,
BASlNSIDRAlNAGE WELL (6X6X8)
44 7 DRAINAGE STRUCTURES, EA $ '1'1(). Db $ lAW'DD
MISCELLANEOUS, ADJUST
45 75 ABANDON FRENCH LF $ W).CD $ .35;lJ'OO
DRAlNIEXFILTRATION TRENCH
SUB-TOTAL $ 31\ , "52.2. Dc>
LIGHTINGlELECTRICAL
46 14,200 2" PVC SCH 40 CONDUIT, LF $ ''-\.100 $ cJO''1. ::,'lD.OO
FURNISH AND lNST ALL,
COMPLETE IN PLACE
47 700 2" PVC DIRECTIONAL BORED LF $ 7J"2.':?:J0 $ -;1~ .(o\b.co
CONDUITS UNDER EXISTlNG
ROADWAY
48 11,800 #6 XHHW CONDUCTORS, LF $ ~)'lpo $~, lfID.OO
PROVIDE AND lNST ALL
49 11 INSTALL NEW SINGLE FIXTIJRE EA $ OlS :?:{).O-) $ ;:;n I "'6(j). CD
AND POLE,COMPLETE IN PLACE
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendwn No.3
7117/06
6
50 13 INSTALL NEW SINGLE FIXTURE, EA s ~5 3D- be s ~11flD'OO
POLE AND BANNER ARM,
COMPLETE IN PLACE
51 MODIFY EXISTING SERVICE EA s \,2~-::,.~0 S \dlPy 70
I'OINT A
52 2 RELOCATE EXlSTING STREET EA S d-\c(j:l. \D s (5~()O'20
LIGHT POLE, FURNISH AND
INSTALL NEW PULL BOX AND
CONCRETE BASE. COMPLETE IN
PLACE
53 RELOCATE LIGHTED STREET EA S d,;;2~(l'1,O s ~;;N9. .1;0
SIGN, CONCRETE BASE AND SIGN
TRANSFORMER, FURNISH AND
INSTALL NEW PULL BOX
COMPLETE IN PLACE
54 2 RELOCATE EXISTING PARKING EA S~41'~O s 4 Lf'14' ~D
LOT LIGHT POLE, FURNISH AND
INSTALL PULL BOX AND
CONCRETE BASE, COMPLETE IN
PLACE
55 NEW PULL BOX, FURNISH AND EA S WlD.~D S 4>4\0.1.0
INSTALL, COMPLETE IN PLACE
SUB-TOTAL
$
LANDSCAPE AND IRRIGA nON
56 11 COCOS NUCIFERA 'GREEN EA S O?~\C>-oo S d'i.. ')10.00
MALAYAN' (COCONUT PALM)
57 5 ROYSTONEA ELATA (FLORIDA EA S 0ID10.OQ S \0, D$O' (X)
ROYAL PALM)
58 5 VEITCHIA MONTGOMERYANA EA S'1\O-oo S o~~()- =
(MONTGOMERY PALM)
59 450 FICUS MICROCARP A 'GREEN EA S 11....00 S ~l.\(j)-OO
ISLAND' (GR. ISLAND FICUS)
60 1,275 JASMINUM VOLUSILE (WAX EA Sq.OD $ \1,'-1'"';'00
JASMINE) 5.DD
61 945 SEASONAL COLOR EA S $\,\ I~S'OO
62 TREElPALM REMOVAL & LS $ \ d-IYJ. oc> S ll...cO.DO
DISPOSAL
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7/17/06
7
63 2 RELOCATE ROYAL PALMS EA $ ') \)(). DO $ \ '-lOO' Q(}
63A 8 RELOCATE MEDJOOLPALMS EA $ IC)OD'OO $ 1;000.00
63B 53 I" WATER SERVICE FOR LF $ '00. DC) $ ISCltO.OQ
IRRJGATION
63B CONNECTION I" SERVICE TO EA $ .;2500.ob $ a"S\)O'oo
EXIST WATER MAIN
64 235 PREPARED SOIL LAYER- CY $ on; .00 $ wS'bO'=
ORGANIC SOIL LAYER, 6"
65 I IRRIGATION LS $ ::>Y X\b'OO $-54. <(;\'b' co
SUB-TOTAL $ \ ~,,\,qcW..O{)
US-I LEFT TURN LANE CONSTRUCTION
ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS
66 724 12" SUBGRADE STABILIZATION SY $ \~.OO $ \Ol\~'=
67 560 12" LIMEROCK BASE SY $ LJ1.'oD $ d.?,5;lO.Ob
68 547 3/4" FRICTION COURSE (FC-5) SY $ 17DO $ r') \\\.00
I
69 560 STRUCURAL COURSE (TYPE SP) SY $ H)'CO $ otoc.:::o.oa
70 4,222 MILL EXISTING ASPHALT (3/4" SY $ .</.00 $ \\.p,~'l;1)- 00
MINlMUM THICKNESS)
71 4,222 3/4" FRICTION COURSE FC-5 (RE- SY $ \:o.DO $ '0'-\ l~to.()(J
SURF ACE INTERSECTIONS)
72 250 TYPE "D" CURB LF $ J.fb ''7"') $ I;;:! r \ ',F)''$O
73 0 REMOVE EXISTING PAVEMENT SY $ 5'~DO $ ~
74 366 REMOVE EXISTING CURB & LF $ 15,"50 $ "5,-<>"'7::>.00
I
GlJITER
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum NO.3
7/17/06
8
75
145
REMOVE EXISTING "D" CURB
LF $ IS.SO
$ "2. "Z.'-\'1.-SO
SUB-TOTAL
$ 1~"'/;,~~q.OD
SIGNS
76 3 RELOCATE EXISTING SIGNS EA $ \ OO.D(:) $ 300.00
77 2 RELOCATE TRAFFIC SIGNAL EA $ !;J.r.:IJ) . a:::, $ 4()CO. 00
BOXES
78 REMOVE CONCRErE POLE EA $ lJOO.ro $ \ 1..cP. OC)
SUB-TOTAL S 6;;5 (X). ot::>
FA VEMENT MARKINGS
79 87 SOLID TRAFFIC STRIPE (24" LF S 2. "bO S .;il\ 710Cl
WHITE) (IllERMOPLASTIC)
80 405 SOUD TRAFFIC STRIPE (18" LF S \ '''DO S '7;19.DO
YELLOW) (TIlERMOPLASTIC)
81 703 SOUD TRAFFIC STRIPE (6" LF $ O' bO;- S ~~.'TS-
YELLOW)
82 428 SOLID TRAFFIC STRIPE (6" LF S O.bS" S ~'1'h';:lO
WHITE)
83 1,489 SKIP TRAFFIC STRIPE (2'-4'. 6" LF S D'b"S" $ qlJ>'1."b~
WHITE)
84 3 DIRECTIONAL ARROWS EA Sl\s.Q<:> $ \ ~.DCJ
(lHERMOPLASTIC)
85 52 REFLECfIVE PAVEMENT EA $Q.g") $ dO'S'I.{O
MARKERS PERMANENT (BI-
DIRECTIONAL) AMBER/AMBER
86 1 REMOVE lHERMOPLASTIC LS $ \ (,'5I:::>-oa S 1"2<;0.=
SUB-TOTAL $ ~"Z.lo\o.OD
STORM DRAINAGE
87 5 DRAINAGE STRUCTURES, EA $ q9D.CO $ L\CJ00.00
MISCELLANEOUS ADJUST
Miami Gardens Drive Ex.tension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7117106
9
SUB-TOTAL
$ L\: Q:"St>'DO
SIGNALIZATION
88 2 CONCRETE CLASS I CY $ 3\S'.1(O $ !P~\.20
89 78 CONDUIT (UNDERGROUND) (2" LF $ l't.~ $ 11.\ ::l-'V-\t::.
PVC)
90 1,489 CONDUIT (UNDER PAVEMENT) LF $ 32 '?J) $ Llt,CR'-\'{O
(2" PVC)
91 I CABLE (SIGNAL) PI $'50:;)'1.'/0 $ '5~~7.~D
92 100 CABLE (INTERCONNECI) LF $ 5.0<0> $ 500.00
93 13 PULL & JUNCI10N BOXES (pULL EA $ S5S. SO $ rYZ:L\-SD
BOX)
94 PULL & JUNCfION BOXES EA $ \~1,.2D $\~'ZO
(INTERCONNECI)
95 ELECfRICAL POWER SERVICE AS $ 00t;~. :0 $ 'OC:::flS,30
96 135 ELECfRICAL SERVICE WIRE LF $ ~'l&O $ '41;\0- 00
97 I MAST ARM ASSEMBLY [SINGLE AS $ ll, f)Clq-so $ oH , ,Cl'1 .'50
ARM].. 649-713-002
98 1 MAST ARM ASSEMBLY [SINGLE AS $ Z.S,qOS. (P $ 2'5, CfD5.co
ARM] .. 649-715-003
99 MAST ARM ASSEMBLY [SINGLE AS $;;(y" 't(,c.J. 00 $ db,%t/.eD
ARM] - 649-717-006
100 MAST ARM ASSEMBLY [DOUBLE $ :~>'),L\~.1cD $ 31, \.\~t.l.oa
AS
ARM] - 649-726-404
101 I SIGN STRUCTURE (MAST ARM AS $;<'~,\;;l\p.'70 $ dS.\.9lPY)O
ASSEMBLY WITIi 2-SIGN PANELS)
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Avetttura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendnffi No.3
7/17/06
10
]02 10 TRAFFIC SIGNAL HEAD AS $ IDeA .'10 $ ID,o<=t9.0D
ASSEMBLY (1- WAY. 3 SECTION)
103 2 TRAFFIC SIGNAL HEAD AS $ I 33I'S'b $ (jJ.e[P!).QO
ASSEMBLY (1- WAY. 4SECTION)
104 3 TRAFFIC SIGNAL HEAD AS $ 11.j~.qD $ ~~,/lp-'lD
ASSEMBLY (I-WAY. 5 SECTION)
105 2 PEDESTRIAN SIGNAL AS $ 1l..2.1.L\() $ .;l ~ ~~ .~Cl
[COUNTDOWN]
]06 7 LOOP ASSEMBLY [LEFT TURN AS $ 0t$ .'1;'C) $ 5'5lX:l.\cO
LANES (5' X 30')]
]07 4 LOOP ASSEMBLY [THRU & RIGHT AS $ lDS ~O $ 3114 ~'z.o
TURN LANES (6' X 30')]
]08 7 LOOP DETECTOR, INDUCfIVE EA $ D;).')O $ 1 DS\.j.Cf 0
]09 1 TRAFFIC SIGNAL CONTROLLER EA $ \'1,[PZC\,'{,O $ 1'1 ,lROl"\ ."60
ASSEMBLY [MODEL 170
(EXTENDED CABINET)]
110 I "Z.4"j;. = \.;114 't.~
1 SYSTEM AUXlUARJES EA $ '"2:-\'ff. ~O~ $
[TELEMETRY TRANSCEIVER]
111 1 SYSTEM AUXILIARIES EA $ \:;:2.4~"OO $ ld'-l"{,:tt>
(UNIVERSAL ADAPTER]
112 14 REMOVE TRAFFIC SIGNAL HEAD EA $ I'-\D''''ie:> $ \'1"11 .010
ASSEMBLY
113 4 POLE REMOVAL (SHALLOW) EA $ \p'bQ'30 $ (p 'T5f) . ,;x)
[BOLT ON ATTACHMENT]
114 ] REMOVE CONTROLLER EA $ Sh~.(O $ -:)100'\0
ASSEMBLY
115 REMOVE CONDillT AND PI $ \tp-m.~ $ \ 1o'iA .-::')0
CABLING
116 1 REMOVE MISCELLANEOUS PI $;ld6d.\.tO $ ~5d ''40
SIGNAL EQillPMENT (PULL
BOXES)
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7/17106
I]
1]7 4 SIGN PANEL [m-IS, STREET EA $ \\0,-\1).'61) $ loS'S \.<.0
NAME SIGN] (MAST ARM
MOUNTED)
118 2 SIGN PANEL [RJ-4, NO V-TURN EA $ \D0,;>.01.0 $ ~\I)~. '-II)
SYMBOL] (MAST ARM MOUNTED)
SIGN PANEL [RIO-liB, NO TURN EA $ \D'5O!. 'dO $ \ D'SO! dO
119 ON RED] (MAST ARM MOUNTED)
IRRIGATION
119A
ABANDON EXISTING EXIST.
IRRIGATION SYSTEM
LS $ "500'00
$ GDO. to
SUB-TOTAL
$ ~'6~ I nip .'10
ALLOWANCES
120
PROVIDE TRAFFIC CONTROL BY
lHE A VENUTRA POLICE
DEPARTMENT
LS $ J 0.??oo.00
$10.000.00
TOTAL VALUE OF BID
$
;;), ;)d~ ,"'1<61;. DO
.
End of Addendum #3
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
Addendum No.3
7/17/06
12
SIGNATURE PAGE FOR AN INDIVIDUAL
If BIDDER is:
AN INDIVIDUAL
By:
(Individual's Name)
(SEAL)
doing business as:
Business address:
Phone No:
Facsimile No:
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-n7-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 14
SIGNATURE PAGE FOR A PARTNERSHIP
By:
(Firm's Name)
(SEAL)
(General Partner)
Business address:
Phone No:
Facsimile No:
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
erA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 15
SIGNATURE PAGE FOR A CORPORATION
By: Williams Pavinq Company, Inc.
(Corporation Name)
Florida
(State of Incorporation)
By: Ron Smith
(Name of Person Authorized to Sign)
Vice President
(Title)
(Corporate Seal) ;)l
An<9~~7
Jose Rodriquez
Business address: 11300 h'W South River Drive
Medley, Florida 33178
Phone No: 305/882-1950
Facsimile No: 305/882-1966
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-D7-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 16
(President)
SIGNATURE PAGE FOR A JOINT VENTIlRE
(Each joint venture must sign. The manner of signing for each individual, partnership and corporation that
is a party to the joint venture should be in the manner indicated above.)
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 _ 17
CERTIF1CATE OF AUTHORITY
(IF CORPORATION)
STATE OF Florida
)
) SS:
)
COUNTY OF Miami-Dade
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a meeting of the Board of Directors of the Williams Paving
Com ,Inc.
a corporation existing under the laws of the State of Florida , held on June
20 01 , the following resolution was duly passed and adopted:
"RESOLVED, that, as President of the Corporation, be and is hereby authorized to execute the Bid dated,
Ju1v 24 . ,20~, to the City of Aventura and this corporation and that their execution
thereof, attested by the Secretary of the Corporation, and with the Corporate Seal affIXed, shall be the official
act and deed of this Corporation. .
I further certify that said resolution is now in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affIXed the official seal of the corporation this
24 '~ 12,2006,
Secretary: ~
Bett<;~ah Rodriguez
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00410 - 18
CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORITY
(IF PARTNERSIIlP)
STATE OF
)
) SS:
)
COUNTY OF
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a meeting of the Partners of the
a corporation existing under the laws of the State of
, 20 , the following resolution was duly passed and adopted:
, held on
"RESOLVED, that, ,as
hereby authorized to execute the Bid dated, 20
partnership and that their execution thereof, attested by the
shall be the official act and deed of this Partnership. "
of the Partnership, be and is
, to the City of A ventura and this
I further certify that said resolution is now in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand this
20
, day of
Secretary:
(SEAL)
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06~07~24~2
eTA Project No. 01-0103.056
0041O~ 19
CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORITY
IF JOINT VENfURE
STATE OF
)
) SS:
)
COUNTY OF
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a meeting of the Principals of the
a corporation existing under the laws of the State of , held on
, 20 , the following resolution was duly passed and adopted:
"RESOLVED, that, as of the Joint
Venture be and is hereby authorized to execute the Bid dated, 20, to the City of Aventura
official act and deed of this Joint Venture. "I further certify that said resolution is now in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF. I have hereunto set my hand this
, day of
,20
Secretary:
(SEAL)
END OF SECTION
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
Cily of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CTA Project No. OI'{)103.056
00410 - 20
SECTION 00420
AWARD PREFERENCE
FOR
IDENTICAL TIE BIDS
Whenever two or more Bids which are equal with respect to price, quality, and service are received by the
State or by any political sulxlivision for the procurement of conunodities or conlractual services, a Bid
received from a business that certifies that it has implemented a drug-free workplace program shall be given
preference in the award process. Established procedures for processing tie Bids will be followed if none of
the tied vendors have a drug-free workplace program. In order to have a drug-free workplace program, a
business shall:
Publish a statement notifying employees that the unlawful manufacture, distribution, dispensing, possession,
or use of a controlled substance is prohibited in the workplace and specifying the actions that will be taken
against employees for violations of such prohibition.
Inform employees about the dangers of drug abuse in the workplace, the business' policy of maintaining a
drug-free workplace, any available drug counseling, rehabilitation, and employee assistance programs, and
the penalties that may be imposed upon employees for drug abuse violations.
Give each employee engaged in providing the COmmodities or contractual services that are under Bid a copy
of the statement specified in subsection (1).
In the statement specified in subsection (1), notify the employees that, as a condition of working on the
COmmodities or contractual services that are under Bid, the employee will abide by the tenns of the statement
and will notify the employer of any conviction of,. or plea of guilty or nolo contendere to, any violation of
chapter 893 or of any controlled substance law of the United Stites or any stlte, for a violation occurring in
the workplace no later than five (5) days after such conviction.
Impose a sanction on, or require the satisfactory participation in a drug abuse assistance or rehabilitation
program, if such is available in the employee's conununity, by any employee who is so convicted.
Make a good faith effort to continue to maintain a drug-free workplace through implementation of this
section.
As the person authorized to sign the stltement, I certify that this firm complies fully with the above requirements.
VENDOR'S SIGNATURE:
~
- Ron Sttith
END OF SECTION
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of A ventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00420 - I
U 1/1~1 'VVO IIt1U 1": lL tA!
I4J 006/007
SECTION 00432
BID BOND
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)
COUNTY OF DADE )
NOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, that we, WILLIAMS PAVING CO., INC. , as
Principal, and Liberty Mutual Insurance Company , as Surely, are held and firmly
bound unto the City of A VcnUlra, a rrmnicipal corporation of the State of Florida in the sum of
Five Percent of Amount Bid . Dollars ($ . 5% l, lawful money
of the United States, for the payment of which sum well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, our heirs,
executors, administrators and successors jointly and severally, firmly by these presents.
THE CONDmON OF TillS OBLIGA nON IS SUCH that whereas the Principal has submitred the
accompanying Bid, dated July 24 ,20~
for: KIAMI GARDENS DRIVE ElITEIlSION; BID NO. 06'-07-24-2
WHEREAs. it was a condition precedent to the submission of said Bid that a cashier's check or Bid Bond in
the amount of five percent (5%) of the Base Bid be submitted with said Bid as aguarancee that the BIDDER
would, if awarded the Contract, enter into a written Contract with the City for the performance of said
Concract, within ten (10) consecutive calendar days after written notice haviDg been given of the Award of
the Contract.
NOW, THEREFORE, the conditions of this obligation are such that if the Principal . within ten
(10) consecutive calendar days after written notice of sUch acceptance, enters intO a written Contract with thc
citY of Aventura and furnishes the Performance and Payment Bonds, satisfactory to the City, each in an
amount equal to one hundred percent (100%) of the Contract Price, and provides all required Certificates of
Insurance. then this obligation shall be void; ctberwise the Stun herein stated shall be due and payable to the
City of A venrura and the Surety herein agrees to pay said Stun immediately, upon dcmand of the City. in
good and lawful money of the United StateS of America. as liquidated damages for failurc lhereof of said
Principal.
Miami Gardens Drive EXJension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07.24-2
CTA Project No. 01-D103.056
00432 - 1
"..~ ..o-v,....... J. .0.11.
Igj007/007
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the above bonded panics have executed this instrument under their several seals
this 24 t h day of J ul y , 20 ~ the ttame and the corporate
seal of each corporate party being hereto affIxed and these presents being duly signed by its undersigned
representative.
IN PRESENCE OF:
Williams Paving Co., INc.
(Cbrporate) (Individual or Partnership Principal)
11300 Northwest South River Drive
(Business Address)
Medley, Florida
33178
(City ISlale/Zip)
305-882-1966
305-882-1950
(Business Telephone)
(Business Facsimile)
By:~1JI
(Impress Seal)
Ronnie Smith, .
Vice President
ATTEST:
As per attached
powez;:;;,rney
Secre~. /I
By: . j)..7~
Charles D. Nielson, Attorney-in-Fact
"Impress Corporate Seal .
and Florida Resident Agent
IMPORTANT
Surety companies '=ecuting bonds mtlSl appear on the Treasury Department's m<lst currertt list (circular 570
as amended) and be authorized to transact business in the State of Florida.
(Corporate Surety)"
Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
END OF SECTION
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
. City of Avemura Bid No. 06~7-24-2
CTA Project No. 01~103.056
00432 - 2
.:
Iii
o
l>.
G>
~:'~
~-\:
1l1:
..J-:f!..
'g~
-~.::~ Ttlat~-r.tY.~~~nd)h~:A'uthQrizati~:$et 101111 aboYe~reJ~~':cQpies.ih~reof~.nqarenow_in-iU"f6~~aOdeffect.
b_'::J-
:~':~:
G>
t:-
cD,D
.....:::J:
. "'0.
c-
"'Xl
0,.....
":"""'>.....
c6_',C)
oj!!
,C:::ra
'.:,;;,....
--~{;;j
"'f!
~-E On thiS 13th - -dayof . March , 2006 ,before. me. a:Notaty Public. personally carne Gamet W. Elliott, to me known, and acl<nowledged ,
~ - that he is an Assistant Secretaly bfUberty Mutual Insurance COmpany; _that:he KnoWs the se'll of said corporation; and that he executed the above j
.:.!I P_owerol-Attomey and affixed the corporate seal of UbettyMutual lttsurance Company thereto with the authority and at the direcUon of said corporation_ ,
~,:;':'NtES:rr~6N'l-'h'~ ,.' _' ,__ , -i~ -Uht9S~ri~~mY--~-ttnd':~ffix~:nwnotariaf~aratPIY~'MeEl~ng,'pennsYtvania,onthedaiand year
!~ flrMabove~itterl. !~~o~:~~\ - T_~=:NkVAN~ . ~ ~
~. "'"_>> ~ .r~~=. ~,---,
I, the undersigned, AssiSlan ecretary olUbetty Mutual Insurance Company. do hereby'certify that the original power of attorney of which 1he foregoing
~ilt~ll,lrue,_~nd, cO~I~!J1,_copy:,jsin:f-ul!'Jo~~e.tlOdeffect)jnt?e_~da~:otth!$,:~rti~Cate;:afld:J-:,t1ofurtrt~r ~~t'tny1f1attJie 'officer-_oroWci"i,!'fho' ax~ed the
said power of attorney Is an Assistant Secretary speciOJly aUfJioriZed:by the ch;linnan or the presIdent to aPpoint anomeys-in-fact as provided in Article
XIIl, S<lction 5 of the By-laws of Ubetty Mutuallnsuranca Cotilpany. _ - -
-Thi~-~~rtifical,e"ar}d Jh~'-a~_vep?Yier,'of ~~orneyrnay:be :-si'gn~-'_~Y:fa~im:U~:9r:~ech~ni6ally'reprcKi~'d$ignatur~s-un~er, and" byalithority of'''the
following vote of 1he board ofiJireclors of Libetty Mutuallnsurance.Cotnpany at'a meeting duly called and held on the t2th day 01 March. 1980_
VOT1;Plha[]h_eJiicsimil~-_,ormechafii~(lIlY, rep.riXI~6dsiQnatHreofany aSsisla(lt .secretary of:the_comp.any, _ wherever appearing' upon a
c~l1ifi_e:dCOPY of~ny poWer _of__attQmeyi$$V~ by ttie,-~Pllnyjn Pqnnection wittrsuretybor)ds,sha!l pe valid:and binding upon the company
withth9sa~Jorceand:effect as t_hough manually (iffixed:
1903239
THIS POWER OF ATTORNEY IS NOT VALID UNLESS ITlS PRINTED ON R!iOllACKGROUND.
ThisP()wl!r()fAuorneylimjtsthe,actsofthos~ named herein, and they have no authority to bind the Company except in the manner and to
the extent herein stated.
LIBERTY MUTUALlNSUIlANCE COMPANY
BOSTON,MASSACHUSETTS
POWER OF ATTORNEY
KNOWA~LP~RSqN~I3YTHESE -PRESENTS: ThatiJberty. Mufualhlsurance ComPanY (the "CoIl1pany"),a Massachuse"s stock insurance
companY,-PW~UanL~() ~and by authority.of the E3y'.lawam:f Al,Jthorizatloll hereinaflersetforth~ does-h~reby name. constitute and appoint
MARY G. ACt::Vt::$,c:I1AR\..t::S .I; NIt::I-SON, WARREN ALTER, KRISl1MESSEL,LAURA CLY/vIER, CHARLES D. NIELSON,
NICOLEM. WllUAMS, DAVID. RHOOVER,ALL OF THE CITY OF MIAMI LAKES, STATE OF FLORIDA _....._..__........._....._
, '.'- - ...., ". ". --. - ..-
.....;.~...-.......~,.........;.....'...'...)o..-.......'~~'.-~.'..-.P.P.~'.-~..'.........~.~~.~'~...'.~.,....-...'..~'._~............~~...~~.......~...'..-..,....'.~..'....,~.,.,......................................
.eachifl~ivjduanY,lftherebe more-than.oneri~m~d,itstrueahdlil~ol-ahomey-jri~facuomak.e. exocute, seal, ackhowledge anddeliver,1orand on its
-'behalf- assore:tvarKtasitsact:80d deoo;_anv-and_allundertakings, - bonds, recognizances arid othersUret:y obligations.lnthepenaJ sUrnnol- exceeding
Fli'TY MILLION AND 00/1 00.................... DOL-lARS ($ 50.000.000.00..... ) each. and the
executior:tof .suchun:dt3!rtakings. -bOrlds; recognizii!1Ce_s and-other~sorety obti9<:itions. '., in pursuance_ : ot.these - pre~nts,. shall be as binding upon the
Company asjftDey.had.:beenduly signedbylhe:pre~dent~ridattested'by ~e_s6Cfetaryofthe Company in 1h~irownproper .person$.
-T~tihi::l p<>weris.~qeaiid....~xeqlrt~_p_yr$~nt. t9 and,bY~lJtf)()ntY{)tthe_:f~l_owingBY.J(lwand Authorlz~tion:
AFrrICLE XIII - Execution of COntraC1s: Section 5. Surety Bonds and Undertaklngs_
AI}'t offi~_[<?f ,JtLe,:~~y_-auth6ri_zed]Or~~tp,~~~)n. Wii.ti,~9:by:the;~irtmln.or ..the::p~eside~~land 6u~ject -to_ suchlimitations-as the_
-chainnan or_the president may' prescribe. shall appoint such attorneys,in-facl. as may be necessary to act in behalf of the Company to make.
ex~~,seal_;:f:\~kflOWl:(tdge _~,: d_elivor :as .surety__anY-~l:lnd.aJl-q(i~e~ngs,._boncf$, _ .re<:x>g_niz~s '~rMt__'qther .:surely--oWi~UC>Os. ..~.
attorneys-ill-fact. $ubject 10. the limitations $atfOM In their r9Spectivo powers of anorney. shall have 1UII power to bind 1ho Company by their
signature andllxecutiOO <If any such instruments and \0 attach 1hereto ihe seal 01 the Company_ When SO exeCuted such instruments shall be
as binding as if signed by the president and attesfed 5y the seCrelillY_ - -
-."-.:- ":'..._':".,'..:-",-".'.'. --'.', -"....--',"'--' --',..". ,--':' .-"-,, "",'-, '-.,. ',--
J3y 1I1e folloWing_Instrument tho chainnan Or the presidenf has-lllJ1hOrlZed the ol1icer or Othe;official named therein fo appoint attomeys4rl-1act:
Pursuant to Mete XIII, Section 5 of the By-Laws, Gamet W. Elfiott, Assistant Secreta')' of Uberty Mutual Insurance Company. is hereby
..authorized \0 appoint such attorneys,ln-fact as may be necessary to act in behalf ot the Gompany to make, execute. seal. acknowfedge and
de1iY{;lras~tJr~any:Cln:(r~ '_iu1derta_l'\ing~. b()Oqsi.{ecogniz~and oth(!r -$uretyooligations. . - --
,
- ... ..".. .'- ... '-. . i
-. .-'.. ...., ." . -- - c
IN WITNESS WHEREOF. thiS_ Power of Attorney has been subscribed by an authorized officer or official of the Company and the colJlOrate seal of 1
Libe~utuallnsurance_Company has been affixed thereto In Plymouth Meeting, pennsylvania 1his 13th day of March , ~
.
.
lIBERl'YMUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
.
l
i
t
"'.. '--
COMMONWEALTH OF PtNNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF MONTGOMERY
I
J
.
.
I
ByC46./- a;(~
GametW. Elfiott. AssistanfSecretary
S$
IN TESTIMQNY...WHEREO~lhai~:hereun1o ~UbS~rib~diny'~_~tn_e-and_-(lffixegihe:.corpOr*t~ seafpf th_e -Saijjtompany,-thi,$
July ,,,,OOb. _
24ch
day of
SECTION 00434
LIST OF PROPOSED SUBCONTRACTORS
BIDDER shall list all Proposed Subcontractors to be used on this project if they are awarded the Contract.
CLASSIFICATION
OF WORK
MILLING
PAVING
ROADWAY
DRAINAGE
TRAFFIC SIGNALS
LANDSCAPING
IRRIGATION
ELECTRICAL
STREET LIGHTS
CONCRETE
PAVEMENT MARKINGS
NAME AND ADDRESS
OF SUBCONTRACTOR
!-&J l\sP'Elt - 4310 N'I 35 lw2., Miani 33142
!-&J l\sP'Elt - 4310 N'I 35 lw2., Miani 33142
~
~
S:J..ttiEast ULhY'-u..rrl - R) II:::oc 9iDl., FT ~~
Hla::X CI:efk N.lJJ'Ery - l52A ~uili lw2., Cbral ~ 146
Hla::X CI:efk ~ - l52A l>b.uili lw2., Cbral G3l:iles ilJ 46
S:J..ttiEast ~~Y'-~ - R) B:Dc 9iDl., Ft larEJrllle 333~
S:J..ttiEast U LhY'-u..rrl - R) B:Dc 9iDl., Ft larEJrllle 33310
~
Jl;M H\rldm lot - fff5 East 51 St::l:tet., !lialJ:ffi mD
This is not an order
END OF SECTION
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CIA Project No. 01-0103.056
00434 - 1
SECTION 00450
BIDDER QUALIFICATION STATEMENT
The BIDDER's response to this questionnaire will be Ulilized as part of the City's overall Bid Evaluation and
Contractor selection.
1. Number of similar Projects completed with a contract price in excess of $100,000.00:
a) In the past 5 years 42)
On Schedule All
Original contract price overrun average % 2%
b) In the past 10 years B:D
On Schedule All
Original contract price overrun average % 4%
List last three (3) completed Projects with a contract price in excess of $100,000.00.
Project Name Please see attached.
Owner Name
Owner Address
Original Contract Completion Time (Days)
Original Contract Completion Date
Actual Final Contract Completion Date
Original Contract Price
Actual Final Contract Price
Project Name
Owner Name
Owner Address
Original Contract Completion Time (Days)
Original Contract Completion Date
Actual Final Contract Completion Date
Original Contract Price
Actual Final Contract Price
Project Name
Owner Name
Owner Address
Original Contract Completion Time (Days)
Actual Final Contract Completion Date
Original Contract Price
Actual Final Contract Price
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07.24-2
eTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00450 - I
IM"ILLI~ItAT.!E;
@
~~,9~
OFFICE: 11300 N.W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE. MEDLEY. FL 33178
TELE.PHONE 305-882-1950
FAX: 305-882-1966
COMPLETED PROJECTS
DESCRIPTION YEAR
OWNER CONTRACT OF WORK AMOUNT COMPL.
CITY OF HIALEAH WEST 14'" PAVING, SITE WORK, 2,519,955.95 2005
501 PALM AVENUE LANE DRAINAGE.
HIALEAH, FL 33010 CONCWORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS SIGN AGE
CITY OF HIALEAH S.E. 9ID COURT PAVING, SITE WORK, 685,820.11 2005
50 I PALM A VENUE DRAINAGE,
HIALEAH, FL 33010 CONCWORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS, SIGN AGE
CITY OF HIALEAH WEST 30'" PAVING, SITE WORK, 1,777,530.45 2005
50 I PALM A VENUE DRAINAGE,
HIALEAH, FL 33010 CONCWORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS, SIGNAGE
CITY OF HIALEAH WEST 16'" PAVING, SITE WORK, 706,485.60 2005
50 I PALM A VENUE STREET DRAINAGE,
HIALEAH, FL 33010 CONCWORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS, SIGNAGE
CITY OF HIALEAH EAST I". PAVING, SITE WORK, 864,046.15 2005
501 PALM A VENUE AVENUE - DRAINAGE,
HIALEAH, FL 33010 PHASE 11 CONC WORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS, SIGNAGE
CITY OF HIALEAH WEST7S"'-& PAVING, SITE WORK, 626,485.41 2005
501 PALM A VENUE 79'" STREET DRAINAGE,
HIALEAH, FL 33010 CONCWORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS, SIGNAGE
CITY OF HIALEAH EAST 42"' PAVING, SITE WORK, 193,780.33 2005
501 PALM A VENUE STREET DRAINAGE.
HIALEAH, FL 33010 CONC.WORK,
LANDSCAPING,
PAVEMENT
MARKINGS, SIGNAGE
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
2. Current workload - Projects in excess of $300,000.00
Project Name
Please see attached.
Owner Name
Contract Price
3. The following information shall be provided for this project.
a) Estimated total construction man-hours 4.267
b) Percent man-hours to be performed by Contractor's permanent staff 80%
c) Pennanent man-hOlUs to be perfonned by direct hired employees for this project
zero
d) Percent man-hours to be perfonned by Subcontractors 20%
The following information shall be attached to the bid.
4.
a) Contractor's home office organization chart. Please see attached
b) Contractor's proposed project organizational chart. Please see attached.
c) Reswres of proposed key project personnel, including on-site superintendent.
Please see attached resunes.
List and/or describe any:
5.
a) Ban1cruptcy petitions filed by or against the BIDDER or any predecessor organizations -None
b) Financial Statements -Attached.
c) Any arbitration's or civil or criminal proceedings~ Attached
d) Judgments related to quality of worle or dishonest dealings -None
e) Instances where bonding or Surety Company had to complete worle or malee fmancial settlement -None
f) Any .tax liens against the company -None
g) All professional licenses, registrations, pennits or certifications held by company or any
employees of your COmpany within the past ten (10) years. -Attached
h) Current status of all licenses. -Attached
i) Any discipline ta1cen against licenses. -None
j) Any instances where company has been investigated or disciplined by the Occupational safety
and health Administration (OSHA). -Attached
k) Complaints fIles with the National Labor Review Board (NLRB) or the Equal Employment
Opportunities Commission (EEOC) -None
I) Suspension of contracts or debarring from bidding by any public agency brought against the
BIDDER in the last five (5) years. -None
. Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-D7-24-2
erA Project No. 01-D103.056
00450 - 2
OFFICE: 11300 N.W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE, MEDLEY, FL 33178
@
~a:,9M.
IM"ILILI.A......s-
lELEPHONE: 305.882-1950
FAX 305-882-1966
PROJECTS IN PROGRESS
1 Project: East 1st Avenue, Phase 1Il
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount 781 Thousand
% Completed: 88%
Completion Date: 08/2006
Bonded: Yes
2 Project: American Express Way
Owner: City of Plantation
Contract Amount 2.4 Million
% Completed: 46%
Completion Date: ll/2006
Bonded: Yes
3 Project: East 1st Avenue, Phase IV
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount 828 Thousand
% Completed: 90%
Completion Date: 08/2006
Bonded: Yes
4 Project: East 16th to 20th Street
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount 930 Thousand
% Completed: 75%
Completion date: 09/2006
Bonded: Yes
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
5 Project: West 77th Street
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 620 Thousand
% Completed: 66%
Completion Date: 09/2006
Bonded: Yes
6 Project: East 15th Street
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 438 Thousand
% Completed: 81%
Completion Date: 10/2006
Bonded: Yes
7 Project: East 10th to East 15th Street
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 1.1 Million
% Completed: 44%
Completion Date: ll/2006
Bonded: Yes
8 Project: Palm Avenue Roadway Improvements
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 510 Thousand
% Completed: 65%
Completion Date: 10/2006
Bonded: Yes
9 Project: NW 102 Road &: 116th Way
Owner: Town of Medley
Contract Amount: 396 Thousand
% Completed: 88%
Completion Date: 08/2006
Bonded: Yes
10 Project: NW Ith Avenue
Owner: Miami-Dade County
Contract Amount: 3.7 Million
% Completed: 7%
Completion Date: 04/2007
Bonded: Yes
11 Project: West 60th Street
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 2.1 Million
% Completed: 39%
Completion Date: 01/2007
Bonded: Yes
12 Project: Victor Wild Park
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 599 Thousand
% Completed 55%
Completion Date: 10/2006
Bonded: Yes
13 Project: East 43,44, and 45th Street
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amount: 1.3 Million
% Completed: 43%
Completion Date: 12/2006
Bonded: Yes
14 Project: East 22nd, East 23td, East 24th
Owner: City of Hialeah
Contract Amt: 2.2 Million
% Completed: 12%
Completion Date: 05-12-03
Bonded: Yes
~
u
~
o
......
Eo-<
~
N
......
Z
~
o
~
o
H
o
~
(j
'"
H
is
17
~
'"
C/J
~
,:::
'" '"
"0 ,:::
.Vj .8
'" ~
H '"
A.. H
'" '"
.~ 8-
>
~
~ ~
,:::"0
'" ,:::
,::: '"
"'~
~ ,:::
.5 '!::
'" '"
::Bg.
C/J
u
"
.0' C
.... "
~S
" g,
.", '"
E ;J
.'" ::E
"'
~
<1.l
o
.~
>
@
~ ~
;:s ~
OJ 0
u '"
.!:: '"
",P:;
o
'"
~
,:::
'"
"0
~
~
,:::
'!::
'"
g.
C/J
?:
'"
....
u
Co
~
'"
C/J
@
E
'"
H
o
~
p.
o
..c:
C/J
g
'"
i5
~
'"
H
'"
;>
.!::
Q
'"
u
a
'"
..c:
u
'"
::B
'"
H
o
~
'"
I)
8"
'"
....
'"
p.
"
~
'"
I)
H
o
.n
'"
....l
.L\ A <2 {.2
OFr'ICI:: 11300 N_W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE. MEDLEY. FL 33176
@
~&,91@.
IMIL.L.I~,^".E;
TELEPHONE 305-882-1950
FAX 305-882"1966
RESUME OF JOSE RODRIGUEZ
2000 - Present
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
President and CEO.
Oversees all construction and
accounting operations.
1988 - 2000
Williams Paving Company, Ine.
Vice President
In charge of bidding and operations.
1983 -1988
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
Chief Estimator
In charge of all bidding and also
involved in administrative tasks.
1975 -1983
Williams paving Company, 1ne.
Foreman
In charge of all underground utilities.
Miami-Dade County, Florida
Certificate of Competency
C.C. No.: E2313
Broward County, Florida
Certificate of Competency
C.C. No.: 88-1019
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
.q(
OFFICE: 11300 N.W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE, MEDLEY. FL 33178
@
~a:,9~.
111I"'1 L..L..JT~IvIT.s;;
RESUME OF LAWRENCE L. COLLINS
TELEPHONE
FAX.
305882"1950
305 882.1966
WORK EXPERIENCE
June 2001 - Present
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
Vice President/Operations
In charge of overseeing all construction/
maintenance projects and managing
various accounts.
March 2000 - June 2001
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
General Superintendent
In charge of all superintendents and
project scheduling. Project manager for
all City of Hialeah projects.
August 1995 - March 2000
Williams Paving Company, Inc.
Superintendent
In charge of construction and project
managing all City of Hialeah projects
Nov. 1974 - May 1995
C & S Paving Company, Ine.
Vice President/Owner
In charge of construction, project
management, estimating, administration
and maintenance.
Nov. 1974 - Nov. 1977
Sea-Bea Construction Company, 1ne.
General Superintendent
In charge of construction and
maintenance. Dispatched crews.
May 1971 - Nov. 1974
Sea-Bea Construction Company, Ine.
Foreman
Supervised construction, water-sewer
drainage and concrete construction.
Supervised a crew.
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
.J(
OFFICE: 11300 N.W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE. MEDLEY, FL 33178
@
~~, 91<<J.
1M"1L...ILI-AJItAIT.5"
TELEPHONE. 305-882-1950
FAX 305-882 1966
RESUME OF RONNIE SMITH
WORK EXPERIENCE
2001- Present
Williams Paving Company. Inc.
Vice President/Comptroller
Assistant to President in all phase of
administration.
1987 - 2001
Stiles Conveyors & Transmission. 1nc.
Secretaryjfreasurer
Administrative duties, purchasing and
sales.
1976 -1987
Hialeah Meter Company, Inc.
Executive Superoisor,
Foreman of Production,
Watt- hour meter testing.
Education
1976 -1979
Miami-Dade Community College
Associates of Science Degree in
Communications.
1973 -1975
Hialeah Senior High School
Diploma
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
1.\
OFFICE: 11300 N.W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE. MEDLEY. FL 33178
@
~a:,~.
IAIILLIAJ1f,#.$'
TELEPHONE' 305-682-1950
FAX' 305-682-1966
RESUME OF ALAN P. LAUDERDALE
WORK EXPERIENCE
1991- Present
Williams Paving Company, 1nc.
General Superintendent
Oversee installation of drainage and
roadway construction
1986 -1991
American Engineering Development
Superintendent
In charge of all scheduling and
installation of underground utilities for
drainage, water mains, sanitary sewer
and force mains.
1980 -1986
Mantell Engineering
Foreman
Oversee installation of underground
utilities.
1976 -1980
Rose Engineering
Foreman
Oversee installation of underground
1974 -1976
College Architecture Engineering
Miami, Florida
1972 -1974
Rose Engineering
Pipe Layer
Oversee underground installation of
water mains, drainage, sanitary sewer
and force mains.
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
tiJ
WILLIAMS PAVING CO., INC.
BALANCE SHEETS
December 31,
ASSETS 2005 2004
CURRENT ASSETS
Cash and cash equivalents $ 2,839,459 $ 2,346,860
Contracts receivable, less allowance for doubtful
receivables of $30,000 in 2005 and 2004 4,173,755 3,587,118
Marketable equity securities 546,960 383,993
Costs and estimated earnings in excess of billings
on uncompleted contracts 70,074 159,756
Prepaid expenses 85,257 210,945
Costs on unapproved change orders 61,822
Total current assets 7,715,505 6,750,494
PROPERTY AND EQUIPMENT - AT COST 7,883,716 7,169,609
Less accumulated depreciation 5,605,432 5,462,610
2,278,284 1,706,999
OTHER ASSETS
Deposits 3,221 2,740
$ 9,997,010 $ 8,460,233
LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY
CURRENT LIABILITIES
Current maturities of long-term debt
Accounts payable
Accrued expenses
Income taxes payable
Billings in excess of costs and estimated earnings
on uncompleted contracts
Total current liabilities
$ 459,287 $ 399,087
2,122,425 1,670,757
61,831 47,898
2,155 298
1,314,892 515,158
3,960,590 2,633,198
434,057 480,044
LONG-TERM DEBT
STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY
Common stock - 500 shares of $100 par value
authorized, 182 Y, issued and 81 outstanding
Additional paid-in capital
Retained earnings
Unrealized holding gain (loss) on available-for-
sale securities
18,250 18,250
18,939 18,939
7,382,726 7,104,074
(12,775) 10,505
7,407,140 7,151,768
1,804,777 1,804,777
5,602,363 5,346,991
$ 9,997,010 $ 8,460,233
Less: 101 Y, treasury shares, at cost
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these statements.
2
.,-
WILLIAMS PAVING CO., INC.
STATEMENTS OF EARNINGS
For the years ended December 31,
2005
2004
Contract revenues
Cost of contract revenues
Gross profit
$ 28,027,841
22,623.976
5,403,865
$27,115,082
21.711,457
5,403,625
General and administrative expenses
Income from operations
2,068,516
3,335.349
1.952,641
3,450,984
Other income and (expenses):
Dividend income
Interest income
Interest expense
Miscellaneous income
Gain on sale of equipment
37,281 20.957
54,613 13,589
(40.075) (14,234)
35,622 25,968
18,017 12,152
105,458 58,432
3,440,807 3.509,416
2,155 298
$ 3,438.652 $ 3,509,118
Income before income taxes
Income taxes:
Income tax expense
Net income
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these statements.
3
-~
;---., ~
BARCELONA HOTEL, L.L.C.
A Florida Limited Liability
Company,
IN TIm cm.CUIT COURT OF TIlE IfllI JUDICIAL cmCUIT
IN AND FOR. MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION DNISION
CASE NO.: 02-18354 CA22
Plaintiff,
VS.
WILLIAMs P A VlNa CO., INC..
A Florida Corpocation.
DefendanL
I.
ANSWEltA.ND AFFlnMAnvE DEFENSES
TO COUIqI OFJ.>~S COMl.'LMNT
DEi'Et-IDANT, WlLUAMs fA VlNa CO.. INC. by and ~gb. undccigncd <XlUlISd,
heccby files this its ^=wee and AffinnatiyC Defenses to Coont I of Plaintiff:; Complaint fil<Xl
hcrcin. and would state as follow~:
:
1. Defendant heccby denies each an<1 evcs;y allegation eoo1ained in paragraphs 1,2
aud 6 ofPIainti1r:; CompWn.t for lad: ofl:nowlroge at this time, and thect<fore demands strict
PlOQf of each and eyCl)' allegation theceof.
2. &; to the allegations cont1lincd in Paragraph 3 ofPbinllff'c Complaint, Defcn<bnt
admits that it is a Flori<h ,corporation aulhorizcd to do and doing business in the State ofFlOJ.ida,
and olhecwisc droics each and eyCl)' othcr allegation contained within p:l.\'agJ:aph 3 ofPlaiuli(['s
COmplaint [0(' lack oflnowledge at Ibis time. II.D.d therefox-e demands &triet proof of each and.
every allegation theeco(
--,.-p..._....--.- -.,-- "- ---- -..----...
1..0..... Ollieq "rr1u! F. auk. o~ D...,.,~. s.u.. 17"7. .... s. D.<l<L..J. nl,.!. . M"'-1" n. H1><'. 305-"70.3135
-
.--,/
CrRffTRACTOR
",AOE: .
ENGINEERING
CATEGORY(Sj:
PAYI.. eN.I~
P~E.
--qr lli'~-'";C':'; -. ......:......._-___~~~'...w- .
jMIAMI.OAD. E COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
111 NW. 1st StREET. SUITE 1510
tIAMI, Fl 33128 (305) 375,2705
W
0:
W
:x:
o
..J
o
U.
ilml~~~,RI~tifNCY
I i:~!:~g~~~'iiil. .~~~
j S.S.NO.P
l~_~~t~~_"""".!,:41~'J _-~._~.
< ....~
r:;
.
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
TAX COLLECTOR
140 W. FLAGLER ST.
14th FLOOR
MIAMI, FL 33130
2005 OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE TAX 2000
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY - STATE OF FLORIDA
EXPIRES SEPT. 30, 2000
MUST BE DISPLAYED AT PLACE OF BUSINESS
PURSUANT TO COUNTY CODE CHAPTER 8A-ART.9l10
ARST-CLA'
U.S. POSTA
PAtD
MIAMI,FI
PERMIT NO.
026791-4 THIS IS NOT A BILL-DO NOT PAY RENEWAL
BUSINESS NAME I LOCATION LICENSE NO. 026791-4
WILLIAMS PAVING CO INC CC' E2313
11300 NW S RIVER DR
33178 MEDLEY
OWNER
WILLIAMS PAVING CO INC
s,,\ ~ gl~E'~'rtrTY ENGINEERING CONTRCT
1lfIS IS AN OCCUPATlOMAl
TAX OfClY. IT DOES NOT
PERMn l1ie LJCENSEE 10
YtOl.ATE ANY ElOSTWfG
REQU\.A,TQRY OR ~
LAWS OF l1fE COUNTY OR
Cfl1ES. NOR DOES IT
EXEIIPT 11iE I..ICt:NSEE
FROM Nf'r ontEA UCEHSE
OR I'ERMT FIEQlNRED BY
UW.TltISISNOTA
t:ER11ACA1lON Of TliE
UC<NS<FS """"""".
noN.
PA'tIIIEKT RECEJYED
""""""cowmw<
"""-"""'"
08/16/2005
00210000035
000184.50
,.,..-:~.
SEE OTIIEIl'Slot
WORKER/S
81
DO NOT FORWARO
WILLIAMS PAVING CO INC
11300 NW S RIVER DR
MEDLEY FL 33178
1",11"11\\11..1\1,""11,"1"","11"1111,"1.1"11..\1"1"11"'11"11.\
~
..J,\'U'l.JU/J
j-m P OOG/008 HIS
U.S. Department of Labor
Oa:upational SaJ'Cly and Reallh AdminisuauOll
~n Number: 304750343
Tn:<pedion IhtM:OlII6f2CYn .('11." r.n~
ls5\U.nce D.uc: 02lZ5/ ~ :: 2
~
fJ'?~~
~~7
":.:..L~/
Citation and N,,:i~~. ,. .1 t.! Pel.
Company Name:
Inspection Site:
Williams Paving Co, Int
Palm Avcnue& 3rd Str=. Hiatc;m. FL 33016
Citation 1 lrem 1 Type of Violation: Serious
29 CFR 1926.65 1 (cX2): A stl~y, Im.dcr, ramp or other safe m::ans of egress vm JlO{ IOCalW in l{'l:nch
<:xcnations lIlat WC{e 4 f= (1.21m) oc mo~ i1\ dcpIh so as to require DO moce t1t:m 25 f\X'( (7.GIm) of lateral
tnvcl foc employees:
On or about January, 16, 2001, an employc:c was wod:ing inside an =vatiOllIWt was DOt provid<:d with. ladder
for safe: access awl. <:grcs$.
PLEASE Non:: CERTIFICATION OF AB....TEMENT IS NOTJU:QUIRED FOR THIS VIOu..UON.
.~~tV15.0~
Citatiou 1 Item 2 Type ofYlo/:uioa: Serious
29 CFR. 1926.651(d): Employ<:cs exposed to public vrhi<:;uIac trillic WQ'c: not: provided. wid! a wa.mio& Test Q(
<<bq ~le t;annents umtJ:d wilh or IIl>dc of refkctorizcd or lUgh-visibility 1113Ierlal:
On or about January 16, 2002.. an employee: WolS standing next to a trench Itg[ ~ next to l.ll. oaive road~y
~~maw~v~ .
PU:A.sE !iOn:: CERTIFICATION OF ABATEMENT IS NOT REQUIlUID FOR TIllS VlOL.A.'l'IoN.
t~ '5""-(;:
S<% ('>.&0 I lUiout;l13 of Ibis C'Ka<iod >all'\Qtir>Otiao. of l'tml<y Ii>< ~ Q<l ~1Qyq ao<l C1D!"<>yao "clotS :In<I r<spoo>i>alio.
Cit3ttoQ. aud NotiCK2tiQ.a of PC"n2.lty
P>.ce G 00
=-1 (\let. 9193)
--
'J..'\
-~, -. ".,,,". VI l....UUJ V::aM
VSWOOTl
HGB n07lO0i HIS
I
U.S. Department of Labor
n.-h";'~lio1l21 ~^'n':' '"111..'." '!.::'-'--'-'-'n
lnspmion NlU)lbcr: 301250343
T ~. .. .n . ..()lf1rrt('\("" .............."......_
~
ky~""'{~
.
-
l:;su~::.:c lJ~~.::
C2f25.~:':~
'0_-~.,y
"",":t~ (":/
C"--"
...
'd N ,'-.-'
f 1 Ol...;..~.
Comp:>ny N:lmt:
lnspect~on Silt:
Williams Paving Coo, tile
Palm Avenue&. 3(d Street, Hialeah, FL 33016
,
Cilatioo 2 Item 1 Type ofYiolatiou: Repeat
29 CPR 1926.652(I.Xl): Each employ<:e in an =va.ti0ll was nO( prOlCClcd from <:aye-ins by >D. adequare
p[()(ecUve syStem designed in llCconlaoce with 19 CFR 1926.652(e). The employer bad nol complied \\"il\llIlC:
pl"o.-ision:i of29 CPR 1926.652(bXIXi) Iv. that Ibe ex.cavatiOll was sl"\X'd u an angle: s=per that 0llC am one haIf
hori=nu.1 to OIl<: vc:nicaI (34 dcg= measured from the horizoo.tA\):
On Ot about January 16, 2002, at the io1crsectiOQ <If 3rd Sttttt with l'aIm ^ \"l::I1Ue, 3D aq>loycc '\1m WIXDng inside
.. tn:u:h that W2$ 6 feet deep by 4..5 {ee( wide and awrollilMtcly 20 feet lOll!'; was 110{ proteclcd. from. a cave-in_
William Paving W2$ previoasly cil:al. foe a vioWiou. of Ibis Occnpaliooal. Safety and HcaIth SUndtrd or ilS
equi.valc:m: St3Ddard 1926.652 (aXl) whicb. Wa> <n1roilr'l in OSHA. ~on ~ 3031&2.802, ciwi<Ju.1IUIDbc:r
01, item number 3, issued on 06I130fXYJ which mp<x:t 10 a wod:pb.ce 10cate4 at UniVt:ISity DrivI: &. Brow;ard
Blvd.. Plantation. Bocid;".
l"l&SE NOl'E: CER.~CA.'llON OF ABA.1'EMnO: IS REQUIRED FOR TIllS VIOLAUON.
:t t.{s~ Q.
'.~;/~4.
LUIS It. ShlfI1A:
Il.rr:a DU:=or
So: ~ 1 ~ 3 of d.k1 C~:aud N<<.U"tQ;faon or P<<u.4:y (u.- in(om:atioo On c:a:rpl<ry'~ iIl:Id employee riclJU: :and ~ila:ics,
C"IIClUoa Uld NotirlCltioa or Paully
r~t.e-7 of7
OSUA-2 (R<-< _ 9,
-"\-
6. Governmental References:
List other Governmental Agencies or Quasi-governmental agencies for which you have done
business within the past five years.
Name Of Agency:
Address:
Telephone No.
Contact Person:
Type Of Project:
Please see attached.
Name Of Agency:
Address:
Telephone No.
Contact Person:
Type Of Project:
Name Of Agency:
Address:
Telephone No.
Contact Person:
Type Of Project:
END OF SECfION
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00450 - 3
OFFICE: 11300 N.W. SOUTH RIVER DRIVE. MEDLEY, FL 33178
@
~~,9~
IIWILLIAIftI,E;
TELEPHONE- 305-882.1950
FAX. 305-882-19G6
References
City of Hialeah
P.O. Box 110040
Hialeah, FL 33010
Contact Person: Jorge Hemandez
Phone Number: 305-687-2668
Ralph Merritt Development Com.
9015 N.W. 13th Terrace
Miami, FL 33172
Contact Person: Ralph Merritt
Phone number: 305-592-3577
Agile Courts
7335 S.W. 104"' Street
Miami, FL 33156
Contact Person: Brian Bauer
Phone Number: 305-667-6959
Bank Reference: Mellon United National Bank
Contact Person: Debra Hine
Phone Number: 305-592-3392
Bonding Company: Nielson, Alter & Associates
5979N.W.151stStreet
Suite 105
Miami Lakes, FL 33014
Contact Person:'Gloria McClure
Phone Number: 305-822-7800
Surety Agent: Charles D. Nielson
SERVING SOUTH FLORIDA SINCE 1952
SECTION 00454
NON-COLLUSION AFFIDAVIT
State of Floreda
)
) SS
)
County of Miami -Dade
Ron ::hUth
being [mit duly sworn, deposes and says that:
(I) HelShefThey is/are the Vice President
(Owner, Partner, Officer, Representative or Agent) of
WilliaIS RNin:r ct.npn{. Ire. the BIDDER that has submitted the attached Did;
(2) HelShefThey certify that the following named individuals are all the owner(s)/officer(s) and/or
directors of record of the above entity:
Jose Rodriguez - PreSident/Owner
Betty Jean Rodriguez- Secretary/Tresurer/Owner
Ron ::hUth - Vice President
Lonnie Collins - Vice President
(3) HelShefThey is/are fully informed respecting the preparation and contents of the attached Bid and
of all pertinent circwnstances respecting such Bid;
(4) Such Bid is genuine and is not a collusive or sham Bid;
(5) Neither the said BIDDER nor any of its officers, partners, owners, agents, representatives,
employees or parties in interest, including this affiant, have in any way colluded, conspired, connived or
agreed, directly or indirectly, with any other BIDDER, fIrm, or person to submit a collusive or sham Bid in
Connection with the Work for which the attached Bid has been submitted; or to refrain from bidding in
connection with such Work; or have in any manner, directly or indirectly, sought by agreement or
collusion, or colWDunication, or conference with any BIDDER, finn, or person to fIx any overhead, profIt,
Or cost elements of the Bid or of any other BIDDER., or to fIx any overhead, profIt, or cost elements of the
Bid Price or the Bid Price of any other BIDDER, or to secure through any collusion, conspiracy,
connivance, or lUlIawful agreement any advantage against (Recipient), or any person interested in the
proposed Work;
(6) The price or prices quoted in the attached Bid are fair and proper and are not tainted by any
collusion, conspiracy, connivance, or unlawful agreement on the part of the BIDDER or any other of its
agents, representatives, owners, employees or parties in interest, including this affiant.
Signed, sealed and delivered
~sn-
By: Williams Pavinq Comoonv. rnc.
Ron ::hU th
(printed Name)
Vice President
(fitle)
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00454 - 1
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Slate of Florida
County of Miani--Qr'le
On !his the 24 day of July ,2006 ,before me, the undersigned Notary
Public 0 fThe State 0 fFlorida, personally appeared
Ron Snith and
(Name(s) of individual(s) who appeared before notary)
whose name(s) is/are Subscribed to the within instrument, and helsbelthey acknowledge that helshelthey
executed it.
WITNESS my hand
and official seaL
~tViAAm=&Q.('~~
NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLORIDA
NOTARY PUBLIC:
SEAL OF OFFICE:
Kimberly A. Callen
(Name of Notary Public: Print, Stamp, or Type
as Commissioned.)
lliI Personally known to me, or
o Personally identification:
(Type of Identification Produced)
~DID take an oath,
or
o DID NOT take an oath.
OPTIONAL INFORMATION:
Type Of Documenl: Number of Pages:
Number of Signatures Notarized:
END OF SECTION
FOR PURCHASING USE ONLY:
The above infonnation was been verified with
the Division of Corporations on
Purchasing Agent
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00454 - 2
NOTARY PUBUC-STATE OF FLORIDA
I~KimberlY A. Callen
Commission # DD531402
Expires: APR. 29, 2010
aonded Thru Atlantic Bonding Co., Inc.
SECTION 00455
REQUEST FOR TAXPAYER
INDENTIFICATION NUMBER AND CERTIFICATE
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00455 - 1
Fam W-g
Request for Taxpayer
Identification Number and Certification
Give form to the
requester. Do not
send to U10 IRS.
(Rev. January 2003)
C>er>>rtmenlolttMlnJa.1UIy
1n1e......~Ser.lc.
Name
'"
.,
0>
..
n
c
o
....
nC
~~
~ 0
02
--
c"
_c
O:~
u
, .
n
.,
..
..
U)
Williams Paving Company,
Busll1e$S ll6fTIO, If different from above
Same as above
lndiv""",,
Check aPPfOpriate box: 0 Sole proprieta (Xl Corpor.atioc\
Address junl).y. street, arld apt.. ()': suite 00_)
11300 NW South River Drive
City. stale, and Z1P code
Medley,. Florida 33178
lbt acc<xr< ~ ""'" lop<ionaIJ
Inc.
o Pa_ 0 0Che< ~ ..__.nmn.__n'
o ~_b.tiL<'
N
Requestor's ~ ar-.j address (optionaJl
Enter your 'IlN ;'1110 llppfopOala box. For Iod..tduals, Ihis is ~ social security runber (SSN),
However, for iI re&ident alietl~ $010 pcl)prietor. or di$(egarded entity, see the Part I instructions on
page :L For other entl~. It is ~ employer idenClflc3tloo runber (ElN). If you do no( have a runber.
see How to get a11t-l 00 page 3.
Note: " rile axount Is In """" than 000 name. see /he chart on page 4 lor gd_ on whose runber
to enter.
Certificatlon
Under- ~ 01 perjury, t certify Ihat:
1. The ~ shown onlhis lom1 is my correct taxpayer Ideotifocalioo runbe< (ar I am waiting lar a number to be issued to mol. and
2. I am no( subfcct to bacIwp willilold;og because:' (all am exempllrom bacIwp wilIlIloIOOg, or '" I have not '-i notifioo by the Inlemal
Reverue SeMce 'RSl 1ha11 am sWject to bacIwp wilttlOld'lll9 as a nlsUt 01. faiI...a to report all kllorosl or divld<lnd;i.. or (c) the IRS has
~ me lhatl am 00 b1ger S<.tJjoct to ~ wI1hho1diog, and . .
3. I. am a U.S. person (lOdooing a U.S. resident aIien).. ,
Ce>rtif'lCation mlnoctions. YOllI'llUSt cross out Item 2 8Ix>Yalf you have been notlfoed by 1110 IRSIhat you "'" currenlIy ..bject to bacIwp
withholding because you have failed t.:> report all k1lerest and dividends on ~ lax return. For real estata transactions, kern 2 does not apply.
For mortgage k1lerest pilId. &cqUsitlon or abardomleni 01 secured property. cancalIatloo 01 debt, COl'llrlbullons to an Ind'ovldual relltem<nl
~ 'RAl. and gooeraJty. ~ other Ulan meres' and dividenOO, you ara nol.n>qJIred to sign the CertiflClltJoo, but YOU, IT"'St
provide your CO<reCt .'IlN. (See 1110 Instructions on pago .)
Sign ........... of
Here u.s. pet:5OR ...
Purpose of Form
A person who Is required to file an Inlormatlon return with
the IRS, must obtain YOlI' correct taxpayer k.lentification
number (TIN) to report, lOf example. h:ome paid to you, real
estate transactions, mortgage Interest you paid, acquisition
or abandonment 01 secUled property, cancellation 01 deb~ or
conbibutions you made to an IRA. .
U.s. person. Use Form W-9 only ff you are a U.S. person
~ncluding a resident alien). to !'<<Wide }'OlI' correct UN to the
person requesting It (the requeste<j and, When applicable, to:
1. Certify that the UN you are giving is correct (or you are
wailing lor a number to be Issued),
2. Certify that you are not subject to backup withholding,
Of
3. Claim exemption from backup withholding ff you are a
U.S, exempt payee.
Note: If a requester gives you a form other than Form W-9
to request your-TIN, you must use the requester's form if it is
substantially similar to this Form W-9.
Foreign person. It you are a foreign person,use the
appropriate FOfm W-8 (see Pub. 515, Withholding at Tax on
Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Entities).
~
or
Date ~
July 24, 2006
Nonresident alien who becomes a resident alien.
Generally, ooIy . ttOfTeSldent aflen In<flVidual may use the
terms 01 a tax treaty to reduce or eliminate U.S. tax on
certain types 01 Income. However, most tax treaties ~tain a
provision known as a "saving clause." Exceptions specified
In the saving clause may permt an exemption from tax to
contirue tor certain types ot Income even alter tile. recipient
has otherwlse become a U.S. resident alien lor tax fJUl'OSes.
If you are a U.S. resident aJien who Is' relying on an
exception contained In the saving clause ot a tax treaty to
claim an exemption from U.S. tax on certain types or Income,
you rrust attach a statement that specifies 1I1e following five
items:
1. The treaty country. Generally, tills must be lhe same
treaty under which you claimed exemption lrom tax as a
nonresident alien.
2. The treaty article addressing tile Income.
3. The article number (or location) in the tax lreaty that
contains the saving clause and its exceptions.
4. The type and amount of income that qualifies {Of the
exemption from tax.
5~ SuffICient facts to justify the exemption from tax under
1I1e terms of the treaty article,
Cat. No. 102J1X
Form W-9 (RoY.1-2003)
SECTION 00456
PUBLIC ENTITY CRIMES
Pursuant to the provisions of paragraph (2) (a) of Section 287.133, Florida Stale Statutes - "A person or
affiliate who has been placed on the convicted vendor list following a conviction for a public entity crime
may not submit a Bid on a Contract to provide any goods or services to a public entity, may not submil a Bid
on a Contract with a public entity for the construction or repair of a public building or public Work, may not
submit bids on leases of real property to a public entity. may not be awarded to perform Work as a
Contractor, supplier, Subcontractor, or Consultant under a Contract wiIh any public entity, and may not
transact business wiIh any public entity in excess of the threshold amount Category Two of Sec. 287.017, FS
for thirty six months from Ihe date of being placed on the convicted vendor list".
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
1be award of any contract bereunder is subject to the provisions of Chapter 112, Florida State Statutes.
BIDDER's must disclose with their Bids, the name of any officer, director, partner, associate or agent who
is also an officer or employee of the City of Aventura or it's agencies.
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00456 - 1
SWORN STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SECTION 287.133(3)(a)
FLORIDA STATUTES, ON PUBLIC ENTITY CRIMES
THIS FORM MUST BE SIGNED AND SWORN TO IN THE PRESENCE OF A NOTARY PUBLIC OR
OTHER OFFICIAL AUTHORIZED TO ADMINISTER OATHS.
1. ThisswornslatementissubmitledtoThe Citv of Aventura by
W;11iHm~ P~ving ~nmpnny. Inc. fur
whose business address is 11300 NW South River Drive, Medley,
Florida 33178 and (if applicable) ils Federal Employer
Identification Number (FEIN) is 59-0895890 (IF the entity had no FEIN,
include the Social Security Nwnber of the individual signing this sworn Slatement: N/A
2. I understand that a "public entity crime" as defmed in Paragraph 287. 133(l)(g), Florida Statutes,
means a violation of any slate or federal law by a person with respect to and directly related to the
transaction of business with any public entity or with an agency or political subdivision of any other
Slate or with the United Slates, including, but not limited to, any Bid or Contract for goods or
services to be provided to any public entity or an agency or political subdivision of any other state of
the United Slates and involving antitrust, fraud, theft, bribery, collusion. racketeering, conspiracy,
or material misrepresentation.
3. I understand that "convicted" or "conviction" as defined in Para. 287. 133(l)(b) , Florida Statutes,
means a fmding of guilt or a conviction of a public entity crime, with or without an adjudication of
guilt, in any federal or state trail court of record relating to charges brought by indicunent or
information after July I, 1989, as a result of a jury verdict, non-jury trial, or entry of a plea of
guilty or nolo contendere.
4. I understand that an "affiliate" as dermed in Para. 287.133(1)(a), Florida Statutes, means:
1. A predecessor or successor of a person convicted of a public entity crime; or
2. Any entity under the control of any natural person who is active in the management of the
entity and who has been convicted of a public entity crime. The term "affiliate" includes
those officers, directors, executors, partners, shareholders, employees, members, and
agents who are active in the management of an affiliate. 1be ownership by one person of
shares constituting a controlling interest in another person, or a pooling of equipmettt or
income among persons when not for fair market value under an arm's length agreement,
shall be a prime facie case that one person controls another person. A person who
knowingly enters into a joint venture with a person who has been convicted of a public
entity crime in Florida during the preceding 36 months shall be considered an affiliate.
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00456 - 2
5. 1 understand that a "person" as defined in Para. 287.133(l)(e), Florida Statules, means any natural
person or entity organized under the laws of any state or of the United States wilh Ihe legal power to
enter into a binding Contract and which Bids or applies to Bid on Contracts for the provision of
goods or services let by a public entity. or which otherwisc transacts or applies to transact business
with a public entity. The term "persons" includes Ihose officers, directors, executives, partners,
shareholders, employees, members, and agents who are active in management of any entity.
6. Based on information and belief, Ihe statement which I have marked below is true in relation to the
entity submitting this sworn statement. (Indicate which statement applies.)
x Neither the entity submitting this sworn stalement, nor any of it's officers. directors,
executives, partners, shareholders, employees, members, or agents who are active in Ihe
management of the entity, nor any affiliate of the entity has been charged with and convicted of a
public entity crime subsequent to July I, 1989.
The entity submitting this sworn statement, or one or more of its officers, directors,
executives, partners, shareholders, employees, members, or agents who are active in the
management of the entity, or an aff1Iiate of the entity has been charged wilh and convicted of a
public entity crime subsequent to July 1, 1989.
The entity submitting this sworn statement, or one or more of its officers, directors,
executives, partners, shareholders, employees, members, or agents who are active in Ihe
management of the enti!), or an aff1Iiate of Ihe entity has been charged with and convicted of a
public entity crime subsequent to July 1, 1989. However, Ihere has been a subsequent proceeding
before a Hearing Officer of the State of Florida, Division of Administrative Hearings and the Final
Order entered by Ihe Hearing Officer of the State of Florida, Division of Administrative Hearings
and Ihe Final Order entered by the Hearing Officer determined that it was not in the public interest
to place the entity submitting this sworn statement on the convicted vendor list. (Attach a copy of the
final order.)
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-07-24-2
CfA Project No. 01-0103.056
00456 - 3
I UNDERSTAND THAT THE SUBMISSION OF THIS FORM TO THE CONTRACTING OFFICER
FOR THE PUBLIC ENTITY IDENTIFIED IN PARAGRAPH I (ONE) ABOVE IS FOR THAT PUBLIC
ENTITY ONLY AND, THAT THIS FORM IS VALID THROUGH DECEMBER 31 OF THE
CALENDAR YEAR IN WHICH IT IS FILED. I ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT I AM REQUIRED TO
INFORM THE PUBLIC ENTITY PRIOR TO ENTERING INTO A CONTRACT IN EXCESS OF THE
THRESHOLD AMOUNT PROVIDED IN SECTION 287.017. FLORIDA STATUTES, FOR CATEGORY
TWO OF ANY, CHANGE IN THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS FORM.
By:
~U
Ron Smith
(Printed Name)
Vice President
(Title)
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 24th
day of July ,20 06
Notary Public - State of: Florida
My Commission Expires: April 29, 2010
A; . n G..u.-71(]. ~ _ ~rly A. Callen
(/ ~ typedU stamped commissioned name of notary public)
rn Personally known to me:
Or
',OTARY PUBUG-STATE OF FLORIDA
~KimberlY A. Callen
Commlsslon # DD531402
Expires: APR. 29, 2010
Jond.d 'i'hrII Atlantic IlondJn& CO., inc.
o Produced Identification
(Type of Identification Produced)
END OF SECI10N
Miami Gardens Drive Extension
City of Aventura Bid No. 06.07-24.2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.056
00456.4
I tn'-':Ji.~-'/3'J8 1111'::" \..LHIIl-I\..AIL IJ IJ:';'U - , ,
ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE
I Willi. North America, Inc. . Regional Cert Center HOLDER. THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AMEND. EXTEND OF
, 26 Century Blvd. ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY TIlE POLICIES BELOW
r. o. Bo)( 305191
Natrhvllle. TN 372305191 INSURERS AFFORDING COVERAGE NAICIt
INSURED Nilliams P.ving Co., Inc. ~SURER^:VirgiDia Surety C~~X. IDe -40827-00
11300 NW Couth River Dr. ~SURER8:Aa~ric.n Guarantee and Liability Inlluranc 2G24.7-0C
Hedley, FL 33178
tNSURERC ~- _...._~--
INSURER D: -
I IfiSURER E:
LU ^~ A MAl I LH VI IHI UI{Mf llUr
COVERAGES
HiE POLICIES or INSUfW'.lCE LISTED BROW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED }.HOVE FOR THE PCX...ICY PERIOD INDICATED. NOTWITI-iSTANOIN
ANY REOUIREMENT. TERM OR CONDITION Of ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WlTH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED C
MAY PERTNN. THE INSURmCE IJ'FORDEO BY THe POlICIES DESCRI8ED liEREIN IS SUOJECT TO AlL THE TERMS. EXClUSIONS mo CONOITlONS OF SLK
POLICIES. AGGREGATE LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REOUCED BY PND CtAlMS. _. _
INSR TIrE Of INSURANCE I"OUCY EFFEClN'E I'()UCYEX 1101< .......,
Y N . f"OUCY NUI<<OER AY .
A Gf.NERAL UMcuTY 4CG50283901 3/25/2006 3/25/2007 EACtt QC;C.(JRfU:HCE .L..LJl.QL.Q
X COMMERCW.. GENERAL lL\8CltTY "" I
....
a.Alt.CSNAQE W OCCUR MmEXl' - . 0
PERSOtW... &. N:N IK.IURV . 1.000.0
GaEJW.. NXlftEGATE . 0
f"RO(l(JCTS.~NX; . 2
l.OC
A 4CA50283801 3/25/2006 3/25/2007 COMBH:D s.r<<JlF.l.J,ftT . 1,000,(
N<Y AUTO 1&_
N..l 0WtiE0 NJTOS 8CXlL Y ltU.f\y .
SCHEIJUl.EO NJTOS (1'0<...-1
HmB> NJTOS OOOLY IHJURY .
NON..owN8) NJTOS (1'0<_
1'RO<'l'R1Y_ .
(1'0<_
GMAGE UAlllU1Y N/TOotLY.EAACCIJEHT
N<Y NJTO OrnER'TtW4 FAW;
NJTOOt&.y: >IX
D EXceS$ u-.aanv AUC591930200 3/25/2006 3/25/2007 FAQ1 0CCtJRllEN(:E
OC<:UR DCWMSWDE ^"""""^'" 0
D€OUCTI6lE
RETI'HTlOtt I
A WORKERS CONPEH$AnoKAHO 4CWS0284001 3/25/2006 3/2S/2007
EMI'l.OYBl$" l.WlIUTY
Nf'( f"ROPRtETORIPAAlNERIEXECUTlVE ELEACHN;aOENl
0fF1CERn.cEM0ER EXa..WHl1 EL DISEASE. w EA EMPlO"t'EE ,
~~bebw E.L otSEASE-f'QUCY lUT .
OTHER
0ESCRP11OtI OfOPERA11OHSIL0CA.llOtCSIYBtI~a.US<<>KS AOOED BY ENO<><<sEMEHTISf'Ecw...PR<MSlOK$
CERTIFICATE HOLDER
Proof of Inaurance Purposes Only
c/o Williams Paving Co~any. Inc.
11300 NW Sou~h River Dr~ve
Hedley. FL 33178
CANCEllATION
Gt10ULD AHY Of lliE AOOVE DESCRlOE1> POlICCES BE CA.NCEI..L.ED BEfORE UtE
DATE lliEREOf, T1tE ISSUUiG SHSURER W1U.. ENDEAVOR. TO MAIL ~ O^'
NOncE TO THE CERT1ACATE HOLDER HAMED TO lME LEFT. BUl FAn-URE 10 t
IMPOSE NO OOLJGA TlON OR UA81UlY Of' AIN Kltm UPON THE "SURER, JlS
ACORD 25 (2001108)
Coll:1583200 Tpl:478574 Cert:7065927
@ACORD CORPORJ
Miami Gardens Drive Connector Improvements
JOINT PARTICIPATION AGREEMENT
This AGREEMENT, made and entered into this
day of
, 2005. by
and between the CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, a municipal corporation of the
STATE OF FLORIDA, hereinafter referred to as the "City", and MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY, a political subdivision of the STATE OF FLORIDA, hereinafter referred
to as the "County".
WITNESSETH
WHEREAS, both parties herein wish to facilitate the construction of a road
improvement project in MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, hereinafter referred to as the
"Project" described as follows:
The construction of a new four-lane roadway to extend Miami Gardens
Drive from Biscayne Boulevard to the western terminus of the property line
of the Aventura Landings Development, with a raised median, sidewalks,
curb and gutters, drainage, decorative street lighting, signalization,
signage, pavement markings, and enhanced landscaping; and
WHEREAS, the County wishes to utilize the resources of the City to
contract, construct and administer the Project, subject to the terms and
conditions of this agreement;
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the promises and covenants
contained herein, the parties agree:
5/23/05
1
Section 1. Desiqn. The City shall provide the completed construction
plans for the Project implementing the standards of Miami-Dade County, and
other appropriate standards specifically provided by the County ("roadway
construction standards") as well as other design criteria deemed appropriate by
the Project's design professional. The City shall also submit to the County a
written certification of compliance that the construction plans meet roadway
construction standards. The final design plan, which shall consist of drawings
and specifications setting forth in detail the requirements for the construction of
the Project, and construction plans, shall be submitted to the County and must be
approved by the County. The City shall provide the completed construction
plans, technical specifications, special provisions, pay items and cost estimates
for the Project in accordance with standard County and/or City, as applicable,
design criteria, to the satisfaction of the County. The Project's design consultant
shall be made available to County at no expense to the County to review shop
drawings and perform required post-design services.
Section 2. Permits and Approvals. During the course of design, the
City shall identify all necessary permits and utility adjustments, and coordinate
the review of construction documents by utilities and permitting agencies such as
the Florida Department of Transportation, Miami-Dade County Water and Sewer
Department and the Department of Environmental Resources Management. The
City shall make all necessary adjustments as required for approval and/or
permitting by those agencies. The City shall obtain all necessary permits, and
5/23/05
2
utility adjustments for the Project in accordance with applicable State. Federal
and Local Laws and ordinances. Acquisition of additional right of way, if
required, will be the responsibility of the City.
Section 3.
Construction. The City shall procure the services of a
licensed contractor holding an engineering contractor's license to construct the
Project. The City may award the contract through any available lawful means
which, in the City's discretion, affords the most competitive price for construction
of the Project and which may include, but is not limited to, bid solicitation, request
for proposals, the award of a change order on existing City contract(s), or the
extension of unit-prices provided in connection with prior competitive bid awards.
Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary, the City shall comply with the
Community Small Business Enterprise (CSBE), Community Business Enterprise
(CBE). and Community Workforce Programs (CWP) in accordance with Section
9 of this Joint Participation Agreement. Regardless of which methodology is
used, the City shall at all times maintain separate accounting for the costs of the
Project so those costs may be independently verified and audited by the County,
at the request and cost of the County.
The construction contract shall also contain a requirement that the
contractor provide a payment and performance bond at least in the amount and
form required by law naming the County and City as joint obligees or joint
contracting public entities. The construction contract shall contain a contingency
amount to address unforeseen conditions and owner required changes which
5/23/05
3
shall not exceed fifteen percent (15 %) of the base amount of the contract. unless
otherwise approved by designated representatives of the County and City. The
commitment for the expenditures of any contingency funds shall not be made by
the City without the prior written approval of the County Public Works Director.
Subsequent to the evaluation of bids or proposals by the City and the
City's determination of the most advantageous bid or proposal, the City shall
provide said evaluation to the County Public Works Director for review and
approval. The County will not unreasonably withhold or delay its approval.
Failure of the County to respond, in writing. to the City's evaluation within thirty
(30) days shall be automatically deemed an approval by County, without the
necessity of future action by the County. Final commitment of County funds for
the Project shall occur upon approval of the contract award recommendation by
the County Public Works Director.
Section 4. Countv Payments of Proiect Costs. The County agrees to
provide funds in the amount of $566,007, for eligible expenses as defined herein,
incurred for the construction of the Project. This amount includes the fifteen
percent (15 %) contingency addressed in Section 3. The County shall incur no
liability for any costs in excess of said funding amount unless there has been a
duly authorized increase approved by the Board of County Commissioners.
The County funds available for this Project are specified below:
5/23/05
4
Funding
Amount
Funding
Source
County Fiscal Year
of Commitment
$566,007
Road Impact
Fee District 3
2004-05
The amount shown above is based on the current estimated costs of the
Project. The parties recognize that adjustments to the above-referenced costs
may be required in the future and that at the option of the parties, amendments
may be entered into to revise the funds available for the Project. Provided that
there is no increase in the amount of County funds required. such amendments
may be executed by the City and County Managers without the need for approval
by the City and County Commissions.
Section 5. Schedule and Manner of Reimbursements Upon execution,
. the City shall furnish the County a copy of the estimated budget for the Project,
and will similarly furnish the County with any and all revisions thereto. At the
time of contract award for this Project, the City shall submit the Estimated
Quarterly Construction Payout Schedule for the Project to the County Public
Works Director. Quarterly disbursement of County funds to the City shall be
based upon City invoices with certified copies of paid contractor estimates
attached and shall not include any other charges.
Section 6. City Responsibilitv for Enhanced Proiect Elements. The
City, having expressed a desire to include decorative street lighting and
5/23/05
5
enhanced landscaping, agrees to provide any funds over and beyond the
amounts tha,t would normally be expended for these items in a standard County
roadway construction project of a similar length. Standard County expenditures
for this Project have been determined to be the amounts as specified below:
Element
Proiect Costs
Standard Street Lighting Costs $28,000
Standard Landscaping Costs $20,000
These costs are considered to be included as part of the Project funds
identified in Section 4 of this Agreement. The parties agree that the County is
not required to increase its participation in the provision of any Project elements
beyond the amounts that would normally be expended for these items in a
standard County roadway construction project of a similar length, nor provide for
their maintenance.
Section 7.
Pedestrian Facilities. To address pedestrian safety issues
anticipated to be created by the construction of the Extension, the City agrees to
provide for the design and construction of pedestrian facilities to provide safe
access for the residents of the Imperial and Sterling Buildings. These facilities
shall be provided for at no cost to the County in consideration of its participation
in the Project.
Section 8,
Construction Administration and Inspection. The City shall
exercise all responsibilities of the owner under the construction contract,
5/23/05
6
including construction administration and inspections. The City may delegate
this function to an authorized agent or Construction Engineering Inspection
consultant. The County's inspector shall have an oversight role in the routine
daily inspections. In the case of a disagreement over the interpretation of the
plans, the County Public Works Director, or his representative, shall have final
authority subsequent to an independent final inspection by the County. The
City's Engineer and the County's designated representative shall jointly perform
the inspection of the Project which immediately precedes substantial completion,
Final payment to the City and obligation of maintenance responsibility to the
parties shall be subject to the final acceptance of the Project by the County
Public Works Director or designee. The City shall certify upon completion that
the Project has been constructed pursuant to the design plans, specifications and
approved change orders.
Section 9, Compliance and Oversiqht. The City agrees to comply with
applicable County regulations pertaining to the Community Small Business
Enterprise (CSBE) Program, Community Business Enterprise (CBE) Program,
and the Community Workforce Program for construction. Specifically, City
agrees to abide by the goals for the participation of specified business entities
and/or trades, and for Community Workforce employment, as approved by the
Business Development Review Committee and administered by the County's
Department of Business Development ("DBD"). The DBD shall have the right to
oversee and ensure compliance with the goals established, including but not
5/23/05
7
limited to, the right to audit and to require reports and documentation related to
the Program goals.
Section 10. Audit. The City agrees to permit the County auditors to
inspect the books, records and accounts of the Project for three years after
completion of the Project. These records shall be made available to the County
for inspection within five (5) working days upon written receipt of a written
request from the County. Audits shall be conducted at the County's cost and
expense.
Section 11. Indemnification. To the extent authorized by Florida law, the
City hereby agrees to indemnify, defend, save and hold harmless the County to
the extent of all the limitations included with section 768.28, Florida Statutes,
from all claims, demands, liabilities and suits of any nature whatsoever arising
out of, because of or due to the breach of this Agreement by the City, its agents
or employees. It is specifically understood and agreed that this indemnification
clause does not cover or indemnify the County for its sole negligence or breach
of contract.
To the extent authorized by Florida law, the County hereby agrees to
indemnify, defend, save and hold harmless the City to the extent of all the
limitations included with section 768.28, Florida Statutes, from all claims,
demands, liabilities and suits of any nature whatsoever arising out of, because of
or due to the breach of this Agreement by the County, its agents or employees
5/23/05
8
It is specifically understood and agreed that this indemnification clause does not
cover or indemnify the City for its sole negligence or breach of contract.
In the event of breach or non-performance by the persons selected by the
City to perform the work, the City shall, upon written request by the County,
assign to the County any and all of its rights under the affected contract for
purposes of the County's prosecution of claims, actions or causes of action
resulting from such breach or non-performance. The City agrees to cooperate
fully with the County in the prosecution of any such claim or action.
Section 12. Maintenance Responsibilities. Upon completion of the
Project, the City will assume all maintenance responsibilities.
Section 13. Notices. Any and all notices required to be given under this
agreement shall be sent by first class mail, addressed as follows:
To the County:
Attention:
Aristides Rivera, P.E., P.L.S.
Director, Public Works Department
Miami-Dade County
111 N. W. 1st Street, Suite 1640
Miami, Florida 33128
(305) 375-2960
To the City:
Attention:
Mr. Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM
City Manager
City of Aventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
(305) 466-8910
5/23/05
9
Section 14. Dispute Resolution, Applicable Law. The parties shall
resolve any disputes, controversies or claims between them arising out of this
Agreement in accordance with the "Florida Governmental Conflict Resolution
Act", Chapter 164, Florida Statutes, as amended. This Agreement shall be
governed by the laws of the State of Florida. Venue in any proceedings shall be
in Miami-Dade, Florida.
Section 15. Entire Aqreement. Amendments.
This document
incorporates and includes all prior negotiations, correspondence, conversations,
agreements and understandings applicable to the matters contained herein and
the parties agree that there are no commitments, agreements, or understandings
concerning the subject matter of this agreement that are not contained in this
document. Accordingly, the parties agree that no deviation from the terms hereof
shall be predicated upon any prior representations or agreements, whether oral
or written. It is further agreed that no modification, amendment or alteration in
the terms contained herein shall be effective unless set forth in writing in
accordance with this section. No modification, amendment or alteration in the
terms or conditions contained herein shall be effective unless contained in a
written document prepared with the same or similar formality as this Agreement
and executed by the parties.
Section 16. Joint Preparation. The parties acknowledge that they have
sought and received whateVer competent advice and counsel as was necessary
5/23/05
10
for them to form a full and complete understanding of all rights and obligations
herein and that the preparation of this Agreement has been their joint effort. The
language agreed to expresses their mutual intent and the resulting document
shall not, solely as a matter of judicial construction, be construed more severely
against one of the parties from the other.
Section 17. Compliance With Laws. The parties shall comply with
applicable federal, state and local laws, codes, ordinances, rules and regulations
in performing their respective duties, responsibilities, and obligations pursuant to
this Agreement and with all applicable laws relating to the Project. The parties
shall not unlawfully discriminate in the performance of their respective duties
under this Agreement.
Section 18. Severance. In the event a portion of this Agreement is found
to be invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining provisions shall
continue to be effective unless the City or County elect to terminate this
Agreement. An election to terminate this Agreement based upon this provision
shall be made within seven (7) days after the finding by the court becomes final.
5/23/05
11
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto set their hands and official
seals the day and year first above written.
ATTEST:
HARVEY RUVIN
CLERK OF THE BOARD
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA,
BY ITS BOARD OF
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
BY:
BY:
County Manager
Deputy Clerk
Approved by County Attorney
as to form and legal sufficiency
ATTEST:
CITY OF AVENTURA, a municipal
corporation of the State of Florida
BY:
BY:
Teresa M. Soroka
City Clerk
Eric M. Soroka
City Manager
(Affix City Seal)
Approved by City Attorney
as to form and legal sufficiency
5/23/05
12
CITY OF AVENTURA
FINANCE SUPPORT SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
BY:
Eric M. Soroka, City
~;;;~. Kilgore,
P ort Services Director
FROM:
DATE: August 28,2006
SUBJECT: Special Purpose Financial Report for ACES FY June 30, 2006
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item S. E-
Recommendation
It is recommended that the City Commission approve the following motion:
"Motion to accept for filing the Special Purpose Financial Report
for the Aventura City of Excellence School for the fiscal year
ended June 30, 2006 and to accept that letter dated August 18,
2006 attached hereto as Attachment I."
Backaround
The Special Purpose Financial Report for ACES and the letter dated August 18,
2006 was distributed to the Mayor and Commissioners on August 28. A
memorandum was distributed along with the Report and letter.
The Rules of the Auditor General, Chapter 10.550, requires that the Report be
filed as an official record at a public meeting. This motion satisfies that
requirement. In addition, the independent audit firm, McGladrey Pullen &
Company, LLP, has requested that the letter dated May 2200,2006, identified as
Attachment I, be accepted for filing with the City Commission.
A representative of McGladrey Pullen & Company, LLP, the audit firm, will be
present at the meeting. However, since the Report is the responsibility of the
City, I respectfully request that any questions be discussed with the City
Manager and me prior to the meeting.
HMKlmn
CITY OF AVENTURA
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM
DATE: August 29,2006
TO: City Commission
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM, Ci
SUBJECT: Resolution Declaring Equipment Surplus
September 12,2006 Commission Meeting Agenda Item..5:..f
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission adopt ,the attached Resolution declaring
police vehicles, a boat and trailer as surplus to the needs of the Police Department.
BACKGROUND
Section 2-258 of the City Code of Ordinances provides that any property owned by the
City which has become obsolete or which has outlived its usefulness may be disposed
of in accordance with procedures established by the City Manager, so long as the
property has been declared surplus by a resolution of the City Commission.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
EMS/aca
Attachment
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA DECLARING CERTAIN
PROPERTY LISTED UNDER THE ASSETS OF THE CITY
AS SURPLUS TO THE NEEDS OF THE CITY;
DESCRIBING THE MANNER OF DISPOSAL;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS
RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Manager desires to declare certain property as surplus to
the needs of the City; and
WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 2000-09 provides that all City-owned property that
has been declared surplus cannot be disposed of prior to the preparation and formal
approval of a resolution by the City Commission.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. Recitals Adopted. The above recitals are hereby confirmed and
adopted herein.
Section 2. The property listed on Exhibit "A" has been declared surplus and is
hereby approved for disposal.
Section 3. The City Manager is authorized to dispose of the property listed on
Exhibit "A" through a public auction, sale, trade-in, transfer to other governmental
agency or, if of no value, discarded.
Section 4. The City Manager is hereby authorized to do all things necessary to
carry out the aims of this Resolution.
Section 5. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its
adoption.
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner _ who moved its
adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner _, and upon being put to a
vote, the vote was as follows
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-
Page 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1ih day of September, 2006.
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
/Vz(h'Y\
CITY ATTORNEY
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
~
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
Exhibit "A"
Year Make/Model
VIN#
2000 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W1YX145505
1999 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W8XX148478
1999 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71WXXX148479
1999 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W1XX232819
1999 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W8XX232820
1999 Ford Crown Victoria 2F AFP71 WXXX 159868
2000 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W4YX145501
2000 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W6YX145502
2000 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W8YX145503
2000 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71WXYX145504
2002 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71VV72X126514
2002 Ford Crown Victoria 2FAFP71W32X126509
1998 Nautica Boat PT J25005J798
2000 Mercury Engine OT162251
2000 Mercury Engine OT162361
1999 Continental Boat Trailer 1 ZJBA2323XM063965
CITY OF AVENTURA
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
DATE: August 30,2006
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM, City
SUBJECT: Resolution Authorizing Execution of A endum to Second Interlocal
Agreement with the County Relating to FPL Franchise Fees
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item S- ~
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached Resolution authorizing
execution of the Addendum to Second Interlocal Agreement with the County relating to
FPL Franchise Fees. The Agreement implements the resolution of the payment dispute
with the County as discussed at the June Workshop Meeting.
BACKGROUND
Prior to the incorporation movement, Miami-Dade County entered into an Agreement
with FPL which among other requirements, provided for FPL to pay the County a 6%
Franchise Fee upon the gross receipts or revenues derived within the unincorporated
areas of the County.
In June of 1997, the City of Aventura along with the Village of Pinecrest entered into an
Interlocal Agreement with Miami-Dade County as part of the incorporation transition
process that provided for the payment of FPL Franchise Fees collected by the County
to the cities. Each newly incorporated city after that date entered into similar
Agreements with the County for the disbursement of FPL Franchise Fees.
In 2002, when the County issued the FPL Franchise Fee payment to the cities for fiscal
year 2001/02, the amounts were reduced compared to the prior year dispute
tremendous growth in the incorporated cities.
After meeting with the County, it was determined the County budget officials unilaterally
decreased the amounts based on their review of the methodology used by the County
to calculate payments of the Franchise Fees to the new cities. They felt the calculation
Iviemo to City Commission
August 30, 2006
Page 2
was flawed in that there was no adjustment included for the credit FPL enjoys for taxes
paid on FPL properties within cities with their own Franchise Agreement.
After several unsuccessful meetings with the County to reinstate the fee amount, the
Cities of Key Biscayne, Miami Lakes, Pinecrest, Sunny Isles and Aventura hired the
firm of Public Resources Management Group, Inc. to audit the entire Franchise Fee
calculation and methodology used by the County.
The report issued in 2005 revealed that the County did not calculate the Franchise
Fees correctly and it was not in accordance with the contractual provisions of the
Interlocal Agreements.
Since the time the report was issued, we met with the County on several occasions to
settle the dispute prior to recommending legal action to our respective governing
bodies.
At out last meeting, the County Manager and the respective cities reached a tentative
settlement subject to the approval of each city's governing body.
The Agreement is as follows:
1. A new methodology to calculate the Franchise Fees was revised to the
satisfaction of the cities that will net to the City of Aventura an additional
$200,000 in revenue annually on a going forward basis.
2. The County agreed to reimburse each city over a three year period the
difference in the disputed Franchise Fee calculation method for three of
the four prior years in which the matter was in dispute. This will result in
payments to the City of Aventura in the amount of $550,426 for the next
three years.
The attached Agreement incorporates the new payment mythology and reimbursement
schedule. This month, the City received its share of the Franchise Fees for this fiscal
year based on the new agreement.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
EMS/act
CC01497 -06
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND OTHERWISE ENTER INTO
THAT CERTAIN SECOND INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT BY
AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF AVENTURA AND MIAMI-
DADE COUNTY RELATING TO FPL FRANCHISE FEES;
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS
RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. The City Manager is hereby authorized on behalf of the City to
execute and otherwise enter into that certain agreement by and between the City of
Aventura and Miami-Dade County relating to FPL Franchise Fees.
Section 2. The City Manager is hereby authorized to do all things necessary
and expedient to carry out the aims of this Resolution.
Section 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption.
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner _ who moved its
adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
and upon being put
to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-
Page 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1ih day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
{vzf~ ~.
CITY ATTORNEY
EMS/tms
ADDENDUM TO SECOND INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT
This Addendum to the Second InterIocal Agreement is made and entered into this _
day of 2006, by and between Miami-Dade County, a political subdivision of the State of
Florida (the "County"), and the City of Aventura, a Florida municipality (the "City").
WHEREAS, County and City (collectively, the "Parties") have reviewed the Second
Interlocal Agreement entered into on June 17, 1997 and have agreed to amend it to state a
methodology to determine the amount of Franchise Fees paid by Florida Power and Light
Company (FP&L) to the County for rights to utilize public rights-of-way located within the City
that should be subsequently remitted annually by County to City (the "City Fees") beginning in
Fiscal Year 2005-2006 (which constitutes the FP&L reporting period of the calendar year 2005)
and continuing; and
WHEREAS, County and City agree that the methodology to determine the amount of
City Fees to be remitted annually by the County should be applied retroactively for Fiscal Years
2001-02, 2002-03 and 2003-04; and
WHEREAS, County and City have determined that the retroactive application of the
methodology agreed by the Parties has resulted in additional City Fees that should be remitted by the
County to the City,
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual benefits derived there from, the
Parties covenant and agree to amend section I. I.I of the Second InterIocal Agreement dated June 17,
1997 as follows:
1. OBLIGATIONS OF THE COUNTY
A. The County shall:
I.l.l In addition to the City Fees previously paid by the County to City for
Fiscal Years 2001-02, 2002-03, and 2003-04 (the "Historical Period"), the County
agrees to pay City $1,651,278 in additional City Fees for such Historical Period.
Such payment of additional City Fees shall be paid by the County in three annual
installments of $550,426 per year during the three fiscal years 2005-06, 2006-07,
and 2007-08. City agrees that these payments will satisfy any outstanding
payment liability of the County for the Historical Period and that no additional
City Fees will be due to City upon the satisfactory payment by County.
1.1.2 Beginning with the remittance of the City Fees for the Fiscal Year 2005-
06 which are to be paid on or before August 15, 2006, and for so long as the
Franchise Ordinance is in effect and enforceable, the County shall determine the
amount of the City Fees to be remitted by the County to the City utilizing the
methodology as outlined in this amendment. With respect to the determination of
the Franchise Fees to be submitted to the municipalities of Aventura, Key
Biscayne, Pinecrest, Sunny Isles Beach, Palmetto Bay, Doral, Miami Gardens,
and Miami Lakes (collectively, the "Cities") by the County, the following
methodology shall be utilized, which is also illustrated on Table I for the
determination of the Franchise Fees to be remitted by the County to the Cities for
the Fiscal Year 2004-05, as follows:
a. Determine from FP&L's records the total amount due to the
Cities, Unincorporated Miami-Dade County Service Area
(UMSA), and any new municipality which is created after the
effective date of this addendum but before the expiration of the
Franchise Ordinance (collectively, the "Recipients") based on
six percent of FP&L gross revenues attributable to service
being provided within the corporate limits and service area of
the Recipients for the respective calendar year ("Gross
Revenues"). See Column A.I
b. Subtract from Gross Revenues the amount of municipal real
and personal property taxes paid by FP&L on its real and
I References to Columns in paragraph 1.1.2 relate to columns in Table I, which illustrates the application of the
formula in paragraph 1.1.2. for the Fiscal Year 2004-05.
2
personal property within the respective corporate limits and
service areas of the Recipients during the respective calendar
year ("Municipal Taxes"). See Column B.
c. Subtract from the Gross Revenues the total Countywide
operating and debt service, Fire, Library, Florida Inland
Navigation, Everglades Project, South Florida Water
Management District property taxes, and other applicable taxes
("Regional Taxes") paid by FP&L on its real and personal
property within the respective corporate limits and service
areas of the Recipients, excluding any Regional Taxes paid on
real and personal property associated with the Turkey Point
and Cutler Power Generating Facility properties. See Column
C.
d. Determine the difference of the Gross Revenues less the
Municipal Taxes and the Regional Taxes as defined above in
items b and c ("Adjusted Franchise Fees"). See Column D.
e. Subtract from the Adjusted Franchise Fees the equivalent
Regional Taxes paid by FP&L for property in cities which have
a separately executed franchise agreement with FP&L which
was in effect as of the date of the Franchise Ordinance and the
Regional Taxes paid by FP&L on Turkey Point and Cutler
Power Generating Facilities that is recognized as a deduction
by FP&L for the remittance of Franchise Fees to the County
apportioned among the Recipients and based on the percent of
each recipient's Adjusted Recipient Revenue to the total
Adjusted Recipient Revenue for all recipients. (Prorated
Amount). See Column E.
f. The amount of the Franchise Fees to be paid by the County to
the Cities shall be determined by subtracting from the Adjusted
Recipient Revenue the apportioned Regional Taxes paid by
FP&L for property in cities which have a separately executed
franchise agreement as referenced in item e above (the "Net
Franchise Fees"). See Column F.
TABLE 1 A B C D E .J F
---,",.-.'--
Gross Municipal Regional Taxes Subtotal Prorate Old
NEW METHOD: Revenue Taxes (without PP) (without PP) Cities and PPs NEW METHOD
-.._-.~-
Key Siscayne 1,052,948.54 (30,067.17) (65,751.72) 957,129.65 (183,488.76) 773,640.89
Aventura 2,935,149.30 (52,721.24) (249,678.96) 2,632,749.10 (504,717.28) 2,128,031.82
Pinecrest 1,410,244.51 (26,993.61 ) (115,092.80) 1,268,158.10 (243,115.19) 1,025,042.90
Sunny Isles 1,154,787.41 (44,890.94) (141,328.73) 968,567.74 (185,681.53) 782,886.21
Palmetto Say 1,318,971.46 (113,681.82) (271,532.87) 933,756.77 (179,008.01) 754,748.76
Doral 2,183,185.46 (28,207.91) (115,562.24) 2,039,415.31 (390,970.85) 1,648,444.47
Miami Gardens 3,559,496.12 (57,675.45) (166,726.69) 3,335,093.98 (639,361.93) 2,695,732.04
Miami Lakes 1,864,173.36 (44,918.20) (162,685.02) 1,676,570.14 (321,410.77) 1,355,159.37
UMSA 54,913,188.18 (4,093,088.04) (8,602,362.23) 42,217,737.91 (8,093,449.45) 34.124.288.46
Total 70,412,144.34 14,492,244.38\1 019,890,721.271 56,029,178.69 110,741,203.77l 45,287,974.92
1.1.3 Coincident with the annual calculation of the Net Franchise Fees to be
remitted to the City by the County, the County will provide all supporting
documentation for each of the local governments shown on Table 1 the following:
i) Gross Revenues; ii) Municipal Taxes; iii) Regional Taxes by individual tax
component; iv) the determination of the Regional Taxes for all cities which have a
separately executed franchise agreement with FP&L which was in effect as of the
date of the Franchise Ordinance by individual tax component by individual
municipality reflected in the calculation and the Regional Taxes paid by FP&L on
Turkey Point and Cutler Power Generating Facilities, both which are recognized
as a deduction by FP&L for the remittance of Franchise Fees to the County (the
Prorated Amount); v) the percentage for allocation of the Prorated Amount; and
vi) the calculation of the Net Franchise Fees determined on the same basis as
discussed above and shown on Table 1.
1.1.4 To the extent that the County does not pay the Net Franchise Fees to the
City by August 15th of each respective year, an interest charge for each day that
payment is delinquent shall accrue. The interest rate will be based on the monthly
30-day investment rate published by the Florida State Board of Administration for
the Local Government Investment Pool (SBA) for each month that payment is
considered delinquent based on the number of days the payment is delinquent in
such month. The delinquent payment will be paid by the County to the City and
will be in addition to the payment of the Net Franchise Fees. Any delinquent
payment will not be considered as a component of the Net Franchise Fees due to
the City by the County.
4
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Addendum to be executed on their
behalf as of the date first above written.
CITY OF A VENTURA, a municipal
corporation
ATTEST:
By:
Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM
City Manager
Teresa M. Soroka, MMC
City Clerk
APPROvED AS TO FORM AND
LEGAL
City Attorney
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, a political
subdivision of the State of Florida
Attest:
HARVEY RUVIN, Clerk
By its Board of County
Commissioners
Deputy Clerk
By:
County Manager
APPROVED AS TO FORM AND
LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
County Attorney
5
CITY OF AVENTURA
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM,
TO: City Commission
DATE: August 31,2006
SUBJECT: Resolution Authorizing Execution of Interlocal Agreement with the
County Regarding Emergency 911 System Service Fees
September 12,2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item nt-
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission approve the attached Resolution
authorizing the City Manager to execute the attached Interlocal Agreement with the
County regarding Emergency 911 system service fees.
BACKGROUND
As you are aware, the City's Police Department is scheduled to begin to provide E 911
service to our community effective January 2007. The service is partially funded from
fees billed by local telephone services and collected by the County from the State. The
Agreetnent provides the mechanism to transfer the fees from the County to the City.
The Agreement is similar to the one the County currently has in place with other E 911
System providers (Le., Miami Beach, Coral Gables, Hialeah and Pinecrest).
The Agreement has been reviewed by the City Attorney and Police Department.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
EMS/act
Attachment
CC01518-06
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND OTHERWISE ENTER INTO
THAT CERTAIN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT BY AND
BETWEEN THE CITY OF AVENTURA AND MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY RELATING TO EMERGENCY 911 SYSTEM
SERVICE FEES; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO
DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE
AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. The City Manager is hereby authorized on behalf of the City to
execute and otherwise enter into that certain agreement by and between the City of
Aventura and Miami-Dade County relating to Emergency 911 System Service Fees.
Section 2. The City Manager is hereby authorized to do all things necessary
and expedient to carry out the aims of this Resolution.
Section 3. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon adoption.
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner _ who moved its
adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
and upon being put
to a vote. the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-
Page 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1ih day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
f~
CITY ATTORNEY
EMS/tms
INTERLOCAL COOPERATION AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this day of
2006 by and between Miami-Dade County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida,
(hereinafter referred as to as the COUNTY), and the City of Aventura, a municipal corporation
under the laws of the State of Florida (hereinafter referred to as the CITY).
WHEREAS, the COUNTY and the CITY both desire to continue to provide their citizens
with a single, primary three-digit emergency phone number as is intended and outlined in the
Florida Emergency Telephone Act (Section 365.171, Florida Statutes) and the Wireless
Emergency Communications Act (Section 365.172, Florida Statutes), and
WHEREAS, the CITY desires to expedite the collection of fees by the COUNTY on its
behalf, it hereby waives the provisions of Section 2-1, Rule 5.06(f), Miami-Dade County Code,
which direct that each County ordinance that affects the jurisdiction or the duties of
municipalities should be brought forward for second reading at least six weeks after its passage
on first reading, and
WHEREAS, local telephone exchange providers will bill their subscribers for the
Emergency 911 fee, collect all Emergency 911 fees paid by subscribers and then transfer to the
COUNTY, less a one (1) percent remuneration for administrative costs, the balance of the
Emergency 911 fees, and
WHEREAS, wireless telephone service providers will bill their subscribers for
Emergency 911 fees, collect all Emergency 911 fees paid by subscribers and then transfer to
the Florida State Wireless 911 Board, less a one (1) percent remuneration for administrative
costs, the balance of the Emergency 911 fees, and the Florida State Wireless 911 Board will
transfer a portion of these funds to the COUNTY pursuant to Section 365.173, Florida Statutes.
NOW, THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the mutual promises and covenants
herein contained, the parties hereto agree as follows:
ARTICLE I
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE CITY
The CITY agrees to:
1. Establish a strict accounting that tracks the use of the funds at issue that allows an audit
to determine whether the funds have been spent as allowed by law, including
establishing at least two separate accounts to be used for the deposit of funds or fees
received from the COUNTY, including: one account designated for funds received
pursuant to the Florida Emergency Telephone Act, Section 365.171, Florida Statutes
(hereinafter referenced as "Hardwire 911 Fee"); and a separate account designated for
funds received pursuant to the Wireless Emergency Communications Act, Section
365.172, Florida Statutes (hereinafter referenced as "Wireless 911 Fee").
2. Restrict the use of Hardwire 911 Fees only to expenses allowed by applicable law,
including Section 365.171 (13)(a)6, Florida Statutes.
3. Restrict the use of Wireless 911 Fees only to expenses allowed by applicable law,
including in Sections 365.171(13)(a)6, 365.172, and 365.173, Florida Statutes.
4. Pay for reasonable COUNTY expenses that are related to any audit legally required to
be conducted by the COUNTY of the Hardwire 911 Fees and Wireless 911 Fees
received by the CITY from the COUNTY, any reasonable costs for similar audits
conducted by the State when the State can legally impose such costs on either the
COUNTY or the CITY.
5. Submit to the COUNTY on or before June 15 of each year, a proposed budget for the
use of Hardwire 911 Fees and Wireless 911 Fees for the next fiscal year beginning on
October 1st of the same year and ending on September 30th of the following calendar
year.
6. Be solely responsible for surpluses or deficits in its own accounts, and accept annual
adjustments to the Hardwire 911 Fees and Wireless 911 Fees as may be required by the
COUNTY and/or the State in order to eliminate surpluses or deficits in the COUNTY'S
and/or CITY's Emergency 911 system fee accounts.
7. Submit to the COUNTY, on or before March 31 of each year a completed audit of
expenses paid for by Hardwire 911 Fees and Wireless 911 Fees for the prior fiscal year
that ended on September 30th. The CITY will bear the cost of such audit.
ARTICLE II
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE COUNTY
The COUNTY agrees to:
1. Receive Hardwire 911 Fees and Wireless 911 Fees from local telephone exchange
providers and the Florida State Technology Office.
2. Transfer to the CITY, in a timely manner, the CITY's share of Hardwire 911 Fees that the
COUNTY receives based on the number of such telephone service subscribers serviced
by the CITY's Emergency 911 system.
3. Transfer to the CITY, in a timely manner, the CITY's share of Wireless 911 Fees that the
COUNTY receives based on the percentage of wireless 911 calls received by the CITY.
ARTICLE III
,
MAINTENANCE AND AVAILABILITY OF RECORDS
Each party shall maintain all financial records and accounts in accordance with
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). Furthermore, each party will maintain all
records related to this AGREEMENT pursuant to law and state-established records retention
schedules. For example, record copies of documents consisting of legal records,
correspondence, reports, purchases of non-capital items and services, etc., relating to this
AGREEMENT must be maintained for five (5) fiscal years after termination of the AGREEMENT
provided applicable audits have been released. See Florida Department of State, General
Schedule For Local Government Agencies GS1-L, July 2001, Contracts! Leases! Agreements:
Non-Capital Improvement (Item# 65). Records maintained by each party pursuant to this
AGREEMENT will be made available to the other party for audit purposes.
ARTICLE IV
TERMINATION/MODIFICATION OF AGREEMENT
Each party retains the right to terminate this AGREEMENT, without cause, provided
written notice of forty-five (45) days is given by U.S. mail. In addition, each party may terminate
this AGREEMENT for cause upon thirty (30) days written notice. Cause shall include a breach
of the AGREEMENT, a violation by either party of pertinent federal or state law, regulation or
rule goveming the use of such fees, or any change in law that materially modifies the
responsibilities of the parties.
ARTICLE V
INDEMNIFICATION AND HOLD HARMLESS
To the extent permitted by law and as limited by Section 768.28, Florida Statutes, the
CITY shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless MDC and its officers, employees, or agents
from any and all liability, losses or damages, including Attorneys' fees and costs of defense,
which MDC or its officers, employees, or agents may incur as a result of any claim, demand,
suit, or cause of action or proceeding of any kind or nature arising out of, relating to, or resulting
from the negligent performance of this AGREEMENT by the CITY, its employees, officers and
agents. MDC shall promptly notify the CITY of each claim, cooperate with the CITY in the
defense and resolution of each claim and not settle or otherwise dispose of the claim without the
CITY'S participation.
The indemnification provisions of this AGREEMENT shall survive termination of this
AGREEMENT for any claims that may be filed after the termination date of the AGREEMENT
provided the claims are based upon actions that occurred during the performance of this
AGREEMENT.
ARTICLE VI
ASSIGNMENT
The CITY shall not assign, transfer, pledge, hypothecate, surrender, or otherwise
encumber or dispose of this AGREEMENT, or any interest in any portion of same, without the
prior written consent of the COUNTY. The COUNTY shall not assign, transfer, pledge,
hypothecate, surrender, or otherwise encumber or dispose of this AGREEMENT, or any interest
in any portion of same, without the prior written consent of the CITY.
ARTICLE VII
TERM AND RENEWAL
This AGREEMENT shall run for a term of two years from the date it is signed by both
parties. Thereafter, it shall automatically renew for additional two year terms unless terminated
by either party.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this AGREEMENT to be executed by
their respective and duly authorized officers on the day and year first above written.
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
George Burgess
County Manager
Attest:
Assistant County Attorney
Deputy Clerk
(seal)
CITY OF A VENTURA
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency
By:
Eric M. Soroka
City Manager
David M. Wolpin
City Attorney
Attest:
Clerk
(seal)
CITY OF AVENTURA
COMMUNITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
BY:
Robert M. Sherman, Direc
servic~
FROM:
Eric M. Soroka, ICMA-CM, Ci
DATE: August 23,2006
SUBJECT: Right-of-Way Reconstruction Agreement with Miami-Dade County
September 1ih, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item 5' I
Recommendation:
The City Commission adopt the attached Resolution authorizing the City Manager to
execute the attached Agreement with Miami-Dade County. This Agreement addresses
timely right-of-way reconstruction in the City after Miami-Dade County has finished
making improvements to water or sanitary sewer facilities. This agreement was
negotiated after the County made repairs to water lines on Turnberry Way (NE 36th
Court), and did not repair the decorative stamped concrete.
Backaround:
The attached Agreement with Miami-Dade County provides that the County will
reconstruct any right-of-ways within the City after making necessary improvements to
water or sanitary sewer lines within thirty days. If the County does not repair these
areas within thirty days, the City may have these areas repaired and the County will
reimburse the City 100% of these costs.
In addition, the County will reimburse the City 50% of the costs for specialty
reconstruction costs such as paver bricks, stamped or specialty concrete. The
Agreement specifically includes the Turnberry Way right-of-way.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
RMS/gf
Attachments
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN
THE CITY OF AVENTURA AND MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
REGARDING RIGHT OF WAY RECONSTRUCTION; AND
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. The City Manager is authorized to execute an Agreement between
the City of Aventura and Miami-Dade County regarding right of way reconstruction
attached hereto as Exhibit "A".
Section 2. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its
adoption.
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner
who moved its adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner and
upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez-Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1ih day of September, 2006.
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
H~ 4-h
CITY ATTORNEY
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
Exhibit "A"
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF A VENTURA
AND
MIAMI- DADE COUNTY
PROVIDING FOR RIGHT OF WAY RECONSTRUCTION
li
THIS Agreement, made and entered into this day of 2006,
between the City of Aventura, hereinafter referred to as the "CITY", a municipal corporation organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Florida, and Miami-Dade County, hereinafter referred to as the
"COUNTY", a political subdivision of the State of Florida.
WIT NESSE TH:
WHEREAS, the COUNTY, through its Water and Sewer Department (MDW ASD) intends to install
new and repair or replace existing water and/or sanitary sewage facilities within the boundaries of the CITY;
and
WHEREAS, installation and repair or replacement of these facilities will temporarily result in
disruption to various CITY owned right of ways but wiIl pennanently result in CITY residents having
improved water and sanitary sewage service; and
WHEREAS, the CITY requires that persons working in the Right of Way post a bond in order to
ensure that the right of way is properly reconstructed; and
WHEREAS, the COUNTY cannot provide a bond to the CITY, but IS wiIling to guarantee
reconstruction of the right of way:
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein, the parties
hereto hereby consent and agree that the above recitations are true and further covenant and agree to the
following terms and conditions:
I. The COUNTY intends to install new and repair or replace existing water
and/or sanitary sewage facilities in the CITY. FoIlowing such installations and
repairs or replacements, the COUNTY shall cause the right of way to be
reconstructed in accordance with all applicable permits and ordinances. Such
reconstruction shall occur no more than thirty (30) days after work by MDW ASD
at a location is complete.
2. The CITY shall cause to be specified, to the extent possible, the specific
reconstruction requirements to be met by the COUNTY, to be included in any
permit for the work issued by the CITY to the COUNTY.
3. In the event that the COUNTY does not cause any right of way to be
reconstructed, the COUNTY agrees that the CITY may reconstruct same, and that
the COUNTY will reimburse the CITY for actual costs for typical reconstruction
and fifty percent (50%) for specialty reconstruction such as brick replacement or
specialty concrete, including the brick reconstruction located at 19606 N.E. 36th
City of A ventura Agreement
Reconstruction of Right of Way
8/22/06
I
Court. Notwithstanding the preceding, the COUNTY shall not be liable for any
delay, extra work, or other direct or indirect claims brought by any contractor
against the CITY related to such work.
4. Upon completion of all work specified herein, the CITY shall deliver unto
the COUNTY a release indicating that all right of ways have been reconstructed.
5. This Agreement shall terminate and be cancelled without further writings between the
CITY and the COUNTY upon either party providing three (3) months notice in writing to the other party
so advising the other party.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this instrument to be executed as of the day and
year first above written.
ATIEST:
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY:
By:
By:
(SEAL)
Clerk
County Manager
ArrEST:
CITY OF A VENTURA
BY:
BY:
(SEAL)
City Clerk
City Manager
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency
Assistant County Attorney
Attorney for City of Aventura
City of A venturn Agreement
Reconstruction of Right of Way
8/22106
2
CITY OF AVENTURA
FINANCE SUPPORT SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO:
City Commission
r /\S
pportse~
FROM:
BY:
DATE:
September 5, 2006
SUBJECT: Resolution Awarding Contract for Property and Liability Insurance
September 12'n Agenda Item 5 -::J
Recommendation
It is recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached Resolution which awards a
contract for property and liability insurance.
Backaround
Since the City's incorporation in November 1995, the City has been insured for property and
liability insurance through the Florida Municipal Insurance Trust (FMIT). The Florida
Municipal Insurance Trust is a pooled insurance program sponsored by the Florida League of
Cities. In July we met with Jim McGinn, our Account Representative and Michael Madden,
the Executive Director, from FMIT reference our renewal premiums. At that time it was
disclosed that property premiums for the City would increase by one hundred percent
(although the City has never had a property claim). The reasoning behind the increase was
the heavy losses suffered as a result of claims throughout the southern United States for
Hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Wilma. These high losses caused cancellations by some
insurers and a lack of re-insurers due to the heavy losses in 2005. We, therefore, decided to
explore the alternatives through the issuance of a formal Request for Sealed Bids covering
the entire spectrum of the City's property and liability insurance needs.
The Request for Sealed Bids was advertised in the Miami Herald on July 18th & 19th, 2006.
Bid documents were available via Demand Star. Sealed bids were opened on Thursday,
August 1 in, 2006 at the Government Center. We received bids from the only two firms who
offer a complete program for the City's exposures. The premium summary for FMIT and
Preferred Government Insurance Trust (PGIT) is included as Attachment I.
In summary, the proposal from FMIT and PGIT were both for a total package covering all
exposures except for property coverages. Bob Hollander, of Brown & Brown Insurance, the
agent for PGIT, expressed a need for more time in order to deliver the property component of
the RFP but has not delivered the property as of the writing of this memorandum.
I Il!'llihl-jl!" I 11 1."'lllnIOlgll;:I!=1 1~1...J1::;:1"""I;<;l=T TAlTCI-I<-,I.....'lLl""'-.'n '_-'A.P'-F<.J'''' 'LL'''''''' I I In. ...
Page (2)
Resolution Awarding Contract for Property and Liability Insurance
We did analyze the costs and programs offered by both FMIT and PGIT and determined that
other than the property portion, the two proposals were substantially similar in total costs.
While the PGIT proposal for comprehensive, police and public officials errors and omissions
premiums were lower than FMIT's quoted premiums, the deductibles and retention limits
were higher for PGIT meaning that we would payout more during the year for the deductibles
and retentions, resulting in the FMIT proposal being considered the most effective proposal.
Similarly PGIT's premium for auto liability and property damage was less but deductible and
limitation of coverage significantly dilute any possible savings in premium. The same is also
true for workers compensation coverages.
The biggest drawback for PGIT was their inability to provide a bid for property insurance.
Bob, Hollander, PGIT's agent, had stated to us that property coverages were difficult this year
because the reinsurance market was either priced out of sight or was just not available
because of the huge losses due to the 2005 hurricanes. FMIT specifically stated in their
proposal that their bid was a "package quote if any of the lines of coverage are not renewed,
the other line pricing will change or coverage offerings on the remaining lines could be
withdrawn altogether. Prooertv is not offered on a stand alone basis."
Based on the foregoing, I believe we have no choice but to accept the bid from FMIT. While
we ended up staying with FMIT, I believe that we did receive some benefit from going
through the bid process. For example, the cost of worker compensation coverage decreased
from $473,021 in 2005/06 to $322,166 in 20CJ6/07 - a difference of $150,855. Part of this
decrease was due to overall Statewide rate decreases, part to a more favorable experience
modification due to better experience in recent years and a portion was due to something the
FMIT describes as experience credit (a special discount based on how bad they want to keep
the business) especially considering that the overall salaries used to make the calculation
was increased by over 12% from last year to this year.
Smaller decreases occurred in all other lines except for property. Property cost the City
$188,187 in 2005/06 based on an insured value of $26,478,626. We added the Charter
School wing and adjusted other insured values of other buildings to raise the insured value to
$29,910,360 for 2006/07 with a premium of $529,320. In 2005/06, we paid approximately
$7.10 per $1,000 of insured value compared to $17.40 per $1,000 of insured value in
2006/07. This is even more than the 100% increase that we were told to expect when we
spoke to the FMIT Executive Director in July. However, since PGIT and virtually everyone
else that I've spoken to is unable to write property coverage we have no choice but to accept
the FMIT proposal.
The 2006/07 budget includes a total of $756,440 for workers compensation spread between
the various departments and $840,000 in non-departmental to cover all liability and property
coverages. Therefore, we will need to amend the budget to reduce the amount in each
department for workers compensation and to increase the amount in non-departmental for all
the other programs. This will be done at some point during the 2006/07 fiscal year.
Based on the foregoing, I recommend that the City Commission approve the Resolution to
award the insurance bid.
HMKlmn
II
~
I '" ~ = '" . ~I \\' ~ N
'" '" 0 '" " ~ ~ .,
'" .. '" " ~ ~... '" i N N ~
! .. qj' "'- a ci , ili '" "! "!
,,- '" ;;; :;> II '" ~ co
0- " ;;; ..
~ '" ~ .. .. ~ '" .. ..
~ ~ . ... ~
z , . ....
<
E E
Ii t
~
~ .
0 1, 0 0 j ~ 0 0 0
~I 0 0 0 8 '" ~ .. 8 0
~ 0 0 0 a j 0 0 0
ci ci ci ~ ci s n 0 ~ 0 0 0 ~
0 0 0 0 .. 0 '" ci ci
0 0 0 ... 0 c... 0_ ... '" 0 0 ...
'" '" '" '" .. i'. '. ;;; ~ ;;; ;;;
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
. .
l; l;
! !
~ ~
.!! , , I
.. 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 0
tl 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ 0 8 0 0
0_ 0_ '" 0_ 5 0 0_ 0_
0 ;;; ;;; of ;;; '" ;;; ;;; ;;;
~ ~ .. i of
~ ~
~ iL ~ <
.5 . ~ :E
0 p; '" 0 ~
~ ~ :; 0 0 ~ i u I~
I .5 c E 0 I
.. ~ '" !l ~ c
~ 0 :g .5 a <'l ~ 0 ~ S
:; . a ~ .5 .. :>l u ~ > II:
]5 ~ ~ '" ~
" E .. . .. m .. 0-
0 0 : a !! .9 c c --' ~ g oi::i . 1i '" ~
:; 0 ~ l! s ~ 0 a ~ !l .., E 0 c -'
E a. ~ ~ '. u < '" 0 "
" 0 W " '" ~ ~ ~ ! a ~ U C 'C . ~ ffi ::l
2 . . a. ~ " " .. U ["' z
~ . a. ~ 0 E u i! a i l1. ~ :l!
~ ~ :s- o 0. ~ ~ .
0 ~ 0 ]5 a a. x .!! ~
CJ W !j ~ c .. a U i! E w ~ 0 I 15 --'
~ .1! c E w .. '" a ~
i< ~ ~ a ~ I
~ . " ~ '5 rn ~
~ E E 0 " 2
a. W 8 a. 0 ~
-
- ---.
j N
'" .. ~ .. Ol ; i ! ! 0 Ol Ol u Ol Ol Ol Ol CO
~ M :il !1 '" '" 0 .,
"'. '" U M -g U -g U U -g U ..
:!' i of 0 p l:i l:i m 0 0 0 0
0- M '" " U '" " " " " " " " CO
:l E l:l l:l '" E E E E E E E ..
~ ~ ~ ~
Z ...
0 ~
0 0 0 0 0 '" .;
~I 0 0 0 0 0 0 M 0 ;; 0 0 0
~I 0 0 0 J 0 0 J 0 J ,.,. 0 0 0 0
ci ci ci 0- 0 ci 0 . 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 ci 0 '" m ~ '" '" ci
0 0 0 0 ;;; o_ m '" '" '" 0
'" '" ",- '" ;;; '" ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
.
.. "
0 0
I 0 "
u .,
. .. u a u
0 0 '1l 0 '# . l " u 0 0 ~ ~
0 0 0 0 0 :5 0 0 0 ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '" E , u :5 a ~ 0
~ ~ ~ ~ . Ol '" ~ Z
~ '" '"
~ u ;;;
0 a.
f--- -- ~ "
--
~ .
~ iL ~ 0 ~
.5 0 e ~ rn B u :E
.5 . 0 p; 0 0 .. rn . Q c
0 . :; g> 0 !l. " I ~ ~ S 2
I :; ~ E c E 0 'Ii I . jj u ~ rn .
.. ~ . ~ '" c
" i< " a 0 .~ . '" 0 ~ a. 0 . g J1 . >- . ~ . a
.5 " I 0 " .. '" (j ~ .., > ~ ~ "
j 0 0 E ~ '" 0 .. ~ .. 0 '" :li ~ rn !
c :; ~ 1'i . c . m ~ c 81 a ~ ~ 6 ~
0 B c --' ~ ~ ~ a c u. '" a. ~ c u.
.. ~ . a E u . 0 .
CJ 0 a. 'l! ~ -. 0 ~ . ~ c 0 . c . -.
.~ C ~ 1111 '8 0. cr . 0 ~ 6 ~ c ~ U u :li ::l
. '" a. il ~ I " u ill '" . c ~ 0
1 WG 0 ~ " E c :li " . S ~ c c
. ..!!!:g .. E - ~ i .. 5 0 ~ '" c [ S 0
c E 0. e- i .. c u u ffi
0 :53 " 8 E 0 Ii u > 0 c 0 c ~ Ii ~
. 'l! .. 0 w ~ ffi . E . " ~ ~
::; a. 8 I c E w .. '" '" E E g
~ ~ II " c y ~ u c ~
E .~ ~l! .... rn .. ;: 5 c u 15
0 2 ~ W ~ 0 ~ ...
8 ;j' 'l. " w E . I
a. 0 c
a. a. 0
,.
..,
Iii
. f 8
if;
i
i.
I
'"
g!
~
"
Z
"
o
ffi
w
~'"
,,"
",'7
::>~
!11",
_0
~
"
Z
o
en
'"
w
u.
o
'"
a.
i
~
-
.
o
!
.
.
!
o
.
.
.
~
a
i
.
i
~
~
.
.
.
o
.
.
Ii
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING A CONTRACT FOR THE
CITY'S PROPERTY AND LIABILITY INSURANCE TO THE
FLORIDA MUNICIPAL INSURANCE TRUST; AUTHORIZING THE
CITY MANAGER, ON BEHALF OF SAID CITY, TO EXECUTE
ASSICIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT
THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; AND PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City of Aventura requires insurance coverages for comprehensive
general liability, public officials errors and omissions, police professional liability, automobile
liability and physical damage, property, workers compensation and other insurable risks; and
WHEREAS, the City has properly solicited and received requests for sealed bids for the
above insurance coverages for the policy year of October 1, 2006 to September 30, 2007; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission, upon the recommendation of City staff, desires to
award contract to Florida Municipal Insurance Trust.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY
OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. The contract for property and liability insurance be awarded to Florida
Municipal Insurance Trust in accordance with the Request for Proposals submitted by said
company.
Section 2. The City Manager is hereby authorized to execute, on behalf of the City, a
contract by and between the parties embodying the terms, conditions, specifications as set
forth in the subject invitation, specifications, proposal and requirements for property and
liability insurance.
Section 3. The City Manager is hereby authorized and requested to take all
necessary and expedient action to carry out the aims of this Resolution.
Section 4. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its adoption.
, who
, and
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner
moved its adoption. This motion was seconded by Commissioner
upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-
Page 2
PASSED AND ADOPTED on this 1ih day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:r-
~~~
CITY ATTORNEY
CITY OF AVENTURA
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, City
BY: 'ects Manager a f. j
DATE: September 8,2006
SUBJECT: Bid No: 06-09-08-2- Waterways Park Expansion-Clearing & Grubbing
September 12,2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item ~ - K.
Recommendation
It is recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached Resolution awarding
Bid No. 06-09-08-2, Waterways Park Expansion Clearing and Grubbing to the lowest
responsible and responsive bidder, MCO Environmental, Inc. for the price of
$278,658.00. This is phase one of the construction of the park site. This project is
included in the Capital Improvements Program and will be funded by Budget Line Item
Numbers 340-5001-572-6203.
Backaround
In accordance with the City's Purchasing Ordinance, bids for this project were solicited,
advertised, and opened on September 8, 2006. The City received two (2) bids for this
project.
MCO Environmental, Inc.
Tarheel Specialties, Inc.
$278,658.00
$369,000.00
This bid price allows for the clearing and grading of the proposed Waterways Park site.
The City Engineer estimate was $300,000 for this project.
If you have any questions or need any additional information, please feel free to contact
me.
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
AVENTURA, FLORIDA AWARDING AND LETTING A BID/CONTRACT
FOR BID NO. 06-09-08-2, WATERWAYS PARK EXPANSION
CLEARING AND GRUBBING, TO MCO ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. AT
THE BID PRICE OF $278,658.00. AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER
TO EXECUTE ASSOCIATED CONTRACTS; AUTHORIZING THE CITY
MANAGER TO TAKE NECESSARY AND EXPEDIENT ACTION TO
CARRY OUT THE AIMS OF THIS RESOLUTION; PROVIDING FOR THE
APPROPRIATION AND ALLOCATION OF FUNDS FOR SAID BID
AWARD; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Manager has, pursuant to the various laws of the State of
Florida and the Code of the City of Aventura, properly solicited and accordingly
accepted bids for BID NO. 06-09-08-2, Waterway's Park Expansion Clearing and
Grubbing; and
WHEREAS, sealed bids have been submitted to and received by the City
pursuant to the City's Invitation to Bid/Notice to Bidders, specifications, proposals, and
requirements for the project1work as cited above; and
WHEREAS, staff has determined that MCO Environmental, Inc. has submitted
the lowest responsible and responsive bid for said project1work; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission, upon the recommendation of the City
Manager, is therefore desirous of awarding said bid/contract to said lowest responsible
and responsive bidder.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA:
Section 1: That bid/contract for BID NO. 06-09-08-2, Waterway's Park
Expansion Clearing and Grubbing is hereby awarded to MCO Environmental, Inc. in the
amount of $278,658.00.
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 2
Section 2: That the City Manager is hereby authorized to execute, on behalf of
the City, a contract by and between the parties embodying the terms, conditions, and
specifications as set forth in the subject Invitation to Bid/Notice to Bidders, bid
specifications, bid proposal and bid requirements, or if a City prepared contract was
part of said bid proposal, said parties shall execute said prepared contract on behalf of
the City.
Section 3: That the City Manager is hereby authorized and requested to take
all necessary and expedient action to carry out the aims of this Resolution in awarding
this bid/contract.
Section 4: That the funds to be allocated and appropriated pursuant hereto
and for the purpose of carrying out the tenets of this Resolution shall be from the
Capital Improvements Program Budget Line Item Number 340-5001-572-6203.
Section 5: This Resolution shall be effective immediately upon its adoption.
The foregoing resolution was offered by Commissioner
, who
moved its adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
, and
upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 3
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 12th day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
CITY ATTORNEY
SECTION 00410
BID FORM
THIS BID IS SUBMITrED TO:
City of A ventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
BID FOR: Waterways Park Expansion - Clearing and Demolition
BID No: 06-09-08-2
The undersigned BIDDER proposes and agrees, if this Bid is accepted, to enter into an agreement with The
City of Aventura in the form included in the Contract Documents to perform and furnish all Work as
specified or indicated in the Contract Documents for the Contract Price and within the Contract Time
indicated in this Bid and in accordance with the other terms and conditions of the Contract Documents.
1. BIDDER accepts all of the terms and conditions of the Advertisement or Invitation to Bid and
Instructions to BIDDER'S, including without limitation those dealing with the disposition of Bid
Security. This Bid will remain subject to acceptance for 180 days after the day of Bid opening.
BIDDER agrees to sign and submit the Agreement with the Bonds and other documents required by
the Bidding Requirements within ten days after the date of City's Notice of Award.
In submitting this Bid, BIDDER represents, as more fully set forth in the Agreement, that
(a) BIDDER has examined copies of all the Bidding Documents and of the following Addenda
(receipt of all which is hereby acknowledged.)
Addendum No. 1
Addendum No. ?
Addendum No.
Addendum No.
Dated:Aug. 21,2006
Dated:AuQ. 22,2006
Dated:
Dated:
(b) BIDDER has familiarized themselves with the nature and extent of the Contract Documents,
Work, site, locality, and all local conditions and Law and Regulations that in any m3Illler
may affect cost, progress, performance or furnishing of the Work.
(c) BIDDER has studied carefully all reports and drawings of subsurface conditions and
drawings of physical conditions.
(d) BIDDER has obtained and carefully studied (or assumes responsibility for obtaining and
carefully studying) all such examinations, investigations, explorations, tests and studies (in
addition to or to supplement those referred to in (c) above) which pertain to the subsurface
or physical conditions at the site or otherwise may affect the cost, progress, performance, or
furnishing of the Work at the Contract Price, within the Contract Time and in accordance
with the other terms and conditions of the Contract Documents, and no additional
examinations, investigations, explorations, tests, reports or similar information or data are
or will be required by BIDDER for such purposes.
(e) BIDDER has reviewed and checked all information and data shown or indicated on the
Contract Documents with respect to existing Underground Facilities at or contiguous to the
site and assumes responsibility for the accurate location of said Underground Facilities. No
Waterways Park Expansion
City of A venmra Bid No. 06-09-08-2
eTA Project No. 01-0103.053
00410 - 1
additional examinations, investigations, explorations, tests, reports or similar information or
data in respect of said Underground Facilities are or will be required by BIDDER in order
to perform and furnish the Work at the Contract Price, within the Contract Time and in
accordance with the other terms and conditions of the Contract Documents.
(f) BIDDER has correlated the results of all such observations, examinations, investigations,
explorations, tests, reports and studies with the terms and conditions of the Contract
Documents.
(g) BIDDER has given Consultant written notice of all conflicts, errors, discrepancies that it
has discovered in the Contract Documents and the written resolution thereof by Consultant
is acceptable to BIDDER.
(h) This Bid is genuine and not made in the interest of or on behalf of any undisclosed person,
firm Dr corporation and is not submitted in conformity with any agreement or rules of any
group, association, organization, or corporation; BIDDER has not directly or indirectly
induced or solicited any other BIDDER to submit a false or sham Bid; BIDDER has not
solicited or induced any person, firm or corporation to refrain from bidding; and BIDDER
has not sought by collusion to obtain for itself any advantage over any other BIDDER or
over the City.
3. BIDDER understands and agrees that the Contract Price is lump sum to furnish and install all of the
Work complete in place. The Schedule of Values is provided for the purpose of Bid Evaluation and
when initiated by the City, the pricing of change orders. Contractor's price will not be adjusted to
reflect any deviation from the Schedule Of Values, except to the extent that the City changes the
scope of Project after the Contract Date.
As such the Contractor shall furnish all labor, materials, equipment, tools superintendence and
services necessary to provide a complete in place Project for the Bid Price of:
$ 278,658.00 / Two Hundred Seventy Eight
Thous.ann Six. H.undreli Fif.ty Eight
-_ dollars and
00/100 centsLUMPSUM
(Written Total Bid Price - From Schedule Of Values)
BIDDER agrees that the work will be complete in full within 60 calendar days from the date
stipulated in the Notice to Proceed.
4. . .<::()IIIIJ:llli)ications concerning this Bid shall be addressed to:
BIDDER:
Address:
Mr.O KnvironmenrRl Inc.
7275 N.W. 64 Street
Miami, Fl. 33166
(305) 468- 1650
(305) 468- 1649
Julio Otazo
Telephone
Facsimile Number
Attention:
Waterways Park Expansion
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-09-08-2
CTA Project No. 01.0103.053
00410 - 2
5. The terms used in this Bid which are defined in the General Conditions of the Construction Contract
included as part of the Contract documents have the meanings assigned to them in the General
Conditions.
SUBMITTED THIS DAY September
--1lli...2006
Waterways Park Expansion
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-09-08-2
CTA Project No. 01-0103.053
00410 - 3
Item Quantity
1
2
3
4
1
SECTION 00410
SCHEDULE OF VALUES
FOR LUMP SUM
CONTRACT
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Description
Unit
Unit Price
GENERAL
GENERAL CONDmONS
LS $32,200
MOBILIZATION
LS $8,500
LS $1,000
MAiNTENANCE OF TRAFFIC
SUB-TOTAL
CLEARING AND DEMOLITION
CLEARING AND DEMOLmON
LS $ 236,958
TOTAL VALUE OF BID
$ 278,658
Wate",'ays Park Expansion
City of Aventura Bid No. 06-09-08-2
E:dended
Cost
$ 32,200
$ 8,500
$ 1, 000
$ 41 ,700
$ 236,958
CITY OF AVENTURA
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, IC
City Manager
TO: City Commission
BY: Joanne Carr, AICP
Planning Director
DATE: August21,2006
SUBJECT: Request of Hi Lift Marina for (1) Conditional Use approval to permit
construction of a new marina and dry dock boat storage building with a
height of 90 feet in the TC2, Town Center Marine District, where a
maximum height of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code; (2) Variance
from Section 31-145(c)(10) of the City's Land Development Regulations to
permit a development with a view corridor of 15 feet, where a 66.76 foot
view corridor is required by Code; (3) Variance from Section 31-221(i)(2)
of the City's Land Development Regulations to permit a minimum buffer
strip of 4'8", where a minimum 7' buffer strip is required by Code; all for
property located at 2890 NE 18ih Street, Aventura (01-CU-06 and 02-
VAR-06)
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item ~
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission:
1. Approve the request for Conditional Use approval to allow a 90 foot tall marina
and dry dock boat storage building in the TC2 zoning district, where a maximum
height of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code.
2. Approve the request for Variance from Section 31-145(c)(10) of the City's Land
Development Regulations to permit a 15 foot view corridor where a 66.67 foot
view corridor is required by Code, and
3. Approve the request for Variance from Section 31-221(i)(2) of the City's Land
Development Regulations to permit a minimum buffer strip of 4'8", where a
minimum 7' buffer is required by Code.
THE REQUEST
The applicant, Hi Lift Marina, LLC, is requesting the following:
1. Conditional Use approval to permit construction of a new marina and dry dock
boat storage building with a height of 90 feet in the TC2, Town Center Marine
District, where a maximum height of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code.
2. Variance from Section 31-145(c)(10) of the City's Land Development Regulations
to permit a development with a view corridor of 15 feet, where a 66.76 foot view
corridor is required by Code.
3. Variance from Section 31-221 (i)(2) of the City's Land Development Regulations
to permit a minimum buffer strip of 4'8", where a minimum 7' buffer strip is
required by Code.
all on property located at 2890 NE 18ih Street, Aventura. (See Exhibit #1 for Letters of
Intent)
BACKGROUND
OWNER OF PROPERTY Hi Lift Marina, LLC
APPLICANT Hi Lift Marina, LLC
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY 2890 NE 18ih Street
See Exhibit #2 for Location Plan
LEGAL DESCRIPTION See Exhibit #3 for Legal Description
SIZE OF PROPERTY Approximately 3.05 acres total
Upland parcel 1.99 acres
Submerged parcel 1.06 acres
EXISTING ZONING TC2, Town Center Marine District
FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION Town Center
Zoning -
Subject property:
Property to the North:
Property to the South:
Property to the East:
Property to the West:
TC2
TC1
RMF3
TC2
B2
Town Center Marine District and
Town Center District
Multi-Family Medium Density Residential
Town Center Marine District
Community Business District
Existing Use-
Subject property:
Dry Dock Boat Storage and Marina
2
Property to the North:
Property to the South:
Property to the East:
Property to the West:
Residential and retail uses
Residential uses
Water and Marine uses
Retail uses
Future Land Use Designation - According to the City of Aventura Comprehensive
Plan, the following properties are currently designated as follows:
Subject property:
Property to the North:
Property to the South:
Property to the East:
Property to the West:
Town Center
Town Center
Medium High Density Residential
Water and Town Center
Business and Office
The Site - The subject site is located in the block bounded by NE 28th Court to the west,
a finger canal to the east, NE 187 Street to the north and an existing 3 story town home
condominium called Aventi to the south.
The Project - The applicant has submitted a revised application for administrative site
plan approval to develop a new marina and dry dock facility to replace the boat storage
facility that presently exists on the property. Color photographs of the existing facility
are appended to this report. The redevelopment application incorporates a new state of
the art computerized, indoor boat storage system with 240 dry slips and 22 wet slips in
a location that currently utilizes both outdoor and indoor space for boat storage and
repairs. The existing facility is approximately 55 feet high and contains a total of 262
slips. While there is no increase in the number of existing slips, the slip size is being
increased to accommodate larger boats. The proposed building is expanding
approximately 55 feet in width, which increases the existing ground level floor area of
39,600 square feet to 50,710 square feet and rising an additional 35 feet in height to
contain the computerized rack system, indoor parking and enclosure of the existing
outdoor storage area. Parking areas are proposed inside the building and in two
surface parking lots at the southwest corner and northeast corner of the site. A 15 foot
landscaped corridor is proposed at the south property limit to screen the new building
from the existing residential development.
The application for conditional use is a revision to a previous application that was
presented to City Commission in March of 2006. The original application was for a
building height of 150 feet, then reduced to 122 feet. Following discussion at the March
7, 2006 public hearing, the application was withdrawn. The present application is for a
building height of 90 feet.
Building height, according to the definition of "height" in the Land Development
Regulations, is the vertical distance between the finished elevation at the center of the
front of the building to the highest point of the roof surface, excluding mechanical
equipment. The 90 foot height is the height to the roof surface. There is mechanical
equipment above the roof surface with screening that measures 14.5 feet above the 90
3
foot height, or 104'5". There are also decorative peaks on each corner of the
mechanical screens that measure another 15'1" or 119'6". The mechanical screens
enclose the boat lift cranes and also conceal the air conditioning units in the middle of
the building, which are at the main roof level of 90 feet.
The application for variance for view corridor and buffer strips are the same as the
previous application in March of 2006.
Proffered Covenant
The TC2 zoning category permits a mix of residential and non-residential uses on this
property. Staff has discussed with the applicant staff's concern with potential
redevelopment that may include both residential at 25 dwelling units per gross acre and
commercial uses at 2.0 Floor Area Ratio and the adverse impacts that a mix of uses
may create at this congested corner. The applicant's proposal is commercial (marina)
use with the same number of slips as currently exist, with improved access and traffic
flow and a 1.36 Floor Area Ratio. As a condition of variance and conditional use
approval, the applicant has proffered a covenant prohibiting residential development.
This covenant will be recorded on title to the property and will bind not only the applicant
but its successors and assigns. Staff recommends that the City Commission accept the
applicant's proffer and that recordation of the covenant be made a condition of approval
of the conditional use and variance requests.
ANALYSIS OF THE REQUESTS
Citizen Comments - The Community Development Department has received no written
citizen comments about this application.
Community Development Department Analysis - The property is located in the
TC2 (Town Center Marine) District. The permitted height in this zone is 4 stories or 50
feet. The applicant is requesting Conditional Use approval to permit a height of 90 feet
which is equivalent to 9 stories. The applicant is also requesting variances to allow a
reduced view corridor to the canal at the east limit and reduced buffer strips along the
perimeter of the building.
Reauest #1: Conditional Use approval to allow a 90 foot tall dry dock boat storaae
and marina buildina in the TC2 zonina district. where a where a maximum heiaht
of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted bv Code.
The plan proposes a building measuring 90 feet tall. The applicant advises that the new
building contains the same number of slips as the existing building which is 55 feet tall.
The applicant advises that the additional 35 feet of height is required to install racks that
store larger boats and to enclose the existing outside storage racks.
4
Criteria
The guidelines for approval of conditional uses as required by Section 31-73(c) of the
City's Land Development Regulation states:
"General Standards of review. In addition to the standards set forth in these LDRs
for the particular use, all proposed conditional uses shall meet each of the following
standards:"
(a) The proposed use shall be consistent with the comprehensive plan.
The use is consistent with the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan, which designates
the future land use category for this site as Town Center. The Town Center designation
states that the "...implementation of Town Centers may be directed through the
establishment of zoning and other land use regulations unique to each zone..." This
property lies within the TC2, Town Center Marine District, which allows the proposed
dry and wet boat storage, marine showroom and boat repair as permitted uses.
The Comprehensive Plan also encourages a mix of uses within the Town Center and
the provision of recreational facilities. The proposed facility will help further both of
these objectives.
(b) The establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed use shall not be
detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety or general welfare.
The redevelopment of the boat storage facility will bring the building up to current
Building Code standards which will enhance the safety of the general public. The
modernization of the existing facility will also benefit the public health, safety and
welfare by completely enclosing all of the operations that currently take place outside
and within full view of the current and future residential neighbors. By enclosing the
boat lifting, storage and repair operations, the noise associated with these activities will
be reduced. Parking areas for the new facility will improve traffic safety as compared to
the existing condition where cars back out onto NE 187 Street.
(c) The proposed use shall be consistent with the community character of the
immediate neighborhood of the proposed use.
The proposed use is consistent with the community character of the immediate
neighborhood. To the west are existing retail uses. To the east and south are
residential and water uses. To the north is Phase I of the proposed Town Center. The
marine character of the use is consistent with other uses on the water. Architecturally,
the proposed building will incorporate elements that are consistent with the neighboring
residential developments.
(d) Utilities, roadway capacity, drainage and other necessary public facilities, including
police, fire and emergency services, shall exist at the City's adopted levels of
5
service, or will be available concurrent with demand as provided for in the
requirements of these LORs.
The redevelopment of the existing marina will not result in a change to the current level
of service required. The City's current levels of infrastructure and services are sufficient
to accommodate the proposed redevelopment.
(e) Adequate measures exist or shall be taken to provide ingress and egress to the
proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets.
Adequate measures have been taken to provide ingress and egress to the proposed
use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets. Currently, the
parking area on NE 187 Street consists of a narrow strip on the north side of the
property between the building and the sidewalk. Cars exiting the property must back
out into NE 187 Street. The new facility will ensure more orderly and safer flow of traffic
by providing controlled ingress and egress with parking both inside the building and in
two surface parking areas.
(f) The establishment of the conditional use shall not impede the development of
surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district.
The establishment of the conditional use will not impede the development of
surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district.
(g) The design of the proposed use shall minimize adverse effects, including visual
impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent property through the use of building
orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria.
The proposed facility has been designed to minimize adverse effects, including visual
impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent property. The proposed Mediterranean
design of the building will replace an old industrial metal building. The exposed outdoor
storage racks will be covered by the new building. The noise and unattractive visual
impact of this outdoor storage area will be eliminated. Landscaping will provide
improved aesthetics for the neighborhood.
Reauest #2: Variance from Section 31-1451cl1101 of the Citv's Land Development
Reaulations to permit a 15 foot view corridor where a 66.67 foot view corridor is
reauired bv Code.
A 66.76 foot wide corridor is required by Code based on the average of the two
frontages opposite the canal. The Code requires this corridor extend from the waterway
to the street most nearly parallel to the mean high tide line. For this particular property,
only 150 feet of its 436 foot length abuts the canal width. Due to the unique shape of
the property, a view corridor at either the north or south limit results in a particular
hardship upon the owner. A view corridor at the south limit would impact approximately
50 feet or 25% of the proposed building width of 200 feet. If the full corridor width of
6
66.76 feet was constructed on the south limit of the property, the existing jog in the
property line with the neighboring Aventi condominium would result in no water view. A
view corridor at the north limit would impact approximately 40 feet or 20% of the
proposed building width. These conditions are shown in the sketch attached as Exhibit
#4.
The proposed plan shows a 15 foot landscaped corridor along the south limit which
functions more as a building setback than a view corridor. To mitigate this condition,
the applicant has offered to construct a 10 foot wide public walkway along the
northeasterly property limit, designed similar to the pedestrian promenade on canal side
of the NE 188 Street properties with City standard bench, trash receptacle and bollard
at the waterfront. This will afford public access and view to the canal which is the intent
of a view corridor and will also allow future connection to the walkway on NE 188 Street.
Criteria
The guidelines for approval of variances as required by Section 31-76(e) of the City's
Land Development Regulation states:
"Standards of review. A variance shall be granted only where competent and
substantial evidence presented in the particular case shows that all of the following
are met:
(1) The particular physical surroundings, shape, topographical condition, or other
physical 'or environmental condition of the specific property involved would
result in a particular hardship upon the owner, as distinguished from a mere
inconvenience, if the regulations were carried out literally.
Due to the unusual shape of this property and its partial frontage on the water,
the 66.76 foot wide view corridor results in a particular hardship upon the owner,
as shown on the sketch attached as Exhibit #4.
(2) The conditions upon which the request for a variance is based are unique to
the parcel and would not be generally applicable to other property within the
vicinity.
The conditions are unique to this site and would not be generally applicable to
other locations.
(3) The alleged difficulty or hardship is not economic and has not been deliberately
created to establish a use or structure, which is not otherwise consistent with
the LOR.
The applicant's difficulty is not economic in nature and has not been deliberately
created by the applicant.
(4) The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity.
7
The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity. The construction of
public access to the water along the northeasterly property limit will preserve the
public welfare.
(5) The proposed variance will not substantially increase the congestion in the
public streets, or increase the danger of fire, or endanger the public safety, or
substantially diminish or impair properly values within the vicinity.
The proposed variance will not substantially increase traffic congestion or
increase the danger of fire or endanger the public safety.
Reauest #3: Variance from Section 31.221{i)(2) of the City's Land Develooment
Reaulations to oermit a minimum buffer strio measurina 4'8". where a minimum
7' buffer is reauired bv Code.
The Code requires a minimum of 7 foot wide buffer strips along the perimeter of all
vehicular use areas. The proposed plan shows a 4'8" wide buffer strip occurring
between the building and the north parking area and a 6' wide buffer strip between the
building and the southwest parking area. The 4'8" width will not impede the plantings
shown on the landscape plan.
Criteria
The guidelines for approval of variances as required by Section 31-76(e) of the City's
Land Development Regulation states:
"Standards of review. A variance shall be granted only where competent and
substantial evidence presented in the parlicular case shows that all of the following
are met:
1. The parlicular physical surroundings, shape, topographical condition, or other
physical or environmental condition of the specific properly involved would result
in a parlicular hardship upon the owner, as distinguished from a mere
inconvenience, if the regulations were carried out literally.
The unique shape and location of the property results in the hardship upon which
the variance is requested.
2. The conditions upon which the request for a variance is based are unique to the
parcel and would not be generally applicable to other properly within the vicinity.
The conditions are unique to this site and would not be generally applicable to
other locations.
8
3. The alleged difficulty or hardship is not economic and has not been deliberately
created to establish a use or structure, which is not otherwise consistent with the
LOR.
The applicant's difficulty is not economic in nature and has not been deliberately
created by the applicant.
4. The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity.
The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity. The proposed width of
buffer strip will allow installation of required plantings.
5. The proposed variance will not substantially increase the congestion in the public
streets, or increase the danger of fire, or endanger the public safety, or
substantially diminish or impair property values within the vicinity.
The proposed variance will not substantially increase traffic congestion or
increase the danger of fire or endanger the public safety.
9
Greenberg
Traurig
Cllfford ^ Schulman
(305) 579-0613
Direct Fax (305) 961-5613
E-Mail schuJmanc@:~gtlawcom
August I, 2006
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Joanne Carr
Planning Director
City of Aventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
A ventura, Florida 33180
~
Exhibit 1
01-CU-06 &. 02-VAR-06
. , LJ(, .V
I/ft.Q
i"'4tf,vl
Re: Hi Lift Marina /2890 N.K I8ih Street, Aventura / Variance
Application / Letter of Intent
Dear Ms. Carr:
On behalf of Hi Lift, LLC, (the "Applicant"), we respectfully submit this letter of
intent in connection with the above referenced Variance application. The Applicant owns
the marina and dry dock storage facility located at 2890 N.E. 187'h Street, A ventura (the
"Property"), and is proposing to develop a new wet/dry dock marina facility.
The Property is zoned Town Center Marine District ("TCM 2"). Pursuant to
Section 31-145 of the Land Development Regulations (the "LOR's"), TCM 2 sites that
abut a waterway must have a view corridor to the bay or ocean. However, due to the
,
dimensions of the Property and other circumstances more fully explained below, a
variance from Section 31-145 of the LOR is required in order to redevelop the existing
marina. In order to mitigate any impact caused by this variance re~uest, a publicly
accessible walkway and viewing areas is proposed to connect N.E. 29t Avenue to the
canal and thus allow the public to enjoy the limited water views. In addition to the view
corridor variance, the applicant also seeks a variance of Section 31-221 (i)(2) of the
LOR's which requires a landscaped buffer strip with a minimum of 7 feet for all areas
adjacent to any street right-of-way plus along vehicular use areas. Although the
landscape buffer is provided adjacent to the street right-of-way, the unique dimensions of
the Property create vehicular use areas that do not provide the required 7 feet of
landscape buffer.
We respectfully submit that the Application for Variance satisfies the revIew
criteria of Section 31-76 of the LOR as follows:
I. The particular physical surroundings, shape, topographical condition, or other
physical or environmental condition of the specific property involved would result
M1A-FS I \1 nwdm02 _.DOC
Greenberg Traurig, P,A. I Attorneys at Law 11221 Brickell Avenue I Miami. Fl33131 I Tel 305.579.0500 I Fax 305.579.0717 I www.gtlaw.com
in a particular hardship upon the owner, as distinguished from a mere
inconvenience, if the regulations were carried out literally.
Due to the irregular shape and unique location of this Property, enforcement of
the view corridor requirement would create a hardship. The Property is located at
the end of a canal with minimal views to the Bay. The canal only partially fronts
the Property along the middle of the site. View corridors are usually provided
along one of the property boundary lines. However, that would not be possible in
these circumstances because the canal fronts the middle of the Property. The
provision of a view corridor on this Property would split it in half and render the
proposed development or any other alternative, impossible. As for the landscape
buffer, it would be impossible to provide the required landscape buffer and the
appropriate vehicular use areas for the proposed project while at the same time
developing the amount of floor area permitted by the LDR's.
2. The conditions upon which the request for a variance is based are unique to the
parcel and would not be generally applicable to other property within the vicinity.
The irregular shape of the Property makes the request for these variances unique
to the parcel and would not be generally applicable to other property within the
vicinity. Since the Property is located at the end of the canal and the frontage to
the canal is only partial, it is highly unlikely that other properties can be alleged to
have the same condition. Furthermore, to mitigate any potential impact the
Aprlicant has proposed a fully publicly accessible walkway that will connect N.E.
29' Avenue to the canal.
3. The alleged difficulty or hardship is not economic and has not been
deliberately created to establish a use or structure which is not otherwise
consistent with the LDR.
The hardship created by the size and location of the Property is not economic and
has not been deliberately created to establish a use or structure which is not
otherwise consistent with the LDR.
4. The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity.
Granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or injurious
to other property or improvements in the vicinity. The new facility will be a state-
of the-art facility utilizing electric bridge crane technology which is fully enclosed
within the new building and eliminates virtually all noise associated with the
current facility such as the smell of fumes, the chatter of employees, and the noise
of tools which are all disruptive and negatively impact the privacy of the
neighboring residents. All service operations will be conducted indoors thereby
providing neighboring residents with enhanced quiet and privacy.
MIA-FSI\lnwdm02_.DOC
Greenberg Traurig, PA
5. The proposed variance will not substantially increase the congestion in the
public streets, or increase the danger of fire, or endanger the public safety, or
substantially diminish or impair property values within the vicinity.
The proposed variance will not substantially increase the congestion in the public
streets. On the contrary, the redevelopment of the marina will enhance the safety
of pedestrians and the safe operation of motor vehicles. The current parking on
site requires tenants of the facility to back their cars out onto lsih Street. The
new facility will provide for parking and organized ingress and egress all in
accordance with the LDR's. This will allow for a safer environment for
pedestrians and the safer operation of motor vehicles. In addition extensive
landscaping will provide further privacy and enhance the aesthetic quality of the
neighborhood. Furthermore, the alternative development scenario for the
property, a 76 unit mixed use residential/retail project, which is permitted "as of
right" by the LOR's, would generate more traffic than the current proposed
development. In addition, extensive landscaping will provide further privacy and
enhance the aesthetic quality of the neighborhood.
Accordingly, we respectfully submit that the proposed development satisfies the
applicable review criteria and respectfully request that you favorably consider our request
and schedule this application for the next available agenda of the A ventura City
Commission. If you have any questions or would like to discuss this matter further,
please contact me at 305-579-0613. Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
~~~~ i~~
~ Clifford A. Schulman
cc: Andrew Sturner
MIA-FSI\ 1 nwdm02 _.DOC
Greenberg Traurig. PA
Greenberg
Traurig
RECEiVED
Aut; .\ 2006
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Clifford A Schulman
(J05) 579-061 J
Direct Fax (305) 961.56]3
E-Mail schulmanc@gtlaw_com
August], 2006
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Joanne Carr
Planning Director
City of Aventura
]9200 West Country Club Drive
A ventura, Florida 33180
Re: Hi Lift Marina / 2890 N.E. 187th Street, Aventura / Conditional Use
Application / Letter of Intent
Dear Ms. Carr:
On behalf of Hi Lift, LLC, (the "Applicant"), we respectfully submit this letter of
intent in connection with the above referenced Conditional Use application. The
Applicant owns the marina and dry dock storage facility located at 2890 N.E. ]87th
Street, Aventura (the "Property"), and is proposing to develop a new wet/dry dock marina
facility.
The Property is zoned Town Center Marine District ("TCM 2"). The TCM 2
district allows building heights to 50 feet. Previously, the Applicant sought conditional
use approval, pursuant to Section 3] -73 of the Land Deve]opment Regulations (the
"LDR's"), to build a facility with a height of ]50 feet. In response to initial staff
comments, the proposed height of the building had been reduced to ] 22 feet. However,
upon further review and comment by the City Commission and staff, and after further
comparison of other building heights in the area, the proposed height of the building has
been further reduced to 90 feet. Accordingly, the Applicant hereby submits a conditional
use approval request so as to build a facility with a height of 90 feet.
To support this request, we have compared the various heights of many of the
buildings in the vicinity which range from 90 to ] 90 feet in height. More specifically, the
Venture located just to the northwest of the Applicant is at 109 feet in height, while the
buildings proposed and under construction along N .E. 188th Street (Harbor Center,
Uptown Marina and Atrium) reach up to ]35 feet in height. The approved Terzeto
project, located to the southwest of the Property is proposed to be 190 feet in height.
We respectfully submit that this request for Conditional Use approval satisfies the
review criteria of Section 3 1-73 of the LDR's as follows:
Greenberg Traurig, PAl Attorneys at Law 11221 Brickell Avenue I Miami, FL 33131 I Tel 305579.0500 I Fax 305.579.0717 I www.gtlaw.com
(1) The proposed use shall be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan.
The Comprehensive Plan encourages a mix of uses within the Town Center and
the provision of recreational facilities for the use of A ventura residents. The
proposed facility will help to further both of these objectives. Proximity and
access to water is one of the many attractions for residents and businesses within
the City of A ventura.
(2) The establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed use shall not be
detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, or general welfare.
The redevelopment of the Hi Lift Marina storage facility will enhance the safety
and general welfare of the public by replacing an antiquated dry storage facility
with a state-of-the-art facility built to today's more stringent building codes. In
addition, the current parking on site requires tenants of the facility to back their
cars out onto 187th Street. The new facility will provide for parking and
organized ingress and egress all in accordance with the LDR's. As such, the
redevelopment will not be injurious to other property or improvements in the
vicinity, and will, in fact, enhance the general welfare by improving recreational
options. Finally, the redevelopment will replace the 20-year old facility.
Hurricane Wilma has highlighted the need to upgrade aging dry storage marinas
to ensure they can withstand today's active hurricanes. The new Hi Lift facility
will be built to current hurricane protection standards, assuring that a windstorm
or fuel catastrophe does not happen.
(3) The proposed use shall be consistent with the community character of the
immediate neighborhood of the proposed use.
The immediate neighborhood of the proposed use is a neighborhood in transition
to increased residential development and mixed uses in the Town Center and
along N.E. 188th Street. The neighboring buildings consist of: Aventi, a low rise
development; The Venture an I I story residential development approximately
109' high; Harbour Center, a commercial office building tower rising
approximately 135' feet above grade; Uptown Marina Lofts, a residential
development approximately 135' high; Atrium, a residential development
approximately 135' high; and Terzetto, a residential development consisting of 2
towers, the nearest one to the property rising approximately 190' feet. The
proposed boat storage facility is an amenity consistent with the new luxury
residential character of the neighborhood.
(4) Utilities, roadway capacity, drainage, and other necessary public facilities,
including police, fire and emergency services, shall exist at the City's adopted
levels of service, or will be available concurrent with demand as provided for in
the requirements of these LDRs.
Greenberg Traurig, PA
The redevelopment of the Marina will not change the current levels of service
required. As such, the City's current levels of infrastructure and services are
sufficient to accommodate the proposed use. Also, the assessed value of the
property for tax purposes will increase by fivefold, at a minimum, thereby
providing increased revenue to the City for future capacity and service
improvements.
(5) Adequate measures exist or shall be taken to provide ingress and egress to the
proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets.
Ingress and egress to this facility are proposed to be enhanced considerably. The
current parking situation is problematic. Currently, the visitor parking area
consists of a narrow strip on the north side of the property between the building
and sidewalk. Cars exiting the property have no choice but to back out into
moving traffic on 187th Street. The new facility will ensure a more orderly and
safer flow of traffic and provide parking inside the building.
(6) The establishment of the conditional use shall not impede the development of
surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district.
A boat storage facility at this location has not and will not impede the
development of surrounding properties.
(7) The design of the proposed use shall minimize adverse effects, including
visual impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent property through the use of
building orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria.
The proposed facility has been designed so as to minimize visual impacts. In fact,
the proposed facility will eliminate many of the adverse effects the current facility
represents for the neighborhood. The new first-class Mediterranean design
replaces the old industrial metal building and calls for the elimination of the
outdoor exposed racks which are unattractive and represent an adverse effect on
the neighborhood. The antiquated forklift technology currently utilized at Hi Lift
employs loud gas engines which together with the "reverse beeps" create
substantial noise that is irritating to neighboring residents. This new facility will
be a state-of-the-art facility utilizing electric bridge crane technology which is
fully enclosed within the new building and eliminates virtually all noise
associated with the current facility such as the smell of fumes, the chatter of
employees, and the noise of tools which are all disruptive and negatively impact
the privacy of the neighboring residents. All of the service operations in this
proposed facility will be conducted indoors thereby providing neighboring
residents with enhanced quiet and privacy. In addition, extensive landscaping
will provide further privacy and enhance the aesthetic quality of the
neighborhood.
Greenberg Traurig. P.A.
The proposed facility is a unique opportunity to enhance the appearance of the
Property and to expand the recreational alternatives in the City. It is important to note
that there will be no net increase in the number of boat slips and that, while 76 residential
units are permitted on the Property as of right, no residential uses are proposed.
Accordingly, we respectfully submit that the proposed use satisfies the applicable
review criteria, and respectfully request that you favorably consider our request and
schedule this application for the next available agenda of the Aventura City Commission.
If you have any questions or would like to discuss this matter further, please contact me
at 305-579-0613. Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sincerely,
,f%uif .J~l - ~~~
.~ Clifford A. Schulman
cc: Andrew Sturner
Greenberg Traurig, PA
BROWARD COUNTY
..-.-.-.-. ...
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
;.
.,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:'
"
IVES DAIRY RD. :,
:'
.,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
;,
.,
;1
:'
.,
:,
:,
:,
:,
;1
.,
:,
:,
:,
:,
;1
.,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:,
:.
:.
,:-
DADE COUNTY
>'
:;;
I
w
8
o
;;:
MIAMI
GAROENS DR.
, , /- ~
I _______
~ n\r""rlr.......... \ ____
."r-.I"."......,...,".I"l........~
Culfstream YACHT CLUB DR. .
Park I
MARINA .
COVE '
CIRCLE '
.
\Nt-'\~P.'i :
,
,
--
AI'('II{/lill
/-(O.\flilill
& MedicIII iij
C('II{I'/ 41
rn~
J
~
Q)
w w
;;: >
<l:
The gj 205
Promenade 0
Shops (I')
203 ST.
o
~m
N
"
'I
,
WATERWAYS BLVD
f~
tU
,
Warerways
Shoppes
207 ST
COUNTRY CLUB DR
cj
>
--'
OJ
2
""
w
o
o
201 TER.
a:
o
ro
::0
--"
o
>-
a:
f-
Z
::0
o
o
Turnberry Isle
Resort & Club
AVENTURA \\\-,,0
Fire I:
Rescue
Station
D
A\'entura
Library
Aventura Mall
192 ST.
192 ST.
191 ST.
Loehmann's
Fashion W
Island ~
m
N
190 ST.
ci
>
--'
OJ
2
Uj
o
o
Atlantic
Ocean
.
.
.
.
.
.
. ".a-.r.' _ 1Il:. . ... . . . . ~
LEGEND
e
Maule
Lake
,~.:',
.
+,,'
f-''?,'_
.!: ,~,,}
+~,
.' ~,
+ '
.
.
. +
'lo+
Roadways
City Boundary
ZIP Code Boundary
Railroad
"'":""..
r ~!-'
':~~
'"i.
Exhibit 2
01-CU-06 & 02-VAR-06
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
PARCEL A-1
Commence at the Northeast corner of the NW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of
Fractional Secti'on 3, Township 52 South, Range 42 East, Miami-Dade County, Florida; thence
run North 0 degrees 39'25" West for a distance of 180.25 feet to a point; thence run North
89 degrees 20'35" East for 0 distance of 70 feet to a point on the East right-of-way line
of N.E. 29th Avenue; thence r.un .South 0 degrees 39'25" East along the ~OS~ right~of-woy
line of N.E. 29th Avenue for a dlstance of 49.74 feet to the pomt of beginning of the
following described parcel and the point of curvature of a curv~ concave to the Northwest;
thence continue along said curve, having for its elements a radius of 198.90 feet, a central
angle of 90 degrees 42'40", for an arc distance of 314.90 feet to the point of tan~ency on
the South right-af-way line of N.E. 187th Street; thence run North 89 degrees 56'45' West
along said South right-of-way line for a distance of 142.58 feet to a point; thence run
South 0 degrees 02'30" West for 0 distance of 188.64 feet to 0 point of curvature .of a
curve concave to the Northeast; thence run along the arc of said curve, having for Its
elements a radius of 30 feet, a central angle of 45 degrees 04'53" for a distance of 23.60
feet to a point of reverse curve; thence run along the arc of a curve concave to the
Southwest, having for its elements a radius of 100 feet, a central angle of 21 degrees 29'05"
for a distance of 37.50 feet to a point on said curve; said pOint beanng North 66 degrees
26'42" East from the center of said curve; thence run South 89 degrees 58'15" East for a
distance of 297.03 feet to a point; thence run North 0 degrees 39'25" West, 216.10 feet to 0
point; thence run North 88 degrees 51 '54" East for a distance of 20 feet to a point; thence
run North 0 degrees 39'25" West for a distance of 225.41 feet to the point of beginning
PARCEL A-2
Together with the canal easement rights more specificalty set out in easement agreement
executed by R.B. Gautier, Jr., individually and as Trustee, I'oined by his wife, Frances Gautier,
and Atlas Terminals of Florida" Inc. to North Dade Acres, nc., doted June 4, 1962, in Official
Records Book 3185, Page 743 of the Public Records of Miami ~ Dade County, Florida.
AND: PARCEL B - SUBMERGED PARCEL: WEST
A portion of the Tract "C", ATLAS TERMINAL RES~DENTIAL, o-ccording to the prat thereof as
recorded in Plat Book 146 at Page 18, of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida,
and being more particularly deSCribed as follows:
Begin at the Southwest corner of said Tract "C"; thence N 00.39'25". W along the West line of
said Tract "c" for 111 10 feet to the Northwest corner of said Tract "C", thence N 88.51'54"
E along the North line of said Tract "c" for 399.91 feet to a point on the Southerly extension
of the West Itne of Fortin, Leavy, Skiles, Inc., Drawing Number 2099-D~179-8, doted February
2, 2004; thence S 00'39'25" E alonq said Southerly extension of the West line of Fortin,
Leavy, Skiles, Inc., Drawing Number 20990-179-8, dated February 2, 2004, for 119.20 feet to
a point on the South line of said Tract "C"; thence N 89'58'36'" W along said South line of
Tract "c" for 399.93 feet to the Point of Beginning.
Exhibit 3
01-CU-06 &. 02-VAR-06
~ ~~ ",:_~^\P~L;;'ie~"'_:~:: ~:Jjmrpuwm~ -t 4~--+
'f~ ~-~--~~~.Cc--=.':__-==~_~ ""M__ ~1il ___
'~, ....;;;; ~:o----- 'IF"'" eo"",,, --- -~- --{1.~' ~ <:
(' /'" ~ - --.-- - ~ \ .
'" ~/;/ -. . -. =='- . \ r,...
~..---.-. ~ ~-'.~--~-- ---~ - - - - - ~\ ~rJ
' -' --- - - - - - - - -1\ I
~/ \ -- ~" ~
// ~, '1
,~...
h_
~
~
",!:'fJ
k t\-j
tJ
<?
'""
0: Ll;'ilc .
L;;;.;.... .
. .(
~~
l -.:;-'= :'..
>.
-. :)
.~
'iq
~~
~~
_0
~~
~"
~
<-
"
m
,
&
m
x
~
-<:"
- .-Ii'
-- !:
P
-fi
~
r"
~
.~~
~m?z
~~~
~~~
~>
~
'<~J
~
~
m
~
~
,.
t9
""
,
o
~~
,.
tlV!
~~
,"
"
~
,
a 0
." "
)>0 '\:I>
~., ^.'
~q m'3;
[
~-r
~
H
~ ~ ~
m \J (J\
;i ffi 7'
o "
~ ~ 11
~ ~ r
d ~
l ~ ~ t.
XI:;; rn
~
[
,
,
r
t
,
,.
,.
,
,.
~
)
~ I'
----1 ~ ~'.
~ I
" r
...., I
I:>
<
~
Ii
~
o
o
l'
'. /,...
'. / :f.:
;<.~,~
z
V'Vlm
,., ;-~
n _ n
~S'i;
: ~~~;
!. .
:: 0N'~5:
\
\
N.E.
~-
. . ,.. '. ..
m ~ -r
~u i
$
. oi
., t
~
~ e,
!1'
1"
~
(l'
"OJ
O'I
b9J~
g;~c
'j'I\]::!)
0~
DJ>
-';;0
e-
m
,-
Exhibit 4
01-CU-06 a.02-VAR-06
~
()
~
J>
r
s ~~~~
-t -t()OI.f\
)> ~C)Cl'=
r r;uJO""U
""U \l >1'Jl,",U"
)> )>. IlJQU'l,
~ ~ ~}>oo'-J
Z z -t.IU"
$ \]'I _~>=
]ilJl(j'\+
~ ~ .n~mlJl
~ l> .......)>;u"
m ~ G;-{)>
\JI If\ O\}Jl\
o AI QIV~
12 ~ ,,\}>::o.
~ ~ ~ ~~
Ol ~ ~ ~~
}> =i z \Iij;
~ -( g.;u
tJI ~~
m
J>
~
F
CJ
~
I
m
~
~
iO 'J111
In 0 iO
;; m~
[J,{)
VI AI In
O' ~io!
~\)l
I l..)
\'---l
C;:;;
- "
()L\
~ ,--
.'-'"'
() I? OJ
~~~S
7 _
APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT
Pursuant to Section 31.71 (b)(2)(i) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code, this Applicant Representative
Affidavit is hereby made and submitted. The undersigned authorized representative of the individual or entity applying for the
Development Permit, which is identified in the accompanying application, and the owner of the property subject to the application
(if different) hereby lists and identifies all persons representing the individual or entity applying for the Development Permit in
connection with the application. as follows:
Name
Relationship (i.e. Attorneys, Architects,
Landscape
Architects. Engineers. Lobbyists, Etc_J
Clifford A. Schulman
Attornev
Mario Garcia-Serra
Mark Saltz
Attorney
Architect
Dan Fortin Jr.
Survevor
NOTICE: ANY STATEMENT OR REPRESENTATION MADE BY ANY PERSON LISTED ON THE APPLICANT
REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT SHALL BE BINDING UPON THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY APPLYING FOR
THE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND THE OWNER OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY. APPLICANTS AND
AFFIANTS ARE ADVISED TO TIMELY SUPPLEMENT THIS AFFIDAVIT PURSUANT TO SEC. 31-
71(B)(2)(tV) OF THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS IN THE CITY CODE, IN THE EVENT
THAT PRIOR TO CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICATION BY THE CITY BOARD OR MISSION, THE
INFORMATION PROVIDED IN THE AFFIDAVIT BECOMES INCORRECT OR INCOMPL
WITNESS MY HANO THIS ~ DAY OF ~~-I
By:
X By
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OF APPLICANT
(Signature)
Signature)
Name Andv Sturner
(Pnnt)
Title: Manaaer Hi Lift LLC
Name:
(Print)
Title:
Address:
Address 2890 NE 187 Street
Aventura FL 33180
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me the undersigned authority personally appeared Andrew Sturner a
of the Applicant and/or the owner of the property subject to the appltcatio ho
swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated erel
-+\..
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME thi&2. day of
. ed representative
me duly sworn, d
true and cor
FIANT
~~ ~OO~
:~, A(lAP~
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission eXPires:J\J\.Il..'j \ D, .d{)() '1
NOTARY ?UBUC.STATE OF FLORIDA
~ Lisa Karcher
Commission # DD428124
Expires: MAY 10, 2009
Bonded Thru Atlantic Bonding Co., Ine.
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDA VIP
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71 (b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code. The undersIgned Affiant hereb)
discloses that: (mark with "x" applicable portions only)
[X] 1. Affiant does no! have a Business RelatIOnship ,,,,ilh any member of the City CommissIOn or any City Advisor;,'
Board to which the application \vil! be presented
] 2 Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a
City Advisory Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follo\\'s
I] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of I %1 of total assets or
capital stock of Applicant or Reprc:sentative;
[] ii. Member ofCiry Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which
are not listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or
Representative in any business venture;
[] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client
of another professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the
City Commission or Board;
[] iv A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative:
[J v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of
his or her employer) and transacts more than $] 0,000_00 of the business of the member of the eit)
Commission or Board (or hIS or her employer) in a given calendar year;
)(
[] vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and
transacts more than $25,00000 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar
year.
J} -L\..
THIS~D ,~..:lCoc..,
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
","-\- \ J
WITNESS MY HAND THIS ~ DA Y OF '-.,)l ')
PROPERTY OWNER
By:
Name'
Title:
,~.~
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
*The terms "Business Relationship, " "Client, " "Customer, " "Applicant, " "Representative" and "interested Person"
are defined in Section 2-395 of the A ventura City Code.
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDA VIP
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-7J(b)(2)(ii) ufthe City of Aventura Land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant hereby'
discloses that: (mark with "x" applicable portions only)
[X] 1. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or aoy' City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented
{ }2. Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a
City Advisory Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows
[J L Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or
capital stock of Applicant or Representative;
[ ] ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which
are not listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or
Representative in any business venture;
[] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client
of another professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the
City Commission or Board;
[] iv, A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of
his or her employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City
Commission or Board (or his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ ] vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and
transacts more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar
year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DA Y OF
,2005.
APPLICANT:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
By:
Name:
Title:
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
.2005.
PROPERTY OWNER:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
By:
Name:
Title:
*The terms "Business Relationship, " "Client," "Customer, " "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person"
are defined in Section 2-395 a/the Aventura CIty Code.
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDA VIP
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant hereby
discloses that: (mark with "x" applicable ponions only)
[ X ] 1 Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented
] 2. Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a
City Advisory Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) \vho serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature ofthe Business Relationship is as follows:
[ J i Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or
capital stock of Applicant or Representative;
[ ] ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which
are not listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or
Representative in any business venture;
[ ] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client
of another professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the
City Commission or Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of
his or her employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City
Commission or Board (or his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ ) vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and
transacts more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar
year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2005.
APPLICANT:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
By:
Name:
Title:
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2005.
PROPERTY OWNER:
(Signature)
(Prim)
(Print)
By:
Name:
Title:
*The terms "Business Relationship," "Client, " "Customer,)) "Applicant,)) "Representative)) and "interested Person"
are defined in Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS ~ DA Y OF ;jL\ \ l,\
\
REPRESENT A TIVE: ( isted on Business Relationship Affidavit)
BylrLU~r .
I '
Name: Matia J. Garcia-Serra
.20rh
g ature) By: (Signature)
(Print) Name: (Print)
(PrInt) Title: (Print)
(Signature) By: (Signature)
(Print) Name: (Print)
(Print) Title: (Print)
(Signature) By:_. (Signature)
(Print) Name: (Print)
(Print) Title: __(Print)
__(Signature) By: (Signature)
(Print) Title: (Print)
(Print) Title: (Print)
(Signature) By: (Signature)
(Print) Title: (Print)
(Print) Title: (Print)
_(Signature) By: (Signalure)
(PrInt) Title: (Print)
(Print) Title: (Print)
Title: Attome
By:
Name: Clifford A. Schulman
Title: Attorney
By:
Name:
Title:
By:
Title:
Title:
By:
Title:
Title:
By:
Title:
Title:
NOTE: 1) Use duplicate sheets if disclosure information for Representative varies
2) Applicants and Affiants are advised to timely supplement this Affidavit pursuant to Sec. 31-
71(b)(2)(iv) of the City's Land Development Regulations in the City Code, in the event that prior to
consideration of the application by the City Board or Commission, the information provided in the
Affidavit becomes incorrect or incomplete.
NOTARIZATION PROVISION
ST ATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMj.DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Clifford A.
being first by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed this '"
therein and that it is true and correct.
Iman the Affiant, who
for the purposes stated
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this a \ day of ~ 20
1l;lrilEIC8fTII
. . My Ccmmi..... DD380120
\: ';I Ell!lim Octcbor 08, 20llll
'O~~/A ~
Printed Name of Natary
My commission expires
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Mario GarCIa-Serra the Affiant, who being
first by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated
therein and that it is true and correct. ;?L ~ _ j~
AFFIANT
~ ~ lri, EIC8""
. ~ . My Commiosion D0380120
'\"., ,,:1 Exp;"" October 08, 20llll
r
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me th]S~\ day or3;.,\. \ l\
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires
5T A TE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appear d
by me duly.sworn, did swear or affinn that he/she execute t
and that it is true and correct.
X SWORN TO AND SUBSCRWfflA'ft~'ptffit\'!;~~~fF~ m c2.co ~
~ Lisa Karcher Kr& eJuf
Commission # DD428124 NO!5:' .Publ.iC; Slate of Flor" a At Large
Expires: MAY 10, 2009 . ';,(l.. K-!>t2c.I.Ae
Bonded Thru Atlantic Bonding Co., Inc. PMnnted Name orNotary f\ ~ 10 """q
y commISSIOn expIres: 1\.1 \ JV\.j
_______.________________._....__._....___________._.__..______.._h___.__........__....___.__._.___.__.________________________________._._......___.____.___.____.._______
STATE OFFLORJDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, who being first
by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein
and that it is true and correct.
.
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71 Cb)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant
hereby discloses that: (mark with "x" applicable portions only)
[X J 1. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City
Advisory Board to which the application will be presented.
[ ] 2. Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City
Commission or a City Advisory Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
the
member selVes).
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which
The nature of the Business Reiationship is as follows:
I] i. Member of City Commission or Board hoids an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total
assets or capital stock of Applicant or Representative;
[J ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder Cas to shares of a
corporation which are not listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer
with the Applicant or Representative in any business venture;
[ ] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a
Client of another professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the
member of the City Commission or Board;
[J iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[J v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board
(or of his or her employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member
of the City Commission or Board (or his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[] vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative
and transacts more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a
given calendar year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS .z4"V DAY OF kt:>vC,i ,200&.
APPLICANT:
By: X
Name:
Title:
Mark Saltz
Architect
(Signature)
(Print)
(Prinf)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,200_.
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested
Person" are defined in Section 2-395 of the A ventura City Code.
MIA-FS1\lK85FOl .DOC
. . -
!';"~"~'."'~'~'" ,~~.,,--, -""'~~.
'~~~ NICHOLLE CHEESMAN
\1f......l:.~ MY COMMISSION #DD336416
EXPIRES: JUL 18. 2008
~BOndedthroU9h1stStatelnsurance
~
Printed Name of Notary ....k D
My commission expires: l1q tv.;laJ3
WITNESS MY HAND THIS 1..4 DAY OF J;..Y,U<71
,200,h.
REPRESENTA VE: (Listed on Business Relationship Affidavit)
By:X (Signature) By:
Name: Mark Saltz (Print) Name:
Title: Architect (Print) Title:
By: (Signature) By:
Name: (Print) Name:
Tille: (Print) Title:
By: (Signature) By:
Name: (Print) Name:
Title: (Print) Tille:
By: (Signature) By:
Name: (Print) Name:
Title: (Pnnt) Tille:
By: (Signature) By:
Name: (Print) Name:
Tille: (Print) Title:
By: (Signature) By:
Name: (Print) Name:
Tille: (Print) Title:
(Signature
(Print)
(Print)
(Signature
(Print)
(Print)
(Signature
(Print)
(Print)
(Signature
(Print)
(Print)
(Signature
(Print)
(Print)
(Signature
(Print)
(Print)
NOTE: 1) Use duplicate sheets if disclosure information for Representative varies
2) Applicants and Affiants are advised to timely supplement this Affidavit pursuant to Sec. 31-
71 (b)(2)(lv) of the City's Land Development Regulations in the City Code, in the event that prior
to consideration of the application by the City Board or Commission, the information provided
in the Affidavit becomes incorrect or Incomplete.
MIA-FS1\1K85F01 .DOC
.~ -
NOTARIZATION PROVISION
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Mark Saltz t Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affinn that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true d correct.
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this .D4- day of
'/.
AFFI
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant who being first by me duly sworn, did
swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
AFFIANT
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
.200_.
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did
swear or affinn that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
AFFIANT
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
.200_.
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMt-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did
swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
AFFIANT
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,200 .
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
MIA-FS 1 \1 K85F01 . DOC
.- -
..
~ojl!~
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71(b)(2)(ii) ot the City ot Aventura Land Oevelopment Code. The undersigned Affiant
hereby discloses that: (mark with "x" applicable portions only)
IX ] 1. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member ot the City Commission or any City
Advisory Board to which the application will be presented.
[ ] 2. Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member ot the City
Commission or a City Advisory Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
the
member serves).
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who selVes on
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total
assets or capital stock of Applicant or Representative;
[ ] ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a
corporation which are not listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer
with the Applicant or Representative in any business venture;
[ ] Iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a
Client of another professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the
member of the City Commission or Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board
(or of his or her employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member
of the City Commission or Board (or his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ J vi. The member ot the City Commission or Board is a Customer ot the Applicant or Representative
and transacts more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a
given calendar year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS?-'fr'tAY oFAU<..IJ~rr ,200_4:>
~/d~/
(By: ~~.?-' ~ (Signature)
Name: Dan Fortin. Jr. (Print)
Title: Survevor (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS!
DAY OF
.200_.
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
'The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Appllcanl," "Representative" and "Interested
Person" are defined in Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code.
f1:Il~-FS1\lK85F01_DOC
Printed Name ot Notary
My commission expires
WITNESS MY HAND THISz..~~DAY OF A lKcv5r
,20~
~TIV~ted 0,'; Business Relationship Affidavit)
: X ~~ (Signature) By: (Signature
Name: Dan Fortin. Jr. (Print) Name: (Print)
Title: Survevor (Print) Title: (Print)
By: (Signature) By: (Signature
Name: (Print) Name: (Print)
Title: (Print) Title: (Print)
By: (Signature) By: (Signature
Name: (Print) Name: (Print)
Title: (Print) Title: (Print)
By: (Signature) By: (Signature
Name: (Print) Name: (Print)
Title: (Print) Title: (Print)
By: (Signature) By: (Signature
Name: (Print) Name: (Print)
Title: (Print) Title: (Print)
By: (Signature) By: (Signature
Name: (Print) Name: (Print)
Title: (Print) Title: (Print)
NOTE: 1) Use duplicate sheets if disclosure information for Representative varies
2) Applicants and Affiants are advised to timely supplement this Affidavit pursuant to Sec. 31-
71 (b)(2)(iv) of the City's land Development Regulations in the City Code, in the event that prior
to consideration of the application by the City Board or Commission, the information provided
In the Affidavit becomes incorrect or Incomplete.
":l!t--FS1I1KB5F01_.DOC
NOTARIZATION PROVISION
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Dan Fa
or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein a
e Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear
de c
AFFIANT
SWORN TOANDSLJ!!SG.fl.l~.~~YOf
~; SDSA.NP.KAY <
~ ..~'''~ i'in' COMMISS10.l'.1 #- D~3D7184 ~
~\ oJ~~~~:, EXPm.ES: Apnl 06. 2008 2
} ].~,3~~INAj('" "H Not~ D1SCQ'.Ult ASS':;;';;:;"';
''-'~'.f?'''';_'^'o_'''>fi,f./'''''''"""",~\iV''JV
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
~~_U_________.'___".______.._'__"_______~.'d_________________._~_________________.._.._...__.._.___________________n~_..___..________'_____.______________"4'.____..__________.__.
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did
swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
AFFIANT
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,200 .
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
-----~--~------------------------_.__._--------------~-----------------_.~-~-_.~--~------------_._~-----------._--_._._----------_._-----------..._--_.~---_..--..
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMt-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant. who being first by me duly sworn, did
swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
AFFIANT
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
.200_.
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
---_._---_._-------~---._--_._---------------_._--_._-----.--_._-------_._-~-_.._-----_.._-----------_..~
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did
swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
AFFIANT
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,200_.
Notary Public State of Florida At large
":'~-FS 1 \1 K85F01_ DOC
RESOLUTION NO. 2006-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA GRANTING
CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL TO PERMIT THE
CONSTRUCTION OF A MARINA AND DRY DOCK BOAT
STORAGE BUILDING WITH A HEIGHT OF 90 FEET IN
THE TC2, TOWN CENTER MARINE DISTRICT, WHERE A
MAXIMUM HEIGHT OF 4 STORIES OR 50 FEET IS
PERMITTED BY CODE; GRANTING VARIANCE FROM
SECTION 31-145(c)(10) OF THE CITY'S LAND
DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS TO PERMIT A VIEW
CORRIDOR OF 15 FEET WHERE A 66.76 FOOT VIEW
CORRIDOR IS REQUIRED BY CODE; AND GRANTING
VARIANCE FROM SECTION 31-221(i)(2) OF THE CITY'S
LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS TO PERMIT A
MINIMUM BUFFER STRIP OF 4'8", WHERE A MINIMUM
7' WIDE BUFFER STRIP IS REQUIRED BY CODE FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2890 NE 187 STREET, CITY
OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
WHEREAS, the property described herein is zoned TC2, Town Center Marine
District; and
WHEREAS, the Applicant, Hi Lift Marina LLC, through Application No. 01-CU-06,
has requested conditional use approval to permit the construction of a marina and dry
dock boat storage facility with a height of 90 feet, where a maximum height of 4 stories
or 50 feet are permitted by Code; and
WHEREAS, the applicant, Hi Lift Marina LLC, through Application No. 02-VAR-
06, has requested variance from Section 31-145(c)(10) of the City's Land Development
Regulations to permit a development with a view corridor of 15 feet, where a 66.76 foot
view corridor is required by Code and Variance from Section 31-221 (i)(2) of the City's
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 2
Land Development Regulations to permit a buffer strip of 4'8", where a minimum 7'
buffer strip is required by Code; and
WHEREAS the applicant has proffered a covenant prohibiting residential uses
on the site and the City Commission has accepted such proffer; and
WHEREAS, following proper notice, the City Commission has held a public
hearing as provided by law; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has reviewed the application for conditional
use and finds that the conditional use requested meets the standards for approval of
conditional uses as set forth in Section 31-73(c) of the City's Land Development
Regulations; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has reviewed the application for variance to
Section 31-145(c)(10) and finds that the variance requested meets the standards for
approval of variances as set forth in Section 31-76(e) of the City's Land Development
Regulations; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has reviewed the application for variance to
Section 31-221(i)(2) and finds that the variance requested meets the standards for
approval of variances as set forth in Section 31-76(e) of the City's Land Development
Regulations; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 3
Section 1. Application No. 01-CU-06 for conditional use approval of a 90 foot
tall building in the TC2, Town Center Marine District, on land described in Exhibit "A" is
hereby granted, subject to the condition in Section 4 of this Resolution.
Section 2. Application No. 02-VAR-06 for a variance from Section 31-145(c)(10)
of the City's Land Development Regulations to permit a 15 foot view corridor where a
66.76 foot view corridor is required by Code, on land described in Exhibit "A" is hereby
granted, subject to the condition in Section 4 of this Resolution.
Section 3. Application No. 01-VAR-06 for a variance from Section 31-221(i)(2)
of the City's Land Development Regulations to permit a 4'8" foot buffer strip where a
minimum 7 foot buffer strip is required by Code on land described in Exhibit "A" is
hereby granted, subject to the condition in Section 4 of this Resolution.
Section 4. As a condition of approval of the conditional use and variances in
Sections 1 through 3 inclusive of this Resolution, the applicant shall deliver to the City,
in form satisfactory to the City Attorney, a covenant prohibiting residential uses on the
property described in Exhibit "A". Such covenant shall be recorded in the Public
Records of Miami-Dade County at the expense of the applicant.
Section 5. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its
adoption.
The foregoing Resolution was offered by Commissioner , who
moved its adoption. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
, and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 4
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 1ih day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGA~ SUFFICIENCY:
YI~
CITY ATTORNEY
This Resolution was filed in the Office of the City Clerk this _ day of
,2006.
CITY CLERK
Resolution No. 2006-_
Page 5
EXHIBIT "A
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
PARCEL A-1
Commence ,at the Northeast corner of the NW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of
Fractional Section 3, Township 52 South, Range 42 East, Miami-Qade County, Florida; thence
run North 0 degrees 39'25" West for a distance of 180.25 feet to a point; thence run North
89 degrees 20'35" East for a distance of 70 feet to a pOint on the East right-oF-way line
of N.E. 29th Avenue; then-ce ..un South 0 degrees 3-9'25" East along the East right-ot-way
line of N.E. 29th Avenue for a distance of 49.74 feet to the point of beginning of the
following described parcel, and the point of curvature of 0 curvt'_ concave to the Northwest;
thence continue along said curve, havlng for Its elements a radius of 198.90 feet, a central
angle of 90 degrees 42'40", for an arc distance of 314.90 feet to the point of tan';lency on
the South right-of-way line of N.E. 187th Street; thence run North 89 degrees 56'45' West
along said South right-of~way line for a distance of 142.58 feet to 0 pOint; thence run
South 0 degrees .02'30" West for 0 d~ston.ce of 188.64 feet to a point of curvature of a
curve concave to the Northeast; thence run along the arc of said curve, having for its
elements a radius of 30 feet, 0 central angle of 45 degrees 04'53" for 0 distance of 2360
feet to 0 pOint of reverse curve; thence run along the ore of a curve concave to the
Southwest, having for its elements a radius of. 100 feet, 0 central angle of 21 degrees 29'05"
for 0 distance of 37.50 feet to a pOint on said curve; sOld pOint bearing North 66 degrees
26'42" East from the center of said curve: thence run South 89 degrees 58'15" East for a
distance of 297,03 feet to a point; thence run North 0 degrees 39'25" West, 216.10 feet to a
point; thence run North 88 degrees 51 '54" East for a distance of 20 feet to a point; thence
run North 0 degrees 39'25" West for a distance of 22541 feet to the point of beginning
PARCEL A-2
Together with the conal easement rights more speclfical~y set out in easement agreement
executed by R.B. Gautier, Jr, individually and os Trustee, IOlned by hiS Wife, Frances Goutier,
and Atlas Terminals of Florida, Inc. to North Dade Acres, nc., dated June 4, 1962. In OffiCial
Records Book 3185, Page 743 of the Public Records of Mi,oml - Dade County, Florida
AND: PARCEL B - SUBMERGED PARCEL: WEST
A portion. of the Tract "C", ATLAS TERMINAL RESIDENTIAL, ql==cording to the plat thereof as
recorded In Plat Book 146 at Page 18, of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida,
and being more particularly descrtbed as follows
Begin at the Southwest corner of said Tract "C'; thence N 00"39'25". W along the West line of
said Tract "C" for 11 1 10 feet to the Northwest corner of said Tract "c" thence N 8S"S1' 54"
E along the North line of said Tract "c" for 399.91 feet to a pOint on the Southerly extension
of the West line. of Fortin, Leavy, Skiles, inc, Drawrng Number 20990-179-8, doted Februarv
2, 2004; thence S 00'39'25" E along said Southerly extension of the West line of rortin,
Leavy, Skiles, Inc, DraWing Number 20990-179-8, doted February 2, 2004, for 119.20 feet to
a point on the South line of said Tract "C"; thence N 89'58'36"- W. olong said South line of
Tract "(" for 399.93 feet to the Point of Beginning.
- ---'j
. .....
~ ""
~ 'it':,
--
,....
-
~
-
I
-
,...~ ,
- ,.. ".,.')
'-----
,
\
!
,
~
..
,
I
I
.,""_+>-n_._'"
~~
~~
--
, ....
--
'....
- -~
-'"'"
..~
\
\
1
I
.
.
.
1"..
..
..
...
:.~,-W1..;;o...!;;; ~
'j
/
.~ !~.
-
-
.~."
... ... __ 0"
J: .. ,.., :::
;...;;!,,:,
~ ...... I~
"" ..,~ c:
';!;"~::'c
~ I .... ~
"- .. --. ';<
3..._~
~-~
: ..,.',
~ - ~ I"
~ '- ~ Is
~ ~:::: I~
~ ....... <i
~ I ... I~
"'- ... ~-.. -<
:3 )IIpII(..... ~
-g-~::
I-~
'I;"'Z,
--
- .~.......
--
"1' ....
.... ._~
.... ..
... ~;
\-.~---
-.\
--;1
;' ~~
0 .~ ~!': -
-
I - - -
, .....
- - I~
I ...
- ~~ ~
~ ... ..
- ~
I' ;..,~
~ 7,
--
...:....
I ~;
\,.-----.
;::: '" ":;0 :'l: ,;;..
. "..................", .,- .-
. .' ~- ~- , ; f - ;-".~,
~. .~ ~. ... '" .. ,. i;t
- c .. .. to . ,Ii
..ca '~-~,"
'>1r
. ,':
,=lIIIJ01
.. ." L
.
. \
~J'
'. :l
-
iilll\!
-
.~
t
~
.. ....
~ --.
~~
- -
.. .....
I '7' ::::
..... -~
...... :
~ -- "'--..'
\ J
-
,
.... *' ... :: 10 ..:111
.... .. .. -
I", .- ~: ,.' ro' :.:: ~ .
.~IU~
=:a,._=
-1"""'.
tOld
;.. . . . 'lI :::
;.~; ; ~;'~
:: .r:. z: . . .- .
-
III
III C
&.=:
o III
a.. a..
a..'t:J
.c:5
u.-
;3:
2:
Y1f'\" F ..
..c
~i'
I
'II
"Ii,
"-"",'
'tl >> ~ l
c;.
"-
i
..
.
. ,,,
.;, Ir
~ r t~
,
.
~
L "
____iL_.
I '1
L---..._..
~
t'
I_
I
LL
I
LL
LL
I
L
c
--.\
- "'"
- <
~ ~:
- -
, .....
.... -
'....
- '-,
JootIIIt ....
i!IIII'i .,., !
\~_.,--'
... .. . 1C ;;:t ~
W;-lI.-'FVF-"'-"'",.' lIIii
'... .f
'."'-M:
:"-'
l. 'III" l L ....
'\..'''' h I r I ',:
. .' It. .
. .
,<
-
..
-
~ ..
-
..
-~
;! ~~ ~
" ... ;i!":
- -
, :::::
- .
I ~
-
= -
"'"' ,
>-)
.;~
III
C
.-
I.
III
:!:
Cl
c
.-
....
VI
')(
W
I
'--~
~.
I!t:~i
.' - --
~-==~
" I ""'" :
ci: ... "'-1 ~
:3....._ ::
~..~~
t
,
-
me
&.~
e l!
A,"C
.c
~~
Ia~
:E
I
~"--
I
....
~
~
-
....
-
....
~
-
~
...
r_
-
-
....
t
-
...
-
I
I
-
RI
III
o
CL
2
Do
~
GJ
Z
~,
:;;;> ..
'" ...., --.. l~
~iii"': [1
~_- i1
C> ~ ~ l~
~ I .... ! ~
- ... --.. I..
:3 ...... ~
~...~
I
':
E-~
~z
--
.-
,-
-~
... -
..~
~., ~--
'11'llliliill' ---
~~~~-- I
l'~'.".(41-
~'~'~''-.'' "
51 "".'f.,tc.t, :f
n~:U;, '
.. "lIiIIIi'
.1.....
It.l\!..ll
~~
:;...~
--
, .....
--
'I =~
-- .,..;
\------ '
\
1'\
3>',jffl"H!".
"" """,.......... ...
~,: 1:'
~! ~J
........
'-~
~--
--
I - .'
-....
... ~
-~~
,
i'
! I
1/
II
Iii
I
,
"
i
!/
),
I'lS
C
.-
a-
I'lS
::E
g'
i
~
I
-
ftI
III
o
Q.
e
a.
~
z
(f'4t?It::ll,,'"llt ill/!
()f Et.'"(.-(>II(>II('(?
Proposed Redevelopment
September 12, 2006
YOUR PASSPOR110 lHE
;UI -IAIF'I'
ft."-:-}..
llARINA ~
----\
Ul TlMA lt60A liNG EXPERI~::!L~~\
I --._-;_,~
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. March 7, 2006 - Proposed Redevelopment Presentation Outline
2. March 2006 - A venti Shadow Study
3. September 12,2006 - Proposed Redevelopment Presentation Outline
4. September 12,2006 - Hi Lift Marina Shadow Study
S. Floor Plan Layout Comparisons
6. September 12,2006 - Aventi Exhibits
7. Aventi Settlement Documents
8. Aventura City Staff Recommendations
9. Comparison Chart of The Port Facility and Hi Lift
':.t
...
.....
....
.....
...
~
...
..Q
~
~
"
...~
\.J
"
"W
.
\,j
...
,
c.,
~
~
'"
'oW
.
~
,,;
~
~
'w
~
~
Q)
s
~
o
~
Q)
;>
Q)
~
Q)
~
~
Q)
00
o
~
o
~
~
\".
,:
1
.i I
~ttIfI~
~ ~ /Z
~iIl ~ .~
..~
-~
I-
.~
~
"'"
1:
I-
o
l-
I-
Q:
o
Q..
t/)
t/)
C
Q..
Q:
~
o
,..
, J.
") /.
.J !
"
z
-
~
c
o
CD
loIJ'
~
c
x:
-
~
~
::>>
~
...
-...
....
"
...
~
...
..Q
~
~
"
.'oW
"
~
.9 ~
~ C'd
C'd~
a~
c.S clj
~ ~ ~
~ ~ .~
~ ~ ~
~ S ~
1
~ 0 ~
~ ~ .~
..~~
U .~
~~
\,0'
.,
"'" r ~
~!-f~
~--~
I-.....~
~~.
~-~
~ 1 -
~.~
~ =,"-..
,:-:. .~~.~
\.J ~
\ . i \
!,).::'
i
),>1
, ,
~ I
. ~
IloIJ
!(,)
!Z
'loIJ
-
ClI:
loIJ
Q.
)(
loIJ
"
Z
-
~
c
o
CD
loIJ'
~
c
x:
-
~
~
::>>
w)
i .f
~
. lIIIIlIIIIII I
~..~~
..... ~..
o I'~ Ii
...... t
li......~
~-.,.!
~~~.!
~ =. ~
" ,j. ~
~ '\
~
<<
Q
o
~
<<
~
~
=
<<
~
~
:3
~
==
rfJ 0
~ bJ) Q):
>~~ro on.
~ 0 .~ ~ ~
~ .~ ~ ~ = ~ on
~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0
.~ ~;; C) d bJ) ~ ~
~C)~~~~rfJO
~ ~ ~ ~ rfJ .~ '"0 ~
~ ~ 00 >-.~ Q)..d
~rfJN~ ~U
~ ..0 I-< >-. Q) '0 ;::$ Q)
· ..-I Q),.....;:> bI) cr ~
~ ~ ~ ~ clj "'0 '..-1 ~
...-1 'S ~ Q) ~ ;::$ 'E ~
~..oO~O..o~~
~
<<
Q
o
~
<<
!
=
:3
~
==
-0
~ @
- (]) Ctl (])
rn Q) Q) :>
'C .r:. C E r.... :>
+oJ+oJ~:;:; Ctl~
en c 0 v
:::::l · - +oJ Ctl C> (]) :;:;
'0 "' C +oJ C .r:. (]) +oJ
C VI Ctl.- +oJ .r:. C
.- C ~ r.... '" +oJ '"
· - 0 +oJ +oJ :::::l V en \U
c1Jo .=Ctlt)(])(])t
Ctl = Ctl:::::l 0 CO Ctl 0
en:::::lIi-r.....o.oCtl Q.
.- .0 o.a en C '5 .~ C E
~ CO t C Ctl (]) C E (]) ._
:J +oJ Ctl (]) ~.r:. Ctl 0 ~ C
I~~~==~E'O :::::l
Q)
-
CO c
u ~
~o
::J I- ·
Q)
Q) Q) ()
.!:.!:c
+""+""Q)
'+-c-
o .- a;
C) +"" ()
c 0 ><
.- 0 W
E~1i-
o Q) 0
() .:::t. ~
Q)",+""
'" \U .-
~+""U
oen(])
crn.!:
.!:+""
C/)+"",+-
.- CO 0
CO.!:+""
C +"" L-
.C 1J CO
CO 0 Q)
~O.!:
+""fQ)
CO.!:
Q).c+-'
L- c
L- .!: ._
::J C) +""
() .- ()
Q) .-
Q)c;:;
.!:_CJ)
....., CO .-
.. .- 0
+""
.!: C L-
() Q) Q)
::J'"C+""
en .- c
en en Q)
<(~u
!' P. ~ ~
~::~~
~-.,.~
.. I .. i
;;=1
; ,
~
<<
Q
o
~
<<
~
~
=
<<
~
~
:3
~
==
co
-00
- +-'
o C
L. .-
co~
~E
L.
a 0
N'+-
en
co c
Q) ro
~l:;
ro-o
+-' c
o ro
+-'
c~cti
0= C
100 '0 Ii:
.- ro ro
> '+- E
ro-o
Q) Q) en
> +-' en
ro ro co
.c 5- C3
Q)~1ii
>CL.
> COt+:
-0 .
Q) OJ ~
en c c
::J .2> (J)
coen=
o Q) Q)
(J) -0 0
.c ~ x
-UJ
~o'+-
~oo
coa.~
.c +-'
=roO
.- '+-
.c0Q)
a.+-,.c
::J::J+-'
cOo
coO>~
O>.~ .c
.~ 10 t
+'" L. 0
.c Q) ~
.2> a. c
'+-0::J
Q) Q) '-
L. L. ~
roco~
Q) .-
>Q)o
>~~
-0
L.
roQ) :....,
c.c<<>coQ)-o
.- -0 (,) C e- Q)
ro c c .- ro -0
c co .- L. (,) Q)
._ en co Q)
(0-0 L. E-o c
E20::J Q)~.c
c 0:: 0
co Q) en .- en ::J -.
.- co .- ~ +-' E ID
(,)+-,~Q)c +-'
<<>o-cen~coCO
E oq- C = '00 -0 ~
Eo>co2Q)co
cen L.CO+-'
o .- co co ro en
(,)~::JCL.Q)en
+-' 0 "'" ._ ~ (,) Q)
en - v ..J .-
m a..- co +-' '> (,)
\U E > E c L (,)
.- Q) Q) <(
Q)Q)-g~>en
= co .- 0 <( L. I
Q) L. 0> +'" 0> Q)E ~
L.2cQ)c ~
co C :i L. .- 0 C
Q) ~ (5~ ~ ~ E
S<(~-oo(,)co
rJ'l
~
~ J
~o
< ~I
~(/)
~~
<u
~~
~~
u
o
~
~
~
~
~
~
rJ'l
\it
=
.-
.foI
~
:;
....
..
~
I:C
oS
..
.
.-
Q
*
0)
>
C '0 ~
o~encCL...
en t ro 0) ro.- 0
L...o ><O)-~c_
'.$LL 0)0.2uoro
C en 0. en 0:;::;'0
.2>.$ 0) ~ E 0 ~ '0 g.c
en o.s '00 0 - _ C L... 0
-L...CL...()~rorocnLL
00.00 O)C.oC_
en 0) .0 C._ ro 0 en
'0 C '0 Co.Q C E '0 U 0)
C 1: ~I C >-:> ::10 ro 3: ~ ,
ro en _..n ro :> .c en
en._ (j) en 0)> '0 0) U .~ _ L...
::S'O>L-. CC_L...::Iro
Oc O)c rorooO)
.c ro Co >-o~ co.c ECI) >-
I-L... ~O..::: _
=.ou
~
Q)
t::
bl)
t::
.....
1-1
.....
S
.....
-
rJl rJl
~ Q)
~ rJl
~ ~
t:: -a
.~ -..-I
Q) a 'S
a 9.g
rJl t::. ....
s 0 rJl
~ t:: ~
>. 'c ;.. 4-t
~. 0 0 0
..... ~ ~;..
~ ;.. rJl '"d 0;>
o Ot) Q)
S s~ ~~
o ] ~ '5 .S
() ~ ~ S bl)
Q) rJl "a Q.; t::
& t:: () bl)'S
.:= .9 0 t:: 0
~ 1-1 - ..... N
~ ()~Q) Q)
~ .c t:: .D ;..
ti ~ rJl Q)
rJl Q) 0 ..... ;..
..... ;.. ~ '"d ~
'"da - t:: t:: rJl
~..... ~ Q)
1-1 _.....
- t:: 6 1-1 .t::
~ 0)8..... = -a
O 1-1 0 ~
cl= t:: ~ cl= '0
;.. e t3 ~ .....
Q) ..... rJl 1-1 3
~j8~~
') ')
') ')
~
-$'
--.....,
t-,",. : j
4
='~'>7:
";~'...".'.'I;.'.'
:'\ "'. oj".'
.., L<'!',,;:,
~.M$
0:)'
I :
., ---,
~ /-:)
=1
-; 1
en 0)
Q) L...
'^ 0) ro 0)
5'0 'O~-.cen.c
:;::;c c>-o_(j)_
u::s <(CL...__c
0) 0 - . cO)o ro.- .
=L...ro'O::s.ocoen3;2
e >- 0 0):;::; Q) CI) E 0).0 0) m
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :E ~ '00 ro g> Q3
::I-o:2uo> ro:2ro:r:
o en - en ::I 0> en L... .c '_
E ::I >- 0) en o.!:.... 0 u E
'- L... ro - - LL 0
ro en '0 _ .c .0 '0. _ ,~
-.- ro en 0) en C en.c _ ~
0) 3: ~ 0) .c ro ';: ~ "S ~ ~
-g 0 ~ 3: u.c '0 ,- 0 ,_~ .
E C en 0) ro L... ro '(3 CI) '0 ~
enO)Co.O) ro roO)
0) O).!: _en <( ;: '0 - (j) 0 C
U C '0 ro t:> 0) > _ ._
C ~ 'S L... 0 0 0) 0) 0 0) ~
o - .0 .3 LL ~ Co ~ = ,~ .0
ro C \U <(_
roo>-O)a>E ~.8 .oro
.2 .0 a. > > L... ro en en E.!:
fa; ro (j) E <( ro.E'2 ro 0) ~ Co
,r: E 3: 0) .8 g 0) ro o.~ ~ E
'1=\ <(o-cO)f;~.o_
tGr = 0. 0 .-
en
203
'+-CO>
OEO
C:CD~en
CO men a.
CD co CD:::
Et:CDen
ouo
- .r::. .- 0
~en2:(O
~~co~o
w . - "C T"'"
.=- E ffi ~ a
~ en en~"C
= .9- a. Q) CD
~II\ en E u CD
· +'" CO CO c: ::
r It CD L... a. +-' en
~J 3: "C en CDE Co
a L... CD CO CD
CD "C c: c: ~
3: 3:'C:J CD
r#t CD 0 CO c: >
....J U. L... E CO ~
:: U
-
t..~
~~I
~ ~-....
~I :;;!
QMi!i
!~G
Q)
Q)~
~ .....
....."'C
--
00
c:r.........
.- 0 -
Q) ..... c:
.....uo
COQ)+:i
r....r....co
O):.c '(3
.~ Q) ~
E.~ (/')
r.........<(
co :::J
-Urn
coQ)Q)
c: X._
coQ)~
- rn
....."'C:::J
coco"'C
O)Q)C:
c:.....-
E(/)Q)
CJ)c:C:
.- Q)'i::
.~ ~ co
E_ ~
:.c - co- CO
rn"'C:2
'-'i:: r....
(/')00
(/')u.u.
Q) r....
U..........Q)
urnrno..
~~~~
Q)~~ rn
...............;:
co55Q)
~(/)(/)c:
w
~
c(
en
...w
c:(/)>
caenlll::
"'w..::;
:8z0
)-z
~~O
"'mO
tn w
jl-.J
'Czc(
.5 0 z
Q)~O
CLL_
Ii: ~ C)
caWw
E~~
-c(u.
~~O
o IlL..
-z..
0.0 ~
G)-c(
G)Za.
~c:
o
~
:)
o
(0
o
o
N
~
CO
N
~
'-
CO
::J
'-
.c
Q)
LL
I
-
CO
.-
'-
o
wI-I
.-
-C
W
-C
-
CO
'-
Q)
I
.-
E
co
1-
~
(]) .~
.c .c
+-'
:2 "0
::J ~ C
o > co
..c e 0.::.
CJ)C)><~
en "0 Q) E
(]) COo
~co+-'c
.- a> 0
() Q) W ()
COcca>
+-' a> a> L.
en CJ) en ::J
~ ~ ~ 0
() 0.~.8
L.(]) 0 co L.
+-'EO
.c ~ +-'
+-'en+-,u
oW-Q)
CJ) a> · en
'" - en
\U +-' a> m
= 0 .C ~
(]) C +-' .-
en >
~a):J"O
CJ)L."Cc
co 0 .~ co
...: E Q) CO
EC)cL.
co C .C ::J
~ '0 cuE 10
~ -c c:
co
'C
.-
~
.2 e
(0 LLO
8 .t: .~
C\J ....~
~ 0
ex:>" 0 .t:
C\J tJJQ)
~ en .t:
~1 ~....
co ).. 0 c
2 Q: ~ 0
.Q~.cE
~C/) ~o
..:::>~ 0
'0 a VI -
...... ~en
~~~(J)
~ LU .- ~
...... <: Q) Q)
E a:: .5 =
co ~ co
~~~~
co co
-q-a>'O
J: .-
'0""'0
e(/J-
co roLL
a>~.c
'0 a> "5
ro ...., 0
OcoC/)
I ~
.-
E .c Q)
.co ~ :5
-=::: 0 a>
~ ~ ~
e: 0) Q)
.- (/J ~
+""-
e '0 (/J
a> ~ a>
u co .-
~~c
a> 0 ::J
a.~o
(f)OJ u .
. . J: +""
!'-tue
a> 0 co Q)
(/Ja.a>~
o Q) ,..,... Q)
~~Wa.
~a>E-q-
mJ:_
~""'roC\l
Uoo..'"
~ ...., \J
2 0)'0 e:
co e e co
~~coc
- ~ Q) Q)
co 0 0 u
e u ~ ~
o u e a>
:;:;rooa.
~LO~o
~ 0 . 'V
uo(/J~
~ C\I ~ 0
~ 0 e (/J
Q) ...., ::J . ~
J:(f)oco
omuO)
,"mcoa>
\JT""'O>
c .-.-
coEat>
(/Jo-a>
+"" ~ LL a.
~ ; 0 (/J
.c~T""~
~ co a..c
o~o+""
o ...., .-
(/J ~ a> ~
e OJ J: ~
o e: ...., (/)
~ ._ '+- C
co....,oo
~ e: .-
...., ....,"'"
(/J a> (/J a.
.- u a> a>
O)~~u
2Q)ox
LL. a. _ a>
~ "C
eu e
~ co
~ 'C ~
c c .-
~ eu ~
cen.8
coco~
Oe-
.- Q)
....~~
'C co .-
~E-
co Q) Q)
~ ~ ;
o Q) en
Oi"iB
'C .-
c -g s-
eu co 1\
Q) .... en
"Cen....
eu ~ ~
Co.c
I ~ .
.- ... )( "C
E en it: .-
eu 0 eu
.- 'C 'C en
:Ecc~
e 0 eu Q)
.- u Q) .t:
~....
t:Q)0 1\
o en .... ~
I .- en c
C)'ioco
c.t:....E
.- C)
i .- en 'I-
>:I:Q)O
!...;~.t:
Q)~Q.~
.t:~~Q)
.... eu Q) ~
~E~i
+"" "' Q) .-
::J w 'I- U
.0.... C
._ co .t: '"
~ .... .... 'v
= en .- c
roQ)~it:
~ i · Q)
a>Q)Q)J:
'O~.c....
co-O'l-
Q) .~ .... 0
-....'C....
~cQ)~
~Q)enO
~:2~C)
'0 en U) c:
e Q) 'C .-
~~n;
Q)C)COo
e c ~.c
~Oco....
robo~
~en.cCo
Q)
> a>
eu e:
.t: 'C
Q) co
c E
.-
Ct
1\ a>
Q).c
en Q)
~I
.... co
'I- e
0:;:;
(/J
'C .-
C ~
<C~
'0
. .-
o co
o (/)
o ~
N....
e ~
._ 0
Q) E
't"'" Q)
E;
o ~
J: ~
c.c
~ 0
0....
'C~
1\ Q)
.5 Co
co 0
Ei
Q) >
~ Q)
en'C
"Ei
co .-
~....
.... c
co Q)
0:2
.c en
M e
't"'"E+oi
~oe:
.... ~ a>
C'l-'O
~ .-
O en (/J
~ a>
" Q) ~
\J 'I- a.
'Coe:
... 0
eu 'C .-
~Q)rn
o > .-
~ ._ U
Nt Q) 0
..... u (/J
e Q) (/J
~ co
.
.
1\
i(f)
.- T""
....
C (/J
Q) -
'C"E
.- co
m ~
~ ~
OOJ
....~
.5 0
~ a>
e:
c 0
~
~ ~
.... Q)
'C+""
C e
eu~
.~ Q)
.t: e
.... . c
Q) co
~~
.-
- Q)
C)-
c co
._ '0
.t: ~
.... a>
Q)'O
E ::J
oj
en a>
Co.c
. - +""
't:+""
o ro
.... Q)
en u
~ e
Q) Q)
Co~
o~
- e
Q) 0
> U
Q) (/J
'C (/J
~ Q)
o ~
'l-a.
.
C)ro(/)
c '0
._ 0') ~
i.~ ~
Q)~+""
Q,::Jco
Co '0 0
co~.c
~roC)
~. en e
Q) t 'c
> a> 'co
en .0 E
..Q)a>
:I~
bIJ Q)
~ ~
~ ~
.~
~ 0 "t) ~
0 ~ ~ ~
~ ~'S 00
Q) bIJ
~ Q) Q) ~
.s ~ ~ >
.~
~ 0 u~ ~
~ ~
~ .~ ~ ~
~ ~
rf'1 0 ~ ~ 0
.~ ~
~ ~
~ ~ ..cO ~
~ rf'1 ~
Q) o · ~ 'S~ oo~
~ ~~ Q) ~ <u
~ 0
rf'1 Q) Q) rf'1 bIJrf'1
~ ~..c > ~ ~"t) =<
.~ ~ Q) .~ ~
~ ~
rf'1 0 r/J .b ~ ~~
= ~ ~ rf'1
0 .~ Q) Q)~
=~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . z~
\C .~ ~ o ~ Q)
rfJ ,.;~ .~ u e~~ <~
rfJ ~ .~
~ rf'1 ~
C) rf'1 ~ e rf'1 Q) ~
u ~.~ " ..c 0
Q)~ ~ ~~ Q) z<
u ~ rf'1 ~
~ "t)Q)rf'1
< ~~ .~ bIJ <~
u ~ o > ~
rf'1N ~ .~ ~O~ UO
rfJ Q) ~ O~~
"t)~ e ~ ~ 0
" Q) 0 "t) ~ e u ~~
~ Q) e
~ rf'1 ~ ~.~ ~
~ .~ <~
rf'1 0 0 . ~ Q) ~
~ 0 U ~O ~~~
~ Z~ > ~.~ =Z
~ ..c@ Q) ~ .~
C) ~ -. ~ . ~~~ ~6
~ Q)O z~ ~ e ~..c bIJ
>.~ ~~~
.~
< ~ @ o ~ ~ e ~Q)bIJ
~ ~ OO~
6 e Q) 0 ~ 8 ~ ~.~
..c~ ~rf'1~ ~~
.9 e ~rJ'J ~bIJ .~ ~ ~
~ 0 .~ ~ Z .S ~ Q).~ ~~
~ ~
~ u ~ Q) Ota S ;;:: 's
~ Q)
~..c ~.~ Q) 0 ~ ~ =Z
o~ 'g C ..c~ Q) rf'1 ~
~~ ~ rf'1 ~Q)~ ~~
~ 0 ~~ rf'1 " o "t) rf'1 ~~
o rf'1 .~ ~ ~o~
:E~ ~ ~ Q) u ~
"t)"t) > Q) Z~
Q) ~ .~ ~ Q) 0 "t)
~ rf'1 ~ ~
~ .~ <-<
~ e I C) I C) C) ~ rf1
.~ ~ .~ >
CO Q) ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ Q) . =
. "t) . r/J . rf'1 ~
, .
!' P. ~ .~
e '- ~ .~
li........~
~-.,.!
~~~.~
~ =.' ~
; ~ 3
, ,
9
o
Q
~
<<
~
.,
~~
~Q
~O
(tJ
tJ~
.,=z
=~
QdQ
::J~
=S
~QQ
o
~
~
~
~
t
<<
'I .
, ~ I
r" .::1
,..... ..z
~'-~~
......~
~_....~
:~~.i
~ =.. i
,. ,'~' i
~ t
-,,-
9
o
Q
Z
<<
<<
~
~
~~
~Q
~O
~tJ
tJ~
~~
Qd~
QdQ
::J~
~
=::J
~=
o
;=
~
~
~
t
<<
.
r' .. .-1..
~ .. ~ ,,~
~'-7~
.....~
~--!
:~~.i
g.. ~
)0.' ~
: ~.. 3
Q
~
<<
~
-
~~
~Q
~ O.
~C)
utD
-~
~~
~Q
~ ~I
=S
~QQ
09
; o~
~ ~
<
~
~
~
<<
,)
J:..::.;;'.
'r,'
,
i
~
CDe
~O
O\tJ
:~
~2
O~
~e
~=
;:~
WJQ
~~
r' 0
,
!P.~~
~,-~g
~......e
~-==!
: I lIIIIlIIIIII i
....."Q,j..
g =:.. ~
: \f'1E4 ;;:.
tJ;
N
...
.....
-....
,..
~
"-
..Q
~
--.,
~
1",
~
~
..
~
...
"-
~
........
~
~
It
~
~
~
.
~
'-
~
o
~
~
t)
:3
~
~
~
;;
~
~f)
~
~ ~ . ~
Q) Q) 0 '"0 fJ1~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ct a a ~ E ~ 1;]
~ t) ~ ~ () ~ ro ~ ~
'1 ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 u .~ ~ ~ ~ ~
jiiiiil - () ~ ~ 5 ~o ~~~z= "d
;j ~~c,.., 5 s o~ >oS""<t: a
~ ~c,..,0 St roo<E~~;' ~-;:
~ 0.$ o,;ro -5~ ~o~~~ ~5
t~ ~ Q) \0 ~ ~ ~ ~ I rl'l ~ .~ ~
~ u ~ > 0 fJ1 0 ~ "I.J ~ ~ 0
~ ~ 0,; ~t'~ S~ g=~~ ......-
~ ~ bfJ "d:9() ~:9~ ~"'"~ ~~
t,,1 ~ oS ~ ~.~ ~ '"0 0 .~ ~ ~ z = z oS >
~ 0 .~ ~ ~ ~ '"0 ~ Q) 0 Q)
~ ~ ~ t,;j J:; fJ1 ~ U J:; fJ1 ~ ~ ~'"O
~ ~ ~.~ ~ a~ a ~ as ~~z~9 ~~
r: U ~ ~ t~ U ~ U ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~
AA ro ~ ~ rJ] ro ~ ro rJ] ro "d ~ ::::r~ ~ O'+:j
~ ['--~ Q) ~~~~~z~~~~~
~ "t ~ 1;] I-<.S 0 ......c ..... ro ;, < ~ = - ~
~ 0-5.$ : a~ 1a~ a~~~~~~:'9
~. M 0 ~ ro~~~B~gO~~z e~
~ ~.~ ~ Q) ~.~ ~ .~ J:; ~ 0 ~ ~ ~
~ O"d~ -q::~~"d~t~= ~ o,;ro
~ ~ E 0 .gJa~o~rJ]=~~~ rorJ]
~ J.\ fJ1 ~ "' · ~ ~ t~ 0 t~ ~ ~ r.....1 t..... ~.~
= '(j) () ~ ~ '(j) ..... 0' ~ 0\ ~ 0 "'0 ~ ~ ro >--
~ g.9 oB~~~ I.Q loS~~~< ~~
~ ().~.~ 5 >-- ~ 0 ~ a ~.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0,;
~ ~ ~ ~>:3=o,,=~=~~~~<~e
~ .~t~'~< onr~Or~ r~~~~ ~<~
rl ~ ~ ~ t~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.~ ~ 0 ~ fJ1
o ro ro ro o.t:: "'" 0 "'" ~ "'"~ z~ ~ I"
~ ~ ~ ~.~.~ ~ ro ~ -5 ~ >-- ~ ~ z = :'9 ~
G:: G:: G:: t G:: ~oS ~ g ~ t ~~~~ rJj~
JJ~&Jo~O~O&~~>o~i
· .... · .... · .... e..... rJ'J. 0 rJ'J. 0 rJ'J. 2 0 0 < Z .t:: c,..,
~ ~~~o,;~<E<ro<~~U=<~o
~ I I I I I I I I I
~
~
~
=
~~
~~
~8
o~
Q~
~~
=~
~cn
o~
cn=
iI iI ~
Zw
8=
~o
~~
::J~
rJ ~I
~<<
-=
QQcc
~~
~Q
~....:
-
::J
QQ
~
+-'
.-
-
'o~
$Q)
-0
Q) ~.-
u - ~
.- -0
~ c '"
L Q) L.
Q) .- Q)
L. .-
en '+- >
L. ~ ro
Q) - Q)
Ero.c
o+-' ",en
+-' c L. Q)
.. en Q) Q) c
G>::JErnro
i U c +-' .2
..,:: 0 ",L.
c+-' L. . L.
CI) ~'> ~ ::J
:L.cQ)I
ucoQ)~E
Cl)uQ)~o
--oL.COL.
caQ)oo'+-
u L. E 1"\ L.
U) = ~ 0
c.enL.Q).n
en Q) > L.
~ co C .- ro
~o co~.c
CI)~~Q)~
>~uQ.ro
._ '" x ,^
ca '+- \U Q) VI
oenenQ)ro
..,.~.~ en en
~"C-O L. C
WI C C co .-
C --0
Ii: ro ro en c
CI) E E c ro
.., Q) Q) .~ E
~-o-o:JQ)
Q)Q).n-o
U) L. L.
1- co co Q) Q)
L. L.
a; en en ro ro
JI::+-'+-' en en
~ c c L. L.
ca Q) Q) Q) Q)
e-o-o+-'+-'
.- .- co co
en en
cuQ)Q)oo
..L.L.!)!)
~ en en en en
.., ~ ~ ~ ~
t: co co co co
"' L. L. L. L.
'II> ::J ::J ::J ::J
+-' +-' +-' +-'
<(cccc
Q) Q) Q) Q)
CI) > > > >
.c<(<(<(<(
... . . . .
o
Q) +"
en 'C ~
:::JC "C~
m m c: .-
u .c
Q)O>enmm
en .c .~ 16 en L.
+" ~ 0 a. ::J
menu =0
Om m.c en
.c 0 U C:\to- g>
s... .0 0 0 ._
Q) en+"L.+"
._ s... .- Q) U
~ ~2;:.c~
Q)(ij~o>EQ)
.c-uc::J~
~ Q) c: .~ c: -
s...:50t:Q)~
Q) Om.c~
0>2 Q) u+" m
Co m.c2 g>~
- 'C L ~ ._
s...OI=UC
o E .~::JAX
\to- en s... "C "'V
'C E 0> ~ Q) s...Q)
c: 0 .~ c: L. +"
mU=o-sm
E~a.+"o~
Q) c: L{) .c 0
'C.sON~+"
Q) en ~ \to-o ~ en
.c +'" .- en en
+,,~::J+"~Q)
2t~-a,~8
mOl .- \U 1ft
\to- 0 Q) s... \U
-gs...z~Q)'C
:::J .c Q)
I Eo en Q)+"C: .
CI) E \to- m :5 15 'm ~
....00~s...Q).=Q)
Cl)uQ)mQ)Nena.
-0 U .~ Q) 'C .- ~ 0
U)menL.c:en'Cs...
.cO m::JQ)ma.
o+" Q) o>~.c Q) Q)
=:5c:c:+"~.c
U) m Q) .- 'w Q) m +"
1- E .c en
ca en U 0 m en c:
t: en m c: +" Q) "~ 0
.- 0 Q) ::J Q) s... ~ +"
... 0 0 menU ,\ .0
ca+" -mC:VQ)
::t Q) .~ Q) Q) .- s... 'C
s...+"+"u~:::JQ)
~ m "r: ~ L. c: 0 .c
.J en m U Q) CO C)+"
~uc:>uC:Q)
.- U 0 Q) Q) .- U
:I m Q) U c: > g .-
....C!:$Q)=>'C2
t: .c .- Q) Q)
CI) . . +" ~ . s... en
...
...
:J
o
~
o
~
~
~
~
~
o
t:
~
;s
~
o
~
~
t:
:3
~
==
{' ~"L
1.. IU
W;' ~ 'ffi
2: .. ~ it
g r. ~ $
I-......~
ct ~ z
O~~;::
a.........C
II) I .-.. i
: -~ ~.
ct ,....'..... !:
;:) -~ l-
~ ~~~ 3
\ .,
i
~ "
~
ct
......
Q.
......,
"'
t:::
CI)
(],)
~
......,
......
'+-..
......
o
~
......
~
t:::
o
t5
......
......
('J
~
QQ
o
~
~~
>~
<~
=~
~~
~=
~
9~
s<
QQ~
~~
=VJ
~VJ
~;
o~
Q
~
~
(1)
........ ~
(1) ca
> In
~ E
- (1)
en""
co~
"-"t/)
-0=
(1) ._
-0-
~-o
- c:
(.) co
c:
O~
(.) (.)
(1) l!
>-c
co (1)
~...,
en co
(1) ~
~ c-
O);
co c: -.
(1)CO-C
- (1)
-~...,
0...,(.)
(.) .- ~
~~b
E ~ en
CO c:
....-co
00(.)
~: (1)
c _ ~
CO .~ CO
E.c ~
..0)C1)
J:c:J:
(.) . - ...,
~ (1) en
CO .c CO
(1)
en en c:
(1) CO 0
~ c 0
.... .- en
o ; t/)
~ E cu
CO ~ (1)
CD(1)G)
~c:-
~ 0
(1) ..., en
=CO.c
<cSO
(1)
C
.-
~
CO
:2
en
en
CO
-
(.)
...,
en
~
.-
....
CO
(1)
~-o
(1) c:
en CO
(1) E
-0 (1)
en-o
...,...,
c: CO
(1)~
-0...,
.-
en...,
(1) (1)
~ (1)
In E
..
~o
-0""
C:C
CO CO
(1) ~
(.) (1)
i ~
-
--0
(1) c:
~ CO
w...,
.... c:
o CI)
~E
..., c
.- 0
o ~
.-
(1) >
~ c:
I- (1)
Q)
.!:
+-'
o ~
+"" Q)
C)c
.~ CO
L- L-
Q) 0
+"",+-
CO
u.:::t.
~o
+"" 0
.- -
-
.- 0
u+""
CO
'+-1J
en CO
en.c
J2 Q)
C( ~
+""
en ..
L- en
. - +""
'+- C
CO Q)
L-1J
o .-
'+- en
'"C ~
c CO
CO L-
E2
Q) C
1J Q)
Q) >
.c<(
+"" Q)
en.c
en+""
Q) '+- .
L. 0 C
1J 0
1J C/) .-
co'"CS
Q)-
o Q) 0
I-cen
~
.0
1J
Q)
Q.
o
-
Q)
>
Q)
1J
E
Q)
+""
en
~
en .
t tJ)
CO E
I Q)
Q)...
.c tJ)
~~
o(/)
I Q)
20)
CO ca
+"" ....
en 0
co'"
.!:(/)
+"" ...
.- .t:
~ U
~ ca
1J>-
c-
::J ca
~ .~
Q)~
S~
~
o
~
~
~
~ rn
t) ~
< ~T~ ~
~ ~ ~ .
~Ti ::J Q
tS~~
~~~
o~~
~ ~<<
~~~
~ V1
~ rn
Q
~
;
~
~
;
~
+-,"0
c: ::J
Q) 0
--
en Q)
~:5
= oo
CO Q)
:J+-'
tC04:
.- c: .-
>.- ~
E ~
06 .- 0
- 'I-
e Q) 0
roQ)~
Q) c: :J
"roro
v~~
~()"O
- ~
roQ)~
+-' 0> "'"
c: "0 \J
Q) .- Q)
~ ~
E en Q)
c: 0 ~
o .- 0
~ ~
.- U a.
~ Q) oo
W-ro
Wo>
"O+-'
Q) ro
"0 0
._ .c
::J~
(9~
~ ~
Q)
oo e
ro 0 ::
...J ~ 'It
co~
Q) ~ 0
Co ~ +-'
oo 0 c:
_ 0
o ~ .-
~ Q) en
+-' ~ .-
e ro 0
o oo ~
()Q)a.
~"O+-'
Q) .- e
+-,>Q)
:J 0 E
a.~
E a. Q)
o "0 0
()ero
ro a.
.
c-
._ CO
+-' C
== ro
.EO+-,
~ e
~Q)Q)
~ e E
~ m c
E - 0
o ~
Q) .-
+-,ro>
en ~ e
~0Q)
(/)'l-Q)
0> O>..c
e .~ +-'
.- "0 e
oo .- 0
c: >
.- 0 +-'
~~o
~ a. ro
Q)C:a.
+-'oE
ro .- .-
>+-'oo
>roen
~ E Q)
ooro-
Q)-"O
~ 0 e
LL~ro
.
ro
+-'
~ Q)
.- ..c
Q)CO+-'
O>e
e ro .-
ro +-' Q)
.~ 0 .c
t:2 a.ro
::Joo~
I ~ ~ e
a. +-' Q)
+-' en
eOro"O
Q) +-' +-' .-
o>ooro~
c:"OO~
._ ~ ro
l:iroe"O
en "0 .- e
oo e Co Q)
~~ ~ ~ -a, "0
ro C/) en .- 0
"OeQ)..co
.9o-ro~
.- oo ~
0+-,-'1-0
+-,~~o.c
~+-,et~
.- 0 e 0>
::J ~ ::Jro Q) .-
eno..(/)..c~
.
I
~
Q)
~..ce
+-' +-' .-
.- 0
~ e ~
E ro'~
Q) +-' CO
+-,OOE
en .~
~roQ)
C/) o>..c
ero+-'
.Q ~ ~
t):J+-'
Q)oojg
+-,eOO
o Q) ro
Q:o>
+-' Q)
Q) "0
.: E +-'
LL ro ro
Eo~
LL+-'
o Q)
+-,LL~ .
OOLL~(O
8<(LL~~
...JT""
.
Ii
o
~
......
~
t::
o
~
.t>
..::::::
(j
.r::. CJ)
'+- .....,
0 0) m
~. C ~
0) o 0) C
N .....,
.- ~ 00 0)- CO
0 00 - 0 +- E
-
N 0) m u m ::J 0
U +-
~ "'"" .r::. - U E
.- m '0
0 ...., ....,
0) m +- 0) .- 0)
tn E c '-' x t::
= N o m
tn .- CO CO c.E 0)
0) E +- >
I... 00
0 (.) .- '0 .0 0) m C
>< x 0
0) m 0) ::J .r::..r::. u
~ E > 00 +-+-
t: m '+- .- 0)
.- ~ .r::. m o ~ C ~
'+- - +- -000
~ - ~ m m ~
~ 0 ::J '+-
'+- CO > +- () ('.
~ ~ +- +- 00 o m ::J I...
C 0) en +- I... 0 I... 0) Z
0) ~ m 0..0 Ui .r::.
= E ~ 0 a. L() C 0) 0
+- +- .0 .- -
+- co () co co 0 ..c t-
CD 00 -
= 0) .r::. m 'O~u ~ -(
+- 0) E
> C'+-'+- - 0
00 -
~ C 0) .r::. .- 0) 0 0 m -
~ +- +- .- .J
CD I... a. EE2 +-
m .r::. 0 C a.
::J . +- E ::J 00 m
= c-~ .- a.
~ +- ~ C o E 8 +-
C 0) U m 00 -(
m I... m U .- .0
~ +- I... 0 ..c 0) X 0) ::J a::
9 Q 00 ~~ +- +- I...m.r::.
.0 '0 . I... oE+- 00 :)
.... I... 0)
~ ::J .- 0) 0) 00 +- t:: 0) 0
== > 0) .9- -
00 - 0) co 0 .0
-( (.) 0) I... _ co C)
~ m ! C 0)00 E cO)o. '0
::J co,..... :.:"-0. - Z
00 .- 00 := co ::J ::J
0) t 00 ~M 0 -
I... ~ '0 00 >
= ~ I... cu+- 'O~ ~ 0 ~
::J I m moO 00 Eo 0
c- O) 0 +- a::
N ~ 00 0) m E C C
~ 0) .coO C ~0'O 0) a.
I... ....+- - +-
m m .-
~ ~ ~ 00 '0 ~U- E a.
; rn ~ 0) 0 - m u ::J
o 0) .- +- -(
+- >.0 ::J +- m 0 00
.- 10)
- .0 0)
~ .- 0) I... ~O) +- en ~ . LL
rn u .... m ~ ~ 0) ~~O) > 0) 0
~ cu- C C
.... 0) 00 0) .r::. ~ C ::J .- .-
~ ~ t:: tn.r::. +- () 0 C c32 en
; 0) I... t-
co C1J+- C1J~ C 0) '0 0) o .-
0) ::J -
0) .- 0) 'EO) .r::.'S> CoO LL
~ .r::.+- .-
+- m 00 +- 0 ~ I... Z
0 .r::. 0:5 0) ::J+-
+- '+-'0 16 U 0) +- C W
'+- o 0 I... I... '0 0) 0)
Q 0 ~~ .r::.0).r::. m
~ E 0 +-~+- I... E
0) +- O)t:: W
~ +- ~ E o ~ 0) O)~ :!:
m ()~ +-O::J ..c co J:
+- () 0 0) ~ > o (j) 00 +-~ a. t-
oo 0) U m C 0) ~rn
.c (,) .c ....., W
CJ) . .co. o m I... +- +-
.- tn +- m +- m - +- ~m C .- a::
~ -
..c L. 0) 0 ~() .~ C~CIJ m C <C
+- cu +-+- - I... t:: ::J
+-- 'i: 0) 0) ::J m 0) m
u- 0) t16"O oeo t-
::J 0 ~ .~ 16 0 ~ a.""" -(
-="C o C C
0)'0 C'O E:.-, J:
00 t: - ::J 0) ~ Q.::JCO
"0 .- N E t ~ . - .r::. ~
5 0 C ::J t U N .- 00 0) 0)
u:: ::J.o ~ ::J C1J'+-V I... .-
~ o I... 0
- o 0) c'O .- C '+-
o .- +- ~o
I- E 1-:5 :> ~ <( ~:>o en
" lIIIIlIIIIII '...
~ ... ~ i~
g,--~~
:r....==i
o L~ _
A. ~ C
~~;;
. ~
:> =.' ;:
~ .~. 3
" ,
0) 0)
c,... Sn .s.s
o , rii .....!:
~ 0) rJ;,.~
II) ~ r-. ro ro
~ ;> ~~ 0 ~
rr'if~ 0 .-< I-< ~ .....
~I II) rJJ II) ~ bO II) :::: a
= ~ ~ a bO ~ ~ .~ S
~ ~ ~ ~ 6- u.S u U "d
~::J rl ~~ ~. ~ rJJ ~ "d ro ro 1I).r:
~) ~I 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~
~ ..... II) ro ro 1-'-1 ;> ..... ~ bO
~ ~ t) ]~g tl 0; ~O ~ro!:
t) 0 ~ ~ ~ 0" ~o ~ ::::~ ~.6~
'Ii;;;;;;I ., '" .... , ....,... ~ ro. 8
h. "- 11),........ ~:> _ "'" ~
"Iii(iiill I-< ~ "d -. rJJ .-< ;> .-;:: I ~~
~ ~ II) :::: C"l
..... :> ro ~ 0; ,~ ~ "d ~ l/)
t) Q F1 ..Q < sac,... ~ :9 ro 'C'SnE
'Ii;;;;;;I ~ t 'if ~I ca I-< ~ ~ 0 ~ · s ;.:: p.. 0 0;
~ ~ ~ u c.8 II) ~ 1-<..... ~ 0; U'-<;j
~~ ~ t) '.p ~ S ~ ] ~ ~ S '> g II)
~ ~. ~ .-;:: ~ 0 c.g ro 0 'u~ ~ N
~ :::; ~ 0; :::; rJJ II) U U .....
~ ~ ~ ~ s ~~ ~ ~ g bn ~; ~
~ tTi 0 ~g~go~ ;~ S"dO
~ ~I .-;::.... 0; ..... ~ II) ~ c II) rJJ
t., ~ . .-< I-< \0 rJJ r ~ 1 ~ ~ :::; ..... .....
~ '\;;;/ ~ '0 0 ['- ~ 00 ~ .-< 0 ro.r:
= ~ ~ g. c,...:a :1 < ~ ~ ~.g g
~ :::; 0..... '<I; ~ II) c .,.., rJJ ~
r'if~ ~ - ~'~ ~ ~ ~ fItJ ~:::;. O:E I-<
=Iii(iiil 0 t) a ro. 9 ca ~ U "3 ] ~ 8 g-c.8
· .... II) ~ ~ U ~ I-< I-< ~ rJJ "d
~,^ S :> ~ 0 Z Z ~ '.p tJ ~ ,.........-<
r' 't# 41 ~ '.-I'.p ~ ~..... ;j;j 0 rJJ S
<< + rJ;, S.~ 0 0 ~ ro "d g rIl 0 ~
o II) ..... "d II) II) ~ ..... < S ~
N ~ ~ '"0 Z Z u CQ.~ rJ;,
fAp..~ro I
I I I I I I
, p.~
::~
...=
;;~
, .~ t_
...
:c
...
o
...
:r
o
..
>II
>II
C
II.
...
~
o
)>
Q
~
>
o
=
~
!
~
. rJ1 ~
~ rJ'l r- \;J
~ 0 ~ ~
i ~~ r/J
a mo oS
i OJ)~~~
j ,5 ~ 0 ~
~ ,~
:: ~ ~ ~
w ~ ~ 0
~ ~ 0) U
M ,:g ,t:: ~
M~rJ'l~
rJ'l ~~ ~
~ 8 ~ ~
~ 0 ~ 0
~~~:s
:.=oU~o
,~ ~ 0) 0)
u .!::> OJ)
,~ rJ'l ~ .~ ~
"l"""I ,~ ~ ,~
~ ~-5b'b~
~S~~2
;j u rJ'l rJ'l rJ'l
u~~~~
0) ~ ;j u
~ ~ ...0
L... ~ rJ'l .~ 0
r~O)~~
0) "0 ~ 0)
~ 0 0 ;j
.~uu~
0)
"0..0 :=
1'1\ ~,~ .'"
~ := ;j :> II~
O'~ "0 0 ;> ~ ~
u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'e ~
~ tl ,'S:52 0 .~ E ,; ~
o Q) ~ u ..0 a Q) ,~ u
00 ~~ on ro ~ e ro ro
N rJ'l o~..o ::: e t"O ~
0) ~ u 0 u ~ ~ ~ 0) 8
:> l/) ~ 0) ~ 0) 0) ~ ~ ,~
ro ~ .~ "0 ~ ~ ~ ro ~ 0)
~ 0 :>'~ ~ ~ 11\ ~ ~ ;>
;> ." ~ ~ \;J ,~l/)'~'
~O) o~ ~~ ~ ~~
:;::: u 0) ~ on rJ'l ~ , .-t ~ ~f\' ~
:>~u~~ ~ rJ'l,.J~~~
;> ~ ~ ~,~ ,~.i ~ \0 ~ 0) t}
~ ~ ~ := ~ ~ U 'e [' 0) ~ ,~
,~ f"'\ ~ ~ ~ ~;j ~ ro ~ ~ "0
~ ... 0 ,~ .... rJ'l - ~ "
,~ ,~,..; ~ 0) ~ ~
u 0) U 0) e 0) rJ'l W 0 ~ ro 0)
, ~ ~ U ,t:: ,~ rJ'l ~ ~ ~ u ~
"l"""I ~ ro rJ'l - ro 0 0) O).~ ....
"0 0) ~ 0) . 'P rJ'l ~ ~ 0)
"0 ~ ,~ "0 rJ'l 0) ~ u,~ ;j U 8 u
0) .... ~ 0) rJ'l 0) U ,~ "0 ~
rJ'l ro 0) rJ'l 0) ~ ~ ~ "0 0)] ro :>
& rJ'l "0 & ~ ~ ,~ ~ ~ :> ;j ~ ;>
o "0 '(j) 0 ~ r/J 0 ~ ~'~ 0 "0 B
~ ~ ~ ~ ^~.s ~ - ~ ~ ~ ~ "0
~rJ'l 0 ~~['.!: ro ro ~ 0) 0)
0) on "0 0) rJ'l 00 .t:: a "0 ~ ~ :> t}
~ .5 0) .!: rJ'l ~ ~ .~ "0 ~ ,~ ~ 0)
r~~~ ~ o~.t:: ~~]~ on
~ ~ on ~ "0 ~ ,~"O ~
roro ~~ "'00 ;:j~o
. ~ ~ . ,~ 0 . ~ ~ . ..0 ~ U
"
----------
'11II
;.c
...
...
....
"
~
,
...
..Q
~
......
"
,.\i,j
~
~
on
.~
00
Q)
Q
"
..
.
\,j
...
...
c.,
---
~
"
~
~
,,;
~
,
~
'w
~
C'd
~
B
u
Q)
~
.~
..0
u
<
~
C'd
Q)
~
C'd
b
Q)
~
.~
~
Q)
~
~
~
C'd
8
~
~
Q)
~
.~
rJJ
...;'
/1
//' 'J}'
{. i
\ ~..~ i
" \, >( i
~ ~ ~ ~\/~
,. ~ '~
. -. ffi
..~
.~ ~ ~
..~ ;
~~
\~ '1.\ ;:)
o
l-
I-
Q:
o
Q..
t/)
t/)
C
Q..
Q::
~
o
,..
, ~
r.
~' p. ~~
~'-a'.5
li.....i
~-==~
~ I = tl
....... ~
... ~
s =..: ~
)0. 3
; \
~
<<
~
~
~
~
=
o
~
~~
V1~
~~
~~
~:S
tlJJQQ
~:J
Q~
~
~
~
~
~
=
t)
"0
cd
rJ1 0
rJ1 ~
Q) rJ1
U rJ1
U Q)
cd U
~ U U
~ ~ .~ cd
lr)~ ~Q)
~ ~~
o g p., '00
~N"O~~
~ ~ Q) 0 0
N~ 0 O"O~
Nlr) ~"O ~
~~S~cd"OO
o Q) cd Q)~
o 0 ~ ,~ Q) "0 cd
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ ;>
" '"d '"d l(") Cii 5 0
o Il) Il) 0 bL) I-< E
~~~N~p.,1l)
Q) ~\J S · ~ ~ ~
E 5 ~ 0 ~.;S ~
o ~ g ~ .~ ~ ,0
~ · .... · .... ~ Il) bL)
.~ ~ "0 "0 ~ ~
'"d ~ 0 Il) ~ 0.....
Il) Il) '"d Q Cii p., &
Q ~. ....;::l ~ '"
.g..... b] ~ 0 ~
Il) '" 0 I-< Il)' .... '"d
I-< E Q Q ~ ~
.... 0 ~ -B ~ Il) Cii
~ I-< Il) '"d t: ~
~ ~ .~ .~ U ~ ~
~~;>~~Q)cd
~ ~ a ~~ ~ a
~ ~ Q) .~ ~ :> '.0
~ ~ ~ "'0 ~ .~
bL) ~ 1::::- ~ ~ '"d
.~ ~ ~ Q) cd "0
Q)~ 0 ~ZM<
~O(/)~ ~
I I I I I I I
<tc
~ c.-
<to!
Q.
~ ~E
- 0
~u
~
~
~
VJ
Q
~
VJ
o
~
o
=
~
..
"O!
G) co fb
~>fJ)fb
.!: O..JI f
CO"~
-Q.~C)
Q.E:>w
E,.201:l
o C)LL. fb
UCCJfb
G)i:e f
"O"coC)
o CO .. C
UQ.~_
r-- m :-l
~ I
(,) I
\ 0 I
c
C) I
t: I
\ ,- I
....
cu
I 0 I
1 -
LL I
I Q) I
....
Q)
~ I
(,) I
\ t: -I
0
() I
t .1
I J
CU
I
Q) I
I J: J
.... 1
I
~
0
I I
I Q)
\ ....
cu
....
en
~ I
Q) 1
z
I
I
I
m
Q)
;;
.-
-
.-
(,)
cu
LL
~
Q)
~
(,)
o
.J
ol5
Q)
C)
t:
:J
o
.J
"C
Q)
....
t:
.-
o
0.
0.
<(
~
:5 ns
~ 'i c ~
.c ~ 0 ns
:s ns L. C)
[l. ~ 't:Q) .5
.. ~ ::.
O_~oI-I;>
'r" ns c: ~ ,~
<C~ns>>
~
;;
~
co
G)
m
-
-
'i
C)
C
'Q.
co
CJ
fb
"0
C
co ~
.Jt
G) G)
> Q.
.- 0
fb ..
CQ.
G)
~ G)
)(~
w~
-
-
:J
~
;;
:J
cu
Q)
m
~
....
.-
-
.-
(,)
cu
LL
Q)
(,)
.-
~
Q)
en
Q)
"C
.-
m
t:
ol5
E
o
o
~
~
o
J:
rJ)
tn
m
cu
-
()
..
III
'r'"
r .. ~ /~
e'--~;
li....iiiilB
2..___1
~ I .. !
~..~~
::l ~
C) ", ::
.. =~ ~
, ,
-
'{
!' P. ~ i
~::~~
~..==!
; ;,= i
.~ 1;'
, . .
p.~ ,
~~
.==
;i~
~ t,
~
..
~
...
II:
o
(%
>II
C
II.
II:
~
o
)0
I
g
~
I
a
..
"'
i
~
" ~ I
w. iW
! ~ !~
e'-~~
~~~.i
~ I i
~.... l!!
5 =' i
.. _.~' ;
~ t'
I
,
, ~ //1
-v'" // ,') ;'
/. I
:- \ i
i ,
1
"'" -- ~ '.i
':4 " ~
~ 1: IloIJ
~ I- 1(,)
... ... /Z
..... . 0 -- ~
'" t loIJ
.... -
... I- It
..... ... I- loIJ
~ !'\ . Q.
~ ~ Q: . )(
, 0 loIJ
... ~ Q.. -- ~ "
..c c., t/) Z
" . t/) -
'" ~ 1 ~
~ ,,; C C
1\ ~ ~ Q.. ..~ 0
...'" Q: CD
\J loIJ'
, ~ ~
~ 0 \Q c
"" ,.. x:
-
~
~
\ . '1. \ ::>>
~)
~, { i,
~
tJ
~
~
~~
~VJ
~o
~~
VJQ
~- ~
~t)
tJ~
~Q
==~
u~
~
l:
~
~
~ Q) '"0
rI'1 Q) ~ Q)
~ bl)~~;>
o ~ 0 f\ 0
.~ 0 ~ rJ'J. S
~~~Q)
~oQ)S~Q)
g, ~ [/1 0,.0
~ ~~
0;;::: Q) 0., Cil
8 ~..c: S::::
.~ ~ Q).~
~~ .~ ~
Q) ~ [/1 0 [/1 .
[/1~~~o~
~~ro2o;!;
o ~ ~ ~ ~ .~
'" Q) Q) ~ ~ u
..... 0., 'tl ~ · ,.., ro
on .~ \J Q) ~
~8~Q)-BQ)
'.;3 · ,.., ;:l..g ~ ..c
rJ'J.;> 0""" ~
.,.., ~ " 0 Q)
~ Q) Q) ~ Q)'tl
Q) rJ'J. N S rI'1 .~
Q) ~;.:= · ~ rJ'J.
v .~ .:j 0 ~
..c: ~ ~ C-H ~ . '"'
~ ~ ~
~~" ~
~ .. ~ ,~
e'--~~
......1:\
~-=cl
~ I = i
~.... \!!
s;ll' i
)0: j
~ \:
~
en
~
o
~
t:
:J
~
~
o
~
il il
~
~
~
~
Q) rJ'j Q) ~=
~ ~
~ ~ I -~
Q) 0 Q) Q)~~
~~ ~ S ~ 0
Q) ~8~
rJ1 ~ 01) 0 ~ ~
~Q)~
~~~ o Q) Q)
01)'~ '~ "E.s~ I 1n e
0) ~ rJ'j
:E "0 ~_~ ~ O)'~ ~ rfJ
:g ~ 0) t:: t~:g ~~"O
~ 0 ~ ,~ o ~ ~ rfJ ~
~~ c.S ,~ ~
~~ ~~
c.S rfJ Q) Q) ,5 ~ 0) 0) "0 0)
0) 01) a N E'~ rn
O1)NO ~rJ'j~
~:.=~~ $J rfJ ~ ~ :.=~o~
'~ '~~ rfJ ~ oo~ '~ ~ ~.~
rfJ'S u ~O) 8 ~ 0 ~O)O)~
,~ ,~O) "0 ~ ~
~ ~~ O),~ 0) 01) ~ ~ o~ ~
~ ~o
0) 01) ~ ~ rfJ ~.~ 0 ,~ ~
rfJ 0 0) O).~ ~ ~ 0)
" rfJ 0) ~ ~ ~. 0) ~ 01)
~o 0) ~.~ ~ ~ ~ .0 ~'S~~
,~ ~ ~ 0) ~ o ~ ~,~ ,~ ~,S'~
~ ~'~ :> 0) 0) ~ 's ~ ~ 8 8,~
,~ u ~ 0) :> o u
~ '~~ ,~ 0:'= ~
~EQ)t< o.sO)~ ~ U 0) Q)
'~l~,',' I ,.
, " ", 'h
" l' Ii, '
., <\....',/\
,\ .
t
,I
w' .. ~ ,.~
~~~~
.....==1
o ~~ _
~7~i
c "'
~.... i
;;) =" ~
e ,,'~ ~
~ '{
u
~
~
fT~
=~
~~
~::J
<
~~
>~
O~
~O
~~
~~
ili1~
E<
~
~
ro~ ~
Q) en Q) 0
o '-.- ro
coOen>=>
'+- c :c ~.- 'C
~.c+-'co~a.
c~~Ec-o
Q) ~ .- .- C) C
> .c L.. .-
L..-S a. en CO
L.. - Q)
::J~ ro-oen
o > 0
enQ)~o~~
+-'+-,Q)cQ)Q)
c Q)~ c.c
Q)L..::J-o +-'
-0 0 .!:) C Q) enQ)
.- C CO .c
en 0 Q) +-' CO
Q) 0 a.~ "Q)
~~roroo>
.- - 0 ~ -0 0
C C) en Q) ._ L..
Q)::J-o>t:a.
> C C 'i: 0 E
<( CO ~ -0 0 .-
+'"
o
c
Q)
L-
ro
r/)
C>
C
.-
'0
.-
:::l
OJ
I
+'"
t)
Q)
cQ)en t:
O c ~ 0
= 0 t)
C) ~ ro c
Q)c+-,.!:)
> .- L.. +-' t::
.- C. Q) Q) 0
~o ro a. en a.
Q)COOo.. Q)
(J) l:; (J) L.. 0 ~
L.. -= "C a..c t:
CO \U C Q) +-'
a. c ro .- ro
(J):J...J~~U)
-.
.-
+'"
C
Q)
>
<{
r/)
t:
ro
~
'0
~
.-
....I
I
m
N
.-
r/)
Q)
E
ro
r/)
Q)
..c
+'"
~
-
Q)
+'"
ro
E
'x
o
L-
a.
a.
ro
I
co
+-'
o~ ~
Z Q)
:>.'E>...
co Q) >'0
>EL.-o
~ Q) coE 'i:
> en L.
,- CO 'i: 0
owo..O
en
~
o
-0
CO
.c
en'
E~
o
L.
'+- '
+-'
U
CO
Q.
E
.. ~ .~
~7~
.....:s
..---~
~~;
=~I !
~ t'
. .
co
o
0')
~
I"--E
0-
0') ro .- ~
~ ~ ~ 0
<DQ)O) Z
o'Q)c
0') .... ._ Q) Q)
~o a. .c'O
L() c ro .... .-
000 Q)~
0') 0 ItJ .... ._
ItJ >- '0 ~ Q)
...._c >
a. 0) CO ,-
...J EO
<(:J =E
cQ)Q) Q)_
o 0)'0
.... ro ~ = .~
0-0) ~.c
roroa. >-0
a. Q):J .... ._
E 0 0 :: .c
-ro.... ~~
Q)'I-'O 'l-c
~ >- cQ) ~ .Q
CO 'E .... Q)c ro
O)Q)C ....
Q) .... .- - Q)
Z~~co~Oa.
O()>~f-
Z .. .
>-. +-'
.. 0)-0
~
OJJ.o 0 aJ !Q)
. =
~.~ .:
~~ ..... = en
~ t' .. CJ Q)O
... ~ ~ .. '-0.
.: = ;..
Q) 0 CJ ~ aJ ;.. = roo
~8: ~ = ~ = .. ::J,-
~ 0 == ;.. era..
= aJ
10 ..... ..... en
.. ~
Q) rn aJ = .. OQ)
aJ ~ ;..
U ~ ~
aJ 0 ~ aJ ;.. U
~ 0 ..... = 0 O~
Q)"O == ~ ;.. ~
CJ ~ .. e O'+-
=~ aJ ;.. ~ .: ~
Q) Q) .. ~ CJ "0
~ ~ ~ ..
U e u = .. ~ = ~u
>< Q) ;.. .. 0 aJ aJ ..
~~ aJ aJ 0 ~ z ~ ~ .-
~ ~ -o~
~~ = = ~ ;.. ;.. ..
o ~ = .. = cCO
CJ aJ ~ = aJ
.o~ ~ 0 .. ..... .Q CO;:;
~ ;.. ~ 0 e
= ~ ..
.~ ~ ~ 0 CJ ;. aJ C/)Q)
UQ) ~ aJ =
= == CJ = cS U
rn ~ ~ .. +"".!:
Q) Q) ~ ~ = == ~ C+""
~~ = ~ ~ ~ =
~~ .. CJ ~ aJ ~ Q)><
~ ~ ~ ~ aJ ~ =
~Q) .. S
o ~ aJ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0 EL!)
~ ~ ~ = = ~ ;.. Q)
rn.o ~ ;.. ;.. ~ I aJ ~ ;.. en t~
~ ..
E~ = ~ ~ .. ~ = CO.~
U ~ ;.. ..... .. '-
Q)'~ ..... aJ ~ ~ aJ ~ U 0 o.~
"CjU ~ = aJ ~ aJ .:
.~~ ~ I .. ;.. 0 aJ a ~ COCO
..... aJ
rn ~ ~ aJ ~ U ~ ~ .. .: '-
Q)..o ~ ~ .. ~ '- (O+""
~ ~ aJ aJ ~ = ~ 0 == ..... 0
~ :> aJ = ..... z 0 1'--0
o~ 0 ..... =
oU ~ ;.. .. .....
~ ~ aJ ~ '- IQ)
aJ ;.. CJ ~ ..
o~ ... a ~ a ~ Q)
"~ ;.. = = = aJ ~ ~ > -en
l.()u CJ a ~ aJ rJ1 = CJ ;.. ..... .- CO
N~ = a ........ = cS = Q) ~Q)
~ ~ 0 ~ 0 = aJ
OJJ~ Z ;.. ~ = '-
aJ ..... = a ~ Q)'-
II ;.. .. .. aJ aJ
~ .Q ~ :> ~ 0 '-u
.~~ ~ II ~ == ..
== CJ ;.. :::::::c
~.~ = ~ .: ~ ..... 0
.~ ~ .. ~ ~ ~ ~ CO.-
~ .. ~ ;.. = aJ
~ ~ ~ .....
e'~ ~ u .. ;.. .. ~ ::J :+:ill
.. '= ~
Q)~.s ~ ;.. aJ = tT c_~
..... ~ ~ t' aJ CJ ..... aJ
.: = .. ;.. Q).- CO
~ ~ ~ == ~ ~ ..... ~ ~ en
CJ ;.. CJ aJ .. = -o~c
Q)Q)Q) .. 0 :> aJ ~
~ aJ . = .. aJ ::J
~~> = .. ~
~ ... ~ == ~ :- ~ ~ aJ +"" .- Q).-
~Q)< ... ~ en,-ro
~ 0.. .. ~ :> CO
~ ~
~~~ + ~ ~ .. rIJ. ~ ~ .. ....., Q)1i-~
~~o ~ ;.. ...== ;.. ~ ~ rIJ. ... C/) ~o
=aJ a :> ~ =
~ ~.o CJ CJ =..... aJ 0 .. =
~ ~ = 0 == ...
~~.~ ~ .. == ;.. = I :- A A
~ a~ u = ~ aJ
r.n~u = = aJ = .....
Q) Q) Q) :- 0 .. a aJ ..
N ~ = ~ ~ ~
~~~ ~ z ~ u = <
fA ~ ~
~.~ ~
.~~ ~
~]~ A A A A A A A A A A
~
...
-...
....
.....
...
~
-...
~
~
~
~
...
"
"
'-
.
~
...
-...
~
.......
~
.
~
,,;
",.~
~
,
~
'-
~
o
.~
~
~
u
.~
~
~
~
<
Q)
00
~
~
C'd
~
o
.~
~
.~
~
~
o
U
/!
/,/
//_) /
/~I
";;
\. i
~\.
. ~ \!~
... IloIJ
--~~
..... -.. )(
~.loIJ
....J~~
I-~
'-"co
.,~ ~'
~-..!
\ ~ ~~ ;::
l
\,.
"y'
4,
..
.,.'
.
'I
"'"
1:
I-
o
l-
I-
Q:
o
Q..
lJ)
t/)
C
Q..
Q:
;::)
o
,..
~}
\, .'
, ~
!,-'.
Q) +-'
Q) '0 co
.c -C '00 .c '0
+-'r-I:+-'Q) +-'
C ea:J t/) U) c
~ c.) ~ 0 .- +-' CO
C .......
L.:....Q)O Q) I:
B.c!ul: E 0
o a.ea~ Q) Q) .-
....
- t/)
+-' t/) Q..c Q)
+-' " Q)
Q. i .c Q) ,...., "
Q) .
-0 C)
:J.......~-O +-' Q) I:
Ol (1) i ~ ffi CO
L. L. 0
C;(1)~....... 0 :J (J
:.c C).t: ;i en Q. C"
Q) L. Q) (J
- (J C L. +-' 0 :: L. .-
" '5 (1) ._ Q) ~ t
" ro u .
.
. .n.t::ct:.c .- C en Q) ea
C Q):~:JOl '0._ C (J ...
CO Q) - Q) .- ....
- .c 0 C. u .- E = E ~
. . a.. +-' +-,Q) t/)
en Q) c>~(1)roc E~Q. (1) (1)
Q) c.....t:.c- OlO t/) N
+-' > .-
ro .- . - (1) .... +-' ro Q)C- ~ E :: .
en L. ~ en .- .- Q) 0
+-' .nea~cc =32>
en C .- I:
. . Q) =t/)~0Q) .- Q) - I:
~ ~ .- (1) .- -0 o:J-o (1) .- 0
:: ro .c ~ (1) I: 10 .- :: . > E;:;
Q) .n
Q +-' .t: (1) en -C ... - Q) .-
.~ C/) L. ~.... .c L. Q) Q) ~.~ :-c
Q. -
.... +-' Q) L. Q) .... +-' '1:
~ . E =Q) Q. (J (.) en C ....
~ Q) .- (.) 0 0 Q) ~ I: en 0
:: C 0 u en L. ea 0 Q) Q) ~ (.)
0 () ~;(ijQ).a-g ... Q. '0 ...
~ ea 0 .- ... :1....
e +"" CO Q).t:==:J... .t: L. en ~ -0 I:
Q. (J Q. ~
e L. Ol C .- '+- (.) Q) Q)
Q) :J CO(1)~o-o~ ~Q)Ol en C
Q U +-' L. _ ~_ C Q)
~ x C o-+-,-co= ~.cc .t: o ~
~ Q) Q) +-' .~ .- CO .- I: +-' 'i: .... Q.(J
.. C > en = +"" ~ ~ ~ 0 0 e (1)
<{ o c> C
= 0 1O.ccocQ)en E-.n .... Q..t:
u '+- .- L. Q) -.c
~ .- '+- Eeac> (1) Q)....
+-' 0 o .- c> en L. ._
.... ro .n~co:J~ ~ .- C) .c ...
00 u
.- ~ Q) .- "0 u > o .... Q) I: +-' (1)
.. - +-' +-' .- (J (J C ea o >
~ Q. () .cenen~Q)o
.~ Q. +-' -0 .- .c Q) (1) Q) .t: +-' 0
.. CO Q) '+-L.X +-,CO .t:~.c (.) en....
~ o CO Q) ~'+- Q) en C
.... Q) .c +-'-oQ)Q)Oen .....t:+-' ea Q) Q)
.~ +-' .c:(.).c
.. .c .!: cc.cQ)~Q) ...+-' I: mE
u +-' .... <( .-
+-' Q)ro+-'- .c .- ~ .-
~ .- E +-' '+- Q. Q) +-' ~ :.... .... Q) Q)
~ .n ~ Q. C/) 0 E 'S; .c - -0 >
~ .... . C ::J c 0
~ +"" .... OQ)Co=~ C "0 (1) t/)
Q) c
- E Q) Q)-oou:J~ Q)O.... Q) co C.
~ .... > oi ~~'O ....Ot/) ... en E
:: ro t/) Q) () N .n .- Q) t/) .c .- ....
.- L. t/) 0 en ._
= .- .- -0 Ol'- .c +-' t/) 0 I: ~ I:
L. t/) Q) CQ)+-,CO C
.~ Q) C .n 0
.... C C L. ... .- .- C>ea
.~ +"" 0 L. .- Q) ea ~ 0 o .c (J -
~ .- - C .
L. Q)-o-o~ 0 ~ .2l Q) .-
u (.) ~ .- .
:: .c=oi-oen . .
. ,....,
= - r-:JE~cen . Q) L. .en
- ..' C CO
U <{ .. .. .-
~ CO roco .. ..
.. ..
..
c:
o
.-
...
CJ
G)
.~
.c
o
G)
c:
o
II)
5:
ca
...
en
'"C
(I) C
>~
~c.
CU ::J
-
Q)(I)CO
=cE
.!: ro en
+""
.- C ro
~:: c
c)-s 0
cenC)
.QQ)c
CO '- .-
--0
-0--
Q) .~ .5
en C).o
Q) C CD
::J .- >
C"" '"C .-
Q) = en
r.... :::::l ~
+""aJE
.!: Q)
.2>.!: ro
Q):.!:
.!:O~
co.c~
C+""..
o :2 U
E~cu
-o'"CE
'"C Q)
ro -c 1- :: .
Q)C--
.!: ro CU Q)
+"" a. ~ u
: >< I~ Co
:::. Q) > a.
. .
ca
.-
'-
G)
...
.-
'-
o
G)
II)
::::)
-
ca
c:
o
.-
...
.-
-c
c:
o
o
t Q) (I)
o.c
(]) Q. +-: (]) ~
:> C. . > 1_
>::J ..- fA
-oenoroo
cO~C)c.
ro+""vQ)(I)
cC)enc,-
c ::J ", 0
o .- +"" \U
~~!cE
ro 0 en .- ..........
c- +""~
'E :E ~ -S i
'- +"" en U
Q) Q) 0 Q) I-
+"" .!: '- ..
Q)+""+""~cu
'O~~cE
Q) E '- ~ CU
>.oro\U1.
~::Jo.o-c
uenE'"Cro
'~'O 0 ~ c
.c c () c ._
~ co c 0 C/)
~(])Q)o:S
-Q).!:c
2rn~Ctl~
Q)ro+"" '-
- ,^ ro c +"" -.
o..~ .!: .C .- ..
E-o+""rouu
o~CEroCUc.
() = 0
::J .- '"C a. E
ro ~ ~ Q) E 1-
, , en ,^ .-
en v 0 VI -
.- Q) c. 0 ro ftS
enc. c.~~
.- C/) '- 0 ~ fA
.!: Q) ::J '- .~ 1_
1-,-00.>>
~
tJ
<<
.J
<<
:J
tn
>
~
~
~
<<
~
~
~
tn
~
<<
Q
o
~
~
tJ
<<
Q..
~
.J
<<
~
tn
>
~
~
~
<<
~
~
~
tn
~
~
Q
o
~
~
tJ
<<
.J
<<
:J
V)
>
~
~
~
<
(D
~
~
V)
~
<
Q
o
~
~
~
t)
<<
~ .
~
.J \f
<<
~
en
>
~
~
~
<<
CD
~
~
en
~
<<
Q
o
~
~
tJ
<<
~
~
.J
<<
::J
~
>
~
)
o
=
=
o
~
o
~
~
t)
<<
~
.J
<<
::J
t/J
>
t/J
)
o
=
=
o
~
o
~
~
~
~
:3
~
~
QQ
Q
~
en
o
~
o
~
~
~
o
~
N
~
en
=
o
.J
o
t
C>>
~
C>>
to-
....
U)
ca
w
Q)C)
... c:
~ .-
....~
c=
C>> ~
>m
C>>
(,)
5:
... 0 C)
~ ... c:
o Q) .-
,g .... ~ "
... c::: LO
ca C>> ~ ('t")
J: (J m <r-
ca
c:
'E:
~ ca
C>> :E
tn
o 4:
c. .-
o .J
... .-
n.:!:
ca
c:
'E:
ca
C):E
c:
.- ;::
.... .-
.! .J
>< .-
WJ:
"
~
co
<r-
"
(J)
o
<r-
"
C\I
C\I
<r-
"
co
LO
...
.r:.
C)
.-
CD
1:
('.
('.
('.
"
LO
co
<r-
"
(J)
co
<r-
"
LO
('t")
C\I
"
o
C\I
C\I
.r:.
...
'C
.-
~
('.
('.
('.
"
o
co
('t")
"
(J)
o
<r-
"
o
o
C\I
"
o
co
<r-
.r:.
...
C)
C
CD
.J
('.
('.
('.
o
o
o
"
o
~
o
o
co
"
o
C\I
o
o
o
"
co
~
o
o
o
"
I"-
~
co
"C Q)
~'C<
o C ~
- ~ 0
U 0 0
C~_
WC)u.
co
Q)
L.
co
L.
o
o
ij::
-0
C
:J
o
L.
.. C>
en
c
-.
C)
Zg>
- .-
0-0
.~ Q} .J ~ _.
-O+-' _.J
=C :).0 C)
:JQ) me Z
(co C) ~ 2i
~o zL. c(
....1.0 _:J W
.- L. ... 0 .J
I ro en Q) ,ft
-oI -.c ~
Q)en ><~ :2
en ro W c
OQ) w~ 0
c> :r: +-' en
OL. L...L. .J
L.ro IQ)
c.. - -. c(
,^ Q) en ~ Q) ,ft
Q) VI :J - > :J VI
.cCOL.O>L.-
+-' Q) r- 0 r- ...
+-'oenen?f.en-
~ .~ .- ... a .- ...
+-' +-' .~ :) M .~ :)
~ffi~mffi~m
~:51 1:51 1
en Q) Q)
ro L. L.
~ 0 0
ro~ ~
~
C/).
~
.
N
+-'
o
Q)
.c
r-
oj(
I . ,.1f-;sg .. .,. ., ".
r';J":,f:~:i;:.,'t,'
.. :?:'.?: Y'>.::.' :)',"'.."': :~ ',,~",
,: . :~. .~. . ", ::'.. ..""......
tJ :':..", r.::
/J} C '/1i..<.i.,.:';.... g ~
<< t;{""" .'>:",0, co .
;rJ 1::-, ' ' ~ 0"
~ " .<, "" th
", ~ C .. ~: .,~,"
~ ~ c). "J;' ,O~Ol:
~ ~ . p'~;~ ~,,;"',... .' ....
~ ,V!; \ : .:~.,:~..:,..:.,~':':.. ':
~ l::r~:; ';'.',:J..\':::, '~'(.;t~
'it.,..j,..,',.;~/lf1tM'. .'
~iB." ...... ': &ilo;Jfnt(O:l3S.).,'
~I;'I~:~' ~n<
< ',""'"
.r..>\>:":" :'.~
..'......,...-.',..
:allltl~.J'~ .
~) 1. j)JJBN ~'l~~: ~
NOO:J.~ 'Ql' .'~. .:.:. ~ .:
~ ~;0?j::~;',; ~ ~
~I ...,~.:......
~ g :f.f',/X::X
<
Q
o
~
~
...
~
...
tl
~
P
Ul
~
~
CJ
ca
.Q
...
Gl
CIJ
<::
~
o
tIl
~
~ ~
... ~ SO,61.U=O
P P ,OfLf=r
~. ~ /iJ'(JJj.1J
II) <::
P
-It.
01
(II) jfZ61 (0) ,roz u s TIfM 'S'g'~ ,~9'O
,9t'09~
.....
Q)
Q)
'I-
II
~I
~I
l\j
j j~ I
i ~ i~ I
01
~
~I
I
, I
~.>fl
i
..,
.
C'
tn
o
o
CD
..
Q)
M DN/U7/fl9 7VJ:)(J3JfJfOJ ~
3J3(JJNOJ/7VJ3Jf J(JOJS- J ~
IE
j
~
"f
+-'
o
o
'+-
Q)
L.
CO
:J
0-
en
a
a
v
...
<0
V
-
ro
+-I
o
r-
llVHdSY
~
~
~
S l\j I
~ "" ~"'J \C
(]1 . -.
:t"f ~
m _____J
,DD'OL 3 "c,;r.Dl.68 N
~
~.
. ..
~
t)
<<
~
~
~
<,
::J
V)
'>
V)
~
o
~
=
o
~
o
~
~
~
0 -.
tJJ ..
u
ns
~ "' "' "' "' "' "' "'
= E L() en ~ "'. "'. <0 ~ L() 0
C") L() L() "'. "'. ~ N ~ ~
- "'. "'. N N
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
<< -
ns
~
t/)
~ .-
>
~
0 "' "' "' "' "' "' "' "' "'
't- N L{) L{) L{) 0 0 0') ~ ('0.
t) 0 N C") C") C") en en 0 CO "'.
0
0:: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ",.
~
== CO 0
tD L.. C en "0
Q)
...... L.. ~ C
~ C CO 0 0
Q) ~ ...J ()
~ ()
Q) 0 0
L.. C ...... ......
== 0 ~ E .c L.. ...... ......
~ U :J Q) Q)
.- ..c 0 :J 0 ...... ~ ~
...J L.. ...... .- C") Q) C
I CO L.. 0 t:: Q) Q) Q)
......
I I :J <( C") <( > r- r-
. . . . . . . . .
iiiii
~I "
d ~' J
r ,i'"
. P- I~
e,-~I
......15
~..---I
i I .. i
...=~
g .. I
,. ,1. ~
=, j
-:. \'
f ,
'11 .. ~ ':i
~~~;
~..---I
~ I .. i
~""=li!
~ -: ~
-, !
'.'~ t ';
;-. '{\,,' '.
^ .
+-'
C
Q)
+-'
en
.- -0
en 0
c 0
O.c
U L.
en 0
.- .0
~.c
~C)
== 'Q)
U c
ro
'+- Q)
CO.c
C+'"
.- '+-
ro 0
~ 03
4:0
.- CO
...J L.
.- ro
I.c
~ u
Q) Q)
Z~
Q).c
.c~
I- ~
11\
o
It)
G)'"
....
..
C
G)
o
..
::::s
o
.c
..
ca
::t
I
11\
0)
It)
,..
!
o
.J
ftS
C
.-
..
ca
:i
c
~
..,
Q.
:J
I
..
~
It)
~
11\
o
~
N
11\
~.
~
o
;:
Q)
~
Q)
~
I
11\
It)
~
N
t,c
...
...
....
.....
..
~
-...
..Q
Q.I
~
!\
...'W
; ,
\,J
~
..,
.
~
...
...
Q.I
~
~
~
.
~
,,;
~
~
'"
'w
00
~
o
.~
~
C'd
U
.~
~
~
~
<
Q)
u
~
C'd
.~
~
C'd
>
, ~
'. \,
",,"
"
z
,,,,'
,1
"'"
1:
I-
o
l-
I-
Q:
o
Q..
t/)
t/)
C
Q..
Q:
~
o
>-
")
~\
l'.\"
"
"
.
en
c 0
0 +-'
.- en L.
+-' 0
ro L. CJ)
0 Q) Q) Q)
CO 0 .c 0 L.
.-
C +" 0 '+-
. L. o ro
.. .- Q) '+-
== CJ) o 0 0
.!:
~ +" +-' ..... = L.
.- -
- :J 0 en.o Q)
Q. en 0 :J :J 0>
e Q) oa. c
L. +-' CO
= ,...., Q) 'i: Q) -0
~ en - :J.c
c .0 .~ +-' Q)
~ ro c
~ 0 .- '+- .c
0 " L. 0
.- " +-'
= en .-
- o c Q)
~ .- a.
> .
~ a. '0 Q) 0 CJ)
0 CO Q) L. .- CO
- L. ro+-'
- a. +-' '+- 0 Q)
cS ~ ro L.
Q) - Q) - :J 0
- Q) L.
~ -0 ro L. ~(j) C
L. 0
~ 0 Q) o C L.
= 0 C ~ .- 0 0
-
.. '0 Q) Q) :0 0 c
~ Q) 0> +-'
ro :J Q) 0
~ .. .- . a..c~
L. L. .-
= +-'
e CO . Q) o t- oj en
! +-'
~ > 0 .0 Q)
.- ........ .- +-' L.
~ C - _ ~ CO 0>
~ .. Q) Q) ro+-,~ c
~ ~ .!: . -0 +" .- Q) 0
~ .: +-' ~ -0 ffi '5 ~ 0
~ .. ~~ c .
= " t Q) co +-' E .- 0 0
I \C 0 > .- ij:
et"'- Q) c c .- -
== = . a.~ Q) l:;Q).o ro
\C +-' Q) .c :J L.
o 0 .-
~ ~\C en . -0+-'0. +-'
L. -0
- a.Q) Q) (\.
~ ~ . en c Q) .~ Q)
~
.. ~ > " en:5 .- co en .
~ .. t"'- .c .oen:5 co ~
.- +-' Q)+-'
.: =" . .c c 0 +-' +-'
.. > In ~ +-' 0 0 .- o C Q) L.~
.- ~ ~ > '+-a. +-' E C Q) ~ o ro
~ ~ .. " o :J Q) 0 = E Q) .~ en
~ ~ .. In Q)a. :J C .- Q) en ~o
~ ~ = .. a.._ 0" 0 ~ > Q) - .-
--
== ~ Q. ro.c .- 0 Q) 0 L. co.o
e .- ._ C
~ ~ .. .. .c en :J Q) oL.a. +:i :J
.- e .. .. en-o +-' C 0.= C 0.
.. Q)
~ =00. L. 0 ro E .- jg Q)
e u .. - ro L. C .-.- ~
> ~.c ro L. . en.c
= ~ ~ en ro L. . .o+-'
~ CJ) L. CJ) > 0 ~
.- ::J L.
~ ~ ~ ~ :J ro C a. 0>~Q) en Q)
.. J. .- = .. c- o
= ~ .- +-,0>
~>= ~ :J ~ +-' .c ct10
Q. ~ en .- Q) ~ o C
~ .- -0 ca. C ro
~ ~~~ Ot '0
.- ~ C _'0
Q ..~~ +-' ro L. co 0 Q)
00. = Q)a. 0 ro L.L..c C
~ :J 0 .c 0> a. +-' ~ Q)
.
. . .. 0
~ M 00.
... ...
... ... ... ...
... ... ...
...
, .
~~P.~/i
e'-~~
li....==1
o ~,~ _
~.....~i
:.. ~
II: i
e =~ i
~ t. I,.
"
=
o
Q
~
~
Q:
o
t)
)
~
S
en
Q)
"0
.-
>
o
L.
a.
Q)
+-'
.-
+-'
CO
.c
....,
+-'
Q)
(J)
L.
+-'
en
J:
+'"
I'-
CO
en
~
Q)
C 0 E
Q)+-' e
J: Q) '+-
+-' ~ L.
I -0 0
-0
W 0 'i:
.- ~ Q) L.
xO'co
Q) = 0
en
en~~~
Q)....,tQ)
o ro Q) ._
-0 W 0. >
o.Q)ero
.- .c (L en
.c+-' Q)
~o~-o
L. +-' ~ ._
co-oo~
.cQ)(J)L.
enL. 0.
"0 ~~ E
.~ E+-'o
'+- Co
-0 0 0 L.
C 0 ~
coen~>
ro 0 0
- CO .c
~o.oen~
0-0+-'10 CO
L. .- Q) 0 -0
o.t: en ",0
0.0" ~+-'
coolDow
en ~ ~ .-
-g .~ CO 5 ~
Q)>C+:i~
E-g~~~
Eo"C.Q(J)
oc~~.g
o CO \U
Q).c
L. c . .
~ Q)
2 C
(J) CO
~
~
tJ
~
~
~
~
~
tJ
<
cg
~
~
tn
;=
~
=
o
~
r------:-l
I ,
i · i
t
I · i
I
I ,
I : i
I
I · ~
t
I 1
I
I
I
\
.c::.c::~ ca
u~tn Q)
.- ~ ca Q) .... "'"
-:>""'-....c<t
.g ~~ ~ ca 2 C)
a. ca "'.... ~ 't c
~ .c:: Q. "'" ._
"'0 ~ u Q) ca Q) ~
-cu:....:>
,.. ca Q) Q) 0 ca .!
<C~mQ:m~>
~
N
-...
.....
.....
..
~
...
..Q
~;
~
!'.
,,'W
\
\.J
....
'W
.
~
...
...
~
.........
~
s.,
~
,,;
~
,
~
'w
~
o
.~
00
~
U
~
o
U
I
/' .1
~i
, ,,/
" -;
" -, I
.10(1
, ,I
~~...~
--~~
..~
.~ = ~
.,~ ~.
g~
\. '1.\ ;:)
\
\ ~
\ d.~ \ . ~ ,~,':.
\ 'iY} ~\'
",-!/,,/
"',, ~
v"
~,
~
o"IJ
J
"'"
1:
I-
o
l-
I-
Q:
o
Q..
t/)
t/)
C
Q..
Q:
~
o
,..
+""
;. Q)
0 QJ ~
. ==
.cl
..... = Q)
~ t--- .. ~
... ~ ~ .. ~
.: == .. ro
~ QJ .. =
~ ~ = :J
= == ..
= .. c:r
~ 0 = QJ
..... .. ~ ..... en
QJ := ..
. QJ ~ .. 0
QJ 0 ~ QJ .. U
..... = 0 0
= ~ .. ~
CJ QJ .. = 0
QJ .. ~ .: ~
.. = ~ ..
. ~ ~ .. 0
u = 0 .. ~ =
.. .. QJ QJ .. ~
QJ QJ 0 ~ z ~ ~
. . '"C
= = ~ .. .. ..
= .. :=
~ ~ QJ ~ ..... := QJ c
~ 0 .. ..... ~
. .. . 0 = ro
:= ~ ..
0 ~ 0 ~ QJ ~ .. QJ = en
= = ~ = ~ u .. +""
~ . QJ := ~ = ~ c
~ = . ~ ~ =
.. ~ . QJ ~ Q)
VJ = ~ = . QJ . :=
.. ~ ~ e E
QJ ~ ~ 0 0
~ = = := ~ ..
::J ~ .. I LU
= .. . QJ ~ ..
= ..
= ~ = .. ~ :=
U ~ .. ..... .. ro._
..J ..... QJ ~ ~ QJ ~ U o..~
~ = QJ ~ QJ .:
= I .. .. 0 QJ e QJ roro
tJ .....
~ ~ QJ ~ U . ~ .. .: '-
~ . .. ~ CO+""
QJ QJ = = = 0 = .....
~ > = ..... Z 0 1'-1J
~ QJ =
= 0 .. .. ... -.
.. ~ ~ QJ ~ .. '- IQ)
0 QJ ~ ..... e ~ QJ e . Q)
.. = = = QJ = -en
~ e ~ QJ rJl = ~ ~ .. ..... > .- ro
tJ = ~ 0 e ......... 0 := = ~ = Q) SQ)
~ Z ~ .. ~ = QJ '-
QJ ..... = e ~ Q)'-
II .. .. .. QJ QJ
~ ~ II = ~ > ~ = 0 .. '-U
= ~ .. ::::::C
:= . =
. ~ .: ~ ~ ..... 0 ro.-
. .. = .. = QJ
~ .....
U .. .. .. ~ ::J ~II
.. \C ~
. .. QJ = cr c_
..... ~ ~ t--- QJ ~ ..... QJ
.: = .. .. Q).-
== ~ QJ ..... = ~ en
~ .. CJ QJ .. = '"C!
.. 0 > QJ ~
= QJ . = .. QJ ::J
:= .. ~
~ ..... QJ = = .. ~ ~ QJ +"" .- Q)
... ~ 0.. ~ ro en,-
= .. >
= . Q),+-
+ ~ .. ~ . QJ .. +""
~ QJ .....= .. QJ cS ~ ..... en 0::0
.. =QJ e > ~ =
CJ ~ =..... QJ 0 .. =
~ = == 0 = .....
.. == .. = I .. A A
~ ~ e~ u = ~ QJ
= = ~ = .....
;. Q .. e ~ ..
N - == - ~ -
~ z ~ u = -<
Vi ~ ~
A A A A A A A A A A
'":i
, lIIIIlIIIIIIl
~ P. ~ !~
e'-~~
li.....e
2..___~
~ I .. I
~....=~
g =,,' ~
~ " ""
- . "
<~ 1.- \
c:
0
.-
..
ca
II ...
, Ii CI)
Ii
Ii -C
'I
II .-
t/)
II
I c:
0
0
...
~
0
>
L-
0
"-
:1
0
>
~
C
ca
J:
~
q ~
. "
,
.a .
"
~ !
r/l "'" - . ~
':.c 1: lloIJ
I- !(,)
" .. !Z
,... "'" 0 r.. Z
, . ~ /loIJ
'-' I- .., -
.... ClI:
" ,... I- loIJ
--. . -- Q.
... " 0 Q: )(
~ ~ 0 loIJ
, "'- ~ Q.. -- ~ "
~ " t/) z
" t/) -
"- . C'd I ~
'" ~ c c
"- ,; ~ Q.. .~ 0
" po ~ Q: CO
..~ ~ "'"
" . r/l ~ =.,,-" ~
~ 0 c
>- x:
-
""' ~
.~ ~ 4~ ~
~ '~ i' \ :;:)
~ A, i .,(.
~ .' ~,
;>
<
~
Q
::J
~
VJ
Q
~
VJ
-
o
o
a.
E ~
ro 0
00'0
CO
+-'.c
CO(/)
+-'
en c
~ .-
N'O
Q) Q)
C L.
::J Q)
J ~
:,i:j (,)
c_
Q) 0
> 0
<(0..
, I
'l' p.~ ~ i
... ~ ..
o t
... "
:r.... i
~..~~
" I = ..
<t "'
11... ~
~ =' ~
o 3
)00 '...
~ \
~
Q
~
~
~
~
Q
~
trJ
-
o
o
(l
E
0-
N
'r-
+-'
CO
+-'
en
'r-
N
Q)
C
:J
J
'-
+-'
C
Q)
>
<t:
~
::J
~
rn
~
Q
~
~
i
~s <~
>..- z_
O "-:r:
.. ~".
~If-<;
1(1)1:: ~;
!If _ p.. ~
" 't...
... -...
a:Z::J7
:IQ1l 1_
... ,Ii = ~
Ii J -
!
E
a.
N
T"""
+-'
ro
+-'
en
T"""
N
Q)
C
:J
J
0')
C
.-
'0
-
.-
:J
ca
0)
c
.-
+-'
en
'x
W
. lIIIIlIIIIII I
~. .. ~ i~
..... ~ it
o E%., :
... ~ .
li......;
~-==;
~ I,~, 2
CL... ~
1I: ~
~ =' -
o ," =
"4, ;:lI
-: ,
~
Q
::J
~
UJJ
Q
<<
=
UJJ
E
a.
N
~
+-'
CO
+-'
en
~
N
Q)
C
::J
J
0>
c
.-
"0
-
.-
::J
ca
~
Q)
Z
, ,
~ =--... .'
... ~ -~,~
~~~i
~ ........ !
~.....:!=,
,,~ -
~, ~
i r:.~ ;
). -.' !
:~ ~'., !
--..
0
0
Q.
~ '-
.......,
c:
~
g ~
~
UJ E
Q.
~ to
.......,
en
0 .......,
(/)
,.....
~ C\J
(l)
i c
:J
""')
'-
.......,
c:
t/J I ~
. <(
..
).ct)~ ~
~ " "-
'I ~
j:~~;
HJ~
"/
loot, ;;
ii. < '('
d
~
Q
::J
~
~
~
Q
~
VJ
-
o
o
c..
E
CO
ex>
+-'
CO
+-'
en
~
N
o
Q)
o
'-
+-'
C
Q)
>
<(
~
::J
~
tn
~
<<
==
tn
-
o
o
Q.
E
c.
N
,...
+-'
CO
+-'
en
,...
N
U
Q)
o
'-
+'"
C
Q)
>
<(
'I.' .. ~ .'~
~fic~~
li........
2..___~
~ I .. i
l\....;~
~ ~
0'" ;:
.. .;.... 5
. ,
;,- :.#
~
Q
::J
~
VJ
~
o
Q
<<
:;
VJ
c
o
o
Z
+-'
ro
+-'
en
~
N
o
Q)
o
0)
c
.-
"C
-
.-
:J
CO
0)
c
'-
+-'
en
.-
X
UJ
~
Q
::J
~
~
Q
~
~
c
o
o
Z
+-'
CO
+-'
en
~
N
o
Q)
o
0>
C
.-
"0
-
.-
:J
(l)
~
Q)
Z
~
~
::J
~
~
~
~
<<
==
~
-
o
o
a.
E
Q.
L!)
+-'
CO
+-'
en
~
N
()
Q)
o
+:i
C
Q)
>
<(
~.c
...
-...
....
"
...
~
,
..c
~
~
"
......
~
~
~
Q)
[~
00
~N
Q) "
;>N
~ Q) ~
~ ~ ~
~ Q) Q)
~~~
~ S
"I ~
~ "-J
, Q) Q)
~ 00 ~
'w 0 ~
~Q)
000
~
~
~,
,:
,:
~ : -~ ~.~
--, I Z
-- ~ .~
..~
-~
I-
.~
=;-..
\-~. ~
o
l-
I-
Q:
o
Q..
t/)
t/)
C
Q..
Q:
:;)
o
,..
"
Z
-
~
c
o
CD
loIJ'
~
c
x:
-
~
~
::>>
. J.\
~, '
':.t
...
.....
......
"
e
.
,
..Q
"
..,
~
"
.'IttJ
"
~
.9 ~
~ C'd
C'd~
a~
~ clj
~ ~ ~
" ~ . ----i
... ~ ~
~ ~ ~
E S ~
~ 0 ~
~ ~ .~
~~~
u .~
~~
/1
/.'
//.' .'
\ ,~~. :
\ :></
~ ~ ttIfI \.L
I- ~ ~ 1(,)
g -- ~ I~
It.~:::
~ ,. ~
~-:-~!
~.~;
~ ~~ !
,.
A
.i
Ii ~,
r.'
, lIIIIlIIIIII I
!..~'~
..... ~"'
o ~ 5
~... ..
:r.... ~
~..---!
!.:.<!
~ =.1 !
'~ \
~
<<
Q
o
~
<<
!
=
<<
~
~
:3
~
=
rfJ 0
~ bJ) C):
>~~~ bJ).
: .9 J ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0
.~ ~ ~ C) d bJ) ~ ~
~Q)~~~~rfJo
~ ~ ~ ~ rfJ .~ "'0 ~
~ ~ 00 >-.~ Q)..d
~rfJN~ ~u
~..o I-< >-. Q) '0 ;::$ 2
· ..-I Q),.....;:> bI) cr
~ .== ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ ~
.~ > ~v ~ ~ "
.~ ~ ~ C) ~ ~ ~ ~
~~o~o~~~
~
<<
Q
o
~
<<
~
:j
=
""0
~ @
co (]) (]) CtlQ) ~
' i: .r:. C E r.... :>
+oJ+oJ~:;:; Ctl~
en c 0 v
:::::l ,- +oJ Ctl C> (]) :;:;
'0 "' C +oJ C .r:. (]) +oJ
C VI Ctl.- +oJ .r:. C
.- C ~ r.... '" +oJ '"
.- 0 +oJ +oJ :::::l V en \U
c'"Co .=Ctl~(])(])t
Ctl = Ctl:::::l 0 V +oJ 0
en:::::lIi-r.....o.oCtlCtlCtlQ.
,- .0 o.a en C '5 .~ C E
~ CO t c Ctl (]) C E (]) ,_
:J +oJ Ctl (]) ~.c Ctl 0 ~ C
I~~~==~E'O :::::l
Q)
-
CO c
U ~
~o
::J I- ·
Q)
Q) Q) ()
.c.cc
+""+""Q)
'+-c-
o .- a;
C) +"" ()
c 0 ><
.- 0 W
E~1i-
o Q) 0
() .:::t. ~
Q)",+""
.o~O
oen(])
cco.c
.c+""
en+"",+-
.- CO 0
CO.!:+""
C +-' '-
.i: '"C CO
CO 0 Q)
~o.c
+""fQ)
Co.c
Q).o+""
'- c
'- .c ._
::J C) +""
() .- ()
Q) .-
CDC.b
..c:_C/)
+"" CO .-
.. .- 0
+-'
.cC,-
U Q) Q)
::J1J+""
en .- c
en en Q)
<(~U
, lIIIIlIIIIII i
~..~~
..... ~"'
o ~ Ii
...... t
:r........~
~ .-'J == ~
>II'" ~
>II I ..
c lIIIIlIIIIII 0
~""Q,j;
e =....~ ~
."~ 3
.~ "
~
<<
Q
o
~
<<
!
=
<<
~
:3
~
==
ro
-c 0
- +-'
o C
L. .-
ro~
~E
a L.
NQ
en
ro c
Q) co
.::t,Z
CO-o
+-' c
o co
+-'
c~cti
0= c
'00 '0 'i:
.- co co
> '+- E
CO-o
Q) Q) en
> +-' en
co ro co
.c ~ 13
Q):P1;)
>CL.
> COt+:
-0 .
Q) Q) ~
en c c
::J .2> Q)
coen=
() Q) Q)
Q) -0 (.)
.c ~ x
-UJ
~O'+-
=00
roa.:>-
.c ~
=COO
.- '+-
.c 0 Q)
a. +-' .c
::J::J+-'
cOo
roC):>-
C).~ .c
.~ 10 t
+-' L. 0
.c Q) ~
.2> a. c
'+- 0 ::J
Q) Q) ........
L. L. ~
roco~
Q) .-
> Q) (.)
>~~
-0
"-
roQ) ~
C.cIDmQ)-C
.- -c (.) C e- Q)
ro C c .- ro "C
C co .- L. (.) Q)
._ en co Q)
(0-0 L. E-o c
E25Q)~.c
c (.):: (.)
co Q) en .- en ::J -.
.- co .- 2: +-' E ID
(.)+-'~Q)C +-'
Q)a-oen~roro
E v C = '00 -0 ~
EC)ro2Q)cO
Cen L.CO+-'
o .- co co ro en
(.)~::JCL.Q)en
+-' 0 "'" ._ ~ (.) Q)
en - \,,/ ...I .-
m a..- ro +-' ~ (.)
\U E > E C L (.)
.- Q) Q) <(
Q)Q)-g~>enl
:5 co .- 0 <( L.
Q) L. C) +-' C) Q)E :>-
L.2cQ)c ~
ro C ~ L. .- 0 C
Q) Q) L. . 00 ID 1;) ())
>>OQ)~::JE
><(~-oO(,)CO
rJ)
~
~ oj
~ ~J
<~
~z
<0
~u
~~
<~
u~
O~
~rJ)
~
~
~
1St
:
""""
~
~
-
""""f
....
....
"
f;1
.a
.=
-
C
;;
Q)
>
C '0 t.;::
o ~ oo C C ~
oo t ro Q) ro._ 0
~O XQ)-~C_
,Q)LL Q)o.2uoro
C en 0. oo 0 :.;:; '0
0> Q) Q) ~ E 0 Q) '0 U'C
'00 -0 ~.- 0 - $ C 2 0
-oo '"__
- ~ C ~ u 1: \U ro oo LL
00.00 o>c.oc_
oo 0> .0 C._ ro 0 oo
'O~OcE'O Q)
'0 .!: Q) ro:.;:; 'S u ~_
ffi ~ 0) I C ~ ~ 0 ro ~ -en
oo.~ (j; oo ~ '0 Q) u.!: _ ~
::l-g>(j;CCCroro5m
.,g ro Co >- O.g Co ~ E (/) >-
I-~ ~Uo::::: _
=.ou
I
~
0)
~
on
~
'''';
+-l
'''';
S
'''';
-
r/)
0) r/)
r/) 0)
::l r/)
~ ::l
~ "a
.'flI'lIl .~
0) a 'S
a ~ ~
r/) ~.,..;
s 0 r/)
::l ~ ~
......c M ~
~ 0 0 0
''''; ~ ~ M
"Mr/)" 0
g o~ 0) ~
~ s~ ~~
8 "8 ~ '5 .S
C) ~ ~ s on
0) r/)- ~ ~
g. ~ ~ on'8
'8 .g ~ .S ~
::l .g >.] ~
~~a r/) 0)
r/) 0) d ''''; M
.,..; M ~ " ~
] ~.9 a ~
Cd +-l _.,..;
- ~ ~ +-l .t::
0)0... _
= a';:: 0 a
~ c=o ~ ct '0
M M,tj 0) '''';
0) ''''; rI.l +-' 3
~~8~~
\\ \\J
oo ~
Q)oo Q) ro Q)
5'0 'O__~oo~
:.;:;c c>-o_(j;_
U::l <( C ~ _ _ C
Q) 0 - . C Q) 0 ro.- .
=~ro'O::l.ocOOO32
JO >- 0 0>:.;:; Q) (/) E 0).0 Q) m
~- .0 U Q) C oo ::l'- _ 0> ~
ooro.o~O:Ec~~ffi~
::l - 0 ,- U 0> 0> ._ ~
o oo - oo oo ::l C _oo 0 u' t:=
E ::l >- Q) ro 0.- _ _ 10;;:
ro ';'0 ;: ~ .0 '0 -: LL .9 .~
-.- ro oo oo C oo ~ ~
Q) ~ ~ Q) ~ ro'~ ~ 'S ~ _
~ 0 - ~ U ~ '0.- 0.....,- .
E C oo Q) ro ~ ro '(3 (/) '0 ~
oo 0> C 0. Q) ro ro Q)
Q) o>.!: -oo <( ~ 15 - (j; 0 C
U C '0 ro t;> Q) > _ ._
C ~ '3 ~ 0 0 Q) 0> 0 0> ~
o - .0 .3 LL ~Q) Co ~ = .!: .0
ro C <(_
roo>-Q)ajE -.9 .oro
.~ .0 0.. > > 0 ~ oo en E.!:
tat ro (j; E <( ro - 'C ro Q) ~ ro
,I; E~Q)ogQ)roOE~E
t:\ <(o-cQ).s~.o:.;:;
~ = 0. 0 ,_
I
en
203
't-CO>
oEO
C:Cl)+:ien
CO C>en a.
Cl)COCl)=
EtCl)en
ouo
- .J::. .- 0
~en~<o
~~co~o
.. . - "C T"'"
.=. B ~ ~ '0
~ en enl-'O
= gc.oj Q)
~\ (f') E u Cl)
W -+oJ co co c: :::
r #i Cl) s.... a. -+oJ en
~.J ~ '0 en Cl)E Co
= s.... Cl) CO Cl)
Cl) '0 c: c: ~
~ ~.C::J Cl)
rJj~e~~.;
::: U
t..~
~~!
~i~
~~
~~
Q)
Q).c
.c ....
...."0
..... -
o 0
c~....
.- 0 -
Q) .... c
....uo
CUQ)~
~ ~ cu
O)~ '0
.~ Q) ~
E.~ en
~....<(
cu ::J
-Uen
cuQ)Q)
c X._
CUQ).;:;
- en
...."O::J
cuco"O
O)Q)C
c....-
.- Cf) Q)
.c C
en C._
.- Q) ~
.~ ~ cu
E _ ~
:c -cri' co
en"O:2
'-'C ~
enoo
enLLLL
Q) ~
U .... .... Q)
uenena.
CUQ)~cu
~;::>a.
Q) .c.c en
............;:
cu55Q)
~Cf)Cf)C
o
Z 00
<( W
ZO~
<(I-J
00-
I-WO
"'-Z<(
......Wu.
:tc.o
~C.W
00<(1-
-:t<(
OO(/):J
i:<(Q
I-:tl- o Z
z <(
<(
! P. ~ i~
~'-~;
:r - 5
o - w
~......~
~I..~. ~
~.. ;
e == !
~ ~ 3
9
o
Q
~
<<
~
~
~~
~Q
~O
~U
t)~
~Z
~~
~Q
::J~
=5
~=
o
~
~
~
~
t
<<
9
o
Q
~
<<
~
~
~~
~Q
~o
~t)
t)tD
~z
ca~
cae
o-J
=5
~CfQ
o
;
~
~
~
t
<<
~
...
o
p.~
::~
..==
s:= ;
'~ t'
....,.
L
<J
~
~
~
~
~
c
o
..
"'
~
:r
o
...
>II
>II
C
...
II:
::>
o
)0
Q
~
<<
<<
~
~
)~
~Q
~O
~c;
c;CD
~~
~:=
~Q
~.J
~
=~
~~
09
;8
~
~
~
t
<<
~
j:~;;"';;' ,
~, :
I
i
~
tOe
~o
O\t)
~~
~Qj
o~
~e
~=
~~
~e
6~
rl 0
~
.....
"-
.....
......
~
,
....
.c
~
........
~
'"
u
~
o
~
t <<~
.....
--
~ t)
..... :3
" ~
'"
.
~ ~.
~ ~
'w
~
;
~
Q) Q)
.- c
~ m
.... OL-
to Q)
c E
Q) ~ a> <( a>
'- E ~ "C .0) a
'- - a a>~ 0
~ a> Q) I m 0 U .c L- a>
0 "C a m +ja:l S
.- '0 a.. LL LL ..... \t- 0
(/) en ~ c o ._
c ..... LL a> a> I L- 0
.- ~ + "C 20 .-
LL L- .0
0 0 0 L-
"' "' "' "' LL (/) ~ m Q)
-q- ,.. N ~ 0 -q- ~
<( c U ..... -
N 0 ~ ~ ,.. en ~ - (J)UJ a..
Q) a>
.- c
~ m
OL-
tU a>
'- E
0 ~ a> <( a>
.- E ~ '0 .0) 0
'- - a>~ 0
.- a
D. a> a> I m 0 0 .c L- a>
'0 0 m ~co S
.- "C a.. u. u. ..... \t- 0
(/) .-
c (/) ~ a> c a ._ 0
..... "' LL a> I L-
.- ~ "' + '0 Q)..... .-
(D "' U. L- ..... 0
0 0 N 0 .- L- .0
"' "' "' u. (/) ~ m a>
-q- co It) en N -q- ..... - ~
N 0 ~ It) ,.. ,.. ~ <( c 0 (/)W a..
-
.... a>
C ~
~ ~ E
- a
.-
'- 0 0
~ a> a> I'- I'- m I'- a>
0 "C "C co co u. co S
.- .- 0) 0) a> 0)
(/) (/) ~ ~ ~ 4:
c ..... "C 0
.- ~ m m .- m
(/) .-
1.0 0 0 0 0 ~ .0
..... L-
0) 1.0 co co N co L- L- ~ L- a ~
.- .- .-
~ -q- N ('f) ~ 1.0 U 0 0 0 LL a..
c -
(/) a m
0. ..... .....
..... ..... c c
.- .c .c (/) E
- Q) Q)
(J) Q) a> 0> 0> Q) > c E Q)
N .- .- c a
~ N a> a> a> .....
m .- c (/)
(/) .- I I L- ..... (/)
0 (/) () a.. m a ~ (/)
. 0) 'C "- L- (J) a>
\t- O) X a> .-
0 m 0) "C L- a> > 0
~ > ~ L- a. c 4: 0
~ -
~ <( co I u. 0 W ...J <(
tJ)
C
o
tJ)
I-
I.
ns
c.
E
o
o
c
ns
-
a.
G)
....
1-
UJ
~
o
~
~
~
~
~ VJ
t) ~
< tT~ ~
~ ~ :J ·
tTi ~ Q
~I ~ ~
~~t
O~~
~~<<
VJ~~
~ VJ
~ VJ
Q
~
;
~
~
;
~
+-,'0
e :J
Q) 0
--
Ci) Q)
~:;
= (/)
ro Q)
:J+-'
trn4:
.- C'-
>.- ~
E L..
ees .- 0
-~
c Q) 0
rnQ)~
Q) c :J
"rnrn
VL..L..
~U"C
- >.
rnQ).c
+-' 0> ""
e '0 v
Q) .- Q)
E L.. L..
ea Q)
c 0 ~
o .- 0
L.. L..
.- '0 0.
~ Q) rJ)
ww ~
"c+-'
Q) rn
"c 0
._ .n
:J.c
C>~
L.. ~
Q)
rJ) e
rn 0 :::
...J:;i ~
rn~
Q) L.. 0
Co ~ +-'
rJ) 0 C
_ 0
o L.. .-
L.. Q) rJ)
+-' ~ .-
c rn 0
o (/) ~
UQ)o.
L.."c+-'
Q) .- C
+-,>Q)
:J 0 E
o.L..
E 0. Q)
o '0 0
"crn
vroo.
c-
._ rn
...., c
:':: rn
~O-t-l
L.. C
.cQ)Q)
:!::cE
~ ro e
E Q) 0
o L..
Q) .-
+-' ro >
(/) L.. C
>.0Q)
(J)~Q)
0> o>.c
c .~ +-'
.- '0 C
(/) .- 0
c >
.- 0 -t-I
c::: L.. 0
L.. 0. rn
Q)eo.
+-'oE
rn .-'-
>-t-I(/)
> rn (/)
.cEQ)
(/)rn-
Q)-"C
L.. 0 c
LL ~ ro
.
rn
-t-I
~ Q)
.- .c
Q)ro-t-l
O>c
c rn .-
rn -t-I Q)
.~ 0 .c
t:~ a.rn
:JOO:;i
I L.. L.. e
a. +-' Q)
-t-I (/)
corn"C
Q) -t-I -t-I .-
o>(/)rn~
c '0 0 L..
._ L.. rn
.;.rnc"C
(/) '0 .- C
(/)cmQ)
~>. jg ~ -a, '0
ro (f) rJ) .- 0
"ccQ).co
.so-rn.c
._ rJ) L..
o+-,-~o
-t-I~>'O.o
::+-,Ct.c
.- 0 c 0>
:J L.. :J rn .-
eaa.(f)~~
I
~
Q)
.c.cc
-t-I -t-I .-
.- 0
~ c ~
E rn 'i:
Q) -t-I ro
+-' (/) E
rJ) .~
>.rnQ)
(J) o>.c
crn-t-l
.Q ~ ~
t):J+-'
Q)(/)jg
-t-IC(/)
e Q) rn
0..0>
+-' Q)
Q) '0
.:: E -t-I
LL rn rn
Eo.c
u..+-'
o Q)
+-' LL L.. .
(/)u..ij:(O
8LL<(~~
...JT'"
o
~
'--.,
::::;
t::
o
~
.t>
...::::
()
, lIIIIlIIIIIIL
w ;.. ~ ,~
= ... ~ ;
2'-~S
.........;
~..==~
~ I ~ ~
:.. ~
.. i
5 =' i
)Jo ..4 .
, ,
Q) Q)
4-< Sn -B -B
o · ;;J -+-' l:::
~ ~ ~.;
c2 ~~ 0 l:::
r,,~ Q) ," Q) bb ~ ~.~
== rJJ ~ $-< ;::l ~ 'S: 8
~ t\l l::: t\l Q) Q) ;;.
QQ t..., ~ ~ g, () () U t\l "0 ~
~ ~ ~,,1l ~.,.; rJJ!'p ~ l::: $-< 8 -+-'
~ &v..&\ ~I .s ~ 0 tH 0., ~ E l::: bl)
~ ~ t) "O~g ~ ~o 5~5
t, 0 ~ ~ t\l "$-< ::::r-- >"0-
Vi '- t\l $-< 0 0 . ,.; .... .". t\l l:::
- '- Q);::l ,..., _...... . ,.;
== ~ ~ .S ~ g ~ 8 .s ~ ~ ] ~
t) Q ~I ..0< S~ ~ :9 a J>5bB
~ = ~ "; 5 5 =:l 0 '3 i ~.9 e-
~ ~ t) .g ~ s ~ ~ ~ S '> 8 ~
~ ~. t\l ~ t:: ~ ~ rJJ l::: 0 '''; ~ N
~I ~ S'S t\l 0 S S ~ U ~ g';;J
t f". ~,,1 ~ Q) g<\I.l S 2 ~ g en -+-' o-+-' ~
~I ~ Q S Q) -< Q) ~ ~ ~ l::: l::: '''; "0 ~
- 0 f". t\l $-< "~ 0., > Q):a t\l S l::: t\l
~ ~I II -+-' ;::l Q) -+-' () ;;. -+-' - :.= 8 ~ ~
~I ~,,~ 0 .0 a :s g B S ] ]'3 0.,8 c] ~
~ · ,.; t:: 0., t\l -+-' '0:::1 ~ !:< -+-' -+-'
~ t) ~ . ;;::: 0 \0 rJJ ~ $-< 0 ~_ R 0 ~~
~ 'liwI ~ () 0., t' - \I.l -+-' -+-' t\l \J U :::: ()
~ ~ ~ S 4-<'a -<"; rJJ ~ ~ Q) 4-<'~ ~
t"ll ~ i-i1 l:::',,; ~~ ~ g ~ ~ S . -g 0] $-<
~I ~ 0 .9 a 0 - ~ - 8 -"; ~ () 8 0.,<2
== 0 L. a Q)'~ ~ u ~ t\l ~'c a ~ ~ ~ "0
~ VJ S c.s.g ~ e ~ .~ ~] ~ a ~ ]
~ + ~.5:a 0 0.,8 .g ~ "O.s ;::l < 8 ~
~ ~ ~ ~ "0 Z ~ ~ a:l.S rJJ U
f.ft~ ~ t\l I I
I I I I I I I
~
o
...
:r
o
...
>II
"
C
...
.
:;;)
o
>-
Q)
t) ~.D =
L ~ r-,rJ'J Q) Q) ~ ~ -~ rJJ
~~~ ~ ~:= ~:s 0;> ~ro
e & ~ r/l U ~ ~ ~ c;g 'E Co
! rJ'1 0 ~ C rJ'1 .~.~ Q) .= ~ "'"
; ""fI ~ ~ t"- Q) ~ . C ~ .D ~ C ~ ~
~ ~..c: :s 00 0 Q) clj U ro Q) ,~ U
· ] ,<;:: 0,..; ~ ~ '8 e.o E a E E ~ a
~~~c Q)~uou ~~ ~Q)a
clj ~ ~ 0 ;> 1I').r:: Q) ~ Q) Q) ~.r:: ,~
~cQ)u ro~~~~ ~c ro~Q)
~ ,~ .t: ~ ..c: 0 ~';> ~ ] Q) ~ >< :>
r'I ~ rJ'J ~ ~ Q) 0 ~ ~.r:: ' 2 II') ',p ,...;
rJ'1~~ro ~uQ)~~ rJ'1~ =~rou
ro a c ~ > c u ~ C ~ '" 00 ~ ~'C
..c 0 Q) 0 ;> ro 5 ~.~ ,~..c ~ \0 :: Q) ti
~ ,>-. ~ ~\J ~ ~ - f '\ , ~ .......... ~\J C \I J
>-. u ~ ~ ~ ~. ro "'Cj'~ ro rJ'1::: ~ '~Q) .~
~. ~ :s ~ :s .~ .D ~ ~ C C ~ ~ ro c ~ ~
:.= 0 u - 0 := 0 .~ .~ - = ~
.~ c Q) Q) U Q) U Q) a Q) rJ'1 ro ~ E ro Q)
u ..c;> ~ ro..c u .t: · ~ rJ'1 ~ C ro u ~
,~ .~ ~.~ c ~ ~ ro rJ'1 - .... 0 Q) Q) .~ ~
~ ta .~ "'Cj Q). w .~ rJ'1 ~ ~ Q)
'S ~ ..c'" ~ ~ "'2 c . C "'2 rJ'1 t) ~ u.t: :s u ~ u
Q) 0 g Q) ~ rJ'1 ro ~ rJ'1 ~ ~ gS:g Q)"'Cj a ~
t: ~ rJ'1 C .D & ~ ~ & bb 00 .~ ro ro .~ = ~ ;>
8UrJ'1~~00~0Q)..co~~tao"'CjB
Q)S~~~a~=a~~c~~c~ro~
..c ro.D 0 t"-..c: C ~ ~Q) Q)
L.. ~ 00 · C 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ rJ'1 00.t: 0 ~ .::: c ::: ~
r Q) ~ ~ ~ Q) ~ rJ'1 ~ ~ .~ "'Cj .~ W Q)
~"'Cj'SQ)~~~~~o~~ro~"'Cj..c~
r:oo:s ~~ ~~ ~~ :-=~c
IrUU"'Cj roro cC ~o :Sco
I ~ ~ I .~ 0 I ro C I .D ro U
, p.~
:=~
.=
;;~
~ \
Q
~
>
o
=
~
~
"
':.t
...
-...
....
"
~
...
.c
~
~
"-
.....
.. ,
\",I
~
01)
.~
00
Q)
o
'"
'w
.
'w
...
...
...
~
.....
"
"W
.
~
"
r...~
~
.
~
'"
~
C'd
~
B
u
Q)
~
.~
..d
u
~
<
~
C'd
Q)
~
C'd
~
Q)
~
.~
~
Q)
~
~
~
C'd
~
~
~
~
Q)
~
.~
rfJ
"",
'..,
r:...ttIfI
~ ~
o r."" ~
I-.~
~..
~-~
~ 1 -
~ ..~
~ =~-..
. ~ ~.~
"'"
:c
I-
.1. '
c:>>
z
-
~
C
o
CO
loIJ'
~
C
x:
-
~
~
::>>
i
.
"
, lIIIIlIIIIII!..
~ P. ~ ,~
;~~~
li.....i
~..==~
~ I ~ il
lL.... ~
GI: ~
:::l =' ;
o , ..
.... . :.:t
r ""
~. \
,J
<
~
~
CD
--
~
o
~
~.J
tii~
~~
CD~
~~
~QQ
~::J
Q~
~
~
~
CD
~
<
=
U
'"0
~
rJj 0
rJj ~
Q) rJj
U rJj
U Q)
~ U
.+-J U U
r. r. ~ ,~~
o l()~ ~Q)
~ ~ ~.+-J
o ~ .~
o 00 ~rJj
.+-J .+-IN'"O~O
r. r. Q) 0 0
Nr. 0 O'"O~
Nl() .+-J"'O ~
~~8.+-J~'"Oo
oQ)~Q)~
o 0 ~~ Q)"'O ~
.+-J .+-J ~ ~ .~ >
" "0 "0 In ro 6 0
oQ)Q)ObOI-<S
~~\/)N~o.,Q)
Q) ro S · .... _ I-<
S b ~ 0 ~.;:l ;>.
o ~ g ~ .~ ~ ,!:J
~ · .... · .... > Q) bO
· ~ ~ '"0 '"0 .+-J 0
"0 ~ 0 Q) ~ 0.....
8Q)~groo.,~
~ > ~'"O rJj 0 u
'"0 ~ ~ Q) rJj 0 rJj
Q) "" 0 I-< Q)' .... "0
I-< S U...c: U ~ ~
~ o~..... ~ Q) ro
Q) ~ Q) "'0 ij ~
"'"" ~ .~ .~ U ~ ~
~ ~~ ;> ;;> .~ Q) ~
0'- _ ~
~~EbO.g~O
r-.. ~\ ~ r-.. ~ .~
.+-J f"*-J \JJ · ~ ~ ~ .+-J
~ ~ ~ '"0 ;;> .~
bl) rJj ~ ~ ~ ~"O
'03 r. 0 3 ZQ) ~ ~
~OrJ)~ ~
I I I I I I I
~
~
~
~
~
-
rn
Q
~
VJ
o
~
o
=
~
ctc
c .-
ct.!
Q.
~E
- 0
~u
= ea
~ 'i c ~
..c~ oea
:Sea ~C)
a. ~ 'E ,E
"'.l:: \AI::>
0_'0"";>
~ ea c ~ ,!
<(~ea>>
r--
~-l
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
.1
1
.1
~
I
J
1
'"
~!
Q) co 1/1
"'>tnl/l
C 0 Q)
,- aJI '"
co"'''\!
-Q.~Cl
Q.E;>W
E'j'.2~
o ClU, 1/1
UCCJI/I
Q)iiE~
~"'coCl
o co '" C
Uo.l-_
I
I
\
I
\
\
I
\
I
tI)
~
(.)
o
C
C)
c
+;
co
o
-
u.
S
G)
~
()
c
o
U
t:
~
I
G)
J:
~
~
o
I
S
~
~
en
~
G)
z
~
;;
::
co
Q)
m
-
-
'i
Cl
c:
.-
Q.
co
CJ
1/1
'C
C
co ~
.J't:
Q) Q)
>Q.
.- 0
1/1 '"
Co.
Q)
... Q)
><J:.
W...
tI)
G)
;;
.-
-
.-
()
~
u.
~
G)
~
(.)
o
.J
~
Q)
C)
c
~
o
.J
"C
Q)
~
c
.-
o
Q.
Q.
<
~
-
-
~
....
+;
~
~
G)
m
~
~
.-
-
.-
()
~
u.
G)
()
.-
~
G)
en
G)
"C
.-
tI)
c
olS
E
o
o
~
~
o
J:
en
tI)
tI)
~
-
u
..
III
~
I p.~ I
..
! rU
i!
0 ::~ Ii
... t
:r ~
0 -= ~
II.
>II i
>II ;,=
c
I. oJ
I: i
;:)
0 ;
~
~ 1,'
I lIIIIlIIIIII I
~ . ~ I~
e'--~;
li.....e
~ .~~== I
>II.... ~
!~~~
::l i
o " ;:
)0 I; ~
'~ 1- \
!
o
...
...
Ill:
o
L
>II
>II
0(
L
Ill:
::I
o
~
, "
!-~
eJ~
-==
;;~
~ 1.
t.
u
z
'"
Ii
e
~
a
to
..
i
~
"
, p.~
::~
-==
i:;
; \
~
...
g
:r
o
Cl.
>II
'11
C
Cl.
II:
::l
o
~
I
..
u
~
..
t
~
~
i
..
~
"
~, , .
' ...!~
r .. "Q,f ,~
~'--~~
._==,
o _..::1 ~
~ ~ c
~ I ... :
:_"Q,f~
-=;i
::) . :
0, 3
)0 '.
~ t'
,
,
, IIII1IIi I
! .. 'q,j .'~
,.. '~
~~7~
;..._~
~....,cl
!~~.!
:l i
~ =' . ~
.' . 3
c~ t'
~. ~
,
~l
,'"
,I}
~ ,~
~~~
~==I
=;~ I
.~ \
~~ I
'"
I}
;!
~a;; "
r
1.1
-== I
$;~ i
'"
i
i
, .
... ~~ it
= I}
~
0 ~~ ~
.. ..
. 1.1
0 -== I
~
'/I i
'/I
C i.;
~
- '"
:l ~
0
)0 i
'~ \
~~ j
... ..
= I}
!!
e ~a;; "
r
1.1
-== I
i;~ i
..
~
i
.~ '\
I iJ.lltt11.J11i1L I
~~. i~
~a;;!
..,cl
I - C
-<:
IiI !
~ ,\',
t, ",
, ......
r ~ ~"Q,f !;
.. ~ <<
o r
.. 1.1
.-a='
o _..::1 ~
~ ~ c
~ I ; i
: - ~
- , i
::) ; =
0" 3
)0> .4,
, ,
,
. i
r ~ ~ .'~
~~7~
._-,
o...a=~
!:<l
~ .;1 3
, ,
,
~ +'"'
.. (1)-0
~
01)0 = QJ !O)
. =
~.~ ~
o ~ .... = en
~B ~ r-.... .. ~ <DO
.... ~ rIl .- L.c..
~ = t-
O) 0 ~ ~ QJ t- = roo
~8: = = Q :: .. :J,-
~ 0 == ;. c-c..
= QJ
I 0 .... .... en
QJ .. ~
0) rJ). :: .. 00)
- QJ rIl ;.
U = QJ 0 ~ t- U
~ 0 .... QJ = 0:5
O)"'C == ~ = ;. ~
QJ QJ .. = o'+-
=~ .. ~ t- ~ .: rIl
Q) Q) - = ~ "0
u ~ ~ .-
u 8 = 0 .. rIl = ~u
~ 0) t- .. QJ QJ ..
~~ QJ QJ = ~ Z Q ~ .-
- - -o~
~~ = = rIl t- t- ..
o ~ ~ == .. :: ero
rIl QJ ~ .... :: QJ ~
o~ = ;. .. 0 .... ro~
- - ==
~ :: ~ ..
.~ ~ = CJ t- QJ en 0)
UO) = rIl QJ = ~ U =
rJ). ~ == ~ ~ .. """.c
Q) Q) = - QJ :: = ~ e.....,
~~ - ~ ~ =
= .. CJ - QJ ~ 0)><
~ ~ - QJ - ::
~O) .. e
o ~ QJ ~ ~ ~ ~ = 0 Ell)
~ ~ = = :: ~ t- O)
rJ).0 = ;. ;. - I QJ ~ ;. en t'-"
= = ..
E~ ~ = .. ~ :: ro.~
U rIl .. .... .. '-
O).~ ~ .... QJ ~ ~ QJ rIl U 0 c..~
"'Cu == QJ ~ QJ
.~~ = I .. .. = QJ e ~ ~ roro
~ .... QJ
rJ). ~ QJ ~ U - rIl .. ~ '-
O)~ rIl - .. ~ '- (0"""
~ = QJ QJ = = = 0 = .... 0
rIl > QJ = .... Z = 1'--0
o~ = 0 ==
oU .. .. ....
QJ t- CJ ~ ~ QJ ~ ~ .. '- I<D
o~ ;. .... e QJ e - Q)
"..c CJ == == = QJ Q = > -en
lr)u = e ~ QJ 00 = CJ .. .... .- ro
C"lC'd e ....... :: ~ == Q) ~O)
~ ~ = ~ = == QJ
01)~ II QJ Z .... .. ~ = == e '- 0)'-
;. .. .. QJ QJ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ > ~ = '-u
.~~ II = == ..
~.~ :: - == CJ ;. ::::::e
.~ ~ .. - - rIl .: ~ ~ = .... 0 ro'-
.. = ;. == QJ
C'd ~ U ~ ....
e.~ ~ .. .. .. ~ :J ~II
.. \C ~
O)~ E .... - ;. QJ = cr e _ ::::'
~ rIl rIl r-.... QJ CJ .... QJ
== .. .. 0)'- ro
~ ~ ~ CJ == ~ QJ .... = ~ en
.. ~ QJ .. = -o~e
0) 0) 0) = .. 0 > QJ ~
QJ . == .. QJ :J
..c~> ~ QJ :: .. ~ rIl .- 0)'-
.... == ..
~O)< .... rIl = Q QJ ....., en,-'-
= =.. .. ~ > ro
+ = - Q) \i- ro
~~~ ~ ~ .. rIl - ~ .- .....,
~~o ~ ..-= ;. ~ ca rIl ..- en ~o~
;. =QJ e > ~ =
~ ta 0 ~ ~ ~ =.... QJ 0 .. =
~ == = == ....
~..c · ~ ~ .. == ;. :: I ;. A A
~ e~ u = ~ QJ
rJ).~u 0 = QJ = ....
0) 0) Q) .. 0 .. e QJ ..
N - == - ~ -
~~..c ~ Z ~ U = <
Vi ~ ~
~.~ ~
.~~ ~
~]~ A A A A A A A A A A
t,c
.....
"
....
~
~
~
"
..c
~
......
~
,,""
\J
...
Ioow
.
'-
....
"
"
~
......
"
'W
.
~
f1tI
r...~
~
,
~
Ioow
~
o
.~
~
~
U
.~
~
~
~
<
Q)
rJJ.
~
~
~
~
o
.~
~
.~
~
~
o
U
~
/1
/'J/
/ '., <.,/
\ . - !
"'""
. !
r:.... _ ~ ~
~ ~ /z
,.. ~ ~
- ~ ~
..~
~-~
T.~
.~;
Q~
\'~ {\~ ;;')
'y'
.
1
w
:z:
~
o
~
~
ct
o
0..
IJ)
IJ)
C
0..
ct
::)
o
>-
\~
r,1
. .
rI).
::
Q
..
.....
=
~
::
~
e
e
Q
~
~
;.
=
=
.....
00.
..
=
..
..
~
.....
..
;.
u
~
rI).
~
-
=
::
Q
..
.....
..
~
::
Q
U
. .
C/)
0)
+'"
m
+'"
C/)
~
m
+'"
en
.
0)
C
o
+'"
0.
0)
(.)
x
0)
C
o
.-
+'"
m
(.)
.-
-
0.
0.
m
0)
~
+'"
~
.c
+'"
(1)
E
m
'C
(])
+'"
'C
(.)
-
-
<{
...
...
.
.
C
m
-
a..
0)
>
.-
C/)
C
0)
J:
0)
L..
0.
E
o
()
m
L..
:]
+'"
C
0)
>
<{
"I-
o
~
+'"
()
0)
J:
+'"
~
+'"
.-
~
...
c:
CI)
...,
t/)
.-
t/)
c:
o
u
..
..
0)
0) "0
~ -c '00
+"'r-C:+",CI)
C ca:] t/)
~ u ~ 0 .-
L..::..., 0) 0
a.c~(.)c:
oaca~O)
+'" t/) 0. J:
+'"
0. i ~.. 0) 1""""1
:]'-...,~"O
0) CI) i J9 ffi
C;(I)~~
~ C) ~ ';:i C/)
- UCL..
'5 (I) .- 0) .8
.c~~t:~
O)""~:]
J: "'0 ^ (.) .Q>
+'" Wi +'" 0)
O)~(I)mc
c""~~-
. - CI) ..., +'" m
L.. ... C/) . -
.cca:::cc
-t/)"'00)
= CI) .- "0
~ (I) c: 10 .- ~ .
~CI)L..C/)-c
~"".cO)O)(I)
=(1) o.L..u
.- U 0 0 0) ~
(.) C/) L...tI
~;(ijQ).3~
0)-,==:5:J,-
0) c: .~ '0 ~ 0)
~CI) _c.c
0= ~- m-
.- +-' 1ft \U -
+'" ~ .- \U .-
CJ) :> l3 O)c ~
-=J:mcO)C/)
\U (.) "I- .- L.. 0)
o .- 0) C/) L.. ._
.c~co:]~
0) ~ ~ (3 (.) .~
~ C/) C/) CO) 0) t)
+'" "0 .- J:
"I-L..x +",m
o m 0) ~"I- 0)
+"'"0 0) 0) 0 C/)
cC~Q)~O)
O)m+"'-:>J:
E +'" "I- Q. 0) +'"
0. en 0 E 'S; ~
O(1)Co=~
Q)"Oo(.):]~
> o~ ~~-o
0) () N .0 .- 0)
"0 O)'c (I) :5 10
(]) c L.. '- .- .-
L.. .- 0) ca ~ (.)
0)"0-0'" 0
J:=oi-oC/)
r-:]E~cc/)
:: OJ ~mm
+'"
m
~
+'"
C/)
+'"
C
0)
E
0)
-
0)
0)
+'"
m
L..
o
Q.
0) L..
+'" 0 ~
m (.) .
.- C C/)
"0._ C
0) _ 0)
E = E
E ~ 0.
0)0
O)c-
.- 0)
:532>
.- 0)
0:]-0
.0
'--orn
(I) 0) .-
..., +'"
U CJ) C
ca 0 0)
'- Q."O
ca 0 .-
-'=L..C/)
U Q. ~
~O)O)
:::J:c
c: +'" 'C
~ ~ 0
E-.c
-J:
EcaO)
~ .-
o ..., 0)
u u c
(I) (I) 0)
~:::~
...,~+'"
,..u~
....'-+'"
::: <C .~
~ :...,
... . c:
c: "0 (I)
Cl)0...,
...,Ot/)
t/) J: .-
.- L.. In
t/) 0 c:
C .0 0
o ~ u
~ .Q> 0)
. 0) L..
..' c m
..
~
.
"0
0)
L..
:]
0"
0)
L..
CI)
U
.-
~
(I)
t/)
...
o
-
(I)
>
CI)
-
...,
c:
(I)
'-
'-
~
u
CI)
~
...,
o
...,
(I)
C)
c:
ca
~
u
ca
c:
.-
...,
-
~
t/)
CI)
'-
....
o
c
-
-
.-
~
..
..
"0
C
m
~
c:
o
.-
...,
In
(I)
C)
c:
o
u
u
H:
ca
'-
...,
t/)
(I)
N
.-
E ~ .
.- c:
c:
.- 0
E;
.-
:-c
'C:
CJ) 0
~ U
:]....
"0 C
0) CI)
C/) t:
o ~
Q.u
e (I)
Q.~
0)....
J: '-
+'" (I)
o >
+'" 0
C/)...,
C/) c:
0) CI)
mE
0) CI)
"0 >
C 0
co 0-
C/) E
CJ) ._
~ C
O)ca
C .
.- .
. .
. 1""""1
..' C/)
.. .-
. .
...
o
c(
c.
:2
-
.J
c(
:)
en
-
>
"-
o
t/)
I-
t/)
~
-
ca
c
c(
=:
ca
..,
en
C
0) C 0 I
en 0 .- ro
'- ....., . -
Q)Q)~~
-6WC:!::
ro :J .~ C3
Q)-ooc
NQ) C)
.- en C).-
,~ 8..~ ~
c:032-o
.- '- .-
Ec..:J'-
=Q).o~
ro..c:'+-.....,
.c"""oo
en'+-Q)-o
o en c
Q) en :J ro
en.....,
:JUQ)C)
ro .c c
-0 c..""" · -
Q) E .c c..
en "' ro
o 1- VI U
c.. - :J en
oroe-o
'-~.cc
0.. · - ....., ro
0) > ~-
..c: C) -t en
....., c 0) '-
'+- .- c.. ~
o-oo'+-
c: :J '- :J
C) C3 o...c
1_ c: ....., en
en .- c ~
Q) en Q) U
-C+-'uro
uro.o
Q) Q) I ~ .....,
.c~-OQ)
~Q)roen
-0 -
Q)c~ ~
0) en ro 0) .-
NOQ)E U
.- 0.. c: 0)
.~ e ~ ro .0 ~
C 0.. '- · c = ....., Q)
.- Q) ....., .- ro .c
EQ):t:en~c_"O
o:5~-5w:J~Q)
.....,'+-\LIc~-o;>>
-0 0 ~ 1- U C ro e
Q)w"O"O~roQ)o..
cUO)QQ)Q)roE
C) ,"'^ "' en ._
.- \u \II c: VI "- <D
~ E"8.ro ~ g C>~
"0 .- e Q) .8 Q) ~ 'S; :: ·
~ro o..~ w.c.8 e-g
Q):JQ)c..o~enc..o
.c .~ .c 0) 0 C) '- = .c
> ~ '- -0 c: 0 .- '-
en _ ....., .- 0 ~ 0
ro C)~= :J"O"O .c
..c: c -t ~ 0 = ....., C).c
1- Q);> :J:J C
~ -0 0.. C) -0 .c 0 .- 12>
~:J CQ) c..Q)
= C3 e .- en ~ .~ ro c
U c 0..32 0 Q)..c: U
ro .- .- 0.. C ....., en 0)
'+-""":J '+--o..c:
-o2c.c >< 0) 0 c.....,
<DUO) Q)..c:.....,ro'-
enO)UO)O)"""U...,jO
o :::: .~:5 .c ~ ro "0 ';;;
c.. Q) -0 '+- I- .c 0.. <D U
o 0) ro 0 C) -0 E ....., ~
a.~cccQ)=~Q)
Q) Q) 0 ,2>:0 0> ~ .- ::;
.c>Q)w=>wEw
r- -g ~ ~ .5 8 'S; ~ ~
~
~
t)
<<
~ '
~ .
.J
<<
::J
~
>
~
~
~
<<
tD
~
~
~
~
<<
Q
o
~
,
, I
! .. ~ ,i
~~~~
.-a=1
o _..::1 ~
~'i'~~
: - ~
III: i
:l =' ~
o " ~
)0 ,
-,~ 1,'
,
IIII1IIiI
~ ~ !~
==~~
.=!
$;~ I
r~"'~
.. ~ "Q,f .~
~~~~
~~a=1
~ =;~ !
>~ 1,'
e.........i.
~"Q,f;
~~~
-a=1
$;; !
"
, 'j
, ...;
r~~!l
;~iiiil~
.-a=-
o _..::1 _
~~;i
: - ~
.. i
:l., ~
~..... 3
.~ "
VJ
~
0 -.
VJ ... I I
U ........ ........
co + +
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ... ...
~ E ~ (j) ~ a L(') CD ~ L(') a
a L(') L(') L(') a ~ N ~ ~
- N N
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
<< -
co
~
t/)
~ .-
>
I
0 ........
+
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
~ a L(') L(') L(') a a (j) ~ a
t) 0 (j) M M M (j) (j) a ex:> (j)
0
0:: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~
== ro 0
to L- -0
Q) C en
.... L- 4= c
c ro 0 0
..
Q) ~ ....J U
~ U
Q) 0 0
L- C .... ....
:= 0 ~ E .c L- .... ....
4= (.) :J Q) Q)
.0 0 :J a .... ~ ~
....J L- .... .- M Q) C
I ro L- a t Q) Q) Q)
....
I I ::> <( M <( > l- I-
. . . . . . . . .
. .
+'"
C
Q)
+'"
CJ)
.- "C
C/) 0
C 0
OJ:
(.) s....
C/) 0
.- .n
~~
:'!:O)
;:: . Q)
~ C
"I- Q)
m~
C+'"
.- "?-
m 0
~ s....
Q)
\I::+'"
.- (.)
...J m
s....
.- m
IJ:
~ (.)
Q) Q)
z=
(1).c
~:'!:
~ ~
11\
It)
~
N
~
...
C
G)
o
I.
::::s
o
.c
I.
ca
:L
I
11\
CJ)
It)
~
!
o
.J
ca
r::
I-
I.
ca
:E
r::
~
...
Q.
:::J
I
..
~
It)
~
......t.
- .. "Q,f,~
e~7~
.__1.1
~.=I
~.:.~~
s .... i
)o.~ i
"~ \'
..
o
,..
N
~
~
I
M
1ft
...
N
t,c
.....
"
.....
~
~
.
"
..c
~
.....
~
"
~
"
Ioow
.
'W
....
"
"
~
--....
"
'W
.
~
f1#
~
~
'W
r.JJ
~
o
.~
~
~
U
.~
~
~
<
Q)
U
~
.~
~
>
,,)
/1
/ ,:) /
~ .'~. "
\ . --.., l
, >( I
'I. .1
", - \ '~
~ ~ I~
-...... /Z
f":.! ~ ~
.~B
.-~
I -- ;
..~ ;
I~~
\ . {\ ;;')
I
.<:-'
"
.1
w
:z:
~
o
,...
~
ct
o
0..
IJ)
IJ)
C
0..
ct
::)
o
>-
,,)
'\ ~\
~
.
.....
::
=
..
-
Q.
e
=
~
~
~
=
~
~
-
~
~
~
=
.....
~
~
::
~
..
rI).
~
~
~
~
I
=
~
=
;.
~
~
.....
..
~
~
~
::
=
..
..
=
~
~
~
.....
::
Q.
rI).
..
~
.
~
..
=
t
;.
~
~
.....
= ....
\C
::t'
= .
\C
~\C....
_ r-.-
~ ril ·
f ~ >
....
=l()~
~~QO
=
~ .. ....
rI). .. ~
~ = ..
~ Q.
:: .. ..
~ ~ ..
e !IIIIl .....
=00.
e u ;.
= ~ ~
~ ~ ~
;. .. ::
~>=
~
=~~
.....=~
00.
.
M
..
rI).
~
=
rI).
=
=
.....
00.
m
c
.-
C/)
+'"
-
:J
en
Q)
s...
,......,
en
c
o
.-
C/)
.-
>
o
s...
0.
Q)
"'C
o
o
"C
Q)
.-
s...
m
>
........
Q)
J:
+"'~
~s...:
-e Q)
Q) C
o.~
o 0
s...
0.Q)
en:5
.-
J: C
+'" 0
'+-0.
o ::J
Q) 0.
0.._
m~
J: C/)
en"'C
s...
- m
~~
U) '-
:J CO
C-
:J a
of
+'" m
Q) 0.
::J
o
..
..
...
..
.
C/)
c
o
.-
+'"
m
o
o
s...
Q)
~
+'"
o
o
+'"
Q)
-
.c
m
o
.-
-
a.
0.
m
~
-
-
m
s...
(])
c
Q)
0)
.
.
+'"
o
C
.
"'C
C
m
Q)
+'"
en
C/)
.-
~
+'"
o
+'"
Q)
::J
c-
.-
C
:J
Q)
s...
m
U)
c
o
+'"
"C
C
o
o
.
..
..
...
...
.
"C
Q)
+'"
m
Q)
s...
o
~
-
Q)
+'"
m
s...
Q)
.c
.-
-
Q)
"C
.
+'"
o
C
.
"C
C
m
o
.-
E
o
c
o
o
Q)
+'"
o
c
en
0.
.-
J:
C/)
"C
s...
m
~
..
..
o
+'"
en
s... C/)
Q) Q)
~ 0
+'" 0
o m
o 0
+-' :=
C/).c
::J :J
00.
'C Q)
::J~
. ~ +'"
C
.- '+-
s... 0
o c
Q) 0
s... .-
m+'"
'+- 0
- ::J
Q) s...
~(j)
o c
.- 0
- 0
.c
:J Q)
0.J:~
o I- Q)
+'" s...
_ ~ m
m+",~
+'" .- Q)
C C ~
Q) '0 >
E .- 0
> .-
.- -
';;Q).c
Q) ~ :J
"'C+",Q.
Q) .~ Q)
.cC/):5
+'" +'"
o C Q)
C Q) 2:
= E Q)
.- Q) C/)
~ > Q)
Q) 0 s...
os... 0.
C 0.=
m E .-
.-.- ~
s... .
m s... .
> 0 ~
O)~Q)
ctn;
.- Q) ~
co.>
m 0 Q)
s...s...J:
0) 0. +'"
..
..
s...
o
Q)
s...
~
'+-
o
s...
Q)
0)
c
m
"C
Q)
~
+'"
Q)
C/)
m
Q)
s...
o
c
s...
o
c
o
.-
+'"
C/)
Q)
0)
c
o
o
o
~
m
s...
+'"
(]) C'-.
C/) .
m ~
Q)+'"
s...~
o m
.~ C/)
~o
rn:5
:;:; ::J
C 0.
2 Q)
en~
.c+'"
::J '-
C/) (])
+",0)
o c
c m
_"C
c
~ Q)
..
..
: j
r'..~ ,~
~'--~~
.-11'
o . "I _
~~I;i
c
~ - ~
- i
S -.:. ~
~ "'. 3
~ '1',
Qd
o
Q
:j
~
Q:
o
t)
)
~
s
+'"
m
~
+'"
+'"
(])
Q)
L..
+'"
C/)
CJ)
Q)
1J
.-
>
o
L..
0.
Q)
+'"
.-
C/)
~
Q)
C 0 E
Q)+'" e
~Q) '+-
+"'::J L..
1"0 0
-0
1i) 0 'C
.- ::J Q) L..
XC-CO
Q) .- 0
C/)-
CJ) ::J ~ ~
Q)+"'tQ)
o m Q) ._
-0 1i) 0. >
o.Q)em
.- ~ a.. C/)
~+'" Q)
~O~-o
L.. +'" ::J . -
m-oO>
.!:Q)ene
C/)L.. Q.
"0 ~~ E
.~ E+"'o
'+- Co
-00 0 L..
C 0 ~
I'I'CC/).::t.>
\U I'I'C 0 0
- \U m ~
~o.cC/)~
o"O+"'16m
L.. .- Q) 0 -0
o.t:C/)I"\O
0.0... ~+'"
mOLO'+-1i)
CJ) ~ ~ 0 ._
-g .~ ro 5 ~
Q)>C~;t-'
E~~~~
EO"O.QQ)
oc"E~.g
o m \U
Q)~
L.. C . .
~ Q)
2 C
enm
J:
+J
f'..
co
~
~
tJ
~
~
~
~
~
tJ
<
QQ
~
~
VJ
;
t
=
o
~
r------~-l
I
i · i
I
I · i
I
I : i
I
\ . ~
I
\ i
I
\
I
I
j
I
I
1
I
I
I
.c.c~ ns
U~(I) Q)
.- ~ ns Q) ..., ~
-;>~-""c<(
.g>d-~nseC)
no ns "'..., "0 'I- C
~ .c Q. ~ ~ ._
"'o~UQ)nsQ)~
-cu="";>
~ ns Q) Q) 0 ns .~
<(~m~m~>
...
~
.....
"-
'....
-....
~
~
...
..c
~
......
~
"
\J
"
..
.
'-
.....
"
~
........
......
"
~
~
#JI
~
,
~
'"
~
o
.~
rJJ.
~
~
u
~
o
U
w
:z:
~
o
~
~
ct
o
0..
IJ)
IJ)
C
0..
ct
::)
o
>-
,,)
,;,
"
'.
/1
/ . i
,1
,
: J ~\,!~
5-.~~
. ~ Q.
,.. ~
...~~
..~ ;
~!
\
. -; -#",
\',\
.....,
;. Q)
0 QJ !
, =
~
.... = (])
rIl r-.... .. ~
.... ~ rIl .. L.
~ == .. ro
~ QJ ;. =
CJ Q :: :J
= == ..
== ;. cr
~ 0 == QJ
.... .. ~ .... en
QJ :: ..
. QJ rIl .. 0
QJ 0 rIl QJ ;. U
.... = = 0
== ~ QJ .. ~ =
CJ .. 0
QJ ;. ~ ~ rIl
.. = ~ ..
. ~ ~ .. 0
u == = .. rIl ==
;. .. QJ QJ .. ~
QJ QJ 0 ~ Z Q ~
. .
= == rIl .. .. .. -0
.. ::
~ CJ = QJ ~ :: QJ c
~ 0 .. .... ~
. .. . = == ro
:: ~ ..
0 ~ 0 rIl QJ ~ .. QJ == en
== == CJ = ~ u .. .....,
~ . QJ :: ~ = ~ c
~ == . ~ ~ ==
.. CJ . QJ ~ Q)
~ = ~ = . QJ . ::
.. 5
QJ ~ ~ ~ ~ = = E
rIl = == :: ~ ;.
:J rIl .. I 1::u
= .. . QJ ~ ..
= ..
= ~ = .. rIl ::
U rIl .. .... .. ro._
~ .... QJ ~ ~ QJ rIl U c..~
~ == QJ ~ QJ .:
= I .. ;. = QJ e QJ roro
t) ....
~ ~ QJ ~ U . ~ .. .: '-
rIJ. . .. ~ (0"""
QJ ~ = == = 0 == ....
~ > = .... Z 0 1'--0
rIl QJ ==
= = .. .. .... -.
.. ~ ~ QJ ~ .. L.. I(])
0 QJ CJ .... e ~ QJ e . Q)
.. == == = QJ Q = -en
CJ e ~ QJ 00 = CJ .. .... > .- ro
t) = ~ = e ......... 0 :: == ~ = Q) ~Q)
~ QJ
~ Z ;. ~ = e '- Q)'-
QJ .... == ~
II .. .. .. QJ QJ ,-u
~ ~ II = ~ > ~ == 0 ..
== CJ ;. ::::::c
:: . =
. rIl ~ ~ ~ .... 0 ro'-
. .. = .... .. = QJ
U ~ .. ;. .. ~ ::J ~II
.. \C ~
. .. QJ = cr c_
.... ~ rIl r-.... QJ CJ .... QJ
~ == .. ;. Q)'-
== ~ QJ .... = ~ en
~ .. CJ QJ .. = -o~
.. 0 > QJ rIl
= QJ . == .. QJ :J
QJ :: .. ~ rIl .- Q)
~ .... == = ;. Q QJ .....,
.... rIl =.. ~ ro en,-
= = .. > Q),+-
+ .. rIl . . QJ .. .....,
~ QJ ....== .. QJ ~ rIl .... en ~o
~ .. =QJ e > ~ =
CJ CJ ==.... QJ 0 .. =
~ = = = = ....
.. == .. :: I .. A A
~ ~ e~ u = ~ QJ
0 = QJ = ....
;. = .. e ~ ..
N - == - ~ -
~ Z ~ U == <
Vi ~ ~
A A A A A A A A A A
!' ~~'.~
~~7;
.__e
2....,c1
~ .. ~
: I ; i
- - ..
5 -,. i
)00 "'.' I-
': ~ 3
,~
I
w
o
en
z
o
u
~
:>
o
>-
0::
o
u.
:>
o
>-
~
Z
<{
I
~
.~
Ki
oj
o <~
>,~ z'"
O .., A -
'" -
~r~ ~~
CI)~ + <:
I i ~~
:::, !-:&:
" f.'
.... .~
~:t :3~
~ .....
<'- -..
I~ -~
c3i - '.
.1 1 ,t-,\1lJl
I II, 1 " i ij I
I -\1\ 1 19 1 I I U i I ~ I I ~ I
I~~I I~ I I I II II I I ! I I I
I~~ 1 I, I ~ I II j I ~ I ! ! I
L_~_~~~_~_~_l_~_J _~_~_l_l_J
-T T-T-T-T-T-T
I ,. I I Ii I'~ jbLI I I I I I i
I 191' I I: I ~ !I I I I I !
, J T l~r'.l -r ,..1 - Jl.T .I.,W. " Jl, -'..' Jl.. "I ,. .!l"r - J T J,1' .1.'1" .1'1
lL I l' I I I I' I 'I I' I . I I' I ,
I lri 1 I I I I : II I I !I !I il I I I ~ I 1 I I U II I i
I .It I JL .L I '. JI U JL II JL .I JL I .L ,r ...L I .L I JL II J I
I(NT T I ~T 11' 11' 11' T T I I
"H: : : ~. : : : : ~ : : ~ I
I I -,vbl I I I I I
L '" .,1,. ._ J.., ..1....". . .",1... .. L..."t, ,.....J, ,JI.,..1 ...1,.. ..1.. .J
-T-T
.1
I u."
I .\1\ 1
I(~I
I'~I
-T-T-T-T-
I 1 I I
I 1 I U
I I I i
I 1 I I
I I I I
~ ~
-
I j
I
I
I
!
.-......---
,....- ......- - .."",,,'.
-
c
m
-
a..
L-
o
o
-
LL
'0
Q)
C/)
o
C-
O
L-
a.
c
m
-
a.
I
"..~. .'..
r-- ,
I
';;;c,,'" ,:.....-=:: ...-. -' "..-
L-
o
o
-
LL
-
m
c
.-
0)
.-
L-
a
c
o
.-
+'"
(.)
Q)
en
0>
c
.-
'0
-
.-
::J
co
'0
Q)
C/)
o
0.
o
L-
a..
c
o
.-
+'"
(.)
Q)
en
0>
c
.-
'0
-
.-
::J
co
m
c
.-
0>
'C
o
'=.c
-
...
. ....
.......
....
""
.
...
..c
'"
......
.......
'"
"..
"'-'
'"
~
......
......
...
~
.......
.......
""
:w
:w
~
~
,.
~
....
~
E:=
~
~
o
....
....
Q:
o
Q.
U')
U')
C
Q.
Q:
:;::)
o
>-
~. J ~
[ill ~
--
.,.,..
.jIjIIIf
il~
;\~ i~'~
\ <5' ~ \
~,A
",4',,/.,0'/
//<><> l
<r;\ ,j. {
...,1
"'<,'/
I
.
I"'"
(,)
Z
"'"
i.i
"'"
Q.
)(
"'"
c::l
!i
l-
e
.0
cr,\
""'.
1-'
e
~
~
t)
~
:1
~~
~tn
Qo ~.
~~
rn~
Q
~~ ~
~t)
t)~
7Q
=~
ilil =
~
t
~
~
?,.
$-4 ~ "'0
rfJ ~ Q)
C bJ)~.s >
o ~ 0 f\ 0
.~ 0 ~ rfJ d
~~~~~
$-4oQ)8~~
8. ::: CIJ 0 .n
~ ~~
0;;:: a.> 0. ';
8~~S~
.~ ~ Q).~
c'Q) .~ ~
a.> ::: CIJ 0 CIJ .
CIJ ::: ~ I-< '0 ~
~~roEo;:::
o $-4 $-4 ~ ~ .~
f"'\ ~ ~ ~ $-4 U
...... 0. "0 - · .... C\l
bJ) .~ Co) ~ ~
::: 8 Z3 a.>.s a.>
';j · .... ~..g ~ ..c
rfJ > 0""'" ~
· .... I-< " 0 a.>
~ a.> a.> ~ a.> "0
a.> CIJ N c CIJ....
Q) ~ ;.:= ~ .~ rfJ
\J .~ .:i 0 C
~ ::: ~ ~ :::' ....
~ clj r-J
r..~~
.. .. ~ ..
o ~ "
~... :
.......~
~..,cl
~ I .. a
~...~;
e -,'I!Il !
"'.!IEi 3
, t
~
VJ
~
o
~
t:
~
~
=
o
~
j j
~
E:
~
~
Q)
~
0) 0
~~
rJ). ~ on
~~~
~ on' ~ .~
. ~ ~ ~.t::
:g~0)t=
~ 0 ~ .~
~~
~ rJ) 0) Q)
0) on a
onNO
~~~~ ~
.~ . ~..c rJ). ~
rJ). ~ u ~O)
.~ ~.~ 0) "'C
~ ~..c O).~
0) on~~ ~
rJ). 0 0) ~
" ~ rJ)
~ 0 0) ~.~
.~ ~ ~ 0) ~
~ ..c'~ > 0)
.~ u ~ 0) >
~ E O)~~<r,
~=
I .~
O)~~
..c 0
~e~
~ ~
00)0)
I ~ e
0) ~ rJ).
ta rJ)
~,~"'C
rJ). ~ ~
C'd ~ ~
Q) "0 0)
N E'~ ril
~ C'd 0 ~
.~ ~ ~. ~
= ~ 0) :g
~ o..c ~
~ ~o
.~ ',-,
>~O)~
;> 0) ~ on
~'S~~
.~ ~.S.~
~ e e.~
.~ 0 ~ ~
~ U 0) 0)
~ 0)
~ ..c
0) ~
5 8
~Q)~
'E~~
C'd O)'~
t~:g
o~ ~
~~~
.5 ~ Q)
~rJ)...c
rJ).~~
oo~
e ~ 0
0) on ~
~.~ 0
~ I'I\.~
~ IJJ ~ .
~ : ~.:S
0) = 'e~ :-=
~ O.~ g
o.sC)~
.:'jt...,~ I 'i)
, l' ,l) _ I
,I 'J
,t
" I
",' .. ~ .'~
J: .. ~ _
.. ~ <<
o t
~ "
........i
~...a=~
~ I ; ~
~... ~
~ - ~
~ -, j
-"",,'
t)
~
~
~
=~
~~
~:J
<<~
~=
>~
O~
=0
~=
:!~
ilil ~
E<
~
~
m~ ~
Q) en Q) 0
(.) '-.- m
mOen>=>
'+- C .- ~._ ._
..c L.. ~ L..
~..c +'" m a.
c~~Ec"O
Q) ~ .- .- C) C
> ~ L.. .-
L.. - > 0. C/) CO
L..-> Q)
B~ m"O~
C/)Q)~O~+:i
+"'+",Q)CQ)Q)
C Q)~ c~
Q) L..o :J "0 Q) 1ii
"0 .cc Q)
.- C m ~
C/) 0 Q) +'" ro
Q)oo.~ "'Q)
C::~mmo>
.- - 0 ~ "0 0
C C> C/) Q) ._ L..
Q):J"O>t:o.
> C C 'C 0 E
<{ m ~ "0 0 .-
+"
o
c
Q)
~
rn
(/)
en
c
.-
"0
.-
::J
CO
I
+"
()
Q)
Co ~ ~ ~
= 0 ()
Q) C>~m c
> .~ t B t
.- a. Q) Q) 0
~ t) CO 0. C/) 0.
Q)rooo", Q)
C/) ~ en L.. 0 0::
L.~"O Q.~ '+-
m \U C Q) +'" \P-
o. C m .- rn
(/):J...J~~cn
-.
.-
+"
C
Q)
>
<(
(/)
t:
rn
~
"0
~
.-
....J
I
~Q)
N
.-
(/)
Q)
E
rn
(/)
Q)
.c
+"
~
Q)
+"
rn
E
'x
o
~
0.
0.
rn
~
m
+'"
o~ "-
Z Q)
:>.E5....
mQ)~o
~Elo..."O
Q) m ._
Q) C/) E t
> .- 0
.- m lo...
owa..O
'" ~~ L
z: I}
~ .~
0 ~~ "
.. r
. 1.1
0 ...= I
~
'" C
'II
C i,~ g
~ ..
- i
:l
0
)0 i
, ,
~~ '~
~~~
......1.1
...a=!
5:; i
~ \
>-
l-
Ll:
ill
0> a..
c 0
"0 Ll:
+.i 'S Q) a..
~m~o
. ,
co
o
0)
~
f'..-E
0-
0) ro .- 0)
. ~ ~ ~
<D0)0> Z
Oa>c
0) ~ .- 0) 0)
. u a. .c "0
\,{) C ro ... .-
oou O)~
0) U CJ) ... ._
~ ~ -g ,~~
a.o>ro EO
~~.....J ~E
CO)O) 0)_
o 0> "0
... ro ~ .~.~
U-o> :>
roo. ro a. ~ .c
~ ... u
E o)u 0 :::.c
- u:>
ro'" ro:>
O)~"O ~c
~ ~ ~ ~ .Q
ro c ... 0) 16
o>O)c c~
0) ~ .- 0)
z~O)ro~a.
oUS~f-O
Z .. .
111111I11111111111111. JIIIIIII 11111 111I 1111
CFN 2005R0060205
OR Bk 23010 P9S 2650 - 2694; (45p9S)
RECORDED 01/19/2005 15:21:29
HARVEY RUVIHr CLERK OF (:OU~:T
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GARY COHEN AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST )
NO. 72-LT-8-U/A/D JUNE 15, 1992 )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff,
v.
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, et al.,
Defendants.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND
FOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION
CASE NO. 04-10226-CA-06
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
SEITLEMENT AGREEMENT
This Settlement Agreement ("Agreement") is made and entered into this~day
of January, 2005, by and between HI LIFT, LLC, a Florida limited liability company
(collectively known as "Hi-Lift"), as successor in interest to GARY COHEN AS
TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72-LT-8-U/A/D JUNE 15, 1992("Trustee") and
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC, a foreign limited liability company, and A VENTI
A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, a foreign limited liability company (collectively,
"A venti"):
1. Nonnan Cohen, and others, entered into a Trust Agreement dated June 15,
1972, and known as Trust Number 72-LT-8. All references contained in this
Agreement to "Trust" mean the Trust just described.
2. Gary Cohen is the duly appointed successor Trustee of the Trust is the
owner, as Trustee, of the real property described in Exhibit "A" attached to this
Agreement and by reference incorporated into this Agreement. All references
contained in this Agreement to the Trust Property" mean the real property described
in Exhibit "A" and to Gary Cohen as "Trustee".
3. The Trust Property is a private canal and is subject to the restrictions and
easements as contained in an Easement Agreement which is recorded in Official
Record Book 3185, Page 743 of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida
and a Notice to Preserve Easement Agreement recorded in Official Record Book
20362, Page 3037 of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida. Copies of
the Easement and Notice are included as Exhibit "B" and collectively referred to as
the "Easement".
4. Defendants A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, a
foreign limited partnership and its general partner PRE OP V, INC., a foreign
corporation, were the fonner owners of the property more particularly described in
Exhibit "C", attached to this Agreement and by reference incorporated into this
Agreement.
5. Defendants, Aventi, are the present owners of all of the unsold
condominium units and all of the "Boat Slip Units", as defined and described in those
certain condominium documents recorded by Aventi at Official Record Book 22609,
Page 1256, of the Public Records of Miami Dade County, Florida, and located on the
above-noted property. The property described in Exhibit "C" is subsequently referred
to in this Agreement as "Aventi Parcel". Aventi's Parcel is subject to the restrictions
in the Easement.
6. Hi-Lift, LLC ("Hi-Lift, LLC"), is the owner of the property more
particularly described in Exhibit "D" attached to this Agreement and by reference
incorporated into this Agreement. The property described in Exhibit "0" is
subsequently referred to in this Agreement as "Hi-Lift Parcel". The Hi-Lift Parcel is
subject to the restrictions in the Easement.
7. Hi-Lift is the assignee of a Contract for Sale and Purchase with Trustee to
purchase the submerged lands shown on Exhibit "E" (the "Purchase Agreement")
and, pursuant to said contract will, upon closing, acquire Trustee's rights to enforce
the restrictions in the Easement, as well as the right to dismiss or be substituted as
party plaintiff in the above-captioned lawsuit.
8. There is situated on the A venti Parcel and the Hi-Lift Parcel certain docks,
pilings, moorings and other structures affecting the navigability of the private canal
situated in the Trust Property. All references contained in this Agreement to the
"A venti Docks" mean the structures just described and labeled on Exhibit "F" and the
"Hi-Lift Docks", labeled on Exhibit "F". Exhibit "F" is attached to this Agreement
and by reference incorporated into this Agreement. The parties hereby agree and
acknowledge that, to the best of both parties' knowledge, the A venti Docks and the
Hi-Lift Docks were constructed in accordance with all requirements of affected
regulatory agencies.
9. Trustee, under the provisions of the Trust, instituted the instant proceeding
against A venti, seeking to enforce the removal of the A venti Docks. All references
contained in this Agreement to the "legal proceeding" means the legal proceeding
above-captioned.
NOW THEREFORE, for and in consideration of the foregoing recitals and other
good and valuable considerations, each paid unto the other, the receipt where it was
2
~
tfJP1
hereby acknowledged, the parties to this Agreement covenant and agree, each with
the other, as follows:
A. This Agreement will become effective either at the time of its execution
or at the time of the closing, as set forth in the Purchase Agreement, whichever is
the later. In the event, however, that such closing does not take place or the
Agreement is not effective as of January 10, 2004, either party, at its sole option,
may tenninate this Agreement and, thereafter, this Agreement shall be of no
further force and effect and each party will be free to pursue any and all legal
remedies or proceedings as if this Agreement had never been executed, without
prejudice. However, an additional precondition to the effectiveness of this
Agreement will be Hi-Lift providing to Aventi, in escrow, a Joint Motion for
Substitution of Plaintiff, whereby Hi-Lift will be substituted as party plaintiff and
attached as Exhibit "G", and a Stipulation for Dismissal, a fonn of which is
attached as Exhibit "H" and General Release by Trustee, a fonn of which is
attached as Exhibit "I". Simultaneously with the closing noted above, the General
Release shall be provided to A venti and the Stipulation for Dismissal filed with
the Court along with a Joint Motion for the Court to Approve Settlement
Agreement and to Retain Jurisdiction to Enforce, a fonn of which is attached as
Exhibit "J".
B. Other than as expressly set forth herein, the tenus of this Agreement
shall not be deemed to alter or modify any of the tenus or provisions of the
Easement. The purpose of this Agreement is to affinn the rights of the parties to
maintain, expand or modify the Aventi Docks and Hi-Lift Docks as set forth in
this Agreement and the Easement and for the parties to acknowledge that the
A venti Docks and Hi-Lift Docks shall not be deemed a violation of the provisions
of the Easement. Except.. as provided by this Agreemen~ nothing in this
Agreement shall be constituted as decreasing the rights or obligations of the
parties under the Easement or to grant to A venti or Hi-Lift any additional rights.
C. Simultaneously with the execution of this Agreement or upon the
closing of the Purchase Agreement, whichever is the later, the legal proceeding
shall be dismissed, with prejudice, including Defendants A VENTURA
APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AND PRE GP VI, INC., even
though not parties hereto. The dismissal shalI not be construed as a bar to any
cause of action arising in the future by reason of any violation of the Easement or
this Agreement occuning subsequent to this date except to the extent that A venti
has.. fulfilled its obligations pursuant to Paragraph F hereof, in which case this
dismissal shalI constitute a bar against any cause of action against A venti. The
parties hereby agree that each and every one of them shall not and will not assert,
in any legal, administrative or other proceeding that, directly or indirectly asserts
that the A venti Docks and the Hi-Lift Docks, as described in this Agreement, are
not in compliance with the Restrictions and any and all applicable pennits and/or
any other envirorunental or other governmental approvals, pennits, or other
permissions.
3
D. Hi-Lift hereby releases A venti from any and all claims, causes of
action, or damages arising out of or in connection with the A venti Docks as they
exist as of the date of this Agreement and as shown on Exhibit "F" and such other
matters which were alleged, or could have been alleged, in the Legal Proceeding
or arising out of the Easement Agreement, except for the specific obligations
contained in this Agreement.
E. A venti hereby releases Hi-Lift from any and all claims, causes of
action, or damages arising out of or in connection with the Hi-Lift Docks as they
exist as of the date of this Agreement and as shown on Exhibit "F" and such other
matters which were alleged, or could have been alleged, in the Legal Proceeding
or in any counter-claim or cross claim that were filed or which could have been
filed in the Legal Proceeding, except for the specific obligations contained in this
Agreement. Moreover, A venti will cause this Agreement to be recorded and
thereby become a covenant running with the land for each and every "boat slip
owner", as that term is more specifically defined in the condominium documents
recorded by Aventi at Official Record Book 22609, Page 1256, of the Public
Records of Miami Dade County, Florida, and that Aventi's obligations,
thereunder, shall be limited to requiring that each an every ''boat slip owner" shall
accept, by deed, the provisions of this Agreement, in a form substantially in
accordance with the deed attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit "K".
F. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, Aventi's
obligations, hereunder shall be fulfilled, in toto, when and to the extent, that
A venti sells or otherwise transfers the above noted Boat Slip Units by the deed
described herein and, thereafter, A venti shall have been deemed to have satisfied
its obligations hereunder as to Boat Slip Units no longer owned by Aventi.
G. Each party shall bear its own costs and attorneys' fees in connection
with the legal proceeding and the settlement of the legal proceedings.
H. Hi-Lift hereby grants to A venti a perpetual easement in favor of and
appurtenant to Aventi's Parcel for the sole purpose of maintaining the Aventi
Docks as they exist as of the date of this Agreement, except as otherwise set forth
herein. This grant of easement to be subject to the following conditions:
i. This grant shall not be construed as an Agreement by Hi-Lift
permitting or authorizing A venti to expand, enlarge, alter or enhance any of the
A venti Docks in any manner or to place additional structures on the A venti
Property.
ii. A venti shall be authorized only to maintain the A venti Docks
substantially in their present condition and to repair or replace such structures
provided such repair or replacement does not materially enlarge, alter or enhance
the A venti Docks or otherwise interfere with the purposes of the Easement, as
4
amended by this Agreement.
1. Subject to existing pennits and applicable governmental regulations,
A venti hereby grants to Hi-Lift a perpetual easement in favor of and appurtenant
to Hi-Lift's Parcel for the sole purpose of maintaining the Hi-Lift Docks as they
exist as of the date of this Agreement. This grant of easement to be subject to the
following conditions:
i. Except as otherwise pennitted in this Agreement, this grant
shall not be construed as an Agreement by Aventi pennitting or authorizing Hi-
Lift to expand, enlarge, alter or enhance any of the Hi.Lift Docks in any manner or
to place additional structures on or adjacent to the Hi-Lift Property.
ii. Except as otherwise pennitted in this Agreement, Hi.Lift
shall be authorized only to maintain the Hi-Lift Docks substantially in their
present condition and to repair or replace such structures provided such repair or
replacement does not materially enlarge, alter or enhance the Hi-Lift Docks or
otherwise interfere with the purposes of the Easement, as amended by this
Agreement.
J. A venti, as the existing owner of the "Boat Slip Units", or the successor
Boat Slip Unit owners, by virtue of taking title to the "boat slip units" subject to
the deeds set forth in Paragraph E above, hereby agree, and hereby grant an
easement to Hi-Lift, to allow the expansion of the Hi-Lift Docks eastward on,
adjacent and/or contiguous to A venti's property as long as extension of said docks
or operations does not unreasonably interfere with Aventi's use and utilization
and/or navigability of Aventi's Docks and as long as Hi.Lift obtains any and all
pennits or governmental approvals required by law and as long as any such
expansion does not violate any of Aventi's governmental approvals or pennits.
A venti, or the Boat Slip Unit owners, as the case may be, hereby agree to
cooperate with Hi-Lift in the processing of any required pennits or governmental
approvals that may be required for any such expansion including, without
limitation, execution of required consents, pennissions, letters of no objection
and/or joinder in ,any such applications (at no cost and expense to Aventi). Aventi
or the Boat Slip Unit owners, as the case may be, agree to execute any such
approvals, consents or joinders promptly and without any unreasonably delay or
modification. '
In addition, subject to applicable governmental pennits and regulations,
A venti hereby agrees to allow Hi-Lift to relocate the nine (9) existing slips
adjacent to the Aventi Parcel, at Hi-Lift's option and sole cost and expense. Any
such removal and relocation of said slips may be to a location, in Hi-Lift's sole
discretion, within the area shown on Exhibit "L". However, in any such
relocation, Hi-Lift hereby agrees that it will provide to any then existing Boat Slip
Unit Owners with an equal 'or equivalent dock at such location prior to requiring
the Boat Slip Unit owner to cease the use of its existing slip. Equal or equivalent
5
slip shall be a slip that is of the same length and capable of dockage of the same
size vessel that the Boat Slip Unit Owners maintained at its previous location, as
well as the provision of the same or better amenities then existing that were
available to serve the prior slip, such as electric connection or other now existing
amenities. A venti, or the Boat Slip Unit owners, as the case may be, hereby agree
to cooperate with Hi-Lift in the processing of any required pennits or
governmental approvals that may be required for any such relocation including,
without limitation, execution of required consents, pennissions, letters of no
objection and/or joinder in any such applications (at no cost and expense to
A venti). A venti or the Boat Slip Unit owners, as the case may be, agree to execute
any such approvals, conserits or joinders promptly and without any unreasonably
delay or modification and A venti will provide in its deed for any Boat Slip Units
owners to agree to amend, if necessary, any and all condominium documents that
may be required to effectuate said relocation.
K. This Agreement shall be recorded in the Public Records of Miami-Dade
County, Florida and shall be deemed a covenant running with the land and shall be
binding upon and inure to the benefit of the parties hereto, their successors and
assigns and the owners, from time to time of the Aventi and Hi-Lift Parcels.
L. Hi-Lift represents that it is the successor to the Trust for purposes of
this Agreement.
6
HI LIFT, LLC
A Florida limited liability company,
By: Hi Lift Partners, LLLP,
A Florida limited liability limited partnership,
As its Manager,
By:
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC, a Delaware limited
Liability company
By:
Name: II e Mendelson
Title: Vice-President
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, a Delaware
Limited liability company
By: fie
Name: II Mendelson
Title:' Vice .President
7
I
. .
tIlf ""rlllllW'lll~ rft""".... .... .~. ;:.;".':.:..-...... lECUIRIIlPlf' rJ nI ','
. .... CIIl Ylr 1I11ll00ICITS ''''' -. ,
_U -. QI1NSfI1UU loa PfIlW/Cllr UIClDPMlTClGUPHIC
MlUCM MTlC," ~ '
AlfI_fllII I I
ld '2!- COURTHOUSE TOIlER ~ ~
.. III ILIIlO LOt&1l'~ DrMY C::.~.cun ciw
.. . .
"
, ,
. .
~~: 1562 4r~346T
~
. A portion 01 the N! 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the 8W 1/4 and & portion
01 the North 1/2 of the South 1/2 of the 8E lit of Fractional Sec.
tIGu 3, Township 52 South, Rl&nq.'42 Eist, Dar!. County, Florld&,
belllg pIltlcWl, described as follows: .
Commence at the Northwest come 01 the HIli' of the BE 1/' '
or the SW 1/401 Blkl Fractional ~etlon 3; thene. fUll Soutl1 000
39125" West along the West boUllda.ry 01 the HE 1/4 of the SE 1/4
of the SW 1/. of Fractional Sect loll 3 , dlltarlce of 205: 59 feet to
the polnt of lntel'8eetlon wlth a lIn. tbat 11 paraJle1 to Qi 126 flit
North 01 the North boundlJ'y 01 ~. South !tJ..o~ the BE 114 of the
SW 1/4 of elld. Fractional Sectlo11 SI thence 1'Wl South SgoSS'OS"
Eaal alon; the lut described line a dlstanc. of SO f.et to \hI Palm
of 8~lmllni of the parcel o11a114 bertlllde: to be deacrlbt4j
thence continue on the ast described cOursel dlltanc. of 818.95
, feet to the point of Inle:uctlon wUh the Eut boUlldary of the sw 114
ot laid fractional Section 3j thence run South .89068'lSQ lut 110" '
a line that Is parallel to and 125 teet North ot tbe North bolllldat1
. of the South 1/2 of the North 1/2 of the South 1/2 of the BE 1/4 of
'llel Fractional Section 3 & dIStance of lest. 02 flet to I polat;
thence rUll North 00031'50' WOlt 11 dlatlnco of 100 feet,.atOr. 0:
Ius, to the lutersecUon with the North blIIk ot &11 txlatlnq CaDalj
thenee rWl Westerly along t~e North b&Jlk of &11 exlstlr.1 cw1;-btlnq
alonq the South bOWldaryof the parcel conveyed to\!Aule ~Ultrlel,
tnc., by Warranty Deed med all J'anIllLl11S, 1958, In Otflclal Re..
cord Book '630 at Paqe 6? ot the P\d)llc Recorda 01 J)dll eoUlltf, '
Florida, a dlst&l1ce of 1906. 15 reet, mort 01' lel8, to lbe Southwelt
cornel' ot Uol'l,lIld parcel; thellCe l'\Ul. South eS0611M" Wut . dll.
tance of tOO. 03 feet to . point; thence run South 0008i'25- East ,
distance ot 111.10 feet to the Point of BlqIllD1ng.
'.., ,'.. e~'H~elf"""'1!f.:: ," ....,.tII.",.,""':
N I~DQCUMEHT^RYS ~
: FlORI A SURT^X! ~
- '!fF' ,;........... ' .. ., = .
':'
,.'
,..\.., ,0,
... ..
, i; , " " I ,,", ,," ::' ,,:,J':-, :,..,'..:, ,,:: "! ;.: ;"::;,:\~.;"'\+-,, :~;
.,
l,~
.EXHIBIT
A-
I ,
,
I!: I ~0265
. ,,,... - .
. .
110', 121
, Clttlc1a PUa lIa. 621.""
ru." ,,"'" 6. 1.
lJ.l\R1l!Rltt AllBBKYE1!I. "tellm4 III ..~ )185...... 'Ill)
XIIO'I'~ MIlf ur 'tllEIIB ~
TIIlI, WIIF.IW/I, It/.. ~\OlIldl, 1, ltM, IIIlI ttcOrtldJl 0, R.
. IlOIik O'lD al J!aI14 <(lIS, th.J.\ r.G~ _,.It, A".AIl 'f2PJ.ar:Ar.e OF J'LOAIDA, .
. . -
Slla., . tl'ltW:l f.oIl'''.U,oft, ':IlIIn1"'~' Ir'Il'l1t MDP. A'~""', nlC. ~ I....
1IIll'........,"' VI'I'iP. .IllI'It-I"".lIAl4 4.,.-1, "'''~, .,.I~ I". t. ~l. '\\0 .111I4 q.
"'th~'ll'Ihl'~,':nr~ 1\''''''.6+iats'Jc.''Il'JlI~~:..\M.r, ,'M .
. '8111<<"Y.~n. 1'7 ~ '~Il\.\II,'llt1y I. I:... ~ .M M{r.~ .II~ f). II. ...
~ . 0'l0 nt ""J~ """, ll. II. iWJI'IM, II\" 1I,l:"I+"ll; a::-:;,:':'I' .~\"'t. JnIMcl
b,J kin wit". rnAlICI~ On IJnP.l\, f.1Ill'I~u1 ~ I=' 11l'1" Dt\;it: M:IlU, IIfC.,
U'I,,",.t\ ~ 'r/'lr.,u.'n, It.'' :"l'Ilunl prllf...nl :!. .t'lln I. i': :L"l. :1hIt:lI nJ4
'sr"~1 .,,:. "~; !', 1.... t ,~ "."'.l ::ir:ll w..! 'I. . . ';.,".,,1 '. ': k ,',,; '~4 tG't,
.01 I. '''''/j 'l,l
'.t;.:;. ".f'.:..; ':; ..'U t..sU'.~:. t. .,.~ . ,', .....:I~..t:,11
. .
d.:-~ VI.,N .t...1I, :: '.C..' ~\>f ~bhll. ",:'1.: ..! i .rj ." . I '; .' i :"':"':: 1,!~l"Illo,
.'
1M! dlIllJr:lIlllt, 1I111l111'.'.::-....1'II ~A I:::l!'l= .1. '/I, ~~ t~w U.'! f~l/.'A 10 IIIe llIO
' "
. or tb4l1;ll~ -\ tAr ~iltl"&:l allIl iiIlIloIrJ 1.'1:;-.r,..I. :Ill "r~ ~M ~'Ie31l7
CI'! forlll herlIbuIt~r; arA
.
WIIF.RJPJ.'. L,r 'IJ" la.'kw.t.~"'~. ~1' ~.* If. to.::;. ~~h/.,. 1leIJl~
.ta IlI'.hJ.!r.J....lfll.~:,l:'..,'..I~'!l1 r,'r L'lt. I.. !:,,'r/'lJol "',11: ..::4
.
'1111~:Il;:A.~ 1.""l',rU... bl:~\.\ ~r' ~'.l\r,'Cl .,! . : r. ,"1.1 ::IIell mlslUa,
. '. .
HCWI, 'l'IfEIIF:t'ORE. III con:llder ~:!.llI..t Illt ~""I<llnq, llI4ll1 6IrIhtr
..
tcNIlddcrallGn ~llho cwi of TtlI DtlJara "IO.l>>J" f'\Id k iI'IUl tl_ta
... .
or n.ollllA, INC.. , fIIorld& eofSllralkla, aad 1M ad4Iu.w, Il\IIll "'hi
. .
, Dollara ($lO.lIOl....ld 10 R. '1). QAU'I'If, 11\. MtllIla wtlft. 'flAMeD
. OAU'l'Il'" !hi ree.:~ w~rCOlllllcl"lL7ll,~nli'lll/ldlJfl<l, IrGm ~:oaTR DAOI
^Cll!I, QIC.. a Jl'\Ur\I~ r.orporaUOQ, III 'lI~1I ~; ~f "UI'lt 'l''''.I' allll VII~
. .
CNldarOlUon. Iha a'" ^ TU.8 TtRIoCI'l.\I./l Clt. ~I.oIUt,^, DIC." . nortcll
h I If
, .
~
i'
, . . \ I
EXIU'''~ "
. .
EXHIBIT
B
Ill: 'eolre
~..~ .
.
.
'110. 127
(aonUllCId)
, .
.. eol'tWftU~,"'; lho lI:li4.. 8. QA\m~ 1R., lOW by kI'~, raADI' ,
nAI1I'lRR, hav~ ~n41!11I)' tIItIlIO ~r,lI: 11'1. aI\.11r...lln.,~rt.<lW\ly" tlOl'l'll
.
, DADE ACIUaI. INC., 1IG 1IIIC<<ll1lO" ~ 11lI.'l1M. M ';:'::~IW~l O'lOt IhI 'IA.
I' I .
, hOl'Olllo'IIlnr _r~~I, I., llle plI'fOl:tlIl:,f(~oll r.el r~1'\II1 14 ~Il:
I. .'" t&OI Uw .ald ~_I.W"" = _ crllllllnH:l&~ 11IO 1& 111 ..
. .
lMIo:e IIVU' IIlCI b~ hill'OlIWltr "~r!!.r..Q !IIr \1;0, r,lltI111Jo.. a.1IM ~
.
\!'AIIIII "I1IIUfn II( ''',Ill. 1l,I'IJIlS, ;hll;l ;':.1 ~':'lr'" ;r, ,,1 ,I~' II,~, '/I:IWIlIIII4
.,dllo'lf::, !.':or;:';:!. .'I..tv.'...'.tl ~~,'r.llIoII: .'1
:;1 ':.. 't.u II. I ,.1~.1~ ,1:11 ::. a:....! :~.:. 01 ~:":. J:"'-:= IJla 'I~
; lr:ul/:tNl'\II!lolll trl\lG u.~ ~nd:l _.roJoll1:.j ,'II: 1M ,:'1.1 .:. '. 'lli:a.'lIJ:./ llii'll9Qlo
, .
fllllld':l\'lllt:1ld.:b 11"1 ;:-'!'I c;wl Q :. :\r.'1:I1Il ~ftd
. ~. Tu \'\"' t\ 'olI choI PNrollr1711l,o:.1l laD!:: 1:'::.1 ~::.I r,'ld ~nal ,
IIllklllllld, l'I\fI"".IIl~11 nm.lu 4Il_11 '\l,J:", 111I\1"" ,1:,."I.lll\ll CO:ll ~
IIlrol:n:_, of u~! :I'.lJ'l!I':~J 1~lId O'IIl'I'r, '~,III' ...:,~", ! In. r I!,.~ :::.m. 10_.
"
"
· slr1~:lf'lln h':~",/'ll III '" 'f\~, ill I ~M I! '\.;.' 'I ':...::.1::' :....: :',.1:,. :-.:I.!" ~ ra.
, '
. qu'~UCtQli; awl
... Tn t!..n t 1\:1 a.,d '\.,..........i: t:, 1;'",1 "II, "I " .ii. , t ~ 1M lYJIIlbud
IIac dr ll\Il ~"iitI\lJ :'~nobj PI'll'lII\lrl, L "ri'~",r. l!'.:Il :'( :11.!, '~lIlJ wUllllll
Worlofll .Ilk ~'WIIll"'.lSfItllll U~ ':wi. .
t
'i'
I
~bo craGumenllMr~ IJPllIri b ~.~ :rI,1~ l'IIl:I \fl~ lilt ltlIclaat
.
which III 1\o1I\<lIlull.. "''''tlllll'l r~ '\1'0 C"l~II",l'J 11711Io....,
Ctr u..a'llra, IIlllIr belra, I. tJprolllllllllU'o:i. ~'GMI'O '114 ....
.. tyI1,OIllOr IAIIIn III1RU", allll. "laln1~ IIlo lIIld .lIlIt,! ~C\J. UIt!lllt
~aom\loa III r1t#1m III nald ,r~" hlCllldln"UIIl rl)lll 10 '1l'an~ ~ ~.
~OOlllonla liS OIp,~. IlorolA 10 olho,r Inlllb~4r; MlrJ"" 1:wIt ld101''''''
:Illd .b.WNJIJIeIllIIl eMU prc\pel'\r, .
" .
;'
" .
. .
'I
. . \ ': . I
: ,4
"
a,
. .' .
." "
. t..,' t. ; ,. .
: .
,
.
..
"
,.
I 1
i W&o.t.
: '1 .'I'
,It \ ~,f'
;1',_
t,
i
I'
\
~
~
~I~...
,(~11l
..
T 1J LI f
.. .
'1b~ P\'IlI:~rty \fIlMll ~111l;~'~ !:..,..'tl,).. t I: ,lh.r ..rl!ll-' Ilbellltlt..
llIJl'*lSlls do;Icrlbcd ulollttl, \0 wJ~
JlftOllIRTY 0111IO BY ATI-'G 'l'WmlAl.4 01 MJWDA, 11I9.
AJ~ ~'nOr~ ' ·
'11l1tl'll'(lilft oI11lfllllUrl7 I';llllllft frl\ll\lt,r.:\l 30-* '. '
T"".1fI r4l :JllIIJI, aaa,., ~~ EAal, I'll~' ("'''''If, .'ort~
'.<If.lII:..J ~~I
Tht :tt.tu, !/).or"",oflJ., " -I'll ::1,,1\ I,' , ,11J.lt Ill/C
o\r ~l" I:" 110111 tllI,:a! :14 I\!. ::,'.'11' I Frl"~ t.tl
~"'Ur4 :'. T...II\I'.I\II' ~ .~, ,"~I, I: 1.,;-' ~~ '.: .l"r.1- e.'.QfIlF,
11..r\oh, 1.i-:"./lll'Jl....,o;t1 I. J 1+ t Cl~f..'.
l.~
. f~,
. ,
. .
AIID
,~'" llr,"," :.11.0 ,4t\ III II.: ,~ 'l\~ ;:1., (; r..,: I U:': Ii lI:l
ollt~.e Illr.! nrllla _I/h( dA :'J-: 1/4 ,., ~ro\':Uo,r.,1
::......lkl\ a, '!\'MIp ~ ~.~" I'.rlttt'II:;: :~. ~olot Collrllr,
~~~, .
1"1:..~'Eit rr aNllED BY II. 1'. ,..\!I'r.f:l', JK., :::llrllDVf.l"LY
6!:ltAll..::mJ;IUII..ll2tif.~ Ill. :,!!tl;~a. ~;\,JJ!~:.i! it;; GAIITlP.Rl
..,
"~'I p,I1I'41 ,." 11\ 0I1n1:r.7 ';'III.1IIr. trl,;I: ,'" ljo. 'II.' S,
T~~..dlll' till ~'MIlh, IlU'I'1 ~~ t:) I. r.,,!.. . "~:7, 7Ittld.t,
.~a.lrlb'~1 u:
1.Y,o(.:.lrJ:f:R at \1;" If'....rw . ! \1:.. I;t; i. i '1 ill II: 1/4
,.f Uvl ;iN 1/'1 01 Fra:\Ir'l'~ .~'l: ~~. 1. 'fl. ~,lr I: ~1lIII.
Ran'Jo14C P.locl, D*G.:llI'.1. r. I'!.L,: -:1":;~'J l"4W.
(;'l~iRIi' ".'I:It lloaJ 1114 WI':'': IIt/: n! 1M ii!: 114' 1 lilt 0&1/4
nltM G'''' 1/4 It llAI4l14':\1'" 31' r II ~1r.1~1. :~ "t ~ lU3 tHl
1111 r1Jr.t MI cIla Kahil II., 1./ \1',1' !:~::. 13! ,I) 1lt':1 of lbo N 1/1
rot 1M Kr. 1/4 01 dlo It 1/4 .'4 ~ ~.Y 1/'" no..", N SoIIIl
rd"'.lft'I!l' P.'lltllolllJ '" I~~r.h 1:1lI' nl ~2111t=a.o lett 011/1.
II 1/2 oIUo1l tIE JI4 0/ UIt :f.l/~.n' Ihe :rlll/~ r,' GIld ....
U"o I/or a rU'btoUO.O~ \.Il!;, ~"!"~1I1 ~4.lllo.ot
:l ~n tIC II tcIallllll :at. ,I; ';1.'Il'l'I rr~u~'k1 :I~rth .
I'll'W' K'~,~ _tho ~r\.'11111'l .IIMr.:'CI.I:fo.OfMloI8lt
II mOIIL't r:E l/411I\Jlll:t.I/I'.f!Lot ::t'l/~'~~~II
~Ia."hl(401 UI6 tllrIh Ilrot. f ,t,~ r.:'I(t. l~:t. " !~ ,,111'.0 H III
,II IhHI J/hl lilt D lit II ~ rr.1/~ .., : .: I :;','\10.. had I"
rll::I;;rJ.\U'tll East 'on '!:'tl\<)o !::,..Il! ,,~ f"C\ ~I. (dill;
'~ NI "'r1II~I~'N~Cl f.l, l &l.\lof'4!,( 1M,. .
/Iho"'tr Itlllllt lIlo u.t't11111l11 ,IIllIIIIuUrll r.....\il "...
.. /\In W0:;4 nlOl\ll1ht /fIlr\ll tI:u;Ic ~:An UlCIGUfll rolllolllw a dII,
'&.\11;00( A,OO~/eat lIIOl'O or 1_1ll1h0 \Von ftIII\ol\n ollaUllfewll
't1lene. rua EoIIII II... IliD Woa\ end ., ." ulaUr,1 cwI,_ ~
dbllllco 01111,10 IoallO tho JlQlnl 01 bccJInnlnrJ,.,
!
I
I
.'
IN "'!'HEIS \MH!R!t), \ll't 9t:1nl11'11laYll hnfllllft\ll ,nlllllMlt
. ~',
.
. .
.':id
.~
. .. .
..
. .
. .
I'
'.
~
, .
.'
.
.
..
m: 1582ms8
~.........,.........
..., ~.' ..,.. ." .......
.
.
'ft. 12'( . , · CuatlllU41
I' '. .Ai'
I r ",
.. aIl4 oed. 0114 .J.::. 61 0( ,.. Ita.
l '
. . .
....
. o,./t.".
.;
IlJ
.
j
,
,
I
P. I. or,
:u-.4:111 ~Wl
'\ d.
..:ill.'- ., ':[CI.l.ii.t'JV
..ra"""~.r .
/8W.)
r'b
~~--. ,<
. .,
o
'. .
, ,
.'
I
. .
. .
.
~
'"
"
"
I
. .
.
.
-
.
. '"
..... .
,
,
.
....,,4,
\
\. ..
t
'.
...
. I,
.
. .',
,
/
r.
~ee ;)O~ll: i B
1I:1D02~
2.0' COHCAETE eu.1W1
\ .
\.
, c,'
;
.'
~
/..'
I. I
.. ~l. (5'
,.
t06. 05'
,
~OOEH OOCK
41'
" ~
"
-
.J
)0 ..
I-
a:
W
Q.
o
cr
0.
... ..
..". .
I"
'\'
. ,
!1,
'- II; 1
~ :: I
.
..
-
..
... ..... . ..11
'~~"'\\.l_-' ~ l- .
..... n,...," Ill'
\.\~\~ '0'1' "
g
.
:'~4~;Nr: vGC~J
w ~lOO' :
~ I ...._,....1'
~' . ! .',"',:,,\', ',:', ' 'wP;. &:~.
III "" ~'.~"I,' "'~V""~: fi .\:
e, I ,.' , .. . I- ' . ."
Ii: ~ i
.I,.. ' .~ I
So.oo.-1t'.
t
';,c. ~
....,t;;
"' - . . .
"" ~ . ] .
~
....
J.. .
---...
I
Ii
~
..
"
.
.
West Line of the N. E, 114 of the
-"--PPS.E, 1/4 of theS,W, 1/4 of
Sec. 3-52-42
I
'o,J
RECORDERS NOTE,
ne _.. wriUna. tJIliIt 01 pMt~ ~Ijs.
.'tIcI"l fa ~ dOCut11flIl whcllD~h\1l, '
, .....
.\"",';;;'..llIflCfoll-- .
lIf""to~,""'"
UCllII YfIlIllI
MatEY MIH
a&u OIClll COIMf . "
.' Jifililii-
II MO,clff,tJA
.
EXHIBIT
I
c
PARCEL' :
A parcel oflarl;f lying ~1he North 1/2oflhe Southeast t/4ot1he SouUM1st t/4ofSectlooa. TownshIp52Sd. Range
~ East, MlarN-Oade CoIny, FIorlda. being mort parIIcuIaJ1y deacrbad IS faIlowc:
Commence at the NOI1hGast comer d the NOI1hweGt 1/4 oflheSoutheastl1.4 01 the 8outf1W88t 1/4 d8lkt SecIIon 3,
thence NIl Nonh 89' 66'46' West alol'Cl the North Ane of the Northwest 1/4 of1he Scd1eaat 1/4 of the 8outhwe8I1/4 of
said SectIon S for I distance of 273.1 t feet.to a poIntj thence run So~ O' 02'30' West I dlslanct of 864 .. to a pen
d CIIVIlul'l d a CUM concave to the Northeast; thence nil along the are d said CUIYt. having for Its elementI. radU d
ao feet, a central angle of 45' 04'53' for a dl$lance of23SJ feet to . poIrf of rmrn Cl.IrvatuI cta CUM COI1CM to the
~ h8\i~ for Is elements a'~lus of 100f8e~. Ct. .n~ of 21' 29'05' fora dI8lInce or 37.eo feet to apaH
on uti CUIVe, said pollt bearing North 88' 26'42" East from lhe oem. cA said ClIVI am being 1he PoIrt d BegIrlrq d
the Parcel hereinafter to be descdbed: thence cor1Inue Southeasl8lfy along the arc of881d CUNe ~ a cer*i lIlgIe
of 23' 34'03' fora dlstinceof41.13 feet to the "mt of tangency; thence nm SOUlhO' OO'4S"Westfora distance of 240.70
feet to a point; thence nm South 89' 59'25' East along a line pIrBllaI to and 70 felt North, IM8IlIICl at right ... from
the South Rne of Nath 1/2 oftheSouthtaat 1/4 of the 80~"1/4 daaJd Sadlon 3 for.dlltance ofB08f1etto.
point: thence run North O' S1'SS'Westalong a 11118 parallel to ard 4OfeetWes~ meauedat rrjltlrVlI. fromthl East
In.of~ North t /2 of the Southeast 1/4 d the ScUhwest 1/4 dsak1 SedIan 3 for a dEtance of 38U8'-to. pok1t;
thence run North 89' 58'05"Westalcnga Una parallelto&rlll25 feet North. measunld atl rlgttangle, tom the North Ine
of the South '/2 of the North 1 /2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 d sakf Seetlon 3 for a dlsIanee of 578.85 feet
to. point; thence run S~ O' 39'25' East along a line paraDeI to and 60 feet Eall. rnea&\Rd Ita rt;1t angle, from the
West line ~ the NorthllSt 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Soutttftst 1/4 of said S8OIIon 3 for 8 distance of 105 feet to a
pOInt; thence run North 89' 58'10' West for a distance 0297.03 reel to the Point 01 B$gInnklg.
lESS
A pOrtion of Seclkln 3, TOWI16h/p 62 South, Range 42 East. Mlaml-Dide Courty. being llYn partWarly ~ as
follows:
Commenclng at the ce~ertlne Intersection of Northeast 28th Court. .70 face road rigtt.<lf-way I8l'8C01ded In OffIcl8I
Records BookOOBS. Page 160, MIam~Dade County records and Northeast 185th Street. I 70 toot fOld rlght-d.wayu
recaded In 0IftcIal Records Book 6879, Page 941, MlamI.oade Cw1ty 11ICOIds; Ihera South 89' 59'25' East. along the
08rterline of Northeut 1B5th Street. 35.00 feet: thence North 00. 00'46' East. 36.00 feeUo the PoInt Of Beginning, a180
being a point on the North rtglt-of-way line fA Northeast 185th Street; thence conllnulng North 00' 00'045' East. along the
EuI r~ht-of.wavllne of NcriteaaU8lh Court, 30.00 feet to 8 point of llUrvaUe of a tangent CU'Vt COncaYI to the
Northeast, having a radIus of 30.00 fe~ thence Southea&terty along the arc d IlIId CUMI. having . cel1nlllngle of SO'
00"0', an arc length of 47.13 feet to. point on the North right-of-way line of Northeast 185th Street; tIwIoe Norlh 89'
68'25' We~ along said North rlglj-of-way Ine, 30.00 felt to the PoIIt d ~ '
"'~~er wi1h "-II n'tt,if+\e ~ itftttfsf w"l~ ~ ~e,i../o,t(
PARCEL 2: ha.' If\ +~e ~\low,~ le$Ct,~tl41StMIt1t~
TOGETHER WITH an easement appu1enant to Parcel 1 lor the use of that certain canal hereinafter descrlbecf (the -canst')
for the navigation, flotatlon 8m transportation cI boats, barges, vas. and shipe, for the docldng of boast, for the
erGCtlon 01 8 b~khead and 181 means d Ingress and egress via waternnsportloo to and from Parcel 1 and the adjobmg
~gablll waters known as the Intracoastal Waterway with YA1lch said Canal now COMICtI. which usa.II more
particularly set forth In numbered paragraphs 1.2, 3. and 4 of that certain Easement Agreernert recorded In 0fIl01aI
Records Book 3185, page 743. of the Public Records of Mlaml.Dade County, FIOOda. the Canalis men particularly
descrtbed 88 fellows: '
That portion of an existing canal kllractlonal Sea/on 3, Township 52 South, Range 42 East, Dade County, FIorkIa,
desCl'ibm liS:
The North SO.O feet of the South 125.0 feet of the North 1/2 of the Northeaat 1/4 oflhe Southe&. 1/4 of the Southwest
1/4 of Fracllonal SectlQn 3. Township 52 South. Ra~e 42 East. Dade County, Rorkla.1.ES8 the West 50.0 feet thereof.
AND
CXHI\'I/IIn
Book22609/Page 1309 CFN#20040749804
Page 55 of 176
The North 60.0 feet tith, South 126.0 feet of the North 1/2 of Ihe North 1/2 of Ihe 80tIh 1/2 of the Soctheut 1{4
d fractional Section 3, T~ 52 South, Range ~ East. Dade Collty, FlorIda. '
That portion d an existing cantlIn fraetfonaI SIdIon II TOWIlIIhIp Y SIUh, Ranat~EaIt, Dade Oaunly, Aorlda,
dncrtldla:
Conmenoe at the Northwest comer ofb Nonheut 1/4 of the SoutheIst 1/~ d the ~ 1/~ {j fllCtlonal
Section 8, T OWI1$hlp 52 Solth. Range 42 East. Dade Ccuty, florida; thence run South O' 39'261 East e1q the
Weatllnedthe NOI1hea&t 1/1, of the Southeast 1/4 oftheSOUlhwast 1/4 of.1d SectIon a faradl8tlnce of205.U
feet to I point on the North ita oIlhe South 125.0 feet ofthe North 1/2 of Ute Northeut 1/4 of the SauIheut 1/4 of
the SoutfMttst 1/1,: thInct M South SQI 58'15' East along the North IN of SouIl125.1lO feet of Ihe North 1/2 (i
the NorthlUt 1/4 dtht Southeast 1/4 of the Southw8ll1/4 of uki Section a for a dl8lal1Cll of 50.0.... to the
POINT OF BEGINNING {j a portb1 of an existing canal; thence continue North 89' 88'151 Ea8t eIong the North line
of the South 12&.OOfeet of the North 1/2 of lheNor1heast 1/4 dthe8<dheast 1/4 of the 80uthweIt 1/4 ofeaij
S$ctkm a and along the NoI1IlIIne of the South 125.0 feet of the North 1/2 of the North 1/2 oftht Salah 1/2 of.,.
Southeast 1/401 saki Section 3100 lis prcIongatlon East for a dstance of 2.605.69 feat to. point: Ihencel\J\ North
O' 31'59" West for a distance of 128 feet more or Ien to the North bank of an existing cenaI: lhIncI run Welt IIq
the North benk of an llld8tIng canel for I dIsIaooe d 2,8l6 feet tnOf8or Ie8s to theWeet end of an ailing C8nII;
thence run South iong the West end 01 an exJsflng canal for a dlsl8nce of 111.10 f8eItO 1h8 POINT OF
BEGINNING.
QIlI', D.I,'IOII
Book22609/Page 1310 CFN#20040749804
Page 56 of 176
EXHIBIT "D"
"HI-LIFf PARCEL"
Legal Description
Commence at the Northeast corner of the NW ~ of the SE ~ of the SW ~ of
Fractional Section 3, Township 52 South, Range 42 Bast, Miami-Dade
County, Florida; thence run North 0 degrees 39125" West for a distance
of 180.25 feet to a point; thence run North 89 degrees 20135. East for
a distance of 70 feet to a point on the Bast right-of-way line of N.E.
29th Avenue; thence run South 0 degrees 39125" East along the East
right-of-way line of N.E. 29th Avenue for a distance of 49.74 feet to
the point of beginning of the following described parcel and the point
of curvature of a curve concave to the Northwest; thence continue along
said curve, having for its elements a radius of 198.90 feet, a central
angle of 90 degrees 42140", for an arc distance of 314.90 feet to the
point of tangency on the South right-of-way line of N.B. 187th Street;
thence run North 89 degrees 56145 II West along said South right-of -way
line for a distance of 142.58 feet to a point; thence run South 0
degrees 02130" West for a distance of 188.64 feet to a point of
curvature of a curve concave to tne Northeast; thence run along the arc
of said curve, having for its elements a radius of 30 feet, a central
angle of 45 degrees 04'53" for a distance of 23.60 feet to a point of
reverse curve; thence run along the arc of a curve concave to the
Southwest, having for its ,elements a radius of 100 feet, a central
angle of 21 degrees 2!P 05" for a distance of 37.50 feet to a point on
said curve, said point bearing North 66 degrees 26142" East from the
center of said curve; thence run South 89 degrees 58115" Bast for a
distance of 297.03 feet to a point; thence run North 0 degrees 39'25"
West, 216.10 feet toa point; thence run North 88 degrees 51154" East
for a distance of 20 feet to a point;, thence run North 0 degrees 39125"
West for a distance of 225.41 feet to the point of beginning.
Together with the interest of grantors in that certain canal
easement more specifically set out in easement agreement executed by
R.B. Gautier, Jr., individually and as Trustee, joined by his wife,
Frances Gautier, and Atlas Terminals of Florida, Inc., to North Dade
Acres, Inc., dated June 4, 1962, in O.R. Book 3185 Page 743, of the
Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida.
Subject, however, to the terms and conditions of that certain
Covenant Running with the land in favor of Metropolitan Dade County
recorded in Official Records Book 13284 Page 512, of the Public Records
of Miami.Oade County, Florida.
EXHIBIT "E"
"SUBMERGED LANDS~'
Legal Description
A portion of the Tract "C", ATLAS TERMINAL RBSIDBNTIAL, according to
the Plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 146 Page 18, of the Public
Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida, and being more particularly
described as follows:
Begin at the Southwest corner of said Tract "C', thence N 00
degrees 39125" W along the West line of said Tract "C" for 111.10 feet
to the Northwest corner of said Tract: "C", thence North 88 degrees
51154" B along the North line of said Tract lieu for 399.91 feet to a
point on the Southerly extension of the West line of Fortin, Leavy,
Skiles, Inc., Drawing Number 20990-179-8, dated February 2, 2004;
thence South 00 degrees 39'25" E along said Southerly extension of the
We.t line of Fortin, Leavy, Skiles, Inc., Drawing Number 20990-179-8,
dated February 2, 2004, for 119.20 feet to a point on the South line of
said Tract 'C"; thence North 89 degrees 56'26" W along said South line
of Tract "cn for 399.93 feet to the Point of Beginning.
t:
~ u..
~
.saMII
.16'zn
,~ I ffi
~
UI
QQ,
~e
a.
1\1
C
t:
.,
E
~ 0
~
0" N
~
a:
.l:W
0
U
~
lD
~
.....
b
10
)(
~
.....
I i
rJ
f i t
.B
I/)
l! dl . e
::s M a.
... 'i ~ ~
C
. r: " c
~ II " ~
0 III 0(
.s
~
11
:7
(/)
en t
'" t
M
II
~ ~
:J III
1:- ~
1l~
if
~ .1:1
K 8~ ~
e ~
III in
a. C)
E '"
"
:J
t:
rJ
.,
%
Slpoa w.1 !H
C)
~ II
~
.ltt .05
,t9t
~OJd ~n IH
:EXH1B1T
. I: c;
"
..-"-"'-".""---.'-'"
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE I I TH
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION
CASE NO: 04-10226 CA 06
GARY COHEN AS TRUSTEE OF
TRUST NO. 72-LT-8 U/AlDJune 15, 1992,
Plaintiff,
vs.
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, a foreign limited partnership;
PRE OP VI, INC., a foreign corporation;
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC, a foreign
limited liability company and A VENTI A VENTURA
HOLqINGS LLC, a foreign limited liability company,
Defendants.
/
STIPULATION AND MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF PLAINTIFF
AND ORDER APPROVING SAME
The Plaintiff, Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72-LT-8, and Substitute Plaintiff, Hi Lift
LLC, by and through its undersigned counsel and pursuant to Rule 1.260 (c) Fla. R. Civ. P. hereby
stipulate and agree and hereby move this Court for entry of an order allowing the substitution of Hi
Lift LLC as the Plaintiff in place of Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72-L T -8. As grounds in
support of said Stipulation and Motion, the movantS would state as follows: I
By virtue of a transaction between these parties, Hi Lift LLC has become the owner
of the rights upon which the allegations of the Complaint are based. As a result, Hi Lift LLC is now
the proper party-plaintiff in this cause. The substitution of Hi Lift LLC in place of Gary Cohen as
CASE NO. 04-10226 CA 06
PAGE 2
Trustee of Trust No. 72- L T -8 will in no way delay the progress of this cause and the substitution will
promote the interests of justice by placing the proper party before this Court.
. By virtue of this substitution, Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72-LT-8 shall have no
further involvement in this litigation. In addition, the finn of Greenberg Traurig shall become
counsel of record for the Plaintiff, Hi Lift LLC and the finn of William C. Hearon, P.A., AS
COUNSEL FOR Gary Cohen, Trust of Trust No. 72-LT-8 shall have no further responsibility for
representing the Plaintiff in this cause.
WHEREFORE, based upon the foregoing, Hi Lift LLC and Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust
No. 72-LT-8 would pray that this Court approve this stipulation and grant this motion.
GARY CO AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST
'NO.72-LT - IAJD JUNE 15, 1992
Telephone: 05 7 -9813
Fax: (305) 8-
~(rlt
Greenberg Traurig, P.A.
Counsel for Hi Lift, LLC
1221 Brickell Avenue
Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone: (305) 579-0550
Fax:' (305)
By. ~ ~~<~;j)~ ,
-CliffuffiA. SchuhluuI \V\o.~;(I GCl(C\c:t~SHr~
Ila.#Bar#lS6010 ~l4'~r.f1 OG,I5'oqq
Consented to by:
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC, a Delaware limited
Liability company
BY:.~-
Name: Ilyne Mendelson
Title: Vice-President
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, a Delaware
Limited liability company
By:
Name: Ilyne Mendelson
Title: Vice -President
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP,
A Delaware limited partnership,
By: PRE-GP VI, Inc., its General Partner
By:
Name:
Title:
CASE NO. 04-10226 CA 06
PAGE 3
CASE NO. 04-10226 CA 06
PAGE 4
ORDER GRANTING MOTION AND APPROVING STIPULATION
THIS CAUSE came on before the Court upon the foregoing Stipulation and Motion for
Substitution of Plaintiff , and the Court having reviewed said Stipulation and Motion, and otherwise
being fully advised in the premises, it is
ORDERED and ADJUDGED that the Motion be and the same is hereby GRANTED and the
Stipulation is approved. Hi Lift, LLC is hereby substituted as the Plaintiff in this cause and Gary
Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72-L T.8 shall have no further involvement in this cause. In addition,
the finn of Greenberg Traurig is hereby substituted as counsel for the Plaintiff and the firm of
William C. Hearon, P.A. shall have no further responsibility for the representation of PI aintiff in this
cause.
'DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers this _ day of January, 2005 at Miami, Miami-
Dade County, Florida.
CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE
Copies'furnished to:
William C. Hearon, Esq.
Clifford A. Schulman, Esq.
John T. Houchin, Esq.
Lewis J. Conwell, Esq.
TIene Mendelson, Esq.
:EXH1BlT
· I ft
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND
FOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION
CASE NO. 04-1 0226-CA-06
v.
GARY COHEN AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST )
NO. 72-LT-8-U/ND JUNE 15, 1992 )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff,
'"
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, et al.,
Defendants.
STIPULATION FOR DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE
Pursuant to Rule 1.420(a)(l), Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, the Parties hereby
stipulate that they have amicably resolved the matters at issue in the instant action and stipulate
to this 4ismissal of this cause, with prejudice, each Party to bear its own attorney fees and costs.
HI LIFT, LLC
A Florida limited liability company,
By: Hi lift Partners, LLLP,
A Florida limited liability limited partnership,
As its Manager,
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC, a Delaware limited
Liability company
By:~
Name: Ilyne Mendelson
Title: Vice-President
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, a Delaware
Limited liability company
By:~
Name: I yne Mendelson
Title: Vice -President
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP,
A Delaware limited partnership,
By: PRE-GP VI, Inc., its General Partner
~(2uy---
:?O VI /0(11 I Y\. ~D(l,JM.a.r...
.2-
II
PMB)h2yz03 _' DOCIRHENDERSON
-EXHIBIT
, -r
--
RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS:
That GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72-LT-8 U/AlD JUNE 15, 1992
(hereinafter referred to as the "TRUSr'), for and in consideration of the sum ofTEN ($10.00)
DOLLARS, or other valuable considerations, received from or on behalf of HI LIFT LLC, a
Florida limited liability company, the receipt whereof Is hereby acknowledged does hereby
remise, release, acquit, satisfy, and forever discharge AVENTURAAPARTMENTS LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, a foreign Iimtted partnership, (hereinafter referred to as "A VENTURA"), PRE
GP VI INC., a foreign corporation (hereinafter referred to as "PRE"), AVENTI @AVENTURA
LLC, a Foreign limited liability company (hereinafter referred to as "A VENT/1"), and AVENTI
A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, a foreign limited liability company (hereinafter referred to as
"A VENTI 2"), of andJrom any, and all manner of action and actions, cause and causes of
action, suits, debts, dues, sums of money, accounts, reckonings, bonds, bills, specialties,
covenants, contracts, controversies, agreements, promises, variances, trespasses, damages,
judgments, executions, claims demands and liabilities whatsoever, in law or in equity, whether
underfederal, state, common, arbitral, regulatory, foreign law or ordinance, which the TRUST
ever had, now has, or hereafter can, shall or may have had or which any personal
representative, successor, heir or assign of said TRUST, hereafter can, shall or may have,
against A VENTURA, PRE, A VENT/1 AND A VENTI 2 from the beginning of the world to the
date of the signing of this instrument, specifically relating to, based upon, or arising out of any
issues which were raised or asserted or could have been raised or asserted in, for, upon or by
reason of, (i) that certain civil complaint filed by the TRUST and pending against A VENTURA,
PRE, A VENTI 1 and A VENTI 2 in Miami-Dade County Circuit Court, Case Number 04-10226
CA 06 (hereinafter referred to as the itAWSUIT'~, including, without limitation, any and all
claims which could have been raised by the TRUST against A VENTURA, PRE, A VENTI 1
AND A VENTI 2 arising from the facts or events relating to the LAWSUIT; and (ii) that certain
restriction (the "RESTRICTION') which reads in pertinent part as follows: "To dock boats and
vessels in said canal parallelbthe bulkhead line of the adjoining lands; provided, however,
that such docking will not interfere with normal navigation in the canal" which RESTRICTION
is contained in an Easement Agreement which is recorded in Official Records Book 3185,
Page 743 of the public records of Miami-Dade County, Florida (the "EASEMENT
AGREEMENT') and which EASEMENT AGREEMENTwas preserved by Notice to Preserve
Easement Agreement recorded in Official Records Book 20362, Page 3037 of the public
records of Miami-Dade County, Florida.
------------.. . -.---
AND
That A VENTURA, PRE, A VENTI 1 AND A VENTI 2 for and in consideration of the sum of TEN
($10.00) DOLLARS, or othervaluable considerations, received from or on behalf of HI LIFT
LLC, a Florida limited liability company, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged does
hereby remise, release, acquit, satisfy, and forever discharge the TRUST, of and from any,
and all mannerof action and actions, cause and causes of action, suits, debts, dues, sums of
money, accounts, reckonings, bonds, bills, specialties, covenants, contracts, controversies,
agreements, promises, variances, trespasses, damages, judgments, executions, claims
demands and liabilities whatsoever, in law or in equity, whether under federal, state, common,
arbitral, 'regulatory, foreign law or ordinance, which A VENTURA, PRE, A VENTI 1 AND
1
PAGE TWO I RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE BETWEEN AND AMONG
GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72.LT.8 U/AlD JUNE 15, 1992
AVENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PRE GP VI INC.
A VENTI @ A VENTURA LLC
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC
A VENTI 2 ever had, now has, or hereafter can, shall or may have had or which any personal
representative, successor, heir or assign of A VENTURA, PRE, A VENTI 1 AND A VENTI 2,
hereafter can, shall or may have, against the TRUSTfrom the beginning of the world to the
date of the signing of this instrument, specifically relating to, based upon, or arising out of any
issues which were raised or asserted or could have been raised or asserted in, for, upon or by
reason,of, (i) the LAWSUIT, including, without limitation, any and all claims which could have
been raised by A VENTURA, PRE, A VENTI 1 AND A VENTI 2 against the TRUST arising from
the facts or events relating to the LAWSUIT; and (ii) that certain restriction (the
"RESTRICTION') which reads in pertinent part as follows: liTo dock boats and vessels in said
canal parallel to the bulkhead line of the adjoining lands; provided, however, that such docking
will not interfere with normal navigation in the canal" which RESTRICTION is contained in an
Easement Agreement which is recorded in Official Records Book3185, Page 743 of the public
records of Miami-Dade County, Florida (the IIEASEMENT AGREEMENT') and which
EASEMENT AGREEMENT was preserved by Notice to Preserve Easement Agreement
recorded in Official Records Book 20362, Page 3037 of the public records of Miami-Dade
County, Florida.
(terms used herein shall include singular and plural, heirs, legal representatives, and assigns
of individuals, and the successors and assigns of corporations, wherever the context so
admits or requires. This RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE may be executed in any number
of counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, and all of which together shall
constitute one and the same instrument. Any executed counterpart of this RECIPROCAL
SPECIFIC RELEASE received by way of fax transmission shall be deemed to be an original
document, binding on the party signing same, enforceable and admissible for all purposes, as
may be necessary to enforce the terms of this RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE,
notwithstanding the requirements of any contrary rule of law or evidence; provided, however,
that this RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE shall not be binding until it has been executed
by each party and transmitted or delivered by each party to the other)]
[SIGNATURES OF AND NOTARIZATIONS FOR PARTIES APPEAR ON THE
FOLLOWING PAGES}
2
"
. PAGE, THREE I RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE BElWEEN AND AMONG
GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72.LT.8 U1A1D JUNE 15,1992
AVENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PRE GP VI INC.
A VENTI @ A VENTURA LLC
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC
rustee of Trust No. 72.LT.8 ulald June 15, 1992
1e'U"~
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this f/(J? day of S~~~bY
Gary Cohen, as Trustee of Trust No. 72-L T-8 u/a/d Ju})e 15, 1992, on behalf of the Trust,
who is personally known to me or who has producetf'Drwe6 U~ as
identification. '
...1 SHANNON R BOLES
tJ'" ., "". NOTARY PUBUC. STATE OF FLORIDA
I \ COMMISSION # 00276265
L ~ ~l EXPIRES 12/21/2007
...fI1.!...... BONDED THRU 1.a8B-NOTARY1
otary Public
Affix Notary Stamp/Seal with
Commissioned Name of Notary Public
and expiration date:
3
PAGE FOUR I RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE BETWEEN AND AMONG
GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72-L T -8 U1A1D JUNE 15, 1992
AVENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PRE GP VI INC.
AVENTI @ AVENTURA LLC
AVENTI AVENTURA HOLDINGS LLC
Aventl @ Aventura LLC, a Delaware limited liability company
n~
By: ,~ ~
IIyne Mendelson, as Vice President and authorized signatory and representative
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF ..ca, ~m \ - tb.cl~ )
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ~ day of ..J An \ , 2001 by
lIyne Mendelson as the Vice President and authorized signatory and representative of
and for Aventi @ Aventura LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of the
company, who is personally known to me or who has prodUC'Sd :J L D /} \ '11-4:1 S. L,' (! .
a identification.
.~., lIlA{)YS OTERO
~i ~'A'" A MY COMMISSION i DO 178114
\j'6:f EXPIRES; January 15, 2007 .
'~P.r.I\ll~ Bonded Thru Notary Public UndelWl~ers
N tary Pu lie
A ,IX Notary Stamp/Seal with
Commissioned Name of Notary Public
and expiration date:
4
PAGE FIVE I RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE BETWEEN AND AMONG
GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72-L T.s U/AID JUNE 15, 1992
AVENtURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PRE GP VI INC.
AVENTI 0 AVENTURA LLC
AVENTI AVENTMRA HOL~INGS LLC
Aventi'Aventura Holdings LLC, a Delaware limited liability company
By:
lIyne Mendelson, as Vice President and authorized signatory and representative
8T ATE OF FLL~~~~~! ~J,. \
COUNTY OF ~
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged, before me this -2 day of j.An I 200:1:. by
lIyne Mendelson as the Vice President and authorized signatory and representative of
and for Aventl Aventura Holdings LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, on behalf of
Ji company, to is personally known 10 me or who has produced
L 1),,\ v~ t Q . as identification.
.........~.
N ary Publi
IX Notary Stamp/Seal with
Commissioned Name of Notary Public
and expiration date:
\'\~~'~""
/~i1" .~ QlADYS OlERO
r( J:~ MY COMMISSION' DO 178114
~~.....~l EXPIRES: January 15 2007
',P,r"lli' · Bendel! ThIV Nota'Y PlilIjc Un~~ers
5
I '
PAGE SIX I RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE BETWEEN AND AMONG
GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72-L T -8 U/AlD JUNE 15, 1992
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PRE GP V INC.
A VENTI @ AVENTURA LLC
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC
Aventura Apartments Limited Partnership, a Delaware limited partnership
By: Pre GP VI, Inc., a Delaware corporation, as its General Partner
By:
as its
v~
STATE OF :In, \'\0 is )
COUNTY OF Coo \( )
The ~oregoing instrument was acknowledged before ~e this sth day of 1:c.YWL\ri_' 200.5.. by
"T>hY\' ~e\J\V\ ~DDr'Mq", as the j \Cc'" lJres\ d~v'\ ~ of Pre
GP VI, Inc., a Delaware corporation, as the General Partner of Aventura Apartments Limited
Partnership, a Delaware limited partnership, on behalf of the partnership, who is personally
known to me or who has produced as identification.
Notary Public
Affix Notary Stamp/Seal with
Commissioned Name of Notary Public
......,...,...""""...-I..,...,."..,~
OFFICI/,!.. SEAL
ROSEMARI: A. RODRIGUEZ
NOTARY PUBUC, sm~ OF IWNOIS
MY COMMISS!Ot\ EXPir,ES 2.5.2005
.v....V\I'-o...."""'''Y.....
6
PAGE SEVEN I RECIPROCAL SPECIFIC RELEASE BETWEEN AND AMONG
GARY COHEN, AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST NO. 72-LT-8 UlAlD JUNE 15,1992
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PRE GP V INC.
A VENTI @ A VENTURA LLC
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC
Pre GP VI, Inc., a Delaware corporation
By:
as its
\P
STATE OF '~\\'nD\s. )
COUNTY OF LDDY.. )
Theioregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ~ day of 1"o.n~"Tr' 200 S" by
JOnV\ K~v\f\ ~oo,('iV\Q',\ asthe ~ k.e t'f~\~~V\ \ of Pre
GP VI, Inc., a Delaware corporation, on behalf of the corporation, who is personally known to
me or who has produced as identification.
Cd~A
Notary Public
Affix Notary Stamp/Seal wit
Commissioned Name of Notary Public
'V
OFFICIAL SEAL
ROSEMARIe A. RODRIGUEZ
NOTARY PUBLIC, SiATE OF ILUNDIS
MY COMMISSIOi( EXPIRES 2.5-2005
~v"'..
7
EXHIBIT
., J
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND
FOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION DIVISION
CASE NO. 04-10226-CA-06
v.
GARY COHEN AS TRUSTEE OF TRUST )
NO. 72-LT-8-U/AID JUNE 15,1992 )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff,
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, et aI.,
Defendants.
JOINT MOTION TO APPROVE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND TO RETAIN
JURISDICTION
Substituted Plaintiff, Hi-Lift, LLC, with the consent of the parties hereto, hereby files this
Joint Motion to Approve Settlement Agreement and to Retain Jurisdiction and states:
1. Substituted Plaintiff and Defendants A venti@Aventura LLC and A VENTI
A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, have entereed into a Settlement Agreement in the instant cause,
a copy of which is attached as Exhibit "A". Said Settlement calls for the dismissal of the instant
case, with prejudice, and a Joint Motion to that effect is being filed simultaneously herewith.
2. The dismissal is as to all Defendants in this whether or not they are parties to the
Settlement Agreement.
WHEREFORE, the below parties hereby respectfully request this Court to accept and
approve the Settlement Agreement and to dismiss this case, while retaining jurisdiction to
enfo~ce the tezms of the Settlement Agreement.
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC
BY:~
I L '1/1p.e V1Aj)-.AdJ Y'VV)
~ FM:da .., JA.,t:..-
Tele: ' ~~
Fax:
A VENn A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC,
a Delaware limited liability company
By:~
Name: 1 '-v( rvP ~ dJ'Irvvl
Title: I, f.
And
A VENTURA APARTMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP and
PRE GP VL INC. ()~ _ '. .
By: (A~~
, hJ1 VI r1 oo(l,~
, Florida
Tele: 11~":J~ 0'" 8~/5
Fax: ~11 "t)6-!r91
* br I P t1~ hc--...y'
.2 -PMBj oint motion to approve settlement ~turner hi-lift vI.I
I
.____._.,,__~~^."._-" _ ..""...---..."..,,".__~.,.",,.,.._..",...,._,,._,_,_.,,..~.~_,,___._.~,"'"_"~,,.~ ...,_._'"_.-><_,_.,,_...._~_...m. ..__,.."_.",...",_~_,,,
f
.
1\ K II
ReCUm to: (endolC IClr..ddraaed atlmped envelope)
Name: Ruden, M"oCbky, Smith, Sclm8ter & RUIleD, P.A.
Address: 701 Brickell Avenue, Suite 1900
Miam~ Florida 33131
Attention: Real Estate Department
11th Instr.ument.lnpared.hy: Muk.R GI:8Jlt,.lRquhe
SPACE ABOVE nus LINE FOR PROCESSING DATA
SPACE ABOVE Tins LINE FOR PROCESSING DATA
GRANTEE 5.5. NO.
GRANTEE 5.S. NO.
PROPERTY APPRAISER'S PARCEL IDBNI'lFlCATlON NO,
SPECIAL CONDOMINIUM WARRANTY DEED
THIS INDENTURE, made this _ day of f 2005, between Aventi @
A ventura LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, whose principal office is located at 6400 Congress Avenue,
Suite 1750 Boca Raton, Florida 33487, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", and
~ whose .post office address is
, hereinafter referred to as "Grantee".
WITNESSE TH:
That the Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00) and other good and
valuable consideration to it in hand paid by the Grantee, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, has granted,
bargained and sold to the Grantee~ and the Grantee's heirs and assigns forever, the following,described real
property situatOO, lying and being in Monroe County, Florida, to-wit
The Condominium Parcel known as Boat Slip Unit No. . A VENTI. at
A ventura ("Condominium''), according to the Declaration of Condominium thereof
("Declaration"), recorded in Official Records Book 22609, Page 1256, of tile Public Records of
Miami-Dade Coonty, Florida,and,auy andallamendmeuts theretcJ, tOgetherwith~uodi~idOO
share in the connnon elements appurtenant thereto, and all Limited Commonb1ements n:served
for the Owners of said Boat Slip Uni~ as more particularly described in the Declaration,
Grantee, by acceptance hereo~ and by agreement with Grantor, hereby expressly assumes and agrees to
be bOWld by and to comply with all of the covenants, tenns, conditions and provisions set forth and contained in
the aforedescribed Declaration, including, but not limited to, the oblig~tion to make, paynmt of assessments for
the maintenance and operation of the Condominium.
This conveyance is made subject to the following:
1. Real estate taxes for the year of closing and subsequent years and any special taxes or
assessments enteredagainst-ooid, property after the' oote'ofelooing;
2. Applicable zoning regulations and ordinances;
3. All of the terms, provisions, conditions, rights, privileges, obligations, easements and liens
set forth and contained in the Declaration and all exhibits and any amendments thereto;
r:n.f,;7:lf,;7t.l
STATE OF FLORIDA )
) SS:
COUNTY OF )
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State aforesaid and in
the County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, the foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me by
, the President of A venti @ A ventura LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, freely
and voluntarily under authority duly vested in him by said corporation and that the seal affixed tbereto is ~ ~
'corporate seal ohaid 'corporation. He'is'peISOmdly"~lJIJwn tome.
WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this _ day of
J 2000.
My Commission Expires:
Notary Public, State of Florida At Large
Typed, Printed or Stamped Name of Notary Public
ACCEPTED BY GRANTEE:
Print Name:
Print Name:
Print Name:
Print Name:
Print Name:
Print Name:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
) SS:
COUNTY OF )
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State aforesaid and in
the County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, the foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me by
, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this day of
,2000.
t'TI.e;n&;71;'1
':)
r
My Commission Expires:
Notary Public, State of Florida At Large
Typed, Printed or Stamped N~ofNotary Public
STATE OF FLORIDA )
) SS:
COUNTY OF )
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State aforesaid and in
the County 'aforesaid to take 'acknawlOOgmmts, the foregoing insttumeut 'Was ~ before mt by
, who is personally known to me or who bas produced
as identification.
WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this day of
,2000.
My Commission Expires:
Notary Public, State of Florida At Large
Typed, Printed or Stamped Name ofNotaI)' Public
E:'TI.t;'7:!~'7C:.l
A
~ U1
! ~
.. .
- N
'V W
a .
i
~
HI Uft Property
161'
HI-Un:
Property
HI Uft Eascmsrt:
Hi Lift Docks
~
II
a
~
w ~ ~
to! ~
.!:t CfJ
a i
J ~
o
CD
i
m
CD
~
CD
::J
~
.....
01
Q
x
~
Q
III
.
~
..'3
:!
gg
-.
i
106
'"
~
:
o
g
if
::J
i
w
i
x
...
:I
:I ~
~ ~
::I ,..
! ~
H
~
~
~
.
::I
~
;
i
c
CD
>
I
0
~
CD ,
(XI 0'
~ Aventi Docks ~
Reconfigured m
..
Gl
C
n
'0
...
o
tJ
CD
~
50'
122.91'
CIbb/a'
~..
r _
m,
~.
,,':
"YjfflRd
IN THE ,CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 11TH
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR
MIAMI.DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION DMSION
CASE NO: 04-10226 CA06
GARY COHEN AS TRUSTEE OF
TRUST NO. 72.LT-8 UlAtD June 15,1992,
Pi . tiff.
am ..'
vs.
A VENTIJRA APARTMENTS LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, a foreign limited partnership;
PRE OP VI, INC., a foreign corporation;
A VENTI@AVENTURA LLC, a foreign
limited liability company and A VENTI A VENTURA
HOLDINGS LLC, a foreign limited liability company,
Defendants.
STIPULATION AND MOTION FOR SUBS1J'l'DTION OF PLAINTIFF
AND ORDER APPROVING SAME
The Plaintiff; Oaty Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72.LT-8, and Substitute Plaintiff; Hi Lift
LLC, by and through its undersigned counsel and pursuant to Rule 1.260 (c) Fla. R. Civ. P. hereby
stipulate and agree and hereby move this Court for entry of an order allowing the substitution of Hi
Lift LLC as the Plaintiff in place of Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72.LT.8. As grounds in
support of said Stipulation and Motion, the movants would state as follows:
By virtue of a transaction between these parties, Hi Lift LLC has become the owner
of the rights upon which the allegations of the Complaint are based. As a result, Hi Lift LLC is now
the proper party-plaintiff in thi~ CAu~c:. The substitution ofl Ii Lift LLC in place of Gary Cohen llS
. ,
. . t
CASE NO. 04.10226 CA 06
PAGE 2
Trustee of Trust No. 72.L T.8 will in no way delay the progress of this cause and the substitution will
promote the interests of justice by placing the proper party before this Court.
By virtue of this substitution, Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust No. 72-LT-8 shall have no
further involvement in this litigation. In addition, the finn of Greenberg Traurig shall become
counsel of record for the Plaintiff, Hi Lift LLC and the finn of William C. Hearon, P .A., AS
COUNSEL FOR Gill)' Cohen, Trust of Trust No. 72-LT-8 shall have no further responsibility for
representing the Plaintiff in this cause.
WHEREFORE, based upon the foregoing, Hi Lift LLC and Gary Cohen as Trustee of Trust
No. 72. L T-8 would pray that this Court approve this stipulation and grant this motion.
GARY CO
NO. n.LT
Telephone'
Fax: (305)
Greenberg Traurig, P.A.
CoUnsel for Hi Lift, LLC
1221 Brickell Avenue
Miami, Florida 33131
Telephone: (305) 579-0550
Fax: (305)
By. ~ ~j'~"4. .
Clift'ef6 t.. Schulmwl ~{,l' GCUt'l" Sf. {r~\
~1tBarNlSeale flq G"r..-t O~/o)('q'l
~(;r,t
. .
.'
Consented to by:
A VENTJ~ VENTURA LLC, a Delaware limited
Liability company
By: ~
Name: I1yne Mendelson
Title: Vice. President
A VENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, a Delaware
Limited liability company
By:
Name: Ilyne Mendelson
Title: Vice -President
A VENTURA AP AR TMENTS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP,
A Oelaware limited partne~hip,
By: PRE.GP VI, Inc., its General Partner
By:
NlUlle:
Title:
.~.~
(t.\,N\0V\
CASE NO. 04.10226 CA 06
PAGE 3
CERTIFICATEOFS~
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was mailed this 12th
day of January, 2005 to all parties on the attached service list.
By:
7.)~
I ,
OR BK 23010 PG 2694
L~ T PAGE
.. I ,
This instrument was prepared by:
Clifford A. Schulman
Greenberg Traurig, P.A.
1221 Brickell Avenue
Miami, Florida 33131
NOTICE OF FILING
In conjunction with that certain lawsuit entitled GARY COHEN AS TRUSTEE
OF TRUST NO. 72-LT-8-U/AlDJUNE 15, 1992v.AVENTURAAPARTMENTS
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, PRE-GP VI, INC., A VENTI @AVENTURA LLC and
AVENTI A VENTURA HOLDINGS LLC, Case No. 04-10226-CA-06, certain
documents have been executed and orders entered, that are hereby filed of record. This
filing includes;
1. Settlement Agreement dated January 3, 2005 and attached legal descriptions
and exhibits;
2. Stipulation and Motion for Substitution of Plaintiff and Order Approving
Same;
3. Stipulation for Dismissal With Prejudice;
4. Signed Order Granting Motion and Approving Stipulation dated January 13,
2005;
5. Signed Order Approving Settlement Agreement, Dismissing Case and
Retaining Jurisdiction dated January 13,2005.
Any an all interested parties shall take notice of the filing of these documents in
the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida.
Clifford A. Schulman
Greenberg Traurig, P.A.
1221 Brickell Avenue
Miami, Florida 33131
January 19, 2005
_~_,____","_,_"_"",_",~,~""__,~_""_",,,,,,,_"_.~"_"__'~~_'M"_"___""'_'_"""'"
CITY OF AVENTURA
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
BY: Joanne Carr, AICP
Planning Director
TO: City Commission
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, IC -
City Manager
DATE: August 21 , 2006
SUBJECT: Request of Hi Lift Marina for (1) Conditional Use approval to permit
construction of a new marina and dry dock boat storage building with a
height of 90 feet in the TC2, Town Center Marine District, where a
maximum height of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code; (2) Variance
from Section 31-145(c)(1 0) of the City's Land Development Regulations to
permit a development with a view corridor of 15 feet, where a 66.76 foot
view corridor is required by Code; (3) Variance from Section 31-221(i)(2)
of the City's Land Development Regulations to permit a minimum buffer
strip of 4'8", where a minimum T buffer strip is required by Code; all for
property located at 2890 NE 18ih Street, Aventura (01-CU-06 and 02-
V AR-06)
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item .JL
RECOMMENDA liON
It is recommended that the City Commission:
1. Approve the request for Conditional Use approval to allow a 90 foot tall marina
and dry dock boat storage building in the TC2 zoning district, where a maximum
height of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code.
2. Approve the request for Variance from Section 31-145(c)(10) of the City's Land
Development Regulations to permit a 15 foot view corridor where a 66.67 foot
view corridor is required by Code, and
3. Approve the request for Variance from Section 31-221 (i)(2) of the City's Land
Development Regulations to permit a minimum buffer strip of 4'8", where a
minimum T buffer is required by Code.
THE REQUEST
The applicant, Hi Lift Marina, LLC, is requesting the following:
1. Conditional Use approval to permit construction of a new marina and dry dock
boat storage building with a height of 90 feet in the TC2, Town Center Marine
District, where a maximum height of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code.
2. Variance from Section 31-145(c)(10) of the City's Land Development Regulations
to permit a development with a view corridor of 15 feet, where a 66.76 foot view
corridor is required by Code.
3. Variance from Section 31-221 (i)(2) of the City's Land Development Regulations
to permit a minimum buffer strip of 4'8", where a minimum 7' buffer strip is
required by Code.
all on property located at 2890 NE 187th Street, Aventura. (See Exhibit #1 for Letters of
Intent)
BACKGROUND
OWNER OF PROPERTY
Hi Lift Marina, LLC
APPLICANT
Hi Lift Marina, LLC
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY
2890 NE 187th Street
See Exhibit #2 for Location Plan
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
See Exhibit #3 for Legal Description
SIZE OF PROPERTY
Approximately 3.05 acres total
Upland parcel 1.99 acres
Submerged parcel 1. 06 acres
EXISTING ZONING
TC2, Town Center Marine District
FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION Town Center
Zoning -
Subject property:
Property to the North:
Property to the South:
Property to the East:
Property to the West:
TC2
TC1
RMF3
TC2
82
Town Center Marine District and
Town Center District
Multi-Family Medium Density Residential
Town Center Marine District
Community Business District
Existing Use-
Subject property:
Dry Dock Boat Storage and Marina
2
Property to the North:
Property to the South:
Property to the East:
Property to the West:
Residential and retail uses
Residential uses
Water and Marine uses
Retail uses
Future land Use Designation. According to the City of Aventura Comprehensive
Plan, the following properties are currently designated as follows:
Subject property:
Property to the North:
Property to the South:
Property to the East:
Property to the West:
Town Center
Town Center
Medium High Density Residential
Water and Town Center
Business and Office
The Site. The subject site is located in the block bounded by NE 28th Court to the west,
a finger canal to the east, NE 187 Street to the north and an existing 3 story town home
condominium called Aventi to the south.
The Project - The applicant has submitted a revised application for administrative site
plan approval to develop a new marina and dry dock facility to replace the boat storage
facility that presently exists on the property. Color photographs of the existing facility
are appended to this report. The redevelopment application incorporates a new state of
the art computerized, indoor boat storage system with 240 dry slips and 22 wet slips in
a location that currently utilizes both outdoor and indoor space for boat storage and
repairs. The existing facility is approximately 55 feet high and contains a total of 262
slips. While there is no increase in the number of existing slips, the slip size is being
increased to accommodate larger boats. The proposed building is expanding
approximately 55 feet in width, which increases the existing ground level fioor area of
39,600 square feet to 50.710 square feet and rising an additional 35 feet in height to
contain the computerized rack system, indoor parking and enclosure of the existing
outdoor storage area. Parking areas are proposed inside the building and in two
surface parking lots at the southwest comer and northeast comer of the site. A 15 foot
landscaped corridor is proposed at the south property limit to screen the new building
from the existing residential development.
The application for conditional use is a revision to a previous application that was
presented to City Commission in March of 2006. The original application was for a
building height of 150 feet, then reduced to 122 feet. Following discussion at the March
7, 2006 public hearing, the application was withdrawn. The present application is for a
building height of 90 feet.
Building height, according to the definition of "height" in the Land Development
Regulations, is the vertical distance between the finished elevation at the center of the
front of the building to the highest point of the roof surface, excluding mechanical
equipment. The 90 foot height is the height to the roof surface. There is mechanical
equipment above the roof surface with screening that measures 14.5 feet above the 90
3
foot height, or 104'5". There are also decorative peaks on each comer of the
mechanical screens that measure another 15'1" or 119'6". The mechanical screens
enclose the boat lift cranes and also conceal the air conditioning units in the middle of
the building, which are at the main roof level of 90 feet.
The application for variance for view corridor and buffer strips are the same as the
previous application in March of 2006.
Proffered Covenant
The TC2 zoning category permits a mix of residential and non-residential uses on this
property. Staff has discussed with the applicant staff's concern with potential
redevelopment that may include both residential at 25 dwelling units per gross acre and
commercial uses at 2.0 Floor Area Ratio and the adverse impacts that a mix of uses
may create at this congested comer. The applicant's proposal is commercial (marina)
use with the same number of slips as currently exist, with improved access and traffic
flow and a 1.36 Floor Area Ratio. As a condition of variance and conditional use
approval, the applicant has proffered a covenant prohibiting residential development.
This covenant will be recorded on title to the property and will bind not only the applicant
but its successors and assigns. Staff recommends that the City Commission accept the
applicant's proffer and that recordation of the covenant be made a condition of approval
of the conditional use and variance requests.
ANALYSIS OF THE REQUESTS
Citizen Comments · The Community Development Department has received no written
citizen comments about this application.
Community Development Department Analysis - The property is located in the
TC2 (Town Center Marine) District. The permitted height in this zone is 4 stories or 50
feet. The applicant is requesting Conditional Use approval to permit a height of 90 feet
which is equivalent to 9 stories. The applicant is also requesting variances to allow a
reduced view corridor to the canal at the east limit and reduced buffer strips along the
perimeter of the building.
Reauest #1: Conditional Use aQProval to allow a 90 foot tall dry dock boat storaae
and marina buildina in the TC2 zoning district, where a where a maximum height
of 4 stories or 50 feet is permitted by Code.
The plan proposes a building measuring 90 feet tall. The applicant advises that the new
building contains the same number of slips as the existing building which is 55 feet tall.
The applicant advises that the additional 35 feet of height is required to install racks that
store larger boats and to enclose the existing outside storage racks.
4
Criteria
The guidelines for approval of conditional uses as required by Section 31-73(c) of the
City's land Development Regulation states:
((General Standards of review. In addition to the standards set forth in these LORs
for the particular use, all proposed conditional uses shall meet each of the following
standards:"
(a) The proposed use shall be consistent wfth the comprehensive plan.
The use is consistent with the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan, which designates
the future land use category for this site as Town Center. The Town Center designation
states that the "... implementation of Town Centers may be directed through the
establishment of zoning and other land use regulations unique to each zone... II This
property lies within the TC2, Town Center Marine District, which allows the proposed
dry and wet boat storage, marine showroom and boat repair as permitted uses.
The Comprehensive Plan also encourages a mix of uses within the Town Center and
the provision of recreational facilities. The proposed facility will help further both of
these objectives.
(b) The establishment, maintenance or operation of the proposed use shall not be
detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety or general welfare.
The redevelopment of the boat storage facility will bring the building up to current
Building Code standards which will enhance the safety of the general public. The
modernization of the existing facility will also benefit the public health, safety and
welfare by completely enclosing all of the operations that currently take place outside
and within full view of the current and future residential neighbors. By enclosing the
boat lifting, storage and repair operations, the noise associated with these activities will
be reduced. Parking areas for the new facility will improve traffic safety as compared to
the existing condition where cars back out onto NE 187 Street.
(c) The proposed use shall be consistent with the community character of the
immediate neighborhood of the proposed use.
The proposed use is consistent with the community character of the immediate
neighborhood. To the west are existing retail uses. To the east and south are
residential and water uses. To the north is Phase I of the proposed Town Center. The
marine character of the use is consistent with other uses on the water. Architecturally,
the proposed building will incorporate elements that are consistent with the neighboring
residential developments.
(d) Utilities, roadway capacity, drainage and other necessary public facilities, including
police, fire and emergency services, shall exist at the City's adopted levels of
5
service, or will be available concurrent with demand as provided for in the
requirements of these LDRs.
The redevelopment of the existing marina will not result in a change to the current level
of service required. The City's current levels of infrastructure and services are sufficient
to accommodate the proposed redevelopment.
(e) Adequate measures exist or shall be taken to provide ingress and egress to the
proposed use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets.
Adequate measures have been taken to provide ingress and egress to the proposed
use in a manner that minimizes traffic congestion in the public streets. Currently, the
parking area on NE 187 Street consists of a narrow strip on the north side of the
property between the building and the sidewalk. Cars exiting the property must back
out into NE 187 Street. The new facility will ensure more orderly and safer flow of traffic
by providing controlled ingress and egress with parking both inside the building and in
two surface parking areas.
(Q The establishment of the conditional use shall not impede the development of
surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district.
The establishment of the conditional use will not impede the development of
surrounding properties for uses permitted in the zoning district.
(g) The design of the proposed use shall minimize adverse effects, including visual
impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent property through the use of building
orientation, setbacks, buffers, landscaping and other design criteria.
The proposed facility has been designed to minimize adverse effects, including visual
impacts, of the proposed use on adjacent property. The proposed Mediterranean
design of the building will replace an old industrial metal building. The exposed outdoor
storage racks will be covered by the new building. The noise and unattractive visual
impact of this outdoor storage area will be eliminated. Landscaping will provide
improved aesthetics for the neighborhood.
Reauest #2: Variance from Section 31.145~ of the City's Land Development
B!gulations to permit a 15 foot view corridor where a 66.67 foot view corridor is
reauired by Code.
A 66.76 foot wide corridor is required by Code based on the average of the two
frontages opposite the canal. The Code requires this corridor extend from the watelWay
to the street most nearly parallel to the mean high tide line. For this particular property,
only 150 feet of its 436 foot length abuts the canal width. Due to, the unique shape of
the property, a view corridor at either the north or south limit results in a particular
hardship upon the owner. A view corridor at the south limit would impact approximately
50 feet or 25% of the proposed building width of 200 feet. If the full corridor width of
6
66.76 feet was constructed on the south limit of the property, the existing jog in the
property line with the neighboring Aventi condominium would result in no water view. A
view corridor at the north limit would impact approximately 40 feet or 20% of the
proposed building width. These conditions are shown in the sketch attached as Exhibit
#4.
The proposed plan shows a 15 foot landscaped corridor along the south limit which
functions more as a building setback than a view corridor. To mitigate this condition,
the applicant has offered to construct a 10 foot wide public walkway along the
northeasterly property limit, designed similar to the pedestrian promenade on canal side
of the NE 188 Street properties with City standard bench, trash receptacle and bollard
at the waterfront. This will afford public access and view to the canal which is the intent
of a view corridor and will also allow future connection to the walkway on NE 188 Street.
Criteria
The guidelines for approval of variances as required by Section 31-76(e) of the City's
Land Development Regulation states:
"StandarcJs of review. A variance shall be granted only where competent and
substantial evidence presented in the particular case shows that all of the following
are met:
(1) The particular physical surroundings, shape, topographical condition, or other
physical 'or environmental condition of the specific property involved would
result in a particular hardship upon the owner, as distinguished from a mere
inconvenience, if the regulations were carried out literally.
Due to the unusual shape of this property and its partial frontage on the water,
the 66.76 foot wide view corridor results in a particular hardship upon the owner,
as shown on the sketch attached as Exhibit #4.
(2) The conditions upon which the request for a variance is based are unique to
the parcel and would not be generally applicable to other property within the
vicinity.
The conditions are unique to this site and would not be generally applicable to
other locations.
(3) The alleged difficulty or hardship is not economic and has not been deliberately
created to establish a use or structure, which is not otherwise consistent with
the LDR.
The applicant's difficulty is not economic in nature and has not been deliberately
created by the applicant.
(4) The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity.
7
The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity. The construction of
public access to the water along the northeasterly property limit will preserve the
public welfare.
(5) The proposed variance will not substantially increase the congestion in the
public streets, or increase the danger of fire, or endanger the public safety, or
substantially diminish or impair property values within the vicinity.
The proposed variance will not substantially increase traffic congestion or
increase the danger of fire or endanger the public safety.
B!guest #3: Variance from Section 31.221~ of the City's Land Develooment
R!gulatlons to permit a minimum buffer strip measuring 4'8" t where a minimum
7' buffer is reauired bv Code.
The Code requires a minimum of 7 foot wide buffer strips along the perimeter of all
vehicular use areas. The proposed plan shows a 4'8" wide buffer strip occurring
between the building and the north parking area and a 6' wide buffer strip between the
building and the southwest parking area. The 4'8" width will not impede the plantings
shown on the landscape plan.
Criteria
The guidelines for approval of variances as required by Section 31-76(e) of the City's
land Development Regulation states:
IIStandards of review. A variance shall be granted only where competent and
substantial evidence presented in the particular case shows that all of the following
are met:
1. The particular physical surroundings, shape, topographical condition, or other
physical or environmental condition of the specific property involved would result
in a particular hardship upon the owner, as distinguished from a mere
inconvenience, if the regulations were carried out literally.
The unique shape and location of the property results in the hardship upon which
the variance is requested.
2. The conditions upon which the request for a variance is based are unique to the
parcel and would not be generally applicable to other properly within the vicinity.
The conditions are unique to this site and would not be generally applicable to
other locations.
8
-..,,'.,......,.....-..-... .,...~,.,._. ..,'~...~...,'. ". -, ..~....'.._..,
3. The alleged difficulty or hardship ;s not economic and has not been deliberately
created to establish a use or structure, which is not otherwise consistent with the
LDR.
The applicant's difficulty is not economic in nature and has not been deliberately
created by the applicant.
4. The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity.
The granting of the variance will not be detrimental to the public welfare or
injurious to other property or improvements in the vicinity. The proposed width of
buffer strip will allow installation of required plantings.
5. The proposed variance will not substantially increase the congestion in the public
streets, or increase the danger of fire, or endanger the public safety, or
substantially diminish or impair property values within the vicinity.
The proposed variance will not substantially increase traffic congestion or
increase the danger of fire or endanger the public safety.
9
...:l "
"
< ~
z "
~ Q'\
~ 1""'1
~ ....
~ -,=.cl
0 1:1) .... bJl
.... 00 ..
~ ~ 0.. 1:1) l:: ~
~ ..... ~.cl
r. - ....
~ r/J ..... ~ .
~ l::
...:l N 0 :J bJl
I ~ >
~ N """ :g<
== - N 0
0
Z
I
~ 'tl
~ ~ "
00 ~ "t
~ ~ 1""'1
> ~ -. ....
~ -,=.cl
a: 1:1) > "'" .... bJl
.. ~ 00 ..
~ 0.. .... :> l:: ~
.... ..... .~ ~
r. ~ - ~.cl
~ ~ r/J l. 1:1) ~ .
~ ~ ........ bJl
0 ~ .....
~ 0 """ ~ l:: ~ >
== 0\ N ~~ ~<
~
~
o
~
~
==
~
....
~
~
~
N
["'-..
1:1)
0..
.....
-
r/J
t{)
N
-
~
....
..
e:
:=
Q'\
N
1""'1
"
"
~
"
t--
1""'1
....
-,=.cl
.... bJl
00 ..
l:: ~
~.cl
~ .
bJl
~ >
~<
~ ~
....
~ e:
Q, ~ ..
e ~
.... .. ~
-
.cl 00. t ~
bJl ~ ~ Q,
..
~ Q, ..
== ~ < -
00.
09/11/2005 20:18 9547228125
PAGE 01/01
I fern &
q ,1").0 b
crele..
Ms. Joanne Carr
Planning Director
City of Aventura.
19200 West COWllry Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
Dear Ms. Carr,
I
I am 'Miting to infonn you that 1 have recently met with Andrew Stumerf the owner of Hi Lift Marina,
our neighbor to the North. Mr. Stumer explained to me his plans for the redevelopment of Hi Lift. 'It has been
explained to me that Mr. Sturner intends to replace the ugly grey metal industrial building and eliminate :the outdoor
exposed racks which are unattractive and represent a detriment to the value of the Aventi town homes. ,In its place
will be: ~ rn.-autifully designed 90' (with parapets to 104" and accent towers to 116') tall world-class facility whose
Mediterranean design will complement the design of the A venti complex. A venti is well aware that th~ antiquated
forklift technology uuU<:ed at Hi Lift employs loud gas engines which together with the "reverse beeps'" l;rea~
substantial noise that is irritating to the A venti residents. It is my understanding that this new facility will be a stare..
of-the..art facility utilizing electric bridee crane technology which i~ fully enc1o~d within. the new building thereby
eliminating virtually all of the irritating noises that awake the Aventi residents 363 days of the year at 7:45am!
I
In addition~ as you know, the existing boat service operations and service personnel utilize: the outside
racks to perfonn service work on the boats. The smell of fumes, the chatter of employees, the noise of their tools is
all disruptive and negatively impacts the privacy of A venti residents and therefore our property values. lIt has been
explained to us that the vast m~iority of aU of the service operations in the beautiful new facility will be conducted
inside the faci1i~ thel'eby providing Aventi residents with muoh deserved quiet and priv~. In addition, we
understand that Mr. Stumer has offered to provide extensive landscaping that will enhance the privacy for the Aventi
residents. I am an ardent supporter of the redevelopment and look fonwrd to the demolition of the 20 y~.ar old
facility that sits on the site today. As you know, Hurricane Wilm.a has highlighted the need to upgrade aging dry
storage marinas to ensure they can. withstand our active hurricane seasons. I am a supporter of this redevelopment
because I understand that the new Hi Lift facility will be built to current hurricane protection code and Will provide
much needed added protection to protect against a collapse similar to that which befell Sunny Isles Marina.
I
For all the foregoing reasons, as President of the Board of Aventi at Aventura Condo Associ~tion, I fully
support Mr. Stumer's efforts to upgrade and benutify Hi Lift Marina and I believe that it will be a great benefit to rl1C
City of Aventura and its residents.
VezyTrulYY~, L! ~ .
[IItfJ1~
Antonio Contarini, Esq.
President
A venti at A'Ventura Condo Association
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
1-; Dtat reZ (7! f4 ~ ku J
my site P61 tif 3
rn.trt.' ~
. f<-I;
1Qlo(NE1ttT
fW~rl/'-A- ~ s J/ It!
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
St€tltf.' 12(01t
IvtIJ6ft:~! ;o0,)f;CJ
iltd
1'i1~f' ~.e", 4'0/
~ 11 ?~()
'1
I
I C)O/1f1. VI fill &Et2&-. /
I
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ ' of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
1', storage facility. This is a residentialltown center with a school for our
i
i
1 children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
f i
,
I
,
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
\ . center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
" ,
! ,
~ ;
; I
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
! .1
SAVE lOUR CITY
~'l
i
I
{p,:'
I:.
r.
>i
I
,
1 NOTICE OF 0.. rJ;/lc heariHq ~
ver"l "'ifV\/f-ed. we. WONi,u IIS(IJ-C/c\l
tx- W/V)('{1/ S~/ON TY\ ee.rlN~ 01,; r
bt./'ep s 'f-e-~rJ CoNs/srtJ.iT
l1fq~e :Dour Stl/ Us oIJr-
WE- Ol.rt -rt-l E vcrrST' 5 _
Sincerely,
,
it
i
'1"
t .
, i
, !
. ii'
; i I
! ! I
. i i I
; I'
.: II
'II
~i'ill
, I
(rJAJ..c' e t1 ~~ : ~
I
p.~6-~
Sl(ol'N- COW7 C{Jh Or
f'tu t,vfJr~.? 1:'1 s liB ()
f-
i.l,
'/
~ , ,~,
,
,
eN {r\~ '4 ~IA
f- t C){i( IJ v
...1
I ({MY, ~L {Jet,joel}
,
I
I Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; i Marina a height increase. Out building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I.
.1 : storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
j
i
! I children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I
i
I
,
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
,
!
I
I
1 .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
: !
! ,
! ;
I
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
;' I
I .
! '
1 ~
I ;
;....;
j
I .
enhances a city.
,
! ,I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE ,OUR CITY
!
,
:.)
i.
I
:',
f
1 NOTICE ~F ct Pt.kllc heariHq ~
ve'd- f..,/(nlhd. we WONlrJ "srffc/c'"
{A ComrtllSblON rneen,l./~ OUl
btJ ep S 'T-~('I'\()..,j' rJ OJNS/ s,7AI r:
'fIGq~e :i)OM/ Sf,ll Us OIJT-
w ~ o.,re. 1/-1 f- vcrrS7' 5 _
Sincerely,
I"
~. .
f}
I:.
r
, ,
, I
,
. 'I .
II
! I
, I
'I
. I
, I
~\lI~f\O,E'H A't\U1 i !
. 'I!
i'
,
,
;k~~'
. C 0.1 J~ Cttb f) Jr,
';..0(0 r c- .1:
~elV/ur~ /1"/ ~ l/ 80
1'.' 1I1t= l~1
\.NA"'~ ~
: I
r-
\"".
.,
" "~
, ,
. 'I:
1
I
i COflAfVt. WeuJk)(''j,
,
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
;
i
I I children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I ..
I
,
I
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
! I
! .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
: l
,
!
I
I
,
I .
I
, ,
i ;
I
I i
enhances a city.
.-l
i
I .
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
! ,I
SAVE lOUR CITY
!
~.~
;
,
{',:I
h
r
:Ij
I
!
1- NOTICE OF 0.. rLkllc AeariNq tA:is
verd- ~i('nlf-cd.. Wi WONirJ I'srrrck"
{A. CoM('I1JS~/OH 1Y\eenN~ OlJi
bt./J ef S ''I"'e-~ rJ CoNS/Slt!; T.
'fIfq~e I)orvr Stll Us OIJT-
wE-art rt-l f, Vm-Gl' 5 _
Sincerely,
,
1 f
. I
,.
i"
i; .
\.
I
, :
, \
. : I .
ii,
, II
! ! I
i i I
:; II
Ii II
II II
'II
. II'
I II
--rA~ (;lvr./'^'ft~! ~
91J~, II
, 1 ilo I v.ct/MfJ Clfh /Jr
~~W'I./ Ii ~118 0
(!,,,s<~*J.1\. I
CIfN~ ·
1.
t
I'
I, : ,;
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~
v ~
Ted grRfrlAAJ
f'/IYS TIC powt
~~,J
.;r7S" rn.1~tic "r Or
rw ltffilfl' 11] liS d
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
K~.J~
r;t Aft COliEIf
T{';liliJt~Ky fo \.,()i~,(
QUvt/~
('f~ Sf TVlntl7 ttAfij- .
"~lItlJ- H ,w." i!b .
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
4L~ ~J t
C(rJ~j~ fa b trLA.
A()')\ IML~ (" (),~ T
~YfUt
~gsl )/~ / fZ Sf'
\ltV1V,~ h.'UIBD
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
(H,?IT I tV j2 t.stlf( K
~z
/tf~5~wr;y
ltVM'If'rl4 ~ lieD
}oR# If{ ~ '1 fOL.J)/t t-
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~~ek ~
/if\I{;fJ.-A YAS~E
mysTIC PLANT ]
V~t
I q{OI J./€}{ C(
AVf..l/riJ(~ I F1 llla;
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~~~
))ffIJ/t 11 troMtJ 1A Tz....
;~l/)r1"z
11~~J' /i~.u,,_.
., IVUV"1 fA.'71f
~~ h lJtfll
TlJUI (J(f ~'fC 1 Tow [(<
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
jAil it1l1{ I Ill" t1J
r~iZ~hv
P-BsllJf liJ sr
/tvilv;Jt~ ft 11/10
!tIJ(YIIII+ L J po tl f
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
/0 nW. IN Cf1.5!;j/~
JifJmlf'~/J 1611
CI1< riu. 0
Hf/,#~ In St
*"WT!dl/.. II >3190
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
}/' ~vt.~L
a--,., llld t'J
li;si, ( --p 01/~+ " -
0~~-
SpoIJ t Iq~ 5"1'
ctu~tJrti\.1 III 3 ~/gD
..1
I c (yv..,Vc, \:s 1 II'J- ~I
I
,
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: i Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
I', storage facility. This is a residential/town canter with a school for our
,
I
I children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I .,
I
,
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
: !
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
,
!
i
I
I
I .
! ,
i ;
. I
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
" .
! "
i ;
I
I ;
;..;
. i
I .
enhances a city.
I
,
, .
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE ,OUR CITY
i
.
:1
I
r
'.'
",
!
1 NOTICE OF 0.. PJoIIC heariHq ~
ve,'! ~irnlf-ed. WE WONlrJ I'srffc/c"
ex.- Coflt('{ll SblON rn eenlJ~ Ou r
b't/, ep s 'rf,trAQu'rJ CoNS/STtAI r:
'fIGQ5e J:)orvr S~/I Us OUT-
WE. ~re. ,NE VcYTST'S _
Sincerely,
,
, f
; ;
,
i.'
~: .
{~I
I:.
r.
11
JeIF ?(U(~ :!
t,
Ii
~ .~.
, 'r ~
,
~(~
J-c)~ c'~. ~. CiJuvt't; cltJt ~
{vt~lIrl'f.. Ii $]180
/
r \f\f
vJt\ If eYll(
'1
I Q~1M Cl f 'Jo(L I
I
I
,
-I Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; i Marina a height increase. Out building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I
I'. storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
I
1 children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
'l .\
I
I
I
f
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
i
!
I
,
I .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
; i
, ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
: : cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
:..;
i
! . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
,
I I
: .
:,'
SAVE lOUR CITY
~~
,
\
,
;':1
i:.
I.'
r
: '~
I
!
~ NOTICE OF <A rtkllc heariHq lP4s
verif- "-i f'n/ tr. d. WE- WoN',J Ilsrfl'C/c"
{A. Co/V)(Y1/ S<(;ION N\ eenN~ 01; r
be./J ep S ''re-('I'\().j rJ CoNS/Slt:A/ T
11fq~e :DC:Jrvr St.ll Us ovT-
w ~ o.-r-e. iH E VcJTGl' 5 .
Sincerely,
,
; r
. I
i
I i
\"
~ .
, i
. . ,
i I .
: j \
! II
, ' I
I: I,
..... 'I II
>~ JJil
l ~ Ii
IJI : I II
'II
. II I'
:\ i !
FE ,I Lt' 1\ \~ au ~\"ir
tloJlt'itJ
3'l{oi IJ. cOuJ/t;' Clv'#:; /)r-
~l)etJfur^- f 2s1 S (J
t N. S~,J I\. \01J\
t \.)~q t1 C)
: I
tl;,-.
',r
: : ,~.
,
,
I
I
:
. I
: I
,
,
\ :
j
, :
'1 .
i
i
I
, I
I :
,
I
: i
!
i
I
,
,
, .
.. ,
! ,
! :
....;
i
I '
!
I
: .
i.1
;~
,
I
..
i"
~. .
"
f'
l'
1"'.
"
r"
>\
t;
II
.1..
'i
i
I
~.. ';})~ ~=~
,
I
Please continue td vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
I
Marina a height incrrase. Our bUilding and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not 1smissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land u~e area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
!
emanating gas and pil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off.l~ading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over.burde+d traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would nol even be considered in other upscale .
I
I
ctties sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
enhances a city. I
ENFORCE OUR ~UILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
I
SAVE lOUR CITY I
! I
I
i
I I
! I
1- NOTICE OF 0.. ?i.kllc heakNq ~
vert- f..-i('V\/f-ed. WE WdNi,u I'srfl-clc"
Oc Cofll(Y1'S~/ON mee N~ oUI
b-eJ, ep S'f""e-~ rJ Co S/STt~ T.
'f/fqGe I26rvr sell lJ OUT-
WE o..rt.tH f VmI 1'5 _
Sincerely,
9 k IIIJ
J.o<; 0 f E .cCNJry ad' Or"
5..-() ~ I i! $ 31ft:>
,
\
: : I
i I
i I
" I
. 'II
, ,
. :i !
~+<V STEiNl !
'\ ,
I
,
W~H RVII?~1 COHDU
it
I
I
r i
, !
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~l-
fr!O~~e
I
(edc
ftOfY'.lf~~ POf(,/
felk
~ ~5' ;()~ It]. 51" .
ItU€/.t(1J1'ff- t/ ~114t'
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Dirt! It) Kt"stl({ k
t e W/f, k..
/f{ISr ~ttf1 OV;4f..
41HiVflIt4- II . .f]l8o ,
'({;tu./ oE It({7 Tow if fZ.
,]
I Co M Illl H () t,::<' i3, E i< G
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I.. storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
!
I
I , children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
"
I
I
I
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
; i
: i
1
i
I
,
I .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
:- I
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
; : cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
:
i enhances a city.
I .
;..;
i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
,
, .
SAVE JOUR CITY
!
~!
i
"
~;
~ .
{'.:l
l;. .
,
>j
i
1- NOTICE OF <A Ptkllc heajl",q ~
velt- "-imlhcl.. WE WONlrJ "srrrclc"
tA Cof()(Y11 S~/ON N\ eenN~ 01; r
be../, ef S ''r~~ rJ CoNS/STilI r
11fq~e :i)OrJ/ SEll Us our-
WE o..re -rt1e VaiGl'S .
Sincerely, .
,
i!
! I
I
! :
, I
fj.e 'wJ.tt IN
'l0S-05 (.c"~{I()e O~
AV'wrl//fl./ c'"' 2.l18D
,
I
. ,
. : I .
; II
I I
_ill'
, ii.1
~ ill
'I
-:II""I ~ B[I{jJ \ TE ; ~ i
. ;1 !
I
.,
,
t
, : .1:
. 'Ii
- (<11/))
'V'I- T t f{ 'II k: 1/'-(
I
I
I
.1
I
I
C-"" M /-1,,( z 6 'r~
Please continue t~ vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
Marina a height incrrase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
: I
\ :
1
I :
1 .
i
I
I
i .!
I
,
i
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage faCility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
! ,
r :
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts .
I
I
emanating gas and pi! fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off.l~ading of boats on trailers contributing to an
I' .
already ()ver.burde~ed traffic situation. This kind o.f facility in the
i
I
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
: I
cities SUph as CorallGables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
enhances a city. !
i
I
I .
ENFORCE OUR tUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
SAVE JOUR CITY I
! !
i
i
,
1 .
, ,
I
I~
. i
I .
!
,
,
I
; .
'.'
.,
I ,
! i
1- NOTICE OF ct ?lkhc heairiHq ~
vert- ~i('t\lt-ecl, Wt WdNlrJ Ilsr(}C/c"
I
().. CoM('{1IS~/ON fY\eenN~ OUI
be./leFS'f"'e~.N eoL'IS1t4T.
'PIfQ5e 'I)OM/ SEll lIl0lJT-
WE. Gtrt.rli E vcm i'S _
Sincerely,
: !
, i
,.
\:.
r
{',:l
I:.
r
i
, :
, I
i i i .
",1
! II
, i I
:; II
. : i I
i i
i I
, II
. ,I, ,
AIITDHY V Ai~! !
WH.~,
~os E. C.(JJ.~ (ttJi, Of..
t1w'AI~/ M ?Jlgo
?. " I fl/'1
WRfe
"
t
\,l..
. .
"
I ,
I
I
, 1
I ~M' t-folziocdl
I
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; i Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
.'
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the ben.efit
\ ' of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
:l : storage facility. This is a residential/town canter with a school for our
j
i
I, children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts '
I
I
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
,
!
i
I
I
1 .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
: i
, ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
; · ctties suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton, StriCt code enforcement
I
; . enhances a city.
I
;...;
'I ' ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
! ,I
SAVE lOUR CITY
;.1
i
i
,
{';l
I'
r"
F,
,
>j
I
!
J NOTICE OF (A rtklic heariHq ~
Vtiif- f-.-iM/f-ed. WE WONltJ "sn'tCk"
CA- CoMf'{IJ S~/ON Tn ee-nN~ OlJ r
ht.// ef S 'r-'f.;~' rJ VJNs/srtA.t r
11fq~e :i)C;rJI SEll Us our-
WE- ~re. 1'l1E VffST'S _
Sincerely,
,
i!
, ,
. I
,:
(.:
~ .
I
, i
, !
~(Jke ~
,2ofo('- t 0l.1~ j)
t/tVf.v../!v;... . etUfJ f}r
fl '80
~VIO G.6.1Di?t? (.(,...
. I .
I
I
I
I
I
!
~
t-
I,
. :.. '..'
. .
.}
,coJ
vvA,eRY 1 ~Oi)
J ,00,..
1<-
" 1
I Co~g lfO/..2l]Ei<&i
,
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ ' of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
\" storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
i
I
1 · children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
~ :
:
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
,
!
\ . center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
" .
! : cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
.....
i
! . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
II
SAVE JOUR CITY
~'!
(
I
rl
f-
r".
r
:',
,
!
-1- NOTICE OF 0.. Pdcllc heari",q ~
vert- "-irn/f-ed. WE WONi,u l/srftCIcIl
~ Cof'l)('(l'S~/ON l'Y\eem./~ OUI
bt-/, ep S 're('l'.().j tV CoNS/Smt r.
11Gq~e :i)crvr $6// Us OUT-
WE. O\,rt. rt-l E vcrrGl' 5 _
Sincerely,
,
, (
I;
. I
,.
\:
~ .
I
, I
, !
VOIdJ,e'J"
~ 'tVi )J. CoJ" rl1 (i uJ ()t~
/WiN1Utft- ,::, ?l/~ U
,: i .
:; I
! 1
i I
~ ; i
II
i I
I .
I !
(', ,- I"," {.I(/ht' J !
\Sf" ~-e "I ~ J ~
. . 'j:'
..
"
. ;
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
L-fJ (j{L./r IJA V I (
G Q A V wJ' (()IV!Ju
04 Vii
1/61 N OM/tl-! c4 Vd.. () {
"'Vf-I,lflJl.+; FI 1.7.180
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
c?"7~i:C>c
fl A//V 11 t- A (3 c::R
g i!.AI/JIZ t1 (O;!/DJ
~8P...
~ '3 0 1(1/ (().h./[;t r e/IJ 8. fJ f!
Mt.NTIJ/l,1 f1 'S~/~o ~,
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
AOAM (VI. g i<.AUER.
Bltf\/JUFLA (UN '01
ElA-I!CK
~~Ji N COJ~ UI!6 }:)R
Itl/{N Ti/fiA; f/ '1>]) e tJ' '
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Iff k ;1- ~t i tJ:>j{ 1
mYJli ( ;: or'vl 5'
~Mky
'Z.S')i) My}f(C/lf';or
4-v'Wtvr!- It 1),ft;
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~.
'J{ti~" u c() ('
mYSflc po',^,1 )--
~"
~53c '1>h''Jf Or,
?{(;.t~Jv r&\. L l6/ B c
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
SUSA,AJ iJ412FyvH1/IJ
rYiVSl7C POIM
()..)("!4Vtll,J
/9/01 Nt"1' cr
IWUltI)r~ k ~1/~/)
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Sincerely,
~//Ij/{
5;/rRhl rnn UcI4
/'Yt y'SfiC poi N r )...
ftM./C~
hit} S ,y (;.?{, cr
!fwvrll<.4 f:J.. lJ/f)()
v
...1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
.1
COM/lA. I/VI.);; b t-J )
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I
, '
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
\
\
I :.
!
j
i
I
'I I
"
I '
I
I
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
j
!
l .. center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
:' l
! ,
! :
,
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
1 "
I ~
I i
:...
i
I .
enhances a city.
il
ij
i.1
/
,
,
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
:",
i
1- NOTICE OF ct Pi.kllc hea;iHq ~
Vf,id- /-'-irr.lf-ecl.. WE WONI,J "srltclc"
Ot- Cofl)('I1IS~/ON N\eenN~ OlJr
beJ, ep s '.....e,rAoJ rJ CoNs/srtA.; T
'fIfqGe :DCiMi S~l/ Us OIJT-
w ~ "'.r e. 1"'/-1 E V crrG 7' 5 _
Sincerely,
,
i!
. ,
i
..
{'
~: .
f~' .
I:.
r
, i
, !
, ("M(,(j7ft-
. ~.cr € <:O~ CWl, ~
i v..A/'t.ll.lf lJ Y.., I' I ~ ~, g 0
: I .
i i
I
, I
I
I I
II
. III
fllvNE L tAIII rr I i ~
I,
i .
,
I
WAr, {VI (LA ( C'OlYlJo
t
I",'
'f
.,
\ r~
.1
I
I
I
,
. I
Co!v1ftI/ STEt2~
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: i
, .
I
Marina a height increase. Out bUilding and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ :
\
I :
1 .
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
j
i
1
.: .
"
I
I
I
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts .
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
; i
; i
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
,
!
I
,
I
, .
" ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
: ' cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
i : enhances a city.
I . i
~
i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
! . SAVE lOUR CITY
!
,
;,!
;
,
I
,
,
:1,
I
!
J NOTICE ~F 0... Pt.kllc heariHq ~
ve'd-- ~j(V\lf-ecl. WE WONirJ l'srl1'C/C',
CA..- CoM((l1 S~/ON N\ eenN~ Ou r
btJep S~~~rJ CtJNs/srtAlT
?!fq5e ::Dorvr Stll Us ouT-
WE o.-re. IN E VffGT' 5 _
Sincerely,
,
: t
! ;
i
! :
t' .
f'.:r
r.
r
, !
: : I .
, I
! I
! I
. ,i I
; il
!I I
. :1 '
lIJ I
S;i M 2v. t~.-A M^ X ' '
!.
W'fA~
'1,.) N 1,,,;"" AU'!.
g-V)''i/ . '>~- f1
A-I){J./filtfl. ( n 11 / S I'
~/IIJt
1JoiU (J f)
'1'.1...
. .,
.1.,
"
I :
1
I
i C 6}1ArtA. yv\. S;1(-: [)tJ /
:
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
!
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
! .
I : storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
i .
;
i
I children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I .,
I I
,
i
,
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
,
!
\ . center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
.. ,
; : cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
......
i
! . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
I "
,
, .
i,'
SAVE JOUR CITY
;.1
i
,
I
fl
I'
(.
r
:'i
!
1 NOTICE OF 0.. Pt.kllc heariHq (A{S
vert /-.,i('r\/hd. we- WONirJ I/S(/fCk.\1
0\... Co/V)('fI1 S~/ON rn ee.nN~ 0(; ("
b-e./I ep S 'r''&rAo..i rJ CoNS/S/'t!; T
11Gq~e J:)6rvt 56// Us OIJT-
W~ o..re. I/-Ic VOTGT'S .
Sincerely,
, t
i;
. I
i
;~;
!: .
! I
, i
. ; i .
~I
. i
. II I
~ - ~,_. -. ii I
. ~il i
. V /0 :,
pr... J1aoD~k\:
g~()(1P1
v-e~
;:H$Nf.~7ST
A-\)cN~ j: j :31180
v If ti\ v\{l.
I "'.
~ , . ~
i :
"
,
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Sincerely,
511{ ;R~-;J
S!1IVOY P-(;~ff#tflIIL
13lAvur 14 (uvtN.J
~wtJ..l+/
1,;0/ IV- (()~ (/Vf) /)r
ftI!<l,vfll'fllf ft 1] 19 b
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~'
i .,
~ L?
!1t!T LEEBoiA/
(jR.AVURA CON'f}0
t..~lJow
23 0 l f/ Cd JI'Itlf CI tJt P/(
IWtAfTM; /~ S3111{)
Comm. Michael stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~
f;: I( SO/v t- T 2
/5RtlU :,i;fj1 (0(1/ !)~J
S<1Jl h
J/o / N Cdi/IV1'1 (/ iJ{j . Of(
f!v(;y17/lftj Ii Z.1; 80
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~r1 ;f~llIm
~... -~--
()o ~A frl A IlkJ<! m
(rIy~/i{ PD//II1 5
, rvv~f kJIft
. .sS"~b /Jty~f'{ pgltll ~Il, .
Jtvtl'/~ ;1'1. Jll~O
COmIll. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
r,
_&~\rv'Q~~
JD AvIV ( C {(ill r (
vq () (Vl1 r t:t i1 f J;? ,
I&IEKlrt R
z.-K 5 i tJ Ii I. q3 .)'/
Av I( Nl1Iftfl/ fl ~ 31 go
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Sincerely,
a~
Crr(L(.JS CSi/. v 1'[t./Vi.i4,iV
rvty ~tlt fC1//Jt I
SJIlfUIlI,;;
I)
bbO..l lit V(7'- A--rJfl,
/tll 1# f7J Pli f{ 33iB<>
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
7: $'{lt4cL !6CAl&D(
AOft'llr~(",J- P oP1
.
Y6/)MrtI'
)..'85'/ /V',{' If.? J1'
JfvwtVtl! R. l$fO
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
,J)ft~
f},Ji, E EIIIYlrl!-(
Ell /I!I!)!
1530"~.uJlic leitvf/J,'-
IhJ.tpIfVJ;;q l11 BO
/Y!Y5ifC (JO;/Jr )_
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
fYJURUl i GJ.ol.. 0 rr+Rij
11\ yJftc Poi)Ji 3
i ... J I ".J:.
vCUlf"W'<}
N/o{ Nt Ji.cr
PtJtJii1/r-pr f1l6/~
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Icrt
-
j iJ 0-;
t9 (os7 vt
('. C ~/../r I At-
(Jflr'-
f1tc!t"
23~ Nt /'1/ fT
~Th h li."~80
.1
I Olllll}1. (n r:;rn tJ,
I
,
I
r Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
I : storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
i
1 children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
' ,
I '
,
I
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
: i
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
j
!
!
I
1 .
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
, ,
; : cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
~
i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
,
, .
SAVE lOUR CITY
;,!
;
i
,
I
!
1- NOTICE OF ct PlkllC heari,A/q LU:ts
vel~ A.-i(\'l/f-ed. Wf. WONI~ "srfrc/c',
01- Co/V)(V1/ S<;ION rn ee.m'~ ou r
b-t/, ep S 'r-'(?,;~' rJ CtJNS/Sltl./ r:
P/fQ5e J:)o~ St.ll Us OUT-
W f. o...re. -r/1 f. VffGT' 5 _
/'1f>-.,.,~~ ..L-
..
i:'
~: .
Sincerely,
f'
I'
('.
r
.
>,
NI\r2IR~'~
7.1i..Mi#
~()50S i (oh.m1 CltJ~ f){'
^Vi:-#Tu{~ I Ft ~;~.;
VI,:H
'y:J Ala ~
. f
1\.
. . .~,
, '.'
I
I
I
I !
I.
I
.
'1
I
i (Of\t1.. 15615 D/AI/'lcNy/..
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
.!
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
.\ ': storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
i
li children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts .
I '
,
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
: l
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
,
!
i
I
,
I .
. .
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
; : cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
:...;
i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
!
!J
SAVE lOUR CITY
!
,
>,
!
J NOTICE OF 0... PlkllC heariHq ~
ve,'! kifY>lf-ed. we WONI.,u IlsrftC/c"
()... Cofl)('(ll S~/ON Tn een}.l~ Ou r
be-I, ep s '....e~ tV CoNS/$/7A; T
11fq~e I)orvr Stl/ Us OIJT-
\N E.. {Art. 1/1 c V()/Gi'S .
Sincerely,
i."
~. .
{',:t
l~' .
I I
,i II
ill.
,I II
il i '
:. I
2 ~cA 'I"\i ,;v..~i'
/!{12~
?l(~l <:(a~! CltI'J J) ('
(1fJf/v I () r~/ IC; ?1( 80
rfN~"f..I~~A-
tQ~l/J l,,)
'~;,
. . . .~.
, ,.l
,
1
I
i CCWtH. G"6la t:::J (~M()/~f I
,
. r Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
,
i
! 1 children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
!
I
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
,
!
\ . center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
" .
; : cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
: .
i enhances a city.
I
...,
i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
: .
SAVE lOUR CITY
',Ii
!
1 NOTICE OF 0... ri.kllc hcariNq ~
ve;~ I--i('f\/f-ed. WE- WONi;J I'Srfrclc"
CA..- Co/Vl('flJ SblON "" ee.T1N~ o() r
b-e../J ep S 't-(.J{'I'\(),j rJ WNS/ s rtA; T
11Gq~e J:)CJrvt 56// Us OUT-
\N E. "'-re. 1"/1 E VrJlGT' 5 _
Sincerely,
it
. ,
i
, ,
\"
r .
f'
I:.
r
, i
. I .
I
I
I
I
I
!
Y kolfl-l1foJ
f2d~M hJ .
.. j,)' CU/JVI11' C / cJ/" j),,~
"'!>L{rJl ' 0
M(.v1vr~ FI ? 3, 8
,
\
IE H}f,../A p rt
, I
tl
I'
~ !, , .'~,
. '
"
.
Corom. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincere\y,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
, ,
I"'\'(sV It 7 (') ~ T' z.
F\O;YII(M J poll
ot(l't....
2~1 /It 1fJ. sf
twe;Jl7JtA.. 11 P/8"tJ
I
1
I ~.~ Qcb~QMM)')
,
I
. r Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
I' storage facility. This is a residential/town canter with a school for our
,
i
! , children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts .
I .,
,
,
i
,
,
!
i
,
I
1 .
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
i i
, ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
, ,
j ;
. I
! .
i ,
I
enhances a city.
I ;
I ..
-'
i
I .
I
,
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I .
,
, .
SAVE lOUR CITY
;.1
/
i
I
{',:I
h
r.
'.'
,',
,
!
1- NOTICE OF 0... PlklFc hearif/q ~
ve'd-A..i(V\/f-ed.. we WONlrJ I'S(ffc/c"
C>.- CoM('IlI Sb/ON IY\ eenN~ O(J r
beJ, ef S r(.;tAo..i rJ CoNS/STtJ.! T.
?JGq~e 'I)or-Jt S~II Us OUT-
W f- "-.r t iN E V rJlG T' 5 _
Sincerely,
: !
! I
..
j;.
f
1J8[ STErN
i I
I I
! I
i i .
i I
! I
1\ i
I!
I .
, .
~.
h,;J
.2..o~~o.r E' c.:o~'::J .cl(j~ iJ....-
t:tv!Jvfv~ 1'-1 1JI80
\ti1\lF.l\~ I f v~
t.
I.'...
I
" .~
. '.'
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
t11/U fJl n r;, /fiR..
rn 1/ SO C P()/ 1./1 I
/
Yh~fL
5 ~ co /'Itit f/l c {if (),..
fttItlliiU/ ~/ JSlg~
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T -
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~)
~~Ml 'lOTtf
Y}t YStic. !OINt 2-
t~
/q,QS f./t1' cr
~~tvrp..-I PI 111~
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
. ..--------
fPL TAlfLu K
'--:B~Au~1 R t~
f'#l1 }b (,
::t Of /y' aJ wrey (I rJ:r, If)IL,
AVCV'f(lt(l, fl (lJ&rJ
Comm. Bob Diamond,
'Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
MA ta~ o-UZ,L'Yl, ItA)
rny~/;c (o//.l ~
W2-ff"'VJ
~l.(()O Ne ,qJ. "
ftvtWhlfA/ FI VIS,)
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS ~~
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BEUEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T' · '. Ii "~"'_
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
<;/ D f6RJVI AN
rn Y sri c (16/>).17 s-
f
po f"I'IuW
35;0 '~1rttc f/"iAffJr-
l)j/.lNrl/t It I fCI s j,g;;
',,'j
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
g~4-
120,tl r't\ 12 t<. f1. I{ I
13 R-/I;(; U f.. A C 0N()J
1'1;~If;
~ JiJ I'" 10 ,ClJUl/ft! tl'f/K
,JtVlNTfltlJ1 ~ IlK
. / ! s]/8o
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
J/JV( /1,.. Vf?tt
M yr;fl C FIJI?,,;I b
Je~
11.t061Ji 19) ft-
au evtI./ (If / '=-I ~ Ji ~ (;
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
NflT/1u: l...[fjloW/T/
'-
Pt/JIJtl Itfli{ PIJ/cl
j...e (150 /)I (1?
)8)( Nt /1] }!
AV(/'ITVU /f/ l3lg()
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
,WOJ7)Z ~
ty\ Arc;A /<10 ~
rs~.-AV'jlti COJAjtJ~
(IOJ
';/ (J [ tV C()il N77'} tI {;[J )J Il
/WtAl riJ M PI 11180
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~~~~
''"Q I IiA VA sseL EV
(] iZM/ukACo./;Ju
V/Ks-tLIH/
~30{ N co iJ!IfK-y o,,!{/(j PIC
. ftVOITVW--; It 53/g0
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
JboL~
~ U C'I'( 5. -c It iAJ~ r I't.-
r^1f,fi( fQ'/IJIS
~C~WP'
~ f1 1],80
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Sincerely, l
/
"J ~~ SUlO 0.>'
('ljS/i( q6i~f s -
';~o~.s
1flo fAJ'-h.- {oN I () r,
avu.JfvrA. (fl b J/80
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
. , /
4,L
L/F'~ L ,~
i . ,I( <J f/ I> q: /V1 A,'~
.^1l/~J( Pl:;J/
j
f....t,rj,.;.wviN
J.')
, ~ ~ Ih~sh 10;, vi (Jr.
;4{Il-/Vfflrt+/ ~/ 3]/8(.1
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMlSSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
IkJWA~f.' cvoUJ/YJAtJ
/'I1y~f1c POI/vI
{Xip,
. nw
jCf/()/ N,( 16 or
fJrrJtlYTiJI./f 1-/ ?llBo
I
I
,
!
I
~lctjJ"'- SL~<tN~cH{{e~)
I
Please continue t~ vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
Marina a height incrrase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be fallowed, not ~smissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land u$e area is not meant for such a large scale
I
I
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the s~reet. Not a place for over-sized yachts
i
emanating gas and ~i1 fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-I~ading of boats on trailers contributing to an
I .
already ()ver-burde~ed traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town woul1 not even be considered in other upscale
. I
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
: I
,
\ :
\
! .
I '.
'1
;
i
I
'1 ~
!
I
i \
!
I
,
I
, .
" ,
I ,
J .
! '
i ,
1 .
I . i
;...;
: i
1 .
!
,
{!.:!
I'
1"'.
r
'"
'1
enhances a city. I
ENFORCE OUR ,UILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
SAVE lOUR CITY I
! I
: I
I
,
! i
J NOTICE OF ct Plio/Ie hcak",q lA:ts
vert- "'-imd-eel. WE- W INirJ IISrIJ-C/c'I
01- Co/Vl('f1/ S~/OH rn ee N~ 01.; I
bt /, ef s'l-ef'/'I(M rJ Co S/SltAl T
'fJfQ5e :Dorvf set I U our-
WE "'-rt rt-l E V~ i'S .-
Sincerely,
,
: f
, i
I .
,
,
:~
;
I
,.
i,.
~ .
I
, :
. !
ftff#) , i
Act;oJ t Co".)-~~J otf)h D.....
CcvUv'fuA.- /GI 31/8 rJ
: : I .
,: I
.! I
,. I
,! I
"
Iii
,I I
.1 .
1\ I
A1~O( P Am1. .
vJAlftel/lfW
t:
F.'
r
l:
'1
I !dfYol. )I/WI (J.OllI-ICIJ1
I
! Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: i Marina a height increase. Out bUilding and zoning laws are in place
)
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
! .
\.'. storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
j
i
! l children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I
,
i
,
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
i
!
\ . center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
" ,
i : cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
...,
. i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
! ,I SAVE JOUR CITY
;'\
~ NOTICE OF 0... PlkllC hcariHq ~
vert- f....i('f\/h:d. Wt WONirJ I'srfrck"
(A. CoM ('11 I SblON rn eenN~ Ob r
be-II ef S "f-~~ rJ VJNS/S/7;.t T
'fIGq~e ::D6~ S~/ / Us ovT-
WE OI.re.. ,HE, VrJlGT'S _
Sincerely,
,
I r
: ;
. I
..
t"
~ .
i
I :
, i
f'
\~. .
.; i .
,~ i I
! i 1
ill
:; I i
'. 'I
. I
Ii
I II
II
II i
. E(')~ leq G
-
f ('five
'1'1.
. , ,~,
i :
I'. : "
,
I'
f' /Cfe I/V
.2oS0( t (()tI';(~ C (vj Dr-
A-U(A.I!",rA....; rei 2 SI8 (I
W
\N ~ 1 't i\"ft
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
!~~
tio .~tY (' ~
MVft'
2J06 A./f 11/ .ff
1rV<ei/ii/i/f IV 11/80
fA'tC C~flr/If{,-
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
ftt'r I--t. KOSiN
P.o~
/1t5)" ltJ/vJJer1 w.IJ'
AvlII'tI/lJ k l~/B()
-4Utll13cf~l v6w/[" ~J
.1
I !1 rWort 00T1I IffJ I
,
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
1
\
I .
.1 .
"
i
!
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
'1 I
I .\
I
I
I
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
i
!
i
I
,
I .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
j !
,. ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
i : cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
:..;
. i
I . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
: .
SAVE lOUR CITY
!
;.1
;'
,
\
I
{',)
h
r.
,
:'j
I
!
-1 NOTICE OF 0.. ?tJ;/IC heariHq ~~
vert ~i(hlf-cd.. WE, WON1.,J "S(frck'l
Ol. CoM('{IIS~/ON 1'Y\eenN~ Out
b-e), ep S 'T-e~ rJ VJNS/SltJ./ T
11Gq~e I2Or-J/ Stl/ Us OUT-
WE. "'-re. .,.-/1 E VrJlGT' 5 .-
Sincerely,
rfL A Crf"-' o'
~OS~ E CO&flrtt C/lJI3 PI( .
~V'i,J,)TII't41 ~I ?yjO
J/J.. ~IfJ Y
! t
. ,
I
! I
, I
,
: I .
; I
! I
, I
: I
. Ii I
'I I
II i
T I..Jf (,..r ~ I
I
,
,:
'r-
r .
i
I
: I
. t
I'
. .~.
, ,.i
\/'fft- T~~ y liS '1/
c-DI.fi'JIi
: I
t
I (~, 2e,J:R--u~,J'''<Wk)
t
r Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
; i Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
\
1 .
I :
! .
j
i
1
: ,
I .\
I
,
I
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
,
!
I
,
I
, .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
: 1
" ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
! ' cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
i . enhances a city.
I .
-'
i
.1 . ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
! ,I
SAVE JOUR CITY
;'J
i
r
,
>j
I
!
-1 NOTICE ~F 0... PJ.-;Ilc hear; f/q tAts
veid- ~I (V\/f-ed.. WE WONi ,J"sn'fCIc"
tA- Co(V)(Yl1 S~/OH N\ eenN~ 01; r
be../, ef S 'r'~rAQ,j rJ CoNS/STtlI r
11fq~e :Dorvr S~I / Us OlJT-
WE. o..re. "n-l E VcYlGT' 5 ..
Sincerely,
1 f
\,
{'
.r.
el
I
, i
, !
\'
('.
r
. 'I .
I
I
I
t
'I.'~
. .,
. I.'
,
\
t1t~ ~(' ,
;....or are. Cr)iA/~ Ctrb [.:)., i
ttiJeA/fvf?L-; Itl 3YlB 0
I?/NI'\ ~*
~ QTC,ILVIe-w
',1
I 001'111.2ev AUE?ZS(kH,
J
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
i i Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
.1
\ :
I
I .
I :.
1 .
i
i
1
'j f
I .,
,
,
i
I
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
: i
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
i
!
I
,
I .
! ,
i :
I
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
" ,
I
: "
; ;
I .
I i
:...;
i
I .
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I I
,
, .
i.'
SAVE lOUR CITY
;,1
t
I
:I~
j
J NOTICE ~F C\. Ptk/lc heariHq (,U4s
verif- !---t {'tIlhe/.. we WON; rJ "srrrclc"
Oc Cof'(JfYlIS<;IOH tYle.e-n.Al~ OUI
b-eJ ep S 'f-e-~ tV CoNs/sriJ.; T
11Gq~e 'I)Or..ll SEll Us OIJT-
WE. o..re. -r/1 E VcJlG7' 5 _
Sincerely,
,
: r
, ,
I
v.r7A.( i
loJ.'ll ilE 50Ch /'tv~
!. IW(./J1vrp.. I'/sY 86
'..\ "
~ : ,~,
, \i
;
VIII ^ t1
?~'
I
, :
, I
,
,.
~:'
~ .
L'
k.
, 1
I
j DJY\r1., ::2.eu AU(K /:3.o..c{l/
I
.1 Please continue to vote against any variance allowing' Hi-Lift
: I Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
\ · of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I .
.1 :: storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
;
'1
1 children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
' ,
I
I
I
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
! ,
r .
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale .
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
i !
: (
1
i
I
I
I .
:. l
I
: '
i ;
I .
I i
enhances a city.
...,
. i
I .
;
,
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,
! ,I
SAVE lOUR CITY
~i
i
,
{'.)
l~'
>\
,
!
1 NDTlCE OF lA. ?dJIIC hcaritlq ~
ver~ "'i~lf-ed. WE- WONirJ Ilsrfl'C/c"
tA- CoM('IlJ S~/ON fY\ eem./~ 01; r
be. /1 ef S ''r~~ rJ (J:;NSI S TtAI T
11fq~e I)CN( $6/1 Us OIJT-
WE o.-re. tHE V~GT'S .
Sincerely,
, t
! ;
[
, ,
'r'
~ .
, i
: i .
, ,
I '
I '
, 1
i I
i i
j
il
. 1..'1 '
! !
I
MQI-it4 L';J!3ul.A,lt T21,
!
,
~(~(;~:h- \
'11./01 i.). 4.V~r ctv~ D (, '
a.,r)e"""fvr~ /C'I ~ Sf 9 ~
fD'f i'!f Ii A 0 tt
'- CCiy'IJ v
r
I'
: : .:~,
"
,
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~~
SeymrJl( r<.uwJ
IJ (\ AVU t: A co/v Do
f2j; B I;..
3, 01 ;tJ Q;J~ c1~ f),c
~# 13I!0
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~J~
~~/9/
q~.~
5', P A J.jR.AIV\.
r)L! f! f ~. ;1.1-1 R AI'VI
4~;n/tAts (oa
/Iti!li1M
}.Sr/,(l,{ If] Jr
ffi'eMW- NlllirJ
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
t~E
~bCI'f /f(*<--
fYt VSf't '- /Je) A/f ').-
A.. 1- LJ
L,~t-
5,5 Z 0 IWfsht fr /Jr,
M'wN r't 11 llJ ~o
I
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
C J4 j2,t. f-t '(t1 0 ::;
111 Y111( t)ul/Vr &
/-UlW{
-ZY(JtJ J.ll /qi- &,
1ti/l#110 /C-/j3/!J
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARlNG WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
"'J' c t: S;{;i iJ ot. 0
fYl'1'rlC puNT I
Set ~l c/
ZI. au ~ytrt- It {JI-
I}tJtli/1vm- 16/ ~~/g;;!
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
lCl-
YV('1 COf\ ref-^-
fVlYJ!' ( ?c, II'~ (-
Cotrt~
1 itOd ~i 1'1') sr
(lA)€lIAvrll-/ tcl 5J18c
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
t
(YINA Ii f\~;.;t.1
Y'YlyW( pui NT
k~~s
Jilfr ""SHe 161/;/ Pi
~'oc:l
IWWTZlflr ,el. ]J/9o
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
/-![PP7 lYJoJ,.1cfsrt:RiJ
((lof!-,e,Jsrp t jJ
3/6//1) cdiJM.tl C/ (it tJt.
}rillfiJtl R 53/80
~RAI/UR {~
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
J'fJC611 cf/(Ulof F
1
TIJ (fI r1 r '-/< f( 1- 04.1 ~ It.
~~
/lfg>5 T~e.7. ~/41
~IIU- II lZllo
. ..:.
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
7-.e L.p A. ('0 It c ~
IV f.NiJ 'efF 7 TO l.IJCICJ
z... o:>U U.)
11f; >$ Tf./()Il1trry ~
1\ueA//{J(I-/ "I 2118"
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
Qv- B~~4QRl
/Jo Rit & lc.NJT [ ( /1/
e~Ai) u rcA t(),JVJ.
t2.rr>tv;17 (j0
?3 0 I }/ CiJ7fAmj cI &~ fli{
M{lIIruu t1 6"l18d
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
,
1j8f t COf!f Ii
BRA UlJ/Z/1 (YJ;v1J u
COb/eN
!:Zb{ IJ,COJA1!tf eN) 8 tJ;[,:.,
AU{;ff{JK-!-; H ],J/~D
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
:2f~
LrJVi.( Felht/
IYtYJfiC ?bllvl s-
~~
.,
)5~ M~hc fb:J {J"
A\JJ.f.IfUr(A ?\, 11{ 80
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
cJm~~~aI~
!kllOlfll lI{Jt~f(.
r()K#6~~! /()wC(
fJJ/~l
/1J~St7liWSll~ ~lIJf
/M~7TlM-/ff ,(111tJ
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
w~
t/JWAIJ.{;) dow, ,v(,.P/\
!JOin I { N.A PO a, r
/tPwwj ~r-
;"iSI /.If 19~ sr
W4JtVf't- It ?Jit'
Comm. Luz Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, But many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to all
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* NOTICE OF THIS PUBLIC HEARING WAS
SHORT. WE WON'T "STACK" COMMISSION MEETINGS.
OUR BELIEFS REMAIN CONSISTENT. PLEASE DON'T
SELL US, YOUR VOTERS, OUT.
~d-.
!J11 L. 7t) 1/ ku R. t!>1ft H
n)1'7~ pOIIv?
!;U/tMiAN
s)")1" fk1Jt n /J;
~\lwtvrl\. ~I UIQ~
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a lInegative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
*' NOTICE OF cA- fJuh/;[/ heaTltJ ().Ja 5
'Ie,; J/(rjlfed. ().Je. WOIJ~P t'/5fad':.
C\. Co m (Yl1 5 SI O;L! M &fT/Nt? . Que.- &f;/... /(;.F~
'Ye.1YIc.:tl}V CON t'" . _ J
/'">_. i::>16/lf.A.f I. P)6QS[.. Do/iT
J Cl_L LJS OuT~ W[.. Y'.
r>'e... TfI IS
va TiS r-S .
Ah iWH V !6~U E,-
if !f'5(;n;t?z
I-o~ ~ .~. C/1I.C JJW)..j C)' t//t''1L1r~,
f,1!t;v?l!.{!J / P f 3:S/f-/J
C o?-O/V' At.:r0 crYl/)()
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
'"* NC/TlC[ OF CA- '/).L/' I. .
'rUQ/(/ neaT/;Jq was
"eY;'/(YlIfed. ()Je, WOIJ'-f F[)-fad~ .
0\. Com(YI/SS/O;L) M&BT/NCi. Ocre- B[LJEF:;
'Ye1Ylo..nv CON G _J
c;'- 16Ilftlf I. PJt:qSL Do/./'
v t::.,LL US Our - 'W II:' Y\
v r> re- TN;,-
\.101/Sr-S . c..
'"VAl coHEI!
o 6f<-OtlfIJJo C oNfJU
-" l-""Y ,
.;} /L-t/lz,hV
il.o;;~~. (..V. ((1.) './''1. ^ < .
" -U",d ;,) r
/}Vi/I........, 1ft: ,C. .....
, . //. ,-./ ~ '/ .s. _s'l13 (J
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
-* NVIICE_OFC\.. fJub/;c- heaTf'tJ was
'Ie--rj"fYl'-fed. ()Je- Wo~,-7 /'5facK .
CA., Co m (Y\ I 5 SI OAJ M f.ETJNj .' QUe.. B(l-I(;:;-"5'
"'re.7Y1CltlV CON r C~>- -
~ ""Iv I 'i./tlj I _ P,f6qS~ DOI/I
5'c/-.-L LIS O()T~ we- V\~...
n. ~TfI /C-'
vo TlS~S _
~/-4--~ -
/I/1/#'7 A:v//;1I1/11
(' OJZOHIJUO [t.JN';;~
fevl"tiJ!l!#VJtt
l-O-;:SS),,{/ /;;Zl).l'}:.{I ?'//.Ih f'1n
-" / I I/O ~.,/l--,
/lr!f ~,f1/ 'T! /1""" .;-/ :>, .~, I
It.. /" 'V,'-f~/ ,'1' Jd/(fJ
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
-* NOTICE Of CA. 'Puh/I{/ ~eaT/;Jq 0Uas
'1el'jllfYI/fed. ())e, WOIJ'-f /"S'facK .
CA. Com(Y\ISS/OAJ MU.{)Nti.. ocre..- S(j../(;f~
'Ye 7Y1cutJ CON <" . _ J
;:,16ilCtl/ /. P,L/5ClSC-. Do)/'T
S't./-L us our~ W& ......
r> r-e.- T 1-1 ie.
vo Tit: ~s .
/B
a:!N/';t.- tlHI'1AN
Co~o,Ja.do (ON}O
o . 1/I!Pi11;!i/.1
~;-:.>s \.'.,1 ('tJ.);ft..'1 c." /1 .o.f')
J to. L JVJI,.. - ,.:--....
/!iI.f;.;;{jt/!- ,;'/. ';J/thl
t
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
"n'iC ,EP - 6 Pi1 2.: 1 \
!.iJUIJ ....
CITY Of AVEHTURA
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anyt.hing less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
&~
~ ,! -<~$
-* NOTICE of CA.. '/) L/' I .. .
. .. rUQ IV heaTtjJq was
'Ie--r"i"fYl,-feri. ()Je. WOIJ'-f /':;faci~ .
0<-. Co m (l'li 5 51 OAJ M tET/NCj .. QUe.. B[J../E/~
Ye7Y1cttlV CON'" . _J
_ ~/61ICtlIl. P/t:CfSE. DO,l./r
5'tl__L US O()T~ we.. Y\
n Ie..- TfllC-
Va TIt. r-S .
)Z V IE S~ rI ,;..11./(<:"
Cot-C,AfitOJ CQIIIJu
~A A./vr
;2o;;;:"s i{). ,'(.IOf'f1tj f!,/,!,:, .<)_
- - ..,. "'. ... , / v~:' ~I?: '-J
l':"iNlvT//jt(J itf .~ ;/,'; d
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a llnegative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~ U~,.~
-* NcrflC[ 0 - I
.... t CA- 900/;(/ neaT/;uq tlUas
'"e'y") l/(Yl/fed. ()Je. wo~"'f /r5'fad:: .
Ov CommiSSION MtET/N1-- ocrt- fl,O..../gF:;
YB 7'f1ClllV Co., '" 6"""-- -
Iv:;,1 I ifN /. PJ.c;qSE- DO/./I
5' E-j...L U 5 OUI ~ \.Ai [. '" _
- n ,e. TI-I/~
va TiSr-S . '-
Sf UYI~ \A) r //'1 f'JC-
C()(AA/It/JO cON'P (I
we 1I,;?t-
.h;;~;S tJ . ();.i'.;"Yt;{t7 Cl U/! J7 c-,
/.'1I"(lv'~II/"I{J /qi' 1:';';,'
Mayor Susan Gottlieb)
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree) but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
-* NVT/CE OF CA- 'fuh/;{/ heaTfjJ (;Vas
'ley'! IilrJlfed. ()Je, WO,(f7 /'5faci~
Ov CommiSSION 'M&ETlNt(.. QUf.. B(I.../t::f~
-re7YIGltlV CON <" _J
~ ""/6iJC.tl/ /. P.Lt:qSE. DOI.;'T
5'(;.j..L US Our ~ W& ^.
n,e- Tf.! iE.
VOT~~S. -
1-t'II#al?f2 "Rt./gIYSTOII'
r-I.l'flizAfi rl! N
:2....0;:>5 I.lJ {eJ,>v-:l.i Ck\~ i\'"
/yl,/flj;""v,tfr; /f/ ;J,/ ,"- "
/
ct'Ji.1\A.lJfpo cONtJO
Mayor Susan Gottlieb,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impacf is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
-* NOTICE Of cA fJuh/;(/ heaT//JL ()Jas
'ley; lifYlifed. UJe, WOIJ~l /'5fru;!: .
D\-- ComfYl/SS/O,A) Mu:,n/Vt.(. ou-t- B(J...!(!l'~
Ye.1Y1GlI'7V CON r _J
_ o,/5Jlf.A/I. PJe;qs[. DOl.;'!
5' t..tL US OuT ~ W [.. V\
nre.- T/-lie
VOT~~S- -
Sincerely,
~4/+
p.osc. HaROW I Tz..
!to!T.:h..v'f 72
lo3;> w. Cd.)'u/Yf t!,/,( )),2.
II,. "...,,~, ,>? Q I
Ir.;'<././, {/.r-It- . /if ,,~t {>(
/
Cdl::n.l!t QO Co Ni'JiJ
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a Unegative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
ckMA~
.4- N. OTter; () t" /J 'Dp- ',~
(;;' vc- U D.. Lie. 11-ft''1 flY (jJ a 5
'Vf5/l.) LIMITCD. WE Wo/Vc~ p 11
/ 1 . fTtZCk
UL co (}'Jm/s~/O. 0) .
"}--'eM . . (\) e-e-.TI AJ.1 . 00,.. 25 e.UfFs
ULI/IJ cOrVC/,S, T[I.../T. ~lEa\e;;Do ./
Sf LL US O"T- . N
v we.. ct.l e... TH e
VOT([R-S.
DiA-H /., S6/lJ/Ff}1?-1,A./
'lit Li.- f"\
1:;)(2 ('J'c 0 IT
trex.1:: J:)/Y! "th'J
...., ..,.- _:r i il"
7:>C>1/!:' a..I..?v1t'7 Ct v,('{ p,e,
AIJ f/" /V/./J- //.s ~ g ,1
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
-4-- N OTIC E () G 0-- PUBLIc.. IfftlJ;('{j was
'-'6("7. 1-11\11.1 TeD WE W d'~ P 11
.. J/'V 1 . f1tlCk
LA- Co (l']m/ s~ /0 (\) O? .
. UTI/'J~c 00(' -:gel/Ffs
'1-eMC{ IrJ colDe So-
. / ;(NT. tea \'e. ;DONI
Seu-..- uS OQT- ,ol!
VH/e. Q...lt:- TH {'::'
VOT([..R-S.
/~....~
/JJIlO/E HZ/! fJ)cr(t(
1/;//11
,2)0 Ie (-1 tJ /1
f1CJt'/:/"d
.i..-o~ I ,VE~ s"'c #Ve,
fr1/'tVv'7VZ;!/ /1'" J?16 d
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
lib IIAlJL- C/..
~ N OTleE () G Cl- PUB" Lie- IIf/tn, (lJaj
"-16('7' /-tMI TED " WE W r)'~ p 1/
v/IJ} , j/ttCk
UL- Co (Yjenl S~ 10 (\) (Y,
1--eM ,"'Je.e.T1N1 '00(, JjeutFs
CnV CO(l)e/s, TOfT. l!:plfa \:e. ;Do;.//'
SeLL us OOT- ,,)1
""'" 'e. CL. Y' e.. rH fS
VOTfE-R-S ,
Vlf}MPlt-
t'1iPtt:~1L
,.1 ~ 9/ /t/'f Ni'h A~,
(J,//;" ,,' ' rrvL_
'. , ..../ V/I/,i7}..- /:<1 :>
, " ; :..J; B (}
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
4. N OTle E () G Cl- PUBLIC- iI-flirt" ,(lJaj
'\,)6('7 /-IMI TED, WE W r' '- ~'/ 11
, " V/IJ) , j/ttCk
UL- Co (Yj(nl S~ 10 (\) OJ' '
,e.e., TI N~' 0,0(' Jj eUffs
1--eM ct I tV C o(l) -
CIs' /[/CIT. lfar:;:e ;DONI
SeLL us OOY- ,,)I/J '
"""'<:r- CCY't.- rHfS
VOTfE-R-S ,
v/('(o/<- CO<< tJ /III
VIII~Af}~
U~W
~11 Ne .i,)?'/' Ilt/'I' ,
It (/tNTll?J/ /'if ,?J) cfo
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
~ NOTleE () /' U,
(;" Cl- 1 UBLlC- Jfflln,' (lJaj
'\,)6('7 /-IMITED ' WE Wr)^J'~ ~'/ 1/
, V/v) . j/ttCk
UL- Co (Yj(nl S~ 10(\) (Y,
"Je.e.,TIN~' 00(' J]eutFs
1-e.MCUtV Cd(l)cr-[ -
S .:::.1/.11 . lfar:;:e ;DONI
eLL us OOT- 1,)1
'-NI e. CL. Y' e.. rH fS
VOTfE-R-S ,
,'/~
I1AgVI# tEtLJt!'(
f!f/lfl- A
'po.2A I)
L'leltrfJ/f.
t.e;?Pi I ;1/ t- 11) /1t/E
IfI/tiv7ZIP;~ '/ () ",~~I
/Vj '/0...1
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
4- NOTleE OG Cl- PUBLIc.. Jfft1n,' ,waj
'\,) 6 '7 1-1 M I TED ' we W ,)'~ P 1/
, C v/V I ' j/ttCk
UL- Co (Yj(nl s~ 10 (\) OJ '
e.e.TI N~- ,00 r J] e(Jffs
1-e.Mct I{I) CC>(l)C/S, -[ ,
iI-iT. lfar:;:e ;DONI
SeLL uS OOT- i ","
""'" <C/ CL. Y' e.. rtl fS
VOTfE-R-S <
Si~
5P '--
5i DNIt,-V &" 7 IE (~r
YI//'1 (.)o;2/\ tJ 19
8/1'4),/
;)a;uli)/t- :J (} 1J.t/'t.
IJw 4Tl/Jr.fr / h' ? 1. Ifl ,\
,.<..>
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~
4. NOT; eE () G Cl- PUBLIC Jfflffl,' (lJaj
'-16('7 I-IMI TED, we W r)'~ r/ 1/
, C v/IJ I "J!ttCk
UL- CO (Yj(nl S~ 10 (\) (Y, ,
r---e.M, ,"'JUTlN,1, . 00(' J]euffs
C{ 110 CcJ(l)C/s' TO/T. V:f?lfar:;:e ;DONI
SeLL us OOT- {,)if)
'-NIt/ CL. Y' e.. rH fS
VOTfE-R-S ,
T~ W~ (J:J
VII/"r iU t;.r A 0 PJ-
Ui"USS
1c.2.JiJ/ All" _?J At/'e/
J!:t/el+l/1)/'.I-- J:-/ 1..1/!d
Comm. lev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
:J?:1S-r-
4- N OT1e E () G Cl- PUBLIC- /ffllf'!" (lJaj
"-16('7 /-IMI TED. W( W o/V'~ C/ 1/
, ,) , J!ttCk
UL- co (Yj(nl S~ 10 (\) OJ '
, e.e.TlN~' ,00(' J]eUtFs
1-e.Mc{'I10 CO(l)c r-
1~"'i[,I.IT. lfa<;:e;DoNI
SeLL us OOT- {,)I
'-""" e. CL. Y' e.. rH fS
VCJTft-R-S ,
p.. vz P I/'{ '0
VIII""
/flr( 11.e>0
!lAlo
J...iU>l1 4t So 0 t1'.I't
lWeNJ1II'IV'r:' ~J/Jj
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
4. NO-Ie
I E () G Cl- PUBLIC- /lt1lf'ttJ (lJaj
"-16('7' .LIMITED W( w")'~ V9~,/ 1/
, " v/IJ} J'J!ttCk
UL- CO(Yj(nIS~/O(\) (Y,
, "Je.e.TI N q ~ 00 (' J] eUtFs
r-eMct 110 COr0C/s Tff.fT. V:plfar:;:e. ;DONI
SeLL us OOT- ,,)}
""",e,. CL. Y' e.. rH fS
VOT([R-S ,
AI 1111 (j.J t k'
VII/11
OoeAo#
JlJfw(t.
~:!ffl At tE." ? c i~ /!tie
ftldl't'lll/l,4.- /./ 7' .. j
" I r' .> ..>//1 C
Comm. Zev Auerbach,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~~
.4- No-rICE^ ,- - TJ,--
",' (, (c (A.. " U buC ilflfnjVq ()'Jaj
VC('l"i LiM/7CD, lA.J" 1,(-,,,'-,. I'~'/ ' 'II
r .' c vv v/v , ~ Sr ctC k
uL ,,^) ",
'-c., .-JrYli:;C 0-- D
" ~,_ .'" "'"I 'v ';eei,'110 if ' 00 r :5 e 111:8
rt,,'Vi<.., ,,'V ("'1"', -. 'h
' ~ 0, .,,.,,,,;.:::, i,( {IT _ "+t'(',--,{ ," '" '~,-, .'+-'
_ _, , " {..' ,t <cJ,,./o/y'!
:Jt I-L ,.;s- C) -,-,..- "
l- I we CL.''(" e.. tti c
/11 Ii t:-i It r:- f 11/1/ C 0
i./()TCE I2..S
a ( /I VUIlI1- CClv/<?(j
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
SinC~IY'
~..~
-* (\once.. Of a FU(3L/C IIE.tlAttlq \}Jay
v6ry L{(lu TeD, WI[ Vvor0T /JiTaciC'
fl COMMI $ )IO/U (YJEi-Tl1\.)(;1' OUf" BELIEFS
r-U'?OtIIlJ CO/,/SIr;"TEt0T. PLEasE UOAJ\j
S€/-L uS 0 -
u \ -------- 'V-)E Cl'<"e. TL-/ t,
VOl E t2..s;
25ft A;"J..oN of
,'"2AMI9V( Q
c:ONlfb
At'--e" r -ft:
Iv v"
3 7 al Ii.J Ci:J!.,?./;7tf Clt//} PI:...
ftJ;/;!fifVt/1 ,c/ 3' :n ,,9 d
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~ f\once.. 06 a PUBLIC l-If.tlR.'liqvJCl5
vt.ty LIfYJde.D, WI[ VYOIVT A.lsTac.i.'
tl COMm.I S <;10/0 (Y)UT7 NC] _ QUI" F,EUEFS
r-cr'?Ol./J\J CO;'lSI~TEI0T. PCElL5c Do^Jr
SEl-l-. us 0-
u \ ------- Wf c::L'C" e. T(,-JE,
VOlE R-S
'PUY'..f. f}t/pJ/eL
,viA j\ltf5v( 0 , .
Y C oN J:::1 <-
o - t"il.t,~/L
3 J (j I AI. L-'d;)~ Ct~prl
I(V{lya{t-~. PI 3';'i6&
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
-*
(\once. Of a PUGUC l-!f.aR/l/qvJCZ5
va! Llf'tIlTeD, WI[ VvotJT /)~TactCl
It COMMI Hlol\) (YJE€n;vCj _ OUr-' EEUEFS
f"fr'?OtIAJ CO/'lSI~7EI0T. PLEase DotJr
S€I-L us 0 T
U ,- v.h o..'<"e. TiAf-
vOl E ,,z-s
Sinc~~ly,
~' ~,j-l--)
," / ~
~
1C;:o~ Sc.!5,E L
F'I AM [NCO
C. 4'v-'lf) 0
4-- ~-&t..~
37"-; ;../ C<:'i'.);.;rry Otvg 11;(
Al/t;:;t-I(1t?Ut: pi > J /8,~
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
-.f- (\once.. 06 Cl PUBLIC /If.aXiI./qvJClS
V6ry Llf'tIITe.D - WI[ V-iol0T A'~TacK.(
fJ- co MMi S5 i 0 l'J (YJ 6€-T7 ,o&J' 00 f" g EU EF S
r-tr'?OttllJ CO.HSI~TErVT, PLEaSe Do,J,
SEt-I- uS 0 -
\,) \...------ \)...)f {L'C"'e. TL-/[,
VOlE R.$
I5.;I(j{ t;: L. (...'Ii R e iv,
!7/-!/7t'/!C() (Okh?
c.tr;;./; 1/1-/
3 76/ // CdUYfly Ci 1/1: })~J
Ai./f5vf(/f!A P 3l'8i.i
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~~
~ (\once,. Of a PUBLIC flEdl..lIJq \}JCl5
va! Llf"liTe.D, WI[ VlOIVT -?'~TactC'
{1. COMM/SSIOJQ 0Ei-T1AJU]- OUI" EEUEFS
('-ET'?OtltO CO;^lS/~7ENT, PLEaSe Do,,}j"
SEt-I- uS 0 T
v ..------- \,)....) f 0..'("" e. nA t
V()IE((~
R.OieT E PL E R.
j'= L n /V} Ic/V 0 CWIJt.) (I
J:E;#';' f' !(
:51c, N' eu:,ii/Ilt (({/(. oe
IWGHru,/{...!J. ?'I 33, ,9.: "
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
JJ2
-* ~nce.. Of a. PUBLIC (-/f.(jAlllqvJCl5
V6r'j LI("uTe.D. we VlOIVT /J'iTaci.'
t1- COMMI S ~IOro (YIEt.Tl NC). OUI" EELiEFS
('-fTY)OtIA) CO/'lSI~7Er0T, PLEasl: Dad,
SEt-I- uS 0 T
U -- V-}f u.'<""'e. TL--It
VOl E t2.s;
IJ'JJI;t.r: . IV V IJ.(
FLA J.lt.W{ 0 Ck,);VR',-,
IV D"('l,~
I," 1" VI', ~
??.:..'.' /'f' ctL5WXi eiUS De
l1l/.t.f.4?)l(..ff -c/;;;.; ,g (J
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
--,f- f\once. Of a. ?U6L1C lif.aR.lJlq waf
vtry Llfr/,Te.D, WI[. VYor0T ""~TactC'
(l C()MMIS~'Oro (Y)t:€n10C)- OUI'"' F,E.UEFS
('- t T'?OL II\J CO!,I 51 5'TE tV T, PU lLSe. Do,.),
SEt-I- uS 0-
v \~ V-Jf. Q...'C"e. Tl-lc-
VOTfE {(S
AViP S'UIOS I\-
riJIMEII~d COV1'"'
/1, Slf?O~"
~7{)1 ,.iCi,)[pri'l cu$ i/!t.
j1tIle;I{Tl/~,;1 I jC/ ?;:318 (J
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~
-* f\orlCe.. Of a PUBLIC flEdRIJ./q vJa5
vay LlflliTe,o, WI[ V-IOrVT -?'~TacK.t
rL COMMI S ~IOlO (l)U:n 10&], Ou I" EEUEFS
('-Er'?OtlflJ CO/'lSI~TEI0T. PCEasc uo,,)i
SUI- uS 0 -
U \..-- WE CL'C"e,. TL-/f,
VOlfE R-S
OA. fV 6/- {V E I?...
F//tr'l tEl'! (' 0 CON I;?<.:>
o O/JVt!:'N..
'570: 1'1- C{)J/'I'7X.1./ c/(,,; ...'It,
. ;::/ I.,>-~, Ii
}(Vi!/Y rl/~Ai / .Y ~ ,{ ()
Comm. Michael Stern,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
~'
-,f- f\ r-.
. v/lCe.. Of a PUBLIC I-If.al./l./q was
vtJ'Y LI~lre.D, Wf.. VYorVy -1~TacK.(
rL C()MMIS~lolO (lJE€T7AJ~ OUl'" /5EUEFS
('-ffY)OtI/lJ cO;,/S,.<;'TEl'vT. PCEasc DorJi
SEl-l- uS o'~
v ~--- V-Jf CL'C"t:. TL-It,
VOl fER.S
;;2AVr() LI.XSo'\!'V
{} /-()i~:.:;v
..."
>7'0; /..-' (";j1,f/7lr (/{)~'" ,?/C
!We/ff(;';tA' ,It'; 3;;' ~~' v
/ J' ~.
__ ' ::- flCO ,
) 7- II Ii !:. r!Otl P <J
\
Comm. Silly Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* uOIICE Of Ul ?a'lIC- Haiti,.)) ffJas
Vtl''j LIMiTED, WE worJf /'5 T/fCK' ,
tl, COMInIr;<;loN me~7)NJ 0 1 'I
. (I" [J<.(. lefs
i<-f(Y}Cllt0 CO;O<;/f,TC,ifT. rU!asc DW"r
<::;*/-.'- uS OUT-we.... a~ T7ilt
\!()JI~ f'S ,
It/'~ e.~t'Z
BKA,1/bIA... CaN~ <.J
t.?4!JeZ-
., '.' . e'i~ /'" '," I)'
":>.>o( j,j,,,c_. "( u(",... ,,/~
AI/-liv1&)t.,.,!- // f,."J/ 9 l)
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* \JolteE 0 ~ Ul POt'LIC HEa/"itJq cuas
ver-j J-IMJTT o. iMe. W o;Jr J ;/5 rife;:"
tt, co lV'il1 I f; (; 10, N me.e---n f.lJ ' 0 L "/.
' (I" IJ'{, I t{f
P-f(Y}CilIf) COtJ'5/STEM"T. fU:aSE DW"r
C;~I-I.- uS OUT - we.... aT'f" 711ft
\I uris I'S ,
J~ Co ~ Iloch /Vll1/iJ
C0fJ rJ 0
:g(A v vf.rk
t5-:f.c H)t,A1V
330' Iv' C'V..IA.fi"7y c/t-t; '>'
flri'HIV/Z. A. / '?, t,-'L"
Ir/ k >rl,9()
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* uO/iCE 0 r cA ?O?Lt~ HElIf"/tJq cuas
Vtr-'-I .LI rVlITf5 0 , W't WO'"'.j/ J "'5 'I
I IV I ,T!lCK-
tl co M/n/~<;/ON mte.--t7l-1q 0 b'!
_ J " VI' ~ l't-fJ'
f-1::(y}OL/~ Co,0~/ STEM"T. ('iRase D y,j" r
<::;*1--'- vS OOT - v../c... a,-r--e:.. (I11t
VUIIS f'S ,
Sincerely,
;$2
SeAN' CA "Y
~~,.AVVl't--fl- C~~
ClUj
5S0{ /i) [t/~ c/v~ P
~VtA,Yi/,I}:1/ /17 ? ~JJ it.
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
'* \JolteE 0 f Ct Ponlc- HEat/Alq [JJL1S
ver-'j J-./MITi5 o. Wt W otJ'r J //5 Tlfct"
tl co /VI /n I ~ <; I ON me.~-rj f.lJ 0 L!.
_ ti" LN 10/,)
j<...i::fYICilltu COtJ'5/ST&M"T. j?[easc DW"r
$ -e 1--'- uS 0 OT - W L- ,a..;r-e... TN It
\lOll;:' f'S ,
L ,.
17
.l"
/' -'
__.....:~=- -e.....,.---
...
, IfP.t)lI~/ 1'112i?R If I
-v" j\VVJl..O
.,r- caN,,:} (j
/!:1 t2-t:.1I1t'1
~,...,-,,- ) , .,
.>~l.-'l: ;t,~(:uZ.t~/ 0"'2";'#'
jqve/VTr/c,I " // 5::5/8 cj ,'"
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* uOllcf o? Ul rO?Ltc. H€atitJq {)JQS
vet; J-/rVllff.D W'e. WON't' J ;'5 (/fell
tZ CO(l(\/fI/!;<;IOj:J mt€c-rlIlJ 0 1,,/
' li" IN It-fS
P-f(YJC/l/;0> CO;O<;/ bTE)/T. fU:.asc D y,j" r
S-f/"'i- uS OOT - we.... a-r-(.. nllt
VO/I; f'S ,
't
t5nJl/ ",itA
( IJ/vlli)
~
'7.,
> >i.'i k ~C()./V7.LA .,
krRN'/1.IrA- ' " / C/t/Jr ,oj(
., If ..?~d;J
c.. (
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* UOltCE C! ~ LA, ?OPLtC- H€fJ,ltJq (}JuS
vel''-I )...,/MITfD, iNt WOA\,~J "'5-, 'I
/ {vi ,'liCK
tl, co 1V1;n I ~ ~'ON mt:e---n;.lJ 0 I!
_ - (i" D-t If/f.J
f-1:(Y)ClIr:> COtJ'5I STEJ/j. fuasc D ../of'r
<:;*1-1- uS' OOT W" /J' y',,/
- <-- vv-r-t" {hit
\I eJn?:. I' 5 ,
t
JIlVI/t-/C- 1..1,4'AKlC
,-" A 1/ we- t$.
.s '(!., C 0IJ1t1l.
tA:vl1t-.l
'S?67 I'J eouII!J.-7 (y~/: ';({ ,
fl-t/t#jl/~:1J-'..e; ? J / B d
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
*' \Joliet 0 ~ LA 'POPLte H€fJtill1C) o.){~S
\ler-j )..../rV\JTfO. W't WONt' J /, blRet"
tL co (If\ /n J !; ~ JON m t~-r., IIIJ 0 b' /
_ " Vi" c( le-fS
P_J::(Y)ClIf\:> CO;O~/STE)/T. fUasc DW"r
C; '*'/-..I-- uS Qu-
I - W t.. a:r-e- IN IE
\!OTIe..I'S ,
Cho.... kADOc...
~MIIV~O
C.ONI;) '-l
IVY'oc
~ 1~1I1/ t'tJi/l.f111 t/{/l',t~J.:.
M ~M rUT If ':;I.? liP J
..... .,.~
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
,Sincerely, '
* \Joliet 0 f (). POfLtC HECltiAlCf ()Jas
\J er-j )..../ rYll T f. 0" W't W 0101' J f' 5 TIICK"
t1l co (V1 hi I r;; r; I 0, N m e.e.--t7 IIj 0 I, /
- (I" 0'-( l't-fJ'
p..E(YJCil/~ Coto'5/ST&J/T. jl0eaSE Dty,f'T
S~I-'- uS (JOT W" /], "j
- <-- vv~ Thlt
\! ()II~ f'S ,
~
fnOf.-,TOIV LE Y1/c/ E
~ (\ VvJtr1
to..... cQiV'" 0
I'll. t-R'&~~AI't.
's~Oi /Y.(d'JV?l-.~ C'If/l["'P;r;
nfleI1rf/l'17 /y,< {Zi:; ,q J"
Comm. Billy Joel,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
-Jk'
U01iC~ or: ~;\ ?iNLlC }-!€OtfNi) {)J{lS
vt-C''1 ...../I'V\I(EO VJr:.. W' "I0't,J" -_', 'I
I (, S Illelc
a: co ~11 /11! r:; ~ f (;;0 W\r..,;-II . f~'? ..... L '/'
I" ,,' f f'f ( U.,;i' '_".{ It' ~j'
'l "''''1?' /' , ..,!
!,-",'.c.\,/ll CO/.)<IC,'-F''''T " '/;-'- , .
'J ,I ,/1//. r L.t:t.i~t D YJ r
S ',i(;'" f- U S 0 1..'",- - V'i t. c.tr-c. Ti I IE
\I UJiS ('S ,
Sincerely,
# #~ ~.:.
/) / "&<0# S' f/F'; ;< /'
a. ~.. A''-'':;~!
,~j: ~4l{ r,,;v
, ~~c I /J [[i.tJ$7 c/,,/:5 DR.
f}1Ji'/V;Yll"1;' // 71/f/ a
8RA VVK6
Q 01-11/ (j
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* rlo/fCE OF a. fukJllc /...eaf'JJ!7 WtL5
ve,~ /Jmlrec{ W-e- wooF t'sr4cl
Ol. co ~tI\J <; SIOtJ JYleeIJAlJ' 001" be./IEpS
re,vY1al,0 CO;J~fS1C1/r, P;,ease- tJO,u'{
S'tl-t- us 0 LIT' -- W 0 Af'€ TA€--
vo-riEP.-s.
S1:>;: CllEt.,#/S/:;-i2.6-
, V ,,e,4
a t. t} 1/ C oil)?"-
(yl~/Jf:M!/'..6'
?3~:,^;C4i.Wl~l ell.:t. Ol!.
1+1/1:,.;1&/'!-1 ,;C/ ] 31fl1
I '. ..
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
* /(iJrrCE OF a. f'utJlic (ea"'-!/./7 WCL5
Vfl~ /Jmlf'ec( We.. WiJ!.)'? "Si&il
OL cO,y\ 1M ~ S 10 ;J rYJ eeiW J' 0 () (' beJ'15fS
Y't4ila.,N CdiJ r; ISTEllr. PtEase.. DON'r
Se/--t,.. us O(JT'-~ W~ Al"f TA~
v o-rrS:p--<:;; .
f}?lke 6ECZ
(V lI~u
Zf..AiJUilJ
fYt .6:.eU
'?,- d r-
So >~, I n "'X:?./T.lf CI' r....,
- / (..!> 1-;(
fld//C/)//l;;'!;t!./ /:/ :>'/' q ,,!
.,::,.,) " ...-"
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
J-lr4
* I/o/(C[ OF ct !,ufn/ic /"'eal'lN'7 Wct5
Vfl~ /Jfl'tII-eC( W-e. woof! t.tsi!Jcil
OL CO 1V\r(\} ~ 5/otJ meenIJ:r QUi^' be'/lI!fS
rt~allJ COJJ SIS-reflT. PI-ease- DON'r
S'ef-.~ us 0 UI-~ We. A/"'f Tf..e..-
vo-rrt:R..$ .
J'lfLk SlJ/ll1lt fe?/
S7w../.A.1f-tir-
.., -7, '
~, .> "" / M C<.)IJ.V,'Zy CI (ll! [) Il..,
Iti/CJ4ITZilJfj PI 3;lg..l
FlM(/LlI<.()
~pc
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
*' /'lo{reE OF fA. fukJlic 1.ea."1/./7 Wt:l..5
Vf'~ /JYYtlfed.." W€r wooF t/sr4cil
OL CO~N'\I~S}O/J JYlee7l,vJ' oUr- iX/Iff'S
rr,.vVl(,{IN COIJ r;/ST(IIT- Ptease. DON'r
S'el-I-- us 001-- W 0 Ar-,€, n€/
vo-rrt:K.~ .
~.
/V'.T I EE;3
, ~ A (Qtl I?J
fV, A /IV
171vef'1J
~>Ci NCtlJAl!2j Clil~)JJt
frY{J/tVrn ;&I ]:J/;~'d
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* /'10/1[[' OF a. Pulo/ie L.etU"i/./1 Wll5
vel~ !Jmrrec( W-e. wd/Jf't/SiiJdll "
Ol. co I\I\It'\H SIO/J rYleet)IJJ - 00", beJ'bfs
rt-V"1auJ Gd;J5tSleNr. Ptease. DON't
Se{..f..- US 0 (Jj-- we.. Ar-f, TAv
v o-rrSP---s ,
Sincerely,
5'4~
s:n 1/1)/
V!JL ij,/J
;:? ,# /j i/1/~4
,.... (,':;1'</h",
'It!
VIit-lf.li:I.c
I
'n Oi NL'fTJ1f71l1.. "q,f:iJl! hi!.",
A-tlei'lrrfr-/!,?..cl 5 Ii 5d
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a llnegative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* !lv/fCE OF a. futolic L.eaf'i1/7 WQ.5
Vfl~ !J'{Ytlrec( We.. wOI,Jf1 t'Sil1cl
oc COrM{\!<;SIO/J J1Ieen/JJ' 001" be,hf/fS
'Y't.A(llaIfJ CO/J 515ftll!', Please-DoN'r
Se/.-~ uS o (JT-- we- Ar-,f.~ T;..v
v 0 -r rEJ<...s .
Sincerely,
{/J# .
Jf1(k s;//fki I(
71tLA()v/t-t4 C CiN 100
5:;;'.I'Tld I/.
5>Ci fi/ COJ,viLi CII.1'$ dr"
/tv'R/"lrtJf'A, rvl 33ifJd
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
-* f!oric[ OF ~ fui<Jlic (au-1Ji7wtL5
Vf'~ !Jmlrec( w~ woof! '''silJcl
Ol- CO 1Y'tr'\1 ~ S IO;J 1Yle.e:nAJJ' OU>" bdll5fs
rt.1'l1i1tl,v Cd;..) 5/STcNr. Ptease..t>ON'r
Se'f.-.i- '05 OUi--- we. Ar-€ T/,.v
v 0 --r r& R-:s .
Sincerely,
~~
Hlttft/ /qOtE f...
is ;t. A y tit, A D::.WP --)
MJI.-<Cf-,
'3 ;l,)[ , I-i, C,,\~vrt:-! Ci u,:) I'"~
?-?' G'"
j'N" N fur fir ,/'(/ .>.s I " ,
I
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
00~~
-* l/o/iCt OF a. pulo/le (eaf'lN1 WCi.5'
v ff'~ /Jm I fec( , We. W04j F t/ S (hi'
0\... COIY"^I~SIO;J JY)eetltLlJ' 00", f:x,hJ!.fS
re.fllal..0 GdAJ [;/Si€NT. Pj.easr::. DDN'r
f)t/--.r,.. us 0 UT- W 0 Ar-,e nv
v 0 -r t& R-s .
1m III? ^ iJ SQ/lhft- L
11M v (J t 1# CeJA./'7 ~
~~
$, :;0, H cc;,.~'A'f(.f' Ct..,f. 1)i'.
, A'-"'~' r') )
AV~j.lnl'f-,c/"" .>71';1"
Comm. Harry Holzberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* /'1 vile [ OF a. fufohc f...earl tfi1 WCL5
vel~ /Jmrr.ed.,., We.. wooF '''5/&1.' ,
oc COIY'>III}~SJoiJ rfleen",,' QUi'" be,htfs
rt,<(llC{uJ COAJ ~/S7C1..;r. Please. DON'r
S 'ef.-.{... \J S 0 (jT-~ W e. fC} t^ € TA €.-r
V 0 -r f[;' R-s .
7R~
fJ 'K. C()'reR
(7 q> A l/ j,1J2 1/ C oJvk? u
p. f'. ~
C.i9.o f " ,-..
3;...>( fy (' C';.IVTi C/I./if il,....
1f1l'eIllTVI1/J; N 3 ;/~.," c)
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
,. SinCerelY~
~~..
c
---
~
i-* NOtiCE OF C\.. PU"E,LiC Iifa.RIJ/f;. was Vfl0f
tlmlTED. WE.. WeJ!y'/ /'SrACL(" f\
0.o.'V\M/5S/ON I'Jf..lTlNCr, OUj(-gEUe.F'5
REP?AIf./ CONS/SiVJr, ?Ltt/LSf UON1T
S' ELL- US OUT We.. A"
- ""t rHe
"lOTti'S,
r;zANk !<tJri[L
j'::j AM k/Y ( 0 C o;v;k (j
t,cf'P'tL
:; ) OJ // cJ:/11!li CI f./f, lft..
Jl.1/~I!I'n (;.11 - f'l :> '> , ,b rI
{flit'; /i.i.",J " _...,..>//, \,:
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
,. i
~,.'Jtf~
"- ',.F. . :/1.,/
t
'~ NOTICE OF 0\.. PU-gLiC HfaR"IJ.I? V-tCl) \!fl<.Y
tim/TeD. WE. WON'! "STACK" A
(lo...V\M/5S/0N I>'IE-lTlNG- _ OUR.I?,EUe.F5
'R.EJYJ A I f-I C.ONS IS7EN7, '?LeCUj[ Dodr
SELL U:; OUT we r\ "
- "'''-,IS THe
IE. t1!Ih HABER.
'10T( t 5
r/fil'1,&,tspo
1!lJt;J~i?
'} )u, !<I Ca;p';7l* CIty.: "
A't.; /./1'1' I',,~ i)-e..
I,S';C",II"'lk! u 1""'1
. I .. ~ ," ~., I}'i{
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
..~
i~ NOT1eE OF lA.. PU-gLiC Hfa.R.IJ./C. We{) \/iK..Y
J::lfVlITED. Wf WrJH'i //SrACL(" f)
00(YlM/5StON IVIt.tTlNCr" OUR 1!,cUe.F5
ReMAIN CONSIStENT. ,?LttJL5t DON'T
SELL. Us oUr we n"
- M\VIS rHe
s ~ V;W{}f.;< /lITT t:~/i1 Ii ""I
"-IorC, '5
FLit MkIV( () Cf..V\I.?;u
13 { rte.r:. ftufJ;J .'
PO~jj {lJ..wriFClt/l!. M1
trV' -u.I ru~J1 1,1;/ 3 ~I g (I v
.'M
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
f,.
^" tkJl ~
.,ltt '~
'JJ. NOTICE or <A. PU?,LiC HEa.R.I}.!? was V'fK'f
K.,mITf;D. WE.. wcJ;y'r /'S7F\CK." f)
QoI'1M/5S/ClAl /"!bETtN(T, OUf( ~'EueFS
'R..E.JV7Alf-I CONS/SiE1JT_ rLttJL5t DoN'T
SELL.. US OUT W-
- t: A\(,,[ IHE
-/d~fZlE. srIJW 4ff'-
"-IOTf f S
R~ EI/C()
OtP/~J
Qll iN';7'~rf2,
~;7 ():' /.J ctJ~ ell/Ill:>.!,
1rV~ 'I. ('k ,...," IL/
)v'iv' eft. /J ((/~'!
f' ,",' / r,- ....",.., '-.
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
. Sincerely,
'\1?~~
'~ NOTle f or 0\.. PU-gLiC Ii [CU?..IJ.I{;.. We{ 5 V f{GY
tJmITED. WE. Wr:J/y'i /'S7ACtC" A
Go."()M/5S/C!N I'If3..lTING-, OUR. "BEUc.FS
~EjY)A I J-.I C.ONS !STDvT, '?LtCtS[ DON'T
SELt.. US oUT w-
- t.. AQ(' rHe
(.)d{:l.,-4 ~I\Y/IN
'-Iorf t S
F1J9t;teNCi;)
~
IJ 11'7/ if;;
:;)V i ,r.i, CiJt?JJti" i>;/;]:1 i)::'"
IJA' & ',''7(',",/1.., [,/ ., 7/ to"
ITII 'f,:;-v I 'J {.-;"p" ; J' .,;.. ~I t)(...'
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
,-
!I~
iJJ. NOlie! t OF <A. PU-gLlC H [aR,lI-I{. Wet) \/tK..Y
J::./fY1ITED. WE. WQ;y'! "'STACK-" f1
Qo,'Y)M/5S/(:lN f'Jf,{TING-, OUR.'"&EueFS
R En A (f-I C.ON S Isn: /IJ{, ?LtCL5 fDoN'T
'SeLL- US OUT we A')
- \\...( rHE
)jetEri' Plum
"-Iorf t:;
1~),qll1tC;Y{O ~-a/tF~
fJ, / GI.?!
5,)0, AiD~Jf/;'l1 (It!! ~"
I}v-"', , ',,-
f'JV1I.1.!1f h ~eS;:/:~.(1
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
.. Sincerely,
f,
~~~
!~ NOTICE OF C'L. PU-gLiC H[aR..iJ./t- was I./tlLf
tlmlTeD. WE. WUN'! "STACL<-." A
QU{V) MIS 51 ().AI JYIECTI N Cr _ OUR-1],cUJE:. 1'5
'R. En A (f./ C.ON S IS/Et-JT, ?Ltt?L5[ DON'T
'S ELL. US ou--
I - We A\(..( rHe
.leeF,v f2ArPO
'\fOTf f S
/2Aifcl/{'O CQ-Yb<J
f4UD
,). ' },.I'
:>, v; /' {o;'-:iTJ?;tt (Yln )~'"
AA.' .,.,\In' A ' 'L
!r ve, ' ,fJ}C/I-, ;t/, .., '> " '
, , ,,", >1/1.,7
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
c
''*- NoTICE OF 0\.. PU-gLiC Jt[aRIJ-/C- WCl<; VU-f
IJmiTED. Wt WQJy"! "S7ACK." fl
Oo{y)M/5S/0N I'1&tTIN{r, OUQ.."'B,i:Lle:FS
'REMA/f.I CONS ISrVJT , ?LtCl5[ VON'T
SELL. us Our w-
- t::.. AI(..ErHE
C-t? vrC€ ,eflT2
'Iorf t S
V~'r,>
-t-""i.rl G-o--
r:,Afwl 0.1 (0 C W06
J.70 I 1/ [(if/lllt-j' C/t1!.IJl!,
lH/el/lv:-t;1. Jt/ Z,l/ll (1
Comm. Bob Diamond,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
,-
t
ii~ I~,~
, ,
!~ NOTle E o~ 01... PU-gLiC. H[a.R.I/../{.. W~S VtK.f
!.:.1(V1ITf:D. WE. WON'! "STf=\CL(." A
Q 0''''' MIS SI C! AI f'lEET IN (r, OUR.1S cue: F 5
1l..efYJAlf-I COAlstsrElvT, ?LC0l5[ uoN'T
SELL US OUT W-= n ')
- "- 1-\\\..[ THE
tAlY# #EWM A tU
'Iorf t S
1-=-t.4/11 t:'1./(CI ('d-'vP'4
i
IVeWl'/l/#
1 70; Y.,Cilll/'oJ"/11 C/f/t~ 1';It,
A'1Ilf/7iftj} J H 51;; d
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
...--
Sincerely,
{~
......
-
fc.at: .s7IfR~A/J
1/(: f./o0Ct2 of a,1u~cc' ~6ctY'-J wzS;;
VEyY LIMIteD ~ WE \}J 0 ,,;', '/51aCK'l
a.. CO/'f\MI~<;iOf.I MEET/flJ - Oor 6eJlE:fS
p...c;/iAlII COXlS/5'TENT -7>/EC(S'E DotJT
5 ttL US 0 UT WE ()-K.-fS 11-1 t.
\I () n; K.S
<~ i'""fff. k: tnlttN
~;..>s W c':'!r.}NTVf Q'l.'fl /)~
IWt'M-.;(;l4-; tCl IS) S c
/
CcyZCvv'A,:}Q C'Oiy'IJ,;
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
;t1~
';'"
!i/( ;.:J o0ce of to?uU.,'c, J.. [,cA. r/] ~~
VEyY LIM, lieD _ 'vVt. \A/DI,i', '(51at 1(1[
a. COfl\M/<;5iOfl MEE/iNJ ' Oor beJlEFS
p-.&/iMH CoflSl51t;NT -7>/EC(S'E Do/JT
S ttL US 0 vI' -- W( ()-ILr[. II--! t
\J o TCK:;
/II/tP.V/)/ rllilt5
.-h,~
(fW ;:>
J...O::;}5 \.1.1 (tJ",l/.I"!/:i Ct Uf! Jr
/t1i<I1TVI[A I h ?]/~ L~
Co[lOiYAf::IO to/</t:::> D
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
ij~~Z-
* N o0ce of a..?obLl'c- t eel. Y):J lA.Xl:.~
VEyY LIMIteD ~ ,"vt. \AIDN I "SlaCK\!
c::L COfYI.MJ\;'SiOI'i MEC-I/f/J " Our belIEfS
P-cli,A{fI CoNS/[;TENT -'f>I&C(S'E DowT
5 ftL US 0 VI' -- '-NE. (YR.-I[. 11-1 t
\JOT(KS
/J14TT k~T2EH
Coi,{~\/ II DO C a/.tl/O
jql..t:'~v
;U;g,35 "",,{'.(j"tVl'1:.lt, C./i/;f? ~
;tJIi'/:/iCli!fl / ;:? s:P8 (! '
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
jell/ 5WAPff< 0
,. fJ 07/0,12 of ~~U"C t. 6~.:Y''-~ q 0-Xl-~
VEyY LIM lieD ~ VoJE \J...IDN"rl //srac'I('l
cc COI"t\fY\/<;5/OH Meu; HJ " 00 r be.! I EFS
P..~MMfI Cof/S/51cWT -'f>IEC(tE DoAlT
5 ttL us 0 VI -- Wt:. &1Lf. 11-1 t.
\lOTeKe;
51;1ff; /-.:
'L1f1s l.J CC)Ju;~ C! i/l? i>/t.
(r1;i(t.//c;/{fj 1:/ .' ~ i/ f! ,J
c ~")''y' pf/ ~
C,v:_c}//100 '
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
~ f./ 0'0012 Of a.-1!);L,'c, A6CA. YJ-~ u.:u.~
VEyY LIMJif!D ~ 'Nt. \AIDN...../ '/51aCK"
cc. COfl\M/<;';)/o/Y 1'1[;,&7;f/J " Our 6eJlc.fs
A.&Ii.A/H Cof./S/51ENT -7/EC(S'E DoiVT
5 ttL US 0 VI -- WE. rYILr[. t1-1 f
\J{jT~KS
Jl /v'~GPE?
S '!II/Ill-n '- . {'-
(j.;;:"f'i:4..
,:J.u-;;S,\.Aj C.<:Uv, r?'f Ci U, g DR..
1JA.'t- f 17 A I' " 1:::>'7 '
If' /'"/V;:"1/ {'-I ' ..s >/7> (I
CO;.. ~/v''I! /)Q C ilivtJ<:j
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
* f/ o0ce of rJvfoU,'c, J.. GCI. Y/-J (;..;a~
VEyY LIMlif!D ~ 'Ne \AI Df"'" ''5IatKIl
a.. COfV\M!<;'fiiOf/ I"lcE:rif/J " Oor 6eJlcFs
p-&Ii,A{fI CoX/S/GTeNT' -'?/EC(:>E DO'vT
S ftL us 0 vi' -- W( c:rQ.1[. 11-1 f
\}OT(!Z...<;
t.tA{
0"''''''( C-~ssMA/.(
CO t...fJN jf-tJ () ~wpll
i~ If' -, 1"1,
w-i..' ))/ Mi1ii
"'II'/h - u' ," !. "'lI'U/ I" ).,
,'lu:;,.,;5 ..,..' C (,1(../". <7' V'L> i- j.:.,
A I,' ' ,~ - , '-. '/ -, 'j
ll-'.I'e/IP IV/<-itj /"/ ;:..> ti C
i
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a llnegative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
/~
~
----"~
----.>-""-
c:.::' "----..........
, N o0ce of a.1uU,~C, f.. erA. ,/v q (.()a.~
VEyY LIMJieD ~ 'NE.. v..IOf-/',d ;(51ac.K\l
?C COfY\tv\J<;f>iOf-/ f"\t'E1 ;HJ .' 00 r bel I E.fS t=D i!p,4?.6!eIt
f1-.cMMII COXlS/5'TENT -7>/EC(S'E DoNT
5 ElL us 0 VI -- WE. ()-Q...L,S 11-1 t.
\}OTCIZ...<;
jitf'n,tt;1'
2.0-;;5" u/ ({/JV!1y Ci'tIJ /X
IrV-f/i./;r,l~J(J; P ?:' I ~l
" ",,)o.>j ." ""
I
(J()lDi/I:ftr; c~()
Comm. Luz Urbaez Weinberg,
Hi-Lift Marina may not agree, but many of Aventura's citizens
believe that having a "negative visual impact" is of paramount
importance. Many of us support Joanne Carr.
The Mayor and commissioners have an obligation to ALL
the citizens of this city to enforce our present bldg. and height
restrictions. Anything less is unacceptable.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES!
SAVE OUR CITY
Sincerely,
~~~--
* f/o0ce of a-'f/;UI'c, t.6IAYI-1 ~~
VtyV LII"\ lieD ~ "Vt \AIDN'I 'l5Tcu!- k:\1
CL CO/Y\rv\/ <;5' IDly' 1"\ EEl /;/J " 00 r be! lEIS
A.c.t1,,Aff! Cof/S/5TENT -'f>IEct$"E DoAlT
5 ttL US OUT -- WE. ()-K..~ n-lf
\/OTtKS,
filIi< II1If/ k.Oi</lBJ-tlft?
{\el:JJ;I//1lJiJ (tJ&/:h
}:J:.r-,ft,l"tt
J.o:;;<,; \.AJ, (C.';'"rrt7 (' IIi..? 9) c.,
fW-e l4t'uN\ I fCl &31& ()
J
1
I
I
I
\
1
I
!
i
] j
! '
i
-'
i
I ,I
t1I')AJ1j NY! I"r~j L' jC'- 17
IlUtJi iilJ(~, (.)--v/ 'lit" /.3 /
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
~ NDTlCE OF C\.. PckllC hea"f/q U5.c{..~
veld- f..-i f'^1f-ed, we. WON'rJ "srftclc"
Oc Co(Vl(Vl1 S<(;/ON m eenN~ 001
b'e.J, ep sy-e-~ rJ VJNS/SI74 T
11Gq~e DONI S~/I Us our-
\N E. OI.,re.. 1"'1-1 E Vr:YIGi'S _
Sincerely,
,f ,/ (~;
l;, -t{
/It--v 5'o,..k,
f!.tl1! /;11'
"""s' ))/
~,." <-,: ""- (,>I _" ?_
, . 'I.,~' C /(, '. ;
,l'iAc 'n"" _ / . I"~ -,7"
rvi'/V.vr..A" I,J ~'. .
/ / '>'>/,';.:;'
VI villiv'
( .0/-<;:) t./ &Lei 0:.' I 0 '-V -e :..
f i
! l
II
, ,
, ,
, I
:1
i i
I i
~ " l
Qt; blr
1
I
,
I
I
!
I
I
I
1 '
i
\
I
i
I
j
j
,
I
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
\
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I
emanating gas and ~i1 fumes, repair and painting services and
i
the loading and off-Ipading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burde~ed traffic situation. This kind o.f facility in the
I
center of town woul<~ not even be considered in other upscale
I
cities suph as corall Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
I
enhances a city. !
i
I
ENFORCE OUR E3UILDING AND ZONING CODES
-'
!
SAVE iOUR CITY
,
,~ NOTICE, ~F cA., ?iJJ/IC Aeair-; Hq UJi{..S'
V12.'(j- /vI ""Ihd Wf..Wd.N'rJ "Srf'rclc"
oc CofV)/YlI5<;ION rn ee~N~ Ou r
b-e/, ep s..-e-,rV\(;U rJ OJ S';SlJt;6./ T
1'lEQ5e :D6f\J7- St.ll I.I OUT-
'v'-J f.. 0.... 'f./I-J E V CYI/;:"/' 5 _
Sincerely,
~o: IA/C~l _
.5 7 l/c.' IV [.4.2. >/
/!/",(/v;rt,;r/! ,.7 ? li/; ,l
,
\
;
1.;
F
1:
~.C::vt ~\.\j I if W C (I N ",'1(,
I
I
\
\
i
! ,
! "
1
,J
i
,
I
!~
I
II
I
Ii
, "V
, f'
mnVt71 aOTTJJRB/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and offMloading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
;
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NcmCE ~F 0... ?d':JI/c hca,i/'lq VJC{..5;
ve.''d- f-..t (YIlh,d, We WON,rJ I/Sn1-Ck"
OL Co(VlfYl1S'!;IO,y rn(enN~ OUI
h,e,I, ep S ''r~rr'\o._i tV CoNS/SI'ItJ..1 T
?/;';Q5e I26N1 SE./I Us ouT-
\Nf.. OI.-r-e. iNE Vc7TST'S _
Sincerely,
i..J-() !>.J;.:.A1VL
,/!4)....<r I /v~: ~ ..:;,.;: J11/i..rl
1!vi'1'/;'{/I-f1" P .? I( 8,1
/
VI/IF-I 'Do~A{)t'i
~~!
,
I
,1 j., C-D/y 2 /i-L IE Z-!
I
I !
I
\
\
i
I
I
1
,
i
I
i
\
\
~
I
,I
i
F.
i,'i,,'
~ t,
1
Ini;VPl ({(}!17Jf6?/
I
I
I
Please continue tc~ vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
to be followed, not ismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I
I
storage faCility. This lis a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the st~eet. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and ~i1 fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-I~ading. of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burde~ed traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
I, ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
i I
i
enhances a city. I
ENFORCE OUR ~UILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
I
i
I
~ NOTICE. OF C\. ?do/IG heair;f/q LUi{.~
ver'fj. ~i""lhd., LA/to WdN'rU I'srfrck:"
Oc. Co/V)/Yl1 Sr;/ON M e.e N~' OUI
b-e./,eps.....~'^oJrJ Co ~/$Tit4T
?!Eq5e DONi SEll U. OvT-
\N 15 OI.-r e.. "11-1 E V C5/,-' T' 5 _
Sincerely,
iLJ!.
gp/</Y ({JAPP
NIII'
~;(,Y7il,t. .e"
)9~ l'ofj- JT
"'i) '-', ..., q.)
JH/fl0Z>;t / Ii f,: lit '
VEIIT{;;<f
1
I
/11 JfltJ)[, (;~}17lJL~/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
II
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
,
, ~
I
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
iJ
SAVE lOUR CITY
-f'- NOTlCE.?F CA.. PiJJ/IC hcarl/Hi ~~
ve,'rJ- /-v1/'Y1lhd. WE. WONirJ "Sr(}clc"
01- Co/Y1(V115<:;10I'-I rn eeTlN~ OUI
b-e.l, ep S"-~.,.r>oJ rJ VJNs/sr/tl..; T
'Pn;Q5e. DONi SEJ/ Us ouT-
\Ai r;. o...r '€- /1-/ E: V cYTF 7' 5 ..
Sincerely,
~/_, ~1__
,~_::rOtA.r""- W~ I (~
vetS.f
,? 11:/ jv: 1'0..;"-'7:1 ~I (/11 (J/t.
h 'e/'//ZJ4 I; I~/ ] ]/ fi (I
h. " '" '" ..It;,
/c,-" i. uv"
, C "'ilV/OC
u
I
I
;Y\/\ilDi( 007101::8
I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
i
1
\
I
I
!
I
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
,
i
i
i
j
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
i ,I
~ NOTICE OF fA ?t.kllC hea ,i f'/q LV4.~
V€"if, f.-.l fV>1t-ccl, WE. WON't! "srfl'clc"
{A.. CofVl(Vl} Sf;ION fY\ een'<l~ Ou r
b'eJ, eF sr-e-~' tV VJNS/SI'7C4 T
?;!;q5e :J:;:?orvr SEll Us our-
w ~ O\..re. -rH EO VcYTGT'S .
Sincerely,
f );
-; ,_ ;".". f /. i
( /' I ) )/(/ H J') ; i
I, " 4l/L c."" (Ie: 6,.::) i!
..' '''''It
--- ~ir
'I
\
!
,
I
I
I
i
I
1,/
1
!
;:'-VI' S'I J. Vf'i< n?{)j..J
!
Ie
~
<;;:i ltj~II'Ak!l.i
3~ Co t~7.'(('K>l'f, D(!.,
A&'((v'i1/' Jl-/ 1'/ (: V .9 c
i
, I
{V\ Y J)J( PO! #/1
/; " I
i
~
,
1 !
1
I
fJJlfY[);( t;)tlf71- IFl;/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
!
I
\
\
1
i
i
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
-'
,
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
,
I I
-1 NDTlCE. OF CA. ?d.o/ic. hea,iHo, li5.:{,S
Ve.I';}- ~i""I1-ed._ We WON''''; "srfrclc"
{)t.. Co(V)(Y11 Sf;ION Tn eeTlN~ OU ('
b.e.!, ep S 're,('Ao..,i rJ CoNS/S i'/t!! r:
11t;q5e DONI 56// Us ouT-
\N f.. OLle. IN 6 VrYlG7' 5 _
Sincerely,
, :
,
~._-)
~./..- ..,/' f'"-"~ ,
~::-:.~..,"-,c::.:;;;~
~'H.ftJ'1 R. 0 ..<><::jV
;2oSt'IJ
.uJJ."j I I'vE A we
1r1/t'//7fl!./i) p ,,;/ q, i
I 'c
V,lf 14 , A-O~4
~'f!.I'
'I l'
ji
h
;j
1
I
IJ1 /J (JrJI/ /"' -n-r.t' '1::-'-:-::>
/1/7 '1L-A L'-{," /J. It:::.!..'";>/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
\
I
1
1
I
I
i
J
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
i
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
,
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities su~h as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
I
;1
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
~ NOTICE, OF C\. ?dolic hca,i,.;Cj (fl4S
ve.'d- f.-.l f\'Ilf-ed W€ WONlrJ "SrfrCk"
OL Co/YlfYlI5f;ION IY\ eenN~ O(J 1
b-e../I ep s '''-e-~' tV CoN'O/S!it6./ T
11Gq~e YOiV/ SEJI Us OUT-
\N Er o..r-e. /1-1 C VrYlG7' 5 .
Sincerely,
-::J1fY\
i
Ii
j' I I
II! !
~o5-e1'-11xr9
iT
l'
,
!nl'~i"1 {'(>a:J
,'- 'V(,' 'r
~W;_?J' W L{.'.)\f,7t C".f' [)P
I ",..,
ILI!f'/, /'r'i/r',/J, ;:;/ )>"q1
17 v ,v I i (.. - / > .)oj c- {,.'
c c>t' 0/,/ A 00 /6w~ ~ ~
j;
1:;
\,:
~1',
;,1'
~..
1
I
rr: Ii VOl{ C)c'1H Ie 10/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
J
I I
j
i
\
I
'J
1
!
J
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
) I
! '
\
,
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
,
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF CA Pi.kllc hea,il'lq WCi.-S-
ver'r!- ;""'1 (nlhd WE. WONirJ "STfrCIc"
0\" Co/Y)(V11 Sf;ION rn f.e.nN~ OU r
be-II ep Sr-e-~ rJ WNS/5litAl r
11Eq~'e :DONi 56// IJg OUT-
\N f.. t;;\.re.. /l-l E VOIGT'5_
Sincerely,
i I
11
1 f
i I
Ii
II
,7_ Ii
/ Ii
Ii
'11
(2.ft F II f-"L /l111-/(A I e/,{o
/'Ai/JZW/E/i (J _
],5))' ()t;'(!IC /:)J/~'(;M'_
Il rl)vIM,tJ /;::; .~~/lj d
fY\ if !;:T/(' POLN r-
t
r
t
1
I
J1; #fOL Jl&{;;6~
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I ,I
.,,':,1,
..
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NDTlCE., ~F C\. PJ"J[IC hca'n'f/q 10<i.~
vei{j, "-I Mlf-ed, We WON,rJ "STfrclc"
0\... Co(Y)(V1/ S'C;ION In eenN~ 01; r
be-II ep 5 '''-e,.~ tV V:JNS/StiC&./ r:
l1Gq5e I26!\J/ SEll Us OuT-
\N r:. CI..re.ri-lE VcYlGl'S .
~g
Sincerely,
-<<L4U~ <;:j'rvvf;
;
, \
J:,
t
l
Sj~V'!7'
).../~ {5 tAr UJ./.../'l: If C / (i)'( Dr?,
~ f - ...
l~ft'V" : /' l' 1/., , (, 1\
. j' " t/... " '/ :>.:,>.. ..J ~J
(! O,'O/V AC'<:;'~L",,;"~-rs.
C U11 In I D;/j /1/ LAI!)/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
\
i
i
!
I
J
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
-"
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
'I
SAVE lOUR CITY
,
'1.'"
i
;,
{',:l
i'
"
r,
~ NOTICE OF CA.. Pdo/{c hear/Nq l04..S"
ve.,'rJ "-1m/he{. WE WON'rJ /Isr;rc/c"
{A. Co(V)(V11 Sf;ION Tn ee:-nN~ 0(; ("
be.!, ep s ......e,.~' tV CoNS/STiCA; T
?JI;q5e :DONI sell Us ovT-
W fr o...re. /1-1 E V<YTG7' 5 _
Sincerely,
~.
f)oT S~ 0 /VI 0/11
I"
r>,~
C [1[" J :I)A. (llV
~o J,J,{ I IJ t ~ i:. /r,Je
AVliv,+-IIY;. PI ,: / ~!.l S,'
11, II /Ii
--:;;;;;, e;{l. A p.fi
1
I
\
I
i
1 I
j
1 '
\
i
I
i
!
i
I
i
I
I
.-;
I
1"
j;
t,.'\'
i
C eM M DIll {V\Ofl D I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NDTlCE ~F iA ?Lkl/c hea,/f/q 054.$
ve.'d- f-../ mired We VvON'rJ "srrrclc\1
{A.. Co/V)(V1/ S<OIOj\( rn ee..T7N~ OUI
b'eJ, ep s..-e-.,.r\Ou' rJ CoNb/SllC6.f T
11GQ5'e :DONI S~I / Us OUT-
WE. OI..re. "t"11 E Vr:YJGr 5 _
Sincerely,
'~L.. .~ \-Ld->e.n
-Jo;')H;,F K. AS 1..':: ,<2"
J9. F,5: (' "-
'~m- //[/\'7" r.-
,"-" I~ l:: J J/.
fb'i/://7-:1J1 )C/, 5.>/5 (I
"-I Ell' r(.,lRE
1
I
[fJ;1f;11, f(J;/J/JkJ/vl1
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I '
i
1
\
I
j
, ,
I '
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I i
I '
i
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
",
~ NOTICE. OF C\. Pi.klic. heaT'<tJq UJcts
V€.r'l ~i(Y>jhcl Wf.WONi.,J J/STfrclc"
0\... Co(V)(Y1/ S~/ON fY\ eeTl,A.l~ Our
b-e./! ep 5 're,-('i)oU tV CoNS/SF&; T
?!Gq5e :Dorvi Sf;.;! Us ouT-
\N f.. ol.re.. T'li 6 VCJ/G7'S .
Sincerely,
~
}
q~. ~--~
r;Pt/l/f;~
.., L>t}. 6'1 ('
.> I' ,! 'v" OJ,iv7itt " '/ r",
/ (,1",-, lk
/}vl//;"(/,(,,4 , /1:/ ') ~ " {j, ' j
I' j",~/(7'
C_I\s:.'T\JH
'.
j!
II
'I
I,
il
!I
. i l
SPtlGLft~
I'.,,' ,!t~",.
' '~:,
",
1 : ',".
, : i
Ec-lieryJ4 ~1/1- ,L
cc~'Jc ,""
1
I
I
I
1
\
I
I
!
J
,I
, ;
j I
1 '
i
i
I ;
'~
II
\
\
\'.
t.:
" ~
] I
/) (i,1I/Il/i' 0" fJ. /1;/)1//1
CUU/lJF vII/II! (.,/lrIJ/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF C\.. ?dol/c hca,if/q UJ~~
ve.r(j. ~i"""lhcl, WE. VvON'.,J "srf/'ck"
{x.. Co/V){Y11 S'(;ION m eenN~ 01; l'
b-d, ep S '.-e-rr'oo"J tV CoNS/Sl7b.; T
?!Eq5e :J::;?orvr 56/1 Us ouT-
WE ot,re. -rl-l E VOIGT'S .
Sincerely,
I ~- i
!i i j
l! ! I.
I.i i I
..h J' !i Ii
~i:I,il
..Y1_ ~~ 1,1,
.1' I
Lf'/ti11 231..~(k~IJi
:1 :
'I
~
glt:{ke--
""U/I' A /'()<':'~'J7':'('" ,. 'n ) '7
.~/'"'I ,'1.(1 '-tv,j,,; ,;U,-, P'/'-I
.p,'Vfy>;;:; !U/{/l t:/ 3s./Fi ()
}Z tl; I,i-N ft fl.1 c,\.
1
,
COI'^ ~'v\ , D i A \''\1\ [) IV D /
l
I
\ '
II '
!
i
!
i ·
J
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed! not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
I
I
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
\
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind o.f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities subh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
,
i
J
il
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF CA.. Plklic hCci,lf/q LDti..~
ve.,'I /-vI (YIlhd, WE WON,rJ "5/7'rCk"
Oc Co(y)fY1/ Sf;iON rn ee.n;</~ Co ("
b"f:/' ep s '..-e,r^OU rJ CoNS/Sl7vv T
l1Gq5e :DONI sen Us ouT-
"" E ot.r -e. -rN E V CJTG 7' 5 .
Sincerely,
A ,
i
"J .'Co- /
3>' ~/{rTKltiv
:'/
I'
"
ii
I,
I!
II
II
ij
SV ~d"cklle~
I !
5'1t 1]<;1:/1-: f ,..
1.,5.~~ ~':;ilIC /C ':-:- ~:l,
Jj iJ..,v7U.~ ;:; >.>18 {,
i
i I
L
~,
i
,VJ.7 S"{IC ?o LAlli
1
I
I
I
I
!
I
(' I
V0,1-ifi11 D!I1J11(}tJjQ
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I '
I
\ '
\
i
!
i
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
.
,
i
I
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
~
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
i ,I
','
'.
~ NOTICE OF CiI.. ?lioltc hea,/flq lu:{S
V€J"'d- "-if'Y1lf-cd, Wf WON'r/ "ST(rC/c',
OC Co/Vl(V11 S'<;ION rn ee:nN~ 01; r
b-e..l, ep 5 're,,~' rJ CoNf;/sr/CA.i T
l1GQ5e. :;:::?OrvY SE.II Us ouT-
\NE. Olre. T"NE ViYTGi'5 ..
Sincerely,
:r"'
r
~',:t
i.
"
r
lLt[t
cJ..'~i.s; F; IV k
I l'
".", "ti,
" r-
, r
, 1
." i
~ ,/1
t' 1/11/
:;Lc:..q/ lJE J(; hfli"
/}1/l!:l./Tv;:.:I1/ ;:/ Z llj I:'
VIII" :\ V\-
'1}6'- fl /J
1
I
1
I
1
\
I
'{
!
'J
;
I
~
i
I
,I
:j
t:
r
r
eulifll/f. OJ /fJJlk))/I))
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTlCE,?F C\. ?ikl,'c hccz'lf/q G04.S"
ve'1-' J.,...j f'nlhd, WeWoN',v I/r;Tfrc/c"
0\, CoIYI/Vl/ 5'1;101'1 rn ee:n"'i~ Ou r
b~/, ep s.....e-~ tV CoNS/S lltA! T
P/EQ5e 720rvT SEll Us OuT-
\N E o\',r e.. /1-1 E V iYlG T' 5 _
Sincerely,
c:::r~:.P':$k~ ~(~Qj
II
11L- MCJ SC asCI ! '
ilIl, r'r ""
r'n/... :>i.- (....l~, v
;;.,().:~ '5' .'~ ((; :;v,,;;{~y C:Y{/Xt fJ Yr-
f:'V e:;ll'q;~'1\) r:,; z;; q (I
w6?5
o .,0
CO~
CLi1ll}/. /)j /j 1// iH12
Please continue to vote against any vatiance allowing Hi-Lift
!
I
\ '
I
i
I
I
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
i
,
I
,
, --
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE JOUR CITY
~ NDTlCE OF 0.. Pi.hl/c hea,lf/q LD<i.~
verif" f...t (VI/he!. WE. wON'fl//STfl-C/c"
CA.. Co/V)(Y1/ S<(;IO;y 1Y\ eeT7N~ Ou r
b-ejl ep s -..-e,-,.rw tV CoNS/Sllt:A/ r:
?!Gq5e 72DN/ Sf/I Us OuT-
\NE OI.,re. ,/-IE VOIST'S ,.
Sincerely,
; :
, I
1 !
i i
~ I
i! I
;1 I
. ~ ! \ i
0.. ~TR o-itE ~
I,
!
I
I
I.
,>
s,r-ei/'/CY"
~::n~~{.V);:~?>I~$~6 ch
;;
I;.
\,1,'
r-
i
Coro,0l\; lOD -r~.)-e it 4
I
I
I
&)11;11 v)A III Mvll I
I
Please continue td vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
to be followed, not 1smissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
I
1
i
I I
I
\ '
\
I
I
I
!
i
,
,I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and iI fumes, repair and painting services and
\
i
\
the loading and off-I ading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already ()Ver-bUrde~ed traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
!
center of town woulJj not even be considered in other upscale
I
I
cities sUPh as Corall Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
'I '
enhances a city. i
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
-'
i
SAVE lOUR CITY
*- NOTICE o~ '^ PJoI,c Aea~i "q uxc,
v e,'d- ~i (YIlt-eel. W f. \tV 4N t rJ 1/5 r;1'ck' I
{)L. Co/V)/Yl/5<(;ION rn eel,'" N~ Our
b-e./, ep S .....~tv'oOu tJ Cbf's/sre4 T
11t;w5e I20Nr SE./I u~ our-
w& "'r" rNE VOT;"I'S
I
I
Sincerely,
I
. ,
~*
~~~\
(;,e',eT
, I
t I
, l
; ,
! I
! I
;i i
li j
:i!
:11
(0 t-If/V
C---'CCil~;&
",,'1 '-
:), D Ne /'-12 S,7
A'Vlr,,~,
" o1//V,/Vr'.I1"I-/' .",^
" -, ->/~ "
" , E'w
So ~ T J... 'f
i'
I.:
t~
l
1
,
I
I
!
I
e q:wn oWi 7
I
I
1
\
I
I
i
i
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
,
,
,
I
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
SAVE lOUR CITY
r
i
,
f'.'
;
r,
!'
~ NOTICE, ~F C\.. ?d(}/ic hCar;"'Cf (A;{.~
Vi-I'd- "-/ (V\1i-ed., WfWON'rJ "srtrc/c"
ex.. CofV)(V11 Sf;IO/y rn eenN~ OUI
b~/Iep S '''-e-~<rJ CoN'i:;/STiWT
?/GQ5e. I2orv-r 5(;,/1 Us ouT-
\N E Olre.. 1/-1 c: V<YrGr 5 _
Sincerely,
! j ~!
~.~ :,:,1
""'-. "I
! "~ (ti1,ii
'II
, -;/\I.i
S; 'till (I<> ''t ~ c. "l'/f-!
i!
;
I < ".."" "it,:",
~"'~,
. : ,,-
<<
.4':5 ((.).:r
, - i r
....,,, ,
;; 'tel:V cel(>:.>;' ('/"C ;c-V,
().vf.v ',," /I 'r' ?;I 6, '
." - /) IV / ~ J>/ t' (!
I!. '" .s ~l/lf tJ /1- .I
. CO)1ao
1
I
(}fl1f/11 /OEt> i
I
I
Please continue t~ vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
I
to be followed, not djismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land u~e area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I
emanating gas and bil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-I~ading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burde1ed traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
I
center of town woul~j not even be considered in other upscale '
I
cities sUPh as Corall Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
- I
enhances a city. I
ENFORCE OUR f3UILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE ,OUR CITY I
i
I
!
, i
~ NOTICE. o~ 0.. ?Jql/c hca1ri,.;q LP4.S"
VfC.r(j- /--./ ('r\1f-ed, WfwolNlrU "sr/l'clc"
0\." Co/V)(V1ISf;ION m eeHN~ 0(; r
b-e./, ep s..-e.l'AOu' rJ Co <;/S;7tA./ T
?!Eq5e :DONI SEll U ouT-
'v"-J E. Ol.r e. 1"/-1 E V CJT. 7' 5 _
Sincerely,
,I
-'
\
" i
"I
f;j~ ill
;: I
,-' i
t".. !4-.: ,I,ll
il i
'-IN 11- ,2 t'\ ~r~
1:
,
~1'1;l1.'!Vrt1~
I
-; (;",..> ,1.f:f' I <j').. Ji--
),. '
/rY'" J./ :7,~(' ,1/ le-:'; --> .>/ B ,1
/
<,\0 "'TA" I E'v C (.{.f (1t;,
~.
1:.
t\
l'
1
I
C[AWI/II/ JoeL. /
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. OUf building and zoning laws are in place
I
I
I 1
\
\
I
I
i .'
I
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
: ,
I l
i I
\ '
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
il
SAVE iOUR CITY
-1- NOTICE OF C\. Pi.kIIC hea,ltlq Li54.S"
ve,'1- I-...i(Y\lhd, WE. \NON'rJ I/srltclc"
Ot.. CofVJJY11 SblOI'( l'Y\ e,e:-nl-l~ 0(; I
h-dieps '.....~~tJ CoNS/Sl7CA./T
P!;;;Q5e :DONI 561/ Us ouT-
WE o...r-e..n-i E VcJlSi'5 .
Sincerely,
~~i
[ " ,i
,'" /~ - ,vI
I
I
ANIIII' /IIIL/</f/ !
"'\: {,
.J
i~lIkl k) A)
Z i{<5 ( /-I. {(}f/I/.;I!.j {'Ita .;..'U
111/IiNll/lfi; H? ~/ir {
.. -" t_' (.f
j:'7Y 1. f;Y/! 111
( {)/l/Ye
1
I
,
I
I
i
C' 10M" ~~ ~ ~,9, ,=
, v!, ' '"-' k L
'I /
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
\
I
!
I "
j
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
II
,..1
:{..
~ NOTICE. ~F 0- ?do/ic hea,;f/q l-04S
ViC-I'; /vI ('rIihd. Wf WONlrJ "srfrclc"
OL Co{Y)(V1JS'bION rneen;"l~ Qur
be: lieF S 're-,.r\o..,i tV CoN~1 s ricA; r:
?!GQ5e. :DONI Sfll Us OuT-
\N f.. OLr-e..iH E VOTers _
Sincerely,
~v.
flo\^-tAt!. (J
t.Fti?f"r<
LJ!-'>;7,sf/'~
-; 6(.\) (~,~/~j7f /':)c///~~ IJ,,~ ,
/..- '~''''1' r /:> "I
J7-1..tN..it,,!, r/ >"1,,"
I \
."", t,'~,.,
' ~i",
' .~.
. : ,
, "
f'r\YJ.i I (
f'Ci",r
lo,,7
C' .....,-: -- '
J '\ iI/A ,,A/1 '.J 0 e::. L-
LHch', ' I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
.
enhances a city.
-'
i '
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
II
~ NDTlCE, ~F C\. PJolic hca,i/'lCj UX{.$"
ve.,~ f.-./~Ihd, WE WON'rJ I'srfrclc"
Oc. CoM(V1/S<(;/ON fY1 eenN~ O(J r
b-e.l, ep s ''r-e,-('I'\Ou'tV VJNS/STaI T
?!Gq5e :I2o(\.jf SE,II Us OUT-
'v'-JE- OLr-e, i/-lE VOTsrS .
Sincerely,
~
!'
Ic,tTZ'e./\.J
)..1X';"1s tA/" G Ci.:NT!:l.. C/ufT. iNi
/ytJ..e IJ;U.I!,4, F! .~ Yp J
/
IMMN I:AT2EN
t
t\
l
CO to /-1 "PO 10 Vv/ C U
1
I
II (//1 ,!' j~1j1 tr'L') iC i
CUj /if lit b !j I C'p-;
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
I
1
i
I
I
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
j I
1 '
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities subh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
;
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
(';1
;:
F
-1- NDTlCE. ?F D-- Plkltc hca,;f/q ~
ve'd- "-i ""Ihel Wf WON'r/ "5T;}CIc"
CA.. Co/Yl(V1ISl;IO,y TY\f.enN~ our
bfJ1ep S'r~~'tJ CoNS/STit:4T
11Gw5e I:;?orv/ SE./I Us OVT-
\N E. 0.... e.n-l IS v OIS 7' 5 .
Sincerely,
t:.
i'.
1
i;
vo~
i, i I
~ 1 ! i
'i i I
Ii I i
ii II
Ii i
'. I,
1111
, I' i i
flo~w'rt
,I:
/'1.,,,' ," or)
~~~~. 'I <..
t.Qifllll ,l(, ;1I/t"
1'-i/ fYlU(l: P/ ? 1/ P .'
V'/' '1 I
/])0 ( Mer
\:
t
fi.
r
, " i'
, '
, "
;
Cu,11fJ1 OOUI
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
j
1
j
I
I
j
J
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
-I.!
1 I
I '
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
.\
1 \
, \
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-i
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
,I
~ NDTlCE OF C\.. ?ikltc h(A,;Nq lPct.~
Ve.r~, f.-..irnlhd Wt WON'rV I/srll'clc"
Oc CoM(Y1/ S<';/O;y tn eenl-l~ OIJ 1
k:,'eJI ep S ~""~"^<Ju' rJ CoNS/Sl7A/ T
11GQ5e. :.DC:Jrvt Sf-/! Us ouT-
"'-I E.. O\.,re. il-l E VOTe7'S .
1\,
~.
"?Z..1;J ~,..-f~ L~ v ~ ~I
~,L-ei./;/
'0"
,?,- !>;tS v. COi."J1l1 (/(/t10/Z
;;'-{/Y'/.I.~i',t. /ii2l/ /i;1 '
-
J ... V..J e .-;;
{J O't.-o N u..J. c
j/
!;.
H
i
1
I
CaYN fi;l c JZ&?/
I
Please continue tc~ vote against any vatiance allowing Hi-Lift
i
Marina a height incr!sase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
I
I
to be followed, not diismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
!
of a few. The land wl,e area is not meant for such a large scale
!
I
I
storage facility. This lis a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the st!reet. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and ~i1 fumes, repair and painting services and
I
the loading and off-Ipading of boats on trailers contributing to an
I '
I
already ()ver-burde~ed traffic situation. This kind o,f facility in the
!
,
I
j
1
i
i
I
I
I
J
I
center of town woul(~ not even be considered in other upscale
i
cities suph as corall Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
I
enhances a city. !
i
!
i
ENFORCE OUR I:3UILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
I
SAVE JOUR CITY I
! I
, I
I
I
-1- NDTlCE. OF CI... ?J:;//c hea!,;HCf ~
V,e. ''I "-I (V\{hcf" We WJ,J Nt.,u, "Stfrck"
OC CoM(V11 S~/ON M e.e N~ 0(; ('
b-e..l, ep s "'-e-~' tV Co 'O/Sle"'l T
?;;';Q5e, :D6rvt S~n v- OUT-
w. Ocre- n~E vorts .
!
1
Sincerely,
~
i
aft/-
IJltHt
?,iH,; /1/[ /'/2- jF
J!wfv/'Vt(,4, Ii" '/,
! ~.> " ','
11 '
:; !
fi i
Ii i
I' I
'I'
II!
!II'
@Eo~'tf.. M i\ r~
'! '
t;.
t'
r
~vll..\Jt'("'N cavd..
"
I
I
I
L'\-i' ,1/1 ;/;/} Iff/iXMelll
Vi'/lflti 1/ '
I
I
I
\
I
I ,
I
j
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
, ,
I j
I '
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
!
\
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities subh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
II
,1
SAVE ,OUR CITY
~ NOTICE OPo... ?i.kllc hca,iHq G04..S"
verd-' f.../ rv>lhcl. We WONirJ /'srll-c/c"
OL. Co/V)(Y1/S<(;ION Tn ee:nN~' Out
b-e./I ep s '''-e.~' tV CoNS/S,'/C4/ T
11Gq5e :DONI Sf/! Us our-
WE o..,re. T"li E VrYlGr 5 .
Sincerely,
5J'. i
-*' "Bill ~#/Vo.<i
i'
, ~s.~:/'j"
P ]JS(-AL [';;J.;''v,!1 t'/~;:] viI,
m,fNTV?'ft- P 1'J/.<; {f
(b~(i;V>A i)u '1b1J.i~ T.'>
t:
V
r
1
I
{C)1f/l1/ jJtulI: Jt///
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
j
i
I
i
!
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
i
I
I
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
i
\
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
.
enhances a city.
-'
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE ,OUR CITY
1,1
~ NOTICE OF 0.... PdollC hca,'f/q U54.~
ve.,'rJ- /--..1 (Y\11-ecl, we WONirV1'STII-C/c"
OL. CoM(VlI S~/ON rn eenN'~ our
b~/J ep S 'T-~~ rJ CoN'C/S lltA.! T
?!.t;q5e. :DoNY Sell Us ouT-
'v'i E. 0..., e. -r/-I E V ()'TS 7' 5 _
Sincerely,
J
I
I '
\ ,.
".J
?Ai11l1[.{{,>,.,1,!?;>J
. . fl' -,(', '(1 ""
J 1/],' N~ iUv1 [, 1/." '_1.,
,-,'.... 1,:,,'., './ QtI
/41/ U'II i/ltt. /' ,~~, v
~,
1i
II
, ii
In,D,2/l1l1ci:111J 1i'1
'I
ii
I
I
./ (.~tJ /f1~,)jo
r:.t!.lfl
(lr1111/'1. fJ(/E)2,i? ACH j
I
I
i '
j
j
Please continue tq vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
i
i
Marina a height incr~ase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
to be followed, not diismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
I
of a few. The land ui,e area is not meant for such a large scale
I
,
\
,
i
storage facility. This lis a residential/town center with a school for our
i
I
children down the stireet. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I
emanating gas and 6i1 fumes, repair and painting services and
I
;
I
the loading and Off-Ibading of boats on trailers contributing to an
I "
i
already bver-burde~ed traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
j
! '- ,
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
I
I
i
cities subh as Coral!Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
I
i
I
enhances a city. I
I
ENFORCE OUR E3UILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
I
SAVE JOUR CITY I
i
i
,~ NOTICE o~ 0... 'Pchllc heal'lf/q U5Ci.S'
veld- /-vi (V\lhc! we. WdNlr/ "STfrC!c"
0\, CofV)fV\1 Sf;ION tY\ e.e: N~ 00 ('
b .~JI ep s..-e,-/'I'I()u' rJ Co f:; /5 !lEA.! T
!1Eq5e yorvY 56/1 If our-
v'i IS ~,re../l-I E Vo-T.- 7'5 _
Sincerely,
,
j
,I
.-'
I
;i II
. ii !:
'1 : t ! !
,SI\I"\ ~Pft:XRi \\,\Ii~(\ '
, P C:'A'tlMi~p'
3';"tt'b AlE /~ ~ r
i'vel./It;~P/ /f" l;/il.1
k-VUrU ill 1/::'11,/
,.",
j~ .
I:;,
[,,:
~t.
t
1
I
l
I
\ I
I
1
\
i
I
!
I
,
,J
\
i
-'
I
I
"
',.
"
\
I!',
"",j
',' ,
erJJ1f/lYr l;(;/~:;CI.5IJC/iL.i
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF C\. ?i.kl/c hea,if/q L0C{..S"
v€-''if- J..ifV\lhd, WE. 'WONlrJ J'sn'rc/c."
{A.. Co/Vlty11 S':;ION tY\ e.e.nl-l~ 0(; I
b'e.I,eps '..-e,('I'>OI..irJ CoN<C/SlltJ,.IT
l1Gq5e ::DotvT 56// Us ouT-
\N E- OI.re. IN c VOIGT'S _
Sincerely,
~ ~il;
/'4 r'R.. IliA L..
rtf!
;'i{()ll./ (U,,~V7:! OtiC ;lit,
. A--"~i/ i7J..(I,~ / fC/ J 1i & (1
A-
:J: ~"'tt 1
(f.tI , /p U
t.. 6/-'
1
I
,
I
I
!
,
('oMt1 Pliei?.F;AOi /
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
1 1
j
1
\
I
I
!
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town canter with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
j I
I '
I
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities subh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
i
I
Ii
I :
il
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF CA. ?iJJl/c hea,; f/q Li54.~
ve.'d- 1..-1 fV>lhd Wf WONlrJ "srfrclc"
01- Co/Y)(Y11 Sf;ION rn ee:nH~ OUI
b-e.11 ep s..-e-rr.oJ tV vJNs/sr&; T
l1Gq5e ::I:;?orv/ S(;./I Us OUT-
\N E oere.. '-rt-l E. VOIGT'S .
Sincerely,
L 1;.t{JfI r-t?lt:OFL
l'
F;t/tl'.{ !..
36()J t:1itSrl(F'r I'/.
;frfhl?/,~I' ;u'; ,;',!! I
' ',/ / > -} {'t
i
, !
t;.
t',
, l.
1"'Ii\ Y! i/C pew 1
Cov
1
I
(]]}lJ1j11. ;ju[/gllt/! I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
1
\
I
I
i
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
; i
I '
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
--
!
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
,I
'l
SAVE lOUR CITY
* NDTlCE, ~F C\. Pi.ki/c hC4,it./Cj Wtt-S"
ve'd-, /-.../ {YIlhcl, WE WON'.,u /'srfrc!,:,"
Ot- Co/Vl(V1ISf;ION In eenN~ OUI
b-e./leps 'y-e-~rJ VJNS/STitAlT
?!Gq5e I;)CJ!V( SEll Us OUT-
\Nt C\.re. ,/-It: V6TGi'S '
Sincerely,
\'
n1 "r.b,/ '"
Ii, (.it TI",.I7"
'lcJ;S- W CC\),;'J/r; {I.v/f. 0t2,_
,1VL'/V /v,:,:V1/ F/ ? i> g ()
C(jrJI~I9!)C lbtJ.N'I-S,
t
I,:'
~ ~.
, ,l
C ut^\"^ A U fd.15 ,/::.,{ ft I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
~
1
1 I
I
i
i
i
!
I
,j
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
i
!
.~ I
! j
1 '
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-<
i
"
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
SAVE JOUR CITY
~ NOTICE. OF 0... ?LkIIC hea,; Nq U54.S
Vf..i(J- /--./ rnlhd, Wt WON'rJ "5TfrCk"
0\.. CofY)(V11 S'i;IO,y rn ee:nN~ 0(; r
b,~/leps "T-e-~tJ CoNS/sTitAtT
P!GQ5e :Do(\.}( $6/1 Us OUT-
w ~ OI..re iliE. VOTF7' 5 _
Sincerely,
<.'-'~
, c::::: ;;/c
T,::,z,zy
f!:,fl=Jcl!-
:?57S IHf(J/C lbll/I/)l{
I~A'-e"'-;'A'" ,-
f;-v I'JliJ)~r; ,iLl. \~>"')! Qlf
. "", I C "'~
MY~I!C
i
t
'~"'.'
I,
, ,
','
j t
ii i
11 t
:,~/'"'';H '
ill
Iii
'. I
!i I
Ui
::> .,., H:~Yi
{~rk. !i!
1 '
f:'c, ir-lf
1
I
C~jN/1l I}ttlZ?iJ3/1'
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
i
\
I
I
i
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
,
I
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind o,f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE. OF 0... PiJol/c hcarl Nq GU':i.S
Ve.r(j,l-...i(Y\lhd, WE. VvON'tl NSTfrC/c',
Oc Co(V)(Yl1 S<,;iON rn ee.nN~ 0(; ("
b,e.JleFs....e.~rJ v;NS/SriCAlT
?!GQ5e. :::i20rv! S~ll Us our-
"'i c Olre.. II--lE V6TGi'S _
Sincerely,
,
; ,
, ,
i
, !
-
.J p.o.,.,
!.
Ii,. .. .,;//
I. Iv...,,- ~
'... /, )". {. ',,, .' , -'''':.-t (';' 1,"-' ',/i
r-v l~:.r vv (,~' vi"':.'I, v (J ; ,. ,., .
r"Yvelv';'Zt,.t"/~) h" ~"'li ,c, l
\.. ~ e(l 0 N o...d c i ()l..c.> -e ..r>
t;
t:
J
1
I
C0JJ1/}f ~7E,eH~
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
I
\
\
i
,
I
I
J
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
i
\
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
il
SAVE lOUR CITY
;:.!
~ NOTICE, ~F 0... PLkhc hcari/'lCf V5C{8
vei'if- /-vi rnlhd. WfWON'rU {/5r;rck"
(}L. Co/Vl/YlIS'!;ION rn(;'.eT7N~ our
be.!! ep s 'y-e-~ tV CoNf;/S/'7CJ../ r:
l1Eq5e :::DC:>r-JI $611 Us ouT-
\N E- OI.,re.. /1-1 E VrJlGl' 5 _
Sincerely,
i, i
;1 I
:1 !
"
VVC'>:f-,1\II Tz' 1
/--.cV1 CP'''
\;
lV-e!IJ{';;i/';"'2:
~ 1'Lk' fr//I.I~:?';,9:! [ill!; ;JIl,
,1 ViivIe/f',4 , /::::/ ]1/5';:1
, /
,::; .'Jtfl/Ylt~"p'-'
1___ ('f '
t
1 t\
, l'
, 1
I
Qo fVI r1 L S;' I E(x..f-I /
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
1
I
I
I ·
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
,
i
I
I
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
: \
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE, ~F c\.., ?r..:kl/c hea,i/'lCf (,;xiS
ve,'rJ /-...1 (YIihd, WE. WON'.,v 1/5l7}C/c"
Oc Co/Vl/YlIS";'ON m ee.nN~ 01.; r
h'eJI eF 5 're,."""O"j rJ CoNS/Sllt:t.I T
?!Gq5e I20rvr $6./1 Us OuT-
'v'i f5. Ol-re,. IN E V()"/Gi'5 .
Sincerely,
i r
. ,
I
"i J i
.A L- ,.l'" , -'-'---;;. ~
~ I ' 1t-{/J;1(/ ):':<-1
I
Do?.,;;; kQ.\~V IT zi
t
li,
~k
l
l<rr:vT~
]575 i\1yJ/lc lev,,"/, o/t,
ll'i(J:/;r/f rrt r: / :?:j ~ L1
'tvf.,..V;ltI.,./ I d~.
;
1\'\Y5./i( p(.<~ii
i
i
0Mtlf'l 57l?l/1.~j
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
j
I
!
i
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
,
I
i
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
...,
,
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE JOUR CITY
II
(o:r
;:
r".
I'
* NOTICE. OF lA Pdolic hca,i",q L0<{.~
ve'd- f..../ (V\lhcl Wf. WON't! "Srfrclc"
{)I.., CoIYl(Y11 S<;;/ON rn ee;nl-i~ OUT
b .e..11 ep S 'r-~I'I'\Ou' rJ CoNS IS i?At r
?n;q5e :D6rvY sell Us ouT-
w E ~.re.. -rl-l E ViYTSr 5 _
Sincerely,
r
\,
kl D,,-,4. A~ U
0:k()~
,/1/), '
"qJ\,..'J
20:;..;.> V.iC-o"::'1,./zy .e.ll/I'{ ';'fL. '
!rv-fNfTJ'fAl., p/ ~;; ~,-'
I '
Co f"'aN'tt- Dc I o'.4.:e R.5
t..
r,
1
C1~'~V71< 5yElli;~
I
i
1
\
I
! .
'1
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I j
I '
I
,
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
, i
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
il
SAVE lOUR CITY
r
.
f')
j'
r,
r
~ NOTICE ~F fA ?LhIIC hea,;Hq lU"i-S-
ve.i'i "-I (nlhd, We WON',.v I'srfrck."
OL CofV)fY11 Sf;ION M ee;rlN~ Ou I
beJ1ep 5 '''-e-~rJ CoN'C/S,'iWT
11Gq~e :DOM! 56/1 Us ouT-
\N E Ol-re.. -,HE VOISI'S _
Sincerely,
frJ (J t:. ~i-S.
!: I
I,
:1 I
ij i
111
Ii I
[I t
~c jf~"1U
I'
l;
i'
t;.
V
!
g...'/1A:::i:
}...o~2S i;;; ('UJ}./!j!y L/i/lJ, /'!:~
A 1 [,/Jl ,,'
T~:(f!/i/Jt:l/ r/ ';'>1'/,)
, , c
Ctd~-(;HI:\ 00 T 6~f!;
1
I
\
I
1
I
i
j
i
I
;
i
!
'f
I
i
I
I ....
i
i
I:.
t.
l~
1
,n
/ " 1/ 1 11/" /"'7'-' ", j
1.....X):/iIJ;. 11/ :::,,/t'/OYI
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind Q,f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVEiOUR CITY
-jt: NOTICE OF 0..., ?Jo/IC hean<'^/Cf L.0"i.S'
vc..ld- I-virnlhcl, Wt WONlrJ "srlrck',
01.. CofV)(V11 S'OION 1Y\ eeT7"'~ 00 ("
bt: II ep s '..-e-~' rJ CoNS/S i'/CA.; T
11Gq5e :DONi Sf-II Ug our-
\N f.. 0I..re. T"I-I E VOTSI' 5 .
Sincerely,
(j/- iil
?i - .~ iill
i ~ I '
,;/ ~I~ll
.':Ji)~fl.i)C n ER.A 6 f!
ij I '
, l i
I'
I'
/ftr-J'jn1:;!$-
)--iJ; IS- ((NC!liV,'o/ t:t'w; jJl:~
A' ". ,>, 'Q
-,I.C!J"v'FfJ;f'iJ ,cl ,>~/(,f\
} V"f.. J .'''' ,,/....f' . . v
\
- 'I .s
'1D~(::...
C.:)!: oN'A {)O
1
I
(;0;11 fJ'l. S'IER;11
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
\
I
I
i
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
! I
I
I
i
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~',: I
r.
r
~ NOTICE ~Fo.. 'Pthflc heariNg UXi.')
ve;{J "-t{Yllhcl Wt WON,rJ "Srfrclc"
01... Co/Vl(Vl1 Sf;ION IY\ fenl-l~ OUI
b-e-/leps ''r~~'rJ VJNS/ST&;T
t1Gq5e :DOr\JI $6/1 Us ovT-
w E.. ~.re. -rl-l E VOTFT' 5 _
Sincerely,
.l:
r
I
\
i
/.-edf'rt.Ui/ >
,:' C' ,-- '
,......v ::> ().> It: c.u '. It. '"
. ~'IJ, ., l.'},,/: ~I'Z'1
"~{;el' .. r7', - J
Ir FJ .. {,'/'lll- l-l 12 -t ~ .\. ,
i>, ' >J./t'f {)
~ !ii
~I;!
qi
:\J .111
, \11
.J i\ "-i L.... eJ"f t:. ~q WJ1 '
, il;
ii'
1 '
[,:
t'
r
'-IV r:~ Tf K. V /1::: V\J
I
I
I '
i
\
\
i
I ,
I "
1
j
i '
1--
il
"I
~,',',',"',',
,
r"'
F.
f,
{':I
,:
k
I
1
\.
\ 1:,
t\
J
thll/J/1/t r"iZp! I
'-.',/" ;. .~ (;11./,,::,
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind o.f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
!
~ NOTICE ~F ClL ?dolic hca,;Hq L0q.~
ver'd- /-.-/ rnlh:d, We WON'rJ I/SrfrCk"
Dc Co(V)(Vl1 S'(;ION 1'Y\ eenN~ Ou I
be.!, ep s '..-e-,,-r.O\.i rJ CoNS/SllcA'; T
l1Gq-; e :I;26r...J( S fEll Us ouT-
\N (5. Ol-r-e. rl-l € vo-r~7' 5 _
Sincerely,
iIU
~b lPV.Ib
h r/?-t,s
.~9' I /"c ~?C> ;tt-'t"
h/ov70VC j':/ -;0.,
/ .I.,~/b'>
VI lilt o'l"'-
1P~8,.,(I
1
I
l
I
I I
i
\
\
i
!
i
!
i j
I '
I
\
i
\
I ;
f:..-;
,
"
il
j
;:,:"
)
I,
I '
;,:"J
, '
/) 'n/l,1~;' ~7I....? /
l:!UM!d. '0; t/'(}.) /
!
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
I
~ NOTICE OF 0... PdollC hear/Nq W4.s'
V€-i'f /--./ rnlhcl, Wf WON'rV "sT;rc/c"
01- Co/Vl(V11 S'i;IO/V rn e.enN~ 0(; I
b'eJ, ep 5 '<-~rA<AJ' tV CoNS/SleA./ T
f;t;q5e :::Z:;orvr SEll Us ouT-
\N E- OLre.n-l C VcYiG'7'5 _
Sincerely, I ;
i
I
I
i
~/ItJ-I))I~ 71l/ML.vi
r; t U,11 fiLl
J-02."/' 1 rl: /' ~
I .IV ." -' "', !yV'l
J!-!/{/vTvr,A., ,/Z;' S i ' C.j
f~ "'/' >10.'
V tJ II' pcJ(J 0 It
1
I
~
i
I ,I
I
\
\' !'
t:
J
., "v11 (1" ,-.-"C:7 A /
CU/id11r '::J/ tC/\..Nj
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind o,f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
I
-1- NDTlCE. OF CA Plkl/c hcarif/q V5ii,S
ve'd-- /--.1 fr'\1f-cd" We WON'rl I/r;Trrc/c"
CI- Co(V)(V11 Sf;ION rn e.enJ.i~ O(J r
b-e../leps 'r-~-tV\(}u'tJ CoNS/ST&;T
?!GQ5e. ::DoNI 56/1 Us ovT-
'.1'-/ r; Ol.r-e. //-1 E V(j/GT' 5 .
Sincerely,
\/ y~-
VIV .~/oc k,
.g/ {,( /2
:;'ii't J.iLi..o:.:c;;,;?;,/ ('ft-C LJ/:.
IrVtW/1i?!I':;;Ii ? //".1
/ ........ (''-''
,r.'f<'O\.~
,.,,_. .' ~ I'L~_
i':: {It } \- ( l.' f'lY)v
1
I
') , '"C> ---, /'
( rlilllj;J1 /,f/r.;;J/I.:; t:: ,( l:"/
VJ~"':.i/. I{.,-I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
i
\ '
I
i
I
i
I
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
i I
I '
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
;
enhances a city.
~
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
-jr- NDTlCE., ~F C\. ?do//c hC4.,i/'lCf GUC{.~
ve.,'1 ~/ ('nlhd. We WON'"u "STfrC/c"
Ot. Co(V)(V1/ S<;;ION rn eenH~ OU ("
b>~//ep 5 T-e-~'rJ CoNS/STitA;T
l1GqGe :DONI $61/ Us ou,-
\N t:.. 0I..r e.. T/--I E V <YIG T' 5 .
Sincerely,
"
'1
Ii
:1
;i
I'
Ii
Ii
--g eNrI'( 110 lit 1
I,
! .
,
\
"
:^Jj)r!.<-/J
'J' ,~ A
bLf"i(., /1/( /tf:2 57>
If 1/ e:.vIV,(/I- iC I ), / t< ,\
/ ,'-, S,) ,'I.:'
s() vT /J VilE vi
t,
l',
l
1
I
1)/]Il/i1I! li/I( IIi/PC/ t ,
GL4 "Itl' I- IA'/I(Ji'f/>'-{,-C'-,
I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\ '
\
I
I
i
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
,
I
;
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
i \
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
~
i
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
SAVE lOUR CITY
-1- Neme[ OF C\..,PdoflC hca,iHq UJ<.{.s
ve,'r}-' /--..irnlhcl WE WONirJ f'srfrc/c"
0\., Co(V)(V11 S':;ION fY\ eeT7J..I~ O(J r
be-I, ep s'<-'e-"^<Ju tJ CoN'O/STitJ..I r
'f!GQ5e I20rvr $6// Us our-
wE-are. "/1-/ E VcYlG7'S _
i j
c i!
! i I
! I i
'I II
, i 'I
" I
:1 i
,ill
VY)sou~t' ~
I'
I!
! . '
V;~~J-t/~2
~:);:;:; j"v, i.'O,,;1f'l1 (1i/0 pI(
!rlielv1{;/ft-f. /"'! ;;?/') d
I . '(
-
Ci.>,^Oi'/ ;'(.j.o I Dv t r~
t,
t'
t
1
I
CbAfll1- tL/t7:flllIS1L't;
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
I
\ '
1
\
I ,
.I "
i
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
! I
1 '
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
,
i
\
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind Q,f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
r'
I '
!,'
~ NOTICE, OF C\.. ?i.hlic hca,;;vCf L.04.-~
V€"(j, /--..Ifnlhcl WfWON',v "STfrclc"
Oc Co(Y)(Y1/ S<(;IO/V tY\ eeT7N~ 0(; r
b-eJ/ ep s.....e,,~ tV CoNSIst?:!; r
11;;q5e :Dorvt 56// us OuT-
WE ~.re. i/-lE VOTGl'S .
Sincerely,
;':1
;
1'"'.
r
7)AV1I;) ,~(ec.c
Ft''-'' c'D
,) ")'?5 ~..; "'0" o/!" (.' I,' y? y?
rv))" L. l, 'illvl~ 1'1-'
(we /VTiJ{[j1, P/ Z it B .)
C o."o.,v,~IOQ 'i-~~,e. 10.
t
tt
, r
1
I
,
I
!
I
C O/iU;11 W tllllSE j{ l?
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
\
i
I
I
!
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
j I
\ '
i
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
;
enhances a city.
~
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
: ,
i ,I
;:1
~ Nemec OF C\.. PJ:JI/c heai,'tiCf CU4.-S"
V~'d- f...-i f'<"\lhcl, Wf WON'.,v "sn'l-ck"
Ot- CoIVl(Y1/ S<(;IO,y 1YI ee-T7N~ OIJ r
b-e.-I, ep s""'~(V\(}u' rJ CoNS/ST/tAl T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' sell Us ouT-
\N 15- ~-1-e. /1-1 c VOIGT'S _
Sincerely,
1fl1J'()N levt H'
'\ \'
"" ",t,:",
' ~)',
I,.
. ,,'
.
Mid j,/
,~/IvE l.J /u,1t:.-
1t1/~/;/71/tAiP ??/& c
I
VIj;,.-LlJ.,
,~AO(J
1
I
'"') ,
/1(/;,11 fA/J / j'~' '-:/ II I
L UIHlt I"' vJ tZll/;;0c ir-:-
Please conti~e to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
1
I
\
\
I
! ,
I '
,]
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
,
,
i
1
I
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
I
SAVE lOUR CITY
','
,
~ NemeE. OF C\.. PJ:JI/c hea"tiCf li54...s-
v~'d- f...-irr-/f-ed, Wf WON'tl "Srt'l-ck',
ex... CoIVl(V1/ S<(;IO,y 1YI (e-nl-l~ OIJ r
b-e.-I, ep s ''''''~(V\(}u' tV CoNS/S''itA./ T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' sell Us ouT-
\N 15- ~,r-e. 11-1 C VtYlGT' 5 _
Sincerely,
s:-~
~"rY\ C-OilD l?i!:eG-
C{).d';~r"
, ;!.o;q I Ivl[ :s J!./ IJ-Ve,
I!ftN'/7/9j P s ]/ff'tl
i
, !
",Il~
Do~A 17ft
u
~ I
1
I
CCMc\lt v,Ji! ,r-/e ~::rc(-- /
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
\
I
\
i
i
I
i
j
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
,
I ~
\
I
i
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
!
~ ...-Ji
i
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
,t'"
i
j,
{)
i:
\'
~ NoTteE OF C\.. ?J:JIIC hea"tiCf LU4.-S-
v~rd- f...-I f'<"\/he!, We WONlrJ "sn'l-ck"
Ot- CoIVl(Yl1 s<(;/o,y Tn ee-n'<i~ OIJ r
b-e.-/Jeps ''''''~('AoUrJ CoNs/sTitA.lT
'f;Gq5e. ::;::Lorvi' se./I Us ouT-
\N E ~.r -e.rt-l c v IYrG T' 5 _
Sincerely,
/-?
,(':
;~'-"-"j "..7-'
.~., , ,"'/', i~'
,'~' i/
i
~-
C
/l'ltilf 2~aCf'
5A.,l!:Kcr
'1.57.( 4'lri,:?i'l'''}/,?'J~ I
I1A/fV'r{)?.'~ ;::Y';:';18(:,
rr V I' I 1!7j'
i
; !
\ !
','.,.. "t"
' \',
l
fV'1H Ie ?CI ,<17
1
I
\
I
!
!
(}J1141, if/;t/,;t/ gEll))
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
1
I I
i
\
\
I
I
!
.~
i
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
--;
i
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVEiOUR CITY
I
II
~ NDTlec OF C\.. Ptkllc hea"tiCf ~s
ve,'[j_ "-I rnd-ed, Wf WON'rJ "5TIICk"
ex- CoIVl(Vl1 S<(;IO,y 1YI ee-Tll-l~ OIJ r
b,e,.I, ep S -""'e-rr.o.J rJ CoNS/STitA; T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' SUI Us ouT-
\N r; ~,r-e. IN E: VOIGT'S '
Sincerely,
~~
!
A. j-/ARK is
t,
t',
" .1:
f1, H'f'rrTI5
ZO;3:S,(;~i, (~J'./TtJ Clv,~ DR:
P(Vit/VjiJf/" Iv,J ~~jLi\
. U\.J
I
Cu;:' ()Ill//) 0" _
Ie} Vi/,C ~ J
1
I
{tl1:~1f. it/[/)/b-'Ei'!r.
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
\
I
I
i
,
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
I
I
emanating gas and on fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
,
enhances a city.
;...
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF C\.., PJ:JIIC hea"tiCf UJ4.-s-
v~'(j. f...-irnl'h:cl, Wf WON'rJ "SrfrCk"
0... CoIVl(Y1! S<(;/o,y 1YI ee:nl-i~ our
b'e.-/I ep s..-e,{<AoU rJ CoN'O/Slit"-l T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' se-ll Us ouT-
\i'-J 15- ~.r-e.n-l C Vo-TG7' 5 _
Sinc~J~__
,....-----..-.
S71t /f../
l
Ii
"
LClove~\
I, ,
I'
i.ilIU'/P,-
'., "''r.1'J . 'vV'? ,-,n
}-cr"?t.- ~,./ L-\.. _1>...1 J ft.- 1.1 I"''' k-IL-~
. >>J
""'1 ' '")"'0 j
(H.l'efJ TV t-A, ;'-, ,," Y (' "
/
(j O....O,vl"l ()D ~,w @ rS
\:
[,
V
1
1
I
1
\
1
1
I
j
i
1
I
i
,
i
\
-'
I
i I
;~.
I
\ I:
, V
,."" ' F,
\"
.~.
: '.
.,': r
C 0;11/11 tl/;fINL?t:XP;
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE. lOUR CITY
~ NOTleE OF CA Pd-:JI/c hea."tiCf ~S'
ve'd- f...-irn/'t'cd, Wf WONirJ I/STI'l-CIc"
Ot- Co/VlfY'lIS<(;roN rnee-nN~ OUI
b-e.-II ep s..-e-(V\(}u' tV CoNS/S,7A.I T
'f;t;q5e ::;::Lorvr seJl Us ouT-
\N E. ~-r-e. 111 C VcYrGT' 5 _
Sincerely,
~h~r
/-lei tC'/v Sc: /i<- i72.
'X ,""v/ it-
'1"", of, il t:. zr..' i'~1I0!.-
J-i....J-tf /"'(, I
~V'j<lriJl!l'-' {--( ?!,i ~ (l
If' "(
,
. \
VI II (\
r-:J)ot A 0 \;{
1
I
C{)!1p/ WEiMJE';?t>
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
!
1 I
I
\
\
I
1
i
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
I
j
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind o.f facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE ~F C\.. PJ:JI/c hea"tiCf W4.-S-
v~'d- A--t fnlf-ed, WfWON'rJ "STII-Ck"
Ot- CoIVl/Yl1 S<(;IO,y m fenN~ 0(; I
be-I'eFs '..-e"r-rYJJrJ CoNS/SlItAlT
11Gq~;e. ::;::Lorvi' SEll Us OUT-
\N 15- ~-r-e.rl-i c VcJTGT'S _
Sincerely,
!
-9rLi.! tJ1
J.5'7S !).~(!7c ,'pI Jllfl
ft-il'{;, .)7" _
.1 ViLd/ll/i1i', l'/s?!",
I ' .), (' c
i
i ~
1'1 A,:. (' liS
/::::t)/ /VT
/)1 y{, ri C
t:
" ~;,
. .i,
1
I
[bAlm 4J ElII73t7l
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
j ,
\ '
i
i
I
i ·
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
:
I
I
i
,
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
i \
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
I
"
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NDTlCE OF C\.. PJ:JfIC hea"tiCf CU4.-S"
v~''rJ- f...-irnlhd, Wf WONirJ {/STt'l-Ck',
0<-- CoIVl(Y11 S<(;/ON Tn ee-n/--l~ OUI
b'e../, ep s '..-~~ rJ CoNS/SFit/.f T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' sell Us ouT-
'v'-J t5 ~r-e. 11-1 E VrYlGT' 5 _
Sincerely,
/!tk;.6F~;;v '
.Lo~5 ,'.,; ,'~" rr-> 'A
~ . I ,'- .,v:;..--t, e,'u'r, "''''
/,'II. , I (1'(-..,. '-/t...,)
'1'/1' "-{N'f7M/!_ -t/ I .."" (",
,.VJ......,/l /~j .s.~/..)..'\
,
: i !
! t I
i i I
'I II
tOQ' .Q~ Ii II
Ii I i
,n ,..." _L !,I,,!)
'tA€N lEe /<...i...' tJ<',"-".::.t l; f'l'T :
, I!
! .
j;
t
.1
"j-'-',, t...~ ~s
CO~O;JA ()C, v~
1
I
1
I
,
l -';
!
\,
t,
t",
,.
, "
, ,', t'
. '1;'
CCi'1/'11 )lOI2ZSj='R.~ I
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF 0.. Ptkl/c heal; tiCf CU4.-S"
ve'd- ~I (nlhd, Wf WON'rJ "Srfrclc"
01.- Co(V)(Y11 S<(;IO,y rY\ ee-nN~ Ou r
b-e:11 ep S"-~,.r.oJ rJ CoNS/Sl7tLl T
'f;Gq5e ::;::LOrvi' sell Us ouT-
v'./ 15- ~.r-e. IN E. VOTFT'5 _
Sincerely,
k.[) ;~~7,'" , '
, .~ l> I, -e,
\, ,,\~~/ ..:..1:5' / "
i'\/),?;;"'r
L;><:fGf::/ vt
CLc),<./A
I-I Etw
;/eell-
'::<;75 fJ'iYS/7( pi, IJ/!.
I ,j .,., 7;-'/11
l(tNJ'ITlJj.~; /-.1 :""I"H
f i
()\ Y ~ 71i [-'Ci1'7
;
i
1
I
i
I
,I
,I
(l'/)1 n; 'Ii; '/ ';? --", .
L LJ' 1/11/ . Ii UJ-.<; b letttr/
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
l
1
I
1
\
I
I
!
i
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
\
i
I
I
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
\
i
\
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already bver-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. StriCt code enforcement
enhances a city.
i
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
~ NOTICE OF C\.. PJ:JI/c hea"tiCf CU4.-S"
V€J-d- f...-i""lf-r:.d, Wf WON'rJ f/srt'l-clc',
CA- Co(Y)/Yl1 S<(;IO,y rn ee-nN~ Ou I
b-e.-I, ep S'''-~(V\(}u'rJ CoNS/STit&/ T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' sell Us OUT-
\N E. ~,r-e. 'rt-t c Vm-ST' 5 _
Sincerely,
;
, ,
\l
fcrpt.1/;':t
lrd/ }./t(ll.;?.J!1~/ CI/.ilJ, ,Ji{,[ .
AJ <;17//,t l ,,",\ '"
Ir/l c///v>>I/ 1. f.j;i..-f
!i
!;
. ~~~ VyJvvrfr II
\1
/'1'\1) P-rtf /f ,1<:1<. If () ~11
Ii
\
I : [j
J
i I .
p lye 1:-/'111 001...
1'- {() {vi? {./
1
I
,
I
,
l
I
l
\'
I
1
\
I
I
I
i
,
1 j
I '
I
i
I
II
I
!
~;
L:
~!,
r
, J;"
C 0 v^'\ .'lf1 / /-J () [,2 13 i- 1'2-(;-
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
I
* NDTle[ ~F C\. PJ:Jllc hca II tiCf liXi.-s-
v~r(J 1---1 mlt-cd, Wf \/vON'rJ I'STt'l-Ck"
CA. CoIYJ/Yl1 S<(;IO,y rn fe-71N3 O{j I
be-II ep S"-~(V\(}u'rJ CoNS/Sl&1 T
'f;Eq5e ::;::Lorvi' sell Us ovT-
\N E. Olr-e. IN E. V()J~T'S ..
Sincerely,
,1"1>' /'
i
((~lfo-L). i
" "/"", ,..____7.,.-"":/ ~~~----;
t....-- ~;;".:;>",,,
JAt-i LET3cVJ
j." -e t:. l) L-{.
;,to,,-, .11if(T[( ,p"'i,vIIX:,
4-'f€,/>,fZ//Z-I? );,.. ;: Xiii (:
(V\ y ~11( P\:}II'-'~
1,
(, C'~
1
I
I
I
\
I
i
I
1 ·
i
,
i
1
I
\
\
j
i '
i~
iJ
\ ' ,'.
,"'." ,,'t~.
; ~';
, ,
, '0'
i),'i'At'/l fj', !)iCe> /1
(])m/'l!, Ila~t~ A(f-,~
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
~ NOTleE OF C\.. Pdo/IC hea"tiCf ~
VU''I "-i(\'II f-c.cl, Wf WONlrJ "ST(l-Ck"
OL CofY)(V1IS<(;IO,y mee-nH~ OUI
b-e.-II ep s"-e-~ rJ CoNS/S,'/tJ.t T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' SEll Us ouT-
\N 15- ~,r-e. 1/1 C V(j/bT'5 _
Sincerely,
. .
~~~tJ2..
~ -
D !3' ,5,?/ I':: -/\'1() It A-
f1v.)~ #
flu;t;q i dE ,N /!vv , ,
, ., I, _"I')
In/f, /7 '/It" ,((.., ,y ,'"Ie
',: It I if ,,' '/ I .,-. 1 I.;'
\I tllfi~ l\P\4
PCI'
1
I
CO}/}1/11. /!&i-28 ~ /2 {~
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
j
j
\
I
I
j
~l
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
. !
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
1 I
j
:(1
r
"
.~ NOTICE ~F C\.. PJ:J/ic hea"tiCf L.04.-S-
v~'';- f...-l mlf-t:d, Wf WONirJ "5r(}c/c"
01.. CoIVl/Y11 S<(;IO,y rn ee-nN~ Ou I
b-e.-/ltp s '''-e-~rJ CoNS/Si'ItA./T
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' se-ll Us ouT-
V'-i 15- ~-1-e. 11-1 c VcJlGT'5 _
Jt1kf?
, /vl/lfJ< (Ot/elf
Sincerely,
[',:1
;
('.
r
tJ1, {lJ~,uv
:; 'Ii1() tV E 1t?,L t;F
, kV'l'tV,rVl1t/ '/0/ ?,," f' ,\
, 1 ( .:>~/ tHo
t;
li,
I
~v.Jt...YlfW
1
I
[uj/)tl1;. l!O[tt3Et( l:-.
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
1
1
i
I
i ·
I
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
i
!
1
,
1
I
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
\
I
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
;
enhances a city.
...;
,
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
"l
~ NOTIce ~FC\.. Ptk/lc hea"tiCf (.,0G{.s
v~;l(l "'I mlhd, Wf WON,rJ "sn'l-ck"
Oc Co/V)(Yl1 S<(;IO,y tn ee-nN~ Ou I
b'e:I, ep s '''-e-~ rJ CoNS/STitA.! r
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' sell Us ouT-
\N ~ ~-r-e. Ii-Ic VffJGT'S _
Sincerely,
AL tlt11f}5TEfi(
r ,! 1._..
LI-{;.{t{ S;' t'i;/)
...~ ,"-., -. ,- ,-,: /" '. "
'1J)-'>,>J 'L./:" (COlJ'f./.'IA,[,/i)'f', "',?fZ.-i
ltIIOt,''-<:I7.1l J-
Ip '<IV/V"t., 1'_; ,:>,; 6 ('~
I ' ,<"~"'I (J .
. ,. -(6vl/ER. &
OD f.- (; ,,/ A (:;JO
t
li,
1
1
I
C0J11/Ulfoaf? t1C 6~!
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
I
I
\
\
I
I
I
j
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
I
I
i
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
I
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE lOUR CITY
! ,\
-1 NDTlCE OF C\.. PJoI'c hea"tiCf CU4.-S
v~'d-- Ivimlhd Wf WON,rJ "STfrC/c"
OC CoIVl(Y1/ S<(;IO,y rn een;LI~ Ou I
b~// ep s"-e-~ rJ CoNS/SliCN T
'f;Eq5e ::;::Lorvi' sell Us OUT-
",-/15- ~-r-e. (HE: VOIGT'S _
Sincerely,
,~'A~
<;;:'/'1 ^^ P--IC'I'<: r-I'<;
I:.
jZ/ei/t"rlJ ,
,20 .. s.5' vIi t r.-;..i"./(/:.1 C{ V3 v ,.~~ i
fM;UITliiL~) F:.I ,?]/b',:1 '
CCrC)I-II'1(JC
T Ot-l.l'< ~ .J
r;,
[,r
~..
t
1
I
{}Vifl~ I/{)~/ft;
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
I
I
\
\
i
I ,
!
J
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and on fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities sUPh as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-'
i
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
II
SAVE lOUR CITY
','
,
~ NDTleE OF c\.., Pi.klic hea,,/'lCf CU4.s
ver',;- f...-if't"llhcl, WewoN,rJ I'srfrclc\1
Ot- Co/Vl(Y1JS<(;/O,y 1YIee-nN~ our
b-e.-I, ep s '''-~rACJ...i rJ CoNS/STltNT
'f;Eq5e ::;::Lorvi' se./I Us ouT-
\N 15- ~,r-e. 11-1 E: V()TGT'5 _
Sincerely,
"
c
L
(}
i.
r".
V
:1 it:
I,
J
SE'c;,m-f'S
:Z-bJ-i{ / A/l, 10 ff?'t'
frl; of/v ,'(; /!/"/ f? ? J/ ~ ,1
, \
VII/It
~j<A py>, ,
lftKCV
Set/A/-? b
~ 1
1
I
Coj~!I:;. l-!a:.-:?j;?.j;;;i2 r)
Please continue to vote against any variance allowing Hi-Lift
Marina a height increase. Our building and zoning laws are in place
\
\
\
i
I
i .'
I
to be followed, not dismissed for financial gain or for the benefit
of a few. The land use area is not meant for such a large scale
storage facility. This is a residential/town center with a school for our
,
i
I
i
children down the street. Not a place for over-sized yachts
emanating gas and oil fumes, repair and painting services and
the loading and off-loading of boats on trailers contributing to an
already over-burdened traffic situation. This kind of facility in the
center of town would not even be considered in other upscale
cities suph as Coral Gables or Boca Raton. Strict code enforcement
enhances a city.
-i
i
i
ENFORCE OUR BUILDING AND ZONING CODES
SAVE iOUR CITY
I
",
~ NOTICE, OF C\.. PJ:Jlic hear/tiCf l.u~s
ve,,'I "-I ""I-/-ed, Wf WONlrJ "srt'l-cf.c"
Ot- Co/V)(Y11 S<(;IO,y rn ee-nN~ Ou I
b'eJI ep s '..-e,.(V\(}u'tV CoNS/S,'ItA! r:
'f;Eq5e. ::;::Lorvi' se./ I Us OUT-
\N 15- ~-r-e. IN E: VcYlGT' 5 _
Sincerely,
'i
! I
ii I
~'l
'"Baa (~, . III
III
!, I
Ii' '1
fY3A ~OSP,^, 9M'
ti
\'.
i l
(-'"I ,'JI,'.. d
t,,---b.'>p "fe, /
:",,-:;;5' ....; <..J::'O...iVft"Z Cr(,,/~ Pf?,
f:-V<N'TI/f( f) F-{ ,-" ;;,' g (l
CO{(}:.l-Itjj)O "TO\.I'ifK,C
CITY OF AVENTURA
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
BY: Joanne Carr, AICP
Planning Director
FROM: Eric M. Soroka, I
City Manager
DATE: August 17, 2006
SUBJECT: Small scale amendment to the City's Comprehensive Plan to change the
land use designation of land on NE 207 Street at the corner of NE 30 Avenue
totaling 3.359 acres from Business and Office to Medium High Density
Residential (01-CPA-06 - Small Scale Amendment)
September 12, 2006 Local Planning Agency Agenda ItemiA
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item-1tl
October 3, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission:
1. Approve the small scale Comprehensive Plan amendment to change the land use
designation of land on NE 207 Street at the corner of NE 30 Avenue totaling 3.359 acres
from Business and Office to Medium High Density Residential; and
2. Approve the transmittal of the amendment to the Florida Department of Community
Affairs and other state agencies pursuant to Chapter 163, Florida Statutes.
THE REQUEST
The applicant is requesting a small scale Comprehensive Plan amendment to change the
land use designation of a parcel of land on NE 207 Street at the corner of NE 30 Avenue
totaling 3,359 acres from Business and Office to Medium High Density Residential to
facilitate a rezoning of the parcel from B2 (Community Business District) to RMF3A
(Multifamily Medium Density Residential District) with density limited to 31 dwelling units
per acre, (See Exhibit #1 for Letter of Intent)
The current landholding of the applicant is 5,932 acres, The total development site area
will be 7.391 acres if the City Commission approves the applicant's request for
abandonment of 1.459 acres of unopened right of way of NE 206 Street, part of the
unopened right of way of NE 207 Street and two 10 foot unopened alleyways reserved on
the plats. This abandonment request will be presented to City Commission concurrent
with second reading of the comprehensive plan amendment. The 3.359 acres subject of
the land use amendment request includes part of the unopened road reservations. The
remaining 4.032 acres will remain in the Business and Office land use designation.
BACKGROUND
OWNER OF PROPERTY
Aventura Land Trust, LLC
Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
NAME OF APPLICANT
Aventura Land Trust, LLC
Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
LOCATION OF PROPERTY
NE 207 Street at NE 30 Avenue
See Exhibit #2 for Location Map
SIZE OF PROPERTY
Approximately 3,359 acres subject of land use
amendment request (total landholding is 7,391
acres including 1.459 acres of unopened rights of
way requested to be abandoned)
DESCRIPTION IBACKGROUND
The site owned by the applicant is comprised of seventy-seven platted lots in Blocks 17
and 18 of the Hallandale Park No.8 plat, Tract 1 on the plat of Lauranna and Tract 1 on a
replat of Hallandale Park NO.8, The landholding referred to in this report also includes the
unopened platted right of way of NE 206 Street, part of the unopened platted right of way
of NE 207 Street and two 10 foot unopened platted alleyways which are subject of an
abandonment request.
The site is currently designated Business and Office on the City's Future Land Use Map,
The northerly half of the land is vacant and is currently being cleared and filled under a
DERM wetlands permit. The southerly half of the site is the former playground area for the
Aventura Turnberry Jewish Center.
The applicant wishes to change the land use designation on the easterly portion of the site
comprising 3.359 acres from Business and Office to Medium High Density Residential. The
area to be redesignated is shown on Exhibit #3. The proposed development includes 36
town homes and 68 loft style condominium units on this easterly portion. A hotel, office
2
building and parking structure are proposed on the westerly portion of the site which will
retain its Business and Office designation,
ANALYSIS
Future land Use Designation
Subject Property:
Properties to the North:
Properties to the South:
Properties to the East:
Properties to the West:
Zoning
Subject Property:
Properties to the North:
Properties to the South:
Properties to the East:
Properties to the West:
Existing land Use
Subject property:
Properties to the North:
Properties to the South:
Properties to the East:
Properties to the West:
Business and Office
Business and Office
Business and Office
Medium High Density Residential
Business and Office
B2, Community Business District
OP, Office Park District
CF, Community Facilities District
RMF3, Multi-Family Medium Density Residential District
B2, Community Business District
vacant, under DERM fill and clear permit
and playgroundlball field
office
religious facility and school
residential
retail plaza
Access - The parcel is bounded by NE 207 Street to the north, NE 30 Avenue to the east
and NE 29 Avenue to the west. Access is proposed from both NE 29 and NE 30 Avenues,
Conformity to City Comprehensive Plan - The amendment is consistent with the goals,
objectives and policies of the City's Comprehensive Plan, More specifically, the proposal
is consistent with the following policies in the Future Land Use, Transportation, Parks and
Recreation and Coastal and Conservation elements of the Plan:
Future Land Use Element
Policv 8.2 Applications to amend the City's Future Land Use Plan map shall be
evaluated to consider consistency with the Goals, Objectives and Policies of all
Elements, other timely issues, and in particular the extent to which the proposal, if
approved, would:
1, Satisfy a deficiency in the Plan map to accommodate projected
population or economic growth of the City;
3
Recent population figures provide information that the City is continuing to
grow and the median age is growing younger. Demand for housing is
therefore increasing. The residential use and mix of different housing types
in this development will accommodate projected population growth.
2. Enhance or impede provision of services at adopted LOS Standards;
Traffic - The traffic generation table provided later in this report supports the
proposed amendment in that a decreased projected vehicle trips per day
enhances the provision of traffic services,
Water - The intensity of maximum FAR of commercial uses as currently
permitted is decreased with the proposed amendment. Therefore, provision
of services will be enhanced.
Sewer - The intensity of maximum FAR of commercial uses as currently
permitted is decreased with the proposed amendment. Therefore, provision
of services will be enhanced.
Mass Transit - A bus transit facility is located at Aventura Mall,
approximately 1.5 miles from the subject properties. The proposed
residential development will be required to provide pedestrian linkage to
County and City transit services that are safe and convenient to transit
users,
Parks and Recreation - The City presently exceeds LOS standards for park
space, therefore, provision of service at adopted level of service standard will
not be impeded by this development.
Stormwater Drainage - The intensity of maximum FAR of commercial uses
as currently permitted is decreased with the proposed amendment.
Therefore, provision of services will be enhanced,
Solid Waste - The intensity of maximum FAR of commercial uses as
currently permitted is decreased with the proposed amendment. Therefore,
provision of services will be enhanced,
3, Be compatible with abutting and nearby land uses and protect the
character of established neighborhoods; and
The proposed amendment is compatible with abutting and nearby land uses
and not only protects but is anticipated to enhance the character of the
neighborhood. Properties to the east and northeast are existing residential
developments and this amendment will form a natural transition from
business uses to the west and north to those existing residential uses.
4
4. Enhance or degrade environmental or historical resources, features or
systems of significance.
The proposed amendment will not degrade the environmental or historical
resources, features or systems of significance. The applicant is currently
filling the site under a DERM wetlands fill permit.
Policv 8,3 The City shall strive to accommodate residential development in suitable
locations and densities which reflect such factors as recent trends in location and
design of residential units; projected availability of service and infrastructure
capacity; proximity and accessibility to employment, commercial and cultural
centers; character of existing adjacent or surrounding neighborhoods; avoidance of
natural resource degradation; maintenance of quality of life and creation of
amenities,
The proposed amendment will accommodate residential development in suitable
locations and densities; accommodate projected availability of service and
infrastructure capacity; accommodate proximity and accessibility to employment,
commercial and cultural centers; accommodate character of existing adjacent or
surrounding neighborhoods; accommodate avoidance of natural resource
degradation; accommodate maintenance of quality of life and creation of amenities,
Policv 10. 1 A ventura shall facilitate redevelopment of substandard or
underdeveloped areas, high intensity activity centers, mass transit supportive
development and mixed use projects to promote energy conservation.
The proposed amendment will facilitate redevelopment of an underdeveloped area
with a mixed use project.
Policv 12.1 All proposed Comprehensive Plan amendments that increase density
(population) shall be required to submit, at the time of application, an analysis of
the impacts of the proposed amendment upon the evacuation routes and
evacuation times as included within the South Florida Regional Hurricane
Evacuation Study, April, 1996, or as may be amended from time to time.
Policv 12,2 The City shall not approve any Comprehensive Plan amendment that
increases density (population) and results in evacuation times exceeding 12 hours,
Property Lot Size Increase in Population Overall Increase
Location Density Factor in Population
NE 207 Street at 3.359 ac 31 dulac 1.79 187 persons
NE 30 Avenue (density
limited by
covenant)
5
Based on the 1996 South Florida Regional Planning Council evacuation model, it is
determined that the increase of 104 dwelling units resulting from the proposed
amendment will increase the clearance time by 2.4 minutes. That additional time
increases the present evacuation time of 11.54 hours (11 hours and 32 minutes) to
11,57 hours (11 hours and 34.4 minutes).
Transportation Element
Policv 1,5 The City will develop transportation management strategies, such as
(but not limited to) traffic calming techniques and neighborhood design concepts to
improve efficiency and enhance the safety of the pedestrian, bicycles and transit
riders within the context of an integrated multi-modal transportation system.
The proposed amendment and associated subsequent site development will
provide a transportation link with provision of sidewalks on all sides of the parcel
for pedestrian safety. The proposed development will be required to provide
pedestrian linkage to transit service facilities that are safe and convenient to transit
users.
Policv 4.3 Transit service shall be linked to major trip attractors and generators and
the transportation disadvantaged. Transit service shall be located such that they
are safe and convenient to transit users,
This new residential development will be required to provide pedestrian linkage to
transit service facilities that are safe and convenient to transit users.
Policv 4.7 Transit shelters, according to the City's approved design, shall be
provided at the time of development by the property owner.
Transit shelters, according to the City's approved design, will be provided by the
owner at the time of development.
Parks and Recreation Element
Policv 4.1 The City adopts a level of service requiring 2.75 acres of net useable
park land per 1,000 residents, implemented by the concurrency management
system,
The estimated current population for the City of Aventura is 29,451. 104 additional
dwelling units results in a population increase of 187 people as shown in the table
above. The amount of park and recreation land required by this park standard is
81,5 acres. The existing available park and recreation land, using the calculations
provided in the Level of Service Standards, is 107.95 acres. Therefore, no
deficiency exists and the proposed amendment will not create a deficiency in this
standard,
6
Conservation and Coastal Management Element
Policv 9.2 The City shall maintain the adopted levels of service on the local
roadways based on the future land use plan to achieve a reasonable evacuation
time.
The traffic generation table provided later in this report supports the proposed
amendment in that a decreased projected vehicle trips per day enhances the
provision of transportation (traffic) services, thereby maintaining the adopted levels
of service on local roadways to achieve a reasonable evacuation time,
Urban Design Element
Policv 1,7 The location of parking, curb cuts, walkways, bike lanes, signage,
lighting and landscape treatments shall be co-ordinated to provide maximum user
safety, while improving the comprehensive aesthetic appearance of Aventura,
The applicant will be required, through the site plan review process, to locate
parking, curb cuts, walkways, bike lanes, signage, lighting and landscape
treatments to maximize user safety and improve the aesthetics of the City.
Traffic Generation - The applicant's traffic engineer has prepared traffic generation
information relative to existing permitted land uses and the proposed amendment. The
letter dated August 8, 2006 prepared by David Plummer & Associates is attached as
Exhibit #4,
Applications land Use Daily Trips AM Peak PM Peak
Area Category HourTrips Hour Trips
13.359 acres)
Existing land Use Business & Office 2,594 365 351
Desianation (all office use)
Proposed Land Medium High 664 53 62
Use Designation Density
Residential
As can be seen from the table above, the proposed residential land use designation
generates approximately 75% less daily vehicular trips and when compared to the am
peak and pm peak hours, generates approximately 82% to 85% less trips, thereby
resulting in significantly less impact on the City's road network as compared to the existing
business and office land use designation.
Consistency with Proposed EAR based amendments to Comprehensive Plan
Although the proposed 2005 EAR based amendments to the Comprehensive Plan have
not received final approval by the State, the following discussion is provided for City
Commission's information and not as part of the analysis of compliance above.
7
The intensity of development and redevelopment and its impacts on traffic were major
issues addressed by the Evaluation and Appraisal Report, along with compatibility of new
development with existing neighborhoods. The proposed change of land use from
Business and Office on the easterly portion of this site to Medium High Density Residential
reduces the intensity of development as seen by the approximate 75% reduction in the
number of daily trips to the site. The residential development on the easterly portion is
compatible with the existing residential development to the east, Villa Dorada and to the
northeast, Aventura Lakes. It provides a transition from those existing developments as
the proposed uses progress from residential on the east abutting residential and
office/hotellretail on the west abutting retail on Biscayne Boulevard,
School Impacts - The application has been provided for comment to the Miami Dade
County School Board in accordance with the Interlocal Agreement entered into between
the City and the Board in February of 2003. Also in accordance with the Interlocal
Agreement, the School Board has been invited as a non-voting member of the Local
Planning Agency for this application.
The Interlocal Agreement provides that the School Board must first advise what options it
has identified to meet the anticipated demand and, then, if the affected schools are at
more than 115% capacity, the School Board will ask the applicant and the City to meet
with it in a collaboration meeting to discuss additional options to relieve overcrowding,
The School Board's letter of August 17, 2006 is attached as Exhibit #5. It notes that the
public elementary, middle and high schools affected by this development are currently
operating at 117%, 191 % and 152% respectively of FISH capacity and that the proposed
development will increase the capacity in the elementary and high school to 119% and
153% respectively. The analysis depicts the relief schools planned in the area pursuant to
the approved 5 year work plan and includes a list of approved Charter Schools which may
also provide capacity relief. The analysis also estimates impact fees payable if the new
Educational Facilities Impact Fee Ordinance is approved. The Board's recommendation is
that the applicant, the City and the School Board meet to discuss options and alternatives,
This meeting will be scheduled and results will be reported at the first reading hearing.
The proposed residential uses on this site will more compatibly support the Aventura City
of Excellence School versus the commercial uses presently allowed.
Conformity to City Land Development Regulations - The proposed amendment will
facilitate a proposed rezoning from B2, Community Business District to RMF3A, Multi-
Family Medium Density Residential District.
Coastal High Hazard Location - The location of this site is not in a designated coastal
high hazard area.
8
~ Bilzin Sumberg
i\,TTORNEYS AT LAW
RECEiVEIl
JUL 11 2006
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
.,0
r \ ,{Jl \) 'L'
"
Brian S, Adler, Esquire
Direct Dial: (305) 350-2351
Direct Fax: (305) 351-2206
Email: badler@bilzin.com
July 10, 2006
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Joanne Carr
City of Aventura
Government Center
19200 W, Country Club Drive, 4th Floor
Aventura, Florida 33180
Exhibit 1
01-CPA-06
Re: Aventura Grand
Application for Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Property located at SW Corner of NE 30th Avenue and Waterways Boulevard
("Property")
Dear Ms, Carr:
lETTER OF INTENT
Please consider this our formal letter of intent in connection with an application to amend
the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan, This firm represents Aventura land Trust, llC as the
owner of a portion of the property and Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC as contract purchaser of a
portion of the property (collectively "Aventura Land Trust"),
The Property is located at the southwest corner of NE 30lh Avenue and Waterways
Boulevard, Our client has acquired a portion of the subject property and is under contract, under a
related entity, to purchase the remaining portion of the site that is bounded between NE 291h
Avenue and NE 30lh Avenue, lying north of the Aventura Jewish Center and south of Waterways
Boulevard,
Aventura Land Trust proposes to develop the Property with an overall mixed use
development consisting of residential, retail, office and a hotel. In that regard, the current City of
Aventura Comprehensive Plan designation does accommodate the development as proposed
without the redesignation of a portion of the property to residential. In that regard, please consider
this our formal request to redesignate the Property from Business and Office to Medium High
Density Residential.
Aventura Land Trust is applying to redesignate the eastern portion of the proposed
development to residential. This proposed development has been designed such that the area to
be designated residential is located across NE 30lh Avenue from an existing residential
community, and diagonal to Aventura Lakes, which also is a residential development
BILZIN S_BJ<1084\JllJ1iIl6!11llt!:\t6:iJl AXELROD LLP
200 S. Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 2500, Miami, FL 33131.5340 TeI305.374.7580 Fax 305.374.7593
Joanne Carr
July 10, 2006
Page 2
Development of the proposed residential and commercial areas will require Administrative
Site Plan Review and Approval, which the applicant anticipates filing within the upcoming weeks,
The proposed development represents several months of planning with Arquitectonica, to
design a development that is not only well designed within the project, but integrates with the
neighboring residential, commercial and office developments,
Our client is excited to bring this project to the City of Aventura and respectfully requests
the City's recommendation of approval in connection with the above application,
Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at 305-350-2351,
Very truly yours,
~ {;>(/ ~/
Brian~ler
BSA/ka
Attachment
~
MIAMI!! 03404.1 7692825653
BILZIN SUMBERG BAENA PRICE & AXELROD LLP
BROWARD COUNTY
..-.-.-.-. ,"
'.
:.
:.
;.
'.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
;'
..
;'
'.
IVES DAIRY RD, :.
'.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
;,
'.
;.
'.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
;,
:'
:'
'.
:'
..
:.
;.
..
:.
;.
:.
..
:.
:.
:.
:'-
DADE COUNTY
MIAMI
GARDENS DR.
>'
;::
I
W
X
o
3i
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
"- .
ff :
"- .
Ci: .
It ·
Ci) .
<: .
g .
I-C .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
33180 :
.
-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-......
' 185ST 33 60:
201 TER.
AVENTURA e\-'>JD,
Fire a D
Rescue Aventura
Station Library
Aventura Mall
, , / ~ ~
. -.-.-.-
..... "\rI"1. .. . . . . ..oo ~ ._._
.ft '1"\'" 1I"'I"'......".1"'l! 11"'I'"
GulfHream YACHT CLUB OR .
Park .
MARINA .
COVE .
CIRCLE .
.
'i'ip.'i .
\""J! .
.
.
/
/")
I
SlTE1_":
WATERWAYS rlLVD~
i/"W
;', ~
..
1,{atcrways
Shoppes
207 5T
COUNTRY CLUB DR
-'
(L
m
N
([
o
OJ
::J
-'
o
>-
([
f-
Z
::J
o
o
Turnberry Isle
Resort & Club
192 ST
City of Aventura_:"_,,,;_,~,::,_,:,,,
Government Center ";:;'-"'.\.:EHM/\
\NILLlM~
~
9:-
Q
<<"
MYSTIC
192 ST
1915T
Loehmann's
Fashion w
Island ~
m
N
T
183 ST,
Little
Maule
Lake
'C::>
190 ST
188 ST,
Dumfoundling
Bay
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Williams
.~~.JI!.,,~... 1:, .. . 111,_ II II "
.t:t,,':':
.(r:':h'. ..
.~:W:'.~i" -~
.t~,~~~.;l,c~t;;.
.
'+' .+
;- .!'.:
" .
MallIe
Lake
LEGEND
--
i~
.
ci
>
--'
ro
Z
<<
w
o
o
ci
>
--'
ro
Z
lfj
o
o
Atlantic
Ocean
e
Roadways
City Boundary
ZIP Code Boundary
Railroad
Exhibit 2
01-CPA-06
EXHIBIT "A"
Exhibit 3
Ol-CPA-06
"
r:;,'
~
.>..
$
~
~
"".
~'
"-
~
~
IJJ
~
~
!#
~
J
~
Qj
WAIE:RW
AyS
CENTER OF
SECTION
130Ul.E:\/ ARD
NE 207th STREE
UJ UJ
::J ::J
Z Z
UJ UJ
> >
<( NE <(
.!: .!:
.... ....
O'l 0
C\J C')
9 UJ UJ
Z Z
NE 205th STREET
SITE
LOCATION SKETCH
SCALE: 1" = 200'
~
Drawn By
Cad. No.
GEM
061310
( SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION I
FORTIN, LEAVY, SKILES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS & MAPPERS
FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTI:lORlZATION NUMBER: ??oo3653
180 Northeast 168tb Street / North Miami Beach, Florida 33162
Phone 305-653-4493 I Fax 305-651-7152 / Email fls@flssurvcy.com
Date 7/7/06
Scale 1" = 200'
Job No. 061310
Dwg. No_ 1006-' 43-1
Sheet 2 of 3
e
wg. 2006-082-1
Plotted
7/7/06 4;09p
-
I , ~=~-~~{;~== = - -:,
"'-"'- '! - - .J ~"'~ys '
I~~n --- __ eOtJL.~'
/ -"'I ___ v~FiO
L_ _________- SJ6'OO' '
$, I ~I 0""'"""'0' ,""'I; - _ ,
1I 1I -----It r.E""'~""E'"
;~ W_ I ;~ ~~SE2~~~h..~J~,,~~J; _ ~~":;~~,:.,.~ di; t'"" I
"~l I, I-I-l'-f;.~-;";r.-I- fl.:r. ;::r, l;oo'~'::::'~"'
~,I<~~ll ,""''''1"''.''''' - HA~~a<?~~~ch ~" I ...~r r
- PLAT BOOK 20. PAGe 49. I f
!i,l : ~! :" I "I " 1 " I " I " i " I ~ I '" i '" I " I '" 1 " I ~ I .. I ~ : I ~ ! .." .",_
'j Iwll I 'Ii:; I I . 1 : 1 I, 'lj:,i,i l'l iE:"'i!b<i; ! l,l I ,
~~;f:--:==Il=~~=~=-l=~=}----I-l rl=~T. =!=~; I ~!! iI i!; :i: i.
I I I I, HA~"~.2nR~ ~. I I " I I I '".""<~... Hi II I inli
I I PLAT BOOK:20, PAOE 49 'I LO""'C",""""""' I ~~~.
" I ,. I " 1 " I' " 1 ro 1 " I " 'I' " 1 " I " I" I " I " I " 1 "II' - - - - ,".." 0"
I I i I I ii, " I I 7 ~5~fr ~.. "';.r..... ~i~
: j ",1_ ilL ~,~'" LL Ll Ll L L ~=f'J :::' ~"': li:I!:'I'
I si- NE 2061h STREET -.Ii: -;= ~:::~~ I
~!il , '--'-I"l-r-rT~~~'l-=~~F"lO' -T '-l-'i-Cl r,-;-~!:,;::.::c",1 ;;;;1
ti<I':~"_"I_._,".1 I I I \ I I ,I SLbck17 U '~C:~~:..,..,,\:,":_,"I
'I - :: H~l..JO,N~LEPAFlKNO r- N8~S22rw .-"- ...'-"-
at I I I 26 I 271 "I :zg I 30 I 31 II "'I 33 I 300 I 3~ I 36137:1 PI.j.ATB I K21 "AjE49 .2 100 -- I --
I-li ~w' I I I I I I 81 38 I 39 40 ", 42 I I- ~Tl;~;:;'c=,"- I
:~! LJ~tj_1J;~:dF~'E::f~;iJ_1IL I 1 i ~J: :~~::'~;i: ;;.:' ll:
I &! '-1'- rl-sT oJ:"KI,-;[l-T -I-I r -]= -I =1=rTI)::~::'"'' H, :~;;., ill
II :zll II ~~:.~~:r~,A~:aNEo..6 I '^C 'O".f"-U''''''.O"",~",-A''~'~'6 -:-- '!;~_ E~ I
~ . .,0000fO'"0."" ,"" "0'"'' I L S69 n:"E ~:.~ :, I
IE"'/W2I'/W1 25124! 231 221 21 1201191'6 i 17 i 161 ,~ 114 i 131 '2111 I ,01 9l r=.~;soo~5~~.E ~~:I Z!I
:"'---\,J LJ 111 L' 1 I f I I L.' LII",~~,::::
- 1~-- - J_L_[ L~_ ~- ~L__
It. t. soo"\,nO"E
" ("'"""""'0' .w G,NTf""_'O' ~SlS
Il<< N''''~'''"'.-r ~. I N<""""'lR'fi N8. '41-w' I 7"
I - ~ I, NE 205th STREET r'<>JS.,~,-'O:-,..YL~'O' ~ "'GH1_0'."'" "'C"'DO' A"",u'<>N.., "",..,,,
" -- ..1::;:~~.:"':"~' ,- r ~ """0'''''''00'''''',."
~-:;'T::.::"",,-;:-;;;;-I- Z~~..--- 'C"~"::;<>r-:;:c;::-.." -- ----------
"'-"0001('''.'''''' I <II,tll .-.. d::'':::~.. ',""',oc-.",,,'G''''' I
T~~ mp!' 'T~'~
",,=,,",= I~':II II ...",=,==-'
1 08!111 It---o--'~=-, ""'"00-''''"'''
....I"". ~.=~.._. "'''''O''''''O'I"'O'"''.uo<,o'
~.J g :1 GRAPHIC":"~:'~~"-"'M
f~ 50 100 2DO
li~ N ' I
,.r [
( IN FEET )
1 inch'" 100 ft
Date 7/7/06
Scale ~ 100'
Job No 06'310
Dwg No 1006-143-1
EXHIBIT "A"
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
7---- /
'~"'""'",,!-Q'W,"~-
I ~l~:;'~T''''''.Y<
AVEr-<TURA::;OFiPORATECENTEP
~EFi FcATBOOK 158,PAGE4?
--
44-
Drawn By
( SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION I
FORTIN, LEAVY, SKILES, INC,
CONSULTING ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS & MAPPERS
FLORIDA CERTlFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER; ??oo3653
180 Northeast 168th Street I North Miami Beach, Florida 33162
Phone 305-653-4493 / Fax 305-651.7152/ Email fls@flssurvey.com
3
Cad No
GEM
061310
Ref Dwg
2006-082-1
Plotted
7/7/06 4:09p
Sheet
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
L-'
:~:'::':GI
I
I , :
I~
1"..1" ,"'.,..
....'-"". ...'-..
-" -.
I i I
of
3
RECEIVED
JUL 11 2006
co
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
All of Lots 7 through 13, 38 through 42 and a portion of Lots 14, 33 through 37, all of Biock 18,
HALLANOALE PARK No.8, including the ten (10) foot alleys adjocent to said lots, Iy,ng within said Block 18,
as recorded in Plot Book 20 at Page 49 All of Troct 1, LAURANNA, os recorded in Plot Book 76 at Page
31 All of Lots 1, 2, 6 through 13, 38 through 42 and a portion of Lots 14 end 37, 011 of Block 17,
HALLANDAlE PARK No 8, including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots in Block 17, os recorded
in Plat Book 20 at Page 49. Tract 1, Block 17, REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANOALE PARK No.8, os
recorded in Plot Book 40 at Page 97 Thot portion of the North One-half of N.E. 205th street abandoned
by Resolution No 2000~11 recorded in a.R.B 19247 at Page 4677. That portion of N.E 206th Street
bounded on the North by Block 18 ond bounded on the South by Block 17 and bounded on the East by
the West right-of-way line of N.E. 30th Avenue (East Dixie Highway) 011 being as shown on HALi....ANDALE
PARK No.8, os recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49. A portion of land bounded by on the North by 0
line 8100 feet South of and parallel or concentric with the North line of Waterways Boulevard os shown on
AVENTURA CORPORATE CENTER, os recorded in Plot Book 158, Page 47, and bounded on the South by the
North line of Block 18, HALLANDALE PARK NO.8, os recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, 011 the above
plats being of the Public Records of Miami~Oade County. Florida, lying and being in the City of Avenlura
and being more particularly described as follows'
Commence at the intersection of the centerline of N.E. 20Sth Street and the centerline of NE. 30th Avenue.
both os shown on said PLAT OF HAlLANDALE PARK NO 8; thence North 89"53'41" West along said centerline
of N.E. 205 Street for 35.01 feet to the Point of Beg:nning of the hereinafter described parcel of land;
thence continue North 89.53'41" West along said centerline for 261.97 feet; thence North 00'00'00" East for
422.33 feet; thence North 90'00'00" West for 119.97 feet; thence North 00'00'00" East for 135.92 feet;
thence South 76"00'36" Eost along a line 8100 feet South of and parallel with North right-of-way line of
Waterways Boulevard for 86.13 feet to a point of curvature; thence Southeasterly along 0 1519.00 foot
radius curve leading to the left through a central angle of 7"37'02" for an arc distance of 201.94 feet;
thence South 00"52'30" East along a line 10.00 feet East of 0 10.00 foot alley adjacent to said Lot 42,
Block 18 of HALLANDALE PARK NO.8 for 8.92 feet to the Northwest corner of said Tract 1 of LAURANNA;
thence South 89'50'24" East along the North line of said Tract 1 for 70.42 feet to a point of curvature;
thence Southeasterly along a 25.00 foot radius curve leading to the right through 0 central angle of
88"57'54" for an arc of 38.82 feet to a point of tangency: thence South 00.52'30" East along the East line
of said Tract 1 for 122.65 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; thence South 89"51'49"' East along the
North line of said lot 7, Block 18 HAlLANDAlE PARK NO 8 for 5.00 feet to the Northeast corner thereof;
thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line of said lots 7 and 8, Block 18 and the Southerly
el<tension thereof for 16442 feet to the Southeast corner of said Lot 2, Block 17 of HALLANOALE PARK NO
8; thence North 89'52'27" West along the South line of said Lot 2, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the Northeast
corner of said Tract 1 of REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK NO.8: thence South 00"S2'30 East
along the East line of said Tract 1 for 75.01 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; Thence South 89.53'04"
East along the North line of said Lot 6, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the northeast corner of said Lot 6;
thence South 00"52'30" East along the East line of said Lots 6, 7 & 8, Block 17 for 5677 feet to a point
of curvature; thence Southwesterly along a 2500 foot radius curve leading to the right through 0 central
angle of 36"52'05" for on arc of 16.09 feet; thence South 00.52'30" East along a line 35.00 feet West of
and parallel to the center line of said NE 30th Avenue for 35.35 feet to the Point of Beginning.
SURVEYOR'S NOTES:
This site lies in Section 34, Township 51 South, Range 42 East, City of Aventura, M;ami~Dade County,
Florida.
Bearings hereon ore referred to on assumed value of 589"53'41"E for the center line of NE 205th Street
Lands shown hereon were not abstracted for easements and/or rights-of-way of records
This is not a "Boundary Survey" but only a graphic depiction of the description shown hereon
- lands shown hereon containing 146,330 square feet, or 3.359 acres, more or less.
Dimensions shown hereon ore based on Fortin, Leavy, Skiles, sketch #2006-099
SURVEYOR'S CERTIFICATION:
I hereby certify that this "Sketch of Description" was mode under my responsible charge an Ju:y 7, 2006,
and meets the Minimum Technical Standards as set forth by the Florida Board of Professional SGrveyors ond
Mappers in Chapter 6tG17-5, Florida Administrative Code, pursuant to Section 472.027, F:orida StC"J:utrs
'"Not valid without t
nature nd the original raised seal of a Florida licensed Surveyor and Mapper'"
,L~~~~
Daniel C. Fortin, For The ~---
Surveyor and Mapper, LS2853
State of Florida
Drawn By GEM ( SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION I Date 7/7/06
Cad. No 061310 FORTIN, LEAVY, SKILES, Scale NONE
INC.
Ref Dwg Job No 061310
2006-082-1 CONSULTING ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS & MAPPERS
FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORJZATION NUMBER: 00003653 Dwg No 1006-143-1
180 Northeast 168th Street I North Miami Beach, Florida 33162
Plotted 7/7/06 4:09p Phone 305.653-4493 I Fax 305-651-7152 / Email fls flssurvey.com Sheet of 3
DAVID PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES
August8,2006
~1s. Joanne Carr
Planning Director
City of l\ventura
19200 West Coumr) Club Drive
Aventura, FL 33180
(30S) 466-8940
Exhibit 4
01-CPA-06
RE: AVlfljfura Grand Trill Generation Com '''''';SOll - #06166
Dear IIh Can:
The AventuraGtand project is a mixed.use development located at Ihe :;uulheast corner ofNE 207
Street (Wattw\va)'s Boulevard) and NE 3D AVenUe in A ventura, Florida, Although the proposedpn~jcct
includes l.37,500 SF of offke. 59,000 SF of retail. 198 hotel rooms. and 104 dwelling units of
townhouses/lofh, this ktter solely addresses the portion heing remncd 10 residential. The purpose of
this kiter ittosUh1marizc and reflon the findings of the vehicular trip genermion comparison between
the proposed residential pOltion ofthc Aventura (jrand project and the Maxinlllm Density scenario for
the samcarca.
The proposed residential pCll1ion of the Aventura Crand project includes 104 dwelling units of
townhouses/lofts, The lvlaximtim Density scenario with the sitc's cnfl'cnt zoning (B-2) can provide
235.591 SFof office sp,jce,
The Institute tlf Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trill Generation manual (7'" editiDn) was w;edlD
cletennilletbe project's AM peak hour. PM peak hour. and weekday daily vehicular trips that will be
gcnerated byboth scenarios, A summary of the analyses is shown below, See Appcndix A for Avenlura
Grand cakubtions and Appendix B li,r thcMaxill1\m1 Density scenario calculations,
Sc:en ario ITE Land US<' Silo/lInits Dllil.v Trips AM peak PM peak
hour hour
fvlaxilillutl OlJic,' 235.591 SF 2;594 365 351
Density (Land Use 710)
T()\\'n bouses..'Lotls 6M 53 62
AvcnlumGrand 104 DU
(l,and Use nO)
Dirrl'rcnC,C 1,9,,0 312 289
Wcckclav Net New Vehicular Trips'
lilp<; iHt.'rwo.\\:i)
SOlll1.:C; [land P1Ul1lllltr MId A$~\j('liltcs
@E)
Ms, Joanne Carr
RE: "ventura Grand Trip Generation Comparison - #06166
Page 2
As shown above; tbe rcsidenti;,l portion of the A ventura Grand project generates approximately 75%
less daily vehic\lIartrips during a weekday lh"n the Maximum Density development scenario, When
compared 10 the Ai\-! peak and PM peak homs, the residential portion orthe Avenlura Grand project
generates approximately 85% and 80% less trips respcet;vely,
Please eallme al (305) 447-0900 if YOllhavc allY questions or need mOre infOrmation,
Sincerelv,
/~1i~jj
Rita Carbonell
Project El1gillc~r
Altachments
cc: Brian Adler. AIUle Cotler. Alex 'Tukh, File
lcn~r)ll()(,_d('c
~~
Attachment A
Aventura Grand Residential Portion
Trip Generation
^v~ntura - cf06160
Sumrr,ary Tr:lp Ger-:cnEltLonCalculatic'>l
For- lC)/! D:.relling Unit~; ;")f R€,5:~de:.Jt,1i):' ',.:-Jf;c):-L::r'larn I Tot,.;:,t:G'JS(
Auqus: D8, 2006
.n, vg. \'\f € t::k.Ja y ) - \~,'=i >' V O>:~: 1 ;--;;
'1-:' ;\:;,\1 Fed$:
",I -'j R:0., Pear.
E:~: t:_ c
~xi L
HOl~r ,?,,::t 8,J
7-9 ArvJ Feak
4-6 2,'-1 f'(::!ak 'l,~~
4 -~ E'N HCiur =<;.:-1:-
1-6 PH Pf;~?}: ;':::,11:-: Ti;lo,::L
rdc..'y"
\,10_1 u:rn,,:'
Scak ~:u~.:t~ E:lt "
j}s.ak h'Y.]::: 2:X.i t
P~~Dk Ho-,,l r- T ;~}':;;c'l
Averd~e Star:dard
Ra'::.e :J(0V1a~ j 0:';
~.cJ;,:strneLt Drive',,",'8"
F;:;ctay Velum!
6. jt;
r:- .:J
1. CC
u T9
C.A 3
,
:1",:"
1.CC
.DC
1.CO
j C "
"
1 "
o
:::.. t U
r;ri
. . GO
]\]nte: !\:;:f':,n i:jdic:C!" (~:.s ~,-- ::hc,t.J eV,] Ji1h~c'
'T.L0,:.t)(;~\r(:, rolt,i'->:; '>,,:C_F' -(>::1 let:] ::':ited fl';'.'JmL:v:;;::~> Lq<li;~:--.l<):J;::.
:2~-rL__ .
2 - ~\' r::y 'J f~, 1 Urt"ii,O;: :
I\\-)
h"Zlk qr. ";or.a;'
4-{; r'.,,)
f',,;,oi,k' Hr.,
l\\-l ,,'~ r:0 lii. T\.:,t.a~_:
PM Ge~ Fk nr. Total:
Sa::. 2
V:)~.'Jjrr:~?;
r' .T';~)t d
::~ ,-j t.. t- i.
~~ <::n. 2
~:,jri .
(1. /1 C
C. ii"
G . ~)<:'
I,
U. L,i
n. r;
i. ,'.
C, C,?
(:. ->2
--. on
c. .,)
:".';. JC
~ ",:
.,'1""
. 8:iLN 1::<
,S::-,:'l (X
C.76 ,
. )]2:,,1':::-:
._:L-
Li:'.:: 21..1 C.' ~
C. Tj Exi1
;; .5 !;i! :J '~')
+
I
,,);1
. ?(
,';;~' ';> =
~Y ':';::!
,~"; - (J. J n:-
C71 . 8 2~1';\ z
>2::..
.1-
U . '3, '-;1 ';:; :::r,.;'; l',':~' 1
::..~ . ;:
,14 (Z)
0.8'3
. C~ X)
>>29 (Xi
0,84
:).~::'~ [nrer,
,;,::;": . :~.C, RF 2
-38 , :~.
U. En
".:,,'. __ -'I p',.,?
,_ r.
'i . t.),
R--2 =
.:J. iX)
.23!~J:1 ~)(; ilj
j;1"'/. (). i i3 t J, rr:ri?T" 1
Tl\T r G E?: SP;.t\ T 1::_' ~J :"'1,'",- r'j:;: r:EC'~- S_llN:
U. B:j
~:xi ~
C.'32 Exil
~).:~6 Exit
U. t14
D. t;f; F.x:.-it
",ga
('L::,
G6c
J
44
:>3
42
;;0
62
80~
39
:33
73
xi t
Attachment B
Maximum Density Scenario
Trip Generation
Avent'Jra 'Jr2:f<-j !'';ax~GJ-,n Sc~er,arlc - -#C(j~6(
:-::u::rrr,arj' c~ T::-:p Gcrcrdti::;n culatiQf
For 235.S9: T~l,G:.Sq_Ft_ uf SenerciJ OfilC0 Buildi[!(
August'. CF:, 2026
/\'}E',t"2 ,)E-: :'Landa.r:d
R2:'~(: 0i2'Jiiltion
AjjlJstme~t Drivewa:
7a(':.cr Vc;l uml
p,V? '
Vn,;
1 '.i (: , 1 u C 2 59<:)
, .. 6 '-' 'J ] C' D 32 ,
n 'j " , (> C 1 0
.. , C' :;: C C 3 6 S
C " " , 1 C- D ~'i 9
1 ) ,~ c r) C ] .. C 2 9 2
] '1 ? ~ 1 c C 35
.. " .
, 3 .. ;-' ] C C ~)5 8
I" ,.) :2 ,; J C ,
C 1.8 :,l iJ I C Ll
L' 'i .. C; " 1 , "
- 9 AJ1 0 OJ ~ .. 0 " ,- .. : t
7 - ? 1...\,,1 Pea \; .. , , .. z
" - :) TiM (.' 1k '..)i,j I t {
.. ..
( - 6 P:'l " " u , .'-' r\ t ..
, -, P:-l n Q IJ .. .;:, y~i
" ..
1 .. c l--'>1 F e 6 k H ) " t c:l
" w .. , ..
:':;3t
2-'I"iay \7')(1:'1''':'
Sa::
Hen;:: :':";-1::',8:
:::J3.c.l..:rd,0Y
Help' L:.~.i t
Heu:- T()~.>:'; 1
NeLl?: 1\ ~(2.rJ ind~ca~c:'; ~H) .:l.,.~t;::~ ~iV;L_l'::l;-~:; r.::.
30;;r(:(,': l:j:;;~,--i;:l~t:;-:c.r Tr(l~,,'j!>;:)r'~at:C;Dl: ",',,-
(~(:[';e':,'~ '-H'" tL ~-~;cj'i.-::}r):Jt ?(; J"
L-~~ '~~r:r;2:Y'::.'\T1Ct,' If:' FlU;i',I" '"
- ..........
~, J}!; --
--......
--
Miami-Dade County Public Schools
.
. .
, .
. ,
Superintendent of Schools
Rudolph F, Crew, Ed,O,
Miami-Dade County School Board
Agustin J. Barrera, Chair
Perla Tabares Hantman, Vice Chair
Frank J, Bolanos
Evelyn Langlieb Greer
Dr, Robert B, Ingram
Dr, Martin Karp
Ana Rivas Logan
Or, Marta Perez
Dr, Solomon C, Stinson
Chief Facilities Office,
Rose Diamond
Planning Officer
Ana Rije-Conde, A/CP
August 17, 2006
Ms, Joanne Carr, AICP
Planning Director
City of Aventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
Exhibit 5
01-REZ-06
RE: AVENTURA LAND TRUST LLC
NE 30 AVENUE AND NE 207 STREET
APPLICATION FOR ZONING AND COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
Dear Ms, Carr:
Pursuant to the state-mandated and School Board approved Interlocal Agreement, local government, the
development community and the School Board are to collaborate on the options to address the impact of proposed
residential development on public schools where the proposed development would result in an increase in the
schools' FISH % utilization (permanent and relocatable), in excess of 115%,
Attached please find the School District's (District) review analysis of potential impact generated by the above
referenced application, Please note that all the impacted school facilities meet the referenced review threshold, The
proposed residential development will impact VA Highland Oaks Elementary, Highland Oaks Middle and Dr.
Michael M, Krop Senior High Schools currently operating at 117%, 191% and 152% of FISH percent utilization,
respectively, However, utilizing the County's Census 2000 figures, the proposed residential development will
increase the FISH % utilization of VA Highland Oak Elementary and Dr, Michael M, Krop Senior High Schools to
119% and 153%, respectively (please see attached analysis),
It is our recommendation that dialogue between the School District, the City and the above referenced applicant
take place prior to the local Planning Agency meeting of Tuesday, September 12, 2006, As such, please send an
email to irodriou@dadeschools,net to schedule a dialogue meeting with District staft,
Pursuant to the recently approved 5-year work plan, please note the attached analysis depicts the relief schools
planned in the area, which includes the recently approved Facilities Five Year Work Program, Also attached is a list
of approved Charter School Facilities, which may provide relief on a countywide basis,
Additionally, pursuant to Miami-Dade County's Educational Facilities Impact Fee Ordinance the proposed
development, if approved, will be required to pay educational facilities impact fees (impact fees) based on the
following formula:
New residential unit square footage X ,gO (Square Footage Fee) + $600,00 (Base Fee) + 2%
administrative fee = Educational Facilities Impact fee
School Board Administration Building' 1450 NE 2nd Avenue, Suite 525. Miami, Florida 33132
305-995-7285 . Fax 305-995-4760 . arijo@dadeschools,net
AVENTURA LAND TRUST LLC - NE 30 AVENUE AND NE 207 STREET
Me. Joanne Carr, AICP
August 17, 2006
Page 2
As an example, assuming the proposed unit is 1,000 square feet, the 104-unit development is estimated
to generate approximately $156,000 ($1,500 per unit, excluding the 2% administration fee) in impact fees,
This figure may vary since the impact fees assessed are based on the actual square footage of each
dwelling unit
In accordance with the Agreement. this letter and attached information should not be construed as
commentary on the merits of the pending zoning application, Rather it is an attempt to provide relevant
information to the City of Aventura on public schools that will likely serve the proposed development and
meet the referenced threshold,
Thank you in advance for your cooperation in this matter, Should you have any questions, please contact
me (305) 995-4501 ,
Sincerely, <; / ,I /;
1- ' ;,/ j~ / I
/, (, /~",
Ik/.'II/'''' ' /d'I/' I'
I ~>l.. (.) i. (,f 1,-, ". ~ :-.;<
,..___Ivan M, Rbdrig ez, RA '//
Director II __">
IMR:ir
L060
Attachments
cc: Ms, Ana Rijo-Conde, AICP
Me. Fernando Albuerne
SCHOOL IMPACT REVIEW ANALYSIS
APPLICATION:
Aventura Land Trust, LLC
REQUEST:
1) Land Use Change from "Business and Office" to "Medium
Density Residential" (25 to 60); and from B2 "Community
Business District" to RMF3A "Multifamily Medium Density
Residential District" (45 DU/acre); and
2) Site plan review
ACRES:
:t3,359 acres
LOCATION:
Approximately NE 30 Avenue and NE 207 Street (Waterways
Blvd,), Aventura
MSAI
MULTIPLIER:
2,1 1,52 Single-Family (SF) Attached & ,18 Multifamily
NUMBER OF
UNITS:
36 Townhomes (SF) Attached and 68 Multifamily
(As limited by City)
ESTIMATED STUDENT
POPULATION:
31
ELEMENTARY:
15
MIDDLE:
7
SENIOR HIGH:
9
SCHOOLS SERVING AREA OF APPLICATION
ELEMENTARY:
VA Highland Oaks Boone Elementary - 20500 NE 24 Avenue
Highland Oaks Middle - 2375 NE 203 Street
Dr, Michael M, Krop Senior High -1410 NE 215 Street
MIDDLE:
SENIOR HIGH:
All schools are located in Regional Center II.
'Based on Census 2000 information provided by Miami-Dade County Department of Planning
and Zoning,
The following population and facility capacity data are as reported by the Office of
Information Technology, as of October 2005:
Highland Oaks
Middle
% UTILIZATION
.h UTILIZATION NUMBER OF FISH DESIGN
FISH DESIGN FISH DESIGN PORTABLE CAPACllY
STUDENT CAPACITY CAPACITY STUDENT PERMANENT AND CUMULA nVE
POPULATION PERMANENT PERMANENT STATIONS RElCOATABLE STUDENTS..
946 145% 117%
654 152 961
961 . 147% 119%
2,296 228% 191%
1,006 198 2,586
2,303 . 229% 191%
3,774 165% 152%
2,290 190 3,795
153%
V,A, Highland
Oaks Elem,
Dr. Michael M,
Krop Senior
3,783' 165%
'Student population increase as a result of the proposed development
"Estimated number of students (cumulative) based on zoninglland use log (2001- present) and
assuming all approved developments are built; also assumes none of the prior cumulative
students are figured in current population,
Notes:
1)
2)
Figures above reflect the impact of the class size amendment
Pursuant to the Interlocal Agreement, all the schools meet the review threshold,
PLANNED RELIEF SCHOOLS IN THE AREA
(Information included in proposed 5-Year Capital Plan, 2006-2010, dated July 2006)
Projects in Planning, Design or Construction
School
Bay Harbor K-8 Conversion
(Highland Oaks Middle School relief)
(551 student stations)
State School "BB-1" K-8
(RB Bay Harbor Elementary I
VB Highland Oaks Middle Schools relief)
(1,624 student stations)
Status
Planning
Projected Occuoancy Date
2008 School Opening
Design
2008 School Opening
Madie Ives Elementary K-8 Conversion
(VB Highland Oaks Middle School relief)
(948 student stations)
Design
2008 School Opening
Lease Space
VB Highland Oaks Middle
(674 student stations)
State School "000"
(Dr. Krop I North Miami Beach
Senior High Schools relief)
(1,593 student stations)
Construction
2006 School Opening
Design
2008 School Opening
Proposed Relief Schools
School
Early Childhood Center (ECC)
(VB Highland Oaks I Madie Ives
Elementary Schools relief)
(396 student stations)
Fundina Year
FY 2006-07
Addition at
Dr, Michael M, Krop Senior
(1,500 student stations)
FY 2007-08
OPERATING COSTS: Accounting to Financial Affairs, the average cost for K-12 grade students
amounts to $6,549 per student The total annual operating cost for additional students residing
in this development, if approved, would total $203,019,
CAPITAL COSTS: Based on the State's September 2006 student station cost factors*, capital
costs for the estimated additional students to be generated by the proposed development are:
ELEMENTARY 15 x $18,140 = $272,100
MIODLE 7 x $19,589 = $137,123
SENIOR HIGH 9 x $25,444 = $228,996
Total Potential Capital Cost $638.219
*Based on Information provided by the Florida Department of Education, Office of Educational
Facilities Budgeting, Cost per student station does not include land cost
T'\9217\lV"",RodrIg~Ana/yIi.\CIbMlOtyofAv-...IA-.tu..~Tf\IIIlLLC\AVW1l".lardTr-..!LLC.doc
,
Charter School Growth in Miami-Oade County
".' "\' ' ""/'. ;,h ,~~'$tin!l.tharter$\lf\oq:ls': . i ' ,'.
Actual Projected Enrollment (as per contract)
School Name Enrollment
111-18-051 2006-2007 2007-2008 Maximum
Academy of Arts & Minds 141 500 500 500
Archimedean Academv 469 525 525 525
Archimedean Middle Conservatory 61 240 240 240
ASPIRA Eugenio Maria de Hostos 365 600 600 600
ASPIRA Youth Leadership 305 450 450 450
ASPIRA South Youth Leadership 203 450 450 600
Ayentura City of Excellence School 699 900 900 900
Balere Language Academy 148 250 350 450
Coral Reef Montessori 345 500 500 500
Doctors Charter School of Miami Shores 412 525 600 600
Doral Academy 730 2200 2,200 2,200
Doral Academy Middle School 815 1250 1,250 1,250
Doral Academy High School 925 1800 1,800 1,800
Doral Performing Arts & Entertainment Academy 45 150 200 200
Downtown Miami Charter School 614 650 650 650
Early Beginnings Academy, Civic Center 43 80 80 80
Early Beainninas Academv - North Shore 20 43 61 70
Florida International Academy 261 350 350 350
International Studies Charter Hiah School 110 750 1,000 1,000
Keys Gate Charter School 1,132 1,150 1,150 1,150
Lawrence Academy 69 250 350 450
Liberty City Charter School 350 705 705 705
Life Skills Center Miami-Dade County 62 450 600 600
Mater Academy 713 1,150 1,150 1,150
Mater Academy Charter Hiah School 1,165 1,300 1,300 1,300
Mater Academy Charter Middle Schoal 1,154 1,300 1300 1,300
Mater Academy East Charter School 303 800 800 800
Mater Academy East Middle School 107 250 300 250
Mater Performing Arts & Entertainment Academy 94 150 200 200
Miami Children's Museum 79 350 350 350
Miami Cammunity Charter School 223 600 600 600
Oxford Academy of Miami 105 450 450 450
Pinecrest Preparatorv Academy Middle School 222 800 800 800
Pinecrest Preaaratory Academy 745 1250 1,250 1,250
Rosa Parks Charter School/Florida City 199 600 600 600
Renaissance Elementarv Charter School 452 500 500 500
Renaissance Middle Charter School 47 700 1050 1,600
Sandor Wiener School of Opportunity 19 72 72 72
Sandor Wiener School of Oooortunity, South 25 36 36 36
School for Intearated Academics & Technoloaies 332 800 800 800
Somerset Academy 525 700 700 700
Somerset Academy Charter Middle School 74 300 300 300
Somerset Academy Charter Hiah School 22 375 500 500
. 78 ;!OO ;!OO ;!OO
Soirit City Academy 39 300 350 400
Sunshine Academy 95 200 275 450
The Charter School at Waterstone 1,012 1,000 1 150 1,000
Theodore R and Thelma A, Gibson Charter School 16 600 600 600
Transitional Learninq Academv 29 48 72 72
Youth Co-Op Charter School ,. 515 525 525 525
TOTAL: 49 schools 16713 30 364 31 331 32 625
* Contract termmated effective June 30, 2006
Revised June 30, 2006, to reflect July 2006 board action. Page 1 of 3
, BOlfr!1!-.Approved Contracts. for Schools to Openln Future Years
School Name Projected Enrollment (as per contract)
2006-2007 2007-2008 Maximum
Charter on the Beach Middle School 250 250 250
. m 4+a ++a
A Child's Journey Charter School N/A 325 600
Atlantic Science Academy N/A 600 840
Coooeratiye Charter School 100 120 200
" eoo eoo eoo
Excelsior Academy of Miami N/A 450 450
Mosaic Bilingual Academy NIA 120 365
North Miami/Florida Inn Uniy, Charter Sr. Hiah School N/A 800 1,600
Pinecrest Academy Charter Hiah School 600 850 850
South Dade Charter Elementarv School N/A 625 750
Swmmerville Ch3rter Scheel" eoo eoo eoo
Excel Academy 250 300 700
Life Skills Center Opa Locka 400 400 400
Mater Academy Lakes Elementary School -0- 800 800
Mater Academy Lakes Middle School 900 900 900
Mater Academy Lakes Hiah School 300 600 1,200
Mater Gardens Academy 900 900 900
Mater Gardens Academy Middle School 450 450 450
Pinecrest Academy (South Camous) 800 800 800
Somerset Academy (Silyer Palms) -0- 600 600
Somerset Academy (Country Palms) -0- 1,000 1,000
Somerset Academy Middle School (Countrv Palms) -0- 600 600
TOTAL: 20 schools 4,950 11,490 14,255
SUB-TOTAL (EXISTING -APPROVED): 69 schools 35,314 42,821 46,880
* Deferment period expired - contracts automatically lapse.
, .Contra~ts Penl'lmg Apprpval , ,
School Name Projected Enrollment (as per contract)
2006-2007 2007-2008 Maximum
Dr. Joseoh Coats Grace Communitv Adyantaae Academy" -0- 750 750
Summerville Advantaae Academy" -0- 750 750
Excel Academy North -0- 250 700
River Cities Communitv Charter School -0- 250 250
TOTAL: schools -0- 2,000 2,450
SUB-TOTAL (EXISTING - APPROVED - PENDING APPROVAL): 73 schools 35,314 44,821 49,330
'* applications approved as Advantage Academy of Miami and Advantage Academy of Miami "B", respectively.
Revised June 30, 2006, to reflect July 2006 bOlJrd action. Page 2 of 3
Board-Approved applications for schools openina in subseauentvears
Aeelicant Maximum Enrollment Caeacitv
Mater Sorinos Academv Elementary School 600
Mater Academv South Charter School 900
Mater Sorinas Academv Middle School 300
Sabal Palm Charter Hiah School 800
Charter Academv of Excellence 600
Palmetto Bav Charter Academv 1,600
Princeton Charter Academv 1,600
Homestead Charter Hiah School 2,000
South Miami-Dade Charter Elementary School 600
South Miami-Dade Charter Middle School 300
Advantaae Academv of Miami "C. 750
Advantaae Career Academv 900
Kush Academv 500
Life Skills Center - Homestead 700
Life Skills Center - Libertv City 700
Romans Charter School 540
South Florida Choir Intermediate/Hiah School 280
Total: 17 schools 13,670
GRAND TOTALS
Number of Schools I Maximum Enrollment Capacity
90 I 63,000
Revised June 30, 2006, to reflect July 2006 board action - Page 3 of 3
..C.(;
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
";(;,+::iOL ~~,c\I-:lE I ,~,OOf(~:::;S tJRL
I (~Ri\wf,
L;::V::"L.,S
?G2?
.'~, ~ 'I ,_ :8i:I'j 0 i f\~~:; <. r,d lo'lin s
, ,",', :~ '~'IT1""j{!S': ,~, !~I;"l,'-a
["l;;::n!; "L_c_:',c-'
http../.tNf-/J_aandm,nel
(j 5', ~'
.l',;-c.i;i:j-;l"J,08r..'\cc-.,:'I_O,'l;i
~:y,~;.'3 2.'.1',"'~,
k 'I ,'~: 1 : i " I, _" is,:;
hllp:t'homepage. mac com/archimedean
_3cadcmyIP,RCIiIMEDEAN_ACADEMY.html
ii070
FSPf~;A
l:li\'8iii'~ klili i<J ~e Hosto: Y 'L1'!: [,(;8::1;-0:'';:1:;:::
C:!12~tG-! :>;: I'Jci
1 ~10 NE I'll 21'11 C(
r""~,, ",~' , '-- :j3 17,
http://lLaspira,org.''Nynwood/Cl1arlerlemi1_charter,htm
:;,e:o:e
.J,srjr:I~. 8')'..,11
"'0\:ti, :.(;"idcrs.i1ip cr-,;;;;)c.~ 8::1lo01
1-1i12-1';: ,-I '20',.'1/ :dB,S 51
l_8iwr? G:'~' "'L 3:)~'~;,3
11\!p :i!ll, BSl1ira orglSouth/CharterfsoUlh _ cha rter, him
,iD20 ,\:;:;::<If'A
V;:,:::I_~ L,::"C€-iShIP Chc~li'~! Sc;-,c,-,]
.'~JJLi i'/,~:r,c',iBI I-J-.',l'
'.' j.,'kv~" F... ,~'.:.. i 0',
SG1':CC,L.. ~.I),..I:;Nl:nF:;/.fC;i~ I
:.:"{'-d'-,L p.D")H:~3S
,':
,',II; Ti1~j::~as L ShEW.'
tishaw@dacieSCI1001s.rL€t
O:'!.: ~,-, ,,_
",-,,:,
:';05.,1V, IlliG
:',(J5-~A()-r:-- -- I"~:,
:;;; , ~; "
J"-J::.',
!H,_':
'''' ~,.:l
i<-~.
11;1:;-- P"t 3oQll1
pbo0th@d<ldeschools.net
;;:,)5-.i;'Q i ~ -i'-~
:IJ~-'i70-(;Gl::; F;"-:
?,;:.'j 24-3 : i
:COG - ;,~ Ij c' : "
" , :\'1" il!3112. Per.a '-jO~;" .."'~ '::'::'50
idpena@dadesChools.n61 3C~-] :':[,1 ,~n; CC".
hllp: I/il aspira, org,INorlh/C hCl rterlnortil_ cha1e,. him
(I::sn
"...~,'t" ";~;) ;'" .-:_.""'i".,..,,, L~"'-rt~' C:-~rr,~t
J-,', _ ., "", _" ,_.'"...'''';' ,',\~ ',,01 '. "~,, _ ~
:3:":'~~i i';~: St
'.~n,t:I:' r-... :'3-,8:.1
!ltlp."WVofll\' Clvl?nturacI1ar1er,org
-: 1 ~ :~
>i:~:~;:-;,~ ~'::!L~}';lag_~ '~:li~~'~G :1,
i',1ic,~ri; H_ ',::189
11ttp:!/W\"."N_balere_org!:::lmrter;'index_lltm
{i[:7;'1
Cu',l 1',.,':;' f'..;C;!'.",ssori'~,r.,,\(!~i"l,/ C,-art.;I- ~:::i10,:i
;L:S';S',",;ZI3Sl
i".I,~;:-,: ,-,
h\1p:i/wroi:eefmontesswLdaeJescl,aols.nel
~~C':;;n
U(-l<o:~ .'\c~de_:-'-",
.: -,t c: i; ;~ 1,-0': .
;,,;i,"',.;i Fl. 0.'. :'i:;'
blip: i :doralClcad em:/, d~ :jescl'iools. net
S,)2::,
[,:;;-1;;11 r,,~wk;'-,r/ C:i8'!"" ..':,~id::- .~:;tjl,::::;1
2('01 ;:V>J ,.:"
1.'i:"ll.tr,. 1'-
ht!fl:/:' muieracademyl1 igh_ dadescl1ools. Il~t
!'J::'.O
~- t::,::t,':'~:':: ..
, ' ., ~~ " , rI'.,1 t
_Il'.,e, j\!\,'"',),
1'.'i',"""':-: ',:,,1-'-;:
::;::11(',0:
hllp; lin18teracadel11yllighliadesclloolS, net
6-~;
ivll rem::mc!o l.opez
llnnez@dadesChooI5.net
5-2
:'.11' Ke'Jir lJ1c,01'-~
kmoore@da1p.schools.net
1,-2
Oi :'atil'2:ine ,'lit:,-pl,..'
l~murpl1y@dad~schoOls. np-!
1<;.::;
1.% r~c.--;k", 1',la'ij:
rmalik@dadeschools_net
i':-;3
1!'-!1s_JlIiict:<:inCi
, julietking@dadeschoois.l1",t
~.'~s ~_Lq':::- :1':~('iif;ri-Gcl(!,,1l i
!<-;:;
:\<10. ::?2:i8.(,O!I-,e::
ileanagomez@dadeschQols.nel
(5-8
;:1: J.J~'~ S"'.~:"
820111@dacJeschools_nel
',-12
.1'1 c':dili; Ji1ll2'1';;~
fjimcnez@d;,;;deschools.net
.,,', '"
:;,;. ~ .
:"
" ',' r'~',:
,.. -..;'5;' ~h::";.'
~Ui _ ,~(I:;5 i',._
.;0;, J' ,,;'('"
:,0'" '-:1-20: F~':
:;'0~' -;,;~;1 0:1.'('
:':(-'5,,,~ 'x Ocr:
:';1:':-, - ;,}~"j
'C",,";;'- "",:":,.\
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
~(>'YI
C" ',,~C":I: ;vi'c'':-,J; Ch:;,i81 -:';d~o~,j
"::;;'!V,':3""..
;'."i'<lI1: ~L ...,12C
http://dovmtownch,merorg
<iO~J
:'C)l"lf.~'_. il"':,.~:nr::ti::.n:1: /',.7a,le,.,-",
i':iJi Bird
Lii""H Il.
MiSSion Sta!Bment
2GiiCi
Ti-,,,,:o:ire'," ", 21lld T!-'""Iill.'l ,"" GiJ;>::.c',,', CII:,"iic" 8;:11,YII
::..:;:;..j;::'}fflll.Jf"Ie
1...l',";-li 10133::::::
t'.lissior'l Stalernent
flttp:f1glb!:>oncharter. dadeschoo\s. net
lOOr
111\(;f.-,;:wor",1 StlKii8S Cil<-irtC! High ScI',Joi
22r~O ;>u'Jti, ,\.4iGll1li 1','iP.I"L!'~
i,i;<l~,l; Fi ~,:'1X/
httpl/VNN!.is:::hs.net'index ht1111
3\dO
:;Sj'~ Gate CI~,Ol;1:!"j Sell'.")1
2DOG2E2E;;:','Jo
l-!(JI118'.:ie:,d [~l :'3L':'~
http:lN:W","'keysd:aI1er,Qrg
{l1}40
Lib8~t'i (;Iej Ch?rli,'1 Sc:~,:,;.1
;;:-:"0 N\/J ~\ve
il':ill'li.FL3::Ji5Cl
No!"',' L2mpl!S
,,-,~~, ~~\/.J 2.'-! 1-\.!e~llI';
i'li:<,.~t;" FL ;'., FiT
11tlp:/Nw,'w Iccschool.C'.om
~110G
."A,lt,,~ ..\i;;:,d'2ln,/
7~.'iJC ;~\/,j 9::;(11 81
:-Ed':::::!l C(III;~ IOl. 'DEi
Illlp: / f mat8racademy _ dadeschoolS, net
5'HZ
H"t'2r ;:,C;;;d'~I"W C':h~l !.'!i 1'.'I~jfe Sc:',oo:
7~1:~; n\.'lJ 'i C.2 S~.
:-:ii'iiiC:;Jii,--:;,'I':12;',:;FL:'l.}r_i(:;
httpifma1eracadernyhigh,dadesc!',ccls.net
3i<:<1
;'_'18i,,:,-c...C2den,~: Ecnt (.:!-,<:'1'10i SCl1'2'()i
,~5u SV\I /:il. S:
!',.ii,j"'1' i'i .",'J,'
htlp:l !malm academyea~l dader,;c:hooi s_ net
?';;,C :'.,'i".!!~r ACcK;('my C',211C':1 11']h ~;,:;"',oo;
;~:~;:~:~;;;';I\~Llll\': ~~ C)0U 1'3
htlp:i.fmaleracademyhigh.d2des.:hools.Il\'lt
l.;iJ(}ll
i','li;~llIi Ch:!C;iSr-'S f-i1u;>e:.I"I~ CI'C1.11::;'~ SO',o('i
C!C'O iv1, /;'iti',u C~',~,,'2V;8j
1..-1iG:,1i FL.',.',!::;2
iC;r;<>!I(oJ1 ,or:' :1' ..n,~
:::<1 -'",
\-.'1;,""1: ". :)~'130
I
1(.(;
"-181,..'[.,'1,-1(1<;
terTymaus@:'dadeschcols ne:
'5,,:
rvl~ S,),'i? !"litcl~cll
smitchell@d3descho3Is,nel
:<-3
id, C!-;3rles Sdl1ei
cgbethel@aacleschoc-l5,net
~'-12
i11s _~,n;, il.i';a,2z-f,I:r:-,c,n
aalvarez-arimon@dadeschools.net
:<-~
i,M, Cr.r;s~li,e\Ji::i;dE:z
cvaladez@dadeschools.nei
i<.:';
"";;;:, ~<?,trh<l V.'iison-Oe'iis
, ~..wils.on-del'is@dadeschools."et
1,_-5
b'f, \,;;1' G;Jilarle
kguilarta@dadesc:nools net
t',,-,
iI"r r:en.. ~;olil"JS"
rrovirosa@dadeschocls,nei
,"1~, D<:!2!ri:. [{:elD
briera@dadesdlce,IS.net
g-,..
I-,]~ JU::',t i',\cl!l')
imany@dadeschools.net
i<:-'-;
l..os ,/i:;:.ri~, iV,:-r,:;;er,tli Gn:-81
mongeotti-greer@dadeschools_net
'3i;:i"'r. :1'1
:V'~" ,;
I r'J.:", i,.,,;.H" 12
~ ri,
'.':,-,.--
:;C'>iic~"::,!,:'-'
:','.">(-;,~ .,: ::.1 ';J'
30CC,i(i..;:2():.;
:iJ3 ,~,':')-,~1 :,(; l"c.
::;G ~;;~ ,(; 1 c-; -i .;;
_"'i__" fJ "'''i h';.
')I;:-.t.i.:';;1J[1
.':0".- i~; __ "'__!:~ r.
~:i~;,\_'~;:;~:-JI-':i)'1
7(i(~-4" ~\"Gc,C'~ ;:,;;;
".r,!",_;;:,,').; c,
:l1.)Z;(',!/-, ,', \-8;
',fE..~:::~: . 'I bGi':
.: (, :;.:i:::'2",c . I .' I'" ~
.~ C ~ ....,.,',
co,,','- ,,(,,::2"1'..
.j\}c, 8::'G :I.!-;:-;
i :::0::: G2:,.G 1 1';1"
i
I
:'
"",i : ~'fJlii'l
,;-j,,'
,<:16 _
~'''::;=-'iJ:!;,.~1 .- 1."
I
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
~102 :'/li::,,1 (;0ilimllil.j; C:V;"<'\I S':il'.:.;:;.: )~-5 i"IS JIi.o: Ec,zc',if' '~:o-::-< <~~h:,
, (.1 , J i"ecll~n( r;~xd jrezaie@dadeschools_net :;!I:,- , " .,.'. , ~J':
:il"',i11 - ~~::. LJ:\ miami"harter@beIl5ouI11 00'
['.!115s:0n Statement
GG, J Drx',tc."" ,':":;:,(:u Sc~c',:A , f IV,ia:I,i 811:;'';8 I (i- ~ : I\;'I.~ r;,k.~Qi~ ~.j;:'i;:;-J';:: ;,) -ee! I, ,
i '}'J5'~; i'.!E ?n("J fl.'.iei':II€ ~O.r:,. ',"':-(1 '.Ie ;~).,
i.;!i;",il,1 ;:';1-,,'.'(<'::0 I~L. .;,,;, ',;'';'
:JSCt; ?ineuf,<;i f',t'l':1r"M)iY Academy 1(-::; r\~" SUSI:: OO!JICC :-',G"28,', 0;:-
;,;,-:;,11 ,-;-,,) 4~' 5t sd::Jpico@dadesch0ols.net 3Y>'(ji i ~ . .. ~:,'~
"'~i")111! 1-': -:~,i-
l\~,,"':;Ai: G'-2€iiS Car,'!},!.:,
, :'1 ?C! S\:\.' :"iDlI. Streci
:\'il"I-:~,. , L :,'\."31 '-'~'
hitI' :iiPinecrestpreparatoryacademy. dadeschools .net
SO:'';: P:i;i::;le31 ."'.uvler,lY Ck'li't-?I j'j,',j1Ie S;;I-,(Jo! G-G i,-~". Jear,"-'tie fJeIl8no:?7_ :',eE- ?(," ~);: I
~ J ~'C 1 S';)V .\7 Sl jeanettemndz@dadeschools.net :;05-2'),- :~ S', F,,"
:,l!am! n ';'," 17"
I~ ':1 ~[!f;!' '3(o~~ns Call ,.'.;;'-
, S!:;a SVv 8au-, S\i~<,l
1',,1!2;,-,1 :~L :,3WO
hltp ./iPmecrestpreparatoryacademy, dadesshool s nel I
,>100 n",IlCli,,~~;;;nr_'e E'em211i,,:'i Cha1"r Sehcal 1<-3 i\'1:~ All" Co,cl.~! ;)l:S-5'J' -~2 :3
:)J:-:C :'l'./'J C,';" C~t acordal@dadeschools,net '30 OJ.. ~J'~': _."', I; " T'
,'i1i.3""i fl. ~3 : :::;:>
!1t!pifw\\rlJ_recschClrter.org
s:;: 'J~1 r-;c.s:~ F"rl " C':c''-~''''i Sd\o~i'I~i-):,i'J8 C:t', j~-8 r,ils ;''/laC\'Ol j~ 3;:'13 ;)',,;, -:~ -'(;;,~':~ ..
,~:-:i ;::I'..'~.'enr:, i".i,'.' 'j(' "': ,,.';,~ !C!c c~ "C',';' :::u, -;:'8'-: :i.j,: '~~
~ 1 :::' \"-}'2S' i-'dlli ;,
Fl"'I'r:j~~ C. 1-" >;O~4
" 3 ,'.!t.',..:ei is ,'ifii I),' , iil!., "OC,1!'/')I'
':.0::; ',II.:c~: , f :,:11',; f:r
F'!,.rj:l ,'~ Cit:: Fi_ ::30:". !
:1"(10 ~:~;I-:dcl ',j'/i8r,o,1 S::inol ::-f ,~ipp011'jr:it~,' ,,<, ,'.')0; Liss,,: G:'I',:ds;;: ::~'~,-r;;1~-':,f,2!
Igol1zalez 1@dadesct1ools,net :-'(l5CT,-S,"::'; F:-;
;'/.3:;-
:::G,-:uf (Ii C1
;.,"'c',tClC!';:" ,c: ;",,-,3,,
:"i;o;i!h<;.;/.(i(:i'?'_;;"
?':.~ D[,:; 1;~~7::' ,
I..:~','~','" ::L :) '=",~ " . "
MI5Siol1 Statement
">"";I"""i"-'.'. V-i'I':' Te:.l'j181 , ~;O"i-~' ':<,((;..)
'''......c..
:1::'::':: ,,:,\-"i :?i 1',1;; ,<c,.~:;w,;:; Oc;i;o.; "',I,"> .-:::~:)4 h~"
;"I;;,i',1:, Fi_ 3:::,1 i,'
:.J:~i: S,~j I'--,,~,I 1:11 ;Ill,;.~Jf~H.,( f\CS':: ,P"~-'~ .'C Tf::c!:l~oiYJjr;:~ (?:V,T.:;c:.,; ^ ;',ls ?,12i'jCi-j", \..J[j'o'. i'/,;,in
lopezI11a@dc~deschoo:s rlet .c,:-,,:-_,::!,')::; 'h ,-
I ;.:;,~i[;':~;"~!~' ',' .~:,ri_::':, ,.7 1 j.) j-;'"
,',,[1 C(;;1:5 (:',,:1t-:::
i;::::;:.,(: ,'3V';' L'~' .'::'t C:'b,if.1ii -:,Cd';
I, 1",-:; ;',,'c-" 1-;, ::,c:,' i ,;
, ,
,cO /,,- '>!.' f;-;
,
;'.IOI'(h
.\liaini ie':.' ,~,' i'",'
:I'J5i; i';"" ~, ;,
;':!!:':J::l; tL.
,
MiSSion Stalt:mc-!11
G321~
S(~'].~
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
':\H-ni!! ;;81 i:",~~,'~:S";l\
.~?1 ,S.,i,; : c' ~ ,''.vr;
j:~I1l; ;-t :;:'L-7
rv1t:.sior. Staiem€f11
httpl/sf)IT:erseietem(ladeschools,net
S(!I',,~ ::;i:t
CI-,"r~;2r r:'1id(I,~
SI/,V' 1 '1- ,".\"~ <<
'V':iCJ::li':i :",::',1";'['
-,~mp':>,'''liY :,~'G~,f'o:n; ,'0:,;/ 05,')5
:8"0: ':O'i'.11~'l, ;:'.'.'i?j',U;;
i\c:izlm: :::1_~3;,7
7.Jt'?
Sr~'1l~)r,~p~'
D'J'! '; ,7 ^\'f;
;'/!:';'il;i H 1'l,~-i'::'
Ci,co..-tsc i-<ig;l,S;:;I,,:,c.l
J.~;cat'C:!]5 r:" 0:;.06
1 :: i\ ';f~,
!Jil;:l"j n 3;172
b"tC1
': 1 ',GO f'!\\' ~.:. ::a
i\'I:'::;1,; i-'1" '<il.
,J2JIJ
~:;ij;,,,l' I',d, E':::!11'<2 ,i,3:y CI12'!:;!f SCl-,~'c;i
';:,.1(,;'j :';'/.' 7::: St
,'",ils:Y,i,r;'::;::'1S2
Mission Statement
1(.:;:;;,
Y',)L,t,l C>Or C:12,tior Si.-'l'JQI
In'5 i \'\, OI'E:ectic-b,~t; ~:d
Hial-",h C(;',., r:i_ 3:;:)'10
http./.''iccs.dCioeschools,lleV
1<,5
1\':$ SU1,EI". Ru:;:
sruiz052C@dadeschools,nei
6.2,
-:-W'.
~>,2
f'ii2-. Dla:~2 j',,1Dralss
dmorat,"s3@dadeschOCls,ne\
1(-5
[oi'.> ':';iS2Ia 8a12"I
gbatan@dadeschools.net
i,-.;)
1',:5 r'Jlnri\;:3A:'agor,
maragon@dadeschools.net
::.I,:~.:::' ::J
~,.;:; C'~" 1'1" h
';05,:>\!,".-;',;L'
:V->-.~7'0-,'- ;::i r""
i,' J~Lil/~,i',.,
~',C5,l;~'.,' ~,i C:. ~c,:(
'YJ5-:7:).C-'1ic;
::C'S::/~; OL.I~ I ,..
305-819.8855
305-819-8455 Fax
'"
'i'
'"
'"
<b
'"
o
o
N
.;,
o
o
N
"
o
"-
en
...J
o
o
J:
U
en
"
w
~
J:
U
~
W
Z
"'
'6
'~
o
::;:<Xl
r--
~C'\I
:.=<9
"'0
"'''''
>'"
,'"
"'0
::;:M
<Xl
.;,
N
~
<Xl
...:.
N
~
.;,
E
o
~
Q)
~
S
"'
~
o
.c
,!Q
E
'"
E
N
Q)
~
'"
>0
~~
.~~
Wr--
- OJ
0",
,'"
"'0
::;:M
N
a,
>::
~
0.
00
.;,
00
~
00
.;,
~ x E .8
o Lf 8
'E '
ctI~<Oro
o~~~
. NO E
rJ) I '(,:::lJ\
Or--C"')~
0)0"'-0
.-J0'l1.00
,..,.'" Q)
....Lt')CO"t:
OOlr-..U
E
o
~
o
'"
>::
~
0.
N
~
do
0;
a.
,- ,.,
" "'
<:-
,- '"
!to.
"0;
"2....0
>,.000
roP;O
-Q)~
eOJ,
"'-ON
UQ)'"
.:t:Lt)
"'<:0
::;:::l",
0;
a.
co T5 Q.)
a. <: <:
.- >. ';:: >. 0
glQ Q..jQ EO.
;:: co R ttI 0'" E
0.. a.. we.. :=:: u q
-co := co ~ -:. 0 ~
~..ca:2:..so'=;N~Q5Mo
ro~~~~zgm~ cE~ctI
-Q.)T""Q,l/l)T"""cgMM ,.....
eULb E()J,€~~ {J'M"'t
ctlUN rn UN '(j)CO .... ::::l......M
()Q.)Ma.Q.)M~N:::l...JNN
u:i:g1O ui:gl.{) .L()~ ujLOW
~::;)g~:>~OgE:2g~
0;
a.
'<:3
C
'C
a.
vi
Q)r--
:9",
~~
"'",
CN
<('"
ui~
::;:'"
N
'0
Q)
'"
'"
0.
>,
E
o Q)
M -0
o '"
M "
'" '" <(
...J ~ c-g
LL_ 0 WroN
~ co -rig b5 EN"'" (5
M ('IJ~ Cr--,"'- 0
~ ,..- 0)0 E '~"'-~Q.l Q)~ _ .c
'" M +-'C/) ro 1::M.... ...... U
~ M W ._ Q.lM...JO - E C/)
Q.l ~~:E -..Ju....c Cl.la:i Q.l III
w i OU 0 ~~~C/) cO ~ ~
~ I'- CO~~~5 Q.lo u ,.....~
() E ~ ~ ::; 0 M ~ 0 .... 0 :~ <( 1.0 ~
Q) ':_ aj ~ ...... 0 ;;; ~ 0 0 ~ co 0 l() 0) to /ll "'t 'E ,..- >-
:0 ~ ~ ro ~ ~"fi M <( 0 - I 0 I N C N E'E;: 8.~ ~ E
U. Q.)O...JC/)aj...J~~~~ OUwaj~~aj~Q)O~~w...J~
~ U5 ~ E <1f.. 5 CD >'l.J.., CD > L.L.. .!: Cf) <( Q') . ~ ~ 0) > M ('IJ > M U E ...J -. ~ LL ('IJ g
N"- '. > III +-' Q) -g - 1::: <( ui E ,...... N C - M C <( co (l) <( co (lJ _ lL W '-' - 0 ......
&j r-- ~ ~ ~ <( 5. c = ro"5 ro LO ~ .... C\I ,..- 'c en M ~ 'c .q- :!2 ::: ..q- :g <(0 f!J _ U :6 co <( u) ~
0)> ro~NE'-cEro~>oO>~C~ o~~~ro~ ~ 5-rn-
"'0 > -oJ I U e w cu is 0 ~ Q) U > ~ ~ > ~ '50'>...J.c 'c>~.Q c ~.Q Q) 1;) u Z I 0 ~""'....J
wU)u..~<(c, Uctl~OlIl~ZU)a..Z Q)~u.._U)(l) u..~g LL...gw W ,:t::W~LL~
nE~--Q)UZ~>Q)Z'-o~'-_oz~Z'_.cmz,_,_z'_Q)>ro WQ)~cn-
~ENErn~~->~~E-oEroo~~ E~b~E~~E~>~O~EQ) E
U...,.ro~'-N~~roOctlUMro~~o~~roo~~roro~ros~~Q)o_-aro
~N'-~~MON.cM.-O~,-o~mrooo'-Zro"""-~"""-ro~~.Y~rnro~._
<(~~m~ro~NUN~O~~O~NWO'>~ W~~~~~....J~u......Jm~~v~
<0
o
o
'"
'"
~
o
r--
r--
o
o
<0
o
3
'"
'"
o
o
r--
r--
N
o
<0
00
o
o
<0
o
00
o
..,.
o
r--
o
..,.
o
o
o
~
'"
o
o
'"
~
do
N
.;.
N
~
d,
l!)
:>::
<l.
.~ ~
~N
"'""
.e
:;
o
CIJ
'E
" ~
E 'c
c: "
'CO 1::
1: g,
r, ~ Q.
Jj ~ 'E- 0 ~
<<5 C"Jro 15 .......
en ("');,;;:: 0. ('I')
t ~ 0 ~
<( Lic. -5 >-...J
~-:ui>.U5tOC/J"""M~ .lL~
._CI) C Ewf'-.. ""'(/)/'--005"5
EMWevO,-Q)..q.....roNCO
......o'EU......C")CCOC"1.9c.oCD
_ .g ....... C'O ~ > M ,~ > C") ....... ..... co
, " > Cl <( > ~ ~ > ~ "w ,-
n. > ..c en ..... (/) .5 E
,-Z (0'00,-: Olt)....:..cZ ro
Q)...... Q) 0""" E"ON E UlM:E
mg~'X~.~ ~~.~ 5~
:2:r--.:l:O.......~CI)......~U)......Z
l!)
:>::
'"
c.
'[;
c:
'C
<l.
C
c:
'5
Cl
u
::<
,,'"
.S ffi
12'7
~ro
.eN
Uro
ui:g
::<""
~
o
t5
1ii~
~i5
00
o c:
-5 ~
'" c:
" '"
iil::<
"
'"
c.
'[;
,5
cl:
N
"
"
c: x
'" '"
E LL
~C\8
",-<to
",-<tN
.- ro J,
.c",,,,
~LON
,l!)l!)
~gg
'"
c.
'[;
c:
it
-<t
~
o
'"
o
~
o
l!)
o
""
o
l!)
ro
:>::
ro
:>::
~ E
u 0
'U
" ,
c: "
o c:
tiS
wt!?ro
Lt'.l ro2Q.
C'!; ~~g
-E 2 o~.;::
Q) .~ 8 '5 0 0 ~
C:O~ C/)..q ..co.....
oeO RM U..cO
.....L:I'O (1)0 ~<.)O
i!J<l.@) =,""" ro,,~:t
~NQ)itiroOC") ot:<1>(l)
c:::JC!:2~ ...J f~L~ffic
(j.g::t:: Vl Eu.r.o ' U.c 0<0"0
.." Owro ~o~ ~:r:..q 0
~ ~2 ~+::n.~~N 0 ~.~~ 0
O:;:::coro:::J-O'L.OC --,
~ .~ ~ 0 0 ~ ClJ ~ 0 ':-: ~ ~ Q.)
N():::JC.Q.)W:gN~~.cO"""6
~ ....: t> E.~ 0 0 L!) x E Q) r.ri (0 ..c
ECl-o~0::~u:g~W~::E~5
"
c:
.8
'"
~
"
ro~
~~-<t
"'''''''
egg
~ii)C")
cX~Li
~ '" .
~$:-g
('01;52
.c '" '"
Uw"
"l!) E
.el!)0
t-roI
-<t
>. l!)
E .g
~U5C'?
"'l!)...J
U""LL
<( ~ .
>. '"
~:S:-"
(jzg
:=:0'
.~o co
~;:J;o
o
l!)
o
l!)
o
~
o
~
00
w
N
~
o
0;
c
"'
(5
o
.e
u
'"
"
"
'"
"
E
o
u
~
"
'E
"
u
x!!2
~~
'"
0.......... Q)
.Q...........,.~
U:C;;o;@)
&;MM 8-
o'<t""<;f"i;::
-, co <.0 .
.' l{) LO CI,)
- 00 U')
:::2:MM.Q.,
>.
'E
"
o
U
<D
"
'"
9
'E
'"
~-
~<Dl!)
2~N
c:-~
"CIJ""
u",""
~$:cr
~z -
(fJ l!) 'E
<D"" '"
::i~~
'"
N
o
CD
l!)
~
o
'"
00
w
0;
c:
"'
(5
o
.e
u
- '"
~I,{)Q)
~N"
ON'"
UN"
co":" @)
cmrn
<(l!)"
. L!) 0
"'0 U
::<""'"
-;;;
"-
'i)
c:
'C
A.
N
o
N
Q)
Cl
'"
<l.
(5
o
.e
U
CIJ
~
~~
",'i'
.c'"
u<;::
~.e
" ~
:!2o
::2:;.....;~
Q.'lUCfJ......
g.E~2j
'" ~ ...J
~f!~LL
.~ 0 z....:
~ ~a E
.... Ii;: <D ro
~~g~
ro
N
o
CD
APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT
Pursuant to Sectlull.J I-f I \DJ\LJ\I) UllIle vl!Y UI !-\velllUli::l LClI1U utlverupfllern \...uue, UlI::i APIJIIC<:Hlll"(epreSerllclllve .....lIIuavit is hereby made and
submilled, The undersigned authorized representative ot the individual or entity applying for the Development Permit, which is identified in the accompanying
application, and the owner of the property subject to the application (it different) hereby lists and identities all persons representing the individual or entity
applying for the Development Permit in connection with the application, as follows:
Name
Relationship (i,e, Attorneys, Architects, Landscape
Architects, Engineers, Lobbyists, Etc.)
Yizhak Toledano
Develooer
Alex Tukh
Proiect Manaaer
Stan lev B. Price
Attorney
Brian S, Adler
Attorney
Anne Cotter
Architect
Bernardo Fort-Brescia
Architect
DieQo DelQado
Assistant to Architect
Carl Skiles
Enaineer
Timothy Plummer
Traffic Enaineer
Andrew Witkin
landscaoe Architect
Kelly Hults
Landscape Architect
(Allach Additional Sheets It Necessary)
NOTICE: ANY STATEMENT OR REPRESENTATION MADE BY ANY PERSON LISTED ON THE APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT
SHALL BE BINDING UPON THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY APPLYING FOR THE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND THE OWNER OF
THE SUBJECT PROPERTY, APPLICANTS AND AFFIANTS ARE ADVISED TO TIMELY SUPPLEMENT THIS AFFIDAVIT
PURSUANT TO SEC, 31.71(B)(2)(IV) OF THE CITY'S LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS IN THE CITY CODE, IN THE EVENT
THAT PRIOR TO CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICATION BY THE CITY BOARD OR COMMISSION, THE INFORMATION
PROVIDED IN THE AFFIDAVIT BECOMES INCORRECT OR INCOMPLETE,
WITNESS MY HAND THIS Ul\-VlDAY OF Th 1'1 ,2006,
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OF APPLICANT:
OWNER
By:
(Signature)
By:
Name:
(Print)
nature)
Name: Alex Tukh Proiect Manaqer and Authorized Sionator
(Print)
Aventura Land Trust. LLC and Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
Title:
Address:
Address: 3624 Estate Oak Circle
Ft Lauderdale FL 33312
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MlaMl-\)OQ(.,
Before me the undersigned authority personally appeared Alex Tukh as th
Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC the owner of a portion of and the contract purchaser of a portio
being first by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the
correct
r of Aventura Land Trust, LLC and
o th operty subject to the application, who
rpo s stated therein and that it is true and
Aiex Tukh rej t M nager and Authorized Signater
Aventura Land Trust, LLC and Aventur Trust 2, LLC
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME this<faay of ~, 2006,
My
,\\i1I"I, Alb .
~'-;'~>'.Y,P~;;\ Kyra arraCLn
g :":',t:~ ~ Commission # DD348962
~3;;','if7Expires: AUG, 22,2008
,;~ OF 1\.\).....
'1IIIlllll" WYo"v,',A.u..O\NOTAKY,com
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
8""',,"
',','-'. ,~.:. :'~', '
", " ,,~:='" ~ :~. "
'\ ,""i'
~<iff"'tP
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant 10 Seclion 31,71(b)(2)(ii) 01 the City of Avenlu," Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hemby discloses thaI:
(mark Wilh:"'7Iicable portions only)
~. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented,
[ J 2, Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(Ust City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves)
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows
(J i Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative:
[J ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[J iil The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board:
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
11 v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and lransacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
I] vi, The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the App!icant or Representatrve and transacts
more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
AND THIS 1 ~ DAY OF rIA.. 'y , 2006
By (Slgnalure)
Name: Yizhak Tal dana (Prinl)
Aventura Land Trust, LC and Avenlura Land Trust 2, LLC
r( DAY OF
-:Jv.J '/
,2006
PROPERTY OWNER:
By: (Slgnalure)
Name: Yizhak Toled no (Print)
Aventura Land Trust, L C and Aventura land Trust 2, llC
'The terms ~Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 oltne Avenlura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,4 7692825653
STATE Of FLORIDA ~
COUNTY OF &<1l1l,};t.(0\.
NOTARIZATION PROVISION
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Yizhak Toledano
executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me this:l<i day 01 ~,2006
Irs! by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she
~..".~ ALEXANDER TUKH
.." . "'" MYCOMMISSIONJIIDD552974
"'''i'QFf\.O'' EXPIRES: May 16, 2010
(407) 398.0153 Florida Noteiy Servictl.com
fr
NolaJ{~~~a'T'Q~~ Large
prinledNameolNotary~b ~b
My oommlSSlOn expires: J U
--..------------------- - --------------------."---------
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY Of
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Alex Tukh the Affiant who being first by me duly sworn. did swear or affirm that he/she executed
this Affidavit for the purposes staled therein and that il is true and correct
Alex Tukh, Project Manager
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006
Notary Public State of Florida AI Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires'
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-lJADE)
.----------------------..--------------.-------- -------------------------------------------------______._________h________________..~__________________.__
Before me, the undersigned authority, personaily appeared Stanlev B, Price
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
the Affiant. who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Slanley B. Price, Attorney
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006,
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
----------------------------- --------------------------...---------..-----------------------------_._-----------+_._-----._~--_.+------_._--------
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI'DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Brian S, Adler
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Brian S, Adler, Attorney
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006
Notary Public Slate of Florida At Large
MIAMI 1090272,4 7692825653
Printed Name of Notary
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuanlto Section 31-71(b)(2)(il) of the Clly of Avenlura Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses thai:
(mark with "x' applicable portions only)
p(1.
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City CommiSSion or any Cily Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
[ 12
Affianl hereby discloses that il does have a Business Relationship With a member of Ihe City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application wiIJ be presented, as follows:
(list name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves)
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i. Member ot City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess ot1 % of tolal assets or capilal stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[I ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co,shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
Iisled on any nalional or regional slock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[ ] iii The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv, A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v, The Applicant or Representative Is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[] vi The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Appllcanl or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representalive in a given calendar year
NDTHIS~AYOF ~,2006
By:
Name:
Tille:
xT h
Proiect Manaaer
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2006
PROPERTY OWNER
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
'The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of/he Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31'71(b)(2)(li) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that:
(mark with "x" applicable portions only)
~ 1, Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
I I 2. Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves),
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows
I I i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capitai stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[) ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
I I ili. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Ciient of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
I I iv, A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
I] v, The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
II vi,
The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
-HA
10 DAYOF~,2006
BY~
Name: Stanle Ice
Title: All
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicanl," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventure City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the CIty of Avenlura Land Development Code The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that:
(mark wIth 'x' applicable portions only)
)(1
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City AdvISory Board to which
the application will be presented,
[ ] 2,
Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as foliows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves)
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[] i, Member of CIty Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
I) ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co,sharehoider (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[ ] iii, The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the CIty Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative IS a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ I vi The member of the City CommiSSIon or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year,
~DAYOF~,2006.
,
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
rian S, Adler (Print)
Attornev (Print)
WiTNESS MY HAND THIS 7#loAY OF ~,2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
'The terms "Business Relationship, " "Client," "Cuslomer," "Applicanl," "Represenlalive" and "Inlerested Person" are defined in
Seclion 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31~71(b)(2)(ii) otthe City of Aventura Land Development Code The undersigned Affiant hereby dIScloses that
(mark With "x" applicable portions only)
[(-1'l Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented,
[ ] 2, Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City CommISsion or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves)
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[Ii
Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[]il,
Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co~shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are no!
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[]iil
The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[Iiv,
A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[Iv,
The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of the member ot the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year:
[]vl
The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer ot the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of Ihe Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
,DAY OF 0IA k.{ ,2006
WITNESS MY
By:
Name'
Title:
(Signature)
Anne Colle (Print)
Architect (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THiS ~ DAY OF ~,2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
'The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of/he Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.37692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
ThIS Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura Land Deveiopment Code The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that:
(mark with 'x" applicable portions only)
,~
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented
[ ) 2,
Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of, Commissioner or AdVISOry Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
Thenature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i Member of CBy Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
I] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v, The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member ot the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the bUSiness of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Appiicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given caiendar year,
,~
WITNESS MY HAND THIS ~ DAY OF ~,2006,
,dJ111/1-1~- (Signature)
Bernirdo Fort,Brescia (Pnnt)
Architect (Pnnt)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS L DAY oFJ\J. , '-I
PROPERTY OWNER:
II vi.
By:
Name'
Title:
,2006,
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692B25653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
ThIS Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31'71(b)(2)(Ii) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code,
(mark wlfh "x" applicabie portions only)
ri1
The undersigned Affrant hereby dIScloses that
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented
[ ] 2, Affiant hereby dIScloses that it does have a Business Reiatlonshlp with a member of the City Commission or a City AdVISory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves)
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows'
[ ] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of hIS or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ I VI The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,00000 of the business of the Applicant or Representative In a given calendar year
WITNESS MY HAND THIS li~~AY OF ~, 2006
, ('
BY~"-\V~~ (Signature)
Name: Dieoo Deioado (Pnnt)
Title: Assistant to Architect (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS ~DAY OF ~,2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title
(Signature)
(Print)
(Pnnt)
'The terms "Business Relationship, " "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "tnterested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 ofthe Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
."
"" ..
~~'~~
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71(b)(21(ii) of the City 01 Aventura Land Deveiopment Code The undersigned Affiant hereby disdoses that
(marl< with ',' applicable pMions only)
)<1.
Affiant does not have a Business Relationsnip with any member of the City Commission Of .any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
i ] 2,
Affiant hereby disdoses thai it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a Cily Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission 0' City Advisory Board upoll which member serves),
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership inleresl in excess of 1 % of totat assets or capital stock
of Applicant Of Representative;
[] iL Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
II IiI. The Applicant or Representative Is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or lor the same employer as the member 01 the City Commission or
Board;
[J iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[I v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board i or of hIS or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the bUSiness of the member of the City Commission or Board ior
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
f J vi The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25.000,00 of the IY.Jsiness of the Applicant or Representative In a given calendar year.
WiTNESS MY HAND THIS l12. DAY OF (77'; I;t--. 2006.
BY:~ L ~(SignaIUre)
Name: Cart Skiles (Print)
Title Enoineer (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS _ DAY OF
PROPERTY OWNER
,2006
By:
Name:
Tille:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The te!T1lS "Business Relationship,' "Client," .Cus/omer," "Applicant, " "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692825653
.'Zf~"~~.'
.E!il.",
I '
'\ .
o",;,}!9'
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit Is made pursuanl to Section 31-71(bX2)11i) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that:
(mark with 'x' applicable portions only)
vz
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
Affiant hereby discloses thai it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as foilows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List Cily Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves),
[ ) 2.
(Ii.
The nalure of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[Jit
[jiii,
Iliv,
I] v,
[Jvt
Member of City Ccmmission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1% of total assets or capital stock
of Applicanl or Representative;
Member of City Commlssioo or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporetion which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
busIness venture;
The Applicant or Representative Is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professionai working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
A City Commissioner or Board member Is a Client 01 the Applicant or Representative;
The Appllcanl or Representalive is a Cuslomer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more Ihan $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar ye""
rf DAY OF 1 fUY ,2006,
By: (SignatUle)
Name: Ti 01 um r (Print)
Tille: Traffic E 'eer (Print)
WITNESS MY NO THIS -=1- DAY OF ~ 20D6,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title:
(Slgneture)
(Print)
(Print)
'The terms "Business Relationship,' "Client,' "Customer,' 'Applicant,' "Representative' and 'Interested Person' are defined in
Seclfon 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MiAMI 1 090272,3 7692B25653
.
I
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that:
(mark with 'x' applicabte portions only)
111. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission Of any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented,
I 12. Affiant hereby discloses thaI it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(Ust City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[1 i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[I ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venlure;
[] Iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for Ihe same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v, The Applicant or Rep,esentative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[l vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS ~ DAY OF ~ '-' ''1 , 2006,
By', ~'\..-- /1~
l.Z. (Signature)
Name: Andrew Witkin (Print)
Title: LandscaDe Architect (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS 6 DAY OF ~,2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Pn'nt)
'The terms 'Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Appticant, , "Representative" and "tnterested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,2 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit IS made pursuant to Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) at the City at Aventura Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses thaI:
(mark with 'x' applicable portions only)
y~,
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any Cify Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
[ 12
Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Com"mission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(Ust City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves),
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1% of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
!) ii, Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
I] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client 01 a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[ ] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[I v, The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[J vi. The member of lhe City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representafive in a given calendar year,
By:
Name:
Title:
Jjjidl;i;"'"
LandscaDe Architect
,2006,
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
By;
Name.
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
'The tenns 'Business Relationship,' "Ctient, ' "Customer, ' "Applicant, ' 'Representative' and "Interested Person' are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692825653
STATE OF FLORIDA _^-'
COUNTY OF lA \/1M\~VVL
NOTARIZATION PROVISION
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Alex Tukh the Affiant, who being first y e uly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed
this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
anager and Authorized Signalor
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this (i!jay o~. 2006
"""1, K Alb .
$1."Y'!'~~-::, yr~, arracm
:: ': 'h,' : ':: CODllllllSIOn # 00348962
'~'A',F'~;~s' AUG "2()"
~~~"""~..'" .....1"....... . , "., 'VQ
...., OF f\: ..," I\.~ N'
J'IIIIII" WWW..n..t\1tOl..OTrn.com
___________________________n__.____________________________________________________.___.__________________________________.__.____..___________________________________.__
arge
Printed Name of Notal)'
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA --oodc-
COUNTY OF tv\\OM \
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared
this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
y me d y sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me this c.May of 1\4.. \ -t-, 2006,
'e t Manager
,"~ii'" "" Alb
/~~~,~,~~\ I\yrl! mad.!!
~ ~:ji ':~YOmJllission # 00348962
'.>_J'~: t:,:'J::--OS: AtiG. '2,20C8
lLarge
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires'
----------------------..--------------------------------------------..------------------------------._-_._-----------------------._-.--..._----------------------..-.+------------------------.....+.-------------------------..-
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Stanlev B. Price
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and corre
~~:~~r~:u~> Kyra Albarracin
i';,'d1".f;~ Commission # 00348962
\~:,,~'iJ Expires: AUG, 22, 2008
--':1> 'p' <1'-
"'1 OF f\\,," """-w AARosNOTAR'f,ccm
'1Iut\ "",
the Affian
rst by me duly sworn, did swear or
,~
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this 10 day of ~, 2006,
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
_________________________._.+..__h________________________._..___________________________.._hh___________________.._..h_________________________....._____________________...._______________________._.._..._______________
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADEJ
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Brian S. Adler the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affirm that he/she executed thIS Affidavit for the purposes staled therein and Ihat It Is true an~~ ~
Brian S, Adler, Atlo
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me Ihls ~ Of~, 2006, //
~\,'"11111
~--;'~!!:Y",~{<;. Kyra Albarracin
~;~ 'd1' ,::Fommission # 00348962
'-:1.J!!!?;,P/ ExPlr!S: AUG 22 2008 Pr/nled Name of Notary
" OF f\.V...... 'l
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653 .",,,,,,,, \\Wvd,'JIO\NOHRl',com
STATE OF FlORIOA )
COUNTY OF MtAMI,DADE)
---
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this ~ day of ,J U L'1 ,2006,
~l ~
N~PUbllc State OfFIO~
Lt' C_iA ' ;;V
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Anne Cotter
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMt,DAD
NclaIy Public, SlIItol.....
'j MyComm~,'on~JuI1._
, .' ,,,,,,,-c_.-oD-4q111,,,,m
,....... _8,_ Ala
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Bernardo Fort-Brescia the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affirm that he/she executed this Affida~1 for thepurposes staled therein and that iUs tr.ue and correct
/
'-
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this G, day of ~, 2006
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMt,DA
.1.~~;;;::S:~,~,
. fF../ Comm~"'n'DD448111
,w.:.~..." Bonded By National Ala
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Dleoo Delqado
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes staled therein and that it is true and correct.
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Diego De~ado, Assistant to Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Carl Skiles
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Carl Skiles, Engineer
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me thIS _ day of
,2006
Notary Public Stale of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
My commission expires:
STATE OFFLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Anne Cotte;
afflrm that he/she executed this Affidalfit for the purposes stated therein and that It Is true and correcL
the Afflan~ who beil)J first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Anne Cotter, Arc1ilect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day 01
,2006,
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Ponted Nam<l 01 Nolary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA I
CDUNTY OF MIAMI,DAOE)
Before me, the undel'5igned authority, pel'5onally appeared Bernardo Fort-Brescia the Affiant. who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes slated therein and that it is true and correct.
Bernardo Fort-Brescia, ArchHect
SWORN TOAND SUBSCRIBED belore me Ihis _ day 01
,2006,
Notary Pu;,lic Slate of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF flORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI'DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Dieao DekJedo
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and l1at It Is true and correct
..".....
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
,-
~~
Un,~
N91a!YPUbl~StateofFl~~
rf.l Z':r:, J\
Printed1fame of Notary . ' I" ~
My commission expires: -1, 1 ' 0'0
SWORNTOANDSUBSCRIBEDbefOremethis~daYOI::J \A ,-'-12006,
o,AssistanttoArchitect
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the unde~igned authority, personally appeared Carl Skiles
affirm thaI he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it Is true and correct.
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Carl SkDes. Engineer
SWORN TO AND SUBSCR1BED before me this _ day of
2006,
Nolary Public State of Flooda At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
MiAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
My commission e)';plres
STATE OF FLORIOA I
COUNTY OF MIAMl,DADEj
Before me, !he unde~igned authority, perwnally appeared Anne Colter
affirm that helshe executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and thaI n is true and correct.
the Affiant. who being firsl by me duly sworn, did swear or
Anne Coner, Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day 01
,2000,
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name or Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA I
COUNTY' OF MIAMl-OADE}
Before me. the unaersignecl authority, personally appeared 01800 DekJado
affirm that helshe executecl1hls Afficlavit for the purposes stated therein and that ~ is true and correct.
the Affiant wtlO being first by me duly sworn, dkl swear or
Diego Dei:)ado, Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me tllis _ day 01'
,2006,
Notary Public State of Floooa At Large
Printed Name 01 Notary
My commission expires.
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADEj
Before me, the undersigned authority, pelSonal1y appeared Car1 Skiles
affirm that heJshe executed this Affidavit for the purposes staled therein and tllal it is true and correct.
.'l,/\.,i....~V'...)',,.I"V~.I
,"""" SUSA.'\!P,KAY
':" "~t<J.~i'" MYCOMM1SSION#DD307184
;; ",}1~t'!J,,"1 F..XPIRE.-'l: April 06, 2008
~ I"'~,~~,f~~i~."n FI NOlaf)'DisCQllIlIAssoc. Co.
!."'.J"\/l'<^"'of..~,~vv~
SWORNTOANDSUBSCRIBEDbelDremelhis 10 daYOIJO 1 ,2006
Printed Name of Notary
My commiSsior) expir6$;
STATE OF FLORIDA I
COUNTY OF MIAMl,DADEj
Before me, the undersigned authority, pelSOllaUy appeared Tilrothv Plummer
affirm that he/she executed this- AffIdavit for the purposes s1ated therein and thai ~ is true and correct.
ttle Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, d~ swear or
Timolt1y Plummer, Traffic Engineer
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ d'y of
,2006,
Notary Publ!: Stale of FloriOa Alla'1le
Printed Name of Notary
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692825653
STATE Of FLORIDA }
, COONTY Of MIAMI,OADE)
Belore me, the unde~~ned authorly, personally appeared TI""thv Plummer
aflirm 1hat he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that Ills true and co
STATE OF FLORIDA I
COUNTY OF M~MI,OADE}
Before me, the undersigned authority, personalty appeared AndrelN Witkin
affirm that tleIshe executed this Affldavit for the purposes staled therein and that Itls true and correct
the Affiant who beIng first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Andrew Wilkin, Larxlscape Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me this _ day of
2006,
Nola~ Pu~ic State of Florida At Large
Printed Narre of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE 0" FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, per.;onally appeared Kellv Hults
affirm that helshe executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein 800 that it Is true and correct.
the Affiant who being first by me duly sworn, dll swear or
Kal~ Hulls, Landscape Arch,ect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before mathis _ day of
2006,
Nola~ Pu~lc Slate of Florida At Large
Pnoted Name of Notary
My commlsskm expires:
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-OADE)
Before me, the undersigned auttlOrity, personally appeared Andrew Witkin the Affiant who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affirm thaI he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and corr~ect,
1t::-1 .--' --
-----.,
rew Witkin, Landscape Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this -.2day o~, 2006,
/*~,ml!iJ:, NERISSA M, MCCLUNG ~1.
,', ,0; MY COMMISSION # 00 534728
';'fi,...." '?} EXPIRES: March 30, 2010
"",9f"r,-~ BondedThruNotaryPublicUnderwrilers .
- ~
c A~
Notary Pubbc Stale of Flo(id~ At Large \. L _
t-..lL>v\SS.A '"^"" CLV""",
Printed Name of Notary
fvty commission expires: 5 . 3t> . 2.. 0 0 ~
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI'DADE)
Before me, the unders~ned aulhority, personally appeared KeH Hulls
affirm that heJshe executed this Affidavit for the purposes staled therein and that it is true and correct
Kelly ults, Landsc Architect
SWORNTOAND SUBSCRIBED befOremethis2daYOf~ !OO~
N~ry pu~~e otFlorida At Larg~
:e.-V\ ~ ^) "-C",[ .
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires: ~~~ ...20\C .
"""~';"'"
''il:,r...~,
h' ',:~
";'. :"'>:
-;"" ,.,!!,>;::
~"~'Rf,~*~'
NERISSA M, MCCLUNG
MY COMMISSION # DO 534728
EXPIRES: March 30, 2010
BondedThruNotarypubllOUnderwrtters
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692825653
ORDINANCE NO. 2006-
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE COMPREHENSIVE MASTER PLAN BY
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP
DESIGNATION FOR PROPERTY LOCATED ON NE 207
STREET AT NE 30 AVENUE, MORE PARTICULARLY
DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT "A", FROM BUSINESS AND
OFFICE TO MEDIUM HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL;
PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL TO THE AGENCIES AS
REQUIRED UNDER CHAPTER 163, PART II, FLORIDA
STATUTES; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
WHEREAS, the Department of Community Affairs of the State of Florida found in
compliance the City of Aventura Comprehensive Plan (the "Plan") in February 1999; and
WHEREAS, the Future Land Use Map of the Plan designated the subject property
Business and Office; and
WHEREAS, the owner has made application to the City to change the land use
designation from Business and Office to Medium High Density Residential; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission agreed to approve a residential zoning
designation on the subject property, conditioned upon the acceptance of a Plan
amendment; and
WHEREAS, the Plan amendment will not result in impacts on any infrastructure
system that will exceed established level of service standards and is otherwise
consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the Plan; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission believes it is in the best interest of the public to
amend the future land use map designation on the subject property from Business and
Office to Medium High Density Residential; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission believes the amendment will maintain the
unique aesthetic character of the City,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. PurDose. This Ordinance is intended to preserve the unique
aesthetic character of the City and ensure that adjacent land uses are compatible, It is
further intended to protect property values, create a better business climate, enhance
the physical appearance of the community and preserve the natural beauty of the City,
Section 2. Amendment of Future Land Use MaD Desianation. The future
land use map designation of the parcel of land situate on NE 207 Street at NE 30
Avenue more particularly described in Exhibit "A" to this ordinance, totaling 3.359 acres
acres and having folio numbers as listed on Exhibit "B" to this ordinance is hereby
changed from Business and Office to Medium High Density Residential.
Section 3. Severability, The provisions of this Ordinance are declared to be
severable and if any section, sentence, clause or phrase of this Ordinance shall for any
reason be held to be invalid or unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the
validity of the remaining sections, sentences, clauses, and phrases of this Ordinance
but they shall remain in effect, it being the legislative intent that this Ordinance shall
stand notwithstanding the invalidity of any part.
Section 4. Inclusion in the ComDrehensive Plan. It is the intention of the
City Commission and it is hereby ordained that the provisions of this Ordinance shall
become and made a part of the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Aventura and that
2
the Future Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan may be revised so as to
accomplish such intentions.
Section 5. Transmittal. The City Clerk is directed to transmit the amendment
to the State of Florida Department of Community Affairs and other agencies as
provided under Chapter 163, Part II of the Florida Statutes.
Section 6. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective pursuant to
Chapter 163 of the Florida Statutes.
The foregoing Ordinance was offered by Commissioner ,
who moved its adoption on first reading. This motion was seconded by Commissioner
and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Michael Stern
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
The foregoing Ordinance was offered by Commissioner ,
who moved its adoption on second reading. This motion was seconded by
Commissioner and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as
follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Michael Stern
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
PASSED on first reading on this 1ih day of September, 2006.
3
PASSED AND ADOPTED on this 3rd day of October, 2006,
Susan Gottlieb, Mayor
ATTEST:
TERESA M, SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICI~CY:
CITYATTOt:;t~ ~
4
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
All of Lots 7 through 13, 38 through 42 and a portion of Lots 14, 33 through 37, all of Block 18,
HALLANDALE PARK No.8, including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots, lying within said Block 18.
as recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, All of Tract 1, LAURANNA, os recorded in Plat Book 76 at Page
31. All of Lots 1, 2, 6 thraugh 13, 38 through 42 and 0 portion of Lots 14 and 37, all of Block 17,
HALLANDALE PARK No.8. including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots in Block 17. os recorded
in Plot Book 20 at Page 49, Tract I, Block 17, REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK No, 8, as
recorded in Plat Book 40 at Page 97, That portion of the North One-half of N,E, 205th street abandoned
by Resolution No, 2000-11 recorded in OR,B, 19247 at Page 4677, That portion of N,E, 206th Street
bounded on the North by Block 18 and bounded on the South by Block 17 and bounded on the East by
the West right-ot-way line of N.E. 30th Avenue (East Dixie Highway) all being os shown on HALLANOALE
PARK No, 8, os recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, A portion of land bounded by on the North by a
line 81.00 feet South of and parallel or concentric with the North line of Waterways Boulevard as shown on
AVENTURA CORPORATE CENTER, as recorded in Plot Book 158, Page 47, and bounded on the South by the
North line of Block 18, HALLANDALE PARK NO, 8, os recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, all the above
plats being of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County. Florida, lying and being in the City of Aventura
and being more particularly described as follows:
Commence at the intersection of the centerline of N.E. 205th Street and the centerline of N.E. 30th Avenue,
both as shown on said PLAT OF HALLANDALE PARK NO, 8; thence North 89"53'41" West along said centerline
of N.E. 205 Street for 35.01 feet to the Point of Beginning of the hereinafter described parcel of land;
thence continue North 89"53'41" West along said centerline for 261.97 feet; thence North 00.00'00" East for
422,33 feet; thence North 90.00'00" West for 119,97 feet; thence North 00.00'00" East for 135,92 feet;
thence South 76"00'36" East along a line 81.00 feet South of and parallel with North right-of-way line of
Waterways Boulevard for 86.13 feet to a point of curvature; thence Southeasterly along a 1519.00 foot
radius curve leading to the left through a central angle of 7"37'02" for an arc distance of 201.94 feet;
thence South 00"52'30" East along a line 10.00 feet East of 0 10.00 foot alley adjacent to said Lot 42,
Block 18 of HALLANOALE PARK NO.8 for 8.92 feet to the Northwest corner of said Tract 1 of LAURANNA;
thence South 89"50'24" East along the North line of said Tract 1 for 70.42 feet to a point of curvature;
thence Southeasterly along a 25.00 foot radius curve leading to the right through 0 central angle of
88'57'54" for an arc of 38.82 feet to a point of tangency; thence South 00"52'30" East along the East line
of said Tract 1 for 122.65 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; thence South 89'51 '49" East along the
North line of said Lot 7, Block 18 HALLANDALE PARK NO, 8 for 5,00 feet to the Northeast carner thereof;
thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line of said Lots 7 and 8, Block 18 and the Southerly
extension thereof for 164.42 feet to the Southeast corner of said Lot 2, Block 17 of HALLANDALE PARK NO.
8; thence North 89'52'27" West along the South line of said Lot 2, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the Northeast
corner of said Tract 1 of REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK NO, 8; thence South 00.52'30 East
along the East line of said Tract 1 far 75.01 feet ta the Southeast corner thereof; Thence South 89'53'04"
East along the North line of said Lot 6, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the northeast corner of said Lot 6;
thence South 00.52'30" East along the East line of said Lots 6, 7 & 8, Block 17 for 56,77 feet to 0 point
of curvature; thence Southwesterly along a 25.00 foot radius curve leading to the right through a central
angle of 36"52'05" for an arc of 16.09 feet; thence South 00"52'30" East along a line 35.00 feet West of
and parallel to the center line of said NE 30th Avenue for 35.35 feet to the Point of Beginning.
<,:'c No, 2006-
Fls Job No, 20061117
Folio numbers
28-1234-006-4610
28-1234-006-4810
28-1234-006-4590
28-1234-006-4580
28-1234-006-4570
28-1234-006-4560
28-1234-006-4550
28-2203-021-0010
28-1234-006-4530
28-1234-006-4540
28-1234-006-4420
28-1234-006-4430
28-1234-006-4440
28-1234-006-4450
28-1234-006-4460
28-1234-006-4470
28-1234-006-4210
28-1234-006-4220
28-1234-007-0031
28-1234-007-0030
28-1234-006-4230
28-1234-006-4240
28-1234-006-4250
28-1234-006-4290
28-1234-006-4280
28-1234-006-4270
28-1234-006-4260
CITY OF AVENTURA
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO: City Commission
FROM: Eric M, Soroka, ICMA-CM
City Manager
BY: Joanne Carr, AICFt\ /"
Planning Director ~
DATE: August 17, 2006
SUBJECT: Amendment of the Official Zoning Map of the City of Aventura by
amending the zoning designation for a parcel of land on NE 207 Street at
NE 30 Avenue totaling 3.359 acres from B2, Community Business District,
to RMF3A, Multifamily Medium Density Residential District. (01-REZ-06)
September 12, 2006 Local Planning Agency Agenda Itemt~,I~
September 12, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item 1B
October 3, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission approve an amendment of the Official
Zoning Map of the City of Aventura by amending the zoning designation for a parcel of
land on NE 207 Street at NE 30 Avenue totaling 3.359 acres from B2, Community
Business District to RMF3A, Multifamily Medium Density Residential District, upon
acceptance of the applicant's proffered covenant to restrict density on the parcel to no
more than 31 dwelling units per gross acre.
THE REQUEST
The applicant is requesting an amendment to the Official Zoning Map to change the
zoning designation of a parcel of land on NE 207 Street at the corner of NE 30 Avenue
totaling 3.359 acres from B2 (Community Business District) to RMF3A (Multi-family
Medium Density Residential District), (See Exhibit #1 for Letter of Intent)
The current landholding of the applicant is 5.932 acres. The total development site
area will be 7,39 acres if the City Commission approves the applicant's request for
abandonment of 1.459 acres of unopened right of way of NE 206 Street, part of the
unopened right of way of NE 207 Street and two 10 foot unopened alleyways on the
plats, This abandonment request will be presented to the City Commission concurrent
with second reading of the rezoning ordinance. The 3.359 acres subject of this rezoning
request includes part of the unopened road reservations. The remaining 4,032 acres
will remain in the B2 (Community Business) zoning district
The RMF3A zoning district allows a maximum of 45 dwelling units per gross acre which
would allow 3.359 acres x 45 dua or 151 units. The proposed plan shows 104
residential units on this site. The applicant has proffered a covenant, as part of the
rezoning request, restricting the density on this parcel to no more than 31 dwelling units
per gross acre. This density restriction will permit a maximum of 104 dwelling units.
BACKGROUND
OWNER OF PROPERTY
Aventura Land Trust, LLC
Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
NAME OF APPLICANT
Aventura Land Trust, LLC
Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
LOCATION OF PROPERTY
NE 207 Street at NE 30 Avenue
See Exhibit #2 for Location Map
SIZE OF PROPERTY
Approximately 3,359 acres subject of rezoning
request (total landholding is 7.391 acres
including 1.459 acres of unopened rights of
way requested to be abandoned)
DESCRIPTION IBACKGROUND
The site owned by the applicant is comprised of seventy-seven platted lots in Blocks 17
and 18 of the Hallandale Park No, 8 plat, Tract 1 on the plat of Lauranna and Tract 1 on
a replat of Hallandale Park NO.8, The landholding referred to in this report also
includes the unopened platted right of way of NE 206 Street, part of the unopened
platted right of way of NE 207 Street and two 10 foot unopened platted alleyways which
are subject of an abandonment request
The site is currently zoned B2 (Community Business District) on the City's Official
Zoning Map, The northerly half of the land is vacant and is currently being cleared and
filled under a DERM wetlands permit The southerly half of the site is the former
playground area for the Aventura Turnberry Jewish Center.
2
The applicant wishes to change the zoning designation on the easterly portion of the
site comprising 3.359 acres from B2 (Community Business District) to RMF3A (Multi-
family Medium Density Residential District). The area to be redesignated is shown on
Exhibit #3. The proposed development includes 36 town homes and 68 loft style
condominium units on this easterly portion. A hotel, office building and parking
structure are proposed on the westerly portion of the site which will retain its B2 zoning
designation,
ANALYSIS
Future land Use Designation
Subject Property:
Properties to the North:
Properties to the South:
Properties to the East:
Properties to the West:
Zoning
Subject Property:
Properties to the North:
Properties to the South:
Properties to the East:
Properties to the West:
Existing land Use
Subject property:
Properties to the North:
Properties to the South:
Properties to the East:
Properties to the West:
Business and Office
Business and Office
Business and Office
Medium High Density Residential
Business and Office
B2, Community Business District
OP, Office Park District
CF, Community Facilities District
RMF3, Multi-Family Medium Density Residential
District
B2, Community Business District
vacant, under DERM fill and clear permit
and playgroundlball field
office
religious facility and school
residential
retail plaza
Access - The parcel is bounded by NE 207 Street to the north, NE 30 Avenue to the
east and NE 29 Avenue to the west. Access is proposed from both NE 29 and NE 30
Avenues.
Conformity to City Comprehensive Plan - The proposed amendment to the Official
Zoning Map will conform to the City Comprehensive Plan upon approval of the
concurrent Comprehensive Plan amendment to change the land use designation on
this parcel from Business and Office to Medium High Density Residential.
Standards for reviewing proposed amendments to the Official Zoning Map found
in Section 31-77 ofthe land Development Regulations:
3
1, Whether or not the proposed amendment is consistent with goals, objectives and
policies of the City's Comprehensive Plan.
The proposed amendment will be consistent with goals, objectives and policies of
the City's Comprehensive Plan provided the City Commission approves an
amendment to the land use designation for this parcel from Business and Office to
Medium High Density Residential.
2. Whether or not the proposed zoning district is compatible with the surrounding
area's zoning designation(s) and existing uses,
The proposed zoning district is compatible with the surrounding area's zoning
designation(s) and existing uses.
3, Whether or not the subject property is physically suitable for the uses permitted in
the proposed district.
The subject property is physically suitable for the uses permitted in the proposed
district
4, Whether or not there are sites available in other areas currently zoned for such use.
There are no other sites available in other areas currently zoned for such use. The
other properties currently zoned RMF3A are developed,
5. If applicable, whether or not the proposed change will contribute to redevelopment
of an area in accordance with an approved redevelopment plan.
This standard is not applicable to this proposed amendment
6. Whether or not the proposed change would adversely affect traffic patterns or
congestion.
The traffic generation table provided later in this report supports the proposed
amendment in that a decreased projected vehicle trips per day enhances the
provision of traffic services.
7. Whether or not the proposed change would adversely impact population density
such that the demand for water, sewers, streets, recreational areas and facilities,
and other public facilities and services would be adversely affected.
A calculation of the impact on population density is shown in the table below.
4
Properly Lot Size Increase in Population Overall Increase
Location Densitv Factor in PODulation
NE 207 Street at 3.359 ae 31 du/ae 1.79 187 persons
NE 30 Avenue (density
limited by
covenant\
The proposed change would not adversely affect population density such that the
demand for water, sewers, streets, and other public facilities and services would be
adversely affected, The proposed residential use of this property will decrease the
demand for water, sewer, streets and other public facilities as compared to the
presently permitted commercial uses.
1. Whether or note the proposed change would have an adverse environmental impact
on the vicinity.
The proposed change will not have an adverse environmental impact on the vicinity.
2. Whether or not the proposed change would adversely affect the health, safety, and
welfare of the neighborhood or the City as a whole.
The proposed change will not adversely affect the health, safety, and welfare of the
neighborhood or the City as a whole,
Traffic Generation - The applicant's traffic engineers have prepared traffic generation
information relative to existing permitted land uses and the proposed amendment The
letter dated August 8, 2006 prepared by David Plummer & Associates is attached as
Exhibit #4.
Applications Land Use Daily Trips AM Peak PM Peak
Area Category HourTrips Hour Trips
(3.359 acresl
Existing Land Use Business & Office 2,594 365 351
Desianation lall office use)
Proposed Land Medium High 664 53 62
Use Designation Density
Residential
As can be seen from the table above, the proposed residential use generates
approximately 75% less daily vehicular trips and when compared to the am peak and
pm peak hours, generates approximately 82% to 85% less trips, thereby resulting in
significantly less impact on the City's road network as compared to the existing
permitted use in the B2 zoning district
5
School Impacts - The application has been provided for comment to the Miami Dade
County School Board in accordance with the Interlocal Agreement entered into between
the City and the Board in February of 2003. Also in accordance with the lnterlocal
Agreement, the School Board has been invited as a non-voting member of the Local
Planning Agency for this application.
The Interlocal Agreement provides that the School Board must first advise what options
it has identified to meet the anticipated demand and, then, if the affected schools are at
more than 115% capacity, the School Board will ask the applicant and the City to meet
with it in a collaboration meeting to discuss additional options to relieve overcrowding,
The School Board's letter of August 17, 2006 is attached as Exhibit #5, It notes that the
public elementary, middle and high schools affected by this development are currently
operating at 117%, 191 % and 152% respectively of FISH capacity and that the
proposed development will increase the capacity in the elementary and high school to
119% and 153% respectively. The analysis depicts the relief schools planned in the
area pursuant to the approved 5 year work plan and includes a list of approved Charter
Schools which may also provide capacity relief, The analysis also estimates impact
fees payable if the new Educational Facilities Impact Fee Ordinance is approved. The
Board's recommendation is that the applicant, the City and the School Board meet to
discuss options and alternatives. This meeting will be scheduled and results will be
reported at the first reading hearing,
The proposed residential uses on this site will more compatibly support the Aventura
City of Excellence School versus the commercial uses presently allowed,
6
~ Bilzin Sumberg
ATTORNEYS AT L!~W
~1\tJ
cJ-~U
avyf
/'lil:?-.
, ~'EIVtD
JlJL It
COMMUNITY 2006
DEVElOPMfNl
Brian $, Adler, Esquire
Direct Dial: (305) 350-2351
Direct Fax: (305) 351-2206
Email: badJer@bilzin.com
July 10, 2006
VIA HAND-DELIVERY
Joanne Carr
City of Aventura
Government Center
19200 W, Country Club Drive, 4th Floor
Aventura, Florida 33180
Exhibit 1
01-REZ-06
Re: Aventura Grand
Public Hearing Application for Rezoning
Property located at SW Corner of NE 30th Avenue and Waterways Boulevard
("Property")
Dear Ms, Carr:
LETTER OF INTENT
Please consider this our formal letter of intent in connection with an application to rezone
the Property, This firm represents Aventura Land Trust, LLC as the owner of a portion of the
property and Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC as contract purchaser of a portion of the property
(collectively "Aventura Land Trust"), The Property is presently zoned B2,
The Property is located at the southwest corner of NE 30th Avenue and Waterways
Boulevard, Our client has acquired a portion of the subject property and is under contract, under a
related entity, to purchase the remaining portion of the site that is bounded between NE 29th
Avenue and NE 30th Avenue, lying north of the Aventura Jewish Center and south of Waterways
Boulevard,
Aventura Land Trust proposes to develop the Property with an overall mixed use
development consisting of residential, retail, office and a hotel. In that regard, the current City of
Aventura zoning on the Property does not allow the development as proposed without rezoning a
portion of the property to residential. In that regard, please consider this our request to rezone the
property from B2 to RMF3A.
Aventura Land Trust is applying to rezone the eastern portion of the proposed
development to residential. This proposed development has been designed such that the
proposed area to be rezoned residential is located across NE 30th Avenue from an existing
residential community, and diagonal to Aventura Lakes, which also is a residential development
The proposed residential component of the project will be an excellent transitional use to the lands
BILZIN SUMBERG BAENA PRICE & AXELROD LLP
200 S. Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 2500, Miami, FL 33131-5340 Tei 305.374.7580 Fax 305.374.7593
MIAMI I 103407,) 7692825653
Joanne Carr
July 10, 2006
Page 2
to the east and northeast The site plans further provides for intensifying uses from the residential
uses on the east to the hotel and office use to the west
Development of the proposed residential and commercial areas will require Administrative
Site Plan Review and Approval, which the applicant anticipates filing within the upcoming weeks,
The proposed development represents several months of planning with Arquitectonica, to
design a development that is not only well designed within the project, but integrates with the
neighboring residential, commercial and office developments,
Our client is excited to bring this project to the City of Aventura and respectfully requests
the City's recommendation of approval in connection with the above application,
Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at 305-350-2351,
Very truly yours,
~~~,
BSA/ka
Attachment
~,
MIAMI I 103407,1 7692825653
BILZIN SUMBERG BAENA PRICE & AXELROD LLP
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.>.. .
!{ .
/!J :
:<: .
g .
" .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
33180 .'
.
-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-"
' 185ST 33 60'
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.~~"........... . . co . . . . . . . . . ,/
._f:~/,
.,~~, :-.:;;,~~;;~
.
.,c_
..'iV1t'1
+,,-
+>i"
.
.t~",
.
.
',-: .+
c:.. .
. .'
'" '
BROWARD COUNTY
..---.----
DADE COUNTY
IVES DAIRY RD,
>'
~
:r:
W
X
is
s:
MIAMI
GARDENS DR
:.
;.
:'
'.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:.
;.
:'
'.
:.
:.
;.
'.
:.
:.
:.
'.
;.
:.
'.
:.
:.
;.
:'
:.
:'
:.
:.
:.
'.
:.
:.
;.
:.
:'
:'
'.
;.
:.
:.
:.
:.
:'
'.
:.
:.
;-
'.
:'-
_//)
/
'W
~
'" ,I .q-
, '"
WATERWAYS JL~~J
An'II/UUI
liosp/wl
& Medical lit
CCII/('/" l.l.J
C]f
cJ
!:}
Qj
w
~
The re
Promenade
Shops
203 ST
\
SITE
Waterways
Shoppes
207 ST
COUNTRY CLUB DR,
L
10'l
N
201 TER
a:
o
CO
:::0
-"
Cl
>-
a:
>-
z
:::0
o
Cl
Turnberry Isle
Resort & Club
J!
-,,"y,
AVENTURA ,,\.\I\)'
Fire fl D
Rescue Aventura
Station Library
()""
,,',r.y'
Aventura Mall
192 ST
191 ST
'C::>
190 ST
Loehmann's
Fashion u..i
Island ~
'"
N
188 ST
Little
Maule
Lake
183 ST
Dumfoundling
Bay
Maule
Lake
Exhibit 2
01-REZ-06
192 ST
LEGEND
--
r~
. ( U
.
ci
::;
co
z
<<
w
Cl
o
~
-'
CO
;Z
iJj
o
o
Atlantic
Ocean
o
Roadways
City Boundary
ZIP Code Boundary
Railroad
EXHIBIT "A"
Exhibit 3
01-REZ-06
'"
0'
~
~
$
g
~
C<J'
::::"
"-
~
~
~
~
~
~
oS::
>S
~
Qj
WA/€Rw:
Jc\ Ys
CENTER OF
SECTION
eOUL€VARD
NE 207th STREE
UJ UJ
:J :J
Z Z
UJ UJ
> >
<( NE STREET <(
.l: .l:
-
OJ ....
0
C\J C')
G UJ UJ
Z Z
NE 205th STREET
SITE
LOCATION SKETCH
SCALE: 1" = 200'
~
Drawn By GEM
Cad. No. 061310
ef. Dwg.
2006-082-1
( SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION I
FORTIN, LEAVY, SKILES, INe.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS & MAPPERS
FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUI'HORlZA nON NUMBER: ??oo3653
180 Northeast 168th Street / North Miami Beach, Florida 33162
Phone 305-653-4493 / Fax 305-651.71521 Em.ai1 fls@t1ssurvey.com
Date 7/7/06
Scale 1" = 200'
Job. No_ 061310
Dwg. No. 1006-143-1
Plotted: 7/7/06 4:09p
Sheet 2 of 3
:.::",,-::~ - /
L1"'O'W".""'"
.0.."'''"0
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
'-
EXHIBIT "A"
--
;E~:~::;::== - -j_ _ _ __
-------- ---
\ _ ------ $':0
I I/'- _ W47"E ------ _ ~~1
~ r6 I - - "W"l,,,,,,S ~
1'!!!~11 - SOUl..
-, ~V4"
/ L_ S16 0
~ ~ ------- .~
ii 1 IiI ~:"~:~~:,~
S I S I N~07th STREET "',.
II W ~ 'll i (ROSElAND BOULEVARD) __
~~I~! I" -I-l'-f;~~~f. 1 rl..~~.a~~}G~j,: I'W:~: I ;;:~;:"~~~~,
~l!, :~! II ~ 1 ~ I " I ~ 1 " 1 " 1 " I ~ I " I " I " I " I " I ~ I "I ., II ~!,
.1 II '-, l ~",..- I-~" ~
'ml';:::~=II=~~=~=l=~=}l~T~I~'l" rL-ll'= IT' =11=ifr'i; i ='~!i II II; I! i I
1 : I I ~~~~~~~}O~ge I 'I I L~~;~', C~~~". ~i~ ~l I ~u
I " I "! ~ I ~ I "1,, 1 " I " 'I " I " I " I" I " I " 'I " 'I "I . I I - - -:--,' ,^ .,^ I ii,':
I ~ I I I I 7 S89S\i;9 ...~. ....;.r.... ~ii
I I \ 1 ~J L ! 1 LJ LJ' I LJ LJ :.",,-1 ~;~;,"~:::;:::' ,I~il
I I '--..l_ _ ~_ _ _ _1. _ _'t'.J L ;;::'=" kil I
I Hi r'~'''''''' r"""."" 1" ",dil I
i1.._ _~'__""m _ --'0. ....L ~f'"'''''.''' _II ~ ~~~.. ~
,,1 SI NE 206th STREET S w !~i~ I
<hi l-"l-rl-T~r~,~..'C~F"l~ -T 'l-I'-'l r-' -- ~ !!3'1
~!;k:ZJ:,,/ I I I I ~I H ~'i?s:id~~~~E:.:~~::~ :.:;. ;.::.1
~1!lw I ~ 1 "I" I" I" 1 "I" I" I ~ I" I ~ 1":1 ,;t:T,:~':oI~~i"" _~--':.. -'1-"
II o. I ' I , I I I I- """'",_,, , """'"'
I~. L 11i"LJ 1 11"..1, Jw,,,J .l I J 'I I 1 Ill:: II """~,~. ,.,,,
I~! _~! - :::!~.'~:='t:::r~~.l_I_ iLL __It.J I ~~1'!l' :,;.. l,1
Ir '-I'r1-.:r ~:T-[l-T-I-- 'J-T-[-rTi)-"', ,;, '"'0" ~II
: wL : p~~..g~~}G~: I i ":K~:;'~:~:;:'~.:;;!~" J( ~:;o;';:~,~ ~;; 11:
I Z I" I "! ~ I "1 " 1 "I "I "II "I "I "I" 1 "I "I " I "I . I ~ -----d;", ml II
",.,. ....,. I I I 11-"'''''7 5e.n I
:.' '-\J_LJ LJ_l_LJ_LJ[~ LJ_LJ_LJ C'~~~H:
I 1 ~ S00'52'3O"E
"I rC'""A"~"" "I """.""'0' ,
II.. LN""~"".'" II I "..,,,"" ""Ef" . '."W 1 T
I -~I NE 205111 STREETrSc>JS"'G'<l.O'-W""~<C'" S """'.OF.",VV'O"'OOY"''''''c'',,,,,,,, >0>''''''
L. ll~ _o.w.i -L~~,"p:~~T:"""T II r 1 ""fWROEO,"O.,'"'''."'''''''''
,--;:,::::,~<w;~.~I- z":;.~ - - - ~"~"::;o;::t;::-'" - - - - - - - - - - --
"'-""C<O><"'.."El. I llli'll --,. d:~~~:::.. "'''0000< ,,,.p,,,,,,, I
~~ =Pl' ~T
~,== ~~ ii-r.~:~P~IC:~~:~~Ub::r
!ii ~ ~o 'I'
~ (INFEET)
1 inch'" 100 ft
AVENTURA GORPORATE CENTER
PERPLATBOOK158,PAGE47
--
"
I
","./'0 ",.,.
....:="~,. ....,:,..-:...
I
I
I
:;:;::01
I
I
I
t
I""./W ""/W
....:.:"~"'. ""..:':...
Drawn By GEM r SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION 1 Date 7/7/06
Cad. No, 061310 FORTIN, LEAVY, SKILES, Scale 1" ~ 100'
INe.
Ref, Dwg. 2006-082-1 CONSULTING ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS & MAPPERS 'Job. No 061310
FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NUMBER: ??oo3653 IDwg No. 1006-143-1
180 Northeast 168th Street /North Miami Beach, Florida 33162 lSheet
Plotted: 7/7/06 4:09p Phone 305-653-4493 I Fax 305-651-7152 I Email fls@flssurvcy.com 3 01 3
RECEIVED
JUL 1 1 2006
co
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
All of Lots 7 through 13, 38 through 42 and 0 portion of Lots 14, 33 through 37, 011 of Block 18,
HAlLANDALE PARK No.8. including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots, lying within said Block 18,
cs recorded in Plot Book 20 at Page 49. All of Tract 1, LAURANNA, os recorded in Plat Book 76 at Page
31. All of Lots L 2. 6 through 13. 38 through 42 and a portion of Lots 14 and 37, all of Block 17,
HALLANDAlE PARK No.8, including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots in Block 17, os recorded
in Plat Book 20 at Page 49. Tract 1, Block 17, REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK No.8, as
recorded in Plat Book 40 at Page 97. That portion of the North One-holf of N.E. 205th street abandoned
by Resolution No. 2000~11 recorded in O.R.B. 19247 at Page 4677. That portion of N.E. 206th Street
bounded on the North by Block 18 and bounded on the South by Block 17 and bounded on the East by
the West right-of-way line of N.E. 30th Avenue (East Dixie Highway) 011 being os shown on HAlLANOAlE
PARK No.8, os recorded in Plot Book 20 at Page 49. A portion of land bounded by on the North by 0
line 81.00 feet South of and parallel or concentric with the North line of Waterways Boulevard as shown on
AVENTURA CORPORATE CENTER, as recorded in Plat Book 158, Page 47, and bounded on the South by the
North line of Block 18, HAlLANOAlE PARK NO.8, as recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, all the above
plats being of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida, lying and being in the City of Aventura
and being more particularly described as follows:
Commence at the intersection of the centerline of N.E. 205th Street and the centerline of N,E. 30th Avenue,
both as shown on said PLAT OF HAlLANDAlE PARK NO.8; thence North 89'53'41" West along said centerline
of N.E. 205 Street for 35.01 feet to the Point of Beginning of the hereinafter described parcel of land;
thence continue North 89'53'41" West along said centerline for 261.97 feet; thence North 00'00'00" East for
422.33 feet; thence North 90'00'00" West for 119.97 feet; thence North 00'00'00" East for 135.92 feet:
thence South 76'00'36" East along a line 81.00 feet South of and parallel with North right-Of-way line of
Waterways Boulevard for 86.13 feet to a point of cUr.Jature; thence Southeasterly along a 1519.00 foot
radius cUr.Je leading to the left through a central angle of 7"37'02" for an arc distance of 201.94 feet:
thence South 00"52'30" East along a line 10,00 feet East of 0 10.00 foot alley adjacent to said lot 42,
Block 18 of HAlLANDAlE PARK NO.8 for 8.92 feet to the Northwest corner of said Tract 1 of LAURANNA;
thence South 89'50'24" East along the North line of said Tract 1 for 70.42 feet to a point of curvature;
thence Southeasterly along a 25.00 foot radius cUr.Je leading to the right through a central angle of
88'57'54" for on ore of 38.82 feet to a point of tangency; thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line
of said Tract 1 for 122.65 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; thence South 89"51'49" East along the
North line of said lot 7, Block 18 HALLANDAlE PARK NO, 8 for 5.00 feet to the Northeast corner thereof:
thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line of said Lots 7 and 8, Block 18 and the Southerly
extension thereof for 164.42 feet to the Southeast corner of said Lot 2, Block 17 of HAlLANOALE PARK NO.
8: thence North 89"52'27" West along the South line of said lot 2, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the Northeast
corner of said Tract 1 of REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK NO.8; thence South 00"52'30 East
along the East line of said Tract 1 for 75.01 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; Thence South 89'53'04"
East olong the North line of said Lot 6, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the northeast corner of said Lot 6;
thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line of said lots 6, 7 & 8, Block 17 for 56,77 feet to 0 point
of cUr.Joture; thence Southwesterly along a 25.00 foot radius cUr.Je leading to the right through 0 central
angle of 36"52'05" for on arc of 16.09 feet: thence South 00'52'30" East along 0 line 35.00 feet West of
and parallel to the center line of said NE 30th Avenue for 35.35 feet to the Point of Beginning.
SURVEYOR'S NOTES:
This site lies in Section 34, Township 51 South, Range 42 East, City of Aventura, Miami-Dade County,
Florida.
- Bearings hereon are referred to an assumed value of S89'53'41"E for the center line of NE 205th Street
- Lands shown hereon were not abstracted for easements and/or rights-of-way of records.
- This is not a "Boundary SUr.Jey" but only a graphic depiction of the description shown hereon.
- lands shown hereon containing 146,330 square feet, or 3.359 acres, more or less.
Dimensions shown hereon are based on Fortin, leavy, Skiles, sketch #2006-099.
SURVEYOR'S CERTIFICATION:
I hereby certify that this "Sketch af Description" was mode under my responsible charge on Ju:y 7, 2006,
and meets the Minimum Technical Standards os set forth by the Florida Board of Professional Surveyors und
Mappers in Chapter 61G17-6, Florida Administrative Code, pursuant to Section 472.027, F:orida St(Jtutc<:>
'Not valid without t
nature nd the original raised seal of a Florida Licensed Surveyor and Mapper"
8
Drawn By GEM ( SKETCH OF DESCRIPTION I Date 7/7/06
Cad No, 061310 FORTIN, LEAVY, SKILES, Scale NONE
ef, Dwg INC.
2006-082-1 CONSULTING ENGINEERS, SURVEYORS & MAPPERS Job No 061310
FLORIDA CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORlZA nON NUMBER: ??oo3653 Dwg No 1006-143-1
180 Northeast 168tb Street 1 North Miami Beach, Florida 33162
Plotted 7/7/06 4:09p Phone 305-653-4493 I Fax 305-65 1-71521 Email fls@flssurvey.com Sheet of 3
DAVID PLUMMER & ASSOCIATES
August 8, 2006
Ms, J oallne Carr
Planning Director
City of A ventura
Inoo West Country Club Drive
A ventura, FL 33180
(305) 466-8940
Exhibit 4
01-REZ-06
RE: Anlltura Grand Trip Generation COffil,al'ison - #06166
Dear Ms, Carr:
The ^ ventura Grand project is a mixed-use development located at the southeast corner of NE 207
Street (Watenvays Boulevard) and NE 30 A venue in ^ vennu'a, Florida, Although the proposed pr()jecl
includes 137,500 SF of office, 59,,000 SF of relaiL 198 hotel rooms, and 104 dwelling units of
townhouses/lofts, this ktter solcly addresses the portion being rezoned to residential. The purpose (If
this letter is to summarize and repol1 the tindings of the vehicular trip generation comparison between
the proposed residential portion "fthe 1\ ventura Grand project and the Maximum Density scenario for
the same area,
'1l1e proposed residential p0l1ion of the Aventura (jranel project includes 104 dwelling units of
townhouses/loth. The Maximnm Density scenario with the site's eurrent zoning (B-2) can provide
235,591 SF of ol'lice space,
The Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trip Generation manual (7'h edition) was used to
determine the project's AM peak hour, PM peak hour, and weekday daily vehicular trips that will be
generated by both seenarios, A summary of the analyscs is shown below, See Appendix A for A ventura
Grand calculations and Appendix B for thel'vlaxinlllm Density scenario ealcu1ations,
Sccmlrio ITE Land US" Size/Units Daily Trips AM peak PM peak
hour hour
tvlaximnm Office 235.591 SJ 2,594 3fi5 351
Density (Land Use 710)
TO\\illhouscsfLofts
A ventura Grand 10,j DU 664 53 62
([,and l)se 2.10)
DilTerenee 1,930 312 2119
Weekd:lV Net "'ew Vehicular Trips'
j Till" aH"I\\iI~.wa)
~{1\lrcc: Uand Plummer and ;\,';~il\:l::llt:S
@EJ
Ms. Joanne Carr
RE: "ventura Gntnd Trip Gcncnttion Cnmpllrisnn - #06166
Page 2
As shown above, tbe residential portion of the AventuTa Grand project generates approximately 75%
less daily vehicular trips during a weekday than the l'vlaximum Density development scenario, When
compared to the AM peak and PM peak hOLlrs, the residential portion of the Aventura Grand project
generates approximately 85% and 80% less trips respectively,
Please call me at (305) 447-0900 ifyoll have any questions or need more information,
'~, "I'=r'~! ".( '.j ( 0 f
~ ~-'r)v--I{j
Rita Carbonell
Project Engineer
Attachments
ce: Brian Adler, f\nne Colter, Alex Tukh, File
IcORn806d,'c
~J
Attachment A
Aventura Grand Residential Portion
Trip Generation
Aventura G~and - #U616E
Summary of Trip Generation Cai.culatiGt
For: 104 D.....elling Ur-,_lts ()f Res'.dentia c,:-;f';C:O:T~:::i;H':, I Tc-.....nhous.
Augus~.: DE, 2006
.A,vg. Weekday 2-\~2:'J'
L'lm('
7 - ? /\:"1 Fea " H "\1'-" -, t
-'.'
"l - j AI" Pea f: Hocr E.:xi
7 - 9 At-1 Ft? ;;1 K H ou " '"' ,:-"t
"
4 - , 2!-1 Plo.;;'J/: IJ uu , , "
4 - 6 P}1 Fe ,~'- " Hour ?:>: j .-
1 - 5 PH yp ak ')\1 r .. 71 d
d
Sat.urdc'/ 2-1.\'i1} 'v'c: t,7L-;"
S"l:IJ
PCi1k
?L'2I.k
?pak
H~);;:;: T )7,:,'~
f;O-.l::
S3:~urday
Sc':i~uU rd,::t'y'
!-tOLl:::
ZX1-t
Not.e: l\ 7e~-<,' -i nd,j
;'.\'~~rage Sta;~(1arc
Rar_e l)evtati;~;T.
~';dj:Jst:nent iJrivewd'
Factor Volu!nl
6.313
(). YJ
1 CO 664
1 CD J
1 CD , ,
"
1 CO ~3
J (1" 42
J ,',n 20
v..'
1 ,~ r,. 62
,-,,,-,
::c 80,j
C 39
~. r: 3J
, . ",',,! Yj
0.C'9
c
c.., --'
, t]~i
c.
(: '~i~:
(;. ,1 C
C./:['
C.;:;:]
'/
c. :;,2
C .;/
,J
.J
. DC
C. ,;
.- ("~; :;0 de:'~' a ,';.V;',! [i':it':'
en; .~lted fr ::r;\ L:-'l{':,. 'T.l-t! i '-';;;0:
The ;'iJ:;(",IC, raTf'~~o; 'n'CT,'
L4-Er.
;:: - ;\' Zl Y \) c 1 'JT':'I>? :
FC<1k Hi. 7,~ji
;r.
:.1' 7"
:~ ~ 2
~F
7','
7_f~! AH
4 - (: ,;~.1
f'ed.~ rl;,. ':',-
AM G~n fk ' Tota::
PM Gen Pk ~r. To:a
i<' L
Sa:. 2-~ay Volume:
8st. ?~ Hr, rota~:
.. 2
Sc.:n.
2-f\',3Y VD}t;IT:0 ~
S~r~_ Pk H~. '!'oLal:
:~ :(
'2
,8"",; IX
,Be,] \:~
C. -; E ,
. >_ll'l,N (X
O. n
. d2 Lt,; (Z
0.8 I U
:5 4 ~ x! .~;.;
0.23 ",,1
Er: ::,. _ , ~-;. :;f ~~^j 1
-,- I F~' (). 8/,
I. . c:; ~"
.:; t
?, "
;:1. 83
+
c
Ex i ~
'_' _~ I
n
;-,L';'C'; I
Exi1
:',.r,:c;," C. Sx.i~
-,.67 X, t'L
.29 :,Xj
0,84
'_5 __,OJ (X,
. 23 ',X)
0. 'j
4:,! . (;,
^j. r-
l';n:J::r,
.~ f) F.xi t
. :; (, E'" ~~
C.88
::J:). )j
:). En"'er.
r; -
Exi t
Irlsti~.:.\;:.e ,:;,'.f ":1 o. SO(;r"Ldt~{)n :'I~~;;:'
r::ip GCnC':::E,tl:::L t:h Ed1~_-i',);l, ;; \,~,'"
T1<:1' G[:;:-Jl.,:;)}-,\TIU!\ :;"<,'-f.- l-JICF'::':TfJ\.:'L
Attachment B
Maximum Density Scenario
Trip Generation
Aventurc.~ Grand Maxirrun 3.:;r::::nar.:..o - #O(jl6(
su:nrcarj' 0: Trip Gcpc:c.at':,;:-J C(:L~culati0:-
Fo~ 235.S91 T?l.Gr_Sq.~t. ()f General O~f~C0 B~~ldln(
l\<lqust CS, ;OC}5
_.~._-~_._" m._._'__
^V0ra~e Sta;ldar:J
Rcil.:e JCVlilLl;:,,,
AVJ. Weekday 2-Way v.)
: I.:,:
r.
, - 9 f\~'1 .. e 0 k ::ct;r
7 - 9 !1M PAa k .. SGr Fz 1
" - 'J A~ c ;-1 Y. E(;u , 1
, .. '" ..
1.36
(). J '9
1. ?'
C.uc
,Oi,;
--;:.::)
, - 6 P:~ Fe a k H.(.;L:r ,'r I
"
4 - 6 P:-l .f::ea k .. ,~ u r S;L t
4 - 0 t~:-1 F'2 " Y. H-.)L; ~ " , ,,1 -
C.25
1. ).'J
1, '19
(:. JC
.1 .:5'
2-'l'lay \l::;: l;:-(
2.:)7
SaLliF.l:i::1./ PfDak h::::c.:: E:l :~'?
Sa~urddY ?eak tl~11r 2x~r
SatGrday Peak j-;r;",,:: T-;~
c.>?
(; a
C.': 1
,';. (',
.f;;
NOt0: A ~e~~ irldlc~~PS ~c iate avai:i::1.b~~
Source': J.:,s~..:i:~\Jt,E' -" ;~ns;):~)r'~:3tJ.(>li E::l~
T:::::c '::;f~r.er.':~: ';'[ h. -:'~(ij",:: "1, ;j',
;\~:: '';L:1\;::,J;.TI,:.:,t~ ~1':: ~."i ( ::(:'FJ..::~
J\dj ust.ms~t
?acr_cr
Drivewa'
Volum(
Jr'
1 CO 2594
1 CC 320
1 CO 45
] CC 365
1 CC 59
1 cc 29/
1 \..''v' 3,,) 1
I CC r.r,-,
~):) b
1 ,--.")
OL
] -15
1 97
~~
~J.t ~
Miami-Dade County Public Schools
.
. .
. .
. .
Superintendent of Schools
Rudolph F, Crew, EdD,
M/eml-Dade County School Board
Agustin J. Barrera, Chair
Perla Tabares Hantman, Vice Chair
Frank J. Bolallos
Evelyn Langlleb Greer
Dr, Robert B, Ingram
Dr, Martin Karp
Ana Rivas Logan
Dr, Marta Perez
Dr, Solomon C, Stinson
Chief Facilities Officer
Rose Diamond
Planning Officer
Ana Rijo-Conde, A/CP
August 17, 2006
Ms, Joanne Carr, AICP
Planning Director
City of Aventura
19200 West Country Club Drive
Aventura, Florida 33180
Exhibit 5
01-CPA-06
RE: AVENTURA LAND TRUST LLC
NE 30 AVENUE AND NE 207 STREET
APPLICATION FOR ZONING AND COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
Dear Ms, Carr:
Pursuant to the state-mandated and School Board approved Interlocal Agreement. local government, the
development community and the School Board are to collaborate on the options to address the impact of proposed
residential development on public schools where the proposed development would result in an increase in the
schools' FISH % utilization (permanent and relocatable), in excess of 115%,
Attached please find the School District's (District) review analysis of potential impact generated by the above
referenced application, Please note that all the impacted school facilities meet the referenced review threshold, The
proposed residential development will impact VA Highland Oaks Elementary, Highland Oaks Middle and Dr,
Michael M, Krop Senior High Schools currently operating at 117%, 191% and 152% of FISH percent utilization,
respectively, However, utilizing the County's Census 2000 figures, the proposed residential development will
increase the FISH % utilization of VA Highland Oak Elementary and Dr. Michael M, Krop Senior High Schools to
119% and 153%, respectively (please see attached analysis),
It is our recommendation that dialogue between the School District, the City and the above referenced applicant
take place prior to the Local Planning Agency meeting of Tuesday, September 12, 2006, As such, please send an
emailto irodriau@dadeschools,netto schedule a dialogue meeting with District staff,
Pursuant to the recently approved 5-year work plan, please note the attached analysis depicts the relief schools
planned in the area, which includes the recently approved Facilities Five Year Work Program, Also attached is a list
of approved Charter School Facilities, which may provide relief on a countywide basis,
Additionally, pursuant to Miami-Dade County's Educational Facilities Impact Fee Ordinance the proposed
development, if approved, will be required to pay educational facilities impact fees (impact fees) based on the
following formula:
New residential unit square footage X ,90 (Square Footage Fee) + $600,00 (Base Fee) + 2%
administrative fee = Educational Facilities Impact fee
School Board Administration Building '1450 NE 2nd Avenue, Suite 525' Miami, Florida 33132
305-995-7285 . Fax 305-995-4760 . arijo@dadeschoots.nel
AVENTURA LAND TRUST LLC - NE 30 AVENUE AND NE 207 STREET
Mr. Joanne Carr, AICP
August17,2006
Page 2
As an example, assuming the proposed unit is 1,000 square feet, the 104-unit development is estimated
to generate approximately $156,000 ($1,500 per unit, excluding the 2% administration fee) in impact fees,
This figure may vary since the impact fees assessed are based on the actual square footage of each
dwelling unit
In accordance with the Agreement, this letter and attached information should not be construed as
commentary on the merits of the pending zoning application, Rather it is an attempt to provide relevant
information to the City of Aventura on pubiic schools that will likely serve the proposed development and
meet the referenced threshold,
Thank you in advance for your cooperation in this matter. Should you have any questions, please contact
me (305) 995-4501,
Sincerely, /, I /
j, /11'z' i / II
'1_- ,I I /1 /
/ - _,f. (/ / ..'
, ,lklll/"'j1 /d'I/'/"
I /l:~l (.,/ _ l. (:f('", \ ~ :-><
,,/Ivan M, Rodrig ez, RA'i/
Director II /"'
IMR:ir
L060
Attachments
cc: Ms, Ana Rijo-Conde, AICP
Mr. Fernando A1buerne
SCHOOL IMPACT REVIEW ANALYSIS
APPLICATION:
Aventura Land Trust, LLC
REQUEST:
1) Land Use Change from "Business and Office" to "Medium
Density Residential" (25 to 60); and from B2 "Community
Business Districf' to RMF3A "Multifamily Medium Density
Residential District" (45 DUlacre); and
2) Site plan review
ACRES:
,:!:3,359 acres
LOCATION:
Approximately NE 30 Avenue and NE 207 Street (Waterways
Blvd,). Aventura
MSAI
MULTIPLIER:
NUMBER OF
UNITS:
2,1 1.52 Single-Family (SF) Attached & ,18 Multifamily
36 Townhomes (SF) Attached and 68 Multifamily
(As limited by City)
ESTIMATED STUDENT
POPULATION:
31
ELEMENTARY:
15
MIDDLE:
7
SENIOR HIGH:
9
SCHOOLS SERVING AREA OF APPLICATION
ELEMENTARY:
VA Highland Oaks Boone Elementary - 20500 NE 24 Avenue
MIDDLE:
Highland Oaks Middle - 2375 NE 203 Street
SENIOR HIGH:
Dr. Michael M, Krop Senior High - 1410 NE 215 Street
All schools are located in Regional Center II.
'Based on Census 2000 information provided by Miami-Dade County Department of Planning
and Zoning,
The following population and facility capacity data are as reported by the Office of
Information Technology, as of October 2005:
Highland Oaks
Middle
% UTILIZATION
-Ie UTILIZATION NUMBER OF FISH DESIGN
FISH DESIGN FISH DESIGN PORTABLE CAPACITY
STUDENT CAPACITY CAPACITY STUDENT PERMANENT AND CUMULATIVE
POPULATION PERMANENT PERMANENT 5T A TIONS RELCOA TABLE STUDENTS"
946 145% 117%
654 152 961
961 . 147% 119%
2,296 228% 191%
1,006 198 2,586
2,303 . 229% 191%
3,774 165% 152%
2,290 190 3,795
VA, Highland
Oaks Elem,
Dr. Michael M,
Krop Senior 3,783' 165% 153%
"Student population increase as a result of the proposed development
""Estimated number of students (cumulative) based on zoninglland use log (2001- present) and
assuming all approved developments are built; also assumes none of the prior cumulative
students are figured in current population,
Notes:
1)
2)
Figures above reflect the impact of the class size amendment
Pursuant to the Interlocal Agreement, all the schools meet the review threshold,
PLANNED RELIEF SCHOOLS IN THE AREA
(Information included in proposed 5-Year Capital Plan, 2006-2010, dated July 2006)
Projects in Planning, Design or Construction
School
Bay Harbor K-8 Conversion
(Highland Oaks Middle School relief)
(551 student stations)
State School "BB-1" K-8
(RB Bay Harbor Elementary I
VB Highland Oaks Middle Schools relief)
(1,624 student stations)
Status
Planning
Proiected OCCUDanCY Date
2008 School Opening
Design
2008 School Opening
Madie Ives Elementary K-8 Conversion
(VB Highland Oaks Middle School relief)
(948 student stations)
Design
2008 School Opening
Lease Space
VB Highland Oaks Middle
(674 student stations)
Construction
2006 School Opening
State School "QQQ"
(Dr. Krop I North Miami Beach
Senior High Schools relief)
(1,593 student stations)
Design
2008 School Opening
Proposed Relief Schools
School
Early Childhood Center (ECC)
(VB Highland Oaks I Madie Ives
Elementary Schools relief)
(396 student stations)
Fundina Year
FY 2006-07
Addition at
Dr. Michael M. Krop Senior
(1,500 student stations)
FY 2007-08
OPERATING COSTS: Accounting to Financial Affairs. the average cost for K-12 grade students
amounts to $6,549 per student. The total annual operating cost for additional students residing
in this development, if approved, would total $203.019.
CAPITAL COSTS: Based on the State's September 2006 student station cost factors', capital
costs for the estimated additional students to be generated by the proposed development are:
ELEMENTARY 15 x $18,140 = $272,100
MIDDLE 7 x $19,589 = $137,123
SENIOR HIGH 9 x $25,444 = $228,996
Total Potential Capital Cost $638,219
'Based on Information provided by the Florida Department of Education, Office of Educational
Facilities Budgeting. Cost per student station does not include land cost.
T:\1I217\1v...Rodrlguez\lmpolcl~~\Cl!)lcfA.v"""''''_uP1lL_T''''LLC\Av.m..l_T'''''UC.doc
Charte,r School Growth in Miami-Dade County
" "i,ii ',ce, '/'/'/ ,:;t'{,~>tistirllICIll~l1er$c'iiQp')S' '.: " ",',', I,' ' "'",
Actual Projected Enrollment (as per contract)
School Name Enrollment
/11-18-05) 2006-2007 2007 -2008 Maximum
Academy of Arts & Minds 141 500 500 500
Archimedean Academy 469 525 525 525
Archimedean Middle Conservatory 61 240 240 240
ASPIRA Euoenio Maria de Hostos 365 600 600 600
ASPIRA Youth Leadership 305 450 450 450
ASPIRA South Youth Leadershio 203 450 450 600
Ayentura City of Excellence School 699 900 900 900
Balere Language Academy 148 250 350 450
Coral Reef Montessori 345 500 500 500
Doctors Charter School of Miami Shores 412 525 600 600
Doral Academy 730 2200 2200 2,200
Doral Academy Middle School 815 1250 1,250 1,250
Doral Academy Hioh School 925 1800 1,800 1,800
Doral Performinq Arts & Entertainment Academy 45 150 200 200
Downtown Miami Charter School 614 650 650 650
Early Beginnings Academy Civic Center 43 80 80 80
Early Beginninqs Academy, North Shore 20 43 61 70
Florida International Academy 261 350 350 350
International Studies Charter Hioh School 110 750 1,000 1,000
Keys Gate Charter School 1,132 1.150 1,150 1.150
Lawrence Academy 69 250 350 450
Liberty City Charter School 350 705 705 705
Life Skills Center Miami-Dade County 62 450 600 600
Mater Academy 713 1,150 1150 1.150
Mater Academy Charter Hioh School 1,165 1,300 1,300 1,300
Mater Academy Charter Middle School 1,154 1,300 1300 1,300
Mater Academy East Charter School 303 800 800 800
Mater Academy East Middle School 107 250 300 250
Mater Performino Arts & Entertainment Academy 94 150 200 200
Miami Children's Museum 79 350 350 350
Miami Community Charter School 223 600 600 600
Oxford Academy of Miami 105 450 450 450
Pinecrest Preoaratorv Academy Middle School 222 800 800 800
Pinecrest Preparatory Academy 745 1250 1,250 1,250
Rosa Parks Charter School/Florida City 199 600 600 600
Renaissance Elementarv Charter School 452 500 500 500
Renaissance Middle Charter School 47 700 1050 1,600
Sandor Wiener School of Oooortunity 19 72 72 72
Sandor Wiener School of Oooortunity. South 25 36 36 36
School for Inteorated Academics & Technolooies 332 800 800 800
Somerset Academy 525 700 700 700
Somerset Academv Charter Middle School 74 300 300 300
Somerset Academy Charter Hiqh School 22 375 500 500
. 78 :lW :lW m
Spirit City Academv 39 300 350 400
Sunshine Academy 95 200 275 450
The Charter School at Waterstone 1,012 1,000 1 150 1,000
Theodore R. and Thelma A. Gibson Charter School 16 600 600 600
Transitional Learnino Academy 29 48 72 72
Youth Co-Op Charter School - 515 525 525 525
TOTAL: 49 schools 16 713 30 364 31 331 32 625
. Contract terminated effeclive June 30, 2006
Revised June 30. 2006, to reflect July 2006 board action. Page 1 of 3
..,. .. BOllrlJl-Approv~d Contracts for Schools to Open in F~ure Years
School Name Projected Enrollment (as per contract)
2006-2007 2007-2008 Maximum
Charter on the Beach Middle School 250 250 250
. :m m m
A Child's Journey Charter School N/A 325 600
Atlantic Science Academv N/A 600 840
Cooperative Charter School 100 120 200
. GOO GOO GOO
Excelsior Academy of Miami N/A 450 450
Mosaic Bilinoual Academy N/A 120 365
North Miami/Florida Int'l Uniy. Charter Sr. Hioh School N/A 800 1,600
Pinecrest Academy Charter Hioh School 600 850 850
South Dade Charter Elementarv School N/A 625 750
Summerville Charter Scheel' GOO eoo eoo
Excel Academy 250 300 700
Life Skills Center Opa Locka 400 400 400
Mater Academy Lakes Elementary School -0- 800 800
Mater Academy Lakes Middle School 900 900 900
Mater Academy Lakes Hiah School 300 600 1,200
Mater Gardens Academy 900 900 900
Mater Gardens Academv Middle School 450 450 450
Pinecrest Academy South Campus) 800 800 800
Somerset Academy I Silver Palms) -0- 600 600
Somerset Academy I Country Palms) -0- 1,000 1,000
Somerset Academy Middle School/Countrv Palms) -0- 600 600
TOTAL: 20 schools 4,950 11,490 14,255
SUB-TOTAL (EXISTING +APPROVEP), 69 schools 35,314 42,821 46,880
* Deferment penod expired - contracts automatically lapse.
, < . "Contracts Pentlifl9 ApprQval < ; .'.,.
School Name Projected Enrollment (as per contract)
2006-2007 2007-2008 Maximum
Dr. Joseph Coats Grace Community Advantaoe Academy' -0- 750 750
Summerville Adyantaoe Academy' -0- 750 750
Excel Academy North -0- 250 700
Riyer Cities Communilv Charter School -0- 250 250
TOTAL: schools -0- 2000 2,450
SUB-TOTAL (EXISTING + APPROVED + PENDING APPROVAL): 73 schools 35,314 44,821 49,330
. applications approved as Advantage Academy of Miami and Advantage Academy of Miami "B", respectively.
Revised June 30, 2006, to reflect July 2006 board action _ Page 2 of J
Board-Approved applications for schools openino in subseauent vears
ADolicant Maximum Enrollment Caoacitv
Mater Sorinos Academy Elementarv School 600
Mater Academv South Charter School 900
Mater Sorinas Academv Middle School 300
Sabal Palm Charter Hiah School 800
Charter Academv of Excellence 600
Palmetto Bav Charter Academv 1,600
Princeton Charter Academy 1,600
Homestead Charter Hiah School 2,000
South Miami-Dade Charter Elementary School 600
South Miami-Dade Charter Middle School 300
Adyantaae Academv of Miami "C" 750
Adyantaae Career Academv 900
Kush Academy 500
Life Skills Center - Homestead 700
Life Skills Center - Liberty City 700
Romans Charter School 540
South Fiorida Choir Intermediate/Hioh School 280
Tatal: 17 schools 13,670
GRAND TOTALS
Number of Schools I Maximum Enrollment CaDacitv
90 I 63,000
Revised June 30, 2006, to reflect July 2006 board action - Page 3 of 3
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
',h.
>'. :.IGCL ~~,,-\,,1E /c:.,DDf,f:S5, l'~L
("K,C'.;)!::
L'::.V:;'L..S
:(;,1?
i.., "::~i:I'J ~i ~\:t" did ['"lilvis
oj ~,_, :>_'nri1Ix!cic, !;!;:ka
l'J<:n\i l-L_""cJ
!lttP:'/"jlV'ii_o21ndm,nel
05;':'
[.','C':;, '~L",v,ar, :'.C,~.:'I_~,fl~Y
1 ;!,~~':5 S'/i ",:.)(
L.,j;,'T! iC\ :::3",.,
li1tp:fll1omepage. maccom/archimedean
_8cadeill)'fARCI11MEDEAN_ACADEMY.html
GOTO
f,$Pt~;A
l::l;',~Gili<; fdi':ii.l De Hosto~ \ :'L;;", L(;,"::!~;-:;ilij2
C!I~:tel ;:':::Ioci
: c,1 C'J ;~E ;')::,"I~li Ci
i',,~ I ,,: :', ~! ,'- c- C',j I :;.,.
http.llfl <1splra.org.'\Nynwood/Cllarlerfemil_charter,htm
3r.SG
/),Sr::1FJ'. S "J';!,
\'cA:ti, Lt."';!2rsili!) (:t',t,;-~<:-: Schoo!
Q-ii2-1.e', i_! S'c'>.j 288 S'
l-",~:;~'r;, (;:'Y :"L :J:3i.):',~-j
htlp:l/fL8Snira QrgISouth,'CharterISQultLcllarter.htm
il!l20
:\::;::>11':.;"
\i,"":.:h U,sdi2i"silip Chal1e'
.~;.;OC; iv~,"ir.cLi<li H.Yj'
,', ;'..~i"J11; F:....J.;. I '3 -i
SC:",rx,!
hUp:lfiI,dspir8.0rg,INorll1:Charterlnortil cha1er,11tm
o:::sn
;'~~<::~.;lt!I,~lr~' C!'y ~;tj:S":i2i'(~e Cl,-.rt f S:txcl
;'.:r"n:t::: "L:<3',2(1
l,tlpl,'WI'./\N <>vF.-nturacharter,org
~1 ;:<
\';2iEiE: !.:;":';,lag~i\I:<i,j~:II',
iO i,V, (:rJ':i~'L'.::,,'rl ~'i'"
,',1i~.r,,' F!... 3':1(.:9
l1t1p:if'.,w;.J ,balere,org!::l1artero'index.htrn
U7,1
C:,!,d f,,,~i f''-:'::i,,';.:;sor; I~.c.vl,=r'l'l Cj"8rt"r ;:~C;1001
i()f;.':i~ <':", .' ::1:'] Sl
1....1' -,-,-
~l\tp:1 .ICOfolreefm 0 i',les~w ,i, dacle.;ch00Is, 1 i8t
,~<::"'o
"W" ;;,;::0"
.....'1 ~ ,,' ~. '\.",! ,,; 'C'
-..'".",,-
:/:1"':;1 ;:[,,_;'1._
ilUp: :":doraIClcademy .da::!eschools.l1et
';:(1::;':.<
[,:;;:'1;;1i ..c,,~?":1,~ ,1\' C:~?_rt21" " ;j:llJ' ~:;;il,,::1
200'1 ,:V'J ,^" \'F
;:1:," 1 ~', i ~, " "', } ~.,
http://mOieracaclemyhigh. dadeschoal~. n~t
i"i}?(J
i>J;,'I.L,':'.;F.I..111/hl::;i;
i 1'.',[, p~\."-' :r/ 3~
,;;:,.;",-, ",:,1-'-;;:
:;::ilGO~
hltp :I!r,li'lleraC8dem~'lligh lia(lescllools net
s:(;r'~(,(,,-- {.'.0;'II:\:I$,T:.< _ " r
;::-F:I',!,_ PD";f:;:::T3
9.;:'
;'.1. Til,;:~~as L ShEW!
t1sl1aw@dadesctloolsnet
'"''
M$ ?ilt 3oc>ll1
pbooll1@dacleschools net
6-:;;
idr fan2nGO lal"e:::
flopez@dadescl1ools.l"1et
G.t
:',11' !(e'ji" J'~C'01,,,
kmoore@dadeschOQls.net
G.S
:v]~ ;11,"1'2 PB~;'-
idpena@dadescrlOolsn€t
1,-2
0: :'alh'2"Il(~Niurpllf
b11Llrphl'@dcdeschools.net
f<:.C
1.'1s r-<.c.--;I.:O\I'.,la:ii:
rmaJik@dadeschools.net
1">3
Lr,s jtili2tl(IIlC.
julielking@di1deSchools n.::t
r.'~s tu',:\' ".:,'11.':": e..G;:;I("'ll
!<-5
1\,13 ::,:-(,':;:', ("orr,e:,
ile<lnagomez@dadeschGolS.net
':-~;
...'I~ J.:).o:.'~ t:"'.l:z,
820'111@dadeschools.llet
i:-l:'
.,5 c':,jl1i~ Jink',F;z
fjimenez@dadeschcols.nE.,j
p~~ ,,- ~,-, "",;
-"/
;;O,=,.II;\2,lltll'
::C'~;-~~,i.-C ,,' :~;v
3:" J'"
')"u.'.
:j~):,
,'::l,;J"
3'_,5<')-; G.15i ~-'
:~J:;.~,':"G-l;81:'; F;r
2(':',24(,1 ::
2,d ::,.:', ~ Fj I,'" !"
:'0::;..'.;::,'3 .~:,=,')rJ
~3G :',:. ,- r 1. ,::,(,;'.
" .", .',
::,~ ,- _. ...'
-, "_"J.',
"' '.. ~ 'cc~' ~h '{.
---'~~, _ ',C,':'" j';>
.;il~, ':'U
:,(\'.' ,',~'I .;;~" F,-'\
::'uc'-SG: C<J'~:,
~,')",,:~C: ,,- "'-,1"'
~;t. r,
"~'J
,(:>.:
_'-~.;'I::
'--",
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
.,
I '::C'JU '."- 'I: :vi'G:-,]; cr.: li<;, Dcl;o,-" I(-S :\',s 1 o;!o;' ('iI2L1~ :}t; i,",i,'- 1:'
,"~, ".:\',.' , .^,' lerryrnaus':Q;.:dadeschcols net - ," ., - ;,
"/''''.1.1: '-l 2,:'12;::
http,I:C:o~mtownchal1~l org
<in'}J ;'clI"I,j,_. i n;,,'~ 1',,, ti S'l 3: /'.-::a(ie<1-'"; oj'0 ".ls S'Xi2 1,,]it(l":dl I ~',(,}::; 1.1<' ':01:'
,",:i:\(1 81\<.: smitchell@oadescho3Is.nel y,~-,-, - ~ P: ,,"' j-"
LII2"(" , ,.
hliissiDn Sl;o;lement I
;~Gii a IT.~:c;:;(:J,, " C1nd i '-,odin" , C~ib;>:'I': ell:;'\"'; St.ll'.c:j1 ",-C' ,di" C!';3rles S21hei :iC!; ','''ie,-.' 121-;
':,'\:;,.\ C,;rarlJ Ale cgbelhel@dadescho0Is.net :;C'_" I;.~ :~-: '. ;;: 1 , ,
I'.:k'.ni i:L :.:.n:,
!
i'.lission Statement
tltlp:f!glb!;Qncha.1er _ dadeschools. net
lor)( 111;,,;I":-,;::-,(i8:-'21 Studi",s Cil(irtcl Higl1 ScI '~:Ol ~;"1 , Us il..n<'o lI.i,'(lr8:i:-P,r,r,-,(1l 30:':: ('1[i,.~29~
~2rJO ::.O'J::, ~_,1iam; ,f',lienU,) aalvarez-arirnon@dadeschoots.nel JJ3 ,,',(;'.:::1:Jf:: l-e,
i' i : d ~, 1 Fi ~~'12",
hItP://W\!N!.isct:s.netlincJ2xhtml
%'10 :~~J'S G:clt;, CLCli1_8! Sshcd K-8 i,Jio. Cr.r;S',iiI0 'Jd"dE:Z 30 ~i- 2: " 1r3i':;
:;"OOG -3[: 28 f",'F: cvaladez@dadesc!loOls,nei ~ ", c;.. ') i;" 1.-'''' I",,':.
r:(J11l8,:ib;,(i H :-'3l-':3~
htlp.llv:w#keysc:t:aI1er .org
(1IH[; lib_,,!t'i.~I;{ C!l?rlc-I Sr::~,:"J1 i{:'; [',::s '(? I r i ~ -I a V.'llson-l),':'.'iS "'i'" " t.i-;::. 1Jl1
, ~', '~:i) j'\)V j !>.vtJ jo:, wil S ofl-d 8vis@dadeschools.'let .~(r;_iCi_ : ',';i" , .",
ik;ll,li FL :):]\58
,
t'l ::' rii ~ C811,pl~S ,
,J~'v , ~N.J ::>-! i->,-':c:!1lI';
j,!li"-",,. FL " 1,:;7 i.iet:~ C;J1;;j-."lc:
, ':CC,'''"",,:-' .
",'[iC4 ~'-lJ_'C', ,-;;;;
Ilttp:/NN,',^,_lccschool,com
~11;')G :"~<1t<:r /\;;::;<.181 Ill' 1:__5 I"i;~, f~.i'L' GuilCli'te . , (: ::-.-;; C. 8 " ~:, ,. (- ..
i;'iJC :':"..r,,j ',13ih :3i kguila rta@dadeschools.net :;rjiiC8:;_:~;_:;~' t-F::
H:2h~::!1 Cell IS "'- 'O1,~
hUD: lfmc:teraci:!'jemy dadescr,ools_ net I
<301? rk,t'~r ,2',c;:d..oI"lV ,-';h8112i" i\id:.i!2 ;:oc:;OG~ I:,-:.) >,<,ir r:O::I-Ic, [';01:1"-)<", :--,U:'- ,,', .l'.--Gi"
7~;'.>i ;'!\.''1 i02 S'. rro\!lrosa@dMeschocls_net :3(' ~, :J~(.0 "-' i:?
)-:ICi:(.,~il '~;,';,:12;1'O. I:i_ 3:,r~'i ,~
Iotlp.l f m;:;1eracadernyhigh, dM.esGncols, net I
:W:,8 ,','1<]i~,:- ",,~sden-,~ lsst C!-.,Jrt~, 5',::1::';) I .\-:: Hs. f.',eo:!ri;: f<:el.1 '~c ~:- ,,,,., , 11;
.{5l' S\\i 1.:',1', s: briera@dadeschools,net -;.;,5 (, :..:n ;. ...
;',.;:,:1"'1' I'i C''''"
,
http://matcracademyeastcladeschools.net I
:/'iGC :'.,l".t:~1 A::;;!CiE'll>)' C'",,'I,("I' ~j!9 il fi.:h::'oi 8-1: 'I~ JldJ,r i-f'arty :::0 ;:;~'i.; ; i:~;:,
'..-~)O'I ;,!V'] 1C:, St jmany@dadeschoOls.nel ':0 ,-;;?;-;.Ci" , 1';'.1'
i-,i":".J!1 GLil'':i Fl 33Ji':;
htlp: l,Imateracademy high. dc:od es.::hools _l1el
t,.:JGO i'.']:i3llii Ch:1cj:'2P'S f-,it!:,e,I;",. GI'21lt2' SC~-Lo~'i i,-~, Us iJl;;;ri". iVi;:.r,gsr,tli C':;'f'1 '!-,~:_(,! "JII-l'''''-'
~.~ [: Q ivli:"'.11i-':J CC:'.!::;'''\\'<l~i i110ngeotti-g r.,er@dadeschools,net ',(";"2,, ,,".,"',
bliCl:;1i FL 2.:-, ! 3~: :,r;:;"::,C',,,J:r.:;~l c;.l~.
i
,'-:;;;;:,"'.!,"""'''' ,',"-, n,~,o:,:
: :.-, ~1 :: :
l.j'2,oi: ;-:: 3~\20
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
0102
:,iri"j;1 Cr)I)',mlli1lt;i C,";;c;',1 8(;i1[.,_1
1(,1 l''i r';:edl-c'K; r~Oi:d
i',.:, iT ;;;_,~ ~', ,J ~,1
!'..'li5$lon Statement
GCi-:J
D'Xl!):-",::-'8!~Er Sc;!"C'GI.. r Mia:],1 S:icJI::;S
i'.>J:,(i i',!E 1m! f'.'iei-,,'e
i..'!icllrn SI-,'_'fi;:S FL. 2,:;' 0;:'
03UU
?il1~CI"f,si p'-"I;?,r::,j(jiyAci3(J.:::r'l)'
;';.;WI ,;"',} 42 S,
,',:i:'ll1i; f"( ~:Oi~:-,
iie'.:.'Ai;' G;2c:iS Cai;,'I.''':,
151::'.') S\.'v ;"iD!h Silber
i\'iicll;~i.;:L 'd '_'.c
btlp JlPinecrestpreparaloryacadel1lydadeschools, net
'30..r.
P!I;e:,lesl ,ll,ul,;lc(,lY Cr,,,!',e.. j"j;',j1ie S"~i-,:;Jo:
lJ''('12,',;,I.',2.'';1
:'Jli,l!Tli r"l,:._,I,,';
{:"I~C/;:;ii Grc~l1:; Can' .'
1_ ! ~0 G\"1 80ti-1 Sli~~l
k1i2((d ?L 'j3E'~
hap:! i Pinecrestpreparatoryacademy ,dadeschool s net
C4(10
RGn8i:;,~::;r1'.'e E!em811\8 cr;a::,'!r :)chcQI
c':/-:r. ~r..',' ",-, ~~t
:'.;li;3'1',I. Fl. '~JF')
hltp:,riw,wl_feCsCh<lrter.org
:}:;:0'.1
i-:V;~l F'xl>; C",-"",:;,,,. ,S':;'loJiHxi:Ji:! City
,~-:; ~J(.':..'elJt::; ;".'," i;C' <'it !,'" ioc<";i(;.'1
71:': l."jest?,,:111; l\
Fhri'jet c>:~. F 3Jl.;:4
w 3 .~!r.I,..'enls:.':ij !):.' ,!,' ii/'., 'I)r;":","-)I'
-,D~ 'N'~'. ~ ;.~li,; Dr
~'IGrici:' Cili' Fi_ :;::',0':;';
5('10
(-;C1IXicl ',:'her,":1 -5:11.)01 c., Dppcr'tur:it;'
.-.",;01:;"
?GC1DC C,
,'y_,-tor:!;, r', :;~C5~"
:".,;:-.i!i:l<;) .(ir:;"?~,~
p.:,) :)(,;; I;-:'.~::',
i~i<<",,'i' PL CS",,- -2.~~r;
Iv1I!>siofl Statement
~. ~~;,;!~j.~~~,:.::1 '" i;~~
il'fl,1;,l: Fi_ 3~, 1 ; .'
:'\L~i)
S'~i ,'.-,cl f;11 i,1'~0r~HH: t,r~'3. :o:I"ic," ~ Tf,;:.i1110iJ;Jic' ;;1. ,T~~:-,;
;;::lil:::;,'-'~!:;t:~)b C'::;'I;S C:'~:11-:':
i;:;:j::ii:.':,''!'i'",:'S,
;,LIYI'2';,,",,:, ,-,
"!Ol\l-
,\-li3ini 1,-,1
:J'J5(;i-i',:"
:':ii:,J"l]fL
i8";)
i.,~iss,or, Stal<:mef11
, ""C.' L, I F
t ~:1s '. '1<; '.(;z~"if'
, jrezaie@dadeschools.nel
miami::harter@bell!>oull1 net
-
,> -
I'i;': 1'.,'lsQQie ~.1~1-',;'F2
1(-5
rv1~ Susi~ DOljlCC
sd:>pico@dadesch,1o!s.nel
'3-3
H~ Je2'r;,-,iiilL1ens-nci:e?_
Jeanetlemndz@decleschools.net
i<-3
F\'1s Ani:: Co,cL~!
acordal@dadeschovls.nel
i~+8
1~1s :'_'1:1, HJ (1,= Jj"i3
,,<,
".'1-; Uss<" G:-'1':-:2:~~
Igonzale<: t@dadesdlOols.net
L_2i"::-:-':'odI81
i'k; ~:~,'.~8r-,c, (X:i,0."
[...'is. ;\'12,-jOii" L,)~~,,';~
lopezllla@dBdeschoois.net
'_:Z<>< -.,_."
, ;" ,I ~ ,_ :... ,i ~ ," " ,
'~~ ,. :_.j
;(',-::. :-(,2;:r,-'.,
:-;0:,-2J'I :0::"
,", J 0:: - :,: (J 7 . ~:.-, :- ; 1 "
:'(;;:-:'F.' .');',
.':05-2')7, :;'0, F'O:-
3(1~l_5:-J -~;2 ',~
~3 GS r.c;, :0;1 .... .- ,
,,~; -;~~',i.;:,,'c'. ,
'~G:' .7.1(<" ~_I:~ : ,~.
. _:'-G2.'c-':;(:3
05-f:r:-SC:?: 1'-"
,1 "'-7.0')'1
3iY.-:::, '>,,::::J4F,l"
i'(,<::in
7'-,",.2,:.1:;-1-<
',;r,lj::':".:71 q i-;,'
:
I C/i~;~1 1":'1", r;"!
(.(,'3.;,-':' 'it:;
;'~ 0:
G520
':::'';ldE!:;rJt;:''c-",:L'i-.1\
< !1S,/iI :~ -''.1/'';
j';c;mi,:L :;~,1-"7
[v]lssior. Statement
htlp 1/ SQrr.~r&ete lem _(!adeschools, rIel
SWJ:\
S'::'I""!,,,:.<:'::
(;1 "r~'2r t,llc!cl,o:
S\N1r- f\"'c "
Mi0:~1i. ::1, 2';, I";',:;
:,~'r:;3UO;IS ie' 05:)5
1 ~,! ,~,\.'ej-d--,;"
j,,':i,.r;1; ::'1_.33 ~.,':
7Q.1_~:
S':"11",1':'~~' Ci ,2.n"" Hiq:l -5ci;.:,;)1
~;\i'J :7 (we ~
i-J!iC'ilji H :r~1:0
ic.,:;a[!c-,')[. f;;i 05.C'6
!1:1A'!l-,
~j;21'-': ::::. 33-1,2
<=,.(1
: i J OC I\i\./ ~::. ,':;1
[,,1:3,11; rL '-,:i'IU
!}2J1J
~;~i'-a' 'I',d~ E:-';;11'.2 "",y ChAr!,"r SCIL'oi
-j :~~O,) :3\'V -;-::: St
bli"lnli I", ~'::.1 :~2
Mission Statement
j['2C-
Y')l,t'l r:':".Or C:1C!~t,~r S,:'lCl('1
1:::C:,51 VV Oh::ecti(O~>'~G ~:(~
Hie!>:!1 C'::i',. F;_ 3:\~)'r&
!lttp:!lyccs_ dClcieo;chool S_IlE:U
CHARTER SCHOOLS 2005-2006
1",.5
iI.'15, SlI1.€k; Ru:::
sruiz052C@dadeschools,net
(j.c,
:T~f'.
~'-, :;.:
f'k" Dia~~2 rk)i'als5
dmCral'2s3@dadeschools.nel
1(,5
r"IS {';~~&18 S2n3.~-'
gbatan@dadeschools.net
i<";j
l\'ls. [<"li:'rit;:::J A.-agGrJ
maragon@cladeschools net
?U~.:2- [;;-.;:)
~,,;:; -I",'" 71; 1";0)'
';05_::-:r.C,"";(J
3V).~7'Cr ; rc,-,
TeiTI'(J12'-~' i,'.J.lib:e.r:,
20::.-5'f;--~'.:,,,:.D
~',C5-"! i'r-~.7 i:'~ !,"~,,:(
]05':'.I~.C47":
::OS:"-,:';02.1:::1""
305-819-8855
305-819-6455 Fax
'"
'i'
'"
'"
..
'"
<:>
<:>
'"
.;,
<:>
<:>
'"
"
o
u.
'"
...J
o
o
:r:
u
'"
"
W
f-
~
:r:
u
::
w
z
"'
is
.~
o
:2:'"
t-
~~
:= ,
",0
"'''''
>'"
'U')
"'0
:2:",
'"
<1>
N
'"
,.:.
E
o
u
"5
'"
N
~
<1>
E
o
u
<Ii
~
">
"'
i'!
o
-'"
.!!1
E
'"
E
E
'"
Iii
E
'"
E
N
i'!
'"
>0
4:~
"'m
=-=~
2m
OU')
'U')
"'0
:2:",
N
~
,
m
0.::
~
0..
'"
<1>
'"
~
00
<1>
~ x E
o ~ 8
'E '
ro..-r.o<U
()~~~
. NO E
(j) I I ~\
ot'--C'?~
(1) 0....... U
--.JO'lLOO
~~~~
OO'lJ'-..U
0.::
~
0..
N
~
.
00
Cij
c.
,- ,.,
u "'
t:-
,- '"
0:0..
-Cij
"El...o
,.,.0 '"
ro~o
-"'~
eULh
"''ON
U",,,,
y)~~
:2:::J",
Cij
c.
ro'(3 Q)
c. t: t:
'->. "C>' 0
g1Q a..1:2 Ea.
e cti ~ ro 0 ro E
o..~ ~~ 13 ~l? 0
-0 ro := (tI C:'o .Q ~
5-i50~..cO:JNroa.;MO
CD ~~.!Q ~~CJ:g :J~ ro
-Q;l.......WQ)......roMMa..,.....
eOJ, EO", :5~~ ~c-?~
C'OuN muN"ii)co l...::I"-
UQ)Ma..Q)M~N:J...JN~
ui:eLO IJi:gLO ~LO~ u:iL[) (1)
:'E:Jg~=>gOgE:Eg~
Cij
c.
'6
t:
't:
0..
vi
"'t-
:2",
~~
"'''
t:N
<{'"
ui~
:2:",
N
'0
'"
'"
'"
0..
,.,
E
o '"
'" '0
o '"
'" u
M ~ <:(
-' ...."E-g
LJ.._ 0 Q)roN
~ co -g c5j EN I'- 0
}',("~r;' 0 cry -g..c r:: t'-- M ~
....... ..- (1)0 E .ffi.......~Q) l...
ro M...... (/) co 1::: M ,-~ .... (l) >. U
c: M ~Q.l Q)C")~o L...C E (j)
Q) E =0 ~ ..........J LI-..c Q) Q) OJ Q)
w ~ ou ~ ~u.~~ ~U u ~
5 I .- 0 CO....x -- ~ :5 (l) u ~ r-- :g
o .~:;;.o M"'VC\JO...... U.:;: <X: _'_ LO::2:
E ',c .....0 "'-00000 roU LOOl LO O>ME .......>.
Q) ro ~u 'M-Q ~t::O.Z U Nt: N>'>Oro ~E
:0 ~ <( ro 0.... CO') <( a) I .- [ ...... - ..... E 'C M'- ~.,
~~M Q) ...J(j)~...JO'l~>r.IJ au(1)(1)ME~M(1)OM~r.IJ...J~ 0
:E (j) co E a.i" 6 CO >'u. Q) > u.. .!: CfJ <( O'l . ~ ~ 0> > M ro > M U E...J i:i:i :J U. ro M
CNM ;,;>~-Q)-g ~t::<(U;Ef'-.N.sU5M c:<:(ro~<(m~_LL u.u.......
ro t'-- M ~ a~ ~ E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~;: .s ~ M ~ .~ ~:g ro ~ ~ <{ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ en ~
~~...J U e cu-55 0..... wU>..c't:>s: 0'l0'>...J..s::: 0>s:.Q cs:- Wt)<3zI 0 ro'Q'....J
Q)w~<{~~oro.....orn~z~~zz~s:~~~z~g ~g~~ww~ws:~
,~E~.-Q)u ~>sz.-Eo~.-_o z.-..s::: ._.~z.-E~>~,_o.~E-~""E-
-.~NEa~~~>.....~ -oEroo~~ Etb~Ec~ ->~ ~, _
u~ro~-N~~~OroOMro.....~O.....~roo.....~roro~ro~~.....Q)o_-oro
~~~~~~~~B~~8;:~8;:~~~~z~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'"
o
o
'"
'"
~
o
t-
t-
o
o
'"
o
.".
o
'"
m
o
o
t-
t-
N
o
Ci)
'"
o
o
'"
o
'"
o
.".
o
t-
o
.".
o
o
o
~
0>
o
o
'"
'"
"
lil
'"
N
~
,
m
ro
0.
'1)
C
'c
a.
Iii
0.
'1)
C
.C
a.
N
'"
'0
C ><
'" '"
E Ll.
"''''''
:r:mo
","0
ro"'fC\l
:O~u1
~lO(;:j
.",",
~~~
"'
~
"'
~
a.
.e
:5
o
CfJ
;3-
."
::>
t::
o
0.
0.
~ 0 N
o "E '0 CO
(J) ~'~"'6 M
1::: ...J:2: 0 (f')
<( u..- ..c >....J
0, U E Ll.
~..: vi' >.C'i5c:.o(f)+-=M aJ . .
._CI) C Ecof'-.. r.,.CI)/,,-'"CCi5"5
EC"')~lJ,)O~g"'>t;;~Nrn
oO....u......("}Q)c:x)(").......tOaJ
't:~"':s> '-> -~ro
"'><!)<l:>u:$:>u: "'UJ'-
o..:>..c en r....CI) .!: E
Z (IJ "00....: OU') ....:.t:z ro
a>...... Q) ot-- E"ON E V,I(")~
~ ~ ~ >< ~ .~ ~ ~ .~ 5 ~ .
~r--.IO......:2"(f)......~(/)......Z
c
.~
::>
<!)
U
:;;
",CD
c""
,- ""
-~
'" ,
'ceo
.eN
U""
,"'
"'0
:;;'"
"
~
o
r--
~
o
U
Q) ~
~i:5
06
o c
-5 ~
N- r.n c:
..9:! C]) rn
'" '0:;;
N ro
c...r '"C.!!! "'t
Oc.o ....('\J
(90......~M
~~~ ~~
::iNC<(N
uj ~ 0 u)~
~C"1-':::/'-.
Iii
0.
'1)
c
&
o
~
o
"'
o
'"
o
"'
""
~
""
~
lS E
U 0
'U
'" ,
c '"
o c
1/)..9
IDl!?-ro
Ll") rn~c.
~ ~ ~ 'g
roE ~ o~i:t
w.Q.8'3 00
c::u....:. CI)..q- ..cO'"C
oco -M U.cO
.... "C ro W 0 00 u 0
Q.l 0.. @) _.2: M co ID l!? ~
]jNQ)Q)roCiM ot:aJQ.)
~ :::I c: .9 ~ ...J ~ ~ ffi c
O~::::(J)Eu..c.oobu..c~c:.o'"C
.... o/i)ro _0""3" (,) '<t 0
"' "'c 2 ~+:: 0.. E~ N .9 ~. .~ ~ 0
~ :;:::::; co ro ::J - (,) ""i' 1O C =',
@.~~oO~ro~O'~ ~~tD
N():::IQ.aJW:gN'::=jj()..q5
ffi ....: e E.S 0 0 L[) x ~ Q) vi co ..c
Eo'"C~a:~u:::g~w~~~~
'"
c
B
'"
Q;
->,
'" '"
~$:"
"'''''''
-co
00'"
,gVjM
u~...J
(/).illu..
~ '" -
"'$:'0
t::_~
"''''-
.e",,,,
UUJ'"
"'"' E
.e",o
I-"":C
"
>, "'
E .g
.gOOC'1
",",...J
U",Ll.
<l:~ -
>'$: '"
- '"
,- U
UZo
:=:O~
.~o
~~O
o
l()
o
l()
o
~
o
~
""
J:,
N
~
'"
Q;
c
00
'0
o
.e
u
'"
'"
'0
'"
'0
E
o
u
~
'"
c
'"
U
><$
ro=
Ll.~
0............ Q)
.9-........q~
U:C;o;@)
~M co) 8-
O"'t'<ti;:
...., co (0 .
,.L()I.() Q)
- 00 (/)
:::2: C'? M.Q.
>,
C
::>
o
U
'"
'0
'"
o
,
E
'"
~-
~"'uo
2~N
c-~
",CfJ",
Ur--'"
~$:ti
:..szZ....:
CfJuoE
"'''' '"
:S~~
m
N
o
CD
"'
~
o
r--
""
J:,
0;
c.
'"
c:
.c
0..
Iii
'0"'
esgj
U~
ro~
em
<l:",
'",
"'0
::;:'"
Q;
c
00
'0
o
.e
U
'"
OJ
'0
'"
'0
@)
ro
'0
~
o
U
ro
N
15
N
OJ
OJ
'"
a.
'0
o
.c
u
en
~
~~
"'c
.cob
uO;:
..9:!~
:g"
.- 0
~~......:gj
<1luCI)......
UO("")C"')
c:~C"?C"')
"'~, ...J
~~~u..
.!Q 0 Z....:
ro Q.o E
c E (,0 co
<1l cu ('1")'-
0::"""::;:
""
N
o
CD
APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT
Pursuant to Sectlun J 1-II\UI\Lj\I) UI ule \,.,llY ur ;-wernurCl LallU uevelul..HIU::Hll L,UUtl, lIlI~ t-IfJfJllt;cHH t\ewe::;elllclllVe f\Tlluavit is hereby made and
submitted. The undersigned authorized representative of the individual or entity applying for the Development Permit, which is identified in the accompanying
application, and the owner of the property subject to the applicalion (it different) hereby lists and identifies all persons represenllng Ihe individual or entity
appiying for the Development Permit in conneclion with Ihe application, as foliows:
Name
Relafionship (i. e, AI/orneys, Architects, Landscape
Architects, Engineers, Lobbyists, Etc.)
Yizhak Toledano
Develooer
Alex Tukh
Proiect Mana<ler
Stanley B. Price
Attornev
Brian S. Adler
Attornev
Anne Cotter
Architect
Bernardo FortMBrescia
Architect
Oieoo Oeloado
Assistant to Architect
Carl Skiles
Enaineer
Timothv Plummer
Traffic Enaineer
Andrew Witkin
Landscaoe Architect
Kellv Hults
Landscape Architect
(Attach Additionai Sheets If Necessary)
NOTICE: ANY STATEMENT OR REPRESENTATION MADE BY ANY PERSON LISTED ON THE APPLICANT REPRESENTATIVE AFFIDAVIT
SHALL BE BINDING UPON THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY APPLYING FOR THE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT AND THE OWNER OF
THE SUBJECT PROPERTY, APPLICANTS AND AFFIANTS ARE ADVISED TO TIMELY SUPPLEMENT THIS AFFIOAVIT
PURSUANT TO SEC. 31-71(B)(2)(IV) OF THE CITY'S LANO DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS IN THE CITY COOE, IN THE EVENT
THAT PRIOR TO CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICATION BY THE CITY BOARO OR COMMISSION, THE INFORMATION
PROVIDED IN THE AFFIDAVIT BECOMES INCORRECT OR INCOMPLETE,
WITNESS MY HAND THIS c.o\-VlDAY OF ~ 1'1 ,2006.
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OF APPLICANT: OWNER
(Signature)
By,
By:
(Print)
nature)
Name, Alex Tukh, Proiect Manaqer and Authorized Siqnator
(Print)
Aventura Land Trust. LLC and Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
Name,
Title:
Address,
Address, 3624 Estate Oak Circle
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33312
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MtQ,v\l -OOQG
Before me the undersigned authority personally appeared Alex Tukh as th
Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC the oWner of a portion of and the contract purchaser of a portio
being first by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed this Affidayit for Ihe
correct.
r of Ayentura Land Trust, LLC and
o th operty subject to the application, who
rpo s stated therein and that it is true and
Alex Tukh roj t M nager and Authorized Signator
Aventura Land Trust, LLC and Ayentur Trust 2, LLC
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME this(tf2ay Of~, 2006,
My
\\IUII, Alb'
~,--;,~',...yp~~\ Kyra arraCLD
-"'A'~'c "# D"'92
" ' : : ': OOlIDlSSlOn D,.., 6
''!l, ''!F''pi~'' AUG 22 2008
-;...~i:'",,#,,,,,!:...ol u...~, 'i
""'I'~~I~\\" WViVi.A>\.Ro\NOTARY,com
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
.'"'co'
'..... "C,',',',,' .
'" ~': .'" -,;'.) .
"\, ~' .
~';fL"'<~
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This AHidavit is made wsuantto Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the City 01 Avenlura Land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant hereby dIScloses Ihat
(mark Wilh:X"/piicable portions only)
~, Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with an~' member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
I ] 2 Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of tolal assels or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[J ii, Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co~shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional slack exchange) or joint ....enturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
I] iii The Applicant or Representati....e is a Client of a member of the City CommiSSion or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the Cily Commission or
Board;
[J iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Clien: of the Applicant or Representative;
[J v, The Applicant or Representati....e is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ I Vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a gi....en calendar year.
WITNESS MY AND THIS 2<6 DAY OF rV\. 'Y ,2006
8y, (Signature)
Name: Yizhak Tal dano (Print)
Aventura Land Trust, LC and Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
WITNESS MY HAND THIS r( DAY OF
"SLA.. li
,2006
By, (SIgnature)
Name: Yizhak Toled no (Print)
Aventura Land Trust, L C and Aventura Land Trust 2, LLC
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representalive" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2,395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.4 7692825653
STATE OF FLORIDA ~
COUNTY OF ~ 1l\l)J.( '"
NOTARIZATION PROVISION
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Yizhak Toledano
executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
SWORN TO AND SU8SCRI8EO belo" me this)~ day 01 ~,2006
Irst by me duly swam, did swear or affirm that he/she
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF
,,o.,,,,,- ALEXANDER TUKH
:~~ MY COMMISSION /I Dm52974
"1'Of~a~ EXPIRES: May 16, 2010
(4071398.{lIS3 Floridlll Notary SeMC4l.com
~
NOla'K~~~a'1"Qt~ La<g'
printedNameofNotary~
My commission expires:)' b b
-------------------- ---------------------------...
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Alex Tukh the Affiant. who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she elCeculed
this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
Alex Tukh, Project Manager
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006
Notary Public Slate of Florida At large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
---------_.------~._---_._-------_._----_.._._------------~-------------------_._---------------------------.----------------------------------..--
STATE OF FLORIOA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,OAOE)
Before me, the urldersigned authority, personally appeared Stanlev B Price
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit lor the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
the Affiant. who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Stanley B. Price, Attorney
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006.
NOlary Public Slale of Florida At large
Ponted Name of Notary
My commission expires:
----------~_._--------~---_._----------~------~~------._---------------------.._--------------------------~-------------------------------------------
STATE OF FLORIOA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Brian S_ Adler
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Brian S. Adler, Attorney
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006.
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
MIAMI 1090272.4 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit IS made pursuant to Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
(mark with "x" applicable portions only)
p(i.
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented
[ ] 2.
Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of Ihe City Commission or a Cily Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows,
(list name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(Lisl Cily Commission or Cily AdvISory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of lotal assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[) ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co~shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
Iisled on any national or regional slack exchange) or joint venlurer with the Appiicant or Representative in any
business venture:
[ ) iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as Ihe member of the Cily Commission or
Board;
[) iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client 01 the Appiicanl or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of Ihe City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ ] vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Appiicant or Representalive and transacts
more Ihan $25,00000 of the business of the Applicant or Represenlative in a given caiendar year.
NDTHIS~AYOF ~,2006
By,
Name:
Title
xT h
Proiect Manaaer
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2006.
PROPERTY OWNER
By:
Name
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the A ventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This AffidaVit is made pursuant to Section 31'71(b)(2)(1i) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
(mark with "x" applicable portions only)
D(j 1. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
[ ] 2. Affiant hereby discloses that It does have a 8uslness Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City AdvISory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership inlerest in excess of 1 % of tolal assets or capital slock
of Applicanl or Represenlative;
[I Ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
! ] iiL The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board,
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative,
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member 01 the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
empioyer) and transacts more Ihan $10,000,00 of the business of the member of fhe City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[] vi.
The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000.00 ollhe business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
Ow.
, DAYOF~,2006
BY<au
Name:
Title,
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
Stanie
All
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2006.
PROPERTY OWNER
By
Name:
Title
(Signature)
(Pnnt)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client, " "Customer, " "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are denned in
Section 2-3g5 ofthe Aventura City Code.
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
ThIS Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31,71(b)(2)(li) of the City 01 Aventura Land Development Code. The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
(mark wilh "x" applicable portions only)
)(1
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
[ 12.
Affiant hereby discloses that il does have a Business Relalionship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on Ihe
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporalion which are nol
listed on any nalional or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with Ihe Applicant or Represenlalive in any
business venture;
[ ] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ ] Vi. The member of Ihe City CommISsion or Board is a Customer of Ihe Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
WITNEss~,~y..,HAN i ~YOF ~,2006.
By, ~, -"------- (Signature)
Name, ' rian S. Adler (Print)
Title: Attorney (Print)
WiTNESS MY HAND THIS 7~AY OF ~,2006.
PROPERTY OWNER
By
Name"
Tille:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code.
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This AffidaVit IS made pursuanlto Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the City 01 Aventura land Developmenl Code. The undersigned Affianl hereby discloses Ihat
(mark with 'x' applicable portions only)
~ Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented
! ] 2. Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves)
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows
[] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1% of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture:
[ ] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv, A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicanl or Represenlative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[ ] vi. The member 01 the City Commission or Board is a Cuslomer of the Applicanl or Representative and Iransacts
more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
WITNESS MY ND THIS pAY OF .:) U ~ ,2006
By,
Name
Tille,
(
(Signature)
Anne Cotte (Print)
Architect (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS l.o.... DAY OF ~, 2006.
PROPERTY OWNER
~1l{
By:
Name.
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Retationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 olfhe Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
ThIS Affidavit is made pursuant to Seclion 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the City 01 Aventura Land Development Code The undersigned Affianl hereby dIScloses that
(mark with "x" applicable portions only)
.x.:
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
[ ) 2.
Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Reiationship with a member of the City Commission or a City AdvISory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of. Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves),
Thenature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[ ] i Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representalive;
[] ii Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
I I iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client 01 a member of the City CommISSion or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board,
I I iv. A Clly Commissioner or Board member IS a Client 01 the Applicant or Representative;
I) v. The Applicant or Represenlalive is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,00000 01 the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer 01 the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000.00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
,---
WITNESS MY HAND THIS ~ DAY OF ~,2006.
.rJn411-1r (Signature)
Bernirdo Fort,Brescia (Pnnt)
Architect (Pnnt)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS c..., DAY oF1\..l I '-/
PROPERTY OWNER
II vi.
By
Name:
Title
,2006
By,
Name:
Title
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code.
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31,11(b)(2)(ii) of the City 01 Aventura Land Developmeni Code
(mark with "x" applicable portions only)
'f){1
The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented
[ 12. AffIant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member otthe City Commission or a City AdvIsory
Board to which the application will be presented. as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves),
The nature ot the Business Relationship is as lollows
[] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ji. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or lornt venturer with Ihe Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[ ] iii. The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[ ] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member 01 the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[] vi. The member ollhe City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicanl or Representative and transacts
more than $25,00000 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS lJ+li1AY OF ~,2006.
. ('
BY,~,../VV'- \'Yv-.- ~ (Signature)
Name: Dieoo Deloado (Print)
Title Assistant to Architect (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS LD~DAY OF ~,2006.
PROPERTY OWNER
By,
Name:
Title,
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavn is made pursuant to Section 31-71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura land Development Gode The undersigned Affiant hereby disdoses that
(mall< with 'x' applica~e ponloos only)
~
Affiant does no! have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented
[ J2.
Affiant hereby discloses that il does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commissioo or a Cliy Advisory
Beard to which the ap~icatioo will be presented, as follows
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who sell'8S on the
(List Clly Commission or Cily AdVisory Board upoo which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows.
[J i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interesl in excess 011 % ollo1ai assets or capital stock
of Appiicant or Representative;
[ ] ii. Member of City Commission or Board IS a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business 'r'enlure;
[J iiL The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
profes~on" working trom the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[I iv, A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative:
[I v. The Ap~icant or RepresentatIVe is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Beard (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the bUSiness of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) i/1 a given calendar year;
[J vi The member of the City Commission or Board Is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more tha'l $25,000.00 of the bUSiness of the Applicant or Representative In a g\'fen calendar year.
WITNESS MYHANDTHIS/Q_DAY OF L]7;/;I ,2006.
BY'~ L ~(SignaIUre)
Name: Carl Skiles (Print)
Tille Enaineer (Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS _ DAY OF
PROPERTY OWNER
.2006.
By:
Name:
Title:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship, "'Client," "Customer,' "Appticant," "Representative" and "interested Person' ere defined in
Section 2-395 of fhe Aventura Cffy Code,
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692B25653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71(bX2)(ii) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
(mark with 'x' applicable portions only)
(Z
[ ] 2.
Affianl does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
Ihe application will be presented,
Affiant hereby discloses that II does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a City Advisory
Board to whicl1the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(Ust City Commission or City Advisory Board upon whlcl1 member serves),
The nature of tI1e Business Relationship is as foliows:
I) i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excass of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ii. Member of City Commission or Board Is a parlner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
[] iii, The Applicant or Representative Is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
I] iv, A City Commissioner or Board member Is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[] v, The Applicant or Representalive is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City CommissiOll or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[J vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Represantative in a given caiendar year,
r;' DAY OF 1 [(iy ,2006,
By: (Signature)
Name: Ti 0 um r (Print)
Titie: Tr ffic E . eer (Print)
WITNESS MY ND THIS -1- DAY OF ~ 2006,
PROPERTY OWNER:
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
8y,
Name:
Tilte:
"The terms "Business Re/allonship,' 'Client," "Customer,' 'Applicant,' 'Representallve' and 'Inferested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Menfum Cffy Code.
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuanl to Section 31,71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Avenlura land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
(mark with 'x' applicable portions only)
t/1. Affiant does not have a Business Relationship with any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presenled.
[ 12. Affiant hereby discloses that il does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Commission or a Cily Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or Cily Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[] i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of lotal assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
[] ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venlure;
[] iiL The Applicant or Representative is a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or RepresentallVe;
(] v. The Applicant or Representative is a Cuslomer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000.00 of the business of the member of the City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[I vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
WITNESS MY HAND THIS L.. DAY OF ~ ...J \ '1 , 2006.
By'. ~,-1~ --"'~
c..z.. (Signature)
Name: Andrew Witkin (Print)
Title: Landsca"e Architect (Print)
WITNESS MY HANO THIS 60AY OF ~,2006.
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Hie,
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms "Business Relationship," "Client," "Customer," "Applicant," "Representative" and "Interested Person" are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692625653
BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP AFFIDAVIT*
This Affidavit is made pursuant to Section 31-71(b)(2)(ii) of the City of Aventura Land Development Code, The undersigned Affiant hereby discloses that
(mark with 'x' applicable portions only)
~.
Affiant does not have a Business Relationship wilh any member of the City Commission or any City Advisory Board to which
the application will be presented.
Affiant hereby discloses that it does have a Business Relationship with a member of the City Com"mission or a City Advisory
Board to which the application will be presented, as follows:
I ] 2
(List name of Commissioner or Advisory Board Member) who serves on the
(List City Commission or City Advisory Board upon which member serves).
The nature of the Business Relationship is as follows:
[J i. Member of City Commission or Board holds an ownership interest in excess of 1 % of total assets or capital stock
of Applicant or Representative;
II ii. Member of City Commission or Board is a partner, co-shareholder (as to shares of a corporation which are not
listed on any national or regional stock exchange) or joint venturer with the Applicant or Representative in any
business venture;
I] iiL The Applicant or Representative IS a Client of a member of the City Commission or Board or a Client of another
professional working from the same office or for the same employer as the member of the City Commission or
Board;
[] iv. A City Commissioner or Board member is a Client of the Applicant or Representative;
[1 v. The App!icant or Representative is a Customer of the member of the City Commission or Board (or of his or her
employer) and transacts more than $10,000,00 of the business of Ihe member olthe City Commission or Board (or
his or her employer) in a given calendar year;
[J vi. The member of the City Commission or Board is a Customer of the Applicant or Representative and transacts
more than $25,000,00 of the business of the Applicant or Representative in a given calendar year.
By:
Name:
Tille,
rj..~';;'ffi;M'"
Landscaoe Architect
,2006.
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
WITNESS MY HAND THIS
DAY OF
,2006.
PROPERTY OWNER:
By:
Name:
Title,
(Signature)
(Print)
(Print)
"The terms 'Business Relationship,' "Client,' "Cusfomer,' "Applicant,' "Representative" and "Interested Person' are defined in
Section 2-395 of the Aventura City Code,
MtAMI1090272.2 7692825653
NOT ARIZA nON PROVISION
STATE OF FLORIDA _..l;
COUNTY OF "^ \Il'-\ l ~VUL
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this ~ay O~, 2006.
\\\111111// K Alb .
$~~Y'~~~' yr~. arracm
~0.:A:i~ COIllllll$SIOn # 00348902
...r.i.,..,'~,'- ExpInS, AUG, 22,2OM
....'I,~~I~\\\' \V\\'W.AA:R01'lNOTARY,com
anager and Authorized Signalor
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Alex Tukh the Affiant. who being first y e uly sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed
this Affidavit for the purposes slated therein and that it is true and correct
arge
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA -ooc\C.
COUNTY OF M\OI\.t \
,f1~mii'" "fIi A1b
/~~~Y"f~;;\ nyra 'arradn
:; ':':" iiQ\ '~~ Commission # 00348962
'"'~<~,J'/!: \.~:~"J"<ls: .~llG, ')2,2nC8
y me d y sworn, did swear or affirm that he/she executed
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Alex Tukh
this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
SWORN TO ANO SUBSCRIBED before me Ihis ~ay of 1\A. \ 1_,2006.
'e t Manager
t Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Stan lev B, Price
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and carre
the Affian
rst by me duly sworn, did swear or
'."'''''''''' Kyra Albarracin
.;.\v..~.'(. ~P~'-:.
'~:'J1.',:,,:~ Commission # 00348962
",;).:,,~'~J EIpim: AUG, 22, 2008
-;'~"..d':'
"'1,0' ",\\,.... HTl~'W tlA.ROSNOTW,ccm
11111 "" ,. '
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires
.::\-v..
SWORN TO ANO SUBSCRIBED before me this 10 day of 'JlA l'i--, 2006.
STATE OF FLORIOA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,OAOE)
Before me, the underSigned authonty, personally appeared Brian S Adler the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affirm thai he/she executed IhlS AffldaVlI for the purposes slated Ihere," and that It IS true an~rr~~ ~ _'
Bnan S Adle~
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me thlS~Y of 'J\Ah-L 2006 /
\\,'IlII/JI
f,,~WP!;~<_ Kyra Albarracin
g :':;j, :~ ~ COmmission # DO'''962
..~. .!IiI'-. J"tO
"';Vi''', .,.;t'/ EIPlns: AUG, 22 2008 Prinled Name of Notary
" OF f\\J\.. I
MIAMI 1090272.3 7692825653 11'''1\\\\\ w\n,.',A..uO\NOTARY.~OJ:!l.
--"-"--------------------------- ----.--------------..------ --.------.-.----------------------- ---------------------- ------- --._------------------------ -------------------
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Anne Cotter
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this ~ day of 'AI L'1 ,2006
,
,
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DAD
NoIIry Public. SlIItall'lDlllll
. i My CommisSion e.po,s Jul7. 200t
, .' "''''''CommISSiCrrU)(t4rl811''''''''
:;;.... Bonde<! By NatiOnII __
'l ") ~
N~PUblicSta,teofFlo~
i t. c- 1.( ;V
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared
affirm that he/she executed this Affida'f"it for thepurposes stated therein and that iUs trile and correct
/
did swear or
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this G. day of ~, 2006
.'
\....
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DA
G),~~7i7i~i~;~, "''''..
..r.\-"" Bonded By NationlM ~
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Dieao Delqado
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Diego De~ado, Assistant to Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006.
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires.
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI'DADE}
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Carl Skiles
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Carl Skiles, Engineer
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
MIAMi 1090272,3 7692825653
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Anne Cotter
affirm that he/she executed th5 Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that It Is true and correct
the Aff~nt who being fir5t by me duly sworn, did swear or
Anne Cotter, An::hitect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
2006,
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Pnnted Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
CDUNTY OF MIAMI'DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Bernardo Fort-Brescia the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
affirm that helshe executed this Affidavit for tl-Je purposes slaled therein and that it is true and correct.
Bernardo Fort-Brescia, Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day of
,2006.
Notary Public State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of ~otary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORiDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI'DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Dieao Delaado
affirm that helshe executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correcl
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
,..
~~
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me tI1is ~ day of ::J \,~ L ----I2D06,
0, Assistant to Architect
Un,~
~ryPUbl",StateofFlo~~
f1 rz.J\
Printed1'fame of Notary ,..., ., Olf ,
My commission expires: I " . \0
STATEOFFLORiOA )
COUNTY OF MIAMf-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Carl Skiles
affirm that he/she executed this AffidavIt for the purposes stated therein and that it (s true and correct.
the Affiant, whc being first by me duly sworn, did swear or
Carl Skiles, EngiJeer
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me this _ day 01
2006.
Notary Public: State of Florida At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expIres:
MIAMI 1 090272,3 7692825653
My commission expires
STATE OF FLORIDA I
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersIJr'led aUlhority, pefWfJallyappeared Anne Cotter
affirm thaI heJshe executed this Affidallit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, dia $Wear or
Anne CottEr, Archllect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me ll1is _ day of
,2006,
Notary Publk: State of Florida At large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUN1Y OF MIAMI-QADE}
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appearad Dieao Oeiaado
affirm that he/she executed thls Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it 15 true and correct.
the Affiant who being first by me duty sworn, dkl swear or
[t1El90 Delgaoo, Architect
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me tllis _ day of
,2006.
Notary Public State of Florida At large
Printed Name of Notary
My commission expires.
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUN1Y OF MIAMI,DAOE}
8efora me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Carl Skiles
affilm that he!she execuledlhis Afflda~it for the purposes staled therein and thaI rt is true and correct.
."~""'~l4"UVV~..s"
,".'. SUSAN P. KAY
", ri:il#' M':.. COMM!SSION # DD307184
~ "<:~~.tr r:XPIRE.";: April 06, 2008
~ 1_~Iii'_,."CoTM:', fL NotaJY DlSCUWlt Assoc. Co
!-.,rv.^"Vv,-~
Printed Name of Notary
My commissJon expires:
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me this 10 day OIJO )'1 ,2006
-------------_._-----~-~--"-" ""._._------~---_...- ._._---_..~---_._---_.._.._---------
STATE OF FLORIDA J
COUNTY OF MlAMI,OADE)
Before me, the undersigned authorlt,', perwnaUy appeared. Tim::lth'l Plummer
affinn that heJshe executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated 1herein and that h is true and correct
the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn, dlJ. swear or
TirTKltlly Plummer, T raffle Engineer
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me !his _ day 01
,2006,
Notary Public Stale of Florida At LaJge
Printed Name of Notary
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692825653
STATE OF FLORIDA )
. COUNTY OF MI'.~I,OAOE)
Before me, the u",",rsigned authorny, personal~ appeared TImothv Plummer
afflfm that hefshe executed this Affidavij for the purposes stated therein and thai it Is true and co
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me this L day of 4. tL Lv 2006,
/ /
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MI'.MI-OAOE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Andrew Witkin
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that It Is true and correct
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED belore me tho _ day of
the Affiant who being first by me duly SW<lm, did swear or
Andrew Witkill, Landscape Architect
,2006,
NolBry Public State of Florida At Large
Pnnled Name 01 Notary
My commission expires:
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Kellv Hults
affinn that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes staled therein 800 that it Is true and correct.
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED before me tI10 _ day of
MIAMI 1090272,3 7692825653
the Affian~ who being first by me duly sworn, dKl swear or
Kel~ Hul1s, Landscape Archrtect
2006.
Notary Pu~lc Stale of Flond, At Large
Printed Name of Notary
My rommlssion expires:
My commission expires:
---------------------------------------------------.--.----------------------------------
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI-OADE)
Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Andrew Wilkin the Affiant, who being first by me duly sworn,
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes staled therein and that it is true and corr~eCl.
J?--.-<f .--1 ~
- -,
rew Wilkin, Landscape Architect
SWORN TO ANO SUBSCRIBED belore me this .2day o~, 2006.
ik'f""i!f.:._ NERISSA M. MCCLUNG 1
!"/';&;";~ MY COMMISSION # OD 534728
~~~W EXPIRES, March 30, 2010
"",9f.,r.-~ BoodedThru NOlaryPublic Underwriters ,
did swear or
<:: ^~
Notary Pubijc s~e of Flo~d~ At Large
"'~S A. '"^"" CLV...."...
Printed Name of Notary
/lAy commission expires: 3 . ao . 2.. 0 0 ~
-_._-------------~----------------~-----------------------------------
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF MIAMI,OADE)
Before me, the undersigned aulhority, personally appeared KeH Hults
affirm that he/she executed this Affidavit for the purposes stated therein and that it is true and correct.
Kelly ults, Landsc Architect
SWORN TOANO SUBSCRIBED beIOremethiS5daYOI~' !O~
~ry pu~~e of Florida AtLarg~
.e...v\ ~ ,,<\ C!.C,.[ ,
Printed Name 01 Notary .
My commission expires: ~~~ ..20\C .
,,'"~''t'''''
/4"i::"'"
~~(~:~~
'. -:...1i,:,....ff::.~
.. 'liOF~.'
!JL_ '""",
~~
NERISSA M. MCCLUNG
MY COMMISSION # OD 534728
EXPIRES: March 30, 2010
BoodedThruNotaryPubllcUnclllrM1l&1S
MIAMI 1090272.2 7692825653
ORDINANCE NO. 2006-
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE CITY
OF AVENTURA BY AMENDING THE ZONING
DESIGNATION FOR A PARCEL OF LAND LOCATED ON
NE 207 STREET AT NE 30 AVENUE AS MORE
PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED IN EXHIBIT A, FROM B2,
COMMUNITY BUSINESS DISTRICT TO RMF3A,
MULTIFAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTIAL
DISTRICT; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY;
PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN THE CODE;
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the applicant, Aventura Land Trust, LLC and Aventura Land Trust 2,
LLC, through Application No. 01-REZ-06, has applied to amend the Official Zoning Map
of the City of Aventura by amending the zoning designation for a parcel of land (the
"Property") on NE 207 Street at NE 30 Avenue, as legally described in Exhibit A
attached hereto, from B2, Community Business District to RMF3A, Multifamily Medium
Density Residential District; and
WHEREAS the applicant has proffered a covenant to restrict density on the
parcel of land subject of this rezoning request to no more than 31 dwelling units per
gross acre and the City Commission has accepted such proffer; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission concurrently with this rezoning application has
considered a small scale Comprehensive Plan amendment to change the land use
designation of the Property from Business and Office to Medium High Density
Residential (01-CPA-06); and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has been designated as the local planning
agency for the City pursuant to Section 163.3174, Florida Statutes, and as the local
planning agency has determined that the rezoning is consistent with the applicable
provisions of the City Comprehensive Plan as proposed to be amended; and
Ordinance No. 2006-
Page 2
WHEREAS, the City Commission has held the required public hearings, duly
noticed in accordance with law; and
WHEREAS, the City Commission has reviewed the application for rezoning and
has considered the testimony of all interested parties at the public hearings, and has
determined that the rezoning action set forth in this Ordinance is consistent with the
Comprehensive Plan, as proposed to be amended; and the health, safety and welfare
of the City.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, THAT:
Section 1. Recitals. The foregoing whereas clauses are hereby ratified
and incorporated within this ordinance.
Section 2. Official Zonina MaD Amended. That the Official Zoning Map
of the City of Aventura is hereby amended by amending the zoning designation for the
parcel of land located on NE 207 Street at NE 30 Avenue with legal description
described in Exhibit A and folio numbers listed in Exhibit B to this ordinance, from B2,
Community Business District, to RMF3A, Multifamily Medium Density Residential
District.
Section 3. Severabilitv. The provisions of this Ordinance are declared
to be severable and if any section, sentence, clause or phrase of this Ordinance shall for
any reason be held to be invalid or unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the
validity of the remaining sections, sentences, clauses, and phrases of this Ordinance but
Ordinance No. 2006-
Page 3
they shall remain in effect, it being the legislative intent that this Ordinance shall stand
notwithstanding the invalidity of any part.
Section 4. Inclusion in the Code. It is the intention of the City
Commission, and it is hereby ordained that the provisions of this Ordinance shall become
and be made a part of the Code of the City of Aventura and that the Official Zoning Map
of the City may be revised so as to accomplish such intentions.
Section 5. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective immediately
upon the effective date of the small scale amendment to the Comprehensive Plan (01-
CPA-06) and upon recordation of the proffered covenant restricting density to no more
than 31 dwelling units per gross acre.
The foregoing Ordinance was offered by Commissioner
moved its adoption on first reading. This motion was seconded
and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
, who
by Commissioner
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Michael Stern
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
The foregoing Ordinance was offered by Commissioner
moved its adoption on second reading, This motion was seconded
and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
, who
by Commissioner
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Michael Stern
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
Ordinance No. 2006-
Page 4
PASSED on first reading this 12'h day of September, 2006,
PASSED AND ADOPTED on second reading this 3rd day of October, 2006,
Susan Gottlieb, Mayor
ATTEST:
TERESA M. SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
UFFICIE~:
CITY ATTORNEY
This Ordinance was filed in the Office of the City Clerk this _ day of
,2006.
CITY CLERK
,"';'1"(,, 'No, 2006-_
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
All of Lots 7 through 13, 38 through 42 and a portion of Lats 14, 33 through 37, all of Block 1 B,
HALLANDALE PARK No.8, including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots. lying within said Block 18,
os recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, All af Tract 1, LAURANNA, as recorded in Plot Book 76 at Page
31. All of Lots 1, 2, 6 through 13, 38 through 42 and a portion of Lots 14 and 37, all of Block 17,
HALLANDALE PARK No, 8, including the ten (10) foot alleys adjacent to said lots in Block 17, as recarded
in Plat Book 20 at Page 49. Tract 1, Block 17, REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK No, 8, os
recorded in Plat Book 40 at Page 97, That portion of the North One-half of N,E, 205th street abandoned
by Resoiution No, 2000-11 recorded in O,R.B, 19247 at Page 4677, Thot portion of N.E, 206th Street
bounded on the North by Biock 18 and bounded on the South by Block 17 and bounded on the East by
the West right-ot-way line of N,E. 30th Avenue (East Dixie Highway) 011 being as shown on HALLANDALE
PARK No.8, as recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49. A portion of land bounded by on the North by a
line 81.00 feet South of and parallel or concentric with the North line of Waterways Boulevard os shown on
AVENTURA CORPORATE CENTER, as recorded in Plat Book 15B, Page 47, and baunded on the South by the
North line of Block 1 B, HALLANDALE PARK NO.8, as recorded in Plat Book 20 at Page 49, all the above
plats being of the Public Records of Miami-Dade County. Florida, lying and being in the City of Aventura
and being more particularly described as follows:
Commence at the intersection of the centerline of N.E. 205th Street and the centerline of N.E. 30th Avenue,
both as shown on said PLAT OF HALLANDALE PARK NO, 8; thence North 89'53'41" West along said centerline
of N.E. 205 Street for 35,01 feet to the Point of Beginning of the hereinafter described parcel of land;
thence continue North 89'53'41" West along said centerline for 261.97 feet; thence North 00'00'00" East for
422.33 feet; thence North 90'00'00" West for 119,97 feet; thence North 00'00'00" East for 135.92 feet;
thence South 76'00'36" East along a line 81.00 feet South of and parallel with North right-of-way line of
Waterways Boulevard for 86.13 feet to a point of curvature; thence Southeasterly along a 1519.00 foot
radius curve leading to the left through 0 central angle of 7'37'02" for on arc distonce of 201.94 feet;
thence South 00'52'30" East along a line 10.00 feet East of a 10.00 foot alley adjacent to said Lot 42,
Block 18 of HALLANDALE PARK NO, 8 for 8.92 feet to the Northwest corner of said Tract 1 of LAURANNA;
thence South 89'50'24" East along the North line of said Tract 1 for 70.42 feet to a point of curvature;
thence Southeasterly along a 25.00 foot radius curve leading to the right through a central angle of
88'57'54" for an arc of 38.82 feet to a point of tangency; thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line
of said Tract 1 for 122.65 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; thence South 89"51'49" East along the
North line of said Lot 7, Block 18 HALLANDALE PARK NO. 8 for 5,00 feet to the Nartheast corner thereof;
thence South 00'52'30" East along the East line of said Lots 7 and 8, Block 18 and the Southerly
extension thereof for 164.42 feet to the Southeast corner of said Lot 2, Block 17 of HALLANDALE PARK NO.
8; thence North 89'52'27" West alon9 the South line of said Lot 2, Block 17 for 5,00 feet to the Northeast
corner of said Tract 1 of REPLAT OF A PORTION OF HALLANDALE PARK NO.8; thence South 00'52'30 East
along the East line of said Tract 1 for 75.01 feet to the Southeast corner thereof; Thence South 89"53'04"
East along the North line of said Lot 6, Block 17 for 5.00 feet to the northeast corner of said Lot 6;
thence South 00'52'30" East aiong the East line of said Lots 6, 7 & 8, Block 17 for 56,77 feet to a point
of curvature: thence Southwesterly along a 25.00 foot radius curve leading to the right through a central
angle of 36'52'05" for an arc of 16,09 feet; thence South 00'52'30" East along 0 line 35,00 feet West of
and parallel to the center line of said NE 30th Avenue for 35.35 feet to the Point of Beginning.
Fls Job No. 20061117
Folio numbers
28-1234-006-4610
28-1234-006-4810
28-1234-006-4590
28-1234-006-4580
28- i234-006-4570
28-1234-006-4560
28-1234-006-4550
28-2203-021-0010
28-1234-006-4530
28-1234-006-4540
28-1234-006-4420
28-1234-006-4430
28-1234-006-4440
28-1234-006-4450
28-1234-006-4460
28-1234-006-44 70
28-1234-006-4210
28-1234-006-4220
28-1234-007-0031
28-1234-007-0030
28-1234-006-4230
28-1234-006-4240
28-1234-006-4250
28-1234-006-4290
28-1234-006-4280
28-1234-006-4270
28-1234-006-4260
CITY OF AVENTURA
FINANCE SUPPORT SERVICES DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM
TO:
City Commission
upport Services Director
FROM:
Eric M. Soroka, Ci
BY:
DATE:
. June 22, 2006
SUBJECT: Ordinance Revising City of Aventura Police Officers' Retirement Plan
1st Reading July 11th, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item '7 -13 (Jl
2nd Reading September 1ih, 2006 City Commission Meeting Agenda Item <l
Recommendation
It is recommended that the City Commission approve the attached ordinance which
amends the Police Officers Retirement Plan,
BackQround
The Attorney for the Police Officers' Pension Board has requested that the attached
Ordinance be approved. The requested changes have no impact on the future operations
of the Plan or the City,
Based on the foregoing, I recommend approval of the amending ordinance.
HMKlrnn
ORDINANCE NO. 2006-_
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA
AMENDING THE CITY CODE BY AMENDING CHAPTER 36
"RETIREMENT" AT ARTICLE II "POLICE PENSION PLAN
AND TRUST FUND" BY AMENDING SECTION 36-24
"CONTRIBUTIONS" AND DELETING SECTION 36-36
"RATE OF CONTRIBUTION"; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN CODE;
PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
NOW THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF AVENTURA, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Section 36-24(a) of the City Code of the City of Aventura is hereby
amended to read as follows:
Sec. 36-24. Contributions
(a) The City shall pick-up, rather than deduct from each member's pay,
beginning with the date of employment, six and three tenths (6.3%) percent
of the member's earnable compensation, Effective October 1, 2005. the
member contribution shall increase to six and seven hundred seventy-five
one thousands percent (6.775%) of the member's earnable compensation,
The monies so picked-up shall be deposited in the Fund immediately after
each pay period. An account record shall be maintained continuously for
each member. Pick-up contributions shall continue until death, disability or
termination of service, whichever shall occur first. Contributions shall
remain in the Fund unless withdrawn as provided in the Plan, No member
shall have the option to choose to receive the contributed amounts directly
instead of having them paid by the City directly to the Plan. All such pick-up
contributions by the City shall be deemed and be considered as part of the
member's accumulated contributions and subject to all provisions of the
Plan pertaining to accumulated contributions of members. The intent of this
provision is to comply with Section 414(h)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code,
For the purpose of accruing and calculating pension benefits, and for all
other purposes of calculating wage related benefits and calculations, the
amounts picked up under this section shall be considered part of the
earnable compensation of a member.
Section 2. Section 36-36 of the Aventura City Code, which reads as set forth in
Exhibit "A", is hereby deleted.
Ordinance No. 2006-
Page 2
Section 3. Severability, The provisions of this Ordinance are declared to be
severable and if any section, sentence, clause or phrase of this Ordinance shall for any
reason be held to be invalid or unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the validity
of the remaining sections, sentences, clauses, and phrases of this Ordinance but they
shall remain in effect, it being the legislative intent that this Ordinance shall stand
notwithstanding the invalidity of any part.
Section 4. Inclusion in the Code. It is the intention of the City Commission,
and it is hereby ordained that the provisions of this Ordinance shall become and made a
part of the Code of the City of Aventura; that the sections of this ordinance may be
renumbered or relettered to accomplish such intentions; and the word "ordinance" shall
be changed to "section" or other appropriate word,
Section 5. This Ordinance shall become effective immediately upon its adoption.
The foregoing Ordinance was offered by Commissioner Auerbach, who
moved its adoption on first reading, This motion was seconded by Commissioner Stern
and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urb8ez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
The foregoing Ordinance was offered by Commissioner
who moved its adoption on second reading. This motion was seconded by
Commissioner and upon being put to a vote, the vote was as follows:
Commissioner Zev Auerbach
Commissioner Bob Diamond
Commissioner Harry Holzberg
Commissioner Billy Joel
Commissioner Michael Stern
Vice Mayor Luz Urbaez Weinberg
Mayor Susan Gottlieb
PASSED on first reading this 11th day of July, 2006.
Ordinance No, 2006-
Page 3
PASSED AND ADOPTED on second reading this 12'h day of September, 2006.
SUSAN GOTTLIEB, MAYOR
ATTEST:
TERESA M, SOROKA, MMC
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
f~
CITY ATT6RNEY
Ordinance No. 2006-
Page 4
EXHIBIT "A"
Sec. 36-36. Rate of Contribution.
The City contribution, effective October 1, 2003 shall be 14.5 percent of covered payroll.
The employee contribution rate shall be six and three-tenths percent The assumed rate
of Chapter 185 insurance premium tax rebates shall be five percent of covered payroll.
Future contribution increases or decreases in the plan shall be shared equally between
the employees and the City through September 30, 2005, Consistent with the
requirements of F,S, SS 112.66 and 185.07, the City shall contribute the amount
necessary to maintain the plan on an actuarially sound basis. To the extent that any
changes are required in the member contribution rate, a separate amendment shall be
required to reflect the revised member contribution.
~ :l:
:;:)
... ::E
z -
'"
w -
~ <
Ci:
... I:
0 0
~ ;:;
"
13 ..
Ul
a;
I:
0
N
a; Q;
'" C
E i..: '"
'" " a. 0
Z '" c :a
1: t: ,2 'I:
" -0 u
,!!l > '"
~ " "
U <J} 0
- -
0 0
II> II>
M M 0
... ... .,; ~
... ...
0 0 -
II> II> ><
... ... N III
i..:
"
.c
E
Q; :0 a;
Z
.c c.
E I: ?':
0
:0 t: ~
z " ~ 0
"0 '" "5
< .E ii) U
a
~
-
5
w
~
*-
~
i
w
..::.
re>
c
S
c
o
u
..
c
.
.
~
,
0.
!
~
,.
R
0.
"
.
..
;
..
c
.
.E
~
..
i!
o
.
.
~
.
.!
.
..
s
.
!
u
1l
c
..
.
e
,
o
>-
.,;
s
5
'5
.E
.
GO
.
0.
..
C
.
!
..
~
c
o
..
..
l
E
.
ii
.
~
I-
.E
..
coG
Q8-
Q~
N-g
- .
Q~
-.
~z;
oo~
Q-lI
~
.
(1)~
-=
eGg
c~
.
C"
o~
._ f
_0.
eG"
CH
= :
,Cili
~~
Q.i!!
16A I wmfl~SDAY,AUGUSll0,200G
IRAN
WORLD
Mi"rn,HuMl.com TflEMIAMIHERAlD
Iran's leader challenges U.N., Bush
~ Ir..n.~p...lclentagaln
lambasledt....au'lhorltyof
Ihe U.N. Security Coundl to
Impo$e sanctlonl on the
co,.n>try'. nuclear prog",m
-~ndsaidheWll"tsto
debalePre.identlkl$h.
BYAU.lll:B.tdlllARElNI
A>soc;.''''''''''''
TEHRAN. Iran - Iran',
hard-1m.. presldent challenged
the UnitedN.tinn, on Tues-
day, two d.y, beiore. Secu.
rity Coundl ultimatum
demanding Teh,au rolloack
its nuclear pn>~ram, and
in'tead proposed. td~vi.ed
debatewi,hPresidentBu.sh
Pre,ideo! Mahmoud Ahma-
dinej.dal,,,,aiJnoonec,n
pre.ent Iran from purSUiD~
what he called. peacdul
nuclearp"'Ilram not even
UN.chie[KuJiAnnao.
"Mr. Annan. too. has tu
mt>ve within the iramework oi
intemalionalre~ulation'. Nu
oDe has a special ri~ht or
advantag..:' the lranianpre<i-
dem..idduriDF:atwo.hour.
wide-ranging new' cooter-
enc-",ldevisedworldwiJ.,
AnILUl is upected in Iran
on Saturday. two dal" .iter
Thursday', U,N, Security
Couocildeadllne for Teman
10 suspend uranium enrich.
ment - a pro~ess that CaD
produce either fuel ior a reac-
tor O' malerial ior weapon,
lraohasreiusedanyimmedi-
ate 'U'pensiOD. calling th..
deadline ille~al, and instead
earlier this week of'-ered a
counterproposal that the
United State, and sorne Euro-
peao nation, ,aid feU short.
Ahmadindad', late,t ,huw
u,detlanceseemedto,olidify
the country'. determination t<,
5nub the Se~urity Council,
comiDF:..iter.,tritll;ofrete01
publlcdispiaysoimilitaryand
politicaldetemtination
The White Hou.e immedi-
atelyrejectedhispropo<aI"Ja
TV debate with Bush a. a
'"diversion" f",m ,eriou, con-
cerns over the country',
ouclearp"'gratn.
Iohiscrih~i.'m(),-theSecu'
~,__n_,
V
CITY OF AVENTURA
NOTICE OF HEARING OF LOCAL
PLANNING AGENCY
ANO NOTICE OF AMENDMENT OF
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
AND NOTICE OF AMENDMENT TO
OFFICIAL ZONING MAP
Pliblic Notice is hereby girenthatlheCllyo!A'lenI!Ir.l Local Planning
Age!lcy't/lllm861 ill a public hearlltO on Thesday,Septumber 12. 200B
ul 6;00 p,m, tn make a IllCOOImendallon rtlllardioglhe ad<JllIIono!lIlu
lolIowingOrtlirlur<;es
AltOflOllWlCEOF'lMEcmOFAVEIfTUIlA,R.llRIDl,
AIlE!I:lItG'lMECOMl'flBEllS/VEtMSTBlPlAllBT
AIBlllNGTllEFUTlllElAlIJlISI:MAPDESlGIIAT1llIl
FORPID'EIlTl'lOCATtOOIlIlE'll11snlEET,u1E3lI
AllEIU:,MllAEPAIlT1CIUIIl.YIlESCRlBEllIlElllllT
",."TOTMEORllIIWICf.ffIOMBUSIlE5SAND
IlFFICETOMEDUIIHlIIIllBBlYlIESlllBfTlAl<
PIIlMOll6RlRTJWlSMlTTAL TOTllEUSIClESAS
l'IfQIJIIIEDlIlDEIlctlAPTEll163,lWlTlI,fLOfIlOA
ST,.MiS; AND PIllMllItG RIll AliI ERECTIVE .,...n.
Isuemapbolowlnr~locatm)
..,
AIlORlllllAllCfOFTllEClTYOFAVEIlTIA\,R.OIlIIIA,
AMEMDltGTHE IJJICW.ZOIIN6MAPOFTIIE CITY
OF AVEIfI1JRA IY AMDlDlIIG M zoutG
DESIGIU.TIOIIRIllAJWlCELllflAllJOIiI.2II1
~,u1lE3lIAVEJU:AS_PUlTJ:II.NILY
DESCRIIED.. EXIll8IT ",." TO TIlE IIlDIWlCE,
FROItB2,CIltAUlTYIlJSlIESSDISTlllCTTO
".3A. IlU.Tl-fAMIILY MfPIUM IlEIISflY
IlESIllEIIT1AL D1SlIIICT; PlllMOIIlll FIll
Sl\'EllAllLITY;PIIO\/lOlNGfOIIlICUIiIlJIIl"TllE
COIlE;PlIOVIIlIIlGRIllNtEffEC1llE.,...Tt.lseemap
be4ow!orPf(lllUrlyIDcatioll)
i
!
f
i
....,~~....>-s
i'~~13'''"' i
1,"-,'.:"" 1
~ .. "",'"'' ",' ~
SITE
Immudiatelyfollc,.;"lll11u lDcalPIiII1I1iogAgencymUUling.ll1eClly
Contmissiono!lhuCilyo!AveoIur.I.aslt1uglMlfl1lngbolly,wil
=:~~~a~~~~~~o~
OrtInanCllSdescftledaboYU
TlluPtlhIicHeanngswmbtlhukllnlt1uCllyC&mnlllllDnCllllllan
Il.CIlyofAnnlln~eenw,ll2OOw.tColmtryCUI
Ildft,A'IIIItIn,fbtd;I,331., Thept1Jp(llllld()(dlnalJ:esmaybe
irtSpeCtedbylt1upk/bjcattlleO!ftaollhuCllyCluOlatlheabove
adGress.lnlefl!U1llljpal1iesmaYappulSatl11uPulilicflearinQl;andbe
heanJY/lIhfflSllOlCllolhuPfOP(lllldOrdinaoces.
InaccortlancewtthlhuAmuricallswilhOl$abllltiesActo11990,al
pIIr$OItSwhoaredisabledamwMl1IIUCspucialaccommoda1loosto
particlpatell1l1"sproouudlngbucauseollhat~!hJuhlcontacl
tlleOflir.u a1lhu City Cletk.I30SI4ffi.8901, nollaterthun lvvo
tllI5inessd!lY5pt1DrIllSochproceedngs
Kapersontlecidastoappualaoyduoi!;ionmatlUbylt1uCity
Commisslonwi\1lrvupacttoanymatlurcllOSidur\lljalameu!Il1llDr
hearin\j.thatpUrsoowlllnuedarewrdolt!leproceudingsand,Jor
suchpurposu,maynuedlounsurethataver!lulinlfto:Drdo1ll1e
procetldillll'iiSmade,wI1ichrecon:lmdulluslhuluslimooyalld
uvldunceupoowllichlhea;tJlUlllistobotla5ed
TlIrt'ISaM,Soroka.MMC,CllyQark
rityCouocU.Ahmadioejadsin.
I\led()uttw""';"perman~ot
members - the Unit~d State,
and Britain - lor what he
called their failu.e toli.t~n to
the """d< oJ other eoutttrie<-
"The U.S. and Britain are
the"Htrceoimanyten,ion,:'
th~ pre,idem said. '"At the
Security Council.wbe.... they
h..~ ,,, protect ,ecurity. they
enjoy the veto ri~ht. Ii any-
body conlt<>nt' them, lhere i,
ooplace"'tak~complain"to.
"Thi. [veto right] i, the
50urce 0'- problem, 0'- the
world ...lti,aninsultt()the
dignity, independence, free-
dom and <overei~nty of
oatioDS," he ,aid.
.I1teUrutedSta'esambas-
sador to the U.N. Jolm IloIton.
dismissed Ahmadinejad',
remarks,andllrilain'sambas.
,ador to the world b,x1y .u~-
~e"ed, somewhat t<'''IfUe.in.
cheek, th.t the comments
were mild compared to Ahma-
dinejad'5 past ,harp rhetor;c
a,.,aiDst Israel and others.
"G;vensome oithe com-
ments he make;, we ,hould
probably take that a, a compli.
IDent:' said Ambassador Emyr
:oE~~~~~n~ia~~~Joi~ ~~~ ~Ea~s(~~~EI':: ~;:t:I~~dK~~~~~~7G~~~;;:~t'
,hould i()cu' on "world issue'
and the way. ();,olviDll 'he ,ibility oidirect dipl()matic
problem.' oithe int.roati<mal talks with the UniledSlates.
communitv" 'ayin~ it could happen il
Hedid;,otru!eoutthep<l5- unspecitied conditions were
p---- ------ --------- ---.
: TIRED OF LOUSY SERVICE? :
'~}(lWA\1.\OI'I"l!~""h"'l'~.oo(""""l!<Il
: .lolol""'-""_'(OIl1fI"IIII"W."'hA"l"'\l~t,:
I __...ntt<I.~_mKhani<.IlH'I""1
I ...,.och!<_'((lII'IfIOOJ,...",I~...-..tol(lUtOfO)/D:lrlI
I <l'<OIMII'Nl(""""""""""",l!t;.lt\opl'\l~l,,..)OU I
I UI'IbiNd.-""""_'AlOIl'd)W......
I ItIfm'lfOOl"""".or4)OUn....pnlbiem....h.'
: ""'.''''''P'''Y,AIltlf'ILiR''''twoIp. :
i ~ Angi~~..~l~! i
, ,
I C.II 13(5) 674-9230 I
I ."',"""'''"''''',..."..,''"''''"'__-,....."....'<.....''""''''',,,,..~. I
~ :::,~-::-~"'::;'.:':':':':"'~::'":. ":t::'~ ~~'~:::: ~
met, Bu! he criticized th~
UnitedSlat~'t"or'"livin~lnthe
dream oj ~e!tio~ the lrani.n
nation back to.lO years "l-"O."
At the Whit. Hou,e.
spoke,woman Dana Perinu
c.UedthedebllteiMa'"ju".
diversloniromthele~itlmate
concem.,tltatlheinternalional
cOIt1lttunity.not just the U.S"
hasahOUllran',behavior,
i",m5upporttorterrori,mt"
pu,"uitOfanudearweap()n.
capllbUity,"
The Bu,h admini,trali()n
earlierthi,weekre.trumedit5
intent lo pu"u~ U.N. ,"nc
tions .~ainst Iran il it dell~,
the appro.achin;: deadline, But
wheth~r lhe US can mu,ter
eDough.upport"ntheS",u-
rityC"uocilto.ctuallyimpose
eithetecono~ic',>rp()litic'al
'anc:tions remarn, 10 quC"Sllon
DEBATE BUSH?
...,MmoodAhrnacliee-
liIO',c"'ITue'd"yto'~
t~e,isodde!o,t~w,tr
Pre,,(!~otB\"r ""O,tro
t",ltlmelreha""'"'€
'eawh^>made<ucha
d"ec!ov~,t",~
E",'I",'r;sY""'""e',
'""de' w<ole" I~"erto
8",r po""y'n"t"~wu,'1
asME'dwltc"n'p"~,-
"'c'e""cggIoDa'h~l't'CJol
th~An"e"c~ngove,e-
mer!."Wa,rlrqto~
orompt'ydi,m;"edtre
'e"era, "'ekov~c-'.ndro'
,(!d.~",oglhekeviml~
of".r'sd;'Du'eclrlJ(,~"'
O""I,"m
Ic~~ewscO!'le't'CKe
Tu",d.y A"madl~e"'<1
cr.lle~9"dBu,Mto"live
deDa'. 00 "wm'd '''ue'
"~d'hew"y,ol,o'vl,'q
'"~p'ob'em'o"he'rt~'
n~t,O!'a' commuMy
W€~r"OUcceou'
y,~w, rh~, c~~ ,~" 'h~",
p'o',i,ledth~t lre'ew,llb~
r0 cen",,,h;p, e,pec"II'i
10'theAm...Oc"~ """p'~
hesald
Ahmadi,,~W,t,~,dtro
<1eIWewo"ld,p<vp'o
.how'''''wmld''how,r;s
IU~ :r""thod 1S0PP'~'-
"v~ "~d comp~'" ~ w't~
th"propo'a'solth~I,'"
nia""~t'oOoOMwto'ur
th~wMdP€tte',di"...-ert
homl"",USmNrodo'
lIseol'o'c~~nd ',",01."
''','arlog~
TheWMeHoc"~";'
m",edlhep,opo;.e',,,,,
dl;t",(t",r,
W'wr Ahm~dIO~J""
,erth., 'etle' to "",h Ic,
"'ay,th~tt,€n.wcite
H"l,,~'QCJl<e<man5cott
,",cC'el1~r ac(lI;""l',~CO'
!r\,irg'ocho"qe 'he 'ub-
lectl'Qmd~m'rd,'ha'"
"l>il~clonu"oiume"''''''
ment
Ahm""tin~i"(jc.,II~d
thotlettt'C"wa"j"o(l
op;olu"'o"~e'''m~n
n~"or"~,~)ed."lrdlnq~
w~y outofp,obl~,W,
laclo')rumaM',S~;(llre
ott",I."'''r''rn~w;
""""',j
AS50ClATcl)P~F~'
YOU ARE
NOT ALONE
lfYQU arc an All.,ot, Horidi.n cu"omcr >.nd your
in>urcdpr<>pcrly"",.damag<<ldu.ingthcr=cnl"".m
All"." 1'1"ridi.ni...aclytohdp, All 1"" h,,'o ,,,clo..
<aU t _'oo_54-_STO~M '" go ,,, AlI.'a'c.,om '" '"po"
a <ioim. You. All"." floridion ag<n' can .1.0 belp
lf1<'"clon'llur",o.<<...'o)'OUrpo1ic1 numbcr,j""g;."
uoyou.n.m<ond..c'llgc,thcdaim.pro<<".t.r<cd
ALLSTATE FLORIOIAN EMERGENCY CLAIMS SERVICE:
1-800-54-STORM
-",,_.....""''''''''"',''''''''...'''..."-''''''''''',~...._,''- ,'"."""...,,....,,"""''''
ALllfAt'
fLO.IDI....N
'N.u..Nc',
, 0'" . ~ '\
-----
MIAMI DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW
Published Daily except Saturday, Sunday and
Legal Holidays
Miami, Miami-Dade County, Florida
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE:
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared
O.V. FERBEYRE, who on oath says that he or she is the
SUPERVISOR, Legal Notices of the Miami Daily Business
Review f/k/a Miami Review, a daily (except Saturday, Sunday
and Legal Holidays) newspaper, published at Miami in Miami-Dade
County, Florida; that the attached copy of advertisement,
being a Legal Advertisement of Notice in the matter of
CITY OF AVENTURA
NOTICE OF PROPOSED ORDINANCE - SEPT. 12,2006
in the XXXX Court,
was published in said newspaper in the issues of
07/14/2006
Affiant further says that the said Miami Daily Business
Review is a newspaper published at Miami in said Miami-Dade
County, Florida and that the said newspaper has
heretofore been continuously published in said Miami-Dade County,
Florida, each day (except Saturday, Sunday and Legal Holidays)
and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post
office in Miami in said Miami-Dade County, Florida, for a
period of one year next preceding the first publication of the
attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he or
she has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation
any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose
of securing thi advertis t for publication in the said
newspaper
Sworn to and subscribed before me this
'~ru
(SEAL) ~i'\. Mana I. Mesa
O,V. FERBEYRE personally knowrCl.~' . My COmrn'5l>,on 00293855
....T,.I Expires MarCh 04, 2008
:PU8L~ NQTlce OF .
"~O""ANe.'
. ";, .' . " ..fP~': '_' .'
NOT~~' IS HEaEBV GlVEN t~ttj:m Tuesday, the, 12t1l day of
Sep~r,2006~ a mEl$ting of~OityCOl'TllTlission of tile City of
,Aver$lfJ, to be ~e1dat 6:00 ""m.,inthe Cornn1is$k:m 9tJaf1\tler at
Aventij(a Gov~nt Genter. ,19affP West OountIY C1ub.Drive,
,Aven~R1, Florida,theOityComml$s~~i11 !;:on$i~theadopli9flof the
following Ordinance ,on second readingl~tted; , ,
AN, ()ROINANCE OF THE CrtY;Of.AVE~RA,~A
AMENDlNGTI'IE cn'Y CODE "Y'~ENDIHG QttAPTER;a&
"RETI,REMENT"AT A.R1,1CLE It,'"-. ICE.PEN$IQ,', ','",t,t,~H
AND. TRUST FUND." BY ~,,'8~'~
"CONTRIBUTIONS" AND DE~SECTlON ~,"RATE
OF ,CONTRIBUTIOH";.PROVI'-', FOR ~RABlUTYj
PROVIQING.fORINCi.USIQN Itlj~; PaoyIDtNG FOfi AN
EFFIaCTlVE DATE.;;,. . f'
The proposed Ordinance fJ\8y,be ins, by tb~ publlP ~ tI)e,.Office of
the City 0Ierk.19,2ooWeat CQ.,' ; .t)rjV.e,'.1~~' Aorida.,
'~~~=~~~~~~~~Anype~~fr:t~a~=:ttl:1
'City PomRJi~PfIanY lttmat ~~ HeeMgm~ do $Q"'r the!
Mayor<>pen8~~tIeltffl'Ig.. t;',:)~ i. . ' ,
In accordan<:e ",~'the Afneric8ns ~', Aclt. Of. 1~. all'
-persons who a" diaIIQ'" and ,who'., ~. ~lJlOdations to:
partlciP$te Ir1 th~ P ,', ~"'} ~5bouJ<jqontact'
the Offla. of ~Oity Q, , ' '.l'Ot later thantwQ buliness
days PriortO~ " , '.... >,~ , y,. ..., ,;
"" ,. ..', I
.If a person decl!Mll to~1 any~~daby~CilYComlPission!
with.respeCt ~'enY IJl8Utr,conside~'~~lJl8efif1Q-i>i.tMla~. thatl
'personwiU n~ a.~rd Of!Jep, . " " .. ", '. ~~\.iijIJ)ij~. ~yl
;need to enswe-Jhal a ~r.cord of , ' ,,'Is made. whiCh,
record Includei'1h8~ ande\lide.\ .~..~ ~Iis to!
be baaed.
~,,~r_.
7/14
. TeresaM. ~,MMCCiiY Clerk:
, '~,.~4.-.o1LZQl170M
~~
MIAMI DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW
Published Daily except Saturday, Sunday and
Legal Holidays
Miami, Miami-Dade County, Florida
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE:
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared
SOOKIE WILLIAMS, who on oath says that he or she is the
VICE PRESIDENT, Legal Notices of the Miami Daily Business
Review f/k/a Miami Review, a daily (except Saturday, Sunday
and Legal Holidays) newspaper, published at Miami in Miami-Dade
County, Florida; that the attached copy of advertisement,
being a Legal Advertisement of Notice in the matter of
CITY OF AVENTURA - PUBLIC HEARING 9/12/2006
APPLICANT - HI LIFT MARINA, LLC
in the XXXX Court,
was published in said newspaper in the issues of
08/25/2006
Affiant further says that the said Miami Daily Business
Review is a newspaper published at Miami in said Miami-Dade
County, Florida and that the said newspaper has
heretofore been continuously published in said Miami-Dade County,
Florida, each day (except Saturday, Sunday and Legal Holidays)
and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post
office in Miami in said Miami-Dade County, Florida, for a
period of one year next preceding the first publication of the
attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he or
she has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation
any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose
of se rin this advertisement for publication in the said
new pap .
[J
Sworn to and subscribed before rne this
~
(SEAL) !':J\ Mana I. Mea
SOOKIE WILLIAMS pe~ik~~ifltln 00293855
or'" ExplleS Mad 04, 2008
CITY 0' AhllTUM
NOTIC. 0-: puaLICHURING
Dat..ndTlmeof PubllctfeltrlN:' Tueeday.September 12,2006
6:00 p.m.,
AppIIcIInt~ber?, ~1~~~~VAR~06)
ApplIcant Requeat: The applicant, Hi Lift Marina. LtC, Is re-
, 'questing:
Conditional Use, ApprovaL to ,permtt
construction of a new marina and dry dock
boat storage building with a height of 90' in
the ,TC2. Town Center Marine District,
Whereamaidrl.Un height of 4 stories or SO'
1s~~CClde;_ ,
Variance from SectIort31*145(c)(10) of the
~ DeYetoprnent Regulations to permit a
15' ,VIltw oorrldor..wherej68.76' ~
corrldot is requiredbyCode; and '
variance from Sec:tIon 31-221(i)(2) of the
Land Develqpment,~ to permit I'.
rriInImumbuff8rstrlp of 4'8., where a
rninirm.lm ..,. buff8r strip Is required by Code;,
. and ' 1
"Locflon otSullleotPnipelty: 2880 HE 187"Street. Aventura
.... DeecrtptIon: AporIIon of SecIton 3, Township 52 South. Range
, . 4a Eald,.Miarnf"Dade County. Florida anda porIIon
of Trade,At1a8 T4mnIn8IRe8IdentIaI.PIat Book
146, Page 18. PubliC 'Aeco!'d8 of Ml8mi-Dade
County, Florida. CIty of Aventura, Florida
(complete JegaI de8crIptIon on file at CommunIty
DevefoPm8ntOepartment) .
Plans are 00 file and may ~.eiasnlinec:Jdqrln9 ~bu8lr1eeeboUrs at
the City of Aventura Government Center, Community Development
Department, 19200 West CountryClubl)rlve~,Aventwa, ~~180.
Plans may be modified at ,or before the Public Hearing. The application
maY c:haIlge t:iuringthe ~ring~. '
The Public Hearing ViOl be held in the ~ Chambers at City of
Aventura Government Center.-19200 West ,Po~ntry Club Drive,
Avent~ ,Florida 33180. Your comments may tle made in person at the .
hearing or flied in writing prior to .~ .hearirMI.. Refer to applicant!
property on correspon~JI1d malt eaine,to City of Aventura
Goverl'llllentc.ntei', Community Development Department. at the
address aboVe. For furthfir information.,.", call (305) 46&$40.
In accordlU)Ce with '1t1e Amerlcana.wIth .,DlsablIlt\88 Act of 1990. all
persons Who' are disabled and whP ~,~ accommodations to,
~'in thls .pn:Ill8eding.~ oftf'* ~ should contact
'the ~,ofthe CItY ~ 46&-8901..not tater_ two business d$ya
prior,toeuch proeeedIng8,
If-a pel80n decideS to appeal 8IlYdecIsIiin, ~ by the CItY Commission
with I'8SpeCt toeny matter coneidItIW at a meeting or hearing. ,that
person wiD need a record of the ~ and. for such purpose, may.
need to ensure that a verbatim reoordof the'~ is rnac:te. which
recOrd includes the teetlmony and tMdenceupon WhIch the app..t!@tCl
be b8sed:
8i25
Tel'8$a M. Soroka. MMe. City ~
, ~~117181~